﻿   Table of Contents
Title Page
Introduction
About This Book
Quackademic medicine and the delusion of being “science-based” | D Gorski
Quackery tolerance – a learned response. Wallace Sampson
A Culture of Standards Matters | S Novella
The facts of the alternative medicine industry | S Gavura
MEDICAL SCHOOLS AND HOSPITALS
CAM In Medical Schools. Steven Novella.
The ultimate in “integrative medicine”. Integrating the unscientific into the medical school curriculum. David Gorski
Teaching Pseudoscience In Universities | S Novella
Forks in the road. Wallace Sampson
The Trojan Horses of Education. Wallace Sampson
Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part I). Kinball Atwood
Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part II). Kimball Atwood.
Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part III). Kimball Atwood
Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part IV). Kimball Atwood
Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part V). Kimball Atwood.
Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part VI). Kimball Atwood
Dummy Medicines, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 1: a Curious Editorial Choice for the New England Journal of Medicine Kimball Atwood
Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.0: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD Kimball Atwood
Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.1: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (cont.). Kimball Atwood
Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.2: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (cont. again). Kimball Atwood
Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.3: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (concluded) | K Atwood
Milestones on the path to integrating quackery with medicine | D Gorski
Why Do Prestigious Hospitals Sell Snake Oil? | S Novella
The infiltration of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) and “integrative medicine” into academia.David Gorski 
Why would medical schools associate with quackery? Or, How we did it. Wallace Sampson
Confronting homeopathy, naturopathy, homeopathy, and other quackademic medicine at my alma mater | D Gorski
Georgian College’s Homeopathy Program: Magical Thinking Presented as Fact | S Gavura
Is medical academia just following academia? Wallace Sampson
Quackademic medicine trickles out to community hospitals | D Gorski
When “CAM” is mandatory: A science-based medical student’s dilemma. David Gorski
Quackademic medicine update: UC Irvine reneges on promise of scientific rigor | J Bellamy
Quackery in Medical School: Chapman Points | B MacBeth
The Integrative Oncology Scholars Program: Indoctrinating the next generation of “integrative oncology” believers | D Gorski
Consortium of Academic Health Centers for Integrative Medicine research conference disappoints even NCCAM | J Bellamy
Oregon Health & Science University SCAM Day | M Crislip
Medical students actively recruited for CAM. Peter Lipson
A University of Michigan Medical School alumnus confronts anthroposophic medicine at his alma mater. David Gorski.
The ultimate in “integrative medicine,” continued. David Gorski. 
Surprise, surprise! Dr. Andrew Weil doesn’t like evidence-based medicine. David Gorski.
Resistance is futile. David Gorski
Touch – a Trojan Horse . Wallace Sampson
Best Hospital Eye Roll M. Crislip
INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE
Integrative Medicine – Sectarians’ Trojan Horse. Wallace Sampson
“Integrative medicine”: A brand, not a specialty. David Gorski 
Lies, Damned Lies, and ‘Integrative Medicine’ | K Atwood
Integrative Medicine: “Patient-Centered Care” is the new Medical Paternalism | Science-Based Medicine
Integrative Medicine Invades the U.S. Military: Part One | J Bellamy
Integrative Medicine Invades the U.S. Military: Part Two | J Bellamy
Integrative Medicine Invades the U.S. Military: Part Three | J Bellamy
CAM practitioners react to Andrew Weil’s proposal for a board certification for integrative medicine. It isn’t (all) pretty. | Science-Based Medicine
Bravewell Bimbo Eruptions | K Atwood
Bravewell Puts Integrative Cart Before Science Horse | S Novella
The Bravewell Collaborative maps the state of “integrative medicine” in the U.S., or: Survey says, “Hop on the bandwagon of ‘integrative medicine’!” (2012 Edition) | D Gorski
Perpetual Motion: More on the Bravewell Report | M Crislip
Bye Bye Bravewell | J Bellamy
The Trojan Horse called Integrative Medicine arrives at another medical school | S Gavura
The future of “integrative medicine” is too close for comfort | D Gorski
Survey says, “Hop on the bandwagon of ‘integrative medicine’! David Gorski 
Quackademia update: The Cleveland Clinic, George Washington University, and the continued infiltration of quackery into medical academia | D Gorski
Integrative medicine advocates react to criticisms of the Samuelis’ $200 million gift to UC-Irvine | D Gorski
More Integrative Propaganda | S Novella
The Marino Center for Integrative Health: Hooey Galore | Science-Based Medicine
Quackademic Medicine at UC Irvine | S Novella
UC-Irvine, integrative medicine, and the delusion of being “science-based” | D Gorski
Integrative Medicine finally admits it’s attracting bad apples | J Bellamy
Dana-Farber Cancer Center’s Integrative Medicine Expansion | D Gorski
Another pebble in the quackademic integrative avalanche | D Gorski
“Complementary and Integrative Health” at the VA: Integrating pseudoscience into the care of veterans | D Gorski
CARA: Integrating even more pseudoscience into veterans’ healthcare | J Bellamy
Integrative Medicine’s Collateral Damage | J Bellamy
The closure of major integrative medicine “Crown Jewels”: Terminating the Terminator? | D Gorski
A surprising article about “integrative” medicine in The New England Journal of Medicine vs. “patient-centered” care | D Gorski
Medical Intuitives: More Integrative Medicine Pseudoscience | J Bellamy
Columbia University finally cuts ties with America’s Quack Dr. Oz | D Gorski
Traditional Chinese herbalism at the Cleveland Clinic? What happened to science-based medicine? | Gorski
Herbal Center at Cleveland Clinic | S Novella
The Medical Director of The Cleveland Clinic Wellness Institute spewed antivaccine misinformation last week. Why is anyone surprised? | D Gorski
Cleveland Clinic Fully Embraces Pseudoscience | S Novella
A tale of quackademic medicine at the University of Arizona Cancer Center | D Gorski
Medicine in the Magic Kingdom of Cascadia. On Naturopathy. | M Crislip
Stanford University will host a conference on pandemic planning featuring the usual (COVID-19) suspects | D Gorski
Bastions of quackademic medicine: Georgetown University | Science-Based Medicine
Pseudoscience North: What’s happening to the University of Toronto? | Science-Based Medicine
University of Toronto Coddles Quackery | S Novella
The Biopolitics of Quackademic Medicine in Iran | K Aramesh
The American Medical Student Association: On “integrating” quackery with science-based medicine | D Gorski
Tens of millions for CAM research — and it’s all on your dime | J Bellamy
Related by coincidence only? University and medical journal press releases versus journal articles | D Gorski
Malingering: The Lord Voldemort of Medicine | J Howard
Ad-Conned: A Critical Look At CASPer | B MacBeth
The Residency Match is Broken | B MacBeth
Can Medical Schools Really Teach 71 Nutrition ‘Competencies’? Should They? | H Miller
Science-Based Satire: Cleveland Clinic Subscription Box Service Introduces Integrative Medicine to Curious Consumers | C Jones
CONTINUING MEDICAL EDUCATION
A Meeting of Incompatibles. Wallace Sampson
Collision of Incompatibles. Wallace Sampson 
The 2nd Yale Research Symposium on Complementary and Integrative Medicine. Part I. Kimball Atwood.
The 2nd Yale Research Symposium on Complementary and Integrative Medicine. Part II. Kimball Atwood.
Learning quackery for Continuing Medical Education credit | J Bellamy
Acupuncture CME. Mark Crislip.
Crank “scientific” conferences: A parody of science-based medicine that can deceive even reputable scientists and institutions. David Gorski.
CAM practitioners react to Andrew Weil’s proposal for a board certification for integrative medicine. It isn’t (all) pretty. David Gorski
“Eliminating cancer” with Traditional Chinese Medicine and other state-sanctioned quackery | J Bellamy
Is the ACCME cracking down on quackery in continuing medical education (CME) offerings? Richard Jaffe thinks so. | D Gorski
AAFP CME Program Succumbs to “Integrative Medicine” | H Hall
Student Health Professionals and Attitudes about CAM | S Gavura
Alternative Medicine Is Infiltrating Veterinary Continuing Education | H Hall
Acupuncture for Heart Attacks and more State-Sanctioned Pseudoscience | J Bellamy
POLITICS AND LAW
The National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM): Your tax dollars hard at work. David Gorski
NCCIH has a new director, and she’s a true believer in acupuncture. | D Gorski
NCCIH Strategic Plan 2021⁠–⁠2025: Meet the new plan, same as the old plan…? | D Gorski
The NIH funding process according to John Ioannidis: “Conformity” and “mediocrity”? D Gorski
MEDICAL PRACTICE
“Urban Zen” and homeopathy at Beth Israel Medical Center, or: Dr. Gorski destroys his chances of ever being invited to join the faculty at BIMC or the Albert Einstein College of Medicine. David Gorski 
The Good Rewards of Bad Science. Ben Kavoussi.
Be careful what you wish for, Dr. Dossey, you just might get it. David Gorski.
“Integrative” oncology: Trojan horse, quackademic medicine, or both? David Gorski.
“Integrative oncology”: The Trojan horse that is quackademic medicine infiltrates ASCO | D Gorski
The Harm of Integrative Medicine: A Patient’s Perspective | J Luke
For-profit stem cell clinics, universities, and “pay-to-play” clinical trials for autism | D Gorski
Hypothesized benefit from integrative treatments for veterans’ chronic pain fails to materialize | J Bellamy
ICD-11: A triumph of the “integration” of quackery with real medicine | D Gorski
Academic Consortium plan: force medical residents to practice integrative medicine | J Bellamy
Pseudoscience sneaks into Ohio guidelines for non-drug pain treatment | J Bellamy
Survey Says… Infectious Disease Docs and CAM | M Crislip
JOURNALS AND ORGANIZATIONS
World Health Organization Endorses Quackery | S Novella
Reporting results from clinical trials is vital for science-based medicine | B Hermes
Time to Move Beyond the Impact Factor | S Novella
Rigor Mortis: What’s Wrong with Medical Science and How to Fix It | H Hall
Scientific Fraud in China | S Novella
Is scientific peer review a “sacred cow” ready to be slaughtered? | D Gorski
Cranks, quacks, and peer review. David Gorski.
Peer Review and the Internet. Steven Novella.
Faking Peer-Review | S Novella
Reporting Research Misconduct | S Novella
A formal request for retraction of a Cancer article | J Coyne
Chinese BioMedical Research: Sturgeon’s Law In Action | M Crislip
Shilling for traditional Chinese medicine: Nature leaves its readers a lump of coal before Christmas | D Gorski
Pseudoacademia | S Novella
Bad Science Journals | S Novella
The New England Journal of Medicine Disappoints Kimball Atwood
NEJM and Acupuncture: Even the best can publish nonsense. Mark Crislip.
Misinformation Doctors Start a Misinformation Journal to Spread Misinformation | J Howard
Feet of Clay | M Crislip
The Annals of Internal Medicine Qualifies for Fail Blog. Mark Crislip
Testing a Chinese Herbal Flu Remedy. Harriet Hall
Trouble in the Library. Wallace Sampson
JAMA on Medical Misinformation | S Novella
Nepotistic Journals | S Novella
PLOS ONE, peer review, and a “crappy” acupuncture study | D Gorski
Infomercial in PLOS One links to website selling unproven treatments for fibromyalgia and dementia | J Coyne
False Balance for Homeopathy in the BMJ | S Novella
Quackery infiltrates The BMJ | D Gorski
What the heck happened to The BMJ? | D Gorski
Once again, The BMJ, wittingly or unwittingly, reinforces an antivax narrative | D Gorski
If the BMJ Wants to Revisit Venerable Institutions Who Misled the Public in 2021, They Should Look Inward at the BMJ | J Howard
Is there a role for speculative journals like Medical Hypotheses in the scientific literature? Kimball Atwood.
In which we are accused of “polarization-based medicine” | D Gorski
A whole issue of JACM devoted to “integrative oncology” propaganda? Oh, goody. | D Gorski
FTC Sues Predatory Journal | S Novella
The Problem with Predatory Journals | S Novella
Andrew Weil and “integrative medicine”: The ultimate triumph of quackery? David Gorski 
The effort of integrative medicine advocates to co-opt the opioid crisis to claim non pharmacological treatments for pain as solely theirs continues apace | D Gorski
The Hazards of "CAM"-Pandering. Kimball Atwood.
Evidence-Based Medicine, Human Studies Ethics, and the ‘Gonzalez Regimen’: a Disappointing Editorial in the Journal of Clinical Oncology Part 1. Kimball Atwood.
Evidence-Based Medicine, Human Studies Ethics, and the ‘Gonzalez Regimen’: a Disappointing Editorial in the Journal of Clinical Oncology Part 2. Kimball Atwood.
Ethical Failures | M Crislip
Ghostwriting As Marketing Tool. Steven Novella.
Threats to science-based medicine: Big pharma pays a publisher to produce a fake journal. David Gorski
The College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario’s muddled draft policy on “non-allopathic” medicine. David Gorski
American Academy of Family Physicians Home Study Course Recommends Non-Science-Based Treatments | H Hall
AAFP should publish research behind finding that functional medicine lacks evidence, contains harmful and dangerous practices | J Bellamy
AFP Promotes Acupuncture. Harriet Hall 
AAFP Promotes Acupuncture | H Hall
American Academy of Family Physicians Supports Integrative Medicine | H Hall
The American Academy of Pediatrics has an Integrative Medicine Problem | C Jones
Update on CPSOs Draft Policy | S Novella
The World Health Organization promotes quackery yet again | D Gorski
Coca-Cola and Corporate Sponsored Research | S Novella
Retracted papers about COVID-19 are more highly cited than they should be | D Gorski
Improving how the NIH decides which grants to fund: Reality vs. conspiracy | D Gorski
The Israeli Academy of Sciences and Humanities elects antivaxer Yehuda Shoenfeld to its ranks | D Gorski
   Science-Based Medicine Reviews: Quackademic Medicine
A Critical Guide for the Health Practitioner and Consumer 
2024 Edition

Executive Editor Steven Novella MD
Managing Editor David Gorski MD PhD
Series Editor Mark Crislip MD

   Introduction 
Steven Novella
The world of health care is becoming an increasingly complex and challenging place. The internet is changing the way we generate and access information, and health information is one of the most popular uses of the internet. It represents an unprecedented democratization of information and opinion. 
While there are many advantages and benefits to such information access, there are also many challenges to health professionals, regulators, academics, and consumers. There is a proliferation of health related products and services, with many provocative health claims. Regulations are generally not keeping up, and often have been watered down, in the face of this onslaught of claims and products. 
The consumer is left with an overwhelming array of health claims, many of which challenge and even directly oppose the traditional experts and institutions. 
The mission of Science-Based Medicine (SBM) is to be a source of reliable information and analysis to help navigate the wild west of health information on the internet and elsewhere. The authors who contribute to this series of e-books are all physicians and other health care professionals who have a great deal of experience educating the public about complex medical issues. We especially take on controversial issues and try to expose pseudoscience and fraud wherever possible.
The Philosophy of Science-Based Medicine
The philosophy of SBM, at its core, is simple: Safe and effective health care is critical to everyone’s quality of life; so much so that it is generally considered a basic human right. Therefore, health care products and services that work and are safe are better than those that do not work or are unsafe. 
The best method for determining which interventions and health products are safe and effective is, without question, good science. Therefore it is in everyone’s best interest for health care to be systematically evaluated by the best science available.
Too often the nature of science itself is misunderstood or misrepresented to the public. Science is not an arcane and privileged discipline. By its very nature it is meant to be transparent and public. Science is nothing more than a systematic and careful use of evidence and logic to evaluate factual claims. And good science possesses certain virtues that are not unique to science but generic to all intellectual endeavors: fairly accounting for all available evidence, using valid and internally consistent logic, using unambiguous concepts and language, proper use of statistics, being quantitatively precise and accurate, and above all being honest.
And yet there are numerous and powerful influences in society that strongly appose the scientific basis of medicine. Driven by some combination of ideology or the desire for profit they wish to eliminate standards of science in health care, or (often under the guise of “health care freedom”) create a double standard in which unscientific methods and products can thrive unchecked. Others simply lack the training or knowledge to achieve minimal standards of quality for scientific medicine. And even the best traditions of scientific medicine can benefit from more critical analysis.
Recognition of the need for careful scientific analysis in medicine partly stems from a recognition that it is very difficult (almost impossible) to reliably assess treatments anecdotally. Human perception, memory, and cognition are prone to a host of flaws, weaknesses, and biases that will tend to mislead us, especially towards conclusions that we wish to be true. Placebo effects, confirmation bias, and simple statistics can make any intervention seem effective, even when they are worthless or harmful. 
Science-Based Medicine vs Evidence-Based Medicine
Within the practice of medicine there is already a recognition of the need to raise the standards of evidence and the availability of the best evidence to the practitioner and the consumer – formalized in the movement known as evidence-based medicine (EBM). 
EBM is a vital and positive influence on the practice of medicine, but it has its limitations. EBM tends to focus on clinical trial results to the exclusion of scientific plausibility. The focus on trial results (which, in the EBM lexicon, is what is meant by “evidence”) has its utility, but fails to properly deal with medical modalities that are highly implausible, or seem to defy well-established findings in science.
All of science describes the same reality, and therefore it must (if it is functioning properly) all be mutually compatible. Collectively, science builds one cumulative model of the natural world. This means we can make rational judgments about what is likely to be true based upon what is already well established. This does not necessarily equate to rejecting new ideas out-of-hand, but rather to adjusting the threshold of evidence required to establish a new claim based upon the prior scientific plausibility of the new claim. Failure to do so leads to conclusions and recommendations that are not reliable, and therefore medical practices that are probably not safe and effective.
The SBM Series
This is why the authors of this series strongly advocate for science based medicine – the use of the best scientific evidence available, in the light of our cumulative scientific knowledge from all relevant disciplines, in evaluating health claims, practices, and products. 
Some of the articles here will analyze individual studies, and explore the strengths and weaknesses of their methods, separating what the study really tells us from how it may be represented in the media. Other articles will summarize what many studies tell us about a specific medical question. 
We will also explore health information on the internet, separating out which information is reliable from that which is misleading, erroneous, or possibly even fraudulent. Likewise we will critique mainstream media coverage of health topics, giving the reader specific tools for to critically analyze health information for themselves.
Other articles will explore topics related to health regulation and academia. Regulations have struggled to keep up with the rapidly changing health care market place, with critical gaps that leave the health care consumer responsible for their own protection. Academic institutions themselves, long the defenders of high standards of scholarship in all fields, including medicine, have been infiltrated by promoters of pseudoscientific belief systems. The result is that there is no longer any single reliable guarantee of scientific integrity. 
The SBM series of e-books is organized by topic, such as acupuncture, chiropractic, homeopathy, and many others. The books are collections of essays, not intended to be a systematic reference, but rather to explore the various scientific issues related to each topic. The goal is to give the reader critical thinking skills and a deeper understanding of, not just the current findings of science, but the process of science, specifically how it relates to health care and the topic of each book. 
Science-based medicine can serve as your pocket guide through the wilderness of health information.

As of 2025, there are over 5000 essays on the Science Based Medicine website. I do no know about you, but I find it difficult to find any post I wrote, much less one written by another contributor. 

So I have updated the books and include almost all the articles through 2025. The volumes are

CAM Concepts
Chiropractic
COVID 
Critical Thinking
Diet and Nutrition
Ethics and CAM
Herbs, Supplements, and Diet
Homeopathy
Infections and Immunity
Law and CAM
Media and Internet
Medicine, Public Health, Dentistry and Pediatrics
Miscellaneous CAM
Naturopathy
Neurology and Psychiatry
Placebo
Quackademic Medicine
Regulation. FDA and FTC
SBM or EBM
Stem Cells, Genetics, AI and Gender
Supplements, Vitamins and Herbs
Vaccine & Anivax
Vaccines and Autism
Vaccines and Preventable Infections

The articles are roughly organized by publication date and topic. Many articles will be in multiple volumes as an essay of, for example, chiropractic and law will be found in both the chiropractic volume and the law volume.

You may find the organization a bit odd. I do. But 4700 plus articles are difficult to organize and I have more to do in my retirement than work of these volumes.

Still, if you find I have missed a nentry or some glaring error, drop me a note and I will fix it for the next edition.

About the authors
Steven P. Novella, MD – Founder and Executive Editor Science Based Medicine.
Founder and currently Executive Editor of Science-Based Medicine Steven Novella, MD.
David H. Gorski, MD, PhD – Managing Editor. Science Based Medicine.
Mark A. Crislip, MD. Editor, Science Based Medicine Guides. 
He did he editing of all the volumes so is to blame for any mistakes.
As to all the other contributors, if you are interested click on the ‘Link’ at top of each essay to go the SBM site, where further information about each author can be found.
A Note On References

The chapters in this book were originally blog entries at ScienceBasedMedicine.org.
Blog and web pages lend themselves to hyperlinks to sources and references that are tedious to translate into footnotes for this ebook.
Under the title of each essay is a hyperlink, cleverly titled ‘Link’, to the original blog entry with all the hyperlinks and references, as well as the comments to the blogs, which often have interesting and thoughtful insights by our readers, as well as some curious comments by the not so thoughtful.
Graphs, tables and links to videos are not in included these essays due to issues of copyright and permission. However, thanks to the ‘Link’, the graphics are a click away.
Thanks for reading the site.
Mark Crislip 








Quackademic medicine and the delusion of being “science-based”
Last week, I was interviewed by the a reporter from the Georgetown student newsletter about its integrative medicine program. It got me to thinking how delusion that one’s work is science-based can lead to collaborations with New Age “quantum” mystics like Deepak Chopra.
David Gorski on February 12. 2018
Link

Here at SBM, we frequently write about what I like to refer to as “quackademic medicine.” A lot of people think that I coined the term, and I really wish that I had. However, in reality Dr. Robert Donnell coined it around a decade ago to describe the infiltration of quackery and pseudoscience into academic medical centers in research, education, and clinical practice. I merely took the term and ran with it.
Recall that quackademic medicine is a phenomenon that has infiltrated medical academia like kudzu over the last two decades. Basically, ostensibly science-based medical schools and academic medical centers have come to embrace quackery. This embrace was once called “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) but among quackademics the preferred term is now “integrative medicine.” Of course, when looked at objectively, integrative medicine is far more a brand than a specialty. Specifically, it’s a combination of rebranding some science-based modalities, such as nutrition and exercise, as somehow being “alternative” or “integrative” with the integration of outright quackery, such as reiki and “energy healing,” acupuncture, and naturopathy—even anthropoosophic medicine—into conventional medicine. As my good bud and former SBM blogger Mark Crislip put it, mixing cow pie with apple pie does not make the cow pie better, but we seem to be “integrating” the cow pie of quackery with the apple pie of science-based medicine thinking that somehow it will improve the smell, taste, and texture of the cow pie.
I bring the topic of quackademic medicine up once again because last week I was interviewed by Alex Lewontin, a reporter at the Georgetown University student newsmagazine, The Georgetown Voice about quackademic medicine for an article that was published on Friday entitled “An Integrative Education: Georgetown’s Complementary And Alternative Medicine Program Sparks Debate.” Not surprisingly, the article was basically “balanced,” with quotes from me as the skeptic and critic of “integrative medicine” and Hakima Amri and Aviad Haramati, the co-founders of Georgetown’s “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) program in 2001. This program was based on based on an NIH grant to develop a curriculum to expose graduate students to the field of complementary and alternative medicine, allegedly in a “critical and evidence based way.” Of course, anyone who’s read SBM on this particular topic knows that the main problem with teaching alternative medicine in medical school or doing research on it is not actually teaching it or doing research on it, but rather teaching it in a credulous manner and wasting resources and potentially endangering patients doing what I like to refer to as “clinical trials of magic.” Also, offering alternative medicine, the way that many academic medical centers do now, before there is solid evidence for its efficacy, is inherently unethical. Sadly, that doesn’t stop medical schools and academic medical centers like Georgetown from doing just that. There’s even an organization for academic medical centers with quackademic medicine programs, the Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine and Health (ACIMH), which is busily trying to get its residents to learn integrative medicine and co-opting the opioid crisis to promote quackery. It’s also grown from eight founding members to nearly seventy in two decades.
As I contemplated the article that quoted me, I was made aware of a study that shows what I was talking about. It doesn’t have anything to do with Georgetown University, but it has a lot to show about what’s wrong in medical academia today.
Deepak Chopra, medical academia, and clinical trials of woo
We’ve written about Deepak Chopra here on a number of occasions, and I’ve written about him elsewhere on a number of others. Whether it’s his invocation of “quantum” to justify quackery, his claim of a “conscious universe,” his denial of evolution, or his fanciful invocation of epigenetics and denial that genes can determine our destiny, Chopra’s blather is a perfect example of how New Age mystical mumbo-jumbo can infect medicine and be made to sound sufficiently “science-y” that doctors don’t immediately laugh out loud at it, as I did at Chopra when he criticized Donald Trump for being insufficiently reality-based. Truly, irony meters everywhere exploded.
I first noted Chopra’s insinuation into medical academia over three years ago, when I first became aware of a clinical trial that he was planning to do. Chopra initially described it for the public in SFGate in an article, “Multi-institutional Collaborative Clinical Trial to Examine Health Benefits of Integrative Lifestyle Practices at the Chopra Center for Wellbeing.”
As I read the original article about the Self-Directed Biological Transformation Initiative (SBTI), one question kept bouncing in my mind: What was the hypothesis? What hypothesis was Chopra testing here? It was a randomized trial, in which study participants were to be recruited for a week-long stay at the Chopra Center at the OMNI La Costa Resort in Carlsbad, CA, where participants were randomized to join either the Ayurveda program or a seven-day stay at the resort without treatment, which served as the control. Chopra’s “Perfect Health” program included a whole bunch of Ayurvedic massage (which can’t be too bad, I would guess), primordial sound meditation, mantra sessions, group sessions, yoga, and, as I speculated at the time, a healthy diet. Participants were to be evaluated four times: at home prior to arriving at the Center, immediately upon arrival, immediately following the treatment program, and one month later in a follow-up assessment. The following markers were tested:
    • RNA expression
    • Telomerase activity (linked to the aging process)
    • A variety of metabolites, peptides, and neurohormones (connected to metabolism, addictions, and mood changes as well as the messaging between brain and body)
    • The microbiome (the enormous population of microorganisms on the skin and in the intestinal tract, and their collective genetic material)
    • Circulating protease activity
    • Mobile cardiac functioning
    • Balance of the autonomic nervous system
    • Assessments of mental, emotional, and spiritual wellbeing
Chopra described the whole thing here in a YouTube video:
It’s only a couple of minutes. If you can stand to listen to it, you’ll hear Chopra describe the trial’s goal thusly:
The idea is to prove—scientifically—that your biology is a product of the choices that you make, and these choices are made every day, and that we can actually consciously create the experience of a joyful energetic body, a loving compassionate heart, a restful reflective mind, and lightness of being.
Whatever that means. Of course, it’s trivial to show that our health is, at least in part, the product of choices we make. I can choose to exercise—or not. I can choose to eat a healthy diet—or not. I can choose to smoke—or not. You get the idea. Of course, that’s not what Chopra means. He wanted to “prove scientifically” that his program does all sorts of wonderful things that aren’t specified beforehand in concrete, measurable ways. He also did it charging participants to use a facility that he owns.
All these issues aside, somehow Chopra got several collaborators from Harvard, Duke, and different campuses of the University of California to buy into this study and collaborate with him on it. Heck, if you want an example of quackademic nonsense, just consider that Deepak Chopra is Clinical Professor in the Department of Family and Preventive Medicine at the University of California, San Diego. Yes, clinical faculty is basically like adjunct faculty in non-medical departments, but a clinical professor is still faculty and, although not paid by the university, has most of the other privileges that being a professor confers.
So when Chopra publishes anything in the medical literature, it comes under the imprimatur of the University of California, San Diego. So far, I know of two publications from this study.
The results thus far…quackademic magic!
I’ve already discussed the results of the first paper that I knew of published as a result of this study. Granted, my discussion was in the context of a systematic review of gene expression changes supposedly associated with meditation and related practices. (Hint: The evidence catalogued in this systematic review was much less impressive than the authors painted it.)
In brief, healthy women aged 30–60 were recruited to stay at Chopra’s resort and then randomized to a vacation arm or novice meditator arm, for a total of 94 participants who completed the program. A comparison group of regulator meditators was recruited from women aged 30–60 who had already enrolled in the retreat. According to the supplemental data, the sample included women who were non-meditators and lived in California who were randomized to a “vacation” arm or a meditation arm. They did not pay for their stay at the resort. The comparison group of non-randomized women (the “experienced” meditators) was recruited from the pool of those already registered for the retreat and paid for their own expenses. Also, the experienced meditators were not randomized, and they could easily have confounding differences that could affect their results. In any event, although it wasn’t described in the methods of the paper itself, promotional literature described the retreat goal as “to promote an intensive period of learning and psychological change.” The vacation group was hosted at the same resort, but they did not participate in any retreat activities. Subjects reported on well-being immediately after (on day 5), 1 month later, and 10 months later to assess maintenance of benefits.
Unsurprisingly, the study noted improvements in psychological well-being in all groups. Investigators also claimed to have identified gene expression signatures that changed in all three groups consisting of 390 genes. This is code for saying that there wasn’t a detectable difference between the groups in changes in this gene signature, which the authors attribute to the “vacation effect.” They did, however, find differences in another gene signature whose change differed between the vacation and novice meditator arms versus the regular meditator arm. The conclusion:
In summary, our results point to both a significant ‘vacation effect’ that benefitted all groups, and a suppression of stress-related responses and immune function related to acute-phase wound healing and inflammation. We also identified a ‘meditation effect’ within the regular meditator group, characterized by a distinct network of genes with cellular functions that may be relevant to healthy aging, and this network was associated with increased expression of a number of telomere maintenance pathway genes and an increase in measured telomerase enzymatic activity. This study provides a strong distinction between beneficial effects of short-term relaxation typical of a vacation versus acute intensive meditation for regular meditators. Future studies expanding upon these results will be critical for further understanding lifestyle acute adaptations capable of promoting stress reduction and overall health and well-being.
In other words, a relaxing vacation will do you good. As for the supposed difference in gene expression signatures between novice and regular meditator groups, even if real (and reproducibility of such gene expression signatures is a huge pitfall of studies like these) it doesn’t really tell us anything, given that the regular meditators could easily have confounding factors at play based on behaviors and diet different from the vacation and novice meditator groups. Basically, this study was pretty unremarkable.
So was this other study, published in the open access journal published by Nature Publishing Group, Scientific Reports. (I can’t help but note that this particular journal is often misrepresented by quacks as being Nature.) One notes that this study emphasizes that the “Perfect Health” program at Chopra’s retreat is based on Panchakarma, an Ayurvedic medicine intervention sometimes called the “fivefold” detoxification treatment. It involves massage, herbal medicines and promises:
Panchakarma will remove the excess doshas and correct imbalances in them as well as eliminate the harmful ama out of your system through the body’s own organs and channels of elimination (colon, sweat glands, lungs, bladder, urinary tract, stomach, intestines, etc). Panchakarma purifies the tissues at a very deep level. It involves daily massages and oil baths, herbal enemas, nasal administrations. It is a very pleasurable experience. Ayurveda recommends Panchakarma as a seasonal treatment for maintaining mental and physical hygiene and balance.
Well, there you go.
In this study, meditation was not really examined. The only comparison made was between the “Perfect Health” (PH) group, which undertook the Ayurvedic Panchakarma detoxification program coupled with meditation, and the vacation controls:
Based on principles of Panchakarma, Ayurvedic Medicine’s principle cleansing and rejuvenation protocols, PH incorporates various treatment modalities such as a vegetarian diet, Ayurvedic herbs using the Zrii Purify™ herbal program per manufacturer’s instructions, meditation, yoga, specialized Ayurvedic oil massage, heat therapies, and lectures on self-care and well-being (see Supplementary Methods S1 for detailed herb, oil, and prebiotic fiber cleanse protocol). The PH program employs a palliation approach, which combines gentle reduction and tonification therapy, and is focused on Purvakarma (preparatory techniques of Panchakarma) procedures and 2 of the 5 main Pradhankarma techniques of elimination, namely Virechana and Nasya. Gentle Virechana is accomplished using the purgative herbs of the Zrii Purify™ herbal program. All study participants were housed onsite at the resort. The study was approved by the University of California, San Diego Human Subjects Research Protections Program Investigational Review Board and performed in accordance with institutional guidelines for research with human subjects. The SBTI study was registered at ClinicalTrials.gov as NCT02481544
It’s interesting to note what the cleanse consisted of. It’s more than just eating a vegetarian diet. For instance, there’s an AM “detox” involving potassium glycinate, a supplement containing Manjishtha (Rubia cordifolia) root, Guduchi (Tinospora cordifolia) root, Kutki (Picrorhiza kurroa) root, Punarnava (Boerhavia diffusa) root, Neem (Azadirachta indica) leaf, Musta (Cyperus rotundus) root, Gokshura (Tribulus terristris) aerial parts, Bhumyamalaki (Phyllanthus niruri) whole plant; another supplement containing dandelion root, burdock root, milk thistle seed, artichoke leaf, parsley leaf, mullein leaf, uva ursi leaf; and a third supplement containing Alpha-lipoic acid, calcium D-glucarate, N-acetyl cysteine, inositol. The PM cleanse involves magnesium oxide and a supplement with cascara sagrada bark, chitrak (Plumbago zeylanica) root, marshmallow root, slippery elm bark, prune fruit, fennel seed, peppermint leaf, and ginger root.
The cleanse itself involves:
A.Upon Rising: Take 4 AM Detox Capsules with 8 oz. of water at least 15 minutes prior to breakfast and at least 15 minutes before taking the Fiber-Herb Blend.B.Breakfast: Take 1 scoop of Fiber Blend with 8 oz. of water, 1 Tbsp. Detox Oil, and a sensible mealC.Freshly prepared Ayurvedic breakfast meal provided.D.Lunch: Ayurvedic meal provided.E.Dinner: Take 1 scoop of Fiber Blend with 8 oz. of water, 1 Tbsp. Detox Oil, and Ayurvedic meal on your own.F.Bedtime: Take 2 capsules PM Cleanse with 8 oz. of water before going to bed and at least 15 minutes after taking Fiber Blend.G.Drinks
     1.  Plenty of water every day – about six 8-oz. glasses.
     2.  Hot water with sliced fresh ginger frequently throughout the day.
     3.  Herbal, non-caffeinated teas.
     4.  Vegetable juice.
     5.  Avoid alcohol, soda and caffeine.
H.Yoga: Two 1-hour yoga classes per day.I.Meditation: Two to three 20-minute mantra-based silent meditation practices per day.J.Massage: Hour-long Ayurvedic massage treatment and external oleation per day.K.Heat therapies: Choice of dry or wet sauna and Ushma Svedana (steam tent) treatment.L.Lectures: Practical morning and afternoon lectures on well-being, food and self-care.
Avoid alcohol and caffeine? This is not the sort of vacation I’d be interested in.
In any case, the researchers drew fasting blood samples from each participant at the beginning and the end of the six day program metabolomics analysis. To their credit, all metabolomic analyses were done blind to treatment arm, and 186 metabolites were measured using the AbsoluteIDQ® p180 kit and liquid chromatography-mass spectroscopy (LC-MS) or Flow Injection Analysis method (FIA-MS/MS). The authors did observe a change in several metabolites in the PH group, including significant reductions in 12 phosphatidylcholines and significant changes in an additional 57 metabolites classified as amino acids, biogenic amines, acylcarnitines, glycerophospholipids and sphingolipids were observed in the PH compared to the control group. To be honest, it’s not that important that you understand what all of these are, other than that phosphatidylcholines are membrane phospholipids that consist of a glycerol core with a choline head group and two fatty acid residue and that eggs are a primary source of phospholipids. What’s so clear that even the authors have to admit it is that it is almost certain that the changes in the levels of these metabolites almost certainly are a result of the diet and supplements. The authors note, for instance, that lower serum phosphatidylcholine and sphingolipid levels have been reported in vegans and vegetarians compared to meat eaters; so it is not at all surprising that they would see the same thing. It’s also been noted that certain phosphatidylcholines have been found to be inversely related to risk of type II diabetes, although the authors could make no comment on whether the profile changes they observed are associated with decreased risk of any disease.
None of that stopped them from speculating wildly, though:
Many dietary constituents serve as substrates that are metabolized by the gut microbiota into products that can alter host physiology. The significant alterations in plasma metabolites following PH are consistent with previous studies that reported that the gut microbiota and host metabolism are altered rapidly following a dietary shift23,24,25. The absence of meat and minimal dairy products in the PH diet are consistent with the alterations in plasma metabolites observed and may suggest that diet may have an impact on the plasma analytes reported here. The timeframe of these changes is consistent with reports comparing human subjects, using a cross over design, consuming an omnivorous or vegetarian diet. The gut microbiota composition displayed marked change after just 1 day with additional changes occurring over the following 6 days post-intervention.
One notes that no data are presented to demonstrate that the gut microbiota changed in the PH group, although, given how the “cleanse” almost certainly induced a bit of diarrhea (or at least loose stools) and a diet without meat can change the gut microbiota, it would be surprising if there were no change. Even so, no health benefit was really demonstrated. Again, as I characterize this study earlier, it was just a big fishing expedition that didn’t really provide much in the way of interesting hypotheses to pursue. Also, given the non-random assignment of the “expert meditators” one can’t help but wonder if they skewed the experimental group based on other confounders.
Which brings us to the study I became aware of last week.
“Mind-body” practices and “spiritual awakening”
The first study looked at a bunch of genomic signatures in the various groups being studied. The second study did not. Rather, it looked at how the members of the various experimental groups felt. Naturally, it wasn’t published in a journal like Translational Psychiatry, which is fairly well respected and has a decent impact factor. Instead, it was published—where else?—in the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine (JACM). Yes, that’s the same journal edited by our old friend John Weeks. The title of the paper ought to tell you all you need to know: “Change in Sense of Nondual Awareness and Spiritual Awakening in Response to a Multidimensional Well-Being Program.” It is truly a masterpiece of quackademic medicine woo, although it does suffer for not once invoking the word “quantum.”
This study looks at the same three groups. In this case, they were asked to fill out questionnaires three times, once at home before the program, once immediately after finishing the program, and once a month later at home. Three of the instruments were fairly unremarkable, such as the 20-item self-report screening tool for depressive symptoms was developed by the National Institute of Mental Health, an eight-item scale that is part of the National Institute of Health research initiative, the Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement System (PROMIS), and the Delaney Spirituality Scale. The scale that really drew my attention, though, was the Nondual Embodiment Thematic Inventory (NETI), which, unlike the other three scales, was the primary outcome of this study. Here’s how it’s described:
Although there are a number of standardized questionnaires that assess spiritual and transpersonal constructs,31–33 few specifically address nondual awareness. For this study, the NETI, a 20-item questionnaire that was developed by John Astin and David A. Butlein, was used. Butlein and a team of experts in nonduality attempt to evaluate qualities of the nondual experience and spiritual awakening.34–37 The NETI yields a single total score that can range from 20 to 100 and attempts to differentiate between individuals with transpersonal ideas from individuals who live the transpersonal at the deepest levels possible.34 The qualities that the scale assesses include compassion, resilience, propensity to surrender, interest in truth, defensiveness, capacity to tolerate cognitive dissonance and/or emotional discomfort, gratitude, frequency of nondual experience, anxiety level, motivational paradigm, authenticity, level of disidentification from the mind, and humility34 (Appendix).
You should look at the scale, as it’s really rather odd. Here are a couple of the questions:
6. Understanding that there is ultimately no separation between what I call my “self” and the whole of existence. Please choose only one of the following:
     1.  Never
     2.  Rarely
     3.  Sometimes
     4.  Most of the time
     5.  All of the time
And:
9. Conscious awareness of my nonseparation from (essential oneness with) a transcendent reality, source, higher power, spirit, god, etc. Please choose only one of the following:
     1.  Never
     2.  Rarely
     3.  Sometimes
     4.  Most of the time
     5.  All of the time
And:
20. A sense of the flawlessness and beauty of everything and everyone, just as they are. Please choose only one of the following:
     1.  Never
     2.  Rarely
     3.  Sometimes
     4.  Most of the time
     5.  All of the time
Of note, this scale, as far as I can tell, has never been validated for anything, much less “nondual” awareness, which, I gather, is woo-babble for being “at one with the universe,” or some such thing. In any case, the authors report that the NETI score increased in the PH group compared to controls. Specifically, in the PH group, it increased from 63.8 to 74.4; in the control group, it increased from 62.8 to 67.8. The authors also noted that both groups showed similar decreases in depressed mood and anxiety; so basically the PH program did no better than a one week vacation for general mental health. They also noted that the NETI score correlated with the Delaney Spirituality Scale.
Interestingly, there was a difference in the dropout rate between the two groups. Out of 65 in the PH group who underwent the program, only 33 (51%) completed the immediate post-intervention follow-up questionnaire and only 20 (31%) completed the one month follow-up. This is in contrast to the control group, where, out of 54 participants, 36 (67%) completed the questionnaire immediately following the intervention, and 25 (46%) completed it one month later. These are both high rates of dropout, and it’s odd that the intervention group would have the higher rate of dropout. Basically, it’s a huge problem with the study when the dropout rate is that high.
So what does this study mean? Hell if I know! It shows no positive results using the two validated instruments and only shows a result using the made-up instrument which, we are assured, correlates with spirituality, even though it wasn’t designed to assess spirituality. I’m just glad that NIH money didn’t go to fund this study for a change.
The problem with Georgetown and all too many academic medical centers
While it wasn’t Georgetown faculty who did this study and collaborated with Deepak Chopra, Georgetown is indeed a major center of quackademic medicine, as I described last time when I listed all the nonsense that it offers. What stood out to me about Georgetown was, in fact, the very program founded by Amri and Haramati, not so much because it taught CAM. That’s unfortunately very common these days. Rather, it was how the CAM was taught. Specifically CAM was—if you’ll excuse the term—”integrated” into the medical school curriculum from day one. I frequently cite the example of how at Georgetown an acupuncturist would teach a session of gross anatomy to point out where acupuncture meridians are. Never mind that no one has ever convincingly demonstrated an association between meridians and any anatomic structure. Similarly, an acupuncturist would teach a session of neuroanatomy and neurobiology to describe how acupuncture modulates pain. Never mind that it’s never been convincingly demonstrated that acupuncture is anything more than a theatrical placebo.
Yet in the article for which I was interviewed:
The CAM faculty doesn’t see it that way, however. “As scientists and academicians, as long as we have the evidence, and our statements are evidence-based, then that’s what we’re going to teach our students,” Amri said. “I want [our critics] to show me what they have read that is really a good study, and shows negative effects. If there are negative effects, I want to know also. I want to show that to the students. We are not teaching the students to become advocates of the field. That’s not our focus. Our focus is to teach them how to separate the good from the bad.”
I can’t help but contrast Amri’s statement above with her statement three years ago for Georgetown Medicine:
Amri enjoys seeing students open their minds to new concepts. Learning disciplines like homeopathy may require students to radically disregard their previous understandings about receptors and responses in toxicology, for example. “I tell students that for the next few hours, put aside all they have learned in biochemistry, pharmacology and cell biology—empty their brains—because homeopathy is a completely different concept. Then I see big eyes on their faces!” laughs Amri.
Well, yes. Accepting homeopathy does rather require one to empty one’s brain of science.
In fairness, Amri states again that she is evidence-based and that her goal is to prepare students to separate the wheat from the chaff. Still, her expressed glee at teaching homeopathy and seeing students’ reaction to it rather belies her claim to be all about the science.
Her partner in woo is no better:
Haramati, a self-described skeptic, sees this as in line with Georgetown’s Jesuit philosophy. When he started the program, he met with university President DeGioia, and warned him that there could be pushback. “I told him, ‘We are going to explore areas with objectivity, and with rigor, and isn’t that the Jesuit way?’”
And:
The Department of Defense, in response to the opioid epidemic, has been investigating acupuncture, mindfulness, and other integrative treatments to help veterans with chronic pain. “This is the military,” Haramati said. “They’re not exactly San Francisco hippies.” The CAM program itself uses the same scientific standards as any other program in the Medical Center. “We’re not going to be teaching students about crystals. We are careful about what subjects we bring to the table. There is something called ‘biological plausibility,’ where we start with practices that are common and which there is an evidence base for.”
Actually, as we’ve documented many times before, the military is not what I’d call the greatest example to point to for scientific rigor in medicine. The Veterans Health Administration is actively pushing naturopathy and auricular acupuncture, while the military itself is promoting pure quackery. As for biological plausibility, all I can say is: “Biological plausibility. You keep using that term. I do not think it means what you think it means.” Why do I say that? Because, as I documented before, Georgetown offers “energy medicine” in the form of reiki in the chemotherapy suite. As I say so often, reiki is nothing more than faith healing based on a religion other than Christianity; it has about as close to zero biological plausibility as you can imagine. Georgetown also offers cupping, which is also pure quackery with close to zero biological plausibility. Ditto the cranial osteopathy that it teaches, whose biological plausibility is nonexistent because the anatomic structures and physiologic processes that it claims to utilize do not exist and do not work the way claimed. There’s a reason Mark Crislip once called craniosacral therapy a “sCAM of infinite jest.” I’d love to hear Drs. Amri and Haramati explain to me the biological plausibility of these modalities. I really would. I’d also like to know why Georgetown has a reiki master as one of its “mind-body facilitators.”
Doctors running integrative medicine programs like the one at Georgetown like to claim that they are evidence-based, that they are all about the science, that they don’t do anything that doesn’t have scientific support. They are deluding themselves. Meanwhile, they continue to get away with it because patients like it and because the vast majority of their colleagues are shruggies. It’s the reason why real scientists will willingly team up with New Age mystics like Deepak Chopra undertake quackademic “research.”

   Quackery tolerance – a learned response
Wallace Sampson
Links
Academic politeness turns to the vicious This is more on the theme of academic and postmodern roots of sectarianism-quackery’s advance on medicine. I illustrate through the personal experience of a noted combatant – Mary Lefkowitz - in the front lines of the war with intellectual and academic buffoonery passing as scholarship. The joke is not in the buffoonery, though. The joke is turning on us.
Some of you are familiar with Prof.Lefkowitz’s academic dispute from publicity last spring. Prof. Lefkowitz is on the list of academic opponents to relativism and postmodernism. Lefkowitz’s travail began in 1993 when another Wellesley faculty member who led a department or course of Africana Studies claimed in lectures that ancient Greek and Roman intellectual advances were lifted from libraries and other sources of ancient Egypt, and that furthermore, those Egyptians were black Africans.
You recognize this as Afrocentrism, one of relativism and postmodernism’s multi-pronged attack on intellectualism and Western civilization. I attended a session on the problem in 1992 (or so) at the AAAS in San Francisco, and did not appreciate or understand what was going on, or why the raised rhetoric and voices. I do now, especially having read excerpts from Lefkowitz’s book, History Lesson, published earlier this year.
Pertinent accountings of History Lesson’s contents can be read in a number of reviews last spring and summer, from the Times of London to NYT and WSJ. Much of this post comes from those reviews, as I did not locate a copy of the book in time. (I’m ordering it.)
Back to Prof. Lefkowitz. As an authority and a scholar of Greek and Roman civilizations, she had opposed this Afrocentric historical claim in essays and books. (one titled Not Out of Africa.) She also attempted to have the title of Martin’s course changed. Several exhanges through writings and university committees ensued. Martin eventually sued Lefkowitz for defamation because she recounted publicly a witness‘s account of a confrontation between Martin and a female student. Martin felt Lefkowitz defamed him.
The details sketched: At a meeting in a residence hall, Martin stood to go to a bathroom, and the student, who was responsible for implementing the hall’s policy that someone accompany persons in the dorm asked Martin who would accompany him through the hall. Martin took it as a racial slur and berated the student. Here is where accounts differ, as Lefkowitz described a witness’s account that Martin threatened the student, who fell to the floor, whereupon Martin bent over her, continuing to harangue. Martin denied doing that. So he sued his adversary for defamation.
After four years of motions to dismiss, denials, appeals of denials and so forth, a judge panel threw out the case. But not before the Wellesley administration distinguished itself by not taking sides., and by refusing even to consider the teaching of falsified history and false information. I do not know about the present status of teaching such claims, but many of us remain amazed that under academic freedom, such pap can be taught to naïve, malleable undergraduates, who do not have the maturity or knowledge to evaluate what is being taught.
In looking for causes of the present institutionalization of quackery, its renaming, and recent acceptance in medical schools, we have the perfect storm of a predecessor. Academic correctness and the failure to define, recognize and distinguish fakery and implausibility.

A Culture of Standards Matters
Perhaps the most dangerous effect of the alternative medicine movement has been an erosion of the culture of dedication to science and standards within medicine. This has to change.
Steven Novella on September 12, 2018
Link
We are often asked “What’s the harm?” when it comes to apparently benign placebo interventions for subjective symptoms. “If people feel better, who cares if it’s pseudoscience?” We have had to point out, endlessly, that there is a great deal of potential harm – delay or even avoidance of effective treatment, opportunity costs, financial harm, psychological harm, and overall promotion of unscientific medicine.
Perhaps the most insidious form of harm, however, comes from the erosion of standards within the medical profession. Medicine is only science-based and ethical if its practitioners are science-based and ethical. There is a standard of care within medicine to maintain a minimum of both quality and ethics.
The erosion of standards takes two basic forms – weakening of the system that maintains standards, and a softening of the culture of dedication to patients, science, and ethics among practitioners. I have discussed before how proponents of alternative medicine have been (successfully) seeking to weaken the regulations that maintain the standard of care, to remove protections for consumers, to change the rules of science to favor their preferred treatments, and to introduce magical thinking into medicine. They are literally changing the laws and regulations to lower the guardrails.
But perhaps an even more damaging effect of the alternative medicine movement is the slow change in the culture. You can post whatever speed limits you want, but if the culture is such that drivers routinely ignore the speed limits, and police routinely look the other way (or simply don’t have the resources or authority to do much about it), the posted limits become meaningless.
Regardless of your political leanings or whether you think the current administration is a good or bad thing for our country, it has clearly demonstrated that our elaborate system of checks and balances mean nothing if individual politicians are not motivated to adhere to them. No system and no institution is robust enough to withstand a culture of disregard for established standards.
This is exactly what I am seeing among a disturbing number of my medical colleagues. Alternative medicine propaganda has been slowly leaching into the medical culture, it has infiltrated medical education and is therefore changing with the generations, and it has weakened our collective dedication to a rigorous science-based standard of care.
I now see many more instances of otherwise reasonable science-based practitioners routinely referring to chiropractors, naturopaths, or acupuncturists without really knowing the kind of care their patients will be receiving, for example.
Perhaps the most common example is medical practitioners actually recommending pseudoscientific interventions, mostly for symptomatic treatment. They have bought into the “What’s the harm?” argument, or the placebo medicine argument of “Who cares if it really works if the patient subjectively feels better?”
This has always been a tempting practice. Everyone will accumulate patients who are difficult to treat, or have symptoms that are refractory to standard interventions. It is tempting to essentially punt, give them some placebo intervention to distract them (for a while, at least) so at least they will call your office less often. It is easy to convince yourself that this is OK – it’s OK to recommend pseudoscience to your patients, as long as its “harmless” pseudoscience.
The harder road, but the one that is better for your patients, is to carefully vet any practitioner or any treatment that you recommend, to make sure they are above the waterline in terms of scientific legitimacy and ethical standards. At the very least, the ethical standard of informed consent demands that you give your patients adequate information.
When patients ask me about an unscientific intervention, I tell them, “I don’t recommend that because I have reviewed the evidence and it is: not convincing, not plausible, too preliminary, or may even demonstrate lack of efficacy.” If they still decide to pursue it, at least you gave them your honest, professional, and informed opinion, and you did your due diligence.
Even worse is the increase in the number of practitioners and institutions who are increasing their income by directly selling pseudoscience. I know many local practitioners who are regular doctors, but they also have a cryotherapy chamber in their office, or sell aromatherapy supplements. Hospitals now routinely offer alternative treatments as add-ons for “quality of life”. Sure, we’ll have someone wave their hands over you for a fee. It’s almost free money.
The only thing that is really keeping doctors and hospitals from practicing rank but lucrative quackery is a culture of dedication to scientific standards in medicine. As that culture erodes, quackery increases.
And that is what the alternative medicine movement has always been about – it is about promoting profitable snake oil. Pesky laws, regulations, and the standard of care have been an obstacle to selling snake oil, and so the purveyors of all sorts of dubious treatments have campaigned to weaken the laws and regulations, and to abolish the standard of care.
They have largely succeeded. I don’t mean that there isn’t dedication to science within medicine, or many practitioners who do maintain high standards. Rather, I mean that the system now happily accommodates anyone who wants to sell snake oil alongside legitimate medicine. It’s all good.
I don’t know if it’s too late to turn this ship around. I’m hoping it isn’t. It will take scientists, academics, and serious politicians to wake up and see what is happening. There are signs of progress here and there, like the retreat of homeopathy over the last decade. It is still possible to make an argument that magic water doesn’t work and should not be accepted as a legitimate part of medicine.
But it will take those of us who clearly see the need for standards and the harm of pseudoscience in medicine to continue to forcefully make our case. Science matters. Standards matter. And while institutions and regulations matter also – the most important thing is a culture of respect for science and standards.

The facts of the alternative medicine industry
Scott Gavura on August 15, 2013
Link
People have been living on earth for about 250,000 years. For the past 5,000 healers have been trying to heal the sick. For all but the past 200, they haven’t been very good at it.
– Dr. Paul Offit
Twenty years is a long time in medicine. I celebrated my 20th pharmacy class reunion last weekend. Of course reunions are time to reflect back to our early years as pharmacists. Lots has changed. Much of the therapeutics I was taught is now obsolete. In 1993, HIV was a death sentence and there were only three, largely ineffective drugs available. Thanks to new drugs, HIV can now be managed like a chronic disease, and some of my colleagues have HIV-focused pharmacy practices. The same dramatic changes have occurred in fields like cancer and transplant medicine. And in some cases, the cause of disease has become more clear – my old textbooks make no mention of Helicobacter pylori as a cause of ulcers.
The practice of pharmacy has changed, too. On the positive side, pharmacists are working in new settings where they can focus on medication management, and not just dispensing prescriptions. Regulators are granting pharmacists the ability to take on new roles, and pharmacists are being compensated for more than simply “count, pour, lick and stick.” From that perspective, it’s a promising time to be a pharmacist. But there’s a much more disturbing side to the profession that’s emerging, too. Community (retail) pharmacy practice is under pricing and competitive pressure, and smaller pharmacies are being subsumed into big retailers where the pharmacy department is buried in the back – a loss leader to bring in patients, but hardly with a health-care focus. And most disturbingly, I see a move within retail pharmacy practice to leverage its professional credibility to sell all types of modern-day snake oil, ranging from detox kits and “cleanses” to dubious “food intolerance” testing. Homeopathic remedies (an elaborate placebo system of sugar pills) are increasingly found on pharmacy shelves, alongside real medicine. And don’t forget the enormous wall of vitamins that seems to get larger and larger. Yes, complementary and alternative medicine is booming, and pharmacy wants its share. Pharmacy regulators turn a blind eye. What do my pharmacy colleagues tell me? They’ll tell me it’s customer demand, and that they don’t recommend the quackery. To me, I see this trend as damaging the credibility of pharmacists in the eyes of the public and of other health professionals.
I understand that medicine is a business and that alternative medicine is a business; but part of the difference in medicine is that we’re supposed to have professional norms, professional values, and professional commitments. If you keep telling people it’s just a marketplace and that they’re just clients and that autonomy of the patient is what must be served to make them happy customers, they you have a collapse of professionalism in the face of consumer demand.– Art Caplan
The progress of medicine, the changing face of pharmacy, and the growing demand for alternative medicine all been percolating in my mind over the past few weeks. It’s almost inconceivable that in 2013 the same pharmacist that dispenses your targeted cancer treatment, one that cost hundreds of millions to develop, and is literally saving your life, may also sell homeopathic remedies and other alternative medicine nostrums, some of which are based on medieval ideas of disease. In integrating alternative medicine into what should be a science-based practice, pharmacists aren’t improving patient care, but doing the opposite. They’re promoting magical thinking, and damaging the profession.
I’ve been writing about, and advocating for, science-based medicine since I spent an early part of my pharmacy career in pharmacy with a strong focus on alternative products. Not having learned much about these products in pharmacy school, I did my research. And what I found was disturbing. Not only were most of these products not backed by good evidence, but some were highly questionable – even risky. Yet the entire regulatory structure was tilted in favour of manufacturers. There was little manufacturing oversight, and even less oversight of the treatment claims being advertised. And never any mention of potential risks. Yet their popularity continued to grow.
If the lack of science supporting alternative and complementary medicine isn’t self-evident to health professionals, is it any surprise that the broader public can’t see the problem? And what explains its popularity in the face of the scientific evidence? Dr. Paul Offit’s new book, Do You Believe in Magic? is an attempt to address that. It’s a concise, comprehensive and highly readable summary of the facts of complementary and alternative medicine. While I’ve never met Dr. Offit, I’ve been an admirer for several years. It’s not just the real science he’s done, like leading the invention of the RotaTeq rotavirus vaccine, preventing infectious diarrhea which killed hundreds of thousands of children every year. And it’s not the fact that he’s a pediatric infectious disease physician. He continues to be a strong and vocal advocate for the safe and effective use of vaccines, which drives the anti-vaccine movement to distraction. He doesn’t flinch, he doesn’t hide, and he calls a spade a spade. One of my favorite references on the autism-vaccine manufactroversy is Offit’s 2008 book, Autism’s False Prophets, which exposes the anti-vaccine movement and its tactics. Not surprisingly the release of his new book is driving antivaccinationists even more apoplectic. Unbelievably, he’s even received death threats for his pro-science, pro-vaccine stances. It’s amazing he continues to take the heat of the public eye. But we’re lucky he does, because Offit is a gifted writer, with the ability to summarize complex topics in ways that are engaging and simple, without being simplistic or dismissive. It’s one of the reasons why I enjoyed his newest book so much. (In the interest of full disclosure, I should note that I received a copy of the book from Dr. Offit.)
Offit opens the book with a revealing and quite personal chapter – his own experience as a patient in the health care system. He describes the disappointing care he’s received throughout his life which is astonishing given Offit’s a physician himself – an insider. From being born with clubfeet (the treatment of which left him with chronic pain) through a cancer misdiagnosis in his twenties followed by orthopedic and prostate problems, he describes his medical care, its limitations, and the alternative medicine advice he received from others, ranging from acupuncture to chiropractic to naturopathy. Offit looked closely at the scientific evidence supporting these practices – and found them lacking or non-existent, which mystified him given their growing popularity.
Offit describes the rise and eventual fall of an alternative medicine treatment from the 1970’s called laetrile to illustrate the factors driving the popularity of alternative medicine. Laetrile is something SBM’s own Kimball Atwood described as “the most lucrative health fraud ever perpetrated in the United States.” And while Atwood and other have written at length about this quack cancer remedy, I admit that I didn’t fully understand the social and political context that drove its popularity. Offit describes the case of Joey Hofbauer, a seven-year-old child diagnosed with Hodgkin’s disease, a highly treatable cancer which can be cured (yes, cured) in many cases with chemotherapy and radiation. When Hofbauer’s parents decided to use a laetrile, a “natural” remedy derived from apricot pits, it set off a legal battle of medicine versus alternative medicine where ultimately, quackery prevailed – in the court, at least. A health victory, however, was denied to poor Joey who quickly died of the cancer; an unnecessary cancer death, and a young life cut short by the laetrile movement. Offit describes the contributors to laetrile’s popularity that he believes continue to drive alternative medicine’s popularity today:
    • a distrust of modern medicine
    • the idea that vitamin supplements are beneficial
    • the belief that natural products are safe and effective
    • the charisma of purveyors of natural products
    • the power of celebrity
    • the influence of the natural products industry
The remainder of the book weaves an analysis of these factors with a critical appraisal of alternative medicine practices, and its proponents.
Dr. Oz, Deepak Chopra, and the distrust of modern medicine
In a sense, The Dr. Oz show is a voyage back through the history of medicine, starting with our most primitive concepts of disease: supernatural forces.– Dr. Paul Offit
I’ve called Dr. Mehmet Oz the biggest purveyor of health pseudoscience and bad health advice on television, and I stand by that description. He’s an accomplished surgeon who brings reiki into the operating room. Oz is the perfect host for a daytime television show that seems to prove each episode that there is no alternative health practice so absurd that it doesn’t deserve a breathless description (“miracle!”) and endorsement. The show, watched by millions daily, regularly promotes debunked, ineffective and even dangerous practices like homeopathy, naturopathy, acupuncture, and chiropractic. He’s profiled psychics and faith healers, too. Offit argues that common thread is Oz’s interest in the supernatural and the occult, which he seems to believe are equally legitimate as science-based treatments. In that way, Offit argues, Andrew Weil and Deepak Chopra have the same schtick – albeit with different approaches. For Weil, it’s Spontaneous Healing, where health is a manifestation of good and evil. For Oz, it’s Ageless Body, Timeless Mind, and what seems to be a never-ending collection of meaningless platitudes that are seem so inane that a bot can generate them.
Why are these gurus so popular? Offit argues it’s what they offer to the public: empowerment and certainty. Medicine is changing constantly as new scientific evidence emerges. It’s confusing and complicated. So why not try a healing system that hasn’t changed since it was invented – like homeopathy? Rather than appreciate the complexity of medicine, why not empower yourself with simplistic ancient wisdom, instead? Feel like you’re being treated with a cookie cutter approach to your health issues? Personalize your own care with what feels right to you. Follow the mantra, buy the book and watch the episode, and you will live a happier, more successful life. It’s natural, and natural is good.
The vitamin con
Do we need vitamins? Yes. Do we need vitamin supplements? In most cases, no. I’ve previously described one of the biggest contributors to the fallacious perception that vitamins are beneficial – Linus Pauling, a truly brilliant scientist whose descent into quackery was as impressive (yet unfortunate) as his scientific contributions. Offit uses Pauling as the starting point for a comprehensive yet concise overview of the current state of the evidence for vitamin supplementation. (There is a substantial excerpt available in a piece published in The Atlantic. What’s most baffling is not that most vitamins are useless at best and harmful at worst. What’s surprising is the sales of vitamins seem completely immune to negative publicity. One negative clinical trial can kill a drug, but Offit notes that vitamin sales seem to be impervious to the evidence. The reason will be well known to regular readers of this blog: a weak ineffective regulatory structure has been designed by the supplement industry to keep consumers as ignorant as possible about the evidence supporting these products.
Natural doesn’t equal safe or effective
One of the consistent arguments put forward by contributors to this blog is that all products need to be held to a consistent, science-based standard of evidence. Simply because a product is naturally-derived doesn’t mean it is safe or effective, or merits a waiver of scientific scrutiny. Consequently, the impact and consequences of the American Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act of 1994 (DSHEA) has been the topic of many posts. The DSHEA established the American regulatory framework for dietary supplements and effectively excludes manufacturers of these products from virtually all regulations that are in place for prescription and over-the-counter drugs. Remarkably, the DSHEA puts the requirement to demonstrate harm on the Food and Drug Administration, rather than putting the onus on the manufacturer to show a product is safe and effective. Offit dedicates a chapter to supplement regulation, contrasting it with drug regulation to illustrate how the current framework evolved. It wasn’t by accident: The natural products industry explicitly and deliberately set out to ensure it would be exempted from any requirement to demonstrate that their products were either safe or effective. While branded with a message of “health freedom” for consumers, it was really about the freedom for manufacturers to offer products without the testing expected of other products. The lobbying and politics were stunningly effective, which today leaves consumers largely in the dark about the products they’re buying. The result? A perpetuation of the dichotomy that supplements natural and therefore safe. On the other side are drug products, held to completely different standards.
The consequences of a weakened regulatory structure
Today, there are thousands and thousands of supplements for sale. Do any work? The evidence is lacking for most. With little incentive to test their products, manufacturers often bring products to market without any credible evidence of efficacy. And the contrast with science-based medicine can be striking. There’s no effective drug treatment for dementia, but there are plenty of supplements with claims of benefit. Echinacea doesn’t prevent or treat colds, but it’s a $130 million-per-year business. Today you find supplements to treat most serious medical conditions, and even made up diseases, like “adrenal fatigue”. Offit discusses the duds but also the products that do have some promising evidence, including omega-3 acids to prevent heart disease, calcium and vitamin D for osteoporosis, and folic acid during pregnancy.
Another consequence of a regulatory structure where the scientific evidence isn’t relevant is the influence of celebrity endorsements and even political pressure. Offit profiles three cases:
    • Suzanne Somers, who promoted dangerous misinformation about cancer while also hyping bioidentical hormones as an anti-aging panacea.
    • Jenny McCarthy, one of the most outspoken anti-vaccine advocates in the media today whose antics have been well documented at this blog. Offit explains the harms of her actions and describes how her anti-vaccine advocacy continues to threaten public health.
    • Attorney General Richard Blumenthal, who tried to legislate “Chronic Lyme Disease” into existence. Offit illustrates how the battle over Lyme disease has become politicized, illustrating the pseudoscientific and dangerous treatments that are offered in the absence of good evidence.
The Burzynski Clinic
There is unlikely to be larger collection of articles on cancer quack Stanislaw Burzynski and his urine-based cancer treatments, (branded as “antineoplastons”) than those written by SBM’s very own David Gorski, who has dedicated thousands of words to the topic. Offit dedicates full chapter to Burzynski’s story, illustrating his promising beginnings, his move away from credible science, and his current cancer practice. Importantly, Offit summarizes what multiple independent reviews of Burzyski’s treatments have concluded: that there is no convincing evidence that Burzynski’s antineoplastons work. The consequences are grim: these treatments continue to be sold for hundreds of thousands of dollars to desperate patients in life-threatening circumstances. Perhaps not surprisingly, one of the biggest boosters of Burzynski is Suzanne Somers.
The chelation cure-all
The name Rashid Buttar may not be as familiar as Stanislaw Burzynski, but his medical practice is equally dubious. Buttar is a strong proponent of chelation, treatments which bind and eliminate heavy metals from the body. According to Buttar, virtually every medical illness is due to “toxins”, and chelation is the universal solution. Offit describes the lack of science underlying Buttar’s ideas, and how Buttar illustrates the hallmarks of today’s medical huckster: offering unproven, scientifically questionable treatments, stating that mainstream medicine is wrong and out to get him, and that his solution (while untested) should be trusted without any doubts.
Why we think alternative medicine works
Offit concludes his book with a thorough discussion of placebo effects, summarizing some of the research that has established that treatments like acupuncture lack any objective effects. That is, acupuncture is a theatrical placebo. As better-quality research increasingly confirms that the effects from alternative medicine appear to be attributable to placebo effects, it is important to note that there is no persuasive evidence to suggest that placebo effects offer any meaningful health benefits. If I had one quibble in this book, it is that Offit doesn’t discuss the newest tactic of alternative medicine promoters – as it becomes increasingly clear that many alternative medicine approaches have no therapeutic effects, “treatments” such as acupuncture or homeopathy are increasingly promoted as strategies that ”harness the power of placebo” without all the pesky costs or side effects of real medical interventions. We are seeing proponents spinning placebo effects as meaningful and worthy of pursuit. Offit’s arguments are somewhat congruent with this position, though he argues this can be done better with real medicine rather than the theatrical rituals and magical thinking offered by alternative medicine purveyors today.
Conclusion
Do You Believe in Magic? is a comprehensive and compelling analysis of the alternative medicine industry, which will appeal to both the regular and the casual SBM reader. More generally, it would be an excellent read for anyone with a passing or deep interest in alternative medicine. Importantly, Offit’s book nicely explains the problems with the continued false dichotomy of describing “alternative medicine” as an entity of treatments and products. Alternative medicine that actually works is no longer alternative: it is simply called medicine. The rest is unproven, or proven ineffective. I’m often asked for resources on science-based medicine for people that don’t read blogs. Offit’s book is an excellent single reference that accurately and concisely summarizes the facts of the alternative medicine industry.

   Medical Schools And Hospitals

   CAM In Medical Schools
Steven Novella 
Link
A recent US News and World Report article on the incorporation of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) into US medical schools credulously repeats the pro-CAM marketing hype. There is no evidence that the author, Meryl Davids Landau, spoke to a single critic of CAM, or is even aware that such criticism exists. The result looks more like marketing copy than serious journalism.
She begins:
Now that nearly 40 percent of American adults swear by some form of complementary and alternative medicine, or CAM—from nutrition and mental relaxation to acupuncture, magnet therapy, and foreign healing systems like traditional Chinese medicine and Indian ayurveda—a growing number of medical schools, too, are supplementing medication with meditation.
There is much to deconstruct just in this first paragraph. The entire article in an argument from popularity. This is a game the pro-CAM community has been playing for years. People are using CAM because it’s popular; medical schools should teach it because people are using it; the government should research it because of all the interest in it; and CAM should be popular because it’s being researched and taught in medical schools. CAM is like Paris Hilton – famous for being famous.
What’s missing from this circular argument for popularity is evidence that any particular CAM modality actually works, or even has scientific plausibility or the potential to teach us something new about the human body and healing.
The argument is not only fallacious – it’s wrong, or at least highly deceptive. This stems from the core fallacy of CAM, and that’s the very concept of CAM itself. It is a false category, which does not describe any cohesive philosophy or approach to medicine but rather exists solely as a marketing ploy to carve out a double standard – to exempt certain modalities from the rigors of science, evidence, and logic. This false dichotomy results in lumping a wide variety of treatments under one umbrella, and then claiming that the entire category is popular.
When we look a little closer at the numbers we find that the vast majority of so-called CAM use in the US is either massage (16%), chiropractic or osteopathic manipulation (21.9%), and yoga (9.5%). (There is overlap in use so you can’t simply add these percentages, but the vast majority of the mythical “40%” figure comes from these categories.) So some form of exercise, stretching, or muscle manipulation accounts for the vast majority of CAM use. Throw in some other modalities that are not really CAM, like relaxation and nutrition (since when has the science of nutrition been alternative to science) and that accounts for even more.
What’s left for the real hardcore CAM modalities like homeopathy and acupuncture? Not much. These modalities have been languishing in the single digits and not significantly increasing. But by lumping them in which relaxation and massage you can generate the false impression that the whole category is popular. The entire exercise is intellectually sloppy and deceptive – by design. And this deception is being used to convince medical schools that “CAM” deserves access to the limited resources of the school, which is then used to convince patients that it’s legitimate (more circular reasoning).
And we’re just at the first paragraph. She continues:
Interest in teaching alternative approaches “has exploded, especially this last year,” says Laurie Hofmann, executive director of the Institute for Functional Medicine, which is based in Gig Harbor, Wash. The nonprofit institute educates healthcare professionals to look for underlying systemic imbalances as a cause of illness rather than focus on treating symptoms and, when possible, to correct with lifestyle changes and mind-body techniques.
No evidence is offered for this alleged “explosion” in interest. What’s missing from the article is any mention of the Bravewell Collaboration – a funding organization that pays medical schools to open up CAM centers. This is part of a very deliberate “quiet revolution” that Wally Sampson has written extensively about, an attempt to change the practice of medicine by influencing medical education (rather than through compelling evidence).
Landau then repeats, without the slightest hint of journalistic skepticism, the claim that “integrative” medicine looks for underlying causes of illness, while mainstream medicine simply treats the symptoms. This is pure CAM marketing mythology, having no basis in reality. Science-based medicine is built upon a systematic attempt to understand the underlying cause of illness. Of course, when scientific medicine searches for underlying causes this is denigrated by CAM proponents are “reductionist.” When they do it, it’s “holistic.”
The difference between the scientific approach and the typical CAM approach is that science is based in reality. It slowly builds a knowledge base that is internally consistent. Whereas most CAM modalities are philosophy-based – they are based on pre-scientific superstitious notions of health and illness that have not been subjected to any kind of systematic study, or that have been left behind by scientific advance (such as the notion of life energy). These philosophies are often mutually exclusive, which doesn’t seem to bother the “big tent” CAM movement. In the end, the alleged underlying “imbalances” sought for by CAM practitioners are illusory and not based in reality. That doesn’t stop them from being smug in their dismissal of scientific medicine.
What follows is a long list of medical schools integrating nonsense into their curriculum – as if this is a good thing. Landau admits that many medical schools find it difficult to find time in their busy curriculum for CAM teaching. This is because there is a large body of medical knowledge that needs to be crammed into four years of medical school. At Yale where I teach every department is clamoring for one more hour here or there to teach their material. There just isn’t enough time, and we have to be creative in maximizing classroom time for the students. This just highlights the importance of not wasting this limited resource teaching the fads of the day.
This gets to the deeper question that is not even addressed in the article – what is the responsibility of academic medicine in determining the standards that should be followed in medical education? Medical schools are being offered what are essentially bribes, and are being told that CAM is popular as reasons to spend precious time teaching (often really promoting) CAM. This is often accomplished without open debate and discussion, and many faculty members are shocked to find out what is going on in their own institution (quiet revolution indeed). But isn’t it the responsibility of medical schools to maintain high standards of science and academia, to resist the forces of pseudoscience, sectarian beliefs, and popular culture? Perhaps I am being too idealistic.
In the end Landau’s article was devoid of any serious discussion of the actual issues. The result was a propaganda piece (intentional or not) for the sectarian beliefs and economic agenda of CAM, at the expense of academic integrity.

   The ultimate in “integrative medicine”. Integrating the unscientific into the medical school curriculum
David Gorski
Links
For the second week in a row I find myself throwing out the original post that I had planned on doing in favor of a different topic. The reason this week is, quite simply, having read Dr. Atwood’s excellent two part post Misleading Language: The Common Currency of “CAM” Characterizations (Part I; Part II). I don’t at this time intend to expand on what Dr. Atwood said, although I may do so at one future time. What caught my attention in his lengthy deconstruction was his segment on the “woo-ification” of health care, which very much echoed my post a while back in which I lamented the creeping infiltration of non-science-based modalities into academic medical centers, as well as the credulous teaching of such modalities in medical schools. What I wanted to explore was just how far this might go and what the end result might be. It turns out that we are already witnessing an experiment in just such a thing.
About a year and a half ago, I first became aware of just how far this infiltration of unscientific “medicine” has infiltrated academia when I saw this brochure published by the Georgetown University School of Medicine. If you’re scientifically inclined, as I am, it ought to make you shudder. Reading this brochure, I truly have to worry whether woo really is the future of American medicine, as has been suggested in some quarters. Certainly, if other medical schools start following Georgetown’s lead, it will be. Not content to offer so-called complementary and alternative medicine (“CAM”) modalities as part of electives that interested students can take if they are so inclined, Georgetown is taking the next logical step that I feared: It’s dedicating significant educational resources and time to teaching “CAM” in its mandatory general medical curriculum, where every student has to learn it:
Figures on how medical schools are introducing CAM education are less definitive. Another study published in JAMA in 1998 reports that 75 of the 117 participating U.S. medical schools offer CAM elective courses or include CAM topics in required courses.
“One of the reasons CAM is usually offered as an elective is that there’s just no time or room in U.S. medical schools to fit in one more massive subject,” says Michael Lumpkin, Ph.D., professor and chair of the department of physiology and biophysics at Georgetown. “When the course is an elective, a self-selected group – maybe 10 or 20 students in a class of 180 medical students – will take it,” Lumpkin says. “What we’ve tried at Georgetown is rather than create all new courses, we take relevant CAM issues and modalities and weave them seamlessly into existing courses.
The “seamless” weaving of CAM into existing classes includes, for instance, a presentation by an acupuncturist on the “anatomy of acupuncture” in the gross anatomy course for first-year students. The same lecturer explores acupuncture’s application in pain relief in the neuroscience course…
Haramati and Lumpkin say Georgetown’s program is distinct from CAM initiatives in other medical schools in two ways: The school is integrating CAM education into existing course work across all four years of each student’s medical education, and the initiative includes a mind-body class to help students use techniques to manage their own health and improve self-care.
Teaching the “anatomy of acupuncture” in formal anatomy classes that every medical student has to take and pass? Great. Heck, why not teach “intelligent design” creationism in basic biology classes while they’re at it? It would be the same idea: Mixing nonscience with science. Next they’ll be teaching Samuel Hahnemann’s “principle of similars” and concept of homeopathic dilution in biochemistry and pharmacy classes! Or maybe they’ll teach about qi in physiology or neurology. In fact, Georgetown’s program is actually coming close, as it is teaching a veritable cornucopia of unscientific methods: the anatomy of acupuncture; stress hormone modulation in physiology; “mechanisms” of acupuncture action in neuroscience; and psychoneuroimmunology in immunology courses. In fact, it’s worse than that. Not only is this sort of material being taught in elective courses, but it is being “integrated” into every aspect of every year of the four year curriculum:
The first year will include an introduction to CAM practices in ambulatory care. In the program’s second year, Georgetown aims to double the number of mind-body session groups and introduce CAM-related issues in lectures in the pharmacology, microbiology, and pathology courses in the students’ second year of medical school.
A CAM elective will also be offered to fourth-year students. Between year two and three of the program, a biomedical research component for students will be introduced; in the remaining years, CAM will be further integrated into the rest of the preclinical courses and most of the clinical clerkships.
“We welcome the medical students to participate with us in conducting those research projects,” Lumpkin explains. “If students get involved in these research projects, it will allow them to go to the cutting edge of CAM. They will become the thought leaders in this field.”
In other words, they will become advocates for non-science-based medicine–exactly what medicine doesn’t need. This is ironic, given that it has been pointed out that “CAM” is actually losing favor in China, where many of the concepts of traditional Chinese medicine that underlie large swaths of alternative medicine originated. Here the same concepts are taking over the medical school curriculum. Here are the principles behind the project:
1.Aim CAM curriculum at all students through required courses.
2.Integrate material into basic science courses. For example:
Gross Anatomy: anatomy of acupuncture
Human Physiology: biofeedback, neuromuscular manipulation
Human Endocrinology: stress hormone modulation (relaxation response, meditation, imagery, breathing regulation)
Neuroscience: mechanisms of acupuncture action
Immunology: psychoneuroimmunology
3.Begin on the first day of school, if possible.
4.Address knowledge, skills and attitudes regarding CAM.
5.Change culture by evolution not revolution
And Georgetown’s rationale for integrating such practices so deeply into the curriculum strikes me as disingenuous:
Haramati realizes that some mainstream medical practitioners remain skeptical of CAM due to the perception that such therapies lack the rigorous scientific testing that traditional therapies undergo. That’s why exposing medical students to CAM practices and principles is so important, he says.
“Perception”? It’s not just a “perception.” The vast majority of CAM therapies do lack rigorous scientific testing that mainstream medical therapies must undergo. That’s a fact, not a “perception.” So what is Georgetown’s solution? Integrate them into the curriculum because they’re not scientifically validated? That’s putting the cart before the horse! “CAM” therapies needs to be validated through science first. In fact, the purpose of medical school is to teach medical students the basics. There’s little enough room in the curriculum to teach them that. No compelling case that I have yet seen has been made that CAM methodologies are so compelling in their efficacy that room must be made in the mandatory medical school curriculum for them.
Georgetown does, however, give one reason that’s semi-reasonable:
“Rather than to say ‘there’s no data here, why teach it?’ we need to inform our students as much as possible about the therapies that are out there … ‘what does the research tell us, which are useful, which are dangerous’,” Haramati explains. He is also quick to note the initiative is not a program of advocacy. “We’re not teaching a belief system or teaching students to practice CAM, but rather we’re informing students about CAM.”
My retort would be that it’s not necessary to integrate this sort of woo deeply into the curriculum in order to accomplish this. For the vast majority of CAM therapies, a brief overview would be all that is needed. It is not necessary to teach “acupuncture points” in regular anatomy class, particularly when there is no evidence that these points mean anything on a strictly anatomic and physiological basis. The organizers of this curriculum also point out that many people take herbal remedies and dietary supplements, many of which can interact with standard drugs, and cite this as a justification for teaching CAM. That is perhaps their best argument, but my retort would be that it’s not necessary to integrate various non-herbal aspects of CAM into the curriculum to accomplish this. In pharmacology class, all that would have to be done would be, when teaching drug interactions, to include herbal remedies and supplements among the compounds and drugs that can interact with each new medication that is discussed and perhaps include a module on such remedies. Drug interactions are a very important topic, and It is not necessary at all to integrate woo into the medical school curriculum to warn future physicians of what herbal medicines might interfere with various drugs.
As for not being a program of advocacy, if that’s the case, then why is Georgetown not only teaching but also actively encouraging the use of “mind-body” skills that may or may not have any scientific basis by its own medical students? Why does its program tout that it will be starting to teach CAM from the very first day of medical school, as described in on the Georgetown website and brochure. This is what I’m talking about:
Year one of the five-year grant began in fall 2001, with CAM lectures integrated into basic science classes. In winter 2002, educators are introducing a new workshop, “Mind-Body Medicine: An Experiential and Didactic Introduction,” which includes topics on a wide range of mind-body approaches, including meditation, nutrition, physical exercise, relaxation, and self-awareness. Students meet in three or four groups of eight to ten people each.
“Over the next five years we’ll be training additional faculty facilitators,” Haramati says. “Then they’ll form their own groups until the entire medical school class is exposed to the utilization of mind-body skills.” “The idea is to help students with the stress of the intense course of study and expectations that come with medical school,” Lumpkin adds. “By learning their own techniques of self-care, students will naturally internalize that and then be able to use it with their patients in the future. This is a skill physicians generally lack because it’s something they were never taught. In some cases it was debunked as being nonsense. Now there’s a new view of its usefulness.”
Let’s see. Georgetown is teaching “mind-body” medicine to its medical students and actively encouraging them to use it, all in the context of teaching other areas of woo. Sure, the faculty claim that they will be teaching students to “critically assess” the various CAM modalities, but you’ll excuse me if I remain skeptical. As I’ve pointed out before, such programs may start out with the best of intentions with regards to a critical assessment of the evidence (or, in the cases of most CAM, the lack of evidence for its efficacy). However, over time, these things tend to develop a momentum of their own. They also tend to get taken over by true believers. This is probably because most doctors committed to EBM just aren’t that interested in CAM because there’s not much good evidence for the vast majority of modalities that fall under its label and because so many CAM modalities are associated with spiritual/religious concepts underlying them that have no business in science. Moreover, advocates of CAM tend to be much more passionate about promoting it than skeptics are about expressing their skepticism about it. Indeed, if they do, they often are labeled as “close-minded” or “intolerant.”
Like the program at the University of Michigan, the CAM program at Georgetown is funded by a grant from the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM). And here’s where we come to the most pernicious effect of all of NCCAM. The problem is that NCCAM doesn’t just fund grants to study CAM, which, although it often leads to studies of dubious scientific merit about therapies lacking even scientific plausibility, much less data, at least is an intellectually and scientifically defensible endeavor. Unfortunately, NCCAM goes beyond this and funds grants to promote the teaching–indeed, the integration–of CAM in medical schools before these modalities are scientifically proven. Once again, this putting the cart before the horse. The usual order of things in medical education is that modalities to be included in the medical curriculum must first have considerable evidence of efficacy such that they are considered standard of care. Medical school is where students learn the basics. During the first two years they learn the well-established basic science, and during the second two years they learn how to take care of patients according to the standard of care. Then they go on to residency, where they expand on the basics and progress to more advanced education in their therapy. The topics and therapies that Georgetown is integrating into its curriculum are neither well-established science nor the standard of care. Teaching unproven CAM modalities so extensively in the core medical school curriculum rather than as electives is neither scientifically nor educationally appropriate, as it puts the imprimatur of scientific medicine as represented by medical schools on therapies that are anything but scientific.
The virus is spreading.
Depending on what Dr. Atwood decides to write, next week I may take a look at the issue of Academic Medicine from October 2007 and examine some of what has been written there in more detail about the teaching of “CAM” in medical school.

Teaching Pseudoscience In Universities
Steven Novella on February 8, 2012
Link
The debate about teaching so-called complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) in universities and medical schools rages on. Attention has turned recently to Australia, where the infiltration of CAM into universities is a growing problem. A new group has formed called the Friends of Science in Medicine to advocate for maintaining high standards of science in medical academia. They have been successful in at least invigorating the debate, leading to a slew of articles on the topic, many of which are reasonable. They have also forced CAM proponents to defend their position, which they do with the usual bad logic and invalid arguments.
The Problem
It is a sign of our times that we even have to defend having standards of good science in the practice of medicine and the teaching of a science-based curriculum in universities. This is an issue we have discussed at length on SBM often. The core philosophy of SBM is that high standards of science in medicine are necessary in order to ensure, as best as we can, that treatments and interventions are safe and effective. It is extremely complicated and tricky to determine safety and efficacy. Humans suffer from numerous mechanisms of self-deception, cognitive flaws and biases, poor grasp of statistics, and perceptual failings that are likely to lead us astray. In fact our biases tend to systematically lead us to false conclusions that we wish to be true, rather than the truth.
Science is the only system that we have developed that systematically controls for all of these biases and flaws to see through to reliable information. Science endeavors to be transparent, thorough, and rigorous. The applications of scientific principles has demonstrably transformed medicine (and human knowledge in general) for the better. As a society we should not lightly abandon the principles of science nor try to change them to meet the needs of the current fads.
Further, universities are supposed to be the exemplars of scholarship and intellectual legitimacy. They believe themselves to be intellectual leaders, not followers, and they are correct (or at least, they should be). Teaching a topic in a university is absolutely an endorsement of the legitimacy of that topic. We can distinguish between teaching about something and teaching the thing itself. It is OK to teach about CAM as a sociological phenomenon or even as an example of pseudoscience. Credulously teaching CAM, however, is an endorsement, the granting of the imprimatur of the university.
It is tempting to cater to prevailing fads, to acquiesce to the vocal advocates and give them what they want, especially when there isn’t much protest. That is exactly what intellectual integrity is about, however – doing the right thing because it is right, not because it is popular or expedient.
I will acknowledge perhaps the only legitimate argument on the other side – that of academic freedom and diversity of opinion. I agree with the principle that a university should also be a place for the free exchange of ideas and should not easily impose censorship. Proponents of nonsense, however, have taken this principle too far. Academic freedom needs to be tempered with quality control. Professors should not be allowed to teach absolutely anything they want without limit. The university has a duty to ensure that the minimal standards of academic legitimacy are met.
This duty includes ensuring that science is taught in science classes. This debate has come up with reference to teaching creationism as science as a matter of academic freedom. Such freedom does not extend to the point of teaching demonstrable pseudoscience as if it were a legitimate science. The exact same thing can be said about teaching homeopathy, for example, as if it were legitimate science-based medicine.
The Solution
The argument above should not be difficult to make and should resonate with academics. It has worked well in the UK, spearheaded mostly by our colleague David Colquhoun, who has used freedom of information requests to obtain the CAM curricula and universities teaching CAM, and then simply sent them to the Dean and/or board of trustees of the university. This one act has led to the removal of CAM courses from universities in the UK. Simply shining a light on what was happening was enough.
In the US we are having a harder time, although we have had some successes also. The American Medical Student Association (AMSA) has been infiltrated by CAM proponents and they have managed to get requirements for CAM to be taught in American medical schools. Of course, we can still teach about CAM (which I actually advocate) rather than promote pseudoscience – something that should not be a subtle distinction but is often difficult to make.
Australia is perhaps having the most difficult time with this issue, leading to the formation of the Friends of Science in Medicine. They already have over 300 individual supporters. Also, the Institute for Science in Medicine, with over 50 fellows, has officially joined FOSM in their protest. Their request is simple – no pseudoscience in universities. They have helped bring the debate to the forefront. CAM’s greatest ally in infiltrating universities is stealth. I have seen this infiltration occur under the radar, deliberately, with the stated goal of avoiding too much attention which might draw criticism. This violates the principle of transparency, and why focusing attention on this trend is so useful.
The response
Of course, CAM proponents are not going to just lie down and go away. I have seen many responses to the criticism of teaching CAM in medical schools, none valid. They trot out the same tired fallacies (another thing they share in common with creationists). I could choose any of dozens of examples, but here is one from a discussion forum on the Australian CAM debate:
There is no better than modern medicine when it comes to surgery, emergency and trauma, but for almost everything else, traditional, natural or alternative medicine is far more effective – particularly for chronic illness which modern medicine is completely unable to treat or cure. These therapies, unlike modern medicine which focuses on symptom control, work to treat the entire person, recognising and stimulating the body’s innate capability to heal the root cause of illness. Modern medicine actually suppresses and thwarts that innate healing mechanism by unbalancing the complex human organism and its systems, particularly the immune system, with the liberal use of drugs and ignorance of the importance of diet and lifestyle.
With conventional medicine’s birth came the slow and deliberate move by the medical profession to discredit what became labelled ”alternative medicine”. I can only presume that what lies at the heart of it is the threat to conventional medicine’s power base and the unhealthy relationship it has long enjoyed with the trillion-dollar pharmaceutical industry.
It is about time the Australian medical profession started educating rather than medicating. It is unfortunate that it is the public’s disillusionment with modern medicine and its inability to treat many diseases, as well as the dreadful side-effects of any treatment offered, that have increased the popularity of complementary and alternative medicine. It should have been due to the interest, enthusiasm and reason of doctors, scientists, researchers and politicians.
As a qualified medical specialist and surgeon, I am ashamed of the medical profession when it so blatantly displays its ignorance and persists in attacking a profession from which we have much to learn.
Dr Valerie Malka is a surgeon and former director of trauma services at Westmead Hospital.
We have deconstructed all of these arguments before, many times, but we will have to keep doing it. The historical revisionism and logical fallacies in this argument are rampant. First comes the claim that “natural” or “alternative” medicine is more effective than science-based medicine for chronic ailments. Dr. Malka makes this claim without evidence and without even a good working definition of what “natural” or “alternative” is. This blog is full of articles and analysis showing that so-called CAM is ineffective. If CAM proponents could demonstrate with solid science that any particular modality is effective for any particular indication, then it would become part of science-based medicine.
Notice also the counter claim that modern medicine is completely unable to treat or cure chronic illness. This is a bold and demonstrably absurd claim. We may not be able to cure chronic illnesses – by definition, that’s why they are chronic – but we can certainly treat most of them to improve quality of life, minimize complications, and extend life expectancy. We have very effective treatments for diabetes, migraine, heart disease, any many other common chronic illnesses. I defy any CAM proponent to name one CAM modality that has been shown to be effective in significantly treating any chronic illness (and not the science-based modalities, like nutrition and physical therapy, that they have tried to relabel as CAM).
She then invokes a conspiracy by mainstream medicine to suppress CAM, which she attributes to nothing but turf protection. This is also demonstrably incorrect – while science-based medicine is not perfect, the treatments that have survived over the decades are those that are supported by the best evidence. It’s a complex and sloppy process, but it is science-based. To reduce the modern institution of medicine to mere professional protectionism is nothing but a malicious lie.
Here again we see an insightful comparison to creationism. Creationists try to simultaneously elevate their religious beliefs to that of a legitimate science, while trying to drag down evolution to that of a mere belief system. I guess their hope is that they will meet somewhere in the middle and at least have equivalence. Likewise CAM proponents are constantly trying to exaggerate the problems with science-based medicine, deny the evidence base for it, and argue that it is all blind, corrupt, and unscientific. They try to drag down SBM because they are the ones engaged in a turf war – trying to promote a trade that cannot compete on the science.
She concludes by assuming that CAM popularity, such as it is, is due to the failings of modern medicine. But the evidence is against this assumption. The evidence shows that it is philosophy and wishful thinking, not dissatisfaction with mainstream medicine, that drives use of CAM.
Conclusion
It is good to see some organized backlash against the infiltration of pseudoscience and nonsense into the very institutions that should be teaching against such things. It is good to see more and more articles written about this topic – we want attention to the issue. We want a discussion of the merits of our position vs the pro-CAM position. Let’s have a very public debate about the facts, about what is science, and how we as a society should determine what medical interventions are worth our public support.
We will confidently stand by our position. CAM proponents, like creationists, have nothing but weak and fallacious arguments, long discredited, on their side.

   Forks in the road
Wallace Sampson
Links
It’s been decades since the onslaught of organized quackery began against science and reason. Although most physicians are still capable of reasoning, the percentage of medical graduates whose brains have been cleansed of that ability seems to have increased. Either the brains have been cleansed or they have learned to coexist with unreason and to use both functions simultaneously. The latter is quite an accomplishment and is a testament to the flexibility and fluidity of the human mind (shorthand for brain function.) Psychologists have names for that function such as compartmentalization, rationalization, denial, heuristic maintenance, and cognitive dissonance.
Physician advocates of quackery are particularly unsettling because they seem to be so rational at times and appear so to the press and the public. Even more unsettling to me are the medical school department heads and deans and others who loosen the restrictions on the irrational so that peaceful coexistence and polite tolerance seem to be the preferred mode of mental existence in faculties. The NCCAM’s example needs no introduction.
Thus the matter-of-fact tone in which was reported an article in this week’s JAMA. As reported in our local papers, the headlines read: “St. John’s Wort fails to help kids with ADHD [Attention Deficit-Hyperactivity Disorder] in study.” That stopped me for more than one reason. First, any headline about a sectarian or implausible claim is a stopper. But second, StJW for ADHD? I’d never seen the claim. But the article explained that the author felt such a trial was worth doing because someone else had found that StJW increased the level of nor-epinephrine-like compounds in rat brains, so that perhaps St JW would work instead of stimulants for hyperactivity.
Makes some sense, right? But it is in fact a long jump. A reason was given by an interviewed mother of a patient, claiming to fear pharmaceuticals so much, she denied them to her ADHD daughter. So the ostensible reason for studying StJW for ADHD was to find a substitute for a purified, regulated pharmaceutical – an unrefined, uncontrolled, unpredictable plant extract. Just what positive social or medical advance does one call that? Perhaps there is a purifed isolate one might obtain from StJW? StJW has been tested in a number of other conditions and situations and found inactive, but with dangerous drug interactions. What IRB had the nerve to approve such a trial? Apparently those questions need not be answered if the NCCAM gives its assent.
Second, there was a small but definite chance the study could have come out positive by chance, or more likely, because of unreported variations in execution. The consequence would have been a series of confirming or disconfirming RCTs that would take 5-10 years and millions of dollars to resolve in the minds of real clinicians, and moreover, if negative would not alter the practices of either the public or naturopaths.
A further reading showed that the first author, described as “of Bastyr University’s School of Naturopathic Medicine, working with colleagues from Harvard University and the University of Washington…“ brought up the previously noted cooperation of UW with its neighbor, Bastyr U. The cooperation has been going on for years, and has resulted in some realistic clinical trials, one of which was a negative trial on Echinacea for prevention of colds in children.
Naturopaths have been consultants for the UW bone marrow transplant and oncology units also for a decade or more. As one Bastyr N’path explained to me on a visit here, N’paths are experts in natural substances and can help MDs to retain confidence of patients who are exploring alternatives, and who interpret words like “it doesn’t work” as personal rejection. N’paths, he said, can also serve as credible authorities in warning patients away from dangerous substances. I wondered aloud if Npaths were capable of warning people about dangerous practices – such as going to naturopaths.
Back to the report, a medical school cooperating with a naturopathic school? Good? Bad? Productive? Suspicious? Are the questions relevant? In a way the cooperation is all of the above, but with differing weights attached to each adjective. One thing is obvious. There is more to be gained by Bastyr than by UW from an alliance. Bastyr naturopaths have not to my knowledge published anything of consequence on their own. The alliance confers respect, allowing N’paths to break into the medical journal system, to build bibliographies, to publish enough credible studies to enable future federal grants, and eventually to obtain hospital privileges and expanded scopes of practice. About that can there be any doubt?
In reality, N’paths hold no fund of knowledge not available to MDs and other medical practitioners. At the same time, N’paths warp that knowledge’s application to fit ideological frames containing life forces, anti-technology, anti-public health measures and irrational fears of progress. Worse, N’paths believe a mass of unproved and false information that they claim as their exclusive area of expertise and which they apply on the basis of hunches and feelings. A N’path supplies no additional positive substance to healing the sick or to the science of medicine. In this sense, UW is an enabler of quackery, even if the short run product for the university could be algebraically positive. The overriding social consequence of enabling quackery, which is taught to Npathy students, is to spread a system of pseudo- and anti-science throughout the society.
One must grant the UW some degree of understanding for taking on this alliance, out of ignorance, innocense, and misplaced beneficense, but the establishing of precedent is an act they will one day regret and will find progressively more difficult to reverse. Bastyr’s existence and UW’s acceptance materialized in a social environment lacking an overarching theory of scientific social beneficence and a sense that something is wrong with anti-science.
Teaching a scientific ethic and philosophy begins with education in our pre-college schools, and continues with magnified importance in universities, which unfortunately have been taken over by political ideologues who teach ethical relativism and who belittle rationality, realism, and science. Medical schools are in a time of crucial transition and choice; to track into the new science of cellular and molecular biology while holding to and teaching classical traditions of reasoning, or to take the baited hook of social determinism and relativism, to an uncertain fate – likely to be as just another dish on the table.

   The Trojan Horses of Education
Wallace Sampson
Link
Last time I described what I could find about the “Quiet Revolution” plan for medicine through the eyes and minds of the Bravewell Collaborative and Christy Mack, wife of the multi-millionaire or billionaire CEO John Mack. The idea seemed two-pronged; “humanize” physicians and medicine generally, and integrate folkway, sectarian and “alternative” methods into the system. What bothered me more, having become inured to patient philandering with quackery, was the brazen attempt to re-educate physicians and indoctrinate students into the political and social views of wealthy idealists. The entry below, one might conclude, has little to do with medical quackery and pseudoscience, but I beg your indulgence for this series as I attempt to connect dots between the stalls of the seemingly unrelated steeds of political indoctrination in universities and the proposed med school re-education camps of Bravewell. For several years a controversy has roiled at the University of Delaware over a program of educational activities for the dorms called Residence Life. The program structures student time with a number of usual activities – games, talks, discussion groups – but the content of the discussion groups and interpersonal counseling upset some students, who complained to an off-campus conservative organization, and got to the attention of faculty, which pressured the administration to stop the program last fall.
To outsiders such as we, the program looked like a feel-good, beneficent guidance tools. To the complaining students and critics the discussions seemed more like indoctrination groups, with political agendas taking on disguised roles as helpful guidance for student angst. Students complained about invasion of their privacy through group and leader pressures, and the faculty saw indoctrination and invasion of their educational duties (turf) by student counselors bearing ideological messages with little qualification.
Critics described the program thus: The University of Delaware subjects students in its residence halls to a shocking program of ideological reeducation that is referred to in the university’s own materials as a “treatment” for students’ incorrect attitudes and beliefs. The Orwellian program requires the approximately 7,000 students in Delaware’s residence halls to adopt highly specific university-approved views on issues ranging from politics to race, sexuality, sociology, moral philosophy, and environmentalism. (http://www.thefire.org/index.php/article/4851.html). Here are the stated goal of the curriculum:
Become an engaged and active citizen by understanding how your thoughts, values, beliefs, and actions affect the people with whom you live and recognize your responsibility to contribute to a sustainable society at a local, national, and global level.
From this stated goal twelve learning outcomes or competencies were developed:
Understand how your social identities affect how you view others.
Understand how differences in equity impact our society.
Understand your congruence with citizenship values.
Understand how others influence you.
Understand the impact of your decisions.
Understand the power of an individual in a community.
Understand the knowledge necessary for the development of a sustainable society.
Learn how to connect personal passions to vocational options in order to be able to contribute to a sustainable society.
Learn how to develop and sustain interdependent relationships.
Learn to contribute to the creation and maintenance of a sustainable society.
Learn the skills necessary to be a change agent.
Demonstrate civic engagement toward the development of a sustainable society.
English is a “slippery” language, with multiple meanings to words. Not surprisingly, critics found specific buzz words felt to imply a more political slant: sustainable society, global level, learning competencies (implying a scale of social adequacy) change agent, etc. (Interesting that “change” became a motto of one of our presidential candidates, with imprecise application, and criticisms to match.)
The 2007 Faculty critique read thus:
The Faculty Senate Committee on Student Life assessed the Residence Life Education Curriculum based on a review of the printed materials provided in the Residence Life Education Curriculum; a presentation from the Vice President of Student Life and the Director of Residence Life, a written report provided by the Director of Residence Life, a student forum on the topic and the deliberations of the committee.
1. Faculty Inclusion: The Student Life Committee of the Faculty Senate believes that Residence Life should have relied on the faculty in the development of a Curricular Approach to Residence Life.
2. Curriculum Content and Implementation: The Student Life Committee of the Faculty Senate acknowledges the fact that some of the topics that were addressed in the curriculum were worthy of discussion, but it would have been appropriate for the discussions on those topics to be led by qualified professionals and faculty.
3. Mandatory vs. Voluntary Participation: The Student Life Committee of the Faculty Senate believes that there was not a clear understanding on whether the participation in the Residence Life Curriculum was voluntary or mandatory. Considering the nature of the topics, it would be imperative that students clearly understand that it is voluntary rather than having the impression it was mandatory.
4. Reliance on Residence Assistants: The Student Life Committee of the Faculty Senate believes that there was an inappropriate reliance on resident assistants in the implementation of the curriculum. It was not in the best interest of either the residence assistants or the residents that certain activities were not led by qualified professionals.
5. Learning Outcomes and Activities: The Student Life Committee of the Faculty Senate believes that although the intent of the curriculum was to engage students in discussion and debate about important topics related to citizenship, on several occasions stated learning outcomes and activities suggested a particular view was a correct view over another rather than encouraging students to have an open and honest discussion.
6. Materials Used and Posted: The Student Life Committee of the Faculty Senate believes that it was inappropriate for the educational materials of guest speaker Dr. Shakti Butler to be posted on the University website. The placement of the materials created an impression that these were the views of the Residence Life program and ultimately the University. Some of the posted material was not used by Dr. Butler in her workshop nor was it ever used in the residence halls with students. This makes the posting on the University website even more inappropriate. [Shakti had given off-campus talks with apparently radical or at least highly polarized content.
Summary: What is most important from these observations is what can be learned. In moving to the future, the Student Life Committee of the Faculty Senate would like to make the following recommendations in regards to the development of a new residence life program.
It is imperative that students clearly understand that participation in Residence Life programming is voluntary rather than having an impression that it is mandatory. Respecting the moral autonomy and intellectual integrity of students should be a primary goal of all Residential Life programs. Such respect requires that no educational program of Residential Life be mandatory.
There followed a list of specific recommended changes too long and detailed for here, but couched in the usual mildness of courteous academic text.
So the administration sent Reslife authors back to the drawing board, but they came up with a barely sanitized version (also too long to detail here.) Presented last month, it was accepted by administration for a year. But the Delaware Association of Scholars, an unofficial watchdog faculty group weighed in with more pointed language:
The […] Association [..] is disappointed by the University of Delaware’s proposed Residence Life program and urges the Faculty Senate to reject it. The proposed program is little more than a re-tread of the notorious indoctrination program suspended last fall. The differences are largely cosmetic. The proposed program still tries to change students’ “thoughts, values, beliefs, and actions,” while focusing on “student learning outcomes.” It changes only the language. Like the old program, the new one centers on “sustainability.” But while the old program defined the term (“the triple bottom line of having a society which is socially just, and communities which are economically and environmentally responsible”), the new program leaves the term undefined. What Residence Life calls “transparency” is nothing more than invisibility. A sign that the programs are much the same is that the new program, which was designed and would be implemented by the same ResLife administrators who had designed and implemented the earlier program, will have a Graduate Assistant for Diversity Initiatives, whose responsibilities include “Stereotyping, Oppression, Prejudice Reduction, Privilege, Heterosexism/ Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual and Transgender Awareness, Racism, Ageism, Sexism, Values Clarification, Multicultural Jeopardy, Classism” (http://www.udel.edu/reslife/candidates/hd_jobdesc2.html).
Back to medical re-education, the techniques used by the Reslife authors bore resemblance to the those of the “Alternative/Integrative” movement. Primary was the use of obscure language to disguise real messages. In Reslife, the two terms that raised the most ire were “sustainability” and “social justice.” Sustainability ostensibly referred to life styles that students could adopt locally to help preserve nature and local life and reduce conflict, a point of political contention. Social justice ostensibly referred to local disputes, respect for cohabitants, and such. But the terms quickly turned to global political ones and the program took on features of political re-education . This metamorphosis was particularly problematic for young students away from home, most for the first time, vulnerable to indoctrination by people in authority. The plan was described also as a “curriculum,” giving it a veneer of academic respectability, to which faculty objected.
There is a difference in the ways that pressures for ideological change have been received in academic universities and in medical colleges. Political domination by polar advocates in universities is now meeting a small nucleus of resistance from more classically oriented faculty, mainly in the social and letters schools. While hard science faculty generally oppose political moves described here, they do not much provoke.
In comparison, the infiltration by “Integrative ” changes into medicine has for the most part been welcomed or at least passively accepted by medical school facultie: , and reactions have been blunted by political correctness and fear of alienating the advocates. And, oh, yes, the taboo on endangering any inflow of funding, which now runs in the billions from NCCAM, NIH, OCCAM and from private pro-sectarian ideologues.
So, we have an Orwellian movement in the dorms at Delaware, while in schools of medicine we have a Huxleyan Bravewell New World, whose 2006 Public TV series was unsurprisingly …”The New Medicine”…(!) Although the aims of the two systems differ, and perhaps even reflect opposing politics, the methods are eerily similar.
Enough said. More infiltration news in some surprising areas next time.

   Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part I)
Kimball Atwood
Link
Several years ago I stumbled upon disturbing information regarding my alma mater, the Harvard Medical School (HMS).† Its professed commitment to investigate implausible medical claims had somehow metamorphosed into the advocacy of such claims. I’ve previously mentioned some of this on SBM (here and here). A couple of pertinent essays appeared in the public domain in 2002 and 2003, but the full story was much more involved than those pieces revealed. In the wake of recent posts on SBM about medical schools exposing students to uncritical portrayals of pseudomedicine, it seems appropriate to tell more of it. I’ve also decided to name names, which is something that I would have been reticent to do a few years ago. The basis for that decision will become clear over the next few posts, I trust. This topic will require at least three posts.
My discovery that HMS had begun promoting pseudoscientific medical claims was occasioned by my experience on the Massachusetts Special Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medical Practitioners, which met from the fall of 2001 to the winter of 2003. Another member of that commission was David Eisenberg, the Director of the Harvard Medical School Center for Alternative Medicine Research and Education (CAMRE) and of the new Osher Center for Complementary and Integrative Medical Therapies. Dr. Eisenberg is best known for his 1993 article reporting the use of ‘unconventional therapies’ by Americans. He had been appointed to the commission by the MA Commissioner of Public Health at the time, Dr. Howard Koh–whom President Obama has recently nominated to be Assistant Secretary of HHS. I assumed then, and still do, that Dr. Koh presumed Dr. Eisenberg to be an objective expert on “CAM,” since that was the persona presented by HMS and by Dr. Eisenberg himself. I had my doubts, but before then I’d not bothered to look into the matter.
It was during commission meetings, when I had the opportunity to hear what Dr. Eisenberg and his surrogate had to say or not to say and when I examined some of their writings and funding sources, that I began to realize how far his project was deviating from what I imagined to be the agenda of HMS. Some of what I saw amounted to frank dishonesty: failure to disclose obvious conflicts of interest to the Commission, for example. I also discovered public promotions of dubious “CAM” practices and practitioners by the CAMRE, in spite of its formal purpose being that of investigating “CAM” practices in an attempt to find out if any might be useful. I was concerned enough to look at other “CAM” information offered in the name of Harvard, and I found more worrisome examples.
I also attended the Feb., 2001 Harvard Complementary and Integrative Medicine Course, directed by Dr. Eisenberg (here is a link to the similar 2002 course brochure). A few of the talks were reasonable, if banal. I did my best to give them the benefit of the doubt, because I still could not accept that HMS would seriously consider homeopathy, ‘life-force,’ and ‘subluxations’ as being worthy of study, much less advocacy. After attending a semi-rigorous talk on raw herbs as medicines (the presenter discussed some studies but not the looming question of why whole herbs might be preferable to purified molecules), I ran into Eisenberg and did my best to be polite and encouraging. I shouldn’t have, because most of the content of the course was misleading and pseudoscientific. Overall, its tone was more like a political rally or a religious revival than a scientific conference.
At that course I ran into Russell Phillips, who had been in my group of interns at the Beth Israel Hospital (Boston) in 1979. I’d seen him around from time to time over the years, and I’d known that he’d stayed on at the BI after his residency. I was surprised, however, to learn that he was now the Director of the Harvard CAMRE Fellowship program. I was even more surprised to learn, during a short conversation with him, that he was innocent of the chiropractic ‘subluxation theory’ and that he’d never heard of Quackwatch. It seemed to me that there was either a surprising naivete among this crowd or an attempt by some to shun unpleasant information.
I discussed these issues with Arnold Relman, the only other skeptical physician on the Commission. Dr. Relman was the emeritus Editor-in-Chief of the New England Journal of Medicine and Professor Emeritus at HMS. He agreed with me in every detail, even offering a terse explanation for why HMS would tolerate such folly: “The five-dollar word is ‘pusillanimous’.” Naively, I hoped that Dr. Relman would use his clout to lead a vanguard of reason back to HMS, and that the matter would be short-lived (I based this expectation on Relman’s recent demolition, in the New Republic, of Andrew Weil’s writings, which suggested to me that he would warm to a fight closer to home).
Dr. Relman, however, wanted little part of any formal complaint to HMS, stating that he had “other fish to fry” and warning that battling quackery was a bottomless pit that would consume me if I insisted on pursuing it. He also must have known something I didn’t yet know: that the “CAM” epidemic had already made zombies out of some at the highest levels of the HMS administration. Nevertheless, Dr. Relman eventually supported me in some very important ways, for which I’m grateful.
I decided to approach Dan Federman, then the Senior Dean for Alumni Relations and Clinical Teaching and the highest ranking member of the HMS administration whom I still knew from my medical school days in the ’70s. Dr. Federman, an endocrinologist, had been a role model for me and for many other students: he was a paragon of kindness, knowledge, rational thinking, and ability to communicate. It seemed to me that he couldn’t possibly be duped by the “CAM” machinations going on right under his nose, if only he knew about them. He had been quoted, when HMS announced the creation of the CAMRE in the summer of 2000, as follows:
The primary function of the new division is to coordinate research and evaluation of alternative and complementary remedies and approaches at Harvard Medical School,” says Daniel Federman, M.D., HMS Senior Dean for Alumni Relations and Clinical Teaching. “When research using standard methods of assessment has demonstrated effectiveness, there should be no need for the term complementary; and when it does not, support for such claims should be withdrawn. This is a large research agenda that will occupy much effort. At the same time, we will be teaching our students how to understand and evaluate complementary modalities and thus help their patients in a comprehensive therapeutic effort.
I first discussed the issue with Dr. Federman in the fall and winter of 2001-02, not long after philanthropist Bernard Osher had granted $10 million to the HMS CAMRE, including an endowed chair for Dr. Eisenberg. Harvard announced the grant in language similar to what Dr. Federman had said in the previous year:
The division rigorously evaluates complementary and integrative medical therapies to distinguish useful from useless treatments and to foster a rational, evidence-based introduction of complementary and integrative medical care into mainstream medical education and practice. The division concentrates on assessing the safety, efficacy, cost-effectiveness, and mechanisms of action of these treatments. Appropriate educational activities and policies pertaining to the clinical delivery of complementary medical therapies are being developed.
In retrospect, I should have recognized the last sentence of that announcement as a red flag.
Dr. Federman and I had 2-3 meetings and a few e-mail exchanges over a couple of months. He seemed appropriately concerned. He agreed that it would not do for the CAMRE to promote ‘CAM’ rather than merely perform ‘research and evaluation.’ He asked me to present him with written documentation of my charges, and promised that if it agreed with what I’d told him he would appoint an ad hoc faculty committee to investigate. I was mostly optimistic, although Dr. Federman made a comment that I found worrisome: he referred to Dr. Relman as a “zealot.”
In the late spring I sent Dr. Federman the documentation that he had requested, in the form of a draft of an article that I had hoped would be accepted by Harvard Magazine. The draft was a response to a misleading, promotional piece about Eisenberg and the CAMRE in the March-April issue (Harvard Magazine declined my offer, but published a letter instead). I’ve made minor language changes and added hyperlinks to sites that existed at the time, to the extent that they are still available. Here is part of it; the rest will follow next week or so.
………………..
Comments on Harvard Medical School’s “Center for Alternative Medicine Research and Education” 
Readers of Craig Lambert’s “The New Ancient Trend in Medicine” (Harvard Magazine Mar/Apr 2002) can’t be faulted for concluding that the mission of HMS’s foray into “alternative medicine” is “the application of skeptical science to…unconventional treatments.” Even that goal is of dubious value and based on false premises, as will be discussed in subsequent parts of this article. The evidence shows, however, that a major additional goal of the project is the public promotion, ranging from implicit to explicit, of practices that are both absurd and dangerous.
Naturopathy
Consider the following advice offered on the “information resources for consumers” webpage of the Caregroup/Harvard Medical School Center for Alternative Medicine Research and Education (CAMRE): 
Please consult your local telephone yellow pages under these categories:
Acupuncture
Chiropractic
Holistic Practitioners
Massage – Therapeutic
Naturopathic Physicians 
In order to appreciate the implications of this appeal, it is necessary to examine the beliefs and practices of at least one of the recommended groups. “Naturopathic physicians” are a recent manifestation of the field known as “naturopathy,” whose origins were in the 19th century German “natural living” movement. Early naturopaths railed against contemporary medical advances such as the Germ Theory and vaccinations, but espoused the “water cure,” fasting, herbs, homeopathy, colonic “detoxification,” and other fanciful methods.
The content of the field has changed little since then, but the trappings have become distinctly modern. A subset of naturopaths now claims to practice “a distinct form of primary health care,” according to the official definition on the website of their national organization, the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians (AANP). They state that they are “primary care physicians, most of whom are in general private practice [and] trained to be the doctor first seen by the patient for general healthcare, for advice on keeping healthy, and for the diagnosis and treatment of acute and chronic conditions.”
“Naturopathic doctors” or “N.D.’s,” as they also call themselves, state that they have received training appropriate to the practice of medicine, including a basic science curriculum equivalent to that taught in medical schools. This training occurs in one of four schools in the U.S., each of which offers a four-year, on campus curriculum, but no significant hospital or residency experience. Three of the schools are unaffiliated with larger universities; the fourth, the University of Bridgeport College of Naturopathic Medicine in Connecticut, is owned by the Unification Church, known more commonly as the “Moonies.” The schools have little interaction with the scientific community at large.
Naturopaths believe in “vitalism,” the long discredited notion that biological processes don’t conform to universal physical and chemical principles. They claim to “treat the cause of a problem, rather than to merely eliminate or suppress the symptoms.” They claim to know how to “boost the immune system” with herbs and homeopathic preparations. They claim to have esoteric knowledge about preventive medicine that is, implicitly, unknown to “conventionally” trained physicians, public health experts, nurses, nutritionists, and others. They claim special expertise in nutrition and in the use of “natural remedies.”
What is the reality of these claims? Naturopaths invoke a few simplistic “theories” to explain the causes of all disease. These include the actions of ubiquitous, but ill-defined “toxins”; widespread “food allergies”; dietary sugar, fat, and gluten; inadequate vitamins and minerals (which naturopaths offer for sale); epidemic candidiasis (yeast infections); vertebral “misalignments” (a canard borrowed from chiropractic); and a few others. To “diagnose” these entities naturopaths use an assortment of absurd methods, among which are “iridology” or iris diagnosis, which claims that the entire body is represented on the iris of the eye; “applied kinesiology” by which, for example, an “allergy” to a particle of food is detected by placing the food particle in one hand of a patient and observing a resulting weakness in the other; hair analysis; “electrodiagnosis,” which measures the skin’s resistance to a tiny electric current; “live cell analysis”; and more.
Naturopathic “therapies” are an eclectic assortment of implausible and unproven methods, among which are “colonic irrigation” (enemas) and fasting for “detoxification,” hydrotherapy (wrapping part or all of the body in wet towels), homeopathy, acupuncture and “oriental medicine,” chiropractic manipulation, aromatherapy, arduous dietary schemes, intravenous vitamin C and hydrogen peroxide, whole enzyme pills, and other dubious “natural remedies” including botanical, animal, and mineral products, several of which are known to be dangerous. Naturopaths sell “remedies” to their clients at a considerable profit, an obvious conflict of interest that is formally approved by their national organization, the AANP.
How does all this translate into the practice of “naturopathic medicine?” Mainstream naturopathic literature shows numerous examples of practices and recommendations that are both absurd and dangerous. Among these are the repudiation of standard treatments of strep pharyngitis, acute otitis media,[1] and other potentially catastrophic childhood infectious diseases, while offering instead such ineffective “alternatives” as homeopathy, hydrotherapy, and “natural antibiotics” (e.g., herbs such as Goldenseal); affiliation with the strident anti-vaccination movement; the repudiation of standard treatments of asthma, offering instead, for example, a hydrogen peroxide bath to “bring extra oxygen to the entire surface of the skin, thus making the lungs somewhat less oxygen hungry” or “gems and minerals…worn as jewelry, or placed around the home in special places”; warnings against proven medical and surgical treatments for hypertension, hyperlipidemia, and atherosclerosis, while instead recommending unproven herbs and EDTA chelation “therapy”;[2]treatment of the acute stroke patient with damp compresses and aromatherapy; claims that NDs can diagnose chronic, debilitating diseases such as multiple sclerosis at a much earlier stage than can “conventional” physicians, and effect a cure by fanciful methods; claims that breast cancer can be prevented and cured by an assortment of unproven, expensive “supplements” and “tests” that are not appreciated by “conventional” doctors, nurses, and public health experts; ubiquitous “toxin” hysteria, including anti-fluoridation statements, warnings against most proven pharmaceuticals, and claims that “25% of Americans suffer from heavy metal toxicity”;[3] claims that they can offer “natural childbirth” at home without complications; the exuberant promotion and sale of “dietary supplements” for all complaints, with little regard for safety; and much more. Naturopaths have not subjected these claims to rational study, because they are already convinced that they work. In summary, “naturopathic medicine” is best understood as a pseudoscientific cult.
A 1999 survey of the small number of N.D.s in Massachusetts, performed by two investigators from Children’s Hospital, is consistent with these findings. They found that only 20% of those surveyed would recommend that parents have their children vaccinated, and that only 40% would refer a two-week old infant with a temperature of 101° F (a dire, life-threatening emergency) for definitive medical care.[4]
Is it possible that the authors of the Harvard CAMRE website are naïve about the recommendations they have made? Not likely. In 1997 David Eisenberg, the Director of the Harvard CAMRE and of the new Osher Center for Complementary and Integrative Medical Therapies, cited the 1st edition of the Textbook of Natural Medicine,[5] the only general textbook of “naturopathic medicine,” in an article entitled “Advising Patients who Seek Alternative Therapies.” The textbook includes most of the claims documented above, but Dr. Eisenberg failed to discuss any of them. Instead of warning of the obvious dangers awaiting patients who seek “alternative therapies” from naturopaths, he blandly stated: “Naturopathy is licensed in 12 states and the District of Columbia. The AANP provides contacts for local licensing and regulatory boards and general information on naturopathy.”
In an address to the American Board of Internal Medicine, also in 1997, Dr. Eisenberg appeared to call for the nationwide licensure of naturopaths and other “CAM” practitioners:
Necessary Tools to Improve the Status Quo
· A national listing of licensed alternative medical providers (e.g., chiropractors, acupuncturists, massage therapists, naturopaths, and homeopaths) in each of the 50 states as well as a uniform credentialing process.”
If his intent had been to rein in dangerous practitioners through strict governmental regulation, this suggestion might have made some sense. It was not, as is clear from the following history.
The Massachusetts Special Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medical Practitioners
Beginning in the fall of 2000 and lasting for more than a year, Dr. Eisenberg was the official representative of the Massachusetts Department of Public Health to the Commonwealth’s “Special Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medical Practitioners.” In spite of its name, the main purpose of the Special Commission was to consider the request of “naturopathic physicians” to become licensed health care providers in Massachusetts. Two legislators friendly to the naturopathic licensing effort had urged the formation of the Commission, and both were among its members. The total membership was twelve, of whom only three were physicians. The other two physicians were Arnold Relman, representing the Board of Registration in Medicine (later represented by the BRM Chairman, Peter Madras), and I, representing the Massachusetts Medical Society. Of the remaining members, none was a scientist. The Commission was to study the naturopaths’ request and make a recommendation to the legislature.
The sort of licensure that these naturopaths were seeking would imply a tacit promise, by the Commonwealth to its citizenry, that “NDs” are legitimate health care providers whose methods have proven validity. It would give them a broad license to diagnose and treat illnesses and to call themselves “doctors” and “physicians.” They would answer to a board controlled by their own colleagues, and thus determine their own standard of care. They would be positioned in the political arena to demand third party reimbursement, as has already happened in the state of Washington. Naturopaths are now licensed in 11 states, with varying degrees of latitude for practice and self-regulation, but in all of these they are free to make broad claims of medical expertise.
Dr. Eisenberg came to only about half the meetings and largely refrained from discussing naturopathic practices. Usually he sent a surrogate, attorney Michael H. Cohen, “Director of Legal Programs, Division for Research and Education in Complementary & Integrative Medical Therapies, Harvard Medical School.” Mr. Cohen’s writings show that he is an unabashed champion of efforts by CAM practitioners to achieve legitimacy not through science, but through legal pressure. His distaste for, and misunderstanding of modern medicine is clear in this passage:
[B]iomedicine by and large perpetuates a delusional sense that a human being is only material–a three-dimensional substance locked in the physical body, amenable to mechanical interventions that are tightly controlled by a series of carefully circumscribed rules. Biomedicine encourages over-identification with the body: it is fear-based; disease induces desperation in the “race for the cure” rather than focus on “care of the soul.”
Later in the same essay he likens “biomedicine” to “sleep,” which “cannot bring us one iota closer to true reality.”
What, then, is the path to true reality in health care? Health and healing can involve the highest of which a human being is capable. Near-death experiences, encounters with angels, and events that touch the individual’s interior castle and border on mysticism-these experiences manifest ‘light,’ in the sense of coming closer to that which is Supreme at the edges of our consciousness.
In the purest sense, therapies from hypnosis to meditation aim to free the dis-eased seeker, and the culture as a whole, from the matrix of mechanism, reductionism, and other ills, to a realm where the human spirit finds rest. As Vasistha says: “Subdue the mind with the mind. Purify the mind by the mind. Destroy the mind by the mind.” When the mind is purified, the real can be grasped. Complementary and alternative therapies offer this possibility.
Elsewhere in the essay Mr. Cohen argues that prohibitions against health fraud are counterproductive, as are disciplinary actions by medical boards against practitioners who “[deviate] from conventionally agreed norms,” i.e., standards of care. In considering what the appropriate role of future health laws might be, he muses:
Would legal structures be able to handle the notion that healing involves mind, body, emotions, and spirit, but also such other dimensions of the human experience as inter-species communication and greater sense of earth-consciousness (Gaia)?
Mr. Cohen and Dr. Eisenberg helped to write the Special Commission’s pro-naturopathic licensure report, which recommends a broad license for naturopaths to diagnose and treat illnesses and to form a self-regulating board of “Naturopathic Medicine.” With a few minor exceptions, it is exactly what the naturopaths had requested. The report lacks any significant discussion of naturopathic claims per se, but clings to the superficial trappings of legitimacy such as the existence of schools, exams, accreditation, and so forth. As both Dr. Eisenberg and Mr. Cohen know, the standard of care for a self-regulating health profession is determined by that profession.[6] Thus if the naturopathic board were to be realized it would inevitably promote, as its standards of care, substandard medical practices.
The pro-licensure report was signed in Jan. 2002 by six commissioners, including an Assistant Commissioner of Public Health who attended the final meeting in Dr. Eisenberg’s stead. An opposition report, which cited multiple examples of dangerous naturopathic claims, was signed by three, including the two remaining physician commissioners. Three commissioners abstained.
The implications of Dr. Eisenberg’s delegation of Atty. Cohen, and of his own lack of engagement in the debate at this commission, are not to be underestimated. Most of the non-expert commissioners deferred to him for guidance, but he was notably silent when the other two physicians characterized naturopathic claims as baseless and dangerous. In private, both Dr. Eisenberg and Mr. Cohen told me that I had called attention to the “excesses” of the field (of which Dr. Eisenberg said he had not previously been aware), implying that such practices don’t reflect those of the great majority of naturopathic “physicians.”
This erroneous view was somehow promulgated to others on the commission, because it was eventually invoked by the Senate Chairman of the Committee on Health Care, one of the abstaining commission members, in a letter to the rest. These practices are standard for “naturopathic physicians,” however, as evidenced by their sources: the Textbook of Natural Medicine, which Dr. Eisenberg had cited in one of his own papers, the Journal of Naturopathic Medicine, the Position Papers and other articles offered on the website of the AANP, which Dr. Eisenberg had also cited in the same paper, articles on the websites of the four naturopathic schools, and other published opinions of the “leaders” of the field.
I asked Dr. Eisenberg several times to meet outside of the din of commission meetings to discuss the issue at some length, but he declined. I subsequently wrote a letter to the Commissioner of Public Health suggesting that Dr. Eisenberg may have a conflict of interest regarding naturopaths. Dr. Eisenberg responded angrily, but did not offer any evidence to refute this charge. Below, it is shown to be true.
If Dr. Eisenberg had stressed to the commission that it must consider the irrational content of “naturopathic medicine,” the outcome might have been different. An example of the level of critical thinking that existed among the non-scientific members was this: In justifying his premature decision to end the debate, the Chairman, who is also the chairman of the Massachusetts Division of Professional Licensure, referred to arguments over scientific validity as merely a “battle of the bands,” with each side having no more claim to truth than the other. This crude postmodern relativism was not challenged by Dr. Eisenberg, who must know that dissolved oxygen can’t be absorbed through the skin in quantities sufficient to revive a suffocating asthmatic.
Does it sound as though the public health interests of the Commonwealth were well represented at this commission? Did its emissaries do Harvard Medical School proud?
This unfortunate affair is consistent with other facts of HMS’s involvement with “CAM.” Dr. Eisenberg accepts funding for his annual Harvard CAM conference from one of the aforementioned naturopathy schools, the Southwest College of Naturopathic Medicine (SCNM) in Tempe, Arizona. The school’s own list of donors is top-heavy with “dietary supplements” companies, beginning with GAIA Herbs, Inc.
The school’s Chief Medical Officer is Thomas Kruzel, ND. Kruzel claims that multiple sclerosis is caused by diets high in fat and sugar, and that naturopaths can diagnose the disease, using “tongue” and “pulse diagnosis,” at a much earlier stage than can “conventional” physicians. This, he writes, allows naturopaths to effect cures (not possible with “conventional” medicine) through a combination of homeopathy, wet compresses (to “increase oxygenation in the blood”), acupuncture, herbs, and a diet based on the patient’s blood type. Kruzel’s claims of medical expertise are broad: for cancer of the prostate he recommends “electrical current in the form of positive galvanism, applied transrectally.”
1. Textbook of Natural Medicine, 2nd. Edition (Pizzorno JE and Murray MT, eds. London. Churchill Livingstone, 1999). pp. 1463-1467
2. Textbook of Natural Medicine, 2nd. Edition. pp. 1078-1082
3. Textbook of Natural Medicine, 2nd. Edition. p. 438
4. Lee CCL and Kemper K. Homeopathy and Naturopathy: Practice Characteristics and Pediatric Care. Arch Ped and Adolesc Medicine. 2000. vol.154, pp.75-80
5. Pizzorno JE, Murray MT. A Textbook of Natural Medicine. Seattle, WA: John Bastyr College Publications; 1993.
6. Studdert DM and others. Medical malpractice implications of alternative medicine. JAMA 280:1610-1615, 1998.

   Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part II)
Kimball Atwood
Link
In Part I of this series† we saw that in 2001 Dr. David Eisenberg, the Director of the Harvard Medical School Center for Alternative Medicine Research and Education (CAMRE), and Atty Michael Cohen, the CAMRE’s Director of Legal Programs, had contributed to a report commissioned by the Commonwealth of Massachusetts that would, if accepted as valid by the legislature, provide state protection for a group of quacks to practice ‘medicine.’ We also saw that Dr. Eisenberg had accepted funds from this very group, without having disclosed that information to the relevant state Commission. We saw examples of the quackery that the group espouses, including methods advocated by Thomas Kruzel, the Chief Medical Officer of the school that had contributed money to Dr. Eisenberg’s Harvard “Complementary and Integrative Medicine” course.
We continue now with the essay that I sent in the spring of 2002 to Dr. Dan Federman, the Senior Dean for Alumni Relations and Clinical Teaching at Harvard Medical School (HMS). As before, I’ve provided hyperlinks to many of the citations that I included in my original essay; some, however, are no longer available.
…………………
The American Association of Health Freedom
Kruzel and Harvard’s Michael Cohen are listed as key figures—Kruzel the Secretary, Mr. Cohen the only lawyer on the Advisory Board—in a lobbying organization known as the American Association of Health Freedom (AAHF). Formerly known as the American Preventive Medical Association (APMA), it was founded by Julian Whitaker, MD, a former orthopedic surgical resident who decided that “natural therapies” offered a more lucrative career path. Its purpose, as suggested by the standard euphemism, is to convince government of the validity of dubious medical claims through political influence rather than science. The AAHF lobbies heavily for the passage of the annually defeated federal “Access to Medical Treatment” act, which would allow quacks to prey freely on unwary consumers.
The organization has prepared numerous statements favoring the reckless marketing of implausible “health” products and methods, including “emergency petitions” to block the FDA from promulgating regulations of “dietary supplements.” One of these petitions argues against the regulation of ephedra products such as ma huang, which contain dangerous drugs and have been associated with thousands of adverse events, including many deaths, over the past few years. The AAHF has also filed an amicus curiae brief supporting a California lawsuit in which the plaintiffs, parents of a child with brain cancer, seek damages from an oncologist because he failed to recommend “antineoplastons,” a dubious “alternative” cancer treatment backed by neither biology nor experimental evidence.
The list of AAHF sponsors, dubbed “Angels,” reveals the basis for the organization’s lobbying preferences. The top twenty contributors are “dietary supplements” companies and commercial “labs” that market fraudulent tests such as “hair analysis.”
An examination of the Board of Directors and the Advisory Board of the AAHF is equally revealing. In 1999 the President, Murray Susser, M.D., was the chairman of the medical advisory board of Gero Vita International, a lucrative “supplements” company whose bogus claims have been the targets of numerous investigations by the FTC, FDA, U.S. Post Office, and congressional hearings. Susser’s practice, the “Longevity Medical Center” in Los Angeles, “uses Acupuncture, Homeopathy, Nutrition, Chelation Therapy, Heavy Metal Detoxification, Physical Therapy, Stress Management, Weight Management, Oxidative Therapies, and Detoxification Therapy.” Susser’s advertisements suggest that he knows the secret to halting the aging process and that he has “solved the mystery of chronic fatigue syndrome.” In 1995 he was disciplined by the California state medical board for “unprofessional conduct, gross negligence, incompetence, repeated negligent acts, and excessive use of diagnostic procedures.” He paid $15,000 and spent three years on probation. He does not mention this fact in the “professional information” section of his website.
Another member of the board of directors of the AAHF is Woodson C. Merrell, M.D., the Executive Director of the Center for Health and Healing at the Beth Israel Medical Center of New York and a regular speaker at Harvard “CAM” conferences. According to the Center’s website, Dr. Merrell’s “acquaintance with complementary medicine began at the age of one, when a neighborhood doctor cured his croup by placing three pellets of homeopathic aconite under his tongue.” The Center considers itself a showcase for “integrative medicine.” On its website one finds the following: suggestions that autism, ADHD, and learning disorders are caused by routine childhood vaccinations; suggestions that “craniosacral therapy” and homeopathy are useful treatments for these and other diseases; the alarmist claim of ubiquitous but ill-defined “toxins” that is common to naturopaths and other “alternative” practitioners; claims of chiropractic being useful for various visceral conditions, such as PMS and asthma; glowing recommendations of Therapeutic Touch, Ayurveda, Traditional Chinese Medicine, and other unlikely or untested methods; and more.
Of the eleven remaining physician members of the two AAHF boards, at least nine advocate fraudulent methods similar to those above, as do several among the non-physicians. Recurring themes are “anti-aging” claims, homeopathy, anti-vaccination hysteria, “immune boosters,” the hawking of “dietary supplements” and other dubious products over the Internet and directly to patients, “detoxification” claims, and the claim that EDTA “chelation therapy” can reverse coronary artery disease by leeching calcium out of atherosclerotic plaques (a well-known form of quackery that has existed for more than 30 years, though lacking in both biological basis and supportive studies).
According to the National Council Against Health Fraud, AAHF founder and board member Julian Whitaker makes $300,000/yr on “chelation” alone). Several AAHF board members have been in trouble with the federal government for misrepresentations of one sort or another [Jeffrey Bland and Jonathan Wright, for example]. At least three of the advisory board members have promoted Laetrile, the notorious, illegal quack cancer “remedy.” One of these, pharmacist Earl Mindell, claims to have a Ph.D. from a university that lacks accreditation, a campus, and a laboratory. Another, Robert Rowen, M.D., still recommends Laetrile through the Cancer Control Society, whose website carries the following warning:
CANCER VICTIMS
The Cancer Control Society Does not believe in the Traditional methods of Surgery, Radiation and Chemotherapy for the treatment of cancer by doctors in California hospitals. This treatment is proving to be flawed, ineffective and destructive to the immune system. More and more patients are seeking alternative methods.
It is clear that most of the “health professionals” on the AAHF boards have significant financial interests in dubious products, and several are smarting from having been inconvenienced by regulatory agencies. They seem to have found a sympathetic ear in fellow board member Michael Cohen, J.D., Harvard’s Director of Legal Programs for “CAM.”
The AAHF has several friends in Congress, including Rep. Dan Burton, who fought for the legalization of Laetrile in his home state of Indiana during the 1970s. Rep. Burton has used his chairmanship of the House Committee on Governmental Reform as a bully pulpit for the advocacy of numerous bogus methods, including the aforementioned “antineoplastons” and EDTA chelation “therapy.” The AAHF applauds his sponsoring of a bill that would prohibit the FDA from interfering with the promotion, sale, and administration of agents that, like Laetrile, are both scientifically baseless and dangerous.
According to the course brochure, Rep. Burton was scheduled to give a Key Presentation at the fall, 2001 “Models of Integrative Care: Present and Future” conference in San Francisco. Michael Cohen and fellow AAHF board member Woodson Merrell were listed among the other speakers. The conference was co-sponsored by Harvard Medical School and co-directed by Dr. Eisenberg.
The NCCAM, the Fetzer Institute, ‘CAM’ Hype, and More Conflicts of Interest
Harvard Medical School is the recipient of several grants from the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM). This organization is a branch of the federal government, so it might come as a surprise to some that its granting decisions are largely based on ideological prejudice. In November 2000, the month that Dr. Eisenberg began his tenure as the representative of the Massachusetts DPH to the naturopathic licensing issue, there were three naturopaths among the 17 members of the NCCAM National Advisory Council. Such representation on a federal advisory board is remarkable, not only because of the naturopaths’ pseudoscientific views (one on the Council is the recipient of an NCCAM grant to study psychic “healing”; another recommends coffee enemas for cancer and multiple sclerosis), but also because of their tiny numbers: there are only about 1500-2000 NDs nationwide. By comparison, there are about 30,000 MDs in Massachusetts alone.
Another member of the NCCAM Advisory Council is Ted Kaptchuk, the Associate Director of the Harvard Medical School CAMRE. Does it seem likely that the Harvard “CAM” project can be publicly critical of naturopathic claims and still hope to receive funds from the NCCAM?
Dr. Eisenberg’s main private funding source prior to Osher was the Fetzer Institute, a promoter of “CAM.” Fetzer funded Dr. Eisenberg’s telephone surveys on the use of “unconventional medicine” by Americans. Dr. Eisenberg and others have used these surveys to exaggerate the real demand for “alternative” methods by over-defining “unconventional,” including within this category, for example, “self-help groups,” “commercial diet,” “lifestyle diet,” “relaxation techniques,” and “massage”; by mentioning rarely-used methods (e.g., acupuncture, homeopathy, and naturopathy: all <1% in these studies) in the same context as common ones, thus inflating the apparent popularity of the former; and by minimizing the distinction between casual self-treatment and the use of practitioners, which are quite different issues. Nor was the conclusion of Eisenberg et al, that “the frequency of use of unconventional therapy in the United States is far higher than previously reported,” accurate. Dr. Eisenberg is also aware of a contemporary study that is much larger and more inclusive than either of his, but that shows far lower rates of use. He cites this study for other reasons in several articles but fails to mention that it disagrees with his own.
Although its website has stated that Fetzer “supports the application of rigorous scientific approaches to these therapies,” it also describes
efforts…underway to assist health care professionals in effectively integrating complementary therapies through continuing medical education courses, survey research on prevalence of use…and a program for producing standardized credentialing…”
The “credentialing program” would seem to further explain what Dr. Eisenberg and Mr. Cohen were doing at the Mass. Special Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medical Practitioners. But what about “integrating complementary therapies,” and why should “prevalence of use” have anything to do with it? Precious few “complementary therapies” have been shown to have any value, certainly not enough to serve as the basis for any course, clinical practice, or “credentialing program.” The statement fails to acknowledge that “integration” shouldn’t even be considered until safety and efficacy have been established.
Another Fetzer publication provides the explanation for this paradox. In his “Overview of Legislative Development Concerning Alternative Health Care in the United States: A Research Project of the Fetzer Institute,” David Sale ponderously concludes:
Given the synergistic momentum that arises from a high level of consumer usage of alternative therapies, the continuing interest of alternative providers in securing professional practice rights, and other patterns of activity in this field, it seems likely that the legislative arena will experience intense pressure in the coming years to accommodate alternative modes of care. If new enactments are predicated on a patient-centered ideal that accords the individual substantial freedom to select a mode of personal care, the interests of health care in the United States would indeed seem well-served.
In other words, let exaggerated popularity trump validity. This, with its attendant financial incentives, is the driving force behind the “CAM” movement. It is reflected in the report of the White House Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medicine Policy, currently in its “draft recommendations” stage, which calls for numerous efforts to shoehorn CAM into mainstream health care by increasing “CAM activities” in federal agencies, creating CAM lobbyists within federal agencies, mandating “coverage and reimbursement” for CAM, declaring CAM practitioners to be “primary care providers,” subsidizing their training, and much more.
The chairman of the White House Commission, James Gordon, has frankly admitted that CAM isn’t about evidence. In a recent quotation for The Scientist, he said: “The reason there is as much interest in complementary medicine as there is, is not because of the science. The moving force has been us.” Gordon, a 1967 graduate of Harvard Medical School, is a Fellow of the Fetzer Institute and a member of the advisory board of the Program for Extraordinary Experience Research, John Mack’s “alien abduction” organization. He was a Keynote speaker at last year’s Harvard Complementary and Integrative Medicine course.
InteliHealth
Harvard Medical School is involved in a joint venture with Aetna, Inc., to provide health information to consumers at a website called “InteliHealth.” Aetna describes the mission as follows:
InteliHealth’s mission is to empower people with trusted solutions for healthier lives. We accomplish this by providing credible information from the most trusted sources, including Harvard Medical School…
How much trust can InteliHealth’s readers place in Harvard Medical School for information regarding “CAM”? In an article entitled “Finding a Doctor who Understands Complementary and Alternative Medicine,” written by a faculty member of HMS, the reader is advised to find such a doctor at one of two sources: the American Holistic Medical Association and the American College for the Advancement of Medicine. A perusal of a newsletter from the first group reveals that numerous childhood diseases are explained by “toxic load,” “fungal dysbiosis,” heavy metals, immunizations, and zinc deficiency: the same fraudulent, alarming misinformation that naturopaths and many other “CAM” advocates preach. The second source is the organization founded more than 25 years ago to promote quack EDTA “chelation therapy” for coronary artery disease. Is the article’s author, who is not a physician, aware of these facts?
Elsewhere on InteliHealth, with the HMS logo prominently displayed above it (“Veritas”), is a fawning treatise [no longer available in Wayback; the link is to the identical essay] on “naturopathic medicine” that is boilerplate AANP propaganda: “NDs are trained as family physicians”; they “treat the whole patient, not just the disease symptoms”; they “successfully combine so many therapies,” etc. The article suggests that if the reader is already consulting an N.D., she may reasonably choose not to see an M.D. A bibliography entitled “Supporting Research” twists an embarrassing fact: it cites an FDA warning about the unfavorable interaction between St. John’s wort and HIV protease inhibitors, implying that this constitutes “supporting research” for naturopathic claims. In fact, naturopaths have promoted St. John’s wort to HIV+ patients as an antiviral agent for years, without plausible evidence, and continue to do so in spite of this dangerous interaction. How many patients may have developed AIDS or suffered relapses because of this is unknown, because naturopaths don’t look. The FDA warning should have been cited as non-supporting research.
InteliHealth offers similar treatises for several other “CAM” methods, in each case backed by the Harvard logo, and in each case making unsubstantiated claims for efficacy. The following examples are from the homeopathy and chiropractic treatises, respectively:
Conditions that respond well to homeopathic treatment include arthritis, migraines, asthma, eczema, attention-deficit disorder, depression, anxiety, ulcerative colitis, Crohn’s disease, chronic-fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia, multiple sclerosis, back pain, gastritis, peptic-ulcer disease, ear infections, and strep infections.
Chiropractic has shown to be effective for acute and chronic low back pain, neck pain, headaches (including migraines), inflammation of the middle ear, digestive problems, menstrual and premenstrual pain, frozen shoulder, tennis elbow and other sports injuries, carpal tunnel syndrome, arthritis, and asthma.
No homeopathic treatment has ever been shown to help any medical condition, and none will, because the basis for the practice is contrary to fact. The great Harvard physician Oliver Wendell Holmes eloquently debunked homeopathy in 1842. All that has changed since then is that we are even more justified, after 160 years of progress in physiology and pharmacology, the discovery of the placebo effect and more, in concluding that homeopathy is nonsense.
Manual therapy may be helpful, in a limited way, for back and neck pain. There is no evidence that chiropractic is effective for any of the other conditions on the list, and no biological basis for predicting that there ever will be. Pediatricians might be alarmed to know that chiropractors claim to prevent and cure otitis media by repeated “adjustments” of the cervical spine, which they recommend even for infants. There is no basis whatsoever for this practice, which has resulted in vertebral artery lacerations and death. Nevertheless, a recent article by a Harvard pediatrician—the director of Boston’s Center for Holistic Pediatric Education and Research at Children’s Hospital—includes a photograph of a chiropractor performing this maneuver on a nine-month old boy. There is no discussion and no critique, only a caption blandly referring to it as “chiropractic care.”
Final note: Several of the InteliHealth articles, including those on naturopathy, homeopathy, and chiropractic, were replaced in March 2002 after this essay was written. The new articles lack some of the more outrageous therapeutic claims but are still misleading. See the accompanying essay on homeopathy for an example.

   Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part III)
Kimball Atwood
Link
In Parts I and II of this series* we saw that from 2000 to 2002, key members of the Harvard Medical School “CAM” program, including the Director, had promoted quackery to the legislature of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. We also saw other explicit or tacit promotions by Harvard institutions and professors, and embarrassing examples of such promotions on InteliHealth, a consumer health website ostensibly committed to “providing credible information from the most trusted sources, including Harvard Medical School….”
Those points were made in an essay that I sent in the spring of 2002 to Daniel Federman, the Senior Dean for Alumni Relations and Clinical Teaching at Harvard Medical School (HMS). I also sent Dr. Federman a treatise on homeopathy, including several examples of credulous Harvard professors and misrepresentations aimed at students, patients, and the public. Much of the content of that treatise has been covered by the series on homeopathy† with which I began my stint here on SBM, so here I’ll post only the parts relevant to promotions by academic physicians, including those at Harvard. There is a bit of redundancy involving InteliHealth, but please bear with me if you’ve made it this far; the discussion will be meatier than the short summary in Part II.
………………………..
Modern Academic Promotions of Homeopathy
Dr. Holmes must be rolling in his grave. Homeopathy is now being given credence by mainstream academic ‘CAM’ programs of the best pedigrees, including Harvard’s. The National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) even takes homeopathy seriously: the former Director, Wayne Jonas, is a practicing homeopath and continues to receive public funding from the NCCAM for homeopathic “research.” At a hearing of Rep. Dan Burton’s House Committee on Governmental Reform in November 2001, Jonas called for homeopathic solutions to bioterrorism threats, praising Jacques Beneviste in his prepared statement. Current Director Stephen Straus cautioned that such remedies should not be substituted for proven measures, even as he bowed to what now seems to be the polite way of discussing quackery:
The prophylactic benefits of exceedingly dilute substances are more in doubt than those of conventional vaccines.”
And, a bit later:
Even though there is some doubt that these products could be effective, we cannot prove the claims to be entirely specious….Exploration of such approaches should first involve careful studies in animals using contemporary methodologies to discern whether they hold any promise against diseases associated with biological weapons.”
Harvard Medical School
Harvard Medical School now presides over several promotions of homeopathy, both as a clinical method and as a subject of uncritical education and research. Descriptions of the practice and its basis are frequently erroneous in Harvard-based literature, as the following examples attest.
From 1997 until March 2002 InteliHealth, a joint effort of HMS and Aetna to provide web-based health information, had this to say about homeopathy:
One of the basic principles of homeopathy is that when a substance in large doses causes certain symptoms, in small doses it can help heal a person suffering from an illness that has those same symptoms. Some treatments in conventional medicine rely on this like-cures-like principle: vaccines, for instance, introduce small doses of an illness-causing agent to cure or prevent disease.
Conditions that respond well to homeopathic treatment include arthritis, migraines, asthma, eczema, attention-deficit disorder, depression, anxiety, ulcerative colitis, Crohn’s disease, chronic-fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia, multiple sclerosis, back pain, gastritis, peptic-ulcer disease, ear infections, and strep infections.
To receive an information package and a directory that lists trained homeopaths in your area, send $10 to the National Center for Homeopathy, 801 North Fairfax Street, Suite 306, Alexandria, VA 22314, or use the center’s free searchable directory online at www.homeopathic.org. Contact the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians at 206-298-0125 to find a qualified naturopath in your area.
The vaccine analogy is, of course, erroneous. Vaccines do not “introduce small doses of an illness-causing agent,” since what they actually introduce are non-virulent, attenuated, or non-viable variants of such agents. Furthermore, the dose of the agent in a vaccine is substantial and determined by rational dose-response curves. The dose of the purported active agent in a homeopathic preparation is miniscule or nonexistent, and determined by homeopathic “provings,” which are invalid as a basis for therapeutic decisions.
There is no evidence for any of the therapeutic claims made in the second quoted paragraph. The “supportive research” section of the article may look impressive to the naïve reader. In fact, some of the references support the non-efficacy of homeopathy and the others are hopelessly flawed.
The third quoted paragraph consists of two advertisements.
Homeopathy, “Integrative Medicine,” and Ethics
The new InteliHealth homeopathy article is more circumspect, but still misleading. It is a good example of what now passes for a “balanced” treatment of the subject:
While homeopathy is relatively safe, it should be a complement to, not a substitute for, standard medical care.
This is a well meaning but naïve attempt, by advocates of “integrative medicine,” to coax pseudoscientific methods into the fold of rational practice. An example of the futility of this approach has already been offered above, in the case of licensed homeopaths advising parents against having their children immunized. It turns out that “standard medical care” is specifically proscribed by the most influential of all homeopathic treatises, Hahnemann’s Organon of Medicine:
§ 52 Sixth Edition
There are but two principle methods of cure: the one based only on accurate observation of nature, on careful experimentation and pure experience, the homœopathic (before we never designedly used) and a second which does not do this, the heteropathic or allopathic. Each opposes the other, and only he who does not know either can hold the delusion that they can ever approach each other or even become united, or to make himself so ridiculous as to practice at one time homœopathically at another allopathically, according to the pleasure of the patient; a practice which may be called criminal treason against divine homœopathy.
So much for homeopathy and “integrative medicine.” There is plenty of evidence that Hahnemann’s stern admonition is taken seriously by contemporary homeopaths (available upon request). Even if some disagree with his stance, it does not follow that homeopathy is thus rendered an acceptable practice. To paraphrase physicist John Farley, homeopathy is no more “complementary” to rational medicine than is alchemy to chemistry, astrology to astronomy, or creationism to evolution. It is theoretically true that if all practitioners of homeopathy also practiced, or referred patients for, rational medicine, and if no patients were seduced into substituting homeopathic preparations for rational treatment, there would be no medical disasters referable to homeopathy per se. After all, homeopathic “remedies,” at least those that are unadulterated, are inert. In reality, such contingencies can never be assured: on the contrary, they are undermined by endorsements, however well intended, from bastions of modern medicine and science.
Here is an example. The aforementioned Dana Ullman is among the most well known homeopaths in the United States today, and certainly one of the most influential in “Integrative Medicine” circles. His several popular books and his website, Homeopathic Educational Services, are recommended by many academic CAM programs, including the Rosenthal Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine at Columbia University and the Zakim Center for Integrated Therapies at the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute in Boston. One of his books was recommended in the first Intelihealth article reviewed above. On his website, Ullman identifies himself as “an instructor in a course on homeopathy at the University of California at San Francisco” and states that he “serves on advisory boards of alternative medicine institutes at Harvard and Columbia schools of medicine.” Ullman is listed as a member of the advisory board of Integrative Medicine: the Worldwide Authority on Integrated Care, a position he shares with four representatives of the Harvard Medical School CAM project along with representatives of the medical schools of Johns Hopkins, George Washington University, SUNY Stony Brook, and the Universities of Arizona, Colorado, Hawaii, Maryland, and Minnesota. If the “integrative medicine” movement has embraced any homeopath, it has embraced Dana Ullman.
Yet it is difficult to imagine that his medical school patrons have read Mr. Ullman’s writings, even as they recommend them to the public. If they had, they would know that Ullman issues dire warnings to parents about “dangerous conventional medicines” and that for strep throat, for example, “you should start with homeopathic treatment” and “it is reasonable to forego antibiotics even for children since rheumatic fever is so rare today.” They might also have noticed an article in last October’s Utne Reader, for which Ullman lists himself as the “health book reviewer,” in which he recommended homeopathic “nosodes” for the prevention of anthrax (Ullman also offers an Anthrax Nosode and Accompanied Remedies Kit, for $33, on his website). Are these recommendations indicative of the benefits of “integrative medicine?” One can only hope that Harvard and the other medical schools that endorse Ullman do so out of ignorance, because the alternative explanation is even more troubling.
Another argument frequently given for the acceptance of homeopathy is the popular demand for a practice that is not intrinsically unsafe, wholly apart from its capacity to divert patients from rational medicine. If for whatever reason it makes some people feel better, the argument goes, why not welcome it? There are several answers to this. The first is that this essay addresses the appropriate role of trusted societal institutions such as medical schools and government, not the choices of a free citizenry. These institutions should be providing education, and doing so with the utmost integrity. At least some of the current demand is due to the very sorts of misleading promotions described here. The second answer is that those who seek homeopathy will always be able to find it, as they have in the past. In the U.S. it has been a tiny, fringe practice for almost 100 years, and it would behoove the public health for it to remain as such. The recent bandwagon-style
promotion of this and other CAM methods, to a large extent fueled by the misleading hyping of Dr. Eisenberg’s telephone surveys, has only served to move homeopathy closer to the popular mainstream—even as the evidence for it remains nonexistent.
Homeopathy was quackery in 1980 and nothing, other than “spin,” has changed. In any case, its capacity to appear to make some patients feel better cannot be divorced from its capacity to divert them from effective therapies. How many children reporting that their sore throats feel better after swallowing homeopathic belladonna or arsenicum, for example, would it take to justify each excess case of rheumatic heart disease?
Mainstream endorsements of irrational claims are also damaging in other ways: they are confusing to a scientifically challenged public, they waste research dollars, they help line the pockets of quacks, and they are embarrassing to the work of the great majority of physicians and medical scientists and to the reputations of the medical schools that feature “CAM” programs. Finally, if practicing homeopathy to the exclusion of rational medicine is unethical, it does not follow that “integrating” it with rational practice would make it any less so, even if it were to become technically safer. A lie is still a lie.
More Harvard Homeopathy Hype
Back to the new Intelihealth article:
It is also a highly controversial form of medicine because it lacks a scientific explanation for why its treatments might work.
Well, not exactly. Rational medical doctors know that it is a classic example of a popular delusion, and that there are perfectly good explanations for why its treatments might, at times, appear to work.
Homeopathic remedies consist of highly diluted preparations of natural ingredients. The ingredient may be diluted 30 to 50 times, sometimes to the point where no molecules of active ingredient remain.
The ingredients are actually diluted far more than 30-50 times, as correctly suggested by the second part of the sentence. Typical dilutions are 10^12-10^60 fold. There is no rational, repeatable basis for determining what might be the “correct” dilution for a given “remedy.”
But an analysis of 89 clinical trials published in a major medical journal, The Lancet, in 1997 found that the clinical effects of homeopathy are not entirely due to placebo effect.
A 1991 analysis of 105 clinical trials published in the British Medical Journal found that 81 of the studies showed positive clinical results while 24 found no positive effect from homeopathic treatment. The researchers concluded that the evidence was positive but insufficient to draw any conclusion regarding the efficacy of homeopathic treatment, and they recommended that additional well-designed studies be undertaken.
These are the kinds of equivocal reviews invariably cited by proponents of homeopathy and of further homeopathy research. Not stated in the InteliHealth article is that all such reviews find that the studies showing “positive effect” tend to be among the most methodologically flawed, whereas the better studies are more likely to show no effect. For this and other reasons such reviews actually support the non-efficacy of homeopathy, and further homeopathy research can be predicted to yield an endless cycle of equivocal results. In the meantime, the conclusions cited in the passages above—that there is some “positive” evidence and that homeopathy therefore needs further research—merely serve to give the practice an unearned appearance of legitimacy. Hence this sort of article—typical among modern, medical school based “CAM” treatises—is not really “balanced,” but implicitly promotional.
The Family Education and Resource Program of Children’s Hospital promotes homeopathy in a brochure aimed at patients and parents. Highlights of the brochure include a misleading definition of “alternative treatment” (“a kind of treatment you don’t usually receive at a regular doctor’s office or clinic”); a sub-heading (“How does homeopathy work?”) that presumes homeopathy to be effective; a misleading suggestion that homeopaths are astute clinicians (“Homeopathic practitioners wish to understand their patients well. Homeopathic remedies are very specific to the patient’s particular symptoms, daily routines and personality”) that is actually an allusion to the nosy, largely irrelevant “symptom” gathering previously described; and spurious suggestions of efficacy: “homeopathy may be helpful for people suffering from allergies, bruises and sprains and for children with diarrhea.” The brochure invites its readers to call the Center for Holistic Pediatric Education and Research at Children’s Hospital, whose national advisory board includes the president of the American Institute of Homeopathy, for “a list of pediatric homeopaths in the Boston area.”
The “information resources for consumers” webpage of the Caregroup/Harvard Medical School Center for Alternative Medicine Research and Education (CAMRE) promotes homeopathy indirectly by the following advice:
Please consult your local telephone yellow pages under these categories:
Acupuncture
Chiropractic
Holistic Practitioners
Massage – Therapeutic
Naturopathic Physicians
Homeopathy is an integral part of the practice of “naturopathic physicians,” as documented elsewhere in these materials, and is also frequently offered by others on the list.
Homeopathy Research and Education at Harvard
Modern homeopathy research is taken seriously at Harvard but, like the endorsement of Dana Ullman, it is shrouded in a veil of ignorance. After Drs. Reilly and Eisenberg had chastised the conventional straw-man at the 2001 Harvard CIM conference, Reilly likened the concept of ultra-dilute homeopathic preparations to examples of small quantities of substances known to exert a biological effect: pheromones, vitamins, and pollen desensitization regimens. These analogies are false, but Reilly was not challenged. In his own syllabus Dr. Eisenberg listed three homeopathy articles under the heading, “Articles/Consensus Reports Suggesting Efficacy,” but none under the heading, “Articles/Studies Suggesting Lack of Efficacy.” Of the three listed articles, two actually support the lack of homeopathic efficacy, and the third is misleading and uninterpretable.
The Faculty Development and Fellowship Program in Complementary and Alternative Medicine at Harvard Medical School lists a homeopath among its faculty members. Here is a quotation attributed to this homeopath:
Quoting from Edward H. Chapman, M.D., Dht, President of the American Institute of Homeopathy, and Clinical Instructor at the Harvard University School of Medicine: “For those who need support in their struggle with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder … they can be assured from two hundred years experience using homeopathic medicines that they are safe. Your conventional doctor may be skeptical if you choose to use homeopathy. Don’t let that stop you. Seek assistance from well-trained homeopathic providers who are willing to work with you and your doctors.”
Is Harvard Medical School developing more faculty members with views such as this? Are fellows, in addition to patients, now being encouraged to think that homeopathy is a valid clinical practice or, at the very least, worthy of research? The Course Description for “Complementary, Alternative, Integrative Medicine” at HMS, which includes homeopathy on its list of covered topics, is hardly reassuring. It defines “CAM” as “refer[ring] to medical techniques not in conformity with the beliefs or standards of the conventional medical community…,” as if to suggest that knowledge has nothing to do with it. What distinguish modern medicine from homeopathy and most CAM claims are not “conventional beliefs” or even standards, but reason and facts. Isn’t this what should be stressed to medical students, fellows, and patients?
An Example of Homeopathy Research and More Ethical Mischief
Harvard’s Dr. Chapman also “uses homeopathy as the primary treatment for AOM” (acute otitis media) in children, according to a recent paper authored by himself and Dr. Eisenberg, among others. This paper is a useful example of modern “homeopathy research” in Boston and another illustration of the mischief that can result from misleading promotions of “CAM” popularity. It is a “pilot study” of homeopathic treatments of AOM in children. The authors justify this by stating that “homeopathy is a frequently used alternative therapy for AOM,” citing Dr. Eisenberg’s first telephone survey as evidence. That survey, however, involved only adults and reported that 1% of the 1539 adults queried, or about 15, had used homeopathy for any reason in the past 12 months; of these about 1/3, or a total of five, had seen a “provider.” The survey mentioned neither AOM nor any other disease in relation to homeopathy.
The homeopathy paper refers to the “principle of similars” as an “observation,” and states as fact the very claim that would seem to be at issue:
Choosing the appropriate medication for an individual patient is time-consuming and challenging, and it depends on the skill and experience of the homeopathic practitioner.”
As discussed earlier, homeopathic “symptom” gathering and “provings” are not valid clinical tools. Most troubling of all, 22 out of the 24 children in the study received nothing but homeopathic “remedies” for a disease that calls for antibiotics† (the other two received antibiotics only after 13 and 28 days, respectively). This appears to be a violation of the Declaration of Helsinki of the World Health Organization, which states, in part:
In any medical study, every patient — including those of a control group, if any — should be assured of the best proven diagnostic and therapeutic method.”
Nevertheless, the study was “approved by the Human Studies Committee at Boston Medical Center.” It would seem that “CAM” has spawned a new era in medical ethics together with its redefining of medical science.
Dr. Eisenberg, who has promised that the HMS “CAM” project will be guided by scientific integrity, seems to use science selectively when considering homeopathy. In testimony to the White House Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medicine Policy (WHCCAMP) in May 2001, he said:
I have given in your handout examples of I think the best examples we have to date, most of them from the last five years, where the evidence suggests that there is some efficacy of CAM therapies for particular conditions…Two studies, meta-analyses suggesting homeopathy as distinct from placebo… You are aware of these. These are sort of the examples of good research suggesting positive effectiveness.
Well, no. These are examples of research that is poor but nevertheless good enough, in the face of a vanishingly unlikely 200 year-old claim, to put the matter to rest once and for all. At the 2001 Harvard CIM conference Dr. Eisenberg, (mis-)quoting Carl Sagan, had declared that “exceptional claims require exceptional evidence.” Here, he seemed to have forgotten that truth.
Later in his WHCCAMP testimony Dr. Eisenberg offered a curious view of science, as it pertains to homeopathy, in responding to a question from homeopath and former NCCAM Director Jonas:
Wayne, I completely agree and I put up this slide to really humbly reflect on how the trajectory has gotten rather cockeyed, that in the absence of a robust basic science program, certainly the scientists in the medical community will continue to be irritated… So, I am agreeing with you.
I would say it a little differently, though. I think my suggestion in a positive, in a way to give a friendly amendment to what has happened, I think it has happened because it has happened. I mean, you know, if the first study was a basic science study of the mechanism of homeopathy, we would have a very different trajectory, but that didn’t happen.
Except that basic science did happen, as irritated scientists know. They might remind Dr. Eisenberg that there is an abundance of basic science pertaining to the “mechanism” of homeopathy: physics (the second law of the universe and no basis for “water memory”); chemistry (molecular theory and Avogadro’s number); biochemistry, physiology and pharmacology (pharmacokinetics, dose-response curves, the law of mass action, molecular receptors); pathology and pathophysiology (the natural history of disease and the classification of diseases according to real biological phenomena, as opposed to treatments based on irreproducible, subjective interpretations of “symptoms”).
A scientific study of the “mechanism” of homeopathy must also consider psychology and experimental design and interpretation for an appreciation of bias, cueing, selective attention, practitioner expectation, patient expectation, confirmation bias, the “Stockholm effect,” cultural predilections, the placebo effect, inadequate controls, error, fraud, chance, statistical pitfalls, publication bias, and more. These are the myriad reasons, i.e., “mechanisms,” by which any dogmatic therapeutic claim with little or no basis in nature can be expected, when subjected to clinical trials, to yield equivocal—as opposed to consistently negative—results.
As for the naïve assertion that even wholly negative results would dissuade true believers of homeopathy or any other magical healing “system,” which is the standard highbrow justification for the existence of the NCCAM, the HMS CAM project, and for the collective acquiescence of all who should know better, the last word must go to the good Dr. Holmes:
… it is impossible not to realize the entire futility of attempting to silence this asserted science by the flattest and most peremptory results of experiment. Were all the hospital physicians of Europe and America to devote themselves, for the requisite period, to this sole pursuit, and were their results to be unanimous as to the total worthlessness of the whole system in practice, this slippery delusion would slide through their fingers without the slightest discomposure, when, as they supposed, they had crushed every joint in its tortuous and trailing body.
………………….
† American Academy of Pediatrics. Judicious Use of Antimicrobial Agents. In Redbook 2000: Report of the Committee on Infectious Diseases, 25th edition. pp. 647-648. I am aware that subsequent to that time, new guidelines provide for a period of observation without antibiotics in some cases of acute otitis media. These were not in place at the time of the homeopathy trial, nor would they have applied to most of the experimental subjects in that trial. The children in the homeopathy trial, moreover, were also not given analgesics and antipyretics.

   Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part IV)
Kimball Atwood
Link
HMS Puts the Messenger in its Crosshairs 
When, during the fall and winter of 2001-02 I first approached Dean Daniel Federman of the Harvard Medical School (HMS) with evidence that the HMS “CAM” program was promoting pseudomedicine, I gave him some materials that I thought would be adequate to make the case: ‘CAM’ Director David Eisenberg’s dubious funding sources and his failure to disclose them to the Massachusetts Special Commission; the website of the Caregroup/Harvard Medical School Center for Alternative Medicine Research and Education (CAMRE), which urged anonymous websurfers to “consult your local telephone yellow pages” for ‘naturopathic physicians’ and other quacks; the presence on the ultra-PPO American Association for Health Freedom (AAHF) Advisory Board of attorney Michael H. Cohen, the Harvard CAMRE’s “Director of Legal Programs” (at the time, Dr. Federman agreed with me that the mere existence of such a position was curious, if the CAMRE’s purpose was ”research and education”); that Dr. Eisenberg and Atty Cohen had contributed to a report to the Massachusetts State Legislature recommending a formal state imprimatur for the practice of pseudomedicine; and other embarrassing findings. A bit later, in March 2002, I sent him a draft of the essay that I posted in Parts I and II of this series.
That material proved not to be adequate, for on March 20, 2002, Dr. Federman sent me the following letter:
Dear Kim,
I ready to undertake a formal review of the Harvard Medical School’s Division of Research and Education in Complementary and Alternative Medicine, and of its leadership to investigate the charges outlined in your letter of November 4, 2001, subsequent emails, and our meeting of January 22, 2002 in my office. I have read almost all of the voluminous literature you sent me and am writing to ask you to assist our efforts. Specifically, I am asking you to prepare a one to three page summary of the specific portions of the material you sent me that you consider erroneous, duplicitous, misleading, or fraudulent.* I do not feel I should summarize your views. Please be specific and give sources, where you can, in support of your statements.
I am committed to achieving a careful and balanced review of the issues you raise.
Sincerely,
Daniel E. Federman, M.D.
* [These are terms that I had used in my communications with Dr. Federman; the only one from which I backed away, after he reacted with considerable alarm, was "fraudulent."]
That was the first real suggestion that the fix was in. The pertinent literature that I’d sent Dr. Federman did not consist of “my views” or even my words. It consisted of statements copied from CAMRE publications and other public sources. Why did Dr. Federman now seem to be framing the issue as a matter of (my) opinion? Why weren’t the points that I’d already presented and documented (they were specific and I gave sources) sufficient to trigger an independent, formal review? What about the summary that I’d already written in the form of a letter to Harvard Magazine, which Dr. Federman had also read? No matter: I was still confident that he would do the right thing when he saw the totality of the evidence, abundantly and overwhelmingly supporting my contention that the CAMRE and other HMS affiliates were promoting pseudomedicine—dangerously, unethically, and in contrast to their stated purpose.
It was then that I resolved to write the essays that I posted in Parts I, II and III of this series.‡ I also prepared the summary that Dr. Federman had requested, which is reprinted below. In June, 2002, I sent these together with this letter:
Dear Dan,
Here is the summary you requested. Along with it are two essays that provide extensive documentation for the assertions made. The first is similar to the one that I sent you in March (I’m not sure you ever saw it), but with some revisions. Please replace that one with this one. Both essays read like magazine articles, because I tried to interest Harvard Magazine in hosting a real debate on the subject of “CAM” at HMS. HM refused. 
As illustrated by these essays, in order to grasp some of the realities of “CAM” it is necessary to invest a bit of time and effort. I’ve done most of that for those that might sit in judgment of this issue; I trust that they will do their part by actually reading the material, as you did earlier this year. I also think that you and I should talk about who might be involved in this inquiry.
Sincerely yours,
Kimball Atwood, MD
…………..
Harvard Medical School’s “CAM” Program Promotes Absurd and Dangerous Practices: Summary 
Harvard Medical School’s “Complementary and Alternative Medicine” program is not what its public image suggests. In addition to dubious “research and education” a major function of the project is the public promotion, both explicit and implicit, of methods that are highly implausible, dangerous, or both. Such promotion is likely to be detrimental to public health, to public perceptions of how science relates to progress in medicine, to the education of medical students, and to Harvard’s reputation as an institution devoted to rational inquiry and to the dissemination of reliable medical information. Most importantly, it is a violation of the ethical principle of veracity.
Some of these promotions are, undoubtedly, well meaning but based on a naïve understanding of the practices themselves. Others are ideologically driven or based on a pseudoscientific view that is unacceptable in a modern medical school. Still others are an inevitable result of the conflict of interest that occurs when a university accepts funds from organizations with ideological biases. In the case of “CAM” at Harvard, some of the funding organizations are the Fetzer Institute, the Osher Foundation, the American Specialty Health Plans, the Templeton Foundation, the Southwest College of Naturopathic Medicine, the New England School of Acupuncture, the New York Chiropractic College, the Cambridge Muscular Therapy Institute, and the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM). A grant from any of these has the same implications for bias in discussion and inquiry as would a grant from the Tobacco Institute—or worse, because the grantor can count on the ignorance, regarding “CAM” claims, of both the public and of the great majority of faculty and students at the recipient institution.
I have summarized several examples of implicit and explicit promotions below. In addition, I’ve provided documents that support most of the assertions made here, and more. They leave no doubt that advocacy is a major part of the HMS “CAM” project. They also explain how I became aware of this matter. They refute, in various ways, any contention that “CAM” claims are mostly harmless and are therefore of little concern when promoted in the context of academic medicine. They also cast doubt on the legitimacy of the “research and education” part of the project.
There are other promotions of dubious health claims that bear the HMS imprimatur, but enough are shown here to make the point. I doubt that many HMS faculty members, including many of those nominally involved with the “CAM” program, are aware of most of the facts described herein.
I. Explicit promotions of dubious and/or dangerous methods.
     1.  The “information resources for consumers” webpage of the Caregroup/Harvard Medical School Center for Alternative Medicine Research and Education (CAMRE) recommends, without further comment, that consumers consult any of several dubious practitioners via the telephone yellow pages. It also recommends a web-based book (Choices in Healing by Michael Lerner) on unproven cancer “remedies,” many of which have no more scientific validity than laetrile.
     2.  Dr. David Eisenberg and Attorney Michael Cohen (“Director of Legal Programs, Division for Research and Education in Complementary & Integrative Medical Therapies, Harvard Medical School”) represented the Massachusetts Department of Public Health at the recently adjourned Mass. Special Commission to Study Complementary and Alternative Health Practitioners. In this role they contributed to a report recommending that the Commonwealth license “naturopathic physicians,” a group of pseudoscientific quacks, as health care providers. Mr. Cohen’s writings and activities demonstrate that he is committed to the promotion of pseudoscientific health claims through legal and political means.
     3.  InteliHealth, a health information website that appears to be a partnership between Harvard Medical School and Aetna, specifically or indirectly advocates several absurd methods in the context of erroneous descriptions of “CAM” practices. Some of the more outrageous therapeutic claims in these treatises have been removed recently, but many of the misleading descriptions remain.
     4.  Homeopathy is explicitly promoted in several contexts within or related to the HMS “CAM” project. Although it is not the only absurd method being promoted, it is useful as an example. Nor is it benign, in spite of what some might imagine. It is also the subject of an unethical study co-authored by the Director and Associate Director of the Harvard Center for Alternative Medicine Research and Education.
II. Implicit promotions of dubious and/or dangerous methods.
     1.  The new Zakim Center for Integrated Therapies at Dana Farber recommends numerous examples of unlikely and unsupported claims. Among these are homeopathy, therapeutic (non) touch, “guided imagery” and other suggestions that cancer can be wished away, and the previously mentioned Choices in Healing by Michael Lerner. Even if some patients are comforted by some of these measures, this does not justify their implicit promotion as disease-altering remedies: it is inevitable that in some cases they will confuse and disappoint desperate cancer patients and their families.
     2.  A recurring Harvard CME course, funded by the Templeton Foundation, is “Spirituality and Healing in Medicine.” A regular speaker in this course is the Chairman of the Board of the Church of Christ, Scientist. How ironic that barely ten years after the last public example of a Massachusetts child being sacrificed to Christian Science “healing,” and at a time when the practice has been successfully marginalized to the brink of extinction, Harvard Medical School may be aiding in its resurrection.
III. Two local examples of the recent widespread promotion of dubious methods.
     1.  Most “CAM” courses in American medical schools are not critical of the claims that they teach.† If the annual Harvard CME “Complementary and Integrative Medicine” course and Dr. Eisenberg’s public proclamations regarding homeopathy and other unlikely claims are any indication, the HMS CAM course is no different. This would be unfortunate for Harvard Medical Students, some of whom are likely, at this stage in their lives, to be susceptible to fanciful medical claims. It would also undermine efforts by other Harvard faculty to impart the critical thinking skills necessary for legitimate scientific inquiry and for the interpretation of the literature of evidence-based medicine.
     2.  The “Marino Center for Progressive Health” is a chain of local medical practices offering “state-of-the-art conventional medicine combined with complementary and alternative therapies.” Among the latter are homeopathy, EDTA chelation “therapy” for coronary artery disease, “craniosacral therapy,” chiropractic for “prevention of disease,” and more. The Marino Center also has its own “health store,” which sells unnecessary vitamins and useless homeopathic “remedies,” apparently for a profit. Several of the physicians on the Center staff are recent graduates of Harvard Medical School or Harvard residencies, and/or hold teaching positions at HMS. The website lists the staff homeopath as a “Teaching Associate in Anaesthesiology, Harvard Medical School.” Perhaps HMS should spend more effort soliciting funds for the teaching of medical ethics, and less for the teaching of “CAM.” 
† Sampson, Wallace. The Need for Educational Reform in Teaching about Alternative Therapies. Academic Medicine 76(3): 248-250. (March, 2001)
Kimball C. Atwood
HMS Class of ‘79
5/31/02 
………………..
On June 27, 2002, Dr. Federman replied:
Dear Kim, 
Thank you for the material you sent. I am beginning an appropriate inquiry.
In one of your points there is no need for investigation. As the representative of Dean Joseph Martin, I can confirm—contrary to your allegation—that Harvard Medical School as such has no advocacy position whatsoever regarding complementary and alternative medicine. The division was undertaken to conduct research and to provide education about, not in, complementary and alternative medicine.
Sincerely,
Daniel Federman, M.D.
Oh boy. At this point I was well on my way to losing confidence in the ‘inquiry.’ I responded as follows:
7/3/02
Dear Dan,
Thank you for acknowledging your receipt of the written material that I sent you.
Apparently one of my points requires clarification. I did not allege, nor did I mean to imply, that the Harvard Medical School per se, or even its “CAM” program, has a formal “advocacy position” regarding implausible health claims. Rather I described numerous examples of such advocacy, and these are simply facts: consider InteliHealth. Thus in my summary a pertinent statement reads as follows: “[These documents] leave no doubt that advocacy is a major part of the HMS ‘CAM’ project” (emphasis added). I continue to stand by that statement. If the distinction between formal and de facto advocacy was not clear throughout the essays, please consider this letter a correction.
I can also assure you that I have never thought that the HMS hierarchy has anything to do with the advocacy of dubious health claims, other than by unwitting association. This inquiry is an opportunity for the HMS leadership to dissociate itself from such advocacy (again, consider InteliHealth). That is one of the reasons that I approached you in the first place.
Advocacy by some in the Harvard “CAM” project has run amok, as demonstrated in the materials that I sent you. I consider those responsible to be ‘loose cannons’ on the ship of HMS, but I can’t know exactly what their motivations are or even if they are consciously aware of such advocacy. Dr. Eisenberg, fresh from advocating state endorsement of naturopathic practices and in receipt of funds from the Southwest College of Naturopathic Medicine, denied it in his answer to my letter to Harvard Magazine. However, as Dr. Holmes might put it, “the question naturally arises: is not this man deceiving himself, or trying to deceive others?” Questions of motivation and deception aside, the insidious promotion of quack practices by those who wrap themselves in the HMS banner is an embarrassment to the Harvard Medical School, to its leadership, and to its alumni. The public doesn’t make the sorts of distinctions that both you and I might wish were apparent.
Sincerely yours,
Kimball Atwood, M.D.
HMS Class of 1979
I was right, and I was pissed. In the American sense, that is.


   Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part V)
Kimball Atwood
Link
September 26, 2002
Kimball Atwood, M.D.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Dear Kim,
I have now had time to look into the allegations in your letter of June 14th which, incidentally, I shared with Dr. David Eisenberg and he with several others. I have sought consultation about our exchanges and the gist of my response follows.
Some of your concerns and allegations are very helpful and constructive. Perceptions are particularly important in controversial fields where there is limited objective proof. Your cautions and interpretations in this area have been very useful to us.
Some of what you said is just plain wrong. This includes the allegation the Harvard has “a stake” in the area and therefore would not look into your allegations objectively. Relatedly, Dr. Howard Koh has written us a construction of the events in the Massachusetts Special Commission that is strikingly different from yours. And Dr. Anthony Komoroff has pointed out that many of your comments about the InteliHealth treatment of CAM are now grossly out of date as the material inherited from another provider has been reviewed by HMS faculty and modified. [Indeed, you have referred in other correspondence to modifications you have noticed.] Dr. Komaroff also commented on the misleading way your citation the treatment of homeopathy was disconnected from the rest of the paragraph.
Some of what you said is a matter of taste or interpretation, where even well intentioned people may disagree. In this particular area I have weighed your arguments carefully and, in places, learned from them.
But I think the biggest difference may be in a misperception about what our purposes are. The Council of Academic Deans of Harvard Medical School approved beginning a Division of Research and Education in Complementary and Alternative Therapies with exactly the focus described. Our goal is to do peer-reviewed basic and clinical research on the claimed, but unproven, efficacies of complementary and alternative approaches to therapeutics. The recent scientific sessions and requests for proposal held by the Division are clear testament to this intent. In addition, in common with the Association of American Medical Colleges and most of the allopathic schools of medicine, we intend to teach our students something about CAM and in particular how to assess its claims rigorously. We do not, repeat NOT, have any intention of making our students CAM practitioners. They have enough to do learning what we have always focused on.
Sincerely,
Daniel D. Federman, M.D.
cc: David M. Eisenberg, M.D.
………………………….
October 5, 2002
Daniel Federman, M.D.
Senior Dean for Alumni Relations
And Clinical Teaching
Carl W. Walter Distinguished Professor
Of Medicine and Medical Education
Harvard Medical School
25 Shattuck St.
Boston, MA 02115
Dear Dan,
Here is a point-by-point response to your letter of September 26, 2002.
Your assertion that I made “the allegation that Harvard has a ‘stake’ in the area and therefore would not look into your allegations objectively” is a straw man. Consider that if I had truly believed that, why would I have bothered to press the matter? The only written content that I can find regarding this is in an email to you on or around 11/20/01, shortly after you had told me on the phone that “we have made a big investment in David.” Here is what I wrote:
I’m confident that if you were to examine the issues as comprehensively as I have you would agree, but I also know that there is a powerful desire not to accept that a mistake has been made (a big investment, and all that), and that you would rather not spend your time on this (nor would I).
My concern at that time was not that you might not look into the matter objectively, but that you might not look into it at all. My reasons—the “powerful desire” and time constraints—had to do with human nature, but not with any suspicion of malfeasance. Later, when we met in your office, you made it clear that you were miffed by the mere suggestion that you might not pursue the matter. I don’t remember what I said, but I’m certain that I accepted your assurance.
The Special Commission
Now, regretfully, I must reconsider. At the time that we met, you told me that my points regarding Dr. Eisenberg’s role on the Special Commission were enough to warrant convening an ad hoc committee to look into the matter. Apparently, no such committee exists. Instead, you “shared my allegations with Dr. Eisenberg and he with several others.” You agreed when we met that the mere presence of Dr. Eisenberg on such a Commission was curious, in light of the professed purpose of the Division: “research and education.” You were also surprised that Dr. Eisenberg had hired a “Director of Legal Programs,” and you agreed that the existence of such a position was disturbing. You were especially concerned that Atty. Cohen, who is not a physician and whose writings reveal an antagonism to modern medicine, had been the de facto representative of the Massachusetts Department of Public Health to the Special Commission while carrying the HMS imprimatur. Implicit in our discussion was the problem of Dr. Eisenberg having dragged the HMS name into a political quagmire without having first consulted you or Dean Martin. In all of this we were in agreement, even if we disagreed about some other aspects of the HMS “CAM” program.
You also agreed, I thought, that Dr. Eisenberg’s acceptance of funds from the Southwest College of Naturopathic Medicine, as he sat in judgment of naturopaths’ aspirations, was a conflict of interest. He did not disclose this arrangement to the Commission. In the essay that I sent you in March, revised in June, I called attention to several other conflicts of interest, of which at least two—funding by the Fetzer Institute and by the NCCAM—bore directly upon the work of the Commission. I left unsaid, but implied, the reciprocal point: that if Dr. Eisenberg ever gets around to investigating the actual practices of naturopaths and other dubious practitioners, his conclusions will be subject to impeachment both because of these conflicts and because of such a political foray. This is hardly consistent with the goals that you state in your letter. Yet you mention none of these points, as though they do not exist. Although I did not think so before, I now doubt that this issue has been investigated objectively.
Dr. Koh did not come to Commission meetings, so it is difficult to imagine that he could have offered a “construction of the events” at all, much less one that is strikingly different from mine (unless, of course, he got his report from someone who was there). There are questions that Dr. Koh might answer: how did Dr. Eisenberg get the job? Did Dr. Koh know that Dr. Eisenberg had called for the nationwide licensure of naturopaths, the very issue that would face the Commission, three years prior to its inception? Did Dr. Eisenberg disclose his conflicts of interest to Dr. Koh? Was Dr. Koh aware of Dr. Eisenberg’s allegiance to Fetzer and its “credentialing program?” What did Dr. Eisenberg tell Dr. Koh about Atty. Cohen? Did Dr. Eisenberg ever discuss naturopathic practices, or the public health implications of licensing naturopaths, with Dr. Koh, even though he refrained from doing so at Commission meetings?
Did Dr. Koh ever read my correspondence to him, in which I explained absurd naturopathic claims and charged that Dr. Eisenberg appeared inadequate to the task of protecting the public health? How could Commissioner Koh have allowed such an anti-public health report to be signed by his representative? To what extent did the influence of Assistant Commissioner Nancy Ridley, the powerful but naïve functionary who admitted to me that she was bedazzled when visiting the Dana-Farber “CAM Fair” with her ill mother, figure in this decision? While interesting, these questions are distinct from the facts of the Commission itself.
The facts are these: Dr. Eisenberg represented the DPH at the Commission, much of the time surrogating Atty. Cohen. The two were laden with conflicts of interest that they did not disclose. In the end the Commission produced a report that, if approved by the legislature, would amount to official endorsement and protection of quackery. According to the Commission’s Chairman, Dr. Eisenberg and Mr. Cohen helped to write the report. Ms. Ridley, who replaced Dr. Eisenberg at the final meeting for reasons unknown to me, signed the report. All other details, including Dr. Eisenberg’s and Atty. Cohen’s contributions (and lack thereof) at the meetings, my correspondence with Dr. Eisenberg, and the secret and possibly illegal proponent sessions that occurred during the summer of 2001 are at least as embarrassing to Harvard Medical School but are unnecessary to make the case. If you had been interested in a corroboration of my account, most of which is a matter of written record, you could have consulted Drs. Relman and Madras.
InteliHealth
Regarding InteliHealth, none of my comments were out of date when I wrote them, and none are “grossly” out of date even now. According to the website, Harvard’s affiliation began in August 2000. The first of the changes to which Dr. Komaroff refers, i.e., to the articles on chiropractic, homeopathy, and naturopathy, occurred in March 2002—several weeks after I had called your attention to the articles. I acknowledged the changes as soon as I saw them. InteliHealth itself, however, did not utter so much as an “oops.” The former treatises had been on the website, according to the copyright, since 1997. As soon as the HMS faculty “reviewed and modified” these, it should have warned hapless readers that they had been duped for the previous five years. When I queried the website wondering what had happened, the reply was a bland “our vendor has changed.” There was no mention that the previous information had been erroneous and dangerous.
Other, very recent changes on InteliHealth were made not because of any review by Harvard faculty, but because of complaints made by Stephen Barrett, the acerbic editor of Quackwatch. One of these involved the recommendation by Ms. Wetzel to “find a doctor who understands complementary and alternative medicine” by consulting the American College for Advancement in Medicine (ACAM). As I explained to you in January and also in my essay, this organization is, and has been for more than 25 years, a front for chelationists. In 1998 the FTC barred the ACAM from advertising EDTA chelation as effective for atherosclerosis. This is common knowledge to anyone with an interest in aberrant health claims. Dr. Barrett correctly observed, in his email to InteliHealth, that “referring readers to ACAM members is like referring people who want to borrow money to Mafia loan sharks.” Dr. LeWine replied that the real agenda of the ACAM had been unknown to the Harvard reviewers, including “experts in CAM,” who were still unable to discern it even when they perused the ACAM website after being tipped off by Dr. Barrett. These reviewers are not experts; they are innocent of the realities of “CAM.”
For Dr. Komaroff’s information, if a patient with chronic fatigue syndrome were to find a doctor through the ACAM, he or she would likely be advised that the syndrome is caused by candida overgrowth and “toxins,” including routine childhood immunizations and “conventional” pharmaceuticals, and that the appropriate therapies are enemas, intravenous EDTA and expensive “supplements,” all hawked by the practitioner, and the cessation of rational medicines. Surely Dr. Komaroff must be aware of these and other fraudulent claims made by ACAM past-president Murray Susser, the convicted quack who is also the President of the American Association of Health Freedom (AAHF). Recall that it is the latter organization upon whose advisory board sat Atty. Michael Cohen, the “Director of Legal Programs” for the HMS “CAM” program.
I reiterate that the new InteliHealth articles are not much better than the old. Here is another example, deleted only last month after another complaint by Dr. Barrett:
Naturopathic practitioners can address most health problems but acknowledge that some serious medical problems (such as life-threatening illnesses, childbirth emergencies and broken bones) are best treated by conventional medicine.
Harvard’s reviewers apparently aren’t aware that naturopathic practitioners have had no post-graduate training, even if the same reviewers imagine that naturopathic undergraduate “training” is equivalent to that found in real medical schools. Even without this passage, the remaining article on naturopathy is unacceptable. With misinformation like this in the public domain, it’s no wonder that legislators are so willing to wish pseudomedicine upon the public.
The new chiropractic article is aptly named: “Fact and Fiction about Chiropractic.” This is about right, because the article contains similar doses of each. Ironically, an excellent article on chiropractic, written by one of its own practitioners, appeared on Medscape a little more than a year ago. It was favorably reviewed by a group from the BIDMC that did not include the usual “CAM” proponents. A link to this article would have been the perfect solution for InteliHealth.
Dr. Komaroff worries that I misled by selectively quoting from the homeopathy article (presumably the new one). It is true that some of the sentences in that article are, in and of themselves, reasonable. The article as a whole, however, is misleading and irresponsible. I could have quoted it in its entirety to even greater advantage, but in the interest of brevity I did not. I would be happy to comment on this or any other InteliHealth “CAM” article, if the editors are truly interested in expert opinion that can be trusted.
Taste vs. Science
You write that some things are a “matter of taste or interpretation, where even well intentioned people may disagree.” This is obviously true, but there is more than one point involved. “Well intentioned” is not the same as “informed,” and in medical matters the latter characteristic is at least as important as the former. I’m quite sure that most homeopaths believe in what they do; I’m equally sure that some academic physicians, who think that homeopathy is merely “unproven” and “might work,” are sincere. They are wrong, however, and this is not a matter of taste or interpretation.
To prove this to yourself, substitute “a perpetual motion machine” for “homeopathy.” Both violate the same fact of nature, as demonstrated by every chemical reaction, nuclear reaction, biological process or physical change that has ever been observed and measured, every engine that has ever been designed, every electrical circuit that has ever been constructed, and numerous other phenomena. To think that this law can be overthrown by a whimsical pre-scientific notion that has no explanatory power in nature and that offers only the flimsiest of “positive” clinical evidence, all of it easily explained by well-established sources of error, is laughable. You yourself told me, almost sheepishly, that you didn’t believe in homeopathy. Why not? There are scientific principles involved in the interpretation of this and all other “CAM” claims. One oughtn’t be afraid to use them.
Promotions
Your final paragraph suggests that we’ve gotten nowhere. You seem to conclude that my main point, that the HMS “CAM” effort promotes absurd and dangerous medical claims, was a “misperception.” Was Dr. Eisenberg’s role on the Special Commission a misperception? Was my reading of the appeal on the Harvard/BIDMC CAMRE website, that anonymous readers should find “naturopathic physicians” and other dubious practitioners through the yellow pages, a misperception? I don’t think so. Nor was the recommendation, on the same site, for a book about “alternative” cancer therapies that praises coffee enemas, “medical intuitives” (psychics), and “anti-neoplastons.” Nor was the article featuring an idyllic picture of a chiropractor performing a cervical spine “adjustment” on a nine-month-old baby. Nor was the brochure in which the reader is exhorted to call the Center for Holistic Pediatric Education and Research at Children’s Hospital for “a list of pediatric homeopaths in the Boston area.” Nor is the exuberant flyer, from the same Center, announcing an “Expo” in June 2002 featuring Therapeutic Touch, “craniosacral,” Reiki, acupuncture, reflexology, and a “free raffle for a holistic treatment.”
Need I go on? I have no doubt that these promotions were not the intent of the Council of Academic Deans. That is exactly why I approached you in the first place. Perhaps my misperception involves the question of whether they emanate from the “Division” per se. I don’t dispute this point, but it is irrelevant.
The results of such “misperceptions” are potentially catastrophic, but probably unmeasurable. If there are sporadic deaths from asthma, or if a few excess cases of rheumatic heart disease or subtle hearing loss occur because of such mischief, who will notice? How many more families will be left to feel guilty that they didn’t discover “guided imagery” in time to save their loved one from cancer? No one, least of all at the Division, is counting.
Equally insidious is a possibility that Atty. Cohen hinted at during Commission meetings: that physicians who don’t refer patients for “CAM” methods will face malpractice suits or disciplinary measures. I didn’t take it seriously at the time, but I would have if I had known about Mr. Cohen’s involvement with the AAHF. Recall that the AAHF filed an amicus curiae brief supporting a malpractice case of exactly this sort, involving a fanciful treatment (“anti-neoplastons”) that has not been subjected to clinical trials. Imagine what might be done with “distant healing” or homeopathy, methods that are also useless but whose proponents have learned to cite equivocal conclusions from error-laden trials and reviews in which prior probability is ignored. Dr. Komaroff could be found negligent for not arranging for anonymous intercessory prayer or hand-waving over a CFS patient; you could be sued for not prescribing a nonexistent dose of mannitol, or a nonexistent piece of pizza, to a patient with diabetic ketoacidosis. Don’t laugh; the real-life example above is no less outrageous.
CAM Research at HMS
The research of which you write has been, so far, elusive. One finds a couple of useful papers from the BI in the early ‘90s, one a review article failing to find efficacy for biofeedback and meditation in hypertension, the other an original study failing to find physiologic correlates to subjective impressions of the “relaxation response.” Since then almost all “CAM” studies emanating from Harvard have consisted of surveys of “CAM” use or attitudes. As previously explained, the most notorious of these were funded by the Fetzer Institute and were misleading, incorrectly interpreted, and used by “CAM” enthusiasts, including the lead author, to push a political agenda. Others presented useful data that should have warned their authors of the folly of dalliances with quacks. This has been clear, to those who pay attention to such matters, throughout the history of medicine. Among those warning of it were some of the most illustrious members of the Harvard Medical School faculty. In the post-modern era of “tolerance,” however, the wide-eyed ingénues of academic “CAM” imagine that theirs is the first such experience, and believe that they can induce pseudoscientific practitioners to become responsible just by being nice to them.
Other articles emanating from the Harvard “CAM” effort are not studies at all, but are deferential apologies for various irrational “CAM” practices. These are misleading to the point of dishonesty, as I have previously explained. An example is a treatment of chiropractic in which the authors obfuscate the core claim of the field (“subluxations”), ignore prior probability when considering chiropractic for conditions other than back pain, minimize the risks of cervical spine manipulation by failing to report that it is usually repeated tens or even hundreds of times, ignore chiropractic’s widespread anti-vaccination and anti-pharmaceutical stance, neglect to mention the preponderance of other quack methods favored by chiropractors, and fail to note that those chiropractors who have renounced the irrational tenets of the field represent only a tiny fraction of the whole.
Curiously, the authors offer an apt description of quackery without seeming to recognize it: “They never fail to find a problem. By rooting pain in a clear physical cause, chiropractic validates the patient’s experience.” Whether this represents naïveté or defiance on the part of the authors is unclear, but it seems to mock the ethical integrity that has characterized the best of modern medicine. Are we to conclude that medical doctors should learn to be so dishonest, in the interest of appealing to patients’ quests for certainty? Or is such deception acceptable only for “CAM” practitioners? The authors end by congratulating chiropractors for “words and deeds of connection and compassion,” which in most cases amounts to nothing more than slick salesmanship.
As for actual research into the safety and efficacy of methods, there hasn’t been much. There was a recent article failing to demonstrate that an “energy healer” could make a real diagnosis by waving his hands near a blindfolded patient. Its authors concluded: “This study points to further need for fair yet rigorous assessment of claims that energy transfer can lead to accurate clinical diagnoses.” There was a well-controlled study from Children’s Hospital that failed to find efficacy for acupuncture in postoperative nausea. I called attention, in the homeopathy piece that I sent you, to a disturbing study in the Pediatric Infectious Disease Journal, co-authored by the director and co-director of the HMS “CAM” effort. A table in that article presents, in a nutshell, much that is wrong with both “CAM” research and “integrative medicine.” I would be happy to discuss it with you further.
I don’t pretend that this is an exhaustive list of “CAM” reports emanating from HMS, but it is a representative overview.
“CAM” for Medical Students
Your mention of the AAMC initiative for the teaching of “CAM” deserves comment because it, along with your use of the term “allopathic” to describe modern medicine, betrays your own naïveté. While it is certainly true that medical students should become aware of “CAM” claims and how to evaluate them critically, the AAMC initiative is unlikely to accomplish that goal. Rather, it will entice students with the same sort of relativistic, “differing paradigms” and “other ways of knowing” rhetoric that is already standard for academic “CAM.”
I have previously called your attention to a survey of medical school “CAM” courses, which found that the overwhelming majority are promotional and uncritical. In the latest issue of Academic Medicine is another survey that came to the same conclusion. In this “theme” issue are several other articles that address the subject. Those by Astin, Maizes et al, Konefal, and Gaudet and Snyderman are erroneous or naïve, but are representative of prevailing opinion within academic “CAM.” The article by Brokaw et al and the letters from Beyerstein, Grollman, Marcus and Sampson are accurate and revealing, but it is not the latter group that is winning the battle for discussions of “CAM” claims on campuses.
That battle is being won by the “Consortium of Academic Health Centers for Integrative Medicine,” of which HMS is a participant. The Consortium was originally bankrolled by the Fetzer Institute, and its most vocal proponent is Andrew Weil, whose “Arizona Program” is considered the model for the rest. Weil is hardly the mentor that a thoughtful dean would wish upon medical students. As psychologist Barry Beyerstein* explains,
[I]t was the realization that shortcomings of perception, reasoning, and memory incline us toward comforting, rather than true, conclusions that led the pioneers of modern medicine to substitute controlled observations and formal logic for the anecdotes and surmises that can so easily lead us astray. This lesson seems to have been lost on proponents of CAM. Some, such as Andrew Weil, reject it explicitly, advocating what Weil calls “stoned thinking,” a mélange of mystical intuition and emotional satisfaction, for determining the validity of a therapy.
Let the student and patient beware. That Harvard might be different is not likely, as I discussed in the essay on homeopathy. Harvard is in the Consortium. The Harvard faculty involved in this effort is out of its league, as evidenced by the comments on InteliHealth above and by almost every other point made in all that I’ve sent you.
Recommended: Quackwatch
Here is a simple plan that would teach HMS students an enormous amount about “CAM” in a reasonable time, would be fun for them, and would provide them with the most accessible and readable reference for any new CAM claim that comes their way: announce, on the first day of medical school, that the recommended initial source for “CAM” information is Dr. Barrett’s site, Quackwatch. Please reject, and help the students get over, the childish notion that if the name is provocative, the content can’t be worthy. I have previously described to you my surprise at finding that one of the directors of the CAMRE had never heard of Quackwatch, which in itself is an indictment of the promise to “assess claims rigorously.” Dr. Barrett has been investigating and writing about “CAM” since long before it was called that, far longer than any of the current crop of academic “CAM” enthusiasts. He is one of the world’s experts on the topic, as Dr. LeWine can attest.
In addition to this, if a course is planned, offer Schick and Vaughn’s How to Think about Weird Things: Critical Thinking for a New Age or some equivalent short introduction to critical thinking (if this had been taught in 1976, HMS might have been saved from itself). Other useful references are Milton Rothman’s The Science Gap and Robert Park’s Voodoo Science: the Road from Foolishness to Fraud, two readable books by physicists that expose the folly of not applying established facts to questionable claims, including much of the content of “CAM.” The latter book also describes how well-meaning individuals who begin with an ingenuous fascination for things that they don’t understand can, quite gradually and almost imperceptibly, travel the road referred to in the title.
Other useful treatments of “CAM” are found in the Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine, available in the Countway Library, and on the following websites: the National Council Against Health Fraud, the American Council on Science and Health, the Entirely On-line Alternative Medicine Primer, the Alternative Health Dictionary, and the Skeptic’s Dictionary of Alternative Health Practices.
Students should also be alerted to the large overlap between paranormal claims (e.g., psychic powers, astrology, and “alien abductions”) and much of “CAM.” Two good sources for this are the Skeptical Inquirer magazine and the James Randi Educational Foundation. Randi, you might recall, is the magician who helped the editors of Nature investigate Benveniste’s homeopathy claim. He has also visited China several times and in 1988 exposed apparent demonstrations of psychokinesis by “Qigong masters,” the same sorts of feats that had beguiled Drs. Eisenberg and Benson, as simple conjuring tricks. Perhaps unaware of this, Dr. Eisenberg continued to be fooled by magical Qigong feats.
Finally, a more advanced treatment of academic “CAM” might include issues that also apply to evidence-based medicine in general. Among these are the pitfalls of systematic reviews and the inadequacy of “P” values, in the absence of considerations of prior probability, for answering questions about how nature works. Students already grounded in the details of “CAM” claims by virtue of having read Quackwatch and other introductory literature will have little trouble seeing through the language and fact distortions that characterize many “CAM” articles in mainstream medical journals, as typified by the article on chiropractic discussed above. Thus they will be able to distinguish reason from propaganda in such places as the “theme” issue of Academic Medicine already mentioned and the current “CAM” series in the Annals of Internal Medicine. In this the students will have quickly surpassed most of their teachers, who tend to be innocent of these realities.
All of these suggestions would make for fascinating learning. They would also help medical students hone their critical thinking skills and impress upon them the importance of scientific literacy, not only for issues in medicine but for things in general.
Your emphatic statement that “we do not, repeat NOT, have any intention of making our students CAM practitioners,” is a red herring. I never claimed that this was your intention, so why the protest? When Dr. Eisenberg made the same point at the Special Commission, however, his explanation was similar to yours: that there isn’t enough time for it. The question left hanging is a disturbing one.
Veritas
In conclusion, your letter ignored or misrepresented most of the points that I had previously made and have reiterated here. In particular it ignored the numerous promotions of pseudomedicine. It also ignored the relationships that exist between the leadership of the HMS “CAM” program and various ideologically biased donors and dubious practitioners and politicians, including veterans of the Laetrile wars. It is understandable, if unfortunate, that some of the players in this game are necessarily subject to political pressures, however incompatible with good medical judgment those pressures may be. This is true of the NCCAM, for example, and also of the Massachusetts Department of Public Health. Universities are supposed to be different.
The term “ivory tower,” though maligned in recent times, has a noble pedigree. It implies that those within are protected, in their search for truth, from the political and financial influences that inevitably distort all other public discourse. It would be naïve to think that this tower is impenetrable. Nonetheless, it makes no sense to smash holes from within by making bargains with the like of Fetzer, Osher, the American Specialty Health Plans, the AAHF, naturopaths, and Rep. Dan Burton.
Eventually, this chapter in the history of HMS will be remembered with chagrin. Please reconsider now.
Sincerely yours,
Kimball C. Atwood, M.D. HMS Class of 1979
Cc: Arnold Relman, M.D.
Peter Madras, M.D.
……………………….
*This post is dedicated to the memory of Barry Beyerstein.

   Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part VI)
Kimball Atwood
Link
Loose Ends: Dr. Koh and More
After Dr. Federman’s letter and my reply, posted in Part V of this series,† there seemed little point in pursuing the matter further. Although Dr. Federman never answered my reply, he did send, at my request, a copy of Commissioner of Public Health Howard Koh‘s written “construction of the events in the Massachusetts Special Commission.” As you may recall, those events had occurred at meetings that Dr. Koh never attended:
July 29, 2002
Dear Dr. Federman:
I have had an opportunity to review Dr. Kimball Atwood’s characterizations of the role Dr. David Eisenberg played as an advisor and designee of the Department of Public Health (DPH) and I am writing to clarify several misrepresentations of that role. As you may know, I personally selected Dr. Eisenberg as my designee for the Massachusetts Special Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medical Practitioners based on his high level of scientific and clinical expertise in the field, as well as his international reputation for evidence-based research. I felt at that time, as I do now, that he was the appropriate choice to represent the Department and I am extremely grateful for his advice and his integrity during this most contentious process.
During the course of the Commission, Dr. Eisenberg brought to my attention some of the conflicts that had arisen among the members, despite his attempts to diffuse the hostility and to engage the members in collegial debate. In an effort to overcome these difficulties and deflect unwarranted criticism, Nancy Ridley, Assistant Commissioner for Health Quality Management, attended the meetings over the last six months as the DPH voting designee, with Dr. Eisenberg as an advisor. She also organized a DPH workgroup of the Commission in an attempt to bring consensus and closure to what had become a very polarized and highly personalized process.
I need to state emphatically that the approval of the final Commission report is my responsibility, and is largely a product of the DPH workgroup that Assistant Commissioner Ridley chaired. Dr. Eisenberg had actually not been supportive of either the “majority” or “minority” reports that were originally presented, and neither was Ms. Ridley. She attempted to address as many of Dr. Eisenberg’s concerns as possible but knew he still had issues with the final document. She feels very strongly that there needs to be regulatory oversight of non-physician practitioners of complementary and alternative naturopathic practice. Assistant Commissioner Ridley, on behalf of the Department and with my consent, signed the report that included a significant number of revisions which narrowed the scope of practice, ensured collaborative relationships between physician and non-physician practitioners, and broadened the scope of any proposed regulatory oversight required. Dr. Eisenberg’s advice to DPH was delivered in a fair and balanced manner based his outstanding experience as a clinician and scientist.
I believe that one of the contributing factors for the polarization within the Commission had little to do with Dr. Eisenberg’s participation rather than that of his staffperson, Michael Cohen, who attended Commission meetings in his absence. Mr. Cohen was repeatedly characterized as the alternate DPH designee, which he was not.
In summary, Dr. Eisenberg’s expertise and professionalism throughout this difficult process have been greatly appreciated by the Department. DPH was truly fortunate to be represented and advised by a person of Dr. Eisenberg’s stature and character. I would be more that pleased to speak to you or Dean Martin on his behalf. Please feel free to contact me at xxx.xxx.xxxx if you need any additional information.
Sincerely,
Howard K. Koh, MD, MPH
The range of self-serving misrepresentations in that letter is wide, and is worrisome in someone who will be “responsible for the major health agencies, including the CDC, FDA and NIH, and [will be] the leading health advisor to the Secretary of HHS.” I have already discussed some of the facts here and here, and will add more now.
Regarding Dr. Eisenberg’s “high level of scientific and clinical expertise in the field,” Dr. Koh can be excused for having at first assumed this to be the case, but not after being presented with mounting evidence to the contrary. After one of several meetings of the commission in which Dr. Relman and I had enumerated absurd and dangerous naturopathic practices, I asked Dr. Eisenberg why he had not spoken up in agreement with our reservations. He replied that he hadn’t previously known about such particulars. If true, this belied his implicit expertise. It was also an indictment of his previous claim to having been familiar with some of the very sources from which we got our information. Now, moreover, he had been made aware of such particulars; yet still he did not speak. I sent a letter to Dr. Koh making this point and calling attention to Dr. Eisenberg’s conflicts of interest, but never received a reply. In other treatises made available to Dr. Koh, particularly the Minority Report, I called attention to numerous challenges to the Public Health that would be posed by licensed NDs.
The assertion that Dr. Eisenberg had attempted to “diffuse the hostility and to engage the members in collegial debate” is laughable. The “hostility,” such as it was—really more a tone of exasperation coming from Relman and me—was based mainly on two, frustrating facts of the commission’s deliberations, each a result of Eisenberg’s efforts or lack thereof: first, that the commission, as a matter of formal policy, would not entertain scientific or medical critiques of naturopathic practices; second, that Dr. Eisenberg himself refused to engage in debate, collegial or otherwise, even though the naive members of the commission looked to him for expertise. Whatever “concerns” or “issues with the final document” Dr. Eisenberg might have had, he didn’t bother to voice them to the commission as a whole. Dr. Koh knew, because I wrote him, that I’d asked Dr. Eisenberg to meet privately to discuss naturopathic practices but he had declined.
Assistant Commissioner Ridley’s organization of a “DPH workgroup” had not been formally disclosed to those commission members opposed to ND licensure, although we had heard of its existence. The workgroup could not have been conceived to “bring consensus,” since it excluded dissenters, and it was probably illegal.
How fortunate was the DPH to be represented and advised by Dr. Eisenberg? The statement, “there needs to be regulatory oversight of non-physician practitioners of complementary and alternative naturopathic practice” reveals that Dr. Koh’s advisor had failed to inform him of the most important point of all: NDs tell patients that they are physicians.
Readers more savvy than I might recognize Dr. Koh’s scapegoating of Michael Cohen as standard procedure for political functionaries. I find it cynical and distasteful, even if I have no use for Mr. Cohen’s views of modern medicine or of “CAM.” I add that Mr. Cohen was the “alternate DPH designee” whether or not Dr. Koh might have approved. This was established not by my “repeated characterizations,” more accurately described as observations, but by Dr. Eisenberg’s having sent Mr. Cohen in his stead more often than not.
Notably missing from Dr. Koh’s letter was an acknowledgment of Dr. Eisenberg’s undisclosed funding sources and of their embarrassing relation to the commission’s work.
Dr. Relman Speaks Up
I sent Dr. Relman a copy of my last exchange with Dr. Federman. To my happy surprise, he went out of his way to support me:
October 11, 2002
Dear Dan:
Kim Atwood sent me a copy of your letter of September 26 to him, and his reply.
I do not want to become part of your dialogue with him, nor do I want to be involved in any discussions between the Dean’s office and David Eisenberg’s CAM center. This is not because I do not have opinions about CAM (you surely know I do), but because I am not sufficiently acquainted with all the relevant events and factual details in this case.
However, I do have first-hand knowledge about two of the issues raised in your letter, and felt compelled to tell you what I know about them.
First, Howard Koh’s “construction of the events in the Massachusetts Special Commission.” I personally attended virtually all of the meetings for more than a year, before I felt impelled to resign as the Commission’s work was drawing to a close. Howard Koh attended none of the meetings and must have formed whatever “construction” he put on events that transpired at those meetings from accounts by either David Eisenberg (who was often absent), or his deputy Nancy Ridley (who suddenly showed up for the last two or three meetings). I resigned to protest the grossly biased manner in which the meetings were being conducted. I personally observed David’s behavior during many meetings (when neither Koh nor Ridley were there) and became increasingly disturbed by his actions and comments, which I thought were equivocating, unscholarly, and anti-scientific. I did not at the time know of any financial conflicts of interest with the naturopaths, but if Kim’s assertion is correct that David’s activities received support from a naturopathic school, this information should certainly have been made clear to all members of the Commission—and David’s behavior at the meetings becomes even more reprehensible. At any rate, I cannot believe that if you had attended those meetings, you would be comfortable defending David against most of the charges Kim now makes.
Secondly, with respect to the avowed mission of Eisenberg’s CAM center. The only justification for its existence at Harvard, it seems to me, should be that it serves as an instrument for carrying out rigorous scientific studies of the effectiveness and safety of CAM modalities. I think I know something about this subject because I have carefully studied the CAM literature for a long time and have paid particular attention to what has come from David Eisenberg and his colleagues. The relatively few credible clinical trials of CAM have been negative or at best equivocal. Eisenberg’s contributions to that scientific literature are almost non-existent.
To date there has been virtually no clinical science from the CAM center at HMS—mostly descriptions of the use and theory of CAM. Were this any other field, I cannot imagine HMS continuing to be so supportive. Why do we not hold CAM to the same standards as other areas in Medicine? What will it take for us to finally say that the Emperor has no clothes—however popular and well-funded he may be?
Sincerely,
Bud
Arnold S. Relman, M.D.
Minor Publicity
As far as I know, nothing much came of my efforts. An opportunity for the matter to become more widely known seemed to appear a few months later, when science writer Chris Mooney called me to say that he was interested in writing something about “CAM” at Harvard and that Stephen Barrett of Quackwatch had told him, “Atwood knows where the body is buried at Harvard Medical School.” This eventually resulted in an article in Reason Magazine, but I never heard a peep about it from anyone at HMS.
More “CAM” Promotions
Although I grew weary of the topic, I couldn’t help but notice, over the years, more evidence of the main point that I had tried to make to Dr. Federman: that HMS promotes quackery. Some of this had occurred well before I entered the fray, but I’d been unaware of it. The 1992 report “Alternative Medicine: Expanding Medical Horizons,” accurately described as “an uncritical catalog of virtually every dubious and unproven treatment method of the past 100 years,” had included Eisenberg, his deputy Ted Kaptchuk, Harvard homeopath Edward Chapman, and Harvard nutritionists Walter Willett and Lilian Cheung among its contributors. The January, 1999 newsletter The Integrator for the Business of Alternative Medicine included this entry (emphasis in the original):
Eisenberg to headline NMHCC track. David Eisenberg, MD, will deliver the kick-off presentation at the National Managed Health Care Congress track. INTEGRATOR publisher-editor John Weeks, the track chair, who was originally scheduled to give the presentation explains simply: “We want to draw people into the CAM conversation and David Eisenberg has been a giant in this movement.” Weeks remains involved as a moderator throughout the seven session meeting. Funding for the change came available when San Diego-based American Specialty Health Plans came aboard to sponsor the track. ASHP has sponsored numerous CAM events in the past two years, including the Casa Colina WholeHealth Forum, the annual meeting by the publishers of Employee Benefits News, and the Healthcare Forum meeting scheduled for Honolulu in early February. The NMHCC has also scheduled a CAM debate, which pits National Council Against Health Fraud’s John Renner, MD, against James Dillard, MD, medical director for Oxford Health Plans. March 29-April 1: 888-882-2500A two-day event in San Francisco in June on integrative clinic skills training, developed by Cambridge Health Resources (CHR) together with Linda Bedell Logan’s Solutions in Integrative Medicine has been firmed up. However, the broader In Health conference which CHR was paired has been canceled for lack of major sponsorship, according to Marcy Robinson. Robinson heads up planning and sponsor relations for CHR. Robinson recently announced that the five speakers include: Bedell-Logan (sessions on practice management), Lynn Budlong, of Budlong, Glassanos and Company (sessions on business development — Budlong has worked in this arena for the Harvard team assembled by Eisenberg), Russell Greenfield, MD, a resident at the University of Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine (clinical integration), and author-expert on CAM legal issues, Michael Cohen, Esq. (legal issues). John Weeks, INTEGRATOR publisher-editor will provide an overview on the state of CAM integration early on the first day.
Several bullets were spent from that smoking gun. When I first saw it I lamented not having known of it at the time of my correspondence with Dean Federman, but I doubt it would have mattered. The hyperlinked file of Integrator newsletters is chock full of more damning information regarding the HMS “CAM” cabal, most of which I’ll leave to readers to discover for themselves. One passage worth mentioning is from January, 2000:
Minneapolis-based MEDTRONIC FOUNDATION has awarded a $900,000 grant over three years to BETH ISRAEL DEACONESS MEDICAL CENTER to support infrastructure developments on a model integrative facility. DAVID EISENBERG, MD, an assistant professor of medicine at HARVARD MEDICAL SCHOOL, will direct the project. A January 19 release identified the leading infrastructure “components” which Eisenberg views as necessary in a conventional medical establishment as: 1) development of referral mechanisms; 2) credentialing and quality assurance; 3) “communication strategies;” 4) creating standards for a natural products formulary; 5) development of educational materials; and 6) creating secured electronic data collection methods.” Eisenberg states the goal as “to develop a model that serves as a resource for other Harvard affiliated teaching hospitals.”
Dean Federman must have known about that grant well before I approached him. I guess I could have saved myself a lot of effort and frustration if I’d known about it, too. Clearly, there was never to be a real reckoning of the charges that I made. Sometimes I wonder why he gave me as much of a hearing as he did. Perhaps he worried that I knew things that would embarrass HMS. I thought I did, but what I knew apparently wasn’t embarrassing enough.
Not long after the first quoted passage from The Integrator was written, Dr. Renner died and Dr. Eisenberg joined with Andrew Weil protegé Russell Greenfield to pull the wool over the eyes of the Federation of State Medical Boards, making it suddenly easier for quacks to peddle snake oil—an event that I’ve discussed here and here on SBM.
Is it “Quackery” only if it’s Deceptive?
At about the same time that I was corresponding with Dr. Federman, Dr. Carl Bartecchi of the University of Colorado School of Medicine sent a letter to HMS wondering about financial conflicts of interest and other aspects of the HMS “CAM” program. At some point Dr. Bartecchi and I discovered each other and he sent me Harvard’s reply, which had also involved Drs. Federman and Eisenberg. There was an interesting passage in Dr. Eisenberg’s response:
Dr. Bartecchi says in his letter, “I long for the day when they label something ‘quackery’.” It should be mentioned that I served as a consultant to the Federation of Sate Medical Boards ‘Model Guidelines for the Use of Complementary and Alternative Therapies in Medical Practice.’ This document describes a series of suggestions, derived through consensus, as to the judicious use or avoidance of complementary and alternative medicine. These guidelines avoid the label ‘quackery’ which explicitly implies deception. I share with Dr. Bartecchi a disdain for any practice which intentionally deceives and manipulates a patient in any circumstance. Moreover, in the annual Harvard Medical School course on complementary and alternative medicine I typically deliver a didactic presentation entitled ‘Advising patients who seek complementary and alternative medicine.’ In this lecture I include a summary of the article by Beyerstein from the Academic Medicine 2001 series on CAM which provides sensible advice in terms of avoiding complementary and alternative medicine practitioners who meet certain criteria consistent with definitions of ‘quackery.’
Wow. I can’t explain how something might “explicitly imply,” but to claim that the practitioner’s intent, which will frequently be unknowable, is a necessary basis for identifying quackery can only be a sign of naïveté or of, well, deception. It is also contrary to other, more influential uses of the term, as I and others have previously explained. Is it not obvious that peddling Laetrile or “colon cleansing” is quackery, regardless of whether or not the peddler believes in those methods?
Dr. Eisenberg’s citation of Barry Beyerstein is laughable. I knew Barry quite well and had many discussions with him about the sad state of affairs on campuses, including that of HMS. He sparred quite heatedly, right on the pages of Academic Medicine, with Eisenberg’s cronies Andrew Weil and John Astin. Here is some of the “Sensible Advice” that Dr. Eisenberg reported having borrowed from Dr. Beyerstein:
Avoid CAM Practitioners who:
1) Are hostile to conventional medicine
2) Cannot supply a reasonable rationale
3) Claim to possess secret ingredients or processes
4) Appeal to ”other ways of knowing”
Nothing to disagree with there, of course, but Eisenberg himself has violated those tenets repeatedly, e.g.,
Please consult your local telephone yellow pages under these categories:
Acupuncture
Chiropractic
Holistic Practitioners
Massage – Therapeutic
Naturopathic Physicians
The Elusive Degree of Dr. So and So
Dr. Beyerstein had also warned against practitioners who “claim degrees from unaccredited institutions,” and Eisenberg included that caveat in his response to Dr. Bartecchi. At around the same time the late Bob Imrie observed that it was curious, in this era of the World Wide Web, that if you Google the “Macao Institute of Chinese Medicine” you get, well, nothing—other than it being named as the alma mater of two American “CAM” enthusiasts. One of them is Ted Kaptchuk, ‘OMD,’ who has long been Dr. Eisenberg’s second in command of “CAM” at HMS. When I first heard this I didn’t think much about it. My reply to Imrie was something like, “what difference does it make? It’s bogus whether it’s bogus or not, because the entire field is bogus.”
Shortly thereafter I realized that there is an obvious, additional ethical problem with portraying oneself as having earned a degree from an institution that most people would assume had been endorsed by some appropriate body, if such is not the case. At the time I was the chairman of the Committee for the Quality of Medical Practice at the Massachusetts Medical Society, and using that title I wrote to the Macao government asking about the Macao Institute of Chinese (or “Traditional Chinese”) Medicine. Here was the reply (emphasis in the original):
Sent: Tuesday, October 07, 2003 12:41 AM
Subject: Reply to the inquiry about “Macao Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine ”
Dear Chairman Kimball C. Atwood,
Thank you very much for your e-mail dated 18th Sept (we received it from Government Information Bureau on 6th Oct.). In reply to your inquiry, we would like to inform you that ¡§Macao Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine¡¨ HAS NOT BEEN one of the higher education institutions in Macao, and the concerned Institute hence HAS NOT BEEN a degree-conferring academic institution.
If there is anything additional you would like to know, please feel free to contact us:
Telephone: 853-3969316
Facsimile: 853-318401
Address: Calçada de Sto. Agostinho. No 19, Edf. Nam Yue, 13o a 15o Andares, Macau
E-mail: info@gaes.gov.mo
With Best Regards
Higher Education BureauMacao SAR
I realize that this does not settle the matter. It is quite possible that in the 30+ years since Kaptchuk reports having attended the Institute, governmental memory has faded or has become selective. That is all the more possible because Macao, like Hong Kong, was ‘handed over’ from its colonial ruler (Portugal, in Macao’s case) to China on the eve of the 21st century. Nevertheless, there are more reasons to think otherwise. One of my correspondents had traveled to Macau prior to the hand-over and was unable to find any record of the MICM in various libraries and pertinent governmental offices. The Web continues to lack any corroborating evidence of such an institute, although there ought to have been many students there from all over the world: according to the two Americans, the school was a magnet for ‘overseas Chinese.’ Other attempts by Dr. Bartecchi and me to get information—from HMS (see below), from the Massachusetts and California Acupuncture Boards, and from Dan Bensky, the other American who reports having received a degree from the MICM—have been frustrated.
Dr. Bensky’s online CV, however, raises more disturbing questions. He calls his degree from Macao a “Diploma in Chinese Medicine,” suggesting that the ‘D’ in ‘OMD’ stands for ‘Diploma’, not for ‘Doctor’—as Kaptchuk has represented it (Bensky can call himself ‘doctor’ in any case, because he subsequently completed the osteopathy program at Michigan State University). Bensky reports having attended MICM with Kaptchuk, and that it took two years to complete. Bensky did not have a bachelor’s degree when he began at Macau. Currently, a doctoral candidate at the Chengdu University of Traditional Chinese Medicine must be a college graduate, and the course of study requires three years.
Bensky also reports that at Macao there were “three main teachers…although in the end, one of the teachers refused to allow Westerners to participate in her clinic.” And: “after graduation…as I was identified with the school, no one else in Macau would work with me.” This hardly suggests an ‘Institute’ or a course of study with externally recognized standards.
According to this report, a couple of years ago at the nomenclature conference of the A.A.O.M. (either ‘American Association of Oriental Medicine’ or ‘Association of Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine’—I’m not sure which)
Dr. Benksy dismissed the long-term expert consensus described in Marnae Ergil’s excellent paper on translation principles as simply “wrong.”
An interested observer, suggesting that Bensky’s credentials might be relevant to evaluating his opinion, responded with this:
Both Dan Bensky and Ted Kaptchuk hold degrees from The Macau Institute of Chinese Medicine. According to Dan in that very discussion on CHA to which Bob makes reference, the school came into existence shortly before he and Ted arrived in 1973 and went out of existence shortly after they left in 1975 with their degrees. Or were they diplomas? Or were they doctorates? What is written on those pieces of paper? This was the question I posed in the post that preceded my being banned from CHA. The notion of being “qualified by expertise and training to establish such standards” (of academic freedom) suggests that training standards themselves are of nontrivial importance in the whole matter of academic freedom. Of course they are. And of course it matters whether the word “diploma” or the word “doctorate” is written on the pieces of paper that Dan and Ted took home with them when their respective sojourns in Macau had come to an end. What does the “D” stand for in the “OMD” that appears after the names Bensky and Kaptchuk? Socrates said that to use words wrongly is not only a fault itself, it also corrupts the soul. Certainly it corrupts the use of words to use highly meaningful terms (including their abbreviations) like “diploma” and “doctorate” interchangeably. If one is qualified by expertise and training to establish standards of academic freedom, then we had better at least know with as much certainty as possible what the basis of one’s qualifications actually is…
Are Bensky and Kaptchuk the MICM’s only graduates?
In 2003 I queried some of the faculty at HMS who were affiliated with Eisenberg and Kaptchuk. I sent them the message from the Macao Higher Education Bureau. They agreed that it would be ’disturbing’ if Kaptchuk’s degree were anything but legitimate. After all, he had parlayed it into his entire academic career, including not only his appointment at HMS (where he now appears to be an Associate Professor), but numerous articles in the Annals of Internal Medicine, the British Medical Journal, JAMA, and other journals. He used it to become a licensed health care practitioner in Massachusetts and probably elsewhere. He also used it to gain public roles that some would consider prestigious, such as his long membership on the NCCAM Advisory Council. He has been referred to as “Doctor” in all of those contexts.
About two weeks after I sent the inquiry to HMS, I got this reply from my old fellow intern, Russell Phillips:
Kim-I researched Ted’s background and am convinced that the credentials he lists on his CV, including his doctorate, are correct. When this came up previously he put together a packet of his diplomas etc that confirm his degree. Additionally, several state licensing boards have given him a license to practice acupuncture after researching his background. The Dean’s office (Dan Federman) has also looked into this and is convinced his credentials are correct. Please let me know if you want to discuss further. Russ
I believe that this reply merely begged the question. The several state licensing boards almost certainly did not research his background, which would have been an impossible task for them. I don’t think that HMS or any of the individuals who looked at the ‘credentials’ had either the will or the competence to investigate them thoroughly and skeptically. It is intriguing that in the past few years Kaptchuk’s ‘OMD’ has disappeared from certain contexts, including at HMS: compare this and this, for example.
I reiterate that I don’t know the answer to this question. There is enough doubt about Kaptchuk’s ‘OMD’ degree, however, to put the onus on him, on HMS, and on the other interested entities to produce the evidence. It should then be evaluated by a disinterested, competent investigator.
Harvard’s Contribution to Unethical Human Studies of Implausible Claims
During the time that I was gathering information for Dr. Federman, I discovered a report of an uncontrolled trial of homeopathic remedies for small children diagnosed with acute otitis media. The trial was a dangerous exploitation of vulnerable subjects for no useful purpose; I have previously mentioned it here and here. Three of the authors were Dr. Eisenberg, Ted Kaptchuk, and Harvard homeopath Edward Chapman, who would soon lose his medical license after having been caught diddling patients.
On SBM I’ve discussed other examples of unethical human trials of “CAM” claims, including NaEDTA ‘chelation therapy’ and the ‘Gonzalez Regimen’ for cancer of the pancreas. As explained here, representatives of the HMS “CAM” project—Eisenberg and Kaptchuk—were guilty of helping to launch at least one of those trials and of misrepresenting both of them.
The Annals of Internal Medicine ‘CAM’ Series
In 2001, the Annals of Internal Medicine launched a ‘CAM’ series, with Eisenberg and Kaptchuk named guest editors. Although it promised “discourse about the effectiveness and safety of commonly used CAM therapies…, critical reviews of the literature…, thought pieces addressing the broader social aspects of CAM therapy…, and the rules of scientific evidence,” most of the articles were puff pieces. They also failed to disclose funding sources, in some cases, or to explain the meaning of funding sources in others. In early 2003 I wrote two letters to new editor-in-chief Harold Sox—one short enough for publication, the other detailed—explaining these points. Here are some excerpts:
Language and Fact Distortions in the Annals “CAM” Series
In summary, Dr. Eisenberg and some others in the academic “CAM” movement have been promoting old-fashioned quackery under the guise of “CAM.” In so doing they have been careful to avoid informing the Annals readership of the abundance of absurd and dangerous practices offered by the “CAM providers” that they endorse. Instead they appear to excuse such practices as “reflect[ing] larger cultural and political collisions concerning evolving definitions of mainstream medical care” and “fundamental philosophic questions as to who determines which providers and therapies will be accepted as safe, effective, appropriate, or reimbursable.”
This is, in a word, nonsense. Does the question of whether a damp compress can abort an evolving stroke depend on “who determines which therapies are effective?” Is the inability of the skin to absorb substantial oxygen a matter of “political collisions?” Chiropractors posing as “primary care providers” are a threat to public health, not a “conundrum.” Homeopaths making therapeutic claims, chiropractors treating infants or recommending spinal “adjustments” for health maintenance, acupuncturists performing “pulse and tongue diagnoses,” massage therapists claiming to contribute to cures by removing “toxins,” and M.D.s prescribing EDTA “chelation therapy” for coronary artery disease are all common examples of health fraud, but readers would have to look outside of the Annals series for competent discussions of such issues.
…………………..
Undisclosed Sources of Bias in the Annals Series
Dr. Eisenberg’s funding sources are conflicts of interest for his Annals articles, disclaimers notwithstanding. Did he report, to the Annals, the conflicts discussed above? According to the instructions, “when authors submit a manuscript, they must disclose all financial relationships that might bias their work.” Moreover, as you have affirmed, “editors should publish this information if they believe it will be important to readers in judging the manuscript.” That means that merely reporting the funding for the paper in question is not enough. Yet, in the “credentialing” article, there is no mention of the Fetzer Institute, the Osher Foundation, the Southwest College of Naturopathic Medicine, the New York Chiropractic College, the New England School of Acupuncture, or the Cambridge Muscular Therapy Institute, each of which has provided funds for Dr. Eisenberg’s activities in the recent past, and all of which favor the veneer of legitimacy that “credentialing” offers to “CAM providers.”
Nor, when considering conflicts of interest, is disclosure by name alone adequate. The “credentialing” article was funded by the NCCAM, whose CAM advocacy is documented above, but whose identity was veiled by the “NIH” designation; by American Specialty Health, an organization representing chiropractors, acupuncturists, naturopaths, and massage therapists, and also the single biggest contributor to both the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians and the licensing effort for “NDs” in California; and by Medtronics, a company whose founder is also committed to the promotion of implausible methods in the absence of validation. These ideologically biased donors may not have “had editorial input into the paper,” but will they donate in the future if they are displeased by the content of the work that they helped spawn? That is the broader truth of all such arrangements, and always has been.
Dr. Sox never replied, and the Annals did not print the short version of my letter. I guess their expectations of authors and editors are flexible. It’s funny: I’ve since met Dr. Sox more than once in other contexts, and have found him to be a thoughtful and decent man. I haven’t talked to him specifically about that regrettable episode in the journal’s history. There’s a lot that I don’t understand, when I think of Drs. Federman, Sox, and others.
HMS Alumni: Scientists, Shruggies and Pascal’s Wager
In 2004 I gave a talk about naturopathy to the Symposium of the 25th reunion of the HMS class of 1979—my class. Dean Federman didn’t come, which irked me a bit but didn’t surprise me. Later I ran into him and he apologized for not having been there. FWIW. There were a few standard reactions to my talk. A couple of classmates who had become biomedical scientists and a couple of clinicians congratulated me for taking a stand against encroaching pseudomedicine. Two or three others had recently been diagnosed with scary diseases and were dabbling with fanciful methods; they wondered why I did what I did. An alumna of some note (not a member of my class) observed that “CAM” advocates could teach us something about prevention. I tried to deliver her of that notion. Most of the audience seemed to just, well, shrug.
Finally:
The proof is in the pudding. Et tu, Daniel?
In spite of it all, there is a glimmer of hope. Everything changes, even HMS. A couple of my old friends have recently become relatively big makhers there. It’s unlikely, of course,…(especially without any moolah)…but who knows?

   Dummy Medicines, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 1: a Curious Editorial Choice for the New England Journal of Medicine
Kimball Atwood
Link
Background
This post concerns the recent article in the New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) titled “Active Albuterol or Placebo, Sham Acupuncture, or No Intervention in Asthma.” It was ably reviewed by Dr. Gorski on Monday, so I will merely summarize its findings: of the three interventions used—inhaled albuterol (a bronchodilator), a placebo inhaler designed to mimic albuterol, or ‘sham acupuncture’—only albuterol resulted in a clinically important improvement of bronchial airflow; for that outcome the two sham treatments were equivalent to “no intervention.” For all three interventions, however, self-reported improvements were substantial and were much greater than self-reported improvements after “no intervention.” In other words, dummy treatments made the subjects (report that they) feel better, whereas real medicine not only made them feel better but actually made them better.
Before proceeding, let me offer a couple of caveats. First, the word ”doctors” in the flippant title of this post refers mainly to two individuals: Daniel Moerman, PhD, the anthropologist who wrote the accompanying editorial, and Ted Kaptchuk, the Senior Author of the trial report. It does not refer to any of the other authors of the report. Second, I have no quarrel with the trial itself, which was quite good, or with the NEJM having published it, or even with most of the language in the article, save for the “spin” that Dr. Gorski has already discussed.
My quarrels are the same as those expressed by Drs. Gorski and Novella, and by all of us on the Placebo Panel at TAM. This post and the next will develop some of those points by considering the roles and opinions of Moerman and Kaptchuk, respectively.
A True Story
Late one night during the 1960s a friend and I, already in a cannabis-induced fog, wandered into a house that had been rented by one of his friends. There were about 8-10 ‘freaks’ there (the term was laudatory at the time); I didn’t know any of them. The air was thick with smoke of at least two varieties. After an uncertain interval I became aware of a guy who was having trouble breathing. He was sitting bolt upright in a chair, his hands on his knees, his mouth open, making wheezing sounds. He took short noisy breaths in, followed by what seemed to be very long breaths out, as though he was breathing through a straw. You could hear the wheezing in both directions. Others had also noticed that he was in distress; they tried to be helpful (“hey, man, ya want some water or somethin’?”), but he just shook his head. He couldn’t talk. My friend, who had asthma himself, announced that this guy was having an asthma attack and asked if he or anyone else had any asthma medicine. No one did.
No one had a car, either, and for obvious reasons no one, not even the wheezing guy himself, was about to call 911. The nearest hospital was about 5 miles away. My friend said that the thing to do when someone has an asthma attack is leave him alone so he won’t get too excited, and he’ll get through it. Yeah, that must be right, we all figured; he has asthma too so he knows. We were all blowing smoke into the wheezing guy’s face as we expressed our concern.
At some point my friend and I left. The next day I heard that the guy with the asthma attack was eventually taken to the ER after another freak had come along who happened to have a car. The guy did all right, I guess. I don’t really know, but if he’d died I probably would’ve heard about it.
Several years later I went to medical school and began to learn about asthma, and as an internal medicine resident I saw enough patients with acute asthma attacks to realize, in a way that still makes me cringe, just how sick that guy had been and how totally clueless and selfish were we, his supposedly concerned companions. If the freak with the car hadn’t shown up…
Cultural Anthropology and Cultural Relativism
All of which has something to do with the surprise I felt a few days ago upon reading the following in the aforementioned editorial in the NEJM, the world’s most prestigious medical journal:
For subjective and functional conditions — for example, migraine, schizophrenia, back pain, depression, asthma, post-traumatic stress disorder, neurologic disorders such as Parkinson’s disease, inflammatory bowel disease and many other autoimmune disorders, any condition defined by symptoms, and anything idiopathic — a patient-centered approach requires that patient-preferred outcomes trump the judgment of the physician. Under these conditions, inert pills can be as useful as “real” ones…
Let’s see: asthma is a “subjective and functional condition”? In the bad old days of paternalistic medicine, the term “functional” meant “without demonstrable pathology.” It was usually synonymous with ”in your head”—whether the physician openly expressed that opinion or not. Doesn’t sound very “patient-centered” to me. I’m happy to report that you hardly ever hear ”functional” anymore, which reflects at least some measure of social progress for the profession. Since the term’s other possible meanings are nearly limitless and therefore vague beyond utility—every complaint or medical condition is in some way “functional,” after all—it seems reasonable to assume that the editorial’s author intended the old meaning, even if it and “subjective” are redundant.
Yet asthma is based in demonstrable pathology, as are most of the other named conditions, and in most of those (migraines, Parkinson’s disease, inflammatory bowel disease, and “many other autoimmune disorders”) there are specific treatments based on pathophysiology that, like albuterol for asthma, effect substantial, objective and subjective improvements. ”Idiopathic” refers to any condition whose cause is unknown, which includes most of those already mentioned and many other diseases for which medicines are effective for both objective and subjective outcomes (diabetes, Grave’s disease), and even some that are, for practical purposes, curable: Hodgkin’s disease, acute lymphocytic leukemia in children, some testicular cancers (remember Lance?), temporal arteritis, pernicious anemia, and many more. How could the author of a NEJM editorial be unaware of such commonplace medical facts?
The answer is that the author, Daniel Moerman, is not a doctor or even a biomedical scientist. He’s an anthropologist who seems to have confused sentimental and poetic aspects of his major academic interests—native American culture, medicinal plants, and healing rituals—with modern science and medicine. I urge you to consider his CV and the excerpts from his book Medicine, Meaning and the “Placebo Effect,” discussed by Dr. Gorski a few days ago. In the very first chapter he betrays more ignorance of medicine when he expresses surprise that a gastroenterologist didn’t find it odd that in a cohort of experimental subjects given only placebos for peptic ulcer disease, nearly half demonstrated healed ulcers after 4 weeks—about the percentage, I’d wager, whose ulcers would have healed with no trial intervention.
Regarding Prof. Moerman’s view of the sort of science that physicians need to know, along with Dr. Gorski I detect shades of Deepak Chopra, although I also detect a bit of down-home, folksy, isn’t-he-wise midwestern ambiguity, possibly delivered in a Mr. Ed voice, such as to give the good professor a way to deny it all. Consider this excerpt from the NEJM editorial, also noted by Dr. Gorski:
What do we learn from this study? The authors conclude that the patient reports were “unreliable,” since they reported improvement when there was none — that is, the subjective experiences were simply wrong because they ignored the objective facts as measured by FEV1. But is this the right interpretation? It is the subjective symptoms that brought these patients to medical care in the first place. They came because they were wheezing and felt suffocated, not because they had a reduced FEV1. The fact that they felt improved even when their FEV1 had not increased begs the question, What is the more important outcome in medicine: the objective or the subjective, the doctor’s or the patient’s perception? This distinction is important, since it should direct us as to when patient-centered versus doctor-directed care should take place.
Does he really believe that the subjective is the more important outcome? It certainly seems so; next he writes:
In a number of other trials in which both sham and actual treatments were evaluated, results were very similar. In one study of major depressive disorder, placebo, hypericum (St. John’s wort), and sertraline all resulted in about the same level of improvement on the Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression. Similarly, in studies of low back pain in both the United States and Germany, true acupuncture and sham acupuncture had about the same effectiveness yet were substantially better than usual medical care in relieving the pain. A number of surgical procedures — such as arthroscopic knee surgery and spinal vertebroplasty — have led to similar results with actual and sham treatments. In these studies and many more, inert treatments have had effects similar to their “active” analogues.
Woah! Sure, the subjective results of those trials “were very similar” to those of the albuterol trial, but so what? What distinguishes those trials from the albuterol trial is that there were no objective outcomes to measure! Moerman has missed the point of the distinction. He seems to prefer that medicine be about “a profound meaning response,” as he explained in an article written jointly with homeopath Wayne Jonas a few years ago, which comes awfully close to asserting that all “healing” is culturally determined:
Anthropologists understand cultures as complex webs of meaning, rich skeins of connected understandings, metaphors, and signs. Insofar as 1) meaning has biological consequence and 2) meanings vary across cultures, we can anticipate that biology will differ in different places, not because of genetics but because of these entangled ideas…
In the NEJM editorial Prof. Moerman doesn’t seem bothered by an inconvenient truth about objective outcomes. That is, maybe he doesn’t:
Maybe it is sufficient simply to show that a treatment yields significant improvement for the patients, has reasonable cost, and has no negative effects over the short or long term. This is, after all, the first tenet of medicine: “Do no harm.”
Prof. Moerman, what about the harm that comes from the NEJM seeming to judge treatments that offer favorable subjective outcomes as being equivalent to those that offer favorable objective outcomes? This kind of harm, for example. Asthma isn’t just a “subjective and functional condition,” whatever that is. It’s a real and potentially lethal disease. Oh, but you wrote “maybe.” Silly me.
Dr. Drazen, Where art Thou?
It is especially puzzling, considering the identity of its Editor-in-Chief, that the New England Journal of Medicine asked Daniel Moerman to write the editorial to accompany the report of the albuterol study. Jeffrey Drazen is not only a pulmonologist, but an expert in the pathophysiology of asthma. He has been instrumental in developing new drugs for asthma, drugs whose effects—I’m willing to bet, but I’ve no time to research right now—have been demonstrated objectively. If memory serves, Dr. Drazen trained at the old Peter Bent Brigham Hospital under ‘Reggie’ McFadden, whose chapter on asthma in my 2001 edition of Harrison’s Principles of Internal Medicine includes this passage:
The most effective treatment for acute episodes of asthma requires a systematic approach based on the aggressive use of sympathomimetic agents and serial monitoring of key indices of improvement. Reliance on empiricism and subjective assessment is no longer acceptable.
I’d be surprised if Dr. Drazen had ever heard of Moerman before the albuterol report was accepted for publication, and I wonder who recommended him. Kaptchuk, perhaps? Heh.
Unfortunately, someone isn’t minding the NEJM store when it comes to certain dubious topics, as Dr. Gorski mentioned and as I’ve written about previously.
Good News, Bad News
Perhaps Dr. Drazen imagines that the editorial won’t do any real damage, because real doctors will immediately identify it for what it is: Bullshit. That is probably true, except for the small but possibly growing number of “integrative” aficianados out there. I worry more about other Dummy Docs, such as naturopaths (ND=Not a Doctor, according to one apostate), who already believe wholeheartedly what Prof. Moerman “maybe” believes, and a lot more:
For an acute asthma attack try a steam inhalation (draping a towel over your head and a bowl of hot water) with a few drops of eucalyptus oil in the water. Be careful that the water is not so hot that the steam burns your face. Some doctors recommend taking baths with a cup or so of 3% hydrogen peroxide in the water to bring extra oxygen to the entire surface of the skin, thus making the lungs somewhat less oxygen hungry. This method can be performed preventively. Another technique for an acute attack is to drink some hot water with the juice of one clove of garlic. [etc.]
And:
How Can Homeopathy Help Asthma?
Like with Traditional Chinese Medicine, each individual is analyzed for their specific symptoms and an appropriate therapy is chosen, not for the disease, but for the person displaying signs of health out of balance. This is a very important distinction, and, very generally speaking, one of the main differences between conventional and “complementary” approaches to health care.
After the homeopath, naturopath or medical doctor trained in homeopathy (they should have the title “Diplomat of Homeopathy” after their other credentials) listen carefully to your story, one of the following remedies are likely to be prescribed. [etc.]
What Kind of Subtle Energy Techniques Are Useful for Asthma?
Some folks like to work with flower essences. Some of the more popular ones to help with asthma are:
    • oak
    • mimulus
    • larch
    • wild rose
    • hornbeam
    • crab apple
    • impatiens
    • gentian
    • Shasta daisy
    • blackberry
    • chamomile
    • agrimony
    • clematis
Other people find it useful to work with color, either by using thin plastic filters over light sources in their home or office environment, or by wearing clothes of specific colors. The following serves as a guide to experiment with color therapy to help asthma.
During an asthma attack try:
    • purple (raises the threshold of pain and is soporific; is a vasodilator; slows heart rate) on face, throat and chest
    • scarlet (acts as a stimulant to the kidney and adrenals) on kidneys
    • orange (an antispasmodic) on throat and chest
    • indigo or violet on throat, chest and upper back for 15 minutes
Etc., ad nauseam. Boy, do Dummy Docs love it when their pet treatments seem to be endorsed by real medicine, especially the highest bastions of real medicine. Science, even! Is it any surprise when something like this happens? Josephine Briggs, are you reading this? If so, please look here for more discussion of that case. You also won’t want to miss the sequels to this post.
…
The Dummy Series:
Dummy Medicines, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 1: a Curious Editorial Choice for the New England Journal of Medicine
Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.0: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD
Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.1: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (cont.)
Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.2: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (cont. again)
Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.3: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (concluded)
…
The Harvard Medical School series:
Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part I)
Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part II)
Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part III)
Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part IV)
Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part V)
Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part VI)
Dummy Medicines, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 1: a Curious Editorial Choice for the New England Journal of Medicine
Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.0: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD
Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.1: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (cont.)
Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.2: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (cont. again)
Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.3: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (concluded)

   Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.0: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD
Kimball Atwood
Link
Review
The recent albuterol vs. placebo trial reported in the New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) found that experimental subjects with asthma experienced substantial, measured improvements in lung function after inhaling albuterol, but not after inhaling placebo, undergoing sham acupuncture, or “no treatment.” It also found that the same subjects reported having felt substantially improved after either albuterol or each of the two sham treatments, but not after “no treatment.” Anthropologist Daniel Moerman, in an accompanying editorial, wrote, “the authors conclude that the patient reports were ‘unreliable,’ since they reported improvement when there was none”—precisely as any rational clinician or biomedical scientist would have concluded.
In Part 1 of this blog we saw that Moerman took issue with that conclusion. He argued, with just a bit of hedging, that the subjects’ perceptions of improvement were more important than objective measures of their lung function. I wondered how the NEJM editors had chosen someone whose bibliography predicted such an anti-medical opinion. I doubted that Editor-in-Chief Jeffrey Drazen, an expert in the pathophysiology of asthma, had ever heard of Moerman. I suggested, in a way that probably appeared facetious, that Ted Kaptchuk, the senior author of the asthma report, might have recommended him.
Editorial Cronyism?
I wasn’t being facetious, even if I was a bit snide. In a 2009 article Kaptchuk touted Moerman’s notion of “the meaningresponse,” also discussed in Part 1. In a 1998 article, one of Kaptchuk’s early forays into the placebo topic, he had thanked Moerman and others “for advice, discussion, and feedback.” In the Acknowledgments for his 2002 book Meaning, Medicine, and the “Placebo Effect,” Moerman returned the complement to Kaptchuk. In a very recent essay on “placebo studies and ritual theory,” Kaptchuk showed some serious cultural anthropology chops with a serviceable impression of Moerman:
…healing rituals are never simply enactments of plots, stories or assertions of truth. Instead, they are compelling multi-sensory dramas involving evocation, enactment, embodiment and evaluation. Rituals and their sensory, affective, moral and aesthetic components transmute the mythos into an experiential reality for participants. Metaphors and symbols, the healer’s prestige, social interactions with relatives and community members in the course of preparation and performance of the ritual, and gesture, recitation, costume, iconography, touch, ingestion and the physical ordeal—all provide vehicles for and multi-dimensional guideposts to a process that is meant to transform a patient from brokenness to intactness.
Authorship by Committee and Mixed Messages
The asthma trial authors themselves seemed ambivalent about the meaning of their results. Here is the larger passage from which Moerman culled the “unreliable” comment:
…although improvement in objective measures of lung function would be expected to correlate with subjective measures, our study suggests that in clinical trials, reliance solely on subjective outcomes may be inherently unreliable, since they may be significantly influenced by placebo effects. However, even though objective physiological measures (e.g., FEV1) are important, other outcomes such as emergency room visits and quality-of-life metrics may be more clinically relevant to patients and physicians.
David Gorski has previously mentioned that his “jaw dropped” when he read those words; so did mine, and so, everywhere, should jaws of asthmatic patients and competent physicians drop. The two sentences are contradictory: if the first is true, the second—essentially similar to the theme in Moerman’s editorial, weasel words and all—is perverse. How could the same authors have written both? Perusing the list of authors provides some hints:
Michael E. Wechsler, M.D., John M. Kelley, Ph.D., Ingrid O.E. Boyd, M.P.H., Stefanie Dutile, B.S., Gautham Marigowda, M.B., Irving Kirsch, Ph.D., Elliot Israel, M.D., and Ted J. Kaptchuk
Thus there were eight authors, suggesting that there may not have been a unanimity of opinion. Of the eight, five—M.E.W., I.O.E.B., S.D., G.M., and E.I.—are identified as “from the Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, Brigham and Women’s Hospital and Harvard Medical School” (the same Division, as I mentioned in Part 1, that spawned NEJM Editor Jeffrey Drazen). It’s a safe bet that those five subscribed to the first sentence quoted above, but not to the second.
I don’t know about the other two authors, but Ted Kaptchuk would appear to agree with the second sentence. Here he’s quoted in the Brigham and Women’s Hospital press release:
“We chose to study patients with asthma because earlier evidence had suggested that placebos would change the underlying medical problem,” explains senior author Ted Kaptchuk, Director of the Program in Placebo Studies at BIDMC and Associate Professor of Medicine at HMS. “While I was initially surprised that there was no placebo effect in this experiment [after looking at the objective air flow measures] once I saw patients’ subjective descriptions of how they felt following both the active treatment and the placebo treatments, it was apparent that the placebos were as effective as the active drug in helping people feel better.”
…adds Kaptchuk, the study results imply that placebo treatment is just as effective as active medication in improving patient-centered outcomes.”It’s clear that for the patient, the ritual of treatment can be very powerful,” notes Kaptchuk. “This study suggests that in addition to active therapies for fixing diseases, the idea of receiving care is a critical component of what patients value in health care. In a climate of patient dissatisfaction, this may be an important lesson.”
Let’s see: “patient-centered outcomes” are now defined as feeling better but not being better? (I wonder if Don Berwick, the nation’s most influential exponent of patient-centered care, would agree). According to whom? Other press reports were even worse:
Treatment, not medicine, helps asthma patients feel better
NEW YORK, July 15 (Reuters Life!) – Inhaling albuterol helps asthmatic lungs work better, but patients who get it don’t feel much better than those treated with a placebo inhaler or phony acupuncture, according to a U.S. study.
The results, which appeared in the New England Journal of Medicine, demonstrate the importance of, literally, caring for patients and not just providing drugs, said co-author Ted Kaptchuk of Harvard Medical School.
The findings also demonstrate the impact of the so-called “placebo effect,” or the phenomenon seen in clinical trials when people given inactive, fake “treatments,” such as a sugar pill or saline, show improvements.
“My honest opinion is that a lot of medicine is the doctor-patient relationship,” Kaptchuk told Reuters Health.
“A lot of doctors don’t know that, they think it’s their drugs. Our study demonstrates that the interaction between the two is actually a very strong component of healthcare.”
…
Treatment of Asthma now Possible with Placebo Treatments
A New study says, “Placebo treatments are equally effective in the treatment of asthma like [sic] any asthma medications.”
According to the researchers, the main reason behind proposition of this study is that several asthma patients have reported that they felt improvement in their asthma symptoms after they received placebo treatments. These treatments also include inhaler treatments and fake acupuncture. The improvement is similar to what they feel after taking asthma medication such as albuterol.
But the researchers also mentioned that unlike asthma medications, the placebo treatments are not capable of affecting the functioning of the lung.
The researcher of the study, Mr. Ted Kaptchuk said, “The practice of treatment can be highly effective for the patients”. “The study also recommends that patients should value not only the treatments for improving diseases but also the intensive care they receive from their healthcare providers” he added.
Mr. Ted Kaptchuk also said, “In the initial stage of the experiment, placebo treatments fail to make any impact. But later, when I observed that patient’s subjective descriptions about what they felt after receiving the two treatments then I concluded that placebo treatments work as well as other asthma treatments”.
At least one blog, citing the Reuters report quoted above, reported that “placebos were just as effective as real therapy” without even mentioning the trial’s having found a discrepancy between objective findings and subjective reports.
I am aware that authors of journal articles can’t be expected to control how every reporter characterizes those articles, but it’s fair to say that the emphasis of the various quotations attributed to Kaptchuk—which, as far as can be gleaned from the web, are accurate—was essentially the opposite of the study’s most important finding.
From Campus Radical to AltMed Superstar
You might have noticed that Kaptchuk’s is the only name on the list of authors that is not accompanied by the mark of an advanced degree, as I will eventually discuss. Like Moerman, Kaptchuk lacks formal training in either modern medicine or biomedical science, although he has learned a lot about the history and methods of clinical trials. How did he get to be Senior Author of an article published in the New England Journal of Medicine, and how did he become Associate Professor at the Harvard Medical School?
Here is the short version:
I was interested in science for a long time. In college, I studied religion and philosophy. Then I studied Chinese medicine in China and I came back and was a practitioner of Chinese medicine. When people became interested in alternative medicines, they asked me to help out at Harvard Medical School. I realized that in order to survive there, one had to become a scientist. So I became a scientist.
Here is the beginning of the longer version. Kaptchuk graduated from Columbia University in 1968, having majored in Asian philosophy. While there he was Chairman of the radical group Students for a Democratic Society (SDS), just prior to the emergence of its more famous chairman, Mark Rudd. I mention this not to commie-bash, but because it helps to elucidate some of Kaptchuk’s later opinions (hint: he has no trouble agreeing with both sentences in the jaw-dropping paragraph quoted above) and to demonstrate some of the ironies of his later choices.
After graduation, in Kaptchuk’s own words, ”I worked in the welfare and social services trying to help people.” During this time “I decided that I wanted to learn a healing art but was disillusioned with some of the aspects of Western allopathy and decided to learn acupuncture.” Kaptchuk pursued training with Asian practitioners in California and “studied every book in English on the subject,” but by 1972 had decided that this would not be sufficient:
Because of the relative unknowness [sic] among non-Chinese Americans of acupuncture and Dr. Hong’s limited practice, I cannot get enough experience to adequately master this healing art. In addition, there is a greater reluctance among other Chinese doctors who have more patients to have a student observe because of legal restrictions concerning their practice in the United States.
Kaptchuk reports having next spent a year in Taiwan, followed by 2.5 years in Macau (click on the image to enlarge):
Within a few years of his return to the United States, Ted Kaptchuk published the book that made him an alt-med superstar:
It is this book that I will discuss in the next part of this series.

   Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.1: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (cont.)
Kimball Atwood 
Link
Rave Reviews
In 1983, Ted Kaptchuk, the senior author of the recent “albuterol vs. placebo” article, and soon to become the long-time Second-in-Command of the Harvard Medical School “CAM” program, published The Web that Has No Weaver.
The book received rave reviews:
A major advance toward the synthesis of Western and Eastern theory. It will stimulate all practitioners to expand their understanding of the causes and treatment of disease.
–Paul Epstein, MD, Harvard Medical School
A lucid and penetrating exposition of the theory and practice of Chinese medicine. While the book’s rich detail makes it of great use to practicing healers, it is in its entirety very simply written, enjoyable reading for the layman…it brings a demystifying balance…Instructive, profound, and important!
Professor Martin Schwartz, University of California, Berkeley
…demystifies Oriental medicine in a remarkably rational analysis…
—Science Digest, Nov. 1982
…an encyclopedia of how to tell from the Eastern perspective ‘what is wrong.’
—Larry Dossey
Dr. Kaptchuk has become a lyricist for the art of healing…
—Houston Chronicle
Although the book is explicitly detailed, it is readable and does not require previous knowledge of Chinese thought…
—Library Journal
The 2nd edition was published in 2000, to more acclaim:
…opens the great door of understanding to the profoundness of Chinese medicine.
—People’s Daily, Beijing, China
…weaves a picture…that is eminently understandable from a Westerner’s point of view…adds a valuable analysis of the current scientific understanding of how the therapies work and their effectiveness.
—Brian Berman
Ted Kaptchuk’s book was inspirational in the development of my acupuncture practice and gave me a deep understanding of traditional Chinese medicine…
Dr. George T. Lewith
…a gift for all who share an interest in deep understanding of healing. This new edition is essential reading…
—Michael Lerner, President, Commonweal
Even Edzard Ernst, still in his foggy period, called the 2nd edition “a brilliant synthesis of traditional and scientific knowledge…compulsory reading…”
Andrew Weil, who wrote a forward for the 2nd edition, praised Kaptchuk for “merg[ing] the insight of a Taoist sage with the skepticism of a modern, inquiring scientist,” and asserted that
…the emphasis of Chinese practitioners on energy and its balanced flow throughout the body is a stumbling block for Westerners who cannot see beyond the limitations of the paradigm of materialistic science.
Margaret Caudill, who wrote forwards to both editions, praised Kaptchuk for having written
…an important exposition of the ancient art of Chinese medicine in terms that can be understood by a Western audience. The author has deftly avoided, as much as possible, the pitfall of interpreting Chinese theory through Western terminology, thereby leaving the central Chinese concept of medical patterns and disharmonies undisturbed.
(One wonders if Caudill had read the book that she introduced. Kaptchuk himself, on the third page of his own introduction, states that he tried to “explain Chinese concepts with a Western vocabulary,” although he’d found that “at times [this] was a very great problem.”)
What readers might expect to find, then, is a book that is easy to read and understandable to Westerners, that is rational, that ‘demystifies’ its subject, that will provide a ‘deep’ understanding of healing, that will “expand their understanding of the causes and treatment of disease,” and that heralds a ‘synthesis’ of Eastern and Western medicine.
I perused the first edition of The Web around 10 years ago, when I was trying to learn something about acupuncture for my work on the Massachusetts Special Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medical Practitioners. A friend had it on his bookshelf, and let me borrow it; he hadn’t read it himself. A few days later I reported back to him: “there is sophistry on nearly every page.”
This review is mostly concerned with the first edition; I’ll mention some things about the 2000 edition in the subsequent posts.
“A Coherent and Independent System of Thought”
Kaptchuk begins by dismissing two, presumably dominant Western notions of Chinese medicine:
Some…see it as hocus-pocus—the product of primitive or magical thinking. If a patient is cured by means of herbs or acupuncture, they see only two possible explanations: either the cure was psychosomatic or it was an accident, the happy result of hit-or-miss pin-sticking that the practitioner did not understand. They assume that current Western science and medicine have a unique handle on truth—all else is superstition.
Other people have an equally erroneous view of Chinese medicine. Deeply and often justifiably disturbed by many of the products of Western science and culture, they assume that the Chinese system, because it is more ancient, more spiritual or more holisitic, is somehow more “true” than Western medicine. This attitude threatens to turn Chinese medicine from a rational body of knowledge into a religious faith system. Both attitudes mystify the subject—one by arrogantly undervaluing it, the other by setting it on a pedestal. Both are barriers to understanding.
But no more a barrier to understanding than the passage just quoted. We who ‘arrogantly’ undervalue Chinese medicine do so not because we see only two possible explanations for its apparent successes; we see many explanations, none involving hit-or-miss pin-sticking, accidental or otherwise. We deny that science is ‘Western,’ any more than the physics of Einstein was ‘Jewish’ (I confess to having used this quip repeatedly, but in my opinion it can’t be repeated enough). We immediately detect, in the phrase “current Western science,” the Galileo Gambit, and we reject that bit of sophistry. We’ve seen precious little evidence of cures by means of herbs or acupuncture, and 28 years later we’re still waiting. Those who think Chinese medicine is more true than ‘Western medicine’ have a problem with science other than merely being disturbed by its “products.” They are, er, deeply ignorant of it.
What, then, is Kaptchuk’s view of Chinese medicine?
Actually, Chinese medicine is a coherent and independent system of thought and practice that has been developed over two millennia. Based on ancient texts, it is the result of a continuous process of critical thinking, as well as extensive clinical observation and testing. It represents a thorough formulation and reformulation of material by respected clinicians and theoreticians. It is also, however, rooted in the philosophy, logic, sensibility and habits of a civilization entirely foreign to our own. It has therefore developed its own perception of the body and of health and disease.
If you’re bracing for an onslaught of the usual sCAMbits—unfalsifiable assertions, propaganda language devices, arguments from ignorance, arguments from tradition, special pleading, changing the rules ad lib, breezy contradictions, and all the rest—you’re on the right track. Right off the bat, Kaptchuk asks that you check your own critical thinking skills at the door:
In order to understand it, we must first accept two principles: that another perspective, though different from our own, can be logical and have predictive validity, and that there can exist another method of healing. In other words, the world can contain two rational and effective medical systems, both describing the same phenomena, but describing them differently. Once we accept these premises, we can begin to understand the Chinese view of physiology.
I’ll give you a taste of that ‘physiology’ below, but first know that for Kaptchuk, Western medicine suffers from a severe case of reductionism, whereas Chinese medicine is far more interested in you as a whole person:
Western medicine is concerned mainly with isolable disease categories or agents of disease, which it zeroes in on, isolates, and tries to change, control, or destroy. The Western physician starts with a symptom, then searches for the underlying mechanism—a precise cause for a specific disease…
The Chinese physician, in contrast, directs his or her attention to the complete physiological and psychological individual. All relevant information, including the symptom as well as the patient’s other general characteristics, is gathered and woven together until it forms what Chinese medicine calls a “pattern of disharmony.”…Oriental diagnostic technique does not turn up a specific disease entity or a precise cause, but renders an almost poetic, yet workable, description of a whole person.
“An Effective Healing Method”
Kaptchuk asserts that Chinese medicine considers some things important that Western medicine does not, and vice versa:
…Chinese medical theory does not have the concept of a nervous system. Nevertheless, it has been demonstrated that Chinese medicine can be used to treat neurological disorders. Similarly, Chinese medicine does not perceive an endocrine system, yet it is used to treat what Western medicine calls endocrine disorders. Nor does traditional Chinese medicine recognize the bacteria Streptococcus pneumoniae as a pathological cause of pneumonia [sic], yet often it effectively treats the disease.
The first two claims are trivially true, of course, but beg the relevant question: the humoral system of medicine was also used to treat all sorts of diseases, as has every pre-scientific form of medicine. The pneumonia claim is another matter, for which Kaptchuk doesn’t offer particularly convincing evidence:
…the Chinese performed thousands of experiments and clinical studies during the fifties. The result was that in 1958 the Central Committee decided to give traditional and modern medicine equal respect and place in China…
The pages of such studies fill entire libraries, yet it is not their quantity that is important, but rather their conclusions: that traditional Chinese medicine can hold its own, that it does work clinically.
It is now evident that Chinese medicine is an effective healing method.
Kaptchuk proceeds to cite numerous, presumably positive or at least promising studies from China, involving heart disease, cancer, kidney disease, asthma, encephalitis, diphtheria, acupuncture anesthesia, and more. He points out that when these are “diseases recognized by the West,”
the actual application and methodology are clearly Western in orientation. The theory of Yin and Yang and other traditional concepts are left behind…
Fortunately for its future, however, the results of the studies generally demonstrate that traditional Chinese medicine does work best when left in the context of Chinese logic.
He continues to plead the case for the unfalsifiable:
…the Chinese view of health and disease as inseparable from a specific person means that the treatment will be well tailored to that person. Such personal shaping seems to maximize the effectiveness of the therapies.
Nevertheless,
Western clinical studies (done in China) of traditional Chinese medicine, by proving its practical efficacy, have helped it win its battle for survival in the twentieth century, and promise it a place in the future of medicine.
Later, in a footnote, Kaptchuk mentions that those weren’t, like, real studies: they weren’t controlled, and many used “imprecise assessment methods. They would most properly be called clinical observations.” Throughout the book he continues to cite them in support of various unlikely cure claims.
Sometimes he just makes stuff up without even attempting to justify it:
Chinese remedies are often more effective than Western ones, and they are always gentler and safer. Chinese prescriptions, for example, do not produce side effects because they are balanced to reflect a patient’s entire state of being.
Chinese medicine, because it emphasizes balance and relationship more than measurable quantity, can also frequently discover and treat a disorder before it is perceptible by the most sophisticated Western diagnostic techniques. Chinese medicine is capable of touching those places that evade the microscope…
Woah. Dr. Epstein, did you even read this stuff? Dr. Ernst? OK: Dossey, Weil, Berman, we expect them to quack right along, but really. Dr. Delbanco? (He’s not one of the reviewers quoted above, but one of my former mentors at Harvard. He told me a few years ago that he’d been Kaptchuk’s patron. Did he read this book?)
Kaptchuk never explains the real reasons that “the Central Committee decided to give traditional and modern medicine equal respect and place in China,” previously discussed here. In that post I also showed how one of the passages quoted above morph’d from the 1983 edition to the 2000 edition of The Web; it isn’t flattering to the ideal of intellectual honesty.
“Images of the Macrocosm”
What about that Chinese view of physiology? It turns out that Kaptchuk, who coined the phrase, asserts only a few pages later that there is no such thing. We already suspected that, but let’s play along:
The highly developed constructs [sic] of chemistry, biochemistry, anatomy, and physiology that form the groundwork for modern Western medicine are of little importance to the Chinese…Chinese medicine therefore has a very limited theory of the human organism itself.
But didn’t he tell us that the Chinese physician directs his or her attention to the complete physiological and psychological individual? I guess it depends on what your definition of “truth” is:
The essential ideas of Chinese medicine…are cultural and speculative constructs that provide orientation and direction for the practical patient situation…The ‘truth’ of these ideas lies in the way the physician can use them to treat real people with real complaints.
Maybe we’re getting somewhere, because the essential ideas are certainly cultural and speculative constructs; but there are those real complaints again, such as pneumococcal pneumonia. I thank Kaptchuk for now having made it clear that I needn’t go into excruciating detail about what I’d imagined he meant by the “Chinese view of physiology,” even as I cringe when I consider that he probably hadn’t intended to insult Chinese people in general.
But wait:
For the Chinese, Qi is not a metaphor; it is a real phenomenon that makes possible integrative descriptions of bodily changes.
Such contradictions are rampant throughout the book (and ya gotta love those “integrative descriptions”):
Chinese medicine is not primarily quantitative.
But:
It has standards of measurement that allow practitioners systematically to describe, diagnose, and treat illness.
Aren’t measurements quantitative? Silly, Western me:
Its measurements, however, are not the linear yardsticks of weight, number, time, and volume used by modern science but rather images of the macrocosm.
Hmmm. Images of the macrocosm: simple, lucid, rational, understandable, demystifying—and each one a measurement to boot! Heck, no less a measurement than Dolores Krieger’s, and the macrocosm’s been around for a helluva lot longer.
The “Chinese View of Physiology”
The ancient Chinese, according to Kaptchuk, were totally into Functions and Relationships. I had therefore imagined that by “physiology” he must have meant the “Fundamental Substances”—Qi (“we can perhaps think of Qi as matter on the verge of becoming energy, or energy at the point of materializing”), Blood (“not the same as what the West calls blood”), Jing (“Essence”), Shen (“Spirit”) and Fluids (“bodily liquids other than Blood”)—; and the Organs (“The Harmonious Landscape”: Yin Organs are Heart, Lungs, Spleen, Liver, and Kidneys; Yang Organs are Gall Bladder, Stomach, Small Intestine, Large Intestine, Bladder, and Triple Burner; Curious Organs are Brain, Marrow, Bone, Blood Vessels, Uterus, and Gall Bladder again); and, of course, how they all work together to get things done. That’s physiology!
The Chinese view, according to Kaptchuk? Let’s see:
The Heart:
    • ‘rules the Blood and Blood vessels’
    • ‘stores the Shen [Spirit]‘
    • ‘opens into the tongue’
The Lungs:
    • ‘rule Qi’
    • ‘move and adjust the Water channels’
    • ‘are the upper origin of water’
    • ‘rule the exterior of the body’
    • ‘open into the nose’
The Spleen:
    • ‘rules transformation and transportation’
    • ‘governs the blood’
    • ‘rules the raising of the pure’
    • ‘rules the muscles, flesh,’ and the four limbs
    • is the origin of Qi and Blood
    • ‘opens into the mouth’
Organs vs. organs
It goes on and on, but I think you get the point. Kaptchuk insists that the ancient Chinese did not seriously intend to portray those Organs as real:
…the Chinese have no system of anatomy comparable to that of the West.
In China, internal anatomy is generally irrelevant to clinical practice.
The Heart, Lung and Kidneys of this volume are not a physical heart, lung, or kidneys; instead they are personae in a descriptive drama of health and disease.
The Organs of the body, defined as they are by their functions and relationships, are another part of the bodily web. They cannot be discussed out of context. The Chinese notions about Organs (or anything else) are not meant to be hard pieces of a theory that can be proved or disproved. They are part of an organizing network to be used when convenient. The Chinese would be indifferent to proof in our accustomed scientific sense.
China’s lack of an anatomical theory like the West’s does not mean its system is unscientific; it means only that there exist alternate systems of thought, one Eastern, one Western.
What are the differences between the two? Here is the remainder of the paragraph partially quoted above:
The tendency of Chinese thought is to seek out dynamic functional activity rather than to look for the fixed somatic structures that perform the activities. Because of this, the Chinese have no system of anatomy comparable to that of the West. Thus, for example, the Organ known as the Liver is for the Chinese very different from the Western liver. The Chinese Liver is defined first by the functions associated with it, the Western liver by its physical structure. This divergence makes it possible for Chinese medicine to identify Organs not recognized by the West—such as the Triple Burner—and for it not to recognize organs and glands clearly identified by Western medicine—such as the pancreas and the adrenal glands.
So it seems that in the West, physicians view organs in much the same way that butchers do: as mere “somatic structures,” without regard to their functions and relationships. This is nonsense, of course. I’m sure that every MD who was trained at least since the Flexner Report has thought of organs as being part of an anatomical and physiological whole, with countless, real functions and functional relationships among them, more of which are being discovered all the time. That’s physiology!
In reality, the ancient Chinese rarely dissected cadavres, so a straightforward explanation for their Organ confusion is the same as that for the centuries-long persistence of Galen’s erroneous anatomy in the West: prior to the last few hundred years the Chinese, like the Europeans, didn’t know any better. What anatomical information they had likely came from fleeting observations of mangled soldiers on battlefields, by extrapolating from the butchery of farm animals or occasional dissections of primates, and from very rare, mostly secretive dissections of human cadavres. Because such dissections were frowned upon, and Arguments from Authority were ‘privileged’ in both cultures until recently, even legitimate challenges to conventional wisdom, if there were any, were not appreciated.
Kaptchuk knows some of this but, once again, you have to go to the small print of a footnote at the end of the chapter to find the relevant passage:
China…had Confucian religious and ethical prohibitions against dissection…
The straightforward explanation is supported by some of Kaptchuk’s Organ descriptions being crudely accurate (the lungs really do “open into the nose”; the Stomach does “receive and ripen” food) and by some being inaccurate in ways that are understandable from a simplistic, purely anatomical point of view. For example, according to Kaptchuk, the “Kidneys are called the ‘root of life’…the source of reproduction,” and dysfunctions thereof are responsible for “sterility or impotence…or lack of sexual maturation.” Well, no, the kidneys have almost nothing to do with those things, but you might think otherwise if you knew only that there are tubes that connect them to the bladder and the bladder to the external genitalia. So much for an understanding of function and relationships.
An “Important Taoist Notion”
There is nothing shameful about a pre-scientific history; all cultures have gone through it. So why the subterfuge? Apparently the straightforward explanation evokes a Pattern of Disharmony with Kaptchuk’s central claim:
Chinese medicine is a coherent system of thought that does not require validation by the West as an intellectual construct. Intellectually, the way to approach Chinese concepts is to see whether they are internally logical and consistent, not to disguise them as Western concepts or dismiss them because they do not conform to Western notions. And the system is internally consistent—it is an organization of all the observable manifestations of the body into an integrated set of functions and relationships. Understanding of these functions and relationships enables the practitioner to identify and treat a disharmony in them.
And finally, his absolute, you-got-no-answer-for-this trump card:
The important Taoist notion—that the Tao (or Dao, the balanced and harmonious Way) that can be talked about and described is not the Tao—pervades medicine.
Ya gotta love the Gish Gallop. You also gotta appreciate how that important Taoist notion morphs, almost seamlessly, into current Quantum Quackery, with its own purported trump cards, misplaced versions of the Observer Effect and of Quantum Entanglement. This is no mere coincidence: Quantum Mysticism was all the rage during the 1970s, especially with the publication of Fritjof Capra’s annoying book, The Tao of Physics. Kaptchuk had apparently read another such book, The Dancing Wu-Li Masters, from which he borrowed this quotation attributed to physicist David Bohm:
Parts…are seen to be an immediate connection, in which their dynamical relationships depend, in an irreproducible way, on the state of the whole system (and, indeed, on that of broader systems in which they are contained, extending ultimately and in principle to the entire universe). Thus, one is led to a new notion of unbroken wholeness which denies the classical idea of analyzability of the world into separately and independently existent parts…
That works perfectly for someone who is hell-bent on dissing “reductionism” in Western medicine. There is that little problem of physiology, though…ya gotta wonder how all those wise reviewers missed it and just about everything else.
But back to ‘observable manifestations of the body’: doesn’t their being ‘observable’ imply that they are real, not just ‘internally logical and consistent’? Which, by the way, sounds awfully ‘Western’ to me. Oops, I stumbled again: throughout the book Kaptchuk refers to “Chinese logic”; that must be different from Western logic.
OK, I’ll try to be a little less snide. It’s possible that a system of thought can be coherent and internally logical and consistent, and yet still not be valid. Astrology, or at least some schools of it, could be such a system. Homeopathy could be another. So could the activities of the Tooth Fairy. There is also the question of just how coherent and logical and consistent Chinese medicine is. I hope this is becoming evident throughout this review.
Meridians: Interior vs. Exterior
Meridians are another important part of the Chinese view of anatomy and physiology:
Meridians are channels or pathways that carry Qi and Blood through the body. They are not blood vessels. Rather, they comprise an invisible network that links together all the Fundamental Substances and Organs…The Nei Jing says: ‘The Meridians move the Qi and Blood, regulate Yin and Yang, moisten the tendons and bones, benefit the joints.’
Are we to take such pronouncements literally? After all, “The Chinese notions about Organs (or anything else) are not meant to be hard pieces of a theory that can be proved or disproved.” Remember, there are many contradictions in this book:
In Chinese Meridian theory, these channels are unseen but are thought to embody a physical reality—the Substances Qi and Blood move along them, carrying nourishment and strength.
The Meridians connect the interior of the body with the exterior. (As has been said earlier, the distinction between inner and outer has more to do with significance than with place—the interior is more important than the exterior.)
Huh? But we were just told that the Meridians embody a physical reality. So do they or don’t they?
This is the basis for acupuncture theory, that working with points on the surface of the body will affect what goes on inside the body, because it affects the activity of the Substances that are traveling through the Meridians. Most acupuncture points relate to the Meridians and most herbs a doctor prescribes will enter one or more Meridian pathways.
Well, the ‘exterior’ seems to really mean the exterior, i.e., the surface. But does “inside the body” not mean the “interior”? After all, “the interior is more important than the exterior.” But “the distinction between inner and outer has more to do with significance than with place,” and elsewhere Kaptchuk tells us that “in China, internal anatomy is generally irrelevant to clinical practice.” This is making me dizzy.
Kaptchuk next discusses the number of meridians and the number of acupuncture points, without mentioning their relation to astrology. Throughout the book he also fails to deal adequately with the abundance of military, political, geographical, and meteorological metaphors in pre-scientific Chinese medicine, as well as the conspicuous numerology (the number 5 recurs over and over again).
More rigorous historians, such as Paul Unschuld, have made compelling arguments that the Chinese actually thought of those entities as offering important insights—not merely convenient terms—for medical ‘theory.’ Unschuld reports that what Kaptchuk calls “Yin and Yang Organs,” the Chinese call “depot and palace organs,” respectively, even if they are “yin-yang pairs.” Unschuld does not agree with Kaptchuk’s mythologic view of Chinese ‘organs’; he (Unschuld) states that they were “understood as actual morphologic entities.” He also spells them in the lower case. According to Unschuld, such concepts as “stagnant qi” or “blocked qi” were likely derived from irrigation systems in farming. Such views would be an embarrassment to the claim that
…the world can contain two rational and effective medical systems, both describing the same phenomena, but describing them differently.
Patterns of Disharmony
Kaptchuk tells us that the Chinese are (were) not concerned with ultimate causes, but with patterns:
There is no distinction between the illness itself and the factor that “caused” it. The question of cause becomes incidental. In this sense, the word ’cause’ is almost a synonym for ‘effect.’ In Chinese pattern-thinking, what might at first seem to be a cause becomes part of the pattern, indistinguishable and inseparable from the effect. Pattern-thinking subsumes the cause, defining it in terms of the effect and making it part of the total pattern. What we in the West call a cause has little importance in Chinese thought. The lines of causality are bent into circles.
This concept is the basis for the title of the book: The Web that Has no Weaver. I have no reason to doubt that such circular thinking was true for some periods or for some aspects of pre-scientific Chinese medicine, because I don’t really know all that much about it other than what I’ve read in Kaptchuk’s book, in a couple of Unschuld’s books, and in a few essays here and there. I do suspect that Chinese physicians who held this view would have nevertheless jumped at the chance to learn about the real causes of disease, as they did in the late 19th century when the Germ Theory reached them, and as modern Chinese physicians are now doing through scientific research.
It seems, moreover, that not all pre-scientific Chinese physicians subscribed to the “cause has little importance” doctrine. According to Unschuld,
When a doctor who felt bound to the tradition of the medicine of systematic correspondence treated a patient, it was necessary for him to determine categorically which evil was afflicting the patient, via what organ the evil (if of exogenous origin) had found its way into the body, where it was currently located in the organism, what damage it had already caused in the economy of qi, and what other spheres it could possibly move into.
Back to Kaptchuk. Here are some of the “signs” that he would call ‘both cause and effect’ in Patterns of Disharmony: the Six Pernicious Influences (also called the Six Evils)—Wind, Cold, Fire or Heat, Dampness, Dryness, Summer Heat; the Seven Emotions—joy, anger, sadness, grief, pensiveness, fear, fright. Here are the Eight Principal Patterns of Disharmony: Yin/Yang, Interior/Exterior, Deficiency/Excess, Cold/Hot. According to Kaptchuk, the Eight Principal Patterns “are the fundamental model for mediating between [the] two realms” of Yin/Yang and the “signs of disharmony.”
Various combinations of these, which are countless, are beyond my patience to attempt to comprehend. The book is sprinkled with “clinical sketches,” however, which can help to give a flavor of how such Patterns are used. I’ll reproduce a couple of them shortly.
Tongue Diagnosis, Pulse Diagnosis and the $1 Million Challenge
Of the Four Examinations in Chinese medicine—Looking, Listening and Smelling, Asking, and Touching—there are two “pillars”: observing (Looking) at the tongue and feeling (Touching) the pulse. Kaptchuk writes that one of his own teachers “described the tongue as a piece of litmus paper that reveals the basic qualities of a disharmony.” Let’s see if this is credible. The following is a small sample of nearly four pages of tongue descriptions:
A scarlet tongue is deeper red than a red tongue, and points to an extreme Heat condition. In a disharmony characterized by External Heat, it indicates that Heat has entered the deepest levels of the body.
A purple tongue usually indicates that the Qi and Blood are not moving harmoniously and that there is a pattern of Stagnant Qi or Congealed Blood…A purple tongue may also be associated with the Liver’s failure to flow or spread properly.
Moss that is puddled with moisture is a sign of Excess Fluids, usually due to Deficient Yang (or Fire, the body’s internal Heat), but is also a possible sign of other patterns, such as Dampness.
A moss that appears firmly implanted on the tongue body, like grass sprouting from the ground, signifies strong Spleen and Stomach Qi. Moss that appears to be floating on the surface of the tongue is a sign of weak Spleen and Stomach Qi.
A greasy moss appears to be a thick, oily film covering the tongue or a portion of it. It can resemble a layer of white petroleum jelly or butter, and is a sign of Mucus or Dampness in the body.
A peeled tongue may be a sign of Deficient Yin or Fluids, or of Spleen Qi too weak to raise smoke.
A stiff tongue lacks flexibility…This type of tongue usually implies a Wind Pernicious Influence or Mucus obstructing the Heart Qi.
A trembling tongue seems to wiggle uncontrollably. When this type of tongue is pale, it is a sign that Qi is insufficient to regulate proper movement. If the tongue is red, the diagnosis is usually Internal Wind moving the tongue.
…particular areas of the tongue are said to correspond to particular Organs…which are helpful but are never considered absolute.
I quoted those passages not so much to demonstrate their absurdity—though absurd they most certainly are—as to demonstrate their obvious hopelessness as repeatable, agreed-upon physical findings (remember that there are many more where those came from). They remind me of the 35 or so shades of sputum that are listed in homeopathic repertories, each one requiring a match with about the same number of sputum textures, that must further be matched to each of hundreds or thousands of other multi-faceted “symptoms”; and even one little “mistake” among all those choices will purportedly make the crucial difference between choosing the simillimum and choosing a dud. (Look here, pp. 79-81)
Has a study ever shown inter-rater reliabilty for Chinese tongue diagnosis? Not that I know of. A couple of abstracts suggest the opposite, as you’d expect.
What about pulse diagnosis? This is the most important of all the Examinations, and is “far more complex than what we know in the modern West.” Kaptchuk takes it quite seriously. He spends about 16 pages describing “the 28 basic pulses.” They are categorized according to Depth, Speed, Width, Strength, Shape, Length, and Rhythm; some of them are the Floating Pulse, Sinking Pulse, Thin Pulse, Big Pulse, Full Pulse, Empty Pulse, Slippery Pulse, Choppy Pulse, Tight Pulse, Short Pulse, Long Pulse, Knotted Pulse, Flooding Pulse, Soggy Pulse, Leather Pulse, Spinning Bean Pulse. If these weren’t trouble enough, according to Kaptchuk they “are more often found in combination than in their pure form…”
Thus, writes Kaptchuk,
…pulse taking approaches the subtlety and complexity that bespeaks an art. It requires thorough training, great experience, and the gift of sensitivity. When the physician takes a pulse, he or she is alert to a tremendous array of sensations that must be expertly understood and arranged as a unity—the “feel” of an individual pulse…
…it is clear that the system is extremely complex, capable of infinite refinement. Pulse diagnosis is a very sophisticated art. It demands sublety and wisdom on the part of the physician to discern the relative importance of each variable and to make of them all an intelligent and precise diagnosis—to weave a useful pattern.
Wiser Weasel Words of Woo have Warely been Weaved.©
How is the pulse taken and what can it tell the physician? Rather than quote Kaptchuk, I’ll turn to Unschuld, who explains it in a clearer fashion, complete with a topographical metaphor that the ancient Chinese apparently took seriously. He notes that there are several methods:
One method was based on the notion that at the high point of the styloid process below (medial to) the wrist there was an imaginary line, called the “pass,” as a narrow passage through mountains. When a finger feels the pulse with light pressure above the “pass,” i.e., toward the wrist, the pulse offers evidence about the state of the lung and heart. The connection lies in the fact that the imaginary line, the “pass,” corresponds to the diaphragm in the human body. The lung and heart are located above this separation, in the yang area of the body. The lung and heart therefore manifest in pulse above the “pass” in the yang region. Below the pass, in the yin region, the pulse reflects the condition of the liver and kidney, organs which lie below the diaphragm in the yin region of the body. Right on the pass, the middle of the three fingers feels the state of the spleen, the organ that lies closest to the diaphragm.
A second method of pulse taking uses the pressure of a single finger. The finger exerts a light pressure in the area of the pass and feels the pulse just below the skin, that is, in a yang region, which provides information about the lung and heart. Somewhat greater pressure allows the finger to penetrate the level where the pulse of the spleen can be felt. Applying still greater pressure so that the fingertip enters the yin region and almost reaches the bone, the level of the liver and kidneys is reached.
This method stands alongside yet another by which the finger, by application of different degrees of pressure, feels the state of the five organs each at five different levels.
The “states” of the organs include the same possibilities that we saw for tongue diagnosis, e.g., dampness, cold, heat, congealed blood, stagnant qi, etc. It should be obvious to anyone with even a passing knowledge of anatomy and physiology, and with even a passing sense of reality—which apparently excludes the reviewers quoted above, assuming that they read the book—that the claims made for ancient Chinese pulse-taking are ridiculous. Dampness aside, if I were in charge of the Randi $1 million challenge, I’d offer it to anyone who could demonstrate that the maneuvres described above can repeatably yield information distinctly referable to each of the named organs, other than, of course, the heart.
The reports of dismal inter-rater reliability for tongue diagnosis also apply to pulse diagnosis.
“Clinical Sketches”
A patient suddenly gets a high fever and a severe sore throat. She has a red face, a dry, hacking cough, and no fear of cold. A Western physician takes a throat culture and discovers the presence of Group A beta hemolytic streptococcus. Antibiotics are prescribed, with good results. If the same patient had gone to a Chinese physician, he very likely would have diagnosed a Heat Pernicious Influence. Herbs like Coptis and Scutellena, which disperse and cool Fire, would have been prescribed. The results would have been adequate though perhaps slower to achieve than with the antibiotic treatment. Modern research shows, incidentally, that both Coptis and Scutellena inhibit the growth of streptococcus bacteria. Acupuncture treatment, such as needling Large Intestine 4 (He-gu, Adjoining Valleys), to cool Fire, would in this case have offered some symptomatic relief and heightened the body’s resistance, but would have been less effective than herbs.
Oh really? I haven’t pursued the claim made for the two herbs, but I suspect it goes something like this. Acupuncture would have “heightened the body’s resistance”? Spare me. The bigger problem is the blithe, ignorant dismissal of effective medicine: antibiotics don’t shorten the duration of uncomplicated acute streptococcal pharyngitis, so the ‘results’ of Chinese intervention, at least the results that Kaptchuk seems to be talking about, would have been no “slower to achieve.” What antibiotics do in this case—and the entire reason for taking them—is to prevent complications, most importantly post-streptococcal rheumatic fever. And you can bet, dollars to donuts, that neither the herbs nor acupuncture will accomplish that. Oops.
Here’s another Clinical Sketch, “taken from the author’s private practice”:
A woman, aged twenty-six, complained of wheezing, difficulty in breathing, and coughing, especially in the middle of the night. The pattern had begun suddenly when the patient was sixteen years old and had gotten steadily worse. The patient constantly felt tightness in her chest, unrelated to seasonal changes, and when an attack started, there was much sneezing and coughing. Phlegm with a thick and yellow quality was produced. The patient’s medical history was otherwise insignificant. Her appetite was good and her stools and urination were normal. She was very thin, with dark rings under her eyes. Her energy level was good except during an attack, and she did not report any emotional stress but seemed jumpy and anxious. Otherwise, her Shen was harmonious and clear. Her tongue was red and cracked in the middle and had scattered red dots. Her pulse was rapid (ninety-six beats per minute) and also slippery and slightly thin.
When she came for treatment, she was taking Western medication but wanted an alternative because the drugs made her dizzy, tired, and nauseated.
Many of the signs pointed to the pattern of Heat in the Lungs: yellow phlegm, rapid pulse, red tongue, and thirst. Other signs, such as the thin body, the chronic nature of the disorder, the peeled and cracked tongue, and thin pulse, pointed to Deficient Yin. The wheezing, thick phlegm, and slippery pulse indicated that Mucus was present. A combination of acupuncture and herbal treatments was administered to cool the Lung Heat, nourish the Yin of the Lungs, and eliminate Mucus. This therapy brought the symptoms under control within two weeks.
Although the patient is still subject to occasional attacks, they are much less frequent and intense. When needed, she takes herbs or uses an herbal inhalator [sic].
Kinda sounds like asthma, no? You’d think he might’ve asked about cigarette smoke, or maybe cats or dust in her abode. How about listening to her lungs, or maybe even considering (gasp) an objective test? Wasn’t he expected to gather “all relevant information?” (No matter, he nailed the tongue and pulse exams.) An “herbal inhalator”?
Conclusion
How does the Web that Has No Weaver measure up (in the macrocosmic sense, of course) to the reviewers’ promises? Let’s see: is it a book that’s easy to read and understandable to Westerners, that is rational, that ‘demystifies’ its subject, that will provide a ‘deep’ understanding of healing, that will “expand [our] understanding of the causes and treatment of disease,” and that heralds a ‘synthesis’ of Eastern and Western medicine?
Wow. No. In a nutshell, there is sophistry on nearly every page. It continues to astound me that such drivel could have been taken seriously by academic physicians. I suppose the two most likely explanations are, in this order, that they didn’t read the book—can’t say I blame’em, it was like wading through molasses—or that they were utterly fooled by the rampant, misleading language. This post could have been the rilly advanced course in that little bundle, and let’s face it, most academics have just not had the privilege of learning about such esoterica. Whatever else you can say about Kaptchuk, he’s a Master of Misrepresentation.
Some might quibble with my not having cited some reasonable or even insightful passages in the book. It’s true that there are a few, and if taken out of context they can make the author look quite respectable, if you’ll excuse the tongue-in-cheek Bostonian observation. Put’em back in context, however, juxtaposed with all the meaningless adjectives, fallacies, contradictions, unsupported claims and the rest, and it’s ever more clear: sophistry. Ya gotta look at the whole.
I heard Kaptchuk speak at the 2001 Harvard Medical School “CAM” conference. Early in his talk he recounted, in a defiant and triumphant tone that brought cheers from the partisan audience, an episode during the 1980s—perhaps at about the time that he’d treated the woman in the second clinical sketch—when he’d been under threat of arrest for practicing medicine without a license. Go figure.

   Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.2: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (cont. again)
Kimball Atwood
Link
“Strong Medicine”: Ted Kaptchuk and the Powerful Placebo
At the beginning of the first edition of The Web that has no Weaver, published in 1983, author Ted Kaptchuk portended his eventual academic interest in the placebo:
A story is told in China about a peasant who had worked as a maintenance man in a newly established Western missionary hospital. When he retired to his remote home village, he took with him some hypodermic needles and lots of antibiotics. He put up a shingle, and whenever someone came to him with a fever, he injected the patient with the wonder drugs. A remarkable percentage of these people got well, despite the fact that this practitioner of Western medicine knew next to nothing about what he was doing. In the West today, much of what passes for Chinese medicine is not very different from the so-called Western medicine practiced by this Chinese peasant. Out of a complex medical system, only the bare essentials of acupuncture technique have reached the West. Patients often get well from such treatment because acupuncture, like Western antibiotics, is strong medicine.
Other than to wonder if Kaptchuk had watched too many cowboy ‘n’ Native American movies as a kid, when I first read that passage I barely blinked. Although the Chinese peasant may have occasionally treated someone infected with a bacterium susceptible to his antibiotic, most people will get well no matter what you do, because most illnesses are self-limited. Most people feel better even sooner if they think that someone with special expertise is taking care of them. If you want to call those phenomena the “placebo effect,” in the colloquial sense of the term, fine. That, I supposed, was what Kaptchuk meant by “strong medicine.”
Turns out I was mistaken. Let’s briefly follow Kaptchuk’s career path after 1983. In the 2000 edition of The Web, he wrote:
In the almost 20 years since the first edition, I have continued to learn and study. I have treated many patients and worked in many hospitals. I have come into contact with the many other health care systems. For the last ten years I have had a full-time academic appointment at Harvard Medical School (HMS). For four years I worked as a series consultant for a nine-hour British Broadcasting Company (BBC) television series on health care and I was sent to visit various healers on three continents. Currently, I am serving a term on the National Advisory Council of the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) at the National Institutes of Health (NIH) where I have the opportunity to contribute to the evolving reconfiguration of America’s pluralistic medical environment.
Kaptchuk used his newfound academic stature to celebrate all sorts of practices in that “pluralistic environment” that had, only a few years before, been widely recognized as quackery. We’ve seen his views on “Chinese medicine”; here, he and co-author (and boss) David Eisenberg wax eloquent on chiropractic:
Treatment by a chiropractor can generate a sense of understanding and meaning, an experience of comfort, an expectation of change, and a feeling of empowerment. Chiropractic’s combination of vitalist “innate intelligence” and simple mechanical explanation can give rich vocabulary for just those illnesses conventional medicine remains poorly equipped to address.
Chiropractors never have to put a patient’s pain in the category of the “mind.” They never fail to find a problem. By rooting pain in a clear physical cause, chiropractic validates the patient’s experience.
Chiropractic is in no sense passive; it is, from the start, engaged. Except when contraindicated (as in patients with neoplastic disease and those with extreme osteoporosis), some form of therapy is almost always indicated. For most symptoms, there is a suitable manipulation or a designated mode of redress.
From the first encounter on, chiropractors generate different expectations from conventional physicians. Because conventional practitioners assume that back pain, in the absence of systemic signs, is likely to be self-limited, it is not unusual for a patient to wait weeks for an appointment with a specialist or for a radiographic diagnostic assessment. Because a chiropractor believes that back pain is both explicable and amenable to treatment, a patient can usually obtain an appointment within 24 hours of a telephone call. The message of empathy, urgency, comprehension, and support conveyed by such a rapid response is reassuring and provides a heightened sense of care and compassion.
Chiropractic’s ultimate lesson may be to reinforce the principle that the patient-physician relationship is fundamentally about words and deeds of connection and compassion. Chiropractic has managed to embody this message in the gift of the hands.
Did the authors realize that they were writing a perfect description of quackery? Apparently not: in the fashion of duplicity-by-euphemism that is standard for quackademia, they refer to the overwhelming evidence that chiropractic is a pseudoscience as “contradictions and tensions [that] exist…between chiropractic and mainstream medicine.”
At some point during the nearly 20 years between the first and second Web, Kaptchuk seems to have begun to wonder if acupuncture and other offerings of ‘various healers’ act via “enhanced placebo effects.” Well, duh. But wait: for Kaptchuk, “placebo” doesn’t mean what it means to me or Mark Crislip or even to Peter Moran or Fabrizio Benedetti. For Kaptchuk, as we’ve already seen, placebo seems to mean something similar to what it means to Daniel Moerman. Placebo is “strong medicine”—maybe even stronger than “Western” medicine. When a trial of “EDTA Chelation Therapy for Coronary Artery Disease” was proposed at a 2000 meeting of the NCCAM Advisory Council,
Dr. Kaptchuk noted that they could find the equivalent of the placebo effect at work here, but both could be more beneficial than conventional therapies…The vote was 11 in favor, none opposed, and two abstentions, so the concept passed for funding.
Thus was spawned the most dangerous, unethical, and expensive boondoggle yet wrought by that August Body, paid for by you and me (Dr. Briggs, are you reading this? Are you, Dr. Nabel?).
Placebo Power and “Power Relationships”: a Postmodern Deconstruction of the RCT
Kaptchuk’s interest in the placebo seems to have arisen from his displeasure with modern medicine’s ‘privileged’ status, which had presented a barrier to establishing himself as a ‘doctor’ back in the USA. It must have been particularly rankling to take a back seat to the despised, reductionist paradigm, with its insistence on evidence from randomized, often placebo-controlled trials (RCTs). In the 2001 HMS conference to which I alluded at the end of the previous part of this series, Kaptchuk referred to the aforementioned “well, duh” attitude as an “accusation of placebo therapy,” and to “CAM” as a “domain for methodological doubt.” He based this on his suggestion that various “CAM” treatments may have “enhanced placebo effects,” effects that are even stronger than specific biomedical treatments. “Is a placebo effect,” he asked, “only a placebo?” He explains this further in an appendix to the 2000 edition of The Web:
Until about 1955, both East Asian medicine and biomedicine shared similar explicit standards for determining the acceptability of a medical intervention: legitimacy was determined by beneficial outcome. While physicians in both traditions also spoke of medicine based on ‘proven’ or ‘recognized’ principles, and inevitably were influenced by cultural assumptions, acceptable therapy was ultimately expected to deliver relief if not cure.¹
In the years after World War II, biomedicine underwent a dramatic shift. Major reforms were undertaken in medical research that sought to free therapeutic evaluations from human judgment based on clinical experience and impressions…The apparatus of the double-blind randomized controlled trial (RCT) gradually established itself as the ‘gold standard’ for determining legitimate therapy.
A major shift had occurred. A medical intervention was now scientifically justifiable only if it was superior to a placebo: method became more important than outcome. Superiority to placebo replaced ability to confirm health benefits as judgment criteria in medicine. Ideally, an acceptable treatment was now a relative outcome that could be isolated, disguised, and compared to the entire matrix of effects embodied in an identical healing ritual lacking this single ingredient.* Healing was no longer an absolute outcome that comprised multiple interactive dimensions. Biomedicine reconceptualized legitimate healing as “a cause and effect relationship between a specific agent or treatment and a specific biological result” [citation to 1998 article titled “Powerful Placebo: the dark side of the randomised controlled trial,” Kaptchuk characterizes the RCT as “self-authenticating”:
In a self-authenticating manner, the double-blind RCT became the instrument to prove its own self-created value system. This shift from emphasizing outcomes to the purity of the means directly parallels developments in medical ethics where ‘informed consent’ replaced ‘beneficence’ as the pinnacle of the value system.
(Hmmm? He offers no support for the last assertion). In that article he also asserts, with justification, that the premise for the placebo-controlled trial, as advanced by Beecher in 1955,
…took for granted that the active drug response results partly from a placebo effect and that the placebo effect buried in the active arm is identical to the placebo effect of the dummy treatment. The placebo was a single and stable ‘power’ that behaved in a consistent manner.
Kaptchuk, with reason, disagrees with that assumption. With less reason he calls for research to “disentangle the ‘non-specific’ and ‘art-of-medicine’ aspects of healing and therapeutic evaluation.”
In a 2001 article titled “The double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial: gold standard or golden calf?” Kaptchuk again characterizes the RCT as “authenticating itself.” He quotes the philosopher Ian Hacking:
The truth is what we find out in such and such a way. We recognize it as truth because of how we find it out. And how do we know that the method is good? Because it gets at the truth.
In that article Kaptchuk tries to make what might seem, at first glance, a good case for the RCT not being all it’s cracked up to be. He begins with a mildly surprising statement:
Until very recently, there was a widespread perception that the absence of the usual components of the masked RCT will “exaggerate estimates of treatment effects“…It was generally believed that identical treatments “are much less likely to be judged efficacious in double-blind, randomized trials than in uncontrolled case series or unblinded, ‘open’ comparisons with contemporaneous or historical series of patients.”
Yes, but there is still that widespread perception. This “discrepancy argument,” as Kaptchuk calls it, is the basis for the RCT’s sitting atop the Evidence-Based Medicine (EBM) evidence hierarchy, and if it weren’t true it would certainly throw the whole project into disarray. Kaptchuk appears to do exactly that by citing several reviews (here, here, here, here, and here, for example) that “make a compelling case that poor methodology could either overestimate or underestimate treatment effects” (emphasis added). He asserts that such findings have led to a “modified challenge to the discrepancy argument,” such that one study’s authors have argued that “research design should not be considered a rigid hierarchy.” He mentions that the editorial accompanying that and a similar study “has cast doubt on the validity of these conclusions,” without revealing the basis of that doubt; according to Kaptchuk, this shows that “The discrepancy debate has intensified.”
Reading Kaptchuk’s essay you might think, if you were unaware of the crescendo of EBM-chatter in the medical literature over the previous 10 years, that he had discovered a heretofore barely acknowledged, critical, even subversive (as he might put it) Truth about the nature of ‘evidence’ in modern medicine; a truth that would, among other things, liberate “CAM” from the ‘microfascism’ of EBM. Just at that point, however, Kaptchuk adds an afterthought:
In terms of blinding, recent comparative assessments remains [sic] consistent with the older evidence. Three studies showed that double-blind RCTs yielded significantly smaller treatment results than trials that were not double-blind. Also, three studies showed that successful concealment of randomization (compared with inadequate concealment of randomization) produces smaller treatment outcomes. Proper masking seems to create distinct outcomes; the discrepancy argument is intact in this domain.
In this domain? IN THIS DOMAIN? Excuse the yelling, but what “domain” was he talking about in the first place? In other words, after spending about 1000 words trying to convince us that “the usual components of the masked RCT” don’t do what we think they do, he off-handedly mentions that, er, the RCTs that he’d been talking about didn’t have those usual components; meaning, like, they weren’t masked. Which was exactly the point that the mysterious “accompanying editorial” had made.
The discrepancy debate has fizzled. And so, to the satisfaction of most observers, has the “self-authenticating” gambit.
Never mind: in that and other essays, Kaptchuk goes to great lengths to argue that masking, “investigator self-selection,” randomization, informed consent, and other standard research methods introduce “possible systematic errors intrinsic in even an ideal RCT” (in a term reminiscent of another current pseudoscience that closely resembles Quackademia, he dubs this process “irreducible uncertainty”). In this he is undoubtedly correct to an extent, but not to the extent that RCTs must be judged no more valid measures of efficacy than are less rigorous tests claiming larger treatment outcomes. Kaptchuk might protest that he does not explicitly make that claim, but I would respond that he certainly implies it, over and over again.
Kaptchuk is in the company of other influential academic “CAM” advocates, such as Andrew Weil, David Katz, Wayne Jonas, and Mehmet Oz, who’ve been making similar, special pleadings for years.
“The Need to Act a Little More ‘Scientific’ “
We’ve previously heard this from Kaptchuk:
When people became interested in alternative medicines, they asked me to help out at Harvard Medical School. I realized that in order to survive there, one had to become a scientist. So I became a scientist.
I won’t take Kaptchuk too much to task for the obvious faux pas in that statement, even though it is entirely consistent with everything that you’ve read above; he has cultivated a pseudo-bumbling, Columbo-like persona for the purposes of some public presentations, and he came of age during the 1960s, when it was fashionable to be utterly serious while pretending not to be (think: Bob Dylan). So it’s quite possible that he pursued science not merely to survive at Harvard Medical School, but because he hoped to learn something about nature—a ‘domain’ about which, as demonstrated by the first edition of The Web, he’d been quite naive. But did Kaptchuk become a scientist? He seems to have learned a fair amount about clinical trial design and probably a fair amount about frequentist statistical inference. Does that make someone a “scientist” these days? What about nature?
I’m doubtful. In addition to his difficulty in distinguishing science from cultural ‘narrative,’ Kaptchuk stumbles in other fundamental ways. In a 2003 article titled “Effect of interpretive bias on clinical research,” he offers this list:
Definitions of interpretation biases
Confirmation bias—evaluating evidence that supports one’s preconceptions differently from evidence that challenges these convictions
Rescue bias—discounting data by finding selective faults in the experiment
Auxiliary hypothesis bias—introducing ad hoc modifications to imply that an unanticipated finding would have been otherwise had the experimental conditions been different
Mechanism bias—being less sceptical when underlying science furnishes credibility for the data
“Time will tell” bias—the phenomenon that different scientists need different amounts of confirmatory evidence
Orintation bias—the possibility that the hypothesis itself introduces prejudices and errors and becomes a determinate of experimental outcome
Some of his discussion is perfectly reasonable; some is further conflation of science and cultural narrative; some is confusing and even contradictory; some is selective in a way that suggests an agenda:
Good science inevitably embodies a tension between the empiricism of concrete data and the rationalism of deeply held convictions. Unbiased interpretation of data is as important as performing rigorous experiments. This evaluative process is never totally objective or completely independent of scientists’ convictions or theoretical apparatus…
Well, which is it? How can unbiased interpretation be so important if it never happens?
Science demands a critical attitude, but it is difficult to know whether you have allowed for too much or too little scepticism. Also, where is the demarcation between the background necessary for making judgments (such as theoretical commitments and previous knowledge) and the scientific goal of being objective and free of preconceptions?…
Interpretation is never completely independent of a scientist’s beliefs, preconceptions, or theoretical commitments.
Again, which is it? Why propose a goal of being free of preconceptions if scientists always have preconceptions?
Evidence is more easily accepted when supported by accepted scientific mechanisms. This understandable tendency to be less sceptical when underlying science furnishes credibility can give rise to mechanism bias. Often, such scientific plausibility underlies and overlaps the other biases I’ve described. Many examples exist where with hindsight it is clear that plausibility caused systematic misinterpretation of evidence. For example, the early negative evidence for hormone replacement therapy would have undoubtedly been judged less cautiously if a biological rationale had not already created a strong expectation that oestrogens would benefit the cardiovascular system. Similarly, the rationale for antiarrhythmic drugs for myocardial infarction was so imbedded that each of three antiarrhythmic drugs had to be proved harmful individually before each trial could be terminated. And the link between Helicobacter pylori and peptic ulcer was rejected initially because the stomach was considered to be too acidic to support bacterial growth…
Let me explain. Kaptchuk is correct that unbiased interpretation can never happen, so it makes no sense for him to propose otherwise on the same page. Biased interpretation is inevitable, moreover, not merely for the mundane or mischievous reasons that Kaptchuk implies, but because it makes no sense to attempt “unbiased interpretation.” That was shown by Thomas Bayes more than 200 years ago.
Kaptchuk seems to know something about this: in the Comments section he writes, without further explanation, “the arguments presented are obviously compatible with a subjectivist or bayesian framework that formally incorporates previous beliefs in calculations of probability.” If he understands what Bayes demonstrated—that attempting to interpret the results of an experiment without regard to previous knowledge is logically incoherent—he withholds it from his readers, whom he has nevertheless presumed to be largely naive.
My view: if he understood the point when he wrote his treatise, he was dishonest in not explaining it and in not citing at least one pertinent article, such as Steven Goodman’s (which I’m willing to bet he had read). If he didn’t understand the point he should have withheld his paper.
Kaptchuk’s portrayal of interpretive bias being based on “beliefs, preconceptions, or theoretical commitments” implies that such bias is more about cultural assumptions and “power relationships” than about science. That, I believe, is his agenda: to suggest that such ‘commitments’ are likely to ‘privilege’ the status quo and to distract from the truth, thus casting enough doubt on the entire project to give at least a tentative free pass to, well, almost anything.
The reality of science is somewhat different: While it is undoubtedly true that an individual scientist’s biases often reflect personal wishes (not so much cultural assumptions), many of the biases of scientists are not only inevitable, but desirable. Kaptchuk’s discussion of “mechanism bias” is notable for its selection of examples that serve only to condemn such bias. A different sort of example would demonstrate an important truth about science, a truth that Kaptchuk either doesn’t understand or would prefer to conceal from his readers.
Such an example would be a ‘positive’ trial of a claim that, if deemed valid, would require discarding a firmly established principle of nature, such as the 2nd law of thermodynamics—a principle that is not merely a preconception or a “theoretical commitment,” but a fact based on data vastly more rigorous and voluminous than the entire body of biomedical literature. In such a case, not to invoke plausibility would (and has, many times) “cause systematic misinterpretation of evidence.”
The inverse of what Kaptchuk calls “this understandable tendency to be less sceptical when underlying science furnishes credibility” is “this understandable tendency to be more sceptical when underlying science furnishes no credibility,” which I would call “good science.” Does Kaptchuk even have a sense of what to look for in a hypothesis? Simplicity, conservatism, fruitfulness, and scope, for example?
Kaptchuk seems to believe his own hype: “method” is more important than science itself. I don’t think that he appreciates, or at least acknowledges, some of the fundamental aspects of science. I also suspect that he isn’t forthcoming about some of the things that he does know, if they don’t suit his agenda.
To be fair, I’ll report that Kaptchuk specifically denies, in the final paragraph of his “interpretive bias” paper, one of the accusations that I’ve made against him:
I do not mean to reduce science to a naive relativism or argue that all claims to knowledge are to be judged equally valid because of potential subjectivity in science. Recognition of an interpretative process does not contradict the fact that the pressure of additional unambiguous evidence acts as a self regulating mechanism that eventually corrects systematic error.
I can’t help but be reminded of another of Kaptchuk’s articles, quoted here a couple of years ago. Its abstract:
The advent of scientific research on complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) has contributed to the current state of flux regarding the distinction between biomedicine and CAM. CAM research scientists play a unique role in reconfiguring this boundary by virtue of their training in biomedical sciences on the one hand and knowledge of CAM on the other. This study uses qualitative interviews to explore how CAM researchers perceive and negotiate challenges inherent in their work. Our analysis considers eight NIH-funded CAM researchers’: (1) personal engagement with CAM, (2) social reactions towards perceived suspiciousness of research colleagues and (3) strategic methodological efforts to counteract perceived biases encountered during the peer review process. In response to peer suspicion, interviews showed CAM researchers adjusting their self-presentation style, highlighting their proximity to science, and carefully ‘self-censoring’ or reframing their unconventional beliefs. Because of what was experienced as peer reviewer bias, interviews showed CAM researchers making conciliatory efforts to adopt heightened methodological stringency. As CAM researchers navigate a broadening of biomedicine’s boundaries, while still needing to maintain the identity and research methods of a biomedical scientist, this article explores the constant pressure on CAM researchers to appear and act a little more ‘scientific’.
Placebo Research: a Critical Positive Impact on Health Care?
What about Kaptchuk having mostly (not entirely) abandoned his advocacy of the purported specific effects of highly implausible medical claims, in the last decade or so, in order to pursue his interest in their non-specific effects? Well, perhaps that has separated him from the rest of the quackpack, to an extent, and for that, some observers feel he deserves credit (Peter?). On the other hand he is no Fabrizio Benedetti, who can call quackery “quackery,” who insists that real, neurobiological placebo effects can’t be studied in clinical trials, not only because of regression to the mean and spontaneous remission, but because of biases introduced by both investigators and subjects (as was likely the case in Kaptchuk’s albuterol vs placebo for asthma trial that triggered this series), and who recognizes that any potential clinical applications beyond the obvious “caring for the patient” are apt to be elusive:
I use the placebo response as a model to understand how our brain works. I am not sure that in the future it will have a clinical application. This is a very important point—a translational research: can we use placebo in routine clinical practice? Well, sometimes it works; but that’s not the important problem. The important thing right now is to understand how our brain works. And I would say the placebo response is a fascinating phenomenon, because it is a sort of melting pot of concepts, of ideas for neuroscience. So, if you use a placebo response, you can understand a lot of brain functions, like anxiety, like social learning, classical conditioning, reward mechanisms, and so forth. So, the clinical application is—I think in English you say it is a ‘different kettle of fish.’
Kaptchuk, on the other hand, in keeping with his belief that the placebo is ‘strong medicine,’ argues that
Learning how to enhance medical outcomes via placebo research could have a critical positive impact on health care and scientific knowledge.
It takes only a bit of perspective to realize that learning how to enhance medical outcomes via placebo research, questionable in itself, is unlikely to have more than a minor impact on health care. That perspective consists of the state of health anywhere in the world prior to the advent of scientific medicine and public health. Kaptchuk, who cut his teeth on “Traditional Chinese Medicine,” might review, in William H. McNeill’s Plagues and Peoples, the appendix titled “Epidemics in China” (part of it can be found here). Does Kaptchuk really believe, or expect the occasional sophisticated reader of The Web to believe, that “biomedicine was adopted by Asian and African countries most often not because of medical outcomes but because of the prestige associated with the other developments of science”?
On Contradiction
For a preview of the final posting in this series, consider these statements:
In clinical practice a sham medical procedure would be fraudulent and deplorable; in research such activities can be legitimate, and this outlying research practice underscores the important ethical differences between clinical trials and medical care.
—Miller and Kaptchuk, “Sham procedures and the ethics of clinical trials“
…both traditional and sham acupuncture were shown to provide clinically significant improvement in back pain and function, as compared with either no treatment or usual medical care, suggesting that the benefit from acupuncture probably derives from the placebo effect. Although this alternative standard for evidence-based validation deserves critical scrutiny and serious debate, we believe that it reflects a more patient-centered perspective for symptomatic treatment. Patients who have continuing pain are interested in pain relief; they are unlikely to care whether this derives from the inherent ability of a treatment to modify pathophysiology or its propensity to promote a significant placebo response.
—Miller and Kaptchuk, letter to the New England Journal of Medicine following the report discussed here, here, and here.

Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.3: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (concluded)
Kimball Atwood on November 11, 2011
Link
A Loose End
In the last post I wondered if Ted Kaptchuk, when he wrote the article titled “Effect of interpretive bias on clinical research,” had understood this implication of Bayes’s Theorem: that interpretations of most scientific investigations are exercises in inverse probability, and thus cannot logically be done without consideration of knowledge external to the investigation in question. I argued that if Kaptchuk had
…understood the point when he wrote his treatise, he was dishonest in not explaining it and in not citing at least one pertinent article, such as Steven Goodman’s (which I’m willing to bet he had read). If he didn’t understand the point he should have withheld his paper.
In researching more of Kaptchuk’s opinions I’ve discovered that he had certainly read Goodman’s article, but that he either didn’t understand it or preferred to obscure its implications in deference to his ongoing project in belittling scientific knowledge. In a letter to the editor of the Annals of Internal Medicine in 2001, Kaptchuk opined that even if “more trials of distant healing with increased methodologic rigor” were positive, it still would not “be persuasive for the medical community”:
The situation resembles the predicament with homeopathy trials, another seemingly implausible intervention, where the evidence of multiple positive randomized, controlled trials will not convince the medical community of its validity. Additional positive trials of distant healing are only likely to further expose the fact that the underpinning of modern medicine is an unstable balance between British empiricism (in the tradition of Hume) and continental rationalism (in the tradition of Kant).
…It seems that the decision concerning acceptance of evidence (either in medicine or religion) ultimately reflects the beliefs of the person that exist before all arguments and observation. [Kaptchuk cites the second of the two Goodman articles that I referred to above, discussed here]
There may be an unstable balance in medical academia, but it isn’t between Hume and Kant; it’s between those who mistakenly believe that deductive inference is the same as inductive inference and those who don’t. Kaptchuk would seem to prefer that his “unstable balance”—“this predicament of an ultimate clash between epistemological knowing and ontological knowing”—persist, in order to make absurdities such as homeopathy and distant healing appear merely controversial. He is dead wrong to suggest that informed estimates of prior probability, based on science, are equivalent to religious beliefs “that exist before all arguments and observation.” Whether that suggestion reflects a displeasure with the “privileging” of science or mere ignorance is a mystery.
Regarding Hume, Kaptchuk—his pedantry notwithstanding—did, perhaps inadvertently, call attention to a valid point: Hume’s Maxim, a variation of “extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence,” can be thought of as a qualitative version of the theorem of Hume’s contemporary Thomas Bayes. The application of either of those precepts shows rather handily that either homeopathy or distant healing would be a far greater miracle than the ‘miracle’ of a rigorous-but-erroneous clinical trial.
Kaptchukian Dialectics: Teaching the Controversy
At the end of the last post, we saw Kaptchuk assert that
In clinical practice a sham medical procedure would be fraudulent and deplorable.
We also saw him acknowledge that for one trial,
…both traditional and sham acupuncture were shown to provide clinically significant improvement in back pain and function, as compared with either no treatment or usual medical care, suggesting that the benefit from acupuncture probably derives from the placebo effect.
There have been enough such trials for Kaptchuk to realize that all apparent benefits from “traditional” acupuncture—which he practiced for years—are similar to those from sham acupuncture, and thus probably derive from the placebo effect. Does he now believe that his own practice was fraudulent and deplorable?
It seems unlikely. Kaptchuk’s entire career has been based on his repeated claim that Chinese medicine (including acupuncture) is
a coherent and independent system of thought and practice that has been developed over two millennia. Based on ancient texts, it is the result of a continuous process of critical thinking, as well as extensive clinical observation and testing. It represents a thorough formulation and reformulation of material by respected clinicians and theoreticians…
It is now evident that Chinese medicine is an effective healing method.
Moreover, Kaptchuk has also argued in favor of the very practice that he called “fraudulent and deplorable”:
Although this alternative standard for evidence-based validation deserves critical scrutiny and serious debate, we believe that it reflects a more patient-centered perspective for symptomatic treatment.
We’ve previously seen numerous other examples of Kaptchuk contradicting himself. As suggested here (scroll to “From Campus Radical to AltMed Superstar”), this may have more to do with intent than with sloppy thinking. Former Columbia SDS Chairman Kaptchuk seems still to revel in that mish-mash of Hegelian dialectics and Marxist-Leninist-Maoist thinking, with its stress on “The law of contradiction in things,” that was in vogue among campus radicals of the 1960s. In the 2000 edition of The Web, he writes:
In the nineteenth century, Hegel finally confronted and denied Aristotle’s law of contradiction and developed the theory that has come to be known as Hegelian dialectics. For Hegel, the intricacies of relationship override the Aristotelian concern that A not be confused with not A. A can, in fact, be other than A, depending on its place in an overall schema. These ideas are so similar to those of Chinese philosophy that Hegelian and Chinese thought have often been compared.
In the introduction to that edition of The Web, Kaptchuk offers a (pretentious) celebration of contradiction that seems consistent with many of the passages previously quoted in this series:
In updating and writing this second edition, I’ve had to contend with the contradiction between a Talmudic intellect and a Hasidic soul. I have grown acutely aware that East Asian medicine is a huge ocean of texts and interpretations. Any assertion is automatically a complex problematic and an opportunity for contending understandings. My hermeneutic tendency would have liked to pursue the paradoxical knowledge produced by irreducible uncertainty.
Yup: Teach the Controversy. OK, the quip is unfair in a sense (we don’t know where Kaptchuk stands on the evolution vs. “intelligent design” pseudo-controversy), but it is entirely fair regarding scientific pseudo-controversies in general: Assertions in East Asian medicine are not automatically “complex problematics.” Most are straightforward questions of fact or myth, and most of those are readily identified as myths. “Contending understandings” seems not only pleasing to Kaptchuk’s hermeneutic tendencies, but has been the key to his maintaining an academic career built on sand.
Shilling for Toxic Chinese Herbs
In the first edition of The Web, Kaptchuk had made the unsupported assertions that “Chinese remedies…are always gentler and safer [than Western ones]” and they “do not produce side effects.” In 1987 he made a similar claim to Vegetarian Times, this time with minor caveats:
 
Kaptchuk had apparently already decided that he was that someone: by 1986 he had begun shilling for East Earth Herb and in 1999 for Kan Herbals, a gig that he still, apparently, has. Such arrangements have provided him an opportunity to celebrate his poetic passion for ‘contending understandings’ in a way that is both cloying and, presumably, lucrative:
Our Western health care system can greatly benefit from Eastern practices, but this knowledge needs to be sensitively transmitted and applied. Systems of healing always reflect the collective dilemma of human beings and their strivings for intactness and authenticity in the context of their communities and cultures. Medicine is universal, yet is simultaneously shaped by its environs.
In developing these products I have tried to remain aware of the tension between East and West, old and new, preservation and growth, accuracy and adaptation. These products are, and will continue to be, the outgrowth of an immersion in classical Chinese herbal texts, along with an attentiveness to the energies and concerns of Western customers. The intention is to be faithful to China’s ancient herbal wisdom, while conscious of the contemporary clinical needs of Westerners.
These Kan Herbals formulations approach Oriental medicine in the most encompassing sense. Traditional Chinese medicine’s primary concern, its self-definition, lies in attempting to bring harmony to the whole human being…
If you want to delve into Kaptchuk’s herbal offerings in esoteric detail, look here. Unfortunately, two of the products that Kaptchuk pitched had to be recalled in 2000 because they contained a dangerous toxin, aristolochic acid. This is from the FDA recall notice:
EUGENE, OR (November 21, 2000) – East Earth Herb, Inc. is recalling Jade Pharmacy brand Meridian Circulation tablets and liquid extract and Jade Pharmacy brand Quell Fire tablets because they may present a serious health hazard to consumers. The products contain aristolochic acid. Aristolochic acid is a potent carcinogen and nephrotoxin found in certain plants and botanicals. This chemical can cause serious kidney damage and the use of products that contain aristolochic acid has been associated with several occurrences of kidney failure. The use of aristolochic acid containing products has been linked to increased risk of kidney cancer in people who have consumed it.
Jade Pharmacy brand Meridian Circulation, and Jade Pharmacy brand Quell Fire were distributed throughout the United States through licensed health practitioners.
Oh, the disharmony! In the 2000 edition of The Web, Kaptchuk finally admits that Chinese herbs have greater risks than he’d previously granted, including inherent toxicities, contamination with heavy metals and other toxins, and adulteration with synthetic drugs. He begins his description of the aristolochic acid debacle by suggesting that it had been a problem of “interaction with Western drugs” (my emphasis):
The most serious incident of a Chinese herbal iatrogenic effect reported in the biomedical literature first seemed to be due to an interaction between herbs and drugs in a combined drug/herbal product once used in a weight reduction clinic in Belgium. This mixture was prescribed by Western physicians with no training in Chinese medicine. At least 100 women developed interstitial renal fibrosis with terminal or preterminal renal failure. The epidemiology of this tragic incident is still unclear and confusing. One possibility is that a Western drug in the slimming pill cocktail may have [interacted with a Chinese herb], and increased the slight toxicity that already existed in the herb and drug individually…
He ends it this way:
Further complicating the picture, a subsequent report of serious nephropathy associated with Chinese herbs containing aristolochic acids (identification of the exact herb is confusing) raises the distinct possibility that this tragic event should be classified as a toxicity incident and not a herb-drug interaction.
Uh, no kidding. By then there was plenty of evidence both for that “distinct possibility” and for aristolochic acid causing cancer. Kaptchuk didn’t mention, in the 2000 Web, that he’d been working for a Chinese herb company. Nor has he typically disclosed that arrangement in his articles for medical journals; the only exception that I’ve noticed is his 2002 article on acupuncture for the Annals of Internal Medicine. In 2007, Kaptchuk finally acknowledged, in an open letter titled “The Quality Control Crisis in China and Our Profession,” common pitfalls of crude botanical preparations (from China or anywhere else) that have been evident for decades, and that are an inevitable result of, well, how those preparations are prepared. What took him so long, and why should consumers have been led to believe, by Harvard Medical School, the NIH, and other presumed authorities, that his previous opinions had been trustworthy?
The Complex Problematic of Kaptchuk’s Degree
At the beginning of this series I explained that “Dummy Doctors” in the title refers to anthropologist Daniel Moerman and Ted Kaptchuk. Moerman has earned that designation, although he has a PhD, because in his New England Journal of Medicine editorial and elsewhere he has displayed his ignorance of modern medicine and science. Kaptchuk has earned it for a more fundamental reason: he appears to have no doctorate, period. For years, Kaptchuk put “OMD” after his name and was called “doctor” and “Dr. Kaptchuk,” and was said to have a “doctorate“; he had purportedly “earned his doctorate in Oriental Medicine from the Macau Institute of Chinese Medicine in 1975,” as stated on the back cover of the 2000 edition of The Web:
In 2009 I explained the reasons for doubting that assertion, to the extent that we knew them at the time:
[In 2002 or 2003] the late Bob Imrie observed that it was curious, in this era of the World Wide Web, that if you Google the “Macao Institute of Chinese Medicine” you get, well, nothing—other than it being named as the alma mater of two American “CAM” enthusiasts. One of them is Ted Kaptchuk, ‘OMD,’ who has long been Dr. Eisenberg’s second in command of “CAM” at HMS. When I first heard this I didn’t think much about it. My reply to Imrie was something like, “what difference does it make? It’s bogus whether it’s bogus or not, because the entire field is bogus.”
Shortly thereafter I realized that there is an obvious, additional ethical problem with portraying oneself as having earned a degree from an institution that most people would assume had been endorsed by some appropriate body, if such is not the case. At the time I was the chairman of the Committee for the Quality of Medical Practice at the Massachusetts Medical Society, and using that title I wrote to the Macao government asking about the Macao Institute of Chinese (or “Traditional Chinese”) Medicine. Here was the reply (emphasis in the original):
Sent: Tuesday, October 07, 2003 12:41 AM
Subject: Reply to the inquiry about “Macao Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine ”
Dear Chairman Kimball C. Atwood,
Thank you very much for your e-mail dated 18th Sept (we received it from Government Information Bureau on 6th Oct.). In reply to your inquiry, we would like to inform you that ¡§Macao Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine¡¨ HAS NOT BEEN one of the higher education institutions in Macao, and the concerned Institute hence HAS NOT BEEN a degree-conferring academic institution.
If there is anything additional you would like to know, please feel free to contact us:
Telephone: 853-3969316
Facsimile: 853-318401
Address: Calçada de Sto. Agostinho. No 19, Edf. Nam Yue, 13o a 15o Andares, Macau
E-mail: [email protected]
With Best Regards Higher Education Bureau Macao SAR
I realize that this does not settle the matter. It is quite possible that in the 30+ years since Kaptchuk reports having attended the Institute, governmental memory has faded or has become selective. That is all the more possible because Macao, like Hong Kong, was ‘handed over’ from its colonial ruler (Portugal, in Macao’s case) to China on the eve of the 21st century. Nevertheless, there are more reasons to think otherwise. One of my correspondents had traveled to Macau prior to the hand-over and was unable to find any record of the MICM in various libraries and pertinent governmental offices. The [World Wide] Web continues to lack any corroborating evidence of such an institute, although there ought to have been many students there from all over the world: according to the two Americans, the school was a magnet for ‘overseas Chinese.’ Other attempts by Dr. Bartecchi and me to get information—from HMS (see below), from the Massachusetts and California Acupuncture Boards, and from Dan Bensky, the other American who reports having attended the MICM—have been frustrated.
Dr. Bensky’s online CV, however, raises more disturbing questions. He calls his diploma from Macao a “Diploma in Chinese Medicine,” suggesting that the ‘D’ in ‘OMD’ stands for ‘Diploma’, not for ‘Doctor’—as Kaptchuk has represented it (Bensky can call himself ‘doctor’ in any case, because he subsequently completed the osteopathy program at Michigan State University). Bensky reports having attended MICM with Kaptchuk, and that it took two years to complete. Bensky did not have a bachelor’s degree when he began at Macau. Currently, a doctoral candidate at the Chengdu University of Traditional Chinese Medicine must be a college graduate, and the course of study requires three years.
Bensky also reports that at Macao there were “three main teachers…although in the end, one of the teachers refused to allow Westerners to participate in her clinic.” And: “after graduation…as I was identified with the school, no one else in Macau would work with me.” This hardly suggests an ‘Institute’ or a course of study with externally recognized standards.
According to this report, a couple of years ago at the nomenclature conference of the A.A.O.M. (either ‘American Association of Oriental Medicine’ or ‘Association of Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine’—I’m not sure which)
Dr. Benksy dismissed the long-term expert consensus described in Marnae Ergil’s excellent paper on translation principles as simply “wrong.”
An interested observer, suggesting that Bensky’s credentials might be relevant to evaluating his opinion, responded with this:
Both Dan Bensky and Ted Kaptchuk hold degrees from The Macau Institute of Chinese Medicine. According to Dan in that very discussion on CHA to which Bob makes reference, the school came into existence shortly before he and Ted arrived in 1973 and went out of existence shortly after they left in 1975 with their degrees. Or were they diplomas? Or were they doctorates? What is written on those pieces of paper? This was the question I posed in the post that preceded my being banned from CHA. The notion of being “qualified by expertise and training to establish such standards” (of academic freedom) suggests that training standards themselves are of nontrivial importance in the whole matter of academic freedom. Of course they are. And of course it matters whether the word “diploma” or the word “doctorate” is written on the pieces of paper that Dan and Ted took home with them when their respective sojourns in Macau had come to an end. What does the “D” stand for in the “OMD” that appears after the names Bensky and Kaptchuk? Socrates said that to use words wrongly is not only a fault itself, it also corrupts the soul. Certainly it corrupts the use of words to use highly meaningful terms (including their abbreviations) like “diploma” and “doctorate” interchangeably. If one is qualified by expertise and training to establish standards of academic freedom, then we had better at least know with as much certainty as possible what the basis of one’s qualifications actually is…
Are Bensky and Kaptchuk the MICM’s only graduates? In 2003 I queried some of the faculty at HMS who were affiliated with Eisenberg and Kaptchuk. I sent them the message from the Macao Higher Education Bureau. They agreed that it would be ‘disturbing’ if Kaptchuk’s degree were anything but legitimate. After all, he had parlayed it into his entire academic career, including not only his appointment at HMS (where he now appears to be an Associate Professor), but numerous articles in the Annals of Internal Medicine, the British Medical Journal, JAMA, and other journals. He used it to become a licensed health care practitioner in Massachusetts and probably elsewhere. He also used it to gain public roles that some would consider prestigious, such as his long membership on the NCCAM Advisory Council. He has been referred to as “Doctor” in all of those contexts.
About two weeks after I sent the inquiry to HMS, I got this reply from my old fellow intern, Russell Phillips:
Kim-I researched Ted’s background and am convinced that the credentials he lists on his CV, including his doctorate, are correct. When this came up previously he put together a packet of his diplomas etc that confirm his degree. Additionally, several state licensing boards have given him a license to practice acupuncture after researching his background. The Dean’s office (Dan Federman) has also looked into this and is convinced his credentials are correct. Please let me know if you want to discuss further. Russ
I believe that this reply merely begged the question. The several state licensing boards almost certainly did not research his background, which would have been an impossible task for them. I don’t think that HMS or any of the individuals who looked at the ‘credentials’ had either the will or the competence to investigate them thoroughly and skeptically. It is intriguing that in the past few years Kaptchuk’s ‘OMD’ has disappeared from certain contexts, including at HMS: compare this and this, for example.
I reiterate that I don’t know the answer to this question. There is enough doubt about Kaptchuk’s ‘OMD’ degree, however, to put the onus on him, on HMS, and on the other interested entities to produce the evidence. It should then be evaluated by a disinterested, competent investigator.
Well, by 2004 we had verified what should have been obvious to Harvard, that the California board had not “researched his background.” Marilyn Nielson, the Executive Officer of the CA Acupuncture Board, wrote this in an email to Carl Bartecchi, MD:
The Board cannot attest to the status of the Macau Institute of Chinese Medicine @ 31 Rua Sacadura Cabral, Macau, China, or the Macau Overseas Chinese Association’s Chinese Medicine Clinic @ 31A Rua Sacadura Cabral, Macau, China.
Now we know more: fellow blogger Ben Kavoussi read my 2009 post and wrote the CA acupuncture board in another attempt to get information. This time it worked. We now know what is written on those pieces of paper, posted here and here:
 
What is on those pieces of paper, whether written by his apparent mentors or by Kaptchuk himself, is “diploma”—not “doctor” or “doctorate” or even “degree.” To be certain that the Chinese version could not be construed as implying a doctorate of some sort, even though Kaptchuk appears to have been satisfied with the translation that he submitted to the CA board, Ben K. asked a Chinese graduate student to look at all of the documents. Here is his response:
Hi Ben, I’ve read through the documents in Chinese. There is not a single phrase mentioning an official title of any sort awarded. So no Physician of Traditional Chinese Medicine referred to him in any of the documents.
The case is compelling that Kaptchuk’s “OMD” never existed—with the obligatory caveat that it’s just possible, however unlikely, that some missing piece of information could change this conclusion.
Veritas
Whither Harvard Medical School? I don’t pretend to know why that institution—my alma mater, it saddens me to say—has insisted on keeping its collective heads buried in the sand, in spite of repeated, initially discrete attempts by Carl Bartecchi, me, and possibly others to alert it to its own folly. I do know that the entire HMS “CAM” project has been rotten-to-the-core since its inception, as documented in excruciating detail in the links at the bottom of this post and elsewhere (here and here, for example). There is evidence that HMS was aware of Kaptchuk’s non-degree, or at least of its likelihood. According to an anonymous source, when Kaptchuk was being vetted for tenure a few years ago HMS asked him to stop using “OMD”—thus explaining why he no longer uses it in most contexts.
If anything comes of this “outing” of Kaptchuk’s non-degree, it should be a thorough investigation of that project (I’ve already done the bulk of the work, so how hard could it be?), culminating in its abolition—not, as is more likely, a mere scapegoating of Kaptchuk himself. The latter course would merely carry on the hypocrisy as usual.
Here’s a prime example. In response to Carl Bartecchi’s 2002 letter to Dean Daniel Federman, in which Dr. Bartecchi wrote, “I long for the day when they label something ‘quackery’,” HMS “CAM” director David Eisenberg wrote, “I share with Dr. Bartecchi a disdain for any practice which intentionally deceives and manipulates a patient in any circumstance.” Eisenberg then wrote that he regularly gives
a didactic presentation entitled ‘Advising patients who seek complementary and alternative medicine’. In this lecture I include a summary of the article by Beyerstein from the Academic Medicine 2001 series on CAM which provides sensible advice in terms of avoiding complementary and alternative medicine practitioners who meet certain criteria consistent with definitions of ‘quackery’.
This series has shown that Kaptchuk meets nearly all of those criteria. (Dr. Eisenberg: I worked with Barry Beyerstein; I knew Barry Beyerstein; Barry Beyerstein was a friend of mine. Doctor, you’re no Barry Beyerstein). Such hypocrisy continues today. The Osher Clinical Center For Complementary and Integrative Medical Therapies, one of Eisenberg’s proudest achievements, is a font of misinformation about acupuncture and other methods. Kaptchuk himself still claims “a degree in Chinese medicine from the Macao Institute of Chinese Medicine,” which is every bit as ethereal as the OMD that he no longer uses.
Another predictable response to revelations of phony degrees is that some people will inevitably defend the perp by arguing that his “mistake” notwithstanding, he is very good at what he does (note to HMS: this never works, as that recent example shows). One of the reasons that I wrote such a long series on Kaptchuk and his writings has been to demonstrate that his views are not really scientific; rather, they are postmodern and consistent with his having invented a ‘degree,’ which he might think of as “a linguistic tool to control medical knowledge.” Nor are his views compatible with what a science-based medical school should look for in a professor. As I suggested regarding the reviewers of The Web, I doubt that anyone who matters, among the HMS faculty, has much familiarity with what Kaptchuk writes. Whatever credibility some might grant him for his placebo articles, moreover, is necessarily lost in the face of his phony degree.
Other Ramifications
As embarrassing as this revelation is to HMS, it is worse in other contexts. Several medical journals will have to consider how to react (haven’t those journals already wondered why Kaptchuk no longer uses “OMD”?): the fake cardiologist of the “recent example” mentioned above, William Hamman, has had at least one journal article retracted. Past and pending co-authors will have a lot to think about. The NCCAM and the FDA will have to consider how to react to past committee appointments based on a misrepresented degree, and the NIH will have to react to a grant awardee whose credentials are, even now, misrepresented. Are there legal ramifications? If so, I can only hope that Harvard Medical School will step up, rather than let Kaptchuk hang out to dry by himself. As much as I object to Kaptchuk’s own duplicity, the roles of HMS and its unctuous “CAM” program are the larger issues here.
…
The Dummy Series:
     1.  Dummy Medicines, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 1: a Curious Editorial Choice for the New England Journal of Medicine
     2.  Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.0: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD
     3.  Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.1: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (cont.)
     4.  Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.2: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (cont. again)
     5.  Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.3: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (concluded)
 …
The Harvard Medical School series:
     1.  Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part I)
     2.  Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part II)
     3.  Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part III)
     4.  Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part IV)
     5.  Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part V)
     6.  Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part VI)
     7.  Dummy Medicines, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 1: a Curious Editorial Choice for the New England Journal of Medicine
     8.  Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.0: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD
     9.  Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.1: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (cont.)
     10.  Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.2: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (cont. again)
     11.  Dummy Medicine, Dummy Doctors, and a Dummy Degree, Part 2.3: Harvard Medical School and the Curious Case of Ted Kaptchuk, OMD (concluded)

Milestones on the path to integrating quackery with medicine
The “integration” of quackery with real medicine occurring in academia and now private hospitals and practices didn’t occur overnight. It began decades ago. Here, we examine what an advocate of “integrative medicine” views as key milestones on the path towards adding pseudoscience and quackery to your medicine.
David Gorski on November 21, 2016
Link

It’s been a long time since I’ve encountered Glenn Sabin. You might remember him, though. He runs a consulting firm, FON Therapeutics, which is dedicated to the promotion of “integrative” health, or, as I like to put it, the “integration of pseudoscience and quackery with science-based medicine. What I remember most about Sabin is how he once proclaimed that “integrative medicine” was a brand, not a specialty. Unfortunately, he was correct in his assessment. Basically, he declared, “CAM [complementary and alternative medicine] is dead. The evolution of evidence-based, personalized integrative medicine, and its implementation in clinic, lives on.” The reason CAM was being killed by its advocates was, of course, because the term CAM contains the word “alternative” in it, and that was a barrier to mainstream acceptance. It didn’t bother Sabin one whit that there’s a lot of unscientific and unproven quackery in the CAM that has mostly become integrative medicine:
It’s true that not all stress reduction techniques, say, Reiki, boast a solid evidence base. But many clinicians who offer services like Reiki do so because they’ve observed it helping many of their patients to relax, thus lessening their need for certain medications. They rationalize that since the intervention is not potentially harmful and their patient is more relaxed and reporting beneficial value, then what difference does it really make if we don’t yet know exactly how it works?
To him, “integrative” health and medicine were the future, mainly because the connotation is much more favorable. To paraphrase how I put it at the time, no longer were CAM practitioners content to have their favorite quackery be “complementary” to real medicine. After all, “complementary” implied a subsidiary position. Medicine was the cake, and their nostrums were just the icing, and that wasn’t anywhere good enough. Those promoting CAM craved respect. They wanted to be co-equals with physicians and science- and evidence-based medicine. The term “integrative medicine” served their purpose perfectly. No longer were their treatments merely “complementary” to real medicine. Oh, no. Now they were “integrating” their treatments with those of science- and evidence-based medicine! The implication, the very, very, very intentional implication, was that alternative medicine was co-equal to science- and evidence-based medicine, an equal partner in the “integrating.”
Unfortunately, that brand has spread and metastasized far beyond what anyone could have imagined even just 10 years ago. Such were my thoughts when I received an e-mail from FON Therapeutics (whose e-mail list I’m still on) touting an e-book by Glenn Sabin and Taylor Walsh entitled The Rise of Integrative Health and Medicine: 1963 to the Present. My curiosity was piqued, given the source, which is about as pro-CAM, pro-”integrative” medicine as you can possibly get outside of John Weeks. I wanted to see what, exactly, Mr. Sabin viewed as the most important milestones in the acceptance of integrative medicine have been over the last 53 years. And what do you know? John Weeks even makes an appearance in the introduction.
Unfortunately, to download the e-book, you have to provide your name and e-mail address, and then FON Therapeutics sends you a link. I understand if many of you might be reluctant to do that (although if you’re really interested there are so many free e-mail services that it’s easy to make a throwaway account just for this purpose). So I took the bullet so that you don’t have to.
First, a word from our sponsor…
The first thing I noted upon reading this e-book was a big ad right after the copyright and publisher page for XYMOGEN supplements, in particular its “ePedigree Verified” (ePV) system designed to ensure only “registered” practitioners were selling its products over the Internet, bragging on its website:
We are the only nutraceutical company that is truly exclusive, and this exclusivity extends to you. We want to make sure you are the only source of XYMOGEN formulas for your patients. This allows you to better track their progress, ensure compliance, and foster relationships.
Well, alrighty then. I guess that this is just XYMOGEN’s way of bragging that its detoxification, cell-life regulation, immune system support, adrenal support, and whatever other support you can think of supplements are better than every other company’s detoxification, cell-life regulation, immune system support, adrenal support, and whatever other support you can think of supplements. Of course, registering with XYMOGEN just requires filling out a web form or paper form, providing a credit card number, and signing a contract and agreeing to terms like this if you want to sell XYMOGEN products online:
…please refer to the No Internet Sales Policy, which supplies an outline of XYMOGEN’s requests for conducting business online. Our primary concerns are that there are no prices listed, no discounts offered, no referral code disclosures, and that the only means by which the general public can purchase our formulas online is through a licensed healthcare practitioner.
Ah, yes. No discounts.
Enter John Weeks
So this is the nature of the sponsor of this e-book. What does our good old buddy John Weeks have to say? To be honest, I didn’t expect to be discussing anything related to Mr. Weeks again so soon, particularly after he accused Steve Novella, Edzard Ernst, Michael Vagg, and I of “polarization-based medicine” and compared us to Donald Trump, not once but twice. The first time around, Weeks, a well-known activist in favor of “integrating” pseudoscience into medicine in the form of “integrative medicine” who has featured in this blog from time to time, was incensed at our criticism of a shoddily executed systematic review of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or “integrative medicine” approaches to pain from the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) which was roundly criticized by Dr. Novella, Dr. Vagg, Professor Ernst, and myself. Basically, Mr. Weeks abused his position as the newly-hired editor of the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine (JACM) in order to attack critics of the NCCIH review in near-apocalyptic terms, while trying to paint himself as the voice of “moderation.”
The second time around, he did it again, this time on what I like to half-jokingly refer to as the “wretched hive of scum and quackery,” The Huffington Post, he attacked Juliana LeMieux of the American Council for Science and Health and us again for having criticized a commentary article in JAMA by Jennifer Abbasi entitled “As Opioid Epidemic Rages, Complementary Health Approaches to Pain Gain Traction” that basically accepted the NCCIH review at face value. LeMieux referred to JAMA as the “journal of medical atrocities,” which actually makes me look a bit tame by comparison. (I might have to up my game.) Now, regular readers know that I’m not exactly a big fan of the ACSH. I view it as too sympathetic to industry interests, particularly pesticide manufacturers as evidenced by its repetition of typical anti-environmentalist smears against Rachel Carson and remarks by its founder dismissing concerns about potentially toxic chemicals, especially pesticides, as “chemophobia,” which she characterized as an “emotional, psychiatric problem.” However, as much as I tended to distrust ACSH, I do have to admit that it’s gotten somewhat less blatant in supporting corporate interests since Hank Campbell took over, which is perhaps why it irritates me a lot less than before. This time around, Dr. LeMieux and I are pretty much in agreement.
Mr. Weeks begins by asking:
At what point can an emergent movement look back and claim a history? And what is that history if, over the course of the time chronicled, separate strands have knit together into a whole that was unimagined at the outset? Do the lineages of each become the shared ancestry of what is emerging?
These questions face anyone who chooses to look back on the evolution of what many of us now call the “movement for integrative health and medicine.” What’s in? What’s out? What stories will rise to frequent retelling in this melded family history? Which will be hushed up or edited down?
The first of the 120 notable achievements in this timeline from Glenn Sabin and Taylor Walsh begins, appropriately, in the ’60s. East met West. Back to nature. Whole foods. Rise of the feminine. Whole systems. That one herb that made us think about the power of others. Environmentalism. Globalism. Social justice.
I can’t help but guess that one thing that will be hushed up and edited down (that has been hushed up and edited down since the dawn of integrating quackery into medicine) is, in fact, the rank pseudoscience inherent in so many CAM—excuse me, integrative medicine—modalities: reiki, acupuncture, the rest of traditional Chinese medicine, reflexology, naturopathy, homeopathy, applied kinesiology, high dose vitamin C for cancer, and many many more. On the other hand, I can’t help but agree that part of the impetus for what is now “integrative medicine” probably does lie back in the 1960s, although I would quibble and say that it really should go back to the late 1940s and early 1950s when, in the wake of World War II, Chairman Mao Zedong found himself unable to provide science-based medicine for his people. So he instead retconned the history of the many strains of Chinese folk medicine to create something called “traditional Chinese medicine” (TCM) and proceeded to show people like Weeks and Sabin the way in terms of “integrating” TCM with “Western” medicine. Indeed, I’ll repost some Chinese party slogans about TCM that Dr. Kimball Atwood wrote about years ago about TCM and Mao’s role in promoting it to the West:
1945-50: ‘The Co-operation of Chinese and Western Medicines’
1950-58: ‘The Unification of Chinese and Western Medicines’
1950-53: ‘Chinese Medicine studies Western Medicine’
1954-58: ‘Western Medicine studies Chinese Medicine’
1958 on: ‘The Integration of Chinese and Western Medicines’
Sounds eerily prescient now, doesn’t it? I’d argue that the last 25 years have been the fulfilment of the last two slogans. No wonder Weeks and Sabin don’t go 10 or 15 years further back in time. This is exactly the sort of thing that’s been hushed up and edited down by proponents of integrative medicine.
Oh, and Chairman Mao didn’t believe in TCM. He preferred “Western” medicine.
Weeks goes on to note that in the 1970s, things started to percolate more. There were the births of societies for “holistic” doctors and nurses. There was the first new naturopathy school in decades. Other events in the late 1970s included the first herb industry association and a national organization for acupuncturists. Weeks notes:
In Washington, DC, during a 1979 congressional briefing, the internationally honored futurist, Clement Bezold, PhD—who 20 years later would become a player in the integrative care movement—had his finger on the pulse. He told the assembled elected officials and their staff that there was a trend taking shape. He called it “alternative medicine.”
In reality, “alternative medicine” is a newer term than most think. It really didn’t gain credence until the 1970s. Before that, what was to become known as alternative medicine was routinely referred to as folk medicine (if the person writing was charitable) or quackery or health fraud (more commonly). I like to remind people of a commentary published in the New England Journal of Medicine by Clark Glymour and Douglas Stalker, “Engineers, cranks, physicians, magicians,” in which “holistic medicine” (which appeared to be used interchangeably with “alternative medicine”) was dismissed as a “pabulum of common sense and nonsense offered by cranks, quacks, and failed pedants who share an attachment to magic and an animosity toward reason” and concluding that it “does no good to join forces with cranks and quacks, magicians and madmen.”
Unfortunately, Weeks is not entirely wrong (although his presentation is very biased) when he notes:
We can, with confidence, now point to distinct eras. Work in silos, following the emergence from the stew. Fifteen years later, the shock to regular medicine and other mainstream stakeholders from a 1993 publication out of Harvard showing widespread patient use and billions spent. The quick synthesis in the invention of “integrative medicine.” Then, just after the century turned, the birth of multiple collaborations and consortia to power up the new potential. Inclusion in a series of Institute of Medicine reports. Key provisions—including a call for “non-discrimination”— in the Affordable Care Act. Barriers between disciplines lowering.
Now with this maturation, we see a potential convergence for these carriers of whole system, patient-centered, conservative care. They increasingly come together with the medical industry’s efforts to form delivery and payment methods that focus on what former Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services administrator Donald Berwick, MD, MPH learned from integrative care leaders to call “salutogenesis” or “creating health.”
Yes, as I’ve described many times, riding on a change in the use of language coupled with a different viewpoint, the brand that is “integrative medicine” has become quite a powerful one, leading to what I like to refer to as “quackademic medicine,” where academic medical centers embrace and study quackery that they would have dismissed even a couple of decades ago.
So what are these milestones? They fall into several categories, of which I can only focus on a handful. First, of course, there is the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH), formerly the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM), and, before that, the Office of Alternative Medicine (OAM).
Infiltrating the NIH: A major milestone in integrating quackery with medicine
A list of 120 “milestones” is just too long (even for me) to want to devote the verbiage to discussing all of them. After all, the e-book is 92 pages long. So, naturally, I’m going to gravitate towards the examples that interest me, either because of their significance, because of the difference between how Sabin views them and skeptic view them, or both. I won’t necessarily discuss them in chronological order, either, although Sabin does present them as a timeline, complete with years and in some cases dates. Not surprisingly, several of these milestones have to do with the NCCIH, a center devoted to studying pseudoscience mixed with plausible lifestyle interventions that almost nobody wanted, at least nobody in the scientific community. However, Senator Tom Harkin did, which is why I start with #23 Congress Establishes the Office of Alternative Medicine, which occurred in 1992. Here’s how Sabin describes it:
With the leadership of Sen. Tom Harkin, D-Iowa, Congress established the Office of Alternative Medicine (OAM) in 1991 (Title 404E Section 601 of the Public Health Service Act), to serve as a coordinating center within the Office of Director (OD) at NIH. Its mandate: “facilitate the evaluation of alternative medical treatment modalities” through coordinated research and other initiatives with NIH’s institutes and centers. OAM’s primary mission, in its first six years, was to emphasize rigorous scientific evaluation of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) treatments, develop an infrastructure to coordinate and conduct research, and to provide information to the public.
And, later in 1992, 24. “Chantilly Report:” First NIH-Organized Workshops on Complementary and Alternative Medicine:
In 1992, the NIH Office of Alternative Medicine (OAM) conducted two workshops in Chantilly, Va. to develop a baseline of information on CAM use in the United States. The meetings examined six fields of alternative medicine and addressed issues of research infrastructure, research, and methodologies. The resulting “Chantilly Report” or “Alternative Medicine: Expanding Medical Horizons”—was released in 1995. It is significant because it was the result of the first NIH sanctioned meetings held to discuss the field of complementary and alternative medicine as a whole.
These initial OAM meetings on CAM are described in the 2002 report from the Institute of Medicine (IOM), “Complementary and Alternative Medicine in the United States.”
And then, in 1998, there was 36. Congress Creates The National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM):
Through an informal coalition of integrative health and CAM leaders inside and outside of government, six years after establishing the Office of Alternative Medicine, the US Congress elevated that office to the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM). At that time, the NIH director said the new NCCAM: “…will provide greater autonomy to initiate research projects at a time when the public is increasingly interested in CAM therapies.” A 16–member outside advisory council was also created (50% of its members were to be from the CAM professions, but that ratio has not been achieved since the founding of the council). Also see 2015 entry 118. “NCCAM becomes the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH)”
I can’t help but note my take on #118, in which NCCAM became NCCIH. As for the rest, this history, of course, ignores the background and context, which has been discussed here many times before. Basically, the OAM ran into trouble almost immediately when its first director, Joseph M. Jacobs, ran afoul of Sen. Harkin by insisting on rigorous scientific methodology to study alternative medicine. To get an idea of what Jacobs was up against, consider that in 1995 Harkin wrote not just one, but two, commentaries, “The Third Approach” and “A Journal and a Journey.” In these two articles, Harkin basically advocated studying what has been “called ‘left-out medicine,’ therapies that show promise but that have not yet been accepted into the mainstream of modern medicine.” and explicitly stated that “mainstreaming alternative practices that work is our next step.” Unfortunately, Sen. Harkin had a bit of a problem with the way medical science actually goes about determining whether a health practice—any health practice—works, and railed against what he characterized as the “unbendable rules of randomized clinical trials.” Citing his use of bee pollen to treat his allergies, he went on to assert, “It is not necessary for the scientific community to understand the process before the American public can benefit from these therapies.”
Ultimately Jacobs resigned under pressure from Harkin, who repeatedly sided with the quacks. It also didn’t help that Jacobs complained about various “Harkinites” on the advisory panel who represented cancer scams such as Laetrile and Tijuana cancer clinics. That Jacobs became tired of fighting and finally resigned is especially noteworthy given that Jacobs himself had been picked to run OAM precisely because of his openness to the idea that there were gems to be found in the muck of alternative therapies. Meddling by Harkin was a theme that kept repeating itself. Later, in 1998 after the then-NIH director had tried to impose more scientific rigor on the OAM, Harkin sponsored legislation to elevate the OAM to a full center, and thus was the NCCAM born. Not coincidentally, the NIH director has much less control over full centers than over offices. Interference by Sen. Harkin whenever the NIH director or NCCIH director tries to enforce more rigorous science has been a recurring theme, right up until Sen. Harkin retired a couple of years ago.
The legitimization of quackery through NCCIH and others
Another area that these “milestones” quite frequently represent are steps on the way towards legitimizing quackery. For example, guess what the number one milestone is, dating back to 1963? It’s 1. Chiropractic Care Attains Insurance Coverage:
Delaware enacted the first state mandate for chiropractic benefits in 1963, followed by 19 states in the 1970s, and 24 in the 1980s. The American Chiropractic Association estimates that by 2015, some 87% of all insured American workers have chiropractic coverage. All 50 states, the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico, and the United States Virgin Islands officially recognize chiropractic as a health care profession, with services available under state workers’ compensation laws. Chiropractic care is available at armed forces and veterans’ medical facilities. Certain services are covered by Medicare and Medicaid.
To be honest, it’s hard to argue with the inclusion of the first state mandate to cover chiropractic as a major milestone towards the legitimization of unscientific medicine. Chiropractic, despite its seeming respectability these days, is based on prescientific vitalism and anatomic abnormalities (“subluxations”) that no one has ever been able to demonstrate in the form chiropractors claim. As I like to say, chiropractors are really incompetent physical therapists with delusions of grandeur. If there ever were a “success” story for the integration of quackery with medicine and the legitimization of pseudoscience, the acceptance of chiropractic in all 50 states is one. It’s a model that naturopaths are now currently trying to emulate.
On a related note, Sabin also views what happened in Washington in 1994 in Washington as even more important, 31. Washington State Enacts “Every Category of Provider” Statute:
In 1995 the Washington legislature passed the Alternative Provider Statute (Every Category of Provider law), becoming the first state to require insurers to include in their coverage plans: licensed practitioners of naturopathic medicine, massage therapy (soft-tissue manipulation), acupuncture and Oriental medicine, chiropractic, direct-entry (homebirth) midwives, and other licensed specialists.
The law, which was successfully defended against insurer attack by then Washington State Insurance Commissioner Deborah Senn, JD, required that insurers “permit every category of health care provider to provide health services or care for conditions included in the basic health plan.” It did not apply to Medicare, Medicaid, state-subsidized Basic Health Plans, or to self-funded plans. The state has since supplied a treasure trove of data on real world integration.
Great, going, Washington!
Not surprisingly, there are a number of steps listed here that have to do with the legitimization of “integrative medicine,” including: the US recognizing the chiropractic education accrediting agency (#2, 1974); the founding of the American Holistic Medical Association (#6, 1978); the founding of Cancer Treatment Centers of American (#16, 1988), about which I can’t help but note that we’ve written about how devoted to integrating quackery CTCA is; the founding of the University of Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine by Andrew Weil (#29, 1994); the formation of the Bravewell Collaborative (52, 2002); and many more.
Education corrupted
Over the years, I’ve discussed more examples than I care to note of the corruption of education by the infiltration of pseudoscience into the medical curriculum, both at the undergraduate and graduate medical education levels. Not surprisingly, Sabin agrees that these are important milestones, although, unlike myself, he thinks these milestones are a good thing. For instance, Sabin lists: the first NCCAM grant for education in CAM (#40, 1999); military training for medics in the use of battlefield acupuncture (#107, 2014), something I’ve written about many times; a meeting at Georgetown University to advance integrative health care (#48, 2001), with Georgetown later fully embracing the “integration” of CAM education into its curriculum and becoming a bastion of quackademic medicine; the funding by NCCAM of integrative medicine in preventative medicine residencies (#95, 2012); and, of course many more. Oddly enough, Sabin didn’t seem to think that board certification in holistic medicine or the formation of the first integrative medicine residencies were that big a deal. Whatever.
The bottom line is that this list is a depressing litany of just how far integrative medicine has come in becoming normalized (to use a common phrase these days) or mainstreamed.
The future
At the end of the list, Sabin and Walsh remark:
What was utterly outside of regular practice is increasingly explored in conventional medical delivery. The calls of the integrative care community for “health care”, rather than the limited reactivity of “sick care”, are increasingly intoned in the pages of American Hospital Association publications. Calls from the integrative and functional medicine movement for a system that focuses on salutogenesis and health creation are percolating in hospital board rooms.
These struggles of the medical industry to become value-based are prying open hearts, minds, and budgets to new contributions.
The answers are not clear, or easy. What will the next milestones be? What is ahead in this new era of convergence? Most important, how will you or your organization fit into this emerging paradigm?
Well, SBM isn’t going to “fit” into this emerging paradigm. However, I can’t help but note how this last passage shows how blatantly integrative medicine co-opts terms and strategies that do not require the embrace of quackery to achieve, such as “wellness” and “health care” rather than “sick care,” in addition to value-based health care. Regarding the latter, I can’t help but note that treatments not based in science and not demonstrated to be effective by science can never be of high value, at least not economically, which is the value that Sabin is trying to co-opt. As for “wellness” and “health care,” one doesn’t have to embrace acupuncture, TCM, homeopathy, naturopathy, functional medicine, or any other unscientific version of medicine in order to promote these as goals. Yet that is exactly what integrative medicine advocates like Sabin, Walsh, and Weeks try to argue.
Amusingly, right after this argument, there is another ad for XYMOGEN supplements, followed by another ad for the XYMOGEN Exclusive Series Healing the New Epidemics. The two speakers, who have been appearing throughout the country as part of this series, include Richard Horowitz, who is speaking about a nonexistent disease widely treated by quacks, “Solving the Mystery of Chronic Lyme Disease and Associated Tick-Borne Co-Infections,” and Kenneth Bock, who is also speaking on a questionable disease that dubiously blamed for autism, “Healing the New Childhood Epidemics: PANDAS/PANS and the “4A” Disorders (Autism, ADHD, Asthma and Allergies).”
This is the sort of other medicine that is being “integrated” with science-based medicine. It probably wasn’t intended as such, but I found the inclusion of that ad right after the last passage of Sabin and Walsh’s book to be more appropriate than they will ever realize.

Why Do Prestigious Hospitals Sell Snake Oil?
It is important for consumers to understand the phenomenon of hospitals, even prestigious hospitals, offering dubious treatments, and how we got here. Don’t be fooled by the apparent endorsement of nonsense. It is still nonsense.
Steven Novella on March 8, 2017
Link

Here is the problem (if you are a hospital director) – there is a lot of money to be made selling nonsense and snake oil to patients. In fact con-artists and fake medicine peddlers have done a fantastic job in the last few decades rebranding their snake oil as “alternative” and giving it a patina of legitimacy. Demand is rising, and people are apparently willing to pay lots of money out-of-pocket for false claims and wishful thinking.
Meanwhile, reimbursement for real medicine has declined as part of the attempt to contain skyrocketing health care costs. Profit margins are slimmer than ever. There is only so much you can do by becoming more efficient and cost effective.
If only there were some way to tap into the burgeoning alternative medicine industry. We could market them as “complementary” or “integrative,” that way they will be offered in addition to real medicine. That’s a win-win, because then profits from alternative medicine will be entirely incremental, and we can reassure ourselves that at least we are still giving our patients real treatments.
But there is still the pesky problem of professional ethics. Hospitals sell medical care, not used cars. Medical care is a profession with strict ethical constraints. Since the Flexner report in 1910 in America, there has also been this burdensome tradition of basing medical care on science and evidence. There is an evidence-based standard of care, and some doctors might actually object to violating that standard, violating basic professional ethics, and exploiting patients by making false claims and selling them worthless snake oil. If those doctors make a stink it might be inconvenient.
Still, hospitals are businesses, and businesses can’t afford to leave so much money on the table.
What to do?
Let the rationalizations begin
A recent article in STATnews (in which, full disclosure, I am quoted extensively) discusses the phenomenon of prestigious hospitals offering dubious services. They do a decent job of outlining the problem, and provide some useful quotes from “integrative” proponents. Unfortunately, they felt the need to end with the usual false equivalency and balance, rather than coming to the obvious conclusion that the rest of the article demands. In a way they demonstrated the exact same cognitive process that they critique in their article. They essentially answered their own question without realizing it.
The thought process that I parody above, in my opinion, is far more accurate. Further, there is a minority of true-believers that significantly promote dubious treatments, and can serve as “experts” hospitals can rely on to sell their snake oil.
This creates a feedback loop in which hospitals partly respond to demand, but in doing so increase that demand which justifies further efforts to meet it. In the end hospitals have exactly what they want – they can make lots of money selling snake oil to their patients, alongside real medicine, and can justify it to themselves and the outside world with prepared rationalizations that the con-artists who created the alternative medicine industry have carefully curated and market-tested over the years.
The STATnews article nicely documents these rationalizations, but there are countless other examples. It also showcases that hospitals are often still a little shy about the whole thing. On some level some of the people involved must know this is all thinly veiled BS. They don’t quite buy it themselves, and would be happy if the entire endeavor did not garner too much attention. Some of the alternative medicine directors refused to comment for the article, even citing in one case fear of backlash.
That is very telling. If they thought they were objectively doing the right thing, they would not be shy about shouting it to the world and defending their position. It seems that they fear they can’t defend their position, and so refuse to comment. Just look the other way while we shamelessly exploit our patients and squander the legitimacy of our profession.
I could have scripted the response of those who did choose to comment, they are so predictable. Here we go:
“Yes, as scientists, we want to be rigid. But me, as a physician, I want to find what’s best for a patient. Who am I to say that’s hogwash?” said Dr. Linda Lee.
A gastroenterologist, Lee runs the Johns Hopkins Integrative Medicine and Digestive Center, which offers acupuncture, massage therapy, and reiki — a therapy that the center’s website describes as laying on hands “to transmit Universal Life Energy” to the patient.
This is a common argument – I just want to offer my patients anything that might work. Lee follows up with, how can she possibly know if a treatment is “hogwash?” It’s not as if we have carefully evolved a system by which we can rigorously and systematically test our therapies in order to tell objectively which ones work and which don’t. It’s not as if we have the basic science to have any meaningful understanding of how the universe works so that we have a basis for making informed judgments about plausibility. Maybe at some point in the distant future we will have this “science” to determine such things. In the meantime, how could I possibly know that a magic treatment with no plausibility and lack of clinical evidence doesn’t actually work?
Of course, if the medical profession cannot be expected to determine that a nonsensical treatment with evidence that it does not work, in fact does not work, then they cannot be held to any science-based standard of care. And that’s the point. In such a world, anything goes. Hospitals can offer treatments to patients that they know are snake oil, but really, who are they to say?
It is statements like this which demonstrate that the alternative medicine movement (however you rebrand it) is, at its core, about eliminating or at least fatally weakening the standard of care. Standards are a barrier to selling magic beans to desperate farmers.
“Here at UF, we do not have alternative medicine. We do not have complementary medicine. We have integrative medicine,” said Dr. Irene Estores, medical director of the integrative medicine program at the University of Florida Shands Hospital in Gainesville, Fla.
This is both wrong and irrelevant. As our own Mark Crislip is fond of noting, when you mix cow pie with apple pie, it doesn’t make the apple pie any better, and doesn’t do much to improve the cow pie either. There is no justification for “integrating” unscientific treatments, which are either unproven or that we have already demonstrated do not work, into science-based medicine.
Further, all of the marketing spin about “integration” is a lie. Over the years, while the marketing has evolved, the offered treatments have largely stayed the same. It is still all about selling homeopathy, energy medicine, acupuncture, and useless herbs and supplements. They are still offered with the same unjustified and implausible claims. They are still offered as if they treat diseases. All this talk about integration is just to help hospital directors sleep at night, and to wave off the criticisms of those who actually think we need to have a real standard of care. As the article notes:
Duke’s Integrative Medicine store, for instance, sells “Po Chai Pills” that are touted on the hospital’s website as a cure for everything from belching to hangovers to headaches. The site explains that taking a pill “harmonizes the stomach, stems counterflow ascent of stomach qi, dispels damp, dispels pathogenic factors, subdues yang, relieves pain.” None of that makes sense in modern biomedical terms.
They then act surprised when the very people they hired specifically to sell snake oil to their patients get caught selling snake oil, as the recent Cleveland Clinic debacle demonstrates. The Chief Executive of Cleveland Clinic still defends this:
“The old way of combating chronic disease hasn’t worked,” Cosgrove wrote in a column posted on the hospital’s website. “… We have heard from our patients that they want more than conventional medicine can offer.”
The first claim here is that science-based medicine has not “worked” for chronic disease. This is a dubious and vague claim. What constitutes “working?” Would you say that a patient with diabetes today is better off than a century ago? Ask a diabetic, or a doctor who treats diabetics. Or, you know, read the scientific literature.
There is no question that modern medicine has been incredibly effective at treating and managing many chronic illnesses. Of course, there are many chronic illnesses that cannot be cured (only managed) and there are those for which we still lack effective treatment, or there is much room for improvement. Is Cosgrove saying that the bar for “working” is a complete cure, and anything short of that is a failure? That is the alternative medicine propaganda position, into which he appears to be falling.
Further, the fact that science-based medicine has not completely cured everything yet, in addition to being an absurd standard, does not mean that any alternative is effective or is better. This is the equivalent of an argument from ignorance, or a god-of-the-gaps argument. Whatever science has not yet figured out, insert your preferred belief system. Just because we have not cured a disease does not justify waving your hands over patients to manipulate non-existent energy fields.
Cosgrove ends with the “demand” gambit. As I said, demand is a more complex phenomenon than the rationalizers suggest. They are not just meeting demand, they are creating it. Further, in a profession like medicine, that is not a justification. Like all professions, we don’t just give our clients anything they want without limit. A client cannot demand of his lawyer that he break the law in defending them. A patient cannot demand of a physician that they violate their professional ethics.
Next up, when in doubt, play dumb:
Asked about the Cleveland Clinic’s promotion of reiki, Dr. Richard Lang, the recently named interim director of the clinic’s Wellness Institute, said he hadn’t had a chance to think about it. “I don’t know that I could give you a plus or minus on that,” he said. Lang served as a vice chair of the wellness institute for nearly a decade before taking the top post.
The obvious implication here being that, if Dr. Lang was vice chair for the Wellness Institute for a decade, a decade in which it offered reiki, he should have an opinion about whether or not this major service they offer actually works. It is easier, however, to “see no evil.”
There is also the strategy of just fully embracing pseudoscience:
At the University of Pittsburgh, Glick echoed that sentiment: “We’re an academic institution … [so] we’re offering services that have greater evidence basis [and] scientific explanation.”
Translation – we rely on worthless preliminary studies that are designed to guarantee a false positive result in order to shield the fact that we are selling rank snake oil to our patients. Or, it’s possible that they simply are not competent to properly interpret the scientific literature and actually think that small studies lacking rigor are sufficient to justify an implausible treatment, which is an even deeper problem.
The STATnews article then goes off the rails and shows how successful some alternative medicine propaganda has been (you guessed it, with acupuncture):
A 3,000-year-old Chinese therapy, acupuncture is based on the belief that by stimulating certain points on the body, most often with needles, practitioners can unlock a natural healing energy that flows through the body’s “meridians.” Research suggests it helps with certain pain conditions and might help prevent migraine headaches — but it also suggests that the placebo effect may play an important role.
Acupuncture is no less pseudoscience than homeopathy or energy healing. It just has better PR. First, it’s not 3,000 years old. What currently passes for acupuncture is decades old. Second, the research has shown that acupuncture does not work for any indication. I just reviewed the evidence a few weeks ago showing that it does not work for migraine prevention, despite that fact that it is promoted as working with the usual low-quality studies.
The article disappointingly ends with a false equivalency argument:
“We do use things that aren’t necessarily 100 percent evidence-based, but I would argue that’s also true within all of medicine,” said Dr. Jill Schneiderhan, co-director of the University of Michigan’s integrative family medicine program. “I feel like it’s not black and white.”
The false equivalency argument is particularly insidious, and has become very popular recently. It’s so common that John Oliver felt the need to expose it with satire on his show:
“Not all problems are the same,” Oliver explains. “It’s like comparing ‘La La Land,’ an Academy Award–nominated movie with glaring flaws, to ‘The Human Centipede,’ a thing that barely counts as a film. Yes, one movie is people sewn mouth-to-anus, but, you know, Ryan Gosling looks at his feet when he dances, so it all evens out in the end.”
Yes, mainstream medicine has problems (pointing out those problems is a major theme of this blog), but what is being sold as alternative medicine “barely counts as medicine.” The two things are not equivalent.
It is important for consumers to understand the phenomenon of hospitals, even prestigious hospitals, offering dubious treatments, and how we got here. Don’t be fooled by the apparent endorsement of nonsense. It is still nonsense. What we need to do is create an understanding that leads to more demand for high standards in medicine. I feel, based on my interaction with many patients, like there is a silent majority of patients who want and expect that they will not be sold lies and false hope. People usually don’t go out of their way to express negative demands.
Many (I would say most) of those who think they want alternative treatments don’t really want to buy magic beans. They are just being misled. They falsely think that a hospital would not be offering the treatment if it were not legitimate. The hospital then uses the dubious demand that they help generate to justify further generating demand. The only thing that will stop the cycle is patients and doctors demanding ethical, science-based medicine.
sw

   The infiltration of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) and “integrative medicine” into academia
David Gorski 
Link
A few years back, my co-blogger Wally Sampson wrote a now infamous editorial entitled Why the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) Should Be Defunded. When I first read it, I must admit, I found it to be a bit harsh and–dare I say?–even close-minded. After all, plausibility aside, I believed at the time that the only way to demonstrate once and for all in a way that everyone would have to accept that many of these “alternative” therapies were no more effective than a placebo would be to do high-quality randomized clinical trials to test whether they worked, and NCCAM seemed to be the perfect funding agency to see that this occurred. Yes, this attitude in retrospect was quite naïve, as I have since learned the hard lesson over several years that no amount of studies will convince advocates of complimentary and alternative medicine (CAM) that their favored therapy doesn’t work, be it chelation therapy for autism or cardiovascular disease, homeopathy, reiki, or various other “energy” therapies that invoke manipulation of qi as a means of “healing,” such as acupuncture, but that is what I believed at the time.
Why are CAM or “integrative therapies” so immune to evidence? One reason, of course, is ideology or even a religious component to devotion to these therapies, which is not surprising given that the whole concept of qi, a “life force” that science thus far has been utterly unable to detect but that “healers” claim to be able to manipulate for therapeutic effect, is far more religious in nature than scientific. Another reason is that many of these therapies were developed in pre-scientific cultures, long before germ theory and a much better understanding of human biochemistry and physiology led to therapies, both pharmacologic and surgical, that actually cured disease. Finally, according to the research studies of John Ioannidis, who has pointed out that it is not uncommon for random chance alone, coupled with the definition of statistical significance of p less than 0.05 can for hypotheses with an 80% chance of being false result in a 25% false positive rate, even if the studies are designed perfectly. Given that the prior probability of most CAM therapies being more effective than a placebo, based on scientific plausibility alone, is almost always less than 20%, that means the false positive rate for CAM research will be even higher, producing many studies that advocates can cite, while ignoring the totality of the evidence. Indeed, as I write this, we have a commenter pointing to such studies for purely “energy” medicine.
Dr. Sampson reminded me of this problem in his post last week about the infiltration of CAM into academic medicine. I’m extremely grateful for the historical perspective for a relative newbie to this debate. While I have only started to become alarmed at the infiltration of unscientific nonsensical CAM therapies being promoted and administered in academic medical centers as though they had evidence supporting them anywhere near the level of evidence expected for “conventional medicine,” Dr. Sampson first noted this trend in the 1980s, when I was in medical school and too busy learning medicine to bother worrying about trends in medical education and academia. It was a trend that continued into the 1990s, when I was similarly too busy doing my residency, PhD, and fellowship. It was only a couple of years ago that I started to become alarmed at this increasing acceptance of non-science-based and non-evidence-based therapy when I noticed them being offered at my own hospital.
Let’s get one thing straight right at the outset. I’m not opposed to teaching about CAM modalities in medical school. After all, many of our patients take various herbal remedies, and it’s important to know how they might interact with drugs or other treatments that we prescribe. Other patients may be using other CAM modalities besides herbs or supplements, and it is important to be able to discuss them. The key, however, is to think critically about these modalities, and, unfortunately, teaching the next generation of medical students to do this is something that academic centers teaching CAM (or, as it is being called more and more lately, “integrative medicine,” which to me is “integrating” unproven therapies with the proven to no benefit that I can detect) appear to be failing at utterly. Indeed, as Dr. Sampson and others have documented, very few CAM or “integrative medicine” programs actually teach a critical, evidence- and science-based appraisal of these therapies. Sadly, this teaching seems to be having an effect. There is at least some evidence that far too many medical students appear to be enthusiastically embracing non-evidence-based CAM therapies, as was reported by Chaterji et al in 2007, in which they found that 91% of medical students agreed that “CAM includes ideas and methods from which Western medicine could benefit.” (I wonder what ideas those are. The concept of qi, the undetectable life force that, it is claimed, various therapies can manipulate to therapeutic intent, perhaps?) Nor am I ideologically opposed to studying the more plausible therapies in randomized clinical trials. My concern about the current situation is that it is wasteful to allocate scarce research dollars to study after study therapies that are so highly implausible on the basis of science (such as homeopathy or reiki, for instance) when such money could be used to study more promising therapies and that the introduction of the less outlandish CAM therapies serves as a Trojan horse to let in the whole package, homeopathy, reiki, and all.
But how entrenched has CAM become in academic medicine in the U.S.? Certainly it’s become entrenched enough that alternative medicine mavens in the media, such as Julie Deardorff of the Chicago Tribune, have noticed. In fact, it’s becoming so noticed that national news magazines, such as the U.S. News & World Report, have published articles about the seeming embrace of these therapies by academia, articles that start out like this:
To be blunt, if my wife and I didn’t think it was helping him, we wouldn’t have continued with it,” says Dan Polley. He’s talking about Mikey, the Polleys’ 2½-year-old in the next room, who was diagnosed with acute lymphocytic leukemia when he was 6 months old. Chemotherapy, radiation, and a bone marrow transplant have been crucial elements of Mikey’s treatment. But the “it” his father speaks of is nothing like these aggressive, costly, and heavily researched exemplars of western care—it is a kind of touch therapy, from the camp of alternative medicine. Gentle and benign, “healing touch” is intended to rebalance the energy field that its practitioners believe surrounds the body and flows through it along defined pathways, affecting health when disrupted. Several times a week, therapist Lynne Morrison spends 20 minutes unblocking and smoothing Mikey’s energy field, which energy healers like Morrison say they can feel and correct.
This scene took place at, of all places, Children’s Memorial Hospital in Chicago, which is affiliated with Northwestern University. Moreover, this article is peppered with quotes from believers like Andrew Weil, who says: “I teach and urge people to use a sliding scale of evidence…The greater the potential to cause harm, the greater the standard of evidence should be.” One can hardly fail to note that, by that standard, homeopathy, which is, after all, nothing more than water, should require no evidence whatsoever. However, the article, in my mind, provided a more compelling reason than Wally Sampson’s original article, why NCCAM should be defunded and its functions folded into the rest of the Institutes and Offices of the NIH: NCCAM is actively promoting the teaching and adoption of “alternative” medicine in academic medical centers before science has validated the vast majority of its therapies:
Until the mid-1990s, most academic centers treated CAM like a pack of scruffy mutts, noisy and unworthy of notice. A large pot of federal and foundation research funds—now close to $250 million per year just from NCCAM and the National Cancer Institute, plus tens of millions more from private donors such as the Bravewell Collaborative—helped turn that sniffy attitude into solicitous attention, says longtime CAM commentator Donald Marcus. “The funding gave them respect from the medical school community,” says Marcus, a professor of medicine and immunology at Baylor College of Medicine in Houston, where he has long taught a CAM course. A survey of hospitals found that 27 percent offered CAM in 2005, up from 8 percent in 1998. At the Cleveland Clinic, for example, NIH money is behind a clinical trial to see whether reiki, another energy therapy, can reduce stress and anxiety in prostate cancer patients.
Enough money will do things like that, and the results have been startling. As an exercise, I set out to get an estimate by looking for centers of “integrative medicine” or CAM. It didn’t take me long to find at least 44 different such centers that offer and/or teach CAM. Indeed, I’m sure that the list that I am about to present to you is nowhere near complete, given that it includes only CAM or “integrative medicine” centers that are easily locatable through web searches and given that I didn’t wade too deeply into Google to find every last one. With those qualifications, here is the list that I came up with:
     1.  The Cleveland Clinic
     2.  The Richard and Hinda Rosenthal Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, Columbia University
     3.  Cornell University Center for Complementary and Integrative Medicine
     4.  The Continuum Center for Health and Healing, Albert Einstein College of Medicine of Yeshiva University
     5.  Duke Integrative Medicine
     6.  Henry Ford Health System (affiliated with the University of Michigan)
     7.  Georgetown University Medical Center (discussed here)
     8.  Harvard Medical School Osher Institute, Division for Research and Education in Complementary and Integrative Medicine
     9.  Jefferson-Myrna Brind Center of Integrative Medicine, Thomas Jefferson University
     10.  Mayo Clinic Complementary and Integrative Medicine Program
     11.  Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center
     12.  MindBody Patient Care Program, New York University
     13.  Integrative Medicine Program, Children’s Memorial Hospital (Northwestern University)
     14.  Northwestern Memorial Physicians Group Center for Integrative Medicine (Northwestern University)
     15.  Beaumont Hospitals Integrative Medicine Program, Oakland University
     16.  The Ohio State University Center for Integrative Medicine
     17.  Oregon Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine in Neurologic Disorders, Oregon Health and Science University (Also, the OHSU Center for Women’s Health Integrative Medicine Program)
     18.  Scripps Center for Integrative Medicine
     19.  Stanford Center for Integrative Medicine
     20.  Complementary & Alternative Research and Education Program, University of Alberta (pediatrics, yet!)
     21.  University of Arizona Program in Integrative Medicine
     22.  Susan Samueli Center for Integrative Medicine, University of California, Irvine
     23.  University of California at Los Angeles Collaborative Centers for Integrative Medicine
     24.  Osher Center for Integrative Medicine, University of California, San Francisco
     25.  University of Colorado
     26.  University of Connecticut Health Center (where a “debate” about homeopathy was recently held)
     27.  Department of Integrative Medicine, Hartford Hospital, University of Connecticut
     28.  University of Maryland Center for Integrative Medicine
     29.  The Integrative Care Project, University of Kentucky Colleges of Medicine and Health Sciences
     30.  University of Massachusetts Medical School Center for Mindfulness
     31.  Institute for Complementary & Alternative Medicine, University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey (UMDNJ-ICAM)
     32.  University of Michigan Medical School
     33.  University of Minnesota Center for Spirituality and Healing
     34.  University of New Mexico School of Medicine, Section of Integrative Medicine
     35.  Program on Integrative Medicine, University of North Carolina
     36.  PENNCAM, University of Pennsylvania
     37.  Center for Integrative Medicine, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center
     38.  University of Texas Medical Branch Complementary & Alternative Medicine Project
     39.  University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center Integrative Medicine Program
     40.  University of Washington School of Medicine Integrative health Program
     41.  University of Wisconsin Integrative Medicine (whose webpages seem to have been deleted but still come up when a search is done using the University web page’s search engine; what this means is unclear)
     42.  Vanderbilt Center for Integrative Health
     43.  Wake Forest Baptist Medical Center Program for Holistic and Integrative Medicine
     44.  Center for Integrative Medicine at the George Washington University Medical Center
Of course, sheer number of programs matter relatively little. What really matters, at least to me, is what is being offered to patients and/or taught to students, residents, and fellows through these programs. So I did a little perusing. The first thing that became immediately apparent is that nearly all of the centers or programs above either offer to patients or teach all or most of the following CAM modalities:
     1.  Acupuncture
     2.  Guided imagery
     3.  Massage therapy
     4.  Nutritional counseling
     5.  Tai Chi
     6.  Yoga
The inclusion of these modalities as first choices in “centers of integrative medicine” is not surprising for two reasons. First, they are fairly harmless for the most part. Second, there is some evidence to support some of them. Indeed, some of them (guided imagery and nutrition, for example) are not necessarily even “alternative” but really should be considered part of “conventional” medical therapies. And, of course, massage therapy, outside of the possibility that it might have a therapeutic effect in certain conditions, at the very minimum feels very good, while Tai chi and yoga can be viewed as low impact exercise, and are probably also at the very least not harmful. Finally, who can argue with nutritional counseling? And why is nutritional counseling considered “complementary,” “alternative,” or “integrative,” anyway? Nutrition is a part of conventional medicine, whether alternative medicine mavens believe it or not. Of course, it depends upon what exactly patients are being told. If they’re being told that megadoses of this supplement or that will treat cancer, then that’s what I call “alternative” nutrition, rather than good, old-fashioned, boring, science-based nutrition. Overall, though, among CAM therapies, the above subset appears to include modalities chosen because they are the least bizarre and therefore the most “safe” for consumption by academic physicians.
To go a step further and find out how much truly unscientific medicine there is in academic medical centers, I decided to identify which centers, if any, either offered to patients or taught uncritically two of the most scientifically implausible of all CAM modalities: homeopathy (which is nothing more than a highly ritualized placebo in which a “remedy” is, as homeopaths will now admit, diluted to the point where there is not a single active molecule left) or reiki therapy (which postulates that a reiki master can somehow manipulate the flows of qi, or the life energy of the patient for therapeutic effect). Note that therapeutic touch, “healing touch,” and a variety of other “energy-based” healing modalities are very similar to reiki in that they postulate that there is some sort of “life force” that the healer can manipulate for therapeutic intent. Neither of these treatment modalities are supported by science. For example, for homeopathy to work, much of what we know about physics, chemistry, and biology would have to be wildly wrong. I therefore chose these two modalities, which are probably the most common of CAM/integrative medicine modalities with the least scientifical plausibility as a weathervane of sorts, to see which way the wind was blowing with respect to seriously non-evidence-based mystical fluff finding its way into medical schools as serious treatment options. The results were disturbing, to say the least, particularly what some of these ostensibly “academic” centers wrote about these modalities on their websites. Here are the medical centers that offer and/or teach reiki or some other form of “energy medicine,” along with what the each program’s web page says about it, if anything:
     1.  Cleveland Clinic: “Reiki is a method of energy-based healing involving the laying on of hands by the practitioner, promoting a deep sense of relaxation for the client. Reiki can help patients access their abilities to promote their own healing in body, mind and spirit.”
     2.  Integrative Medicine Program, Children’s Memorial Hospital, Northwestern University: “Our bodies are always trying to move toward balance and health. Energy healing encourages the flow of our natural energies. The term “energy healing” covers a wide range of styles and techniques which serve to positively affect the human energy field. Hands-on energy work assesses disturbances in the human energy field, and helps to aid the individual’s body to enhance the natural flow of healthy life force. Patients and their families report that energy healing often provides a sense of deep relaxation, and reduction in the experience of pain. Energy healing is also called “touch healing” in our studies. Research is presently being conducted to provide evidence to show how the disturbances and movement of these subtle energies may affect the physical condition of the human body.”
     3.  Albert Einstein College of Medicine: “I use Reiki in addition to other healing practices to help my patients activate their innate capacity for self-healing. By promoting a relaxed and peaceful state, stress is decreased, immune function is enhanced and the body has a greater ability to heal. As a practitioner I also benefit from this work; through centering myself I feel both calm and energized.” Aurora Ocampo, MS, RN, CS
     4.  Duke University: Reiki is a spiritual healing practice that helps restore emotional, mental, physical, and spiritual balance. “Rei” means universal or highest and “Ki” means subtle energy. Practitioners learn to channel primordial chi (or Tao), which may be thought of as universal consciousness. Essentially, both practitioner and client enter a space of meditation so that spiritual, mental, emotional, and physical healing is facilitated…The practitioner lays hands on several different places on the body for several minutes at a time as the individual lies fully clothed on a massage table. People typically feel very relaxed and peaceful during a treatment, and sometimes fall asleep. After a one of two day class from a reiki master, individuals can begin to practice reiki on themselves and others. This is recommended for people with chronic illness or chronic stress so that daily practice is possible to create more peace and support the ability of the physical body to heal itself.”
     5.  Beaumont Hospital: Energy balancing is a complementary method that focuses on promoting health and well being and decreasing responses to stress, anxiety and pain. During these relaxing, non-invasive techniques, the practitioner very gently places her hands in a series of positions on what are believed to be the energy centers/pathways of the body. Contemporary research in this area show some of common responses to treatment include: induced relaxation and calmness; reduction in stress and pain; promotion of wound healing.”
     6.  Scripps Center for Integrative Medicine: “In use at Scripps since 1993, Healing Touch is an energy-based, non-invasive treatment that restores and balances energy to help decrease pain and relieve associated anxiety. Healing Touch is performed by registered nurses who recognize, manipulate and balance the electromagnetic fields surrounding the human body, thereby promoting healing and the well-being of body, mind and spirit. Healing Touch is often used as an adjunct to surgery and other medical procedures to assist in pain reduction, relaxation and healing.
     7.  University of Connecticut Health Center
     8.  University of Maryland
     9.  UMDNJ: “Reiki is the natural healing energy that flows through the hands of the Reiki channel in a powerful and concentrated form. Reiki functions on all levels of a person’s being and adjusts itself according to the needs of the recipient, helping them to take responsibility for their life and to make changes in attitude and/or lifestyle to promote a happier and healthier life.” (At least they say that electromagnetic therapy is not scientifically unproven.)
     10.  University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill
     11.  University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center
     12.  University of Wisconsin
     13.  George Washington University: “The purpose of Reiki is to promote the client’s own natural healing process by providing deep relaxation, abatement of signs or symptoms of distress, or a sense of harmony or balance. Reiki can be used in conjunction with any other treatment to enhance and accelerate its effectiveness.”
Next, here are the medical centers that offer and/or teach homeopathy, along with what they say about it on their websites (that is, if they say anything at all):
     1.  Thomas Jefferson University: “Homeopathic medicines are intended to stimulate the body’s own healing abilities. Homeopathy utilizes a wide range of mostly naturally occurring substances such as plants and minerals. These medicines are prepared through a specific process of stepwise dilution. Many homeopathic medicines contain only an infinitesimal amount of original substance. Although the mechanism by which these “ultradilutions” can work is unexplained, studies have been published in medical journals showing homeopathic medicines may provide clinical benefit.”
     2.  University of Connecticut Health Center
     3.  University of Maryland
     4.  UMDNJ It doesn’t appear that UMDNJ actually offers homeopathy, at least not as far as I can tell, but this is what its website says about it: “Samuel Hahnemann, a German physician conceived the practice of homeopathic medicine, in the late eighteenth century. It was developed in response to the horrific medical practices of the time and is based on the Law of Similars, or ” like cures like”. It embodies the idea that large doses of a substance cause a symptom, and very small doses of that same substance can cure it. Hahnemann and colleagues gathered volumes of descriptions of the symptoms caused by the ingestion of various plants, minerals, animal products, and other substances. When a patient came into the clinic with a series of complaints, these texts were consulted, and the preparation that caused the most similar response was given to the patient. These books, called Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia, are the basis of modern homeopathic therapy. The focus of homeopathy is on the symptoms. Symptoms are seen as attempts by the body to restore health…It works slowly and is thought to have a number of systematic benefits. Homeopathic medicine is very individualized. Treatment is based on the person’s response to the disease, so the actual cause of the disease is not a focus. Remedies are very dilute substances, which are prepared through a process of potentization, which involves repeatedly diluting with either water or alcohol and shaking a remedy (perhaps 100 times). Some solutions are diluted as low as (10)-30 or (10)-20,000. Various homeopathic medicines have been incorporated into modern conventional medical practice. Nitroglycerin was first used as a medicine by a homeopath. Digitalis and gold salts are other examples.”
     5.  University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill
     6.  University of Washington School of Medicine: “When dilutions greater than 24x or 12c are prepared, basic chemistry holds that it is unlikely than even a single molecule of the original substance is still present in the remedy, leading many to question how such a therapy could work. Homeopathic theory explains that the vigorous shaking or succusions leave an imprint of the substance being diluted, and that it is this imprint which can stimulate healing in the body, stimulating the body’s own healing responses.”
This is by no means a complete list of schools offering “energy medicine” or homeopathy. One reason is that many of the sites don’t list the actual modalities that are offered. Instead, they describe their programs using vague generalities about offering multiple CAM modalities or about “integrative consultations.” Also, I didn’t exhaustively peruse each website, although I do note that in my surfing not a skeptical word was found. Some may say that it’s really not so bad that I found five, maybe six at the most, medical schools or academic medical centers that offer homeopathy to patients and/or teach it to trainees. That anyone in academia would think that shows just how far we’ve fallen. Personally, I found it truly depressing that even a single medical school teaches homeopathy uncritically and offers it to patients. After all, even NCCAM admits the scientific implausibility of homeopathy and has funded only one study of homeopathy.
I also looked at miscellaneous CAM modalities while perusing all these websites and noticed that there are even a couple of centers offering reflexology, including the University of Maryland and the University of Pittsburgh, the latter of which advocates it for migraines, hypertension, fibromyalgia, and menstrual cramps, among other things. One (the University of Wisconsin, whose integrative medicine pages appear to have been removed since I first started researching this post) even made a totally unsupportable statement about CAM for cancer about “choosing therapies that help prevent cancer or prevent a recurrence,” where preventing a recurrence is something for which there is no good evidence that CAM do. One other (Thomas Jefferson University) even touts Rudolf Steiner’s anthroposophically Extended Medicine. Sadly, that’s not all. I found the University of Maryland offering craniosacral therapy, while UCSF offers spinal manipulation. Meanwhile, the Susan Samueli Center for Integrative Medicine at UC Irvine claims to be able to treat depression, hypertension, leukopenia, schizophrenia, allergies, diabetes, and cornucopia of other conditions.
After looking over these websites, I came to the conclusion that the vast majority of university hospital-based CAM programs appear not to apply a critical, scientific view to CAM modalities. Rather, the impression I get is that the faculty in most of these programs are probably believers. Indeed, I found very few indications of any serious scientific examination of whether these CAM therapies actually work (i.e., result in more of an effect than a placebo for real disease or pathology). Worst of all, instead of first asking, “Do these therapies work?” these programs seem to be assuming that they do work and then asking either “How do these therapies work? or “How can we combine these therapies with conventional therapies?” A quote from the U.S. News & World Report article epitomizes this attitude:
Those who work in academic CAM programs freely concede there is much about CAM that they do not comprehend—yet—but they also argue that the standards of western medicine should not block its use. Just because all of the evidence isn’t in, says Donald Abrams, director of clinical programs at UCSF’s Osher Center, “should I never try these therapies with my patients?”
Not only is that a combination of a straw man argument and an appeal to other ways of knowing, but it’s also putting the cart before the horse and of questionable ethics to boot. One of the most accepted principles of medical ethics is that, unless a therapy has solid evidence to support it, that therapy should not be offered to patients outside of the context of a clinical trial designed to study its efficacy. Yet, here we have a respected physician arguing that unproven therapies shouldn’t be denied to his patients. He would have a point if there were compelling, but imperfect, evidence that they might work, but such is not the case. I would respond to him by saying that he could do basic science and randomized clinical trials to test these therapies but that he shouldn’t be offering them to patients outside the context of a clinical trial.
One question that remains after looking at the increasing acceptance and even boosterism for CAM and integrative medicine in academia is a simple one: Why? Insurance doesn’t pay for the vast majority of these therapies, insurance companies, whatever their greed and other well-known shortcomings, having decided that there is no evidence that they work. Consequently, it’s cash on the barrelhead for academic medical centers reeling from recent cuts in Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement.
Still, that’s not enough to explain it. So what is? It turns out that, if you look closely at these centers, many of them are the result of a donation or endowment from a wealthy donor (or donors), as is the case for Duke University, Thomas Jefferson University, Columbia University, UC Irvine, Children’s Memorial Hospital, just to name a few. If it’s not a wealthy donor, it’s the Bravewell Collaborative. Also not to be underestimated is the publicity and marketing clout that having a famous media doctor, such as Andrew Weil or Mehmet Oz on the faculty provides. Alternatively (if you’ll excuse the term), it’s NCCAM funding that drives the creation of these centers, which is a reason why I’ve become less hostile to Dr. Sampson’s view than I used to be. As he points out, the assault on science-based medicine being taken to the very heart of academia appears to be part of a broader agenda designed to transform the very nature of medicine away from science and evidence, and, either willingly or as a useful but unwitting ally, NCCAM appears to be doing a lot to promote this transformation. Remember, NCCAM was not created because scientists or doctors clamored for it; it was created because powerful politicians with a penchant for alternative medicine demanded it.
The final question that inevitably comes up in discussions of offering CAM at academic medical centers is: What’s the harm? Why be so negative? After all, patients seem to want it, and if it makes them happy, what’s the problem, as long as the therapies being offered appear to be harmless?
Academic medicine is supposed to be different. It is supposed to exist for the purpose of applying scientific principles to medicine and thereby making new discoveries to use to treat disease, testing them in clinical trials to find out if they are effective, and then applying them systematically. Uncritically introducing therapies that are by their very nature unscientific, therapies like homeopathy, reiki, reflexology, and “energy medicine” taints the entire scientific enterprise at these institutions. Worse, offering such therapies outside the context of a clinical trial in academic medical centers gives the patina of scientific credibility to therapies that have not earned it, promoting the impression that science supports their efficacy. Moreover, it is bandwagon medicine, where the therapy is offered and evidence is sought post hoc to demonstrate its efficacy. That this happens in “conventional” medicine as well (the rapid introduction of laparasocopic cholecystectomy 15-20 years ago, for example) and that it is driven by patient demand are not justifications for allowing it to happen for CAM as well. Neither is the fact that sometimes therapies adopted before clinical trials demonstrate efficacy (laparoscopic cholecystectomy again) do turn out to be an improvement. The adoption of CAM in so many medical schools, with many more clamoring to jump on the bandwagon, appears to be a step backward. Medicine has finally, after over a hundred years, evolved to the point where it can actually become truly science- and evidence-based. From my perspective, the growing uncritical acceptance of CAM in academic medicine is a major threat to the continuation of that evolution. There should be no such thing as “alternative” medicine, anyway. There is medicine that is effective, as determined by science and clinical trials, and there is medicine that is not or is as yet unproven. We should not be “integrating” the latter with the former, and especially not in academia.

   Why would medical schools associate with quackery? Or, How we did it.
Wallace Sampson
Links
Why would medical schools risk association with quackery?
…a question from a Washington Post reporter in 1998.
The following hypothetical answer composed in response was never sent. It awaited a proper forum. Could this be one?
Well, Jeff, quackery is a pejorative term. Some time ago we recognized that words raise emotions and mental pictures. We recognized the cognitive dissonance raised by them, so we tried to eliminate quackery. We recognized the cognitive dissonance raised when one discusses acupuncture, chiropractic, homeopathy, and healing at a distance as if they were quackery when we made claims. For a century, most people just could not allow for the possibility that these things really work.
So over time we recognized that we had to do something about our language. That would be the first step in enabling the thought revolution that is upon us, and changing the paradigm in medicine and science. We simply changed the adjectives, and gave alternate names to the methods, added a few phrases to eliminate negative reactions, and shifted the negative terms to descriptions of the Medical Establishment (and, note the caps in that one.)
And along with that, we took advantage of a shift in perception, to be sure that the public would adopt a non-judgmental attitude. Of course, we had to wait decades for that attitude to mature to the point that they would be willing to give our claims a hearing, whereas just thirty years ago they would have dismissed the claims out of hand. Not only did we get that non-judgmental mind-set, but with it, a strong negative reaction to a description that contained an opinion or one that used any kind of loaded language to describe an underdog – no matter how true or justified that language happened to be. Fortunately for us, a wave of change spread across the intelligentsia, especially in the universities and the literary community, reinforced by the press. This was nicknamed “Political Correctness” or PC by other observers, but it was a new social standard that worked wonders for us. No scientific paper could be published that contained pejorative or negative wording, and almost all popular press reporting became dominated by the same press ethic. The press call it “balance“ or “objective reporting,” and they called reports’ wording of 10-20 years previous to be “biased” or “prejudicial.” And those were sins worse than using four letter words. We were delighted.
We now use words like unorthodox, nonstandard, unconventional, alternative, complementary, and the latest, “integrative.” They produce no emotional reaction. Along with this we invented false dichotomies, which became accepted facts; like holistic vs. reductionist, Western vs. Eastern medicine, linear vs. non-linear thinking. The dichotomies reinforced people’s feelings that these things were opposites, but of equivalent linguistic and scientific value.
Then we had to build a few straw men to show how bad and dangerous medicine was: The Medical Establishment, “cut, burn, and poison,” “cold and impersonal,” Medical Monopoly, Big Pharma, and adopted phrases to use in lobbying like “that‘s just a turf war…” Then we added slogans to replace realistic description like they do in advertising, because they really do work. So we made up Metabolic Therapy, Orthomolecular Medicine, treating the whole person, Treating the cause, not just the symptoms, Medicine for the 21st century, and “complementary and alternative medicine (“CAM”) itself. And how about “changing paradigm” we stole from Tomas Kuhn, “emergent methods” and “emergent technologies” – some of our co-borderliners used that one for cold fusion. [One wealthy foundation just constructed “The New Medicine.”]
So, y’see, what we did was ride a changing social and political scene to construct an entirely new thought system for medicine and health (oh, yeah, we also now use “health” instead of “medicine.”) – a new lens through which all our methods and claims would be seen as “good” or at least neutral. Descriptions such as implausible, unproven, disproven, fraudulent, dubious, would be out. Yet we would be free to use terms to describe medical science as removed, intellectual, unapproachable, elitist, and members of the System would be seen as arrogant, unfeeling, dominating,… well, you get the point. And, quackery, charlatan, irrational, fringe, are no longer linguistically correct (LC.) The cultural relativists, post-modernists, deconstructivists, have paved the way. The educational system, most of the academic, and much of the medical educational system are now etymologically and epistemically correct (ET.)
An example of our success was at the National Library of Medicine a few years ago when a medical author-editor inquired about the recent use of the term, “alternative medicine,” as a subject heading for its reference system. He was told the wording was now part of the common lexicon, and had to be honored, because that was the term the public would use to obtain references. Then just last week, he was asked to moderate a debate on “CAM” for an internet biological science magazine. He suggested the title not be “CAM” or “AM” but “aberrant medical practices.” The editor rejected the change, stating that the last term was prejudicial whereas “alternative” was not. Talk about your success!
We are thankful to the popular media – especially the print media for fifteen years of support. Of course, the press would not consider it support, because its members are blind to the problem. Their system of … ethics is different from that of science. And especially of medicine. They adopted a common theme – actually a template for writing about us. First, they are not interested so much in facts as they are in stories – keeping the attention of readers. So they almost always have a human interest story in an article about us. A leukemia cure by modern drugs by a highly educated and skillful clinician is not a story. Now if an insurance company refuses to pay for the treatment because of its expense, that’s a story. Or if a disgruntled patient didn’t get no satisfaction for a set of symptoms that the physician could not fit into a disease category (often just concern over common bothersome though unimportant symptoms) and then went to a chiropractor or acupuncturist and got relief, however temporary or expected on the basis of waiting and time, that’s a story. Or if a medical school forms a department for using some “alternative” treatment, and teaches the techniques to students, that’s a story. Of course, if the teaching is supported by a large grant from a private foundation run by some of our supporters, that would not likely be mentioned because it could be interpreted as biased. (And between you and me, we would not volunteer that information, would we?.)
And what percent of the readership would read about the structure and function of genes or the physics of heart-lung machines, or of the details of transplant operations? They figure most readers won’t get past paragraph four. It’s so much diagrammatic clutter. We know that in hard times the first sections they sacrifice are the medicine and science pages. There is always a market for sports and entertainment. So your editors will usually go for the first page of the B or the Living Section. And most people don‘t know that those articles don‘t come out of nowhere or just from an editor’s head. We started news releases, writing books and having our agents get us on the radio, and getting reviews of our books. And fortunately, they have lay readers do the reviews; we know what kinds of reviews we would get from real scientists and clinicians. As for the occasional idea you might get for a hit piece, or to tell it like it is, the editors cower – they fear the accusations they will get from us and our attorneys for defamation and interfering with commerce. We sort of have them there.
How about you science writers, who have had background education, special training, and consider yourselves no fools when it comes to so-called scams? With few exceptions, you have already felt the effects of the editors’ marker pens. And the power of that unspoken “balance” thing you were taught as far back as journalism school. And what would you do about getting other points of view anyway? We have seen your formula for articles. A front piece about a happy patient, 15-20 paragraphs about the patient, you, and the method, and two paragraphs by some doubter – a self-described expert skeptic – somewhere between paragraphs 15 and 28; and I thank you for almost always giving the last word, sentences, and paragraphs to us. Besides, you are usually on a deadline, our agents have just about pulverized regulatory agencies through Congress in the name of personal freedom, and most of all, we would never suggest any of those troublemaking skeptics’ names. Count on that.
So with the new postmodern academic teaching in most universities, the slow changes in attitude from language distortion (we call it language capture), and the cooperation of the press, all we needed were two more institutions – a sizable pool of private foundations and a foothold in the government. We got both. We got a powerful senator, chairman of the Health Education and Labor (and Pensions) Committee, egged on by a couple of House members who cajoled the others and the head of the NIH, and got our semi-permanent NIH Institute, now a Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine and its $120 million per year “awards” to our centers. Those assured the presence and persistence of medical school teaching of our material, special clinics where they are applied, and a an institutional source of employment for us for the first time in more than a century.
And it all mushroomed from there beyond our expectations. We got over 30 of our journals listed and abstracted in Medline/Pubmed of the NLM, and our people and sympathizers have excluded skeptical journals from Pubmed. We got our people to write the descriptions of our methods in government information sources like the NCCAM, the NIH itself (Intellihealth) we got our med school teachers to write the “CAM” sections at the American College of Physicians web pages, and we got essentially all med school website “CAM” sections to describe us in those “neutral” terms, without negative descriptions – even after proof that our methods don’t really work. The entire information establishment has accepted us, has changed its language as we have dictated, and captured hearts and minds of most generators and disseminators of information. [An addition from June, 2008: And now for the real current reason: That $100 million/year from NCCAM, a similar amount from other NIH institutes, and a large dose, perhaps as much as $50 million from private foundations - all into the pool of funding for the medical schools. A subject for 2 prior and yet another post.]
So now watch the straight-thinkers howl. They still don’t realize what hit them or how and why. Neither do you in the press, sticking to your high-minded principles of “balance“ and “fairness“ while feeding the public our intentional restructuring of the language, and not realizing it at all. While the running dogs of righteousness, the straight-laced, long-faced, mind-constricted, conservative, backward-looking, sexist, xenophobic, old men of medicine stomp and holler, and while deans and congressmen are deaf to their pleas…OoooWeeeh. Have we made it or what?

Confronting homeopathy, naturopathy, homeopathy, and other quackademic medicine at my alma mater
Several years back, I was forced to confront quackery at my alma mater in the form of an anthroposophic medicine program at the University of Michigan. The situation has deteriorated since then, as now the Department of Family Medicine there is inviting homeopaths to give talks and teaching acupuncture as credulously as any acupuncturist. Will the disease metastasize to other departments in the university? I certainly hope not.
David Gorski on August 27, 2018
Link

Regular readers know that I’m a proud graduate of the University of Michigan Medical School. Part of the reason for my pride is that, back in the late 1980s when I attended, U. of M. Medical School was really hardcore about science, so much so that it was viewed by prospective students and many other medical schools as seriously old school. No new (at the time, at least) organ system approach to the curriculum of the first two years for us! No getting us seeing patients from the first week! No, we had to earn seeing patients with a year of biochemistry, anatomy, physiology, etc. I also walked a mile uphill to attend classes and a mile uphill on my way home every evening. (Actually, the walking a mile part was not entirely inaccurate; on nice days I’d skip the shuttle bus from the Ann Arbor VA, which was right across the street from my apartment building and ran from the VA to the U. of M. Medical Center.) In any event, during the first two years, every four weeks, like clockwork, we’d have what was called a concurrent examination, which basically meant that we were tested (with multiple choice tests chock full of Type K questions, of course!) on every subject on the same morning.
At the time I studied there, the medical curriculum for the first two years had been fairly constant for quite some time, with a heaping helpin’ of anatomy, histology, biochemistry, and physiology in the first year and the second year packed full of pharmacology, pathology, and neurosciences, plus physical examination skills. Nowhere to be found in the curriculum was anything resembling “energy medicine” or anything that wasn’t science-based! Of course, back in the 1980s, the infiltration of quackademic medicine (the mingling of quackery with academic medicine) into medical schools and academic medical centers hadn’t really begun in earnest yet, although the rumblings of what is now called “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) and, more frequently these days, “integrative medicine” (IM) were starting to be detected in East Coast and West Coast schools. In flyover country, though, it was all very stodgy and scientific, which was fantastic.
Unfortunately, it didn’t last, at least not in the whole medical school. Although for the most part U. of M. is still pretty hardcore about science, there is one department, the Department of Family Medicine, that is becoming a wretched hive of scum and quackery. That particular department first came to my attention when I learned several years ago that there was a program in anthroposophic medicine, the mysticism-based, homeopathy-loving form of medicine founded by Rudolf Steiner, who also invented “biodynamic farming.” Although some of the links to the program have disappeared, you can still find the the purportedly multidisciplinary “Integrative Family Medicine” program that boasts of a “team of family physicians with advanced training in holistic medicine, anthroposophic medicine, and acupuncture,” along with Ricardo Roberto Bartelme, MD, emeritus faculty of Family Practice who lists anthroposophic medicine as one of his specialties. Sure, it appears that the anthroposophic medicine footprint in the department isn’t what it once was, but the fact that it is still in a department of a major medical school and academic medical center is inexcusable.
It goes deeper than that. U. of M.’s department of family medicine now sports a naturopath on its faculty, Suzanna Zick. Not-A-Doctor Zick is even co-director of the integrative medicine program in the department. She was also part of the team who developed the clinical care guidelines for breast cancer patients published by the Society of Integrative Oncology (SIO) in 2014 and updated last year and was even president of the organization from 2015-2016. She’s also published a dubious study on acupressure. Again, given that naturopathy is quackery and that you can’t have naturopathy without homeopathy or antivaccine beliefs, it is profoundly distressing to me to see a naturopath on the faculty of my alma mater.
The quackademic medicine situation at the University of Michigan appears to be getting worse, at least in the Department of Family Medicine. Not only does the department have anthroposophic medicine, but it has a credulous approach to The One Quackery To Rule Them All, homeopathy, and wait until you see what it’s teaching its residents about acupuncture!
Enter the Queen’s homeopath
My favorite term to describe homeopathy is The One Quackery To Rule Them All. (Yes, I’m a massive J.R.R. Tolkien fan.) The reason for that, of course, is obvious to anyone who knows anything about homeopathy. Basically, homeopathy is based on two principles, neither of which is rooted in science, but rather vitalism and magic: The Law of Similars, which states that you treat a symptom by using a substance that causes that symptom; and the Law of Infinitesimals, which states that diluting a remedy makes it stronger. The consequences that flow from these two “Laws” can get really bizarre, such as homeopathic saliva from a rabid dog. That is why I was quite shocked to see this Tweet the other day about talks about homeopathy given by Peter Fisher and Iris Bell at my alma mater, the University of Michigan:
Homeopathy research presented at University of Michigan: https://t.co/BCv9XABmWL
— Kathleen Slonager (@Homeopath_Kat) July 24, 2018
Which led me to this Facebook post:
I must pause to note here that Peter Fisher was recently killed when he was hit by a truck riding his bicycle to work in London. The talk in this video was from May.
I also love how this post includes a stock photo of a scientist in a lab in front of a large instrument, all in order to imply that homeopathy is scientific. It’s not. I also wonder how the American Institute of Homeopathy came to host Peter Fisher, the Queen’s physician and homeopath and very prominent in British homeopathy. The talk was a two-fer, as well. Included in the session was Iris Bell, a believer in homeopathy based at Andrew Weil’s integrative medicine program at the University of Arizona. I also have to wonder what, exactly, it was that the American Institute of Homeopathy hosted, given that the YouTube video shows both Peter Fisher and Iris Bell giving their talks by teleconference. Clearly, there was no travel expense. Maybe there were honoraria. Maybe the American Institute of Homeopathy paid for lunch, given that this sounded like a lunchtime lecture. (Near the end of the talks, both of which ran long, it’s mentioned that a lot of the physicians attending had to leave to get to their afternoon clinics by 1 PM.) Who knows?
First up, the Queen’s homeopath
It didn’t take long for Peter Fisher to get right into things. Indeed, a funny thing is that in his talk Peter Fisher describes these two laws in detail and admits quite freely that, thanks to Avogadro’s number, a homeopathic dilution greater than 12C (or 23X) is highly unlikely to contain even a single molecule of starting material left. Then, however, he goes on to say on more than one occasion variations of, “The fact that there is no starting substance present doesn’t mean there is nothing present” or “Do not confuse that [the lack of starting material after serial dilutions]” with ‘nothing is present.'” When I heard that, I had a feeling I knew where the talks were going to go, but I’m getting a head of myself here. First, let’s link to the video, which you are welcome to watch in its one hour, one minute quack glory if you so desire, but I do have to discuss its “high”—or should I say “low”—points.
So here’s the video:
The first 36 minutes or so of this woo-fest at the University of Michigan is Peter Fisher, and the remainder of the video is Iris Bell. Let’s dig in.
Since I already mentioned that Fisher described the invention of homeopathy by Samuel Hahnemann and how homeopathic remedies are made; so I’ll skip over those. He did, however, start by listing the topics he wanted to address:
    • Homeopathy is much misunderstood
    • Who uses homeopathy?
    • Comparative and cost effectiveness research
    • Systematic reviews and meta-analyses
    • Biological models of high dilutions response
    • Physical chemistry research
That’s a heck of a lot to pack into what presumably was supposed to be a 30 minute talk! Of course, given that the talk is about homeopathy, I was seriously tempted to make any of a number of homeopathy jokes about the brevity of the talks. I restrained myself. I will give him credit for defending vaccination, but will also point out that he’s deluding himself if he thinks that homeopathy is not antivaccine or that homeopaths don’t claim that homeopathy can substitute for vaccinations. Homeopathic nosodes, anyone?
Hormesis abused
Given the utter implausibility of homeopathy based on chemistry, physics, and biology, Fisher spent an awful lot of time on topics #2 and #3, who uses homeopathy and comparative and cost effectiveness research. This allowed him to cherry pick multiple uncontrolled studies. Before he does that, though, he invokes hormesis as the principle that allows “ultralow” concentrations of molecules to have biological effects. Basically, hormesis is a term to describe how some compounds can have nonlinear dose-response curves. He used examples of chlordane against crickets, showing graphs where very low concentrations of this pesticide induce greater weight gain in young crickets before the curve turns south and increasing doses cause slower weight gain and ultimately weight loss and death.
I once discussed hormesis in the context of radiation after the Fukushima nuclear spill after an earthquake and tsunami that devastated northern Japan. Basically, Ann Coulter and the usual suspects who try to downplay environmental catastrophes were trying to argue that Fukushima wasn’t a big deal because a little (or even more than a little) radiation is actually good for you based on—you guessed it—hormesis. Let’s just say that she cherry picked her studies and exaggerated hormesis, while misrepresenting the reasons for the linear no-threshold (LNT) model used by regulatory agencies. The name is relatively self-explanatory, and the model states that any radiation is a hazard in a linear fashion. As I pointed out, at very low doses, it’s hard to distinguish between an LNT model and hormesis, and the radiation levels at Fukushima were above any reasonable estimate where hormesis might be possible. (As an aside, not too long ago, I watched the episode of the Netflix series Dark Tourist in which David Farrier visits Fukushima, which is now deserted because of radiation, and is forced to cut his tour short because radiation readings were much higher than advertised and higher than what was deemed safe.) Let’s just say that Fisher, like Coulter, oversold hormesis as being a near-universal phenomenon (it’s not). Let’s also just say that, given that there is no starting material left in most homeopathic remedies, invoking hormesis as a basis of homeopathy is—shall we say?—completely irrelevant.
Observational studies and bad systematic reviews and meta-analyses
As for the observational papers, holy hell! Fisher started going through several observational, uncontrolled studies. One showed that homeopathy use is most prevalent in France (10% of the population) and might be higher in India. Given what I’ve learned recently about the popularity of homeopathy in France, I was not surprised. He also noted that in the US, only 2.1% of the population has used homeopathy in the last year, but that homeopathy use was associated with high levels of education, female sex, a “healthy lifestyle”, and multiple complementary therapies. He noted a study from France, which compared conventional family practices versus homeopathic family practitioners, versus “mixed” (practices where homeopathy was integrated). The claimed finding was that homeopathy use was associated with less use of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, less use of antibiotics, less use of psychotropic drugs, and that it cost 20% less. He cited another study from Germany that claimed better results with homeopathy for the same cost. Another study cited by Fisher of “homeopathy in the real world” claimed to show that the use of homeopathy could avert the use of antibiotics for acute otitis media. Of course, given that antibiotics are not always necessary for acute otitis media and in some cases “watchful waiting” plus treatment of symptoms are appropriate, it would take a randomized controlled trial to tell whether homeopathy is doing anything, and this wasn’t it. The same could be said of a study cited by Fisher that purported to show that homeopathy could decrease antibiotic use in acute upper respiratory infection. (Most URIs don’t require antibiotics.) I also couldn’t help but note that a lot of these studies were old, too. The otitis media study is from 2001, for instance.
Interestingly, Fisher also cited the Swiss Health Technology Assessment from 2012. This is, as Jan Willem Nienhuys put it, a case of “homeopathic optimism” and, as Edzard Ernst puts it, a report that only homeopaths take seriously any more. Fisher also cites a database supposedly at this URL: https://www.carstens-stiftung.de/core-hom, where, he claims, as of May 2018 there were 1,210 clinical trials of homeopathy. I clicked on that link and got a 404 page not found error. Whatever’s going on, I can’t help but point out that Edzard Ernst had a look at this database three years ago and was less than impressed, because some trials weren’t randomized; some weren’t even clinical trials; the list includes reanalyses of already published studies; a lot weren’t peer-reviewed or even placebo-controlled (it’s hard not to make jokes here); and the majority are of terrible methodological quality.
Fisher also cites a meta-analysis by Mathie et al from 2014 that claimed (hilariously) that not only is homeopathy effective, but the effect size increases with better-designed studies, which is the exact opposite of what we would expect for any treatment, conventional or alternative, because that’s how it goes. Initial, less rigorous trials often yield more impressive results, which often “decline” in later, more rigorous trials. That raised my eyebrow right away. Fortunately, again, Edzard Ernst is familiar with this nonsense and has discussed the Mathie meta-analysis in detail. Basically, he’s noted that this meta-analysis somehow managed to omit “the two most rigorous studies which happen to be negative.” Let’s just say that misleading by meta-analysis is a common tactic of homeopaths. Sadly, faculty at the University of Michigan were unable to pick up on this.
Fisher finished rushing through a bunch of the usual suspect studies for mechanisms. I couldn’t help but laugh uproariously when he spent some time claiming that the studies in mast cell degranulation by Jacques Benveniste were good evidence of a biological effect of homeopathic remedies. Benveniste’s work was fatally flawed and shown to be nonsense by James Randi himself. Basically, Randi and the team of referees asked Benveniste to repeat the experiment, but went to extraordinary lengths to make sure that the people carrying out the experiments didn’t know what groups were the control groups and which groups were the ultradilute samples. Under these conditions, Benveniste’s results were not replicable. This showed how critical proper blinding was to experiments involving homeopathy. Fisher also blew through a few other papers, which I might have to look into if I get the time, but they all looked to suffer from similar issues.
Iris Bell: Nanoparticles prove homeopathy!
Last up was Iris Bell. Bell, as you might know, is a physician and homeopath (and emeritus professor at the University of Arizona) whom I first noticed ten years ago after she had gotten a grant to study homeopathy from the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM), now known as the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) and from her debate appearance in 2007 at the University of Connecticut. She’s clearly unhappy with skeptics, because she declares right at the outset, “Skeptics keep saying, “There’s nothing there, so this is ridiculous.'” Why, yes. Yes we do. Then she goes to a straw man, claiming we say, “If you have a positive finding, so what? It’s an accident.” Actually, our arguments about Bayesian considerations are quite a bit more nuanced than that. But whatever.
Her response is a striking set of data that “allow you to put together a potential model for how this all works. The emphasis is that you’re going to find, truly, structures in the material that generate signals that have been demonstrated that will then trigger nonlinear responses in the organism, a complex adaptive system that is self-organized and actually has self-similarity (?) at certain levels.” Her overview of the “healing process” is as follows: Pick correct remedy for diseased organism and organ, which leads to a self-amplified adaptive response across the networks, which leads to healing and a healthier organism. She emphasizes that skeptics misunderstand homeopathy because homeopathic remedies are “not acting like a drug,” but are rather “acting like a signal that tells the body that it can heal” (whatever that means).
Here’s where Bell gets into what I knew was coming from the beginning, when Fisher said that just because homeopathic remedies don’t contain any original remedy doesn’t mean that there isn’t something there. Yes, we’re talking nanoparticles, baby! Not only are nanoparticles the One True Cause Of Disease in some alternative medicine, they’re also the cure because they make homeopathy work! It’s one of the favorite “explanations” for homeopathy out there other than the “memory of water” and it’s just as plausible and convincing (as in not at all plausible). I remember when I first heard of this gambit back in 2010, upon encountering a paper published by homeopaths in India that confused what were almost certainly heavy metal nanoparticle contaminants from the manufacturing process for particles arising de novo as a result of the succussion (shaking) between each dilution step. I later heard about how homeopaths were invoking silica nanoparticles as “proof” that homeopathic remedies were not just water. Of course, can’t help but wonder where silica nanoparticles come could possibly come from, if in fact they have actually been detected in homeopathic remedies. It couldn’t have anything to do with the fact that most homeopathic dilutions are made in glass (which is to say silica) vials, could it? Perish the thought! Basically, Bell’s been peddling this same line for quite some time.
According to Bell, all that grinding and succussion generate nanoparticles, and these nanoparticles do things. All sorts of things. Magical things. Like homeopathy things. They can even emit electrical signals! Oh, wait. The paper Bell cites to justify that claim is the infamous paper by Nobel Laureate Luc Montagnier, who, unfortunately, appears to have fallen prey to the Nobel Disease and become a crank. Indeed, that particular paper was roundly criticized by skeptics for its poor methodology and conclusions not supported by its data. These days Montagnier is subjecting autistic children to long term antibiotic treatment and appearing at quack conferences like Autism One, along with women who think that giving autistic children bleach enemas is a good way to treat autism. In other words, as sad as it makes me to say it, Montagnier is no longer a good scientist, and I wouldn’t trust anything he publishes these days any more than I trust what Dana Ullman publishes—or, for that matter, Iris Bell.
Of course, in this talk, it’s not just silicates from the glass, but she even mentions how homeopaths use natural cork stoppers and speculates how cork might adsorb to the nanoparticles. Her explanation for how nanoparticles “get there” is epically hilarious:
Basically, it’s a whole lot of handwaving involving the lactose that is sometimes in ground up homeopathic remedies before they are placed in a water/ethanol solution to be diluted, combined with shaking, nanobubbles, interactions between nanobubbles on the surface of the glass with entrapped air bubbles and the formation of a layer of nanoparticles on the surface of the remedy. It’s all utter nonsense, as I’m sure any physicist, chemist, or materials scientist will be happy to back me up about. She also cites Luc Montagnier’s claim of electrical signals from homeopathically-prepared E. coli. That’s when she jumped the shark, even for a homeopath, although she did also invoke quantum entanglement, as all good defenders of quackery do.
Bell, too, had to rush through her last few slides, which left a couple of minutes for questions. To be honest, I was very disappointed. Not a single skeptical question was asked—not one!—and the last question basically set Bell up to go on about how she wants to find collaborators who have model systems she’s interested in and ultimately use “big data” to answer how homeopathy works.
Because of course she does.
Teaching integrative medicine in the Department of Family Medicine
You might ask, given the leadership role in resident education held by a naturopath, the lack of skepticism towards homeopathy, and the presence of an anthroposophic medicine advocate in the department, what the U. of M. Department of Family Medicine is teaching its residents and the medical students rotating through its clinics. The answer, it turns out, was on the U. of M. website, where the Department of Family Medicine provides a helpful webpage entitled Family Medicine Education Modules, which are:
Our education modules are made available through a partnership with Open.Michigan, a University of Michigan initiative committed to open content licensing and supporting the use, redistribution, and remixing of educational materials. Open.Michigan has reviewed this material in accordance with U.S. Copyright Law and has tried to maximize your ability to use, share, and adapt.
There are three integrative medicine modules:
Integrative Medicine Based Approach to Care
    • Asthma
    • Depression
    • Diabetes Type 2
    • Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease (GERD)
    • Headache
    • Menopause
    • Obesity and Weight Loss
    • Prenatal Care
    • Upper Respiratory Infection (URI)
Integrative Medicine: Body-Based Therapies
    • Acupuncture
    • Manual Medicine
    • Massage Therapy
Integrative Medicine: Mind-Body Therapies
    • Overview
    • Guided Imagery
    • Hypertension
I perused the list, and zeroed in on the most pseudoscientific treatment there, acupuncture. I was somewhat surprised there wasn’t anything on naturopathy in the modules, but I predicted that a lot of what naturopaths do would just be “integrated” into the education. I also realized that I really wish I had a U. of M. login, because there were pre- and post-tests that I could have looked at but didn’t have access to. In any event, the acupuncture module is listed has having been developed by “U-M Department of Family Medicine integrative medicine fellow, Andrew H. Heyman, MD, MPH, in 2007” and is currently being “maintained by faculty member, Tarannum A. Master-Hunter, MD,” with the last review being in February 2018. Her clinical interests are listed as family medicine, sports medicine, and clinical acupuncture. Great! We have a physician administering what I consider to be quackery at my alma mater!
What about the module? Ever the optimist, I was hoping for better, but what I got was typical misinformation about acupuncture. For instance, we get the narrative that acupuncture is ancient:
“The superior physician controls disease before any illness has declared itself;the average physician practices acupuncture before the disease has come to crisis; the inferior practitioner treats the patient when illness is already dying away.”– Zhen Jiu Jia Yi Jing(Comprehensive Manual of Acupuncture and Moxibustion, 282 AD)
Chinese medicine has evolved from a theoretically and clinically heterogeneous heritage that includes ancestor healing, demon exorcism, magic correspondences and herbal medicine.
    • Its history is well documented in more than 10,000 medical treatises.
    • The first European reports on Chinese medicine came from 16th and 17th century Jesuits.
    • Missionaries to Asia brought back the theory and practice of Traditional Chinese Medicine to Europe (see Acupuncture – European history).
Today, Chinese medicine embraces a complex, internally consistent and comprehensive medical tradition that includes acupuncture, herbology, nutrition, meditation, exercise, and manual therapy.
Aside from treating disease, Chinese medicine has maintained a vigilant position on health prevention.
Of course, there are wildly varying estimates for how old acupuncture is that depend on how reliable one considers ancient texts and what, exactly, one counts as acupuncture. I like to think of it by asking a simple question: Did the technology exist to make fine needles 2,000 years ago? The answer, of course, is no. So if acupuncture existed, it must have been very different then than it is now, given that the technology to produce such thin needles didn’t exist until much, much later. Indeed, it is very likely that acupuncture started out as no more than an Asian variety of the bloodletting practiced in Europe, with acupuncture points and meridians being near veins to be opened. There was also a strong connection between ancient acupuncture and astrology, such that one of our guest bloggers, Ben Kavoussi, once referred to it as “astrology with needles.” Indeed, it’s pretty clear that acupuncture was likely an offshoot of bloodletting.
Kavoussi also noted a lot of other things about the history of acupuncture that acupuncture advocates forget. For instance, although needling is often cited in the Yellow Emperor’s Canon of Medicine, relatively little has been written about it elsewhere and that, reportedly, by the middle of the second millennium, the practice had been largely abandoned, with Chinese and other Asian societies actually taking steps to eliminate it, even by outlawing it. Indeed, by 1757 a book documenting the history of Chinese medicine called acupuncture a “lost art.” For example, in 1822 an edict banned its practice and teaching from the Imperial Medical Institute in China, and the practice was banned in Japan in 1876 and finally outlawed in China in 1929. Then in the 1930s a Chinese pediatrician named Cheng Dan’an proposed that needling therapy be resurrected because now its actions could be explained through neurology. He also replaced the previously used coarse needles with the fine filiform needles in use today.
If you want to read what acupuncture was like over 100 years ago, read Harriet Hall’s review of a book by a Scottish surgeon Dugald Christie, who was stationed in China from 1883 to 1913. The descriptions feature children with needles left plunged deep in their bodies for days, including one who died. Of course, I’ve picked up the history of acupuncture beginning with the era of Chairman Mao Zedong, who basically retconned the history of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) and acupuncture and promoted it to the world, a promotion that is still going on today. This retconned version of the history of TCM, in which it is presented as a unified whole philosophy of medicine and acupuncture uses very fine needles, is what U. of M. is teaching. Never mind that acupuncture as we know it has existed for probably less than 100 years. No wonder there are so many varieties of acupuncture.
Let’s just say that if the module gets the history so wrong, opting for propaganda over actual history, I have grave doubts about the rest of it. I was not wrong to have them. For instance, qi is described pretty much as “energy” or the “vivifying force contained in (and circulating through) all natural phenomena and life forms” and as flowing “through these meridians in an organized fashion to provide nourishment and protection to the organism,” with acupuncture points described as “nodes” along the meridians that “serve as access gates or switches that send information and can influence internal physiologic processes.” There are also a lot of hand-waving “explanations” for how acupuncture “works” like this:
Since nerve conduction alone does not explain all biologically-related phenomena induced by acupuncture, new explanatory theories are emerging. One set of explanations include the cell to cell depolarization of electro-ionic shifts in sodium, potassium and calcium causing the stimulus to pass along tissue planes such as fascia. Additionally, small shifts in electro-magnetic potentials occur during acupuncture treatment that can accumulate to cause larger organ system responses once thought unlikely.
This is, of course, nonsense, as is the claim that acupuncture is good for a large number of conditions, such as those listed here. Apparently, the Department of Family Medicine doesn’t understand that acupuncture is nothing more than a theatrical placebo. It has no specific effects for anything or that “pulse diagnosis” is bogus—or that whenever you hear a quack make a statement like this, it’s nonsense:
Symptoms may worsen 24 hours after a treatment, followed by marked improvements, which usually signals a positive response.
Ugh.
Basically, there is no skepticism in the entire module. It’s taught the way that an acupuncturist would teach acupuncture. There isn’t even anything resembling a serious acknowledgement that science doesn’t support acupuncture. It’s just assumed that it works, and presumably that’s what family practice residents and medical students are learning.
I’ll have to go through the rest of the modules when I get a chance.
Quackademic medicine at the University of Michigan
It saddens me that even one department in the medical school that trained me has drunk deeply from the quackademic medicine firehose. I only reassure myself by telling myself that the department of surgery there is relatively free of this nonsense, as is (most) of the rest of the medical center. I only hope it doesn’t metastasize from the Department of Family Medicine.
Of course, it’s not just Michigan. I’ve been documenting for nearly 14 years the infiltration of quackademic medicine pseudoscience into some of the most prestigious medical schools and academic medical centers in the world, institutions as storied as Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, Georgetown, Harvard, Yale, and the University of Arizona. I’d be naïve indeed to think that my alma mater couldn’t fall prey to the same sort of pseudoscience. I reassure myself by noting that, as far as I can tell, it’s just one department and that my current institution, although not completely free of “integrative oncology” and “integrative medicine,” has a far smaller amount of it than a lot of the most prestigious medical schools in the country. I aim to do what I can as faculty to keep it that way.

Georgian College’s Homeopathy Program: Magical Thinking Presented as Fact
Georgian College in Ontario, Canada is now offering a 3-year advanced diploma in the pseudoscience of homeopathy.
Scott Gavura on January 25, 2018
Link

[Update as of February 9: Georgian College has cancelled its homeopathy program.]
When academic institutions teach nonsense, students suffer the most – not only have they wasted their tuition, but they’ve wasted their time. Georgian College is a community college in Ontario, Canada with over 11,000 students. It recently announced plans to offer a three-year diploma program in homeopathy. This announcement has understandably raised questions from critics about Georgian College’s educational standards. That’s because homeopathy as a health practice is pseudoscience, where the “treatments” lack any medicine at all. It is the air guitar of medicine: It goes through the motions of health care, and looks a bit like medicine, but actually accomplishes nothing at all.
Science and evidence is the basis of medicine today
Evidence-based medicine is a (relatively) new model for health care delivery. Medicine was very different just 100 years ago. Formal medical education had varying standards before 1910. That changed when the American Medical Association commissioned Abraham Flexner to evaluate American and Canadian medical education and make recommendations on their improvement. Flexner was highly critical of the education standards he observed, and recommended consolidating schools, increasing education prerequisites, enhancing the scientific rigor, and embedding the role of research in education. Flexner was also highly critical of dubious “alternative medical practices” and recommended the closure of under-performing institutions that continued to offer education and training based on principles other than science.
The effects of the Flexner report on medical education and the practice of medicine (and affiliated health professions, like pharmacy) can’t be overstated. Medical education became grounded in a rigorous foundation of science, and schools abandoned unscientific practices like naturopathy, homeopathy, chiropractic, and osteopathy. The result is the medical education and the medical standards you see today. Of course, the purveyors and supporters of these now-rejected practices never fully disappeared. They retreated, regrouped, and fought back, continuing to seek the public legitimacy and credibility now offered to medicine and its related health professions. Over time, these practices became known “alternative” medicine, and eventually, “complementary and alternative” medicine (CAM). Today, CAM is often called “integrative” medicine. The branding of alternative medicine as “integrative” or “holistic” is a marketing tactic, but the reality hasn’t changed. There is still no need to adopt or accept practices into medicine that are not grounded in high-quality science, as this (still current) 1998 editorial pointed out:
There is no alternative medicine. There is only scientifically proven, evidence-based medicine supported by solid data or unproven medicine, for which scientific evidence is lacking. Whether a therapeutic practice is “Eastern” or “Western,” is unconventional or mainstream, or involves mind-body techniques or molecular genetics is largely irrelevant except for historical purposes and cultural interest. We recognize that there are vastly different types of practitioners and proponents of the various forms of alternative medicine and conventional medicine, and that there are vast differences in the skills, capabilities, and beliefs of individuals within them and the nature of their actual practices. Moreover, the economic and political forces in these fields are large and increasingly complex and have the capability for being highly contentious. Nonetheless, as believers in science and evidence, we must focus on fundamental issues—namely, the patient, the target disease or condition, the proposed or practiced treatment, and the need for convincing data on safety and therapeutic efficacy.– Phil B. Fontanarosa & George D. Lundberd
Dilutions of grandeur: The history of homeopathy
I’ve discussed homeopathy several times before, and will refer curious reader here if you want more. Among all the forms of alternative medicine, homeopathy is possibly the most implausible of them all. Homeopathy is based on the idea that “like cures like”, in that a small dose of what causes a symptom can actually cure that symptom. Like-cures-like is simply sympathetic magic, a pre-scientific belief that was first described by anthropologist Sir James George Frazer in his 1890 book, The Golden Bough. In the book, Fraser outlined the two components of sympathetic magic:
If we analyse the principles of thought on which magic is based, they will probably be found to resolve themselves into two: first, that like produces like, or that an effect resembles its cause; and, second, that things which have once been in contact with each other continue to act on each other at a distance after the physical contact has been severed. The former principle may be called the Law of Similarity, the latter the Law of Contact or Contagion.
The so-called “Law of Contagion” underlies societal preoccupations with pseudoscientific ideas such as “detox” and “eating clean“. Sympathetic magic is the entire basis for the homeopathic belief system:
    • Like-cures-like: in homeopathy, a substance that is believed to cause a symptom, is diluted to treat that same symptom. Any substance is thought to be an effective remedy if it’s diluted enough: cancer, boar testicles, crude oil, oxygen, skim milk, even vacuum cleaner dust or moonlight can be a homeopathic remedy. Deciding which substances will cure which symptoms is determined by a process called a “proving” which is equally without any scientific basis. (Here are homeopathic provings for the Berlin Wall remedy and also sunlight reflected off the planet Saturn, to give you an example of the how the remedies are created by homeopaths.)
    • Water has a memory: the more you dilute the substance, the more powerful its effect. And when I say dilute, I mean dilute. The 30C “potency” is a common dilution used in homeopathy – that’s a dilution of 10-60. You would have to give two billion doses per second, to six billion people, for 4 billion years, to deliver a single molecule of the original, pre-diluted material. The result is that most homeopathic remedies are completely inert, and don’t contain a single molecule of what’s on the label. Whether bottled as a liquid or dripped onto lactose and sold as tablets, they are pure placebo.
Samuel Hahnemann invented the practice of homeopathy, based on the ideas of sympathetic magic, in the early 1800s. Hahnemann attempted to position homeopathy as a separate and more effective form of medicine compared to conventional medical practices. Given homeopathy is an elaborate placebo system, homeopathy probably was safer than medical practice at the time, which was still based around the idea of the four humors and was referred to as “heroic medicine” because of the dramatic treatments used and effects they caused. Eventually, germ theory emerged, ideas of humors disappeared, as did the elements of vitalism and magic, and medicine slowly turned towards a scientific model based on objective observations. Homeopathy, on the other hand, has never progressed or evolved based on evidence, because it was never based on evidence to begin with. Its practices today are frozen in the same beliefs from the 1800s.
Homeopathy is ineffective
Despite the implausibility of homeopathy, and its ejection from the practice of medicine, it retained some popularity over time, with a resurgence in the past few decades as an “alternative” medical system. Rigorous clinical trials confirm what basic science predicts: homeopathy’s effects are placebo effects. While there are plenty of clinical trials that show homeopathy is associated with positive clinical effects, they are always small, poorly controlled, and often biased. Two of the more recent comprehensive reviews of the evidence are the 2010 Evidence Check from the United Kingdom’s House of Commons Science and Technology Committee and the 2014 Australian National Health and Medical Research Council review, the latter of which made the following conclusion:
Based on the assessment of the evidence of effectiveness of homeopathy, NHMRC concludes that there are no health conditions for which there is reliable evidence that homeopathy is effective.Homeopathy should not be used to treat health conditions that are chronic, serious, or could become serious. People who choose homeopathy may put their health at risk if they reject or delay treatments for which there is good evidence for safety and effectiveness. People who are considering whether to use homeopathy should first get advice from a registered health practitioner. Those who use homeopathy should tell their health practitioner and should keep taking any prescribed treatments. The National Health and Medical Research Council expects that the Australian public will be offered treatments and therapies based on the best available evidence.
That’s not all. Edzard Ernst has compiled a list of twelve different statements on homeopathy from international or national organizations, all of which make a similar point: Homeopathy lacks plausibility, and has not been shown to be effective.
Georgian College’s homeopathy program
With this in mind, you might wonder how a post-secondary community college like Georgian College can possibly justify a three year diploma program what is essentially magical thinking. Yet it does:
The graduate has reliably demonstrated the ability to:– practice in a professional and competent manner within the defined scope of practice and consistent with the current legislations and standards of practice;– critically analyze and administer treatment using established homeopathic principles, theories and methodologies;– select, formulate and dispense homeopathic medicines in accordance with homeopathic principles, practices and regulatory criteria;– implement safe and effective client care and practice management consistent with the ethical and professional standards;– integrate interdisciplinary knowledge for the effective provision of client care and promotion of interprofessional collaboration;– communicate effectively in educating clients, families, the community and the broader healthcare field about the benefits and efficacy of homeopathy;– provide respectful and culturally sensitive care to clients in the homeopathic clinical setting;– implement and advocate environmental sustainability and best practices relevant to the profession;– establish a plan for lifelong learning and professional development;– apply entrepreneurial strategies to create and respond to new opportunities.
The entire three-year curriculum is posted:
Mandatory CoursesBIOL1036 Human Health Systems and BiochemistryBIOL2008 Human PathophysiologyBUSI3007 Business Principles for the Regulated ProfessionalHLTH1005 Holistic NutritionHLTH1006 Holistic Nutrition and Lifestyle ManagementHOMP1000 Foundations of HomeopathyHOMP1001 Professional Practice and JurisprudenceHOMP1002 Introduction to Materia MedicaHOMP1003 Introduction to Case TakingHOMP1004 Homeopathic RepertoryHOMP2000 Materia Medica 2HOMP2001 Physical Examination and Emergency MedicineHOMP2002 Repertorization and Case AnalysisHOMP2003 Homeopathy Therapeutics 1HOMP2005 Conventional and Herbal MedicinesHOMP2006 Materia Medica 3HOMP2007 Homeopathic DispensaryHOMP2008 Homeopathy Therapeutics 2HOMP3000 Homeopathy Therapeutics 3HOMP3001 Homeopathy Therapeutics 4HOMP3002 Homeopathy Practice ManagementHOMP3003 Environmental MedicineHOMP3005 Contemporary Integrative MedicineHOMP3006 Research MethodologiesHOMP3007 Preparation for Provincial RegulationPSYL1001 Introduction To Psychology
ClinicalsHOMP1005 Clinical ObservationsHOMP2004 Clinical Grand RoundsHOMP2009 Clinical Case ManagementHOMP3004 Clinical InternshipHOMP3008 Clinical Internship Advanced
The curriculum embraces homeopathy’s root principles:
HOMP1000 Foundations of Homeopathy 84.0 HoursIn this course, students are introduced to the philosophy, fundamental principles and theories of classical homeopathy. Samuel Hahnemann’s Organon of the Medical Art forms the basis of discussion and analysis. A historical overview of homeopathy highlights significant contributions by prominent figures in the profession. Foundational concepts – including the law of similars, totality of symptoms, provings, minimum doses, miasms, direction of cure and potentization – provide the framework for the remainder of the program.
Emphasis added.
It appears the curriculum will give students the impression they can use homeopathy to treat acute conditions, as well as trauma:
HOMP2003 Homeopathy Therapeutics 1 42.0 HoursIn this course, students examine the etiology, pathogenesis, symptomatology and therapeutics associated with traumatology, acute conditions, dermatology and musculoskeletal disorders. Homeopathic medicines are examined and compared in the context of their clinical application in relationship to specific diseases. Polycrests as well as smaller remedies are studied. The concept of prophylactic homeopathy is discussed. Rubrics, modalities and approaches for differential diagnoses are reviewed.
There’s that strange term, “homeopathic medicines”.
And yes, the curriculum include homeopathic nosodes, which are efficacy-free products sold as “alternatives” to vaccines but offer no protection from infection.
HOMP3001 Homeopathy Therapeutics 4 42.0 HoursIn this course, students study mental and emotional health issues, palliative care, epidemics and the emergence of modern society’s environmentally generated diseases. The role of the homeopath in interdisciplinary and complex care is examined. Special attention is given to guidelines, communication strategies and safety precautions associated with the treatment of these specialty areas. The role of nosodes is discussed.
Let’s hope it’s made clear to these students that there is no “role” for nosodes, which are not a substitute for actual vaccination. Regrettably, anti-vaccine homeopaths are not uncommon.
I could easily go through the entire syllabus course-by-course, but there’s no need for a trip down that rabbit hole. It’s remarkable that it will take Georgian College three years to fully train students to be ill-equipped to deliver health care.
Conclusion: Wasted time and dollars on homeopathy
It’s disappointing to see academic institutions like Georgian College offer programs in homeopathy, where student might be led to believe homeopathy has something meaningful to offer patients and the broader community. Ignoring the evidence, it has created a three year course in what is essentially magical thinking, with a curriculum based on ideas that have no basis in fact. Every dollar spent by Georgian College students on its homeopathy diploma program will be a dollar wasted, that could have been otherwise directed towards a more meaningful and credible health career. It’s easy to ignore and even dismiss endeavors like this one as fringe activities offered by colleges putting revenue ahead of evidence. But programs like this will create graduates ill-equipped and potentially without the insight to recognize they’ve been taught nonsense. People like ex-naturopath Britt Marie Hermes, who recognized her education hadn’t prepared her to provide credible health care, are rare. Let’s hope that prospective students do their due diligence and show more critical thinking than Georgian College has.

   Is medical academia just following academia?
Wallace Sampson
Links
Is Medical Academia repeating Academia’s history? In a recent essay in a small-circulation, specialized periodical, Academic Questions, Prof. John M. Ellis, emeritus Professor of Literature at the University of California, Santa Cruz, recounts the past 4-5 decades of changes in liberal arts departments in US colleges. (How Preferences Have Corrupted Higher Education, Acad Quest, 2008; 21(2):265-274) One modern academic controversy not needing recounting is the takeover of liberal arts departments by post-modernist theology and the partial takeover of universities themselves by radical politics dating from the 1960s. But as recounted by Prof. Ellis, the fifty-year metamorphosis has not only changed universities, but has produced a branching network of intended and unintended consequences.
We have noted before that medicine is both a science and a practice that reflects current social attitudes and mores. (I minimize the aliquot of art, persisting from prior centuries; cultural influences being a more accurate term.) But the changes in universities now reflect in the normative thinking and mores of the modern medical school – at least a nucleus of them. Thus Dr. Ellis’s observations may be a metaphor or template for a medicine of the next several decades.
Medicine’s cultural roots anchor in recent as well as distant history. In the distant past, pre-scientific medicine was based in Greek philosophies and proto-religions with concepts such as miasms, humours, opposites, balances, and ideas of reference and similars. Recent influences include the Soviet –Marxist based Lysenkoist theories that set back Russian genetics for decades, the People’s Republic of China’s politicization of traditional Chinese medicine, and of course the racial theories of the 1930s that justified brutal practices in Axis-occupied Europe. Today’s American pluralistic system of private, group, and public care systems reflects the heterogeneity and conflicts of American political thought. Prof. Ellis now documents a trail of developments in universities, set in motion by a beneficent but planned social movement - racial and ethnic preferential admissions policies to aid social and economic mobility - in the cause of a better society, free and egalitarian.
Yet the trail has left a network of forks and alleyways of consequences. In this segment I want to outline the academic community’s trail as recorded by Dr. Ellis. Readers can use their imaginations in drawing correlations to today’s climates in many medical schools. The two sets are not identical. Different mechanisms and motivations drive the two sets of changes. Overlapping areas are only partial and others may seem unrelated. But there is enough similarity to take away some lessons and to stimulate thought. The main lesson is not to oppose movement toward equality and fairness, but to try to predict consequences and dangers of manipulating normalized social structures.
Dr. Ellis outlines the following steps. Numbering is mine but the sequence is Dr. Ellis’s. Direct quotes are in italics.
1. This story of the series of changes initiated by [admission and hiring by minority] preferences begins in the 1970s, as pressure slowly grew for colleges and universities to admit more minority and women students, and to hire more minority and women faculty. 
2. Soon this pressure became intense, and every new faculty appointment was expected to help increase the numbers of minority and women faculty. Many departments began to do what was expected of them, and in the humanities and social sciences almost all did.
3. Implementing the concept of diversity led to use of diversity as the primary selection indicator for applicants.
4. Once a significant or “critical” level of like-thinking faculty was reached, political belief replaced academic curiosity, imagination, and excellence as primary qualification. And so we now have the first major unintended consequence of preferences in faculty hiring: as the number of these new appointees mounted, the entire political complexion of the faculty was slowly tilted, not to the left, but to the radical left.
5. When the nucleus of new faculty feel constrained by policies of their departments, accordingly they soon press for new departments of their own where they will make their own rules—not academic ones. New departments of women’s studies, black studies, ethnic studies, and others like them soon arise.
6. New departments needed additional faculty to staff them, which meant still more political radicals added to the faculty, and ever greater campus influence for radicalism.
7. Even so, they were still very far from a majority, and so one might have expected their influence to be limited, especially since they were out of step with the values of the rest of the academy. But in point of fact that was precisely why they were so effective. Their behavior was so unlike that of academics that administrations and faculty alike were completely unprepared for dealing with them.
8. The unintended consequences of preferences had now developed through the initial stage of simply more radicalism on campus, on to separate radical departments and finally to major radical influence on campus—which meant that something that was completely out of step with the core values of academic life had now gained considerable influence over it.
9. Another major unintended consequence of preferences is a transformation of college administration. If you were to examine any speech made by a university president forty years ago, you would find that the word “Excellence” occurs with great frequency. That concept was the guiding light of the academy. If you made the same examination now, you’d find that the word “Diversity” has taken its place. That change has altered both the relationship between administration and faculty, and the pecking order within the faculty.
10. The obstacle to real educational progress for minorities that now surfaced had its roots in the fact that political radicals don’t look at the past and see accumulated knowledge and wisdom, nor do they look at their society with respect for its institutions and achievements. Their natural instinct is to denigrate society as it is and has been, in order to make the case for the sweeping social change that they think is necessary.
Substitute medical school models for the academic ones and one can see the similarities. Dr. Ellis was not writing about radical politics replacing a dominant political belief system, but of replacing an academic tradition that led to the Enlightenment, political advancement, the rise of reason and science, and evolution of functioning democracy with individual freedom. Now, if a reader were to substitute for “radicals,” terms like “CAM advocates” or “Integrative medicine,” and substitute an intention to change medicine to “more holistic,” to “humanize,” to “become more humanitarian and subjective,” and to “be less removed, cold, unreachable,” it’s like using an overlay map. Perhaps there is less to expand on than I thought might be necessary, because most people will have gotten it. We are in the early to middle phases of a “quiet revolution” leading to a wholesale change of what it means to be a physician, what the practice of medicine is, what evidence and proof are (see Steve Novella’s post of yesterday) and what the roles of rationality and science are.
One can anticipate a clanging of politically-inspired expletives and ad hominem accusations by some who might want to accuse such thinking as right-wingism. Yet the issue is real – is how direct political action in the name of ideological principles have the potential for repelling intellectual and rational advances. Recounting the rise of “CAM” observed through this historical lens will be not only obvious, but I hope enlightening, and a warning.

Quackademic medicine trickles out to community hospitals
David Gorski on June 11, 2012
Link
One of the major themes of this blog has been to combat what I, borrowing a term coined (as far as I can tell) by Dr. R. W. Donnell, like to refer to as “quackademic medicine.” Quackademic medicine is a lovely term designed to summarize everything that is wrong with the increasing embrace of so-called “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or, as it’s increasingly called now, “integrative medicine” (IM) into academic medical centers. CAM/IM now a required part of the curriculum in many medical schools, and increasingly medical schools and academic medical centers seem to be setting up IM centers and divisions and departments. Fueled by government sources, such as the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) and private sources, such as the Bravewell Collaborative (which has been covered extensively recently not just by me but by Kimball Atwood, Steve Novella, and Mark Crislip), academic medical centers are increasingly “normalizing” what was once rightly considered quackery, hence the term “quackademic medicine.” The result over the last 20 years has been dramatic, so much so that even bastions of what were once completely hard-core in their insistence on basing medicine in science can embrace naturopathy, Rudolf Steiner’s anthroposophic medicine, reiki and other forms of “energy healing,” traditional Chinese medicine, and even homeopathy, all apparently in a quest to keep the customer satisfied.
Of course, in a way, academia is rather late to the party. CAM has been showing up in clinics, shops, and malls for quite a while now. For example, when I recently traveled to Scottsdale to attend the annual meeting of the American Society of Breast Surgeons, I happened to stop in a mall looking for a quick meal at a food court and saw this:
Basically, it’s a massage and reflexology stand. I’ve seen its like popping up in many malls throughout the country. Some go beyond a stand in the middle of the mall and actually have a storefront in the mall. More recently, unfortunately, I been noting similar stands selling various forms of woo in malls, but with a difference. For example, last year over the Christmas holidays, we visited friends in Cleveland and, while doing a little shopping at Beachwood Place, we noticed this:
Yes, it’s the Cleveland Clinic’s “Wellness” Institute, which offers acupuncture, “holistic psychotherapy” (whatever that is), reiki, chiropractic, and many other CAM modalities. (Look upon the CCF’s reiki page and weep at the spiritualistic mumbo-jumbo that is used to justify using reiki.) Then, just last week, a Facebook friend posted this on my wall:
Yes, it’s the Mayo Clinic providing its CAM services in the Mall of America. If you take a look at Mayo’s CAM program, you’ll see that it offers a lot of the same things that the Cleveland Clinic offers, including supplements and botanicals, acupuncture, traditional Chinese medicine, Ayurvedic medicine, hypnosis, and meditation.
One of the more insidious consequences of the infiltration of pseudoscience into academia in the form of quackademic medicine is that it gives the imprimatur of science to modalities that can best be described as pseudoscience. When people start seeing highly respected names in academic medicine, institutions generally viewed as the leaders in advancing the frontiers of medicine, such as the Mayo Clinic and the Cleveland Clinic selling acupuncture and reiki in malls, what are they supposed to think? Most of them, trusting in these hallowed names, will conclude that this stuff must be OK. It must be scientific. It must work. After all, would the Mayo Clinic and the Cleveland Clinic put their names on services offering these modalities if they didn’t work? Would they be selling them in stands and shops in malls if they didn’t work?
Alas, regular readers know the true answers to those questions (“yes” and “why not?”), but few others do. Quite reasonably, the average consumer might conclude that this stuff is actually medicine rather than quackery. In fact, even non-academic community hospitals, which previously hadn’t offered much in the way of CAM services, might conclude that they should get in on the act. And they are. Let me tell you the story of one example that is, unfortunately, right here in my own state. It’s a disturbing little tale, particularly given that the vast majority of health care is delivered by private physicians, the vast majority of whom have their admitting privileges not at huge academic medical center conglomerates like the Cleveland Clinic and the Mayo Clinic, but rather at hospitals like Oaklawn Hospital in Battle Creek, MI.
Quackery infiltrates the heartland
It’s not new that quackery has been infiltrating the heartland. Indeed, naturopathy, for example, has been showing up in places as remote as rural Montana. However, up until now, most of the hard core quackery has been restricted to clinics and individual practices, with maybe a little of the “gateway woo” that many academic medical centers promote, such as massage, acupuncture, and various “mind-body” interventions, making it to community hospitals. Then, a while back, Ed Brayton of CFI-Michigan contacted me because a reporter had contacted him for the skeptical viewpoint of a story he was doing on Oaklawn Hospital’s new Holistic Center. Ed sent me this press release:
Oaklawn Hospital is pleased to announce the April 2nd opening of a holistic care center that is located at 15217 W. Michigan Avenue on their Bear Creek campus, a quarter-mile west of I-69. “Our vision is that Oaklawn Holistic Center will provide health care choices that offer complementary therapies that can integrate with conventional medicine to enhance healing and promote wellness,” said Oaklawn President & CEO Rob Covert.
Holistic medicine dates back thousands of years and is focused on therapies that treat the patient as a whole person, as opposed to mainly treating a particular symptom or ailment. Its techniques are centered on improving the body’s immune system and looks at an individual’s overall physical, mental, and emotional well-being before recommending treatment. The practice of holistic medicine does not rule out allopathic or conventional medicine, and the Oaklawn Holistic Center will work closely with Oaklawn primary care physicians to assure that their patients are receiving effective complementary care.
Martin Holmes, MD, of Oaklawn Medical Group-Albion is the Center’s medical director and Karla Anderson, RN, CNHP oversees the daily operations and treatments that come from nutritional therapists, massage therapists, naturopathic practitioners, and other practitioners of complementary treatments.
It’s all blather, of course, standard boilerplate about CAM that we’ve heard time and time again and that inspired Kimball Atwood to produce his infamous serious of posts under the title of the Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo. (In fact, I encourage you to do a W^5 “waluation” of this press release in the comments, along with commentary on the subject matter at hand.) Of course, I was more than happy to speak to the reporter, Andy Fitzpatrick of the Battle Creek Enquirer about this “holistic center.” I was even happier to do so after I read this part of the press release:
Anderson is a strong advocate of the holistic approach and using naturopathic therapies to strengthen the body’s immune system. “I’ve seen a lot of people turn to holistic medicine who suffered chronic ailments and were not experiencing much success through allopathic treatments. Often times these patients not only found relief for their chronic conditions, but found that other health problems improved as well due to improvement in the performance of their immune systems.” Naturopathic therapies emphasize using diet modification, nutritional supplements, herbal medicine, acupuncture, hydrotherapy, massage, joint manipulation, and lifestyle counseling.
The Center offers classes and treatment that include numerous modalities, initially specializing in Therapeutic Body Work, Functional Normalization, Pregnancy Massage, Trigger-point Therapy, Healing Touch, Reflexology, Migraine Headache Relief, Injury Rehabilitation, Essential Oil Massage, Hot stone Therapy, Lymphatic Drainage Therapy, Comprehensive Holistic Assessments, pH testing, Aromatherapy, Bach Flower Therapy, Loomis Digestive Health Assessments, Fastech Foot Forms, Ionic Foot Baths, Ear Candling, Natural Health Life Classes, Holistic Life Coaching Club, QiGong, and Live Foods.
My reaction after reading that last paragraph was stunned silence. I couldn’t believe that a reputable hospital would offer what I consider to be so much rank quackery. I was relieved, if you can call it that, that this center apparently doesn’t offer colon hydrotherapy or iridology. Yet. In any case, most hospitals are fairly careful. They offer modalities like acupuncture, for example, because they know that, if challenged, they can point to studies that seem to indicate that acupuncture works. We at SBM, of course, have written time and time again about how these studies do not show what advocates of acupuncture think they show and how acupuncture is almost certainly nothing more than an elaborate placebo. Usually, even the most die-hard quackademic institutions stay far away from the more hard core quackery for fear of damaging their reputations. Oh, sure, there are some academic centers that will delve into naturopathy and even occasionally homeopathy, but for the most part they tend to stick with the “safe” and (semi-)”respectable” CAM, such as meditation, massage, healing touch (and/or reiki, which is more or less the same thing), acupuncture, and maybe a few supplements here and there.
Not for Oaklawn Hospital is such a wimpy approach! Oh, no. Oaklawn has, for whatever reason, decided to offer what I consider to be some serious quackery to its patients. And I expressed my own amazement at this to Mr. Fitzpatrick, as I had never seen a hospital, academic or otherwise, offer ear candling. Ear candling, as you might recall, is a form of quackery in which a candle is inserted into the ear canal and lit. Supposedly, so it is claimed, this practice will “detoxify” by leeching out toxins, the better to relieve all manner of ailments, from sinus pressure and pain to vertigo to tinnitus to a number of other maladies. At the very least, it’s claimed to be able to remove ear wax. (It can’t.) Ear candling is pure quackery, of course, and potentially dangerous. How a reputable hospital could put its imprimatur on such a practice I’ll never know.
The same is true of ionic footbaths. These “detox footbaths” are infamous in the skeptical community. Basically, they involve putting electrodes in a salt water bath, having the patient put his feet in the bath, and then running a low level electric current through it. It is claimed that by doing this one can remove toxins, enhance the bioenergy (qi), realign the body’s energy field, increase vitality, and, of course, rid the body of toxins, chemicals, radiation, pollution, synthetics, and other foreign material trapped in the skin layers that have clogged up the body’s systems of elimination. But that’s not all! You might not believe this, little fella, but it’ll cure your asthma, too (or at least remove liver parasites). As “proof” that it works, they’ll often show you impressive pictures like this:
Wow! It really must work, right? What is all that nasty brown stuff showing up in the water? Ironically enough, one of the best deconstructions of this bit of quackery comes from, of all people, a denizen of CureZone, an alternative medicine online community:
I recently saw my wife and several friends get duped about supposed benefits of an Ionic Detoxification Unit. Don’t get suckered into buying or paying for a session in an ionic detoxification foot bath! Guess what, the water turns “toxic” colors whether your feet are in there or not, because it is just the corrosion of the electrodes that causes the water to change color. The manufacturer below says that “sales pitches” are used to make people think that different colors mean different toxins were ionically removed from the body through the soles of the feet; in reality it is just the results of passing an electric current between electrodes in a conductive solution of water. Their own studies (backed by other independent fraud investigation analyses) find only what you would expect to find in water where electrolysis took place, i.e., no “toxins” released from the body were found.
Think about it, how likely are your feet to start “leaking toxins”, if that happened then you’d find that happening in whirlpool spas etc. It doesn’t happen.
It turns out that the water changes color whether a person’s feet are in there or not. In fact, many manufacturers even admit this, but try to discount the fact that the change in water color is all due to electrolysis and claim that the exact shade of color indicates what organ is being effected or to argue, regardless of whether the water changes color or not, the feet are a great part of the body through which to “absorb negative ions.”
I could go on and on about how reflexology, pH testing, Bach flower remedies, aromatherapy, and the like are beyond utter nonsense, but regular readers already know this. Even so, I can’t help but note that even I didn’t know what Loomis digestive health assessments are. It didn’t take me long to find the Loomis Institute home page, and, let me tell you, I do think that a future post might be indicated on this, given that it appears to be a form of dietary pseudoscience that claims that dietary manipulations involving enzymes are the key to health.
In the meantime, I’d like to get to the article for which I was interviewed. Fitzpatrick did a decent job, but even with his known skeptical bent that led him to talk to CFI, his article turned out to fall too hard for the “tell both sides” trope that infects journalism. I have no way of knowing whether it was Fitzpatrick or his editor who was most responsible for this, but it is a frequent problem I see whenever journalists write about topics like the Oaklawn Holistic Center.
When “telling both sides” isn’t
The article appeared about a week ago in the Battle Creek Enquirer under the title Oaklawn Hospital gives alternative medicine a try: Holistic methods spark controversy. It starts out, as these stories often do, with a patient anecdote about a woman with lupus named Dorothy Height who believes that “holistic care” saved her life. It then proceeds to tell the tale of the center’s director, Dr. Martin Holmes, who gives his reasons for turning to CAM thusly:
Dr. Martin Holmes, the center’s director, said he’s been a family practice physician for about 40 years. However, he was struck by the number of patients who came to him that he couldn’t help by using only the skills and tools of what he calls an allopathic doctor.
Allopathy is a term used by those in the holistic or naturopath fields to refer to traditional, science-based medicine.
“I brought them the concept of going outside of the box of North American allopathic medicine, primarily giving evidence on essential oils, massage therapy, nutritional counseling, acupuncture, acupressure, which I use in my practice quite a bit, and, something I’ve recently learned, which is therapeutic qi- gong,” Holmes said.
You know, I don’t remember whether the issue of the use of the term “allopathy” ever came up in my interview, but if it did, I would have informed Mr. Fitzpatrick never to use that term. Why? It’s a derogatory term coined by the founder of that quackery of quackeries, homeopathy, to describe medicine that was not homeopathy; i.e., conventional medicine. The term is a false dichotomy. Unfortunately, it’s a false dichotomy that even too many science-based physicians accept. Be that as it may, Dr. Martin has fallen far down the rabbit hole of vitalism. Indeed, he explicitly calls qi the “life force,” and says that if you don’t have any qi, you’re “on the slab and you’re done.” Not surprisingly, he is also hostile to science-based medicine:
Holmes, of Oaklawn, described a reliance on double-blind, placebo-controlled studies a tragedy of mainstream medicine. In such a study, one group is given the treatment and another group is given a fake treatment without being told. These studies also account for the placebo effect; that is, an increase in health due to a reason other than being given a medication or procedure being tested.
“There are people who jump out of airplanes without parachutes who survive, and there are people who have jumped out of airplanes with parachutes who have not survived,” Holmes said. “There hasn’t been a placebo-controlled double-blind study (of parachutes), so we can’t in conscience give evidence that it’s better to jump out of a plane with a parachute.”
I’ll give Dr. Holmes credit for boldly stealing an example that skeptics and supporters of science-based medicine use to criticize the obsession of evidence-based medicine with only clinical trials. Indeed, this example is frequently used to criticize, what has been called methodolatry, or the profane worship of the randomized clinical trial as the only valid method of investigation. In fact, as Kimball Atwood has pointed out, the whole point of the analogy, which was used in an infamous BMJ article to ridicule the excesses of evidence-base medicine, is that there are some things that are so self-evident based on basic science considerations alone (such as the fact people without a parachute will reach terminal velocity and slam into the ground at a speed that is, except in very rare cases, incompatible with further life) that they do not need to be tested in randomized clinical trials. Ironically enough for Dr. Martin, other examples of such things that require no RCTs to dismiss include his reflexology, ear candling and several of the modalities he offers at his holistic center, because they are completely incompatible with well-established understandings of anatomy and physiology.
In addition, Karla Anderson, Dr. Holmes’ nurse, who also happens to be a naturopath, invokes placebo responses to claim that it’s impossible to test something like acupuncture using an RCT. This is a fallacy that we’ve dealt with time and time again, and it is quite possible to test such modalities using RCTs. what Anderson doesn’t like is that whenever treatments like acupuncture are tested in RCTs, they fail to do better than placebo. Particularly amusing is this little blurb:
Anderson added that in something such as acupuncture, which involves placing needles in the body’s various points that are believed by practitioners to be tied to a person’s well-being, a placebo-controlled study is impossible.
Even without doing a double-blind, placebo-controlled study, there is still real evidence for holistic practices to work, Anderson said. She said such evidence is on the Internet, although she did not specify any particular studies.
I declare a new logical fallacy: Argumentum ad Internetium!
Among the proponents of these modalities interviewed by Mr. Fitzpatrick, another popular argument is the argument from antiquity that says that the fact that these remedies have been around a long time means that they must work. In all fairness, Fitzpatrick did let us skeptics have our say. In particular, we refuted the argument to antiquity, pointed out how many of these treatments are pure quackery, and tried to answer the special pleading that whines that these treatments can’t be tested in RCTs. But we’re up against it when we come across statements like this from NCCAM that state unequivocally that acupuncture can relieve pain, as well as nausea and vomiting after surgery, when the state of the evidence is anything but that, and it is certain that acupuncture effects are anything above and beyond placebo effects.
All of which brings us back to the beginning.
I started this post by lamenting how when academic medical centers like the Mayo Clinic and the Cleveland Clinic start not only studying “alternative” medicine but embracing it to the point where they sell it in malls their aura of science and respectability encompasses the quackery they sell. Clinics offering various pseudoscientific treatments have existed for a long time and would probably exist regardless of whether quackademia existed or not. They do not depend upon their respectability and reputation to attract marks patients in the same way that community hospitals do. Moreover, the latest innovations in treatment tend to be developed in academic medical centers and then, over time, filter out first to the larger community hospitals and then to even smaller community hospitals that have the resources. Unfortunately, the “innovation” of “integrative medicine” appears to be following that pattern just as much as the latest surgical breakthrough or latest form of chemotherapy does. From my perspective, I very much doubt that Oaklawn Hospital would be willing to offer so much pure quackery to its patients if it weren’t for institutions like the Mayo Clinic, Cleveland Clinic, Harvard, Stanford, and many others paving the way.
It is only part of the harm that quackademic medicine does.

   When “CAM” is mandatory: A science-based medical student’s dilemma
David Gorski
Link
Early in the history of this blog, I wrote a rather long post expressing my dismay at the infiltration of unscientific “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or “integrative medicine” (IM) modalities into American medical schools. In it, I listed the medical schools that had embraced pseudoscience through having started a CAM/IM program (a list desperately in need of an update). Moreover, we have also complained vociferously here about a clear effort on the part of advocates of faith-based medicine to infiltrate bastions of science-based medicine and to piggyback their agenda onto President Obama’s health care reform initiative in a clear political strategy to slip CAM/IM into any health care reform legislation as a form of “preventative medicine.” It’s all part of a multi-pronged strategy to claim popular and legal legitimacy in the absence of scientific legitimacy. At one point I even despaired because of the apparent success of half physician, half CAM huckster Dr. Andrew Weil at developing a CAM/IM curriculum that would be part of the mandatory training program in several family medicine residencies, while the rest of us watch Senator Tom Harkin try to promote pseudoscience in the halls of the Senate.
However, since one of our newest co-bloggers, medical student Tim Kreider, arrived, I’ve come to appreciate that medical schools and medical school curriculae are ground zero in the battle for science- and evidence-based medicine. Besides the infiltration of non-science-based modalities into the standard curriculum, another technique for making medical students believe that woo is equal to science is the student “campus CAM group” that invites, for example, homeopaths and naturopaths to give talks to medical students, too many of whom are too timid to challenge them on their pseudoscience. However, a reader of a “friend” of mine wrote me an e-mail that truly appalled me. In fact, it appalled not just me, but all of my co-bloggers who read it. It’s from a medical student in an American medical school. It’s not Harvard or a huge famous medical school. However, it is in medical schools like this one where the vast majority of medical students are trained in this country. If the infiltration of CAM/IM into medical schools continues in this way, we’ll have more than just “integrating” woo into the medical school curriculum from day one. We’ll have more tales like this; eventually, no one will find such tales unusual or even unacceptable anymore. The shruggies will no longer even shrug anymore. Such clinics will become simply the way medical students are educated. The following e-mail is de-identified, and I’ve edited it a bit to make as sure as I can that it is not traceable:
Dear Dr. Gorski,
I’m a third-year medical student going through my clinical rotations. The particular outpatient site I’m at promotes woo. A few of the attendings practice acupuncture, conduct OMM [osteopathic manipulative medicine] clinics, and just started to offer cupping. Sadly, most of the attendings recommend CAM therapies to patients, the residents incredulously try them out, and I know they’ve recently Matched fourth-year students because this program promotes woo. Laughingly, an attending actually lectured us on how to use acupuncture to control post-partum bleeding!
Unfortunately, I’ve been assigned to participate in acupuncture clinic. I feel like a fraud to these patients and I despise being part of this sham. I’ve already been asked “where I stand” on the issue of CAM. As practicing physician I could choose to not hire someone who’d inflict CAM on patients, or as a professor I could fight to de-fund CAM departments, but as a student, I can’t speak up without the real risk of ruining my grade. What do you think I should do?
If you choose to use this email as part of a post, then please de-identify it.
Thank you for your advice.
Student X
First off, Student X deserves kudos for his realization that being asked to participate in an acupuncture clinic is in essence being asked to subject patients to unscientific, religion-based, placebo medicine that has never been convincingly shown to be more efficacious than a placebo for any condition.
Next, I’m sure most readers of this blog will be as disturbed as I was to read this. At least I hope so. None of these therapies are science- or evidence-based. We’ve discussed why acupuncture is nothing more than placebo medicine on many occasions, although we haven’t discussed OMM at all. OMM is the aspect of osteopathic medicine that most resembles chiropractic, in that it postulates that realigning bones and muscles can somehow cure all manner of ills by physiologically dubious mechanisms. Although it’s still taught in most osteopathic medical schools, it’s more as a historical footnote, and few D.O.’s practice OMM anymore. That’s one reason why D.O.’s have over the years become virtually indistinguishable from M.D.’s, which to me is a very good thing indeed. In fact, the best surgical intensivist I’ve ever had the pleasure to work with is a D.O., and I’ve worked with excellent oncologists who are also D.O.’s. My overall impression is that science-based D.O.’s are somewhat embarrassed by these vestigial aspects of osteopathy, but clearly some osteopathic doctors still practice OMM. Some even practice a form of osteopathy called either “cranial osteopathy,” “craniosacral therapy,” “cranial therapy,” or similar names. Practitioners of these methods claim, as chiropracters claim for the spine, that the skull bones can be manipulated to relieve pain and remedy many other ailments. Worse, they claim that there is a “rhythm” in the flow of the cerebrospinal fluid and that diseases are characterized by changes in this rhythm, which can be used to diagnose many diseases, and that these abnormalities in this “rhythim” can be corrected by manipulating the skull. Student X didn’t mention whether any of these practitioners practiced craniosacral osteopathy.
Finally, before moving on to advice (such as it is) I have to point out that cupping is pure quackery. It is a method from traditional Chinese medicine that involves heating the air within a cup and then placing it on the skin so that it is drawn into the cup as the air within cools. There are two varieties: dry cupping, which involves just the cupping, and “wet” cupping, which involves puncturing the skin before applying the cup over it. “Wet” cupping is said to “draw the toxins out” while all forms of cupping are claimed, like acupuncture, to “unblock” or “realign” the flow of qi and thus restore health. It has no role in science-based medicine and should especially have no role in the education of medical students, which is why I was horrified that students anywhere in the U.S. are being taught about it as thought it were a legitimate therapy.
So what should Student X do? Before I answer, let me briefly summarize what else I learned in my e-mail exchange with him. He’s already midway through the rotation; so leaving or changing rotations is not really an option. Also, he was not aware until recently that he would be assigned to the acupuncture clinic. Finally, he has assured me that this is the only site affiliated with his medical school where students are assigned to an outpatient rotation where, as he put it, the “woo runs free.” Being the cancer surgeon that I am, I can’t help but use an analogy here. It sounds to me as though the cancer needs to be cut out of this school before the “woo runs free” to the point where it invades and metastasizes elsewhere and endangers what Student X assures me is an otherwise very supportive, science- and evidence-based medical school. Indeed, I extensively searched the medical school’s website and was unable to find anything about the clinic described. All I found was that one faculty member has an NCCAM grant to study natural products and that one faculty member had finished an “integrative medicine fellowship” before joining the faculty. In that, at least on the surface, there would appear to be less woo at Student X’s school than now exists at my alma mater. Finally, Student X, although not going into the specialty of the Woo Clinic (which is what I will call it from now on) where he is currently rotating, does not feel that he can risk burning bridges, as he needs favorable evaluations.
Back to what to do. Every fiber of my being wants to tell Student X to go to the dean and complain forthwith about the infiltration of quackademic medicine into his medical school. However, I appreciate his situation, and do not wish to give him advice that’s going to land him in a world of hurt, even though fiber of my being also wants to try to get Student X to give me permisison to name names, to call out his medical school right here on this very blog. Unfortunately, Student X informs me that the dean censors anything said by medical students on blogs or online forums that might bring the medical school into disrepute. Were I to name his medical school and it ever became known who had complained to me, the consequences are likely to be unpleasant. Given that it is known who’s rotating at the Woo Clinic right now, it wouldn’t be too hard for his dean to figure out who had complained to me, especially if he had answered honestly the question of “where do you stand on CAM?” So, I will not reveal the medical school.
That being said, regardless of the dean, the very first step Student X needs to take now is to gather as much information as he can. He needs to document everything: every dubious therapy recommended, every credulous statement, every bit of advocacy of unscientific therapy, and every instance of outright quackery. If the clinic has fliers on various CAM/IM modalities that it hands out to patients, he should collect them as evidence. If the clinic has published handouts, outlines, and notes that it uses to teach medical students about CAM/IM (particularly cupping), he should save those, because if he ultimately does complain he will need as much ammunition as he can get. This very blog and various other sites, such as QuackWatch, can provide material and scientific studies showing how discredited these therapies are. If this all blows up, more documentation is better to cover his behind. What critics of unscientific practices in medical often find out is that most of the faculty has essentially zero idea what is actually being done and taught. When they are informed of exactly what “cupping” is, for instance, they are often appalled that such woo is being taught in their medical school to medical students. Ditto reiki, homeopathy, and a lot of the other “woo-iest of the woo” that falls under the CAM/IM rubric. The best tool to educate shruggies, who refuse to believe that anyone would believe, much less teach, such mystical pseudoscientific nonsense is to show them exactly what is being taught to students in the very words of the CAM/IM practitioners. That is often more than damning enough evidence.
The second step is for Student X to find out if there are other students who agree with him and then to hook up with them. Indeed, he should go beyond that and find out if there are other faculty members in the department to which that outpatient clinic belongs who are concerned about the woo being taught to the medical students alongside scientific medicine. In fact, he should go beyond even that and find out whether there are any faculty in the medical school, period, who are proponents of science-based medicine and willing to take a look at the situation. In other words, he needs to find first those who are not shruggies first and network with them. That has to be done before there is any hope of changing the minds of the shruggies. The dean could easily ignore the voice of one lone medical student, but he could not so easily ignore the voices of several medical students if they are backed up by even a handful of faculty–or even just one senior influential faculty member. Ideally, he should seriously consider writing up a letter of complaint to the dean and getting as many signatures as he can on it. Having discussed this case with my cobloggers, I believe I can say with some confidence that all of us would also sign such a letter; indeed, we’d help Student X draft it.
As I’ve thought about this case over the weekend, I completely understand Student X’s reticience about speaking out. Quite frankly, I don’t know if I would have had the intestinal fortitude to have spoken out about an issue like this when I was in medical school. Fortunately for me, that was over 20 years ago, and the infiltration of CAM/IM had not yet become an issue. Indeed, I don’t remember its even being on the radar screen back then. In that, I and other physicians of my generation were fortunate; we weren’t put to the test. However, now, if we are not yet being tested, we soon will be. With NCCAM providing the cloak of undeserved legitimacy to these modalities, it is hard to speak out without being labeled as “close-minded” or even “bigoted,” given how many of these modalities are part of traditional Chinese medicine, Ayurvedic, or indigenous populations, usually mixed in with the usual appeal to ancient wisdom, a logical fallacy if ever there was one. These charges are a powerful blunt instrument to beat the critics of CAM/IM over the head with, which is why we must acquire thick skins to handle them. My counterargument is to ask why ancient Chinese or Indian medicines should be held to a lower standard as far as evidence goes than ancient Western medicine, like bloodletting and purging with toxic metals, which were ultimately abandoned based on science.
Finally, even as understanding as I am about Student X’s position, I’m going to point out that silence is acquiescence. If no one speaks out, the problem will only continue and likely get worse. The woo will spread and metastasize to other areas of Student X’s medical school. Unfortunately, speaking out can have consequences, but if there’s one thing I’ve learned it’s that CAM/IM infiltration thrives best when it’s under the radar. When the light is shined on CAM practitioners in academia and exactly what they do, they usually do not like it, and, unfortunately, their first reaction is often to try to attack the messenger. However, it is on the frontlines, such as the clinic where Student X is currently assigned, where the battle for science-based medicine in academia will be lost or won.
That is why we at SBM will help any medical student who asks us in whatever way we are able. If that includes writing letters, talking to program directors or deans, or even (if it can be pulled off), arranging for one or more of us to come to give talks at medical schools where students are being subjected to rotations teaching them pseudoscientific medicine along with scientific medicine, then we will do that when we can if asked. If it consists only of advising medical students who are science-based and object to the infiltration of pseudoscience into their medical schools on tactics to slow down or stop the CAM/IM train, we will do that as well. We also ask any faculty of medical schools who will support us in this effort to contact me or Steve. You can either do so by publicly leaving a comment below or e-mailing either of us at the e-mail addresses in the Contact tab above. If it’s feasible, you could even become more active by attending the Science-Based Medicine conference in July and networking with like-minded physicians and scientists. There’s nothing like a little face time to build relationships and alliances.
I now conclude with a request. First, of my fellow SBM co-bloggers, I request your input and that you chime in with your advice to Student X. Second, of our readers, I request the same thing. I also open the comments to any medical students or faculty who may have had a similar experience to that of Student X. It would be better if you used your real name, but I understand if you, like Student X, don’t feel comfortable doing that; you may register under a pseudonym if you like. We at SBM will never “out” you unless you give us permission to do so. Look at this post as a springboard to begin the process of organizing. We at SBM want this blog to be more than just a blog; we want it to be a clearinghouse, the beginning of a movement, a hub where like-minded supporters of science- and evidence-based medicine can gather. The CAM/IM revolution has gone frighteningly far; it’s long past time for the counterrevolution for science- and evidence-based medicine to begin.
Who’s with me?

Quackademic medicine update: UC Irvine reneges on promise of scientific rigor
In 2017, UC Irvine promised that the Susan Samueli Integrative Health Institute would be “rigorously evidence-based”. A recent review discovers plenty of pseudoscience.
Jann Bellamy on February 27, 2020
Link

A little over two years ago, Henry and Susan Samueli, wealthy patrons of medical pseudoscience, gave $200 million to the University of California Irvine (UCI) to establish the eponymous Samueli College of Health Sciences. But the gift came with some troubling strings attached: most of the money goes to so-called “integrative medicine”, including up to 15 faculty chairs and training for medical students. As a part of this package deal, the existing Susan Samueli Center, which offered homeopathy and other alternative treatments, became the Susan Samueli Integrative Health Institute (SSIHI).
The gift’s size and emphasis on “integrative medicine”, coupled with the Samuelis’ penchant for quackery, engendered a sharp response from adherents to science-based medicine and some bad press. SBM’s own Drs. David Gorski and Steve Novella were quoted in several articles criticizing UCI for accepting tainted money. They wrote their own SBM blog posts on the subject as well, appropriately calling it out as “quackademic medicine”.
Steve told the Los Angeles Times that it was “an absolute failure of academia to allow this to happen” and STAT that the gift “puts the imprimatur of a university on things that have been discredited as medical fraud for 50 years”. He pointed out that the term “integrative” makes little sense:
You have to ask what are they integrating? Are they integrating things that don’t work. If it worked, we wouldn’t need to integrate it – it would already be part of the system.
Or, as David put it to STAT, more bluntly:
The only reason “integrative medicine” exists is to integrate quackery into medicine.
And:
It’s been said that what’s good about integrative medicine not unique, and what’s unique about it is not good.
Exactly.
UCI’s medical brass pushed back hard against these criticisms. In addition to the usual appeals to “open-mindedness” and attempts to window dress integrative medicine as “holistic” and being about nutrition and exercise, they swore up and down that unproven treatments would never, ever darken the door of the UC Irvine Susan Samueli Integrative Health Institute.
Dr. Howard Federoff, the university’s vice chancellor for health affairs, told various publications at the time:
The teaching, research, and treatment funded via the Samueli endowment will be rigorously evidence-based.
We are not going to promulgate things that have been established to be ineffective.
There’s nothing I would ever allow in the context of clinical care if I believed the clinical evidence was lacking.
My promise [to the Samuelis] all along is that we will collect the best evidence.
Any non-proven or non-evidence based approach? We will not deploy it.
UCI med school professor Dr. Jay Gargus added that the idea that the med school was going to become a home of “witchcraft” is “just not going to be the case . . . We’re only going to be doing evidenced-based medicine.”
Recently, serendipitously, an internet search just happened to land me on the UCI’s Susan Samueli Integrative Health Institute website. It sounded familiar. A quick search brought me to (where else?) SBM and refreshed my memory. This, I thought, presented the perfect opportunity to have a look around SSIHI and see if UCI stuck to its evidence-based guns.
So, what did I find? Let’s start with the witchcraft.
Mayan abdominal therapy
Under the massage therapy offerings, we find:
Arvigo Techniques or Mayan Abdominal Therapy: This technique addresses the position and health of the pelvic and abdominal organs, and is widely known for its ability to correct prolapsed uterus, fallen uterus, tilted uterus, premenstrual symptom, menopause and the relief of many digestive disorders.
The Arvigo® Techniques of Maya Abdominal Therapy, as its official website calls it, were developed by a “naprapathic physician” based on her apprenticeship with a Mayan healer and is described as:
a non-invasive, external, massage technique that gently guides internal abdominal organs into their proper position [from which they have migrated due to activities like running] for optimum health and well-being. The technique works to relieve congestion and blockages by improving The 5 Systems of Flow (arterial, venous, lymphatic, nerve and chi). This results in improved organ function by releasing physical and emotional congestion from the abdomen.
In addition to “correcting” a prolapsed uterus, etc., proponents claim it is beneficial for all sorts of maladies in women, men, and children, ranging from bladder infections to benign prostate hyperplasia to Crohn’s Disease.
Is this, as promised, “rigorously evidence-based”? How about lacking not only evidence, but also scientific plausibility and a basis in human anatomy? If Mayan Abdominal Therapy is “evidence-based”, one can imagine the surprise of general surgeons at UCI Health (“One of America’s Best Hospitals”) who, upon performing a laparotomy, find the abdominal organs have shimmied over to random locations unknown to Gray’s Anatomy. Call the Mayan Abdominal Therapy practitioner!
Functional medicine
Also on the SSIHI menu is so-called “functional medicine” (also here), described as an alternative to “providing a prescription for a symptom” (tsk, tsk, you medical doctors!). Functional medicine practitioners, SSIHI claims,
search for the underlying causes of disease, including genetic predisposition, food intolerances, infectious diseases and environmental toxins.
This is all sufficiently vague to obfuscate what functional medicine really is, or does. Real medical specialties, like surgery or oncology, are literally open books, with their scientific underpinnings, diagnostic methods, and treatments all laid out in medical texts and other literature. Functional medicine, on the other hand, keeps its secrets safely locked behind a $15,000 paywall, available only to the “integrative” physicians, naturopaths, chiropractors, acupuncturists, and other health care practitioners who take its courses.
It is only by extrapolation from the paucity of publicly available information that we have been able to surmise its true nature. In David Gorski’s apt summation functional medicine is characterized by reams of useless tests, boatloads of prescribed supplements (often conveniently sold by the practitioner), and a huge invoice, with some quack diagnoses (e.g., “adrenal fatigue“) thrown in for good measure. And, in the estimation of the American Academy of Family Physicians, functional medicine lacks supporting evidence and includes harmful and dangerous treatments.
Despite assurances from Dr. Shaista Malik, SSIHI’s director, that naturopaths on staff would be supervised by MDs and used “for their expertise in nutrition and dietary supplements”, the Medical Director of the functional medicine operation is Afrouz Demehri, a naturopath, whose brief appears to go far beyond nutrition and supplements. In a video on UCI’s website, she depicts herself as an expert in hormonal, GI, thyroid, and mental health issues who wants to substitute her judgment for that of medical specialists or, as she says, be “the umbrella person that puts all those specialties in one area”, presumably functional medicine.
In addition to graduation from a naturopathic school, which is itself chock full of pseudoscience, and being a Doctor of Homeopathic Medicine, Demeri’s alleged expertise comes from several dubious sources. According to her practice’s website (where her name is spelled “Demeri”, not “Dehmeri”, and her connection to UCI is prominently displayed), in addition to her certification in functional medicine, she holds certifications in HeartMath (Steve Novella: “noise-based pseudoscience”), the Bredesen Alzheimer’s Protocol (Harriet Hall: “treatments are based loosely on his hypotheses about causation, with no clear rationale for the combination of interventions”), and platelet-rich plasma injections (Scott Gavura: “lots of hype, no convincing evidence”). She also completed an “Advanced Endocrinology Fellowship” with the American Academy of Anti-Aging Medicine, a fringe medical group criticized by scientists, and naturopath Ben Lynch’s course on MTHFR genetic screenings, which have been thoroughly debunked by real experts in genetics (also here) but are nevertheless used in functional medicine.
SSIHI’s functional medicine operation claims it can treat “any chronic health condition in children or adults” specifically including “leaky gut“, depression, genetic issues (“including autoimmune disorders and mitochondrial dysfunction”), hypothyroidism, and hormonal imbalances with therapies like “detoxification” and herbs and dietary supplements. It also touts bioidentical hormone therapy “to maximize your quality of life and prevent significant illness”, the sort of exaggerated assertion Harvard Women’s Health Watch criticizes as falsely suggesting bioidentical hormones “are a veritable fountain of youth”.
An extraordinary range of diseases and conditions that would, in conventional medicine, be managed by specialty-trained physicians with years-long residencies in, for example, gastroenterology, endocrinology, or rheumatology, appear to fall under functional medicine’s “umbrella”. Given the pseudoscience inherent in functional medicine, as well as its Medical Director’s education, training, and claims of expertise in numerous specialties, UCI would do well to critically evaluate whether its functional medicine operation is keeping the school’s supposed commitment to evidence-based medicine.
Acupuncture and Traditional Chinese Medicine
I guess this is what passes for an “evidence-based approach” at UCI:
A key goal of these therapies is to restore qi (pronounced chee), the “vital energy” that flows through intricate pathways throughout the body. By stimulating acupuncture points, this flow of energy is harmonized and optimal health can be restored.
SSIHI’s director, Dr. Malik, told STAT in 2017 that Chinese herbal treatments “would be used very rarely and, being unproven, would likely be phased out.” They weren’t. From the SSIHI Acupuncture and Traditional Chinese Medicine menu:
Chinese herbal medicine: Traditional Chinese herbal therapy has been practiced safely and effectively for centuries. It offers the greatest potential for beneficial results when prescribed by a trained acupuncturist.
In addition to the “unproven” herbs, which have magically become safe and effective since 2017, SSIHI offers a cornucopia of TCM pseudoscience: acupuncture, cupping, moxibustion, and something called “facial acupuncture renewal”, which
views the face as an extension of the pathways that travel the whole body. By needling the face, blood flow increases and qi (energy) carries nutrients to the cells.
What does TCM treat? For this, SSIHI relies on the WHO’s 1998 list of diseases and conditions “for which acupuncture has been proven, through controlled trials, to be an effective or promising treatment”, a claim that is demonstrably false. Even if it were true at the time, evidence-based medicine would require a reassessment of the evidence twenty-two years later.
In any event, the WHO’s list is extensive, including dysentery, hyper- and hypotension, leukopenia, correction of malpositioned fetuses, and stroke, for which there is no reliable evidence that acupuncture is “an effective or promising treatment”, acupuncture being, in fact, an elaborate placebo.
More “rigorously evidence-based” [sic] stuff
SSIHI also offers:IV infusion therapy
IV infusions of “micronutrients, such as antioxidants, metabolites, co-factors, vitamins [including high dose vitamin C “if medically indicated”] and minerals” for “mental focus, boosted energy, regained vitality, improved fat loss and sports performance, improved healing and recovery, enhanced immune support against pathogens and detoxification.” Each infusion requires “lab testing prior to infusion and is tailored to the needs of the individual.” Considering the hype about high-dose vitamin C, the lack of evidence for routine vitamin infusions and their abuse in the hands of naturopaths, as well as SSIHI’s use of unvalidated lab tests, while some infusions may be “medically indicated”, one suspects most of them are not.
Ayurvedic therapies
As with acupuncture, SSIHI is again all in for magical explanations of human functioning, presumably dismissing our vast body of scientific knowledge for no other reason than Ayurvedic “medicine” originated in India “more than 5,000 years ago”, even though none other than the Indian Medical Association has denounced it as “quackery”. Their repertoire of Ayurvedic therapies is limited to the external application of herbal oils which, they claim, defying reality, have some amazing internal effects, including joint lubrication, stimulating digestive enzymes, revitalizing the central nervous system, cleaning and fortifying the blood, and building muscle tissue.
Training in pseudoscience
To ensure that pseudoscience becomes firmly established in the medical profession, the UCI Department of Family Medicine, in collaboration with SSIHI, is developing “a new model of primary care” with a track in integrative medicine, offering education and training in treating primary care patients “using the tools and philosophies of integrative medicine”. I’ll have to give them this: They’ll have plenty of “tools and philosophies” to choose from at SSIHI. There is also a residency program for naturopathic doctors at UCI, apparently a first for U.S. medical schools, and a special integrative medicine program for medical students.
In sum, UCI obviously reneged on its commitment to evidence-based medicine in launching the Susan Samueli Integrative Health Institute. Of course, no one really thought the result would be otherwise because, by definition, integrative medicine requires the inclusion of pseudoscience. Otherwise, it’s just plain old medicine.
Fortunately, it appears that at least some in medicine are waking up to the fact that medical institutions have become infested with nonsense and are urging reform. I’ll end with a quote from an excellent 2018 article in the medical journal Surgeon (abstract here; discussion by Dr. Edzard Ernst here), which, incidentally, called out the Cleveland Clinic’s Center for Functional Medicine, where “patients are unaware of the potential harms and lack of therapeutic effectiveness that come with receiving care from a centre that holds strong non-evidence-based beliefs about medicine.” The authors warn:
Academic medical institutions are supposed to show the highest level of commitment to evidence-based medicine. When they support CAM, it sends the message that practices without a proven therapeutic or safety profile have a place in modern medicine. Indeed, the presentation of proven ineffective therapies alongside high quality, evidence-based medicine in academic medical centres inadvertently legitimizes their usage and is confusing for the public. This is dangerous for patients and damages the reputation of medicine as an evidence-based discipline. More detrimentally, the public may be misguided into thinking that CAM is evidence-based. . . Health care professionals must understand how deep CAM runs in their institutions . . . and advocate against the practice of non-evidence-based medicine. [Emphasis added.]
We’ve been saying the same thing for over a decade at SBM. It is therefore gratifying that the authors cite two SBM posts in their article. Medicine is finally taking notice. Someone should tell UCI.

Quackery in Medical School: Chapman Points
Braden MacBeth on February 21, 2020
Link

If you want to become a physician in the United States, you have two educational routes available to you: osteopathic and vanilla medical schools. Osteopathic medical school graduates earn a Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine (D.O) degree, and vanilla medical school graduates earn a Doctor of Medicine (M.D) degree. If you’re wondering what the difference is between the two, the answer is basically nothing. Students at osteopathic medical schools must take the COMLEX series of board exams, and can optionally take the USMLE series of board exams which are important for the residency matching process. Students at DO schools also receive 200 hours or more of training in osteopathic manipulative medicine (OMM). Outside of those things, there’s no difference between MD and DO schools. The research has shown that there is no difference between physicians with an MD or DO degree in the quality of care provided, approach to patient encounters, or clinical decision-making despite what the American Osteopathic Association’s marketing would have you believe. In short:
Osteopathy rarely gets talked about because very few physicians who graduate from osteopathic medical schools utilize OMM in their practice (as Mark Crislip put it, OMM “is the price they pay to obtain an otherwise standard medical education“). Also, physicians with a DO aren’t running around saying OMM can treat stuff like ADHD. In other countries, osteopaths are not physicians and are basically the same as chiropractors. While there are some OMM techniques that have at least some evidence they work, the same could also be said about chiropractic techniques. Many aspects of osteopathy are abject quackery not unlike chiropractic. But the American Association of Colleges of Osteopathic Medicine make it very clear in their Brief Guide to Osteopathic Medicine that they don’t want osteopathy to be mixed up with chiropractic:
Chiropractic was first enunciated in 1895 by Daniel David Palmer, who observed that displacement of vertebrae could affect neurotransmission, thus manifesting as disease. Palmer was a magnetic healer, but unlike A.T. Still, he did not have a medical background.
Now that is really odd statement to make if you want to deny the similarity between the two because A.T Still was also pretty into hydropathy, diet, bonesetting, and magnetic healing. They go on to say that chiropractic is focused on the nervous system while osteopathic medicine is focused on the need to restore blood flow via manipulation of the neuromusculoskeletal system. I’m still struggling to see how they’re dissimilar, but okay. I imagine one difference you could point to is chiropractic subluxations. Many chiropractors claim that there are invisible misalignments in the spine, subluxations, that can cause organic disease and can be cured through chiropractic manipulations. A major topic in OMM education is Chapman’s points or Chapman reflexes, which aren’t any different from meridians, or chiropractic subluxations. They’re total nonsense, let’s look at why.
The foundations of Chapman’s reflexes
Before we get started, I want to make it clear that I’m not just digging up the craziest stuff I can find. Chapman’s points are a key topic in OMM and are explicitly mentioned in the AACOM’s brief guide to osteopathic medicine. Throughout this piece I will be referencing the 3rd edition of the Atlas of Osteopathic Techniques (Atlas) and the 3rd edition of Foundations of Osteopathic Medicine (Foundations). The Foundations textbook was written and published in partnership with the American Osteopathic Association. With that out of the way, let’s do this.
What are Chapman’s reflexes and what do they do? According to the Atlas:
The current definition used by the osteopathic profession defines CRs as “a system of reflex points that present as predictable anterior and posterior fascial tissue texture abnormalities (plaque-like changes or stringiness of the involved tissues) assumed to be reflections of visceral dysfunction or pathology” (ECOP, 2006). This definition encompasses the lymphatic, neuroendocrine, and autonomic response to injury, illness, and disease as palpable and predictable viscerosomatic tissue reflexes found on the anterior and posterior body surface.
I have a question for people that write like this in medical journals and medical textbooks. Do you kiss your mother with that mouth? Nobody understands what you’re saying. What they’re proposing is that when you get sick, bumps called Chapman’s points or Chapman’s reflexes will appear on your body in specific locations based on what’s wrong with you. The most recent version of the Atlas describes these bumps as being rice, BB-shot, or pea shaped. They may be severely or slightly painful when pressed, or completely painless. The osteopathic societies have created charts illustrating where these points will show up and the illnesses or organ systems they correspond to:
Posterior Chapman points:
Anterior Chapman points
Now if you’re an SBM regular you might be feeling like you’ve seen these charts before. You’re probably mistaken, but it’s easy to see why you might get it mixed up with another alternative medicine chart. Perhaps you were thinking of a chart like this?
This is a chart of reflex points I pulled from a random reflexology website. Maybe you’re thinking this one?
This is a chart of meridians used in acupuncture. What do all of these charts have in common? They’re all utter nonsense. The Foundations textbook doesn’t really cite any credible evidence showing that they actually exist and that the presence of these points correspond to a dysfunction in the part of the body. The book spends a quarter of a page explaining the proposed scientific basis of these points and two more talking about the history of Chapman points and the heroes of osteopathy. The book describes several proposed mechanisms for why these Chapman points might appear by “those who value their use empirically”, whatever they mean by that. These theories include: lymphatic abnormalities, fibrositis deposits, inflamed lymph vessels passing over ribs and bones, inflamed nerve endings, and inflamed sympathetic nerve filaments around terminal arterioles. This is the equivalent of me saying the web page is broken because of something wrong with the network connection, the database connection, or the code on the web page. That isn’t a mechanism, it’s listing possible thing under the sun that could possibly explain almost any given phenomenon in the body.
Obviously it’s hard to show that they don’t actually exist because the only evidence the authors provide is either from papers written in the 1940s that I don’t have access to, or single case studies. In the they reference Case Studies Presented at Chapman’s Think Tank Retreat. In what universe does this count as good evidence or a valid source in an academic setting? There isn’t any good research validating the existence of “Chapman points” or that they correspond with some type of dysfunction in a specific part of the body. In Foundations the authors state that palpable tissue texture changes corresponding to dysfunctions of the body have been mapped for thousands of years in the case of acupuncture. They reference a study that found there was 44.2% topographical congruence between posterior Chapman points and acupuncture points. Acupuncture points have no scientific validity, so showing that the two are similar doesn’t make either of them more scientifically valid. They begin their conclusion of the section:
A given point in a given system does not need to “read a book” to know where it should or could be; it simply exists.
If don’t want me to argue that a given magical point system doesn’t exist, you’re going to have to meet me halfway and present credible evidence they do exist. Despite lacking any credible scientific evidence that Chapman points exist, they tell readers that “Chapman points” can be used as a diagnostic aid.
Chapman’s points as a diagnostic tool? Nope.
In Foundations the authors claim that many physicians utilize Chapman points as a diagnostic tool or to show that there is organ dysfunction. But they make it clear from the start that nobody should make a diagnosis based on the presence or absence of a tender Chapman point alone. However they are ultimately claiming that the presence of these points has diagnostic value, backing their claim with only individual case studies. Let’s look at one of them:
A 13-year-old female is admitted to the pediatric floor of an osteopathic teaching hospital for complaints of severe lower abdominal pelvic pain. She is examined and is found to be tender in the RLQ and midline pelvis. Urinalysis is normal. In this age group, the three most likely diagnoses to consider (in no particular order) are as follows: (1) Appendicitis, (2) Cystitis, and (3) Ovarian cysts. CRs showed bilateral tender reflexes on the anterior/medial pubic bones near the pubic symphysis and unilateral posterior CRs at T9-10 on the right side only.
Let’s look at the charts to diagnose what is wrong with her. According to the book we need to start with the anterior points first.
We’ve already run into problems. In the Atlas there are ten Chapman points on the chart in the pelvis/groin area. The chart in Principles of Osteopathic Medicine only shows four anterior points in the pelvic area. They also don’t line up at all. The Foundations chart says that the ovaries and urethra share the same Chapman point, but the Atlas chart shows that the ovaries and the urethra have their own Chapman points in very different positions in addition to another Chapman point for the urinary bladder. I guess we can rule out appendicitis? On the board we still have bladder inflammation and ovarian cysts. Now we should be able to get to the bottom of this by looking at the posterior Chapman points:
We’ve hit the same problem, the charts don’t match up. Who am I to believe? It’s not like there’s any evidence there’s a correlation with whatever condition she may have and the presence of anterior and posterior Chapman points. There isn’t even a correlation between where Chapman points appear on the body and what organ dysfunction they correspond to between textbooks. In Foundations, T9-10 are clearly labeled and correspond to the ovaries and the pylorus of the stomach. The chart in the Atlas is a bit harder to read so you have to use your imagination to approximate where T9-T10 are, but it looks like they correspond to the two Chapman points that the appendix, ovaries, adrenal glands and ileum all share. Based on these findings we can conclude it’s an right ovarian cyst. It’s the only part of the body corresponding to both the anterior and posterior Chapman points that were felt on physical examination. So how’d I’d do?
    • Preoperative diagnosis (without the use of CRs): Appendicitis versus right ovarian cyst (50/50 probability)
    • Preoperative diagnosis (with the use of CRs): Problem with right ovary involving the entire ovary—both the medial and the lateral halves
    • Postoperative diagnosis: Massive right ovarian cyst obliterating the entire right ovary
With diagnostic prowess like this, the medical schools should be sending applications to me. There are a lot of problems with this this, chiefly there’s no evidence that this diagnostic technique works and there’s no good reason to believe that it does. How often do the presence of these Chapman points in these specific locations predict that the patient will have a specific problem? We don’t know because after looking, it seems like there’s no published evidence. So from a diagnostic standpoint they should be given as much credence as a horoscope, but that’s also how much weight the doctors in this case gave them. If you’ll notice, cystitis wasn’t even considered in the pre-operative diagnosis because the urinalysis came back negative. They didn’t know the diagnosis going into surgery, so using Chapman points had no impact on diagnosis or treatment. It was basically a lucky guess, so what was the point? No doctor is using these as a diagnostic tool. In the absence of any good scientific evidence, the only thing palpitating these imaginary points will do is induce salivation in medical malpractice attorneys because you’re using pseudoscientific relic from pre-internet era to diagnose potentially serious medical conditions instead of doing literally anything else.
Chapman reflexes for treatment?
While the authors of Foundations admit there is very limited evidence proving the effectiveness of using Chapman points to treat medical conditions, they still present the some studies that suggest that they could. The study they reference was published in 1978 titled “The application of neurological reflexes to the treatment of hypertension” in none other than The Journal of the American Osteopathic Association. I was unable to find the full-text of this study. The JAOA website has it listed as a free article but there’s no text. So it’s impossible to know the sample size of the study, the exact outcomes, or what osteopathic technique they used to treat patients using “Chapman points”. According to the authors, it was shown that patients had reduced serum aldosterone levels lasting 36 hours after treatment. First, if you want to claim that a therapy treats hypertension, you have to actually measure the patient’s blood pressure.
You’re probably wondering what osteopathic technique they used involving Chapman points. Neither Atlas nor Foundations tell which osteopathic specific treatment is supposed to be used but Atlas does give a hint. The word hypertension is used exactly once in the entire book, and it appears in the Chapman points chapter of the book as an indication for vibratory or stimulatory treatment. While there are many treatments listed in the chapter, only two seem like they might possibly have anything to do with blood pressure. The first is the Occipitomastoid Suture Pressure which is referred to in the literature as the V-Spread technique. It involves applying light pressure to certain points on the back of the patient’s head to supposedly treat cranial somatic dysfunction.
The second is Alternating Pressure Left Second Rib, which involves the physician implying pressure at specific points on the patient’s chest and back. It is supposed to “treat thoracocostal somatic dysfunction at this area, which may influence cardiac rate”.
Now I would assume since these techniques fall under the “Reflex Oriented Treatment” category, the treatment would involve stimulating the appropriate Chapman points, but that’s not what we see. If you’ll direct your attention to the anterior Chapman point charts above, you’ll see that the physician is pressing on the part of the chest where the anterior and posterior heart Chapman points should be (theoretically, if they exist). If this therapy were based on stimulating the Chapman points corresponding the dysfunctional organ, they should be stimulating the adrenal chapman points located much, much lower on the torso. Aldosterone is released by the adrenal glands. The V-Spread technique is pressing on the points corresponding to the tonsils, eyes, sinuses, pharynx, and larynx, so it’s way off. These therapies don’t make sense considering the Chapman reflex point theory, let alone the established laws of the universe or common sense. There’s no evidence showing that these imaginary Chapman reflex points can be used to treat any medical condition.
Conclusion: Disenchanted
You don’t need to have any medical education to see that Chapman points or Chapman reflexes are bogus. You won’t be able to find an article in JAMA or Nature looking at Chapman points as a diagnostic tool, a treatment, or even a thing that exists. The entire theory is so convoluted; the presence of Chapman points supposed to be used as a diagnostic tool, but later in chapter there’s a guide to treat them as if they’re a medical problem in and of themselves. On top of all of that, the book suggests that stimulating these Chapman points can somehow treat serious medical conditions. The only research I’ve found on Chapman points are case studies published in The Journal of the American Osteopathic Association with no more than 50 cases in them. Chapman points are only taught in American osteopathic medical schools, and I really, really doubt any doctor uses them.
I’m not bashing medical schools that award a DO degree or physicians with a DO degree. To reiterate there is no difference in the care provided by physicians with either degree. There are MD schools that require students take courses in alternative medicine. They have been and should be criticized for it. But you won’t see something like homeopathy or acupuncture appear on the USMLE. The theory of Chapman reflex points is ridiculous and it’s obvious Chapman points don’t exist, but every year medical students at DO schools are required to memorize the locations of these magical points and regurgitate them on their school and board exams. No doctor is using Chapman points to diagnose appendicitis, we have labs and scans for that. Someone could fail out of medical school or fail boards because they couldn’t remember that the Chapman point for the kidneys is located on the left side of L1 vertebrae. Students have to pretend every year that they can feel Chapman points in their OMM lab. This is madness.
The American Osteopathic Association tries really hard to make itself seem like it’s not a budget-AMA. They claim that their goal is to “advance the distinctive philosophy and practice of osteopathic medicine”. No offense AOA, but I don’t think a distinctive philosophy of teaching medical students to rub a patient’s head to treat hypertension with no evidence it will work is a philosophy you want to be promoting. I could rip on the techniques in these books for as long as I want, and believe me I want, but Chapman’s points are a perfect place to start. I downloaded the most popular OMM Anki deck posted on /r/MedicalSchool, AnkiStill, and there is a 200 card subdeck on Chapman’s points, it’s one of the biggest ones.
The AOA and DO schools aren’t going anywhere, and removing Chapman points from the curriculum doesn’t mean that the AOA is legally obligated to merge with the American Medical Association or whatever. It just means they’ll be saving hundreds of thousands of future physicians from hours of trying to master mystical arts that they will hopefully never use when they graduate. The American Osteopathic Association and the American Association of Colleges of Osteopathic Medicine are growing fast, 6 new DO schools will open next year. Twenty five percent of physicians will graduate with a degree from a DO school. Listen AOA, you’re a grown-up medical organization. Part of growing up means ditching the dark eye-liner, lip rings, and My Chemical Romance.

The Integrative Oncology Scholars Program: Indoctrinating the next generation of “integrative oncology” believers
“Integrative oncology” involves “integrating” pseudoscience, mysticism, and quackery with science-based oncology and co-opting science-based lifestyle modalities as “alternative” in order to provide cover for the quackery. Unfortunately, my alma mater, funded by the National Cancer Institute, is running a course to indoctrinate 100 health care professionals in the ways of “integrative oncology.” The Trojan horse of “lifestyle interventions” and “nonpharmacologic treatments for pain” is at the gates. The quackery will leap out as soon as it’s in the fortress.
David Gorski on October 22, 2018
Link

Three weeks ago, I wrote about a whole “Special Focus” issue of the flagship journal for integrating quackery into medicine, the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine (JACM). The issue was devoted to “integrative oncology,” which I view as being devoted to “integrating” mysticism, quackery, and pseudoscience into the clinical care of cancer patients while co-opting diet, exercise, and lifestyle interventions as somehow being “integrative” or “alternative” rather than part of conventional medicine, the better to provide cover for quackery like traditional Chinese medicine, energy medicine, and the like. Because the Special Focus issue was going to be available for free until October 24, I had planned on writing a follow-up post, but somehow (as is often the case) other topics intervened. Then, over the weekend, our very own Jann Bellamy sent me a PubMed link to an article from that issue touting something called the “Integrative Oncology Scholars Program”. I had mentioned that article in my previous loving deconstruction of the JACM integrative oncology Special Focus issue, but Jann’s email jolted me, making me realize that I really should have written more about this particular aspect, particularly given that it’s being spearheaded by my alma mater, both undergraduate and medical, the University of Michigan. In other words, it’s the perfect topic to discuss in more detail as a follow up to my previous post, and it’s still available for two more days to read for free online.
The article is, as is often the case for articles like this, credited to many authors, but the first (and corresponding) author is Suzanna Zick, a naturopath who is in charge of the Integrative Family Medicine program in the Department of Family Medicine at the University of Michigan, where she’s been teaching what I consider to be misinformation and retconned history about traditional Chinese medicine and hosting homeopaths for Family Medicine Grand Rounds, all while publishing dodgy acupressure papers. I also note that the Integrative Family Medicine program at U. of M. purports to provide “advanced training in holistic medicine, anthroposophic medicine, and acupuncture”. Anthroposophic medicine, as you might recall, was first invented by Rudolf Steiner, and it is loaded with mystical nonsense. Yet my alma mater has a program in it.
How did a naturopath find a faculty position in the family medicine department of what has traditionally been a bastion of science-based medicine? I have no idea, but it’s been a source of continual embarrassment to me ever since I discovered it. After all, U. of M. is my alma mater, and I still collaborated with U. of M. faculty as recently as 2017. It also doesn’t help that Zick is a player in the Society for Integrative Oncology (SIO), having been president of the organization a couple of years ago and having had integral (if you’ll excuse the term) involvement in drafting the SIO’s dubious guidelines for the integrative oncological care of breast cancer patients, an updated version of which, alas, was recently endorsed by the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO).
So let’s take a look at what Zick et al have written, “Integrative Oncology Scholars Program: A Model for Integrative Oncology Education“.
The Integrative Oncology Scholars Program: Framing the frame
Basically, the Integrative Oncology Scholars Program is all about increasing the number of oncology professionals who buy into integrative oncology. (Note that I will quote fairly liberally, because after October 24, this article will go behind a paywall.) It all begins, as is usual for articles promoting “integrative medicine”, with framing integrative medicine as very, very popular, and therefore:
Despite this high level of use, communication about complementary and integrative medicine (CIM) use between oncology providers and patients is not ideal. Over half of oncology providers do not ask about CIM use3,4 and indicate the main reasons being a lack of knowledge about CIM approaches and not knowing what to do with the information once collected.3,5,6 This lack of communication can leave patients and their families with many unanswered questions, can result in negative (e.g., herb–drug) interactions and toxicities,7,8 and may prevent patients and survivors from receiving treatments that could help reduce cancer treatment side-effects and improve quality of life.9 Also, while the majority of CIM treatments are being delivered in the community by complementary providers, few oncology professionals and complementary providers communicate or are aware of the others’ practice. Oncology professionals rarely refer patients to complementary providers, with oncologists only referring for more information about complementary therapies 16% of the time, and nurses and social workers 13% and 36% of the time, respectively.4,10 One possible solution to the unsatisfactory interaction around CIM for both patients and providers (conventional and complementary) is education.
Of course, I’m all for education, as long as it’s based on science rather than promotion. Oncology professionals—heck, all physicians, nurses, physicians assistants, and anyone who gives medical advice to patients for a living—should have a working knowledge of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or “integrative medicine”. There’s the rub, though. I insist upon science-based education, which demonstrates that the vast majority of CAM doesn’t work and that which does work, such as exercise, science-based dietary modifications, and the like, is almost always already part of conventional medicine. (Low carb diet and weight loss as initial interventions for type II diabetes, anyone?)
It’s all about demand, though; that is, if you believe Zick et al. She and her co-authors are only doing this in response to overwhelming provider demand:
Oncology providers have expressed a desire to be more informed and to receive more education about oncology-specific CIM.6,11 Until recently, however, no oncology-specific CIM training has been available and the majority of educational opportunities have been designed for physicians (e.g., in the form of fellowships), despite the multidisciplinary and growing professional diversity of oncology teams.12 In response to this educational gap, we have designed the Integrative Oncology Scholars (IOS) Program.
See? We perceived a huge need for this education in “complementary and integrative medicine” (CIM). (I wish advocates of CAM, CIM, or whatever would make up their mind on what acronym they want to use.) So what will this program consist of?
The Integrative Oncology Scholars Program: The course
Now that the authors have established the desperate “need” for this education on integrating nonsense into oncology, how do they propose to provide for this need? The answer is simple. The authors have devised a program with the following goals:
The IOS Program is funded by a National Cancer Institute R25 grant. It has the joint goals of training 100 integrative oncology (IO) leaders over 4 years and facilitating partnerships between IO leaders and complementary practitioners within their communities. Eligible participants, who are designated as IOS, include a multidisciplinary selection of physicians, physician assistants, nurses, psychologists, social workers, physical or occupational therapists, and pharmacists, who are actively engaged in clinical oncology practice. IOS instructors are experts in the field of IO and/or adult education and reflect the multidisciplinary nature of the program with professions as diverse as patient advocates to oncology clinicians. Details on course instructors, program eligibility, and how to apply are available on the IOS Program website.*
An R25 grant from the NIH is, basically, an education grant whose purpose is “to support research education activities that: (a) Complement and/or enhance the training of a workforce to meet the nation’s biomedical, behavioral and clinical research needs; (b) Enhance the diversity of the biomedical, behavioral and clinical research workforce; (c) Help recruit individuals with specific specialty or disciplinary backgrounds to research careers in biomedical, behavioral and clinical sciences; or (d) Foster a better understanding of biomedical, behavioral and clinical research and its implications.”
This particular R25 grant (R25 CA203651), entitled A short course for creating integrative oncology leaders, is, surprisingly, not a grant issued by the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH), but rather from the National Cancer Institute. Not surprisingly, Suzanna Zick is the principal investigator. It’s not a huge grant, but it’s a decent chunk of change ($220,155 to $237,612 per year thus far). Its specific aims include:
     1.  Develop an interdisciplinary short-course in evidenced-based integrative oncology;
     2.  Train 100 integrative oncology leaders (25 participants per course x 4 courses = 100) via the short-course developed in aim #1;
     3.  Create partnerships between oncology leaders and complementary practitioners (who provide the majority of complementary oncology services) within their communities (~25 community-based complementary partners per year {one per oncology leader} for a total of 100 over 4 years)
     4.  Evaluate the impact of this short-course by measuring the process and the outcomes of the various educational activities over the course, and measuring the implementation and outcomes of the capstone projects initiated by participants at their home institutions after completion of the program;
     5.  Disseminate the findings through peer-reviewed journals, presentations at professional meetings, and through both conventional and integrative oncology networks and associations.
So, basically, the NCI has spent nearly a half million dollars (thus far) to support this educational endeavor in two years, with three more years to go in the grant. One might ask: Why wasn’t NCCIH involved? As I’ve mentioned before, unfortunately the NCI has a very large CAM program; indeed its yearly budget is nearly as large as that of the NCCIH. The program is called the Office of Cancer Complementary and Alternative Medicine, which has one of the most cringe-inducing (in context) acronyms ever: OCCAM. A decade ago, I once spoke with a representative of OCCAM at the American Association for Cancer Research (AACR) meeting, and his blather about “emperor” and “assistant” herbs was every bit as cringe inducing as the OCCAM acronym.
So basically, the Integrative Oncology Scholars Program involves two parts. First, there is an online eLearning component implemented using a Canvas website designed by Instructure, Inc., in Salt Lake City. Second, there are three in-person sessions at—groan!—the University of Michigan. You’ll just have to excuse me if I remain…skeptical…about the eLearning modules, given that an evaluation of the U. of M. Department of Family Medicine eLearning module on acupuncture shows that it teaches acupuncture and traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) with great credulity and totally buys into the retconned version of TCM originally promoted by Chairman Mao.
The article by Zick et al actually isn’t that detailed regarding the curriculum. It does list the components of what will be taught in the three in-person sessions at U. of M. Predictably, there’s a lot on natural products and “mind-body” interventions, but there are also modules on dietary interventions both science-based and dubious (e.g., ketogenic, alkaline, paleo, macrobiotic, etc.). There’s also modules on energy medicine and traditional Chinese medicine. As far as the web-based modules, there are additional modules on:
    • Diet – (1) Ketogenic Diets, (2) Calorie-restricted Diets and Fasting, (3) Anti-oxidant Supplementation During Cancer Treatment, and (4) Soy and Cancer
    • Whole Systems of Medicine – (1) Homeopathy, (2) Ayurveda, and (3) Naturopathy
    • Unique Pharmacological Treatments – (1) Vitamin D, (2) High Dose Vitamin C, and (3) Melatonin
    • Botanical Products – (1) Cannabis and Cannabinoids, and (2) Mistletoe.
Homeopathy is, of course, The One Quackery to Rule Them All. Naturopathy is basically a cornucopia of quackery, while Ayurveda and TCM are prescientific systems of medicine whose resemblance to anything science-based tends to be purely by coincidence (e.g., Artemisinin). Meanwhile, high dose vitamin C has consistently been shown to be, at best given the most generous interpretation of the existing evidence, a long run for a short slide.
In other words, what we see here is the typical “integrative medicine” approach: Co-opt some science-based diet and lifestyle modalities—such as exercise, various dietary interventions (often mixed with the more dubious, like the ketogenic diet), and mindfulness (which might be science-based)—and use them for cover for the quackery, such as homeopathy, naturopathy, high dose vitamin C, that is included with the modalities to be “integrated.”
As for the methods, besides eLearning, here’s how the in-person sessions will be organized:
As part of the TBL model we will employ a flipped classroom approach. In the flipped classroom approach scholars will read key materials, watch lectures, or complete modules before coming to class, and then engage in active educational strategies to maximize educational effectiveness during in-person class time.14 These strategies will include group discussion sessions, case studies, as well as demonstration and role-playing. Cancer patients, their families, advocates, and community-based complementary providers will be invited to be part of the curriculum to bring their experiences into the learning environment. Use of TBL and flipped classroom strategies improve short-term outcomes in health professions’ curricula,15 and out-perform traditional lecture-based continuing medical education in both short-term knowledge retention and daily practice behavior.16
So, in other words, they’re trying to be very, very effective in indoctrinating oncologists and other health care professionals into believing in integrative oncology and referring patients to integrative practitioners, including quacks like naturopaths.
Finally, let’s look at the faculty who are teaching the Integrative Oncology Scholars Program. Suzanna Zick, a naturopath, is of course the course director. Another naturopath, Heather Greenlee, will also be teaching. The first thing you’ll notice is a relative paucity of actual oncologists in the list. There’s a medical oncologist and a radiation oncologist, as well as a PA in gynecologic oncology. That’s it. There are, however, psychologists and a nurse. For instance:
Judith M. Fouladbakhsh, PhD, RN, AHN-BC, PHCNS-BC, CHTPDr. Judi Fouladbakhsh, Associate Professor at Oakland University, and former faculty of long standing at Wayne State University, College of Nursing, holds advanced clinical practice certifications in Community Health and Holistic Nursing, Healing Touch, Reflexology and Reiki. Dr. J has extensive experience in complementary and alternative (traditional) medicine, integrative oncology, pain management, public health and cancer nursing. Research interests include effects of yoga on breathing, mood, sleep and QOL of lung cancer patients funded by the NIH, and yoga therapy and qigong for pain management among breast cancer survivors. She also serves as faculty at the Beaumont Health System School of Yoga Therapy.
How depressing. She has apparently been faculty at my current medical school for a long time. Worse, she’s into healing touch and reiki, forms of “energy medicine” that rely on belief in the existence of a mystical magical “energy field” that healers can manipulate to healing effect. As I’ve said more times than I can remember, reiki, for instance, is nothing more than faith healing in which Eastern religious beliefs are substituted for Christian religious beliefs. Unfortunately, nonsense like reiki is available and promoted in far too many NCI-designated comprehensive cancer centers.
There’s also an acupuncture researcher:
Dr. Richard Harris, PhDRichard Harris is an Associate Professor in the Department of Anesthesiology and the Department of Internal Medicine at the University of Michigan. He received his Ph. D. in Molecular and Cell Biology from UC Berkeley in 1997. Dr. Harris is currently investigating mechanisms of acupuncture and acupressure in the treatment of chronic pain and fatigue conditions. His recent investigations have focused on the role of brain neurotransmitters in acupuncture analgesia and chronic pain.
Teaching focus areas: Pain; acupuncture/acupressure; traditional Chinese medicine; diet, exercise, and supplements in cancer prevention, cancer treatment and survivorship; GI disturbances
I perused Dr. Harris’ PubMed publication list (note that he is not this Richard Harris). There’s surprisingly little about acupuncture there, but what is there is pretty credulous, including a publication in JACM about how acupuncture “rewires” the brain with lasting effects and an article in the quack journal Medical Acupuncture about how cellular reorganization plays a vital role in acupuncture anesthesia. In other words, it’s quackademic medicine at its purest, and much of what will be taught to these “integrative oncology scholars” will either not be science based or will be a co-opted version of science based treatments framed as “integrative or alternative.” No big surprise there.
The Integrative Oncology Scholars Program: The goal
In the end, what is the goal of the Integrative Oncology Scholars Program? Clearly, it’s to increase the number of believers in integrative oncology in key locations, particularly academic medical centers (which, truth be told, are already hotbeds of pseudoscience). The investigators even have metrics that they want to look at for their “graduates” and their program:
To evaluate the IOS Program, we will use a mixed method approach employing tools developed from the University of Michigan Integrative Faculty Scholars Program in Integrative Healthcare and modified for the IOS Program. Overall, the IOS evaluation plan is composed of three elements: (1) evaluate overall IOS Program progress, (2) monitor individual IOS advancement, and (3) evaluate the IOS Program and make adjustments for subsequent cohorts, as needed.
We will also assess IOS progress toward nine goals focused on building IO research, clinical and educational impact: (1) writing applications for IO NIH funding, (2) authorship of IO publications, (3) presenting at IO-related conferences, (4) academic appointments to a faculty (or equivalent) position, (5) gaining employment in an IO team, (6) obtaining an IO leadership position, (7) individual IO-focused research grant support from NIH or other sources, (8) leadership as an IO “resource” person, and (9) improved IO clinical skills and knowledge as measured by a self-assessment tool.
The first cohort of 25 scholars is already well into the training, too:
The first cohort of 25 IOS has been accepted and will begin the program in August, 2018. The cohort is comprised of 10 physicians from radiation, medical, and surgical oncology as well as primary care, dermatology, and palliative care; 5 advanced practice nurses; 5 social workers; three physician assistants; 1 pharmacist; and 1 physical therapist. Several of the social workers and nurses coordinate cancer survivorship programs at their institutions. IOS come from 13 states and the District of Columbia and represent 23 U.S. healthcare systems, including comprehensive cancer centers (refer to Fig. 1).
It’s interesting to me that a minority of the first cohort are physicians and an even smaller minority appear to be from oncology-related specialties. Perhaps there is hope after all. On the other hand, this is only the first year. One can expect this program, if successful, to grow and metastasize to other institutions.
Now excuse me while I go and find a paper bag to put over my head, given that it’s my alma mater that’s leading this effort.

Consortium of Academic Health Centers for Integrative Medicine research conference disappoints even NCCAM
Jann Bellamy on July 10, 2014
Link


In May, the International Research Congress on Integrative Medicine and Health (IRCIMH) conference was held in Miami. In the words of its website, the conference was “convened by” the Consortium of Academic Health Centers for Integrative Medicine (CAHCIM), “in association with” the International Society for Complementary Medicine Research. As CAHCIM chirped in this tweet: “Three days, 22 countries, 100 academic medical institutions, [and] 900 researchers, physicians, educators, and trainees…” Interestingly, despite the fact that “use of all appropriate … healthcare professionals and disciplines to achieve optimal health and healing” is part of CAHCIM’s definition of integrative medicine, actual CAM providers were barely visible among the conference committee bigwigs.
Emmeline Edwards, Ph.D., Director, Division of Extramural Research at the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM), herself on the conference’s Program Committee, was decidedly underwhelmed. (NCCAM helped fund the conference. Additional funding information here.) After offering rather tepid congratulations to the organizers and participants, Dr. Edwards launched into a pointed, but very politely delivered, criticism of the research presented (emphasis mine):
The poster sessions offered a great opportunity to meet many new investigators engaged in exciting research in the field of integrative health. Reflecting on some highlights of these sessions, I was brought to the realization that we could strive for better balance in the science featured in the IRCIMH poster presentations. The clinical research posters outnumbered the basic research presentations 3:1, and research on mind and body strategies dominated the research landscape. One concern is that many clinical research projects were not developed from adequate mechanistic studies and, hence, the outcomes from these projects may not be very informative, provide a well-defined path for the next study, or give direction for future research programs.
How right you are, Dr. Edwards! We’ve been saying some of the same things here at SBM for years. We’ve noticed these very same problems in the organization you work for. Recently, as a matter of fact.
Perhaps I can help Dr. Edwards understand the deficiencies she noted. Integrative medicine proponents prefer clinical research over basic research and don’t particularly care for “adequate mechanistic studies” because having to demonstrate a plausible mechanism of action would eliminate their use of too many of the tools of IM, such as acupuncture, homeopathy, therapeutic touch and reiki. They much prefer tooth fairy science, where prior plausibility is considered unnecessary and plunging right into clinical research allows them to skip the hard stuff.
It doesn’t matter that the outcomes may not be “informative” or provide a “well defined path” or guide future research. Outcomes aren’t that important. You will find an array of “alternative” therapies employed by IM practitioners (also here and here, among many others) where there is no good evidence of effectiveness. Nor is a “well defined path” to the next study necessary when research continues willy-nilly on all sorts of implausible and unpromising treatments. (Just look at the list of abstracts at the very conference you discuss.) How many times have you seen the statement “more research is needed” at the end of a study of some wholly implausible treatment that shows no evidence of effectiveness? As long as “more research is needed” and researchers can find the money to fund it from, say, NCCAM, or other taxpayer funded or private source, research will continue, whether we need it or not.
And why is there so much emphasis on “mind and body interventions?” That’s where the money is. Your agency, NCCAM, has lumped just about all of CAM into one massive category called “mind and body medicine.”
As used in this plan, mind and body encompasses interventions from the three domains of mind/body medicine, manipulative and body-based practices, and energy medicine.
In the ever-shifting definition of CAM, a category called “mind and body medicine” includes “mind/body” as one subset and “body” as another subset. Clear on that? Me neither. Thus, now practically all of CAM is “mind and body medicine,” including such diverse practices as acupuncture, yoga, spinal manipulation, Pilates, reiki, craniosacral therapy and reflexology.
An independent review
The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine has granted open access to the abstracts of poster presentations from the conference. Let’s take a look and see why Dr. Edwards might be concerned that the poster presentations weren’t up to snuff. And let’s see if these presentations measure up to the CAHCIM’s mission of “disseminating information on rigorous scientific research.”
The existence of a Scientific Review Committee for the conference indicates there were some sort of criteria these poster presentations had to meet, but there is no information I could find as to what those criteria might be. Evidently, the bar was extremely low, as we shall see. The Committee was headed by Chairs David Eisenberg, MD, of Harvard, who has a position at the Samueli Institute as well, and Peter Wayne, PhD, also of Harvard. Dr. Eisenberg’s colleague at the Samueli Institute, Wayne Jonas, M.D., was on the Committee too, in charge of Research Methods.
Tooth fairy science
We’ll start with a few examples of tooth fairy science, or as Dr. Edwards put it, clinical research “not developed from adequate mechanistic studies,” and begin with a real jaw-dropper. Six pediatric patients who presented with appendicitis at the Children’s Hospital in Los Angeles emergency room were recruited for a trial of Japanese acupuncture for pain and inflammation. The rationale?
Acupuncture has been shown to treat various medical conditions including acute and chronic pain, and there is speculation that it has anti-inflammatory effects.
Since when is “speculation” a sufficient basis for pediatric human subjects research?
Many iterations of acupuncture were the subject of poster presentations: Japanese acupuncture, “regular” acupuncture, electro-acupuncture, group acupuncture, bee venom acupuncture, and music electro-acupuncture. Had to look that last one up.
[Researchers] suggested that sound waves converted to electric currents may be used to stimulate acupuncture needles to get better results. An apparatus has been devised . . . to convert music into electric waves suitable for use in electro-acupuncture by which the frequency is changed in accordance with the music.
Researchers at the School of Acupuncture-Moxibustion and Tuina in Beijing tested this on rats to see if it might improve mild depression and concluded that it “could have a positive effect.” I wonder if the type of music matters? Is punk rock better or worse than classical? How about jazz versus country music? Obviously, more research is needed.
In addition to many studies of acupuncture, there were studies of wet cupping on depression and anxiety as well as on markers of inflammation and Hsp proteins in patients with metabolic syndrome. You’ll not be surprised to learn that wet cupping didn’t work.
It seems TCM practitioners are dissatisfied with their “theories,” so much so that they feel the need to correlate them with “Western” tests and diagnoses. One study of TCM diagnoses opined that “liver housing blood” could be concluded from lab tests showing, for example, reduced potassium levels. Another found that “the changes of tongue picture can reflect the severity of hepatic cirrhosis in a certain extent.”
Apparently, in kinesiology “theory,” one muscle will weaken after the practitioner speaks a lie and stay strong if he speaks the truth. According to this series of studies, kinesiology practitioners correctly distinguished lies from the truth more often than by chance alone or by guessing. Sense About Science take note: the researchers are from the University of Oxford and City University London.
Researchers concluded that therapeutic touch had significant effects on immune responses by down-regulating serum cytokines, macrophages, and modulated lymphocyte subsets in mice. It also significantly reduced metastasis but not primary tumor size in a mouse breast cancer model. Per another study, Bach Flower Remedies, whose intent is to “harmonize the ethereal, emotional and metal body”, decreased anxiety.
One study employed The Reiki Client Quality Monitoring Tool (who knew?) and found that a decrease in pain and stress and an increase in “happiness” for both in- and out-patient oncology patients. (No control, no blinding.) Brennan Healing Science is another energy healing modality. (This was the first I’d heard of “BHS.”) A “survey development and pilot testing” for a BHS study to see “which conditions may be amenable to energy healing” was presented. If you ask the healers, a lot of conditions are amenable, according to the abstract. The healers reported that 25.4% of physical symptoms and 27.8% of psychosocial symptoms improved completely. (I‘m not sure what “improved completely” means.) “Spiritual factors” (whatever they are) improved the most. This small survey of healers will now be “administered to hundreds of others worldwide.”
Integrative medicine research can make for strange bedfellows. The Upper Cervical Research Foundation, which posits that “when a small but measurable spinal misalignment known as the Atlas Subluxation Complex (ASC) is detected and corrected, a return toward good health and normal activity can be realized,” partnered with the University of Calgary and Alberta Health Services to conduct research on the effect of upper cervical manipulation on migraine headaches. They determined that this intervention was indeed beneficial.
And here are some stunning statistics regarding “unconventional” lab tests. Researchers from Yale, Georgetown and Ohio State conducted a survey of 638 licensed healthcare professionals who were “associated with” CAM/integrative medicine organizations. The most frequently used lab tests included, among others, stool analyses, salivary hormone assays and urine heavy metal tests, all biggies in the alt med field. The results showed that about a third of adults and up to a whopping 46% of pediatric patients were subjected to these unconventional tests. 61% of practitioners used unconventional tests for children and adolescents. 40-53% of adult tests were reimbursed by third parties, such as Medicare and private insurance.
So what were the researchers’ recommendations? Investigate why taxpayers are footing the bill for nonsensical tests? Outrage that children were being subjected to these tests? A call for tighter regulations on lab testing? Nope. None of these. They want “further study” of their validity, apparently based on the nonsensical rationale that “unconventional tests are often utilized in chronic conditions without reliable mainstream treatments.” So, since there isn’t a science-based treatment, we need to study how CAM providers determine the need for bogus treatments with bogus tests.
Rebranding
Apparently, the quest to rebrand is never ending in integrative medicine. Here we have an example from the University of Kansas. The victim is the discipline of Dietetics and Nutrition. As the abstract points out,
Integrative Medicine is an expanding field of healthcare that emphasizes nutrition as a key component.
Yes, expanding by rebranding. Dietetic interns were placed in the IM program and a new subspecialty was created, Dietetics in Integrative Medicine (“DIM”), which includes a new Master of Science degree for a Graduate Certificate in DIM. As budding dieticians, perhaps the DIM students could perform an actual demonstration of Crislip’s Theorem:
If you integrate fantasy with reality, you do not instantiate reality. If you mix cow pie with apple pie, it does not make the cow pie taste better; it makes the apple pie worse.
Rebranding in integrative medicine includes not only poaching from science-based medicine, but also recasting negative results as positive. Two examples:
In a Norwegian study, two medical doctors reviewed complaints of adverse reactions to homeopathy. These reactions were then evaluated independently by two homeopaths. The homeopaths rebranded about two-thirds of the adverse effects as “homeopathic aggravations,” which actually “indicates an improved health status after an initial aggravation.”
Good evidence has been rebranded as bad attitude. In a survey of 750 CAM providers, 47.6% reported feeling pressure to demonstrate practice effectiveness. Cranial sacral therapists reported the least pressure, which is good for them, considering there is no evidence whatsoever that cranial sacral therapy is effective. Chiropractors, naturopaths and reiki practitioners (of all people) reported more pressure. I would think this increased perception of the importance of evidence-based practice would be viewed as a positive development, but research begs to differ. Why? Because, according to Self-Determination Theory, healthcare providers who feel pressure to demonstrate effectiveness “will adopt a controlling rather than an autonomy-supportive motivational orientation.” So now evidence-based practice is bad? (Which would sure be a good thing for CAM.) And is the hegemony of reductionist conventional medicine applying the screws? Nope. They are the least mentioned source. Most common source? The general public. Good for them.
Physics
No discussion of CAM research would be complete without a look into what we’ll call “alternative physics.”
One presentation from two researchers at the University of Maryland and its medical school purported to test the hypothesis that “human bioenergy fields consist of a form of energy that can push against physical objects, as in psychokinesis.” (James Randi, are you listening?) They claim to have discovered, by using a torsion pendulum balance, not only that “effects were dramatic” but also that “the pendulum oscillated with many new frequencies.” They found “intriguing” the fact that “effects exerted by the subject on the pendulum persist for 30-60 minutes after the subjects departs from the pendulum” suggesting to them that “the effects are somehow retained within the molecular/atomic structure of the steel mesh or coco fiber hemisphere” which were the aforesaid physical objects in this research project.
William Tiller and Nisha Manek of the Tiller Institute had a poster presentation on “Information Medicine: Emergence of a New Medical Paradigm.” Tiller is the founder of the Institute for Psychoenergetic Science, an outfit showcasing, well, basically, him. Here’s the abstract’s word salad, I mean, conclusion:
Information (intention) is a source of free energy and can change whole living systems in a specific and beneficial direction and robustly expands the normal molecular theories of bio-information. Crucially, human consciousness as the source of free energy is capable of driving chemical processes and opens the door to INFOMED. Modern physics concepts of information theory suggest a higher level of therapeutic intervention that go beyond the traditional mental, emotional and physical approaches to treating diseases.
In another strange bedfellows combination, the Tiller Institute teamed up with the Biostatistics Department at the University of Iowa to conduct a study of an “Intention Host Device [IHD] imprinted with intention to assist autistic individuals [n=39], located around the globe, to integrate into the physical bodies and experience.”
The researchers concluded that “intention broadcast by an IHD resulted in significant gains” for the test subjects in sociability, communication and other improvements.
There were four poster presentations on two related products, the BioPower Bioceramics Pad and the BioPower Bioceramics shirt. What are they? BioPower products are a combination of two “technologies.” From the company’s (Multiple Energy Technologies, LLC) website:
BIO Power technology is based in part on bioceramics, ultrafine mineral particles with photothermal properties that are extracted from the Amazon rainforest. When heated by the human body or another source, the minerals embedded in the product emit long infrared radiation that increases cellular metabolism, induces analgesia, promotes muscle relaxation, and decreases inflammation and oxidative stress.
The other half of BIO Power’s dual technology is vibrational therapy, the practice of
manipulating energy fields to affect health. The human biofield is a network of complex electromagnetic fields engendered by the movement of sub-atomic particles. BIO Power products are imprinted with signature frequencies that transmit to the user upon contact, rebalancing the energy fields that help to regulate cellular physiology.
Apparently these studies did not test the claim that the “energy fields” of mice or men (or women) could be manipulated to “rebalance” them. It is not clear from the website whether the shirts include the vibrational therapy feature. In any event, according to these researchers, the bioceramics pad was beneficial to mice pain, paw strength and stamina. The shirts were beneficial to judo practitioners’ and basketball players’ performance.
Why bother?
All in all, I think you’d have to agree that CAHCIM certainly met its goal of “disseminating information on rigorous scientific research” with these outstanding presentations. Excellent job, Scientific Review Committee!
Dr. Edwards ended her comments by reminding integrative medicine researchers of NCCAM’s goals for its research portfolio (emphasis mine):
research that is conducted at the appropriate stage based on current evidence; research that is statistically powered to assess clinically meaningful outcomes (when the evidence base is sufficient to support an efficacy trial); and research that proposes realistic timeframes and budgets and test hypotheses that will guide future research. We want to encourage our investigators to give strong consideration to the strength and quality of their preliminary data, the appropriateness of the proposed methods to answer their stated hypotheses, the feasibility of a clinical trial as designed, and the potential impact of trial outcome to shape future studies.
The most likely result of following these rules, of course, is that even more studies will demonstrate a lack of benefit for CAM practices. And since evidence doesn’t seem to matter to integrative medicine practitioners, why bother?

Oregon Health & Science University SCAM Day
Mark Crislip on March 18, 2016
Link


I was looking over a recent class catalog from my alma mater, University of Oregon. I see the Astronomy Department is having a day devoted to astrology, inviting astrologers to talk about their profession. And the Chemistry department is having alchemists give an overview on how to change base metals into gold. And, to green our energy, the Physics Department, where I acquired my undergraduate degree, is having a symposium on perpetual motion machines. I am so proud.
I kid.
But not when it comes to SCAM (Supplements, Complementary and Alternative Medicine). Medicine is strange in that has no issues embracing pseudo-science. My medical school, OHSU, had an afternoon devoted to Integrative Medicine for the third year medical students, with lectures by a chiropractor, a traditional Chinese pseudomedicine practitioner, a naturopath and an integrative medicine practitioner. They also had a small group discussion of a case of irritable bowel syndrome where one of the discussion leaders was a……Qi……….Gong………..master. Really. I would be so pissed if I was going $166,000 in medical school debt and I was being taught about the approach to ANYTHING by a Qi Gong Master. It was a day to ignore that whole ‘science’ thing in the name of the school.
I have no issue with medical schools teaching about SCAMs. SCAMs should be taught as part of the medical school curriculum. But not proselytizing propaganda by proponents of pseudo-medicine. Can I alliterate or what?
Unfortunately I was unable to attend to lectures so I do not know what the spoken content of the lectures were, but I did receive from a former resident a copy of the slides used. The slides are interesting not only for what they say, but what they do not say. Lies of omission as it were.
So, for the sake of OHSU students who might wander into this post, here is a deconstruction of the slides. I do not cover all the nonsense on these slides, but this site can fill that lack for those who want to explore the topics further. For those of you who are regular readers, there is little new in what follows, so you might want to go read something else.
Traditional Chinese pseudomedicine
Their slide set had only 5 slides, which is 4 more than needed to cover the reality-based aspects of TCPM. Evidently they covered Chinese acupuncture (ignoring all the other forms of the acupuncture, especially the one true form, Tong Ren. The rest are posers) and have slides showing acupuncture (No gloves used. Of course. That is why there are some many reports of infection from acupuncture) and moxibustion).
The two lecturers have a website for their practice that contains all the usual nonsense about acupuncture, well-covered on this website for you OHSU students who have wandered this way for the first time.
I wonder if they mentioned that there is no qi and no meridians.
I wonder if the lecturers mentioned that acupuncture has never been found to be effective for ANY process in any high quality study. It is but a theatrical placebo. But there are 2,208 references searching PubMed for ‘acupuncture complications’, quite a price to pay an intervention that does nothing.
But at least, as noted on the cover letter with the slides, the students learned how to capture the qi of a tree in the forest to cleanse the liver.
Chiropractic
Two chiropractors from the University of Western States, the local Chiropractic trade school, gave this lecture.
They start with the guiding principles of chiropractic:
    • The body has the ability to heal itself through natural means
    • Balance is created by fostering the structural integrity of the spine allowing for continued movement and decreased stress on the nervous system
    • Treating the cause of the patient’s symptoms
The first always sounds appealing, the appeal to nature fallacy. Western States teaches the myth of the subluxation complex, and for chiropractors that is the cause of almost all symptoms. When all you have is manipulation, everything is subluxation.
I wonder if they mentioned that the fundamental precepts of chiropractic, that of subluxation, innate energy, and their interventions of spinal manipulation are completely based in fantasy? Doubt it.
They mention it was founded by DD Palmer in 1895. Founded? You mean how he pulled it out of, er, well, thin air, after allegedly restoring hearing by adjusting the spine? You are a medical student. Is the 8th nerve anywhere near the spine? That make any sense to you? Does chiropractic? I thought not.
They mention chiropractic education as having more hours than medical school. But really, if the hours of education are spent reinforcing the fundamental fiction of chiropractic subluxation and manipulation, are those quality education hours? Nope.
And they mention no residency. Has there ever been an MD who was competent to take care of patients right out of medical school? Are you? Nope. Chiropractic education is qualitatively inferior to an MD and their training is minimal. Not a good background for diagnosing and treating the ill.
There is a slide for:
    • Conditions we have Strong evidence for treating with manipulation
    • Acute, sub-acute & chronic low back pain
    • Acute, sub-acute & chronic neck pain
    • Migraine & Cervicogenic Headaches
    • Cervicogenic Dizziness
    • Extremity conditions- knee OA, patellofemoral pain syndrome, plantar fasciosis
The reference, by chiropractors, for chiropractors (no bias there) shows that only chronic low back pain is considered to have high quality evidence, which I would consider strong evidence, the rest are moderate quality evidence at best.
The actual abstract says:
Spinal manipulation/mobilization is effective in adults for: acute, subacute, and chronic low back pain; migraine and cervicogenic headache; cervicogenic dizziness; manipulation/mobilization is effective for several extremity joint conditions; and thoracic manipulation/mobilization is effective for acute/subacute neck pain. The evidence is inconclusive for cervical manipulation/mobilization alone for neck pain of any duration, and for manipulation/mobilization for mid back pain, sciatica, tension-type headache, temporomandibular joint disorders, fibromyalgia, premenstrual syndrome, and pneumonia in older adults. Spinal manipulation is not effective for asthma and dysmenorrhea when compared to sham manipulation, or for Stage 1 hypertension when added to an antihypertensive diet.
I little, well, disingenuous don’t you think? And for low back pain? The independent Cochrane review, who make no money from spinal manipulation therapy, says:
Combined chiropractic interventions slightly improved pain and disability in the short term and pain in the medium term for acute/subacute LBP. However, there is currently no evidence that supports or refutes that these interventions provide a clinically meaningful difference for pain or disability in people with LBP when compared to other interventions.
By that definition, Bud Light would be a strong beer.
By the way, did they mention the risk of stroke that is the tradeoff for an intervention that likely has no clinically-meaningful difference when compared to other interventions with less risk?
Although current biomechanics evidence is insufficient to establish the claim that CMT [cervical manipulation therapy] causes CD [cervical artery dissection], clinical reports suggest that mechanical forces play a role in a considerable number of CDs and most population controlled studies have found an association between CMT and [vertebral artery dissection] stroke in young patients. Although the incidence of CMT-associated CD in patients who have previously received CMT is not well established, and probably low, practitioners should strongly consider the possibility of CD as a presenting symptom, and patients should be informed of the statistical association between CD and CMT prior to undergoing manipulation of the cervical spine.
Did they also mention that Oregon chiropractors oppose immunization? Maybe if they spent more time on public health and less on the subluxation complex, they might learn something useful for patient care.
It was a nice piece of chiropractic propaganda.
Naturopathy
The lecturer was from the National College of Naturopathic Medicine. The first slide mentions education. If you want to know the truth about naturopathy from a former naturopath, go to Naturopathic Diaries.
They mention a 4 year medical school. Did they mention that much of that is spent learning the pseudo-sciences of homeopathy, energy therapies, hydrotherapy, colonics and more? I doubt it. Oddly, homeopathy, one of the main pseudo-sciences of naturopathy, is not mentioned on the slides. Time spent in edumcation in pseudoscience is not time spent in real medicine.
They mention 1,200 clinical hours? That is 150 eight hour days. Half a year. NDs education is a fraction of what it takes to be a family practitioner, 5,000 hours for NDs vs 21,000 hours for Family Practitioners, and FPs are trained in reality based medicine. Not to mention some of those clinical hours don’t involve actually having contact with a patient.
They mention they are trained for primary care. Did they mention that Oregon naturopaths object to vaccination, that they do an inferior job at vaccinating their patients, who are then more likely to have a vaccine preventable disease? Did they mention they also do a poor job at cancer screening? None of which should come as a surprise if you understand their training and edumacation.
Then they go through a series of slides discussing the naturopathic approach to patients, and the slides are remarkably vague. They mention none of the widespread pseudo-medicines that are the bread and butter of naturopathy. See “Disingenuous: Deconstruction of a naturopathic white paper” and others on this site for the truth THEY do not want you to know, about the reality of naturopathic practice. The devil is, as is always the case, in the details, and the details of ND practice should scare the hell out of any doctor.
And please.
Whole system approach. That is what we do, real doctors, based on years of education and training in reality based medicine. Do not let the frauds of SCAM, whose whole systems are based in fantasy, have you believing otherwise.
Naturopathy, chiropractic and acupuncture are to real medicine what guitar hero is to Jimmy Page. They play at medicine, but the result of playing at medicine is dead people, as demonstrated in Canada with Ezekiel Stephan, a 19 month old boy whose naturopath treated meningitis with tincture of echinacea. The first patient I took care of paid with their life thanks to naturopathic care, taking alkaline therapy for their cancer and dying of progressive untreated malignancy
Don’t think a naturopath has even the vaguest sense of real disease and treatment.
Integrative medicine
What is integrative medicine? It:
combines treatments from conventional medicine and complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) for which there is some high quality evidence of safety and effectiveness (NCCAM)
What are the CAMs suggested?
    • Natural products: herbal, vitamins, minerals and other natural products
    • Mind body medicine: deep breathing, meditation, yoga, acupuncture, guided imagery, tai chi, hypnotism, progressive relaxation, qi gong
    • Manipulative and body based practices: massage, manipulation
    • Energy medicine: Reiki, healing touch, qi gong
    • Chinese medicine
    • Ayurvedic medicine
    • Functional medicine
    • Homeopathy
    • Naturopathy
    • Traditional healers
    • Environmental medicine
    • Group Visits
This is a list of all the pseudo-medicines that do not work, cannot work if known reality is to be understood, and only have toxicities and side effects. None of the above have high quality evidence for effectiveness. Many (homeopathy, reiki) are literally nothing. The basis of therapeutic touch was disproven by a 6th grader and published in JAMA. Chinese and Ayurvedic products might have well been made using Portland air and Flint water, they are so often filled with toxins – real toxins, like lead, arsenic and mercury.
So integrative medicine is taking rank pseudo-scientific nonsense and combining it real medicine. That is why I say, when you integrate cow pie with apple pie, the cow pie is not made better, the apple pie is made worse.
And then the usual mea culpa as to why these modalities cannot be or are not studied:
The double-blind placebo-controlled trial is not ideal for studying interventions which individualize care, such as homeopathy and acupuncture.
“Either homeopathy works or controlled trials don’t!” said Scottish homeopath David Reilly. The reason that double-blind placebo-controlled trial is not ideal is that homeopathy and acupuncture are cow pies.
The healing interaction may be dismissed by many researchers as “placebo” effect, whereas we acknowledge this is often more important than any other treatments we apply.
If you are relying on placebo, you are relying on nothing. And it is considered unethical to give placebo outside of clinical trials, not that SCAM practitioners worry about the ethics of their practice.
Meta-analysis, often set as the gold standard, is problematic because it often pools reasonable studies with poorly-designed studies which may have used an inferior botanical extract, used inadequate dosing or had other serious methodological flaws, so that a truly effective intervention may be discounted based on such pooling of good and bad studies.
Or maybe it is because the aforementioned modalities are based on nonsense and as such do not have efficacy? 50 years of research into SCAM and they still can’t find efficacy for any of the above interventions. Rather than admit they are not effective, they rationalize away their failure. It is why no SCAM is ever abandoned or altered. Ever. SCAM is immune to data.
As best I can tell, there are no lectures from a reality/science-based medicine perspective on SCAM. If that is the introduction to integrative medicine, the students at OHSU are in a world of hurt. If one of you have made it this far, please send the link for this blog to all your classmates.
In the real world, the curse scam:
This scam involves convincing the mark that she and her valuables, including cash, are cursed and that the con artist, posing as a psychic, Tarot card reader, Gypsy, clairvoyant or the like has the power to cleanse the person and her money and jewelry, thereby lifting the curse. Modern con artists sometimes claim the problem is “negative energy” rather than a curse, which might appear too old-fashioned a term for people hip to the New Age.
is punished with jail. In, what is in my opinion (as is this entire post, although opinion better supported by reality) the medical equivalent:
This SCAM involves convincing the patient that she has an imbalance or toxins and that the provider, posing as a real doctor or the like has the power to cleanse the person of toxins or restore balance thereby treating the illness. Modern providers sometimes claim the problem is found by identifying the real cause of disease and open Integrative Medicine clinics, to appear modern for people hip to the New Age.
and is rewarded with tenure track academic positions.
If I were a medical student at OHSU, I would ask for a prorated tuition refund for the four plus hours devoted to pseudo-scientific propaganda.
And any student at OHSU who would like free, yes free, pdfs of the complete set of Science-Based Medicine ebooks, including books on acupuncture, chiropractic and naturopathy, send an email to admin[at]sfsbm.org and I will send you a link.
The final irony, and perhaps of source of true perpetual energy, is that at one time science-based medicine was important in US medical schools thanks to the Flexner Report. That is no longer the case. Now Flexner must be spinning in his grave at such a ferocious rate if we could just wrap him in copper wire we could generate enough electricity for the whole state.

   Medical students actively recruited for CAM
Peter Lipson
Link
Here at Science-Based Medicine we’ve been getting a lot of letters from medical students. This is a good thing and a bad thing. I’m glad people see us a a resource for SBM, but I’m unhappy that medical students: 1) need us; 2) don’t have someone to approach on campus. Let’s explore some of the more subtle ways cult medical practices infiltrate medical education.
Outpatient Rotations
In order to give all of their students experience in outpatient medicine, most med schools must reach out to the community. Sure, some med schools have big enough clinics to support an experience for all of their students, but that’s the minority. For their internal medicine, pediatrics, and family medicine rotations, med students often spend time at private doctors’ offices. These offices are minimally vetted, and I’d venture to guess that the vetting does not include checking for non-standard practices. In fact, schools are so desperate for spots, that almost any office will do. It’s good for students to see how medicine is practiced in the “real world” but that real world often involves cult medicine practices. Along the same lines, many practitioners are not up to date on the most recent best practices. I remember a family doc I worked with who used to give huge doses of intramuscular steroids to people for seasonal allergies. This isn’t the best idea, but I was a student. Who was I to tell him how to practice medicine?
We don’t police our colleagues very effectively—we have surrendered that duty largely to the courts. However, if doctors want a medical school affiliation, it seems a small price to allow the school to come in and see if the office practices medicine according to the standard of care. In addition to checking for the most minimal quality standards, it would rule out docs who are offering voodoo in place of medicine.
Sponsored Groups
There are dozens of medical student groups out there—some supporting peoples’ choice of specialty, some with religious or cultural affiliations, and other simply for fun. It’s not unusual for these groups to bring in speakers. There is generally a collegial atmosphere at medical schools—for example, I am staunchly pro-choice, and a friend and fellow student was staunchly anti-abortion, and belonged to a Christian medical student group. We sparred frequently, including having dueling letters to the editor in the Chicago Tribune, but we also often had a beer together and hung out. We understood that we would not agree on this issue and that we would each fight hard for our position.
What happens when this collegiality breaks down? I’ve heard of instances where medical students have spoken out and been slapped down by their fellow students. This is a very common tactic of cult medicine groups—since they can’t win on facts, they cannot tolerate dissent. If a student is harassed for speaking out against CAM on campus, who is she to turn to for support? Will she receive support from her dean? Will she be asked to make nice with the people promoting harmful practices?
At a recent meeting of the American Medical Student Association, a bill was introduced to officially recognize naturopathic students as “medical students”. Medical students are just starting their journey to become doctors are are vulnerable to this “inclusiveness” message. The bill was thankfully voted down, but this helps illustrate how deeply the alties are working.
Ethical Crisis
We are at a crossroads in medical education. Proponents of made-up medical practices are infiltrating the academy at every level, and trying to convert medical students at a vulnerable time. When they are called out, they cry foul. The tactics are quasi-religious. Those of us in medical education have a grave responsibility. We must train doctors who are compassionate and who understand the difference between science-based medicine and everything else. It’s time to be less inclusive in our curricula. It’s time to have coursework that specifically addresses made-up medical practices, explains why they are wrong, dangerous, and unethical. It is time to take the offensive. It both delights and saddens me that this blog is one of the centers for the defense of medicine. It shouldn’t have to be that way. That being said, we will continue to be a resource for those interested in keeping the science in medicine, and will hopefully help birth some additional resources in the near future.
If you are a student or educator and are concerned about made-up medicine in your institution, feel free to email us. We share emails among ourselves but with no one else, and we will not write about your situation without your explicit permission. It’s time we all joined the battle.

   A University of Michigan Medical School alumnus confronts anthroposophic medicine at his alma mater
David Gorski
Link
I graduated from the University of Michigan Medical School in the late 1980s. If there’s one thing I remember about the four years I was there, it’s that U. of M. was really hardcore about science back then. In fact, one of the things I remember is that U. of M. was viewed as being rather old-fashioned. No new (at the time) organ system approach for us! Every four weeks, like clockwork, we’d have what was called a concurrent examination, which basically meant that we were tested (with multiple choice tests, of course) on every subject on the same morning. The medical curriculum for the first two years had been fairly constant for quite some time, with a heaping helpin’ of anatomy, histology, biochemistry, and physiology in the first year and the second year packed full of pharmacology, pathology, and neurosciences. Nowhere to be found was anything resembling “energy medicine” or anything that wasn’t science-based!
Of course, back in the 1980s, the infiltration of quackademic medicine into medical schools and academic medical centers hadn’t really begun in earnest yet, although the rumblings of what is now called “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) and, more frequently these days, “integrative medicine” (IM) were starting to be heard in East Coast and West Coast schools. Even there, though, the incipient CAM movement was viewed as fringe, not worthy of the attention of serious academic physicians. Indeed, in the late 1980s, even at what are now havens of quackademic medicine if someone had suggested that diluting substances until there is nothing left, as in homeopathy, or waving your hands over a patient in order to channel the “universal source” of energy into a patient in order to heal a patient, as in reiki, had any place in scientific medicine, he’d have been laughed out of medical school–and rightly so.
Not so today, unfortunately. Although the problem of infiltration of quackademic medicine into academic medical centers goes way beyond this example, I can point out that faith healing based on Eastern mystical beliefs instead of Christianity is alive and well and ensconced in academic medical centers such as the University of Maryland School of Medicine Center for Integrative Medicine, where reiki masters are roaming the halls of the University of Maryland R. Adam Cowley Shock Trauma Center and Bonnie Tarantino, a Melchizedek practitioner, holographic sound healer, and an Usui and Karuna Reiki Master holds sway. Meanwhile, all manner of woo, such as acupuncture, homeopathy, craniosacral therapy, reiki, and reflexology are offered. Truly, you know that when an academic medical center has gone so far as to offer homeopathy, reflexology, and reiki, it’s all over as far as academic credibility is concerned, and it has become a center of quackademic medicine. Sadly, even a hospital where I trained, MetroHealth Medical Center, has succumbed to the temptation to add the quackery that is reiki to its armamentarium. That aside, I had never expected that my old, hardcore University of Michigan would go woo in such a big way.
I was wrong.
Over the last decade, the University of Michigan Medical School has gotten into alternative medicine, adding IM to its curriculum and even having a fellowship in IM. At the time I first learned of this a few years ago, as disturbed as I was, I reassured myself that at least U. of M. seemed to be sticking to the milder woo, like acupuncture and massage. Then, while browsing the blogs last month, I came across reports by P.Z. Myers and Tufted Titmouse, both of which contained a link to the University of Michigan Integrative Medicine (UMIM) resource page. And what to my wondering eyes did appear? (Actually, I should rephrase that as, “What to my despairing eyes should appear?”) The answer: Anthroposophic Medicine. Yes, it’s anthroposophy, Rudolf Steiner’s mystical, magical system that is the bottom of a lot of quackery and anti-vaccine beliefs. Indeed, outbreaks of vaccine-preventable disease have been distressingly common at Waldorf schools, where the educational philosophy is based on the teachings of Rudolf Steiner, which is why they are sometimes called Steiner schools or Steiner-Waldorf schools. Although the European Council for Steiner-Waldorf Education, which represents approximately 700 of the 1000 Waldorf schools world wide, has stated unequivocally that opposition to immunization forms no part of the goals of Waldorf education, Waldorf schools are magnets for parents opposed to vaccination. One example occurred in California in 2008, when there was a measles outbreak at the East Bay Waldorf School in El Sobrante. Given that the UMIM program, although interdisciplinary, boasts heavy involvement of family medicine faculty, I can’t imagine the cognitive dissonance that must be going on. After all, many family medicine doctors also take care of children and are responsible for making sure they are properly immunized just as much as any pediatrician.
But let’s look at what UMIM’s webpage on anthroposophy says about it:
Anthroposophic medicine views health as a matter of mind-body-spirit balance. It is centered on the idea that humans are not independent organisms but, instead, beings composed of the interactions of physical body, inner life body, soul (mind and emotions), and spiritual ego (self-awareness). Whereas conventional medicine focuses on “fixing” the part of the physical body that is “broken,” anthroposophic medicine prescribes treatment for the whole being through conventional methods in combination with holistic methods. As such, anthroposophic medicine integrates theories and practices of modern medicine with alternative, nature-based treatments and a spiritual-scientific understanding of the human being. The practice is based on Austrian philosopher Rudolf Steiner’s concept of anthroposophy, a scientific and philosophical world view that connects the spiritual within the human being to the spiritual in nature, the world and the cosmos.
This is consistent with what the Holistic Health Internet Community says about anthroposophic medicine:
Austrian scientist and philosopher Rudolf Steiner (1861-1925) refused to accept the contemporary scientific view of the body as a purely physical entity. From that conviction was born the doctrine of anthroposophy, a word he coined from the Greek words for “man” and “divine wisdom.” Steiner believed in the uniqueness of each human being, and contended that health and well-being deteriorated without that belief. Trained as a scientist and a mathematician, he was influenced by Hindu and Buddhist beliefs and founded a school in which his theories became practice.
Anthroposophical medicine determines the nature of illness based on Steiner’s principal of polarity. His system attempts to link and harmonize both the upper and lower poles of the body. Good health then depends on a harmonious relationship between the physical, etheric and astral bodies, and the ego. Practitioners are trained as medical doctors and may treat childhood infections, hay fever and asthma, anxiety, depression, cancer, musculoskeletal problems and fatigue.
If twenty years ago someone had told me that one day that not only would my medical alma mater be publishing dreck like this, but that it would have formed an interdisciplinary program devoted to it, I would have told that person he was delusional. If you had told me that anthroposophy would be part of a larger program of woo run by a physician who is described as having “studied herbalism and spiritual healing for 14 years with a Native American Healer” and as having research interests that include the “use of herbs, energy healing, environmental healing, and the therapeutic relationship” or that a physician trained in “functional medicine” would be a big part of a program in anthroposophic medicine there, I wouldn’t have believed it. All I can wonder is what Bill Kelley, the infamously hardcore scientific chair of the Department of Internal Medicine while I was at Michigan, would think or say if he were still at U. of M. In fact, having read the section on anthroposophy on U. of M.’s website, I wish I were delusional. But I’m not. The section is real, and the medical school from which I graduated has not only started to tolerate such nonsense, but begun to embrace it.
Anthroposophical medicine, it turns out, is rooted in prescientific vitalism. Rudolf Steiner, before he came up with the idea of anthroposophy, had led the German section of Theosophy. When he became enamored of his spiritual concept of anthroposophy, Steiner in essence caused a schism. Anthroposophy, it further turns out, is far more a religious and spiritual philosophy than a scientific or medical one. Based on his philosophy, Steiner created Waldorf schools, anthroposophic medicine, and biodynamic farming, the last of which would be a suitable topic for an amusing post on a non-medical blog. Suffice to say that some of the practices of biodynamic farming involve stuffing Yarrow blossoms (Achillea millefolium) into urinary bladders from Cervus elaphus, Red Deers, placing them in the sun during summer, burying them in earth during winter and retrieving them in the spring, all to strengthen the “life force” of the farm. There’s also a lot of use of cow horns, based on Steiner’s rationale, “The cow has horns in order to reflect inwards the astral and etheric formative forces, which then penetrate right into the metabolic system so that increased activity in the digestive organism arises by reason of this radiation from horns and hoofs.” Moreover, many of the concepts of homeopathy are combined with Steiner’s woo, such that many of the concoctions of biodynamic farming, which consist of various bits of dead animals plus or minus ground quartz crystals, are diluted into many tons of compost, to be spread over acres of farmland.
But let’s get back to anthroposophic medicine, which is based on the same sort of mystical philosophy that biodynamic farming is. Simon Singh and Edzard Ernst characterize this form of medicine thusly in their book Trick or Treatment?:
Applying his philosophical concepts to health, he [Rudolf Steiner] founded, together with Dr. Ita Wegman, an entirely new school of medicine. It assumes metaphysical relations between planets, metals, and human organs, which provide the basis for therapeutic strategies. Diseases are believed to be related to actions in previous lives; in order to redeem oneself, it may be best to live through them without conventional therapy. Instead, a range of other therapeutic modalities is employed in anthroposophic medicine: herbal extracts, art therapy, massage, exercise therapy, and other unconventional approaches.
Perhaps the most common example of anthroposophic medicine is the use of mistletoe extracts for the treatment of cancer. Perhaps you’ve heard of Iscador? While Iscador might actually have some activity against, for example, breast cancer, it is not without toxicity, and the evidence for its efficacy in cancer is at best conflicting. Even if Iscador turned out to be an effective treatment for breast cancer, it would be an example of being right for a reason that is spectacularly wrong. That’s because Steiner argued that mistletoe is a parasitic plant that eventually kills its host. To him, this represented a striking parallel to malignant tumors, which, like mistletoe, are parasitic entities that eventually kill their hosts. Steiner’s conclusion? Because of this resemblance, mistletoe must be an effective treatment for cancer. Readers knowledgeable about homeopathy will immediately recognize that Steiner clearly must have believed in the homeopathic principle of “like cures like.” In fact, he even went beyond that to generalize that “a plant is a healing plant when it has a distortion or an abnormality in its physiology and morphology,” presumably related to human disease. Indeed, according to Dr. Peter Hindenberger this represents a “modern, scientific reformulation of what, in former times, existed in the ‘doctrine of signatures‘”; i.e., the belief that God has marked everything he created with a sign (signature) that is an indication of the purpose for which the item was created.
Although you can read more about anthroposophic medicine, either at a Steiner website or the Physician’s Association for Anthroposophic Medicine (to get it right from the horse’s mouth, so to speak) or over at The Skeptic’s Dictionary and Quackwatch, including a description of what being a student at a Waldorf school is like, because this is about UMIM’s apparent embrace of anthroposophical medicine, I think that I will close by discussing what UMIM says about it. But, before I do so, let me quote a passage from what PAAM says about it in a PDF booklet. After all, U. of M. includes a link to PAAM on its website, which leads me to assume that the UMIM program in anthroposophic medicine endorses PAAM. So does the fact that PAAM is based in Ann Arbor. But back to the PAAM pamphlet:
Medicine based purely on material science is limited to explaining an illness solely on the basis of the laws of physics and chemistry.
I’m sorry. I can’t help but interject here that PAAM says this as though it were a bad thing. Personally, though, I’m curious as to how we can explain illness not based on the laws of physics and chemistry. Unfortunately, PAAM is more than happy to tell us how anthroposophic medicine is “more ambitious” than us mere practitioners and proponents of science-based medicine. I suppose it is, casting off, as it does, all those inconvenient laws of physics and chemistry that took hundreds of years to discover and understand:
Anthroposophic medicine is more ambitious. It takes into account additional factors, both general and individual, that may affect the patient’s life, mind, and soul, and their physical manifestation: in growth, regeneration, microcirculation, fluid retention in the skin, muscle tone, biorhythms, head distribution, posture, uprightness, gait, mental focus, speech. When illness occurs, examination of the above may reveal deviations, imbalances, and extremes–additional diagnostic parameters that need to be considered when selecting a therapy. Anthroposophic medicine also has a different understanding of the role played by the patient in overcoming illness. The patient is not simply a passive recipient of medical skill, but an equal partner with the doctor. After all, nobody can know the patient better than the patient. During an illness, the patient has the opportunity to recognise the state of imbalance body and soul have reached, to understand this and rectify it. The illness can provide an opportunity to learn new modes of behaviour, to develop further insights, and acquire greater maturity.
And, yes, anthroposophic medicine embraces homeopathy:
In addition, other substances tailored to the patient’s unique characteristics are administered. These are frequently homeopathic substances designed to stimulate the organism and its powers of self-healing.
Science-based medicine, anthroposophy clearly is not. Of course, that’s quite obvious from what UMIM itself says about the anthroposophic view of health. According to UMIM, this consists of these tenets, with my comments in brackets after each item:
    • Health involves a dynamic balance and high functioning of all aspects of a person’s life. [This is so vague as to be meaningless and all but impossible to argue with, but it's the sort of trope common in alt-med circles.]
    • Illness is the result of disharmony and imbalance amongst the three systems of the body and their related forces and effects. [This sounds very much like attributing disease to imbalances in the four humors. Teach the controversy! about the Four-fold Man!]
    • Illness is a tragedy, but also an opportunity for learning and transformation. [This sounds very much like the quackery that is the German New Medicine and Biologie Totale to me; that is, if you strip away Steiner's belief in reincarnation wherein illness isn't the working through of unrecognized emotional traumas in this life (as German New Medicine teaches) but is rather the working through of issues from previous lives.]
    • The signs and symptoms of an illness are often the body’s attempts at healing and, in general, should not be suppressed, but rather, aided, observed and resolved. [More German New Medicine- and Biologie Totale-like gobbledygook. Again, odd how U. of M. leaves out Steiner's belief that these body's attempts at healing are related to past life experiences.]
    • Many illnesses, especially benign ones, should not be artificially prevented, but should be allowed to occur and be treated and healed. The patient thereby gains strength and experience, both biologically and spiritually. [This would appear to be the basis for so many anti-vaccine beliefs that permeate every aspect of anthroposophic medicine and the education taught in Waldorf schools. After all, what is vaccination, but preventing illness? I guess your kids get so much stronger, spiritually and biologically, if you just let them, take their chances with measles, mumps, whooping cough, and Haemophilus influenzae type B. Because, you know, that worked out so well for children in terms of childhood mortality back in the days before vaccines could prevent these diseases. Oh, wait. No it didn't.]
    • True prevention of illnesses involves a healthy lifestyle with positive habits, strengthening the biological, psychological and spiritual aspects of a person, and avoiding the detrimental and illness-producing effects of much of modern civilization. [Do I detect a reference to "toxins" here? I think I do.]
UMIM even goes on to link to a company that produces skin care products and medicines based on Steiner’s biodynamic farming (including Iscador and homeopathic remedies), as well as to point out that many anthroposophical remedies can only be administered as an inpatient at a facility like the Rudolf Steiner Health Center in Ann Arbor, Michigan. There, you can find a video about anthroposophic medicine:
”The Art of Healing” (English subtitled) from Frigyes Fogel on Vimeo.
Check out the part around 24:25, where a chemist describes how anthroposophic medicines are made, including the part about how he “potentizes” many of them in decimal fractions, just as homeopaths do with their remedies. His goal is, as he puts it, to “strengthen the vital forces within the living organism while at the same time respecting its natural rhythm.” He also heads out to the French border at 4 AM during the summer so that he can harvest Arnica plants at dawn, thus allowing the “morning strength” to be maintained in them. I kid you not. Then, get a load of this description of anthroposophic medicines, right off the U. of M. website:
Many anthroposophic remedies are specially prepared using homeopathic or modern alchemical pharmaceutical processes to naturally stimulate healing processes in the ill person.
Yes, it would appear that alchemy is alive and well at U. of M.!
Fortunately, the Rudolf Steiner Health Center does not appear to be affiliated with the University of Michigan, at least as far as I can tell. Unfortunately, it’s still very disturbing that UMIM would recommend such an institution and even more disturbing that “anthroposophic physicians at the University of Michigan” appear to be partnering with the Rudolf Steiner Health Center to research anthroposophic medicine as supportive care for cancer patients.
Personally, I think that Robert Carroll gets it exactly right when he characterizes anthroposophic medicine as being “even more out of touch with modern, science-based medicine than homeopathy.” Think about it. Homeopathy is based on just two magical ideas: The Law of Similars and the Law of Infinitesimals, which together can be viewed as an expression of the ancient principles of sympathetic magic. In marked contrast, anthroposophic medicine is based on many ideas with no basis in science that can best be described as pure magical thinking. Indeed, to me at least, anthroposophic medicine resembles more than anything else naturopathy in that there doesn’t appear to be a form of unscientific, prescientific, vitalism-based woo that it doesn’t embrace. In fact, anthroposophic medicine appears to go far beyond naturopathy in that respect. It also brings into play a veritable cornucopia of mystical concepts, including the etheric body, the astral body, and the ego. It postulates that the soul, the senses, and the consciousness are beings that have an independent existence outside of the body and further asserts that herbs, essential oils, and movement therapy known as eurythmy can bring these things into harmony and balance with each other and the physical body. Reading about anthroposophy and anthroposophic medicine, I had some serious acid flashbacks to my youth, when I used to be an avid Dungeons & Dragons player. My personal oddities during my high school and college years aside, anthroposophic medicine openly denigrates science-based medicine for only being able to diagnose and treat disease according to its understanding of the laws of physics and chemistry, to which I respond: Upon what else would a physician base his understanding of disease? As Carroll put it:
Steiner approached medicine the same way he approached everything else from astrology to Atlantis to education to farming to metaphysics: He dictated his visions. Why anyone considers him a scientist is a great mystery. His notion of science as involving the explanation of how immaterial entities affect material entities is the very opposite of science.
Indeed, and the medical school from which I graduated over 20 years ago now has a program dedicated to teaching physicians and medical students as fact the medical philosophy of this very man, whose philosophy is not only far more religion and mysticism than science but is indeed antiscience at its very core despite its superficial declaration of allegiance to science. Indeed anthroposophic medicine’s assertion of relationships between the various bodies (physical, etheric, etc.) and astronomical bodies is far more akin to astrology than science. Would that it were only homeopathy U. of M. were teaching and practicing!
I used to be very proud to have graduated from the University of Michigan Medical School. When I was there, it was one of the top public medical schools in the country and compared quite well with any private medical school in the U.S. you could name. In many ways, it still does. Unfortunately, like those other top medical schools, including Harvard, Yale, Stanford, and Columbia, U. of M. appears to have embraced quackademic medicine. I only wish it had, instead of imitating such schools, resisted the siren call of unscientific, prescientific, and pseudoscientific medicine. Unfortunately, as its embrace of anthroposophy demonstrates, it has not. As a result, the pride I have as a U. of M. alumnus is now tarnished with the knowledge that, even though the vast majority of what happens at the medical school and its affiliated hospitals is still solidly science-based and U. of M. boasts some of the best medical research programs anywhere, there now exists section within it that teaches pseudoscientific nonsense as if it were science. It makes me very sad and depressed to contemplate.
No doubt the U. of M. faculty and leadership responsible for this travesty will say that they pick and choose only the bits from anthroposophic medicine that are evidence-based and ignore all the woo. Quite frankly, to me anthroposophic medicine is pretty much all woo as far as I can tell. Or perhaps they would argue that the anthroposophic medicine program is a tiny part of a vast enterprise of science-based medicine. This is almost certainly true. It’s also probably true that relatively few U. of M. faculty even know about the existence of a Steiner-inspired program at their school. To me, however, there is zero place for such religious- and mysticism-inspired nonsense in any reputable medical school, other than as a footnote in courses in the history of medicine. Certainly there is no place for it being taught or practiced as though it had any validity whatsoever anywhere near medical students, residents, or fellows–and especially nowhere near patients.
Finally, knowing that U. of M. is teaching and practicing anthroposophic medicine makes me very irritated whenever I get mail soliciting donations for its medical school. From here on out, I think that, whenever a U. of M. Medical School solicitation arrives in the mail, I’ll send it back with a link to this post as the reason why I must decline.

   The ultimate in “integrative medicine,” continued
David Gorski 
Link
It’s been a recurring theme on this blog to discuss and dissect the infiltration of quackademic medicine into our medical schools. Whether it be called “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or “integrative medicine” (IM), its infiltration into various academic medical centers has been one of the more alarming developments I’ve noted over the last several years. The reason is that “integrative” medicine is all too often in reality nothing more than “integrating” pseudoscience with science, quackery with medicine. The most popular modalities that medical schools and academic medicine centers can’t seem to resist are acupuncture and various forms of “energy” healing, such as reiki and therapeutic touch. Unfortunately, when you “integrate” something like reiki or therapeutic touch (TT), which basically assert that there is mystical, magical energy source (called the “universal source” by reiki practitioners, for example) that practitioners can tap into and channel into patients for healing effect, you are in essence integrating a prescientific understanding of the world with science, religious faith healing (which, let’s face it, is all that reiki is), and magic with reality.
Why would medical institutions ostensibly based on science do that?
I don’t know, but I know it’s happening. There are many forces that conspire to insert sectarian versions of medicine into bastions of scientific medicine. These include cultural relativism leading to a reluctance to call quackery quackery; financial forces such as the Bravewell Collaborative, which funds a number of IM programs at academic centers; the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM); and a variety of other factors. It’s been a depressing slide, and periodically I wonder just how much more pseudoscience can be “integrated” into medical schools and academic medical centers or how much further medical schools can go in pandering to nonsense. I’m not wondering anymore, at least for now, not after learning about a cooperative agreement between Georgetown University and the National University of Health Sciences:
National University of Health Sciences (NUHS) has announced a new cooperative arrangement with the Graduate Program in Complementary and Alternative Medicine at Georgetown University Medical Center in Washington D.C., which will benefit students preparing for careers in health care and integrative medicine.
Faculty at the two schools will now work together to help students seeking advanced degrees in health care, by advising students of the benefits of each other’s programs and providing preferential seating and advanced standing in each other’s programs when appropriate.
Take a look at the NUHS website. Look at its offerings: chiropractic, naturopathy, traditional Chinese medicine, acupuncture, massage therapy, and “biomedical science,” which, given all the other woo being taught at NUHS, I have to wonder about. Just take a look, too, at the curriculum for obtaining a doctor of naturopathy degree. It’s full of homeopathy, traditional Chinese medicine, hydrotherapy and, of course, naturopathy. I must admit, however, to some amusement when I saw that there is a course entitled, “Evidence Based Practice: Critical Appraisal of the Biomedical Literature.” Quite frankly, if this course truly taught evidence-based practice, then it would teach that all that homeopathy taught in other courses is nonsense, along with naturopathy itself.
Fat chance of that happening, not with “integration” like this:
Program directors at Georgetown selected NUHS as a top-tier institution providing educational excellence in its professional degree programs, thus meriting Georgetown’s recommendation for its graduates seeking professional degrees. According to Aviad “Adi” Haramati, who co-directs the program with Hakima Amri, PhD, the academic affiliation is intended to “…break down the silos that hold the disciplines apart and create relationships between the disciplines and the educational institutions that prepare the nation’s future healthcare providers.”
Great. Just what we need: “breaking down silos” separating pseudoscience from science-based medicine. That’s exactly what’s happening here, and Georgetown is leading the way, so much so, in fact, that this is not the first time it has forged a partnership with an institute dedicated to teaching pseudoscience and quackery. If you want to see another example of this sort of “integration,” behold this academic “integration” model championed by Georgetown University, this time with the infamous school of naturopathy, Bastyr University:
A model inter-institutional relationship may help bridge the chasm that separates health professions education in conventional academic health centers from institutions educating students for the distinctly licensed integrative practice (“CAM”) professions. Says one leader: “I believe we are poised to make an important advance in how the future training of health professionals may evolve.” The speaker is Adi Haramati, PhD, integrative medicine leader at Georgetown University, describing a new relationship between Georgetown and Bastyr University relative to Bastyr’s naturopathic medical program and Georgetown’s MS CAM program. Haramati and his co-director Hakima Amri, PhD are exploring similar relationships with chiropractic schools and other health professions institutions. The developers “would like nothing more” than to see this bridge-building relationship be used as a model for other academic health centers and CAM institutions.
That’s right. Georgetown is partnering with schools of pseudoscience in order to train the next generation of CAM practitioners. It’s not enough to team up with the naturopaths. Even several months ago, when Georgetown first teamed up with a naturopathic school, Dr. Haramati had been envisioning teaming up with chiropractic schools. That’s what the NUHS is, mostly, and the agreement between Georgetown and NUHS seems to be the first step towards realizing the vision he presented at the time he teamed up with Bastyr.
But it’s more than that. More than five years ago, Georgetown decided that CAM should be “integrated” into its curriculum to the point where it was made part of its medical school curriculum. However, Georgetown went way beyond simply having a lecture or two on CAM here and there and offering clinical electives to fourth year medical students in CAM. That wasn’t enough. The vision was far more bold and—dare I say, given what’s happened in the last five years?—forward-looking. What Georgetown offered was what it referred to in its own brochures as:
The “seamless” weaving of CAM into existing classes includes, for instance, a presentation by an acupuncturist on the “anatomy of acupuncture” in the gross anatomy course for first-year students. The same lecturer explores acupuncture’s application in pain relief in the neuroscience course.
I wish this were a joke, but it’s not. The “anatomy” of acupuncture? Which “anatomy,” given that the magical, mystical meridians along which a life energy that science can’t detect allegedly flows? Teaching such material in anatomy class is indeed the ultimate seamless “integration” of pseudoscience with science, quackery with science-based medicine. Breaking down silos, indeed. Fast forward five years, and here is the vision for true “integration” in medical education towards which Georgetown is working with Bastyr (and now, NUHS), in which it isn’t just Georgetown but Georgetown teaming up with institutions of quackery:
Student A completes an academic Masters of Science program at a highly esteemed academic health center. He or she is wondering her/his future. The program focused on the science of complementary and integrative medicine. But what does the individual’s future hold? Go on to medical school? Personnel with the program lay out options. Among them, without prejudice: Have you considered this naturopathic medical school?
Meantime, Student B is considering naturopathic medical college. The field of complementary and alternative medicine intrigues. But is he or she ready to make the jump for that 4-year, residential commitment? Is naturopathic medicine or regular medical school or chiropractic medical education what they want? Personnel with the naturopathic medical program say: You might consider this year-long Masters of Science in complementary and alternative medicine at this academic health center.
The basis of this relationship between Bastyr and Georgetown, we hear, is a new “respect” being shown towards CAM modalities, and this is the way that the joint program will be structured:
The fundamental aim of this program is to provide students with competencies in three areas: grounding in science (especially systems and cell physiology), introductory exposure and understanding of CAM disciplines and philosophies, and the ability to rigorously assess the state of evidence regarding safety and efficacy of various CAM therapies.
Let’s see. Science…good. We like to see medical students exposed to science. Exposure to CAM disciplines…not so good. Don’t get me wrong. I very much believe that medical students should be taught about CAM modalities, but they should be taught about them from a the perspective of the state of the science, the evidence, and clinical trials. They should be taught about skepticism and critical thinking. They should be taught about how various CAM remedies, such as herbal medicines, interact with pharmaceuticals. That is not what this program sounds like, as a science-based perspective leads to the conclusion that the vast majority of CAM either hasn’t been shown to work or has been shown to work. If such weren’t the case, CAM wouldn’t have the word “alternative” in it.
Let me just put it this way. When this program claims to teach students how to “rigorously” assess the state of evidence regarding the safety and efficacy of various CAM therapies, the word “rigorously” applied to such teaching doesn’t mean the same thing that “rigorously” means when scientists actually do rigorously assess the evidence. What it usually means is buying into the aforementioned philosophy of various CAM disciplines and then proceeding from there. Either that, or it means what Harriet Hall likes to call Tooth Fairy science, which refers to doing research on a phenomenon without first establishing that the phenomenon exists first. In essence, it’s like studying the Tooth Fairy. You can measure how much money she leaves under the pillow. You can study whether she leaves more or less money for the first or last tooth. You can get a whole lot of data that appear reproducible. You might even get data that is statistically significant. But at the end of the day you haven’t actually established that the Tooth Fairy actually exists.
A better metaphor for research into CAM modalities like reiki, TT, or homeopathy is hard for me to imagine. After all, reiki is nothing more than faith healing that substitutes Eastern mysticism for Christian beliefs. TT is basically reiki lite, where even the Eastern mysticism is stripped down to vague New Agey-sounding ideas like channeling “energy” into patients through their hands. (You know, whenever I picture reiki or TT, I visualize one of my favorite comic book characters of all time, Dr. Strange, casting a spell. In fact, as has been suggested before, that’s the only real way I can see of making homeopathy work: a fictional Sorcerer Supreme and Master of the Mystic Arts casting a spell.
But, wait, I hear: What about something that’s less highly improbable? Homeopathy is obviously utter nonsense. So are reiki and other “energy” therapies. What about herbal medicine? What about manipulative therapies (leaving aside the dubious philosophical underpinnings of some such therapies, like homeopathy, which similarly appeal to “energy flow” through various locations)? Well, there’s already a branch of pharmacology that can study herbal remedies. It’s called pharmacognosy, and it isolates the active fractions of natural products and studies them, just as pharmacologists have done for decades, if not centuries. There’s nothing “alternative” in that that needs to be “integrated” into science-based medicine. Similarly, manipulative therapies are not beyond the reach of science to study rigorously, either. However, to do such studies it is necessary first to verify that a phenomenon exists, which can be done using the scientific method. What I fear will happen in this new Bastyr-Georgetown integration will be Tooth Fairy science. There’ll be a lot of data, but it won’t mean anything.
The other purpose of this integrated program is explicitly promotional of CAM. It explicitly seeks the “integration” of quackery with science-based medicine. Don’t believe me? Check out this vision:
The Georgetown agreement with Bastyr, and those Haramati and Amri are seeking with other schools, are terrific steps, laying scaffolding toward the vision, articulated at NED and embraced by ACCAHC, of “a healthcare system that is multidisciplinary and enhances competence, mutual respect and collaboration across all CAM and conventional healthcare disciplines.”
Georgetown is the trailblazer in “integrating” quackery into science-based medicine, but, although it’s first, it won’t be the last. This is a well-coordinated, longstanding effort on the part of CAM advocates, in which they actively lobby for such partnerships and such “integration” with science-based practitioners. Indeed, the Academic Consortium for Complementary and Alternative Health Care supports what it calls the Center for Optimal Integration, which explicitly works towards the sorts of partnerships that Georgetown has undertaken with Bastyr and NUHS.
Personally, I don’t see how “integrating” CAM into science-based health care would enhance competence, but then that’s just the nasty reductionist in me who rejects the false dichotomy of “alternative” medicine. After all, “alternative” medicine is nothing more than medicine that either hasn’t been shown to work or has been shown not to work. “Alternative medicine” that works is no longer “alternative.” It’s just medicine. Naturopathy is a hodge-podge, a grab bag of all sorts of unscientific and pseudoscientific medical treatments, most of which fall squarely into the “alternative” camp in every definition, particularly the ones about either not working or not having been demonstrated to work.
Unfortunately, when it comes to quackademic medicine, the false dichotomy lives, and institutions like Georgetown are betraying science-based medicine by being so open to the point of its brains falling out—and partnering with Bastyr to integrate nonsense with sense, pseudoscience with science, and quackery with medicine.

   Surprise, surprise! Dr. Andrew Weil doesn’t like evidence-based medicine
David Gorski
Link
Dr. Andrew Weil is a rock star in the “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) and “integrative medicine” (IM) movement. Indeed, it can be persuasively argued that he is one of its founders, at least a founder of the its most modern iteration, and I am hard-pressed to think of anyone who did more in the early days of the CAM/IM movement, back before it ever managed to achieve a modicum of unearned respectability, to popularize CAM. In fact, no physician that I can think of has over the course of his lifetime done more to promote the rise of quackademic medicine than Dr. Weil. The only forces greater than Dr. Weil in promoting the infiltration of pseudoscience into academic medicine have been the Bravewell Collaborative and the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM). Before there was Dr. Mehmet Oz, Dr. Dean Ornish, Dr. Mark Hyman, or any of the other promoters of IM, there was Dr. Weil.
And why not? Dr. Weil looks like an aging 1960s rock star, and, operating from his redoubt at the University of Arizona, is quite charismatic. For all the world he has the appearance of a kindly, benevolent Arizona desert Santa Claus, an ex-hippie turned respectable dispensing advice about “natural” medicines, writing books, and making himself ubiquitous on television and radio whenever the topic of alternative medicine comes up. Before Dr. Oz told Steve Novella that “Western” science and medicine can’t study woo like acupuncture, Dr. Weil was there, paving the way for such arguments, previously considered ludicrous, to achieve a patina of respectability.
In fact, he’s still at it, doing it far better and far more subtly than the ham-handed Dr. Oz. Unfortunately, it’s the same anti-science message and the same appeal to other ways of knowing built upon tearing down straw men versions of evidence-based medicine (EBM) with gusto. This was brought home last week when Dr. Weil co-authored an opinion piece with Drs. Scott Shannon and Bonnie J. Kaplan for the journal Alternative and Complementary Therapies entitled Safety and Patient Preferences, Not Just Effectiveness, Should Guide Medical Treatment Decisions, an article that was noted at the blog Booster Shots in a credulous, fawning post entitled Dr. Weil says there’s a better approach to evaluating clinical drug trials. In contast, Steve Novella put it far more succinctly (and accurately) in the title of his post: Andrew Weil Attacks EBM. That’s exactly what Weil and company did in this article.
While Steve is absolutely correct, I also see it more as Dr. Weil demonstrating once again that, upstarts like Dr. Oz aside, he is still the master of CAM/IM apologia, much as, even though both were Sith Lords, Emperor Palpatine remained master over Darth Vader until just before the end. You’ll see why in terms of the arguments, both subtle and not-so-subtle, that Dr. Weil and his acolytes make. Moreover, even though his disciple Shannon is granted the coveted first author position, the arguments presented leave little doubt that it’s Weil who’s driving the bus.
Efficacy, effectiveness, and safety, oh, my!
Shannon et al begin by emphasizing that there is a difference between “efficacy” and “effectiveness,” and from the very beginning take pains to separate their definitions of the two, pointing out that they will not use the terms interchangeably. Specifically, they refer to the definition of “efficacy” as “demonstration of benefit under ideal conditions, typically in randomized controlled trials” and “effectiveness” as “demonstration of benefit in real-life conditions.” These are relatively new concepts, comparatively speaking. Even so, they are nothing “alternative,” being instead firmly within the bailiwick of EBM. This doesn’t stop Shannon et al from presenting these concepts as though EBM and science-based medicine (SBM) don’t consider questions of whether treatments work under real-life conditions. As you will see, it is also the opening volley in a rather complex set of fallacious arguments designed to support the watering down of scientific rigor in order to allow CAM/IM modalities that can’t stand up under close scientific investigations to be labeled as “effective” (or at least acceptable).
First of all, let’s see a bit more what Weil and company are up to when they compare “effectiveness” with “efficacy.” Mostly, it’s meant to attack the reliance of EBM randomized clinical trials (RCTs) in order to set the stage for proposing something else more to their liking:
The value of efficacy lies mainly in its ability to indicate potential for effectiveness accurately. Sadly, in the drive to emphasize the importance of delineating clearly sound measures of clinical effectiveness, modern medicine has come to equate RCTs as the final arbitrators of clinical decision making. As discussed below, RCTs are but one tool to sort out these complex questions. In integrative medicine (IM), particularly, with its emphasis on patient variables and practitioner participation, evaluation of efficacy is not sufficient.
I agree that one major value of efficacy in RCTs is that it indicates the potential for effectiveness in the real world. I also even partially agree that EBM overemphasizes RCTs as the final arbiters of clinical decision-making, although, I note, not for the same reason as Weil and his acolytes. We at SBM frequently make the argument that plausibility based on science should be a much more important consideration in evaluating treatments than it is in EBM. Indeed, this is a major reason that the term science-based medicine, as opposed to evidence-based medicine, was coined in the first place. EBM emphasizes RCTs without considerations of prior plausibility, relegating basic science considerations that conclusively demonstrate CAM/IM modalities like homeopathy to be so implausible as to be not worth studying in humans to its lowest rung in its scale of evidence. So, while we agree somewhat that EBM overemphasizes RCTs, we most definitely do not agree with Dr. Weil about how it does so. Whereas Dr. Weil seems to think that RCTs are overemphasized because they are too standardized and do not adequately take into account real-world conditions, he most definitely would not like SBM’s plea to EBM to consider scientific plausibility, because doing so would relegate modalities like energy healing, homeopathy, and acupuncture to the hopelessly implausible.
Dr. Weil also does a very clever thing with his argument. While he correctly points out that evaluation of efficacy is not sufficient to determine whether a treatment is effective, as Steve Novella pointed out, Dr. Weil conveniently neglects to acknowledge that it is at the very least necessary. If RCTs indicate that a therapy is not detectably more efficacious than a placebo, which is the case for the vast majority of CAM/IM modalities, then there is no point in doing trials in “real world” conditions because there is no reason to expect the to be effective. Basically, RCTs serve as a screening test to identify promising therapies that are likely to be effective in real world use. In essence, Dr. Weil is echoing the same two-pronged attack that CAM/IM advocates make against RCTs, the first being the claim that “Western science” can’t study his woo, which is the same fallacious argument that Dr. Oz made regarding acupuncture. The second prong of the attack is to point to what Weil calls “alternative sources of valid information” as demonstrating that his woo works when RCTs do not support its efficacy. Although Dr. Weil is careful never to state this explicitly or even use the term “pragmatic trial,” his emphasis on “effectiveness” over “efficacy” is in essence a plea for relying much more heavily on observational trials, in particular pragmatic trials.
But what are “pragmatic” trials? They are trials that seek to determine if a treatment is effective outside the confines of an RCT, in other words, out there in the “real world.” RCTs, because they seek to determine efficacy, need to control for as many potentially confounding factors as possible, which makes them inherently artificial to one extent or another. Once efficacy is established under controlled conditions, it is sometimes then useful to determine whether this efficacious treatment is effective under usual circumstances in the “real world,” where patient compliance might be poor, either due to side effects, cost, or difficulty in adhering to the therapy; where complicated protocols might be more problematic to follow compared to academic medical centers; and where use of the treatment will inevitably be expanded to patient populations not represented in the RCTs used to approve the drug.
Pragmatic trials can go one of two ways. In the case of treatments demonstrated efficacious in RCTs, most commonly pragmatic trials demonstrate a lower level of effectiveness than the efficacy measured in RCTs might indicate. As Harriet Hall discussed a couple of years ago, a classic example of a treatment that was shown to be efficacious in RCTs but potentially more dangerous in pragmatic studies of actual use in community hospitals was the clot-busting drug t-PA, which was effective for ischemic strokes in RCTs but resulted in a higher death rate. For efficacious interventions, the “real world” is almost always less hospitable than the “ideal world” of RCTs. There is one case, however, where the “real world” can make a treatment seem more effective than it is by any objective measure, and that’s for treatments that are essentially placebos. Outside of the rigorous, carefully controlled world of RCTs, placebo medicine can seem to have effectiveness, which is exactly why proponents of pseudoscientific medicine love pragmatic trials. The populations aren’t as well-defined; often there is no placebo control; and they are almost always unblinded. There is a good reason why, after well-designed RCTs have demonstrated acupuncture to be no more efficacious than placebo or sham acupuncture, acupuncturists have returned to pragmatic studies, as, I will note in a shameless plug, Harriet Hall will discuss tomorrow. The hospitableness of pragmatic trials to placebo medicine is also behind much of the attack on RCTs by advocates of pseudoscience, and Shannon et al certainly engage in such attacks with gusto:
RCTs have dominated decision making about efficacy in health care for almost 50 years. Many researchers have explored the difficulty of subjecting IM treatment approaches to RCTs. There are some characteristics of IM interventions that make RCTs particularly difficult to carry out, and perhaps even less relevant, than for conventional allopathic medicine. As Fønnebø pointed out, the gap between published studies of integrative approaches on the one hand, and the clinical reports by practitioners on the other hand, may partially result from the fact that placebo-controlled RCTs are designed to evaluate pharmaceutical interventions.
Or, more likely, they result from the biases and lack of adequate controls for placebo effects inherent in “clinical reports” by practitioners. Also note the Oz-like argument that RCTs can’t evaluate Weil’s favored woo.
Granted, uncontrolled clinical reports from practitioners can, if carefully documented, represent one form of pragmatic trials; more often they are at best preliminary data and at worst nothing more than anecdotes. To support their attack, Shannon et al cite a prominent New England Journal of Medicine study, namely Concato et al, which found that well-designed observational studies often produce the same results as RCTs, meaning that placing observational studies lower on the rung of the EBM hierarchy might not be justified. Unfortunately, the authors failed to note that Concato et al only looked at studies of clinical questions with objective outcomes, including the Bacille Calmette-Guérin vaccine and tuberculosis, mammography and mortality from breast cancer, cholesterol levels and death due to trauma, treatment of hypertension and stroke, and treatment of hypertension and coronary heart disease. Moreover, Concato et al have been criticized for cherry picking their examples. In contrast, most CAM modalities are designed to treat symptoms with a major subjective component. Also going against Weil’s argument that, because RCTs are designed for pharmaceutical treatments, they might not be so good evaluating non-pharmaceutical treatments is a more recent study comparing effects in RCTs versus observational studies in digestive surgery, which found that a quarter of observational studies gave different results than randomized trials and that between-study heterogeneity was more common in observational studies. If this study holds up, it would appear that RCTs work just fine (and better than observational studies) for surgical interventions.
The merits and flaws of Concato et al aside, it is a false dichotomy that we must choose either controlled RCTs or or less rigorously controlled observational studies. EBM and SBM encompass them all; they simply disagree on how much relative weight to give each type of evidence. Fortunately, Weil doesn’t make the argument that we must favor one or the other. Unfortunately, he’s more subtle than that. What he does instead is to argue for decreased influence of RCTs by arguing that they should be only one part of the picture, an argument he makes by bringing up the Bradford-Hill criteria.
Trying to shrink the importance of the RCT
The heart of the argument in this paper is that RCTs should be only one (presumably of many) factors that determine whether medicine considers and intervention to be effective or not. As the title suggests, safety and patient preferences play a prominent role in Weil’s argument, but first Weil yokes poor Sir Austin Bradford-Hill, FRS, a pioneering early to mid-20th century epidemiologist best known for his work linking smoking to lung cancer and pioneering the RCT, into his service. Bradford-Hill proposed a set of criteria for drawing causality about disease etiology, but his nine criteria are sometimes used in considering the effectiveness of treatments.
Shannon et al set the stage:
As he [Bradford-Hill] pointed out, not all criteria are appropriate for all issues being analyzed, but he listed nine in total from which appropriate ones should be selected for any given situation:
    • Strength—referring to the robustness of the association between the causative agent and the outcome
    • Consistency—meaning being able to obtain similar results across different research sites and methodologies (i.e., replication)
    • Specificity—by which Bradford-Hill meant one disease having one specific outcome, which may not be relevant to complex disorders (e.g., psychiatric problems)
    • Temporality—referring to the commonsense notion that the cause always precedes the outcome
    • Biologic gradient—which is best described as a dose– response curve: increased treatment would presumably result in a proportionate increase in the effect (again, not relevant in all disorders)
    • Plausibility—referring to whether the results are biologically sound
    • Coherence—which refers to the agreement of a study’s findings with what is already known (hence, not relevant in situations of truly novel interventions)
    • Experiment—the situation in which randomly introducing the causative agent results in the outcome
        ◦ Analogy—which is the idea that a similar cause results in a similar outcome.
It is particularly interesting to note that the Bradford-Hill criteria, specified by the individual who influenced the methodology we now accept for RCTs massively, lists experiment with randomization methods as only one of nine criteria for establishing causality.
See, you nasty, reductionist scientists? RCTs are only one criteria! They’re not the be-all and end-all of clinical evidence! I can’t help but point out that there is an implicit straw man here in that embedded in many of the Bradford-Hill criteria are the same sorts of arguments we make at SBM, particularly criteria numbers 1, 2, 5, 6, and 7. In particular, we at SBM like criteria numbers 6 and 7. Key to the very concept of SBM is that interventions should have biological plausibility. They should also be congruent with what is known about the disease or, if not congruent, the evidence supporting an intervention must be sufficiently compelling that it justifies overthrowing the existing paradigm (for example, in the case of the discovery that H. pylori causes peptic ulcers). I also can’t help but point out that most CAM/IM treatments still fail most of Bradford-Hill’s criteria. In particular, CAM/IM treatments almost always run afoul of all of Bradford-Hill’s criteria other than #4, and, quite frankly, sometimes the wackier ones even seems as though they could run afoul of #4 as well.
Perhaps realizing this, Weil says nothing more about Bernard-Hill criteria other than to mention them again briefly in his conclusion. Instead, he and his merry trio of woo-apologists move on, Gish gallop-like, to other deficiencies in the “Western, reductionistic” model.
Use and abuse of systems biology and “holistic” methods
Unable to abuse poor Bradford-Hill anymore, Weil moves on to list “unique” features of CAM/IM research that—surprise!—turn out to be not-so-unique and not nearly as difficult to take into account in SBM (or even in EBM) as he implies:
For instance, the healing relationship of a doctor and patient is generally excluded or “controlled for” in conventional RCTs, whereas some researchers would argue that unconditional positive regard forms the underpinnings of the healing relationship between two people.
The enhanced focus on the healing relationship is thus another factor delineating IM from conventional health care models. A second example is the concept of individualized care, which is rarely included in RCTs (perhaps the MTA study in childhood ADHD is a notable exception). The notion that each patient is unique and quite different permeates IM.
I like the admission that most CAM/IM is placebo medicine, though. Oh, you didn’t see that? The emphasis on the “healing relationship” between practitioner and patient tells you that what Weil is talking about is placebo medicine. After all, that relationship is very important to placebo effects.
Be that as it may, I’ve discussed the so-called “individualization” of CAM treatments before, as well as the difference between the “personalized medicine” when practitioners of SBM use the term versus when CAM/IM advocates use the term. For the full discussion click on the links; the CliffsNotes version follows. Basically, the notion that each patient is unique is a notion that is recognized in EBM and SBM. It’s also utterly facile and obvious, given that no two people are alike. What EBM and SBM try to do is to classify and stratify patients based on science-based characteristics that can be objectively related to disease severity, etiology, and response to therapy. As genomic medicine, systems biology, proteomics, and metabolomics become more sophisticated, it has become possible to make finer and finer distinctions between patients based on biology. The hope is that ultimately knowing these fine distinctions will allow us to “personalize” therapies to individual patients, thus ushering in an era of truly personalized medicine.
In contrast, in CAM/IM the idea of “individualization” and “personalized” medicine most frequently boils down to making it up as the practitioner goes along and doing whatever the practitioner feels like, all without a basis in sound science and evidence. In fact, Weil appeals to just such “personalization” or “individualization” based on magic and fairy dust as being a problem with applying RCTs to CAM/IM:
However, classic RCT research design requires patients to be broken out into groups with a similar diagnosis, which impairs the ability to evaluate an individualized treatment system, such as classical homeopathy, Traditional Chinese Medicine, or Ayurveda. In each of these systems, the patient must be individualized into a quite unique pattern that does not lend itself to a more broad disease generalization such as that found in conventional allopathic medicine. Curiously, the cutting edge of modern medicine anticipates that customized and individualized care looms as a result of advances in single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and the ability to create a specific genetic fingerprint for each individual.
Imagine that! Using groups that are based on diagnosis and actual disease biology, rather than based on prescientific vitalistic thinking! The nerve of those reductionistic “Western” physicians!
Here’s a hint: Genome variations, as demonstrated by SNPs, are not an example of the sorts of classifications one finds in homeopathy, traditional Chinese medicine, or Ayurveda, although I am impressed at the attempt to liken CAM classifications to “cutting edge” genomic variations and science-based classification systems. Sadly, though, leaving aside the utter ridiculousness of the analogy, Weil appears to be behind the times when it comes to personalized medicine and genomics. Ask any systems biologist or geneticist. SNPs aren’t even really “cutting edge” anymore. Maybe they were ten years ago (possibly even five years ago), but other methods and markers are rapidly supplanting SNPs, in particular direct sequencing of relevant parts of the genome, a technique made practical by next generation sequencing technologies and the concomitant exponential plummeting of the cost of such analyses. Also, as Harriet Hall has pointed out, the claim to “personalization” is a sham; many CAM/IM therapies ultimately appeal to one of many examples of the “One True Cause of Disease” fallacy.
Speaking of shams, so is Dr. Weil’s claim of being “holistic”:
A third methodological issue that distinguishes IM from the environment of pharmaceutical RCTs involves systems thinking. With its roots in holistic, natural, and aboriginal medicine, IM has always embraced a more systems-based orientation to patient care than conventional care. It should come as no surprise that a narrow modality for evaluating treatment effectiveness would become increasingly limiting to IM research. The movement toward increasingly narrow scientific evaluations may create an artificial and arbitrary view of human health, medicine, and treatment effectiveness. Fritjof Capra, PhD, the well-known physicist, indicated that the great surprise of twentieth century science was that complex systems cannot be understood by analysis. Ecology and epigenetics are examples of the strong movement toward systems thinking in modern biology.
This is, of course, utter nonsense. “Holistic,” “natural,” and aboriginal medicine relied upon a prescientific, not a “holistic,” understanding of biology and patient care. Appealing to “systems” thinking based on prescientific or outright religious systems, such as homeopathic provings, traditional Chinese medicine, Ayurveda, and “energy healing,” is meaningless when the systems being invoked are without a grounding in science—or even reality. The rise of systems theory in biology and elsewhere has nothing to do with the sort of false “holistic” thinking invoked by Weil and his ilk. Rather, it has to do with the increasing ability to analyze more than one aspect of a complex system at once. For example, in my field (cancer), thirty years ago it was only possible to analyze one gene or perhaps handful of genes at a time. Then, beginning in the late 1990s, the development of cDNA microarray chips made it possible to analyze hundreds, then thousands of genes simultaneously—then every gene in the genome. As technology and computing power increased and scientists and mathematicians developed techniques to analyze ever larger datasets, it became possible to take the data from these sorts of experiments and begin to understand the complex networks inherent in the expression of the thousands of genes that are produced in human cells. Today, it is becoming increasingly possible to integrate massive quantities of data from various sources, including genomics, proteomics, and metabolomics and begin to understand the vastly complex networks that they form, how they resist perturbation, and how they can be restored when they are perturbed.
That is real holism. Not homeopathy. Not traditional Chinese medicine. Not Ayurveda. What Weil represents as “holism” is in reality a series of pretenders to “holistic” understanding that substitute non-evidence-based prescientific belief systems for science, gussying them up in “science-y”-sounding language that co-opts new science the way CAM/IM co-opts science-based modalities like diet and exercise as being somehow “alternative.”
The rest of the rest
Those who have actually read Dr. Weil’s article will note that I have not yet mentioned one point that Weil hammered on relentlessly, apparently thinking himself Maxwell bringing his silver hammer down upon the heads of those who think scientifically, the better to knock the propensity towards SBM (or even EBM) out of them. That issue is safety. Weil goes on and on about patient safety, even going so far as to propose a ranking system for patient safety. This part of his article is, quite frankly, an insult to physicians’ intelligence. Physicians practicing EBM already weigh efficacy/effectiveness versus safety; all Weil is doing is to rename and rebrand something that EBM does already. To a small extent he has a point that EBM does not yet have a as rigorous “hierarchy” of risk or harm to evaluate treatments as it does levels of evidence for efficacy, but even if we did have such a rigorous hierarchy, risk-benefit estimates still require weighing benefit versus risk. If the expected benefit is zero, or near zero, then even a tiny risk can quickly become unacceptable. To take one example, in the case of acupuncture, where the benefit is not distinguishable from that of placebo, then even a tiny risk of, say, a pneumothorax from a needle stuck too deep becomes very problematic. In other words, Weil’s classification system is unlikely to make CAM seem as attractive as he seems to think it will, although no doubt his intent is to make that evil “reductionistic” allopathic medicine seem more dangerous by comparison.
In addition, Weil makes a big show of complaining about commercial influence, in essence using a weaker form of the “pharma shill” gambit to dismiss pharma-funded RCTs whose conclusions he does not like. This serves, more than anything else, as a ploy to imply guilt by association, given that virtually all pharmaceuticals are manufactured for profit. As we have written about here on numerous occasions, commercial influence is a problem that is recognized in EBM (and SBM). It is increasingly appreciated as an issue, and practitioners of EBM do consider funding sources when considering clinical trial results. Indeed, one can’t help but wonder why Dr. Weil’s concern about pharma influence is so conveniently limited. Does he complain about the influence of supplement manufacturers (which, by the way, are increasingly owned by various pharmaceutical companies and wield a great deal of clout in Congress)? If he does, I haven’t seen evidence of it. Steve was right; this part is just window-dressing, as is Weil’s proposal for a different five-level hierarchy of evidence that not-so-subtly tilts the playing field so that some observational studies and other studies that can’t be considered RCTs could be considered Level One evidence.
What’s truly ironic is that Weil would never admit that there are few, if any, CAM modalities that can meet the criteria of level one evidence even under his own proposed system! In fact, most of the very best-supported CAM modalities would fall either into level four (“Weak indicators of uncertain value: poorly designed studies without strong support from the Hill criteria; small observational studies”) to level five (“Very weak indicators of efficacy or effectiveness: expert opinion of effectiveness; case series; multiple anecdotal reports”). That’s why it’s tempting simply to grant Weil his new system and then challenge him to show more than a pitiful handful of CAM modalities that have evidence to support them stronger than level four.
Finally, two of the more pernicious proposals in Weil’s paper are related. First, he repeats his explicit argument for favoring placebo medicine:
Given the history and philosophical preferences of allopathic medicine, it should come as no surprise that the factors defining the healing response become minimized or ignored in current practice. This failing must be remedied, as these factors account for a huge component of how humans heal and recover. The healing relationship has taken a much larger role in IM as practitioners in nearly all CAM modalities place a much higher emphasis on it. The importance of these issues can be demonstrated most clearly in psychiatry research, where the placebo response plays a huge role accounting for as much as 40%–90%+ of the total response.26
Significant placebo and expectancy responses inhabit other areas of medical practice, such as dealing with pain and even life expectancy in patients with terminal cancer. Clearly, patient factors must compose a significant part of all treatment selection processes. Ideally, every treatment should be matched to the individual’s belief system to reach the highest level of response possible.
Aside from stating, “CAM is placebo medicine, and we should use placebo medicine when it fits in with patient beliefs,” a more explicit admission that what is being proposed in this opinion piece is placebo medicine I cannot imagine. Worse, it’s based on misinformation, the most egregious of which is Weil’s claim that placebo and expectancy effects can increase life expectancy in patients with terminal cancer. Would that it were true, but unfortunately it’s not, either in late stage cancer or early stage cancer. Nor is there any evidence that it has an effect on recurrence. This is where Weil’s second, related thrust occurs. Using this assumption that placebo medicine “works” better if its tenets match the patient’s belief system, he proposes turning the entire concept of informed consent on its head with respect to medical decision-making (MDM):
The ideal process in MDM would remodel the process of informed consent. The actively engaged patient would be offered a quick overview of appropriate treatments (both CAM and conventional) with an unbiased reflection of both safety and effectiveness. The patient would then declare a preference for one over the other(s). Once a practitioner ascertains the basic worldview of a patient (natural versus conventional; safety versus effectiveness) many simple elements of MDM would flow quickly in the future.
This is a process that to which I’ve referred in the context of two other discussions, vaccines and supplements. In essence, what Dr. Weil is proposing is an ideology-based version of misinformed consent. Although Dr. Weil would not doubt strenuously object to my comparison, when you boil it all down, what he is doing, although more subtle, is not materially different than what anti-vaccine groups do when they grossly exaggerate the risks of vaccination and downplay its benefits or what “health freedom” groups do when they exaggerate the benefits (and the scientific evidence for such benefits) of supplements. What these groups each do is to give patients a skewed view of the risks and benefits of an intervention, intentionally making it more likely that patients will choose the “alternative” option. Weil is doing the same thing by trying to confuse the issue of efficacy/effectiveness by throwing in the issue of “patient belief” and placebo medicine. As is the case with anti-vaccine activists and supplement hawkers, the purpose is, having failed to win on “conventional science,” to find a way to tilt the playing field back towards the “alternative” using other means.
Conclusion
The proposals in Shannon et al are nothing original, although I must grudgingly tip my hat to Weil and his acolytes for having repackaged old ideas in a very attractive, slick new package. In essence, they boil down to a massive appeal to other ways of knowing, hence the attack on RCTs in which they point out deficiencies that those of us advocating SBM and EBM have recognized for decades; the emphasis on effectiveness over efficacy that ignores the fact that it’s necessary to have good evidence of efficacy before even considering effectiveness in the “real world”; the tarting up of safety considerations as though EBM doesn’t take safety into account; and a direct appeal to placebo medicine via the methodology of misinformed consent. All of these strategies are clearly designed to try to give CAM/IM a leg up on science that it can’t achieve through science alone. Unfortunately, although such strategies are transparent to SBM bloggers (and, I daresay, many of our readers), to others they are not so obvious, even to proponents of EBM. I also can’t help but think: If Dr. Weil detests EBM so much, he’s really not going to like SBM at all. Not one bit.
Perhaps the most ironic part of all of this is that many of us at SBM actually agree with the contention that EBM relies on RCTs too much. Many of us would even agree with several of the Bradford-Hill criteria as considerations that are worthy of more emphasis in EBM. Where we differ is in how to do this. Most importantly, we emphasize much more strongly scientific/biological plausibility. Prior probability appears to be anathema to Weil, given that he mentions it as part of the Bradford-Hill criteria and then completely ignores it thereafter. No doubt, he knows how scientifically implausible many CAM/IM modalities are. Instead, Dr. Weil Gish gallops off to emphasize, as he does in the title of his article, patient preferences and safety, in essence using these issues to bolster an explicit plea for placebo medicine. Rather than accepting that rigorous scientific examination of his favorite CAM/IM modalities fails to find any benefit over placebo, Dr. Weil cleverly embraces placebo medicine and argues for lower scientific standards to permit pseudoscientific and unscientific medicine to appear to be co-equal with EBM.
Unfortunately, such are the arguments that have been the wedge used to insert quackademic medicine into medical academia. Even more unfortunately, they are working.
REFERENCE:
Shannon, S., Weil, A., & Kaplan, B. (2011). Medical Decision Making in Integrative Medicine: Safety, Efficacy, and Patient Preference Alternative and Complementary Therapies, 17 (2), 84-91 DOI: 10.1089/act.2011.17210

   Resistance is futile
David Gorski
Links
Dr. Sampson’s droll post on Thursday written from the point of view of an advocate of unscientific “alternative” medicine modalites (these days known as “complementary and alternative medicine”–abbreviated “CAM”–or “integrative” medicine), coupled with Dr. Atwood’s most recent contribution to his ongoing series on how the mish-mash of a little valid herbal medicine mixed with a whole lot of woo otherwise known as the “profession” of naturopathy is pushing for greater legal legitimacy, depressed me mightily. The posts depressed me because they are but more evidence of just how effective advocates of non-science-based medicine have been over the last several years at twisting the linguistic landscape to their advantage and winning. Indeed, I’ve written about this before on this very blog, including my (in)famous list of medical schools that have embraced CAM and my lament about a medical school that has even gone so far as to “integrate” so-called “integrative” medicine into every aspect of its curriculum from day one of the first year. These disheartening trends accompany and draw succor from the $120 million a year budget of that center of woo in the heart of the National Institutes of Health, the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, the equal amount of money coming yearly from, alas, the National Cancer Institute, and, of course, the financial clout of the Bravewell Collaborative.
Things are not looking good for science-based medicine in academia right now. I say this in particular because I just learned of a press release issued three weeks ago by Andrew Weil and his University of Arizona Program in Integrative Medicine that, as Emeril Lagasse would say, “Kicks it up a notch,” but not for the better.
The press release begins:
TUCSON, Ariz., June 12 AZ-UofA-CoMPIM-Award TUCSON, Ariz., June 12 /PRNewswire/ – The Arizona Board of Regents recently conferred Center of Excellence status on The University of Arizona College of Medicine Program in Integrative Medicine — a move that reaffirms the positive impact integrative medicine has had on health-care system transformation.
Now known as the Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine (AzCIM), the program underwent an intensive evaluation process and earned unanimous endorsements from UA health sciences program directors and college deans. The new designation formally recognizes the center’s achievements in the field over the past 14 years, and its status as the world leader in integrative medical education.
Founded in 1994 by internationally renowned author and integrative medicine pioneer Andrew Weil, MD, the Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine joins nine other Centers of Excellence at the UA College of Medicine.
“Having our work recognized in this way is among our greatest accomplishments to date,” Dr. Weil said. “The Center of Excellence designation formally recognizes us as an innovator in educating the next generation of physicians and health-care professionals. Our challenge now is to remain at the forefront of innovation so as to make integrative medicine available to everyone, regardless of economic or geographic limitation.”
Indeed it is one of Andrew Weil’s greatest accomplishments in pushing his not-so-unique blend of some science-based nutrition advice mixed with a whole lot of woo. Steven Novella once rightly referred to him as wanting to change the rules of scientific evidence supporting the efficacy (or lack of efficacy) of various medical interventions, and indeed he clearly does, favoring “uncontrolled clinical observations” over well-controlled, double-blind randomized trials:
But for all the other stuff, we don’t have time to do that, so we have to have other methods of estimating how things work. Now one of the attitudes that I run into in the research community that just drives me up the wall is people who dismiss what they call anecdotal evidence. And I have challenged some of these people in public to strike the word “anecdote” from the medical vocabulary.
I think it is a trivializing word. If you want to call this uncontrolled clinical observation, that’s fine with me. The fact is that the scientific method begins with raw observation. You notice something out there that catches your attention, that doesn’t fit your conceptions. You see it again. That gives you an idea that generates a hypothesis which you can then test. It is this kind of uncontrolled observation which is the raw material from which you get hypotheses to test in a formal manner. If you dismiss all that stuff, if you drop it into a mental wastebasket labeled “anecdote,” you cut yourself off from the raw material of science.
Of course, Dr. Weil is being disingenuous. In science- and evidence-based medicine, anecdotes are indeed the raw material from which we as medical scientists derive hypotheses, and “anecdotes” are published all the time in the medical literature. They’re called “case reports.” We do not dismiss them out of hand just because they are “anecdotes.” When appropriate, we dismiss “anecdotes” because frequently they are “testimonials” and not controlled observations or because anecdotes themselves, even when the observations are controlled, are often deceiving, which is why further study in the form of more controlled trials is always necessary before science-based medicine will accept a claim. Anecdotes are not enough, but doctors like Dr. Weil want to give them far more weight in medical science, often (as Dr. Weil does) reducing their arguments to a tu quoque fallacy, as Dr. Weil does in characterizing research on St. John’s Wort and depression as “useless information.”
But I digress. However it is a relevant digression, because the real effect of the CAM movement is to downplay the importance of science in medicine and to elevate anecdotal evidence far above what its role should be. In this, CAM is moving medicine back to the days of Hahnemann and homeopathy. Indeed, physicians like Dr. Weil are more dangerous than quacks like Hulda Clark, because he mixes his brand of unscientific medicine with enough scientific medicine to make it sound plausible and to blur the line between the two to the point that it is not always apparent even to skeptics where science ends and woo begins.
He’s succeeding, too, in transforming medicine in a way bigger than one “integrative” medicine program being recognized by its university as a so-called “center of excellence” (which makes me wonder just how low the University of Arizona’s standards are in that respect) indicates. The real significance of this press release is that it also announces another huge step made by Dr. Weil and his fellow ideologues in “integrating” non-scientific and non-evidence-based medicine into science- and evidence-based medicine. It is the next logical step after the “integration” of woo “seamlessly” into the medical school curriculum:
The Center of Excellence designation will enhance the center’s ability to court top-tier faculty and inspire a new era of program growth — led by the center’s most ambitious program to date: the Integrative Medicine in Residency (IMR). The center’s integrative medicine curriculum soon will be incorporated into standard three-year family medicine residency programs across the nation. Residents will learn to incorporate integrative medicine concepts into their practices, including patient-centered care techniques that facilitate lifestyle change.
Through funding raised from both public and private sources, an IMR pilot program will be launched in July at eight family medicine residency programs nationwide, including the UA; Beth Israel Medical Center, New York City; Carolinas Medical Center, Charlotte, N.C.; Maine Medical Center, Portland, Maine; Maine-Dartmouth, Augusta, Maine; University of Connecticut, Storrs, Conn.; Hennepin County Medical Center, Minneapolis, Minn.; and the University of Texas Medical Branch, Galveston.
“This will be the first program in the nation to create a required curriculum in integrative medicine for physicians during residency,” said Victoria Maizes, MD, executive director of the Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine. “Over the next 10 years, development of IMR into the national model for residency education is a major goal for the center. We will gradually move beyond primary care into subspecialty training.”
I can’t help but mention that clearly I need to add every one of the above medical schools and academic medical centers into my hall of shame, clearly a project for the impending Fourth of July weekend. That aside, this accomplishment represents a quantum leap in the infiltration of CAM into academia. In one fell swoop, Dr. Weil has transformed CAM from a mere elective to a fully co-equal and mandatory element of the family medicine residency. True, it’s only eight residencies now in a pilot program. However, given the current attitude in this country and in medicine, it’s highly likely that this pilot program will be “successful” (successful for woo, a disaster for science-based medicine), in which case it will spread, and it is no longer unthinkable to visualize something like IMR insinuating itself into the national standards of the American Board of Family Medicine in a decade–or even less. Certainly it doesn’t help that Medicare and third party reimbursements have become so paltry for primary care doctors that woo suddenly becomes attractive as an “alternative” (or should I say “integrative”) additional source of income; that only makes resisting it more difficult.
If Dr. Weil succeeds, every new family practice physician will graduate from his or her residency program with a knowledge of CAM. This would not be a bad thing if it were truly a science- and evidence-based approach to CAM and a knowledge of what herbal remedies might interact with “conventional” pharmaceuticals. The optimist in me would like to believe that that’s what would happen, but the realist in me knows that it’s not. Given the history of CAM programs in medical schools and academic medical centers thus far, where credulous promotion of quackery–yes, I say quackery–such as reiki, therapeutic touch, and even that quackery of quackeries, homeopathy, somehow manage to be “integrated” into science-based offerings with nary a word of skepticism about the extreme (and I do mean extreme) lack of scientific plausibility and the preponderance of scientific studies demonstrating no greater efficacy for these modalities than placebo, I fear that when I visualize myself in the hospital 20 or 30 years being subjected to therapies parodied in this video, I may look back at it as prophetic, not funny. Steve Novella was right to wonder whether a golden age of quackery and antiscience is upon us. My fear, though, is that 20 or 30 years from now, we will look back upon these days as beginning of the end and yearn for the level of science in medicine that we have today.
The Brave(well) New World is upon us. Resistance is futile. Your life as it has been is over. From this time forward, medical culture will adapt to service CAM. Science is irrelevant.
Think I’m exaggerating? I guess we’ll see in 20 or 30 years.

   Touch – a Trojan Horse
Wallace Sampson
Links
Touch – Ouch. here they are again.
I had planned to post contents of a letter written a decade ago to a Washington Post reporter on why med schools would entertain associating with quacky methods and their advocates. But an article in the SF Chronicle intruded on May 25 on a research project at Stanford on “Healing Touch” (HT). The project is to test if HT affects symptoms of cancer and chemo- and radiotherapy. HT at Stanford?
I had sat down to write a letter to the editor when a call came through Center for Inquiry, where the reporter had called asking for someone to give her information on HT at Stanford. She called within a minute, apologetic for not having included critical comments from others. She had received emails already from irate scientists who told her about 11 year old Emily Rosa’s experiment published in the AMA Journal showing non-existence of human energy fields, which the HT practitioners claimed to be manipulating. And wasn’t HT different from Therapeutic Touch – (TT?) From the reporter’s description, I saw little difference except these HT people seemed to make more of fixing subjects’ chakras.
I was surprised by the article, in that I had not known about the study. But there were a few new wrinkles. I presumed the study was under the “complementary” medicine clinic run by David Spiegel of group therapy for cancer fame. I had thought that the clinic just allowed group therapy, acupuncture, meditation, and a few other more modestly offensive methods. As I read on I found the HT study is under a special program called Healing Partners, a group of like-minded women and cancer patients (<links.sfgate.com/ZDLO>.) The study is supervised under the department of Women’s Health, associated with the ObGyn Department. I’m still unclear on the administrative arrangement, but med school departments are run almost autonomously, with perhaps cooperation with others, but with little to no review from others or deans. That takes care of objections from outsiders.
Second, I was reading a reporter’s report, depending on her take as to what was given to her by proponents and the indoctrinated. As per most articles, this one was mainly descriptions given in testimonial style by the satisfied and convinced. One of them stated that her wound healed under HT – implying that the HT did it (I’m thinking, she should have been on the OJ jury…) Here’s the quote: “It opened my mind to the fact there are some things in this world we can’t explain, and that doesn’t make them any less real. ” said CP, a trained geologist….[Analyze that sentence for logic]…” As a scientist I didn’t have a real spiritual background, …I found it really powerful.” [I stumbled - real spiritual?" But who's talkin' logic and reality here?] Did the report reflect the real quality of the study?
I think so. The report was frank and open about some aspects, like the beliefs of the practitioners as well. I wondered how the study got so far, how it had passed an IRB inspection and so forth, but as if to answer that, they told the reporter about their international organization, Healing Touch International, Inc.
HT Int., Inc. lists some 85 or more certified instructors, and the list of official and unofficial practitioners must be a multiple of that. And there are five stages of expertise and advancement. Most are RNs. I did not see the Stanford people on the list of instructors. One can safely assume that through the organization a template for research protocols could be developed, and a plan of action as well.
But more important was what I found on searching for federally sponsored research – projects initiated through or listed at the NIH. There are 11 separate HT protocols in US medical schools, 9 testing HT results in cancer patients. None of the studies has as end points, tumor recurrence, survival, tumor growth, etc., but all have end points of symptom control and quality of life. Those make it easier to pass IRB scrutiny. Most of the studies are NIH/NCCAM sponsored.
The surprisingly large numbers of trainers and research protocols, the faithfulness of the Stanford practitioners’ description to those of others’ projects and to the material on the international organization’s web site, suggested an organized push for acceptance of HT by the establishment through medical school research. Despite being denied a place in the curriculum at the place of origin, U. of Colorado School of Nursing, the HT/TT community has found an opening in gullible and academically correct medical schools. I have no question that HT/TT will be found “positive” in a number of projects. The blinding procedures probably leave lots of holes for subject detection of practitioner activity. But positive reports are common in studies of things that don’t work, anyway. Positive biases outnumber negative ones, and even in well controlled studies, results form a normal distribution array around the zero effect point. Some systematic reviews or meta-analyses (MAs) will record positive results. Relationships among HT practitioners, patients, and some physicians will result in formal programs at the schools. Satisfied patients may even fund special sections for continuation of HT.
The reporter told me she felt bad about not having looked more deeply into the matter, called for other opinions, or presented the other side. She intended to write another article as a sort of second part, presenting the history and material we gave her. But that was not to last. She called back later that day to say that the editors disapproved a second other-side article, and suggested revisiting the study after completion. That would be 3 or more years hence. I told her that at my age I might not be around (but of course I’ll leave a forwarding phone number ..)
Well, I don’t know the editors’ names, but from prior experience with that newspaper, there does not seem to be a thirst for truth or reality there. It’s more a matter of pandering to a readership known to be – um, more interested in the possible and exciting rather than probable? What does one call the praising of cult leader Jim Jones? The praising of the NIH acupuncture conference report, and rejecting an article revealing its errors? Stuff like that.
So the SF Chron’s readership is left with an accurate report but based in biased information from cult-like advocates of a cult-like organization with probable ulterior anti-scientific motives – to change the character of medicine from science based to feeling-based. And a reporter is left with knowledge that she did an inadequate job after being taken in by HTers’ masks of goodness; knowing what a good report should have looked like. Awaiting assignments from editors who should know better, to a reporter who does know better.
And we are left with the effects of an anti-scientific cult, members of which have learned how assume the mask of goodness and innocence, but with a salient sharpened to penetrate the thin veneer of science that medical schools think is protecting them. That veneer’s faults are guarded by sleeping sentries and are willingly opened by gullible recent graduates and trainees coming out of other “Integrative” programs financed by last week’s power idealists. Medical academics: Beware. Presidential candidates and politicians: Take notes from these people.

Best Hospital Eye Roll
Link
Mark Crislip on March 19, 2024
Science: Figuring things out is better than making things up.
A tee shirt I recently saw.
Except…
In a recent post Mayo Clinic Promotes Reiki, Steve seemed surprised that the Mayo was offering Reiki. I don’t know. Maybe he was channeling Louie. I know the Mayo is a top hospital, but I trained in Minneapolis at Hennepin County and we would have the occasional patient go to Rochester for a second opinion*, only to return with a repeat of our evaluation and no change in the diagnosis or treatment plan, but a few dollars poorer for the experience. As a result, our motto was always Hold the Mayo.
I remain skeptical about the whole concept of top hospitals and doctors. While there are certainly lousy doctors and hospitals, in my career most doctors and hospitals, at least in the Portland metropolitan area, were pretty much the same. Surgeons? Well, some do have better motor skills/hand eye coordination, but that’s about it. Dr. Oz is always called a great surgeon, but I have never been able to discover the criteria used to determine that greatness. A lower death rate? Fewer infections? Shorter length of stay? The use of reiki in the OR? No idea. I have been a US News top doctor, so you know the methodology is suspect.
I thought it would be entertaining to go through the US News and World Reports BEST HOSPITALS HONOR ROLL 2023-2024 and see what SCAMs they had to offer. I went to each website and searched for various SCAMs using search terms like ‘integrative’, ‘complementary’, ‘acupuncture’, ‘reiki’ and the like. Many of these honor roll hospitals are part of health care system, so I often had search results return for the system and the relationship between the honor roll hospital and the SCAM offer by the hospital system is not always clear. As my father used to say, you can judge a person by the company they keep. All the hospitals on the honor roll trumpeted the designation on the website, so let us see what kind of honor roll for SCAMs they have, shall we.
Barnes-Jewish Hospital
“Where you deserve extraordinary care.”
Part of a 6 hospital system.
The offer acupuncture as part of their Physical Medicine and Physical Therapy and as part of their Living Well Center as well as Tai Chi and Lifestyle medicine. You may or may not want to include the last two in the SCAM category. But otherwise, not much on SCAM and their information sites on SCAM have a bit of a skeptical tinge.
Brigham and Women’s Hospital
“There’s no better place to be.”
They have the Osher Clinical Center for Integrative Medicine which offers acupuncture, both Chinese and Japanese as well as moxibustion, acupressure, and laser acupuncture. What, no electro-acupuncture? Posers. They suggest
Clinical studies show that acupuncture –by itself, or in combination with conventional therapies – may be an effective treatment for nausea caused by surgical anesthesia and cancer chemotherapy, pain syndromes such as: dental and postoperative pain, headache and facial pain, myofascial pain, osteoarthritis, low back pain, joint pain, TMJ, carpal tunnel syndrome and tennis elbow; primary dysmenorrhea and problems associated with pregnancy such as morning sickness, late term and possibly correction of breech position; allergic rhinitis, including hay fever; and assistance in stroke rehabilitation.
Note the may be effective. Charge for worthless quackery based on a may. I wonder if patients can say the may pay for the acu-whatever.
They also offer chiropractic care, craniosacral therapy, and therapeutic Tai Chi/Yoga. In the race to the bottom for being goofy, craniosacral therapy could very well win. See my Alas poor Craniosacral. A SCAM of infinite jest, of most excellent fancy for details.
They note that
Contemporary chiropractors blend the art of hands-on therapy with the science and technology of modern medicine and physical rehabilitation.
News to me.
And in discussing potential risks mention
The risk of serious, irreversible complication from spinal adjustments is rare.
Without specifically mentioning the risk of catastrophic vertebral artery dissection, what I call the chiropractic hanging, from an intervention with no basis in reality.
They also discuss fiction like it is reality:
The ultimate goal of tai chi, like acupuncture, is the free flow of qi – energy flow that sustains living beings – throughout the body, thereby healing the systems that have become imbalanced and further strengthening the systems that are already robust.
They do not offer i.e. charge for reiki, but they do support it:
At BWH, any nurse, volunteer, or other approved hospital staff member who is trained, certified, and competent in Second Degree Reiki or above thus meets our hospital’s minimum policy requirement to perform Reiki on patients.
How does one become trained, certified and competent in fiction? I, in case you should be stabbed by a Black Breath, am trained, certified and competent in the use of Athelas.
And reiki as part of their colorectal treatment options
the Center provides counseling, physical therapy, pain management, integrative therapies like massage as well as integrative therapies like reiki and acupuncture for pneumonectomy.
Just what I need when they remove my lung, reiki.
Cedars-Sinai Medical Center
They have acupuncturists on staff and the Spiritual Care Division offers reiki. That’s it. No programs or institutes that focus on SCAMs. I rotated at Cedars-Sinai as a fellow. It is in Beverly Hills and I would have expected far more woo.
Cleveland Clinic
“Every Life Deserves World Class Care”
They have a Center for Functional Medicine, which has been discussed over at Respectful Insolence.
Functional medicine aims to find the root cause of illness and treat in a holistic way.
Someone’s been reading the naturopathic websites. Which, given that they have a naturopath who promotes homeopathy as one of their acupuncturists comes as no surprise.
And the Center for Integrative and Lifestyle Medicine , which offers acupuncture, traditional Chinese pseudo-medicine/Chinese herbal medicine, chiropractic, osteopathic manipulation (I wonder how the two groups get along), holistic psychotherapy, reiki, craniosacral therapy and, if you want to include them as SCAMs, yoga and culinary medicine. Reiki is also available through Cancer Care, where they will lighten the load of your wallet while you receive your chemotherapy infusions.
They are pushing craniosacral therapy for epilepsy, MS, autism, stroke and traumatic brain injury among other indications, all, they warn, not covered by insurance. I have to wonder. Is it greed? cynical? gullible? to offer such rank nonsense to ill people.The discussions on the website of these SCAMs are less than critical, presenting the fictional basis of these SCAMs as if they were facts.
Hospitals of the University of Pennsylvania-Penn Presbyterian
As is often the case, SCAM is offered through the Integrative Oncology Services.
Always offer your cow pie to the most vulnerable.
They have acupuncture, aromatherapy, guided meditation and a mindfulness program, massage therapy, reiki therapy, and yoga.
Acupuncture offers many benefits to cancer patients. When added to your treatment plan, acupuncture can enhance general quality of life by reducing the side effects of cancer treatments and help promote an overall sense of balance and well-being.
Acupuncture is actively promoted without weasel words like ‘may’. The also promote acupuncture and herbs use another emotionally vulnerable population, those with fertility issues.
Reiki is available while undergoing chemotherapy or radiation therapy and
Reiki sessions are natural and holistic; there is no physical manipulation, nothing is ingested and nothing is applied to the skin.
In other words, they are doing absolutely nothing. And charging you for it.
Houston Methodist Hospital
Part of an 8-hospital system. As best I can determine, they have no specific program that focuses on SCAM. They do offer acupuncture for variety of pain conditions and were involved in one electroacupuncture trial. But that is it. I searched for all the usual suspects and nothing. Even the Cancer Center is SCAM free. Not even reeky (The Game of Thrones Alt Med?) er, I mean reiki. Two big thumbs up for Houston Methodist.
Johns Hopkins Hospital
“Community Care. Worldwide Healing.”
Part of a 6 hospital system
Acupuncture of course, described as
Acupuncture is an ancient Chinese practice involving the use of tiny needles to stimulate the nervous and immune systems. During the procedure, a licensed acupuncturist inserts hair-thin needles into the skin at specific points on the body. Acupuncture is painless, and research shows it helps support conventional treatment for a range of problems that include stress, chronic pain and digestive disorders. Experts note that it may be particularly effective for insomnia.
Supports conventional treatment. The weasel words that mean nothing; the intervention as a sling.
Acupuncture is offered for a huge number of medical problems as well as Chinese herbal therapies at the Acupuncture and Chinese Medicine Clinic , which is just one guy.
There is bit of reiki and a single chiropractor.
So Johns Hopkins is more of a SCAM dabbler.
Massachusetts General Hospital
“Our Strength Is Yours”
They have the Katherine A. Gallagher Integrative Therapies Program that offers qigong and acupuncture as part of their cancer care:
Acupuncture uses fine, sterile needles applied to specific areas of the body to stimulate energy flow. It can help reduce stress and relieve symptoms and side effects related to cancer treatment such as anxiety, nausea, dry mouth and fatigue. Acupressure involves applying gentle pressure to these same points with the hands.
What is this energy of which they all speak? Rank pseudo-science.
Remember: Complementary therapies have a cumulative effect. This means it may take several treatments for you to notice any changes. Be patient with the process.
Translations: If you wait long enough you will get better on your own.
As far as I can tell, they do not offer reiki to patients, but they do to staff.
Those who receive reiki treatments do so to relieve stress and pain, induce relaxation, accelerate natural healing and support other medical modalities. During a session, the practitioner sends healing energy towards an individual, group, event or a situation in the past, present or future.
Wow. Time travel. I knew the Mass General was at the forefront of innovation, but sending healing energy into the past AND the future? I hope we can use that energy to power hover boards.
Mayo Clinic-Rochester
“Hold the Mayo” Sorry. Wrong motto. It’s “Transforming your care”.
I never did like the Transformer movies, which I saw when my boys were young. Incoherent. Not unlike much of SCAM.
We know that the Mayo offers reiki, as mentioned at the start of the blog entry. What else?
Mayo Clinic’s integrative medicine specialists are focused on your needs. They work with you and your other members of your care team to provide a holistic approach to encourage healing and wellness.
because
The treatments used by Mayo Clinic’s integrative medicine experts have been tested for safety and effectiveness.
And they offer a variety of interventions that offer no effectiveness over transferring money from the patient to the Mayo. Besides the worthless reiki, there is acupuncture, herbal medicine, acupressure, reflexology, and the always risible craniosacral therapy. They have a chiropractor on staff so they can have an intervention that is neither safe nor effective.
Of course, the SCAMs are integrated with cancer care..
But by integrating cow pie with apple pie, they can say
There have been many claims for herbal supplements and other alternative therapies. Many of them have more to do with marketing than science, but well-designed research studies, including many conducted by Mayo Clinic, have shown the real value of integrative therapies.
And these studies at the Mayo? There is the profoundly embarrassing A Study to Determine the Effect of Distance Reiki on Patient Reported Quality of Life and Immunity Among Multiple Myeloma Patients
This study aims to demonstrate acceptability and feasibility of the use of Distance Reiki therapy versus sham Reiki therapy among multiple myeloma patients.It also aims to determine if there is a minimal clinically meaningful improvement in various QOL domains (Physical, Social, Emotional), overall QOL with use of Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System (PROMIS-29) and Single Item Linear Analogue Scale (LASA) after Distance Reik. Lastly, it aims to analyze the effect of Distance Reiki on expansion of the immune repertoire by comparing immune repertoires at baseline and at the end of the study by using Mass spectrometry by CyTOF® and multiplex polymerase chain reaction (PCR) sequencing of the T-cell receptors (TCRs) for assessment of immune repertoire diversity by iRepertoire®.
Given the ludicrous nature of the study, I wonder how it got approved.
They have evidently evaluated acupuncture for autonomic dysfunction, arrhythmias(?!?), and loss of smell post COVID, among others. I can’t see where these studies have been published to demonstrate the effectiveness of acupuncture based on Mayo Clinic studies. I am sure that supportive data is out there somewhere, I mean, the Mayo would never have more to do with marketing than science, am I right?
Mount Sinai Hospital
They offer acupuncture for pain of many types. Treating pain, by the way, not inflicting pain. The note that
Mount Sinai’s Integrative Medicine practice treats your pain as well as its underlying cause.
But is the cause of your pain your qi being “out of sync”? Color me skeptical.
The Institute for ‘Advanced’ Medicine unironically offers as advanced
Integrative Medicine: We provide massage, yoga, acupuncture, meditation, and other stress reduction therapies
The division of Integrative Medicine also offer ‘medical’ acupuncture, cupping, Gua sha (scraping), all to balance your chi, as well as yoga, all for pain. Decrease it, not add to it I suppose.
And what it medical acupuncture?
When Western-trained doctors perform acupuncture, we call it “medical acupuncture.”
That explains it. Not. When Western-trained doctors perform acupuncture, I call it wrong.
The breast center offers foot reflexology, relaxation techniques (guided meditation and breathing exercises), and reiki for cancer patients.
And for cancer and reproductive medicine, the whole panoply of SCAM:
Physical and traditional medicine approaches such as acupuncture, cupping and gua sha, yoga, tai chi, qigong, therapeutic massage, osteopathic manipulation, craniosacral therapy, movement and exercise.
Relaxation/stress reduction, mind-body and spiritual approaches such as meditation, mindfulness, hypnotherapy, behavioral therapies, biofeedback, journaling, breathing exercises, reiki, therapeutic touch, pet therapy and guided imagery.
Nutritional, herb and supplement consultations
The reproductive medicine department is evidently ready to forgo science-based medicine entirely (emphasis added):
A comprehensive selection of integrative therapies is available that can be used either in combination with or in lieu of traditional Western medicine in order to provide a holistic approach to care.
Urology adds Tui na, a form of Chinese massage, to their SCAM repertoire:
The name comes from two of the actions: tui means “to push” and na means “to lift and squeeze.” Other strokes include shaking and tapotement (A French term, it refers to a rhythmic percussion, most frequently administered with the edge of the hand, a cupped hand, or the tips of the fingers.)
I am not certain I would want any of that applied to my prostate, even with holistic prostate care. And they suggest that
Acupuncture and mind-body approaches are effective for chronic prostatitis, chronic pelvic pain, flank and groin pain, lower back pain, and male and female lower urinary tract symptoms such as urinary urgency and frequency (commonly related to conditions such as BPH, interstitial cystitis, painful bladder, and pelvic floor dysfunction).
News to me.
They have a chiropractor as part of their Spine Center, but at least no naturopaths, probably as they are not able to be licensed in New York.
New York-Presbyterian Hospital-Columbia and Cornell
“Stay Amazing”
Part of a 10 hospital system.
They have an Integrative Health and Wellbeing Program that offers acupuncture, guided imagery, herbal therapy, hypnotherapy, massage therapy, meditation, nutritional counseling, progressive relaxation, qigong, reiki/healing touch, tai chi and yoga. They say
Integrative health approaches are backed up by the findings of medical research.
Just not positive findings that demonstrate benefit. I can see, at some level, how the average HCW could be bamboozled into thinking there was something to acupuncture. The literature is a Gish Gallop that takes more time and care than most people have to wade through. But reiki and therapeutic touch? Absolute nonsense.
Manna Lu-Wong says she needs only one minute to convince skeptics of the therapeutic effects of Reiki.
Hm. Tell that to a 9-year-old like Emily Rosa.
Acupuncture and therapeutic touch are offered at Cornell-Weil where they offer the idea that
Each point provides a specific function to regulate a free flow of blood and vital energy, or “chi.”
Free flow of blood. What is that? So I put free flow of blood and acupuncture into Pubmed.
Your search was processed without automatic term mapping because it retrieved zero results.
I should know better than to think there was actual studies to support their advertising. Silly me. Maybe they mean bleeding at the needling site? Probably not.
They also have a urologist who is an acupuncturist as well. Don’t worry. The male genitals is one of the few places, along with the eye and under the nails, that have no acupoints. Or so I hope.
And, of course, these services are targeted at cancer patients.
North Shore University Hospital at Northwell Health
“Reimagining what health care can be—together”
Part of New Yorks largest health care system.
The North Shore University hospital has a chronic pain service that
offers many complementary therapies including reiki therapy, aromatherapy, pet therapy, meditation and guided imagery
They are part of a system that is awash in SCAMS such as reflexology, acupuncture and reiki through their Center for Wellness and Integrative Medicine and other sites. The system looks favorably on the concept of detoxification
And one of the cancer centers in the system offers
Integrative medicine therapies with a registered nurse who specializes in aromatherapy, reiki/energy healing, guided imagery, gentle touch, reflexology, and acupuncture provided by a licensed acupuncturist.
Otherwise SCAM offerings at the University Hospital appear to be minimal. Or my Search is off. They do offer reiki to the staff one way of granting legitimacy to nonsense.
Northwestern Medicine-Northwestern Memorial Hospital
They have the Osher Center for Integrative Health which offers traditional Chinese pseudomedicine including acupuncture, herbs, cupping, tua na, and gua sha. “Energy” medicine that includes reiki and therapeutic touch. They have reflexology, chiropractic, and cranio-sacral therapy. While search for homeopathy yields no results, they say
Our highly-qualified team of providers provides acupuncture, massage, counseling, mind-body therapy, chiropractic, naturopathy, nutrition and supplement advice, and fitness/wellness education.
And where there is a naturopath, homeopathy is not far behind.
They are also the first to mention
Meridians have been shown in recent research to be more than energetic pathways, but rather real, anatomical structures potentially involved in tissue restoration and repair.
Really? I can find the study on Pubmed to confirm that statement; I sure wish they had references. But I did come across a better understanding of meridians
We present here a model of meridians in the formalism of the gauge theory paradigm of quantum field theory with spontaneous breakdown of symmetry. We discuss the origin and dynamic self-focusing propagation of the electromagnetic field in coherent states and the role it plays in our meridian modeling. Within this frame, we consider the formation of solitary waves on proteins and anatomical filamentary structures and discuss nondissipative energy transport. Finally, we analyze the relation of meridians with anatomical filamentary structures, the reciprocal actions between meridians, and biochemical activity and the key role played by free energy, internal energy, and entropy.
They also suggest these interventions for everything from cancer to fertility to arthritis, so as best I can tell they offer every SCAM for every disease, perhaps the most comprehensive collection of SCAMs of all the hospitals in the list.
For women’s health they offer all the usual SCAMs for a variety of medical problems including infertility except, oddly, birth control based on integrative medicine. Funny, that.
For energy therapy they note
Energy treatments are aimed at healing imbalances in the energy fields purported to be in and around the human body.
I love they way they use weasel words like purported to justify the application of worthless interventions with no basis in reality outside of linking to a credit card. That is typical in all these SCAM offerings and you have to wonder if in their heart of hearts they know what they are doing is pure BS?
NYU Langone Hospitals
They offer acupuncture, reiki, therapeutic touch to not only cancer and pain patients, but they offer integrative medicine to children, emphasizing
The Importance of Integrative Medicine
At least the reiki and theraputic touch for children is free. If you are going to do nothing, you should charge nothing.
One of their reiki ‘masters’ is a reflexologist, so I assume that bit of nonsense is being fobbed off on the vulnerable as well. And they offer yoga and guided therapy as well, if you want to consider those part of SCAM.
They do have a sense of humor in their ironic use of the term evidence-based:
Therapeutic Touch® is an evidenced-based energy therapy that is used to promote balance and wellbeing. Direct touch is not necessary for the treatment but may be used.
Given all the evidence is negative. Love that registered trademark.
For fertility issues
Acupuncture aims to calm the nervous system and improve blood flow to the pelvic region. It may improve pregnancy rates when used in conjunction with fertility treatment.
Ah, that weasel word may, used to justify the
Initial 90-minute visit, $160; follow-up 60-minute visits, $120.
And it often takes multiple visits to see the effect.
Although the rehab service has a different mechanism of action
stimulate the nervous system to release important chemicals in the brain, such as pain-relieving endorphins. An improved energy balance also stimulates the body’s natural healing abilities.
For cancer acupuncture has a different mechanism:
the release of proteins, hormones, and brain chemicals that control a number of body functions.
that is nice and specific.
Acupuncture has been shown to affect blood pressure and body temperature, boost immune system activity, and release endorphins, the body’s natural painkillers. Acupuncture complements cancer treatments, helping to improve the body’s energy balance.
Why you would to want to alter body temperature with acupuncture is not mentioned and I can’t think of a reason why a cancer pateint would want to do that. There is an extensive literature on changes in skin temperature at acupoints, what I read was less than impressive.
None of these sites, however, explain just what this energy is and how it is balanced by so many different interventions. I wish the electric grid was so amenable.
Massage and acupuncture treatments must be paid for at the time of service, before the session. We accept cash, checks, major credit cards, and flexible spending account (FSA) cards.
Rush University Medical Center
“Among the nation’s best” and part of a multi-hospital system.
At first I was optimistic. I searched the site for ‘complementary’ and ‘alternative’. Nothing of note. Did I finally find a SCAM free hospital? Of course not.
There is acupuncture offered for everything from pain to hypertension to infertility to cancer.
Researchers think acupuncture works by stimulating your nervous system in a way that promotes health and well-being and reduces pain.
Really? In what way? And I suppose these researchers are quite gullible.
Rush Excellence in Acupuncture
Acupuncturists at Rush regularly conduct research designed to increase knowledge of how acupuncture works and what it most effectively treats. Their acupuncture approaches are based on the latest research about what works best to ease which symptoms and conditions.
Although if that were really true, the practice of acupuncture would have been abandoned.
But that’s it. Searching the site finds no reiki or energy medicine or any of the TCPM derivatives. No fly by night SCAMs for Rush.
Stanford Health Care-Stanford Hospital
They have their Center for Integrative Medicine which
combines the best of mental (meditation, hypnosis), nutritional, acupuncture, and lifestyle treatments with mainstream modern medicine and psychotherapy to provide care for the whole person: mind and body. Started in 1998, the Stanford Center for Integrative Medicine (SCIM) is committed to evidence-based practices.
Which begs the usual question, how do these Centers say open if the are committed to evidence-based practice. Oh, I see. Just ignore the quality of the evidence. Got it.
They offer their SCAMs for a wide variety of problems, from pain to infertility.
We help patients to combine “alternative” techniques, including acupuncture, hypnosis, mindfulness, and information regarding dietary supplements, with traditional medical care.
I love that alternative is in quotes, implying it is legit? Or a sly dig that it isn’t, like “fresh” fish. Probably the former.
Our evaluation and counseling staff includes a physician-naturopath
Now there are two words that really don’t belong together. But if there is a naturopath, then all sorts of wackadoodle options are on the table.
They note
Traditional Chinese Medicine theorizes that there are more than 2,000 acupuncture points on the human body
so with the average human being 3000 square inches, excluding the eyes, nails and genitals, that is about one point per square inch. Hope they are precise in their needling.
They offer whole body detox, but at least no reiki, therapeutic touch or chiropractic that I could find.
UCLA Medical Center
“Your best care is closer than you think.”
Unless it is Integrative medicine, which they offer for many programs for digestive health, cancer, menopause, and more, as well as a Center for East-West Medicine. Also aromatherapy, yoga, tai chi, and meditation if you want to count those as SCAMs. Whether you do is very dependent of the message offered.
You’ll receive exceptional care from board-certified doctors who pioneer research in integrative health, nutrition, traditional Chinese medicine and more.
How one gets “exceptional care” from the rank quackery that is acupuncture, acupressure, traditional Chinese pseudo-medicine, and reiki is uncertain.
A Japanese vibrational energy therapy facilitated by light touch, on or slightly off the body, that balances the human biofield—the field of energy and information that surrounds and permeates the human body.
Not even a weasel word, reiki and its underlying fictional premise is presented as fact.
UC San Diego Health-La Jolla and Hillcrest Hospitals
“World Class Care- Here for You”
Part of a 15 hospital system.
They do not have a Center or a web page for SCAMs. They do offer acupuncture for pain and endometriosis, but low key with no push or advertisements for the intervention. Searching the site for all the usual suspects yields nothing. As best I can tell, it is one of the least SCAMy hospitals on the list.
UCSF Health-UCSF Medical Center
One of several metastases of the Osher Center for Integrative Health. Of course they offer acupuncture for a wide variety of processes, from pain to infertility, although the photograph of the ungloved hands was the most cringe-inducing of all the acupuncture photos I saw during the preparation of the post. They also offer Chinese herbs and supplements.
They offer Ayurveda, which along with TCPM, propose to reinstate balance. Is it the same balance as acupuncture? Or reiki? Or are they different? Does one imbalance need TCPM and another imbalance need Ayurveda? While yet another imbalance needs ‘energy’ medicine? They never clarify which balance might be required and why for a given imbalance.
Cancer patients are, of course, a focus. All predators know to go for the weakest in a herd. They note
Integrative Medicine is an approach that looks at each person as a complete, unique person, rather than just someone with a set of “symptoms” that need to be corrected.
I think it is kind of sad that symptoms are in quotes. Makes you wonder what kind of diagnosticians are in integrative medicine center. The pattern of the signs and symptoms are what is key for reaching a diagnosis. I suppose I should say they are integrative “doctors”.
They offer reiki and have provided it free to the homeless. For those that have nothing, they offer more of the same.
They aspire to
Advancing the science of integrative health by conducting and disseminating rigorous research.
But looking over that research? Meh. Not a lot of rigor I can see. The one acupuncture study was pilot and not randomized. Why bother? But SCAM researchers love their small, poorly designed, placebo-free studies as quality studies will only demonstrate the worthlessness of their intervention.
Included are
The styles of massage offered are deep tissue, Swedish, acupressure techniques, healing and therapeutic touch.
They describe massage as
Depending on the style of massage, techniques may include stroking, kneading, rocking, tapping or holding steady pressure.
Somehow, therapeutic touch, and sometimes reiki, is included as a form of massage but in both interventions the patient is not touched, so that is a massage just how? There is the nothing burger and the nothing massage.
University of Michigan Health-Ann Arbor
The have Integrative Family Medicine of all things. Yet another that “is informed by evidence” but then proceeds to ignore that evidence by offering acupuncture.
They are very non-specific with their options, almost as if they are embarrassed to wade in the pool of SCAM.
A well rounded treatment plan is then created that suits each individual’s unique needs, offering specific recommendations for mind, body, spirit and emotion that aims to optimize health. Integrative therapies such as holistic nutrition, relaxation techniques, acupuncture, massage, herbs and supplements are blended with the best of medical science and technology that is the hallmark of the Michigan Difference. This approach fosters optimal wellness and healing no matter what the health challenges.
They do, of course, offer Integrative medicine to cancer patients and even have a fellowship.
Otherwise searching the website with specific SCAM terms such as reiki yields nothing. However, with an ND as the co-director of their program, I would suspect many a fiction-based therapy may be on the table.
UT Southwestern Medical Center
99% SCAM free. I suppose in Texas they have enough other irrational belief systems that they can’t burden their health care system with another. Even the cancer center appears to be SCAM free. But searching the website for all the usual suspects finds nothing but a lone family practitioner who is interested in SCAM. And if you search outside the website, you can find a few practitioners of acupuncture, but the service is not explicitly offered. So, wow. Wonder how long that is going to last.
Vanderbilt University Medical Center
Vanderbilt is another of the metastatic sites of The Osher Center. But it appears to be relatively low key. Acupuncture, of course, and qigon, yoga and tai chi. But no reiki, therapeutic touch etc. Kind of SCAM light, as it were.
Conclusions
So that is what the Honor Roll of hospitals has to offer for SCAMs. Or maybe it should be the Honor Trick-Roll:
A trick-roll is when a health care worker commits a SCAM on a client or potential client irrespective of whether any medical therapy takes place.
Acupuncture and reiki are the most popular fiction based interventions, so even the alleged best and brightest succumb to the siren call of $CAM. I am less than surprised. And I debated about making the S a dollar sign, it is kind of dis-ease-y. Not certain if that will become a thing moving forward.
What I do not understand is why these interventions are not considered fraud. Computer companies seem to get sued for far less. If this were business and you lied about the size of your real estate or the accuracy of your diagnostic testing or the value of your cryptocurrency, it would be fined millions of dollars, lose their license to practice and maybe even go to jail. In medicine? You get an academic appointment and your very own Center. Perhaps businesses should say they use Integrative or Complementary or Alternative business practices along with more weasel words. Maybe it would keep them out of jail.
There was an article in The Atlantic on shrinkflation that noted
the government could more strongly enforce existing laws about deceptive selling practices and work to further prohibit misleading tactics, including with stricter labeling rules.
Why that doesn’t apply to SCAMs I will never understand.
I have little doubt that most of the HCWs in these institution lack the time and interest to care. They shrug, the medical equivalent of the banks didn’t lose any money.
I am of the old school opinion that physicians and hospitals need to strive to a higher standard of ethical responsibility. HAHAHAHAHAHAHAQHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA. Oh, I crack myself up. But people trust HCWs with their lives, health, time, and hope. Seems a shame to take it all away with SCAMs.
I used to think that Sisyphus was the mascot for SBM. Then maybe Hercules mucking out the Augean stables. Now? Probably a telepod-related mash up of both, as neither the work nor the horseshit will ever diminish. Sisyphus as dung beetle? Works for me.
Addendum to my last post.
Science published another article, Teach Indigenous knowledge alongside science. Note the word alongside. It is a reasonable, precise, and well thought out article, unlike the prior editorial. They note:
We do not argue that Indigenous knowledge should usurp the role of, or be called, science. But to step from “not science” to “therefore not as (or at all) valuable and worthy of learning” is a non sequitur, based on personal values and not a scientifically defensible position.
The difference between those in upstate NY and those in New Zealand.

*When asked about a second opinion, I always think of the joke. Doctor: You are crazy. Patient: I want a second opinion. Doctor: OK. You are ugly too.

INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE

   Integrative Medicine – Sectarians’ Trojan Horse
Wallace Sampson
Links
Integrative Medicine – Sectarians’ Trojan Horse leapfrogs science (Or, I can misuse language with the best of them…)
I stumbled across an article from Archives of Internal Medicine, 2002 (Integrative Medicine: Bringing medicine back to its roots. Arch Intern Med. 2002 Feb 25;162(4):395-7). It is one of the first authored by Andrew Weil on “Integrative Medicine “ – another is BMJ in 2001. This one he co-authored with Ralph Snyderman. Dr. Snyderman was dean of the Duke University med school, and is now upstairs as a chancellor of health affairs. He is one of the highest ranking academicians to express fondness for sectarian systems (they prefer “Integrative Medicine.”) Fondness in his case is an understatement. He appears to have fallen up to his frown into the sectarian vat and emerged transformed as the poster-prof for the Bravewell Collaboration, funding organization for the 36 departments and programs in US medical schools. Andrew Weil, of course is one of the prime movers of the “CAM” phenomenon, and may have invented the neo-term, “Integrative” – with the clever occult purpose of diverting attention away from plausibility and toward acceptance according to our suggested motto, “teach it and use it regardless of efficacy.“ He directs this activity from his spread near Tucson, where he also heads the U. of Arizona “integrative” program.
I experienced several problems on reading the article – mainly a cloud of dysphoria and a sense that of disagreement with it, but through a fog of obscure language, I could not identify why. One has to look closely at the language. The abstract alone yields enough for this entry. It displays language distortion by re-definition, as Kim Atwood recently explored, language obscurantism – use of generalizations and words with obscure or multiple meanings, and invented language. It also mis-states, misrepresents, assumes; these are established propaganda techniques and used to construct false labels on sectarianism’s Trojan Horse. After starting this I found a similar article by Edzard Ernst in Mayo Clinic Proceedings in 1993. Nothing new under the sun…
One might also look at the personalities of these two authors who keep the drum-beats of the movement going. I’ve not met Dr. Snyderman, but just observed some of his TV clips. He seems to have few doubts if any about the necessity for a revolutionary change in medicine. I shared a podium with Dr. Weil at a national meeting once, but again, know him mostly through his books, newsletter, and TV fund-raising ads on Public Television. And through the description by Arnold Relman MD (Stoned Thinking.)
I got some enjoyment from “deconstructing” the language of this Archives article, written soon after the appearance of “integrative” in literature. “Integrative” by the way, is now the official term adopted by several medical school departments or sections formerly called “CAM,” including UC San Francisco, and for the “New Medicine” promoted by the Bravewell Collaborative. Take a quick read of the abstract.
ABSTRACT The United States health system is in crisis. Amidst unprecedented opportunities to transform healthcare for the better, American medicine faces threats from two directions. One is financial and cannot be solved by the profession alone. Health care technologies are more expensive, more people want access to them, and reimbursement mechanisms neither provide universal coverage nor reward improved care or prospective planning.The second threat is intrinsic to our practice and must be solved from within. Facing the pressures of economic and bureaucratic strains as well as the seduction of technology, conventional medicine has become separated from its roots of caring, engaging with patients and meeting their real needs. This has caused many to seek alternative approaches. Integrative medicine is a movement that addresses this latter threat by retraining physicians to understand their roles as healers. To do this they must incorporate the best of science and technology with the appropriate use of complementary approaches, always remaining mindful of the centrality of the therapeutic relationship and the healing power of nature. Through its focus on health prevention, and meaningful physician-patient relationships, the Integrative Medicine movement can improve health care and the quality of medical practice, and perhaps reduce health care costs as well. In our view, it is essential that the leaders of American medicine consider adapting medical education to encompass the principles inherent in Integrative Medicine.
Let’s take a closer look:
“The United States health system is in crisis.” This proclamation has been posted for so long and so frequently without anything actually occurring, that it has become a non-sequitur. A crisis, according to Dictionary.com is,1. A stage of instability of events at which the trend of all future events, … is determined; a turning point. 2. A condition of instability or danger…leading to a decisive change 3. A dramatic or circumstantial upheaval in …life.
I disagree that medicine is in crisis – a state that critics maintain has been present for at least 40 years. Describing that as a crisis requires a re-definition of the word. Occurrence and persistence of defects in a system do not define the system as being in a crisis. During the past century, revolutionary advances brought through basic and applied science have changed medicine – for the better – we would not agree the system is in crisis. Yet people who stand to benefit from the concept continue to use it and many of the public and the press go along. The fact is that if a society is free from stultifying regulation, a certain degree of chaos results with swings in popularity and efficiency – yet, overall, a free system controlled mostly by voluntary ethical codes probably works more effectively and with less dissatisfaction than whatever regulatory system is proposed by critics. In this case, the authors’ proposal to correct their perceived “crisis” through understanding and empathy and use of ineffective sectarian methods would convince only true believers.
It continues:
Amidst unprecedented opportunities to transform healthcare for the better, American medicine faces threats from two directions. One is financial and cannot be solved by the profession alone. Health care technologies are more expensive, more people want access to them, and reimbursement mechanisms neither provide universal coverage nor reward improved care or prospective planning.
In the first sentence, the two ideas – opportunities to transform and the concept of threats to medicine are unconnected. What follows does not help to connect them, because 1) return to folkway and sectarian medical methods will not replace applied science and technology, and 2) countering threats or correcting deficits does not necessarily imply transformation – a rather radical concept that just happens to fit what the authors have in mind. That medical care (“health care” as they prefer to call it) is expensive is true, but that is largely due to increased technology, increased number and skill required of professional and support personnel, and the explosive changes brought through scientific research. The authors admit this in what follows, but neither they nor others show that expense or lack of coverage cause people to “seek alternative approaches,” nor will they show that their revolution would fix the problems. Most who “seek” have higher incomes or are well covered by insurance. Not mentioned is that sectarian followers share their leaders’ anti-scientific, anti-authoritarian views that shape their decisions. [My original interest in this began with interviews of 33 Laetrile-taking cancer patients, all of whom shared resentments against medicine and physicians that antedated their involvement in that quackery.] Involvement in sectarian systems is cult-like behavior.
“Health Care” has replaced medical care in many descriptions. A probable reason is that “medical care” implies physician-run or physician-performed care, while “health” opens the discussion and available roles to non-physicians. We found this in a recent survey of journal editors – nursing journal editors avoiding the term “medical“ entirely, even when in “Alternative and Complementary Medicine,“ preferring the term, “Alternative and Complementary Health…” I had wondered in passing about the popularity of “health care” but had not known it was specifically substituted for ideological, professional and perhaps turf-motivated reasons.
And then, “…universal coverage,… improved care, [and] prospective planning…“ seem to have little or nothing to do with ‘integrative medicine’ or whatever that means to the authors. They seem to be basic and reasonable enough. The abstract continues:
The second threat is intrinsic to our practice and must be solved from within. Facing the pressures of economic and bureaucratic strains as well as the seduction of technology, conventional medicine has become separated from its roots of caring, engaging with patients and meeting their real needs.
Note the wording. The authors use the first person plural possessive, “our” , inserting themselves into the mainstream of internist readers. Thus, the actual creators of the problem, the cultist and sectarian proponents, now complete the Trojan Horse entry into Fortress Medicine by assuming to be “one of us”, rather than being the outlying sectarian ideologues they are. From that position they offer their expertise and aid, as “all of us” solve the problem through the “New Medicine” they promote. [The New Medicine was the title of last year‘s Bravewell-sponsored several hour program on “Integrative Medicine“ on Public Television.]
Then comes the trite but never proved generalization that “conventional medicine has become separated from its roots of caring …etc”. First, “conventional” medicine is one of the ten or so original derogatory adjectives ideologues use to isolate medicine from its universality of science-based knowledge and ethically-based practice and to demean its stature, while allowing sectarian systems to be described as simply “unconventional” – the preferred term for the Congress-directed, Office of Technology Assessment, 1989 report on obstructions to acceptance of quack cancer cures.
Second, the “separation” generalization draws a mental picture of all physicians as a helpless, mythical, synthetic mass of cold, uncaring and hapless technology geeks. The power of one or two words, incorporated. Ask most docs and they will complain about scheduled time requirements, but few of them feel sacrificed to a life of unfeeling. It continues:
This has caused many to seek alternative approaches. Integrative medicine is a movement that addresses this latter threat by retraining physicians to understand their roles as healers. To do this they must incorporate the best of science and technology with the appropriate use of complementary approaches, always remaining mindful of the centrality of the therapeutic relationship and the healing power of nature. Through its focus on health prevention, and meaningful physician-patient relationships, the Integrative Medicine movement can improve health care and the quality of medical practice, and perhaps reduce health care costs as well. In our view, it is essential that the leaders of American medicine consider adapting medical education to encompass the principles inherent in Integrative Medicine.
Here they begin rubbing our wounds with insulting salt solutions conceived by ideologues of the anti-scientific Left. (Some might call it the Right, and I‘ll buy that, also) More: The solution of “retraining physicians” implies admission that Snyderman and colleagues failed to educate us. But of course he did not admit it. Nor could Weil, even though he is now part of “we” and assumed to be just as deficient in human qualities.
Even more prospects crouch in these wordings and in their minds. “Integrative Medicine will solve the threat of inhumanity by retraining physicians to understand their roles as healers.” How insulting and demeaning and arrogant! Yet their advocates and followers accuse physicians of arrogance. The clear definition of chutzpah.
Not only does this preposterous proposal imply changing our standards of behavior (our ethics), but also introduction of a coercive set of standards for “feeling.“ In other words, what Snyderman, Weil, and Bravewell think is that they have discovered the secrets of sensitivity and of being human, but that they will now bring courses of indoctrination of how to feel and how to relate.
Think about it. Oh, the chutzpah. Here are two people with MD’s after their names, one who never practiced, and another who spent his life in academic medicine, removed from primary responsibility, neither one responding to middle of the night phone and emergency calls, house calls on the sick and dying, and ministering to the bereaved. They have discovered the answer to being human, and want to bring their utopian concepts to the rest of “us.“
We already have such arrogance thrust on physicians through legislatively directed requirements of specific post-grad education hours in geriatrics, pain relief, and other legislatively perceived deficiencies. At age 70, I was required to sit through hours of instruction in the care of patients over 60.
More recently we hear calls for re-education in “cultural competence” in a nation with immigrants from scores of differing nations and cultures – as though it were possible even if that competence were ever defined. And, without courses for immigrant patients on how to relate to American physicians and the medical system, as if we bear the responsibility for educating ourselves for every group deciding to immigrate here. In other circumstances and other countries such activity this has been called anything from state coercion to tyranny. Re-education. Doesn’t that have a familiar ring to it? The intent and the inevitable conclusions are obvious and inescapable. Revolutionary. And we are supposed to take our behavior orders from these two and their cultist followers? And just how did reviewers and editors allow publication of such arrogant nonsense? I have yet to touch on the claim that “…Integrative Medicine can improve health care and the quality of medical practice, and perhaps reduce health care costs as well.“ I don’t have to at this point. We could wait for the evidence, right? Don’t they admit that their “IM” includes only the best and most effective of the “alternatives”? Hey, there’s a lot more buried in this paper, but I am out of steam, time, and your patience. You get the point. I’ll deconstruct more in a few weeks. Meanwhile, my resentment may increase.

   “Integrative medicine”: A brand, not a specialty
David Gorski
Link
Author’s note: This post was inspired in part by a post by Wally Sampson entitled Why would medical schools associate with quackery? Or, How we did it.
PRELUDE
Once upon a time, there was quackery.
Long ago, back in the mists of time before many of our current readers were even born and far back in the memory of even our wizened elders of medicine, “quackery” was the preferred term used to refer to ineffective and potentially harmful medical practices not supported by evidence. Physicians, having a grounding in science and prior plausibility, for the most part understood that modalities such as homeopathy, reflexology, and various “energy healing” (i.e., faith healing) methodologies were based either on prescientific vitalism, magical thinking, and/or science that was at best incorrect or at the very least grossly distorted. More importantly, physicians weren’t afraid to call quackery quackery, quacks quacks, and charlatans charlatans.
Not surprisingly, quacks and charlatans did not like this.
Then, a few decades ago, most likely beginning in the 1960s and 1970s, supporters of quackery decided that they would never get anywhere selling their products, except to a small minority of people, if they continued to allow physicians to define their favorite quackery as being…well, quackery. To change this, they joined with physicians whose scientific rigor could best be described as…questionable. Together, these practitioners of pseudoscience and the credulous physicians smitten with the romance of that pseudoscience decided that a new term was needed, a more soothing, reassuring term, a term that was not so derogatory. As a consequence, the term “quackery” somehow morphed into “alternative medicine.” Alternative medicine was (and, when the term is used, still is) medicine that does not fit into the current scientific paradigm, a term used to describe medical practices that were not supported by evidence, were ineffective and potentially harmful, and were used instead of effective therapies. Physicians understood that modalities such as homeopathy, reflexology and various “energy healing” (i.e., faith healing) methodologies were based either on prescientific vitalism, magical thinking, and/or on science that was at best incorrect or grossly distorted. More importantly, they weren’t afraid to say so.
Although practitioners of alternative medicine liked this term better than the terms “quackery” and “quacks,” they were, not surprisingly, still not satisfied.
That’s why, sometime lost in the mists of time of the 1990s, alternative medicine practitioners (i.e., quacks) decided that they would never get anywhere selling their products, outside of a small minority of people, if they themselves defined their very own products as somehow being outside the mainstream of scientific medicine by calling them “alternative.” Such was not the way to win friends, influence people, and, above all, become (or at least seem) respectable. Thus was born the term “complementary and alternative medicine,” which had the nice, pithy abbreviation of “CAM.”
CAM was (and is) medicine that does not fit into the current scientific paradigm, including treatments that are not supported by evidence and are ineffective and/or potentially harmful. The difference? CAM therapies are used in addition to real medicine. Over a relatively brief period of time, the name change had its intended effect. No longer did many physicians automatically view modalities that were once considered quackery, later considered “alternative,” and now considered “CAM” as quackery, and those that still did were dismissed as close-minded, stubborn, and dogmatic, relics who were trying to swim against the coming wave of wonderful CAM magic. Modalities such as homeopathy, reiki, various energy healing methods, and even reflexology were no longer reflexively (sorry, couldn’t help it) dismissed. Despite several of them (especially homeopathy and the various energy healing modalities) violating known laws of physics and requiring that our understanding of physics be not just wrong, but spectacularly wrong, for them to work, somehow methodolatrists preaching “evidence-based medicine,” valuing randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trials above all else even when physics, chemistry, and common sense should tell them that a treatment (such as homeopathy) cannot work, allowed the background noise of clinical research caused by the occasional false positive clinical trial to convince them that there might be something to these modalities. Also, by using their former quackery in addition (i.e., as complementary) to real medicine, CAM practitioners (mostly) neutered the biggest complaint about alternative medicine, namely the concern that patients forego effective therapy in order to pursue alternative medicine. Meanwhile, many physicians who might have in the past opposed the infiltration of such quackery/alternative/CAM therapies turned into shruggies and no longer cared enough to speak out. The stage was set for the widespread adoption of CAM by medical schools.
And CAM practitioners did declare that this was indeed good–but not good enough.
That’s why CAM advocates, even though they had made huge inroads introducing quackademic medicine into medical schools and academic medical centers, bolstered by the influence of the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) and the Bravewell Collaborative, an organization founded by Christy Mack, the wife of a wealthy investment banker, for the express purpose of promoting the study and use of CAM in medical academia, decided that even their remarkable success was not good enough. Thus was born in recent years a new term for CAM. CAM practitioners (formerly alternative medicine practitioners, formerly quacks) hit upon the perfect term for their treatments. It is a term so media-friendly, so seemingly reasonable that it is a wonder that no one had thought of it before.
“Integrative medicine.”
No longer were CAM practitioners content to have their favorite quackery be “complementary” to real medicine. After all, “complementary” implied a subsidiary position. Medicine was the cake, and their wares were just the icing. That wasn’t good enough. They craved respect. They wanted to be co-equals with physicians and science- and evidence-based medicine. The term “integrative medicine” (IM) served their purpose perfectly. No longer were their treatments merely “complementary” to real medicine. Oh, no. Now they were “integrating” their treatments with those of science- and evidence-based medicine! The implication, the very, very, very intentional implication, was that alternative medicine was co-equal to science- and evidence-based medicine, an equal partner in the “integrating.”
And to IM practitioners, it was very good indeed. Quackery had successfully infiltrated scientific medicine to such an extent that it could metastasize everywhere.
It’s all about the branding
No doubt, there will be some who proclaim my little introduction above to be too “harsh.” Too “strident,” even. Not nearly diplomatic or “respectful” enough. So be it. My narrative has the advantage of being largely true, and only mildly exaggerated for (I hope) dramatic effect. The terms “CAM” and “integrative medicine” are not serious, sober names for a serious, sober, science-based specialty. They are about the branding of quackery. They have always been about the branding of quackery. They are about double standards whereby treatments that can’t pass scientific muster are admitted to the “club” of science-based medicine under lowered standards. I frequently repeat a cliche, but just because it’s become a cliche does not make it untrue. There is no such thing as “alternative” medicine. There is medicine that has been proven safe and effective through science; there is medicine that has not; and there as medicine that has been proven unsafe and/or ineffective through science. Whatever you call it, “alternative,” “CAM,” or “integrative” medicine, when medicine, whatever its source, is demonstrated to be safe and effective through science, it ceases to be “alternative” or “complementary.” It becomes simply “medicine” and is automatically integrated into the current armamentarium of medicine, no special name needed, no special consideration needed to provide a lower standard of evidence.
If you have any doubt that the term “integrative medicine” is all about the branding, I present to you a couple of examples. First, here’s Mark Stoiber on both that wretched hive of scum and quackery, The Huffington Post asking Who Will Own the Brand of Integrative Medicine? His post is mirrored on his own blog as well. In this post, Stoiber, who is an advertising talent who describes himself as “creative director, entrepreneur, green brand specialist and writer,” describes a model of “integrative medicine” pharmacies that stock everything from real medicine to fake medicine (i.e., homeopathic remedies). In this case, he is talking about “integrating” pharmacies with the “vitamin shop model” and the “natural remedies” model, using the Pharmaca pharmacy chain as an example:
Pharmaca has demonstrated the market power of this common sense, scaling from one pharmacy in Boulder to 23 stores in Colorado, New Mexico, California, Oregon and Washington State.
Panzer attributes the success not to stocking shelves with products running the gamut from conventional pharma to natural remedies and homeopathy. Instead, it’s about creating crossover expertise.
The common US model is one pharmacist, and a bunch of clerks stocking shelves. In our case, we have the highly trained pharmacist, but also highly skilled practitioners with homeopathic or naturopathic backgrounds. No one expert has the full answer. Instead, we collaborate to offer our customers a more holistic approach to managing their health.
Stoiber then cites another advocate of “integrative” pharmacy:
Speaking with Bob Mehr, President of Pure Pharmacy in Vancouver, the importance of evidence-based remedies becomes apparent.
Up to now, there’s been a polarization between advocates of traditional and conventional pharmacy. We believe the way forward lies in using treatments that are backed by evidence, regardless of their origin.
Mehr says the only path to mass-market acceptance of integrative medicine will be with evidence. “I want to get rid of the whole east meets west stereotype. This isn’t about east meets west. It’s about getting the best product, or combination of products, for our customers. And those products come with proof of efficacy.”
The evidence-based model of integrative medicine is de facto in Europe. In Germany, for example, pharmacists at the ‘Apotheke’ feel completely comfortable prescribing conventional pharma, along with herbal and homeopathic supplements to augment recovery.
I realize that it’s just the reductionistic, “Western,” materialism-based scientist in me, but I have to say to Mr. Mehr and Mr. Stoiber: “Evidence.” You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means. After all, if the “integration” in medicine that they recommend were truly evidence-based, then homeopathy would not be a part of it at all. In fact, any truly evidence-based paradigm, be it science-based medicine (SBM) or IM, homeopathy should be excluded because in the end homeopathic remedies are, after all, water. Indeed, for homeopathy to work, huge swaths of well-established sciences, such as physics, chemistry, and biochemistry, would have to be not just wrong, but spectacularly wrong. Both Pharmaca and Pure Pharmacy sell homeopathic remedies; they cannot plausibly claim to be evidence-based, regardless of how much they “integrate” such nonsense with scientific medicine. Indeed, Pure Pharmacy has a homeopath on its staff and offers non-evidence-based services such as thermography, which is not a validated or reliable test for the early detection of breast cancer; bioenergetic health scans, which are devices akin to William C. Nelson’s infamous Quantum Xrroid Interface System; various detoxification products, none of which have any value; and bioidentical hormones, which are neither safer nor more effective than conventional hormone replacement therapy.
I said it at our panel discussion at TAM9, and I’ll say it again: “Integrative medicine” is in reality the “integration” of quackery with real medicine.
CAM is dead?
But back to the marketing aspect of the term “integrative medicine.” Last week, I saw a post from a supporter of IM who made the case, albeit inadvertently, better than I ever could. In fact, the man who wrote this is Glenn Sabin, a board member for the Society of Integrative Oncology who is described as a “staunch proponent and leader in the area of integrative medicine” even goes so far as to proclaim that CAM is dead:
Over the past 25 years, practitioners integrating the best of Western, Eastern and other evidence-based models of medicine into their practices have endured a series of catch-all titles that describe their model of care. Not long ago, all medicine not tacking closely to conventional allopathic care was termed “alternative”. Then about 15 years ago the term complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) began to seep into the medical vernacular. NIH’s National Center for Cancer and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) became a full-fledged center in 1991. Although most of the major hospitals and cancer centers did not introduce their integrative centers until a decade later, NCCAM’s “CAM” acronym stuck, and had an influence on new private clinics and centers across the country.
Mr. Sabin apparently doesn’t know much about history of NCCAM. In 1991, NCCAM was indeed born, except that it was not a full-fledged center. Rather, thanks to woo-friendly Senator Tom Harkin (D-IA) and $2 million of discretionary funding, NCCAM started its life as the Office of Unconventional Medicine, which was soon renamed the Office of Alternative Medicine (OAM). It was not until October 1998 that NCCAM received its current name and was elevated to a full center. Mostly, this was a big “screw you” from Tom Harkin to the then director of the NIH, Harold Varmus, who, responding to objections to the OAM from the scientific academic community, moved to place the OAM under tighter NIH control. The result? Tom Harkin introduced and passed legislation that elevated the OAM to an independent center within the NIH. Soon after, appropriations skyrocketed to over $100 million a year. NCCAM’s current budget hovers in the $125 million range.
One wonders what else Sabin gets wrong.
Whatever he might get wrong or right on a factual basis, Sabin echoes Stoiber’s message about “integrative medicine” that reveals the mindset of promoters of non-science-based medical treatments in the very next paragraph:
Today several integrative centers across the country still contain the words CAM in their name. This is both confusing to health consumers and damaging for these centers’ brand. Most clinics and centers launched during the last decade have evolved with their branding to include today’s more appropriate terminology of “integrative medicine”, “integrative services” or “integrative therapies”.
(Bold not mine, but rather Sabin’s.)
I will give Sabin credit. Whether he realizes it or not, he’s basically just admitted that the move to rename CAM as IM is all about the marketing of quackery. Yes, I know that he would never, ever admit that’s what he just did. After all, like Stoiber, Sabin liberally sprinkles his post with terms like “evidence-based integrative medicine,” which makes me wonder why IM aficionados haven’t renamed IM to “EBIM.” Perhaps that’s coming later in the next iteration of marketing buzzwords for quackery.
But I digress.
Getting back on track, I note that Mr. Sabin does a wonderful job of expressing the confusion at the heart of so-called “evidence-based integrative medicine,” almost certainly without realizing that he is doing so. See if you can figure out what I mean before I explain it:
Alternative medicine is often pushed in lieu of proven conventional care. Alternative medicine does not have an adequate science base behind it and is not practiced in clinics within an academic setting. Integrative medicine integrates proven therapies into conventional medicine. True, not all methods of mindfulness-based stress reduction techniques like, say, Reiki have a solid evidence base behind it, but in this case, many clinicians that offer services like Reiki do so because their clinical observations tell them that it helps many of their patients relax and may lessen the need of certain pain meds.
So, let me get this straight. IM is better than “alternative medicine” because alternative medicine is “often pushed in lieu of proven conventional care” while in contrast (allegedly) IM “integrates proven therapies into conventional medicine”? Is that what Sabin is saying? Yes, it is. Then, right after saying that, Sabin admits that “not all” IM methods have a solid evidence base behind them but that clinicians use them because of anecdotal observations. Here’s a hint for Mr. Sabin: Anecdotal observations are not the same thing as being “proven.” Far from it! As we have explained many times before right here on this very blog, anecdotal observations can be profoundly misleading, thanks to well-known phenomena that confound “clinical observations,” such as regression to the mean, confirmation bias, and placebo responses. That’s why “conventional” medical researchers long ago realized that well-designed clinical trials, preferably randomized and well-controlled, are necessary to minimize these biases and to correct for placebo responses. Mr. Sabin comes across as profoundly confused about the science in that he doesn’t seem to realize that the vast majority of “alternative medicine” modalities that he wants to see “integrated” with conventional medicine are not “proven” by any stretch of the imagination.
“Evidence-based.” You keep using that word, Mr. Sabin. I do not think it means what you think it means. Oh, wait. I used the same Princess Bride joke twice in one post. Inconceivable! (Sorry about that.)
Not that any of this stops Sabin from misrepresenting CAM as “personalized” medicine when it is anything but and the whole appeal to “personalized medicine” is a classic CAM bait-and-switch. Here’s how Sabin himself puts it:
CAM is dead. The evolution of evidence-based, personalized integrative medicine, and its implementation in clinic, lives on.
A similar sort of “bait-and-switch” is used by Stoiber near the end of his HuffPo article:
Speaking with Mehr and Panzer, I began to understand that the brand of integrative medicine demanded a shift in perspective. Instead of creating an omnipotent pharmacist, their models relied on collaboration. This bodes well for any integrative medicine brand that can open its doors to feedback, information sharing, education and ongoing learning.
This bait-and-switch is the bait-and-switch of representing CAM/IM as being all about “patient empowerment.” It is a ploy that I find particularly galling and very much akin to the trap that journalist David Freedman fell for when he wrote a completely credulous pro-CAM story for The Atlantic. His argument basically boiled down to this: Medicine as currently practiced all too often doesn’t permit doctors the time to spend with their patients to maximize the benefits of a caring physician-patient relationship, while CAM practitioners are all about spending that time. So let’s just cede that part of medicine to the quacks. As I said before, no, that’s not a straw man, either. Stoiber’s argument boils down to the same thing. If scientific medicine doesn’t sufficiently “empower” patients, then let’s “integrate” quackery into scientific medicine in order to give them choices that make them feel empowered. That’s it. Both are, of course, false dichotomies. It is not necessary to “integrate” quackery with scientific medicine to improve the doctor-patient relationship and realize the benefits that come from that or to “empower” patients. Neither require the quackery that is CAM or IM to achieve, but IM advocates really, really want you to think that they do.
As I said, first and foremost, IM is all about the marketing.
In the end, off course CAM is dead! CAM advocates themselves killed it because they sensed a better marketing opportunity if they could come up with a term that didn’t have the connotation that their treatments are inferior to those of conventional medicine. The killing of CAM was deliberate, calculated, and premeditated, but it is not yet complete. Rather, it is an ongoing process. But don’t worry. Marketers like Glenn Sabin and Marc Stoiber will make sure that before too long the corpse of CAM will be well and truly dead, cold, and buried. In its place will rise the zombie that is “integrative medicine.”
In fact, it’s already happening.

Lies, Damned Lies, and ‘Integrative Medicine’
Kimball Atwood on March 6, 2009
Link
Last week, two events took place in Washington that ought to inspire trepidation in the minds of all who value ethical, rational, science-based medicine and ethical, rational, biomedical research. One was the Senate Panel titled Integrative Care: A Pathway to a Healthier Nation, previously discussed by my fellow bloggers David Gorski, Peter Lipson, and Steve Novella, and also by the indefatigable Orac (here and here); the other was the “Summit on Integrative Medicine and the Health of the Public” convened by the Institute of Medicine (IOM) and paid for by the Bravewell Collaborative, previewed six weeks ago by fellow blogger Wally Sampson. This post will make a few additional comments about those meetings.
Senator Harkin and the Scientific Method
Thanks to Dr. Lipson, I didn’t have to listen to the Senate Panel video to find out that Senator Tom Harkin (D-Iowa) made this statement of disappointment regarding his own creation, the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM):
One of the purposes of this center was to investigate and validate alternative approaches. Quite frankly, I must say publicly that it has fallen short. It think quite frankly that in this center and in the office previously before it, most of its focus has been on disproving things rather than seeking out and approving. (from last week’s hearings, time marker approx. 17:20)
Are scientists at the NIH really too afraid of Harkin to explain to him how science works? Apparently so. Otherwise Harkin might learn that his statement is more wrong-headed than it would be for one of us to complain that the Supreme Court ought to assume that a defendant is guilty until proven innocent, rather than the other way around. In scientific inquiry, for those who don’t know, good experimental design is always directed at disproving a hypothesis, even one that pleases its investigator. The rest of Harkin’s sentiment—“seeking out and approving”—is incoherent.
The Selling of ‘Integrative Medicine’: Snyderman Trumps Weil
Spin doctors shilling for ‘integrative medicine,’ which the NCCAM defines as “combining treatments from conventional medicine and CAM,” appear to have now decided that subtler language is more likely to sell the product. We’ve previously seen an example offered by ‘integrative’ Mad Man Andrew Weil:
The addition of proven CAM to conventional medicine would be an improvement, yet this combination alone is not what could be defined as integrative medicine….Integrative medicine is defined as healing-oriented medicine that reemphasizes the relationship between patient and physician, and integrates the best of complementary and alternative medicine with the best of conventional medicine. We believe that this synthesis of humanistic medicine, patient- and relationship-centered care, preventive health, allopathy, and CAM is the model for creating an improved system of health care.
It takes someone who knows his way around a faculty meeting much better than does ex-hippie Weil, however, to understand that the surest way to usher ‘integrative medicine’ into the curricula of medical schools is to press the delete button whenever the pesky ‘CAM’ term comes up, and to replace it with a few trendy slogans that everyone can agree on. Ralph Snyderman, MD, the former Chancellor for Health Affairs at Duke University, is just such a person. As far back as 2002, Snyderman wrote:
Integrative medicine is an approach to the practice of health care based on a sound scientific approach with an emphasis on the responsibility of the physician to engage the patient in his or her own unique plan for health. Essential aspects include the recognition of the importance of the mind-body relationship and a willingness to consider unconventional modalities with informed skepticism and scientific evaluation. Above all, integrative medicine encompasses the caring bond between the patient and the caregiver, and the responsibility of the latter to enable the patient to benefit from a full array of modalities that can be shown to benefit health.
No surprise, then, that Snyderman was a key figure in last week’s “Summit.” Here is how he introduced the topic prior to the meeting:
“What we currently have is not a health care system, but a disease care system,” said Ralph Snyderman, M.D., chair of the Summit Planning Committee and chancellor emeritus of Duke University. “The summit will explore how science and a patient-centered, prospective, integrated approach to care can make a positive difference.”
It seems that ‘integrative medicine’ now might have something to do with preventive medicine, ‘patient-centered care,’ and fixing the health care system. The Summit’s Issue Background, authored by professional writer Vicki Weisfeld, makes it official:
Integrative medicine orients the health care process to create a seamless engagement by patients and caregivers in the full range factors known to be effective and necessary for the achievement of optimal health over the course of one’s life. In integrative medicine, patients are active partners in their health and providers care for them as individuals in different life circumstances, rather than just treating their illnesses. Thus, integrative medicine takes into account biological, psychological, social, and spiritual aspects of individuals’ lives, draws the best evidence for their needs and circumstances, and engages both treatment and prevention, including diet, exercise, stress management, emotional wellbeing, and socio-environmental factors. Integrative medicine makes use of the best conventional care and the latest advances in predictive, preventive, and personalized medicine and uses all appropriate evidence-based prevention, treatment and supportive approaches. Finally, it asks physicians to serve as guides, role models, and mentors and to recall that “healing is always possible, even when curing is not.”
Widespread implementation of an integrative medicine approach would fundamentally transform our nation’s current fragmented, inefficient, expensive, and reactive “sick care” system to one that is more proactive, personal, efficient, and appropriately focused on enhancing the health of each person and the population as a whole. Five chronic conditions—mood disorders, diabetes, heart disease, asthma, and high blood pressure—now account for more than half of all U.S. health expenditures. The onset and serious consequences of these conditions may have been partly or wholly preventable. Current patterns of care do little to enhance health, prevent illness, or treat it efficiently and effectively when it occurs. The reimbursement system encourages this pattern, by financially rewarding units of service, rather than outcomes, prevention, and the integration of care processes that each patient should expect. Little encouragement, through incentives or care patterns, is offered to individuals to take active part in their own care to enhance wellness and minimize disease.
Hmmm. No ‘CAM’ mentioned there. Nor will you find it until the bottom of page 3, where it is dressed up as “proven complementary approaches,” without further comment:
In 1910, the Flexner Report changed American medicine by insisting that doctors should be trained to diagnose and treat illnesses using the scientific tools of the day. Since then, the medical sciences have splintered into more and more specialties concerned with narrower and narrower aspects of the human body. Medicine’s focus on pathophysiology alone, and the reductionist perspective, do not well serve the many patients whose complex problems are incompletely understoodand treated by “find it and fix it” approaches.
As the Flexner centenary approaches, it is again time to reevaluate the training in U.S. medical schools…This requires taking a broader view of individual patients that takes into account the social, family, and physical environments in which they function as well as the patient’s own empowerment and motivation. It requires use of the best conventional medicine and cutting-edge diagnostic and treatment methods in combination with appropriate mentoring, compassion, and proven complementary approaches.
You don’t see it again until p. 9:
Some elements of an integrated approach to health care also have their roots in practices that began under the rubric of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM). The effectiveness of such approaches has been strengthened as experience and evidence has [sic] been gained.
Aha, you’re thinking: we’re about to find out what those mysterious, “proven complementary approaches” are! Think again, because here is the rest of the paragraph:
In 2003-2004, the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine sponsored a series of grants to strengthen awareness and knowledge about complementary and alternative medicine practices among medical students. The goal was to broaden the array of evidence-based techniques that physicians have at their disposal. A common finding from these projects was that culture change, including faculty development, was a necessary accompaniment to curriculum changes, and the result is a growing presence of relevant courses in the nursing and medical curricula. Expansion of these trends will require additional research, resources, incentives, continuing education courses, licensure requirements, and, perhaps, ultimately, reimbursement incentives.
It seems that ‘experience and evidence’ have shown that the only way to foist implausible medical claims into medical and nursing school curricula is to dupe medical and nursing students, bribe faculty members, and twist some arms. Or, perhaps, to pretend that ‘integrative medicine’ does not involve prescribing non-existent drugs, manipulating non-existent ‘energy fields’ and non-existent ‘rhythms,’ balancing non-existent ‘qi’ in various non-existent organs through non-existent ‘meridians’ and non-existent ‘acupuncture points,’ correcting non-existent ‘subluxations,’ diagnosing and treating diseases by examining non-existent homunculi on ears, eyes, and feet, hosing non-existent toxins out of colons, and all the rest.
How much easier it must be, when faced with a profession that has become maddeningly wedded to science—that vexing “reductionist perspective”—to pretend that one’s pet project doesn’t include such anti-scientific drivel (well, maybe it includes a little of the socially acceptable sort: “mindfulness meditation, acupuncture, massage and biofeedback…nutritional practices and dietary supplements” is what you get in this essay). Instead, why not claim that the program is about ‘patient-centered care,’ prevention, improving access to care, improving reimbursement for primary care physicians, making health care less expensive, considering psycho-social aspects of patient care, improving communication skills among health care professionals, and other uncontroversial topics?
So what if these have long been recognized as worthy goals, both individually and in the aggregate, since well before ‘integrative medicine’ or ‘CAM’ began to contaminate rational discourse in medical schools and government? So what if ‘integrative medicine’ has nothing new to add to them? This is all of little concern to the savvy chairman, who knows that the most important determinant of smooth sailing at a meeting is to avoid saying anything that might awaken the participants.
Is ‘Integrative Medicine’ Preventive Medicine?
Does ‘integrative medicine’ have anything to add to preventive medicine? You’d sure think so if you’d emerged from a 40-year coma last week to read the Issue Background:
Since integrative medicine begins from the perspective of maintaining and promoting individual health, it is necessarily closely attuned to the array of behavioral and environmental factors that put health at risk. Inevitably, the health system must look beyond the individual patient to broader social and environmental influences. As mentioned, many environmental factors require public health advocacy and intervention. However, even individual behavior, such as smoking and exercise, is susceptible to social and environmental approaches. Widespread anti-smoking advocacy and supportive public policies, like anti-smoking rules in workplaces and public spaces, increased tobacco taxes, and consumer education programs have changed the environment in the United States from a pro-smoking to largely anti-smoking culture. Similarly, public policies that promote exercise by building bike, jogging, and walking trails, corporations and city planners that encourage office and residential buildings to include gyms and showers, and an array of other public policies support a health-promotion culture. Health professionals have credibility in public discussions of such policies and can do a great deal for their own patients and the community by endorsing such pro-health initiatives. Medical researchers and health policy analysts can develop the clinical research and public policy assessments on which sound public policies can be based.
Really, now. That such spin was apparently composed with a straight face can only be a measure of how few people will read it. Which, alas, is exactly what the Bravewell crowd has in mind, and why Snyderman is such a brilliant choice as Propaganda Chief. The prevention hype is everywhere; here’s Harkin again, this time from his written statement:
We need a paradigm shift that places a much greater emphasis on preventing disease and keeping people healthy rather than merely treating people once they become sick. Integrative care can help us achieve this goal.
But has ‘integrative medicine’ or any of its ‘CAM’ progenitors contributed anything to real preventive medicine, as introduced yesterday by Peter Lipson? Have any of the preventive measures that most physicians can think of right off the bat—oh, in no particular order, by no means comprehensive, and not without uncertainties about usefulness or best uses: immunizations, blood pressure measurement and treatment, cholesterol screening and treatment, mammography, occult blood in stool, colonoscopy, smoking cessation, folate and iron in pregnancy, other prenatal care, bone density, weight, diet, exercise, pap smears, skin exams for melanoma, prostate-specific antigen, and many more—been introduced by ‘integrative medicine’? Let’s look. First, a list of
Preventive Measures Supported by Science that have been Advanced by Modern Medicine and Public Health

Guide to Clinical Preventive Services, 2008
Recommendations of the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force

The Guide to Clinical Preventive Services includes U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) recommendations on screening, counseling, and preventive medication topics and includes clinical considerations for each topic. This new pocket guide provides general practitioners, internists, family practitioners, pediatricians, nurses, and nurse practitioners with an authoritative source for making decisions about preventive services.
ContentsForewordPrefaceSection 1. Preventive Services Recommended by the USPSTFSection 2. Recommendations for AdultsCancer* Aspirin/NSAIDS for Prevention of Colorectal CancerBladder Cancer in Adults, ScreeningBreast and Ovarian Cancer Susceptibility, Genetic Risk Assessment and BRCA Mutation TestingBreast Cancer, ChemopreventionBreast Cancer, ScreeningCervical Cancer, ScreeningColorectal Cancer, ScreeningLung Cancer ScreeningOral Cancer, ScreeningOvarian Cancer, ScreeningPancreatic Cancer, ScreeningProstate Cancer, ScreeningSkin Cancer, Counseling to PreventSkin Cancer, ScreeningTesticular Cancer, ScreeningVitamin Supplementation to Prevent Cancer and Cardiovascular Disease, RoutineHeart, Vascular, and Respiratory DiseasesAbdominal Aortic Aneurysm, ScreeningAspirin for the Primary Prevention of Cardiovascular Events* Carotid Artery Stenosis, Screening* Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease, ScreeningCoronary Heart Disease, Screening* High Blood Pressure, ScreeningLipid Disorders in Adults, ScreeningPeripheral Arterial Disease, ScreeningInfectious DiseasesAsymptomatic Bacteriuria, Screening* Chlamydial Infection, ScreeningGenital Herpes, ScreeningGonorrhea, ScreeningHepatitis B Virus Infection, ScreeningHepatitis C in Adults, ScreeningHIV, ScreeningSyphilis Infection, ScreeningInjury and ViolenceFamily and Intimate Partner Violence, Screening* Motor Vehicle Occupant Restraints and Avoidance of Alcohol Use While Driving, CounselingMental Health Conditions and Substance AbuseAlcohol Misuse, Screening and Behavioral Counseling Interventions in Primary Care to ReduceDementia, ScreeningDepression, Screening* Illicit Drug Use, ScreeningSuicide Risk, ScreeningTobacco Use and Tobacco-Caused Disease, Counseling to PreventMetabolic, Nutritional, and Endocrine ConditionsDiet, Behavioral Counseling in Primary Care to Promote a HealthyHemochromatosis, ScreeningHormone Therapy for the Prevention of Chronic Conditions in Postmenopausal WomenIron Deficiency Anemia, ScreeningObesity in Adults, ScreeningPhysical Activity, Behavioral Counseling in Primary Care to PromoteThyroid Disease, ScreeningType 2 Diabetes Mellitus in Adults, ScreeningMusculoskeletal ConditionsLow Back Pain in Adults, Primary Care Interventions to PreventOsteoporosis in Postmenopausal Women, ScreeningObstetric and Gynecologic Conditions* Bacterial Vaginosis in Pregnancy, ScreeningBreastfeeding, Behavioral Interventions to PromoteGestational Diabetes Mellitus, ScreeningRh (D) Incompatibility, ScreeningVision DisordersGlaucoma, ScreeningSection 3. Recommendations for ChildrenBlood Lead Levels in Children and Pregnant Women, ScreeningDental Caries in Preschool Children, PreventionHip Dysplasia, ScreeningIdiopathic Scoliosis in Adolescents, Screening* Lipid Disorders in Children, ScreeningNewborn Hearing ScreeningOverweight in Children and Adolescents, Screening and Interventions* Sickle Cell Disease, ScreeningSpeech and Language Delay in Preschool Children, ScreeningVisual Impairment in Children Younger Than Age 5 Years, ScreeningAppendixesAppendix A. How the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force Grades Its RecommendationsAppendix B. Members of the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force 2001-2004Appendix C. AcknowledgmentsAppendix D. ACIP Recommended Immunization Schedules
* New recommendations 2007 to March 2008.
And now:
Preventive Measures Supported by Science that have been Advanced by ‘Integrative Medicine’
Got it?
…………..
The Misleading Language and Weakly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo series:
     1.  Misleading Language: the Common Currency of “CAM” Characterizations. Part I
     2.  Misleading Language: the Common Currency of “CAM” Characterizations Part II
     3.  The Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo #2
     4.  The Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo #3
     5.  The Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo #4
     6.  The Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo #5
     7.  The Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo #6
     8.  The Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo #7
     9.  The Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo #8
     10.  The Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo #9
     11.  Lies, Damned Lies, and ‘Integrative Medicine’
     12.  The Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo #10
     13.  Integrative Medicine: “Patient-Centered Care” is the new Medical Paternalism

Integrative Medicine: “Patient-Centered Care” is the new Medical Paternalism
Kimball Atwood on December 9, 2011
Link
Integrative Pitchmen
Several of us have written about how contemporary quacks have artfully pitched their wares to a higherbrow market than their predecessors were accustomed to, back in the day. Through clever packaging,* quacks today can reasonably hope to become professors at prestigious medical schools, to control and receive substantial grant money from the NIH, to preside over reviews for the Cochrane Collaboration, to be featured as guests and even as hosts on mainstream television networks and on PBS, to issue opinions in the name of the National Academy of Sciences, to be patronized by powerful politicians, and even to be chosen by U.S. presidents to chair influential government commissions.
The most successful pitch so far, and the one that the fattest quack-cats of all have apparently decided to bet the farm on, is “integrative medicine” (IM). Good call: the term avoids any direct mention of the only thing that distinguishes it from plain medicine. Its proponents, unsurprisingly, have increasingly come to understand that when they are asked to explain what IM is, it is prudent to leave some things to the imagination. They’re more likely to get a warm reception if they lead people to believe that IM has to do with reaching goals that almost everyone agrees are worthy: compassionate, affordable health care for all, for example.
In that vein, the two most consistent IM pitches in recent years—seen repeatedly in statements found in links from this post—are that IM is “preventive medicine” and that it involves “patient-centered care.” I demolished the “preventive” claim a couple of years ago, as did Drs. Lipson, Gorski, and probably others. Today I’ll explain why the “patient-centered care” claim is worse than fatuous.
Patient-Centered Care and Respect for Autonomy
“Patient-centered” is a term of recent vintage, used in legitmate contexts to emphasize the modern view that patients (or their competent surrogates) are free agents who are entitled to make their own health care decisions. Thus “patient-centered” is to be contrasted with “paternalistic,” the bad old style in which physicians merely told patients what to do, with explanations varying from none to fanciful (“take this [placebo], it’ll help”).
Physicians are now, ideally, expert consultants whose job is to give patients the information that they need to make rational decisions (even if patients don’t always make rational decisions). The formal ethical basis for this new “patient-centered” practice is the principle of Respect for Autonomy. This is also the ethical basis for the requirement of informed consent—both in trials and in medical practice. Thus informed consent is the sine qua non of patient-centered practice.
Integrative Medicine: “Patient-Centered Care” is the new Medical Paternalism
Do IM practitioners inform patients adequately? Let’s find out. Here are the first five M.D. practices that appear in the Google search, “Integrative Medicine Ontario” (can you guess why I chose Ontario?):
     1.  Integrative Medicine Consultants Inc.
     2.  Integrative Medicine Clinic
     3.  Seekers Centre for Integrative Medicine
     4.  Markham Integrative Medicine
     5.  Toronto Clinic for Preventive Medicine
Rather than spend my usual many hours copying, pasting, and explaining lengthy quotations from those sites, in order to demonstrate the wellspring of misinformation that each of them is, I’ll simply guarantee you that I am correct in that assertion. As difficult as it is to be fighting this uphill battle against modern quackery, one thing is utterly predictable: between the nature of the claims and the apparently irresistible urge that all quacks have to make them, you will almost always find whatever flim-flam you’re looking for. I’ve perused those sites just enough to see that the stuff is rampant, but I confess that I’m too tired to do the busywork now; perhaps I’ll add it piecemeal over the weekend. Alternatively, if any of you is moved to cull a juicy passage or two, I’ll be happy to heap praise upon you in the comment section.
Yes, there are vast deficits of informed consent in integrative medicine. Hence, when an integrative medicine advocate uses the term “patient-centered,” he actually means its historical opposite: medical paternalism. Now take another look at Andrew Weil, and you’ll see him in a whole, new, er, make that old, light. He doesn’t just pine for the days of pre-scientific treatments; he pines for the days of doctor-as-mystical-priest-figure. That, of course, is what IM advocates really mean by “patient-centered”: “my patients want me to be a shaman who can weave magic, damn it, and I really get a kick out of that ego trip myself!”
QED
…………………..
*A sampling from our 4 years of speaking truth to packaging:
Misleading Language: the Common Currency of “CAM” Characterizations Part II
Why would medical schools associate with quackery? Or, How we did it.
Tom Harkin’s War on Science (or, “meet the new boss…”)
Lies, Damned Lies, and ‘Integrative Medicine’
Integrative Obfuscation
“Integrative medicine”: A brand, not a specialty
………….
The Misleading Language and Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo series:
     1.  Misleading Language: the Common Currency of “CAM” Characterizations. Part I
     2.  Misleading Language: the Common Currency of “CAM” Characterizations Part II
     3.  The Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo #2
     4.  The Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo #3
     5.  The Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo #4
     6.  The Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo #5
     7.  The Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo #6
     8.  The Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo #7
     9.  The Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo #8
     10.  The Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo #9
     11.  Lies, Damned Lies, and ‘Integrative Medicine’
     12.  The Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo #10
     13.  Integrative Medicine: “Patient-Centered Care” is the new Medical Paternalism

Integrative Medicine Invades the U.S. Military: Part One
Jann Bellamy on July 25, 2013
Link
Integrative medicine proponents claim superiority over physicians practicing “conventional” medicine. (Which I will refer to as “medicine” so as not to buy into integrative medicine’s implied claim that medicine can be practiced with two separate standards.) While conceding that medicine is good for treating conditions like broken arms and heart attacks, physicians who purport to practice integrative medicine argue it ignores “the whole person, including all aspects of lifestyle.” Their vision of a new, improved practice of medicine “emphasizes the therapeutic relationship between practitioner and patient, is informed by evidence, and makes use of all appropriate therapies.””
But, as we know, the practice of medicine already takes into account “the whole person, including all aspects of lifestyle,” is “informed by evidence” and uses “all appropriate therapies.” This includes recommendations regarding diet, exercise, relaxation and vitamin and dietary supplement use, which are often erroneously labeled “CAM.” Medicine appears to be well aware of problems in the current model of health care delivery and is actively seeking ways to improve it. If integrative medical practitioners and their proponents were simply directing their time, energy and resources toward facilitating a better model for delivering health care I suppose no one would have any problem.
But they aren’t. They are claiming rights to an entirely new specialty in medicine. Proponents do this by advancing two dubious arguments. First, integrative medicine alone can deliver on this “whole person” model of care. Second, inclusion of alternative medicine is essential to good patient care.
From a consumer protection standpoint, I find integrative medicine troubling. Proponents are unfairly misrepresenting medical practice as inferior and offering themselves as the solution when there is no evidence that they can deliver on these claims. Unfortunately, despite this lack of evidence, integrative medicine has seized the imagination of public policy makers and legislative bodies. It is included in the Affordable Care Act and continues to metastasize throughout the military health care system, which together will soon control delivery of the vast majority of health care in this country.
In the next two weeks we will examine one unfortunate example of this process in the making. This week, we look at recent testimony of Wayne Jonas, M.D., before a Senate Committee and how it exemplifies the unconvincing arguments in favor of integrative medicine. Next week we will consider the proposed legislation Dr. Jonas supports.
Senate hearing
In May, the Senate Committee on Veterans’ Affairs, chaired by that champion of alternative medicine, Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT), heard testimony on Senate Bill 422 and 852, which would, respectively, increase veterans’ access to chiropractors in particular and to complementary and alternative medicine in general.
Apparently, no proponents of science-based medicine were invited to testify. Only an emissary from integrative medicine, Wayne Jonas, M.D., made an appearance. (His testimony begins at about 1:09 on the video. He also submitted written testimony.) Dr. Jonas is currently the President of the Samueli Institute. The Institute’s revenues for 2012 were about $13 million, approximately half of which (about $6,750,000) came from the federal government. In his testimony, he described Samueli as a nonprofit research institute “that examines the inherent healing capacity of individuals with a scientific lens in order to determine how they can be implemented into whole systems.” Dr. Jonas is past Director of the U.S. Office of Alternative Medicine, the predecessor of NCCAM. (You can read more on Dr. Jonas here.)
Dr. Jonas’s short testimony was interesting indeed. As is typical of integrative medicine proponents, he began with criticism of medicine as currently practiced. The solution?
We need a whole system, whole person approach to dealing with these things the way people experience them, not a divided disintegrated system. Thus, we need practices that can help them reset, re-heal, tap into their inherent healing processes, and more importantly teach them the skills that they need in order to build resilience for the long run . . . We want . . . a life time of optimal healing and functioning. These practices have the potential, if they’re properly evaluated and integrated, not just simply to treat a disease, but in fact to provide that resetting.
I am sure you noted that his testimony starts off with two of the signature, but wholly unproven (in fact, wholly implausible), claims of alternative medicine: it taps into the body’s inherent healing capacity and it doesn’t just treat the disease, but the whole person.
Dr. Jonas then referred to three studies which I presume he feels support his notion that the practice of integrative medicine is superior and that this superiority stems, in part, from the inclusion of alternative treatments. We will first look at what Dr. Jonas said about each study and then take a look at the actual studies.
Study 1: chiropractic
Jonas’ testimony:
We just published actually – one of our funders that we publish – the first randomized control trial published in Spine of low back pain with chiropractic, demonstrating that chiropractic added on to usual care significantly improved chiropractic in active duty populations who have carried big loads for many years.
(As an attorney, I’ve winced many times at transcriptions of depositions I took or hearings in which I participated. Verbal stumbles are easy to make when you are speaking, even from prepared notes, so I am not going to be snarky about the occasional stumbles here. I think it is clear what he meant.)
The study: Adding chiropractic manipulative therapy to standard medical care for patients with acute low back pain: results of a pragmatic randomized comparative effectiveness study.
This study was headed by Christine Goertz, D.C., Ph.D., of the Palmer Center for Chiropractic Research. According to the journal article in Spine announcing its results, “Samueli Institute grant funds were received to support this work.” No other funding source is listed, but according to the Palmer chiropractic school website, Samueli funded the study out of a grant from the Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences. The Palmer research facility has received $30 million in grants and other funds since 2000, a lot of it from the federal government. One of the research center’s three areas of study is:
mechanisms of care, which encompass normative data, spine lesions (e.g. vertebral subluxation complex) and spinal manipulation/adjustment.
Putting 2 and 2 together, it appears U.S. taxpayers are funding research into the “vertebral subluxation complex” and the “adjustment” of subluxations. As a taxpayer, I would be interested in knowing how they conduct research on something that doesn’t exist.
This was a prospective, 2-arm randomized controlled trial pilot study comparing Standard Medical Care (SMC) plus Chiropractic Manipulative Therapy (CMT). Participants were U.S. Active Duty Military Personnel. Median duration of participant current low back pain was 9 days and 43% had radicular signs. The primary outcome measures were changes in back-rated pain on a numerical rating scale and physical functioning at 4 weeks on a disability rating scale. There was no blinding of participants or practitioners. At the end, results from 32 SMC only and 41 SMC plus CMT patients were analyzed. According to the article, “participants had a higher expectation of helpfulness for SMC plus CMT compared to SMC.”
Now, to the interventions. The study didn’t restrict access to SMC or prescribe a SMC delivery protocol. Here is what actually occurred:
Standard care included any or all of the following: a focused history, diagnostic imaging as indicated, education about self-management including maintaining activity levels as tolerated, pharmacological management with the use of analgesics and anti-inflammatory agents, and physical therapy and modalities such as heat/ice and referral to a pain clinic.
In both groups, SMC was delivered by physician assistants, family practice physicians, physical therapists or aides, nurse practitioners, physical medicine practice physicians, athletic trainers and chiropractors. Yes, according to the study, chiropractors constituted 3% of the providers in the SMC group. Go figure. The mean number of visits for SMC was 1.4, although the majority had only 1 visit (range 0-8), in the SMC group and 1(range 0-4) in the SMC plus CMT group.
In the SMC plus CMT group, CMT included high velocity low amplitude spinal manipulation delivered to the lumbar spine or sacroiliac joint for all participants. In addition,
patients may have received 1 or more of the following services provided by the DC: mobilization, brief massage, use of ice in the lumbar area, stretching exercises, McKenzie exercise, advice for activities of daily living, postural/ergonomic advice. The median number of visits to the DC was 7 visits for CMT (range 2-8).
I e-mailed Cristine Goertz, D.C., the lead author, asking her to explain why the manipulation is described as “chiropractic,” and whether there was some way this manipulation was different than that performed by other providers. I also asked how the determination was made to manipulate at a particular location and whether that it involved the detection of a “subluxation.” Finally, I asked why visits for SMC were reported as a mean and visits for CMT were reported as a median number. I received an auto-reply that she is out of the office until early August so I will have to update this when and if she replies.
The authors’ conclusion:
The results of this trial suggest that CMT in conjunction with SMC offers a significant advantage for decreasing pain and improving physical function when compared with only standard care, for men and women between 18 and 35 years of age with acute LBP.
Well of course it did! If you want to do a study guaranteeing your results will show an added intervention will work better than standard care, make sure the group getting the additional intervention already expects it will work, give them eight times more treatments for back pain than the other group, give both groups a non-standardized mixture of (by my count) 18 different treatments so you don’t know what really worked and what didn’t, further confuse the issue by giving a few of the same treatments to both standardized care and the additional intervention groups, and don’t blind the participants or the providers.
But that is just a layperson’s view.
Here’s something I’ll bet you’ve already predicted. The last sentence of the article:
It is clear that additional high quality randomized controlled trials are required to establish the appropriate role definitively for CMT in diverse populations within pragmatic health care settings.
Fortunately for the Palmer Research Center and the Samueli Institute, such a study is already underway. They and the RAND Corporation received a $7.4 million, four-year grant from the Department of Defense last year to conduct a similar multi-site clinical trial, this time with a sample size of 750 active-duty military personnel.
Study 2: acupuncture
Jonas’ testimony:
We just completed a study at Walter Reed [National Military Medical Center], with – in partnership with Walter Reed – looking at the use of acupuncture for post-traumatic stress syndrome. One month of eight treatments of acupuncture reduced post-traumatic stress syndrome by 56 percent, and improved all the other symptoms of the trauma spectrum, including pain, improved sleep, reduced medication, and even, to my surprise, improved cognitive function.
Dr. Jonas also claimed that “they continued to maintain improvement” in follow-up.
The study: Acupuncture for Treatment of Post-Traumatic Stress among Military Personnel.
A 56% reduction in the syndrome itself plus improved cognitive function goes far beyond what the current research would have predicted. As Carl Sagan wisely advised, the prudent person would require extraordinary evidence for this extraordinary claim.
From his description, I had trouble finding the study at clinicaltrials.gov or published results so I sent an e-mail to the Samueli communications department asking them to “please identify the study . . . and tell me where I could find more information about the study, including the clinical trial number, methodology and results.” I got a very cordial and quick response telling me that it is NCT00320138. According to clinicaltrails.gov, the treatment is “Acupuncture, using Chinese Medicine methodology,” consisting of 4 weeks of 2 treatments per week, 4 being “standardized” and 4 being “individualized.” These terms are not further defined. There are 55 participants, one group randomized to acupuncture and the other to “no intervention/ wait list /usual care.”
If you were hoping I would describe the results, you’ll have to wait. According to the e-mail from Samueli,
The study in question is under review and has not yet been published. Dr. Jonas is not the lead author.
The study’s completion date is listed on clinicaltrials.gov as 2007, so I am not sure why there are no results available in 2013. Nor do I know why, if the study is still “under review,” Dr. Jonas was able to announce the apparently unqualified results in his testimony. Again, stay tuned. I’ll be checking back on this one.
Study 3: guided imagery and healing touch
Jonas’ testimony:
And the study published about four or five months ago that we did in conjunction with Scripps at – and the Camp Pendleton Marines and post-traumatic stress syndrome, took a very simple relaxation self-care practice taught by nurses to induce a relaxation skills training program in individuals with post-traumatic stress syndrome, added on to usual behavioral care, significantly reduced posttraumatic stress syndrome.
When that was then followed up, as was the acupuncture, when after those were finished, three months later they continued to maintain improvement. In other words, it wasn’t a one-off treatment, it was actually a reset, a rehealing of those practices.
The study: Healing Touch with Guided Imagery for PTSD in Returning Active Duty Military: A Randomized Controlled Trial.
This study offers another excellent example of what Harriet Hall has aptly named “tooth-fairy science.” The researchers go through all kinds of standard research mechanisms and statistical analyses: excluding pregnant women and nursing mothers, using a CONSORT flow diagram, determining sample size using a power analysis, measuring results with reliable scales, calculating p-values, and so forth.
The alternative practices this time consist of listening to guided imagery tapes plus healing touch, two sessions per week for 3 weeks, with 102 participants, who were experiencing “one or more” post-traumatic stress disorder symptoms. The healing touch was delivered by nurses, who played the guided imagery tapes during the sessions, a decision “based on consultations with expert practitioners.” Participants were encouraged to listen to the tapes at home, although the researchers don’t know if they did. Obviously, there was no blinding of participants or practitioners. It was done under the auspices of the Scripps Center for Integrative Medicine with Erminia M. Guarneri, M.D. taking the lead there. The Samueli Institute participated as well. Study results were published in Military Medicine.
According to the article, the group receiving treatment as usual with these two CAM interventions had “substantial reductions in PTSD symptoms.” We won’t spend much time on “guided imagery,” a definition of which is provided on the website of Belleruth Naparstak, a psychotherapist and proponent of guided imagery who has apparently managed to convince a lot of folks to buy into her enthusiasm for guided imagery and to buy her guided imagery tapes.
Guided Imagery is a kind of deliberate, directed daydreaming that uses soothing music and narrative to evoke multisensory memory, symbol and fantasy. This combination gently guides the overactive mind into a relaxed, immersive state of healing reverie.
A small number of studies have looked at guided imagery for various health conditions but they were generally of poor quality and there isn’t any good evidence of its effectiveness.
For “healing touch,” which is apparently the same thing as therapeutic touch, the evidence is clear cut: it shouldn’t work and it doesn’t. Which leads me to wonder how researchers continue to slip this one by the IRBs. Here’s how the article defined healing touch:
a type of biofield therapy that involves gentle, non-invasive touch by trained practitioners, who utilize specific techniques with the intention of working with the body’s vital energy system to stimulate a healing response.
Never mind that the body doesn’t have a “vital energy system.” But wait, it gets worse. There are specific types of healing touch. In this study three were used:
Chakra Connection . . . involving techniques used along the body, intended to stimulate movement of vital energy though the body.
Mind clearing . . . techniques performed on the head, intended to stimulate mental relaxation.
Chakra Spread . . . an advanced technique . . . generally reserved for patients with more severe symptoms, intended to promote deep healing for emotional and/or physical pain.
Chakras are, for the uninitiated, “energy centers” in the body that, when blocked, cause illness. Unblocking whatever is blocking the free flow of energy restores balance and health. Just like acupuncture, subluxation-based chiropractic, reflexology, cranial sacral therapy, reiki and Ayurveda. (It is odd that so much of alternative medicine, which can be so . . . um . . . creative in its approaches, still manages to end up at the same place.)
And despite Dr. Jonas’s claim that results were maintained at follow up, the journal article states that, while follow-up assessment was originally planned, it was not possible due to unavailability of participants because of their deployment.
In addition to Dr. Jonas’s testimony, hype also flowed from Scripps. From the Scripps website, which describes healing touch as “an energy-based, non-invasive treatment that restores and balances the human biofield to help decrease pain and promote healing”:
Healing touch combined with guided imagery (HT+GI) provides significant clinical reductions in post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptoms for combat-exposed active duty military, according to a study released in the September issue of Military Medicine. . . . “Scores for PTSD symptoms decreased substantially, about 14 points and below the clinical cutoffs for PTSD,” said Dr. Guarneri. “This indicates that the intervention was not just statistically significant, but actually decreased symptoms below the threshold for PTSD diagnosis. It made a large difference in reducing PTSD symptoms.”
I’ll leave it to the experts to evaluate the results from a statistical standpoint. Here’s the layperson’s view of this study: Relaxation tapes may have some as-yet-undetermined value in treating PTSD. Healing touch does not, and this study doesn’t prove that it does. There is no “energy system” to “stimulate” or “human biofield” to “restore and balance.” You can’t measure something that doesn’t exist.
And, yes, you guessed it:
Future studies examining the impact of this intervention as a complementary treatment to help eliminate PTSD and depression in our military are warranted.
Maybe it’s just me, but are you starting to notice that research outfits which get a lot of money for studying alternative medicine keep pushing for more studies of alternative medicine? And, as a taxpayer, are you concerned, like I am, that you are paying for these studies?
Given the opportunity to present, without any opposition, the most recent, most compelling evidence in support of integrating alternative medicine into the Veterans’ Administration health care system, this is the best integrative medicine can do? I’m underwhelmed. I hope the Senate is too.
Next week: Two bad bills.

Integrative Medicine Invades the U.S. Military: Part Two
Jann Bellamy on August 1, 2013
Link
An unfortunate side effect (if you will) of states licensing of “CAM” practitioners is their ensuing insinuation of themselves into the nooks and crannies of the American health care system. Sometimes this is voluntary, such as their inclusion as providers of health care services in medical practices and other institutional settings in the form of integrative and quackademic medicine. Where voluntary action is not forthcoming, CAM practitioners and integrative medicine proponents are not shy about petitioning the state legislatures and Congress to wave the wand of legislative alchemy. “Poof!” and they appear. One example of this is the legislative mandates that their goods and services be covered by private insurance. Another is including CAM providers in publicly-funded health insurance, such as Medicare. And next year we will see the effects of the non-discrimination provisions of the Affordable Care Act begin to unfold.
Two bills currently before the U.S. Congress invoke the magic of legislative alchemy by expanding the availability of CAM to military veterans and funding CAM research at the expense of legitimate research. One deals with chiropractic, the other with CAM in general. As we saw last week, one of this country’s foremost supporters of integrative medicine, Wayne Jonas, M.D., recently testified before the Senate Committee on Veterans’ Affairs in favor of these bills. I think any fair review of his testimony would find it unpersuasive and I hope the Committee will agree.
VA chiropractors
Chiropractors have already forced their way into the Veterans Administration (VA) medical system. For our readers not familiar with the fragmented American health care system, in addition to having a combination of public and private health insurance, or, in some cases, no health insurance at all, we have an entirely separate system of medical care solely for the military that includes its own hospitals and out-patient clinics. Military veterans have had access for some time to chiropractors at a limited number of these VA hospitals and clinics. According to the American Chiropractic Association (ACA), the “military’s medical bureaucracy continues to try to impose new barriers to chiropractic care.” This meant the ACA had to get its supporters in Congress to pass several bills to speed up implementation of the 1995 law requiring the current limited chiropractic benefit. The subtext I read in all of this is that the Veterans’ Administration, or at least those in charge of medical care, was not particularly thrilled with having chiropractors working in their facilities and has dragged its feet in implementing the law.
Perhaps one reason for resistance is the fact that under the current law
chiropractic care and services available . . . shall include a variety of chiropractic care and services for neuro-musculoskeletal conditions, including subluxation complex.
VA health care providers, such as medical doctors, nurses and physical therapists, were undoubtedly aware that there is no such thing as the chiropractic subluxation or “subluxation complex,” the latter being one of the many terms chiropractors have adopted to make it appear they have refined their “theory” when the real purpose is to paper over the fact that these subluxations don’t exist.
As part of continued efforts by the ACA and the International Chiropractors Association (ICA) to expand benefits even further, Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-CT) and 7 co-sponsors (including, of course, Sen. Tom Harkin) have introduced Senate Bill 422, the “Chiropractic Care Available to All Veterans Act of 2013.” A similar bill, House Bill 921, has also been introduced.
As I learned from reading Dr. Paul Offit’s fine new book about alternative medicine, Do You Believe in Magic?, Sen. Blumenthal has a soft spot in his heart for quackery. And he doesn’t mind using taxpayer money to support crank theories. As Attorney General of Connecticut, he sued the Infectious Diseases Society of America (ISDA) and the American Academy of Neurology (AAN) for antitrust violations because both groups reached the same conclusion regarding the non-existence of Chronic Lyme disease.
According to Blumenthal, both groups’ reasoning in reaching the same conclusion “at times used strikingly similar language.” He smelled a conspiracy. In his view, the guidelines “improperly ignored or minimized consideration of alternative medical opinion and evidence regarding Chronic Lyme disease.” Apparently, Blumenthal knew so little about science he didn’t realize that when the same evidence is reviewed by two different groups it is perfectly reasonable for them to come to the same conclusion. Nor did he realize that, in reviewing evidence, it is not appropriate to consider any quack theory that comes along, no matter how ludicrous. The irony is obvious: Blumenthal was willing to accept Chronic Lyme disease despite the lack of evidence that it exists. He then turned around and sued the doctors’ groups for relying on good evidence to support their conclusion that it didn’t.
In any event, SB 422 would expand chiropractic “care and services” to all veterans’ medical centers by the end of 2016. The bill would also add chiropractic to rehabilitative services for veterans, which already include
such professional, counseling, and guidance services and treatment programs as are necessary to restore, to the maximum extent possible, the physical, mental, and psychological functioning of an ill or disable person.
Of course, any physical rehab services veterans need are now being provided by physical and other therapists, so this is completely duplicative of what is already available. As the American Physical Therapy Association’s (APTA) website says:
More than 1,000 physical therapists are employed by the Veterans’ Health Administration providing rehabilitation services to our nation’s veteran population. The need for physical therapist services is expected to increase with the aging of the veteran population and due to the complex impairments associated with the returning veterans from Iraq and Afghanistan. APTA supports measures that aim to help meet this growing need for physical therapist services.
Unfortunately, according to the APTA, “chiropractors have initiated action at . . . the Veterans Health Administration” to limit what PTs can do by seeking “to prohibit PTs from using TJM [thrust joint manipulation].”
In addition, preventative health services, which now include, among other things, periodic medical and dental exams, immunizations, and mental health services, would include “periodic and preventative chiropractic examinations and services.” Now there’s a real opportunity for mischief.
We can safely assume that these “periodic” exams must be for the purpose of providing “preventative” services, as the purpose of this section of the law is to list what preventative services are available. And we can safely assume that these exams and services address “neuro-musculoskeletal conditions, including subluxation complex” as is also specified in the law. Finally, we can also assume that the condition to be prevented is asymptomatic, because if it were causing symptoms the law already allows a veteran to see a chiropractor.
Let us posit, then, a veteran with an asymptomatic neuro-musculosketal condition going to a chiropractor for a periodic checkup. Exactly what would the chiropractor be looking for in these exams, how would he find it, and what preventative services would the chiropractor provide? After all, absent symptoms, one does not regularly see an orthopedic surgeon or neurologist or physical therapist just to have him poke around for a neuro-musculoskeletal condition.
I suspect the primary purpose of this section of the proposed law is to give chiropractors the authority to “detect” and “correct” subluxations in a patient with no symptoms. In other words, what is known as “maintenance care” or (the newer term) “wellness care.” This is a nonsensical exercise which purports to get rid of non-existent subluxations before they cause problems. Perhaps this is why the ICA is so excited about the prospect of the bill’s passage. I suspect chiropractors employed in the VA hospitals and out-patient clinics might be reluctant to try this stunt for fear of having to explain it to the medical staff. But the law also authorizes referral to chiropractors in private practice.
Or perhaps I am underestimating the chiropractors’ motive here. Maybe this is yet another attempt to refashion chiropractors into primary care physicians.
Forcing more CAM on the VA
Another bill, Senate Bill 852, has been introduced by Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) to “improve health care furnished by the [VA] by increasing access to complementary and alternative medicine.” Notice the unfounded assumption that health care will improve via increased access to CAM. The bill does have some uncontroversial provisions creating access to fitness centers for overweight veterans and a provision of “wellness care,” although the latter could simply serve as another vehicle for the entry of CAM into the system, as is the case with chiropractic “wellness care” discussed above. The bill supports further infiltration of CAM into health care for veterans in three ways.
First, “centers of innovation” will be established to figure out how to spread CAM further throughout the VA medical system. This includes such activities as training health care professionals on how to furnish CAM services, including how to make referrals to CAM providers. In one especially disturbing provision, funding research on implementing CAM services will be siphoned off from the Medical and Prosthetics Research Account. Even worse, if the research projects involve providing CAM to veterans in rural areas, funding requests receive priority status. Considering the large number of veterans returning from the Iraqi and Afghanistan wars needing prosthetics and the potential for research to improve these devices, this is absolutely unconscionable.
Second, in tandem with figuring out how to spread CAM throughout the VA, 15 centers in the VA medical system will be established “to promote the use and integration of complementary and alternative medicine services for mental health diagnosis and pain management.” For some unexplained reason, these services “shall be administered by clinicians who exclusively provide services consisting of complementary and alternative medicine.”
I can imagine the VA doctors will just love having roving bands of reiki masters, cranial sacral practitioners, reflexologists and assorted other CAM providers running around their facilities. And I wonder how these providers will be credentialed by the VA? What level of reiki training would one have to achieve to have privileges at a VA hospital?
Veterans will be able to get CAM services for mental health and pain, whether or not they are receiving “traditional” (which presumably means “conventional”) treatment. So, let’s say a veteran addicted to drugs chooses to rely solely on “auricular acupuncture”, which has zero plausibility and, not surprisingly, no good evidence of effectiveness. In the meantime, effective “traditional” treatments that could actually improve his health are eschewed. Now multiply this by the hundreds and you will have enriched auricular acupuncture providers at the expense of the taxpayer and have a lot of veterans still addicted to drugs.
Third, the bill requires a study of “barriers encountered by veterans in receiving complementary and alternative medicine from the [VA].” The study will also look at whether veterans are aware of the availability of CAM services, the “effectiveness of outreach to veterans on the availability of CAM”, and their satisfaction with CAM in primary care. Of course, none of this has anything to do with whether the treatments themselves are safe or effective.
And so it is that the attempt to infect the American health care system with implausible and unproven (or disproven) treatments continues apace. It is especially disturbing that these bills are aimed at forcing the Veterans Administration health care system to embrace CAM. It is heartbreaking to see all the young soldiers returning from two wars plagued by physical injuries and mental health issues. CAM (that is, real CAM, not plausible treatments such as exercise rebranded as CAM) will not help them one bit. And to think funds are being diverted from medical and prosthetics research is sickening.
On it goes
It appears CAM researchers have found a new cash cow in the form of the U.S. Military. Whether these bills pass or not, the NCCAM is poised to hand out money for “Non-Pharmacological Approaches for Managing Pain and Co-Morbid Conditions in U.S. Military Personnel, Veterans, and Their Families.” These “non-pharmacological, complementary, and integrative approaches” include (but are not limited to) acupuncture, and “multidisciplinary or integrated models of care” which could “include physicians, physical therapists, psychologists, or complementary therapists, etc.”
Why?
Research has suggested that some approaches hold promise for helping individuals manage chronic pain conditions and for the amelioration of symptoms but additional research is warranted.
Of course it is.

Integrative Medicine Invades the U.S. Military: Part Three
Jann Bellamy on August 8, 2013
Link
Nobody seems to know exactly how to define “integrative medicine” (“IM”) or to demonstrate what it does that is superior to the “conventional” kind. There is a lot of talk about addressing the “whole person” and not just the disease, patient-centeredness and the like, all of which are already aspects of conventional medicine. But, however defined, the central idea seems to be that if you incorporate complementary and alternative (CAM) into conventional medicine the practice of medicine will improve tremendously.
Despite not having any clear idea of what IM is, or does, the military, prestigious medical institutions, hospitals, and individuals practitioners are eager to imprint the integrative medicine brand firmly on their public images. Hence the Consortium of Academic Medical Centers for Integrative Medicine, a newly minted medical specialty in integrative medicine, societies devoted to integrative medicine practitioners, CME courses, conferences, and so on.
But – whoops! – proponents, in their overblown hype for IM, apparently didn’t give enough thought to the fact that there isn’t much of an evidence base for this loosely-defined but supposedly superior system. And – whoops again! – you can’t really research something unless you know what it is you are researching. These little oversights have brought about efforts to decide which of the competing definitions of integrative medicine should prevail and, whatever it is, whether there is any evidence of benefit for the patient.
Several journal articles over the last few years have taken a crack at these problems. Today we look at three of them, a series on the subject by Ian D. Coulter, Raheleh Khorsan, Cindy Crawford (no, not that Cindy Crawford) and An-Fu Hsiao, appearing in the Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics (2010), Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine (2011), and Integrative Medicine Insights (2013).
What is integrative medicine? Good question.
In the first article, the authors identify what they see as two issues: (1) no clear definition of what constitutes IM, and (2) no taxonomy of IM practices to guide a research agenda. In other words, this is going to be a tough one. But they wade right in and come up with two definitions competing for the top spot. The first is the “adjunctive” model:
Medicine that reemphasizes the relationship between patient and physician, and integrates the best of complementary and alternative medicine with the best of conventional medicine.
The “best” of CAM? I take it that “best” is not equated with “evidence of effectiveness” or even “biological plausibility,” because we know that, so far, neither has been convincingly demonstrated for CAM practices. Even the authors admit that evidence is not a necessary criterion for choosing, as you shall see below. Without those standards, I’m not sure how a selection of the “best” would be made.
Then there is the “collaborative” model of IM, sometimes referred to as Integrative Health Care (“IHC”), described in this quote from another researcher (emphasis mine):
1) an interdisciplinary, non-hierarchical blending of both CAM and conventional medicine that provides a seamless continuum of decision-making and patient-centered care and support; 2) employs a collaborative team approach guided by consensus building, mutual respect, and a shared vision of health care that permits each practitioner and the patient to contribute their particular knowledge and skills within the context of a shared, synergistically charged plan of care; 3) seeks, through a partnership of patient and practitioners to treat the whole person, to assist the innate healing properties of each person, and to promote health and wellness as well as the prevention of disease; and 4) results in more effective and cost-effective care by synergistically combining therapies and services in a manner that exceeds the collective effect of the individual practice.
In other words, the medical doctor is just one person on the team, with no more say-so than the acupuncturist, chiropractor, naturopath, or homeopath. Or the reiki, therapeutic touch, cranial sacral, reflexology, or crystal therapy practitioner. Or, presumably, practitioners of whatever assorted treatments or diagnostic methods that could be (and will be) invented in the future.
It is interesting to note that nothing in the collaborative model actually requires the services of a CAM practitioner. For example, if we accept that a “synergistically charged plan of care” has any meaning in the first place, there is no reason to think it couldn’t be achieved through a combination of “conventional” health care practitioners, such as medical doctors, physical therapists, nutritionists, trainers, nurses and psychologists, all employing a “shared vision of care” that consists of biologically plausible and evidence based diagnostic methods and treatments. So why the insistence on the “blending of CAM and conventional methods?”
As to the second issue, the taxonomy of practices, the authors decide that there isn’t any. For one thing, there is no agreement on:
what practices are permitted. This ranges from those who only include evidence-based practices to those who include either practices that “have stood the test of time” or those practices in most demand by the public.
Putting aside the issue of what IM practitioners might think is evidence-based CAM, the authors are refreshingly honest in explicitly admitting that IM can be based on something other than actual evidence. It is fortunate that conventional medicine did not employ this same standard. Otherwise doctors would still be bleeding patients and laudanum would be an over-the-counter remedy.
After coming down firmly on the side of the collaborative model, the authors then set out to see exactly what is out there, evidence-wise. As it turns out, pretty much nothing. A lot of discussion about how to construct an IM practice but little in the way of demonstrating that any patient will actually benefit from it. Most articles focused on describing practice models and conceptual/philosophical models, whereas there are fewer randomized controlled trials and observation studies. As the authors note, this lack of consensus on a clear definition and taxonomy for integrative medicine represents a major methodological barrier on conducting systematic literature review and meta-analyses.
And the evidence supporting integrative medicine? Not there.
Even with these obstacles, Coulter et al. soldier on to see what might be useful in this morass of uncertainties. Which brings us to the second article. The authors reiterate their conclusion that the collaborative model is the only way to go and that the mere inclusion of CAM in conventional medicine practice isn’t really integrative medicine at all. In fact, they say the adjunctive model might actually be a bad idea because integration “without a unifying paradigm or joint management” risks adverse interactions between the CAM and conventional treatment. In other words, medical doctors cannot be trusted to recommend CAM treatments to their patients.
So they set out to review and summarize the randomized controlled trials (RCTs), controlled clinical trials (CCTs), and systematic reviews on the collaborative brand of integrative health care (through mid-2009) and to make recommendations for future research.
I am not competent to comment on the design of their search or its results. But several things are noteworthy. First, although their search methods yielded almost 12,000 citations, only 6 studies fit their search criteria. None of the studies demonstrated cause and effect, only correlation. All used a combination of CAM compared to usual care, therefore none could correlate a positive result with any particular intervention. (Which makes me wonder – are researchers to try a never-ending combination of CAM and conventional treatments until they hit on those that “work?”) All included some treatments appropriated from conventional care and rebranded as CAM, including relaxation, health education and coaching, and stress management. One included “off-site prayer,” also branded as CAM. Most outcomes were measurements of highly subjective results (e.g, mood). Even then, the results were less than impressive. The authors themselves noted the lack of credible controls for the placebo effect, lack of long-term benefit assessment, and insufficient sample size.
The authors then discuss (again) how researchers don’t really know what IM is or how to measure its effectiveness (if any) or what outcomes they should measure to determine effectiveness. There is a lot of what Steve Novella calls “special pleading,” the argument that less exacting standards of research must be applied to CAM and IM:
the claimed inherent holistic nature of Integrative Health Care in which the social, psychological, spiritual, physical, and behavioral components oriented towards support and the stimulation of healing and the achievement of wholeness (i.e., the whole system) present special challenges with respect to design of clinical studies and especially with respect to the calculation of a total effect size.
And (quoting another author):
the lack for trial [sic; of trials?] might also reflect that controlled trials may be an inappropriate research model here and that what are required are methods for whole systems research. “Thus, unlike biomedical research that typically examines parts of health care and parts of the individual, one at a time, but not the complete system, integrative outcomes research advocates the study of the whole. The whole system includes the patient-provider relationship, multiple conventional and CAM treatments, and the philosophical context of care as the intervention. The systemic outcomes encompass the simultaneous, interactive changes within the whole person.”
The conclusion?
There is still insufficient evidence from trials to strongly support the higher efficacy of integrative medicine regimen compared with usual care.
Strongly support? That is quite an understatement. It seems more accurate to say that there is no evidence of higher efficacy.
And, of course:
Additional high quality RCTs and CCTs are therefore needed to build a stronger evidence-based body of knowledge. This is the same recommendation that has been made for CAM.
The third article reiterates what is, and is not, true IM, and notes the difficulty the lack of an agreed-upon definition can hinder, or even mislead, the researcher. One comment of note:
They [CAM practices] may lack biomedical explanations, but as they become better researched, some physical therapy modalities, diet, and acupuncture become widely accepted, were as others (humors and radium therapy) quietly fade away. . .
Again, I’d have to disagree. It doesn’t seem that research results have any effect on acceptance. IM practitioners employ CAM no matter what the research says. In fact, the authors themselves admitted that. And diets and physical therapy aren’t “CAM.” In fact, I imagine the American Association of Physical Therapists would be alarmed to hear this. Finally, despite what the authors think, the humors are alive and well in naturopathy.
The U.S. Army to the rescue!
By now you might be wondering what all of this has to do with the U.S. Military. The answer: the research and writing for all three articles was supported by the U.S. Army Medical Research and Materiel Command under Award No. W81XWH-07-02-0076 through the Samueli Institute. And in each the authors express their appreciation to Dr. Wayne Jonas for his guidance and recommendations.
I don’t know why it is the Army’s job to sort out what is and isn’t true IM or what is or is not evidence for or against it. After all, it seems the Army has other, more pressing claims on its limited research funds, such as suicide prevention or the infectious disease research program.
This infiltration of integrative medicine into the military is further explicated in an 2012 Explore article by a different author:
the bottom line for the military is to identify safe and effective treatments that can be implemented on a widespread basis within the current military infrastructure . . . This includes modalities such as acupuncture, yoga, homeopathy, and mind-body techniques . . . This is where the Samueli Institute comes in. For the last decade, [Samueli] has been making the case, through rigorous research, for the military in integrative medicine.
Homeopathy? Rigorous research? Here’s an example. In 2001, the Department of Defense asked Samueli:
to evaluate research done by Jacques Benveniste . . . in which he asserted the ability of water to retain a “memory of substances previously dissolved in it to arbitrary dilution.”
I do wonder who gave the Department of Defense the idea that this research was warranted. Beneveniste’s claim had been thoroughly debunked several years earlier, not that there was any reason whatsoever to believe it in the first place unless you were a supporter of that “perfect quackery,” homeopathy. Not surprisingly, “the Institute’s researchers were not able to demonstrate these biological effects.” However, according to Dr. Jonas, all was not lost, because:
what was more interesting about this project was the emergence of a “social management” process for doing research in controversial areas, bringing together investigators who come in with biases on both sides of the issue. This was the first time a conflict management process was used in science to test a hypothesis.
In other words, we don’t need the scientific method to test a hypothesis in “controversial areas.” We need a “social management process” in which science is just another “bias.” Apparently, the Department of Defense is sold, because it:
has since supported the development of using balanced methodologies to bring together other disparate opinions that would otherwise not be investigated.
Let’s hope this new approach doesn’t metastasize into other areas of Department of Defense research such as, say, designing a new fighter jet. Otherwise, the Department might use this “social management process” to investigate the possibility that a perpetual motion machine could power a jet and physics would become just another “bias.”
A blank check drawn on the taxpayers’ account.
This series of three posts began with what I thought would be one post on a couple of bills before Congress promoting more CAM and more chiropractors in the VA health care system. But what I found was more disturbing.
Actual research confirmed that integrative medicine is an undefined set of practices centering on the unproven concept that the integration of unproven (or disproven) CAM into conventional medicine somehow results in a whole that both is greater than the sum of its parts and beneficial to patients. And now promoters want to go on what amounts to a taxpayer-funded wild goose chase to see if they can drum up some evidence that their claims are true. This apparently will require an endless set of randomized controlled trials and assorted other studies (and maybe some “social management process”) combining different alternative therapies with different conventional therapies. Some of these studies have already been done, with unimpressive results and without anyone ever having whittled down, from a laundry list of variables, a working model of integrative medicine everyone can agree on. And after all this expense, there is little indication IM practitioners will base their decisions on the evidence anyway. If they aren’t paying attention to the evidence now, why would they do so later?

CAM practitioners react to Andrew Weil’s proposal for a board certification for integrative medicine. It isn’t (all) pretty.
David Gorski on October 31, 2011
Link
About a month ago, I discussed a rather disturbing development, namely the initiative by Dr. Andrew Weil to set up something he was going to call the American Board of Integrative Medicine, all for the purpose of creating a system of board certification for physicians practicing “integrative medicine” (IM), or, as I prefer to call them, physicians who like to integrate pseudoscience with their science, quackery with their medicine. Harsh? Yes. Accurate? Also yes. Unfortunately, many medical centers, both academic and community, are hopping on the IM bandwagon while more and more medical schools are “integrating” pseudoscience into their curricula. While one might expect Josephine Briggs of the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) to be cozy with IM, depressingly, even current director of the National Institutes of Health, Francis Collins, seems to have fallen into the trap.
As was admitted by Dr. Weil and his colleagues, this decision to create a board certification in IM was a huge about-face in that Weil had always argued that IM should be infused into all specialties of medicine. What happened, of course, is that once again marketing won out over idealism. Dr. Weil was concerned that there were lots of physicians and practitioners out there claiming to practice “integrative” medicine, many of whom had no qualifications in the field. At this point, the wag in me can’t resist pointing out that, given that IM “integrates” pseudoscience with science and that there really are no standards, scientific or otherwise, to guide IM practitioners (mainly because so much of IM is rank pseudoscience), why would this matter? The answer, again, comes down to branding and turf protection.
All of this is why seeing the reactions to Dr. Weil’s initiative from members of the “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) and IM community is very instructive. Fortunately, John Weeks of the Integrator Blog has come through again, quoting over twenty different people, including physicians, naturopaths, chiropractors, journalists, and other IM practitioners in an article entitled, appropriately enough, Integrator Forum: 20 Voices on Weil/U. Arizona and the American Board of Integrative Medicine. Yours truly is even mentioned (disparagingly, of course).
Uncharacteristically (for me), I’ll cut to the chase and tell you the results before I show you some of the quotes (with, of course, my own translation of what the IM-speak really means). Basically, physicians practicing IM tend to love what Dr. Weil is doing. All other practitioners (chiropractors, naturopaths, etc.) hate it. Of course, that’s not a big surprise given that Weil’s plan would in essence cut out all non-physician IM practitioners from being able to call themselves “integrative physicians” or, at the very least, to relegate them to a lower, non-board-certified rung in the practice hierarchy, which, I suspect, was the point all along. Andrew Weil wants IM to be “respectable,” and to him it will only become so if the riff-raff (i.e., non-physicians) are excluded.
A typical reaction from MDs can be found from doctors like Patrick Massey, MD, PhD, the medical director for complementary and alternative medicine for the Alexian Brothers Hospital Network. (Remind me never to use an Alexian Brothers-affiliated hospital) In any case, Dr. Massey, a graduate of Dr. Weil’s IM residency, is very happy:
Certification is a topic that is long overdue.
Integrative medicine is a complex area of medicine that incorporates many aspects of traditional and nontraditional medicine: formal education is important. Considering how many people are blending medicine on their own, it is important for them to have qualified physicians to make sure they are not doing anything dangerous.
It cannot be done by primary care physicians. They are barely able to keep abreast of the recommendations for diabetes, HTN and CAD. Integrative medicine is not remotely in their sphere of expertise, nor the expertise of PAs and NPs, unless specifically trained in integrative medicine.
Again, one wonders what science-based standards exist to guide IM practitioners. I’ve asked the question before many times: When do you choose acupuncture versus, say, homeopathy? Or will MD IM practitioners finally admit that homeopathy is nothing more than pure quackery with no basis in basic or clinical science but a huge basis in prescientific magical beliefs? Or how do you know what herb you should use? Or when is chiropractic more appropriate than other therapies? They don’t know. There’s no real science behind many of the modalities that fall under the rubric of IM.
One physician, Richard “Buz” Cooper, MD, pointed out something that, quite frankly, hadn’t occurred to me but should have:
This is just one more of example of Weil’s entrepreneurial reach. It will enhance his 1,000 hour costly and profitable training program. He is pursuing it through a rump group, the American Board of PHYSICIAN Specialties [ABPS], which “certifies” a few marginal specialties (e.g., urgent care), rather than through the American Board of MEDICAL Specialties [ABMS], the recognized authority, which certifies legitimate specialties and which apparently has turned down the idea of certifying Weil’s Integrative Medicine. Tainting the emerging discipline of Integrative Medicine with ‘Weil’s Entrepreneurism’ will push it in the wrong direction and be a disservice to generations of patients.
You know, I really should have thought of this one myself when I wrote my first post on this issue. Dr. Cooper makes a devastatingly accurate point about how Dr. Weil has chosen to seek board certification for IM through a less-than-respected board, namely the American Board of Physician Specialties. It’s very obvious that the ABMS wouldn’t be interested in Dr. Weil’s plan; so he looked elsewhere. Weeks, ever the Weil apologist, criticizes Dr. Cooper for “personalizing” his commentary against Dr. Weil. While this is to some extent a legitimate point, it’s also legitimate to point out that Dr. Weil’s residency program in IM would become a whole lot more desirable, both to graduating medical students and, more importantly, to the medical schools and residency programs to which Weil franchises his program, if IM became more respected as a specialty and especially if there were a real board certification in the specialty. (The two, of course, often go together.) Moreover, there’s more to personal interest than just money. Weil is an ideologue who wants to spread his “faith” of IM to as many people as possible. Indeed, Weeks basically admits this in response to Dr. Cooper when he points out, “He is investing in something that may swell the historic importance of his work. Big egos are often associated with good things. Who isn’t seeking to have more rather than less positive impact?” And IM is lucrative, as are Weil’s many, many other business interests related to IM.
Interestingly, and perhaps not surprisingly, those most vociferously opposed to Dr. Weil’s program were all chiropractors. I say “not surprisingly” because of the history of battles between chiropractic and the American Medical Association. For example. chiropractor Lou Sportelli comments:
Look at the Medical board of this proposed group, I care not who they are, but what they know. It will take a lot of convincing to get me to believe that this is nothing more than the old medical model at work in three stages.
     1.  Condemn
     2.  Investigate
     3.  Take over
The AMA was notorious for doing this to any thing that was not allopathic. This is their modus operandi and they had been successful with it until folks got wise.
Dr. Weil and his new idea are not so novel, but are highly suspect. Sounds like a lot of hype and no substance
Chiropractor James Winterstein:
[This is] an interesting move on their part. Down deep, I fear it is more of the same – dominance at all costs – in a circumstance over which they have had little control (the interest by the public in alternative medicine). Now, they form a specialty and take it [over]. I hate to say it, but I think that is a likely probability. We have already seen them work toward usurping our ‘tools.’ I don’t like the sound of this, John.
Chiropractor and homeopath Nancy Gahles:
You KNOW [the MDs] will get the juice because they are the REAL doctors. The ones you can trust. What do they even study to make them ‘integrative’? Homeopathy? NO. Functional medicine…betcha! Little nutraceutical is now the new Big Pharma. Please tell me I am dead off base here, please!
My comment is that this looks like a duck, walks like a duck and acts like a duck: co-opting integrative healthcare, calling it integrative MEDICINE and creating a Board Specialty will identify integrative healthcare with medical doctors and they will own it, be reimbursed for it and thereby drive consumers to use them only as they will get insurance for it.
One notes that Gahles is described as someone who “has been the modern leader in pushing the field of homeopathy into the nation’s health policy dialogue” as the president of the National Center for Homeopathy. I never thought I’d be in partial agreement with a homeopath, but what Gahles says is more or less what I said in my previous post when I pointed out that Weil’s desire to infuse all medical specialties with his woo apparently can’t stand up to the cold, hard reality of how medicine really works. I’ve also pointed out that excluding the real woo, such as homeopathy, from IM is but a tiny first step in trying to make the specialty into something respectable.
Perhaps the most amusing retort from a chiropractor comes from Stephen Marini. Unfortunately, it’s not amusing because it’s a devastating criticism of Andrew Weil and the concept of board certification for IM. It’s unintentionally hilarious because…well, just read for yourself how he describes himself as “a vitalist trained in classical science and conventional medicine” who appreciates “the role of energy/information on an individual’s health and healing processes.” Also note that the link to information on Marini used by Weeks comes from an entry on that repository of all pseudoscience and conspiracy theories Whale.to and that Marini is on the board of directors for the International Chiropractic Pediatric Association (ICPA). With that background, you can truly appreciate Marini’s criticism of Dr. Weil in its proper context:
The concept of a medical specialty in integrative medicine is inherently contradictory. The paradigm of conventional medicine is reductionistic, hierarchical, & mutually exclusive to other paradigms of health and healing. So to ponder the concept of such a medical doctor would require drastic changes on a medical, anthropologic, sociologic, political levels etc…..
What is needed within a complementary system is a new species of health care provider that can appropriately triage a patient with regard to Era 1, Era 2 & Era 3 health care components.
If Era III reminds you of this, you will be forgiven. So what does Marini mean by “Era 3”? Apparently this:
    • Era I Medicine: Allopathic Therapies. Paradigm: CHEMISTRY – STRUCTURE – FUNCTION
    • ERA II Medicine: Holistic/Holoenergetic Therapies. Paradigm: ENERGY – CHEMISTRY – STRUCTURE – FUNCTION
    • ERA III Medicine: Intercessory Therapies. Paradigm: UNIFIED – ENERGY – CHEMISTRY – STRUCTURE – FUNCTION FIELDS
I say this in particular because following another link from the Whale.to entry on Marini leads to a statement that Marini provided to Jochim Shafer, who apparently wrote a book entitled The Trial of the Medical Mafia, in which Marini states bluntly that there ” is no credible scientific evidence to negate the hypothesis that vaccines cause immediate or delayed damage to the immune and nervous systems of children resulting in a rise in auto-immune and neurological disorders including asthma, learning disabilities, hyperactivity, autism, chronic fatigue syndrome, lupus, diabetes, epilepsy, multiple sclerosis, Guillain-Barre Syndrome, and other diseases.” He concludes that the “universal compulsory vaccination of all healthy children should be halted.”
You know, I think I’ll stick with Era 1 medicine, thank you very much, especially if in Era 3 medicine I have to rely in intercessory therapies and am not allowed to vaccinate children against infectious disease. After all, intercessory prayer has been shown more than once not to work, and vaccines have arguably saved more lives than all other science-based medical interventions combined. Say what you will about Andrew Weil (and we at SBM have certainly said a lot), I’ve never perceived him as being anti-vaccine. Marini clearly is.
In the five weeks or so since I wrote the first installment about Dr. Weil’s initiative to develop a board certification for IM, I’ve thought a bit about what the intent might be and what the consequences might come to be. The more I think about this, the more I think that the chiropractors and naturopaths who don’t like the plan are probably perceiving it quite correctly. It is a dagger aimed right at their hearts, and it is MDs who are holding the hilt. Dr. Weil’s denials notwithstanding, led by Dr. Weil, the pro-woo physician contingent is trying to make sure that no non-physician specialty can claim to be “integrative physicians.” It’s a big deal, too. If you don’t believe just how much it matters to non-physician CAM/IM practitioners to be able to claim the title “physician,” read this revealing article by John Weeks himself.
As I said before, this in and of itself might not be that bad a thing in that many of the practitioners being targeted base their practices on nothing more than prescientific vitalism tarted up with science-y-sounding language. Certainly acupuncturists, chiropractors, homeopaths, and, yes, naturopaths do this. Making it harder for them to practice their non-science-based placebo medicine is probably a good thing, as would be increasing the scientific rigor of what passes for “integrative medicine” now.
Unfortunately, I don’t see that happening. What I do see happening is that, like the Thing in John Carpenter’s famous 1982 movie of the same name, Weil will try to kill off the non-physician “integrative” practitioners but after doing so he will take on their appearance, just as the monster in The Thing took on the appearance of the people it killed. (Hey, it’s Halloween; I had to pick a horror movie metaphor.) In doing so, he will then permanently infect the entire body of academic medicine with the virus that is IM. At least, that is his plan. He has, after all, said as much.

Bravewell Bimbo Eruptions
Kimball Atwood on February 17, 2012
Link
This is yet another response to the recent “Integrative Medicine in America” report published by the Bravewell Collaborative. Drs. Novella and Gorski have already given that report its due, so I won’t repeat the background information. Inevitably, I’ll cover some of the same points, but I’ll also try to emphasize a few that stand out to me. Most of these have been discussed on SBM over the years, but bear repeating from time to time. Let’s begin with:
If it ducks like a quack…
Misleading language is the sine qua non of ‘integrative medicine’ (IM) and its various synonyms. The term itself is a euphemism, intended to distract the reader from first noticing the quackery that is its distinguishing characteristic. As previously explained, Bravewell darlings Andrew Weil and Ralph Snyderman, quack pitchmen extraordinaires, recognized nearly 10 years ago that if you really want to sell the product, you should dress it up in ways that appeal to a broad market.
Let’s see how this is done in the latest report. Here is the very first sentence:
The impetus for developing and implementing integrative medicine strategies is rooted in the desire to improve patient care.
Who would disagree with improving patient care? (Try not to notice the begged question). Here’s the next paragraph (emphasis added):
The Bravewell Collaborative, a philanthropic organization that works to improve healthcare, defines integrative medicine as “an approach to care that puts the patient at the center and addresses the full range of physical, emotional, mental, social, spiritual, and environmental influences that affect a person’s health. Employing a personalized strategy that considers the patient’s unique conditions, needs, and circumstances, it uses the most appropriate interventions from an array of scientific disciplines to heal illness and disease and help people regain and maintain optimum health.”
Who would dare to disagree with those points? Other than biting off more than it can chew (see below), the definition applies to modern medicine, which tries to be patient-centered, holistic (in the honest sense of the term), “personalized,” scientific, etc. You have to be pretty savvy to recognize the misleading hype in that paragraph:
    • “The Bravewell Collaborative…works to improve healthcare.” That would require that highly implausible medical claims—the only things that distinguish IM from real medicine—actually do what their proponents claim. They don’t, as we at SBM have been explaining for years.
    • “…puts the patient at the center.” That implies “patient-centered care,” which requires that practitioners provide honest, comprehensive information about the methods in question. IM practitioners are universally dishonest about such matters. They have to be, because otherwise they’d have to tell patients the truth: that the methods are worthless. In a subsequent post I’ll provide examples pertinent to this report.
    • “…an array of scientific disciplines.” This is standard quackspeak for “an array of pseudoscientific disciplines.” Here’s an example from that Mother of All IM centers, Andrew Weil’s Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine:
[Iris Bell, MD, PhD] is a clinical researcher with an emphasis on systems theory as a conceptual framework and the use of psychophysiological methodologies (EEG, cardiovascular) to study the linear and nonlinear effects of homeopathic remedies and low level environmental chemicals.
    • “…to heal illness and disease.” The standard muddling of everything that might bother anyone, whether medical or not, other than being strapped for cash. This effortlessly leads to offering anything that might make someone feel better, whether medical or not, other than money. See how easy IM is?
    • “…maintain optimum health.” Another standard IM gambit: its special and specious claim to preventive medicine.
Making promises they can’t keep
A recurrent theme is that IM can do, well, everything. We saw evidence of that above:
…an approach to care that puts the patient at the center and addresses the full range of physical, emotional, mental, social, spiritual, and environmental influences that affect a person’s health.
In the very next paragraph, the Bravewell Report makes it explicit (emphasis added):
…very little information had been collected regarding the actual practice of integrative medicine, which by definition treats the whole person.
It may not immediately occur to many readers, in this Era of Hype, but such a claim is ridiculous. Philosophers Clark Glymour and Douglas Stalker recognized this nearly 30 years ago in their essay about ‘holistic medicine,’ previously discussed on SBM here and here:
Another doctrine said to be holistic is that one’s state of health is affected by everything. Whatever this means, it has nothing to do with any possible practice of medicine, for no one can attend to everything. If physicians cannot distinguish relevant from irrelevant factors, important from unimportant causes, then they can do nothing.
Glymour and Stalker’s next few sentences, by the way, were these:
A variation of this doctrine is not vacuous but merely vapid: ‘Fundamental to holistic medicine is the recognition that each state of health and disease requires a consideration of all contributing factors: psychological, psychosocial, environmental, and spiritual.’ [Pelletier 1979] This is not a new revelation about medicine. Insofar as such multiple factors are known and believed to be important, they are routinely addressed in conventional medicine practice.
It would seem not to be a new revelation about ‘integrative medicine,’ either; just a repackaging of the same old stuff by a different label. Even the authors are the same.
An established part of healthcare?
From the Bravewell report’s conclusion:
The strong affiliations to hospitals, healthcare systems, and medical and nursing schools as well as the centers’ collaborative work with and growing referrals from their own health systems reveal that integrative medicine is now an established part of healthcare in the United States.
Being “an established part of healthcare” is not the same as being accepted as valid in any important medical sense. I suppose one would be technically correct to write, “chiropractic is now an established part of healthcare,” but that would ignore the only interesting question about chiropractic.
There is no question that some of the centers looked at in this report are affiliated with hospitals and healthcare systems. Some that claim to be so affiliated are not, however. The Marino Center for Integrative Health in Cambridge and Wellesley, Massachusetts, is identified in the report as having a “hospital affiliation” with the Newton-Wellesley Hospital, which is where I work. In fact, some but not all of the Marino Center physicians have been granted staff privileges at my hospital—a mistake, in my opinion—but there is no institutional affiliation whatsoever. In two weeks I’ll look at the Marino Center in some detail.
More from the Bravewell conclusions:
…high levels of concordance of interventions for specific conditions suggests that integrative medicine practice is informed by a common knowledge base.
The naive reader might assume that a “common knowledge base” suggests something about medical validity. It does not. It suggests something about faddism.
The data from the survey reveals that integrative medicine centers embrace a group of core values that inform and radiate through their practice and interactions with their patients.
Ah, ’embrace,’ ‘inform and radiate’: you don’t need a baloney detection kit to notice that such metaphors inform and radiate through quack treatises everywhere.
Ultimately, Bravewell quacks
Here’s the final paragraph of the conclusion in the Executive Summary:
One of the most striking, though perhaps predictable, conclusions of this study is that integrative medicine is, in fact, integrative. It integrates conventional care with nonconventional or non-Western therapies; ancient healing wisdom with modern science; and the whole person — mind, body, and spirit in the context of community.
Don’t you just love how spin doctors occasionally slip, and admit to what you knew was the case all along? I’ve been referring to what Bravewell calls “nonconventional or non-Western therapies; ancient healing wisdom” by the useful and accurate shorthand, “quackery.” For a somewhat broader treatment, let’s go to Glymour and Stalker:
The therapies described and recommended in a typical book of the genre include biofeedback, hypnosis, psychic healing, chiropractic, tai chi, iridology, homeopathy, acupuncture, clairvoyant diagnosis, human auras, and Rolfing. One of the larger books of this kind was even subsidized by the National Institute of Mental Health.What ties together the diverse practices…? In part, a banal rhetoric about the physician as consoler… In part, familiar and rather useless admonitions about not overlooking the abundance of circumstances that may contribute to one condition or another. Such banalities are often true and no doubt sometimes ignored, with disastrous consequences, but they scarcely amount to a distinctive conception of medicine. Holist therapies can be divided into those that are adaptations of traditional medical practices in other societies—Chinese, Navajo, and so forth—and those that were invented, so to speak, the week before last by some relatively successful crank.Insofar as it extends beyond banality, the holistic medical movement constitutes both a deliberate attempt to substitute a magical for an engineering conception of the physician and an attack on scientific understanding and reasoning. Although the holistic movement does not contain a conception of medicine distinct from those we have discussed, it does contain a reactionary impetus to return the practice of medicine to the practice of magic and to replace logic and method with occultism and obfuscation.
“Welfare for the rich”
The two philosophers warned of what Bravewell calls “integrative medicine” becoming “an established part of healthcare”:
If holistic-health advocates were content with encouraging sensible preventive medicine or with criticizing the economic organization of American medicine, we might be enthusiastic, but they are not. If the movement were without influence on American life, we would be indifferent, but it is not. Holistic medicine is a pablum of common sense and nonsense offered by cranks and quacks and failed pedants who share an attachment to magic and an animosity toward reason. Too many people seem willing to swallow the rhetoric—even too many medical doctors—and the results will not be benign. At times, physicians may find themselves in sympathy with the holistic movement, because some fragment of the rhetoric rings true, because of certain practices and attitudes they encounter in their daily work with colleagues and patients, or because of dissatisfaction with the economic and social organization of medicine. One hopes they will speak bluntly, but it does no good to join forces with cranks and quacks, magicians and madmen.
    • Bravewell is what can happen when ditzy rich people who know little about medicine or science get it into their heads that they know something—some crucial secret or secrets, little known to most in medicine except for a few cranks who themselves have found the secret to easy money. That would be maddening enough, although we must expect it as part of living in a free, democratic society. What we shouldn’t have to accept is that those rich people haven’t been using their own money. They’ve been using ours.

Bravewell Puts Integrative Cart Before Science Horse
Steven Novella on February 15, 2012
Link
The Bravewell Collabortive is a private organization whose stated mission is to, “accelerate the adoption of integrative medicine within the health care system.” They are well-funded, and they have successfully used their money to advance their mission. They also now appear to be an effective propaganda machine, producing what they are calling a “landmark report” on the use of integrative medicine in the US. The report is indeed revealing, but perhaps not in the way Bravewell intends.
The report is simply a survey of 29 integrative centers in the US. Before presenting the major findings the report defines “integrative medicine:”
“an approach to care that puts the patient at the center and addresses the full range of physical, emotional, mental, social, spiritual, and environmental influences that affect a person’s health. Employing a personalized strategy that considers the patient’s unique conditions, needs, and circumstances, it uses the most appropriate interventions from an array of scientific disciplines to heal illness and disease and help people regain and maintain optimum health.”
This is the standard marketing propaganda, which we have dissected many times before (so one more time won’t hurt). It is important to note that this is not a legitimate philosophy or approach to medicine, but pure marketing hype with the purpose of rebranding medical pseudoscience and quackery. There is a growing list of terms used for this rebranding – first “alternative” or “holistic” then “complementary” now “integrative”, “personalized”, and “patient-centered.” It’s the same nonsense, only the labels have evolved (market-tested, if you will).
The report first equates integrative medicine with patient-centered medicine. This is a false dichotomy based upon a straw-man vision of science-based medicine. Medical ethics places the patient at the center of health care and all health care decisions. The physician is ethically obligated to be an advocate of their patient first and foremost. Further, the modern (meaning in the last half-century) model of medicine is to treat the patient as a partner in their own health care (replacing the older paternalistic model). This was a process, of course, not a sudden change.
As part of that process, and the cultural evolution of the physician-patient relationship, the term “patient-centered care” was used within the medical literature to describe this change – centering decision-making more on the patient. It was a shaking off of the last vestiges of paternalism in medicine (at least within the standard of practice, if not ideally achieved by all practitioners). The integrative movement then co-opted this term and made it their own, as if they invented it, and then ironically accused mainstream medicine (who invented the idea and the term) of not being patient-centered. You will see this pattern repeated.
The next bit of propaganda is the description of holistic care (without using the term – I guess it’s not market-testing as well these days). This too is a fiction. In the 1980s I was taught in medical school about the biopsychosocial model of medicine – taking into account not just the biological illness but the social and cultural factors in which it is embedded, and the patient’s psychological response to their illness and the patient-physician relationship. This has been part of my training and practice from my first day in medical school. So I have always found it frustratingly odd that the integrative movement has (successfully, unfortunately) claimed that they invented this notion and that mainstream medicine is not “holistic”. We have argued on SBM (persuasively, I think) that science-based medicine is much more holistic than most “integrative” medical practices. We actually consider the patient’s biology, psychology, and social situation, whereas most alternative treatments are based upon a very narrow philosophy of all disease. They are the antithesis of holistic.
The tricky item of the integrative holistic list is “spiritual.” Mainstream medicine does consider the beliefs of the patient, and often must accommodate them in deciding on appropriate treatments. However – medical ethics dictates that we do not impose any religious belief onto our patients, neither are we judgmental. To our patients we are neutral on matters of faith, but can certainly be supportive of our patient’s use of faith as a support structure for dealing with their illness. In alternative medicine circles, however, “spiritual” can mean “faith healing” or its equivalent – actually treating the patient’s spirit or “energy”. This is not medicine – this is spiritualism and religion.
Next they throw in the “personalized” marketing term. Again, this is not a concept that is new to the integrative medicine movement. Regular science-based medicine is “individualized” (the term for what Bravewell and others now call “personalized”). The reason we take an elaborate history and perform a physical exam, followed by specific laboratory tests, is to individualize the diagnosis and treatment of each patient. There has been, in fact, a continuous evidence-based effort to more and more individualize treatments for patients, according to their age, sex, and genetic background. I often individualize treatment strategies to a patient’s educational level and socioeconomic status. This is just another false-dichotomy, another rebranding of ordinary medicine as a special feature of “integrative” medicine. It is just more marketing fiction and propaganda.
Next we get to the core fiction of integrative medicine, that it “uses the most appropriate interventions from an array of scientific disciplines.” That, of course, is a description of mainstream medicine. We use any intervention that is science-based – that has an appropriate combination of plausibility and direct evidence for safety and efficacy. Integrative medicine, rather, is the mixing of appropriate science-based interventions with treatments that are not science-based, that are highly implausible, or have been shown to not work. Otherwise they would already be part of medicine.
So what is integrative medicine? When you strip away the rebranding and co-opting of features and treatments of mainstream medicine, you are left with the usual list of pseudoscientific practices that have been trying to insert themselves into mainstream medicine for decades through a series of marketing and propaganda strategies. Bravewell has positioned itself at the forefront of that effort.
The body of the report I found to be almost entirely uninteresting and predictable – integrative centers are using integrative medicine and they feel (of course) that it works. Wow. The one bit I did find interesting was the list, in descending order, of the “integrative” methods these centers use:
• Food/Nutrition• Supplements• Yoga• Meditation• TCM/Acupuncture• Massage• Pharmaceutical
First we see another rebranding – calling nutrition integrative or alternative. We have pointed out numerous times on SBM that nutrition is a medical science. It is already part of mainstream medicine, and it is mainstream medical researchers who have figured out everything we currently know about the role of nutrition in health and disease. This is just one more thing that the integrative movement has tried to steal (metaphorically) from mainstream medicine to make part of its brand.
Two items on the list, supplements and TCM/acupuncture, are methods that do not work but have been the most successful in being marketed to the public. A thorough exploration of these modalities is beyond the scope of this article, but you can find numerous articles on SBM demonstrating the lack of an evidence based for the most popular herbal supplements and for acupuncture, for any indication.
Yoga, meditation, and massage are essentially exercise, stress-reduction, and relaxation – all things commonly used and recommended by science-based practitioners. There is no evidence to support the notion that there is anything special about these particular manifestations of exercise, stress reduction, and relaxation. Most studies of Yoga, for example, have no comparison group to other forms of stretching and exercise. The implication is that there is something special or magical about transcendental meditation, for example, or Tai Chi, or specific forms of massage – again without evidence. There is no evidence that charging patients for a consultation with a specialist in one of these treatments is any more effective than just telling them to get more exercise – do something convenient and enjoyable.
About the only kernel of utility in this approach is that it may foster compliance with lifestyle changes. I say “may” because evidence is lacking for this as well. And again – there are already voices within mainstream medicine teaching a greater emphasis on patient education to foster compliance with lifestyle changes. Doctors are admittedly not very effective in changing patient behaviors, but that is because nothing is. It is very difficult to change behavior, and “integrative” practitioners have not hit upon any magical way to do so. They simply point out how bad mainstream medicine is, without acknowledging the fact that every studied method of changing lifestyle behaviors has a poor success rate. Even those that tout their success are just incrementally better than simply advising patients to quit smoking, exercise more, or lose weight.
What we need is to continue to experiment and research – to use science to figure out how to more effectively improve health behaviors in the public. Of course, if scientific research ever does develop a really effective method the integrative movement (or whatever it’s calling itself at that time) is likely to steal it and pretend that they invented it, then turn around and criticize mainstream doctors for not using it.
At the bottom of the list is pharmaceuticals. This does, perhaps, distinguish the integrative approach from some alternative approaches that are more purist in their pseudoscience. A homeopath, for example, uses only homeopathy. This appears to be a general trend with alternative practice, however. Naturopaths, for example, are fighting in many states and in Canada to get the right to prescribe actual medicine. This way they get to practice real medicine and then charge for a lot of extra stuff that is either worthless or just an expensive version of a simple healthy lifestyle. It’s quite a racket.
At the end of the report, under the category “next steps,” they write:
Providing funding for analysis of these data, which could provide important information about the efficacy of integrative medicine approaches as well as the treatment of chronic health conditions, should be a priority for funding sources and institutions.
Let me translate that for you, in the context of the whole report: Isn’t it wonderful that integrative medicine methods are being used, now let’s go see if they actually work. If there is anything that defines alternative, complementary, integrative medicine it’s putting practice before evidence. In fact, the evidence is irrelevant to practice. Practice is philosophy-based, not science-based. Evidence is an obstacle, used only for marketing purposes, not for determining which treatments are effective. That is why they keep trying to redefine scientific evidence in medicine. They need science to change to accommodate their treatments, not conform treatments to the science.
In my opinion the Bravewell Collaborative is a force for pushing pseudoscience and nonsense into mainstream medicine. This report reflects that reality.

The Bravewell Collaborative maps the state of “integrative medicine” in the U.S., or: Survey says, “Hop on the bandwagon of ‘integrative medicine’!” (2012 Edition)
David Gorski on February 15, 2012
Link

Earlier today, Steve discussed a new report hot off the presses (metaphorically speaking, given that it’s been published online) from the Bravewell Collaborative. Naturally, given the importance of the issue, I couldn’t resist jumping in myself, but before you read the blather I have to lay down, you really should read what Steve wrote about it. It’s that good. (Also, he’s our fearless leader, and I wouldn’t want him to be…unhappy about my having muscled in on his usual day to post.) Have you read it? Good. Now we can begin…
One of the most common (and potent) strategies used by promoters of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM)–or, as its proponents like to call it these days, “integrative medicine” (IM)–to convince the public and physicians either to use it (or at least to remain a shruggie about it) is in essence an argumentum ad populum; i.e., an appeal to popularity. Specifically, CAM/IM apologists like to use the variant of argumentum ad populum known as the “bandwagon effect,” in which they try to persuade patients and physicians that they should get with the CAM/IM program because, in essence, everyone else is doing it and it’s sweeping the nation in much the same way New Coke did in the 1980s. (Admittedly, CAM/IM apologists are, unfortunately, much better at sales than Coca-Cola was.) Not coincidentally, this is one type of method of persuasion much favored by Madison Avenue when selling cars, clothing, music, movies, food, beer, and nearly every other product–like Coca-Cola. I say “not coincidentally” because what CAM proponents are doing, more than anything else, is selling a lifestyle, a brand, a belief system, and, of course, many, many products whose value reminds me, more than anything else, of the aforementioned New Coke. In using this appeal to popularity, CAM/IM proponents try to portray stodgy physicians (you know, like pretty much every one of us at this blog) who insist on plausibility, science, and evidence to support the use of drugs and treatments as hopelessly behind the times, dogmatic, out of touch, and in general no fun to be around at all, particularly at parties.
Arguably no single private organization has been more effective at promoting the infiltration of CAM/IM into medical academia (or, as I like to call it, quackademic medicine) than the Bravewell Collaborative. Co-founded by Christy Mack (yes, that Christy Mack), wife of John J. Mack, the former CEO and Chairman of the Board of Morgan Stanley who now serves as a Senior Advisor, and Penny George, the Bravewell Collaborative was formed when Mack and George hit up a bunch of wealthy, woo-friendly donors to form a charitable organization in 2002 to support the “advancement of integrative medicine.” One result has been the proliferation of quackademic departments in medical centers all across North America like so much kudzu fertilized by Bravewell Collaborative money topped off with a bit from the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) lovingly applied by true believers choking off science-based medicine. Known as the Consortium of Academic Health Centers for Integrative Medicine, this group of divisions, institutes, and departments of quackademic “integrative medicine” now numbers fifty and includes some of the most famous medical schools in the nation, such as, for example, Duke, Harvard, Stanford (as much as Wally Sampson hates to admit it), Yale (as much as Steve Novella hates to admit it), and my alma mater the University of Michigan (as much as I hate to admit it).
So successful has the Bravewell Collaborative been in inserting pseudoscientific and prescientific “healing” modalities right into the heart of medical academia that it decided to update a project that it called a “nationwide mapping project” whose purpose was: (1) to describe the patient populations and diseases most commonly treated with integrative medicine, (2) to define the core practices and models of integrative care, (3) to determine how integrative care is paid for, and (4) to identify the biggest factors driving successful implementation. Christy Mack wrote in 2010 that she hoped the project would be complete by, well, the end of 2010, but apparently there were some glitches along the way, because the project was just released to the Bravewell website as a report entitled Integrative Medicine in America: How Integrative Medicine Is Being Practiced in Clinical Centers Across the United States (executive summary here). As Steve so aptly put it, it’s a massive case of putting the integrative cart before the the science horse in that it is looking at what Bravewell has wrought in terms of promoting quackademic medicine without paying attention to whether any of this stuff actually works or whether “integrating” this woo into medicine does anything whatsoever to improve the quality of care at the medical centers that have jumped on the “integrative” bandwagon.
Before getting into the meat of the report, it’s worth noting that this is not the first survey of this kind. In fact, Bravewell was beaten to the punch by another major promoter of CAM/IM, the Samueli Institute. Together with the Health Forum, the Samueli Institute published a report five months ago entitled 2010 Complementary and Alternative Medicine Survey of Hospitals, which I reviewed in depth. The difference between the Bravewell report and the Samueli report is that the Samueli report focused way more on motivations (i.e., why hospitals decided to start CAM/IM programs), means (how they started up their CAM/IM programs), and finances (how much of do these programs cost and do they make any money?) than the Bravewell report does. The two reports do, however, show considerable overlap in trying to survey the specific CAM/IM modalities offered by the hospitals surveyed that reported having CAM/IM programs. Also, the Samueli report had more breadth and less depth in that the investigators sent out a surveys to nearly 6,000 hospitals, while Bravewell focused its attention on 29 hospitals, nine of which were Bravewell Consortium members, the rest of which were not. In other words, the differences between the Samueli survey and the Bravewell survey can be summarized as looking at a broad sampling of all hospitals (or at least trying to) and taking a focused look at true believers.
Like the Samueli report, the Bravewell report begins with the same distortions of language to which we’ve become accustomed from CAM/IM apologists:
The Bravewell Collaborative, a philanthropic organization that works to improve healthcare, defines integrative medicine as “an approach to care that puts the patient at the center and addresses the full range of physical, emotional, mental, social, spiritual, and environmental influences that affect a person’s health. Employing a personalized strategy that considers the patient’s unique conditions, needs, and circumstances, it uses the most appropriate interventions from an array of scientific disciplines to heal illness and disease and help people regain and maintain optimum health.”
Over the past two decades, there has been documented growth in the number of clinical centers providing integrative medicine, the number of medical schools teaching integrative strategies, the number of researchers studying integrative interventions, and the number of patients seeking integrative care. But whether integrative medicine was being offered in the same, similar, or disparate ways was unknown. In addition, while previous studies focused on the prevalence and use of complementary or alternative medicine (CAM) by patients1, 2 or by practitioners in hospital settings3 by enumerating the use of single CAM therapies, very little information had been collected regarding the actual practice of integrative medicine, which by definition treats the whole person.
That was from the executive summary, but the same sort of language pervades the introduction to the report proper, in which the authors go on and on about how “all factors that influence health, wellness, and disease are taken into consideration,” “care addresses the whole person, including body, mind, and spirit in the context of community,” and how care is “individualized” (in reality this is fake individualization) Note the canard of “holism,” in which (or so it is claimed) CAM/IM is supposedly capable of taking care of the “whole patient” in a way that scientific medicine is not. This is, of course, utter nonsense built on a false dichotomy that says that a practitioner has to embrace pseudoscience and prescientific beliefs, such as those behind homeopathy, “energy healing,” and the like, in order to take care of the “whole patient.” It’s been a successful ploy in that quite a few physicians have apparently bought into the lie inherent in the very name “integrative medicine.” If they hadn’t, there wouldn’t be so many CAM/IM programs that have sprung up over the last ten years, to be surveyed now.
The report is fairly easy to read, and it tells us all sorts of things, including that the most common model of CAM/IM care is consultative care, with less than half of the centers surveyed offering primary care (thank heaven for small favors). We also learn tidbits about which I care almost nothing at all, such as that 72% of CAM/IM centers surveyed use electronic medical records (yawn) and, oddly enough, 72% also offer self-care and wellness programs for their practitioners and staff (double yawn). One notes that my university offers self-care and wellness programs; so this isn’t particularly impressive to me. But I’ll take science-based care over woo any day, and “wellness” is a term that’s been so thoroughly co-opted by CAM/IM that I can’t help but grimace just a little whenever I read or hear it. Then, of course, a huge number of these programs say they do research, which makes me wonder what has become of the word, or, to repeat yet again one of my favorite bit: Research. You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means. Either way, these little tidbits, while useful, were not particularly novel.
More interesting to me were the specific modalities offered in CAM/IM centers in their order of frequency:
The interventions prescribed most frequently across all conditions, in descending order, are:
    • Food/Nutrition
    • Supplements
    • Yoga
    • Meditation
    • TCM/Acupuncture
    • Massage
    • Pharmaceuticals
Notice anything? I do. Look at what the number one most frequently prescribed treatment by these CAM/IM centers. It’s nutrition or food. When I saw that, I had two questions. First, when, exactly, did nutrition or food become somehow “alternative” or “integrative”? Did I miss something somewhere? Nutrition is a science-based field (or should be), and the use of nutrition to prevent and alleviate illness is (or should be) science-based medicine. Yet, here nutrition is magically “rebranded” as somehow being part of CAM or IM! That’s what we here at SBM mean when we describe the “bait and switch” of CAM/IM. Plausible, potentially science-based treatments are reborn as CAM/IM and then used as evidence that CAM works. They’re also the Trojan horse that CAM/IM proponents use to trick the guardians of SBM into bringing into fortress of academia. After these modalities have been accepted as “CAM,” out jumps the real woo, such as “energy healing,” to take over. It’s not so far-fetched, given that my alma mater has a program in Steinerian woo known as anthroposophic medicine. I can’t wait until its botany department starts offering courses in biodynamic farming.
Snark aside, note that, out of the top seven modalities reportedly used, only one of them is truly “alternative,” namely TCM/acupuncture, while one is borderline (supplements). For the rest, the same observation I have about nutrition applies. Massage? Since when is that “alternative,” badly interpreted studies of massage notwithstanding? Pharmaceuticals? You might as well see a real doctor! Yoga? Stripped of its woo, it’s just a form of exercise. Meditation? It’s just a variant of relaxation therapy. Supplements could be woo or non-woo, depending upon how they’re used, but when naturopaths, homeopaths, and chiropractors use them they’re almost always woo. And, of course, traditional Chinese medicine and acupuncture are nearly all woo.
Particularly revealing is a section in which the survey asks for what diseases/conditions does IM produce “success.” That is, of course, a question so incredibly vague that, unless the patient dropped dead immediately upon contact with the therapy recommended, centers could claim some level of “success” with almost anything, and they do. No metrics for what constitutes “success” are described. Instead, the survey just takes the word of center directors for it. Basically, center directors were asked what conditions they considered to be conditions “among their top five most successfully treated conditions.” This generated the following, utterly useless table (click to enlarge):
Cancer was number five, with 52% of institutions claiming it to be in their top five conditions for which they have “success”? What do they mean? Certainly they don’t mean better survival, because I’d sure like to see that data if their claim is that they are successful treating cancer with CAM that way. I do have to admit that I chuckled grimly at this passage:
Cancer Treatment Centers of America (CTCA) at Midwestern Regional Medical Center in Zion, Illinois and The Integrative Medicine Center at MD Anderson Cancer Center in Houston, Texas. These two institutions only treat people with cancer. At CTCA, all treatment teams include a dietician, naturopathic doctor, mind-body therapist, chiropractor, and pain management clinician (including an acupuncturist) as well as a medical oncologist. MD Anderson’s integrative medicine center offers acupuncture, massage therapy, and mind-body-spirit practices such as meditation, guided imagery, yoga, tai chi, and music therapy. Therapies are provided to caregivers as well as patients.
Yes, Bravewell actually lumped together the Cancer Treatment Centers of America and M.D. Anderson Cancer Center. In woo, apparently, they are equals, which is far more an indictment of M.D. Anderson these days than it is praise for CTCA.
Next up, this survey touts the “personalized” care that these CAM/IM centers allegedly offer, with 93% of the centers surveyed claiming to offer “individualized care plans” for their patients. No, I’m not doubting that these centers come up with “personalized” care plans designed for each of their patient based on whatever “integration” of science-based medicine and pseudoscience takes their fancy. After all, when a Tarot card reader gives you a reading it’s personalized, as are psychic readings. What irritates me is that this CAM/IM apologists claim they are so much better at “individualizing” care than SBM, a claim that is pure nonsense. In breast cancer, I make individualized care plans for each of my patients as well. Nearly all of our breast cancer patients have multidisciplinary plans individualized to each of them involving multiple specialties (usually surgery, medical oncology, and radiation oncology, sometimes with genetic counseling as appropriate). In other words, Bravewell’s claim and that of its respondents are meaningless. The only thing that surprised me was that it wasn’t 100% of centers that claimed to offer “individualized care plans.” In fact, I’m downright amazed that two of the 29 didn’t claim to make them. It must have been the evil reductionistic “Western” scientists who forced them into offering “one-size-fits-all” treatments, just like us evil reductionistic “Western” doctors.
Finally, I found it interesting to look at where the rubber hits the road, so to speak, namely the practitioners whose salaries these centers are willing to pay (click to enlarge):
Not surprisingly, nearly all of these centers employ MDs. After all, we can bill and feed the referral machine. They also nearly all employ massage therapists and acupuncturists, both of which are what I like to view as gateway CAM, although massage can be justified easily without an appeal to pseudoscience or mysticism. What surprised me is that only 28% of them employ naturopaths, 21% employ osteopaths (maybe they’re all too busy being real doctors), and only 17% employ Ayurvedic practitioners, the last of which is no different than the number employing homeopaths. What didn’t surprise me is that some of these centers employ reflexologists and Rolfers, although I must admit that I have no idea what an “energy psychologist” is. Nor do I really want to know.
So now that we know the “what,” as in what services are offered, what are the outcomes? As it turns out, that is where this survey is unintentionally revealing. Basically, there are no medical outcomes reported. There are, however, lots of patient satisfaction surveys showing that patients like the woo being offered. Sadly, there is little or no discussion of actual efficacy and safety other than self-reported efficacy with no metrics to let us know whether or not the ideas of the center directors filling out the surveys of what constitutes efficacy had any connection with real measures of efficacy when they listed the conditions for which their centers have the most success.
All of this is very thin gruel upon which to base the conclusions of the report, such as:
The number of centers included in this study who expressed to the authors that their patient numbers were growing and/or their roles in their respective healthcare systems were expanding, suggests an increasing acceptance of integrative medicine by the American public and the medical professions.
Remember, there were only 29 centers surveyed. That’s a mighty big conclusion to rest on such a little study, particularly given that the survey used couldn’t measure acceptance of IM by the public anyway. One wonders why it took Bravewell so long to finish the study. Maybe it was the difficulty in figuring out a spin to put on it, although a blog from at least one institution surveyed in the study had no difficulty doing so.
The authors also conclude that IM really, really needs three things, the first of which is outcomes data. No kidding! On the other hand, as Steve points out, this is still putting the cart before the horse, as outcomes studies are usually indicated only after a treatment has been shown scientifically through a combination of basic science and translational research plus well-designed randomized clinical trials to be efficacious and safe. Until that evidence is there, there really aren’t any good reasons to study outcomes because there aren’t any scientifically valid reasons to be using these therapies to begin with. Oh, wait. The whole point of this survey is for Bravewell to congratulate itself on how much it’s managed to legitimize CAM/IM. Never mind. Be that as it may, if there aren’t any good reasons to be doing outcomes research, then there really aren’t any good reasons to be trying to identify best practices, which is the second recommendation of the report. After all, how does one identify best practices when there is so little scientific evidence to support the practices being examined? But don’t worry! Bravewell will definitely be doing another survey. It says it will. That is, after all, its third recommended next step.
None of this stops the authors from concluding:
One of the most striking, though perhaps predictable, conclusions of this study is that integrative medicine is, in fact, integrative. It integrates conventional care with non- conventional or non-Western therapies; ancient healing wisdom with modern science; and the whole person — mind, body, and spirit in the context of community.
The breathtaking inanity of Bravewell’s conclusion took my breath away, and all your bases are belong to us.
My conclusion is different. I conclude that “integrative medicine” integrates pseudoscience with science, quackery with medicine. Where it fails to do that, it rebrands science-based modalities like nutrition as somehow being “alternative” so that it can be listed as being CAM. On the other hand, one thing the writers of this report tell us in no uncertain terms is that, whatever you do, don’t call “integrative medicine” CAM. Just don’t do it, because Bravewell really, really hates it:
As was well articulated by Benjamin Kligler, MD, and Roberta Lee, MD, in the textbook Integrative Medicine: Principles for Practice, “Integrative medicine is not synonymous with CAM.” This survey has shown that integrative medicine centers embrace a group of core values that inform and radiate through their practice and interactions with their patients. Integrative care is, in practice, patient-centered care and is a fundamentally collaborative enterprise fostering cooperation between patients and practitioners, and among the practitioners themselves.
The problem, once again, is that it is not necessary to “integrate” pseudoscience with science-based medicine in order to practice collaborative patient-centered care. It’s really not, just as it’s not necessary to “integrate” pseudoscience into SBM in order to be “holistic” or to “take care of the whole patient.” Bravewell keeps selling that false dichotomy. I’m not buying, and neither is any member of the SBM team. Unforunately, though, a lot of doctors and medical centers are buying what Bravewell’s selling. They seem to want to view themselves as special flowers, but, no matter how much Bravewell, NCCAM, and other CAM/IM apologists try to convince patients and physicians otherwise, as our very own Harriet Hall has so frequently and eloquently said about naturopaths and CAM/IM practitioners, “What they do that is good is not special, and what they do that is special is not good.”
One of these days I’m going to have to try to come up with a statement that so succinctly and accurate describes CAM/IM, but I doubt that I will ever succeed.

Perpetual Motion: More on the Bravewell Report
Mark Crislip on February 24, 2012
Link
I’m not here to convince people that we are right, although it would be nice if it turned out that way. I’m here to tell the truth and let readers decide for themselves.”
— Kimball Atwood, Science Based Medicine, Bravewell Bimbo Eruptions
I had been too inarticulate to formulate what is essentially my approach to this blog: to tell the truth. That would appear to be simple enough. Of course it gets down to what constitutes the truth, and whether you can handle the truth.
What is truth, small ’t’? Truth with a big ’T’ is provided by belief systems that originate in a personal epiphany and you suddenly understand the meaning of life, the universe and everything. Or conjure up reiki or chiropractic. I suspect I was either born without the part of the brain that allows me to appreciate the mystical/spiritual aspects of human existence, or perhaps it was my upbringing. Probably a bit of both, although having raised two kids in the eternal nurture/nature debate has swayed me heavily towards the nature side of the fence. I bet I was born that way. But I am totally tone deaf to issues of spirituality and the surrounding issues of big ’T’ Truths, so I am going to stick to the little ’t’ truths.
Little ’t’ truths’, or as I like to call them, facts, consists of the approximate understanding of the reality provided by the scientific method. Note the word approximate. I have always liked Richard Dawkins metaphor of science as climbing a series of peaks (at least that is how I remember it, having read the book years ago). Get to the top of one peak, and it provides a vista of understanding, but there is always another peak to climb to offer an even more comprehensive view of the topic. Every year our understanding of reality is refined and extended. Understanding something as ostensibly simple as influenza vaccination gets more sophisticated and subtle every year. It is not as simple as give an antigen, develop an antibody and become immune to that strain of flu. It is the continuing increased understanding of the multiple facets of infectious diseases is in part what makes ID the most endlessly fascinating specialty in medicine.
There are still lots of unexplained phenomena in the universe, but mostly at the extremes of scale: the quantum level and the universe. At the approximation of the human scale, the scaffolding upon which we hang our understanding is quite well worked out. The basic sciences (physics, chemistry, biochemistry, anatomy, physiology, pharmacology, evolution, etc.) that inform our understanding of medicine do not leave any space for ‘new’ concepts. The existing concepts that underlie medicine do not support much of what passes for the underlying mechanisms that are the alleged basis of supplements, complementary and alternative medicine (SCAM’s). If is more to human existence, wondrous strange, I have yet to see it demonstrated.
Horatio:O day and night, but this is wondrous strange!
Hamlet:And therefore as a stranger give it welcome.There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio,Than are dreamt of in your philosophy.
If there are phenomena at the human scale that exist outside our understanding of the basic sciences, it has never been demonstrated over and above the ability for humans to convince themselves that magic exists. My philosophy seems pretty comprehensive
At some level I am not a ‘true’ skeptic, since given the current understanding for the reality, the following not only do not exist, but cannot exist. Their prior probability is zero. A true skeptic would give credence to the possibility, however small, that a counterexample could be produced to confirm the reality of some bit of pseudoscience. The following incomplete list do not and cannot be true, small ‘t’, and are fictions:
    • Telepathy
    • Astrology
    • Psychics
    • Talking to the dead (or at least the dead talking back)
    • Homeopathy
    • Chiropractic subluxations and all interventions that derive from that idea
    • Meridians and chi, and all interventions that derive from the idea
    • Energy medicine
    • Reiki
    • Therapeutic touch
    • Iridology
    • Reflexology
    • Craniosacral therapy
    • Large swaths of naturopathic training,
It reinforces the idea that science based medicine is reality based medicine. SBM is based on facts and small ’t’ truths. While SCAM’s use the tools of science, much of the underling conceptual framework is imaginary. Dr. Hall’s idea of Tooth Fairy Science conceptualizes the idea perfectly.
There is a lot of uncertainty in medicine, both diagnostically and therapeutically. What does the patient have and how best to treat it can be very complex and the often the most reliable diagnostic intervention, the autopsy, is refused by the patient. The uncertainty in medicine is still within the framework of the sciences and the difficulty in the sorting through the great variability of disease presentation and treatments requires no understanding of CSF tides, energy blockages or Laws of Similars.
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome, CFS, is perhaps a good example where medicine fails. There are still no diagnostic or therapeutic interventions that shed light on the disease or improve the quality of life for the patients. I remain reasonably convinced that a subset of CFS patients have an infectious trigger, and that someday we will have an understanding of the pathophysiology of these patients. I do not think it is ‘all in their head’, although as Takotsubo cardiomyopathy demonstrates, there is a mind-body connection, just not the mystical connections promulgated by many SCAM providers. There are no features about CFS to suggest its etiology will not eventually be amenable to understanding. As I have mentioned before, humans operate within very narrow physiologic parameters and have a limited repertoire with which to respond to the environment and CFS appears to be variations on a theme.
In medicine we have an understanding of truth, of reality, an expanding collection of facts and their interrelationship, provided by the basic sciences. At the center of medicine is applying that reality as best as is possible to ill, frightened people. The ill are vulnerable. When you are sick you often do not have the luxury to search for the best product available, like finding a TV on consumer reports. And even if you have the time, the complexity of medicine may preclude a good understanding of what the diagnosis and therapy. Hell, when I had my lipids checked, my primary said they were bad. She started to talk about LDL and HDL and ratio’s and risks and I stopped her. I didn’t care. I have better things to occupy my neurons with than lipids; I have blogs to write. What did I need to do? Lose weight. So I did. Now my lipids are fine. Just do not ask me what my numbers are or what they mean. I don’t care to learn the ins and outs of lipids; I trust my doctor.
There was a time when medicine was less standardized and reality based. At the beginning of the 20th century there were multiple competing forms of medicine and no standardization of medical education. Becoming a doctor could be as easy as hanging up you shingle, declaring that since you cured deafness with a pop of the spine, you were a doctor and a healer. Because of the hodgepodge of disparate medical practices and the lack of an organized medical education, the Carnegie Foundation financed a review of medical education in the United States. Authored by Abraham Flexner, for some unknown reason it became known as the Flexner Report, and it became the foundation for the standardization of medical education.
The Flexner Report resulted in a reorganization of medical schools and gave rise to the system of medical training in use today. Among the many changes was a clear delineation between those aspects of medicine that were science/reality based and those that were not: chiropractic, homeopathy, and naturopathy.
When Flexner researched his report, “modern” medicine faced vigorous competition from several quarters, including osteopathic medicine, chiropractic medicine, eclectic medicine, naturopathy and homeopathy. Flexner clearly doubted the scientific validity of all forms of medicine other than that based on scientific research, deeming any approach to medicine that did not advocate the use of treatments such as vaccines to prevent and cure illness as tantamount to quackery and charlatanism. Medical schools that offered training in various disciplines including eclectic medicine, physiomedicalism, naturopathy, and homeopathy, were told either to drop these courses from their curriculum or lose their accreditation and underwriting support.
The last 100 years has seen the proliferation of reality based biomedical sciences and there has been a similar proliferation of fantasy based SCAM’s that, one would think, would have no reason to be included in modern medicine. The Flexner report had put medicine firmly on the path of reality/science based medicine, which I would argue is the ethically based medicine as well. Diagnosis and therapies based upon what is, well, made up shit, should have no utility in medicine. Ill, vulnerable people should not, one would think, have their lives, their health, and their finances put at risk on the basis of fictions. This is the point in the essay where someone will mention Vioxx. Thank you. Vioxx bad. Got it. Vioxx gone. SCAMs persist. That is the important difference.
Fast forward 100 years to the Bravewell report. Many of the issues of the Bravewell report have already been discussed by Dr’s Gorski, Novella and Atwood; I might as well pile on. What is striking about the report is how many of what I would have thought of as premier medical institutions in the US have repudiated science and reality in favor of fantasy based medicine. These are what I would have thought of as top notch medical centers: UCSF, Scripps, Vanderbilt, Duke, Cleveland Clinic and MD Anderson are on the list.
As always with proponents of SCAM’s there is a spectrum from legitimate therapists and therapies to the completely wackaloon. I am going to limit myself to the 100% fantasy based wackaloon SCAMs offered by institutions who really should have known better. But that’s me. I do not think popularly and profit should trump truth and integrity. Shame, I guess, is not a concept embraced by our ‘top’ medical centers. I am using quotes; I worry that soon I will be typing in caps and using multiple exclamation marks, the sure sign on the web that the writer is unhinged.
70% of these institutions employ an acupuncturist, 62% a TCM practitioner, 38% a chiropractor, 28% a naturopath, 17% an ayurvedic practitioner, 17 % a homeopathy practitioner. Almost one in 5 think it is legitimate medical practice to offer water to treat their patients. The mind boggles. If your medical institution has so little grasp of reality that they hire homeopaths and their fellow travelers, the naturopath, time to seek care elsewhere. 38% have hired a holistic nurse, what ever that is. Probably who is doing the reiki and therapeutic touch. Other fantasy based therapists employed included energy psychologist, Feldenkrais practitioner, Qi Gong practitioner, and a reflexologist.
Of the 29 centers 15 used healing touch or reiki for cancer or chronic pain. Legitimate medical centers waving hands over patients to treat cancer. Really, there is no shame. None. Evidently they are proud of the fact; I am sure the Board of Directors is pleased. For asthma, 9 used healing touch, 4 used chiropractic, 3 used homeopathy. For cancer, 15 used reiki, 15 used healing touch, 4 used homeopathy. For diabetes, 7 used reiki, 5 healing touch, 2 homeopathy. These are real diseases with well known pathophysiologies and complications for which they offer magic.
Interestingly, for diabetes, only 24 of 29 used “food/nutrition” and 18 of 29 used “exercise/fitness” in their therapies And here I thought diet and exercise were the mainstay of diabetes treatment. Same with heart disease with 24 of 29 used “food/nutrition” and 20 of 29 used “exercise/fitness” and for obesity with 25 of 29 used “food/nutrition” and 24 of 29 used “exercise/fitness.” I wonder, rather than diet and exercise, how they treated diabetes, obesity and heart disease; the lists suggests probiotics, therapeutic touch, reiki or homeopathy.
And post operative care? 3 of 29 used endurance training or Pilates. Doesn’t seem, off hand, to be the best time for endurance training. They are probably not getting the patient ready for an iron man after their hip replacement. Or I would hope. Given the approach to diabetes, obesity and heart disease, I am not so sure.
It gets worse: 38% have on site retail sales of homeopathy, 21% from their website, and 7% from pharmacy or gift shop. They are selling water and are happy to proclaim it to the world. Similarly 48% gave on site retail of TCM or Ayurvedic, 21% from their website, and 3% from pharmacy or gift shop, and 38% have on site retail of AROMATHERAPY (!!!!!!!!!) , 17% from their website, and 7% from pharmacy or gift shop.
It is a serious question: Why not have a psychic on staff to predict the patients course? Or have John Edwards visit after a patient dies so that the family can talk to their dead? Does anyone see any difference between those interventions and the ones already offered? I can’t. Major medical institutions are offering fiction to their patients.
It would be nice, or at least easier, to practice in one of those institutions. Where I work I have to justify adding new drugs to the formulary. We review the costs and benefits of new interventions and decide, based on the available data, if an antibiotic should be added to the formulary. We have to follow standards and review the literature. If I were to practice at Duke or Scripts, I could do whatever I damn well pleased. They evidently have no standards of care since and any institution that sells homeopathy should have no institutional credibility to control their pharmacy.
Flexner was a fool for thinking
Such exploitation of medical education … is strangely inconsistent with the social aspects of medical practice. The overwhelming importance of preventive medicine, sanitation, and public health indicates that in modern life the medical profession is an organ differentiated by society for its highest purposes, not a business to be exploited.
A scientific basis of medical care and medicine have a higher purpose. I love humor. As the Bravewell report says “cash remains the most frequent form of payment.” When the choice is between reality and an exchange of fantasy for money, as Las Vegas demonstrates, fantasy wins.
The humor continues in the Bravewell report. They report that clinical success is based in part on “Using an evidence-informed approach to care.” I presume for those institutions that offer the fantasy based therapies, the evidence is from billing and collections, not Pubmed.
While most of the institutions measure patient satisfaction, the results of those measurements are not mentioned. I would bet that patient satisfaction is high. Unfortunately,
higher patient satisfaction was associated with less emergency department use but with greater inpatient use, higher overall health care and prescription drug expenditures, and increased mortality.
That may be why they do report outcomes. I would postulate that high satisfaction with your alternative care would be associated with increased mortality.
My bias is that medicine should be based on the best approximation of reality that the scientific method can provide. Science based medicine is reality based medicine. The forms of therapy offered by what used to be considered top notch medical institutions are neither based on science nor reality, but I understand that popularity and profit are more important than honesty and integrity. That’s the wave of the future. I was always under the impression that you can judge of person by the company they keep.
One of the most striking, though perhaps predictable, conclusions of this study is that integrative medicine is, in fact, integrative. It integrates conventional care with non- conventional or non-Western therapies; ancient healing wisdom with modern science; and the whole person—mind, body, and spirit in the context of community.
If you integrate fantasy with reality, you do not instantiate reality. If you mix cow pie with apple pie, it does not make the cow pie taste better; it makes the apple pie worse.
I had long thought that the laws of thermodynamics prohibited perpetual motion machines. No longer. If we can some how harness the kinetic energy of Flexners corpse, we would no longer have to import oil. At the rate it must be spinning, it is probably going to rotate forever.

Bye Bye Bravewell
Jann Bellamy on June 16, 2016
Link
Exactly one year ago tomorrow, The Bravewell Collaborative shut down, an event so momentous that few seem to have noticed. It’s been a while since we at SBM devoted much attention to Bravewell, although, at one time, its doings were a regular feature of SBM posts.
For those of you not familiar with Bravewell, a brief history. The main mover and shaker behind The Bravewell Collaborative was Christy Mack, wife of former Morgan Stanley head John Mack and a financier of sorts in her own right. She and the widow of another Morgan Stanley bigwig, Susan Karches, neither of whom had any particular expertise in finance, managed to get about $220 million in bailout funds from the Federal Reserve, a boondoggle recounted in Matt Taibbi’s 2011 hilarious Rolling Stone article, “The Real Housewives of Wall St.” Ms. Mack had established the Bravewell Collaborative a few years earlier, with her own contributions and that of other philanthropists, as a private operating foundation, a further opportunity to benefit from government largesse in the form of tax deductions.
Here’s Bravewell’s definition of “integrative medicine”:
Integrative medicine is an approach to care that puts the patient at the center and addresses the full range of physical, emotional, mental, social, spiritual and environmental influences that affect a person’s health. Employing a personalized strategy that considers the patient’s unique conditions, needs and circumstances, integrative medicine uses the most appropriate interventions from an array of scientific disciplines to heal illness and disease and help people regain and maintain optimal health.
This vague, and typical, cut and pasting of appealing terms: “personalized strategy,” “appropriate interventions,” “optimal health,” and so forth, is a hallmark of integrative medicine. It masks the one characteristic of integrative medicine that differentiates it from “conventional” medicine – the incorporation of quackery into medical practice – a feature that becomes clear once you dig into the details, which we’ll get to in a moment.
In the words of Ms. Mack, the organization was “sunset” on June 17, 2015, because
We formed back in 2002, and have since worked together to change how Americans think about their health and the kind of healthcare they receive, and to bring about the cultural change necessary to create a healthier nation. Then, when our principal strategies had achieved our goals, and when integrative medicine had become part of the national conversation on healthcare, our members collectively decided that it was time to sunset the organization.
Note that she does not claim Bravewell actually improved healthcare or the nation’s health one whit, and she’s right. There is no evidence that it had any such effect. I suppose you could truthfully say that “integrative medicine had become part of the national conversation on healthcare” – it was certainly part of our conversation here at SBM.
Dubious achievements
So, what did Bravewell accomplish? Here’s the highlight reel, according to its website, which is still up and running.
Bravewell Clinical Network
The Bravewell Clinical Network is a group of nine “leading” integrative medicine sites. (I guess this means the 60 or so integrative medicine centers in the Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine & Health don’t all rate as “leading.”) The Network develops “successful models of care” and improves their financial viability. (Someone call David Eisenberg and Ted Kaptchuk with this revelation; they seem totally unaware that all of their problems have already been solved by Bravewell.)
This effort resulted in “Best Practices in Integrative Medicine,” published in 2007, and, as far as I can tell, not updated in the nine years since it came out. “Best practices” in these “leading” IM sites include offerings of acupuncture, acupressure, aromatherapy, herbs, Chinese and “Eastern” medicine, craniosacral therapy, reiki, healing touch, functional medicine, homeopathy, Qi Gong, reflexology, rolfing, and zero balancing. See what I mean? You don’t have to dig far to find the quackery.
Network patients can participate in “Patients Receiving Integrative Medicine Interventions Effectiveness Registry” (“PRIMIER”), patient-reported outcomes modeled on the NIH’s Patient Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System (“PROMIS”), the major difference being that PROMIS measures patient-reported outcomes from evidence-based interventions, while PRIMIER is currently evaluating pseudoscientific interventions such as acupuncture and energy medicine. Preliminary findings, based on a small sample of patients, indicate that a combination of manipulation, acupuncture and energy medicine (such as reiki) yielded an “impressive decrease” in pain. Of course, if the underlying treatment isn’t evidence-based, and there are no controls, this “research” can’t really tell us anything useful. Or, GIGO.
IM fellowships
To ensure that the nation is not deprived of a supply of fresh IM practitioners, Bravewell sponsored 88 fellowships in IM at Andrew Weil’s University of Arizona IM program, where they learned about botanical medicine, homeopathy, naturopathy, and energy medicine, among other pseudoscientific practices. Wouldn’t Abraham Flexner be pleased to learn that, having worked so hard to bring medical education out of the darkness of quackery and into the light of science, Andrew Weil and Bravewell have played their part in marching them right back in to the 19th century?
Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine & Health
Bravewell’s funding of the Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine & Health for 10 years may be its most significant achievement, just not in the way Bravewell thinks. The Consortium has probably contributed more than any other factor to the devolution of academic medicine into quackademic medicine through its relentless devotion to the ideology of integrative medicine. It is interesting to note that, even as the possibilities for finding any evidence of safety and efficacy to support the use of alternative treatments have shrunk, both Bravewell and the Academic Consortium have stubbornly insisted that CAM must absolutely be a part of this always promised, but never realized, potential for transformation of American medicine. The Consortium has established clinical centers offering sheer quackery like craniosacral therapy, various forms of energy healing, acupuncture, naturopathy, herbal medicine and the like, having apparently dropped the pretense that evidence has anything whatsoever to do with the services they sell to patients. (Because, you know, you need a “more fluid” concept of evidence.)
It has been less successful in instituting a standard IM curriculum in medical school or IM as part of residency programs, try as they might. “Core Competencies in Integrative Medicine,” from 2004, another Bravewell project, is still on both the Consortium and Bravewell’s websites, apparently without updating in the past dozen years. While they have no doubt enjoyed some victories, especially at certain institutions such as Georgetown, in making quackery at least an elective at some schools and a part of some residency programs, their main achievement has been the establishment of what are essentially spas offering both “conventional” (diet, exercise) and “CAM” services.
The Summit on Integrative Medicine and Health
A signature “achievement” of the Bravewell Collaborative received its share of attention here on SBM. The Summit on Integrative Medicine and Health of the Public, a partnership between Bravewell and the Institute of Medicine, is the perfect exemplar of integrative medicine’s ongoing attempt to rebrand preventive medicine and its emphasis on exercise and diet as “integrative,” while, at the same time, slipping quackery into medical practice. Kimball Atwood called them out on this, but good, with a long list of preventive health measures supported by science advanced by “conventional” medicine compared to those from integrative medicine, the latter being exactly zero. This was back in the day when you could actually write to institutions being unduly influenced by integrative types, like the IOM here, and hope that you might make a difference, which is exactly what the late, great Wally Sampson did in response to this effort, to no avail.
Team SBM v. Bravewell
“Integrative Medicine in America”
Perhaps no one document has been so thoroughly investigated by Team SBM than Bravewell’s “Integrative Medicine in America: How Integrative Medicine is Being Practiced Across America,” which garnered what must be a record 4 posts for any one event: from Steve Novella, David Gorski, Kimball Atwood and Mark Crislip. Taken together, their posts are as good a lesson as you’ll get in wading through the doublespeak and false premises of integrative medicine in general and Bravewell in particular.
Misleading language (Kimball Atwood):
Misleading language is the sine qua non of ‘integrative medicine” (IM) and its various synonyms. The term itself is a euphemism, intended to distract the reader from first noticing the quackery that is its distinguishing characteristic. As previously explained, Bravewell darlings Andrew Weil and Ralph Snyderman, quack pitchmen extraordinaires, recognized nearly 10 years ago that if you really want to sell the product, you should dress it up in ways that appeal to a broad market.
Co-opting concepts from conventional medicine (Steve Novella):
The integrative movement . . . co-opted this term [“patient-centered care”] and made it their own, as if they invented it, and then ironically accused mainstream medicine (who invented the idea and the term) of not being patient-centered. You will see this pattern repeated.
Importation of quackery into medicine (Novella):
Next we get to the core fiction of integrative medicine, that it “uses the most appropriate interventions from an array of scientific disciplines.” That, of course, is a description of mainstream medicine. We use any intervention that is science-based – that has an appropriate combination of plausibility and direct evidence for safety and efficacy. Integrative medicine, rather, is the mixing of appropriate science-based interventions with treatments that are not science-based, that are highly implausible, or have been shown to not work. Otherwise they would already be part of medicine.
Rebranding of conventional modalities as CAM (David Gorski):
I conclude that “integrative medicine” integrates pseudoscience with science, quackery with medicine. Where it fails to do that, it rebrands science-based modalities like nutrition as somehow being “alternative” so that it can be listed as being CAM.
Quackery is not necessary to good patient care (Gorski):
The problem, once again, is that it is not necessary to “integrate” pseudoscience with science-based medicine in order to practice collaborative patient-centered care. It’s really not, just as it’s not necessary to “integrate” pseudoscience into SBM in order to be “holistic” or to “take care of the whole patient.” Bravewell keeps selling that false dichotomy. I’m not buying, and neither is any member of the SBM team.
Or, more succinctly (guess who?):
If you integrate fantasy with reality, you do not instantiate reality. If you mix cow pie with apple pie, it does not make the cow pie taste better; it makes the apple pie worse.
Leadership Program in Integrative Healthcare at Duke University
Bravewell’s last, and ongoing, project is
The Leadership Program in Integrative Healthcare at Duke University. This leadership program is designed to create a new type of leader for the future of medicine — one grounded in the philosophy of integrative healthcare.
And:
A practical strategy, integrative medicine puts the patient at the center of the care and addresses the full range of physical, emotional, mental, social, spiritual and environmental influences that affect a person’s health. Treating the whole person addresses both the patient’s immediate needs as well as the effects of the long-term and complex interplay between a range of biological, behavioral, psychosocial and environmental influences are addressed. This process enhances the ability of individuals to not only get well, but most importantly, to stay well.
Sounds like the “new type of leader” is a whole lot like the old type of “integrative medicine:” a lot of high-minded talk about patient-centeredness, wellbeing, and so on, but (when you check out the curriculum) a chance to sneak quackery into healthcare. (Actually, when I read through the program’s materials, what came to mind was not so much integrative medicine as Silicon Valley’s “Conjoined Triangles of Success.”)
“Cam-ectomy”
Bravewell’s demise was brought to my attention by none other than John Weeks, in a recent post on Integrative Practitioner, who highlighted the intractable problem with integrative medicine that neither Bravewell nor any other integrative medicine proponent has been able to solve: Just how integrative does integrative medicine want to be?
In the Bravewell model,
The care, while multi-disciplinary, is physician-directed. . . . Conventionally degreed physicians oversee the care and personally deliver conventional medical services, mind-body interventions, nutritional counseling, and in some cases acupuncture. Other appropriately trained health care providers deliver services such as Healing Touch, acupuncture and massage.
This annoys Weeks, who, while congratulating Bravewell, criticized what he calls its “cam-ectomy.”
The leaders credit their success in part to “vetting [their] partners well” as Mack . . . put it: “Identifying and engaging the right people has always been key to Bravewell’s success.” To Bravewell this meant, with minor exceptions, choosing to work with and through medical doctors in academic medical settings. Chiropractors, naturopathic physicians, licensed acupuncturists and the other licensed “CAM” professions and the work of their organizations to foster an integrative health and medicine future did not make the grade.
My single significant concern with Bravewell has continuously been that, while they promoted a new model of care, they did so while upholding a vertical, top-down, MD-dominant hierarchy. Strategically, the “other” consortium with the “CAM” fields, the Academic Collaborative for Integrative Health, did not merit consideration. The policy-related interprofessional Integrative Health Policy Consortium also failed to make the grade. Bravewell’s exclusiveness, given its power as a donor, sometimes fostered a chill between the two academic consortia.
So, there is dissension in the ranks, with chiropractors, naturopaths and acupuncturists not wanting to sit around twiddling their thumbs until the MD calls them in to do a few carefully supervised procedures. Get the popcorn ready.
Bravewell wasted a cool $30 million promoting quackery tarted up as “patient-centered care.” Its biggest accomplishment was the establishment of an entrenched integrative bureaucracy, housed mostly in academic medical centers, where too many salaries depend on the survival of integrative medicine for it to easily go away. As Kimball Atwood said,
Bravewell is what can happen when ditzy rich people who know little about medicine or science get it into their heads that they know something—some crucial secret or secrets, little known to most in medicine except for a few cranks who themselves have found the secret to easy money.

The Trojan Horse called Integrative Medicine arrives at another medical school
Scott Gavura on August 29, 2013
Link
Medicine is a collaborative practice. Hospitals are the best example, where dozens of different health professionals work cooperatively, sharing responsibilities for patient care. Teamwork is essential, and that’s why health professionals obtain a large part of their education on the job, in teaching (academic) hospitals. The only way that all of these different professions are able to work together effectively is that their foundations are based on an important, yet simple, principle. All of us have education and training grounded in basic scientific principles of medicine. Biochemistry, pharmacology, physiology – we all work from within the same framework. As a pharmacist, my role might include working with physicians and nurses to manage and monitor medication use. A team approach is only possible when you’re working from the same playbook, and with the same aim. And in medicine, that playbook is science.
That’s why “integrative” medicine frightens me so much. Integrative medicine is a tactic embedding complementary and alternative medical practices into conventional medical care. Imagine “integrating” a practitioner into the health system that doesn’t accept germ theory. Or basic disease definitions. Or the effectiveness of vaccines. Or even basic biochemistry – perhaps they believe in treatments that restore the body’s “vital force” or manipulate some sort of “energy fields”. Instead of relying on objective signs and symptoms, they base treatments on pre-scientific beliefs, long discarded from medicine. There may be entirely different treatment goals, which are potentially antagonistic to the scientific standard. Imagine a hospital or academic setting where this occurs, and the potential impact on the quality of care that is delivered.
If you integrate fantasy with reality, you do not instantiate reality. If you mix cow pie with apple pie, it does not make the cow pie taste better; it makes the apple pie worse.
– Mark Crislip
Dr. Crislip’s health care “cow pie” is an effective metaphor for the reality of “integrative” medicine. Medicine today is based on a single scientific standard, with an array of providers divided by specialty and expertise. Integrative medicine explicitly seeks to “integrate” providers that do not provide science-based care, and instead offer treatments that run the spectrum of useless to unproven to potentially dangerous. Positioning of these treatments and services as “integrative” is simply a Trojan horse or branding exercise, aimed at distracting governments and health organizations from recognizing the obvious – that “integrative” products and purveyors can’t meet the established standard of care.
The branding of alternative medicine as “integrative” medicine has been a marketing tactic for at least a decade, with proponents continually citing it as the future of medicine (a future, perhaps, with compromised scientific standards), and opponents simply pointing out that there is no compelling need to “integrate” treatments into medicine that are not grounded in high-quality science.
There is no alternative medicine. There is only scientifically proven, evidence-based medicine supported by solid data or unproven medicine, for which scientific evidence is lacking. Whether a therapeutic practice is “Eastern” or “Western,” is unconventional or mainstream, or involves mind-body techniques or molecular genetics is largely irrelevant except for historical purposes and cultural interest. We recognize that there are vastly different types of practitioners and proponents of the various forms of alternative medicine and conventional medicine, and that there are vast differences in the skills, capabilities, and beliefs of individuals within them and the nature of their actual practices. Moreover, the economic and political forces in these fields are large and increasingly complex and have the capability for being highly contentious. Nonetheless, as believers in science and evidence, we must focus on fundamental issues—namely, the patient, the target disease or condition, the proposed or practiced treatment, and the need for convincing data on safety and therapeutic efficacy.– Phil B. Fontanarosa & George D. Lundberd
Turning the clock back
Medicine wasn’t always grounded in rigorous science. In fact, it was very different just 100 years ago. Formal medical education varied dramatically from school to school prior to 1910, when the American Medical Association commissioned Abraham Flexner to evaluate American and Canadian medical education and make recommendations on their improvement. Flexner was highly critical of the education standards he observed, and recommended consolidating schools, increasing education prerequisites, enhancing the scientific rigor, and embedding the role of research in education. Flexner was also highly critical of dubious “alternative medical practices” and recommended the closure of under-performing institutions that continued to offer education and training based on principles other than science. Not all schools were evaluated to be weak. Highly rated schools included Michigan, Case Western Reserve, Johns Hopkins, and in Canada, McGill University and the University of Toronto.
The effects of the Flexner report on medical education and the practice of medicine (and affiliated professions, like pharmacy) can’t be overstated. Medical education, now grounded in a rigorous foundation of science, rejected and abandoned unscientific practices like naturopathy, homeopathy, chiropractic, and osteopathy. The result is the medical education and care you see today – and the consistent framework for health professionals. Of course, the purveyors and proponents of these now-rejected practices never fully disappeared. They retreated, regrouped, and fought back, craving the public legitimacy and credibility now offered to medicine and its related health professions. What was quackery became “alternative” medicine, and then “complementary and alternative” medicine (CAM), implying these practices could be used alongside other treatments. Today’s CAM is called “integrative” medicine. Old wine in a new bottle. Regardless of the qualifier, it’s simply an end run around the scientific standards that were defined back 1910.
All of this brings me to my hometown Toronto, and my alma mater the University of Toronto, and this job posting from the university:
Director – University of Toronto Centre for Complementary and Integrative MedicineThe Faculty of Medicine and the Leslie Dan Faculty of Pharmacy at the University of Toronto seek a Director to lead their new interdisciplinary program in complementary and integrative medicine, which will be housed in the new Centre for Complementary and Integrative Medicine (CCIM). The Centre will begin with two primary foci: Traditional Chinese Medicine and natural health products. It will support research and health professional education. Applications are invited for the position of Director for a 3-year renewable term effective January 1, 2014.
The mission of this new Centre is to facilitate, conduct, and obtain support for collaborative basic, clinical, and health services research in complementary and alternative medicine; to serve as an educational resource and to develop integrative curricula and educational programs on complementary and alternative medicine; to work collaboratively with other departments within both Faculties and their hospital partners to support the integration of evidence-based complementary and integrative medicine into existing clinical settings and clinical research programs.
Candidates must have a MD and/or PhD degree(s), a strong track record of scholarship and history of peer-reviewed extramural funding. The Director will be expected to maintain a vigorous and independent extramurally funded research program; to build productive collaborations within the University of Toronto and other local and global partners; and to grow CCIM into a nationally and internationally recognized Centre for natural products and complementary medicine education and research.
In addition to a record of academic excellence in a relevant area of research, the successful candidate will possess outstanding leadership, administrative management, communication, and relationship-building skills. The individual will bring an inclusive scholarly vision and strategies to enable the Centre to build and to sustain effective academic partnerships. Candidates should have demonstrated experience in multidisciplinary and collaborative academic environments. Candidates should have a track record of successful and innovative leadership in research and education, and must be eligible for academic appointment at the rank of Associate or Full Professor.
Much has been already been written at this blog about what’s been described as “quackademic” medicine. (Check out David Gorski’s talk on quackademic medicine and the evolution of quackery). Gorski started compiling a list back in 2008 of academic medical centers that offered one or more alternative medicine modalities. Disappointingly, U of T isn’t alone in its plan to push CAM, although this one is the first I’ve seen that includes two faculties: pharmacy and medicine. It’s a clever strategy: If the intent is to change the medical playbook, and the scientific foundation for medical care, you have to hit both the pharmacists and the physicians. Otherwise one will call out the other for quackery. Normalize it for both groups, and there’s less likelihood that either will notice. Most worrying is the explicit objective of pushing CAM interventions into university-affiliated hospitals. Again, normalize the pseudoscience with students, and then embed it in teaching centres, where other health professionals will see it. And finally, change the standard of care. The first salvo will be Traditional Chinese Medicine and then natural health products. None of this is surprising, given the Canadian context.
TCM: The invented tradition
“Even though I believe we should promote Chinese Medicine, I personally do not believe in it. I don’t take Chinese Medicine.”– Chariman Mao, quoted in The Private Life of Chairman Mao
Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) is a collection of beliefs and practices that was accurately described in the 1930’s by a Chinese medical school dean as a “weird medley of philosophy, religion, superstition, magic, alchemy, astrology, feng shui, divination, sorcery, demonology and quackery.” Current practices that are labelled as TCM include herbalism, acupuncture, massage, energy therapy, and dietary interventions. Treatments are based on the idea that they are restoring “balance” or eliminating “energy blockages”. TCM moved from folklore to government embrace when Chairman Mao realized the potential for TCM in the 1950’s as a means of both boosting Chinese pride, but also to address acute physician shortages in a country of 500 million. Without Mao, there would likely be little TCM, so TCM is very much an “invented tradition”.
The “Traditional” qualifier in TCM gives away the game right away: TCM is simply an appeal to antiquity, the belief that because an idea has persisted, it automatically has merit. And just like the term “integrative”, it is yet another qualifier introduced to rationalize away the requirement to treat based on science-based principles. TCM is comparable to Traditional Western Medicine, except traditional “Western” practices that were demonstrably useless (e.g., bloodletting) were discarded from “Western” medical practice – in part because of Flexner’s work.
The remarkable thing about science-based medicine is that it knows no geographic boundaries. If it works, it works. The idea that the Chinese would respond differently to objective, scientific medicine is as absurd as thinking that “Canadian” medicine would differ significantly from “American” medicine simply because we Canadians love maple syrup, Tim Hortons coffee, and socialized health care. If a treatment objectively works, it’s simply called medicine – no qualifiers are needed. Artemisinin is an excellent example. The Chinese identified the herb Artemisia annua in the 1970’s as potentially effective against malaria. This wasn’t testing to see if it could unblock chi: researchers were looking at how effectively parasites were cleared from the body. Scientific research in China subsequently identified the active ingredient and isolated it. The use of the drug has spread worldwide – not as TCM, but simply as medicine. Unlike the herb, however, the drug is now synthetically manufactured, so the dose can be calculated precisely. And chemical variations of the drug have been developed that are consistently absorbed, resulting in a vastly safer and superior product than the herb itself.
Despite the problematic and unscientific basis for TCM, those that offer it must be licensed in Ontario. The two acts which practitioners are permitted to perform are:
    • Performing a procedure on tissue below the dermis and below the surface of a mucous membrane for the purpose of performing acupuncture.
    • Communicating a traditional Chinese medicine diagnosis identifying a body system disorder as the cause of a person’s symptoms using traditional Chinese medicine techniques
So TCM in Ontario encompasses two functions: The first is the ability to deliver a theatrical placebo which lacks any objective effects. The second is a reference to “traditional” diagnoses and treatment with “traditional” techniques – again, code for practices which are not based on scientific principles, but on historical one. In short, TCM in Ontario means objectively useless needling, as well as giving diagnoses of disease based on prescientific concepts, and giving treatments based on those principles.
TCM and natural health products
The support for TCM isn’t just coming from provincial regulators. Health Canada, the Canadian equivalent to the FDA, administers the Natural Health Product (NHP) Regulations, which are somewhat similar to the American Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act of 1994 (DSHEA). The NHP regulations, like DSHEA, effectively exclude the manufacturers of natural health products from meeting the regulatory standards for drugs. While the Canadian regulations have implemented important steps to improve manufacturing quality, the requirement to show product efficacy was effectively eliminated in the regulations. It’s a boon to manufacturers, but problematic to consumers, as there’s no guarantee that any product approved for sale actually works. Canadians now have access to hundreds of homeopathic remedies deemed “safe and effective” by Health Canada: even homeopathic insect repellent. On the supplement side, failed prescription drugs have been rebranded and marketed as a “natural supplement”, simply because there’s no barriers in place to their sale. And there are now hundreds of TCM products approved for sale. Health Canada approved the following labeling for horny goat weed (Epimedium sagittatum):
Traditional Chinese Medicine used to tonify the kidney and fortify the yang, for symptoms such as frequent urination, forgetfulness, withdrawal, and painful cold lower back and knees. Contraindicated in patients with fire from yin deficiency. If dizziness, vomiting, dry mouth, thirst or nosebleed occur, discontinue use.
In the science-based, reality-based world, there is no yang that needs to be fortified, just as there is no such thing as a yin deficiency. Yet your licensed TCM practitioner can sell you horny goat weed which is Health Canada approved to treat your forgetfulness and cold lower back. And if the University of Toronto is successful with its new Centre for Complementary and Integrative Medicine, this type of material may soon be “integrated” into its medical and pharmacy education. The entire concept is absurd. As an alumnus, I’m appalled and embarrassed. I like to think my pharmacy education was a good one. It was rigorous and grounded in the basic sciences (too much organic chemistry, I thought at the time). And I’ve trained alongside (and work with) many graduates of U of T’s medical school. The Faculty at both schools are among the best and brightest in Canada, and U of T has an international reputation for excellence in education. So it’s deeply disappointing to see this move by the university.
Conclusion
Moves to embed CAM into academic settings start with the assumption that “integrative medicine” is a good thing, in the absence of any data to show that is the case. Based on the information that does exist, it’s reasonable to assume that increasing the levels of “integrative” medicine at the University of Toronto will reduce and compromise the quality of medical and pharmacy education, and ultimately, the quality of care offered to patients. It’s sadly ironic that the University of Toronto, with a medical school lauded by Abraham Flexner in 1910, is now turning its back on those qualities, 103 years later.

The future of “integrative medicine” is too close for comfort
David Gorski on September 2, 2013
Link
I was the other day. I’ve been on vacation this week (staycation, actually, as I stayed at home and didn’t go on any trips); so you would think it would take a lot to depress me. Unfortunately, today is the last day of that vacation; so the thought of diving back into the fray trying to fund my lab. It didn’t help that I read Scott Gavura’s Thursday post how another once-proud academic medical center, the University of Toronto, is letting the Trojan horse that is “integrative medicine” into the halls of its medical school and school of pharmacy. As I frequently say, much to the annoyance of advocates of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) and “integrative medicine,” what “integrative medicine” does is to “integrate” quackery with real medicine, which neither validates the quackery nor improves the real medicine. Or, as my good bud and fellow SBM blogger Mark Crislip so aptly put it:
If you integrate fantasy with reality, you do not instantiate reality. If you mix cow pie with apple pie, it does not make the cow pie taste better; it makes the apple pie worse.
Yes, I’ve been trying to come up with a quote that captures the essence of “integrative medicine” better than Mark’s quote. I’ve yet to succeed; so I steal his quote whenever I need to. It’s sort of the same way that I didn’t actually coin the term “quackademic medicine” to describe the infiltration of quackery into academic medicine. (Dr. R. W. Donnell did, as far as I’ve been able to ascertain.) However, I believe I’ve done more than anyone else to use and promote the term, both here and at my not-so-super-secret other blog. As I like to say say, mediocre bloggers borrow. Great bloggers steal.
Be that as it may, Scott’s post reminded me that I hadn’t looked much at quackademic medicine, at least not at the status of its infiltration into medical academia, in a while. Then I saw a review article entitled The Future of Integrative Medicine in The American Journal of Medicine by Victor S. Sierpina, MD, ABFM, ABIHM and James E. Dalen, MD, MPH. (Note that ABIHM stands for the American Board of Integrative Holistic Medicine and ABFM stands for the American Board of Family Medicine.). The article itself has no place in any self-respecting peer-reviewed medical journal, but there it is, much the same way that quackademic woo has been intermittently infiltrating the New England Journal of Medicine. The article itself is one massive apologia for integrative medicine. In fact, it’s useful to look at because it follows a script that virtually all such articles follow, with only relatively minor variations.
Not surprisingly, it starts out, as virtually all such articles start out, with the logical fallacy known as the appeal to popularity. As I just alluded to, there must be a script for these sorts of articles about CAM, in which they all must begin with a paragraph trying to demonstrate how popular CAM is, the larger the percentage of people using CAM the better, even if the author has to include prayer and spirituality (which are religion and not medicine), exercise (which is a science-based modality rebranded as somehow “alternative”), and nutrition (which is similarly not “alternative” but a science-based modality similarly “rebranded” as “alternative”; that is, as long as the claims being made for it aren’t overblown). Sierpina and Dalen’s article is no exception. They immediately cite an article from 20 years ago that claimed that one in three people used “unconventional therapies.” (I can’t help but note that 20 years ago it was still acceptable to call quackery “unconventional” rather than to refer to it as CAM or “integrative medicine.” Unfortunately, that was also about the time that that started to change in a big way.) In any case, using this logical fallacy, they strongly imply that because CAM is popular that there must be something to it. I always respond to such arguments by pointing out that nearly half of U.S. adults don’t believe in evolution. Does that mean that evolution is not a valid scientific theory? Science is not a popularity contest.
Next in the script of these articles—and I’ve read more of them than I can remember—is to extend the appeal to popularity to imply that you, as a reader, should jump on the bandwagon. The reason, if they are to be believed, that you should jump on the bandwagon is because modern medicine is too high-tech, doctors have lost touch with their roots as healers, and patients “feel lost” in our health care system. For example, Sierpina and Dalen write:
In the past several decades we have seen a sea change in the medical landscape from the solo practice, primary care country doctor to large urbanized health care systems, from high-touch, low-cost care to high-tech, specialized, expensive, sometimes impersonal health care. Some patients feel lost in our current health care system. They see specialist after specialist and receive prescription after prescription and test after test. They wonder whether their specialists speak to each other.
In the context of these historical and social changes, a field of unconventional medicine has evolved that has been known by a progression of names: holistic medicine, complementary and alternative medicine, and now integrative medicine. It is hoped that the perspectives offered by integrative medicine will eventually transform mainstream medicine by improving patient outcomes, reducing costs, improving safety, and increasing patient satisfaction.
Of course, just because modern medicine can be impersonal and confusing is not a justification for introducing quackery into medicine. I like to remind people that the primary care country doctor of 50 or 100 years ago that is so lionized as the ideal by CAM providers because of the “human touch” he provided often couldn’t do a heck of a lot other than commiserate with their patients and provide that human touch. Don’t get me wrong. That’s a critically important part of medicine that is difficult to maintain in our current healthcare environment. However, a far better solution would be to reintroduce the human element of caring and retain the efficacy of science-based medicine without introducing the mysticism, vitalism, and prescientific thinking that is at the heart of so much CAM. It’s a false dichotomy that is being argued: It’s either impersonal, mechanized medicine or it’s “integrating” quackery into medicine. CAM apologists like Sierpina and Dalen like to imply that those are the only two choices. They aren’t. There is another way that does not involve weakening the scientific foundation of medicine.
Even more off-base, the script for this sort of article always includes a claim that somehow CAM will “transform” medicine. No doubt it will, if current trends continue and quackademic medicine continues to infiltrate unchecked. Indeed, it already has. Unfortunately, that “transformation” is not for the better, given that it involves injecting mystical faith healing like reiki and healing touch, vitalistic quackery like homeopathy and traditional Chinese medicine, and cornucopias of quackery like naturopathy into modern medicine. To CAM advocates this is a good thing that will somehow “humanize” medicine. To me it is unnecessary quackery. Unfortunately, it is ascendant right now.
Next up in these articles is often the attempt to define just what “integrative medicine” is. My definition is fairly clear: Integrating quackery with real medicine. (I know, I repeat myself, but I want to drive this point home.) However, let’s see how Sierpina and Dalen try to explain how it is defined:
Integrative medicine has been defined as “the practice of medicine that reaffirms the importance of the relationship between practitioner and patient, focuses on the whole person, is informed by evidence, and makes use of all appropriate therapeutic approaches, healthcare professionals and disciplines to achieve optimal health and healing.”
This definition, quoted from the Consortium of Academic Health Centers for Integrative Medicine, is nonsense, of course. It’s complete gobbledygook that reinforces the false dichotomy that so irritates me. Once again, it is not necessary to embrace quackery in order to “reaffirm the importance of the relationship between practitioner and patient” or to “focus on the whole person.” It just isn’t. Yet that’s the false dichotomy at the heart of all these articles. Yet that is exactly the dichotomy that CAM apologists hammer advocates of SBM over the head with in an effort to paint us as uncaring and more concerned with science than with actual patients. Of course, it is because we are so concerned with patients that we reject this dichotomy and insist on science-based medicine, but that’s a message that is sometimes hard to communicate, which makes it easy for writers like Sierpina and Dalen to write things like this:
The most obvious differences between integrative and conventional medicine are its practitioners, who offer longer consultations and emphasize minimally invasive therapies, such as mind-body approaches, nutrition, prevention, and lifestyle changes, and focus on healing and wellness. In addition to conventional therapies, they may recommend alternatives, such as acupuncture, dietary supplements, and botanicals. The doctor-patient relationship emphasizes joint decision-making by the patient and the physician.
Once again, it is not necessary to abandon SBM in order to emphasize joint decision-making by the patient and the physician. As I’ve pointed out multiple times before, the days of “Dr. Kildare”-style paternalism of 60 years ago and earlier are over, and that is generally a good thing. These days, good science-based doctors emphasize joint decision-making. The reason CAM practitioners emphasize joint decision-making so much, to the point of fetishizing it, is because that’s all they have that’s of value. The rest of what they offer consists of either quackery or science-based modalities that have been rebranded as being somehow “alternative,” such as pharmacognosy (natural products pharmacology) rebranded as herbalism and supplements, nutrition, lifestyle interventions, and exercise.
Once again Sierpina and Dalen continue to hammer on the appeal to popularity by launching straight into a discussion of how many academic medical centers have integrative medicine programs, in essence gloating about how in 1999 there were only eight medical school deans who met to discuss CAM and create the Consortium of Academic Health Centers for Integrative Medicine, which ultimately had eleven members. In 2012, there were 54 medical and health professions schools belonging to the Consortium, and today, according to Sierpina and Dalen, here’s where integrative medicine stands in 2013:
There is clear evidence that integrative medicine is becoming part of current mainstream medicine. Increasing numbers of fellowships in integrative medicine are being offered in our academic health centers. In 2013, there are fellowships in integrative medicine in 13 medical schools. In 2000, the University of Arizona established a 1000-hour online fellowship that has been completed by more than 1000 physicians, nurse practitioners, and physician assistants. This online fellowship makes it possible for fellows to continue their clinical practice during their fellowship.
A 200-hour curriculum for Integrative Medicine in Residency has been developed and is now in place in 30 family practice and 2 internal medicine residencies. The curriculum includes many of the topics that are not covered in the medical school curriculum, such as nutrition, mind–body therapies, nutritional and botanical supplements, alternative therapies (eg, acupuncture, massage, and chiropractic), and lifestyle medicine. A similar curriculum for pediatric residencies is being developed. The eventual goal is to include integrative medicine skills and competencies in all residency programs.
Sadly, they say this as though it were a good thing. It’s not. Unfortunately, thanks to the University of Arizona, the efforts to “integrate” pseudoscience into science-based medicine continue apace. For example, just the other day I saw an article cum press release touting how the University of Arizona’s Pediatric Integrative Medicine in Residency recently expanded its online offerings:
UA’s Pediatric Integrative Medicine in Residency program recently expanded its online curriculum to include four other universities in the United States, making it the first national online pediatric integrative medicine program.
Still in its pilot stage, the online curriculum now includes pediatric departments at Stanford University, the University of Chicago, the University of Kansas and Eastern Virginia Medical School Children’s Hospital of the King’s Daughters. Prior to the national launch, the online pilot program was only used at UA’s College of Medicine.
The Pediatric Integrative Medicine in Residency program allows medical school graduates working on their specialization to learn a variety of methods to treat children beyond traditional medicine.
These practices range from nutritional treatment to the Chinese healing tradition of acupuncture. Pediatric residents also learn stress management and physical activity as forms of treatment for their patients.
It always makes me cringe to think about subjecting children to acupuncture, sticking needles into children for no therapeutic benefit.
In any case, as I said at the beginning of this post, now I’m depressed. On the other hand, I’m also getting recharged. I go back to work tomorrow. Not only is it time to get back into my research again and to take care of my patients again. It’s also time to dive back into the fray and promote SBM.

   Survey says, “Hop on the bandwagon of ‘integrative medicine’!”
David Gorski
Link
A Brief Clinical Vignette
In researching this post, I found an article published nearly two years ago in The Hospitalist entitled Growth Spurt: Complementary and alternative medicine use doubles, which began with this anecdote:
Despite intravenous medication, a young boy in status epilepticus had the pediatric ICU team at the University of Wisconsin School of Medicine and Public Health in Madison stumped. The team called for a consult with the Integrative Medicine Program, which works with licensed acupuncturists and has been affiliated with the department of family medicine since 2001. Acupuncture’s efficacy in this setting has not been validated, but it has been shown to ease chemotherapy-induced nausea and vomiting, as well as radiation-induced xerostomia.
Following several treatments by a licensed acupuncturist and continued conventional care, the boy’s seizures subsided and he was transitioned to the medical floor. Did the acupuncture contribute to bringing the seizures under control? “I can’t say that it was the acupuncture — it was probably a function of all the therapies working together,” says David P. Rakel, MD, assistant professor and director of UW’s Integrative Medicine Program.
The UW case illustrates both current trends and the constant conundrum that surrounds hospital-based complementary medicine: Complementary and alternative medicine’s use is increasing in some U.S. hospitals, yet the existing research evidence for the efficacy of its multiple modalities is decidedly mixed.
My jaw dropped in horror when I read this story. Acupuncture for status epilepticus? There’s no evidence that it works and no scientific plausibility suggesting that it might work. And what does the questionable research suggesting that acupuncture might ease chemotherapy-induced nausea and vomiting or radiation-induced xerostomia (which, if you look more closely at the studies, it almost certainly does not, but that’s a post for another time) have to do with this case, anyway? Nothing. Worse, Dr. Rakel fell for the classic post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy; i.e., despite his disclaimer, he appears to be implying that, because the child recovered, acupuncture must have contributed to his recovery. He also repeats the classic fallacy that I’ve written about time and time again in the context of cancer therapy, namely that if a patient is using quackery as well as science-based medicine, then either it was the quackery that cured him or the quackery somehow made the conventional medical care work better.
I expect better from an academic medical center like the University of Wisconsin. Unfortunately, increasingly I’m not getting it. Quackademic medicine is infiltrating such medical centers like kudzu.
A survey, a survey, my kingdom for a survey!
One of the most frequently used arguments by promoters of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or, as it’s more frequently called these days, “integrative medicine” (IM) has nothing to do with science at all. Actually, few of the arguments put forth for “complementing” or “integrating” quackery (which, let’s face it, is all the vast majority of IM really is) with science-based medicine actually have anything to do with science, favoring vague and fuzzy appeals to “holistic” medicine and the “whole patient,” as though it’s not possible to be holistic without adding a heapin’ helpin’ of magical thinking to medicine. It’s the classic false dichotomy: Either we inject a generous dose of woo into our medicine, or medicine remains “non-holistic” or, even worse, reductionistic, and we all know how evil “Western” reductionistic science is, right?
No, one of the favorite tactics used to market CAM/IM comes straight out of the Madison Avenue playbook. Indeed, I can imagine Don Draper of Mad Men cooking it up. It’s a classic argumentum ad populum, whereby CAM/IM advocates try to represent their “product” as being very popular and gaining in popularity every day. These sorts of appeals on the part of CAM/IM frequently emphasize the various subcategories of argumentum ad populum, such as the “bandwagon fallacy,” in which it is argued that, because most people believe something (or because large numbers of people; i.e., a sizable majority) you should believe it too, or at least consider it more seriously. Regular readers should be able to see the problem inherent in that approach. After all, many people believe in ghosts or astrology; the fact that such beliefs are popular does not make them true. The second form of argumentum ad populum is known as “snob appeal,” in which CAM proponents try to persuade you of a conclusion by appealing to what an elite or a select few (but not necessarily an authority) in a society thinks or believes. Of course, I view this variety of argumentum ad populum as more an appeal to authority than anything else, and, as I point out from time to time, an appeal to authority is not always a fallacy, which is why legitimate authorities need to be careful and responsible in what they say. What they say matters to non-experts.
We in medicine have apparently been failing in this respect utterly with respect to CAM/IM.
What led me to this conclusion yet again is a recent survey that’s being flogged in the CAM/IM blogosphere that reports to have found that CAM/IM programs are becoming more common in hospitals and medical centers. My first reaction was almost shruggie-like in that I just wanted to shrug my shoulders and agree with Steve Novella that pseudoscience sells. But then I decided to take a closer look.
What I’m referring to is the 2010 Complementary and Alternative Medicine Survey of Hospitals, a survey that was carried out by the Samueli Institute in collaboration with Health Forum, which is listed as an American Hospital Association Company.” Oddly enough, this survey was not funded by the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM), but rather by the US Army Medical Research and Materiel Command under Award No. W81XWH-10-1-0938. With two wars going on, one would think that the Army would have better things to spend taxpayer dollars on. Apparently you’d be wrong.
For those of you who don’t remember the Samueli Institute, it’s one of the major forces, along with the Bravewell Collaborative, promoting the infiltration of quackademic medicine into academic medical centers. It even describes itself thusly on the cover page of its survey report:
Samueli Institute is a non-profit research organization investigating the safety, effectiveness and integration of healing-oriented practices and environments. We convene and support expert teams to conduct research on natural products; nutrition and lifestyle; mind-body practices; complementary and traditional approaches such as acupuncture, manipulation and yoga; and the placebo (meaning) effect. We support a knowledge network that assists in integrating evidence-based information about healing into mainstream health care and community settings and in creating Optimal Healing Environments.
The “meaning” effect“? Holy Dan Moerman, Batman!
Professor Moerman aside, in a couple of talks I’ve given, I’ve used the Samueli Center for Integrative Medicine at UC-Irvine as an example of just how egregious quackademic medicine can get. Indeed, right there on the SCIM website you can see a homeopath, along with acupuncturists and naturopaths. Some of these might well recommend something called FirstLine Therapy, which is basically a program marketed by Metagenics. Not surprisingly, dietary supplements are part of the program, as is “Ultrameal,” which is billed as “medical food” and takes the form of expensive drink mixes and bars. Yum.
But I digress. What about the survey itself? Let’s go to the Samueli Institute’s press release first:
Hospitals across the nation are responding to patient demand and integrating complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) services with the conventional services they normally provide, according to the results of a new survey released today by Health Forum, a subsidiary of the American Hospital Association (AHA) and Samueli Institute, a non-profit research organization that investigates healing oriented practices. The survey shows that more than 42 percent of responding hospitals indicated they offer one or more CAM therapies, up from 37 percent in 2007.
Note how this is a clever combination of the bandwagon appeal and an appeal to authority. After all, there is “patient demand,” and the authorities (i.e., hospitals) are responding. The unspoken subtext is the assumption that hospitals wouldn’t respond to such a demand if there weren’t something to it. They are, after all, health care institutions made up of health care professionals, right? Well, yes, but hospitals are also businesses, and many of these health care professionals have either bought into the myth that “holism” and improving the doctor-patient relationship requires woo, or they are shruggies.
Meanwhile, CAM/IM apologists and supporters are jumping all over this survey as “evidence” that they are winning. John Weeks of the Integrator Blog, for instance, crows:
The most significant data point here is that 74% say that “clinical effectiveness” is a top reason for inclusion. This growth took place in a down economy and despite the lack of good payment models for CAM. These findings will be interesting to view after new incentive structures that might support CAM inclusion kick in with the growth of accountable care organizations (ACOs).
“Clinical effectiveness”? Based on what? Certainly not science in most cases.
In any case, the story has gotten some traction in the mainstream media, such as the L.A. Times, which, tellingly, chose to report on the survey on its Money & Company blog under the title Alternative medical services growing at U.S. hospitals, quoting widely from the joint press release of the AHA and Samueli Institute.
But does the survey actually show what it claims? Let’s go to the report itself. The first thing I noticed when I read the report was that it’s full of the typical “bait and switch” language of CAM designed to inflate the numbers of people who apparently use “CAM modalities.” For instance, diet, exercise, and the like are represented deceptively as being somehow “alternative” when their utility not only can be studied by science but has been studied by science. None of this is surprising, but it is harmful in that it applies a layer of “mystery” and “danger” to modalities that physicians have been prescribing their patients for a long time, such as better nutrition and more exercise. These modalities are, in effect, “woo-ified.” Then, they are lumped together with the real woo, such as acupuncture, homeopathy, and “energy healing,” in order to provide legitimacy by association. For instance, if you look at Figure 2, you’ll see that natural products are the most commonly reported CAM modality, which tells me that the supplement industry’s marketing hype has been effective. More tellingly, other than chiropractic, all of the top nine modalities are nothing that couldn’t be considered SBM. True, homeopathy just barely squeaks into the top ten at number ten, but only 1.8% of adults in the U.S. have reported using it. (I suspect the number would be higher in Europe.) Where’s traditional Chinese medicine? Where’s acupuncture? Where’s “energy healing”? Apparently none of them made the top ten. For instance, if you go to the 2007 National Health Interview Survey Report, you’ll find that only 1.4% reported using acupuncture; 0.4% reported using naturopathy; 0.1% reported using Ayurveda; and 0.5% reported using reiki.
No wonder the bait and switch move is necessary, at least if CAM practitioners want to represent the popularity of their methods as being higher than single digit percents (or in some cases higher than 1%).
Here’s how the survey was done:
The 2010 Complementary and Alternative Medicine Survey of Hospitals, a 42-question instrument, was mailed to 5,858 hospitals from American Hospital Association’s inventory of opened and operating member and nonmember hospitals in March 2010. Respondents had the option to either complete the survey online or mail back a hard copy. A total of 714 responses were received for a response rate of 12%. Of responding hospitals, 299 (42%) stated that they offered one or more CAM therapies in the hospital—which could be either in the form of services provided to patients or employees.
Does anyone see the problem here? It’s fairly obvious, namely the response rate. It’s pretty hard to say much of anything based on a 12% response rate. Basically, all we can say is that 42% of the respondents have a CAM program of some sort or another, but we have no idea whether the respondents are a representative sample. Indeed, they almost certainly are not; there is probably major selection bias going on here, with respondents more likely to be the ones who have some sort of CAM program. Just the geographic distribution of responses makes me wonder, though, with 23% coming from the Midwest and only 11% coming from West Coast states. Later in the report, it is pointed out that “most of the hospitals responding to this survey would be considered ‘early adopters’” who are, apparently, adopting CAM “because they believe it’s the right thing to do or because it’s important to respond to the needs of their communities and patients.” Clearly, this is not a representative sample. Be that as it may, it can still be informative to examine this non-representative sample. For example, the “bait and switch” continues here, with the top six outpatient modalities being:
     1.  Massage therapy
     2.  Acupuncture
     3.  Guided imagery
     4.  Meditation
     5.  Relaxation
     6.  Biofeedback
And the top six inpatient modalities being:
     1.  Pet therapy
     2.  Massage Therapy
     3.  Music/art therapy
     4.  Guided imagery
     5.  Relaxation training
     6.  Reiki and therapeutic touch
The authors of the survey report conclude with amusing understatement:
Looking at the top modalities offered in hospitals it is clear that hospitals are “playing it safe” and starting with fairly conservative and non-invasive therapies to appeal to the broadest range of patients and consumers in the their community. Pet therapy has been growing in popularity. Massage therapy is provided predominantly for pain and stress management and for cancer patients, according to the American Massage Therapy Association’s 2007 Survey of Massage Therapy Utilization in Hospitals.
Other key findings include:
    • Majority of respondents offer wellness services for patients and staff, including nutritional counseling, smoking cessation, fitness training and pastoral care;
    • Massage therapy is in the top two services provided in both outpatient and inpatient settings;
    • The majority of hospitals that offered CAM were urban hospitals (72 percent); and
    • Seventy-five percent cited budgetary constraints as the biggest obstacle for implementation of CAM programs.
It is rather instructive, though, to look at the differences between inpatient and outpatient. First of all, who decided that “pet therapy” was in any way alternative? It’s not really “therapy,” either: it’s a great way to raise spirits among hospitalized patients, but lumping it in as a “CAM” therapy seems a major stretch to me. (If pet therapy is an “alternative” or “integrative” therapy, then sending hospitalized patients a card and flowers to lift their spirits must also be alternative or integrative therapy.) Secondly, it is interesting how reiki and therapeutic touch are major offerings in the inpatient realm but not in the outpatient realm. Very likely this is due to the decades-long infiltration of therapeutic touch in the nursing profession, leading too many nurses to come to believe that they can somehow realign a patient’s energy field to healing effect by waving their hands around. Reiki fits right into that, particularly given that reiki practitioners have been making a concerted effort to get into hospitals and offer their “services” to patients.
Money vs. ideology
It’s even more instructive to look at the reasons given for starting up a CAM program. Inevitably, financial considerations, plus popularity and a perceived demand among patients, are among the handful of factors that predominate:
Link
Look at what comes in as number one: patient demand at 85%. None of this is surprising, given that in the introduction it is stated:
The American public is also demanding that their hospitals offer more than conventional allopathic health care and begin to integrate CAM therapies into the care they receive in the hospital. In response, hospitals have been looking to meet the needs of their communities. The demand for CAM services is significant, even though insurers may not cover all services or products, with the American public spending approximately $12–19 billion on CAM providers and a total of $36–47 billion on all services and products combined.
Which at first suggested to me that it’s almost all about the business. There’s a lot of money to be made in CAM, and it’s paid for out of pocket. It’s also instructive to look at the reasons given for choosing the CAM modalities offered:
Link
There are, however, a couple of anomalies here. Most prominent, given that only 27% state that market research drove their decision to offer CAM, one wonders how all the others who didn’t do any market research (78%) knew that there was enough patient demand to justify spending the money to offer specific CAM services. In any case, I consider it also telling that the survey reports that 85% will use patient satisfaction as a metric to evaluate the CAM program while only 42% plan on evaluating health outcomes and 31% will evaluate quality. Don’t get me wrong, patient satisfaction is important, and we measure it for science-based medicine. However, there’s something wrong when twice as many hospitals with CAM programs will be looking at patient satisfaction as will be looking at health outcomes.
Perhaps the most interesting part of this study suggests that it may actually not be all about the money, despite the listing of how lucrative CAM can be. For example, only 57% of facilities will be using volume as a criterion for evaluating their CAM program. Is there a clinical program on earth (or at least in the U.S.) that doesn’t use volume as part of its criteria for evaluating it? It may be one of many, and it might not even be one of the more important criteria, but it’s usually a significant criterion. Adding to this, only 39% will use revenue; 20% will use profit; and 8% will use market share. To me these suggest that perhaps CAM is indeed more ideological than financial, particularly when coupled with the finding that 75% of hospitals reported that budgetary constraints are the biggest obstacle to implementing a CAM program, even though such programs can cost as little as $200,000 to start up. (One notes, in contrast, that only 43% reported that a “lack of evidence-based studies” was a major obstacle.) No wonder quackademic medicine is trying so hard to entice third party payers to reimburse for their services; if that were to happen, no doubt many CAM programs that are currently not financially viable will become viable. Perhaps, for as unrepresentative a sample as was surveyed, this survey serves the inadvertent purpose in providing evidence to suggest that the infiltration of quackademic medicine is not driven primarily by money, as skeptics and supporters of SBM (myself included) have on occasion speculated.
Maybe it really is about the ideology.

Quackademia update: The Cleveland Clinic, George Washington University, and the continued infiltration of quackery into medical academia
David Gorski on September 29, 2014
Link

Quackery has been steadily infiltrating academic medicine for at least two decades now in the form of what was once called “complementary and alternative medicine” but is now more commonly referred to as “integrative medicine.” Of course, as I’ve written many times before, what “integrative medicine” really means is the “integration” of quackery with science- and evidence-based medicine, to the detriment of SBM. As my good bud Mark Crislip once put it, “integrating” cow pie with apple pie does not improve the apple pie. Yet that is what’s going on in medical academia these days—with a vengeance. It’s a phenomenon that I like to call quackademic medicine, something that’s fast turning medical academia into medical quackademia. It is not, as its proponents claim, the “best of both worlds.”
In fact, it was my two recent publications bemoaning the infiltration of quackademic medicine into medical academia, one in Nature Reviews Cancer and one with Steve Novella in Trends in Molecular Medicine, that got me thinking again about this phenomenon. Actually, it was more my learning of yet another step deeper into quackademia by a once well-respected academic medical institution, occurring so soon after having just published two articles bemoaning that very tendency, that served as a harsh reminder of just what we’re up against. So I decided to greatly expand a post that I did for my not-so-super-secret other blog recently beyond a focus on just one institution, in order to try to demonstrate for you a bit more how and why quackery has found a comfortable place in medical academia and how, just when I thought things can’t get worse, they do. There is also room for hope in that I also found evidence that our criticisms are at least starting to be noticed. I begin with the sad tale of the Cleveland Clinic Foundation, which has gone one step beyond its previous embrace of traditional Chinese medicine. I’ll then discuss another unfortunate example, after which I’ll look a bit at the pushback and marketing of “integrative” medicine.
The Cleveland Clinic Foundation: Quackademia now reigns supreme
Quackademic medicine has been infiltrating many formerly science-based academic medical centers. Such centers have a seemingly-amazing ability to compartmentalize, insisting on rigorous science for most treatments but possessing an amazing blind spot when it comes to anything having to do with “integrative medicine.” Unfortunately, in few places is this tendency as intense as it is at the Cleveland Clinic Foundation (CCF). It’s an institution with which I have more than a passing familiarity. After all, I lived in Cleveland for eight years from the late-1980s to the mid-1990s when I did my surgery residency at the University Hospitals of Cleveland (now known as University Hospitals Case Medical Center) and my PhD at the Department of Physiology and Biophysics at Case Western Reserve University (CWRU), both of which were just down Carnegie Avenue from the CCF. I also worked part time as a flight physician for Metro Life Flight, for which a frequent destination for cardiac patients that we picked up from outlying hospitals was—you guessed it—the Cleveland Clinic. Twenty years ago, the CCF was Case’s chief rival in terms of medicine, science, and competition for patients. These days, their relationship is no longer as acrimonious as it was when I was at Case, but unfortunately the two institutions appear to have become rivals in quackademic medicine.
It’s a rivalry the CCF appears to be winning. Sure, Case has a big integrative medicine program and sponsored a meeting of the Society for Integrative Oncology and has been caught recommending reflexology, but that’s nothing compared to the CCF’s promotion of “energy healing’ (in particular reiki), acupuncture for children, and, most recently, the opening of a traditional Chinese medicine clinic run by a naturopath.
So what can CCF do to top that foray into quackademia? I really wish I hadn’t asked. The reason is that I just learned last week that the CCF has ratcheted up the pseudoscience to 11 and beyond. How? Simple. See this article in the Cleveland Plain Dealer:
In its ongoing focus on wellness and disease prevention, the Cleveland Clinic is opening a new Center for Functional Medicine. In doing so, the Clinic is the first academic medical center in the United States to embrace functional medicine, the focus of which is more on identifying underlying causes of illness and less on symptom management.
The center will work together with Clinic specialists to study the impact functional medicine has on certain chronic diseases.
Within the next few weeks, screening will begin for the first of up to 300 patients for one of four clinical trials comparing the standard treatment for asthma, inflammatory bowel disease, type 2 diabetes and migraines with that of functional medicine approaches.
The new center at the Clinic’s main campus is a collaboration between the Clinic and The Institute for Functional Medicine. Dr. Mark Hyman, chairman of The Institute for Functional Medicine, whose offices are in Washington state and New Mexico, and founder of The UltraWellness Center in Massachusetts, will serve as director of the new Center for Functional Medicine.
That’s right. The CCF has embraced the medical pseudoscience that is “functional medicine” and even hired its most famous practitioner, Dr. Mark Hyman. We’ve met Dr. Hyman before many times. For instance, he has argued for turning back the clock and relying on anecdotal medicine instead of scientific medicine and has mangled cancer research and systems biology to justify “functional medicine.” He’s also twisted autism science beyond recognition. Most recently, it’s been reported that Bill and Hillary Clinton have fallen under Dr. Hyman’s spell.
So what does this mean for CCF? Highly dubious medicine. Quackery, even. That’s what it means. Don’t believe me? Go back and read my recent description of functional medicine. Look at Wally Sampson’s multi-part analysis of what functional medicine is claimed to be here, here, here, here, and here. Basically, it’s a vaguely defined “discipline” in which it is claimed that measuring a whole bunch of metabolic factors and other lab values will lead to a “holistic” approach to disease, a situation well demonstrated by a “subspecialty” of functional medicine known as “functional endocrinology,” which involves running a number of expensive and generally unnecessary tests in order to “diagnose” various endocrine disorders and is often invoked by alternative medicine practitioners. Never mind that just what “functional medicine” actually entails is kept quite vague. That vagueness is the very thing that allows Dr. Hyman to claim:
“Functional Medicine looks at the underlying causes of disease, while focusing on the whole person rather than an isolated set of symptoms,” Hyman said in the news release. “We look at a patient’s history and the personalized interactions among genetic, environmental, and lifestyle factors that can influence long-term health and complex, chronic disease.”
The new center is a collaboration with The Institute for Functional Medicine, an organization also led by Hyman.
Or, as the press release describes:
Functional Medicine is a personalized, systems-oriented model that empowers patients and practitioners to achieve the highest expression of health by working in collaboration to address the underlying causes of disease. The primary drivers of the chronic disease epidemic are the daily interactions among an individual’s genetics, environment, and lifestyle choices. Functional medicine addresses these underlying causes of disease and equips healthcare practitioners to help their patients manage this complex, interconnected web.
Of course, “functional medicine” does nothing of the sort, at least not any better than conventional medicine. According to news reports, Hyman will only sully his shoes by setting foot in Cleveland three days a month (sorry, having lived in Cleveland, I know just how much those East Coast types like Hyman look down on it), which makes me wonder how he can be the director of anything there, much less a center at a large institution like the CCF. Not surprisingly, the CCF has hired a physician to do the day-to-day grunt work of running this new center: Dr. Patrick Hanaway, who was the chief medical officer of Genova Diagnostics from 2002-2012, a laboratory that offers all sorts of tests of, in my opinion, questionable medical value seemingly custom-made for functional medicine assessments, including a saliva adrenal stress profile, comprehensive diagnostic stool analysis, and toxic effects CORE, among others. Of course, Dr. Hanaway is an integrative “holistic” practitioner. After that, he apparently became the director of medical education for Dr. Hyman’s Institute for Functional Medicine. Frighteningly, the practice where Dr. Hanaway works offers “holistic newborn and pediatric care,” including what is characterized as “grounded discussions” on vaccines:
Each talk is facilitated by Dr. Susan Bradt or Dr. Lisa Lichtig, board certified family physicians who practice holistic medicine. We cover the hot topics of controversy including links made to autism and asthma, the ingredient thimerosal (mercury), individualizing schedules and current outbreaks of vaccine preventable disease in our community. We review each disease and its associated vaccine and discuss vaccine ingredients, school requirements and legal issues. An extensive handout is provided to supplement the class and serve as a future reference. This class is essential for all families so they can be more informed about vaccinations. It is especially helpful for parents feeling concerned or hesitant about vaccinating their children according to the standard schedule. It provides a grounded explanation of the issues and helps remove fear surrounding the topic thus helping parents navigate decision making from a more balanced and educated starting place. You will walk away with a great foundation on the topic of childhood vaccines and be able to confidently make choices that feel safe for your family.
I recognize the code words, as, I’m sure, do many of you who follow the vaccine manufactroversy from a science-based perspective. The big giveaway is that the website doesn’t dismiss the “links made to autism and asthma” (hint: there are no such links, at least none that are evidence-based) and claims to discuss “ingredients,” a sure sign that the class involves the “toxins gambit,” a fallacious gambit designed to cause fear, uncertainty, and doubt about vaccines. It’s of a piece with Dr. Hanaway’s boss Dr. Hyman’s recent foray into anti vaccine fear mongering with antivaccine crank Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.. This antivaccine effort even included an appearance on The Dr. Oz Show a mere week before the announcement of the functional medicine center at the CCF. One wonders why the CCF would hire someone who spreads such blatant antivaccine propaganda as Dr. Hyman does and who even teams up with someone who is as vociferously antivaccine as RFK, Jr. (I know antivaccine when I see it, or at least pandering to antivaccine views.)
Then there’s this:
For uncomplicated pregnancies we encourage laboring at home as long as possible with the support of a birth partner and/or doula. Once at the hospital we help create an intimate and encouraging atmosphere utilizing low lighting, freedom of movement, homeopathy, vocalization, massage, water, birthing ball and stool to support women in labor as it intensifies. Medications and epidurals are available upon request. Woman birth in a variety of positions including in the water and squatting.
Homeopathy? Water birthing? Yep, Dr. Hanaway’s partners practice “natural childbirth” woo. One wonders if the CCF will “integrate” such services into its obstetrics unit or stop being so certain about recommending vaccines to children in its pediatrics clinics. Perhaps CCF will now try to help recreate the Los Angeles experience with respect to vaccines in the Midwest.
So how on earth was someone like Dr. Hyman or Dr. Hanaway offered a job at an institution as prestigious as the CCF? Listen to the CEO of the CCF, Dr. Toby Cosgrove. He’ll tell you:
In the release, Clinic CEO Dr. Toby Cosgrove said the new center is “not a departure for Cleveland Clinic, but a continuation of the innovative, holistic approach that we have embraced.” Cosgrove cited the Clinic’s wellness institute, Center for Integrative Medicine, its Chinese herbal therapy clinic and the Center for Personalized Healthcare.
I can’t argue with this. The CCF has been traveling down the road of quackademic medicine for a long time. This new initiative is nothing more than a continuation of the “integration” of quackery into medical practice at the CCF. Cosgrove also demonstrates an attitude all too common among CAM advocates:
“What we really want is validation of what we believe to be true,” Cosgrove said.
Not: “We want to find out if this works or not.” Rather: “We want to prove this is true.” It reminds me of Tom Harkin’s famous remarks.
In any case, there’s nothing “innovative” about what CCF is doing. It’s just embracing ancient, pre-scientific medicine on the one hand (the traditional Chinese medicine clinic) and taking the worst “shotgun” testing modern medicine has to offer, cranking it up to 11 and beyond, and calling it “functional medicine.” The idea seems to be to check as many lab values as possible until something is found to be wrong (as it will be with virtually everyone if you check enough lab values) and then to “treat it,” labeling the “treatment” as somehow “holistic.”
I can’t argue that CCF isn’t a “trailblazer,” though. Unfortunately, it’s a trailblazer in introducing quackery into conventional medicine. Cosgrove ought to rename the CCF to the Cleveland Quackademic Clinic. Former rival of my surgical and doctoral alma mater the CCF might be, but it is sad for me to contemplate the decline of this once-great institution. It has fallen for the fallacious argument, beloved of proponents of “integrative medicine” that, because current medicine has problems with providing the “human touch” and in some cases dealing with chronic disease, “integrating” quackery into science-based medicine is the only answer. No wonder John Weeks (you remember John Weeks, don’t you?) is busily declaring this new center at the CCF a “tipping point” for integrative medicine.
George Washington University does the CCF one better
From my vantage point it’s depressingly true that the CCF has gotten very, very bad indeed with respect to its promotion of medical pseudoscience. Besides its traditional Chinese medicine clinic and its Center for Functional Medicine, just take a look at its Center for Integrative Medicine, which offers chiropractic, acupuncture, and the magical faith healing that is reiki. If you really want to see how far gone the CCF is, just read its Reiki Factsheet.)
Then look at the Center for Integrative Medicine at the George Washington University Medical Center (GWCIM). Compared to the GWCIM, the CCF’s integrative medicine program looks like a bastion of science-based medicine. GWCIM’s list of services includes acupuncture (of course!), chiropractic, craniosacral therapy, infrared light therapies, glutathione infusions, Myers’ Cocktail, naturopathy (again, of course!), reiki, intravenous high dose vitamin C, and genetic profile results that include “customized interpretation of 23andme.com genetic profile results with specific accent on methylation and detoxification profiles.” It’s a truly horrifying website to contemplate, given how little of it has any resemblance to science-based medicine and how much of it includes outright quackery like reiki. Perhaps even the GWCIM is a bit embarrassed, because it can’t even provide a correct description of reiki:
Reiki describes both a harmonizing energy and a non-invasive therapy which involves the placing of hands in a sequence of locations on or near the body. It is not massage, as the hands remain stationary at each position.
The purpose of Reiki is to promote the client’s own natural healing process by providing deep relaxation, abatement of signs or symptoms of distress, or instilling a sense of harmony and balance. Reiki can be used in conjunction with any other treatment to enhance and accelerate its effectiveness.
No, reiki is faith healing that substitutes Eastern mystical beliefs for Christian beliefs, as I like to point out any time a discussion of reiki comes up. At least the CCF describes the magic that is the channeling of “healing energy” from the “universal source” more or less correctly.
I perused what GWCIM writes about a few other modalities, and its website’s descriptions of various alternative medicine modalities are depressingly and similarly credulous. Acupuncture is described as being used for “for treatment of respiratory, digestive, urinary and reproductive systems, as well as the disorders of muscle tone, hormone production, circulation, and allergic responses” plus “pain relief, gynecological conditions and symptoms, insomnia, anxiety, and to enhance wellness.” Naturopathy is described as a “comprehensive approach to health and healing that combines modern scientific knowledge with traditional and natural forms of medicine,” with naturopaths addressing “the mental, emotional and physical aspects of an individual, and aim to treat the root causes as well as the symptoms of illness.” According to GWCIM, naturopaths are “trained as primary care doctors at accredited four-year naturopathic medical schools.” They are not. Their training is inadequate and usually consists of as little as 20 days of primary care practice during their third or fourth years of naturopathy school. Meanwhile naturopaths embrace the four humors and tend to be staunchly antivaccine with rare “sort of” exceptions. Doesn’t GWCIM know that? Or doesn’t it care? Apparently not.
Indeed, look at what GWCIM says about high-dose intravenous vitamin C therapy for cancer. After citing in vitro and animal studies that are not particularly compelling and then claiming that there are “several case reports published in peer-reviewed medical journals that meet quality standards set by the National Cancer Institute” that “demonstrate that a small number of patients have responded to a high dose IV Vit-C infusion treatment after all other treatments have failed” (which is patently incorrect, as these cases are as unconvincing as Stanislaw Burzynski cases), all the while admitting that there aren’t any compelling randomized clinical trials, GWCIM writes that in practice:
Based on a vast pool of clinical experience, IV administration of high dose Vit-C has been shown to essentially have no side effects, unlike chemotherapy drugs and radiation therapy. Since IV Vit-C works just like chemotherapy and radiation therapy by releasing free radicals, there are no contraindications for their simultaneous use. In fact, Vit-C may work synergistically with chemotherapy and potentiate its effect.
However, there are some disadvantages. The course of therapy is long and intense, two to three times per week (2 hours each) and for the duration of about a year. It can cost over $20,000 for a year-long course of treatment if it is not covered by an insurance.
When evaluating new innovative cancer treatments we need to ensure that three basic requirements are met:
One: There is a clinical plausibility, i.e., credible case reports exist.
Two: There is a biological plausibility, i.e., the mechanism of action is clear.
Three: Proven clinical effectiveness, i.e., a randomized controlled trial has been conducted.
High dose IV Vit-C therapy has met the first two requirements. It is unfortunate that it would take many years before the last step can be accomplished.
We feel compelled to offer this treatment to patients when there are no other choices even though the definitive clinical evidence of its effectiveness is not yet available.
Clinical plausibility? Intravenous vitamin C might not be homeopathy-grade implausible, but it’s not particularly plausible either. As I like to say frequently, vitamin C, even if it worked, would be a really long run for a short slide, given the incredibly high concentration of ascorbate that’s ever been shown to have in vitro anticancer activity. If vitamin C were anything other than “natural,” doctors would have abandoned it a very long time ago as far more trouble than its minimal-to-nonexistent promise warrants. Achieving such concentrations is difficult, and it is not without side effects, contrary to GWCIM’s claims. I therefore call nonsense on number one. As for biological plausibility, the mechanism is anything but clear. It could be generation of free radicals, but there are also studies suggesting that ascorbate could interfere with chemotherapy, as the Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center integrative medicine web page acknowledges as it says that high dose vitamin C shouldn’t be used outside of a clinical trial. I call nonsense on number two. Finally, while it’s true that there hasn’t been a large randomized clinical trial for vitamin C for cancer, there has been a phase I/II clinical trial that was basically negative, as I described earlier this year. So I call nonsense on number three as well.
In other words, there is no reason for oncologists at GWCIM to “feel compelled” to offer this treatment, especially given that GWCIM admits that there is no definitive clinical evidence of its effectiveness, particularly considering that, contrary to what GWCIM claims, high dose ascorbate is not without the potential for adverse events. None of this stops GWCIM from recommending high dose vitamin C for the treatment of “a variety of infections as an adjunctive modality.” I fear that GWCIM interprets the science of alternative medicines in the same way it interprets the evidence on vitamin C as a cancer treatment: Through wishful thinking and the most positive spin possible on a body of evidence that does not support their efficacy. Oh, and you can detox, possibly get chelation therapy, and help study reiki at GWCIM, too!
See why I’m depressed?
Integrative medicine advocates strike back
Three years ago, I wrote a post in which I characterized integrative medicine as a “brand, not a specialty.” In it, I described how in the 1990s “alternative medicine” was rebranded as “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) and, over the last few years, has been further rebranded as “integrative medicine,” which is frequently portrayed by advocates as the “best of both worlds.” It’s not that kind of “best of both worlds,” but rather this kind, with integrative medicine “assimilating” what should be—and usually is—science-based medicine, such as nutrition, exercise, and natural products into itself and fusing it with a purpose inimical to science-based medicine.
Glenn Sabin apparently doesn’t like such arguments. And, to be fair, there could be counterarguments based on sound reasoning and evidence. Unfortunately, Sabin appears incapable of offering them. Instead, he proclaims that there are “dwindling skeptics,” using what I like to call the logical fallacy known as the bandwagon fallacy. It’s a fallacy Sabin embraces with gusto:
This phenomenon is fueled by growing patient demand and an emerging cadre of integrative-trained clinicians. Patients across the spectrum of conditions and pathologies consistently experience quality outcomes vis-à-vis these services delivered by a wide range of licensed integrative health disciplines.
I like to respond to this sort of argument thusly: You know what else and who else were enormously popular? Yep, Nazi-ism and Hitler. No, I’m not claiming that integrative medicine is in any way like Nazi-ism. It is simply a suitably and intentionally overblown comparison designed to demonstrate the ridiculousness of appeals to popularity like Sabin’s as an argument. Just because something is popular does not mean it is evidence-based or good. It might be, but it also very well might not be. To take another example, half the people in the US do not believe in evolution. Does that mean evolution is not valid science? Of course not. All an appeal to popularity means is that something is popular, and often that popularity in such appeals is exaggerated.
As happy as Sabin is about the seeming “popularity” of integrative medicine, he’s equally ticked off about criticisms that it’s nothing more than a “rebranding” of quackery:
These skeptics darkly describe a continuous ‘rebranding’ of the field: from alternative medicine, to complementary alternative medicine (CAM) to the integrative health and medicine field of today. It’s not a rebranding. It’s an evolution. Some view it more like a revolution. This is about patient-centered health creation and self-efficacy. It’s the natural progression towards greater population health.
That’s right! New Coke wasn’t a rebranding! It was an evolution! Actually, the rationale for recent proposal by that the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) be renamed the “National Center for Research on Complementary and Integrative Health” sure sounds like a rebranding:
We see the growth of integrative health care within communities across the US, including hospitals, hospices, and military health facilities. With these changes in the research and practice landscape, we believe that our current name no longer accurately reflects our Congressional mandate, which is, in part, to study the integration of these practices as a complement to conventional care.
We also recognize that our current name is not explicit about our research mission, and that it may be misconstrued as advocacy or promotion of unproven practices.
As I pointed out at the time, this is the very same rationale that’s been used since time immemorial (or at least over the last 30 years or so that has seen the rise of CAM and quackademic medicine) every time a name change for “alternative” medicine has been proposed. As I’ve also pointed out, the reason for this continual rebranding of quackery is that words have power.
Sabin is also off base when he writes:
Naysayers declare that nutrition and exercise are neither “alternative” nor “integrative”; that they’ve always been part and parcel of “plain medicine”; that integrative and lifestyle medicine physicians are “coopting conventional medicine!” The truth is that a mere fifty years ago our food was largely unadulterated, grown in fertile soil and much more nutritious. People were generally more active and doctors were teachers (”teacher” actually comes from the Latin word for doctor”). Unfortunately “the teaching” aspect is largely missing today and nutrition, exercise and psycho-social counseling play no central role in the practice of conventional medicine.
Food fifty years ago was unadulterated? What about the concerns about pollution and pesticide use back then that led, in part, to the dawn of the environmental movement and stricter laws and regulations? Wonder Bread was more nutritious? Nutrition, exercise, and psycho-social counseling play “no central role in the practice of conventional medicine”? Whatever Sabin is smoking, I’d want some were it not that I can’t inhale. If psychosocial counseling plays “no central role” in, for instance, oncology, then why is it that the American College of Surgeons Commission on Cancer’s (ACS CoC’s) requirements for cancer program certification now include standards for psychosocial distress screening, survivorship care plans including addressing patients’ psychosocial needs, risk assessment, nutrition services, and physical activity and weight loss programs? Why does the ACS CoC also require education programs regarding cancer awareness and prevention to meet the needs of the community? Why is it, as I mentioned in my NRC paper, that the standard of care for prediabetes and recently diagnosed type II diabetes includes dietary interventions and encouragement of exercise? Sabin is just plain incorrect.
I can’t help but wonder if at some level Sabin knows that we “skeptics” (or, as he calls us, “cynics”) have a point, given that he writes this about us:
Perhaps they’ll refocus their energies on the real perpetuators of medical quackery: those unprincipled charlatans who often rob their patients of life and treasure with ineffective or dangerous products, agents, interventions or ideology in lieu of proven curative and often life-saving standard of care interventions.
One wonders if he means Stanislaw Burzynski. Or perhaps he means treatments like Nicholas Gonzalez’s treatments. Probably not. He does, however, castigate us for this:
I would like to see better attention paid to the contraindications between natural and formulated pharma agents, or a deeper scientific dive into the controversy surrounding antioxidant adjuvant chemotherapy and radiation therapy, and, um, less on whether acupuncture works or if Reiki’s really helpful with reducing stress and anxiety. Clearly, if patients benefit and there are no significant safety concerns, who really cares exactly how they work? (I’m not implying that scientists should stop investigating these matters. I’m emphasizing the primacy of favorable patient outcomes.)
One wonders whether Sabin doesn’t want us paying so much attention to reiki and acupuncture because, deep in his heart, he knows almost as well as skeptics do that they are quackery based on prescientific mystical belief systems. Unfortunately, as I pointed out above and can be found on SBM in other discussions of reiki quackery at the CCF, University of Arizona, and elsewhere, acupuncture and reiki are some of the most commonly-offered alternative medical modality in quackademic medicine. Notice how he also seems to be admitting that these modalities are placebo modalities, asking “Just because some health creation programs, processes and interventions (especially those based on whole systems) do not perfectly align with the traditional random controlled, double-blinded pharma model of reductionist scientific discovery, does it cancel out the patient’s positive outcome?”
The problem is that the positive outcomes touted have not been demonstrated to be due to these modalities, and, as Steve Novella, Harriet Hall, Mark Crislip, and I have discussed repeatedly, placebo effects are subjective effects, require deception, and are simply being “rebranded” as “self-healing” and the “power of positive thinking.” It’s a narrative being sold by people like Sabin.
Finally, I can’t help but note that Sabin himself has admitted that the name “integrative medicine” is a “rebranding of CAM in an article entitled “CAM Is Dead“:
Today several integrative centers across the country still contain the words CAM in their name. This is both confusing to health consumers and damaging for these centers’ brand. Most clinics and centers launched during the last decade have evolved with their branding to include today’s more appropriate terminology of “integrative medicine”, “integrative services” or “integrative therapies”.
The bold text is Sabin’s not mine. As I pointed out at the time, Sabin basically admitted that the term “integrative medicine” is about the marketing of quackery. This is not surprising, given that Sabin is the founder of FON Therapeutics, a company that exists for this purpose:
FON is dedicated to positioning integrative health organizations for long term growth while advancing evidence-based integrative medicine as the standard of care.
A leading business development consulting firm, FON specializes in customized solutions—focused on growing patient volume, program and product sales—driven by innovative marketing, messaging and branded storytelling, all rooted in fiscally viable business models that work.
FON offers an e-book by Sabin entitled Grow Your Integrative Medicine Business by Telling Bigger Stories (wow, I wonder if Sabin knows what that sounds like) and a white paper on ‘How to Increase Clinic Utilization of Integrative Medicine Services in 60 Days“, while expressing admiration for the Cancer Treatment Centers of America as the 800-pound marketing gorilla. FON is a marketing company, offering all sorts of marketing services to integrative medical centers, pointing out the economic potential of integrative medicine as being projected to reach $50 billion annually. Indeed, in Weeks’ article on the Hyman-CCF partnership, Sabin worries:
Sabin then raised some questions about the intersection of typical functional medicine business practices with the Cleveland Clinic culture. He noted that in Hyman’s private clinic an office visit with the doctor to the Clintons can run pretty steep. It’s $1,500 for 80 minutes with Hyman. Fifty minutes with a nutritionist will set you back $240. Hyman’s clinic does not accept insurance. Hyman’s business model also includes profiting from supplement sales, from which he donates a portion for functional medicine research.
Sabin adds a further question: “How deep will Cleveland Clinic go in terms of embracing a model of comprehensive functional labs looking at biochemical milieu to inform recommendations of well-placed nutraceuticals.” Such lab work-ups can also be quite expensive for patients even as are the bags of natural medicines that are typically part of functional medicine therapeutic regimes.
Although ideology and a misguided view that to become more “holistic” one must embrace quackery seem to be driving the infiltration of quackery into medical academia, we must never forget that there is a clever and sophisticated marketing campaign behind it as well. Does anyone think that the CCF would have embraced Mark Hyman if it didn’t think he can make the hospital significant money? I doubt it, Mark Hyman’s anecdote about how he told the CCF’s Cosgrove that it “probably didn’t want him there” notwithstanding, and I bet Sabin would agree with this point at least. As much as advocates claim that it’s not just about the money, it’s also about the money.

Integrative medicine advocates react to criticisms of the Samuelis’ $200 million gift to UC-Irvine
Last month, Susan and Henry Samueli donated $200 million to the University of California, Irvine to promote integrative medicine. We were pleasantly surprised by the unflattering coverage in the press of the gift. We were unpleasantly unsurprised by the reaction of integrative medicine advocates to the criticism.
David Gorski on October 16, 2017
Link

[Editor’s note: This post might seem familiar to some because it appeared on my not-so-secret other blog in other forms. I apologize, as I pride myself on producing new material for SBM every week, but I do have a good excuse. I’m currently in Manchester, England, having just finished attending QEDCon, where I gave a talk on integrative medicine. There just wasn’t time to do more material.]
John Weeks has long been an activist for what is now known as “integrative medicine,” earlier known as “complementary and alternative medicine”(CAM). Basically, for many years Mr. Weeks has been at the forefront of encouraging the “integration” of quackery with real medicine and promoting what I like to refer to as “quackademic medicine,” a perfect term to describe the increasing encroachment of pseudoscience and quackery in medical academia in the form of—you guessed it—integrative medicine. For some bizarre reason in May 2016 he was appointed editor of the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine (JACM), even though he has zero background in science or medicine of a type that one would expect in a journal editor. Once there, he wasted little time comparing doctors advocating science-based medicine and opposing pseudoscience in medicine to Donald Trump.
Fast forward a year and a half, when the University of California, Irvine (UCI) accepted a $200 million gift from Susan and Henry Samueli to vastly expand the integrative medicine offerings at UCI (which were already quite extensive) in the form of establishing the Susan and Henry Samueli College of Health Sciences, with the current Susan Samueli Center for Integrative Medicine becoming the Susan Samueli Integrative Health Institute. Amazingly, it wasn’t just skeptics like Steve Novella writing negative articles about this development. Michael Hiltzik of the LA Times wrote an article in which Dr. Novella and I were quoted with a lovely headline, “A $200-million donation threatens to tar UC Irvine’s medical school as a haven for quacks.” Elsewhere, Usha Lee McFarling over at STAT News chimed in with a story with a somewhat less critical but still quite unflattering headline, “A $200 million gift promotes alternative therapies at a California medical school — and critics recoil.” Both articles contrasted the claims by Dr. Howard Federoff, CEO of UC Irvine’s health system that the new institute and college will be rigorously evidence-based with the reality of the homeopathy offered by UCI. Hiltzik, amusingly, pointed out how UCI was trying to send references to homeopathy on its website down the memory hole and failing miserably. Meanwhile, Rick Seltzer at Inside Higher Ed quoted Steve Novella as he asked, “Does $200 million quack?” (My answer: Yes. Very loudly. And, yes, I used that line in my talk at QEDCon.)
Steven, of course, used this story to point out that UCI has long embraced homeopathy. Also, because all naturopaths are trained in homeopathy, you can’t have naturopathy without homeopathy. Those of us who know how deeply “integrated” (couldn’t resist) quackery is in naturopathy couldn’t help but point out that Dr. Federoff’s claim that UCI’s new integrative medicine effort will be rigorously evidence-based is complete and utter bullshit unless UCI gets rid of naturopaths, at least as a start. Also, given that the Samuelis are very much believers in homeopathy, so much so that they mentioned support for research into homeopathy in one of their gift agreements with UCI in 2004, I highly doubt that UCI could dump homeopathy very easily even if Dr. Federoff wanted to. Indeed, given Dr. Federoff’s long history of integrating quackery into medicine at Georgetown, which was his gig before he moved to UCI, I doubt that Dr. Federoff is particularly serious about getting rid of the quackery, anyway. It’s now too entrenched.
This sort of coverage clearly enraged poor Mr. Weeks, who goes to great lengths to project a facade of civility in comparison to all the “anger” he portrays on “our” side. Indeed, his facade slipped so much that he misspelled Mr. Hiltzik’s name alternatively as “Hitzig” and “Tiltzig” in a post published—where else?—that original wretched hive of scum and quackery, The Huffington Post, in the form of an article entitled “Shameful Media Response to the Samueli’s Visionary $200-Million Integrative Health Investment at UC Irvine,” in which he refers to critics of integrative medicine as “antiscience” and as “having blood on our hands.” You can get a taste from the introduction:
The response of the LA Times, STAT, Medpage, and most media to the visionary $200-million integrative health investment of Susan and Henry Samueli at UC Irvine has been a shameful display of media descent into Trump-like, polarizing tweets. Worse yet, the coverage has been a profoundly anti-science. These media, and others, have chosen to provide platforms to a small handful of individuals who for decades have denied the evidence of acupuncture, chiropractic, mind-body and multiple other integrative approaches.
Mr. Weeks is nothing if not predictable. These days, to him any criticism of integrative medicine is “Trump-like” and “polarizing.” This is the schtick he came up with last year, before the election and continuing after it. To this recent but now familiar trope, Mr. Weeks adds a new epithet: “Anti-science.” In essence, he is doing exactly what climate science denialisms and antivaxers do: Try to flip the narrative and portray themselves as the true defenders of scientific inquiry and their critics as close-minded dogmatic skeptics who will not consider all the evidence. This is, of course, nonsense when antivaxers and climate science denialists do it, and it’s no less ridiculous when Mr. Weeks does it. Also, note how Mr. Weeks also tries to minimize the criticism by minimizing the critics, referring to us dismissively as a “small handful of individuals,” in order to portray us as being a tiny minority who can safely be ignored. Elsewhere in his article, he refers to Medscape “bleating” out a link to McFarling’s article in STAT. (Get it? We’re sheeple.) Sadly, Mr. Weeks’ tactics are all mind-numbingly obvious, but at this point in his jeremiad, Mr. Weeks turns out to be just getting started. It doesn’t take him long to work himself into a fine lather:
From his LA Times podium, Michael Hiltzig first gives voice to David Gorski and then to Steven Novella, long-time colleagues and back-slapping companions as anti-integrative medicine vigilantes. Hiltzig quotes Gorski first, shaping the Samueli’s investment this way: “The only reason ‘integrative medicine’ exists is to integrate quackery into medicine.” Tiltzig immediately turns to Novella to use the Trumpish, name-calling term that Gorski himself favors: “In a blog post, Novella flayed UCI’s establishment of an integrative medicine curriculum as ’quackademic medicine.’”
“Back-slapping companions as anti-integrative medicine vigilantes”? I laughed out loud when I read that line. Maybe we should change the name of the blog from Science-Based Medicine to Vigilante-Based Medicine. On second thought, SBM is such a nice abbreviation. The whole “vigilante” charge, though, is meant to further demonize Steve and me, who slap each other on the back like dudebros after each new takedown of integrative medicine. Maybe next he’ll portray us as bumping chests and shouting, like football fans. (Seriously, could Mr. Weeks be any more obvious?)
The answer, apparently, is no:
It would be one thing if this were just journalistic laziness. Sure, go ahead and run polarizing copy based on a tweetish view of the universe that makes a story fit for afternoon TV. In fact, however, these media have chosen to trumpet fake news. They promote this polarizing grandstanding rather than honor the emerging scientific consensus that is yet poorly integrated into health professional education and practice – and that utterly backs the Samuelis’ investment and direction at UC Irvine:
He then cites four references that actually show how deeply embedded quackery has become in medicine, thanks to the efforts of people like Mr. Weeks. For instance, he mentions the Joint Commission’s 2015 revision of its pain management standard that recommends nonpharmacologic approaches to pain, and mentions acupuncture, chiropractic, and osteopathic manipulation. Now, I’ve discussed many times before how integrative medicine mavens have latched on to the opioid crisis as an opportunity to expand their influence by rebranding CAM/integrative medicine as “nonpharmacologic approaches to pain.” Indeed, the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Medicine (NCCIH) enshrined this in its 2016-2021 strategic plan. Ever since the opioid crisis inserted itself into the national consciousness, proponents of integrative medicine have seen a golden opportunity to use it to further the integration of quackery into medicine. Only they want to be seen as science-based; so when programs like the one at UCI are caught advertising The One Quackery To Rule Them All, homeopathy, they scramble to hide the evidence of it.
Mr. Weeks makes a great show of mentioning guidelines published by the Mayo Clinic, which, if anything, showed that the “complementary” approaches to pain examined do not have an effect greater than placebo. Truly, it was an awful review article. Predictably, he also mentioned the American College of Physicians guidelines for low back pain. I can’t help but note that those recommendations characterized evidence base for acupuncture, for example, as low quality evidence, moderate at best, and cited the GERAC Study, which basically showed that acupuncture does not work. Another mixed “electroacupuncture” (which is basically TENS) with acupuncture. Truly this was thin gruel for the ACP. Finally, he referred to the National Academy of Medicine’s review on nonpharmacological approaches to pain. I perused it. It misrepresents the evidence base for acupuncture in a far too favorable a fashion, for instance claiming that recent “reviews and meta-analyses examining the effect of acupuncture on musculoskeletal pain (neck and back pain, osteoarthritis, chronic headache and shoulder pain, fibromyalgia) have found that overall, acupuncture is superior to sham and no acupuncture, but with relatively modest differences between true and sham acupuncture.” Yes, the NAM cited the Vickers meta-analysis, which showed that acupuncture doesn’t work, with no clinically significant effect on pain, although the conclusion was spun to be the exact opposite. Yes, Mr. Weeks is doing what any “thought leader” in integrative medicine has to do: Exaggerate or even misrepresent the evidence base supporting the quackery that integrative medicine is seeking to add to medicine.
Up until now, Mr. Weeks didn’t actually anger me. Rather, he amused me, as he recycled the same tired, dubious arguments that he’s always used, complete with his dismissive comparison of critics of integrative medicine to Donald Trump, which he’s now done so often that to me it’s a cliché. Indeed, I’m half tempted to make a drinking game out of Mr. Weeks’ references to Donald Trump as a means of denigrating his opponents: Take a drink each time he compares our writing to Trump or to Tweets. The only problem is that playing the game would probably put me at risk for alcohol poisoning.
Here’s where Mr. Weeks actually managed to anger me. It’s hard for an apologist for quackery to do, but Mr. Weeks managed it:
The roundhouse, condemnatory, “quackademic” perspectives of Gorski, Novella, Caulfield and their like toward complementary and integrative health and medicine need to be treated and dismissed by the LA Times and others as the anti-science that they are. Sure, discussion can be engaged over specific approaches or therapies. Yet giving a platform to this broad dismissal of the Sameulis’ investment is no different than repeatedly quoting non-believers in climate change at the top of an article about a massive, exciting effort to correct human environmental degradation.
And while the scale is different, both forms of science denial have blood on their hands. The residual, reactive, medical ideology of these anti-integrative careerists to which the LA Times and others give a platform is a barrier to potentially lifesaving directions toward which the Joint Commission-Mayo/NIH-American College of Physicians-NAM-Attorneys General jointly urge us – and the Samueli investment would propel us.
What utter cluelessness.
We’re doctors. Mr. Weeks is not. We save lives. Mr. Weeks does not. I’m a medical researcher. Mr. Weeks is not. I can deal with his unwarranted attacks on us as “antiscience.” I can laugh at them, even. I know we have the data, the science, and reason on our side. Also, contrary to how we are portrayed, we do not dismiss massage, mindfulness, exercise, diet, or other lifestyle aspects of integrative medicine. We merely point out that they are more appropriately a part of science-based medicine and that integrative medicine is “rebranding” them as somehow being “alternative” or “integrative” and then throwing in quackery like acupuncture, reiki, naturopathy, and the like. The purpose, of course, is to legitimize quackery. That’s why I say that there is no reason for integrative medicine to exist other than to provide a vessel through which quackery can be integrated into medicine.
As for being an “anti-integrative medicine careerist,” I view this as a thinly disguised variant of the “pharma shill” gambit, in which Mr. Weeks insinuates that we must be biased because we’ve made a career out of being “anti-integrative medicine.” Would this sort of thing were even possible! Seriously, though, Mr. Weeks should look at my publication record. Only two of my publications indexed on PubMed can be characterized as even being about integrative medicine. However, Mr. Weeks’ little tirade has med me think that maybe I should try much harder to publish more of this in the peer-reviewed scientific literature. The reason I haven’t is because I’m not an “anti-integrative medicine careerist.” Maybe I should become one, except that I’d call it being a pro-science careerist.
To get an idea of where Mr. Weeks comes from, he repeats a number of anti-medicine tropes. For instance, he does his best to paint critics of integrative medicine as a discipline as not caring about prevention. That’s an old chestnut, because integrative medicine proponents have tried very hard to rebrand any sort of interventions to prevent disease as their bailiwick. He also cites a BMJ paper concluding that medical errors result in 251,000 deaths per year and are the third largest cause of death in the US, clearly having selected that particular paper because it has one of the largest numbers of deaths estimated anywhere in the literature. (Über-quacks Mike Adams, Gary Null, and Joe Mercola would be proud.) As I pointed out when this study was published in 2016, the methodology used to calculate this number was highly questionable, at best, and basically custom-designed to inflate the number of deaths due to medical error, particularly through misattribution of the cause; i.e., mischaracterization of complications that had nothing to do with medical error as being due to error.
Mr. Weeks then defends the poor, put-upon Samuelis as being philanthropists of the highest order, listing their charitable donations over the last two decades. No one is denying that the Samuelis have made worthwhile charitable donations over the last 25 years. It is not those particular donations that I and people like Steve Novella and Tim Caulfield have a problem with. Rather, it is the Samuelis’ repeated donations in the cause of furthering integrative medicine that we criticize. Remember, as has been pointed out in multiple articles, the Samuelis are true believers in The One Quackery To Rule Them All, homeopathy. Does Mr. Weeks think that homeopathy is science-based? I’m sorry, but you cannot credibly claim the mantle of science if you believe in homeopathy. Period. You just can’t. You can try, but you will be called out, even laughed at—and deservedly so. Homeopathy is quackery based on concepts of vitalism and sympathetic magic.
Mr. Weeks concludes:
Reporters: stop giving a platform to anti-science. Do us all a favor and get serious, and scientific, about your reporting of an investment of the Samuelis at UC Irvine that – despite this apparently necessary stone throwing – may prove to be the most influential philanthropic investment in the substantial course correction that US academic medicine and medical industry need.
Actually, that’s what I’m afraid of, that the Samueli investment will be the most influential philanthropic donation in medicine. I’ll show you what I mean.
Quackery in medical education
One aspect of quackademic medicine that I probably don’t write about as much as I should is the “integration” of quackery into the curricula of medical schools. Part of the reason for that, I suspect, is that I am fortunate enough to be faculty at a medical school and cancer center that remain relatively untouched by the pseudoscience of integrative medicine. True, our medical school does have at least one credulous lecture about “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) that the medical students have to imbibe, but it really is pretty close to the bare minimum required by the accrediting agencies. Oh, yes. Proponents of integrative medicine have been so successful that one requirement for accreditation by the Liaison Committee on Medical Education (LCME) is that there be adequate instruction about CAM. Actually, that’s not quite true. Among the educational objectives in the LCME requirements is ED-10: “The curriculum of a medical education program must include behavioral and socioeconomic subjects in addition to basic science and clinical disciplines.” This is where CAM and integrative medicine are slipped in. That’s because the Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine and Health successfully lobbied the LCME to include CAM in its list of topics addressed in the LCME Medical Education Database relative to accreditation standard ED-10. Unfortunately, how that is done in practice is often in the form of entirely credulous teaching of CAM.
Here’s where the Samueli donation comes in. The purpose of the Samuelis’ $200 million donation is to create a college of health sciences that will encompass several UCI schools, including its school of medicine and nursing school, dedicated to “integrating” quackery at all levels into medicine thusly:
The Samuelis’ gift will provide $50 million toward construction of a facility to house the college and $5 million for state-of-the-art technology and labs – forming the foundation of a national showcase for integrative health. It also earmarks $145 million to create an endowment for:
    • Up to 15 faculty chairs across the medicine, nursing, pharmacy and population health disciplines for senior, midcareer and junior faculty with expertise in integrative health
    • Integrative health training and mentoring for interested medical school students
    • Scholarships and fellowships for undergraduate and graduate students planning careers in related fields
    • Innovative curricular development and campuswide interdisciplinary research projects
    • Ongoing clinical services, research and education in the Susan Samueli Integrative Health Institute, including investigations of nonconventional interventions as part of medical treatment and educating medical and lay communities about benefits and risks associated with new healthcare approaches
Here’s the one that should concern all physicians and advocates interested in promoting science in medicine, number 3: “innovative curricular development.” That’s CAM-speak for teaching CAM alongside real medicine as though homeopathy has scientific validity. This brings us to an article by noted cheerleader for “integrative medicine” Glenn Sabin, “Integrative health’s place in the medical school curriculum.” If you want to know where Sabin’s coming from, consider my previous discussions related to his promotion of alternative medicine, such as his “history” of the integration of quackery with medicine and his advocacy for anecdotal evidence disguised as “N-of-1 trials” over clinical trials in determining if various alternative medicines “work.” He also first got my attention for openly admitting that integrative medicine is a brand, not a specialty. Also consider this paragraph from his latest:
My colleague, John Weeks, wrote a terrific response in Huffington Post to the media’s shameful coverage of the visionary and game-changing Samueli gift to UCI. He cogently supports his position with actual research, facts, and developments that illustrate just how out-of-touch these dwindling skeptics are—and how a few media outlets took the bait that led them down a narrow-minded narrative centering on one controversial therapy: homeopathy.
For me, though, the back-and-forth with the cynics is not worth the expended energy. This is not just about acupuncture or chiropractic or massage or dietary supplements. It’s much bigger.
The Samueli gift is about the future of health, led by the doctors of tomorrow, like my nephew, Max, who is in his first year of medical school at George Washington University.
Homeopathy is not “controversial.” It is rank pseudoscience. This is not even in dispute. Just look at the way UCI started furiously scrubbing its websites of references to homeopathy as soon as critics started looking at the Samuelis’ gift in detail. Clearly, the administration was embarrassed. I also note that one earlier gift agreement between the Samuelis to UCI explicitly mentioned that it was to be used to promote research into homeopathy, among other pseudoscientific modalities and that until recently UCI advertised the services of a naturopath and homeopath on its website. Even proponents of integrating quackery into medicine are embarrassed by homeopathy.
When discussing the “integration” of quackery into medical school, I like to discuss another “George” university namely Georgetown. In many ways, it was a “trailblazer” in “integrating” quackery into medicine. I recounted its history just a couple of years ago, citing a 2003 Georgetown brochure:
One of the reasons CAM is usually offered as an elective is that there’s just no time or room in U.S. medical schools to fit in one more massive subject,” says Michael Lumpkin, Ph.D., professor and chair of the department of physiology and biophysics at Georgetown. “When the course is an elective, a self-selected group – maybe 10 or 20 students in a class of 180 medical students – will take it,” Lumpkin says. “What we’ve tried at Georgetown is rather than create all new courses, we take relevant CAM issues and modalities and weave them seamlessly into existing courses.
The “seamless” weaving of CAM into existing classes includes, for instance, a presentation by an acupuncturist on the “anatomy of acupuncture” in the gross anatomy course for first-year students. The same lecturer explores acupuncture’s application in pain relief in the neuroscience course…
Haramati and Lumpkin say Georgetown’s program is distinct from CAM initiatives in other medical schools in two ways: The school is integrating CAM education into existing course work across all four years of each student’s medical education, and the initiative includes a mind-body class to help students use techniques to manage their own health and improve self-care.
Yes, fourteen years ago, Georgetown was “integrating” pseudoscience into its medical school curriculum at every level, starting from day one. Twelve years later, it was celebrating pseudoscience on the cover of the medical school’s magazine. That’s not all, though. Reflexology is taught as fact, along with prescientific medical systems, such as traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), “energy healing” like reiki and therapeutic touch, and pretty much every “integrative” quackery you can think of. In 2007, Georgetown partnered with the naturopathy school Bastyr University to train the next generation of integrative medicine practitioners.
This is the sort of future of medicine that Weeks and Sabin so strongly desire.
It’s also not as though George Washington University isn’t itself a bastion of quackademic medicine. Three years ago, I wrote about all the quackery advertised on its website. GWCIM’s list of services includes acupuncture (of course!), chiropractic, craniosacral therapy, infrared light therapies, glutathione infusions, Myers’ Cocktail, naturopathy (again, of course!), reiki, intravenous high dose vitamin C, and genetic profile results that include “customized interpretation of 23andme.com genetic profile results with specific accent on methylation and detoxification profiles.” It’s a truly horrifying website to contemplate, given how little of it has any resemblance to science-based medicine and how much of it includes outright quackery like reiki. In addition, its website’s descriptions of various alternative medicine modalities are depressingly and similarly credulous. Acupuncture is described as being used for “for treatment of respiratory, digestive, urinary and reproductive systems, as well as the disorders of muscle tone, hormone production, circulation, and allergic responses” plus “pain relief, gynecological conditions and symptoms, insomnia, anxiety, and to enhance wellness.” Naturopathy is described as a “comprehensive approach to health and healing that combines modern scientific knowledge with traditional and natural forms of medicine,” with naturopaths addressing “the mental, emotional and physical aspects of an individual, and aim to treat the root causes as well as the symptoms of illness.” According to GWCIM, naturopaths are “trained as primary care doctors at accredited four-year naturopathic medical schools.”
No. They. Aren’t.
I also can’t help but note that John Weeks’ article is the very same one I started this post discussing, in which Weeks accused us of having “blood on our hands.” Apparently, Sabin approves of such rhetoric, as long as it’s directed against his opponents.
Sabin’s article is yet another example of how “integrative medicine” rebrands science-based modalities, such as nutrition, exercise, and lifestyle modification as somehow “alternative” or “integrative” and then uses them as the vehicle in which quackery is also “integrated” into medicine, while trying to dismiss anyone who points out the pseudoscience as the “old guard—the few out-of-touch, aging critics pushing back.” (I note that Sabin and Weeks aren’t exactly spring chickens themselves.) Naturally, he tries to push back against the critics’ narrative:
These same integrative health and medicine naysayers essentially conflate quackery—which ought to be called out and confronted—with the larger, progressive, and impactful, integrative health and medicine movement.
Critics also purport that nutrition, physical activity, and stress reduction are already consistently applied (or taught) clinically—that it’s already ‘part of medicine’. These few critics are wrong. Their view is incorrect. Their statements are patently false. We know this because, if these truly preventative measures were applied—if this was remotely the case—our healthcare delivery system would be consistently delivering ‘health care’, not ‘chronic disease care’.
Proponents of integrative medicine always try to sweep all the quackery their specialty embraces under the rug. Pay no attention to that quackery behind the curtain, they say. We’re all about nutrition, lifestyle, and stress reduction. They somehow never manage to address the question: Why is quackery so associated with integrative medicine? If integrative medicine really were about “nutrition, lifestyle, and stress reduction” and nothing else, the quackery would be unnecessary. Homeopathy, naturopathy, acupuncture, “energy healing,” functional medicine, bogus allergy testing, and more forms of pseudoscience and quackery than I can list here (but have discussed over the years on this very blog) would not find such a comfortable home in “integrative medicine.” That they do fit so nicely in “integrative medicine” is by design, not accident.
Nutrition and lifestyle, the Trojan horse of integrative medicine
Consider this. Let’s, for the sake of argument, concede that Sabin has a point. Perhaps nutrition, physical activity, and stress reduction are not sufficiently consistently applied in clinical medicine. If that is indeed the case, the answer is to develop strategies to change this shortcoming in medicine. Those strategies, assuming they’re science based (as they should be), will not involve embracing pseudoscience and quackery. Sabin and Weeks go on and on and on about promoting the “nutrition, physical activity, and stress reduction” aspect of medicine, but fail to explain why a separate specialty is needed to emphasize these health promotion activities more. That’s because they can’t. The entire unspoken rationale that they cannot admit is that “nutrition, physical activity, and stress reduction” function, in essence, as a Trojan horse for hardcore quackery. Integrative medicine shows up at the gates of academic medicine looking like “nutrition, physical activity, and stress reduction,” but once the horse is pulled into the ivory tower of academia, out jumps the real quackery, like naturopathy, homeopathy, acupuncture, functional medicine, and the like.
Also unspoken is that the reason integrative medicine proponents want so badly to insinuate their specialty and thinking into medical school is because they want “nutrition, physical activity, and stress reduction” forever linked with the quackery that they also champion. At schools like GWU and Georgetown, it’s working, too. I fear, however, that UCI will soon far surpass both GWU and Georgetown as bastions of quackademic medicine.

More Integrative Propaganda
Defenders of integrative quackery attack proponents of science-based medicine for simply pointing out the scientific evidence and exposing their poor logic.
Steven Novella on October 4, 2017
Link

History indicates that many people can be convinced of something completely nonsensical if it is packaged in an appealing narrative, one that stokes our emotional needs and resonates with our cognitive biases. That is the essence of effective propaganda.
So there are cohorts of people who believe fervently that the most effective public health intervention in human history (vaccines) is actually harming children and there is a massive conspiracy to cover up this fact. There is also the widespread belief that “they” have the cure for cancer but somehow vested interests are keeping it from the public. Under close scrutiny such beliefs collapse in a heap of poor evidence and worse logic, but they persist none-the-less.
An alluring narrative has also convinced much of the public that there are alternatives to science-based medicine. At its core SBM is very straight-forward – the medical profession should use the highest quality evidence available, in the context of a thorough scientific evaluation, to determine which medical interventions are likely to be safe and effective. There are only two real premises here, that treatments which work and are safe are better than treatments which don’t work or are unsafe, and that rigorous science is the best method for making such determinations.
When you strip it down these premises are not controversial. Yet amazingly proponents of interventions that 50 years ago were considered health fraud have managed to convince a large number of people that it is OK to use treatments that don’t work, or for which there is either no credible scientific evidence that they can or do work, or actually evidence that they don’t work. 
Integrative propaganda
Recently I and other proponents of SBM criticized UC Irvine for opening a center for integrative medicine, essentially becoming the standard bearer for pseudoscience and quackery in academic medicine. We correctly called them out for contributing to the anti-scientific and anti-intellectual narrative with which pseudoscience is promoted in medicine.
Predictably proponents of pseudoscience in medicine struck back. Specifically John Weeks, who is the Publisher-Editor of The Integrator Blog News & Reports, published a rant in the Huffington Post attacking UC Irvine’s critics. He specifically named myself, David Gorski and Timothy Caulfield. The piece is an excellent example of pseudoscientific propaganda, and exposes many of the strategies of integrative medicine proponents.
He begins:
The response of the LA Times, STAT, Medpage, and most media to the visionary $200-million integrative health investment of Susan and Henry Samueli at UC Irvine has been a shameful display of media descent into Trump-like, polarizing tweets. Worse yet, the coverage has been a profoundly anti-science. These media, and others, have chosen to provide platforms to a small handful of individuals who for decades have denied the evidence of acupuncture, chiropractic, mind-body and multiple other integrative approaches.
I wonder if it’s time to extend Godwin’s law to include gratuitous references to Trump. What Week’s is doing here is framing the narrative for this issue. Integrative medicine is “visionary” and all those who oppose it must be anti-science. Further, they are just a “small” group of malcontents who deny the evidence. The media should ignore them, and focus only my perspective.
Part of this strategy is to flip the skeptical narrative on its head. Legitimate skepticism can always be unfairly portrayed as denial. You can them impugn the motives of the skeptics and compare them to some unsavory bogeyman.
He continues in this style:
From his LA Times podium, Michael Hiltzig first gives voice to David Gorski and then to Steven Novella, long-time colleagues and back-slapping companions as anti-integrative medicine vigilantes.
The approach was repeated at STAT by Usha Lee McFarling. Her post was bleated out again by Medpage Today. McFarling gives the honor of shaping her story to Novella: ” … putting an imprimatur of a university on things that have been discarded as medical fraud for 50 years.” She then turns to another lifer in anti-CAM activity, Timothy Caulfield. Caulfield doubles down against this “legitimization” message.
He criticizes McFarling for “shaping” her story a certain way, meanwhile is framing his own article in extreme and one-sided terms. We are deep into his article and Weeks so far has only engaged in personal attacks against the critics of his beloved integrative medicine, trying to marginalize and minimize them and their opinions. He has not yet actually engaged with any of our arguments.
After attacking the media for not being one-sided enough in his direction, he finally gets to something akin to an actual argument:
They promote this polarizing grandstanding rather than honor the emerging scientific consensus that is yet poorly integrated into health professional education and practice – and that utterly backs the Samuelis’ investment and direction at UC Irvine:
It really is amazing to read a screed that can only be characterized as polarizing grandstanding which criticizes others for polarizing grandstanding. But let’s address his kernel of a point here, which is really just a false argument from authority. He goes on to reference cases in which integrative medicine has managed to infiltrate legitimate medicine.
He cites four reviews and reports on pain management that recommend non-pharmacological approaches, including chiropractic and acupuncture. As we have pointed out before, part of the con of integrative medicine is to rebrand science-based interventions as alternative. Their false premise is that science-based medicine includes only drugs and surgery, and therefore everything else is “alternative.” This is demonstrably false – nothing but historical revisionism. Exercise, relaxation therapy, massage, and proper nutrition (when kept within the scientific evidence) are all part of mainstream medicine.
This is all part of the broader narrative that derives from creating these false categories in the first place – alternative, complementary, or integrative medicine. These categories exist only to create a double standard of lower scientific evidence, and to create an umbrella under which real treatments can be used to lend legitimacy to quackery. So if yoga is useful in certain conditions, because it is exercise and stretching, then, they argue, that legitimizes the entire category of “integrative” medicine, and therefore other things which are pure quackery, like homeopathy, must also be legitimate.
How do things like acupuncture and homeopathy slip onto these lists of recommended interventions by legitimate organizations? That’s a good question. It is not because of the evidence. What tends to happen is that clueless academics put proponents in charge of reviewing the evidence for “alternative” therapies (because they are the alleged experts).
Acupuncture is a great example. After thousands of studies the only sensible scientific conclusion is that acupuncture does not work. The evidence clearly shows that it does not matter where you stick the needles, or if you stick the needles, and that chi and acupuncture points do not exist. Acupuncture is nothing but a theatrical placebo.
Yet proponents have been surprisingly successful in willfully misinterpreting the scientific evidence – interpreting negative studies as if they are positive for example. Many studies of acupuncture show a difference when comparing a non-intervention group to an acupuncture group, but no difference between true acupuncture and sham or placebo acupuncture. Proponents have actually interpreted these clearly negative studies as “acupuncture works, we’re just not sure how it works.” These same proponents find their way onto committee and panels who shape recommendations that include acupuncture, while academics are asleep at the switch.
This is a great example of pseudoscience justifying itself. Proponents do poor studies or misinterpret negative studies, then use their own misinterpretations as if it legitimizes their claims. Integrative medicine is a beast feeding on itself. Favorable news coverage is evidence that it is legitimate and popular. Negative news coverage is evidence that its critics are biased and must be worried. Any infiltration into legitimate medicine is used to promote further infiltration into medicine. The public wants it, they argue, therefore we should promote it. But they only want it because it is being promoted.
What they don’t have is external scientific legitimacy – which is all that matters.
After doubling down on his anti-science denial stance, Weeks then goes off the rails with this statement:
And while the scale is different, both forms of science denial have blood on their hands. The residual, reactive, medical ideology of these anti-integrative careerists to which the LA Times and others give a platform is a barrier to potentially lifesaving directions toward which the Joint Commission-Mayo/NIH-American College of Physicians-NAM-Attorneys General jointly urge us – and the Samueli investment would propel us.
This is the ultimate emotional appeal of the integrative crowd – but what if this nonsense we are promoting actually works? Then those calling for scientific evidence might be delaying or denying treatments to people. This, of course, puts the entire logic of modern medicine on its head. The whole point of using careful rigorous science is to determine which treatments are safe and effective. We need to be able to make evidence-based risk vs benefit decisions.
This is not a “barrier” to effective treatments, it is the only road to effective treatments. Without solid science, medicine tends to drift off into fantasy land. We literally have thousands of years of experience to validate this view.
Proponents of science-based medicine spend their time and energy doing what we do for one reason – to protect patients from fraud and abuse. To protect the public from medical services and products that are worthless or harmful. To inform the public and our fellow professionals about the often complex relationship between science and medicine.
If anyone thinks they have a life-saving medical intervention, there is a well-established route to making this intervention widely available. Do the science, and convince your colleagues. Proponents of real quackery can’t do this, because the science is not on their side. So instead they make progressively more shrill arguments, attack their critics, distort the science, lobby the courts, and try to carve out a double standard for their treatments.
As an example, the Samueli’s that Weeks thinks are so “visionary” are big believers in homeopthy. Homeopathy is pure pseudoscience, and only causes waste and harm through delayed treatment and diverted resources. That is what the Samueli’s want to promote. That is what Weeks is defending. We are just pointing out the scientific evidence. Weeks doesn’t like that, so he is essentially arguing for us to shut up, and for the media to ignore us.
Sorry, Weeks, that’s not going to happen. Your emperor has no clothes and we are never going to stop pointing it out.

The Marino Center for Integrative Health: Hooey Galore
Kimball Atwood on March 2, 2012
Link
Two weeks ago I promised that I would discuss the Marino Center for Integrative Health, identified in the recent Bravewell report as having a “hospital affiliation” with the Newton-Wellesley Hospital (NWH) in Newton, Massachusetts, which is where I work. I also promised in that post that I’d provide examples of ‘integrative medicine’ practitioners offering false information about the methods that they endorse. I’d previously made that assertion here, and Jann Bellamy subsequently discussed its legal and ethical implications here. The Marino Center is a wellspring of such examples.
A Misleading ‘Affiliation’
Let’s quickly dispel the “hospital affiliation” claim. According to the Marino Center website:
Hospital Affiliations
In support of our services and to ensure that our patients have access to exceptional tertiary care, the Marino Center maintains deeply established relationships and affiliations for referrals and admitting privileges with major medical facilities in the Boston area.
The Marino Center:
    • Is a proud member of the Partners Healthcare family
    • Is affiliated with Newton Wellesley Hospital
    • Makes referrals to Mass General Hospital, Dana Farber, Children’s Hospital and more
Well, it wouldn’t surprise me if the Marino Center is a ‘member’ of the Partners Healthcare family, which includes not only the Newton-Wellesley Hospital, but lesser known entities such as the Massachusetts General Hospital and the Brigham and Women’s Hospital. After all, there are already unfortunate pseudomedical schemes involving Partners entities, such as the Osher Center for Complementary and Integrative Medical Therapies and, even under my own roof (I shudder as I write this), a Reiki Workshop. Nevertheless, it’s telling, I hope, that not only does the Marino Center fail to appear under any list of Partners affiliates, Community Health Partnerships, Wellness, Prevention, or any other conceivable category, but it fails to yield a single ‘hit’ when entered as a search term on the Partners website (the term ‘integrative’ yields seven hits, but none appears to be about ‘CAM,’ except possibly for an RSS feed that I’ve no patience to peruse. Is it possible that Partners is embarrassed by the Osher Center? I hope that, too).
I’ve previously asserted that the NWH is not affiliated with the Marino Center, other than that some Marino Center physicians have been—against my judgment, not that I was consulted—granted hospital staff privileges. I made this assertion in my original Bravewell post a couple of weeks ago, after having questioned the NWH Chief Medical Officer, Dr. Les Selbovitz, who verified it; nothing on the NWH website suggests otherwise.
I’ve no reason to doubt the Marino Center’s third bullet above, “makes referrals to Mass General Hospital,” etc., but this is something that any physician can do, regardless of affiliation. I suspect that if there were an ‘integrative hospital‘ in Boston, reason forbid, the Marino Center would make referrals to it.
False and Misleading Information about ‘Services’
Let’s get to the meat of the problem.
For years, the Marino Center website included this:
Medical Services
Medical specialties include Internal Medicine, Family Practice, Medical Acupuncture, Homeopathy, Naturopathy, Neurology, Urology, Gynecology, Rehabilitation Medicine and Pain Management.
And Eric Healing, perhaps? Apparently not, but it might as well be included. “Medical” acupuncture? Oh, the spin. Elsewhere on the Marino site, until very recently, were chiropractic, craniosacral ‘therapy,’ ‘nutritional services…to help rid your body of toxins,’ herbs, ‘infusion therapy,’ ‘chelation therapy,’ and more. I’ll elaborate on a few of these.
Homeopathy
There was a self-described homeopath listed on the Marino website until about 2005. Even after he disappeared, the site’s explanation of homeopathy, featuring a hodgepodge of misleading-if-factual statements, half-truths, and utter nonsense, persisted:
Homeopathy is a system of medicine founded and developed by the German physician, Samuel Hahnemann more than two centuries ago. In fact many of today’s finest American medical schools and hospitals actually originated as homeopathic colleges and hospitals. The effective use of this method of care has been well documented throughout the years and although its effects can be powerful and dramatic, homeopathy’s mode of action is gentle. In 1938 the FDA declared homeopathic remedies to be safe, and substantiated claims of their clinical effectiveness even in treating serious diseases when using practitioner-recommended remedies.
Homeopathic remedies are prepared from a wide variety of substances including plants, minerals, and animal products. Because the effectiveness of a remedy has less to do with content than with the precision of its “match” with the patient, homeopathic medicine is said to operate according to what is known as: The Law of Similars, “Let like substances treat like conditions.”
Vaccinations are developed according to a similar concept. For example, a vaccination containing a small amount of the Cowpox bacillus [sic] causes the body to develop antibodies and immunity to the similar, serious disease, Smallpox. Homeopathy expands on this idea in two ways:
1) The homeopathic “like” substance or remedy is customized to meet the specific needs of an individual in all of his/her complexity.
2) Homeopathic remedies are far more dilute (weaker in concentration) than vaccinations. It is believd the more dilute a constitutional dose of a homeopathic remedy becomes, the more “energetic,” or clinically powerful it is.
How to get startedThe selection of a homeopathic medicine relies on a thorough understanding of patient personality including typical likes and dislikes, diet and exercisepatterns and other traits, in order offer an adult or child a well-matched constitutional remedy. When the proper prescription is delivered, its effectiveness is demonstrated not only by the elimination or alleviation of symptoms, but also at the highest levels of brain function – emotions, attitudes, and behaviors.
In order to develop a homeopathic medical history an initial consultation is required. This in-depth discussion can last up to 1½ hours and may cover a wide range of topics, including your food cravings, habits, personality traits, and attitude towards the illness or symptoms being addressed.
After this evaluation, your homeopathic practitioner is able to recommend one or more homeopathic remedies, and advise you on the most effective ways of taking these remedies. Homeopathic remedies consist of extremely dilute preparations of natural substances, which are inexpensive and available without a prescription. An experienced homeopathic practitioner can help a patient find the best remedy or remedies for his/her particular symptoms and personality.
Following the initial consultation you may want to return for one or more follow-up visits to “fine tune” the use of homeopathy or address additional problems or concerns.
Homeopathy and ChildrenIf conventional medical approaches have been ineffective in treating your child’s problems, or you are concerned about side effects of medications or other treatments, gentler, more subtly-acting medical systems such as homeopathy may be helpful. Homeopathy’s individualized approach is designed to address underlying problems contributing to your child’s symptoms or behaviors.
Homeopathy may be if your child suffers from Failure to Thrive, Attention Deficit Disorder (ADD), Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), Persistent Colic, Chronic Ear Infections, or Asthma.
What Conditions Can Homeopathy Help?Homeopathy can be a gentle and safe method of treating numerous conditions including:
Mental Health
    • Chronic Depression
    • Phobias
    • Panic and Anxiety Disorders
    • Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD)
    • Unresolved Grief
    • Addictive Behavior
OB/GYN
    • Dysmenorrhea
    • Pre-Menstrual Syndrome
    • Endometriosis
    • Menopausal Symptoms
Gastroenterology
    • Irritable Bowel Syndrome
    • Ulcerative Colitis
    • Persistent Nausea or Reflux
Dermatology
    • Post-Herpetic Pain
    • Chronic Eczema
First Aid/Emergency(Telephone or Self-Care Support)
    • Fever Control
    • Insect Bites and Stings
    • Bruises and Abrasions
    • Sprains
    • Allergic Reactions
    • Stomach Cramps
    • Colds and Sore Throats
Contact UsTo schedule a homeopathic evaluation and treatment session, please contact the Marino Center For Progressive Health by using the information here.
Dear Readers, such ‘information’ is fatuous, reckless tommyrot. For accurate information about homeopathy, I invite you to revisit my first-ever series on SBM, beginning here.
Traditional Chinese Medicine
A similar meal of misinformation awaits, but I’ll only bore you with some of it:
What is Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM)?
In general, TCM is a holistic medical system consisting of acupuncture, herbal medicine, meditation and diet. The first TCM book was published more than 2,000 years ago. Through the generations, the wisdom of thousands of volumes of medical literature and countless clinical experiences have been passed down for our use. TCM has developed greatly within the last 30 years by integrating its practices with modern medicine in China.
…Our goal is to make this holistic, physical, and spiritual healing practice available to anyone who could benefit from it.
What Is Acupuncture?In the holistic philosophy of TCM, all parts of our bodies are seen as inter-connected. Energy and signal transactions (Qi flow) are carried through pathways called meridians, which are distributed on the surface of the body. It is believed that blockages of the Qi flow through meridians cause imbalances which, in turn, result in illness. Acupuncture attempts to heal by restoring the flow of Qi through the meridians–allowing the body to heal itself. Modern techniques like finger pressure, laser, heat, maxa, and electro-magnetic therapies have also been developed based on the theory of acupuncture.
What Conditions can Acupuncture Help?The World Health Organization has publicly announced that the following conditions are suitable for acupuncture treatment:
1. Neurological and muscular disorders
2. Respiratory Disorders:Bronchial asthma (in children and adult when uncomplicated)
3 Gastrointestinal Disorders:Esophageal and cardio spasm, hiccup, gastroptosis, acute or chronic gastritis, sour stomach, duodenal ulcers, colonitis, acute bacillary dysentery, constipation, diarrhea, and paralytic ileus.
4. Eye Disorders:Acute conjunctivitis, central retinitis, nearsightedness (in children), and cataracts without complications.
5. Ear, Nose and Throat Disorders:Toothaches, gingivitis, otitis, sinusitis, rhinitis, nasal catarrh, and acute tonsilliti. In general, acupuncture can be used for treating almost all kinds of pain, paralysis or neural dysfunction, allergies, immune imbalance and most gynecological problems.
What are Chinese Herbs?
While nature may produce disease, it also produces healing. Chinese herbs have a long history of successfully treating many types of diseases. Countless reports show that Chinese Herbs may aid in healing where traditional medicines are less effective.
Are Chinese Herbs Safe?Yes. Over 30 years of toxicology studies have shown that Chinese Herbs are safe and have fewer side effects than chemical medications…
“There is nothing between Heaven and Earth but Qi and its laws”
– ancient Chinese saying
Behold the awesome power that signal transactions and ancient Chinese sayings hold over hopelessly gullible honkies! Makes me embarrassed to be one, sometimes. An accurate summary of the relevant material: acupuncture has no specific effect on any disease; the philosophical bases for what Marino calls TCM are not based in observable reality; the term TCM is only about 50 years old, having been invented in the People’s Republic of China as an appeal to Western audiences; it is an awkward, arbitrary cobbling of several, disparate and sometimes contradictory ideas and methods that existed at various times and places in the long, pre-scientific history of the very large region that is China; TCM can’t, by any stretch of the imagination, be construed as holistic, because it knows very little of anatomy, physiology, and pathology, and nothing whatsoever of microscopic or molecular matters; over 30 years of toxicology studies have shown that many Chinese Herbs are not safe.
“Nutrition”
Why the quotation marks? Well, nutrition is not “CAM,” but “nutrition” is:
Why Cleanse?
The modernization of the American diet (changing agricultural practices, fast foods and more refined foods) has greatly upset the balance of health in this country. Just as our planet has its chemical waste problems our smaller environment, the body, is also greatly threatened.
Toxins may accumulate in the colon and liver and may lead to fatigue, headaches, premenstrual tension and other chronic symptoms. We may take these symptoms for granted without realizing that they represent a state of ill health.
Who Should Cleanse?
Dietary cleansing helps to cleanse and revitalize the body. It helps to improve health and vitality in healthy individuals and is particularly encouraged for individuals who what to improve poor eating habits and those with diet-related illnesses such as:
    • fibromyalgia
    • high blood pressure
    • high cholesterol
    • high blood sugar
    • arthritis
    • allergies
    • some fatigue problems
    • chronic skin problems
    • gastrointestine disturbances
What to Expect
There is nothing like a dietary cleansing program to ensure lasting will power and inner strength. [etc.]
That last line almost has me convinced.
Chelation and the Law
I hope you’re still with me, because I’ve saved the best for last. Chelation ‘therapy,’ for those who don’t know, is among the very worst forms of quackery perpetrated by licensed physicians in the U.S. The treatment is both ineffective and dangerous; this has been known since the early 1960s. The history of the fringe group of physicians who peddle it, several of whom are convicted felons, is inextricably intertwined with Laetrile, the most lucrative health scam in American history. For nearly a decade, the NIH has been funding the unnecessary, dangerous and unethical Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy for coronary artery disease (TACT). To do this it has recruited several of the aforementioned felons, whom it now calls “respected experts,” to act as investigators and consultants. All of this is explained and documented in detail here. I’ve previously discussed it on SBM here, here, here, here, here, and here.
At least until 2010, the Marino Center website offered this:
Chelation Therapy
Atherosclerosis (hardening of the arteries) is our nation’s number one killer, leading to over 500,000 deaths in America every year. Our bodies’ blood vessels are constantly being damaged – by high blood pressure, toxins in our diet and environment, and by the effects of stress. The body’s attempts to repair this damage lead to a build up of cholesterol and calcium – plaque – in arteries throughout the body. This is a contributing factor to death and debility from:
    • heart attack,
    • stroke and
    • poor circulation to extremities.
Conventional medical approaches to these problems include prevention (by reducing risk factors such as high blood pressure and high cholesterol) and treatment with medications aimed at reducing symptoms, or treatment with invasive procedures (angioplasty, stents or bypass surgery).
Since the 1950’s, EDTA Chelation Therapy has offered patients an alternative. EDTA Chelation Therapy is given as a series of 20-30 weekly infusions, each lasting 3 hours. This therapy, which is FDA-approved for the removal of lead, is thought to reverse atherosclerosis when used in a program including vitamins, stress reduction, and lifestyle changes.
The Marino Center ‘s EDTA Chelation Therapy is administered according to protocols established by the American College of Advancement of Medicine.
The American College for Advancement in Medicine (ACAM), which calls itself the “voice of integrative medicine,” is the Mother of all Pseudomedical Pseudoprofessional Organizations. Its ‘protocols’ for “EDTA Chelation Therapy” call for Na2EDTA, which has never been FDA-approved for the removal of lead—rather than the safer CaNAEDTA, which has been so approved. The misleading statement about lead was echoed for years in the protocols and consent forms of the NIH trial itself, until we complained, and even then the Office for Human Research Protections somehow allowed the trial to proceed. 
At the same time that the Marino Center was plugging chelation, it was also one of the “community chelation sites” for the TACT:
Current research projects/studies include:
    • National Institute of Health sponsored study- Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy (TACT)
Have You Ever Had a Heart Attack?
Are you age 50 or older?
If you answered, “yes” to both of these questions, you may be eligible to take part in a national study of an investigational treatment – chelation therapy and vitamin therapy – for people with heart disease.
What is chelation therapy?
Chelation therapy is an investigational therapy using an amino acid (EDTA)*. It is added to the blood through a vein. Some people believe that chelation therapy may help treat heart disease. However, this has not been scientifically proven. This study will seek to find out whether chelation therapy is safe, and effective in treating heart disease.
What will the study involve?
As a study participant, you will be assigned to receive chelation therapy or its placebo (inactive treatment). In addition, you will take either high-dose vitamin and mineral supplements or identical placebo pills. All participants will receive low-dose vitamin and mineral supplements. It is important that you continue to take your standard heart disease medications.
What are the costs?
Study-related treatments will be provided at no cost. Other medical costs remain your responsibility. For more information call Barbara Feinberg at 617 661 6225 (x 302) or ask your Marino Center Physician for more information.
*Calling EDTA an “amino acid” may be technically true but is entirely misleading. EDTA is quite different from any of the amino acids in our proteins. Nevertheless, the designation ‘amino acid’ is how quacks rationalize chelation as “natural.”
Here’s an item in the Code of Federal Regulations:
Sec. 312.7 Promotion of investigational drugs.
(a) Promotion of an investigational new drug. A sponsor or investigator, or any person acting on behalf of a sponsor or investigator, shall not represent in a promotional context that an investigational new drug is safe or effective for the purposes for which it is under investigation or otherwise promote the drug. This provision is not intended to restrict the full exchange of scientific information concerning the drug, including dissemination of scientific findings in scientific or lay media. Rather, its intent is to restrict promotional claims of safety or effectiveness of the drug for a use for which it is under investigation and to preclude commercialization of the drug before it is approved for commercial distribution.
(b) Commercial distribution of an investigational new drug. A sponsor or investigator shall not commercially distribute or test market an investigational new drug.
Please understand that those regulations are not matters of picking nits. Violating them necessarily introduces intolerable bias into a study, both by influencing the views of subjects and by diverting potential subjects away from the study to receive the experimental treatment in preference to the placebo. The Marino Center is hardly alone in having violated these regulations—almost all of the approximately 100 TACT “community chelation sites” have done the same thing, and so far neither the OHRP nor the FDA appears to have responded—but that does not excuse the practice. Along with countless other problems, however, it will likely render the trial uninterpretable.
And More
There has been other misleading information on the Marino website over the years—chiropractic mythology, shilling for ‘vitamins and supplements,’ ‘environmental medicine,’ and more. Very recently the website has been changed to a new look, and some of the previous material is absent. I don’t know whether this is because it has yet to be reinstated, or whether the Marino Center has decided to be more subtle in the public domain. Time will tell.
In summary, the Marino Center for Integrative Health, a center worthy of having been included in the recent Bravewell Report on “Integrative Medicine in America,” upon whose Board sits the Director of the Complementary and Integrative Medicine Program at the Mayo Clinic, has repeatedly decided that when it comes to informed consent and “CAM,” the truth is irrelevant.

Quackademic Medicine at UC Irvine
UC Irvine Medicine School opens a center for integrative medicine, selling out to promote quackery in medicine.
Steven Novella on September 20, 2017
Link

The skeptical movement and science-based medicine would not have to exist if academia was doing its job. Unfortunately, in some very important ways, they are collectively failing the world. The latest example of this failure is the Susan Samueli Center for Integrative Medicine UC Irvine School of Medicine.
How do you get to have a center named after you in a major medical school? You don’t necessarily need to have any medical accomplishments. All you have to do is bribe, I mean donate, $200 million. To be clear, there is nothing wrong with a philanthropist making a major donation to a hospital or medical school and being honored for that donation by having a building or center named after them. That’s pretty much how it works.
What is a problem is dictating the academic and scientific standards of that medical school through your donation. Samueli did not intend to support the teaching and practice of medicine, but to change the teaching and practice of medicine according to her own misguided ideology.
To put this into perspective, imagine if a wealthy donor wanted to give millions of dollars to a major university department of astronomy so that they would open up a center for astrology, or a department of biology so that they would open a center for creation research. What if the Koch brothers had a couple hundred million lying around and wanted to donate that money to a prestigious university to create chairs (a university position supported by an endowment) to “study” climate change, but had a few hand-picked climate change deniers they wanted in those positions?
The only respectable answer to any of those offers, regardless of how much money they would bring the university, is, “No thanks.”
What is clearly happening here is an attempt to put a giant thumb of the scale of science and medicine through money. That is essentially what has been happening with so-called alternative medicine for the last four decades. There is literally billions of dollars to be made selling fake medicine and medical services. Prior to around the 1980s selling fake medicine was considered health fraud and was largely opposed by the medical profession, scientists, and academia. This opposition was half-hearted, little more than occasionally shoeing away an annoying fly.
Over the last few decades, however, sellers of fake medicine have used their ill-gotten gains to change the game. They have used their influence to lobby state and federal governments for more friendly laws, to demand licensure and insurance coverage, and to water down consumer protections. They have marketed to the public to rebrand health fraud as “alternative” then “complementary” and now “integrative.” Make no mistake – these are essentially the exact same practices just under different labels.
Convincing a largely scientifically illiterate public and politicians was the easy part, but the real scandal is that they were able to work their way into the halls of science and academia. Academia should have been a bright line beyond which quackery and fraud could never penetrate. Sadly, it turns out all it took was a combination of apathy and some well-greased palms.
The Samueli Center represents the full realization of this phenomenon, the infiltration and celebration of rank quackery into medical academia. Here is the press release for the opening of the center, hitting just about every CAM trope with amazing efficiency:
The Susan Samueli Center for Integrative Medicine, part of UC Irvine Health, is proud to offer an innovative, holistic approach to healthcare that is backed by the latest medical research.
What exactly is integrative medicine? It’s a philosophy that makes use of all therapeutic approaches, healthcare providers and disciplines to achieve optimal health and healing. Integrative medicine:
    • Focuses on the whole person
    • Is informed by scientific evidence
    • Brings together conventional and alternative approaches in a coordinated way
    • Reaffirms the importance of the doctor-patient relationship
Our integrative approach to healthcare is aimed at prevention and balance. Instead of reacting to symptoms as they occur, we seek to uncover the root causes of illnesses and disease before they negatively impact your life.
This is nothing but the standard stream of lies and misconceptions proponents use to malign science-based medicine and promote their competitive brand. There is nothing “holistic” about alternative medicine. They are not informed by science, they do not focus on the whole person, and they do nothing to address root causes of illness or to treat preventively. That is all just marketing spin, and it is embarrassing that a medical center would promote such nonsense, no matter how much money was in it for them.
Despite the evolving marketing strategies, when you dig down you find the same list of pseudoscience and quackery that has been around for the last century. Their website is still a little vague on exactly what they offer, but they do include this:
Integrative medicine incorporates traditional Western medicine with alternative or complementary treatments such as acupuncture, massage, herbal medicine, biofeedback and yoga. As part of our focus on maintaining wellness and promoting health, we offer clinical services in acupuncture, naturopathy, herbal medicine, nutritional supplements and a therapeutic lifestyle program.
This, again, is the usual mix of either complete quackery, or lifestyle factors stolen from mainstream medicine and rebranded as “alternative.” Science-based nutrition and exercise is not alternative, and they don’t need to be “integrated” into medicine because they have always been there.
They combine that with things like acupuncture, which is based on magic and does not work. Acupuncture proponents have managed to fool naive academics by lying about the science and changing the rules as needed. Basically, they just don’t have their eyes on the ball because they don’t perceive what is actually happening. I know many academics who see the entire phenomenon as if it were massage – benign treatments to make patients feel better. But that is just the Trojan horse used to infiltrate hard-core quackery into mainstream medicine.
Naturopathy is a great example. It is an approach to medicine that basically uses anything not based on science. One of their favorite treatment is homeopathy, which again is based on magic and demonstrably does not work.
Herbal medicine is at least plausible, based largely on plant-based drugs. However, it is a poorly studied and regulated form of drug therapy – a wild west of medicine with little quality control. The regulations seem crafted to benefit the industry at the expense of consumers.
When confronted with claims of integrative medicine, you have to always ask yourself, what exactly are they integrating? If mainstream medicine, by its own standards, uses interventions which have been shown to be safe and effective, the only things left to integrate are treatments that have not been shown to be safe and effective. Some of these unproven treatments are also highly implausible, sometimes to the point that they are essentially magic potions and witchcraft.
The bottom line is that the University of California Irvine should be thoroughly ashamed of itself for compromising its own academic integrity. It is now the standard bearer for quackery in academic medicine. This happened through the usual combination of apathy, ignorance, and misguided ideology. I don’t know to what extent the decision-makers at UC Irvine believe the integrative propaganda, are unaware of what it actually means, or just don’t care – but none of those options speak well of them.

UC-Irvine, integrative medicine, and the delusion of being “science-based”
Last month, a billionaire couple, Susan and Henry Samueli, announced a $200 million gift to UC-Irvine to found the Susan and Henry Samueli College of Health Sciences, which will be devoted to integrative medicine and studying “unconventional” treatments. Its founders promise that it will be rigorously science-based in articles in a large, glossy magazine. There are many reasons for doubts about this claim.
David Gorski on October 23, 2017
Link

A week ago at QEDCon, I was honored to give a talk about “integrative” medicine, specifically how it is little more than a vehicle for advocates of pseudoscience to use to “integrate” quackery with medicine. Unsurprisingly, the University of California, Irvine (UCI) featured prominently in the talk, specifically the $200 million donation by Susan and Henry Samueli to “transform” the medical campus by creating a new center for integrative medicine that will encompass at least four schools and provide 15 endowed chairs to promote research, education, and clinical practice in integrative medicine. Naturally, we at SBM were quite critical. Steve Novella, for instance, used one of my favorite terms to refer to it as quackademic medicine at UCI, noting how Michael Hiltzik had reported that UCI started frantically trying (and failing) to scrub all references to The One Quackery To Rule Them All (homeopathy) from its online presence. Meanwhile, a friend of the blog noticed that studying homeopathy had been baked into a 2003 gift agreement between the Samuelis and UCI. In response, advocates of integrative medicine, stung by the criticism, lashed out, with one even going so far as to charge that those of us critical of UCI’s integration of quackery with medicine have “blood on our hands” while trying to paint us as “anti-science” and repeating his tired old trope of comparing critics of integrative medicine to Donald Trump.
We at SBM frequently discuss how integrative medicine serves as a vehicle to integrate quackery, such as acupuncture, naturopathy, functional medicine, and even homeopathy, into medicine. This is indeed a pernicious effect. Less often do we speak of what integrative medicine does to actual potentially science-based treatment modalities involving lifestyle, nutrition and diet, exercise, and the like, which is to “rebrand” it as somehow being “alternative” and thus of a piece with all the quackery. That’s why I think it’s worth discussing UCI once again, because it has published the fall issue of its magazine with the Samuelis on the cover and the tagline, “reimagining the future of health,” and there are several articles in it touting integrative medicine at UCI and what the school will do with the Samueli donation.
But, first, a word from Andrew Weil…
If there’s anyone who could be called the Big Kahuna of the world of integrative medicine, it’s Andrew Weil. That’s why a letter to the editor of the LA Times, which published Hiltzik’s critical article about the UCI gift, “A $200-million donation threatens to tar UC Irvine’s medical school as a haven for quacks,” by Weil caught my eye as a nice prelude to wading into the UCI Magazine articles themselves. In a letter entitled “Why more doctors are embracing scientifically sound integrative medicine,” Weil provides us with a succinct example of what UCI and the Samuelis do on a regular basis: Try to represent integrative medicine as being science-based. First, he takes umbrage:
We take umbrage at Michael Hiltzik’s column challenging the Samueli family’s $200-million donation to UC Irvine for integrative medicine. Hiltzik is concerned that the donation will “integrate quackery” into the curriculum and “tar” the reputation of the medical school. (“A $200-million donation threatens to tar UC Irvine’s medical school as a haven for quacks,” Sept. 22)
Take all the “umbrage” that you want, Dr. Weil. The truth hurts. Dr. Weil then attacks a straw man:
“Quackery” refers to dishonest practices performed by those who pretend to have special knowledge and skill in some field. In contrast, integrative medicine, or IM, is defined as healing-oriented medicine that reaffirms the importance of the relationship between practitioner and patient, focuses on the entire patient and body systems, is informed by evidence, and makes use of all therapeutic and lifestyle approaches to achieve optimal health and healing.
No, quackery refers to ineffective and/or pseudoscientific treatments represented as medicine. Although many quacks are dishonest, quack practices do not necessarily have to be dishonest, nor do the practitioners have to “pretend to have special knowledge.” I can point you to an example of someone who illustrates that principle quite nicely: Britt Hermes, the naturopath who realized that what she was doing was quackery and as a result left naturopathy to study to become a scientist and to tell the world about her former profession. I just spent some time talking to her at QEDCon, and I also know from her past articles and talks that when she was a naturopath she really believed in what she was doing and that naturopathy did great good. I have no doubt that the Samuelis, the UCI, and even Dr. Weil himself believe that the quackery they embrace improves medicine.
Let’s take a look at that definition, though. It’s basically a minor rephrasing of the definition of integrative medicine on the University of Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine website, other variations of which can be found all over the place in integrative medicine literature. Typically, it incorporates many of the tropes that integrative medicine advocates want you to believe about the “discipline.” I call them tropes because they are oft-repeated by advocates, but, more importantly, there is a major assumption behind all of them, which is that conventional medicine doesn’t do these things or that it disagrees with these things. For instance, take a look at the list on the UA website after the definition of integrative medicine that Dr. Weil paraphrased:
The Defining Principles of Integrative Medicine
     1.  Patient and practitioner are partners in the healing process.
     2.  All factors that influence health, wellness, and disease are taken into consideration, including mind, spirit, and community, as well as the body.
     3.  Appropriate use of both conventional and alternative methods facilitates the body’s innate healing response.
     4.  Effective interventions that are natural and less invasive should be used whenever possible.
     5.  Integrative medicine neither rejects conventional medicine nor accepts alternative therapies uncritically.
     6.  Good medicine is based in good science. It is inquiry-driven and open to new paradigms.
     7.  Alongside the concept of treatment, the broader concepts of health promotion and the prevention of illness are paramount.
     8.  Practitioners of integrative medicine should exemplify its principles and commit themselves to self-exploration and self-development.
No one—and I mean no one advocating for science-based medicine—disagrees with #1, 2, 5, 6, 7, or 8. In fact, we wouldn’t have (much of) a problem with #3 if it didn’t include alternative medicine in it or even #4 if it didn’t make the false assumption that natural is better and instead stuck with suggesting only that less invasive therapies should be used whenever possible. I also can’t help but point out that when you compare reality to #5 you will often find that in much of integrative medicine alternative medicines are accepted uncritically. UCI itself is a great example, given the history of naturopaths using homeopathy there, but I could also point to Harvard, Georgetown, George Washington University, the Cleveland Clinic, and the University of Kansas, among many others.
Dr. Weil then tells us integrative medicine is all about the evidence, man:
These studies have yielded robust enough results that medical societies include IM in clinical guidelines. For example, the American Heart Assn. states that meditation “may be considered a reasonable adjunct to guideline-directed cardiovascular risk reduction,” and the American College of Physicians recommends acupuncture and mind-body approaches for low back pain.
I’ve discussed the ACP recommendations before. They’re based on really weak evidence, as I mentioned when last I discussed the Samueli gift. Similarly meditation and mindfulness studies are plagued with methodological problems, not the least of which is an extreme lack of standardization of definitions of basic terms, such as “meditation” or “mindfulness,” as Steve Novella pointed out recently. That’s probably why the best even an advocate can point to is a statement from the AHA that meditation “may be” a “reasonable adjunct” to guideline-based modalities. One can’t help but wonder why, if integrative medicine is so science-based, Dr. Weil couldn’t come up with better examples to support his argument than this truly thin gruel. Moreover, even if it turns out that meditation has cardiovascular benefits, then it would simply become part of science-based medicine, no need for a separate specialty devoted to rebranding lifestyle medicine as somehow “alternative” needed.
Integrative medicine everywhere, but not a mention of what it really is
Like nearly all universities, UCI produces a slick quarterly magazine in which it touts its activities and achievements, the better to garner donations from alumni and other interested parties. The cover of the fall issue features the Samuelis beaming at the camera as they apparently “reimagine” the future of health. Within the pages are five—count ’em, five!—articles on integrative medicine, UCI, and the Samuelis, plus a graphic defining health:
There’s also a quote from Dr. Howard Federoff, the Vice chancellor for health affairs and CEO of UCI Health:
The future of health lies in an integrative approach that recognizes no two patients are alike. Our individual genomes, history, lifestyle and decisions make each of us unique and deserving of the best possible care. At UCI, doctors and allied health professionals will use scientific evidence, cutting-edge therapies and traditional medicine to pave the way for a healthier tomorrow.
Yes, each of us is unique, but we’re also not so unique that we can’t identify what treatments work in large groups of us.
Here are the articles:
    • “Just What the Doctor Ordered“
    • “A Heart for Healing“
    • “Wellness Champion“
    • “Whole-Body Experience“
    • “A Picture of Health“
Each is slick. Each is glossy. Each is very PR-savvy. Recall, now, that the $200 million is to be allocated thusly: $50 million towards construction of a facility to house the Susan and Henry Samueli College of Health Sciences, which, we learn, is to be matched by UCI, which will also contribute $50 million to build this facility, projected to open in 2021. We also learn that one-third of that space will be occupied by the Susan Samueli Integrative Health Institute, described as a “hub for educational programs and research on nonconventional and complementary treatments, such as acupuncture to relieve pain and meditation to control stress.”
Over and over and over again, the articles emphasize how science-based everything is going to be. For instance, in the first article, here’s Dr. Federoff:
Dr. Howard Federoff, vice chancellor for health affairs and CEO of UCI Health, says that several nonconventional treatments are “poised to go mainstream” but need further study before they’re “ready for prime time.” Anecdotal evidence isn’t enough, he cautions. Citing aromatherapy as an example, he says the benefits described by patients must be confirmed by “rigorous” experiments.
I’m always amused at how integrative medicine proponents are always claiming that there are “several unconventional treatments” that are on the verge of being validated and “going mainstream,” but somehow none of them ever really do. It would be one thing if this infiltration of alternative medicine into academia were a new thing, but it’s been going on close to 25 years now, and yet it’s always the same old song. As for aromatherapy, yes, humans like good smells. They can lift our spirits. It’s like massage. It feels good when done properly. The problem, as with so much of “complementary” medicine is when specific medical claims are made for such modalities.
Dr. Shaista Malik, a cardiologist who directs UCI’s existing Susan Samueli Center for Integrative Medicine echoes Dr. Federoff’s sentiment:
Malik agrees: “The science for many of these remedies isn’t there yet, except in bits and pieces. Our mission in the next 10 years is to research not only whether a method works, but how it works.” Among other things, that entails taking steps to rule out “placebo effects.”
Once a treatment’s effectiveness is scientifically validated, UCI will offer it to all patients and think about incorporating it into the curricula, Federoff says.
I’ll give Dr. Malik credit for speaking the right words. For instance, she says “whether” a method works, but if there’s one thing I’ve come to discover about advocates of integrative medicine, it’s that whenever they say they will study “whether” and “how” a treatment works, the evidence they accept as confirming “whether” a study works is generally pretty low quality and they tend to spend their time doing what Harriet Hall likes to call “tooth fairy science” studying “how” a pseudoscientific treatment works. Acupuncture is a fantastic example. Despite the manner in which the totality of the evidence base for acupuncture strongly supports the conclusion that it does not work detectably better than placebo for anything, there is a huge cottage industry of researchers studying “how” acupuncture “works,” complete with functional MRI studies, animal models, and electrophysiology.
None of this professed devotion to hard core scientific evidence, I note, stops UCI from offering an optional three-year integrative track for its family medicine residents, in which residents cover acupuncture, mineral supplements, traditional Chinese medicine and “holistic cures.” Depressingly, two-thirds of the residents opt for this track. That’s because integrative medicine is all about the future, ma-an, unlike us hidebound relics of the past:
“The current generation of students is far more open-minded” than the medical establishment, Federoff notes. For that reason, it may take a decade or so for UCI’s approach to gain wide acceptance, he says.
Federoff, an exercise buff who formulated a few ideas for UCI’s new health paradigm during early morning runs and bike rides, says his own receptiveness to avant-garde therapies grew out of nearly 30 years as a neuroscientist. Having watched one dogmatic theory after another get toppled by new discoveries, he says, “I came to believe there’s a lot we don’t know. You can’t look at the world through a lens that was ground 100 years ago and believe that’s the only way to look at the world.”
Of course, this is utter and complete nonsense. Science has changed medicine in unbelievable ways over the last 100 years—even over the last 30 years. In my own specialty, I’ve watched and adapted as breast cancer treatment has changed radically since my time in medical school. Let’s put it this way. If we were truly viewing medicine through a lens that was ground 100 years ago, we’d still be doing radical mastectomies for breast cancer and treating people for “autointoxication” from their own feces as the root cause of ailments large and small, even psychiatric ones. (Anyone remember Dr. Henry Cotton?) I would counter that integrative medicine is the force in medicine looking at the world through a lens that was ground 100 years ago—or even 1,000 or 5,000 years ago—not conventional medicine.
A picture of health?
Of the remaining articles, two focus on faculty members studying integrative medicine, one on patient testimonials (yes, patient testimonials), and the last one on Susan Samueli. One faculty member, Dr. Malik, provides an excellent example of how conventional science-based medical interventions are relentlessly “rebranded” as somehow “integrative.” In the profile of her, we learn that she became a cardiologist because there was a strong history of heart disease in her family, with many family members having heart attacks in their 40s and 50s, and that, observing how so many patients just went back to their same unhealthy lifestyles after stenting or bypass surgery, she decided to try to do something about it:
Hoping to break the cycle, Malik launched a cardiac prevention program at UCI five years ago. Over eight 90-minute sessions, participants conferred with a dietitian and an exercise physiologist on strategies to lose weight and restore their well-being.
The results were often dramatic, she says: “I could see the power of nutrition and lifestyle adjustments to improve people’s health trajectory.”
None of this is outside of science-based medicine, and none of this is in any way “alternative.” Unfortunately, as is so often the case in integrative medicine, it wasn’t long before she went down a pseudoscientific path. First, it was stress reduction, which isn’t pseudoscientific, which led to yoga, which isn’t pseudoscientific as long as it is treated as a form of exercise, but then she went down a dubious road:
After noticing that her cardiac group exercised more and ate better while practicing stress management techniques, Malik started exploring other treatments offered by the Samueli Center.
“I had women with microvascular disease who were taking eight or nine medications but still showing symptoms,” she recalls. So Malik added acupuncture to their treatment plans and, she says, the symptoms cleared up.
Another set of patients couldn’t take anti-cholesterol statin drugs because of side effects. Malik put them on herbal supplements – such as berberine (derived from barberry), artichoke extract and citrus bergamot, alone or in combination with decreased statin doses – and again achieved positive results, she says.
Overall, she notes, the cardiac prevention program’s success rate (loosely defined as long-term weight loss, regular exercise and lower cholesterol) rose from roughly 35 percent before integrative methods to nearly 55 percent after. About 300 people have been through the program, which also includes lab tests, genetic screening and cardiac imaging to assess heart disease risks.
I was interested to see if Dr. Malik had published any of these amazing observations. So I did a PubMed search, which is rather difficult because Malik is a common name but somewhat easier because apparently her entire career thus far has been at UCI. To her credit, she has a nice large R01 grant to “study how blood, genetic and imaging tests can predict who will develop heart disease,” none of which involves the “integrative” modalities she’s touting. In fact, her publication record is admirably and boringly…conventional. If she’s published her results with herbal supplements, acupuncture, and success rate of her program, I haven’t been able to find it. It’s almost as though a double standard were operating, where she does rigorous science for “conventional” cardiology but accepts a lesser standard of evidence for all the “integrative” stuff. Annoyingly, the article conflates her NIH grant with the woo she’s into.
As for rigorous science, the article on UCI physicians and researchers rather belies that claim. Yes, there are researchers examining exercise and nutrition. Dr. David Kilgore, for instance, works on managing stress, helping patients learn to eat a healthier diet, and manages a healthy food pantry. There’s also an orthopedic researcher named Joyce Keyak who is testing a technique to add radioisotopes to bone glue and using it to “precisely treat cancerous tumors while fortifying weakened or fractured bones.” What this has to do with “integrative medicine,” I have no idea. Then there’s Dr. Mahtab Jafari studying Rhodiola rosea, a golden flowering plant that grows in the Arctic, as a potential anti-aging drug. In other words, she’s doing traditional pharmacognosy. Finally, there’s Dr. Aimee Pierce, who is part of the 18-month, national EXERT Study, which aims to determine if exercise by seniors can prevent or delay the onset of Alzheimer’s disease. None of these studies or activities are in any way “alternative” or objectionable from a scientific standpoint.
However, there’s also quackademic medicine there, too. For instance, Dr. Anna Monique Halbeisen practices osteopathic manipulation:
Halbeisen practices neuromusculoskeletal/osteopathic manipulative medicine with an eye toward integration, working with a team of highly qualified health professionals to empower her patients to take a proactive role in their own care, particularly when it comes to managing stress.
“I don’t see a single patient with low back pain that doesn’t deal with stress,” she says. “But we all hold stress differently in our bodies, depending on our life experiences and our injury patterns. When times get tough, usually that’s when we see a lot more physical manifestations of issues. You really cannot separate the mind and spirit from the actual physical body.”
Hint: Osteopathy is not supported by anything resembling rigorous science.
Then there’s Dr. John Longhurst, who is studying acupuncture:
Now the lab is examining auricular acupuncture, which stimulates different points of the ear, to determine its effects on pain and hypertension. The team also is looking into how electroacupuncture might benefit menopausal women.
“Acupuncture is just one of many forms of therapy that activate our body’s own ability to heal itself,” Longhurst says. “It triggers endorphins, enkephalins and dynorphins – opiates that we produce naturally. We can demonstrate how acupuncture works down to the cellular level. When we do that, it changes people’s notions about it.”
Um, no. You can’t. Because acupuncture doesn’t work. Auricular acupuncture, in fact, is based on completely pseudoscientific ideas mapping organs and body parts to places on the ear. Let’s just put it this way. If you’re studying auricular acupuncture with the belief that it might have benefits, you are not being “scientifically rigorous.”
This is what integrative medicine does, though. It “integrates” quackery with science as though they were equivalent, using scientifically plausible treatments, such as nutrition and exercise, as cover for the pseudoscience like osteopathy and acupuncture.
We see this in the testimonials prominently featured. One patient, Dannie Cassell, has metastatic breast cancer and developed heart disease. Dr. Malik helped her alter her lifestyle and diet to increase healthy eating and have her do more exercise. Mel Shubash has chronic back pain and came to Gottschalk Medical Plaza’s Center for Pain Management, where he has been receiving science-based approaches, such as physical therapy, epidural injections, and steroid injections, but also doing yoga and acupuncture. Justina Cortes was obese and prediabetic, and suffered from panic attacks as well. She’s been undergoing lifestyle and nutrition counseling and has done very well, to the point where she is no longer prediabetic. Lesley Ginsburg was diagnosed with ovarian cancer and underwent grueling surgery and chemotherapy. I found what her doctor, Dr. Robert Bristow, director of gynecologic oncology services for UC Irvine Health was quoted as saying to be highly telling:
Bristow says he’s a “huge fan” of integrative health. “For the most part, modern medicine is driven by clinical trial-based work that’s been proven and published in the New England Journal of Medicine,” he says, “but we can lose sight of other treatments that are also effective. We limit ourselves as doctors.”
He advocates everything from art therapy to acupuncture – not as a substitute, but to offer relief from highly invasive traditional cancer care. Painting classes, for example, could provide a beneficial routine for cancer patients also suffering from depression – and could be vital. If people can’t get out of bed, he notes, they’re not going to make it to chemotherapy.
This is, of course, true, but one doesn’t need acupuncture to overcome depression and fatigue. Similarly, there’s nothing wrong with painting classes, music, or other activities to keep one’s mind occupied while going through care. We used to call such activities patient support or morale services. What integrative medicine does is to medicalize them unnecessarily.
The author of it all
The final article is a portrait of Susan Samueli, the author of it all. What is revealing, if you know it, is more what is left out of this portrait than what is told. For instance, after she married her husband Henry:
Eventually, they married, moved to a comfortable San Fernando Valley home of their own and began a family. She gave up her IBM career after 13 years. It was then that she began fully exploring her newfound passion for complementary care approaches.
“I started learning everything I could about what was then called alternative medicine,” Samueli says. “I was using a different side of my brain than I did with computer programming, and it felt great. And then my children were born.”
When their first daughter became sick at 4 months old and was given antibiotics, she suffered side effects that troubled her mother.
Samueli discussed it with her husband and said, “I’m going to take her off the antibiotics and try alternative treatments.” He agreed, noting that the baby might have a virus anyway, rendering the antibiotics useless. To her delight, their daughter was quickly restored to good health.
What we know from other sources is that Susan Samueli’s passion for alternative medicine developed when she developed a cold on a trip to France and was offered a homeopathic remedy (aconite), which she tried. Because she had a cold, she got better, but she became a believer. Indeed, she is now a homeopath herself, having received a PhD in nutrition from the American Holistic College of Nutrition in 1993 and a Diploma in Homeopathy from the British Institute of Homeopathy in 1994. She converted her husband, who is now a believer himself, such that he has been quoted as saying:
When I feel a cold or flu coming on, rather than run to the doctor, I run to Susan to figure out which homeopathic remedy or Chinese herb I should be taking.
Indeed, she quacks:
She earned nutrition and naturopathy degrees and opened a nutrition business in Northridge. Her clientele grew, she recalls, as she guided other people weaning their children off antibiotics.
“Very often, they were hyperactive because of antibiotics, and so the parents were very, very thankful that we could get them off round after round and get them healthy,” says Samueli, who – working with doctors and their care plans – also was able to help adults going through chemotherapy avoid nausea and anxiety and help chronically ill individuals experience less stress and greater well-being.
One wonders what these children were on antibiotics for.
Quackademic medicine ascendant
In the end, the Samuelis’ $200 gift will indeed transform biomedical sciences and medical education at UCI—and not in a good way. Remember what “integrative medicine” is. What is being “integrated” into medicine is, of course, quackery. Oh, sure, integrative medicine also emphasizes lifestyle modification, such as diet and exercise, but that is part of “conventional medicine” already. There is no good scientific or medical rationale for a separate specialty devoted to just that. What integrative medicine does is that it rebrands perfectly science-based modalities, such as diet and exercise, as somehow “alternative” and then “integrates” quackery, like naturopathy, acupuncture, functional medicine, applied kinesiology, homeopathy, and basically any form of quackery you can think of. Without the quackery, there is no integrative medicine. Worse, the phenomenon has resulted in a most pernicious effect in medical academia, the infiltration of outright quackery into the research and education efforts there, a phenomenon I like to refer to as “quackademic medicine.” What is happening at UCI is the ultimate triumph of quackademic medicine.
Of course, The Very Serious Academics In Very Serious and Very Pressed White Coats who have come to believe in integrative medicine to the point of devoting their careers to it, such as Dr. Federoff and Dr. Malike, vehemently disagree with my characterization. I’m referring to the sort of doctors who present at conferences of learned academics and write what they claim to be evidence-based care guidelines for breast cancer patients. Perhaps the best thing to mention to rile up serious academic advocates of integrative medicine is homeopathy. Any mention of homeopathy is guaranteed provoke paroxysms of self-righteous denial. “Oh, no,” they’ll say, “homeopathy is pseudoscience! It’s quackery. Integrative medicine is evidence-based, and we would never do anything that isn’t evidence-based!” Sadly, as I’ve pointed out time and time again, you can’t have naturopathy without homeopathy, as homeopathy is an integral part of naturopathy. As long as you have naturopaths, you will have homeopathy. Oddly enough, many of these The Very Serious Academics In Very Serious White Coats are utterly oblivious to this simple fact, even ones who write Very Serious Clinical Guidelines with naturopaths and welcome naturopaths into their Very Serious Medical Society.
Dr. Federoff and Dr. Malik might actually believe that their center will be different from all the other integrative medicine centers, that theirs will be a scientifically rigorous integrative medicine program. As long as they stick with the modalities that integrative medicine has claimed from science-based medicine and rebranded, like nutrition, exercise, lifestyle, and stress reduction, they might have a chance to pull it off. However, Susan Samueli is a strong believer in homeopathy. There are doctors offering quackery like auricular acupuncture and osteopathy at UCI. There is at least one naturopath there whose “preferred mode of treatment” is homeopathy:
If Dr. Federoff is serious about being rigorously science-based, the first thing he needs to do is to get rid of all the doctors using auricular acupunctures, naturopaths, and homeopaths. Will we see that? Of course not. That’s why any claim made by the UCI administration that somehow its integrative medicine center and activities will be science-based is either a lie or self-delusion.

Integrative Medicine finally admits it’s attracting bad apples
Integrative medicine proponents finally acknowledge their field is attracting bad apples but fail to identify the real source of their problem: It’s rejection of science-based medicine, not lack of training in integrative medicine.
Jann Bellamy on September 13, 2018
Link

Just yesterday, Steve Novella decried the alternative medicine propaganda that “has been slowly leaching into the medical culture” because it “weaken[s] our collective dedication to a rigorous science-based standard of care.” In addition to delay or avoidance of effective treatment, opportunity costs, financial and psychological harm, and overall promotion of unscientific medicine,
[p]erhaps the most insidious form of harm, however, comes from the erosion of standards within the medical profession. Medicine is only science-based and ethical if its practitioners are science-based and ethical. There is a standard of care within medicine to maintain a minimum of both quality and ethics.
This integration of alternative medicine, that is, unproven, disproven and/or frankly fantastical diagnoses and treatments, into conventional medical practice is otherwise known as “integrative medicine.” Surprisingly, in a recent article, two practitioners of, and advocates for, integrative medicine agree that quality and ethics are problematic in their chosen “specialty.” The article is full of the uncritical boosterism that characterizes integrative medicine and only tangentially acknowledges that a lack of evidence of safety and efficacy might be an issue. To their credit, however, it does seem to be slowly dawning on them that, in Mark Crislip’s immortal words:
when you integrate cow pie with apple pie, the cow pie is not made better, the apple pie is made worse.
We’ll return to the authors’ particular take on the infestation of poor quality of care and unethical behavior in integrative medicine in a moment, but first, let’s briefly introduce the authors and the journal in which their article appears.
The article, described as a “commentary from the JCAM [Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine] partnership with the Osher Collaborative for Integrative Medicine,” was written by Melinda Ring, MD, and Sandy Newmark, MD. Ring is with the Osher Center for Integrative Medicine at Northwestern University’s Feinberg School of Medicine and a member of the Board of Directors of the American Board of Integrative Medicine (ABOIM), the organization offering a dubious board certification in integrative medicine. Newmark is with the Osher Center for Integrative Medicine at the University of California San Francisco.
Both are full-throated proponents of integrating unproven or disproven treatments into medical practice. Ring has written, for example, that
Acupuncture can balance glucose and insulin sensitivity, assist in weight loss, reduce inflammation, balance hormones, and induce ovulation in patients with PCOS.
Actually, acupuncture is a theatrical placebo and doesn’t work, for anything, including PCOS.
Newmark admits using “nonstandard” testing sent to “specialty labs” in his treatment of autism spectrum disorder, as well as “biomed” treatments (including gluten-free, casein-free diets, a “non-supported as a treatment for autism“), herbs, dietary supplements, and Traditional Chinese Medicine, his rationale apparently being that if evidence-based treatments aren’t available, the physician should feel free to abandon evidence-based medicine.
The editor of the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine is John Weeks, who has no background in science or medicine of the type that would be expected of a medical journal editor. He is a relentless cheerleader for integrative medicine. (And no fan of this blog.) His loyalty is such that, in his Editor’s Note, he can’t even bring himself to accurately describe Ring and Newmark’s article, saying their “focus is on the mosaic of integrative practices of medical doctors,” completely ignoring, as we shall see, their actual focus on what they see as the primary risk to patients from integrative medicine practitioners. The JCAM‘s editorial board is chock full of those who promote integrating unproven/disproven/fantasy treatments, such as homeopathy, acupuncture, and functional medicine, including Dana Ullman, Iris Bell, Wayne Jonas, Heather Boon, Richard Niemtzow, Patrick Hanaway, Suzanna Zick, and Gloria Yeh.
In the title of their article, Ring and Newmark ask:
“Practice Drift: Are There Risks When Integrative Medicine Physicians Exceed Their Scope?”
Despite their enthusiasm for unproven/disproven treatments in their own practices, the authors admit to misgivings about integrative medicine:
In response to the growing number of providers seeking a new practice model, individual clinicians, educational organizations, and businesses are increasingly providing trainings and certifications in areas such as functional medicine, antiaging medicine, regenerative medicine, and integrative medicine. These trainings are typically offered as brief in-person courses or online modules. Some are promoted as profitable, turn-key sources of revenue [citing “Functional Medicine University” as an example of the latter].
While these proliferating continuing education and certification opportunities can provide expanded options for providers and patients, they often lack third-party verification of their standards through organizations that accredit credentialing bodies. They may enroll medical doctors from any medical specialty, and typically lack clinical oversight in the practical application of diagnostic testing and treatments to real patients.
In this context of practice expansion for clinical, business, or mixed reasons, providers from disciplines across the board risk going beyond their primary training in unethical or dangerous ways.
Which made me wonder: What sort of practitioner did they expect would be attracted to integrative medicine and its rejection of science (and even scientific plausibility) and evidence as the appropriate measure of a treatment’s efficacy and safety? Did they not anticipate that the embrace of quackery would invite those prone to ethical lapses?
In fact, they need look no further than two luminaries of the integrative medicine movement as excellent examples of their concern. Andrew Weil, MD, the main instigator behind the creation of a board certification in integrative medicine, did a one-year internship but did not complete a residency in anything. Mark Hyman, MD, functional medicine guru, did a family practice residency and has no university-level education in nutrition.
However, the authors quickly disavow any criticism of these practices per se:
The purpose of this article is neither to censor any particular group of providers nor to advocate for unreasonable restrictions on integrative practices.
And:
The growing complexity can be viewed as a positive in many ways, with greater access for patients and increasing diagnosis and treatment options for medical doctors who are interested in expanding their care options and approaches.
Thus, their issue with functional medicine, antiaging medicine, regenerative medicine (a legitimate specialty hijacked by stem cell quackery), and integrative medicine is not that these practices lack evidence of safety and efficacy to the point of rank quackery. It is that their practitioners may not have sufficient education and training to use the unproven or disproven diagnostic methods and treatments they typically employ.
The impression that they are unconcerned with evidence-based medicine, as opposed to the practitioner’s level of training in alternative medicine, is reinforced by three examples they give of a physician’s moving outside his training and scope of practice, a phenomenon they admit “seems particularly prevalent in the practices of medical doctors who have chosen to enter into complementary and integrative medicine.”
    • A psychiatrist, who has no training in infectious diseases and endocrinology, completes functional medicine training and Lyme-literacy courses. His practice includes specialized testing, diagnosing patients with “adrenal fatigue,” parasites, and “chronic Lyme” and prescribing, among other treatments, antibiotics and “extensive supplements.”
    • An “integrative gynecologist” prescribes bioidentical hormones not only for women, but also children and men, “populations not included in his postgraduate residency.”
    • A primary care physician does some self-study and takes a weeklong class and “rebrands” herself as an integrative consultant.
Ring and Newmark fail to note that “chronic Lyme,” parasites, and “adrenal fatigue” are popular fake diagnoses. They also fail to explain that “bioidentical hormones” is a marketing, not a medical, term, and are of both unproven effectiveness and questionable safety. To them, the problem is whether
simply having graduated medical school [should] entitle a physician to practice in any area of medicine, whether or not a few short trainings are added.
This is an odd criticism coming from Ring, who sits on the ABOIM. The ABOIM does not require board certification in any particular specialty to become board-certified in integrative medicine. It is only recently that the ABOIM required a “fellowship” (none of which are ACGME-accredited, as best I can tell) in integrative medicine. Even then, a fellowship is not required if the physician has a degree from a naturopathic, chiropractic, or oriental medicine school. Prior to these requirements, all an applicant needed was to be board certified or board eligible in anything, have a license to practice medicine, and rack up 500 points of “documented training and experience,” including at least one year of clinical experience, worth up to 250 points and could be documented with a couple of short letters. The rest could be gotten by taking the very type continuing education courses the authors complain about.
The authors identify four risks of inadequate training, two of which are real and two of which are of concern only to those who buy into integrative medicine ideology. They correctly point out that patients may be harmed by inappropriate or missed diagnoses and incorrect treatment and “subjected to significant financial risks from paying for excessive laboratory testing and other costs”. They also correctly point out the risk of malpractice liability and board discipline for practicing outside one’s scope.
In fact, it was not too long ago that a ABOIM board-certified integrative medicine physician had his license revoked by the Florida Board of Medicine when a young patient died under his care for lack of treatment of her cancer. He rejected the cancer diagnosis of several experts in favor of those favorite integrative bugaboos, allergies and hormonal issues. Several physicians have been disciplined for their substandard care based on their quack diagnosis and treatment of “chronic Lyme.” And just this week, Kaiser Health News reported on the discipline of a California physician, Prudence Hall, for her inappropriate prescription of “bioidentical hormones,” a standard but unproven “integrative” treatment. She also failed to diagnose a cancerous uterine tumor in one patient despite performing numerous ultrasounds, which she was not qualified to read. The news report noted that another California physician had previously lost his license for inappropriate “bioidentical hormone” prescribing.
The authors also say that practice “drift” is “a risk to the credibility of integrative medicine”, which, again, they identify solely as a function of lack of training, ignoring the lack of evidence of safety and efficacy of the practices that define the field:
Although integrative medicine steadily gaining acceptance, there is still much doubt and skepticism. Then providers treat outside of their scope of practice, negative judgment about the particular provider involved could generalize to negative impressions of the entire field of integrative medicine.
As an example, one of the authors cites personal experience in the reaction of infectious disease experts to the IV antibiotic treatments employed by the psychiatrist treating “chronic Lyme”. Somehow, I doubt that lack of training was the ID experts’ only objection.
The authors cite no evidence supporting the notion that integrative medicine is “steadily gaining acceptance”, although, anecdotally, it appears to be true, as Steve Novella discussed yesterday. It is also true that there is “much doubt and skepticism”, well-deserved in SBM’s view, although the main critics seem to be limited to bloggers, either in the blogs themselves or in the medical literature (also here and here). Otherwise, academic medicine appears to be fully on board and it’s crickets from the rest of the medical community.
Finally, practice “drift” risks “alienation of complementary providers”, something the ABOIM has already managed to accomplish by its very existence. In any event, the authors cite, as an example, licensed acupuncturists, who have far more training than medical doctors in acupuncture. Once again, it’s the lack of training in theatrical placebo that is the problem, not the use of theatrical placebo itself.
As a remedy for integrative physicians exceeding their scope of practice, the authors prescribe various remedies, like acknowledging inexperience to patients, patient resources on identifying “red flags” on provider practice websites and materials (actually, these already exist – also here and here – but their warnings would eliminate too many integrative practices), ethics and scope of practice modules in fellowship and certification programs (apparently, this not standard practice or they wouldn’t have mentioned it), and medical board discipline.
In the end, what the authors really want to have their gluten-free cake and eat it too.
As the [integrative] medical field grows up, it must be considered how best to guide it toward its best self – one who recognizes the risks of “off-label” practice and ensures that safeguards are in place to prevent harm, while balancing the need for practice autonomy and individualized clinical exploration and care.
In other words, they want to ensure “safeguards” to “prevent harm” while, at the same time, rejecting the one method that actually ensures that an adequate risk-benefit analysis is performed for any diagnostic method or treatment: the rational application of science to the practice of medicine. “Practice autonomy” and “individualized clinical exploration and care” are, of course, dog whistles for rejecting science-based medicine, as evidenced by the authors’ studied refusal to criticize their “specialty” for its signature feature: the embrace of, at best, unproven diagnostic methods and treatments, and, at worst, outright quackery. Recognizing “the risks of ‘off-label’ practice” is welcome, but it ignores the most important risk to patients and the practice of medicine from integrative practitioners: the abandonment of science as benchmark for the standard of care in medicine.

Dana-Farber Cancer Center’s Integrative Medicine Expansion
Clay Jones on August 12, 2016
Link


In June, an article in the Boston Globe covered yet another incursion of pseudoscience into a major academic medical center, this time at the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute. Dana-Farber, located just a couple of miles from the library where I’m writing this post, has provided world-class care for children and adults with cancer since 1947. It’s kind of a big deal.
Sidney Farber, already known as the “father” of pediatric pathology, was the first person to induce remission in pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia, which had a 100% mortality rate up to that point. He then went on to earn the title of “father” of modern chemotherapy by also curing Wilm’s tumor, a rare pediatric cancer of the kidneys. Farber, who was featured in the phenomenal book The Emperor of All Maladies: A Biography of Cancer by Siddhartha Mukherjee, would almost certainly be opposed the double standard being employed to justify quackery in the facility bearing his name (or anywhere else).
To Farber, a scientific approach to treating pediatric cancer patients was paramount, even to the point where he at first refused to initiate the combination therapy that would open the age of modern chemotherapy because he wanted to protect children from a potentially haphazard rush to cure them. He wanted strict scientific protocols in place and assurances that the evidence would be followed regardless of the outcome, so that the intense desire to find a cure for children that otherwise faced only suffering and death would not add to that suffering.
Unfortunately, combining science-based medical care with medical fantasy is hardly new at Dana-Farber. The Leonard P. Zakim Center for Integrative Therapies has been doing this since the fall of 2000. Using marketing clichés such as “providing cancer patients and their families with the opportunity to take a more active role in their care,” the Zakim Center has increased the number of patients seen yearly from 778 in its first year to 4,000 in 2008.
In 2015, 3,000 patients received acupuncture or massage alone, with many more taking advantage of other services, such as art, music, meditation, nutrition, and various forms of exercise. In addition to the list of interventions that have been co-opted by and relabeled as alternative, pure quackery like reiki, reflexology, and the aforementioned acupuncture are also available for patients. The Zakim Center was also a founding member of the Society of Integrative Oncology. If you aren’t convinced that Dana-Farber has sold its soul and placed marketing over ethical patient care, here is a recent post from their Insight blog entitled “How Can Reflexology Help Cancer Patients?”
Another meaningless anecdote
The recent Boston Globe article, entitled “Easing a patient’s pain – even without proof it works”, discusses Dana-Farber’s $2 million “integrative therapies” expansion that will allow twice as many outpatient appointments for Zakim Center services. But not before providing the typical opening anecdote to hook the reader and prep their brain to ignore the lack of actual evidence, because kids with cancer = emotions:
Massage therapist Maria Barbara “Bambi” Mathay roamed the pediatric clinic at Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, looking for takers. It wasn’t long before she spotted Carlie Gonzalez, 15, wrapped in a yellow blanket and weary from seven months of chemotherapy.
The image of a predator stalking its prey, or a carnival barker attempting to entice passersby, comes to mind while reading that. These patients are, in a very real sense, vulnerable to predation and misinformation. But maybe that isn’t fair. I believe that Mathay believes that what she is doing is helpful, that it helps to relieve some of the intense pain and nausea children with cancer sometimes experience. But does it matter what she believes? It would be one thing if she were simply giving relaxing massages, but…
As the liquid dripped into her arm, Carlie rolled up a pant leg for a session of foot reflexology. “It kind of takes your mind off your stomach,” she said. While Mathay gently pressed on her toes, Carlie sleepily closed her eyes.
So rather than simply a calming foot rub and some pleasant conversation with a caring individual, which would be just fine, the patient is subjected to quackery and is being used as part of the propaganda that helps it spread. She even admits that the process simply distracts her from her nausea. Distraction is a well-known phenomenon that science-based healthcare professionals employ daily in the care of ill patients.
Distraction, or rather altering the attentional state via passive or active methods, has been established as effective in modulating response to both acute and chronic subjective symptoms, particularly pain, in a variety of circumstances that don’t require deception. We know that active distraction is usually more effective than having a patient simply watch TV or listen to music, for example. So you could argue that this patient would have been better off with an electronic game to play. Better yet, Dana-Farber could use the $2 million to hire more Child Life practitioners who can assess each patient individually to find what mode of distraction would best suit their personality and abilities. This would be a lot more holistic than a foot massaging unitasker.
This anecdote, as sweet as it is, is just another example of two very common problems we regularly encounter. On one hand, stories like this are part of a bait-and-switch tactic commonly used by proponents of integrating unproven and implausible interventions with conventional medical care. To the uninitiated this probably seems like a good thing. Reflexology may just be a fancy name for a good old fashioned foot rub after all. It isn’t until almost the end of the article, after most readers will have moved on to something else, that the author provides a brief and inaccurate explanation: “Practitioners believe that pressing spots on the foot that correspond to organs, glands, and other parts of the body can promote deeper relaxation.” That may be the sanitized version Dana-Farber promotes, but it isn’t what reflexology proponents in the real world (or even other academic institutions) are claiming.
The other problem is the utter cluelessness that the media tends to demonstrate when it comes to pseudoscience in medicine. The author of this Globe article, Liz Kowalczyk, is a healthcare and medicine journalist and was a finalist for the Pulitzer in 2013 but she has offered up to the public a pile of credulous tripe. It contains an iota of token skepticism sandwiched between two emotional anecdotes and a barrage of pro-quackery clichés. Why not include one of the many easily-available cases where a child was directly or indirectly harmed by unproven therapies? Why not avoid worthless anecdotes altogether and do your job as a journalist? If Kowalczyk can’t get this stuff right, what chance does the public have to find accurate information?
They don’t need no stinkin’ evidence!
The article continues with a seemingly endless stream of fallacies and blatant misinformation:
A growing body of research supports acupuncture as a treatment for pain and nausea in oncology patients, but few high-quality studies exist on the effectiveness of reflexology and reiki.
It is true that the body of acupuncture research continues to grow, however this is a very poor synopsis of it. As regular readers of Science-Based Medicine know, the most accurate interpretation of the acupuncture literature, and one that takes into account basic science, prior plausibility, and the use of effective controls, is that acupuncture doesn’t work for any condition in any patient. It is theatrical placebo that evokes greater expectation of benefit, and thus greater subjective response, when the practitioner puts on a better performance. The imprimatur of one of the most highly-respected cancer centers in the world certainly adds to the impression of legitimacy and thus likely increases any expectation of benefit.
It’s also true that few high-quality studies have looked into reflexology and reiki. Dana-Farber offers them anyway though. The statement is misleading however, in that we already know enough to say with confidence that these nonsense therapies offer no objective and specific benefit, at best eliciting only subjective placebo responses similar to that of acupuncture or playing with a therapy dog. The dog at least exists, as opposed to mystical human energy fields or an undetectable connection between your foot and your spleen.
Then there is the best sentence in the entire article:
The investment by Dana-Farber, a leading cancer treatment center, underscores a growing willingness among mainstream medical institutions nationally to offer complementary therapies that appear to help patients — even without definitive proof.
There it is, right there in all its glory. The author lumps everything together into the category of “complementary therapies,” another common mistake made by reporters who don’t understand the topic they are covering and often a calculated strategy used by proponents looking to get their foot in the door with co-opted science-based therapies like exercise and relaxation. Exercise doesn’t just “appear to help patients.” We know it does based on decades of high quality research. Acupuncture and its ilk have only the appearance to efficacy and these mainstream medical institutions have an ethical duty to be honest with patients. When a Dana-Farber physician recommends reflexology because it seems to work, without explaining the lack of plausibility and supporting evidence, they are violating that patient’s autonomy, or parent’s authority, to make medical decisions based on accurate information.
Why are academic medical centers opening promoting quackery?
Why would a major academic cancer center offer therapies, like acupuncture and reiki, without solid proof of benefit? Why would they risk taking a hit to their credibility? While I don’t know what is in the hearts of hospital administrators with certainty, it is very likely the result of a combination of marketing aspirations and the work of a vocal minority of believers with money and influence. But those influences needed fertile ground to take root.
As we have discussed before numerous times, the vast majority of physicians working at these centers know that reflexology and reiki are baloney but just aren’t interested in this issue. They have patients to treat and cancer to cure, which are admirable endeavors. With the addition of these integrative medicine centers, they still have research to do and cancer patients to treat, some of which may now be more likely to take part in risky alternative therapies or to forego conventional treatment altogether. These huge numbers of physicians and other healthcare professionals that are uninterested in quackery infiltrating their institutions deserve the lion’s share of the blame for it.
Clearly there are physicians that believe in these interventions. The Globe article quotes Dr. Jennifer Ligibel, who is the director of the Zakim Center and a breast cancer specialist. I would love to eavesdrop on a conversation between her and David Gorski at the next ASCO conference. Ligibel provides a few examples of sloppy thinking and bogus rationalizations used by proponents of irregular medicine:
“Our cancer treatments have gotten better and patients are living longer than ever after diagnosis,” said Dr. Jennifer Ligibel, director of the Leonard P. Zakim Center for Integrative Therapies and a breast oncologist. “The flip side is our therapies have a lot of side effects. And traditional Western ways of trying to treat these side effects are pretty limited.”
Yes, science has helped many people avoid certain death from a cancer diagnosis and to live longer than doctors a generation or two removed would have dreamed possible, so let’s try something else? Of course science-based therapy has side effects. If it can alter physiology of the human body, it can alter the physiology of the human body, regardless of the intervention’s origins. In addition to demonstrating her bias and cultural ignorance by labeling science-based care as “Western,” she begs the very large question that alternative approaches are an improvement. If they were, the science would show it and we wouldn’t be having this discussion.
Many patients also are burdened with depression, and anxiety that the cancer will return.
This is undoubtedly true…so reiki? Perhaps providing your patients with counseling rather than nonsense would be a more effective intervention.
Ligibel said Dana-Farber will study different therapies and approaches — including whether 15-minute sessions during chemotherapy improve patients’ quality of life — in part to help guide other providers. “Without research it’s hard to know where resources should be devoted,” she said.
The OAM NCCAM NCCIH has spent billions of dollars of taxpayer money investigating alternative medicine and has failed to provide high quality evidence that any of it works. And the studies they’ve funded showing it doesn’t are consistently ignored. There are already thousands of poorly-designed and controlled studies with positive results for believers to cling too, so what possible benefit could come from a few more? Sadly this comes across as just a transparent justification. In reality, we already have research and the basic science knowledge enough to confidently divert resources away from such medical misadventures.
Speaking of transparent justifications:
Ligibel said more research is needed to sort this out. “I struggle with the mechanism of a lot of these therapies, but I’ve seen them work for people,” she said.
And:
Lorenzo Cohen, director of integrative medicine at MD Anderson said doctors don’t understand the biological mechanisms of these therapies, which is why there is debate. Still, he said, the risk of harm is nearly nonexistent, and if patients feel better “there is something to be said about that.”
There is debate because these therapies are blatant pseudoscience. And I wouldn’t exactly call it a debate. The existence of integrative medicine centers and believers within the medical profession doesn’t mean that there are two legitimate sides to this issue any more than the existence of the Discovery Institute means that there is a debate between evolutionary biologists and…irreducible complexionists?
We don’t understand the biological mechanism of acetaminophen, but we have clear evidence it reduces fever and has analgesic properties. We don’t understand the biological mechanism of IVIG in the treatment of Kawasaki disease, but it’s malpractice if you don’t give it because there is clear evidence that it substantially reduces the risk of serious injury to the coronary arteries. It doesn’t seem that they are “struggling with the mechanism of these therapies” as much as they are struggling to find something, anything to justify their use in the face of so much negative evidence and that they have already decided that these therapies are effective based on anecdotal experiences.
Conclusion: Fighting quackery in hospitals is hard
It’s 2016 and we continue to see quackery being integrated into our best academic centers, which I assume can now generate electricity from the spinning of the many medical pioneers who made them great centers of science and medical progress. Dana-Farber certainly won’t be the last to announce expansions such as the one written about in the featured Boston Globe article. Even Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, home of Paul Offit, has caved and began offering acupuncture to children last month. It doesn’t look good for those of us struggling to push back.
I’m frequently at a loss when trying to come up with something positive to include in the conclusions to posts like this. Yes we should fight the good fight. We should try to reach out to others who are on the fence or who are skeptical and looking for like-minded folks and science-based information. Of course we should support organizations such as the Society for Science-Based Medicine and reach out to our government leaders. We should vote with our feet, when possible, and not support organizations that promote quackery with our business.
We should do all of these things as much as possible. Still, it is difficult to avoid a sense of helplessness. I am forced to focus on little accomplishments, such as when I discuss a concept such as this or one of the many we cover on SBM with a student and they get it. Every now and then one of them doesn’t just get it, but they are excited about it and they want to learn more. Maybe one day I’ll set someone on a path of skepticism that will result in meaningful change somewhere down the line. Sure it’s unlikely, but it’s a nice thought, and certainly a better one than what I’ve written about with the previous 2,600 or so words of this post.

Another pebble in the quackademic integrative avalanche
We’ve documented the infiltration of quackery into academic medicine through the “integration” of mystical and prescientific treatment modalities into medicine. Here, we look at a pebble in the quackademic avalanche. Is it too late for the pebbles to vote?
David Gorski on April 9, 2018
Link

“Integrative medicine” is a frequent topic on this blog because, as a pseudo-specialty it represents as well as quackademic medicine just how deeply pseudoscience has insinuated itself into academic and, increasingly, community medical centers. It’s a process that’s occurred over the last 25-30 years or so, as, increasingly, ostensibly science-based academic medical centers, started studying and then embracing mystical and pseudoscientific alternative medicine modalities like reiki, acupuncture, and even anthroposophic medicine. Billionaires like Susan and Henry Samueli donated hundreds of millions of dollars to UC-Irvine to transform it into a center for quackademic medicine, while Georgetown University embraced all manner of nonsense and the Cleveland Clinic started peddling traditional Chinese medicine and functional medicine to the point that its brains fall out and one of its leaders embarrassingly spewed antivaccine nonsense before opening his own quack clinic. Meanwhile, Andrew Weil promotes a “board certification” in “integrative medicine” that isn’t real, at least not in the sense that most board certifications are, but it does allow him to promote a residency curriculum in “integrative medicine.”
Compared to some of these developments, what I’m about to discuss might seem to be a minor thing. Indeed, it might be the equivalent of a pebble in an avalanche. Still, I think it’s telling and worth discussing. After all, it is through an accumulation of these minor triumphs that “integrative medicine” is increasingly blurring the line between science and pseudoscience in academic medical centers. I’ll start with something I saw on Twitter last week:
Great news in #integrative medicine! New @CedarsSinai integrative clinic led by medical doctor-naturopathic doctor team, Janet White, MD and Steven Meeneghan, ND, LAc. Learn more! https://t.co/FzYRdPlfSi @Bastyr @NUNM_EDU @AANP pic.twitter.com/fqIbqoTQL6
— AANMC (@AANMC) April 6, 2018
Cedars-Sinai Medical Center is a huge academic medical center in Los Angeles that’s affiliated with UCLA, USC, and other universities. It’s a level I trauma center and has 958 beds. It was founded in 1902, and in 2013 opened its 800,000-square-foot Advanced Health Sciences Pavilion, which is touted as bringing patient care and translational research together in one site. Basically, Cedars-Sinai has a long and storied history of patient care, along with medical research and education.
So let’s take a look at what John Weeks (a major proponent of and cheerleader for “integrative medicine” whom I’ve discussed multiple times before here) had to say about this:
In the late 1990s, Cedars Sinai medical center, one of the West Coast’s most prominent medical institutions, looked to be an early adopter of complementary medicine. In the integrative-friendly Los Angeles environment, a 1,150 square foot clinic was created with a break even plan of four years.
Yet like many early models, the clinic’s response to consumer interest was shuttered for lack of integration with specialty groups and a failure to generate projected revenues. All integrative practice did not end at Cedars. A sprinkling of acupuncturists remains credentialed in inpatient services to support an integrative oncology program, for instance, and an employee wellness program offers some integrative services.
Two decades after the first clinic, the Cedars Sinai has a new initiative. This time, instead of being part of the hospital, the new site for integrative health is part of the Cedars Sinai Medical Group (CSMG). Contacts with CSMG personnel make clear that this is an entirely new initiative.
The now 4000 square foot operation is a few blocks from the main Cedars-Sinai campus. And according to director Janet White, MD, the new effort – developed with her partner in the initiative, Steven Meeneghan, ND, LAc – is tracking toward their break even goals. After a slower than projected start, “in the last 2-3 months,” says White, “our revenues are ramping up faster than we had projected.”
It is not uncommon for the medical group under which an academic medical center’s physicians work to be a separate entity from the hospital itself, with outpatient facilities that are affiliated but not part of the actual hospital. I myself work under such an arrangement and did so at my previous job as well. In my current job, I get two paychecks, one from the university and one from the medical group, which add up to my total compensation. It can sometimes cause issues at tax time, for instance, of I miscalculate how much money from each entity is being placed into each retirement fund and over-contribute. It’s also somewhat confusing to have two different retirement funds, particularly when the medical group decided to switch companies a few years back. None of this, however, means that I’m not faculty at my university and medical staff at my hospital. It’s also not uncommon for academic medical centers to farm the quackery out to a separate facility, the better to maintain plausible deniability. The Cleveland Clinic Wellness Center, for instance, is not located on the main campus, but rather in Lyndhurst, a suburb east of Cleveland close to affluent suburbs like Pepper Pike and Beechwood. A quick look at its Integrative Health program reveals several of the usual suspects, like acupuncture, herbal medicine, and the like. It also has the same “expert team” of Dr. White and Not-A-Doctor Meeneghan.
It’s interesting to note where this new integrative medicine center is, on Wilshire Boulevard. A quick look at Google Maps shows me that it is indeed only a few blocks away from the Cedars-Sinai main campus, about a 15 minute walk, but it’s in Beverly Hills, making it hard not to think that this is an effort to attract a wealthy, woo-loving, West Coast clientele.
So let’s take a look. We’ll start with the naturopath and acupuncturist, Not-A-Doctor Meeneghan, because to me it is utterly egregious and unacceptable that an academic medical center or its medical group would employ a naturopath for anything involving patient care. His Cedars-Sinai web page indicates that Meeneghan graduated from the National University of Natural Medicine in 2012 and completed a “residency” (such as it is) at Bastyr University in 2014. He lists his clinical areas as including acupuncture, alternative medicine, integrative medicine, as well as the usual list of conditions for integrative medicine, such as fibromyalgia, insomnia, back pain, and the like, plus breast cancer, colorectal cancer, and other serious conditions.
In his LinkedIn profile, Meeneghan states:
I use a functional medicine approach to evaluate my patients, allowing me to see the complex patterns that make up the whole person, not just their symptoms. By thoroughly listening to each patient’s history and utilizing conventional and specialized functional testing methods, the root causes of disease can be revealed.
As a practitioner of natural medicine, my approach is different than that of the conventional disease-focused model. Rather than trying to take away disease, my goal is to help my patients to add health, thereby supporting the body in healing itself. To do so, I utilize diet and lifestyle counseling, gentle detoxification techniques, targeted vitamin and mineral supplementation, botanical medicine, bio-identical hormone therapy, and traditional Chinese and Japanese medicine.
I practice Chinese and Japanese traditional medicine in combination with naturopathic medicine in order to further individualize the assessment and treatment of each patient. Using pulse, tongue and abdominal diagnosis, these traditional medicines offer unique insights into my patients’ symptom presentation and underlying constitution. I integrate acupuncture, moxibustion, bodywork, qi gong and herbal formulas with naturopathic medicine in order to treat the mind, body and spirit as a whole.
Functional medicine is, of course, quackery that combines the worst of both worlds of conventional and alternative medicine, pairing massive overtesting and overtreatment that aren’t even evidence-based with quackery like homeopathy, acupuncture, and beyond. Its name is the ultimate misnomer in medicine. I do like the bit about how he’s not trying to “take away disease,” to which I can only respond: Why the hell not? Strike that. I know the answer. The reason he doesn’t try to “take away disease” is because he can’t. He can’t cure anyone with his pseudoscience. After all, “detoxification” as practiced by naturopaths and other alternative medicine practitioners is quackery that often involves purges, treatments to remove “heavy metals,” and even coffee enemas. Never mind that the body rarely needs detoxification because the lungs, liver, and kidneys do a fine job of removing real toxins.”Detox” is worthless and potentially dangerous, basically ritual purification masquerading as medicine, no matter how fashionable it might seem. Similarly, traditional Chinese medicine techniques of pulse, tongue, and abdominal diagnosis are based on prescientific mystical ideas and have not been validated by modern medicine.
I also learned from his LinkedIn profile that Meeneghan bounced around a bit before he landed at Cedars-Sinai. He was on staff at San Francisco Natural Medicine for a year, where a perusal of the website reveals that the clinic offers craniosacral therapy, detoxification, traditional Chinese medicine, intravenous nutrient therapy and injection therapy, and more. He also worked for 14 months at Thyme Integrative Health, which offers a similar suite of quackery, but larger, with homeopathy and biotherapeutic drainage added to the mix.
Other oddities exist in Meeneghan’s history. For instance, on Twitter, our very own Clay Jones pointed out:
Back in 2014 while working for SFNM he used Black Lives Matter protests to drum up business. pic.twitter.com/4HzpT1hxGy
— Clay Jones (@skepticpedi) April 6, 2018
Yes, here’s the original page, and he touted it on his Facebook page:
In other words, Meeneghan is a pretty typical naturopath, which is why he should be nowhere near an academic medical center.
But what about Dr. White? She’s a real MD, having graduated from the UCLA David Geffen School of Medicine in 1992, completed an internal medicine residency at Stanford, and undertaken Andrew Weil’s integrative medicine fellowship at the University of Arizona. Interestingly, she finished her internal medicine residency in 1995 but didn’t finish her integrative medicine fellowship until 2016. This suggests to me that she practiced rather normally as an internist for close to 20 years but then somehow had a mid- to late-career conversion and, for whatever reason, decided to go woo. As Weeks notes:
White, a 22-year-member of CSMG, has been upping her own integrative skills in recent years. She completed the University of Arizona Fellowship in Integrative Medicine and maintains memberships with the clinically-oriented Academy of Integrative Health and Medicine and Society for Integrative Oncology. She is presently working on submitting an application for Cedars Sinai to become a member of the Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine and Health to allow her team the learning and collegiality of that North American organization.
So basically, after around 20 years of practice at Cedars-Sinai, she decided to undertake Weil’s fellowship, which, fortunately for her, is a distance learning program. She didn’t have to take a leave of absence from Cedars-Sinai or the huge pay cut that leaving to do a fellowship would entail for most specialties. (Rather considerate of Dr. Weil, don’t you think?) She only had to travel to Phoenix for three one-week sessions over two years. It’s supposed to be a 1,000 hour curriculum, though, and that’s basically 25 weeks. So I’m sure there were lots of nights and weekends spent learning a mixture of nonsense like energy medicine and acupuncture plus some nutrition (which probably wasn’t particularly science-based).
Now here’s a particularly disturbing passage from Weeks:
The clinic has been in the works for over three years. Much of the planning has involved Meeneghan, who was also her first hire. White said she found no resistance to hiring a naturopathic doctor-acupuncturist: “His specialty didn’t exist here before so it took him awhile to get credentialed since it was learning from scratch for the system. And it was easier for us because we were only credentialing him for outpatient care – our focus.” (Cedars has credentialed acupuncturists across the board, for inpatient and outpatient services.) She noted that doctors from oncology, pain, labor and delivery and two pediatric specialties have already expressed interest in how the integrative health team may enhance their care options.
No, it isn’t disturbing that the clinic had been in the works for three years. What disturbed me is that no one opposed hiring a naturopath for this clinic. If true, that bespeaks an astounding lack of awareness or concern among the CSMG and its credentialing committee over what naturopathy really is and really involves. (I’m not sure what would be worse, a lack of knowledge or lack of concern.) Worse, the reported interest from Cedar-Sinai’s oncologists in integrative medicine disturbs me personally as a cancer surgeon. Clearly, they, too, have no clue what “naturopathic oncology” involves. Naturopathic oncologists (like Not-A-Doctor Meeneghan apparently has attained as an additional certification) like to pretend that theirs is a real specialty, but it’s no more science-based than naturopathy.
Finally:
The payment model is cash. The clinic provides patients with a super bill. White was not aware of what percentage of the clientele may have Health Savings Accounts.
Because, of course it is. What else would it be, but cash on the barrelhead? I couldn’t help but chuckle, though, at Weeks referring to providing the patients with a “super” bill. (I bet it’s a super bill.) I know, I know. There really is such a thing as a superbill for healthcare. It’s nothing special, basically nothing more than an itemized form used by healthcare providers for listing rendered services. It’s just that Weeks’ separating it into two words was unintentionally hilarious in its implication. Freudian slip, perhaps?
It is gratifying to note that the Cedars-Sinai integrative medicine clinic appears not (yet) to be as successful as the Cleveland Clinic’s functional medicine clinic, which has been, alas, wildly successful. However, it does appear to be moving towards being in the black:
Marketing has been internal, via such mechanisms as grand rounds, and bringing some big-name speakers – Wayne Jonas, MD first, and soon Dean Ornish, MD — for events. White notes that it hasn’t hurt that she has all the relationships that she has built up in 22 years as a physician practicing in the CSMG.
On the Cedars-Sinai website, White and her team offer a list of 18 conditions that “respond well to an integrative approach.” While they are effectively a specialist model within the medical group, the net they cast is wide. Referrals are picking up from a couple groups within the system, notably oncology. Yet word of mouth – integrative health marketing’s best friend – appears to be driving the recent up-turn in patient volume and will be the necessary engine for the near future toward hitting the break-even targets this time around.
Yes, I know that this is one incident, one academic medical center embracing quackery up to and including naturopathy. It’s a big and important academic medical center, but it’s just one. The problem is that academic medical centers all over the country are launching similar initiatives, either through wanting to capture market share (or at least preserve market share by making sure that woo-prone patients don’t go somewhere else) or through the same “open-mindedness” towards pseudoscience that’s contributed so much to the existence of quackademic and integrative medicine—or both. As they say, an avalanche starts with one pebble. What I fear is an echo of the words of Kosh, the Vorlon ambassador, in one of my favorite SF TV series of all time, Babylon 5. True, they were used in another context, but they also fit here: “The avalanche has already started, it is too late for the pebbles to vote.” The Cedars-Sinai integrative medicine clinic is clearly not the pebble starting an avalanche. I fear we might already be in the middle of the quackademic avalanche and that it’s too late for us pebbles to vote. I still won’t give up, though.


“Complementary and Integrative Health” at the VA: Integrating pseudoscience into the care of veterans
In return for their service to our country, veterans deserve the best science-based medical care that we as a nation can provide. Unfortunately, the VA is integrating quackery into its medical care even more enthusiastically than medical academia.
David Gorski on July 18, 2016
Link
I was originally going to write this post for the 4th of July, given the subject matter. However, as regular readers know, I am not unlike Dug the Dog in the movie Up, with new topics that float past me in my social media and blog reading rounds serving as the squirrel. Then I got a copy of the movie VAXXED to review last week, and before I knew it this post had been delayed two weeks. Never let it be said, though, that I don’t circle back to topics that interest med. (Wait, strike that. Sometimes, that actually does happen. It just didn’t happen this time.) This time around, I will be using documents forwarded to me by a reader as a means of revisiting a discussion that dates back to the early days of this blog, before discussing the broader problem, which is the infiltration of pseudoscientific “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) into VA medical centers.
The return of the revenge of “battlefield acupuncture”
Today’s topic is the Veterans Health Administration (VHA) and its embrace of pseudoscience. VA Medical Centers (VAMCs) provide care for over 8 million veterans, ranging from the dwindling number of World War II and Korean War veterans to soldiers coming home now from our wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. Although there have been problems over the years with VAMCs and the quality of care they provide, including a recent scandal over hiding veterans’ inability to get timely doctor’s appointments at VAMCs, a concerted effort to improve that quality of care over the last couple of decades has yielded fruit so that today the quality of care in VA facilities compares favorably to the private sector. Unfortunately, like the private sector, the VA is also embracing alternative medicine in the form of CAM, or, as its proponents like to call it these days, “integrative medicine,” in order to put a happy label on the “integration” of pseudoscience and quackery with conventional medicine.
Of course, I (and others at SBM) have discussed the intrusion of woo into the military before. For instance, a post I wrote in SBM’s first year of existence discussed Col. (Dr.) Richard Niemtzow, a radiation oncologist by training but also one of the Department of Defense doctors trained as certified acupuncturists, and his advocacy for “battlefield acupuncture.” The form of acupuncture that Col. Niemtzow advocated was auricular acupuncture, which involves inserting tiny needles into the ear and leaving them there until they fall out. He even pioneered a program to train physicians in “battlefield acupuncture” and deploying them to combat zones. Not surprisingly, the evidence base cited in support of such a program was—how do I put this?—underwhelming, but that hasn’t dampened enthusiasm for the idea and other alternative medicine in the military. Given that my last post on battlefield acupuncture was in 2009, I thought I’d take a look again at the infiltration of “integrative medicine,” including battlefield acupuncture, into the military and the VHA. Unfortunately, unlike Clay Jones’ satirical—or…is it?—piece about robotic acupuncture, this is no joke. It’s really happening.
Not surprisingly, where the military goes, it doesn’t usually take too long for the VHA to follow, largely because its patient base is veterans and many of its physicians come from military medicine backgrounds. Indeed, there is even an organization called the Defense and Veterans Center for Integrative Pain Management (DVCIPM), which has teamed with the Department of Defense (DoD) and the VHA to set up a program called Acupuncture Training Across Clinical Settings (ATACS), to promote battlefield acupuncture (BFA):
ATACS will be deploying certified Battlefield Acupuncture (BFA) trainers to receptive Department of Defense/Veterans Affairs (DoD/VA) medical centers to teach this technique to qualified providers and collect data to assess patient and project outcomes. The intent is that these trained providers will act as “sustainers” and assist with the ongoing incorporation of Acupuncture into practice within the MHS/VHA. Under the discretion of the DoD/VA medical facility leadership, ideal candidates would be physicians, nurses, any healthcare provider that has pain management responsibilities either at the Medical Treatment Facility (MTF) or deployed.
Yes, you read that right. The intent of this program is to “integrate” acupuncture into routine practice in the VHA and DoD medical facilities. Even now, the VHA is claiming:
The Battlefield Acupuncture technique is a unique auricular (ear) Acupuncture procedure developed in 2001 by then Air Force Colonel Richard Niemtzow, M.D, to train Physicians, Physician Assistants, Nurse Practitioners, and other providers to treat pain throughout the MHS and VHA. This technique provides a much needed alternative in cases where the initiation or continuation of opioid analgesics is deemed clinically risky, in cases where current medications and other therapies are not working, and cases where the existence of and potential for substance abuse, addiction and tolerance issues make medication therapies impractical.
The BFA course – usually 1-2 half days – teaches non-acupuncturist clinical providers the BFA technique. Training in BFA offers providers the opportunity to enhance their clinical practice skills in musculoskeletal and pain management conditions by adding Battlefield Acupuncture technique to their “tool bag.” It is hoped that this technique will be a primary or secondary modality to reduce the use of opioids and habit forming drugs.
If acupuncture is, as David Colquhoun and Steve Novella so aptly put it, nothing more than a theatrical placebo, then auricular acupuncture is placebo without a lot of the theatrics. What impressed me most about the FAQ on BFA published by the DVCIPM (see, I can use alphabet soup acronyms and abbreviations like the ones the military uses too) was the utter lack of scientifically compelling evidence. All there is, except for an ancient (2002!) functional MRI study is a small unblinded pilot study that I’ve discussed before, a larger unblinded study using a grab bag of different forms of acupuncture, discussed here, and a study of the “feasibility of introducing BFA into the aeromedical evacuation system.”
Typical of CAM research, this is putting the cart before the horse. First, it should be established that a treatment actually works (i.e., is efficacious and safe). Only then should studies examining the feasibility of integrating the treatment into the aeromedical evacuation of wounded soldiers be undertaken. Unfortunately, this is a metaphor for what the VHA is doing: integrating unscientific and unproven CAM modalities in the absence of compelling evidence to treat, in particular, chronic pain and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), both unfortunately very common afflictions of veterans, particularly combat veterans.
Yet, the VHA is charging full steam ahead to “integrate” dubious treatments into its array of offerings.
Lots of CAM in the VA, but we need more, more, more…
One of the documents a reader sent me was the report, “FY2015 VHA Complementary and Integrative Health (CIH) Services (formerly CAM).” I note that “complementary and integrative health” (CIH) seems to be the new government-sanctioned term for CAM, as reflected not only in this report but in the recent renaming of the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) to the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH). One could view this as just another step in the evolution of “integrative medicine.” Be that as it may, this report is very revealing, particularly taken in context of the history of CAM/CIH use in the VHA, as represented by major “achievements” touted by the VHA, not the least of which is a 2011 VA survey showing that 9 out of 10 VHA facilities offer at least some CAM/CIH and the expansion of VA funding for studying CAM treatments for PTSD in the same year, because there was “scant evidence” from randomized controlled clinical trials. This report is more recent; so let’s take a look.
Here are some of the key findings of the FY2015 report:
    • Most administrative parent facilities offer at least one CIH service to Veterans (93% in 2015 vs. 89%in 2011).
    • Although many facilities offer CIH services, the availability of these services is limited. In facilities offering an individual CIH service, only acupuncture, chiropractic, mindfulness, Stress Management Relaxation Therapy (SMRT), acupressure, and movement practices are offered at a rate equivalent to at least one half day per week.
    • CIH services are offered in all the VA clinical care settings inquired about in this survey.
    • Most CIH services are offered by VA providers, however, a portion of this care is provided by Without Compensation (WOC) providers. The most common CIH services being provided by WOC providers include Yoga (58%), Animal Assisted therapy (52%), and Tai-chi/Qi gong (36%).
    • Chiropractic care and acupuncture are the two modalities most likely to be referred to non-VA care providers by a VA facility.
    • Of the 131 sites offering CIH services, the top perceived factors enabling services are that CIH is consistent with patient-centered model of care (122 sites), promotes well-being (121 sites), being adjunctive to chronic disease management (109 sites), as well as patient preference (104 sites). (Table 1.b.)
    • Providers’ perception of the top three services for which veterans are asking for more offerings include acupuncture (80%), chiropractic (80%), and massage therapy (81%).
Here are the sorts of CIH/CAM offered at VHA facilities (click to embiggen):
One notes a lot of the usual modalities rebranded as somehow being “CAM/CIH,” such as diet, exercise, relaxation, and the like, but there are also acupuncture, which is a modality based on the vitalistic principles of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), such as the flow of qi, or “life energy.” There’s also chiropractic, and, as I like to say, chiropractors are incompetent physical therapists with delusions of grandeur, which tells me all the funds wasted on chiropractic would be better used hiring more physical therapists at VHA facilities. And what is this with 13% of VHA facilities offering sweat lodges and 30% offering “energy medicine,” which encompasses reiki, therapeutic touch, and other forms of what can only be described as pure quackery?
The naturopaths pounce
As I like to point out any time the topic comes up, naturopathy is a hodgepodge of modalities ranging from traditional Chinese medicine, to reflexology, to supplements, to applied kinesiology, to just about any pseudoscientific medicine you can think of, all mixed with a dollop of diet and lifestyle co-opted from science-based medicine to give the quackery a patina of seeming scientific respectability. All you really need to know to know how bad naturopathy is this: The One Quackery To Rule Them All, homeopathy is an integral part of naturopathy, takes up many hours of instruction in naturopathy schools, and is featured on the NPLEX, the naturopathic licensing examination. In other words, you can’t have naturopathy without homeopathy.
Predictably, last fall, seeing the open embrace with which the VHA is inviting quackery into its VAMCs, naturopaths saw their opening and decided to pounce on this opportunity. The largest “professional” organization for the quacks known as naturopaths, the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians (AANP, which unfortunately shares an abbreviation with the American Association of Nurse Practitioners and must be distinguished from such a respectable organization) has teamed up with American Veterans (AMVETS) to lobby Congress to pass a bill that would pay for “natural, non-pharmacological approaches to treating veterans suffering from chronic pain“:
AMVETS, one of the nation’s largest veterans service organizations, has joined with the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians (AANP) in seeking to promote natural, non-pharmacological approaches to treating veterans suffering from chronic pain.
The organizations have collaborated via a “Dear Colleague” letter in the US House of Representatives calling on the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) to take steps to employ licensed naturopathic physicians, who are specially trained in natural, non-invasive methods of healing. A “Dear Colleague” letter to that effect has begun circulating in the US House of Representatives. Leading the charge is Congressman Mark Pocan (D-WI), who – like many of his colleagues – is concerned about the dangers of overmedicating veterans, especially with painkilling opioids. Rep. Pocan is joined by Representatives Julia Brownley (D-CA), Suzan DelBene (D-WA), Earl Blumenauer (D-OR), Raul Grijalva (D-AZ), and Walter Jones as the letter’s initial signators.
“After incidents across the country of veterans overdosing on or abusing opioids associated with chronic pain, it is clear we need a new approach to veterans’ pain management,” Rep. Pocan stated. “Our veterans deserve access to all possible forms of care when making their healthcare decisions, including the services provided by naturopathic doctors (NDs).”
So let’s see. Rep. Pocan’s argument, fed to him no doubt by the AANP and facilitated by AMVETS, seemed to boil down to this: Opiate pain relievers, as effective as they are, have a downside, including dependence, addiction, and overdosing. If anything, since last September, this argument has become more potent, given the recent news coverage of the high level of opioid dependence and death in the US. Because of these problems, a common problem with opioids is that physicians are often overly cautious prescribing opioids, resulting in undertreatment of chronic pain. What “non-pharmacologic” treatments of chronic pain would help? Neither the AMVETS press release nor Rep. Pocan’s “Dear Colleague” letter said.
More importantly, how would our veterans be provided access to naturopathic care? AMVETS, the AANP, and Rep. Pocan urged VA Secretary Robert McDonald to assign an employment code to licensed NDs so that they can be brought into the agency’s healthcare system. Right now, apparently, NDs (or, as I like to refer to them, “not a doctor“) cannot be on staff at VA hospitals and VA facilities right now, which is good. There is no employment code for them.
But why? Why should the VA change its policy and allow NDs to be on staff at VA facilities in order to offer naturopathic modalities to our veterans? The AMVET press release trotted out the usual misinformation and naturopathy talking points:
For military veterans, chronic pain often coexists with other health problems such as posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), depression, anxiety, and sleep disturbances. NDs are well suited to help, since they are specially trained in natural, non-pharmacological approaches that facilitate the body’s self-healing ability.
Approximately 4,400 NDs are licensed to practice naturopathic medicine, having earned their degree from 4-year postgraduate naturopathic medical schools accredited through the US Department of Education. The approaches studied include nutritional counseling and stress reduction, botanical medicine, therapeutic manipulation, and oriental medicine. A strong emphasis is placed on disease prevention and educating patients on proactive self-care to maintain wellness. Resolutions passed by the US Senate have urged Americans to learn more about this “safe, effective, and affordable form of health care.”
No. As has been described by “naturopathic apostate” Britt Hermes, naturopathic education is nowhere near the equivalent of the education conventional physicians receive in medical school and their clinical residencies and fellowships. Naturopathic research is rife with unethical practices, and the accreditation of naturopathic education is a sham. None of this stopped Tracy Gaudet, MD, director of the VHA’s Office of Patient Centered Care and Cultural Transformation from, while speaking at last fall’s annual DC Federal Legislative Initiative held by the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians, characterizing naturopathy as “a huge answer for the country, for practice, for patients” that is available “at a pivotal transformational moment” in health care and referring to them as “pioneers” who have been practicing integrative medicine “all along.” One notes that, before being hired by the VHA, Dr. Gaudet was a very high profile promoter of “integrative medicine,” having served as the director of Duke Integrative Medicine, a “pioneer” institution in quackademic medicine, as well as, before that, the founding director of the University of Arizona Program in Integrative Medicine with Dr. Andrew Weil.
The plan: Advancing Complementary and Integrative Health in VHA
I revisited “battlefield acupuncture” intentionally at the beginning of this post, using it as an introduction to survey the breadth and depth of “integrative medicine” offered at VAMCs, because it is a glaring example of how deeply quackery has embedded itself into military medicine and the VHA. It thus didn’t surprise me (although it depressed me) to be sent this memo from the Co-Chairs of the Veterans Experience Committee (VEC) to the Under Secretary for health, dated May 3, 2016 under the subject of “Advancing Complementary and Integrative Health in VHA.” The memo is disturbing for a number of reasons, which is why I provide a link to the PDF, for readers who wish to read the whole thing themselves. Because it’s a scanned document that’s 11 pages long, I won’t be typing everything, but I will cite key points in selected excerpts.
First:
VA is shifting the current culture of health care from problem-based “sick care” to “whole health care,” which engages and inspires Veterans to their highest level of health and well-being. The Office of Patient Centered care and Cultural Transformation (OPCC&CT) and the Veterans Experience Committee (VEC) have worked with VHA leaders and clinical champions across the system to work towards this transformative goal. One aspect of this mission includes the promotion of complementary and integrative health (CIH) services such as acupuncture, mind-body techniques, yoga, and massage, within the VA healthcare system. CIH services promote self-healing and complement conventional (or allopathic) medical approaches to support Veterans on their path to health and well-being. In 2013, VHA established the Integrative Health Coordinating Center (IHCC) within OPCC&CT. The IHCC is charged with developing and implementing CIH strategies in clinical activities, education, and research across the system. Its two major functions are: (1) to identify and remove barriers to providing CIH across the VHA system; and (2) to serve as a resource for the clinical practices and education for both Veterans and clinicians. Thus, the IHCC supports VHA’s strategic plan and the MyVA plan to provide Veterans with “Access to Innovative Health Care.” Implementation of CIH services across the enterprise directly supports VA’s Strategic Goal #1, to “empower Veterans to improve their well-being,” and the VHA Strategic Goal #1, “provide Veterans personalized, proactive, patient-driven health care.” This is reinforced by the sustained high degree of congressional interest and support for CIH services, including sections 441 and 442 of the proposed bill S.425. The IHCC receives weekly inquiries of the types and and availability of CIH services within the VA.
I was unfamiliar with S.425; so I looked it up. It’s the Homeless Veterans’ Reintegration Programs Reauthorization Act of 2015. It’s a bill to reauthorize homeless reintegration programs in the VA until 2020, which is an odd place to put anything about CAM. Be that as it may, this memo makes it very clear that it is official VHA policy not only to offer CAM or CIH services, but to actively promote it and remove barriers to providing CIH services across the entire VHA system, which in military-government jargon means forcing providers to offer them, much as advocates have tried to force residents to learn and offer CAM/CIH. Indeed, the above paragraph is chock full of government bureaucratic jargon combined what Kimball Atwood used to call the “Weasel Words of Woo,” complete with rhetoric about moving from “sick care” to “whole health care”; “patient-centered” or “patient-driven” care, which is frequently co-opted to justify the integration of quackery; empowering patients (in this case, Veterans with a capital V); and, of course, “personalized” care. (My head was hurting by the end of this, so thick was the government jargon mixed with “weasel words of woo.”)
The purpose of the memo is to request “review and approval” of the Under Secretary of Health a “recommended path forward to provide policy, guidance, and regulatory change required to implement CIH services that meet the definition of basic care as described in the standard Medical Benefits Package (38 CFR 17.38(b)).” The VEC notes that “high priority” areas for the “integration” of CIH services in the VHA include chronic pain management, mental health conditions (e.g., anxiety, depression, and PTSD), and chronic disease management (e.g., cardiovascular disease, hypertension, diabetes, and obesity). Also, according to the VEC, the vetting process for new CIH modalities will include:
    • Clinical evidence
    • Licensing and credentialing
    • Clinical practice guidelines, current evidence, community standards, and potential for harm
    • Veteran demand, although it is noted that “the clinical need and appropriateness of any treatment is based on the clinical judgment of the provider and services are not provided solely at the request or preference of the patient” (imagine my relief).
    • Supports transformation of healthcare delivery (whatever that means)
As far as “clinical evidence, the VEC cites the Institute of Medicine recommendation that the same “principles and standards” of evidence should apply to all treatments, but then it immediately starts special pleading for CIH, noting that the “characteristics of some CAM therapies—such as variable practitioner approaches, customized treatments “bundles” (combinations) of treatments, and hard-to-measure outcomes—are difficult to incorporate into treatment-effectiveness studies,” which is true. It’s also true that these “characteristics are not unique to CAM” but are “more frequently found in CAM than in conventional therapies.” What is more common in CAM is special pleading that these difficulties should be excuses for accepting a lower standard of evidence. If, for instance, I were to make the sorts of pleas that I hear from CAM practitioners about, for example, genomic-based personalized, or precision, medicine, where difficulties in randomization and doing clinical trials are epic (a topic I might review again in the future), CAM advocates would lambaste me for special pleading—and rightly so. What I fear is what happens so often with CAM: That a lot of pseudoscience will be “integrated” into VHA offerings based on dubious evidence. It’s already happened with auricular acupuncture, after all.
Also I fear this, straight from the memo:
Adjustments to VHA business processes will be required to provide infrastructure of CIH service delivery across VHA. Additionally, CIH services may need to compete for resources with existing VHA programs. These processes have begun and will be reinforced by the clarification provide by this memo.
Yes, barring increased appropriations from Congress (highly unlikely), every dollar directed to CIH services in the VHA is a dollar redirected from science- and evidence-based treatments currently offered. It is a zero-sum game, and the VEC knows that. Even so, Under Secretary David Shulkin approved the memo.
Indeed the process had already begun long before this memo was sent to the Under Secretary, and is continuing. It is, unfortunately, a very big deal because the VHA runs the largest healthcare system in the US and has a great deal of influence because of that. Just as the VA pioneered the use of electronic medical records in the 1990s, it could be now “pioneering” the infiltration of quackery into an enormous health care system.
Our veterans deserve much better than this. They deserve the best science-based medicine we can offer. Unfortunately, thanks to “competition for resources” by an ever-growing CIH program at the VA and “marching orders” demanding more CIH/CAM, they are likely to be getting more woo and less science-based medicine.

CARA: Integrating even more pseudoscience into veterans’ healthcare
Jann Bellamy on July 28, 2016
Link
The pixels were barely dry on David Gorski’s lament over the expansive integration of pseudoscience into the care of veterans when President Obama signed legislation that will exacerbate this very problem. The “Comprehensive Addiction and Recovery Act of 2016” (“CARA”) contains provisions that will undoubtedly keep Tracy Gaudet, MD, and her merry band of integrative medicine aficionados at the VA busy for the next few years integrating even more quackery into veterans’ medical care.
CARA is intended to address the serious prescription drug abuse problem in the U.S. It provides grants for local communities dealing with drug abuse crises and for drug abuse programs, improves access to overdose reversal medication and medication-assisted treatment for drug addiction, and assists in training first responders, among other things. It also includes provisions related to pain management, such as development of best practices to treat pain. None of that is the problem.
Deep in the Act, almost at the end, is “Subtitle C – Complementary and Integrative Health,” which begins with “Expansion of research and education on and delivery of complementary and integrative health to veterans.” I am not sure who stuck this into the new law, but it is only tangentially related to addiction and recovery. It establishes the “Creating Options for Veterans’ Expedited Recovery” Commission or, in the acronym-rich language of government, “COVER.”
The COVER Commission is to examine the evidence-based therapy treatment models used by the VA for treating mental health conditions and “the potential benefits of incorporating complementary and integrative health treatments available in non-Department facilities.” This effort is to be directed at improving “wellness-based outcomes.” Authority to use “non-Department facilities” means that complementary and integrative services not provided in-house will be available to veterans, substantially expanding the opportunity to send them to questionable facilities.
And how is the VA to go about this? It is to examine the research on complementary and integrative health treatment therapies for mental health issues and identify what the benefit might be for including them. There’s a handy list of what Congress had in mind in the way of CIH (as it is now called) treatments: music therapy, equine therapy, training and caring for service dogs, yoga and meditation therapy (since when are yoga and meditation “therapies?”), outdoor sports therapy (same question), hyperbaric oxygen therapy, accelerated resolution therapy, art therapy, magnetic resonance therapy, and “other therapies the Commission determines appropriate.” As always, there’s a blend of more or less conventional stuff (art and music therapy, dog training) with pseudoscience (acupuncture), although I note that many of the standards didn’t make it, like reiki, healing touch, guided imagery, reflexology dietary supplements, and tai chi. Of course, they could fall into the catchall “other therapies” if the Commission so chooses.
I was intrigued by the inclusion of hyperbaric oxygen therapy. How could that possibly benefit mental health issues? That feat appears to be the result of a series of lobbying efforts by proponents of HBOT for PTSD, although clinical trials to date have not supported its use, nor do experts in HBOT think it’s effective. Behind this effort is a group of doctors of what appears to be the “brave maverick” variety, especially Dr. Paul Harch, who believes HBOT is an effective treatment for autism, if that tells you anything.
Accelerated resolution therapy (ART) is another new one. It is, according to the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, (SAMSA),
a brief, exposure-based psychotherapy aimed at treating psychological trauma, depression, anxiety, phobias, obsessive–compulsive disorder, and substance use. The program is delivered in one to five, 60–75 minute sessions over 2 weeks. The program incorporates specific visualization techniques enhanced through the use of rapid eye movements (similar to the rapid eye movement stage of sleep) and a directive approach that reduces physical and emotional reactions to distressing memories and images stored in the brain.
SAMSA has concluded that ART is effective for reducing depression, improving personal resilience and self-concept, and reducing trauma and stress-related disorders, and is already in use in the military. The relationship, if any, between ART and the questionable Eye Movement Desensitization Reprocessing therapy is unclear. I am not sure why it is included as a CIH therapy, although that is the problem with the entire idea of CIH: There are no clear parameters and what is and isn’t CIH is too often in the eye of the beholder.
Magnetic resonance therapy is an off-label use of transcranial magnetic stimulation, which is FDA-approved for drug -resistant major depression. It is now the subject of a clinical trial for PTSD. Again, it is unclear why MRT is included in this category.
Eighteen months after the Commission’s first meeting, it is to issue a report on the VA’s evidence-based therapy model used for veterans with mental-health problems. As well, the report is to include
an examination of complementary and integrative health treatments [on the list] and the potential benefits of incorporating such treatments [in mental health therapy].
The VA must come up with an “action plan” for “improving wellness-based outcomes,” whatever that means. If the Commission recommends a particular CIH therapy and the VA doesn’t incorporate it, the VA has to justify its decision to Congress.
How all of this plays out likely hinges on who is appointed to the Commission, which is to be selected by various members of Congress and the President. CARA specifies that half must be veterans with a background in treating mental health and have experience working with the military and veteran population. They cannot have a financial interest in the CIH treatments reviewed. They may (but don’t have to) seek out guidance from outside groups, such as foundations, nonprofit groups, institutions of higher education and “other organizations,” leaving open the distinct possibility that CIH proponents could have a say in the outcome. If the Wayne Jonases of the world populate the Commission, we may well turn out to have another Whitehouse Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medicine on our hands.
Just what we need: more CAM research
CARA also says that, within 180 days of enactment (on July 22nd), the VA
shall develop a plan to expand materially and substantially the scope of the effectiveness of research and education on, and delivery and integration of, complementary and integrative health services into the health care services provided to veterans.
Expanding “the scope of the effectiveness of research” sounds a little like Tom Harkin’s desire that NCCAM “validate” CAM instead of finding it doesn’t work, if it makes sense at all. How do you expand the scope of the effectiveness of something?
In any event, all pretense of having anything whatsoever to do with mental health issues or drug abuse is abandoned and there is no list of treatments Congress favors. They mean all CAM/CIH for anything.
The plan must include research on the effectiveness of CIH health services, approaches to integrating CIH, and education and training for health care professionals in integrating CIH and “appropriate use of such services,” as well as “metrics and outcome measures to evaluate the effectiveness of integrating CIH.” In formulating the plan, the VA shall consult with, among others,
institutions of higher education, private research institutes, and individual researchers with extensive experience in [CIH] and the integration of [CIH] into delivery of health care [and] nationally recognized providers of complementary and integrative health.
Thus, CIH proponents will have an opportunity to influence the plan. No equal time for skeptics or SBM proponents is mandated.
Not only that, but the VA has to establish a pilot program at 15 VA medical centers to evaluate, among other things, whether CIH services are effective “in enhancing the quality of life of veterans” and in “increasing adherence to primary pain management and related services” and whether they “have an effect on the sense of well-being of veterans.” Note that this has nothing to do with effectiveness of the treatment per se, but basically looks at whether the CIH service makes the patient “feel better.” As we know, a quack treatment can do absolutely nothing objective for the patient’s condition, but the patient will perceive improvement where there is none.
And who is to provide these services?
Professionals or other instructors with appropriate training and expertise in [CIH] services who are employees of the Department or with whom the Department enters into an agreement to provide such services.
In other words, the VA can contract with chiropractors, acupuncturists, reiki healers or what-have-you to handle the pseudoscience.
As far as I can tell, CARA does not give the VA any money to do any of these things, although perhaps these mandates will be funded in the next budget.
According to David’s post, much of this is already happening, or is about to happen, at the VA anyway, as mandated by a memo from top brass. CARA puts the imprimatur of Congress on the whole enterprise and ensures it is enshrined into law, giving any dissenters little chance of stemming the tide.

Integrative Medicine’s Collateral Damage
Jann Bellamy on October 17, 2013
Link
Integrative medicine combines the practice of medicine with alternative medicine. Proponents tend to take a paragraph or two to say this, but that is what remains when boiled down to its essence. By putting this more concise definition together with Tim Minchin’s often-quoted observation about alternative medicine, you get: integrative medicine is the practice of medicine combined with medicine that either has not been proved to work or proved not to work. If it is proved to work, it is medicine.
I couldn’t find an official start date for integrative medicine, but it seems to have been around for about 15-20 years. (Osher Center for Integrative Medicine at the University of California, San Francisco, an early adapter, opened in 1997.) Yet despite some lofty pronouncements about transforming patient care, there is still no good evidence that integrative medicine improves patient outcomes. It seems unlikely that such evidence is forthcoming. It is illogical to assume that adding therapies that do not work, or are proven not to work, would benefit a patient except by inducing the ethically problematic placebo response.
Whatever its goals initially, integrative medicine now appears to serve two purposes. First, it attracts funding from wealthy patrons (Samueli, Bravewell) and the government (the military, NCCAM). Second, it is a marketing device used by hospitals, academic medical centers and individual practitioners. As an added bonus, alternative medicine is usually fee-for-service because very little of it is covered by insurance. And whatever its charms as a money-making device, given the lack of proven health benefit it is fair to ask: is integrative medicine worth it? To answer that question, let us look at what might be called the supply side of integrative medicine practitioners’ delivery of alternative medicine. Here we run into some unpleasant facts proponents seem unwilling to acknowledge: integrative medicine’s collateral damage. 
The alternative medicine services and products offered by integrative medicine practitioners do not exist in a vacuum. They are supplied by chiropractors, naturopaths, acupuncturists, and reiki masters, among others. They include dietary supplements, botanicals and homeopathic remedies. Let’s look at just a few of the less savory aspects of these practices and products we’ve discussed at SBM. (SBM devotees can skip this part. You’ve heard it all before.)
Chiropractic
Chiropractors purport to diagnose and treat imaginary subluxations. They claim they can treat asthma, allergies, ADHD, menstrual problems, endocrine disorders, and a host of other conditions and attract patients with practice-building schemes. They also promote the idea that they are primary care physicians able to diagnose and treat the general population, including children. (A claim convincingly refuted by one of their own studies.) Their use of disproven diagnostic techniques and treatments is well-documented: applied kinesiology, cranial sacral therapy, and machines which purport to detect nutritional deficiencies, to name a few. Their disproven treatments can cause stroke and death although there is no systematic data collection, so the real incidence is unknown. Many chiropractors are anti-vaccination.
Naturopathy
Naturopathy is simply a collection of treatments, not a systematic approach to human health. As he has done before, David Gorski summarized naturopathy practice nicely just last week:
The problem with naturopathy, of course, is that it is so diffuse and encompasses so many different forms of quackery that it’s hard to categorize. Basically, it’s anything that can be portrayed as “natural,” be it traditional Chinese medicine, homeopathy (which is an integral component of naturopathy, something that should tell you all you need to know about naturopathy), herbalism, energy healing, Ayurvedic medicine, the four humors, or whatever. Add to that a number of bogus diagnostic modalities, such as applied kinesiology, live blood cell analysis, iridology, tests for imaginary “food allergies” and “nutrient deficiencies” that conventional medicine doesn’t recognize, plus an overwhelming emphasis on purging the body of “toxins,” unnamed and named but all unvalidated by science, and it rapidly becomes apparent that naturopathy is a veritable cornucopia of pseudoscience and quackery. Seemingly, there is no quackery that naturopathy does not credulously embrace . . . Basically, naturopathy is a hodge-podge of quackery mixed with science-based modalities magically “rebranded” as “alternative” and “natural.” In that, naturopathy is the ultimate in “integrative medicine,” in which quackery is “integrated” with science-based medicine.
Naturopaths have simply invented diseases to treat, use bogus diagnostic methods and are anti-vaccination. Naturopathic care is associated with worse outcomes and you needn’t look any further than David Gorski’s post on Tuesday to see the horrible consequences of their practices. Yet they are making a huge effort to become licensed primary care physicians in all 50 states, with the same scope of practice as M.D. and D.O. primary care physicians. Like chiropractic, there is anecdotal evidence that their treatments can cause injury and death, although their failure to systematically collect data means the true incidence is unknown.
Acupuncture
Acupuncture is an elaborate placebo although proponents continuously attempt to portray it otherwise. It is based on the pre-scientific notion that energy (or “qi”) flows through the body which, when blocked, causes health problems. Unblocking this energy with needles supposedly restores the proper flow. None of this has any plausible basis in human physiology. Acupuncturists, like chiropractors and naturopaths, use bogus diagnostic devices, as well as offering iridology, Kirlian photography and other disproven methods. Again, there is anecdotal evidence of harm cause by acupuncture but the true incidence is unknown because of lack of data collection.
Dietary supplements and homeopathy
The extremely lucrative dietary supplement industry refuses to reveal its effectiveness and safety research to the public and fights all efforts to make it do so. It opposes government funding of additional safety research. Homeopathy is nothing more than fraud and unregulated fraud at that. The federal government has defaulted to a private agency run by homeopaths to police its own industry. Two medical toxicology organizations recently stated, flat out, that no one should take dietary supplements, botanicals or homeopathic products, a warning that will no doubt be ignored by alternative medicine providers because evidence of safety or effectiveness is not a requisite for their practices.
“Mind and body” practices
Favorite offerings of integrative medicine centers include “energy medicine” techniques like reiki, reflexology and cranial sacral therapy. None of these have any plausible basis in human physiology. All have been studied in clinical trials and none perform any better than placebo.
In sum, alternative medicine practitioners regularly take patients’ money for treatments we know are ineffective, unsafe or both. They diagnose conditions we know don’t exist using bogus diagnostic methods. Alternative medicine injures and even kills patients with treatments that provide no benefit. And practitioners spread anti-vaccination misinformation, even to the point of supporting anti-vaccination organizations.
Alternative medicine doesn’t exist for the convenience of integrative medicine. Nor could it. Providing the limited supply of alternative medicine used by integrative medicine practitioners is not an economically sustainable model. The sole purpose of alternative medicine is to put into practice its varied (and conflicting) philosophies and to make money doing so. Alternative medicine schools don’t send their graduates out into the world to become handmaidens to integrative medicine practitioners. And alternative medicine practitioners aren’t going to stand for some role subordinate to medical doctors, limited in their practices to what integrative physicians think they should be doing. In fact, alternative medicine practitioners regularly denigrate medical doctors. Nor do dietary supplement and homeopathic remedy manufacturers make products for consumption on the recommendation of integrative medicine practitioners. They make products to sell to the public and they want to make as much money as possible, often without regard to whether their products are effective and, for some, without regard for safety.
I have to assume that even the most devoted integrative medicine practitioner would not endorse much of what their compatriots in the alternative medicine field do, if they bothered to research the subject. I hope I am right. (If not, integrative medicine is an even bigger problem than we thought.) Yet by incorporating alternative medicine providers and products into their practices, integrative medicine must face the fact that it is supporting alternative medicine in all its guises – the quackery, the deceit, the wasted money, the injury and death. The naturopaths employed by Cancer Treatment Centers of America come from the same system that produces the naturopath who treats Chris Wark. The chiropractors employed by CTCA come from the same schools that educated the chiropractors who misinform patients about the safety and efficacy of vaccinations. And these practitioners aren’t outliers. They are part of the mainstream. The treatments employed by Wark’s naturopath are standard naturopathic treatments. Neither the American Chiropractic Association nor the International Chiropractic Association, the two main chiropractic trade associations, endorses the CDC vaccination schedule for patients. Two chiropractic organizations actually support the notoriously anti-vaccination National Vaccine Information Center. (Or, as we prefer to call it, the National Vaccine (Mis)Information Center.)
Integrative medicine helps keep this entire alternative medicine enterprise afloat. It’s reminiscent of that saying about women (or men, depending on your perspective): “you can’t live with them but you can’t live without them.” Integrative medicine practitioners cannot endorse much of what alternative medicine practitioners do, but they can’t live without them either. Integrative medicine’s defense would no doubt be that it is actually helping patients navigate this world of snake oil, quackery and pseudoscience by vetting alternative medicine and delivering only the “best” to patients, even if it is admittedly unproven or disproven. But that doesn’t let them off the hook. That excuse is no different from an art museum admitting it buys from art thieves but defending itself by saying it buys only the best of what they have to offer. It is the same as the fashion and computer retailers who turn blind eye to the appalling conditions under which their products are manufactured.
So let’s return to the question: is integrative medicine worth it? Is it worth the collateral damage? It certainly appears to benefit a limited segment of the medical industry when employed as a marketing device or to attract funding. To my mind, that hardly outweighs the harm, especially without any demonstrated improvement in patients’ health. Perhaps integrative medicine can make the case that somehow these financial benefits outweigh the damage. A good start would be by addressing the issue at all.

The closure of major integrative medicine “Crown Jewels”: Terminating the Terminator?
When it comes to expansion and infiltrating medicine, “integrative medicine” has frequently seemed like the Terminator: utterly relentless. Recent setbacks at major integrative medicine “Crown Jewels” resulting in their closure cast that narrative in doubt. However, I never forget that after its seeming destruction, the Terminator always comes back.
David Gorski on June 5, 2017
Link

If there’s one thing about the march of the pseudomedical entity known as “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM), “integrative medicine,” “complementary and integrative medicine” (CIM), “complementary and integrative health” (CIH), it’s that over the last 25 years or so its progress towards being mainstreamed has appeared utterly relentless. I like to paraphrase Kyle Reese, the warrior from the future sent back in time to save Sarah Connor in The Terminator: “Listen, and understand. That terminator is out there. It can’t be bargained with. It can’t be reasoned with. It doesn’t feel pity, or remorse, or fear. And it absolutely will not stop, ever, until science-based medicine is dead.” And sometimes it certainly seems that way. After all, the number of “integrative medicine” programs in academic medical centers has skyrocketed over the last two decades to over 60, and that doesn’t count the many more non-academic medical centers. Meanwhile, Andrew Weil has successfully produced an “integrative medicine” residency that has metastasized far and wide throughout medical academia, while major conferences devote major sessions to “integrative oncology” and respected medical journals publish “state of the art reviews” of pseudoscience and “clinical guidelines” written by naturopaths. There’s even a board certification in “integrative medicine,” although it’s not backed by the usual certification mechanism.
These developments have conspired together to produce an illusion of inevitability to the mainstreaming of “integrative medicine.” It’s an illusion that integrative medicine proponents actively cultivate, the better to paint opponents as crotchety cynics standing in the way of progress to the perfect integration of the “best of both worlds,” to the “marriage of equals” (never mind that the pseudoscience “integrated” into medicine by integrative medicine is anything but equal), to the ultimate in “patient-centered” medicine. Certainly, even to those of us who bemoan the integration of quackery into medical academia to produce what I like to refer to as quackademic medicine, the infiltration of pseudomedicine into medicine often seems unstoppable, not unlike the aforementioned Terminator. As I survey the continuing advance of pseudomedicine, I can’t help sometimes thinking of Arnold Schwarzenegger’s voice saying “Hasta la vista, baby!”However, surprisingly, all is not completely rosy in the world of integrative medicine. I don’t know how I missed these articles, which are actually all at least two months old, but I did. They’re both by John Weeks, that tireless promoter of integrative medicine whom we’ve discussed on SBM quite a few times before. In a couple of columns in (where else?) The Huffington Post, Weeks bemoans the disappearance of two behemoths in the world of integrative medicine. First, he noted Mt. Sinai Merger Shuts New York’s Integrative Medicine “Crown Jewel”. Then he wrote about Wayne Jonas, MD and the Closure of the Influential Samueli Institute: Next Steps. Upon seeing these articles, my thought was: Whoa! These closures are both big deals.
The Continuum Center for Health and Healing: Quackery at its “finest”
Let’s take a look at Mt. Sinai first, because the Continuum Center for Health and Healing at Beth Israel Medical Center was one of the examples that first demonstrated to me just how low an academic medical center could go. This center was also sometimes referred to as “Urban Zen” because its creation was funded by Donna Karan’s Urban Zen Foundation, created after her husband and business partner, Stephan Weiss, died of lung cancer in 2001. Basically, Urban Zen started out as a whole cancer treatment floor being turned over to “combining Eastern and Western healing methods.” As the New York Times put it:
Instead of just letting a celebrated donor adopt a hospital wing, renovate it and have her name embossed on a plaque, the Karan-Beth Israel project will have a celebrated donor turn a hospital into a testing ground for a trendy, medically controversial notion: that yoga, meditation and aromatherapy can enhance regimens of chemotherapy and radiation.
And it spread from there, as you will see, to three floors.
Some of the center’s webpages have been replaced with an announcement of the closure of the center on October 28, 2016, but there’s plenty left of the website so that it’s possible to see how in its prime the center offered reiki, Rolfing, prayer, Therapeutic Touch, traditional indigenous healing therapies, acupuncture, even that woo of woo, that One Quackery To Rule Them All, homeopathy. To give you a taste of the “science” supported by Urban Zen, let’s take a look at what its homeopath was saying about homeopathy:
People tend to believe that generally the higher a dose of any given medicine, the greater its potency, but the opposite is claimed to be true for a homeopathic remedy. Homeopathic solutions can be diluted to the extent that literally no molecules of the original substance remain; yet according to homeopathic philosophy the more diluted it becomes the greater its potency becomes.
Samuel Hahnemann based his theory of how homeopathy works only on the results of experiment and observation. He found that remedies could exhibit their healing qualities only after they were homeopathically potentized (diluted and vigorously shaken). Even after the remedy is diluted beyond the Avogadro number, it remains biologically active, but only if it was potentized. The conclusion was that the biological activity of homeopathically prepared remedies involved energy. Hahnemann suggested that during the process of vigorous shaking (called “successions” [sic] in homeopathy) the energy of the original substance was transmitted to the neutral matter (water) in which it was diluted. The dynamic force which causes the illness and the homeopathic healing, was called “vital force” by Hahnemann.
Despite certain experimental evidence that high dilutions of biologically active substances can retain activity if they were vigorously shaken during the dilution process, this issue remains controversial. A unique molecular organization of water has been implemented in its potential ability to transmit biological information.
No, the issue does not “remain controversial.” Science has shown that homeopathy cannot work. As I like to put it, for homeopathy to “work,” not only would huge swaths of well-supported physics, chemistry, and biology have to be wrong, but they’d have to be spectacularly wrong. Yet, here was a standalone center affiliated with Beth Israel, which at the time was affiliated with the Albert Einstein College of Medicine, spouting off about homeopathy on its website as though homeopathy were more than vitalistic pseudoscientific twaddle.
Not surprisingly, Mr. Weeks bemoans what has befallen Urban Zen:
The work at the Continuum Center was leading edge. The team fostered a high level of interprofessionalism and team care. They generated an important body of research. They experimented with business models and experienced times of profitability. Yet amidst a larger economic drama of what was called a merger between Continuum Health Partners and the now dominant Mt. Sinai Medical Center, the formerly 32-clinician integrative center, with its 6,000 visits per month, was put on the corporate chopping block last fall.
Basically, Urban Zen was losing money, and, as its director Dr. Ben Kligler put it, he “totally understands how it looks from [Mt. Sinai’s] point of view. We just looked like another practice in a hospital that was losing money.” He blames the closure on bad luck and bad timing:
Kligler views the loss of the Center as “just bad luck.” Why? “[Mt. Sinai] came in when we were the most vulnerable.” Had the merger come through a couple of years earlier, it would have been when the center “was booming.”
Kligler explains. In 2012, demand exceeded the ability to fulfill on meeting patient interest. The Center was operating profitably and expanded to a third floor. New investment coupled with new practices not yet overflowing added up to a temporal moment of significant red ink. Had the merger come later, in Kligler’s view, the new configuration would have had time to fill out and flourish. Mt. Sinai caught the snapshot of that moment’s performance rather than considering a promising revenue trajectory. Kligler summed up his view: “Honestly, we can’t hold Sinai responsible. It was terrible timing.”
This explanation, of course, sounds very self-serving. Maybe the Center was on a trajectory to profitability, but, really, when viewing a unit that is losing money most businesses (and, of course, hospitals are businesses) consider whether that unit is likely to return to profitability any time soon and how profitable it is likely to be. Reading between the lines, I sense that Mt. Sinai either didn’t see the Center becoming profitable soon enough for its liking and perhaps didn’t have enough interest in maintaining an integrative medicine center.
Unfortunately, Mt. Sinai isn’t abandoning “integrative” care altogether (which would have been a most excellent outcome). Rather, a core of four physicians relocated to a clinic in West Village (where else?) and that group was apparently lobbying to keep some of the non-MD practitioners previously associated with the Continuum Center (i.e., acupuncturists, naturopaths, etc.). The grants held by the Center transferred to the Mt. Sinai Department of Family Medicine, the better to bolster its standing in quackademic medicine.
Don’t feel too bad about Dr. Kligler, though. He’s landing on his feet. He’s now the new National Director of the Integrative Health Coordinating Center at the Veteran’s Health Administration, where he will work closely with Tracy Gaudet, MD, the director of the Office of Patient Centered Care and Cultural Transformation, to continue what Dr. Gaudet started and infuse the medical care of veterans with a healthy dose of pseudoscience and quackery.
I can’t help but picture Schwarzenegger as the Terminator, saying, “I’ll be back.”
Bye, bye Samueli
We’ve also written about the Samueli Institute many times. In brief, the Samueli Institute was one of the two sugar daddies for funding the integration of pseudoscience into medicine. It was very influential, as influential as the Bravewell Collaborative, which itself shut down two years ago using the reason that it was no longer necessary, or, as Christy Mack, one of Bravewell’s founders put it, “…when our principal strategies had achieved our goals, and when integrative medicine had become part of the national conversation on healthcare, our members collectively decided that it was time to sunset the organization.” (Given how thoroughly integrative and quackademic medicine has become entrenched at major academic medical centers, that reason was actually believable.) So learning from Mr. Weeks that the Samueli Institute will be closing in 2017 shocked me as well.
Wayne Jonas, the President and CEO of the Samueli Institute, tried to put a happy face on its shuttering in much the same way that Ms. Mack did for Bravewell, by saying it was no longer needed:
The value of that “somewhere” that Congressional appropriations enabled through the Institute is encapsulated in Jonas’ response on why the Institute was ending operations: “When we started out there really wasn’t much complementary and integrative medicine going on in the VA or the military.” The Institute’s research output and military partnerships led to the seminal 2010 Military Medicine report “Total Force Fitness for the 21st Century: A New Paradigm”. Expansive integrative health research, education and practice initiatives are now presently underway in both agencies, due to this ground work, but without the Institute’s direct presence. Added Jonas: “The work we were doing is now going on inside the DoD and the VA. Our work is not so necessary anymore. What we did has worked. It’s not that I won’t be in touch with them. But what we set out to do is done.” Bridge built.
Again, this excuse is somewhat plausible. There is a lot more integrative medicine around now than there was when the Samueli Institute was formed over 15 years ago. On the other hand, it clearly doesn’t tell the whole story:
So why the shut-down of the Institute? Jonas offered a response that felt at once both like putting a nice face on a tough situation, and a spot-on reflection of a job well done.
The “nice face” is connected to the Institute’s rapidly declining portfolio of government and particularly military research grants, and the staff to fulfill on them. An Obama-era federal policy change limited members’ of Congress ability to appropriate specific funds to specific entities for specific projects. While Congressional “earmarks” may be considered “pork barrel” when they are for bridges to nowhere, the grants to the Samueli Institute sought to bridge the nation’s medical industry from mono-therapeutic management of disease to a whole system focus on health. That’s a “somewhere” that deserves investment in the United States where the medical industry is the 3rd leading cause of death and at least one-third waste.
Translation: The Samueli Institute apparently relied too much on grants that weren’t competitively awarded, as NIH grants are. Instead, it appears to have relied on woo-friendly legislators to send money its way via earmarks, the process whereby individual legislators could “earmark” appropriations to favored entities to do work that a legislator reserving an earmark wanted to support. When those grants dried up, Samueli had an increasingly difficult time staying viable. Also, Jonas had apparently become tired of just administering grants, saying, “I’m not sure that focusing on the minutia of administering large grants is the best use of my skills [The Samuelis and I] decided to take a step back. A lot of our best work has been as catalysts. How can we catalyze what we want nationally? I couldn’t do that and run contracts.”
Of course, like Bravewell, Samueli won’t entirely die. It transferred $7 million of grants to the Thought Leadership Foundation, whose mission is: “To promote new and innovative thinking that leads to transformative change in the healthcare, education, economic opportunity and environmental arenas by engaging thought leaders in research, writing and program activities to address intractable problems plaguing those communities.” On the surface, TLF doesn’t look that woo-ful an organization. It supports initiatives in autism; translational medicine’s impact on treating Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI), Lyme disease, HIV/AIDS, other chronic diseases; renewable energy sources; mobile medical care plans; and other environment- and medicine-related projects. There doesn’t appear to be much, if anything, about integrative medicine on its website. I rather suspect that that will change, though. Mr. Weeks notes that TLF “saw huge growth with the transfer of the Samueli Institute’s research portfolio, quadrupling TLF’s size.” This suggests that Samueli’s “integrative medicine” portfolio is taking over TLF.
So basically, the Samueli Institute won’t really die either, nor are Jonas and the Samueli’s going away:
Serving as a catalyst is the seed of what Jonas will bring forward in his next phase of partnership with the Samuelis. “Dialogue about integrative health care will not be the focus, but integrative health will be at the table, in the mainstream.” (Notably, this was already modeled with in the project that will be carried by IHI, where integrative health representatives served on the steering committee.)
Moving forward, their goal will be to “catalyze nationally some of the work we have been doing.” Approaches such as social impact investment may be considered, together with not-for-profit initiatives and other business models. “We are moving,” he said, “toward a more convergent platform. We are thinking about how we can accelerate this movement.”
I’m not sure exactly what that word salad is supposed to mean, other than that Jonas and the Samuelis will use the Samueli money to do something else to promote the integration of quackery into medicine. The Terminator’s voice again echoes in my head, “I’ll be back.”
A fit analogy?
On the surface, the events I’ve described, the closing of the Continuum Center, of the Samueli Institute, of Bravewell, seem to indicate that maybe integrative medicine isn’t the unstoppable juggernaut that we skeptics portray it as. Indeed, these aren’t the only examples. In his article about Mt. Sinai, Mr. Weeks notes that other centers had shut down too, while in an article published at the end of 2016, he noted:
To the budgets of the multi-billion juggernauts of the US medical industry inappropriately styled as “healthcare systems,” integrative medicine is – as a colleague suggested recently – a “rounding error.” And as has become clear over the past two decades of multiple shuttering of significant integrative centers, a profound economic misalignment exists between the “volume-based” and technology-driven industry and the mission-and-value orientation of relatively low cost, human-intensive, integrative care. Still it was a shock when word came out – apologies, I am part way into writing this story – that the powerfully influential Continuum Center for Health and Healing no longer fit into the plans of its parent, the $3.5-billion, plus, Mount Sinai Health System. Meantime, when the $7-billion Banner Health took over University of Arizona Medicine they showed no interest in the Phoenix-based Arizona Integrative Health Center where the Andrew Weil-founded Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine anticipated proving integrative health’s business model as a low cost option for chronic disease. Be aware: another shoe is about to drop. Each, notably, was showing patterns of positive outcomes. Are these centers simply a misfit with the industrial focus of the volume based system?
I’m guessing that the “other shoe” to which Mr. Weeks referred was the closing of the Samueli Institute. In any case, you get the idea. Although the pseudoscientific practices in integrative medicine are often perceived as a license to print money (and sometimes they are), because insurance doesn’t reimburse for them it can be much harder to build a sustainable business model providing such services than you’d think. That’s one reason why integrative medicine advocates lobby so hard to license naturopaths and to have laws passed requiring that services like acupuncture, traditional Chinese medicine, and the like be covered by health insurance plans. It’s why Sen. Tom Harkin inserted a clause in the Affordable Care Act requiring insurance plans sold through federal exchanges to cover the services of specialties licensed by the state, such as naturopathy, chiropractic, and acupuncture. So basically, what integrative medicine practices can bill insurance companies for are the services they provide that are the real medicine into which they are integrating their quackery. The problem, of course, is that those services are not well-reimbursed (as any cash-strapped primary care practice can tell you), and apparently the “cash on the barrelhead” integrative medicine services don’t make up the difference, particularly given how one of the main appeals of integrative medicine is how much time practitioners spend with patients, which greatly limits the volume they can see.
Unfortunately, there are those who have figured out how to make money integrating quackery into medicine:
This article is one in a series on significant ups and downs with major centers. We see significant expansion at Jefferson in Philadelphia, a new 17,000 square foot space for the Center for Functional Medicine at the Cleveland Clinic, and system-wide integrative health at Meridian Health. The build-up of integrative health and research in the Veterans Administration with which Kligler is now involved is another bright light.
Yes, the Cleveland Clinic is one such institution, and we’ve written many times about it—and even joked about it.
I still think that The Terminator is an excellent analogy for integrative medicine, though. When the Terminator says, “I’ll be back,” he always does come back. The Terminator is usually destroyed at the end of each movie, but somehow he’s always back in one form or another in the next. I have no doubt that the closure of the Samueli Institute and other major integrative medicine centers will only slow the advance of pseudoscience infiltrating medicine; that is, unless medicine starts to value science over pseudoscience and stops falling for the false narrative that you have to “integrate” quackery in order to take care of the “whole patient” in a patient-centered manner. I’m not holding my breath waiting for that
ADDENDUM 9/20/2017: Samueli is not dead. It’s been resurrected in a new, much more powerful and malignant form. There was a press release earlier this week that Susan and Henry Samueli are donating $200 million to the University of California, Irvine to establish an “integrative” (i.e., quackademic) medical college that “integrates” several schools at UCI into the service of integrative medicine. When the Samuelis said they were tired of administering grants, maybe this is what they wanted instead: A willing academic partner who will sell out science for a $200 million donation. “I’ll be back,” indeed.


A surprising article about “integrative” medicine in The New England Journal of Medicine vs. “patient-centered” care
David Gorski on March 5, 2012
Link
The New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) is published on Thursdays. I mention this because this is one of the rare times where my owning Mondays on this blog tends to be a rather large advantage. Fridays are rotated between two or three different bloggers, and, as awesome as they are as writers, bloggers, and friends, they don’t possess the rabbit-like speed (and attention span) that I do that would allow me to see an article published in the NEJM on Thursday and get a post written about it by early Friday morning. This is, of course, a skill I have honed in my not-so-super-secret other blogging identity; so if I owned the Friday slot I could pull it off. However, the Monday slot is good enough because I’ll almost always have first crack at juicy studies and articles published in the NEJM before my fellow SBM partners in crime, unless Steve Novella managed to crank something out for his own personal blog on Friday, curse him.
My desire to be the firstest with the mostest when it comes to blogging about new articles notwithstanding, as I perused the table of contents of the NEJM this week, I was shocked to see an article that made me wonder whether the editors at NEJM might just be starting to “get it”—just a little bit—regarding “integrative” medicine. As our very own Mark Crislip put it a little more than a week ago:
If you integrate fantasy with reality, you do not instantiate reality. If you mix cow pie with apple pie, it does not make the cow pie taste better; it makes the apple pie worse.
Lately, though, I’ve been more fond of a version that doesn’t use fancy words like “instantiate”:
If you integrate fantasy with reality, you don’t make the fantasy more real. You temporarily make your reality seem more fantasy-based, but reality always wins out in the end.
The part about the cow pie needs no change, although I think ice cream works a bit better than apple pie. Your mileage may vary. Feel free to make up your own metaphor inspired by Mark’s.
In any case, in the Perspective section, I saw three articles about “patient-centered” care:
    • Goal-Oriented Patient Care — An Alternative Health Outcomes by David B. Reuben, M.D., and Mary E. Tinetti, M.D.
    • Shared Decision Making — The Pinnacle of Patient-Centered Care by Michael J. Barry, M.D., and Susan Edgman-Levitan, P.A.
    • Defining “Patient-Centered Medicine” by Charles L. Bardes, M.D.
As I and several of my fellow SBM bloggers have pointed out, the whole concept of “patient-centered” care, as worthy as it is in theory, is all too often in practice co-opted by promoters of unscientific, pseusocientific, and faith-based health care modalities to justify quackery. That’s why the fourth article on the list surprised me:
What’s the Alternative? The Worldwide Web of Integrative Medicine by Ranjana Srivastava, F.R.A.C.P.
When I saw this title, I was rather expecting apologetics about “integrative” medicine. What I got instead was an article that would have been appropriate right here on this very blog, a post about a woman who had fallen prey to a dubious test promoted at an “integrative” health fair and the devastating results of that test. That’s why I was suprised.
After all, let’s look at the record of the NEJM over the last couple of years. What is still considered to be one of the best medical journals in the world, if not the best, appears to be the victim of a conscious effort on the behalf of its editors to dethrone itself as king of medical journals through its increasing acceptance of the spin placed on medical science by those who would integrate fantasy with reality in medicine in the hope of improving medicine. Unfortunately for them reality has a way of always winning out in the end, just as the cow pie wins out in Mark’s metaphor.
For me, the first sign of major trouble appeared back in the summer of 2010, when the NEJM published what was on the surface an unremarkable study that found that tai chi appeared to have a beneficial effect on symptoms in patients with fibromyalgia. Indeed, I remember it well because its publication coincided with my trip to Chicago to give an invited talk to the Chicago Skeptics, the Women Thinking Free Foundation, and CFI-Chicago. (Hey, come to think of it, it’s been a long time since then. Maybe the skeptical crew would want to invite me out again to give a talk. But I digress…) In any case, part of what was so annoying about the article is that, as I put it, the NEJM completely and uncritically let the authors spin their results in—shall we say?—an “alternative” frame. As I pointed out at the time, let’s say that tai chi is the greatest thing since sliced bread and that it alleviates fibromyalgia pain and stiffness better than anything we’ve yet come up with. Let’s assume all of those things are true, just for the moment: what thought comes to mind to you? I know what thought comes to mind to me. What on earth is “alternative” or “complementary” about such a finding? In reality, such findings would simply indicate that certain forms of low-impact exercise could help fibromyalgia symptoms, which is not anything particularly surprising at all, given what we already know about fibromyalgia. In the interim, this NEJM article has been touted far and wide by apologists for “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM), or, as they prefer to call it these days, “integrative medicine.”
Around about the same time, the NEJM published an even more credulous article about acupuncture in its Clinical Therapeutics section. As I described at the time, it was a clinical vignette, a little case presentation if you will, by Dr. Brian M. Berman, who has managed in a brief period of time to become the foremost popularizer of acupuncture in academic medical centers. In this vignette, the acupuncture was presented as a perfectly fine alternative for low back pain, and, as both Mark Crislip and I described, Berman did some pretty creative spinning to make it seem as though evidence favored acupuncture.
Since then, there have been other examples of the once-venerable NEJM falling for what can best be described as utter nonsense. In fact, even when publishing what could be a scientifically interesting and medically useful paper on placebo effects, its editors allowed the authors, led by Ted Kaptchuk, to spin the results in a way to imply that patients can have symptomatic relief without actual reversal of the underlying physiologic derangement that caused their symptoms in the first place and that that’s OK. In this case, the disease was asthma, and the paper published showed that placebo acupuncture resulted in asthma patients feeling better but didn’t reverse the airway constriction that led patients to feel short of breath in the first place. Peter Lipson quite properly described this as “folly,” but it’s worse than that. The NEJM doubled down and published an accompanying editorial by Daniel Moerman, who is about as postmodernist as it gets and all about “meaning” in the doctor-patient interaction. I’m going to quote the same passage from his editorial now that I quoted then, in which Moerman makes an explicit plea for placebo medicine based on the concept of patient-centered care:
The authors conclude that the patient reports were “unreliable,” since they reported improvement when there was none — that is, the subjective experiences were simply wrong because they ignored the objective facts as measured by FEV1. But is this the right interpretation? It is the subjective symptoms that brought these patients to medical care in the first place. They came because they were wheezing and felt suffocated, not because they had a reduced FEV1. The fact that they felt improved even when their FEV1 had not increased begs the question, What is the more important outcome in medicine: the objective or the subjective, the doctor’s or the patient’s perception? This distinction is important, since it should direct us as to when patient-centered versus doctor-directed care should take place.
For subjective and functional conditions — for example, migraine, schizophrenia, back pain, depression, asthma, post-traumatic stress disorder, neurologic disorders such as Parkinson’s disease, inflammatory bowel disease and many other autoimmune disorders, any condition defined by symptoms, and anything idiopathic — a patient-centered approach requires that patient-preferred outcomes trump the judgment of the physician. Under these conditions, inert pills can be as useful as “real” ones; two inert pills can work better than one; colorful inert pills can work better than plain ones; and injections can work better than pills.
Which brings us to today, skipping over the recent incident where the NEJM apparently has decided that accepting dubious advertisements is acceptable. The article about the cancer quack begins with a patient who out of curiosity wanders into an “integrative” health exhibition, and this is what happens:
Out of curiosity, an impressionable woman in her 30s attends an integrative medicine exhibition; having recently had a child, she’s been sleep-deprived and wants to investigate natural remedies. At the seminar, she wins a door prize — a blood test that promises to diagnose cancer. She was considering getting a blood test anyway and seizes this opportunity for a more comprehensive workup. After all, you can’t be too careful about avoiding cancer.
Weeks later, she receives a call from an apologetic but alarmed stranger telling her she has advanced cancer.
“How do you know?” she gasps.
“Your blood test is positive for circulating tumor cells.”
“What does that mean?” she cries.
He sends her a three-page report and tells her to seek immediate help. She spends a nail-biting week awaiting an appointment with the recommended integrative health expert.
Glancing at the report, the expert declares, “You have advanced non-small-cell lung cancer. You need treatment now.” The woman is petrified: Has her teenage smoking habit come back to haunt her?
“Are you sure?” she asks.
“Absolutely. There are circulating tumor cells in your blood.”
Tears streaming down her face, the woman asks, “What now?”
Ten years ago, it was whole body scans, which, while not really advertised as “integrative” or “alternative” produced the same sorts of results: Terrified people who thought they had a horrible disease based on an “incidentaloma.” The end results were frequently multiple additional imaging tests, with the concomitant unnecessary doses of radiation, invasive procedures, and even surgeries to try to determine whether these incidentalomas were actually cancer or anything else to worry about. Because the prevalence of abnormalities on such scans is so high, the fraction of these “false alarms” was (and remains) very high. The result is that such highly sensitive tests indiscriminately applied to a population in which the likelihood of the disease being sought is low are far more likely to cause harm through false alarms that result in further tests than they are to save lives through early detection. Sure, there will be the occasional “save,” in which a potentially deadly tumor is discovered at a very small size and resected. Certainly that is what the whole body scanning businesses that sprouted up a decade ago and have now (thankfully) mostly gone away would tout in their advertisements. What they wouldn’t tell you is the cost, how many were harmed or how many were sent off on wild goose chases compared to the rare person who might have been saved by such a pickup.
After hearing the recommendation of the “integrative practitioner” that she undergo a 12-week course of intravenous vitamin C, at a cost of $6,000, the patient decided to seek out an oncologist. As I’ve pointed out time and time again, vitamin C has pretty much failed as a potential treatment for cancer, its advocacy by a Nobel Laureate notwithstanding. Basically, it requires incredibly high doses of vitamin C. There might be a very modest antitumor effect at incredibly high doses, but it’s such a long run for a short slide that it doesn’t really make sense to use, particularly given that there is evidence that vitamin C at high concentrations can interfere with convention chemotherapy treatments.
But let’s get back to the “diagnosis.” A decade ago, it was full body scans. Apparently today it’s “circulating tumor cells.” (And, of course, thermography is forever.) Remember how extensively I’ve written about how earlier detection is not always better? Overdiagnosis, detection bias that favors less aggressive cancers among screening-detected cancers, stage migration (the “Will Rogers effect”), and a number of other confounders make it difficult to determine just when and how often to use good screening tests for which we have data from very large population-based studies and clinical trials, like mammography. There remains controversy to this day regarding when and how to screen for breast cancer and even whether to screen for prostate cancer. In the meantime, trying to screen for lung cancer using CT scans has largely been a failure.
So here we have a quack—yes, a quack—looking for circulating tumor cells (CTC) in the blood of a young woman in whom there is no strong reason to suspect cancer other than a distant smoking history. Who knows if the test is valid? That is, of course, the first thing I would question, given where the company was promoting its wares and what the “integrative” practitioner recommended. But let’s for the moment assume that there were circulating tumor cells in a woman with no known tumor? Do we know what to do with such things? No! We have no idea. Measuring circulating tumor cells in the blood is a hot area of research right now, which is no doubt why “integrative” practitioners are apparently offering such tests, to capitalize on the interest. In any case, the research that is going on is primarily focused on using CTCs as prognostic markers in patients diagnosed with cancer and for following response to therapy, and, even in those situations, they have not been validated to the point where they have become standard of care. Measuring CTCs is still, at best, experimental, and there is as yet no good evidence that they will be useful as screening tools in populations not at high risk. Scientists still argue over the proper cutoff points for patients with cancer; they have no idea what to use as a cutoff measurement in healthy patients. As Max Wicha put it, not all detected cells are bad and not all bad cells are detected.
The rest of the story goes something like this. A skeptical friend of the woman suggested that she should have a scan, and she had a cousin of hers, who happened to be a physician, order a chest X-ray and CT scan (which is another excellent example of why physicians should not treat family members), which revealed “two tiny nodules, 2 mm each in diameter.” On the radiology report were those waffle words that clinicians dread reading, “Clinical correlation is recommended in the context of a smoking history” (which is another reason physicians should not order tests whose results they won’t know what to do with). After trying to get in to see a thoracic surgeon, the patient is referred to an oncologist’s office, that of Dr. Srivastava, the author of the paper. This is what happens next, as described by Dr. Srivastava. I’ll quote as liberally from the article as I think I can and still be in the bounds of fair use, because, oddly enough, even though the three articles on patient-centered care are free for the download on the NEJM site, this article on cancer quackery is not. I wonder why. In any case, on with the story:
“There’s no evidence of cancer,” I reply, seeking to reassure her.
Instead, her tone sharpens: “But I have circulating tumor cells! How can you say that?”
Incredulous, I try to explain too many things. The blood test is a long way from being validated for clinical use. It was unscrupulous even to offer it. Does it make sense to her that it was sent to an unheard-of overseas laboratory for processing? Why did no one recommend that she see an oncologist?
Rolling her eyes, she counters, “I’ve heard that I need a PET scan. And if the spots light up, this test will have been my lifesaver.”
She is right on one count: the surgeon she sees orders a PET scan, saying he needs to be sure. She loses sleep over the results — the surgeon’s appointment is 2 weeks away, and she wants to schedule the operation. Feeling sympathetic, I tell her the PET scan was clear and the two small nodules seen on the first CT have disappeared; the radiologist thinks they were probably transient foci of inflammation.
But any relief the woman feels is ephemeral. “So what does that mean?” she asks. “The PET scan is faulty?”
“There is no cancer,” I reiterate.
“But someone has seen cancer cells,” she insists.
“That was not a validated test — not something we currently use to diagnose cancer,” I protest.
Dr. Srivastava goes around and around with the patient, trying to reassure her that she does not have cancer. She largely fails. The patient insists on being followed by her because she thinks she has a tiny cancer somewhere that’s just waiting to blossom, leading Dr. Srivastava to lament, quite appropriately, “How does one ‘disprove’ a serious diagnosis once its specter has been raised by an unqualified ‘expert’?” How indeed? I’ve had the same sort of problem with women who come in with thermograms convinced that they have breast cancer and wanting a double mastectomy. Fortunately, this is not common, at least not in my practice. Very fortunately.
Dr. Srivastava then hits the nail on the head:
At one time, the worst offense one encountered was someone prescribing a few herbs to a desperate patient who’d exhausted all other means of treatment. The usual thinking was, “At this stage, it can’t do any harm.” But insidiously and alarmingly, “alternative medicine” has crept from offering last-ditch treatments to making diagnoses. As the cancer armamentarium has expanded with targeted therapies, unscrupulous practitioners of alternative therapy have devised competing offers that sound at least as impressive to the average patient, who is often marginally health-literate and eager to embrace the promise of a cure without toxicity. But the radical, completely unregulated, and often dangerous options on offer can and do cause harm.
After describing the sorts of quack treatments she’s seen her patients use, Dr. Srivastava then drives to the heart of the matter when she points out:
The practitioners never write directly to oncologists and refuse to be accountable for their actions. Unauthorized to order tests, they tell patients, “Ask your doctor to do these bloods,” or “You need to have a scan to see whether the microwaves are working.”
Alternative therapies need meet no burden of proof except a patient’s gullibility. One never hears of alternative therapies that failed: the patient merely waited too long to try them. For every patient who openly discusses such treatments, there must be many who assume the treatments aren’t worth mentioning to “traditional” oncologists. After all, to make integrative health the multibillion-dollar industry it is, people must be supporting it; those people are our patients.
Physicians would be naive to ignore the elephant in the room. Integrative medicine comes in many forms — some useful, but many dangerous. It also comes at tremendous personal and societal cost. The initial expenditure may come from patients’ pockets, but often the health care system eventually inherits the problem. Although there’s probably no way of calculating the psychological cost, for many it is high and unending.
Indeed. Maybe I’ll send Dr. Srivastava an invitation to write a post or two for SBM. She sounds like my kind of doc.
All of this brings us back to “patient-centered” care and how it relates to the article about the cancer quack. Indeed, I wonder whether the NEJM editors are actually starting to “get it” by tacking Dr. Srivastava’s article on to the end of the NEJM Perspectives section. Think back to Dr. Moerman’s definition of “patient-centered care.” Now look at what we are told in the first article, by Ruben and Tinetti:
Perhaps the most important barrier to goal-oriented care is that medicine is deeply rooted in a disease-outcome–based paradigm. Rather than asking what patients want, the culture has valued managing each disease as well as possible according to guidelines and population goals.
Ultimately, good medicine is about doing right for the patient. For patients with multiple chronic diseases, severe disability, or limited life expectancy, any accounting of how well we’re succeeding in providing care must above all consider patients’ preferred outcomes.
Dr. Bardes writes in the third article:
“Patient-centered medicine” is the newest salvo in these ancient debates. As a form of practice, it seeks to focus medical attention on the individual patient’s needs and concerns, rather than the doctor’s. As a rhetorical slogan, it stakes a position in contrast to which everything else is both doctor-centered and suspect on ethical, economic, organizational, and metaphoric grounds.
But what does that mean? Ruben and Tinetti discuss prioritizing patients’ desired outcomes and helping them to achieve these outcomes, as long as they are possible. Dr. Bardes likens the relationship between doctor and patient as one of equals, like two binary stars orbiting a common center of gravity, a double helix, whose strands circle each other, or even the caduceus, with two serpents intertwined. I have to hand it to Dr. Bardes, he’s a poetic guy, but he goes too far. While patient and physician might be equals as human beings, in terms of medical knowledge they are not. If they were, then the patient arguably would not need the physician and would be able to handle his health problems himself. A better way of looking at it would be that the physician is the expert consultant, whose skill and knowledge the patient requests, while the patient is free to accept or refuse the physician’s advice. This is not the same as the old paternalistic model, where the doctor ordered and the patient acquiesced, because the patient is actively involved in seeking advice and can reject that advice. In other words, the relationship is more equal, but not exactly equal.
Now let’s think of what extreme patient-centered care would mean in the case of the woman described by Dr. Srivastava. This woman wanted more tests either to prove she didn’t have cancer or to remove the tiny 2 mm masses that were suspected to be cancer. That was her greatest concern, and medicine could address that quite easily by doing what the patient wanted; i.e., either operating on her or otherwise treating her. As it is, Dr. Srivastava could very easily have simply taken the patient on as a regular and seen her periodically, ordering tests every so often to assuage her fears. That would have been less potentially harmful than doing additional tests or even surgery. A physician could (and some do) build up lucrative practices of just such “worried well.” Would that be patient-centered care? It would certainly be giving the patient what she wants and placing the patient’s desires over that of the physician’s.
Certainly many “integrative” practitioners have wholeheartedly embraced the concept of patient-centered care. However, they have done so more out of a desire to be able to justify placebo medicine. If it makes the patient feel better, it must be better, you know, just like the sham acupuncture that made the asthma patients feel better without reversing their underlying airway constriction. Those patients felt great and probably would continue to feel great until they turned blue. “Patient-centered care” is easy when it devolves into giving the patient what she wants without consideration of science. Real patient-centered care is hard and must contend with situations where what the patient wants is unrealistic or impossible.
Certainly a better model is the one described by Barry and Edgman-Levitan, which calls for shared decision-making:
For some decisions, there is one clearly superior path, and patient preferences play little or no role — a fractured hip needs repair, acute appendicitis necessitates surgery, and bacterial meningitis requires antibiotics. For most medical decisions, however, more than one reasonable path forward exists (including the option of doing nothing, when appropriate), and different paths entail different combinations of possible therapeutic effects and side effects. Decisions about therapy for early-stage breast cancer or prostate cancer, lipid-lowering medication for the primary prevention of coronary heart disease, and genetic and cancer screening tests are good examples. In such cases, patient involvement in decision making adds substantial value.
This is probably true, but it depends upon the patient being provided with scientifically valid information to help guide their part of the shared decision-making process. I’ve frequently referred to a concept that I like to call “misinformed consent.” Basically, that’s how practitioners of unscientific nonsense will exaggerate the benefits and minimize the risks of their recommendations, all the while exaggerating the harms and minimizing the benefits of conventional therapies. A particularly apt example is the antivaccine movement, which tries to convince people that vaccines don’t work and are very dangerous. CAM practitioners do the same thing in their vision of “patient-centered care,” but informed consent is not optional, and without informed consent patient-centered care cannot work.
I wonder whether the editors realized that they just might be making a statement when they juxtaposed Dr. Srivastava’s article about what happens when “integrative” care runs rampant with three articles describing the very “patient-centered” care that such practitioners take advantage of. It’s not possible to have real patient-centered care without real informed consent, and “integrative medicine” relies on misinformed consent.

Medical Intuitives: More Integrative Medicine Pseudoscience
The integrative medicine industry is all in on making a “scan” of your “biofield” part of your physician’s diagnostic toolkit.
Jann Bellamy on September 1, 2026
Link

In 2022, a woman named Wendie Colter recalled a fantastical incident to an interviewer. Colter said she had “scanned” the body of a woman with wrist tendonitis “like an MRI”, seeing not only inflamed tendons, but also a healed wrist fracture, along with “a cloud of grief and emotional pain” around the woman’s wrist.
At the same time, Colter had a vision of the woman’s past experiences, including a breakup with a boyfriend and being struck on the wrist by an abusive parent. Colter concluded that the woman’s wrist was “holding onto . . . grief, emotion and physical trauma.”
She further “discerned some sleep and gut health issues” after “ask[ing] the [woman’s] body what it might want or need to find balance.” The woman, according to Colter, confirmed certain aspects of her history and, after a few days, reported her wrist pain was gone.
Colter, who started out as an “energy healer”, told the interviewer that she had accomplished all of this in her work as a “medical intuitive”, performing “an intuitive assessment” of the woman’s “physical body and biofield”, a term she equates with the “chakra system” and “aura field”.
Medical (not!) intuitive
The National Organization for Medical Intuition (NOMI), which Colter heads, defines medical intuition as
a system of expanded perception gained through the development of the human sense of intuition. Medical Intuition is a process of intuitive observation and assessment of the physical body and energetic systems of the body.
As NOMI further explains, although the practice has intentionally chosen to use the word “medical”, it is not, in fact, “medical”:
Although Medical Intuition uses the word “medical,” it is not to be considered the practice of medicine, psychotherapy, or any other licensed healthcare practice, and is not a substitute for licensed medical or psychological care, diagnosis or treatment, but rather a skill intended to support all healthcare practices.
In actual practice though, as we shall see, medical intuitives very much intend for their “diagnoses” (just don’t call it that) to guide medical decision-making.
Color me doubtful
I don’t believe for one minute that Colter actually has the powers she describes, no matter how much she thinks she does, because:
     1.  Well-controlled experiments refute the existence of a human “biofield” or “energetic system” of the kind she describes. For example, Emily Rosa famously demonstrated, in a 1998 study, published in JAMA, that “therapeutic touch” practitioners, who claimed the ability to feel and manipulate a human energy field, performed no better than chance.
     2.  Instruments have never been able to detect this putative biofield.
     3.  There is no plausible mechanism of action for the biofield.
     4.  Numerous trials of biofield-based diagnostics and treatments, like reiki, fail to show any effect beyond placebo.
     5.  Correlation is not causation. The fact that the woman’s tendonitis got better after a session with a medical intuitive is not evidence that the two are related.
     6.  Resolution of the woman’s tendonitis has other, scientifically plausible explanations, like the natural fluctuation of symptoms.
     7.  MRI-like vision is a comic book superpower, unknown to science.
(Did I miss anything?)
To be fair, it’s not hard to see why confirmation bias or other, more plausible, explanations for Colter’s perception of her abilities might elude her. A bio posted by a business she owns discloses no scientific or medical training.
In my view, Colter’s pretensions as a medical intuitive should be dismissed as pseudoscience. And certainly no physician should ever subject his patients to the indignities of this nonsense.
Integrative Medicine is all in
Unfortunately, the integrative medicine industry disagrees with me.
Integrative medicine (sometimes referred to as “IM”), as you may recall, is based on a two-part strategy of (1) rebranding standard healthcare practices (diet, exercise, stress-reduction) and approaches (holistic, whole-person, patient-centered) as “integrative”, and (2) incorporating pseudoscience (e.g., homeopathy, acupuncture, naturopathy) into medical practice. Its reliance on pseudoscience, and a decidedly superciliousness in its attitude toward “conventional” medicine, has made IM the topic of numerous SBM posts.
In today’s post, we’ll see how the integrative medicine industry, yet again, provides support for a practice that should be rejected as quackery, one more telling example of its unprincipled disregard for science.
Familiar bedfellows
Colter’s interview, which offered zero pushback on her incredible claims, was with an online publication called Integrative Practitioner, an enterprise helmed by the same outfit that puts on the annual Integrative Healthcare Symposium. This year’s symposium featured familiar names from the SBM integrative medicine files: Jeffrey Bland and Dr. David Katz, as well as a physician who worked with Dr. Nicholas Gonzales on the infamous “Gonzales Regimen” for cancer.
According to the Integrative Practitioner article, Colter, “MCWC [Master Certified Wellness Coach], CMIP [Certified Medical Intuitive Practitioner]”,
serves on the Bioenergy & Health Committee of the Integrative Health Policy Consortium (IHPC), was chosen as rotating faculty for the Integrative Medicine Elective Rotation (IMER) program at the Andrew Weil Center for Integrative Medicine [at the University of Arizona] and is an educational contributor for the Academy of Integrative Health & Medicine Fellowship.
In other words, Colter, and her claims to medical intuition, have been embraced by the stalwarts of the integrative medicine industry.
The IHPC heavily promotes the “integration” of acupuncturists, chiropractors, naturopaths, and functional medicine practitioners into mainstream medicine and pushes the government to force public and private insurers to fully cover their services, no matter the lack of evidence of safety and effectiveness or, for that matter, scientific plausibility.
The Weil Center is part of what we at SBM call quackademic medicine, and its namesake, Integrative Medicine guru Dr. Andrew Weil, has been the subject of several posts. The Center’s Integrative Medicine Rotation allows medical students and residents to “explore” quackery like homeopathy and energy medicine (which is where, I assume, Colter’s tutelage came in).
Completion of The Academy of Integrative Health & Medicine [AIHM] Fellowship (now allied with Thomas Jefferson University) allows one to qualify for (the unfortunate) board certification in Integrative Medicine for physicians. The AIHM itself includes alternative medicine practitioners like chiropractors, acupuncturists, and naturopaths, which led me to describe the acceptance of its fellowship into the bosom of MD board certification as
perhaps the apotheosis of the fetishization of alternative medicine by IM proponents.
Indoctrination
According to Colter, her IM students enthusiastically embraced her teachings:
The feedback from my integrative practitioner graduates is that . . . [using a medical intuitive] saves them so much time. They can quickly get to the root causes of issues and put together a tailored care plan. It’s cost effective as they can prioritize testing and treatments. They have also found that patient compliance can be enhanced by bringing awareness to the underlying energetic causes of their issues.
[An aside: Integrative medicine practitioners might want to consider how they would explain to a jury, under oath, on cross-examination by a plaintiff’s attorney, their decision to “save time”, “put together a tailored plan”, and “prioritize testing and treatments”, based on a medical intuitive’s advice.]
As mentioned, Colter is also the founder and CEO of the National Organization for Medical Intuition, an outfit whose
aim to integrate Medical Intuition into all forms of healthcare.
NOMI is assisted in its efforts by an Advisory Board that includes Leonard S. Wisnesski, MD, an endocrinologist and IM practitioner, who is on the faculty of George Washington University and the University of Colorado. He is also Chairman Emeritus of the Integrative Health Policy Consortium which, according to his bio, and as noted above, pushes legislation favorable to naturopaths and the like.
Learning pseudoscience for CE credit
Colter is also the CEO of The Practical Path, a medical intuition training program, which
offers a powerful skill set designed to provide fast, accurate intuitive health assessments. Identify the underlying causes of health issues to support and enhance whole-person health—body, mind, and spirit. [Emphasis in original.]
And:
Foundational training in intuitive assessments of the human biofield. The biofield is the electromagnetic field that surrounds and permeates the human body. The health of the biofield is believed to affect our daily energetic balance and well-being. [Link in original.]
Thus:
Imagine the possibilities of being able to intuitively pinpoint the root causes of illness, imbalance, and disease!
In sum, based on a “belief” (their word) in a “biofield,” which (as these researchers concluded) “remains undemonstrated”  and for which “no quality scientific work has established any clinically significant effect”, you’ll learn to “pinpoint” the “causes” of illness and disease. (Just don’t call it a “diagnosis”.)
Yet, in addition to support from the previously-mentioned IM establishment, Colter has, according to The Practical Path, presented to the UCLA Center for East-West Medicine, UC San Diego Centers for Integrative Health Grand Rounds, USC Institute for Integrative Health, the Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine and Health, the Institute for Functional Medicine, as well as the University of Colorado med school and a Florida osteopathic school. The Practical Path’s home page displays the logos of several prominent educational institutions, among them UCLA and USC. (Whether with their permission or not, I don’t know.)
The California Board of Registered Nursing offers CE credit for The Practical Path’s courses. (As do chiropractic and acupuncture course accreditors, unsurprisingly.) The Practical Path is also an authorized vendor for the VA’s “Whole Health” program.
Tooth Fairy Science
The Practical Path touts two “extraordinary research results”:
In one study:
Certified graduates [of their program] show 94% accuracy in location and assessment of health issues, 98% accuracy in describing life experiences that may correspond to health issues, 94% consistency with known diagnoses, and more.
And in the second:
All of the physicians highly rated medical intuitive sessions as accurate, influential to their clinical process, would recommend using medical intuitives to colleagues, and would continue to use medical intuitives.
Both are excellent examples of Tooth Fairy Science, and both were supported by the integrative medicine industry.
The first, “Assessing the Accuracy of Medical Intuition: A Subjective and Exploratory Study”, was published in the Journal of Complementary and Integrative Medicine. The authors are a Ph.D. who is the Director of the Center of Excellence for Research and Training in Integrative Health, Family Medicine and Public Health, at UC San Diego, and Colter.
The article is behind a paywall but, according to the abstract, medical intuitives “scanned” 67 study participants in 30-60 minute sessions via phone or video.  The intuitives’ conversations with participants were limited to “telling them information they were ‘seeing’ during the scanning process”. Afterwards, the participants filled out forms “documenting their assessment of the reading”, with the results as reported.
Of course, in addition to the incredible implausibility of such “scans” producing reliable information, an exploratory study is not evidence of the effectiveness of either medical intuition in general or The Practical Path’s training program in particular.
The second study, “Physician and Patient Perspectives of the Usefulness and Accuracy of Medical Intuition: A Prospective Pragmatic Trial”, consisted of medical intuitive remote “scans” of 40 patients referred to the study by six unidentified physicians recruited through contacts in the integrative medicine community. As with the first study, physicians and participants filled out assessment forms afterwards. Again, the study is not evidence of the effectiveness of medical intuition, which the authors themselves admit.
Also again, the integrative medicine industry supported this endeavor. The study was published in Global Advances in Integrative Medicine and Health, which is affiliated with the Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine and Health. The authors, in addition to Colter, include the aforementioned Dr. Wisnessk, as well as a naturopathic doctor on the faculty of the Oregon Health & Science University.
Cow Pie
NOMI recognizes Edgar Cayce, a psychic and “medical clairvoyant” from the early 20th century, as a forefather of the modern medical intuitive. In his time, Cayce was regarded as a quack and was prosecuted for the unlicensed practice of medicine. Now his progeny teach medical residents and nurses.
Medical intuition is pseudoscience and has no place in medical practice. Yet, the integrative medicine industry, through its co-option of otherwise respectable medical institutions, creation of pseudoscience-promoting organizations, as well as support for, and publication of, trifling research, has created a “safe space” in which such practices can flourish and metastasize into the public body.
Or, as Dr. Mark Crislip more piquantly summarized the issue:
If you integrate fantasy with reality, you do not instantiate reality. If you mix cow pie with apple pie, it does not make the cow pie taste better; it makes the apple pie worse.


Columbia University finally cuts ties with America’s Quack Dr. Oz
Decades after Dr. Oz pioneered “integrating” quackery into medicine and after many years of promoting diet scams and quackery on a nationally syndicated daily television show, Columbia University appears finally to have had enough and has quietly downgraded his status. What took so long?
David Gorski on May 2, 2022
Link

It’s never been a secret that we at SBM are not fans of Dr. Mehmet Oz. It’s hard not to have encountered him before, given his fame and now his full embrace of President Trump for his campaign to become the Republican nominee for the Senate from Pennsylvania. As you might recall, Dr. Oz was a young rising star in academic cardiothoracic surgery in the 1990s, and even I have to admit that his achievements back then were impressive. Then something happened. Dr. Oz embraced reiki, founded Columbia University’s integrative medicine program, and ultimately, after having met Oprah Winfrey and been featured on her show periodically as “America’s Doctor” (which led me to start referring to him as “America’s Quack” beginning years ago), hosted The Dr. Oz Show, which ran for nearly 13 seasons; that is, until Dr. Oz cut the last season short a few months ago and ended his show to run for the Senate for Pennsylvania. Of course, Dr. Oz being the long-time quack and grifter that he was, it didn’t faze him in the least that he had lived in New Jersey, not Pennsylvania, and worked in Manhattan for decades; he voted absentee in 2020 using his wife’s parents’ address in the Philadelphia suburbs. When last we discussed him on SBM, unsurprisingly Dr. Oz was pulling a common quack trick by challenging his critics (in this case, specifically Dr. Anthony Fauci) to a “debate”.
Those of us who promote science-based medicine and try to counter quackery and antivaccine misinformation have long lamented how Dr. Oz, despite promoting misinformation about health for over a decade, maintained his positions at Columbia University as professor and vice-chair of surgery at Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, as well as the medical director of the Integrative Medicine Program (i.e., Columbia’s quackademic medicine) program at New York-Presbyterian Hospital. It’s a lament that we tended to repeat almost any time Dr. Oz hit a new low in promoting quackery (which was depressingly not infrequent). We kept wondering why Columbia would continue to employ him in such high level leadership positions for so many years, despite his increasingly awful reputation in medicine for promoting quacks like Joe Mercola and even Mike Adams. That’s why a spate of stories that appeared over the last couple of days caught my eye:
    • Columbia University Quietly Changes Mehmet Oz’s Position Amid Senate Run (Huffington Post)
    • Dr Oz dropped by Columbia amid pro-Trump Republican Senate run – report (The Guardian)
    • ‘Chickenshit’ Move: Columbia Quietly Cuts Ties With Dr. Oz (The Daily Beast)
    • Columbia University has almost entirely scrubbed Dr. Oz from its website after years of criticism from members of medical community (The Insider)
Given Dr. Oz’s history, I thought it would be interesting to discuss what happened in relation to his longstanding leadership positions at Columbia University, calls for Columbia to disassociate itself from him over the years, and his general history of having promoted dietary supplement scams, cell phone-cancer pseudoscience, homeopathy, psychic mediums, and other quackery going back decades.
Dr. Oz and Columbia: What happened?
The first story about this appears to have been the Huffington Post report, published in January:
TV doctor-turned-politician Mehmet Oz has apparently retired from clinical practice and his faculty role at Columbia University since announcing his Senate run in Pennsylvania.
Oz, who once served as vice chair of the surgery department, now holds the title of “professor emeritus of surgery” at the Ivy League school.
The title reflects the fact that Oz, 61, no longer sees patients, according to a Columbia spokesperson, but it’s unclear how long he’s been retired from his clinical practice. Oz didn’t have the emeritus title as recently as last month, just after he launched his campaign.
An emeritus status is conferred to retired professors and faculty members “in recognition of distinguished service to the university and eminence in their discipline,” according to the university.
The university didn’t respond to questions about when the change took place or how involved Oz still is with its medical faculty. Oz is also now a special lecturer in the surgery department.
More:
Columbia University’s Irving Medical Center maintains a page for Oz, listing an office for him at its Washington Heights campus and noting that he specializes as a board-certified cardiac and thoracic surgeon.
But as of early December, Oz was still listed as a professor of surgery and as director of the Integrative Medicine Center — a department that, according to its description, would combine traditional medicine with alternative practices such as acupuncture, meditation and yoga. It’s unclear what happened with that role.
I was actually surprised at how long ago this news article was published, as I thought I had become a bit of an expert on Dr. Oz and his quackery. Yet, for some reason, before the more recent reports (the other three in the list, all of which were published over the weekend), I had never heard about the change in his status at Columbia University, nor had I known that he had stopped seeing patients at least a few years ago. Indeed, it made me wonder whether the very convenient resurrection of the Huffington Post story two weeks before the May 17 Pennsylvania primary election next week was the work of one of Oz’ Senate rivals. Whatever the reason the story resurfaced, I’ll mention again how I’ve often wondered how Dr. Oz could hold those leadership positions at Columbia and host a daily hourlong syndicated TV show with an insatiable maw for new material, and still maintain competence at a surgical specialty that, even among surgical specialties, is very technically demanding. It requires regular practice to be able to stay slick and smooth sewing those little blood vessels together so that the anastomosis stays open and doesn’t clot, for instance.
It’s also interesting to note that if you click on the original Columbia webpage link for Dr. Oz mentioned in the HuffPo report, the page is no longer there, and the Wayback Machine at Archive.org gave me an error message searching for it. Interestingly, his former page at the Department of Surgery at Columbia returns an “access denied” message, but the Wayback Machine does return a version of it as late as December.
As mentioned in the article, it would make sense if Dr. Oz had been kicked up to emeritus status, as that is frequently what happens when long time faculty members retire. It allows them to keep a title, continue to have access to university email and library services, while maintaining some connection to the university for teaching or part-time research. (Indeed, I hope that when I finally retire I can become an emeritus, as one of my partners did a couple of years ago.) However, apparently the HuffPo article got that part wrong. Although a January 26 addendum to the story states that Dr. Oz “became a professor emeritus and special lecturer in 2018,” the story in The Daily Beast notes:
His name no longer appears in website searches for doctors with the school’s Irving Medical Center. A Columbia faculty listing still says Oz has an office, along with the role of special lecturer—though not “professor emeritus.” But as with a handful of other names on the list, Oz’s listing no longer links to his faculty page, as it did one week before he launched his campaign. (Nearly every other faculty member without a link is no longer affiliated with the medical center; one of them died last year.)
The outgoing message on Oz’s voicemail for the listed number is quite dated, directing callers to medical services when Oz stopped taking patients four years ago. The message also advertises audience tickets to his now-extinct daytime TV show.
The timeline I’m getting here is that four years ago Dr. Oz’s position at Columbia changed. Whether he stepped down or was pushed out, apparently he no longer had a leadership position at the medical school, nor did he even (again, apparently) continue to have a position as a full professor in the department of surgery there. What truly happened in 2018 is likely known only to Columbia University administration and Dr. Oz himself. What these reports do reveal is that, whatever happened, both the university and Dr. Oz kept it on the down-low, which led to the headline of The Daily Beast story on Saturday, ‘Chickenshit’ Move: Columbia Quietly Cuts Ties With Dr. Oz:
Dr. Daniel Summers, a Boston-area pediatrician and writer, called Columbia’s stealth purge a “chickenshit” move.
“Their handling of his status there is a massive blot on their reputation. What a chickenshit thing to do,” Summers told The Daily Beast.
Dr. Summers is not wrong, of course. It was a rather cowardly way of cutting ties with Dr. Oz after he had been there for more than three decades, during most of which he promoted his brand and quackery. However, even after that, Dr. Oz remained a presence on the Columbia website. Knowing how university websites tend to work the way that I do, I rather suspect that the usual slow (or nonexistent) process of updating Columbia’s website to reflect Dr. Oz’s true status ran headlong into the news coverage of Dr. Oz’s impending Senate campaign that began in late 2021, leading to a panicked scrubbing of the website. In other words, it’s unlikely that the most recent scrubbing was anything nefarious, but Dr. Summers does have a point that, if Columbia and Dr. Oz severed ties four years ago, it was rather slimy to have done it so secretly that no one really noticed until Dr. Oz decided to run for the Senate. That, of course, assumes that this severance occurred in 2018 and not a few months ago.
As bioethicist Art Caplan notes in a story from The Guardian yesterday:
The prominent medical ethicist Dr Arthur Caplan, who in 2014 accused Oz of “promoting fairy dust”, told the Guardian he was not surprised Columbia had “quietly eliminated” Oz.
“They won’t have a press conference in the middle of this guy running for the Senate saying they were throwing him out … it could be seen as trying to influence an election, it could be risking bad blood should he become a senator,” said Caplan, professor and founding head of the Grossman School of Medicine Division of Medical Ethics at New York University.
“My question becomes, ‘What took so long?’ He’s been a huge danger to public health in the US and around the world for a long time with respect to quack cures for Covid and touting quackery to treat diseases.
“I was among the voices saying he had to be removed years ago. And I still think it’s the right thing to do because he really has forfeited credibility as a doctor. Whether that will matter in terms of the election, we shall see.
“I think it should, I doubt it will.”
All of this is true but assumes that this severance occurred a few months ago, when Dr. Oz first decided to run for the Senate. If it happened in 2018 and the Columbia website just never reflected it until now, then the reasons mentioned by Dr. Caplan don’t apply. Whatever happened, though, I think it’s useful to relate Dr. Oz’s history at Columbia and wonder why Columbia defended him and maintained him in multiple leadership positions at its medical school for so long. I also can’t help but briefly relate an incident very much like what Dr. Caplan described from years ago when a group of doctors did try to shame Columbia into doing something about Dr. Oz, an effort that backfired spectacularly.
The long and quacky road of Dr. Oz
As I said at the beginning of this post, I’ve long been extremely critical of Dr. Oz, even having coined the term “America’s Quack” to describe him, an obvious riff on Oprah’s name for him, “America’s Doctor.” Of course, Dr. Oz didn’t catch Oprah’s eye for just being a rising star in academic surgery in the 1990s. Rather, long before Oprah ever noticed him, Dr. Oz had made a name for himself by embracing pseudoscience and mysticism in the form of reiki. However, his embrace of pseudoscience goes back to long before even the 1990s, back to his childhood, as related by Julia Belluz at Vox in 2015, in which she noted the disconnect between his promising start and what he had become:
Oz has achieved some of the greatest scientific accomplishments of his career at Columbia. While a resident there, he was the four-time winner of the prestigious Blakemore research prize, which goes to the most outstanding surgery resident. He now holds 11 patents for inventing methods and devices involved in heart surgeries and transplants. This includes helping to research and develop the left ventricular assist device, or LVAD, which helps keep people alive while they’re awaiting a heart transplant. Oz had a hand in turning the hospital’s LVAD program into one of the biggest and most active in the world.
Dr. Oz has been a rare beast on one respect. It’s pretty uncommon these days for an academic physician or surgeon to spend his entire career after medical school at one institution, but that’s what Dr. Oz appears to have done, starting with his residency, after which he became junior faculty and made his way up the academic ranks. Whatever the shape of his career, I always imagine what could have been if Dr. Oz had not been seduced by the siren call of quackery. Can you imagine the scientific and surgical accomplishments that he might have made in an alternate timeline in which, instead of embracing reiki and then other forms of nonsense, he had stuck to science-based medicine and research? Unfortunately, though, as Belluz notes, the “roots of Oz’s experimentation with alternative techniques go all the way back to his childhood, and that his departures from evidence-based medicine have gotten more extreme as he’s become more famous”. Although he had had exposure to quackery as a child in Turkey, his turn to the dark side appears to have really accelerated after he met his wife:
There was another influence, too. While he was studying for his medical degree and MBA at the University of Pennsylvania, Oz met his wife, the actress Lisa (then Lemole). Lisa’s dad was also a cardiothoracic surgeon who embraced alternative medicine and Eastern mysticism, and, according to a profile in the New York Times, her mother “believed fervently” in homeopathy.
In 1994, Oz launched the Cardiac Complementary Care Center at Columbia-Presbyterian with a certified perfusionist and registered nurse, Jery Whitworth. The center, one of the first of its kind in the nation, was “created, in part, as a response to consumer demand for comprehensive care,” Oz and Whitworth wrote in a 1998 scholarly article.
I also note that Lisa Oz herself became a reiki master, and later in the 1990s:
They also used audiotapes to try to subconsciously relax patients before surgery and brought reiki — or “energy medicine” — into the operating room. Reiki, an ancient Japanese healing art, has never been shown in scientific studies to alter the outcomes of patients. One high-quality study on the effect of reiki on pain in women after C-sections showed that it had no effect. Science-based thinkers have wondered whether it’s ethical to continue studying reiki, given that we know it works no better than a placebo and we may be diverting funds from treatments that could actually help people.
Oz’s work with the center drew critics. One Mount Sinai physician told the New York Times in 1995: “I call practitioners of fraud practitioners of fraud. It’s my feeling that the [center] has been promoting fraudulent alternatives as genuine.”
I can’t help but note that Belluz cited an article by Steve Novella and me that questioned whether clinical trials of “magic” (like reiki and homeopathy) could ever be ethical. (Spoiler alert: We concluded that the answer was—and is—no.) I also can’t help but note that the problem of academic medical centers legitimizing quackery under the guise of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or “integrative medicine” is nowhere near unique to Columbia, although Columbia’s integrative medicine center under Dr. Oz’s leadership was one of the “pioneers” (if you can call it that) of “integrating” quackery into medicine. Just look at the examples of the Cleveland Clinic, UC-Irvine, UCSF, Georgetown, the University of Michigan, and many others, if you don’t believe me. Dr. Oz, unfortunately, is merely the most famous example (among the general public, at least) of physicians “integrating” mysticism, pseudoscience, quackery, and just plain grift into medicine.
In any event, instead of Dr. Oz continuing his research prowess to provide actual advancements in cardiothoracic surgery and cardiology, instead we got the huckster Oz, America’s Quack. But why? Michael Specter once noted in 2013, quoting Dr. Oz:
“I would take us all back a thousand years, when our ancestors lived in small villages and there was always a healer in that village—and his job wasn’t to give you heart surgery or medication but to help find a safe place for conversation.”
Oz went on, “Western medicine has a firm belief that studying human beings is like studying bacteria in petri dishes. Doctors do not want questions from their patients; it’s easier to tell them what to do than to listen to what they say. But people are on a serpentine path through life, and that is the way it is supposed to be. All I am trying to do is put a couple of road signs out there. I sit on that set every day, and that is what I am focussing on. The road signs.”
As I’ve long noted since I read that article, back when our ancestors lived in small villages, medicine consisted of shamans, priests, and magicians who couldn’t actually do much for anything other than relatively minor physical injuries, for which they could bind up wounds, sew up lacerations, and splint fractures. Then, they could do little or nothing to treat serious infections and other diseases. If people got better, it was usually because the disease was self-limited or the victims were fortunate. Oz also appears to buy into the false dichotomy that drives me crazy whenever I hear it: Namely that in order to be a good “holistic” doctor, you have to embrace the quackery that is much of what is now referred to as CAM or “integrative medicine”. My retort is always that you don’t have to become a quack to be “holistic”. I also question Oz’s romantic view of these “healers”. It sounds all too much like the “noble savage” myth, a case of Oz falling for romantic primitivism, which he seems to want to fuse with modern medicine.
If you want to know why Dr. Oz promotes so much quackery, I’ll refer back to Specter, who explained it by letting Dr. Oz speak for himself and asking Oz how he can feature on his show people like Joe Mercola, who are anathema to science and promote pure quackery. This passage is what I view as the central exchange in Specter’s entire article, as to me it revealed exactly why Dr. Oz has been the way he is and why he promotes the quackery he promotes:
“I’m usually earnestly honest and modest about what I think we’ve accomplished,” Oz told me when we discussed his choice of guests. “If I don’t have Mercola on my show, I have thrown away the biggest opportunity that I have been given.”
I had no idea what he meant. How was it Oz’s “biggest opportunity” to introduce a guest who explicitly rejects the tenets of science? “The fact that I am a professor—one of the youngest professors ever—at Columbia, and that I earned my stripes writing hundreds of papers in peer-reviewed journals,” Oz began. “I know the system. I’ve been on those panels. I’m one of those guys who could talk about Mercola and not lose everybody. And so if I don’t talk to him I have abdicated my responsibility, because the currency that I deal in is trust, and it is trust that has been given to me by Oprah and by Columbia University, and by an audience that has watched over six hundred shows.”
I was still puzzled. “Either data works or it doesn’t,” I said. “Science is supposed to answer, or at least address, those questions. Surely you don’t think that all information is created equal?”
Oz sighed. “Medicine is a very religious experience,” he said. “I have my religion and you have yours. It becomes difficult for us to agree on what we think works, since so much of it is in the eye of the beholder. Data is rarely clean.” All facts come with a point of view. But his spin on it—that one can simply choose those which make sense, rather than data that happen to be true—was chilling. “You find the arguments that support your data,” he said, “and it’s my fact versus your fact.”
The problem, of course, is that Mercola was overjoyed to be on The Dr. Oz Show, recognizing it correctly as a great opportunity to promote his brand. Did Dr. Oz point out all the quackery that Mercola promotes? (I think you know the answer to that one.) Worse, it’s clear that Dr. Oz bought into what has become known as the “post-truth” narrative, in which science is just another way of knowing, another religion so to speak—before the term “post-truth” was coined. Sadly, it was all of a piece with Oz’s other stated desires in the article, namely to have healers the way we used to hundreds or thousands of years ago. Many of those healers were shamans or priests, and much of what they did was little more than placebo medicine and faith healing. So for Dr. Oz to pine for a return to that time made perfect sense in the context of his other activities. Of course, I’m sure that Dr. Oz has always imagined that he will “integrate” those ancient healing practices with modern medicine. That’s what “integrative medicine” is, after all.
The Teflon doctor
It’s long been clear that Dr. Oz is a huckster, dedicated to being a showman more than he was ever dedicated to science—or even being a “shaman-healer”. That’s why one consistent thread throughout Dr. Oz’s career going back 30 years (at least) is his uncanny ability to promote his brand while defending it quite effectively from attack. Julia Belluz noted that in her article:
Monique Class, a family nurse practitioner and another former employee of the center, said the media attention negatively affected their work. “It became about Oz. Not about the project. Not about the patients. Not about the work. That all became secondary to his rise to the top.”
It wasn’t uncommon, Class said, for Oz to say some version of the following to her or to the other employees: “Give me a patient because the cameras are coming in, and tell me what I need to know.”
Class said, “He was always acting. He didn’t know this patient. He was not connected to this patient. We’d give him a two- or three-minute sound bite and he’d sit there in front of the cameras like he’d done this work and had this deep connection.”
Which is actually exactly the opposite of what shaman-healers did and also an indication that it’s not about the patients but rather about Dr. Oz and his brand. Shamans actually tried to form attachments to their patients based on their long history of living in the same villages and communities, of which patients and shamans were both part. In contrast, Dr. Oz has long used his patients as steppingstones to become famous, which he justified to Michael Specter thusly:
One day, I asked Oz whether he minded that many of his medical peers criticized him for following the dictates of daytime television more than the demands of scientific truth. “I have always played offense,” he responded. “So I don’t care what people call me. I used to. I felt that to say I was an entertainer was dismissive. But it is part of what I have to do. I want to get my message across to people who are not going to get it in other ways. And I can’t do that if I am not palatable to the people who watch the show.”
I’m sure he tells himself the same thing about his decision to become a carpetbagger from New Jersey running for Senate in Pennsylvania, just as he did when he invited Donald Trump to appear on his show before the 2016 election. I’m equally sure that he told himself the same thing back when he started promoting hydroxychloroquine and other unproven treatments for COVID-19 two years ago, when the pandemic was new.
The perfect example of Dr. Oz’s uncanny ability to defend his brand occurred in 2015, when a group of ten doctors led by Dr. Henry Miller wrote a letter to the Dean of the Faculties of Health Sciences and Medicine at Columbia University arguing that Dr. Mehmet Oz shouldn’t be on the faculty at Columbia University because of his “disdain for science and for evidence-based medicine, as well as baseless and relentless opposition to the genetic engineering of food crops” and “an egregious lack of integrity by promoting quack treatments and cures in the interest of personal financial gain”. The letter produced a fair amount of media attention at the time, but I predicted that it would backfire for a simple reason, which I’ll briefly explain now.
Of the ten signatories, two were from the Hoover Institution, a conservative think tank based at Stanford University whose fellows tend to be climate change denialists. In other words, it’s an institution whose commitment to science is highly questionable to nonexistent in one area, and it’s attacking Oz for pseudoscience? Two others are affiliated with the American Council on Science and Health (ACSH), a group that is pro-science when that science aligns with industry interests, particularly the pesticide industry. ACSH’s late president Elizabeth Whelan was known for dismissing any concerns about various chemicals as potential health hazards as “chemophobia” and even referring to “chemophobia” as an “emotional, psychiatric problem,” which is not very skeptical at all. Indeed, as I’ve mentioned before, a few years ago, when ACSH invited me to be on its board of advisors, I turned it down because I perceive ACSH as going too far in the other direction (not to mention the problem of its behaving largely like an industry shill) to the point that it takes the germ of a reasonable idea (that there’s too much fear mongering about “chemicals”) and takes a despicable turn with it by implicitly likening concerns about chemical pollutants and other chemicals that might cause health problems to mental illness by labeling them “chemophobia”. More recently, ACSH demolished whatever credibility it might have had as being about science more than politics when a week after President Trump’s inauguration ACSH President Hank Campbell published an article on its website heartily endorsing Trump’s picks for key science and medical posts. (I note that the article is no longer there, producing an Error 503 message of “This article is temporarily unavailable. Please check back in a few days,” but thankfully the almighty Wayback Machine at Archive.org has preserved it.)
I bet you can see where this went. Dr. Oz is nothing if not masterful at propaganda. He struck back on his show, sighing heavily about “ten mysterious doctors” with industry ties to for trying to shut him up because he criticized genetically modified organisms (GMOs), before predictably attacking the ACSH using predictable lines of attack, many summarized in a TIME interview with Dr. Oz that was so pro-Oz that I thought someone from his staff had written it:
With a few clicks and some simple searches, a remarkable web of intrigue emerged—one that the mainstream media has completely missed. The lead author, Henry I. Miller, appears to have a history as a pro-biotech scientist, and was mentioned in early tobacco-industry litigation as a potential ally to industry. He also furthered the battle in California to block GMO labeling—a cause that I have been vocal about supporting. Another of the letter signees, Gilbert Ross, was found guilty after trial of 13 counts of fraud related to Medicaid. He is now executive director of American Council on Science and Health, a group that has reportedly received donations from big tobacco and food and agribusiness companies, among others. Another four of the 10 authors are also linked to this organization.
The attacks were particularly devastating, as cheesy as they were on his show, because they were mostly true. ACSH is basically an astroturf organization that represents industry interests, particularly for the food and pesticide industries. Its stances on vaccines, alternative medicine, and GMOs do align largely with those of SBM, but also largely for the wrong reasons (particularly GMOs and pesticides). Basically, the stunt resulted in a lot of attention from the press on ACSH’s more unsavory elements and history, to the point that even Ross himself regretted signing the document, saying in an interview:
“Given the mistake I made more than 20 years ago, I now recognize that I should not have added my name to (the) letter,” Dr Ross is quoted as saying. “Even though I believed in the letter’s content — to focus attention on the often-questionable medical advice Dr Oz dispenses on TV — I see that by doing so it only opened me up to personal criticism. It also diverted necessary attention away from challenging many of Dr Oz’s unscientific claims. My involvement was solely based on trying to protect America’s public health.”
Ya think?
I also can’t help but note that one of the signatories of the article is someone who’s become rather famous since the pandemic hit, Dr. Scott Atlas, the neuroradiologist with no expertise in infectious disease, epidemiology, or public health and was associated with the conservative Hoover Institution think tank who headed up President Trump’s coronavirus task force in 2020. He was known for advocating for fewer interventions to slow the spread of the virus, consistent with his admiration for the Great Barrington Declaration and it’s “let COVID rip” strategy to achieve “natural herd immunity”.
Currently, the polls that I’ve seen show the contest for the GOP nomination for Pennsylvania Senate to be close, with some polls showing Oz leading and others showing him behind, but none by that much and the overall trend being that Dr. Oz is slightly behind. It’s still possible that Oz could win the primary.
Still, if politics is the reason that Columbia finally severed ties with Dr. Oz (or at least led them to finally fire him from his leadership positions), all I can say is that it’s sad that it took politics, rather than Dr. Oz’s long promotion of quackery and pseudoscience to motivate the administration there to do the right thing, something that should have been done at least a decade ago. Unfortunately, if Dr. Oz overcomes the odds and becomes the next Senator from Pennsylvania, he’ll be more powerful than he’s ever been and able to influence health care policy in a major way. Even if he loses (as I suspect that he will), I’d be willing to bet that it won’t be long before he resurfaces to quack again.

Traditional Chinese herbalism at the Cleveland Clinic? What happened to science-based medicine?
Quackademic medicine has taken a bold step forward at The Cleveland Clinic, which has opened a traditional Chinese medicine herbal practice.
David Gorski on April 26, 2014
Link
I don’t recall if I’ve ever mentioned my connection with the Cleveland Clinic Foundation (CCF). I probably have, but just don’t remember it. Long-time readers might recall that I did my general surgery training at Case Western Reserve University at University Hospitals of Cleveland. Indeed, I did my PhD there as well in the Department of Physiology and Biophysics. Up the road less than a mile from UH is the Cleveland Clinic. As it turns out, during my stint in Physiology and Biophysics at CWRU, I happened to do a research rotation in a lab at the CCF, which lasted a few months. OK, so it’s not much of a connection. It was over 20 years ago and only lasted a few months, but it’s something that gives me an obvious and blatant hook to start out this post, particularly given the number of cardiac patients I delivered to the CCF back in the early 1990s when I moonlighted as a flight physician for Metro LifeFlight.
Obvious and clunky introduction aside (hey, they can’t all be brilliant; so I’ll settle for nauseatingly self-deprecating), several of my readers have been sending me a link to a story that appeared in the Wall Street Journal the other day: A Top Hospital Opens Up to Chinese Herbs as Medicines: Evidence is lacking that herbs are effective. I also noticed that our fearless leader Steve Novella blogged about it and was tempted to let it pass, given that I had seemingly lost my window, but then I realized that there’s always something I can add to a post, even after the topic’s been blogged by Steve Novella. Whether that something is of value or not, I leave to the reader. So here we go. Besides, if this article truly indicates a new trend in academic medical centers, it’s—if you’ll excuse the term—quantum leap in the infiltration of quackademic medicine into formerly reputable medical centers. It’s a depressing thing, and it needs to be publicized.
Of course, the Cleveland Clinic has long been a poster child for the evils of quackademic medicine. Indeed, take a look at its Center for Integrative Medicine. Offerings there include acupuncture, chiropractic, something called “holistic psychotherapy,” reiki (of course!), and Chinese herbal therapy. I frequently use the CCF’s woo-ful description of reiki using the “universal life source energy” to heal patients as an example of the utter mystical-religious nonsense that has infiltrated once-proud medical institutions, along with other prime examples carefully curated from selections from other quackademic academic medical centers. So, naturally, it’s not surprising that the CCF would be a “pioneer” (if you can call it that) in bringing traditional Chinese herbal medicine right into the heart of an academic medical center.
The WSJ article isn’t too bad in that it’s not overly credulous and, as the title even proclaims, notes that there isn’t much evidence to support the use of herbal medicine. Of course, herbal medicine is among the most plausible of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or “integrative medicine” for the simple reason that, for an herb to have a medical effect, there must be a chemical (or chemicals) in it that have pharmacological activity. In other words, there have to be drugs in them thar plants! That’s why pharmaceutical companies and the NIH are so interested in screening natural compounds for chemical properties and pharmaceutical activities that might indicate that they could function as useful drugs. True, much of the low-hanging fruit in terms of naturally occurring chemicals that can make useful drugs has been found and turned into drugs, but there are likely to be lots more where that came from. It just won’t be as easy to identify and characterize them as it was in the past.
As I’ve also described many times and Steve Novella mentioned in his post, the problem with herbal medicines is that they are adulterated drugs (or, as Steve put it, “dirty” drugs). They are not pure. It’s almost impossible to control lot-to-lot consistency with respect to content of active ingredients, given how location, weather, soil conditions, rainfall, and many other factors can affect how the plants from which the medicines are extracted grow and therefore their chemical composition. Let’s just put it this way. It’s much safer and more predictable to administer digoxin to a patient who needs its activity on the heart than it would be for the patient to chew on some foxglove leaves. Given digoxin’s relatively narrow therapeutic window (the difference between the doses needed to produce therapeutic effects and the lowest dose that will cause significant toxicity), that’s critical. There are lots of herbs that can cause significant toxicity, such as Aristolochia, which can cause kidney damage; kava, which can cause liver toxicity; and many others.
The reason physicians moved away from herbal medicine to pharmaceutical drugs is for predictability. Purified active components have a more predictable action because the amount of drug is tightly controlled and known to a very precise degree, while impurities are kept to a minimum. Moreover, these drugs can be combined with various inactive agents to control how fast they are absorbed into the bloodstream, thus providing another level of control. All of these characteristics make the drugs much more predictable than any drugs still contained in dead plant matter. None of this even takes into account the widespread problem with contamination of herbal remedies with heavy metals, such as lead or even arsenic. It’s such a problem that a particularly obnoxious supporter of quackery has started trying to “distinguish” himself and his supplements from the competition by setting up a lab, measuring heavy metals in his competitors’ products, and then periodically publishing scare stories about “contamination” of various supplements and herbal products. (Yes, I’m referring to Mike Adams.)
So what, exactly, is the CCF doing? Let’s take a look at the patient vignette that begins the WSJ article:
Christina Lunka appeared nervous and excited as she sat in the Chinese herbal therapy center recently opened by the Cleveland Clinic.
The 49-year-old had been to many doctors seeking help for ongoing issues that included joint pain and digestive problems. Now the Kirtland, Ohio, resident was hoping to find relief through herbal remedies.
“Do you have something for inflammation?” Ms. Lunka asked herbalist Galina Roofener during a one-hour consultation.
“Absolutely,” responded Ms. Roofener. “This is for pain, for digestion, for inflammation, all of the above,” she said, handing Ms. Lunka a bottle with capsules of an herbal combination called Xiao Yao San, which translates as free and easy wanderer. The capsules include about eight different herbs, including licorice, mint leaf and white peony root.
This is nonsense. I’d bet a dollar (to steal a cliche) that Roofener has no solid evidence to support any of these claims. It’d be among the safest of bets, particularly given that this isn’t even a single herb she’s talking about. It’s a bunch of herbs all ground together. Even Dr. Josephine Briggs, the director of the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM), whom we’ve discussed many times before, is quoted in this article characterizing the “evidence base for these approaches using modern rigorous methods of randomized trials” as “quite thin,” which is an understatement. Surprisingly (to me at least) she also apparently admitted that, although NCCAM is looking at the basic science of some herbal products, it is currently not funding any efficacy studies involving humans (i.e., randomized clinical trials) of herbal remedies right now. If NCCAM isn’t even funding clinical trials of herbal medicines, they really must not be showing any promise lately. Actually, they aren’t, and haven’t been for quite some time. There are a number of trials now showing that various herbal remedies thought to be very promising don’t actually work, such as ginkgo biloba for memory, saw palmetto for benign prostatic hypertrophy, or black cohosh for menopausal symptoms.
It’s also some good money. Consultations are $100, and follow-up visits are $60. True, many visits to real doctors cost more, but in most cases insurance covers them, minus acopay, with all the paperwork that’s required. This sounds as though it’s pure cash on the barrelhead. Add to that the cost of a month’s supply of herbal remedies ($100), and it sounds as though the CCF could easily turn this clinic into a pretty nice profit center, after a slow start. The practitioner, Galina Roofener, is a graduate of the East West College of Natural Medicine in Sarasota, which is largely a school of acupuncture and traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). It seems a bit confused about what TCM is, though. Under a section of its website entitled What is traditional Chinese medicine? it lists electroacupuncture (who knew they had sources of usable electricity in ancient China?), biopuncture (yes, biopuncture), and homeopathy. Who knew? Maybe Samuel Hahnemann was Chinese.
In any case, Roofener worked at clinic called Asian Therapies Acupuncture Clinic before taking a job at CCF. All that’s there now is a message describing how she sold her practice and moved to Cleveland to work for the CCF. However, the Wayback Machine of Archive.org reveals what the website looked like in 2011. There, I found a number of interesting things. Unfortunately, even many of the Archive.org pages are gone, but the titles live on, titles touting the quackery that is thermography for breast cancer, acupuncture for the flu, and lots of evidence that Roofener used homeopathy, which is not surprising given that she’s a naturopath as well, apparently. (Her LinkedIn page also confirms her use of homeopathy.)
Deceptively, Roofener is required by law to invoke the quack Miranda warning as…well, I’ll let the WSJ article explain it to you:
Ms. Roofener’s license doesn’t allow her to claim she treats diseases, a Cleveland Clinic spokeswoman says. She can’t say that Chinese herbs will treat colitis, for instance, but she can say that she can stop diarrhea and pain. She cannot treat arthritis but can alleviate joint pain, the spokeswoman says.
And:
At the Cleveland Clinic’s herbal center, new patients are given a one-hour consultation that may include a battery of questions (How’s your sleep? Body temperature? Ringing in your ears? Headaches?), a physical examination of the tongue, and the traditional Chinese method for pulse-taking (three fingers on each wrist to check different pulses corresponding to various organ systems). They are asked to sign a waiver acknowledging that “herbal supplements are not a substitute for a medical diagnosis.”
Clearly.
Still, in another recent story about Galina Roofener and the herbal clinic at the CCF, Roofener is quotes thusly:
The center doesn’t take walk-ins and primarily sees patients with conditions that Western medicine has, for whatever reason, failed to remedy. “For something like acute pneumonia, Western antibiotics may be faster and more cost-effective,” says Roofener. “But if someone has antibiotic resistance, we can strengthen their immune system.”
Egad! “Strengthen the immune system”? Seriously? That’s one of the top quack claims, regardless of what the quackery is!
Yes, as Steve Novella noted, the CCF is out-and-out admitting in the quack Miranda warning on its consent form for its herbal medicine clinic that the TCM diagnoses Roofener is making and the herbal remedies she is prescribing to treat them are not real medical diagnoses and not real medicine. That’s a staggering admission for an academic medical center to make, that it is offering to its patients medicine that is not real medicine, a system of diagnosis that is not a science-based system of diagnosis. Worse, its physicians are actually referring patients to this clinic, even though they know that there’s no real evidence that it works. For example:
Maged Rizk, a gastroenterologist at Cleveland Clinic who referred Mr. McGeehan, says Chinese herbal medicine is still being critically evaluated. “In the past it wasn’t even considered seriously,” Dr. Rizk says. “At this point there is a thinking, ‘Some of the things we’re doing now aren’t very effective. Should we really be looking at alternatives a little more seriously?’ I think the verdict is still out,” he says.
So, basically, Dr. Rizk seems to be arguing that because current science- and evidence-based treatments for some conditions don’t work as well as we would like we should try treatments with no evidence to support them.
I think I know what’s going on here. I could be wrong, but it sure smells like it. Basically, what we are talking about here are patients with chronic conditions, particularly conditions causing chronic symptoms (there is, for instance, a patient in the story who suffers from chronic nausea), that are not well controlled or well treated with current science- and evidence-based medicine. Understandably, doctors become almost as frustrated as patients when they can’t alleviate their patients’ symptoms. They feel powerless. It’s not surprising that there is a strong temptation to fob the patient off on someone else. It’s also very easy—seductively so—to rationalize a referral to someone like Roofener based on the rationale that maybe she can do something. And if she can’t at least the patient will be someone else’s problem for a while. I know, I know. That’s harsh, but it’s a bit more complicated than that. Few doctors actually want to give up. It’s just that, given an “out” like Roofener’s clinic, it’s not surprising that even good doctors (you have to be good to be on the staff of the CCF) might be tempted to take that out.
Still, we rely on institutions like the CCF to be at the cutting edge of science. We expect that the treatments they offer will be based on the best available science. We do not expect that institutions like the CCF will embrace a prescientific system of medicine that is rooted in what is, in essence, the Asian variant of the humoral theory of medicine in which disease is attributed to imbalances in the five elements rather than the four humors, whose treatments are based on a rationale of somehow channeling or redirecting the flow of a nonexistent “life energy” that has yet to be detected by science and whose medicines are impure mixtures of natural products with nothing resembling what we could consider rigorous evidence of efficacy and safety.
The infiltration of quackademic medicine into medical academia continues apace, to our shame as a profession.

Herbal Center at Cleveland Clinic
Steven Novella on April 23, 2014
Link

The infiltration of pseudoscience and simply bad medicine into mainstream medicine continues. Hospitals are an easy breech point because they are run by administrators who may have more talent and interest in marketing than in science. Many hospitals in my area, for example, proudly display their “integrative” centers, offering nutrition advice and massage alongside more dubious offerings, such as reflexology and reiki.
So-called “alternative” treatments are tempting because they are often not covered by insurance, and so patients will have to pay cash for them, and they are often inexpensive to run – so they are a nice cash cow for hospitals.
The Wall Street Journal reports another, more serious, chapter in this infiltration – the opening of Chinese herbal clinics, specifically in the Cleveland Clinic. The article itself is reasonably balanced, and lacks the gushing anecdotes that most such pieces have, but could certainly have been more hard-hitting in terms of the serious problems with herbal medicine.
Herbal treatments are interesting from a scientific point of view because they are perhaps at the most plausible end of the CAM spectrum. The WSJ article would have benefited from stating explicitly that herbs are drugs. Their actions in the body are entirely pharmacological. This fact is often missed by proponents and in discussions of herbal remedies. They are drugs.
Herbs, however, are drugs that have not been adequately studied, whose active ingredients may not be known, that contain many chemicals, with unknown pharmacokinetics, dynamics, and drug-drug interactions. Dosing is nearly impossible to standardize. Bioavailability is anyone’s guess. And quality control is highly dubious. Other than that, they’re great.
I’m not sure why anyone would choose to take a poorly studied, dirty, variable, and poorly regulated combination of drugs with unknown efficacy. The answer, of course, must be marketing. People think herbs are “natural,” an irrelevant feature that does nothing to mitigate the many downsides of these dirty drugs. They are also reassured by the fact that they are part of an ancient and exotic medical system, the argument from antiquity. Of course, bloodletting also survived for thousands of years.
Plants are a perfectly reasonable source of potential pharmacological compounds. Much of the low-hanging fruit, of course, has already been picked. There is also huge incentive on the part of pharmaceutical companies to find other useful compounds in plants, and herbal remedies might provide a clue to potential targets. What’s left over are the dregs, what is now marketed as “herbal medicine.”
Many of the most popular herbal products, those that have been studies in rigorous clinical trials, have been found not to work. Gingko biloba does not work for memory or dementia. Echinacea does not work for the cold or flu. Black cohosh does not work for menopausal symptoms. Saw palmetto does not work for benign prostatic hypertrophy.
Perhaps the best candidate for an effective herbal remedy is St. John’s wort for depression. Apparently there is some anti-depressant effect from this herb, but only if you speak German (German studies are much more favorable than studies from other countries). Otherwise the benefits are mild and inconsistent. This is not surprising because St. John’s wort contains MAO inhibitors, which have a known antidepressant effect. They also have serious drug-drug interactions.
There are other herbs with promising preliminary results – but as readers of SBM know well, preliminary results are very unreliable and not predictive of the outcome of large rigorous trials.
The notion that herbs are somehow magically safe is very insidious. They are drugs with all the potential toxicity and drug-drug interactions of drugs. Perhaps they have the virtue, because their active ingredients are not purified, of generally having low doses of the chemicals they contain, but that cuts both ways, reducing useful effects and side effects alike.
Assuming lack of toxicity is largely based on the relative paucity of studies looking for toxicity. Toxicity from herbs, however, is not uncommon. Nephropathy (kidney damage) from Aristolochia, liver damage from kava-containing products, and black cohosh has also been linked to liver damage (here is a more extensive list of popular herbal products with known toxicities).
Toxicity can occur even when an herbal product is unadulterated and taken as intended. However, perhaps the biggest problem with the herbal industry is its poor regulation. There are problems with fungal contamination, mislabeling or mistranslating of herbs, and heavy metal contamination.
When buying herbal remedies off the shelf they are likely not even to contain what the label indicates. A recent study found that:
Most (59%) of the products tested contained DNA barcodes from plant species not listed on the labels. Although we were able to authenticate almost half (48%) of the products, one-third of these also contained contaminants and or fillers not listed on the label. Product substitution occurred in 30/44 of the products tested and only 2/12 companies had products without any substitution, contamination or fillers. Some of the contaminants we found pose serious health risks to consumers.
Therefore, even when a clinical trial, using carefully prepared and verified herbal preparations, finds some potential benefit, you cannot assume that a commercial product based on that herb will have the same effect. You may not even be getting the herb you think you are getting.
In his latest book, Paul Offit tells the story of attempting to regulate herbal product use in his hospital. Eventually he settled for one criterion, that the manufacturers provide documentation of what is actually in the products. They refused to do this. One has to wonder why.
How does an herbal clinic work in practice? The WSJ reports about the Cleveland Clinic, when asked for something for inflammation:
“Absolutely,” responded Ms. Roofener. “This is for pain, for digestion, for inflammation, all of the above,” she said, handing Ms. Lunka a bottle with capsules of an herbal combination called Xiao Yao San, which translates as free and easy wanderer. The capsules include about eight different herbs, including licorice, mint leaf and white peony root.
Not only does the preparation contain all the unrefined chemicals of a single herb, but a combination of many herbs. They also report:
At the Cleveland Clinic’s herbal center, new patients are given a one-hour consultation that may include a battery of questions (How’s your sleep? Body temperature? Ringing in your ears? Headaches?), a physical examination of the tongue, and the traditional Chinese method for pulse-taking (three fingers on each wrist to check different pulses corresponding to various organ systems). They are asked to sign a waiver acknowledging that “herbal supplements are not a substitute for a medical diagnosis.”
So – herbal remedies are not real medicines that treat actual diseases. They are just claimed to alleviate symptoms – without, of course, any evidence of efficacy except for the anecdotal experience of the practitioner. Pulse analysis, by the way, is nothing but a medical cold reading, not unlike iridology or any other bogus diagnostic method.
Conclusion
We advocate for high standards of science within medicine because that is the only way to offer patients the best chance of safe and effective treatments. It is also the only way to give proper informed consent, which requires transparency and reliable information.
It is a scandal that a hospital would offer a medical service to their patients that is not based on the best science has to offer, is based on numerous deceptions and misrepresentations, logical fallacies, and poor methods. In fact, they make patients sign wavers that essentially say that what they are providing is not real medicine.
Only the insanity of brilliant marketing can pull off such a deception.

The Medical Director of The Cleveland Clinic Wellness Institute spewed antivaccine misinformation last week. Why is anyone surprised?
A social media firestorm erupted over the weekend after Dr. Daniel Neides, Director of The Cleveland Clinic Wellness Institute, posted an article full of antivaccine misinformation. The Cleveland Clinic promptly disavowed it, but shouldn’t have been surprised that one of its “integrative medicine” leaders is antivaccine. If you “integrate” medicine that teaches that “toxins” cause disease and “detoxification” is the cure, antivaccine quackery can’t be far behind. If you abandon science for magical thinking, nothing is off limits to magic.
David Gorski on January 9, 2017
Link


I did my general surgery residency at the University Hospitals of Cleveland (UHC), which was affiliated with Case Western Reserve University. At the time, there was an intense rivalry between UHC and its larger neighbor on Euclid Avenue, the Cleveland Clinic. This rivalry dates back many decades. In the early 1990s while working on my PhD, I also moonlighted as a flight physician on Metro LifeFlight. In that role I not infrequently delivered cardiac patients to the Cleveland Clinic, which has a well-respected and pioneering cardiovascular program. During my PhD studies, I also did a three month rotation with a cardiovascular researcher at the Cleveland Clinic. After these experiences, I couldn’t help but be impressed by the facility and respect UHC’s rival down the street.
Unfortunately, these days I’m not so much impressed by The Cleveland Clinic as appalled. The reason has been the Cleveland Clinic’s increasing embrace of quackery in the form of “integrative medicine.” It’s an embrace that’s gone farther than most ever thought it could, as evidence by a post published on a local Cleveland paper’s blog (Google cache version here) that reveals the director of the Cleveland Clinic Wellness Institute to have dangerous pseudoscientific antivaccine beliefs. It was a post that would have been quite at home on NaturalNews.com, Age of Autism, or any of a number of antivaccine websites. The post ignited a firestorm in the medical social media, as well it should. There was outrage, which was appropriate, but there was also surprise, which I didn’t share so much. After all, if you “integrate” medical quackery (e.g., naturopathy) that posits that a lot of disease is due to “toxins” that you must “detoxify” to cure, antivaccine quackery will not be far behind, given how much antivaccine ideologues blame “toxins” in vaccines for autism, ADHD, autoimmune disease, and all the other bad things they attribute to vaccines.
Before I get to the op-ed itself, let me briefly recap for viewers who are not familiar with the history of the Cleveland Clinic’s “pioneering” embrace of quackademic medicine. While I didn’t coin the term, I do use “quackademic medicine” a lot because it perfectly describes what is going on at academic medical centers like the Cleveland Clinic (and, alas, UHC as well these days). If there is a “leading light” of quackademic medicine, these days the Cleveland Clinic would definitely be in hot contention for that “honor.” Long ago, it founded the Cleveland Clinic Wellness Institute, which offers modalities ranging from acupuncture to energy medicine. Since then, the Cleveland Clinic has set up a traditional Chinese medicine herbal medicine clinic, staffed by a naturopath, and embraced functional medicine quackery by setting up a functional medicine clinic. Unfortunately, the functional medicine clinic has been wildly successful. There should have been some warning that there might be antivaccine pseudoscience in their Wellness Institute given that Dr. Mark Hyman, who founded the Clinic’s functional medicine clinic, is antivaccine. He even co-authored an antivaccine book with Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. entitled Thimerosal: Let the Science Speak: Mercury Toxicity in Vaccines and the Political, Regulatory, and Media Failures That Continue to Threaten Public Health, that blamed thimerosal for all sorts of ills two years ago.
Aside from its recruitment of Mark Hyman to such a high profile role, however, I had never had a concrete reason to doubt the Cleveland Clinic’s commitment to vaccination as a key public health intervention. Indeed, if there’s one area that proponents of integrative medicine are always quick to assure doctors and the public about, it’s vaccines. To my knowledge, all the major integrative medicine thought leaders (until now) have always told us in no uncertain terms that they are really, truly pro-vaccine. Even though the very same alternative medicine modalities, such as chiropractic, naturopathy, and various flavors of “natural medicine,” are quite frequently intensely antivaccine, proponents of integrative medicine are always quick to assure us that antivaccine beliefs will never, ever taint integrative medicine. Such claims have always had a hint of self-delusion, however.
Showing that delusion quite nicely is Cleveland Clinic physician Daniel Neides, MD, MBA, who wrote a blog post entitled “Make 2017 the year to avoid toxins (good luck) and master your domain” (again, Google cache version here; Google Cache’s involvement will be made clear momentarily.) His article made it impossible for The Cleveland Clinic to deny that it has a quack problem.
Dr. Daniel Neides: Antivaccine and “detox” quackery galore
Before I go on to discuss the misinformation, quackery, and pseudoscience in Dr. Neides’ article, I think it very important to point out why this is so disturbing. It boils down as much to to who he is not as to who he is. He is not Dr. Bob Sears. He is not Dr. Jay Gordon. He is not Andrew Wakefield. He is not Dr. Sherri Tenpenny. He is not Dr. Suzanne Humphries. All of these doctors are antivaccine, but none of them work for a major academic medical center. None of these doctors has any cachet outside of alternative medicine and antivaccine circles (but I repeat myself). None of them is the frikkin’ Acting Medical Director of the Tanya I. Edwards Center for Integrative Medicine and Vice Chair and Chief Operating Officer of the Cleveland Clinic Wellness Institute! (I wanted to use the real f-word, but we have a policy here at SBM not to use any cuss word stronger than a certain word for male bovine excrement. So I restrained myself. Barely.) As such, he is a high-ranking member of the “integrative medicine” club in academia. There is no way he should be writing or even believing garbage like this:
I am tired of all the nonsense we as American citizens are being fed while big business – and the government – continue to ignore the health and well-being of the fine people in this country. Why am I all fired up, you ask?
I, like everyone else, took the advice of the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) – the government – and received a flu shot. I chose to receive the preservative free vaccine, thinking I did not want any thimerasol (i.e. mercury) that the “regular” flu vaccine contains.
Makes sense, right? Why would any of us want to be injected with mercury if it can potentially cause harm? However, what I did not realize is that the preservative-free vaccine contains formaldehyde.
WHAT? How can you call it preservative-free, yet still put a preservative in it? And worse yet, formaldehyde is a known carcinogen. Yet, here we are, being lined up like cattle and injected with an unsafe product. Within 12 hours of receiving the vaccine, I was in bed feeling miserable and missed two days of work with a terrible cough and body aches.
My anger actually stems from a constant toxic burden that is contributing to the chronic disease epidemic. And yet the government continues to talk out of both sides of its mouth. We want our citizens to be healthy and take full advantage of the best healthcare system in the world (so we think), yet we don’t treat our bodies with the love and attention they deserve.
As our own inimitable Dr. Crislip would say: Dumbass.
The stupid, it burns. I know, I know. Here on SBM, I’m supposed to be a bit more…civil…than my usual persona at my not-so-super secret other blog. Sorry. Not this time. I’m down with ZDoggMD’s rant on this one. What Dr. Neides is spewing is antivaccine bullshit of the highest—or should I say, lowest?—order. This is antivaccine nonsense that would not be in the least bit out of place on antivaccine crank blogs like Age of Autism, as I could easily demonstrate by taking Dr. Neides’ article and comparing it to any number of antivaccine propaganda pieces I’ve deconstructed over the years. Heck, Dr. Neides’ little rant here wouldn’t be out of place on NaturalNews.com. It really is just that bad. Even worse than that, it’s incredibly irresponsible for a physician like Dr. Neides to post an antivaccine rant like this right in the middle of flu season in which he blames “toxins” in the flu vaccine for his feeling crappy for a couple of days and having to miss work. There is no excuse, particularly when he uses the “toxins gambit.” In fact, what Dr. Neides is spewing is even more ignorant than the toxins gambit spewed by the average antivaccinationist. Yes, it’s just that bad. Here’s why.
Dr. Neides starts out equating thimerosal with mercury, which is not quite accurate. Yes, thimerosal was used as a preservative in childhood vaccines until its use ceased 15 years ago. Yes, thimerosal does contain mercury. However, it is not mercury, contrary to what is implied by Dr. Neides. As a family practice physician, he should also know that the hypothesis that mercury in vaccines causes autism is a failed hypothesis. Science just doesn’t support it. In the meantime, though, notice how Dr. Neides pivots from thimerosal as a preservative in vaccines to formaldehyde as a “preservative.” This can only be intentional, as it immediately brings to mind the use of formaldehyde as the main component of embalming fluid.
Of course, vaccines don’t contain formaldehyde as a preservative. Vaccines contain tiny amounts of formaldehyde because it is used to inactivate the viruses during the manufacture of vaccines. Moreover, the human body makes formaldehyde as a normal byproduct of metabolism. Surely, as a physician, Dr. Neides must know this from his biochemistry course in his first year of medical school. Perhaps he’s forgotten; so I’ll take this opportunity to school him. Formaldehyde is a common chemical that is found in many places and in many foods. As I noted before, it has a scary connotation because of its use to embalm bodies, but embalming bodies involves a high concentration of formaldehyde, a situation quite different from (and not analogous to) its presence in some vaccines. Formaldehyde is present in some—but by no means all—vaccines. For instance, it can’t be used in attenuated live virus vaccines because it would kill the virus. As far as vaccines that could have formaldehyde in them go, I like to refer the antivaccine cranks ranting about formaldehyde to the CHOP Vaccine Education Center entry on formaldehyde. Granted, true antivaccine cranks won’t pay attention because the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia is where Paul Offit practices, and to antivaccine cranks Dr. Offit is Lord Voldemort, the Dark Lord Sauron, and Darth Vader all rolled up into one villain. However, presumably Dr. Neides is not part of the hard core antivaccine crankosphere. So maybe he would listen to Dr. Offit, who knows a hell of a lot more about vaccines than Dr. Neides does, when his website tells him that the amount of formaldehyde in vaccines is not a concern in an infant.
Basically, formaldehyde is everywhere in small amounts that are harmless. The dose makes the poison, and formaldehyde in vaccines does not reach levels that make it a poison. Add to this the fact that these calculations are for babies and that Dr. Neides is a fully grown adult male, and from a scientific standpoint Dr. Neides’ fear mongering about formaldehyde becomes even more ridiculously cringe-worthy. Then, when he refers to formaldehyde as a “known carcinogen,” Dr. Neides neglects to note that the carcinogenic properties of formaldehyde depend on high exposure, as in funeral industry workers.
Dr. Neides fears the “toxins”
If there’s one concept that underlies much of alternative medicine, in particular naturopathy, it’s the idea that “toxins” are at the root of all illness. If you accept that idea, then the obvious solution to the problem (and cure to the health problems and diseases caused by “toxins”) is to “detoxify.” Of course, the idea that “toxins” are causing all disease is a very ancient idea, dating back to ancient Egypt (at least). Sadly, Dr. Neides promises to commit his efforts in the new year to “educating” people about these dread “toxins”:
Our air, water, and food supplies are completely compromised and so it is time for us to take matters into our own hands. This year, I am committing to providing you with the educational resources to make you the best YOU. It may get confusing and frustrating at times, but stressing out over this won’t help. Take three deep belly breaths and let’s get started.
We live in a toxic soup. There are over 80,000 chemicals used in various industries country-wide. There are over 2,000 new chemicals being introduced annually. We breathe in these chemicals through exhaust, eat them in our processed foods (just look at the labels that have 20 or 30 ingredients and good luck pronouncing their names), textiles (clothing, bedding, furniture), and personal care products, including make-up, deodorant, shampoos, and soaps.
“Just look at the labels that have 20 or 30 ingredients and good luck pronouncing their names”? The Food Babe would be proud. Of course, we make fun of the Food Babe (Vani Hari) because of her extreme ignorance and her fear of chemicals that leads her to demonize chemicals whose names she can’t pronounce. I expect more of a physician, and yet here we see Dr. Neides making the same sort of ignorant appeal to ignorance in which chemicals whose names the average person can’t pronounce must be bad. I’ve referred to The Food Babe as the Jenny McCarthy of Food. It’s depressing in the extreme to see a physician in a leadership position in a major academic medical center making the same sorts of ignorant arguments as those favored by The Food Babe or the most idiotic of antivaccine websites. It’s even more depressing to see him actually recommend The Food Babe’s website, as Dr. Neides does later in the post by quoting a functional medicine quack, Jessica Hutchins’ endorsement of her.
Back to antivaccine fear mongering, courtesy of Dr. Neides
Not satisfied with his first volley of antivaccine fear mongering coupled with his invocation of “toxins” as the be-all and end-all of chronic disease, Dr. Neides proceeds to endorse the idea that vaccines cause autism, while leaving himself some plausible deniability, as he recounts a litany of antivaccine “greatest hits”:
Slight detour. Why do I mention autism now twice in this article. Because we have to wake up out of our trance and stop following bad advice. Does the vaccine burden – as has been debated for years – cause autism? I don’t know and will not debate that here. What I will stand up and scream is that newborns without intact immune systems and detoxification systems are being over-burdened with PRESERVATIVES AND ADJUVANTS IN THE VACCINES.
The adjuvants, like aluminum – used to stimulate the immune system to create antibodies – can be incredibly harmful to the developing nervous system. Some of the vaccines have helped reduce the incidence of childhood communicable diseases, like meningitis and pneumonia. That is great news. But not at the expense of neurologic diseases like autism and ADHD increasing at alarming rates.
When I was in medical school in the late 1980s, the rate of autism was 1 in 1,000 children. For those born in the 1950’s and 60’s, do you recall a single student in your grade with an Individualized Education Program (IEP) for ADHD or someone with a diagnosis of autism? I do not.
As of 2010, the rate of autism in the U.S. escalated to 1 in 68 children. The deniers will simply state that we do a better job of diagnosing this “disorder”. Really? Something (s) are over-burdening our ability to detoxify, and that is when the problems begin.
So let me be clear – vaccines can be helpful when used properly. But the vaccination timing and understanding one’s epigenetics (how your genes interact with the environment) are all critical to our risk of developing chronic disease. Please talk to your doctor about the optimal timing of vaccinations for your children, and therefore reduce your risk of raising a child with a neurologic complication.
I reproduced this lengthy passage to let you see it in all its antivaccine glory. Notice how he disingenuously claims not to be taking a position on whether vaccines cause autism. Why do I say “disingenuously”? Because his claim is nothing more than a variation of the “I’m not ‘antivaccine,’ I’m pro-vaccine safety” denial that many antivaccine activists use to deflect the charge that they are antivaccine. It’s been a favorite of Jenny McCarthy, for instance. I frequently refer to antivaccine dog whistles, which are terms that, to those unversed in antivaccine propaganda, sound benign but signal to antivaccine believers that the person using them is with them. Let’s just put it this way. Dr. Neides goes way, way beyond antivaccine dog whistles and into antivaccine bullhorn territory.
Let me count the antivaccine tropes in the passage above. Aluminum is dangerous to the immune and neurologic symptoms of newborns? Check. And wrong, wrong, wrong. The implied claim that vaccines cause autism? Check. And also wrong. There’s lots more evidence than this debunking the myth of the vaccine-autism link, but as an example, a small pebble pulled from a mountain of evidence not supporting a vaccine-autism link, I will mention a recent meta-analysis examining cohort studies involving nearly 1.3 million children conclusively failed to find a link between vaccines and autism. I’ll also mention a massive systematic review that found that severe adverse events due to vaccines are very, very rare. The claim that there is an “autism epidemic” and that it must be due to vaccines? Check. (And holy confusing correlation with causation, Batman!) Yes, this is another claim that is incorrect. Although the prevalence of autism disorders has increased to 1 in 68, existing evidence suggests that the increase is mainly due to broadening of the diagnostic criteria back in the 1990s and, yes, picking up more subclinical cases through increased screening. Whenever you look more closely for a condition or disease—any condition or disease—you will find more of it, often a lot more of it that had not been clinically apparent, as I explained in my discussion of autism prevalence. That’s not even counting diagnostic substitution and how, when you control for methods of capturing diagnoses, “true” autism prevalence has not changed detectably in at least 20 years.
Before I move on again, I can’t help but note how Dr. Neides invokes the magical mystical “epigenetics,” a concept that’s been embraced by quacks the way that proponents of “energy healing” embrace the term “quantum.” It’s the hottest fad in “integrative medicine” to “explain” how we can allegedly control our gene expression through the peerless power of our will. He even attacked the hepatitis B vaccine birth dose as unnecessary and dangerous, even though it is safe and there are good reasons to administer it at birth.
Basically, Dr. Neides’ post is nothing more than a list of antivaccine lies and detox quackery, all wrapped in a mantle of “I’m not ‘antivaccine,’ I’m pro-vaccine safety” and an attempt at plausible deniability (“I don’t know” and “I won’t debate here” whether vaccines cause autism), with a lukewarm concession that “some” vaccines do good and have reduced the incidence of deadly diseases coupled with a false equivalency (but only “at the expense of neurologic diseases like autism and ADHD increasing at alarming rates”). He is clearly antivaccine by my criteria at least.
No one, least of all The Cleveland Clinic, should be surprised by such antivaccine views in “integrative medicine”
As you might imagine, Dr. Neides’ article unleashed a social media firestorm over the weekend, with STAT News noting the PR…difficulties…caused by Dr. Neides’ post. Also, Tara Haelle over at Forbes did a deconstruction. I’m a bit late to the game, but that’s not necessarily a bad thing. It allows me to comment on not just Dr. Neides’ post, but the reaction to it.
Dr. Neides’ post was temporarily taken down (hence the need for Google Cache, it’s now back up with a note that it was “inexplicably removed” for a couple hours), and he issued a very unconvincing apology, saying that that he “fully supports vaccination” and was only trying to open a conversation about their safety, not question their use. Later, through a Cleveland Clinic spokeswoman, he issued this statement:
I apologize and regret publishing a blog that has caused so much concern and confusion for the public and medical community,” the statement said. “I fully support vaccinations and my concern was meant to be positive around the safety of them.
Dr. Neides sure has a strange way of being “positive around the safety of” vaccines, wouldn’t you say? After all, he did liken vaccination to being “lined up like cattle and injected with an unsafe product.” Indeed, his imagery of cattle going to the slaughter is a common one used by antivaccine ideologues. Perhaps Dr. Neides considered his words “positive around the safety” of vaccines because he showed amazing self-restraint in not using the word “sheeple” to describe those being vaccinated. I bet that’s it.
In any event, this is far from the first time I’ve seen this sort of “notpology” from an antivaccine doctor caught publicly spewing antivaccine quackery. Indeed, Dr. Neides’ notpologies include common standard issue responses that are not to be believed, particularly in light of the highly inflammatory language in his blog post and in some of his responses in the comments.
The Cleveland Clinic, for its part, released a statement yesterday:
Cleveland Clinic is fully committed to evidence-based medicine. Harmful myths and untruths about vaccinations have been scientifically debunked in rigorous ways. We completely support vaccinations to protect people, especially children who are particularly vulnerable. Our physician published his statement without authorization from Cleveland Clinic. His views do not reflect the position of Cleveland Clinic and appropriate disciplinary action will be taken.
This is, of course, the bare minimum The Cleveland Clinic could have done, but I rather suspect its leadership is waiting until today to figure out what to do.
I feel for the science-based physicians and scientists who work for the Cleveland Clinic, and there are a lot of them. I know someone who gets medical care from the Cleveland Clinic, and what’s relayed to me is that the primary care doc seen scoffs at all the “wellness” woo. Indeed, Amrit Gill, the patient safety officer at The Cleveland Clinic, took to Twitter to defend her institution:
@tarahaelle one doctor does not represent all of @ClevelandClinic. Overwhelming majority docs support vaccines and evidence based medicine.
— Amrit Gill (@amritgillmd) January 8, 2017
A cutting response:
If that’s true, then why do @ClevelandClinic docs tolerate rank quackery like reiki, functional medicine, and TCM at the Wellness Institute? https://t.co/TyLV5Wrtwh
— David Gorski (@gorskon) January 8, 2017
My guess is that it’s a combination of ignorance of just how bad the quackery is and the shruggie disease. Same as it ever was.
It must be pointed out that the Cleveland Clinic brought this PR debacle on itself. It was well-nigh inevitable that antivaccine pseudoscience would eventually rear its ugly head in some form or another the moment the Clinic embraced quackery wholeheartedly for its Wellness Institute. Indeed, I welcome this PR meltdown, because I hope that it will finally shine a light on the utter quackery that has been promoted by the Cleveland Clinic over the last decade at least and how that quackery is inseparable from the antivaccine quackery promoted by Dr. Neides in his post. I also hope that this debacle shines attention on Dr. Hyman as well, who has largely gotten a pass.
Even though the Cleveland Clinic officially disavowed Dr. Neides’ position on vaccines, it continues to cling to pseudomedicine where antivaccine views are inherent, such as chiropractic, energy medicine, and others. Its staff list is chock full of chiropractors, acupuncturists, reiki masters, and “holistic doctors.” I also note that Dr. Mark Hyman, founder and director of the Cleveland Clinic’s functional medicine clinic, co-authored an antivaccine book with one of the most famous antivaccine cranks out there, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. They even appeared on The Dr. Oz Show together to discuss the book! He’s also written blog posts in which he blamed vaccines for autism and recommended rank quackery to treat autism.
Let’s just put it this way using one example. The Cleveland Clinic hired the co-author of an antivaccine book to run its functional medicine clinic, and it’s surprised that antivaccine views have apparently found a comfy home in its Wellness Institute? I can’t help but be reminded of Captain Renault in Casablanca and how he was shocked—shocked—to find that gambling quackery is going on here!
That part where one of Rick’s employees brings Captain Renault his gambling winnings is especially applicable to this situation.
As for Dr. Neides, I’m only disappointed that it took so long for others to take notice of his belief in rank quackery. All you have to do is to peruse his list of blog posts for Cleveland.com to see his proclivity for “detox” quackery in posts with titles like “To combat chemicals tainting our food and air, detoxify” (in which he fully bought into claims that glyphosate causes inflammatory bowel disease, obesity, depression, ADHD, autism, Alzheimer’s disease, Parkinson’s disease, ALS, multiple sclerosis, cancer, infertility and developmental malformations), “Everyday toxins poison our best intentions” (in which Dr. Neides lists a bunch of chemicals to avoid), and the like. He also appears to treat his patients for “chronic candida” infection, a favorite quack diagnosis. I also can’t help but note that in a 2014 post Dr. Neides recommended the flu vaccine, noting the 2009 H1N1 influenza pandemic. What happened since then? Who knows? Was one bad reaction (if it was even that) to a flu shot enough to change his mind so much?
His extracurricular activities aside, there’s another alarming thing I noted about Dr. Neides. He’s also Associate Director of Clinical Education for The Cleveland Clinic Lerner College of Medicine (CCLCM), where he oversees all clinical activities during years three through five of the medical school. That means he plays a big role in how medical students at The Cleveland Clinic are educated. That is profoundly scary.
I can’t help but finish this long post by referring you to the Cleveland Clinic’s reiki factsheet. (I’ve saved a copy in case it disappears.) I urge you to read it in its entirety. It’s chock full of references to “life force energy,” the practitioner’s and patient’s “energy field,” and the “universal source,” with no science whatsoever, representing complete acceptance of the mystical mumbo-jumbo behind reiki. After you read this, you will understand why I liken reiki to faith healing. Both reiki and faith healing rely on a belief that some sort of healing power can be channeled by the practitioner from a source to the patient. In the case of faith healing, that source is the Judeo-Christian god. In the case of reiki, it’s the “universal source.” They’re the same thing, faith healing. It’s just that they’re based on different religious traditions.
My purpose in referring you to this factsheet is simple. If an institution embraces mystical or religious quackery like reiki uncritically as valid medicine, it soon won’t be able to limit the magical thinking to just a few areas, particularly if the quackery is popular and makes money, as it appears to be and do at the Cleveland Clinic Wellness Institute.
As Alan Levinovitz put it on Twitter:
.@ClevelandClinic: “We are NOT anti-vaccine! Also, energy healing can help detoxify your pet’s vibrational frequency.” https://t.co/hnH8pTZDjg
— Alan Levinovitz (@AlanLevinovitz) January 8, 2017
After that, he went off on an epic Twitterstorm explaining further what I’m talking about.
If you as an institution embrace multiple forms of magical thinking, you shouldn’t be surprised if your institution’s belief in magical thinking grows and metastasizes. Nothing will be off-limits, even antivaccine views. Now, The Cleveland Clinic has a TCM herbal clinic and a functional medicine center. Given how integral beliefs in “detoxification,” from which naturally flow antivaccine beliefs, are so much part of the quackery being “integrated” into medicine through integrative medicine, it should not be a surprise that there are at least two antivaccine quacks in leadership positions at the Cleveland Clinic, Drs. Mark Hyman and Daniel Neides. After all, if you “integrate” medicine that teaches that “toxins” cause disease and “detoxification” is the cure, antivaccine quackery can’t be far behind, and when you abandon science for magical thinking nothing is off limits to magic.
The Cleveland Clinic can discipline or fire Dr. Neides from his leadership positions for his irresponsible post (which looks to be the likely outcome now), but that won’t solve its problem. That’s because The Cleveland Clinic’s problem stems from the integration of quackery into its Wellness Institute. Unless the leadership of The Cleveland Clinic cleans house in a big way, eliminating the quackery, what will happen is that the remaining “integrative medicine” doctors who are antivaccine will simply know not to speak publicly about their antivaccine beliefs. Even though firing Dr. Neides would be a good first step in cleaning house, it would be nowhere near enough to fix the problem at The Cleveland Clinic.
Finally, I hope that this whole kerfuffle is just the wakeup call needed for all the good doctors at The Cleveland Clinic who practice science-based medicine to learn just how deep the quackery at their institution runs, a wakeup call that leads them to a shruggie awakening to realize that it’s not that great a step from seemingly “benign” woo to dangerous woo, like antivaccine woo.

Cleveland Clinic Fully Embraces Pseudoscience
A recent and embarrassing anti-vaccine screed from the Director of the Cleveland Clinic Wellness Center produced a media backlash. Toby Cosgrove, CEO and President of the Cleveland Clinic, had the opportunity to re-dedicate his organization to good science and medical practice. Instead he doubled-down on the Cleveland Clinic’s embrace of quackademic medicine and pseudoscience.
Steven Novella on January 18, 2017
Link

Last week the Director of the Cleveland Clinic Wellness Center, Daniel Neides, wrote a crank anti-vaccine screed in a column for a local news outlet. This prompted an immediate backlash of criticism from professionals who care about the integrity of science in medicine. It also prompted some immediate damage control by the Cleveland Clinic, who released the following statement:
Cleveland Clinic is fully committed to evidence-based medicine. Harmful myths and untruths about vaccinations have been scientifically debunked in rigorous ways. We completely support vaccinations to protect people, especially children who are particularly vulnerable. Our physician published his statement without authorization from Cleveland Clinic. His views do not reflect the position of Cleveland Clinic and appropriate disciplinary action will be taken.
That was a reasonable immediate response, but of course does not address the underlying problem – the Cleveland Clinic has increasingly embraced unscientific “alternative” medicine in recent years, and their Wellness Center is a primary example, being a hotbed of pseudoscience. It’s interesting to note that when mainstream medical practitioners or institutions embrace so-called alternative medicine they often draw the line at anti-vaccine quackery. There is no real scientific reason for making that the line in the sand (the CAM services they do offer are just as unscientific as anti-vaccine nonsense), but there is a very real PR reason.
CAM is often sold to academics and hospitals as offering more choices to their customers (Uh, I mean patients), but anti-vaccine claims don’t do that. Further, vaccines (which are a clear home run for science-based medicine) remain very popular, and it is still common to view anti-vaccine claims as conspiracy quackery. That is why it is always amusing when centers like the Cleveland Clinic get burned by the anti-vaccine pseudoscience that flows into their institutions along with the CAM quackery they knowingly let in.
The immediate response of the Cleveland Clinic led us to speculate whether or not this episode might cause some at the Cleveland Clinic to engage in genuine soul-searching and substantive change, or would they just do damage-control, sweep it under the rug, and go on embracing pseudoscience.
Well, our speculation is now over. Toby Cosgrove, MD, President and CEO of the Cleveland Clinic (I think it’s fair to say he speaks with some authority regarding the Cleveland Clinic) published an article on the Cleveland Clinic website in which he indicates that the Cleveland Clinic will continue to fully embrace pseudoscience and quackery in medicine (as long as it is called “alternative”).
The article is very useful in that is presents an excellent example of the propaganda and misdirection that leads to what we call “quackademic medicine” – the embrace by otherwise mainstream or science-based institutions of popular quackery.
Preventive medicine
Cosgrove begins with one of the biggest myths of CAM, that scientific medicine does not adequately address wellness, or preventive medicine, and that we need to embrace CAM in order to do so. He writes:
Smoking, poor diet, and lack of exercise were the leading factors that placed patients under my scalpel.That’s why we established the Cleveland Clinic’s Wellness Institute in 2007 and placed its leader in the C-suite with the title of Chief Wellness Officer. From its inception, the goal of the Wellness Institute is to focus on “health care,” not just “sick care.”Historically, healthcare has not done a good job of promoting disease prevention. Our Wellness Institute has built a framework to guide patients to healthier lifestyle choices.
It is disturbing when the propaganda of the enemy is internalized and accepted. It is uncontroversial that much of the disease in our society is the product of lifestyle factors (that and aging). I also fully endorse hospitals and medical centers having resources dedicated to health promotion and disease prevention.
However, it is simply not true that mainstream medicine focuses only on “sick care” and not on “health care” or preventive medicine. All of the principles of preventive medicine, including the risks of smoking, the benefits of exercise, and the relationship of nutrition and diet to health and disease, were discovered and promoted within the paradigm of mainstream scientific medicine. CAM proponents simply rewrote history and took credit for anything preventive.
Primary care physicians would likely be surprised to discover from Cosgrove, a cardiothoracic surgeon, that they do not engage in preventive medicine. This is simply a myth, as big as any of the anti-vaccine myths that Cosgrove condemns.
What about the claim that healthcare has not done a good job of promoting disease prevention? This claim is vague – does he mean that healthcare providers don’t try, or that their attempts are not successful? The former interpretation is simply not true. The latter is a complex question. It is very difficult to change lifestyle behaviors of patients. There is, in fact, a robust program of research investigating how better to do just that. Simply telling patients that a certain behavior is a risk factor for disease has little (but non-zero) effect. Educating them about healthy lifestyles also has a real but small effect.
Researchers have investigated new techniques, such as motivational interviewing, in which the patient is encouraged to express their health goals so that the provider can help them achieve those goals. This works better than the older “scared straight” method but still has a modest effect. There is also research into society-level interventions, to nudge patients to better choices, or make them easier to make and maintain.
The bottom line is that changing behavior is extremely difficult, but there is a robust and active effort to prevent diseases by promoting healthy lifestyles. So what, exactly, is Cosgrove saying? Does he or the Cleveland Clinic have any magical new techniques for promoting healthy behavior they would like to share with the rest of us? I would encourage them to simply publish their results in the peer-reviewed scientific literature. Do they really think they are just trying harder than the rest of us? We can brush that off as a bit of self-serving marketing.
Unfortunately, what Cosgrove is doing is using the trope that mainstream medicine does not do preventive medicine as justification for embracing quackery. If the Cleveland Clinic Wellness Center were simply a center of preventive medicine, trying to push forward the science of health promotion, I would be all for it. Alas, that is not what it is.
The link to anti-vaccine claims
Cosgrove, after posturing about preventive medicine, responds to recent critics (presumably including SBM):
Harmful myths, untruths and junk science about vaccinations have been scientifically debunked. Serious adverse effects are incredibly rare. And there is no demonstrated link between autism and vaccination.Still, critics have used the column to disparage the Wellness Institute as a whole and the concept of wellness in general.
We have not criticized the concept of promoting wellness. That is an unfair straw man. We have criticized the Wellness Institute, and Cosgrove fails to acknowledge or address that criticism. Our criticism is that when you lower the standards of science in medicine, when you embrace dubious health claims and treatments that have historically been considered fraudulent quackery (until they were rebranded as alternative or integrative), then you open the door for all sorts of nonsense, including anti-vaccine quackery.
Cosgrove and the Cleveland Clinic can spend as much time as they want praising the virtues of vaccines, and condemning anti-vaccine myths, but that does not address the core criticism. Cosgrove does not even mention how the Director of their Wellness Center could embrace and promote, “Harmful myths, untruths and junk science about vaccinations.”
By his silence I can only infer that he thinks that the philosophy of the Wellness Center and Dr. Neides’ anti-vaccine quackery are somehow unrelated. This view is supported by Cosgrove’s statement:
However, in a recent online column, the Wellness Institute’s medical director shared his personal views about vaccination – views that do not represent Cleveland Clinic in any way.
He is trying to distance himself and the Cleveland Clinic from Dr. Neides by dismissing his article as his “personal views.” I’m sorry, but that does not work. Dr. Neides is a doctor and the director of a clinic. His views on vaccines are not just his “personal views,” they are his professional views, and dictate his professional behavior, which includes teaching students and treating patients at the Cleveland Clinic.
Further, they do, in fact, represent the Cleveland Clinic, because the clinic endorses Neides by hiring him as the director of their Wellness Center (which Cosgrove believes is an extremely important center), and because the very philosophy of the Cleveland Clinic Wellness Center is perfectly aligned with anti-vaccine quackery.
Cosgrove pretends this conflict does not exist, and does not address at all. Any hope that the Cleveland Clinic would have an epiphany and realize that their embrace of CAM quackery may not be a good thing has evaporated.
Still, with what I have quoted so far one might think, hopefully, that Cosgrove is defending his institution while planning to quietly back away from the quackery that, until now, has characterized their Wellness Center. Let me dash those hopes.
Some approaches may be considered unconventional, but most – acupuncture, yoga, Chinese herbal medicine, guided imagery and relaxation techniques – have scientific backing. We have heard from our patients that they want more than conventional medicine can offer and we believe it is best that they undertake these alternative therapies under the guidance of their Cleveland Clinic physician.
I wonder which approaches Cosgrove considers “unconventional,” and what, exactly he means by “unconventional”? The use of vague and slippery terminology is a hallmark of pseudoscience, and it is discouraging to see Cosgrove slip into that form so easily. On their website they promote energy medicine:
A method of healing that involves balancing and restoring the body’s natural energies for the purposes of increasing vitality, balancing emotions, and improving health.
This is pure vitalism, which is a prescientific notion that was discarded 150 years ago. Their website also claims that the treatments “patients find most helpful” include things like reiki (which is just Eastern faith-healing). Notice how they carefully avoid saying that these treatments actually work, or that they are demonstrated by scientific evidence, but patients find them helpful. So I guess by “unconventional” Cosgrove means that they are pseudoscientific quackery.
What about the treatments that Cosgrove claims “have scientific backing?” We have discussed acupuncture at length here. Systematic reviews of the evidence show that acupuncture does not work for any indication. Acupuncture does not have better scientific evidence supporting it, just better marketing. Yoga is exercise, and it has the benefits of exercise. This is not alternative. Relaxation techniques also, in my careful reading of the scientific literature, cause relaxation. I know that may come as a shock, but it’s true. Relaxation, it turns out, is relaxing which reduces stress (which is pretty much the opposite of relaxation). Again – there is nothing alternative about any of this, unless you make “healing” claims that go beyond the evidence.
Chinese herbal medicine is more of a complex topic. Herbs are drugs, which can have real effects. There is nothing magical about herbs (unless you believe that they are, in fact, magical). But there are two big problems with Chinese herbal medicine. The first is that it is embedded in Traditional Chinese Medicine, which is mostly ancient superstition, no different than Galenic medicine and bloodletting.
The second is that herbal medicine is just sloppy. The herbal drugs used are poorly characterized, not standardized, insufficiently studied and the claims made for them are not adequately evidence-based. It’s just messy pharmaceutical treatment based mostly on tradition and anecdote, rather than careful scientific evidence.
Elsewhere in the article Cosgrove praises their Functional Medicine center. We have discussed functional medicine at length before, and I won’t repeat it here. Suffice to say this is just another flavor of CAM pseudoscience in medicine, sprinkled with more lab tests and a more deliberate appearance of science, without actually being science-based.
Cosgrove justifies embracing “unconventional” and pseudoscientific treatments, at least in this article, in two ways. As quoted above, patients want these treatments, so Cleveland Clinic might as well make money off of them (I mean, guide their patients to proper use, whatever that is). This is misguided (if sincere). Patients still look to experts and professionals to give them proper advice and guidance. They assume that large venerable institutions of medicine base their recommendations on science and evidence. When you embrace pseudoscience you don’t control it – it controls you. That is what this recent episode with Neides should have taught Cosgrove, but apparently didn’t.
He concludes with an appeal to need:
Cleveland Clinic is the first major academic medical center to embrace many of these alternative strategies. We believe that doing so is justified by the magnitude of the disease challenge. By making healthier choices, people can avoid medications and procedures. And that truly is the best medicine.
This is just poor logic. Needing to prevent disease does not justify embracing pseudoscience. In fact, the opposite is true. Yes, the disease burden facing our aging population is enormous. Also, as we solve the simpler medical problems we are left with more and more complex problems. As technology advances, our choices get more complex. This requires an increased dedication to medicine that works. We know what is safe and effective because of careful, rigorous, thorough, and unbiased assessment of all available evidence.
Watering down the rigor of evidence in medicine will not move us toward greater health. It will not solve the problems faced by the growing demands for health care. It will worsen them.
The Cleveland Clinic had an opportunity to reassess its approach, and to make a much needed course correction. Instead its CEO has reaffirmed his dedication to embracing pseudoscience and quackery under the umbrella of marketing terms that are meant to deceive and distract. In doing so, he has made The Cleveland Clinic into a powerful force for pseudoscience in medicine.

A tale of quackademic medicine at the University of Arizona Cancer Center
NCI-designated comprehensive cancer centers like the University of Arizona should provide rigorously science-based treatment. Unfortunately, magical mystical “treatments” like reiki are offered to UA patients, as I learned from a father of a child treated there.
David Gorski on March 17, 2014
Link
Quackademic medicine.
I love that term, because it succinctly describes the infiltration of pseudoscientific medicine into medical academia. As I’ve said many times, I wish I had been the one to coin the phrase, but I wasn’t. To the best of my ability to determine, I first picked it up from Dr. R. W. Donnell back in 2008 and haven’t been able to find an earlier use of the term. As much as I try to give credit where credit is due, I have, however, appropriated the term “quackademic medicine” (not to mention its variants, like “quackademia”), used it, and tried my best to popularize it among supporters of science-based medicine. Indeed, one of my earliest posts on this blog was about how quackery has infiltrated the hallowed halls of medical academia, complete with links to medical schools that have “integrative medicine” programs and even medical schools that promoted the purely magic-based medical modalities known as reiki and homeopathy. It’s been a recurrent topic on this blog ever since, leading to a number posts on the unethical clinical trials of treatments with zero or minimal pre-trial plausibility, the degradation of the scientific basis of medicine, and the acceptance of magical thinking as a means of treating patients in all too many medical centers.
One strong candidate for quackademic ground zero, if there can be such a thing for the phenomenon like quackademic medicine, which is creeping up like so much kudzu in the cracks of the edifice of science-based medicine (SBM), is the University of Arizona. U. of A. is, of course, the home of one of the originators of the concept of quackademic medicine and one of its most famous and tireless promoters, Dr. Andrew Weil. Dr. Weil, as you might recall, has even been the driving force for creating a highly dubious “board certification” in integrative medicine. Sadly, apparently this new board certification has been so popular among physicians wanting to “integrate” a little quackery into their practices, that its first examination has been delayed from May to November 2014, so that the American Board of Physician Specialties can figure out how to accommodate the unexpectedly large number of applicants.
So what happens when a patient arrives at U. of A. for treatment? I found out last week when I received an e-mail, which led to a fairly long e-mail exchange, with a man whose son was diagnosed with leukemia and is being treated at the University of Arizona Cancer Center (UACC). Although this man gave me permission to use his name, I am going to decline to do so because there is a child involved, although anyone involved in his case at U. of A. will likely quickly be able to identify who the man is. It turns out that he is a professor at U. of A. in a humanities department (which is why I’ll refer to him henceforth as the Professor), and, even though he is not a scientist, he clearly knows how to think (which would not be surprising if you knew what department he was in). In his e-mail, he told me how appalled he was at the sorts of treatments being offered to his son:
I was appalled to discover that the center offers treatments like Reiki, Reflexology, Acupuncture, Cranial massage, etc. These treatments are advertised as “healing”–including boosting one’s immune system, complementing conventional chemotherapy etc. I wrote the the [sic] director of the center who at first expressed concern and thanked me for calling these things to her attention. She said she would convene a board of physicians to look into it. After three months went by, I wrote to her asking for an update. She told me the board was still working on it and that she was “confident they would take care of it”. I have been asking her for a timeline and she is not returning my emails.
At first I thought this was probably the pernicious influence of Andrew Weil, but I have since discovered that cancer centers around the country are offering these “treatments” including places like Sloan-Kettering. Because of this, I’ve concluded there is no point in going to the media to try to expose what’s going on.
Of course, blogs are the media. The new media, but media nonetheless. At least I like to think so.
The Professor is probably correct about going to the traditional media, though. There probably is little point in going to the press, although we can always hope. Most of the time, when the press looks into the infiltration of quackademic medicine into medical academia, the result is a story like this appalling one from a year and a half ago in which NBC News chief medical correspondent Nancy Snyderman strongly embraced quackademic medicine to the point that she even said that if a doctor “doesn’t know” about integrative medicine, “I think it’s time to ask for a referral to someone who does.” It made me sad to see a woman who normally stands up for science, at least with respect to vaccines and combatting the antivaccine movement, to fall so hard for pseudoscience when it exists at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center. Even I have had to hang my head in shame when I discovered that my alma mater both for medical and undergraduate school, the University of Michigan, actually has a program in anthroposophic medicine.
Unfortunately, although I hoped that the Professor would make as much of a stink as he could, I felt compelled to warn him that I doubted he would be successful because this sort of “integration” of quackery with academic medicine is very much entrenched at the University of Arizona. It started with the pernicious influence of Andrew Weil, but if Dr. Weil were to drop dead or retire today I doubt that it would change much, if at all, because quackademic medicine has had years to become embedded in the culture there. To put it bluntly, U. of A. is one of the centers of quackademic medicine in the US, if not the world, and I don’t see that changing any time soon. I also looked up UACC’s director, Dr. Ann E. Cress, and noted that she’s an interim director, which makes it highly unlikely that, even if she were so inclined, she could do much of anything. An interim cancer center director isn’t going to be able to take on Andrew Weil. It also doesn’t help that there are researchers at U. of A. like Dr. Myra Muramoto, who recently scored a $3.1 million from the National Cancer Institute (NCI)—not the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, mind you, the NCI—to do this:
Dr. Myra Muramoto, Arizona Cancer Center member and associate professor in the Department of Family and Community Medicine at the University of Arizona College of Medicine, has received $3.1 million from the National Cancer Institute to develop and evaluate a new program to train chiropractors, acupuncturists and massage therapists in effective ways to help their patients and clients quit tobacco.
The grant will fund “Project Reach,” which will partner over the next five years with Pima County chiropractors, acupuncturists, massage therapists and their office staff to evaluate ways they can best help their patients quit tobacco.
That’s a big chunk of change of the sort that cancer centers value above all, money from NCI grants. When cancer centers are being considered for NCI-designated comprehensive cancer center status (NCI-CCC)—or trying to renew their status—one huge consideration is the level of NCI funding its investigators have. Basically, for this purpose NIH grants are good, but NCI grants are the best. That’s why any investigator with a $3.1 million NCI grant will have outsized influence and an NCI-CCC or any cancer center seeking NCI designation. Of course, because chiropractors, acupuncturists, and massage therapists often claim, without valid scientific evidence, to be able to help people quit smoking with their woo, such a grant would almost certainly have the effect of encouraging referrals of smokers to these practitioners, to make sure enough patients accrue to the study funded by the grant.
Quackademic medicine at UACC
It turns out that U. of A. does indeed offer its patients tons of “supportive” care therapies not rooted in science. A quick look at its Survivorship Care page reveals:
In collaboration with the medical and psychosocial services at The University of Arizona Cancer Center, we will work with patients to:
    • Reduce physical symptoms associated with cancer and its treatment (e.g., pain, fatigue, insomnia, etc.)
    • Manage side effects of chemotherapy and radiation with therapies such as acupuncture, botanicals, and mind-body medicine
    • Examine lifestyle factors and situations (e.g., diet, risk for undernutrition, physical activity, emotional coping skills, support network, and spirituality) that may affect symptoms and/or course of disease
    • Develop and work toward goals for health, wellness, and what is most meaningful and valuable after diagnosis, as well as during and after treatment
    • Actively participate in their health care
    • Regain a sense of control and well-being despite the diagnosis
Notice the quackademic medicine “integrated” with potentially science-based modalities for supportive care: acupuncture, botanicals, “mind-body” medicine. Note how such useless modalities like acupuncture are listed as being, in essence, co-equal with various dietary, lifestyle, and coping modalities. This is basically how quackademic medicine “rebrands” what should be science-based modalities as somehow being “alternative” or outside the mainstream. It then lumps them together with modalities that are pure quackery (acupuncture, reiki, therapeutic touch, etc.), the implication being that it’s all part of a lovely “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) package that represents the “best of both worlds.” Of course, we at SBM reject the idea that there are “two worlds,” citing the oft-repeated adage that there is no such thing as “alternative medicine.” Rather, there is medicine that has been scientifically demonstrated to work. There is medicine that has not been scientifically shown to work. There is medicine that has been shown not to work. The reason “alternative medicine” is alternative is because it falls into one of the latter two categories. What do you call alternative medicine that’s been shown scientifically to work?
Medicine.
I know, I know. We say this a lot here, but it’s true. Also true is Mark Crislip’s almost famous adage, which I like to use in almost all of the talks I give about “integrative” medicine these days:
If you integrate fantasy with reality, you do not instantiate reality. If you mix cow pie with apple pie, it does not make the cow pie taste better; it makes the apple pie worse.
As I’ve said many times before, I wish I had thought of this quote.
Trying to hide the stench of cow pie in the apple pie
Make no mistake about it, UACC is “integrating” fantasy with reality by offering reflexology (or, as I like to call it, a nice foot and hand massage with delusions of grandeur), reiki (or, as I like to call it, faith healing substituting Eastern mysticism for Judeo-Christian beliefs), craniosacral massage (or, as I like to call it, a nice scalp massage with delusions of grandeur), healing touch (also known as therapeutic touch, which I like to call reiki without the foreign name), and many others. At least, I wasn’t able to find anywhere that the UACC offers homeopathy to patients, although one of the most famous of the “magical grants” awarded by NCCAM was to a University of Arizona researcher in Dr. Weil’s department to study homeopathy.
It didn’t take too long for it to become clear to the Professor that UACC was not dealing with him in good faith. At least, that’s what he told me in a subsequent e-mail. What led him to believe this was a combination of not getting his e-mails answered and then what happened after he complained about perhaps the most egregious example that he found at UACC. He first brought this issue up back in December, and, after several requests to have a meeting, the Professor became frustrated and basically sent a threat to go to the media. Shortly after that, the web page on the UACC site that had so disturbed the Professor became this:
Yes, that’s a big “Access Denied” message. One wonders whether UACC deleted the page or just hid it so that you need a University of Arizona login to see it. Maybe one of our readers from U. of A. could check and report back here.
Thankfully, due to the magic of Google Cache, we can see what was there until as recently as a week ago:
One wonders if the administration of UACC, out of concern that the Professor might actually do what he said he would do (shop his story around to newspapers), got rid of the web page for Frank Schuster. Of course, it’s not so easy, as I showed above, and, in case anyone’s interested, I’ve saved a web archive of the page for permanent archival purposes (for me, that is).
I can see why the UACC administration would be embarrassed enough to act like this. On the now defunct page, potential patients for UACC were treated to incredible claims like:
Very simply, Reiki is energy that flows through the body of the practitioner, and conveyed through the hands into the body of the recipient. It is subtle energy, but it can be felt – usually as a warmth, tingles or slight pressure.
And, perhaps the most ridiculous claim of all:
Any particular effects cannot be predicted. The energy is intelligent and it will do whatever is best. What can be stated is that it will help any condition.
That’s right. Apparently this “healing energy” from the “universal source” is so intelligent that it will do whatever is needed or best. That totally must be why it can’t be studied! Its effects are so darned unpredictable! It’s also hard not to note that on the old web page about Mr. Schuster there was a link to his practice’s web page Energy-Therapy.net, where there’s also a link to his blog Energy Therapies, which appears not to have been updated since 2005 but is quite revealing nonetheless. Indeed, in one post on Mr. Schuster’s web page, we see a claim that speaks for itself:
ALL illness and disease are indications of an unbalanced or depleted energetic condition. The resulting manifestation as pain or anxiety is the body’s way of letting you know that something in your life is out of balance.
But don’t worry, Mr. Schuster can help. You don’t even have to come to his practice or UACC! That’s because, you see, Mr. Schuster offers distance healing:
Distant Healing is defined as a “mental intention on behalf of one person, to benefit another at a distance.”
In this context, prayer is a mental act of intercession in which the believer (pray-er) puts himself “between” God and the recipient.
God then uses the prayer (pray-er) as the conduit for the request – be it healing, therapy, or another type of petition. God’s healing power is directed through the healer to the person in need. If that person is present, the power can be conveyed through touch. In the event that person cannot be present, God’s healing power is effectively conveyed by mental intention through the thought process. In this realm distance is not a consideration.
One might not believe any of this, nor have faith that this kind of healing can occur. Actually, that is irrelevant. The only faith that really matters is that of the healer or pray-er. The single requirement of the recipient is to be in a receptive mode, open to healing possibilities. It is not necessary to believe that the acts of prayer, distant healing or touch healing are effective.
This is, of course, completely unscientific. It’s religion, pure and simple. In fact, I would argue that it’s just another form of faith healing, given how Mr. Schuster invokes God as the source of the “healing power.” And it’s only $25 for four 15 minute sessions! (More if you want to donate more.) What a bargain! At least there’s a quack Miranda warning at the bottom of the page, and one notes that Mr. Schuster also includes a plug for NCCAM.
I don’t know whether Mr. Schuster actually offers distance healing to UACC patients, although it’s clear from his web page that he offers it. Regardless of whether he offers it to UACC patients or not, I hope that I would not be alone in arguing that mystical nonsense like reiki (which Mr. Schuster appears to implicitly admit to be faith healing) has no place in an academic medical center, much less an NCI-CCC like UACC. There are only 41 NCI-CCCs in the entire country. I’m faculty at one and am proud of having been on the faculty of two different NCI-CCC’s. The NCI designation is supposed to mean that these cancer centers are the best of the best, adhering to only the highest standards of patient care, research, and community engagement. To see an NCI-CCC offering faith healing, distance healing, and treatments based far more on magical thinking, religious and mystical ideas, and prescientific concepts of disease, such as reiki, reflexology, and acupuncture, embarrasses me almost as it would to learn these modalities were being promoted for patients by my own cancer center as though they were legitimate treatment modalities. Fortunately, they are not, which is one reason I’m proud of my cancer center, but I nonetheless fear this occurrence. After all, if M.D. Anderson Cancer Center and Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center can fall so deep into the rabbit hole of woo, I’m under no illusion that it can’t happen where I work too. All it would take is a new cancer center director, a new director of supportive services who is more “open” to these sorts of treatments, or maybe a new member of the board of directors who is woo-friendly. SBM is fragile these days.
Perhaps Dr. Cress feels the same way, along with many of the other excellent science-based clinicians and researchers based at UACC. I doubt it’s a coincidence that there isn’t a single mention of CAM or “integrative medicine” in a recent history of UACC published on the UACC blog last fall. In a way, I feel a bit sorry for Dr. Cress in that, as an interim director, she probably has neither the authority nor inclination to deal with this issue definitively. She probably wants to let whoever is appointed the next permanent director deal with it. Whatever the case, the Professor still doesn’t know whether Mr. Schuster is still affiliated with UACC or not, the removal of his web page from public view notwithstanding. I’m not sure that even the minimal action of removing from the UACC website a webpage that links to a website offering distance healing would have happened if the Professor hadn’t been faculty at the University of Arizona and threatened to go to the press.
Maybe they were concerned that people would also notice that Mr. Schuster’s other website, Paths-Mind-Is-It.com, offers a veritable cornucopia of dubious products, such as Increased Synchronicity, which claims to be able to:
    • Increase in awareness of the present moment. Fully appreciating the here and now
    • Have future self send information back through time to current moment. This is specific for the following periods of time…1 minute, 1 day, 1 week, 1 month and 3 months
    • Have current self send current information back through time to past self. This is also specific for the following periods of time…1 minute, 1 day, 1 week, 1 month and 3 months
    • Increasing unity/harmony between past, present and future self
Hey, if Mr. Schuster can send healing messages over distances, why not forward or backward in time, too? Yes, basically, his PATHS “utilize proprietary breakthrough technology” that claims this:
Rapid Data Transfer (RDT) GENERATION II embodies a quantum leap in Mind Technology. RDT Gen. II is a unique technology that helps you use the potential of your own mind without any drugs or medications. It can help you to improve in almost every area of your life including, health (physical, mental, emotional & spiritual), enlightenment, productivity, success, communication, finances, relationships, fitness and sports – even improve your memory!
RDT has been helping thousands of individuals, like you, improve their lives in many ways (click here to read success stories) in as little as 3 minutes a week.RDT or Rapid Data Transfer facilitates high-speed communication between an on-line Theater Presentation and the human subconscious.
As best I can figure, PATHS are multimedia computer presentations that claim to be able to do all sorts of things for you, including improving your stem cell health, strengthening your connective tissue, and doing quantum meditation. Note that the word “quantum” features prominently in this “technology,” and regular readers know what the use of that word almost always indicates in this context.
What remains of the cow pie
Even if Mr. Schuster is indeed gone from UACC, there’s a lot of woo that remains there, as the Professor mentioned in his e-mails. Specifically, he pointed out something called The Seven Levels of Healing, a program created and offered by Dr. Jeremy Geffen, MD, FACP, who is described as a “board certified medical oncologist and leading expert in integrative medicine and oncology and is the author of the book The Journey Through Cancer: Healing and Transforming the Whole Person.” I think I’ll quote the Professor about why he found this so objectionable, because, really, without letting myself go, I’d have a hard time putting it better myself. In his criticism, the Professor also cites examples from Dr. Geffen’s website:
Today I’m in the cancer center and I’ve noticed something else. You offer here something called “The Seven Levels of Healing”. I looked up this program. Level 7 is about the nature of spirit. Here’s one thing they say:
Spirit is our true nature: timeless, eternal, and dimensionless, the source from which all awareness, all creativity and, ultimately, all healing flows.
As you know, this claim is scientific nonsense. One may have religious faith in such a claim, but is it appropriate for this claim to be made by the cancer center? The description continues:
The goal of “The Nature of Spirit” is to assist each person to discover this spiritual aspect of themselves, and to bring this into full, ongoing awareness. When what we experience as physical reality is threatened, it is more important than ever before to remember that another part of us is timeless and eternal, and remains strong, healthy, and powerful, no matter what our physical circumstances may be. In recognizing the nature of our spiritual selves, and the incredible mystery of awareness itself, we uncover the source of ultimate love and freedom — an infinite ocean from which healing can be drawn.
Again, completely unscientific claims about healing. As far as I know, the “Seven Levels of Healing” program is free. This makes it less objectionable, although in my mind, it is still objectionable for the cancer center, a supposedly scientific, evidence-based institution, to be pushing what is essentially religion. Moreover, in the description of level 3: “The Body as Garden”, they say the following:
Here we explore the full spectrum of complementary approaches to healing: nutrition; exercise; massage; yoga; herbal therapies; Ayurvedic, Tibetan and Chinese medicine; acupuncture; homeopathy: chiropractic; and visualization. We do not offer or promote these approaches as cancer treatments per se, and we do not believe that they should be viewed in this manner. However, we do believe that they can supplement conventional care by cleansing, toning, relaxing, and strengthening the body, thus giving health and well-being the greatest chance to emerge.
Although these claims are vague, it would be quite natural for someone to interpret them as meaning that these treatments, some of which are offered at the center for a fee, can aid in one’s recovery from cancer. I know of no evidence to support this claim. And do you have any idea what they mean by ‘cleansing’ and ‘toning’ the body? Do these terms have any scientific meaning in this context?
Likely, the Professor learned of this program through a fliers or pamphlet like this one. He is quite correct, too. By offering this particular program, UACC has irresponsibly placed its imprimatur and thus the assumed imprimatur of science on pseudoscience and mystical, religious mumbo-jumbo. There is no excuse for this.
This “Seven Levels of Healing” represents a program by a physician who is not UACC faculty but is promoted by UACC to its patients. It offers homeopathy, which, no matter how much homeopaths try to deny it, is pure quackery, as we’ve described many, many times here. Ayurveda and traditional Chinese medicine are modalities based on prescientific ideas of how diseases work not unlike the four humors in prescientific European medical traditions. Worse, according to the biography on the website, Dr. Geffen is apparently “focused on implementing ‘The Seven Levels of Healing’ program in cancer centers throughout the United States, along with writing, speaking, and consulting with hospitals, cancer centers, and professional organizations in developing leading-edge integrative programs for medicine, wellness, and life.” Although several cancer centers appear to have adopted the “Seven Levels of Healing” woo, from what I can tell, UACC is the only NCI-CCC that is involved, making it by far the most prominent cancer center to be using Dr. Geffen’s program. I really hope that I don’t learn of any more.
Given the infiltration of quackademic medicine into even the most respectable medical centers, it’s hard to know whether UACC is merely the cancer center that’s gone the farthest down the rabbit hole of pseudoscience or whether I just don’t know of ones that are even worse. Given the large shadow that Andrew Weil casts over the medical school there, it might well be so that, when it comes to quackademic medicine in oncology, UACC reigns supreme. As prominent as M.D. Anderson and Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Centers are, as far as I can tell, neither of them has yet offered distance healing to their patients, although many are the academic medical centers that offer a quackery only slightly removed from distance healing, namely reiki. After all, what’s the difference between saying you can channel “healing energy” from the “universal source” into a patient if you’re in the room with him or if you’re thousands of miles away? In my mind, not much. At least one academic medical center offers homeopathy. (Actually, I wish it were only one.)
Can anything be done?
Often, I’m asked something like, “What’s the harm?” After all, UACC and the other cancer centers that offer up “integrative oncology” don’t deny patients science-based treatments for their cancer. True enough. However, as the Professor demonstrates, the existence of “integrative oncology” programs has a profoundly confusing effect on patients and their families, who, quite reasonably, assume that an NCI-CCC would not offer any treatments that were not science-based. Consequently, the line between science and pseudoscience is becoming increasingly blurred, to the point where even a lot of physicians have a hard time telling the difference when it comes to modalities like acupuncture, which has been the most successful at projecting a facade of science over prescientific mystical origins and a mid-20th century resurrection based on political need in China, thanks to low quality studies and random noise in clinical trials. Worse, this infiltration has led to grossly unethical clinical trials, such as the Gonzalez trial, in which patients undergoing a “natural” therapy for cancer did much worse than conventional therapy, even for a disease with as grim a prognosis as pancreatic cancer. Perhaps an even more pernicious effect (actually, there’s no “perhaps” about it) is that this blurring of the lines between science and pseudoscience so badly batters the filters against pseudoscience that a cancer center like UACC can allow practitioners like Frank Schuster and Dr. Jeremy Geffen to be associated with its programs, and even hire them to provide unscientific medicine.
My first wish is that more patients like the Professor would so vigorously protest the infiltration of quackery into academic medical centers like UACC. My second wish is that it would take more than the potential embarrassment of publicity about a practitioner that even the quackiest of quackademics can’t defend to push a cancer center to act to protect the scientific basis of cancer care. Maybe the Professor can serve as an example of the first wish, but I fear I will not live to see the second ever fulfilled.

Medicine in the Magic Kingdom of Cascadia. On Naturopathy.
Mark CrisliponSeptember 4, 2015
Link 

When the Pacific NW secedes from the Union it is to be part of a new country, Cascadia. The capital would be Portlandia, I suppose. Somehow, I think not. But when I watch the devolution of health care in Oregon, I think back to The Onion (?) when they reported that the United Kingdom was to be sold to Disney, being renamed as “The United Magic Kingdom.”
That is health care in Oregon due the steady insinuation of naturopathy and other pseudomedicine into real health care.
Oregon Health and Pseudoscience University
Growing up my alma mater was the University of Oregon Medical School. Since then it has undergone two name changes, first to Oregon Health Sciences University and then to the current Oregon Health & Sciences University (OHSU)—with, it should be noted, an ampersand. Not an ‘and’.
Perhaps they need one more name change, since they are not always that interested in the “Science” part of their name.
Some background is needed.
Portland has a trifecta of pseudoscience schools: Naturopathic (National College of Natural Medicine), Chiropractic (University of Western States) and ‘Oriental’ (Oregon College of Oriental Medicine).
Lucky us.
As an aside my kids let me know that the word ‘Oriental’ as used to describe people from the East, the term I grew up using, is persona non grata. I understand the reasoning. The proper term, they tell me, is Asian. So I have a mental cringe every time I see the name “Oregon College of Oriental Medicine”.
All three schools are steeped in pseudoscience and pseudomedicine, removed from known reality. As examples, the naturopathic school teaches homeopathy (and more), the chiropractic school teaches the subluxation complex, and the ‘Oriental’ (cringe) school teaches acupuncture. Reading the curricula of the schools suggests that there is no pseudomedical stone left unturned.
In the 1980s, OHSU received a grant to study low back pain in conjunction with the chiropractic school. As Cyndi Lauper noted, Money changes everything.
Why worry about standards, reality, plausibility, and science when there are Benjamins to be had? The Oregon Collaborative for Integrative Medicine was born, the OCIM:
The Collaborative was formally established in 2003 as the Oregon Collaborative for Complementary and Alternative Medicine as the result of a National Institutes of Health R25 CAM Education grant awarded to OHSU. UWS, OCOM and NCNM were all subsequently awarded follow-up R25 education grants.
With OHSU and Pacific University joining up with the troika to, among other plans, develop the Medical Education version of the Island of Doctor Moreau, with grotesque and unnatural hybrids, far worse than any hyena-swine or sloth-creature:
Standing beside the traditional MD/PhD or MD/MPH will be the ND/ MD, the MD/DAOM, the ND/DC, the ND/PhD, the DAOM/MPH and countless other combinations to build new vanguards of cross trained clinicians focused on inclusivity and collaboration
It is like the chemistry department at the University of Oregon having an alchemy degree, the astronomy department having an astrology degree, and the physics department a degree in the Time Cube (I may need a new example soon). But for millions of dollars, why not?
Their website mentions that:
In 2003, OHSU was awarded a $1.5 million dollar grant to develop, implement, and evaluate a new four-year curriculum for medical students in complementary and alternative medicine.
$1,500,000 is a lot of money. As best I can tell from talking with medical students, there is no four-year SCAM curriculum. There is one rotation in an Integrative Medicine Clinic [PDF] that I would fail, being unable to “establish and maintain a climate of mutual respect, dignity, diversity, integrity, honesty, and trust” with any pseudomedical provider. But that’s me. They have maybe a half-dozen publications as a result.
I just think about what we could do with 1.5 million dollars. I could create an amazing SCAM course with that kind of money. I wonder, could we apply for an NICCH education grant?
For support to develop and/or implement a program as it relates to a category in one or more of the areas of education, information, training, technical assistance, coordination, or evaluation.
We do that.
That is all I can find so far, but I have more digging to do. I have yet to figure out how to find the results of an NIH grant and how the money was spent. For that kind of money I would expect one hell of a curriculum, unless they wasted at least 1.5 million dollars in NIH money and have nothing to show for it. Nah.
At least they have other research to show for their efforts, for as it says on their web page:
OCIM and our members have a wealth of past and current research.
And they proudly list, what, oh well…
This section of our website is in development, please check back soon to learn about the enormous breadth of research that has been done and continues to be done in integrative medicine and health…
I would love to see this wealth of research, although I suspect it may be as comprehensive as the medical school curriculum they have developed, implemented and evaluated.
It is true, there has been and continues to be an enormous breadth of research in pseudomedicine. Most of the SCAM research, as we know from this website, is poorly done and the high-quality studies demonstrate no utility for most the pseudomedicines promulgated by the OCIM.
And now they are proud to announce a Fellowship in Integrative Medicine.
My motto: when you integrate cow pie into apple pie, the cow pie is not improved, the apple pie is made worse.
For $31,000 over two years virtually anyone (MD, ND, DC) can participate in an virtual classroom of topics that, at least to look at their titles, appear to contain nothing that anyone really needs to know to practice medicine.
But perhaps the content-free titles in the curriculum are hiding a deep and meaningful substantive medical education.
Given that NDs, DCs, dietitians, social workers and psychologists are among those eligible for the program, a comprehensive understanding of modern science-based medicine would appear not to be a requirement.
I also wonder how the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) and Accreditation Council for Continuing Medical Education (ACCME) approved this program.
So OHSU continues down the road to becoming OHPSU.
Spit take
This was in the local paper: “Naturopathic clinic designated as top tier primary care facility.” Good thing I was not drinking when I read the headline.
It has, by the way, my favorite picture of acupuncture technique, because not only are there no gloves on the hands of the acupuncturist as her fingers are next to the needle, there is a box of (unused) gloves behind her on the shelf. I use this photo in every acupuncture talk and the audience always responds with disgusted laughter.
But how could a naturopathic clinic be a top tier primary care facility?
Remember, in Oregon, naturopaths are designated in the statutes as primary care providers. This is like designating pi as equal to 3.14, but it is the law of the land here in the Magic Kingdom of Cascadia. It does not matter that their education and training in real medicine are about the same as buying a Fisher-Price Medical Kit Playset and declaring you are a doctor. According to the state, playing doctor makes you a doctor.
So what then are the requirements to become a top tier clinic?
Core Attributes
– Access to care: Patients get the care they need, when they need it.– Accountability: Recognized clinics are responsible for making sure patients receive the best possible care.– Comprehensive: Clinics provide patients all the care, information and services they need.– Continuity: Clinics work with patients and their community to improve patient and population health over time.– Coordination and integration: Clinics help patients navigate the system to meet their needs in a safe and timely way.– Patient and family-centered: Clinics recognize that patients are the most important members of the health care team and that they are ultimately responsible for their overall health and wellness.
If you go through the standards, there is almost nothing about adhering to science-based medical care and standards. Use homeopathy, acupuncture, energy and water therapy and other fantastical interventions? Not even relevant to the designation. And so not only can the naturopathic college get a designation, so can A Natural Path, an ND clinic in Seaside Oregon. Get it? Naturopath, Natural Path? So clever. There is nothing in the core attributes concerning the actual appropriate diagnosis and treatment of diseases. It is all about service and coordination of care, the infrastructure for providing care, not the actual medical care itself. This is something that medicine has not always been all that good at in the past.
No good deed ever goes unpunished. Just as evidence-based medicine can be misused to make pseudomedicine appear effective, the goal to provide better medical care can be misused by those with no medical training at all.
As I read the standard, for something as fundamental as childhood vaccinations clinics do not actually have to give vaccines – they just need to:
offer(s) or coordinate(s) recommended age and gender appropriate preventive services based on best available evidence.
Not actually give the vaccine, just offer and coordinate. Although they do have metrics for meeting minimal vaccination standards for children and adults. I will have to investigate this further as well as determine if I can access the submission forms used by the state to qualify the ND clinics. I have not heard back from the state as I write this.
As far as the designation as a top tier primary care facility, it does not matter in the least, as in the case of naturopaths, that the providers have no education or training in real medicine and that their entire paradigm of medical care is rooted in pseudoscience and fantasy. It is almost all about the service provided, not the quality of medicine practiced.
The designation is like restaurant sanitation grades [PDF]. Important information about the infrastructure of the facility but says nothing about the quality of the food. And in the case of an ND clinic, it is like getting the Just Like Home Dinner Play Food.

Addendum
I did not want to hijack the thread on Jann’s post yesterday, but my main response?
Batman would win. Period.
Hijack away.

Stanford University will host a conference on pandemic planning featuring the usual (COVID-19) suspects
This week, Stanford University announced a conference on pandemic policy that features several of the usual suspects who spread misinformation during the COVID-19 pandemic. Truly, Stanford has become the “respectable” academic face of efforts to undermine public health.
David Gorski on August 26, 2024
Link
If there was one thing that I would not have predicted—but, arguably, should have been able to predict—regarding the COVID-19 pandemic, it’s the degree to which my fellow academics, particularly physicians and scientists, would contribute to public fear, misunderstanding, and doubt about public health interventions utilized to mitigate the worst of the pandemic. If I had been able to predict the level of complicity of my fellow academics in advocating for just letting the disease rip in a futile bid to achieve “natural herd immunity,” opposing tried-and-true interventions to slow the spread of respiratory diseases (e.g., masking) using a narrow fundamentalist interpretation of evidence-based medicine (EBM), promoting unproven “repurposed drugs” as near miracle cures, and even fear mongering about vaccines, I might have been able to predict that Stanford University would end up being the epicenter of such activities, if only because of its tight affiliation with the right wing think tank, The Hoover Institution. If that weren’t enough, then the fact that one of the authors of the Great Barrington Declaration, the document advocating a “let ‘er rip” approach to the pandemic promising “natural herd immunity” in six months, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, is Stanford faculty should have helped. So should the fact that Dr. John Ioannidis, formerly the greatest EBM guru (whom I once admired) who very early in the pandemic took a heel turn in favor of minimizing how dangerous COVID-19 was and advocating—you guessed it—”natural herd immunity” approaches to the pandemic.
That background is why, while I was disappointed, I wasn’t entirely surprised to start seeing posts like this on social media:
Sweet Jesus. Vinay Prasad and Monica Ghandi the two people who have literally not once been correct? The very people who have disabled and killed ppl with their misinformation?
— CleanTheAir #CleanTheAirInSchools (@ProHealth4MyKid) August 25, 2024
Vinay Prasad and Monica Ghandi are only two of the participants in this conference and, arguably, not even the worst ones.
And:
It's not so much that these individuals should be censored or the conference cancelled, But balance is needed. Their (shoddy) track records and (highly compromising) conflicts and incentives should be examined and laid bare.@SalvMattera @michaelzlin
— If I may… (@Mr_Inquisitr) August 25, 2024
Actually, given the way the conference is organized, I suspect that any “balance” would turn out to be false balance, in which the opinions of the academics who have turned into cranks are represented as being equal to the opinions of public health scientists.
Of course, four years later, I’ve become all too familiar with the dismal track record of certain prominent Stanford University faculty with respect to promoting bad science, pseudoscience, and misinformation about the pandemic. For example, look what happened to Renée DiResta, who was the technical research manager at Stanford Internet Observatory, a cross-disciplinary program of research, teaching and policy engagement for the study of adversarial abuse in current information technologies. Unfortunately, the example of DiResta is just another example of why Stanford has gotten even more problematic. The mission of the Stanford Internet Observatory has been “refocused,” with Stanford having having ended the Election Integrity Partnership’s rapid-response election observation work designed to analyze and counter election misinformation. As a result of Republican pressure, the Stanford Internet Observatory is in essence being dismantled right before the election, and Stanford didn’t renew DiResta’s contract or the contracts of several other employees.
Naturally, I was intrigued. So let’s take a look at this one-day conference, who is participating, and how these participants have “distinguished themselves” as—alas!—highly influential (mostly) academic pandemic minimizers and COVID-19 misinformation spreaders.
Pandemic Policy: Planning the Future, Assessing the Past?
The title of the conference is Pandemic Policy: Planning the Future, Assessing the Past, which should tell you a lot? For example, knowing who the speakers and panelists are, I know that “assessing the past” will likely consist of highly revisionist history of the COVID-19 pandemic presented through the lens of claiming that public health interventions didn’t work and then justifying a “plan” for the future in which all those pesky public health measures that interfered with “freedom” be minimized or not used at all. Let’s take a look at how the conference is being advertised:
Bringing together esteemed academics, public health practitioners, journalists, and government officials from all sides of the COVID-19 policy debate in conversation with one another with an eye toward reforms in science and public health to better serve the public.
With millions of lives lost, the COVID-19 pandemic wrought havoc on the world. Despite decades of planning for the “next” pandemic, public health systems faced tremendous stress and often buckled and failed. Universities served as centers for valuable scientific work but failed to support their academic freedom mission by sponsoring vigorous discussion and debate on matters of pandemic policy. To do better in the next pandemic, we need to learn the lessons of the COVID-19 era.
“Esteemed academics, public health practitioners, journalists, and government officials from all sides of the COVID-19 policy debate”? My first reaction was to laugh derisively. No, far from “all sides” are represented. The best that could be said is that the truly radical “infect the all to reach ‘natural herd immunity’ faster” contingent—e.g., Scott Atlas (yes, that Scot Atlas!)— is “balanced” by those who think that it was acceptable to do some public health interventions and try to save some lives, as long as the interventions weren’t too “onerous” (by their definition) and didn’t disrupt business or school too much (again, by their definition). It’s like the line from 1980 movie The Blues Brothers in which the owner of a bar where the Blues Brothers were been booked to play answers their question about what kind of music the bar features: “We got both kinds. We got country and western!”
“We got both kinds of COVID contrarianism. We got “‘natural herd immunity’ infect them all”-based COVID minimization and COVID antivax!”
Here’s another thing that I noticed about this conference that I bet most did not, even those rightfully criticizing Stanford for hosting a conference of this type: its date, October 4, 2024. Does that date ring any bells? It did immediately for me. Why? Because it’s the fourth anniversary of the signing of the Great Barrington Declaration, which was signed on October 4, 2020 and then released to the world the following day. I have a hard time believing that the selection of this particular date for this particular Stanford conference was not entirely intentional, given the involvement a signatory of the Great Barrington Declaration (Sunetra Gupta) and GBD-adjacent faculty as a panelists. I could be wrong—and maybe I am wrong—but it’s hard not to see the choice of date as very intentional. Another oddity is that October 4 is during Rosh Hashanah, one of the most important Jewish holidays, with the site even noting this thusly, “We are aware that the conference date coincides with Rosh Hashanah. We deeply appreciate the significance of this holiday and regret the overlap.” I guess lining the conference up with the fourth anniversary of the signing of the GBD was too important to schedule the conference on a day when Jewish faculty could attend.
OK, I’ll stop, as I know I’m risking starting to sound as conspiratorial as some of the faculty recruited as panelists for this conference!
Still, it’s worth a brief reminder. The Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) was a “scientific” declaration facilitated by the right wing “free market” think tank, the American Institute for Economic Research (AIER). Named for the location of AIER’s headquarters in Great Barrington, Massachusetts, the GBD called for what was, in essence, a “let ‘er rip” approach to the pandemic to achieve “natural herd immunity” in six months by letting the young and healthy just get COVID and using “focused protection” to keep those at high risk of death and complications from COVID safe. It’s a tactic that never would have worked—and didn’t work—and was profoundly social Darwinist at its heart. Of particular note, how “focused protection” would work was never really spelled out in sufficient detail to determine just how the GBD signatories would keep those most at risk for death and severe disease due to COVID-19 safe.
Also, adding to the imprimatur of Stanford University being placed on this conference, Stanford President Jonathan Levin will be providing the opening remarks to introduce the day’s proceedings. Of note, he became President of Stanford on August 1, 2024; so he’s new in the job. I also note that the Wayback Machine shows that the conference’s webpage first went live on or around August 2, a placeholder that described the conference, but left all the speakers and panelists to be “announced later,” which they were last week. Most likely, this conference was being organized before Levin officially became Stanford University president, but it is disturbing that he would basically agree to participate, even in the ceremonial manner that most university presidents giving opening remarks at a university-hosted conference do.
Levin, of course, is not a public health scientist or physician. Rather, he is an economist who was elevated to university president after having served before that as the Dean of the Stanford Graduate School of Business. He’s also a collaborator who has published with Dr. Jay Bhattacharya before in economics journals. Even thought Bhattacharya is not a speaker or panelist, it makes sense that Levin would be amenable to participating by introducing the conference.
Let’s look at the various sessions of this conference.
“Evidence-Based Decision Making During a Pandemic”?
Session 1 is entitled Evidence-Based Decision Making During a Pandemic. The blurb describing it seems benign enough; that is, if you are unfamiliar with the participants:
The interventions undertaken to control the COVID-19 pandemic – lockdowns, extended school closures, social distancing, mask mandates, vaccine mandates – were unprecedented in their scope and global impact. How well did these policies work to protect the public from COVID-19 and what were their collateral harms? How can scientists better inform pandemic policy in real time during the next pandemic?
Of course, the key aspect of the GBD and pandemic minimizers is that they always underplay the harm of the virus and overplay the “collateral damage” from public health policy designed to address the pandemic. One of the key giveaways here is the choice of “language,” particularly “lockdowns.” Basically, “lockdowns” has turned into one of those right wing dog whistles that the “freedom über alles” contingent always uses—usually with a sneer—to describe business and school closures and shelter in place orders. It is true that there were business and school closures, there was never anything in terms of policy that approached the sorts of real “lockdowns” that one saw in some authoritarian regimes, in particular China. Moreover, again, the GBD was never about protecting the public from COVID-19. It was about opening up the country for business as fast as possible without regard for harms that the “young and healthy” might suffer from the virus, and only a passing nod to protecting those who were actually the most vulnerable to severe disease and death from COVID-19. Again, as I like to point out, “natural herd immunity” was always a pipe dream for SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, given that natural herd immunity requires lifelong—or at least very long-lasting—postinfection immunity. It was known in 2020 that postinfection immunity from coronaviruses tended to be relatively brief and that coronaviruses were good at evolving variants that could bypass preexisting immunity as a result of infection with prior variants. One had to ignore everything that was known about coronaviruses before 2020 to think that “natural herd immunity” was even a possibility, much less than the truly fantastical belief that it could be achieved in six months.
But let’s look at the participants in this session:
Eran Bendavid, Professor of Health Policy, Stanford
Monica Gandhi, Professor of Medicine, UCSF
Marty Makary, Chief of Islet Transplant Surgery, Johns Hopkins
Anders Tegnell, Former Swedish State Epidemiologist
Drs. Marty Makary and Monica Gandhi have been discussed many times on this blog, mostly by Dr. Jonathan Howard, but also by me. Makary, you might remember, was one of the originators of the false claim that medical errors are the third leading cause of death in the US, a claim based on ridiculous extrapolation from relatively small studies that doesn’t pass even a basic “smell test.” What I mean by that is that, 250K-400K deaths from medical errors would translate to up to 15% of all deaths and over half of the deaths of hospitalized patients in the US that occur every single year. The real number, although still too high, is likely 10- to 20-fold lower. As embarrassed as I was then that Dr. Makary shares my specialty (surgical oncology), I was even more embarrassed at how he quickly became a COVID-19 minimizer starting very early in the pandemic, repeatedly proclaiming an “end to the pandemic” because we’ll have herd immunity” by this date or other and repeatedly being wrong about the pandemic being over.
Monica Gandhi probably represents one of the “both kinds” of COVID-19 minimization in that throughout the pandemic she presented herself as the “reasonable” middle ground between “let ‘er rip” ideologues like Makary and Atlas and conventional public health science recommending standard public health interventions to mitigate the pandemic, viewing the latter as too strict, all the while polluting the COVID-19 information landscape with obvious misinformation and falsely pacified people the worst was over, when in fact the worst was yet to come. Basically, she tried to have it both ways, as Dr. Howard described:
Though she initially said, “It’s simple math. We don’t need to vaccinate those under 11 to get to herd immunity”, she eventually wrote an passionate defense of pediatric COVID vaccination, for example. It’s also likely she will discuss uncontroversial blunders, such as the CDC’s botched tests at the start and the tragedy of those who died due to anti-vaccine misinformation. Who could argue with her call to encourage outdoor activities?
However, these potential areas of agreement aside, Dr. Gandhi unleashed a firehose of poor predictions and bogus statistics throughout the pandemic, always minimizing the virus, of course. If you are unfamiliar with her overwhelming litany of pollyannaish prognostications, repeated declarations of herd immunity, and mocking those who disagreed- “I genuinely with all my heart apologize for anyone who continues to try to scare you about variants“- I suggest you familiarize yourself here: Pandemic Accountability Index, Mehdi Hasan, me, and me again.
Those last few links are excellent summaries of why Dr. Gandhi has been so problematic.
But what about the other two? I’m less familiar with Eran Bendavid other than that he, too, is Stanford faculty, but he has featured on this blog before. For example, he was coauthor with Drs. Jay Bhattacharya and John Ioanndis of an early infamous study that vastly overestimated the seroprevalence of COVID-19 in Santa Clara county and was widely used to argue that the infection fatality rate (IFR) was so low that we didn’t really need to do anything—hint: “lockdowns,” masking, and social distancing—to address COVID-19. He also co-authored a March 2020 op-ed with Bhattacharya in the conservative Wall Street Journal asking, Is the Coronavirus as Deadly as They Say? (You can guess their answer.) As we here at SBM like to remind our readers, pretty much everything Jay Bhattacharya has said about the pandemic has turned out to be spectacularly wrong, particularly his predictions. As for Bendavid, as he decried the “Faustian bargain” that made pandemic scientists media figures in 2021, he also revealed a bit too much of an open mind, to the point of being open enough to allow one’s brains to fall out:
The ideal scientist comes into her trade with a sense of wonder, curiosity, openness, and marvel at what nature has to show us. The corruption of scientific norms is a collective manifestation of the erosion of many scientists’ spirits. Many—I would venture most—scientists hold that spirit as a personal ideal. Its erosion happens when science gets blended with social, economic, and psychological forces that exploit the human being inside the scientist, and none more strongly than the media with its fondness for conflict, strife, and black-or-white-ism.
This all sounds lovely, if you don’t know the actual context and the veritable cottage industry of contrarian scientists who stoked fear, uncertainty, and doubt about public health—and continue to do so—and that Bendavid collaborated willingly with scientists who are experts at the very dark arts he self-righteously decries.
As for Anders Tegnell, those who sought to minimize the severity of COVID-19 and advocate a “let ‘er rip” approach loved Sweden because, supposedly, its policies were not so restrictive, while falsely representing Sweden’s COVID-19 results as being as good or better than its neighbors. (And, yes, Sweden did close schools.) Tegnell was a central figure in this and has represented himself as some sort of truth teller who stood up to conventional wisdom (and was right). Let’s just say that GBD author Martin Kulldorff thanked Tegnell in March 2020 for his “wise epidemiological sane Covid-19 work.” What did he mean by that? Pursuing a “natural herd immunity” approach to the pandemic, of course! He also declared in March 2020, “Herd immunity before vaccine is inevitable, basically no matter what we do to prevent it.” By April 2020, he was voicing the delusion that there “may be herd immunity in Stockholm by May.” (How did that work out?) Again, the Pandemic Accountability Index has a roundup of Tegnell’s actions and quotes that demonstrate clearly that he was solidly in the “natural herd immunity” camp, as well as a deconstruction of the “Swedish myth” that Sweden did well because of that approach and evidence of how much of a fanboy Tegnell was of one of the most notorious social media influencers pushing COVID-19 misinformation, Ivor Cummins, a.k.a. The Fat Emperor.
Truly, a “fair and balance” panel. I’m sure they’ll express a moderate, evidence-baed take on the successes and failures of public health interventions for COVID-19. (Yes, that’s sarcasm, in case it wasn’t obvious.)
Onward to Session #2.
Pandemic Policy from a Global Perspective?
The second session is entitled Pandemic Policy from a Global Perspective. It is represented thusly:
Because the world economy is global in scope, pandemic policy decisions made by Western governments had profound impacts on the health and economic prospects of people worldwide, including the collapse of global markets, severe supply chain disruptions, large-scale government borrowing to finance pandemic policies, and global inflation. How can the interests of the world’s poor be better represented in the decisions of Western government during the next pandemic?
Yes, you can guess what this will be about. It will likely misrepresent real concerns and debates about disparities in pandemic response, access to vaccines, and health care capacity in poor nations compared to rich nations being exacerbated by the responses of wealthy Western governments as reasons that we should have just pursued a “natural herd immunity” approach. Yes, I’ve seen this movie before. The basic argument is that, because the populations of less developed, poorer nations tend to be on average younger than the populations of more developed nations, letting the virus rip in such countries can achieve “natural herd immunity” faster and with less potential suffering and death than in developed countries (although this fact never stopped that GBD-adjacent from arguing that we should pursue “natural herd immunity” in developed countries too). Never mind that the crowding, the poorer health and nutrition, and the much less robust healthcare infrastructure in such countries would likely obviate any “advantage” in terms of lower morbidity and mortality when a younger population undergoes mass infection.
Let’s look at the participants:
Kevin Bardosh, Applied Medical Anthropologist, University of Washington
Sunetra Gupta, Professor of Theoretical Epidemiology, Oxford University
Anup Malani, Professor of Law, University of Chicago
Vinay Prasad, Professor of Medicine, UCSF
I won’t say much more about Sunetra Gupta, given that she was one of the authors of the GBD and remains an advocate of “natural herd immunity.” Nor do I find it necessary to say a lot about Dr. Vinay Prasad, given that he’s been one of the most prolific social media influencers promoting COVID-19 minimization, antimask misinformation, and even fear mongering about the COVID-19 vaccines that has expanded to echoing old antivax tropes about the childhood vaccine schedule. Suffice to say that Dr. Prasad opposed the COVID-19 vaccine for children even before it was approved for children; has portrayed cancern about the virus as “irrational” fear; embraced the antivax message of “do not comply”; frequently misrepresented studies as demonstrating the the COVID-19 vaccine is dangerous; approved of reporting parents who want to vaccinated their children against COVID-19 to child protective services; has repeatedly denied that virus mitigation measures work; and echoed antivaxxer Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s misleading claim that most of the childhood vaccination schedule has never been tested against saline placebo controls in RCTs.
I’m not as familiar with Kevin Bardosh and Anup Malani as perhaps I should be. Bardosh is Director and Head of Research at Collateral Global, a research institute and educational charity based in the UK. He is also affiliated with the School of Public Health, University of Washington and Edinburgh Medical School, and a perusal of his X (Twitter) feed shows that he is very much on the side of emphasizing the harms of the world’s COVID-19 response compared to any benefits. Collateral Global is anything but a pro-public health organization, too. Basically, it’s a GBD-adjacent, anti-“lockdown” org formed by GBD author Gupta and others:
Collateral Global is founded and directed by Sunetra Gupta and her partner Alexander Caccia, a UK Ministry of Defence contractor with ties to Canadian government fossil fuel investments, who had secretly drafted the GBD document. He had also secured PR support for Gupta’s claims about herd immunity from an agency linked to the Cabinet Office ‘Nudge Unit’. OpenDemocracy has now revealed that Gupta personally received funding for her discredited research on herd immunity from a Tory billionaire.
Indeed, it appears to have been formed by all three GBD authors, as discussed in this email:
From the depth of our hearts, a belated thank you for signing the Great Barrington Declaration. With over 850,000 signatures, together we opened up the pandemic debate. While many governments continued with their failed lockdown and other restrictive policies, things have moved in the right direction. For example, most schools have re-opened, most countries prioritized older people for vaccination and Florida rejected restrictions in favor of focused protection without the negative consequencesthat lockdowners predicted.
While occasionally censored, we have not been silenced. Since authoring the Declaration in October 2020, the three of us have actively advocated for focused protection through social media, op-eds and interviews on, for example, vaccine passports and natural immunity.
We have also launched Collateral Global, a charity staffed with academics from across the world to document and disseminate information about the collateral damage of the restrictive measures so that we don’t repeat the mistakes of this pandemic and are able to inform future policy with evidence and analysis. Collateral Global is crowdfunding so that this work can be done to the highest possible standards. You are welcome to join us and help us in those efforts at www.collateralglobal.org, as well as follow us on Twitter, etc. We are also planning an initiative on scientific freedom soon.
With enormous gratitude,
Jay Bhattacharya Sunetra Gupta Martin Kulldorff
Well, alrighty then. Of course, if you don’t believe me, feel free to peruse its website, where Kevin Bardosh bemoaned the WHO calling misinformation spreaders “conspiracy theorists” (which the vast majority of them are). He also published (with several of the usual suspects, including Makary, Prasad, and others) an infamous article arguing that college booster mandates were unethical, based on inappropriate comparisons.
As for Anup Malani, he’s an Indian economist and lawyer, faculty at the University of Chicago, not a public health scientist or physician. He seems to think that because economists are good at statistics they are also good at analyzing COVID-19:
On this I disagree. 1/ Empirical economists are good at…stats. And stats are useful for analyzing Covid data. See eg recent AER-I paper on selection bias in COVID surveillance.2/ Fields (including economics!) often get trapped in particular ways of thinking about things.… https://t.co/FWBmjcAOza
— Anup Malani (@anup_malani) December 22, 2023
While I don’t disagree that sometimes an “outsider” can bring a new perspective to investigations, I also note that often “outsiders” lack deep subject knowledge that is possessed by actual subject experts. Perusing Malani’s publication record, I find less to object to from him, other than his being interviewed by the COVID-19 minimizers at Collateral Global. Perhaps he’s one of the “both” country and western, as well. (If anyone is more familiar with his work than I could become Googling him, perusing his publications, and looking at his social media feeds, please weigh in down in the comments.) It will also be interesting to see how he responds to the virus minimization blather of the other panelists and the borderline antivax bleatings of Dr. Prasad. If he is one of the reasonable panelists, he will likely turn out to be the token skeptic on the panel.
Onward to Session #3.
Misinformation, Censorship, and Academic Freedom?
Session #3, Misinformation, Censorship, and Academic Freedom, is the one that produced the biggest “WTF?” reaction from me, for obvious reasons, namely the panel participants. Its description is full of false dichotomies:
The pandemic saw the conflict of two clashing approaches to informing the public and protecting it against rumors and harmful falsehoods. On the one hand, governments censored information contrary to public health pronouncements in social media settings and heavily influenced traditional media sources to convey those pronouncements. On the other hand, dissident scientists and university professors sought means to reach the public with their message despite censorship and suppression. Does the suspension of free speech rights during a pandemic help keep the population better informed or does it permit the perpetuation of false ideas by governments?
“Dissident scientists”? More like “brave maverick doctors,” COVID-19 minimizers, and outright cranks, many of whom started out as one or the other of the first two and, as the pandemic progressed, evolved into the third. (Martin Kulldorff and Vinay Prasad immediately come to mind.) Also, although I wasn’t (initially) familiar with the moderator (George Tidmarsh), get a load of the panelists:
Scott Atlas, Senior Fellow, Hoover Institution
Jenin Younes, Litigation Council, New Civil Liberties Alliance
Yikes! Hosting a panel on misinformation, censorship, and academic freedom with Scott Atlas and Jenin Younes as the sole panels is a lot like having a discussion panel on childhood vaccines and autism consisting of Andrew Wakefield (godfather of the 21st century antivax movement) and Aaron Siri (a lawyer who frequently works with antivaxxers like RFK Jr. and Del Bigtree)! Also, why just two on the panel? It’s not as though the conference lineup isn’t packed with COVID-19 cranks bemoaning how they’ve supposedly been “canceled” and “censored.” Surely one or two of them could have done double-duty and appeared on two panels.
Dr. Scott Atlas, you might remember, is a neuroradiologist and, so it seems, a formerly well-respected one, having served as the chief of the neuroradiology section at Stanford University. Unfortunately, Dr. Atlas became a right wing hack at The Hoover Institution at Stanford, a conservative think tank that’s been a font of bad takes on COVID-19. In 2020, he improbably (and briefly) served as a key advisor to President Donald Trump about the government pandemic response, despite his utter lack of expertise in any relevant medical or scientific discipline to do so. Atlas, of course, has been a fairly frequent topic on this blog given all the misinformation he has spewed (and continues to spew), particularly thanks to Dr. Howard, who’s kept a careful log of his statements, most recently last month. Unsurprisingly, Dr. Atlas was entirely on board with the GBD, and, as a result, in October 2020 the Trump administration was seriously considering a herd immunity-based strategy before there was even a vaccine.
By November 2020, Stanford was distancing itself from Dr. Atlas because he had urged resistance to public health policies and mandates:
Stanford University on Monday evening distanced itself from White House coronavirus task force member Dr. Scott Atlas, a senior fellow at the school’s Hoover Institution, after he urged Michigan residents to “rise up” against new public health measures.
“Stanford’s position on managing the pandemic in our community is clear. We support using masks, social distancing, and conducting surveillance and diagnostic testing. We also believe in the importance of strictly following the guidance of local and state health authorities,” the university said in a tweet.
“Dr. Atlas has expressed views that are inconsistent with the university’s approach in response to the pandemic. Dr. Atlas’s statements reflect his personal views, not those of the Hoover Institution or the university.”
In particular, this now deleted Tweet caused an uproar, and this is personal to me because Atlas’ Tweet was in response to pandemic restrictions in Michigan:
Atlas later tried to take it back, but no one believed him:
I remember that in April 2020, armed militia menaced legislators in Michigan because they disapproved of the “lockdowns” and public health mandates that Gov. Gretchen Whitmer had ordered. I highly doubt that Dr. Atlas was unaware of that history when he urged people to “rise up.” His reaction to the criticism of his Tweet was very disingenuous.
I could go on and on about Dr. Atlas, but just use the search box on this blog or my not-so-super-secret other blog, and peruse Dr. Howard’s recent post about him.
As for Jenin Younes, yikes again! First, note that she is a lawyer who has been closely associated with AIER, under whose auspices Bhattacharya, Kuldorff, and Gupta wrote the GBD and whose Twitter handle used to be @leftylockdowns1. A brief perusal of her articles and social media feeds demonstrates that she’s all about opposing any mandatory public health response to COVID-19, including “lockdowns” and mask and vaccine mandates. Her New Civil Liberties Alliance also sued to enjoin California’s law penalizing doctors for disseminating so-called misinformation about Covid-19 to patients. So, she’s pro-quack, too.
I’m sensing a theme here for this conference. On to Session #4!
COVID-19 Origins and the Regulation of Virology?
The last session is entitled COVID-19 Origins and the Regulation of Virology. Given what’s come before, I’m sure you can guess what the focus will be here, but let’s see what the organizers say:
The stakes in the debate about the origin of the pandemic could not be higher. If the pandemic started from an inadequately regulated wildlife trade or zoonoses, reforms to reduce the likelihood of human contact with wild species is vital. On the other hand, if the pandemic started due to dangerous laboratory experiments and inadequate protocols to prevent leaks, then more stringent regulation of such experimentation is warranted. What is the evidence on these topics, and what is the path forward?
This sounds reasonable enough, particularly the first part. Note, however, the false equivalency between a zoonotic origin for the pandemic and “lab leak.” Also note the only person on this panel, which makes me wonder if they plan on adding someone else or if this will just be a talk. And who is this sole panelist? It’s Laura Kahn, Co-Founder, One Health Initiative.
I must confess that I wasn’t very familiar with Kahn, who is a physician and biosafety researcher with a book coming out in early October (surely another coincidence?) entitled One Health and the Politics of COVID-19. Some of the reviews suggest to me where she is coming from:
This book challenges One Health’s most pernicious dogma—that nature is necessarily deadlier than the consequences of human hubris. The book is especially courageous as it criticizes leading contemporary scientific powerholders who support unnecessarily risky virological work. Trust in science requires ethics and transparency.
Some of her social media posts suggest that, although she does emphasize zoonosis and how to prevent zoonotic spillover whenever possible, she is also rather open to lab lake conspiracy theories. I mean, Tweeting:
BREAKING NEWS: Rand Paul Confronts FBI's Wray About Declassifying COVID-… https://t.co/wNrVtpCVx6 via @YouTube
— Laura Kahn (@LauraKahn1) October 31, 2023
Let’s just say that treating anything Rand Paul says about COVID-19 as serious is not a good look for someone who purports to be evidence-based. Nor is credulously publicizing something like this from an anti-GMO group known for promoting lab leak conspiracy theories:
This is that anti-gmo group, right? I knew I had seen these authors before.
— Gigi Gronvall (@ggronvall) April 24, 2022
In addition, Googling found an article that she wrote for the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists in March 2022, The origins of SARS-CoV-2: still to be determined, in which she makes “lab leak”-adjacent arguments if not outright arguments for lab leak, denigrating two of the key papers published in 2022 that supported a zoonotic origin from the Wuhan animal markets, which both Steven Novella and I wrote about at the time.
Her take:
Two recent papers, Worobey et al. and Pekar et al., present geospacial analysis of animal stalls in the Huanan market and viral phylogenetic analysis but do not provide convincing evidence of natural spillover. The data and analyses discussed by Worobey are equally consistent with both hypotheses: (1) that SARS-CoV-2 first entered humans at the Huanan Seafood Market in Wuhan, and (2) that SARS-CoV-2 first entered humans at another location and was subsequently brought to the market and then amplified in the market by humans. The authors’ assertion that the data and analyses support only the natural spillover hypothesis is false.
Perhaps, but not really. The evidence in those papers is far more consistent with a SARS-CoV-2 spillover event at the Huanan Seafood Market, as Steve and I discussed. I also note that she wrote about the preprints, given that her article was published in March 2022 and the final versions of the papers were published in July 2022, honing in on one phrase that lab leak proponents really hated, to the point that they gloated over its removal in the final version of, first raging that the “hypothesis that SARS-CoV-2 originated from a laboratory-related spillover—for example, from a laboratory-acquired infection—remains a viable possibility” before proclaiming:
Science is the objective pursuit of truth. Preventing future COVID-19 pandemics requires finding the truth. Premature, false declarations of “dispositive evidence” or “proof” does not generate public trust in science and does not protect public health.
That sure sounds like a lab leak proponent argument. As I pointed out, the use of that word in the preprint really ticked off lab leakers, to the point where they responded to its removal by gloating:
Those preprints from a while ago, arguing for wet market spillover (against e.g. lab leak followed by market super-spreading), are now published.Idk when I'll get to them but at least they don't say "dispositive" anymore.https://t.co/nXAvtTN5PThttps://t.co/zyXaHuGIaP
— David Bahry (@DavidBahry) July 26, 2022
The real part of the article that raised my eyebrow, though, was in the Acknowledgements:
Kahn would like to thank Elisa Harris, Milton Leitenberg, and Richard Ebright for their invaluable comments, edits, and suggestions.
Richard Ebright? Yikes! He’s a Rutgers University chemistry professor who has been one of the most obnoxious and hostile lab leak proponents, he and his fellow lab leak believer microbiologist Bryce Nickels to scientists who publish in support of a zoonotic origin “fraudsters,” “liars,” “perjurers,” “felons,” “grifters,” “stooges,” “imbeciles,” and “murderers.” Milton Leitenberg has published with Ebright, in particular this lab leak-promoting An appeal for an objective, open, and transparent scientific debate about the origin of SARS-CoV-2 and published on his own Did the SARS-CoV-2 virus arise from a bat coronavirus research program in a Chinese laboratory? Very possibly., in which he denied that lab leak was a conspiracy theory. As for Elisa Harris, she was a cosignatory of an open letter to Nature Medicine, along with lab leak conspiracy theorists Alina Chan, Richard Ebright, and others demanding an expression of concern followed by retraction.
And…uh-oh:
Important Op Ed. Opinion | The Pandemic Probably Started in a Lab. These 5 Key Points Explain Why. – The New York Times https://t.co/K4J5UVzz1T
— Laura Kahn (@LauraKahn1) June 3, 2024
This horrible NYT op-ed by Alina Chan (called “important” by Kahn) was full-on lab leak conspiracy theory, and I discussed why soon after it was published. It’s not for nothing that I’ve referred to Chan as the queen of lab leak conspiracy theories.
I’ve changed my mind. Kahn appears to be at least lab leak-adjacent. I’ve long argued that the current version of lab leak is primarily a conspiracy theory far more than it is a useful or valid scientific hypothesis (most recently three weeks ago), but on what can be gleaned from some Googling I don’t think Kahn is a hard core lab leak proponent. She does, however, seem, at minimum, a little too receptive to the idea given how little the actual scientific evidence supports it.
Stanford should be ashamed, but won’t be
Wrapping it all up is another Stanford Professor, Dr. John Ioannidis, because of course he is. Before the pandemic, Ioannidis was someone whom I admired. Unfortunately, since the pandemic, my opinion—and that of a lot of Ioannidis’ former admirers—soured. Why? Early in the pandemic Ioannidis was quick to embrace “natural herd immunity” approaches to COVID-19 that later became the basis of the Great Barrington Declaration. Again, the GBD was a strategy that never would have worked—and didn’t work—and was profoundly social Darwinist. Although Ioannidis was not an author—indeed, in fairness he refused to sign it, although not based on disagreeing with the GBD’s premise but because of his opposition to “signing petitions” as a means of settling “questions of scientific fact”—his call early in the pandemic for what sure sounded like a variation on the idea of “focused protection” was all over the GBD. He was also a co-author, along with GBD co-author Jay Bhattacharya of the infamous Santa Clara seroprevalence study that misleadingly claimed that over 80 times more people had been exposed to COVID-19 than previously thought (and therefore the infection fatality rate, or IFR, was way lower than was being claimed, meaning COVID was not nearly as dangerous as claimed and therefore all those public health interventions were unnecessary). Ioannidis also made a vile evidence-free accusation that ICU doctors were inadvertently killing COVID patients by intubating them willy-nilly when the patients really didn’t need mechanical ventilation. And don’t even get me started on Ioannidis’ infamous “Kardashian index” paper, in which he smeared scientific critics and opponents of the GBD as “science Kardashians” using risibly bad methodology based on what was originally published as a satirical index to comment on scientists with more social media influence than influence in the scientific literature. Through it all, Ioannidis continues to treat theoretical death from a vaccine as being of more concern than actual death from COVID-19 and to falsely accuse expert panels whose conclusions he doesn’t like of “panel stacking.”
Sadly, it sounds like a very appropriate wrap-up for a conference so loaded with COVID-19 misinformers.
So what happened to Stanford? At the risk of comparing apples to oranges (although I don’t think I am), I liken it to the case of the Cleveland Clinic, an institution that is generally science- and evidence-based, but through ideology allowed in whole centers and institutes that support “integrating” quackery like “functional medicine,” acupuncture, reiki, and others into conventional medicine. How that ideology got entrenched, I don’t know, but it remains so. As for Stanford, my best guess is that it is the right-wing libertarian/conservative influence of The Hoover Institution that attracts COVID-19 contrarians opposed to anything that can be cast as a “lockdown” or any other public health mandate.
The sad thing is, whatever good public health faculty there are at Stanford, their voices do not dominate. Rather, it is the voices of the worst of the worst contrarians, like Jay Bhattacharya, Eran Bendavid, John Ioannidis, and Scott Atlas who dominate the public discourse regarding public health science coming out of Stanford. This is a propaganda-fest masquerading as a legitimate conference on public health responses during a pandemic, and Stanford University ought to be ashamed for putting its imprimatur on the whole affair.

Bastions of quackademic medicine: Georgetown University
David Gorski on July 27, 2015
Link


We frequently discuss a disturbing phenomenon known as quackademic medicine. Basically, quackademic medicine is a phenomenon that has taken hold over the last two decades in medical academia in which once ostensibly science-based medical schools and academic medical centers embrace quackery. This embrace was once called “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) but among quackademics the preferred term is now “integrative medicine.” Of course, when looked at objectively, integrative medicine is far more a brand than a specialty. Specifically, it’s a combination of rebranding some science-based modalities, such as nutrition and exercise, as somehow being “alternative” or “integrative” with the integration of outright quackery, such as reiki and “energy healing,” acupuncture, and naturopathy, into conventional medicine. As my good bud and fellow Science-Based Medicine (SBM) blogger Mark Crislip put it, mixing cow pie with apple pie does not make the cow pie better, but we seem to be “integrating” the cow pie of quackery with the apple pie of science-based medicine thinking that somehow it will improve the smell, taste, and texture of the cow pie.
I remember how, when I first discovered how prevalent outright pseudoscience and quackery had become in medical academia (which was before I became one of the founding SBM bloggers), I was in denial. I couldn’t believe it. Then I tracked this phenomenon with something I called the Academic Woo Aggregator. It turned out to be a hopeless endeavor because, as I soon discovered, the phenomenon was so pervasive that it was really hard to keep the Aggregator up to date. Since then, I’ve generally only focused on particularly egregious examples, naming names when institutions like my alma mater embrace anthroposophic medicine; “respectable” journals publish “integrative medicine” guidelines for breast cancer patients; cancer organizations include “integrative oncology” in their professional meetings; NCI-designated comprehensive cancer centers promote reiki to pediatric cancer patients or offer high dose unproven vitamin C treatment to patients; or respected academic institutions embrace traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) and the quackery that is function medicine. You get the idea. It’s depressing just how far medical academia has fallen in terms of being “open-minded” to the point of brains falling out when it comes to medical pseudoscience.
From time to time, I’ve briefly thought about reviving the academic woo aggregator, but quickly and inevitably ended up giving up trying to come up with lists of the worst of the worst. There are just too many now, and keeping such an aggregator up to date would be too much work, as I discovered when I wrote my Nature Reviews Cancer article on integrative oncology last year. However, I do believe in featuring specific institutions when something comes up that draws my attention to them, and this just happened last week with Georgetown University. Basically, a reader at my not-so-super-secret other blog pointed out the Spring/Summer issue of Georgetown Medicine Magazine. It’s an issue devoted to integrative medicine at Georgetown and it is horrifying to anyone who believes that medicine should be science-based. Not surprisingly, it was a Georgetown alumnus who was so shocked when he received this issue in the mail that his embarrassment knew no bounds for having come from that institution. Worse, from the tone of the articles in this issue, Georgetown is proud of its integrative medicine program, to the point where it is touting it as a strength and featuring it on the cover of its magazine. Just look at its cover, which features a picture of a woman preparing to get an acupuncture needle stuck somewhere, along with the title of the issue, “Caring for the whole person with integrative medicine”. Yes, it’s the “holistic” trope that drives me crazy because you don’t have to embrace quackery to be a holistic physician.
Integrating pseudoscience into the medical curriculum
Longtime readers might remember that I’ve discussed Georgetown before because it was a “pioneer” (if you can call it that) in “integrating” quackery into the medical school curriculum. Having received a grant from the then-National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM), renamed in December the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH), to integrate CAM into its core curriculum, Georgetown proceeded to do just that. Here’s an example, a blast from the past if you will, quoted from a 2003 Georgetown brochure (retrieved again, thanks to Archive.org):
“One of the reasons CAM is usually offered as an elective is that there’s just no time or room in U.S. medical schools to fit in one more massive subject,” says Michael Lumpkin, Ph.D., professor and chair of the department of physiology and biophysics at Georgetown. “When the course is an elective, a self-selected group – maybe 10 or 20 students in a class of 180 medical students – will take it,” Lumpkin says. “What we’ve tried at Georgetown is rather than create all new courses, we take relevant CAM issues and modalities and weave them seamlessly into existing courses.
The “seamless” weaving of CAM into existing classes includes, for instance, a presentation by an acupuncturist on the “anatomy of acupuncture” in the gross anatomy course for first-year students. The same lecturer explores acupuncture’s application in pain relief in the neuroscience course…
Haramati and Lumpkin say Georgetown’s program is distinct from CAM initiatives in other medical schools in two ways: The school is integrating CAM education into existing course work across all four years of each student’s medical education, and the initiative includes a mind-body class to help students use techniques to manage their own health and improve self-care.
Teaching acupuncture points during gross anatomy? You can hear the cringing of advocates of science-based medicine everywhere, given that acupuncture points do not exist except in the minds of acupuncturists, as there are no anatomic correlates to them. So what’s been going on since then? Jane Varner Malhotra tells us in Georgetown’s Evolving Study in Complementary and Alternative Therapies. Here’s what happened after Georgetown got the $1.7 million grant in 2001:
Haramati recalls some uncertainty around the method for how to actually make it happen. “We were walking a path where the advocates were saying, ‘You’ve got to do more,’ while skeptics were saying, ‘What are you doing teaching nonsense?’” he recalls. “And we were going down the path saying, ‘We’re going to look at this objectively.’”
Objectively. You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means. An objective analysis of acupuncture would not support “integrating” the teaching of acupuncture points into gross anatomy and neurology class. Once again, acupuncture points do not exist except in the minds of acupuncturists, and even then I’m not so sure.
The article also does the requisite rebranding of natural products pharmacology as somehow being “CAM,” when it’s not. There’s a pharmacologist named Hakima Amri, featured smiling with her arms crossed in one of those stereotypical poses that magazines like this like to use in their photos bragging how she had realized that in her research she was “using top-notch technology in the biomedical sciences,” such as PCR, animal studies, cell culture, all “to study a plant extract” (Ginkgo biloba). None of this, of course, is CAM.
And Georgetown credulously teaches homeopathy, The One Quackery to Rule Them All:
Amri enjoys seeing students open their minds to new concepts. Learning disciplines like homeopathy may require students to radically disregard their previous understandings about receptors and responses in toxicology, for example. “I tell students that for the next few hours, put aside all they have learned in biochemistry, pharmacology and cell biology—empty their brains—because homeopathy is a completely different concept. Then I see big eyes on their faces!” laughs Amri.
Yes, Georgetown is telling its medical students, forget all that boring old reductionist “Western” science you’ve learned all these years. Open your mind to the sympathetic magic that is homeopathy. Never mind that it has no basis in science and its precepts violate multiple well-established laws of physics and chemistry. Personally, I don’t mind a medical school teaching homeopathy, but only so that doctors know what it is and how utterly pseudoscientific it is. (Most doctors still think it’s just herbal medicine.) However, clearly that’s not what Georgetown is doing. How a pharmacologist can teach homeopathy as anything but as an example of the most abject pseudoscience is beyond me, but that’s what Amri sure appears to be doing, her claim that “we are teaching them [medical students] how to evaluate the science of the therapy, critically analyze it and learn about these medical systems in the most open-minded way” notwithstanding. She seems to be all about the open-mindedness and not so much about critical thinking, similar to the entire Georgetown CAM curriculum.
And its faculty are proud of Georgetown’s role in promoting quackademic medicine:
Since the early years of complementary medicine research and education at Georgetown, the university has held a critical place on the national scene. Hosting multiple cross-disciplinary dialogues, Georgetown has convened chiropractors and conventional doctors, acupuncturists and anesthesiologists to advance the science-based study of integrative medicine.
And:
Over the past 15 years, the way CAM has been taught at Georgetown has evolved, but the goals have remained constant: to train students to objectively and rigorously assess the safety and efficacy of various modalities, and explain the mechanistic basis for therapies like acupuncture, massage, herbs and supplements, and mind-body interactions.
If Georgetown teaches homeopathy as anything other than an example of pseudoscience and integrates acupuncture into its gross anatomy, physiology, and neuroscience curricula, it’s doing nothing of the sort. Let’s take a look at the sort of research into the “mechanisms” of acupuncture that Georgetown is so proud of.
Torturing rats in the name of acupuncture pseudoscience
In another article in the issue “Where’s the Evidence? Probing the Underlying Mechanisms of Acupuncture“, a recently-published study by a member of the Georgetown faculty is featured as a great example of how Georgetown is doing what it claims with respect to evidence for CAM. First, though, we learn that a nurse anesthetist and licensed acupuncturist Ladan Eshkevari, Ph.D., teaches sessions on acupuncture in the second year physiology class. There, she also teaches TCM medicine pulse analysis. Now, certainly every physician should know how to assess a pulse, but that’s not what’s going on here. What’s going on here is the teaching of an ancient, prescientific method of assessing pulses:
The professor of nursing, pharmacology and physiology shows the students three different pulse points on each hand used in TCM to diagnose the health of specific anatomical organs. The best practitioners employ over 70 different ways to describe the subtle variations in the human pulse, she explains, as the students touch their own wrists. Is the pulse skipping, surging, floating, faint? Determining the right descriptor can be a challenge, Eshkevari adds, but the richness of the options reveals the complexity and nuance of the ancient practice.
“In traditional Chinese medicine, organs are viewed by their energy function, not their anatomic function,” Eshkevari continues, showing visual maps of the body linking heart and small intestine, lung and large intestine. She explains that with holistic medicine, everything is connected, versus the more typical American, allopathic medical practice of dividing the body into compartments and developing specialties.
One notes that these “subtle variations” are in general not reproducibly detected from practitioner to practitioner and have little or no evidence to show that they reliably link to specific organs. The same is true of tongue diagnosis in TCM, in which different organs are mapped to different parts of the tongue, such that examining the tongue can lead to diagnoses of abnormalities of specific organs. It’s utter nonsense, of course, no more than a TCM version of reflexology, which does the same thing, only mapping organs and body parts to the soles of the feet and palms of the hand. Yet at Georgetown, TCM reflexology is taught as fact.
Let’s take a look at the study that is featured in a large chunk of this article:
Eshkevari turned to rats to help her find answers. Using a successful stress model developed by a fellow researcher at Georgetown, she exposed three of four groups of animals to one hour a day in a container with a layer of ice water on the bottom. After two weeks, the rats measured high stress hormone levels that would not come down to baseline. They had chronic stress.
Won’t someone think of the poor lab rats?

Note that in the accompanying photo, Eshkevari is shown in the same pose as everyone else, arms crossed, with the exception that the smile is missing and she’s wearing a lab coat standing in front of an impressive lab bench full of chemicals and instruments, the better to paint the picture of her in the mind of the reader as a Very Serious Scientist. At least the photographer restrained himself from filling up Erlenmyer flasks and beakers with multicolored solutions, which is the ultimate photographic cliché in stories of this sort. I also note that the Georgetown magazine story seems to be part of a PR offensive to promote this study, complete with a press release and breathlessly credulous descriptions of the story in the media with titles like “Rats help scientists get closer to solving the mystery of acupuncture.”
In any case, these stories follow a template. Basically, every study is represented as “the strongest evidence yet” that the “ancient Chinese therapy” (which, remember, really isn’t particularly ancient, at least not the way it’s currently practiced) is more than placebo and that a definitive mechanism has been found through which this magic works. In this particular case, notice how it’s claimed that acupuncture does the same thing as actual drugs used to treat stress and pain. So it must be real! In every case, if you go and look at the actual study, there’s way less there then is being sold. This case is no different, as I saw when I looked up the actual study, “Effects of Acupuncture, RU-486 on the Hypothalamic-Pituitary-Adrenal Axis in Chronically Stressed Adult Male Rats.”
The first thing I noticed about this study is that it uses a common bait-and-switch favored by acupuncturists, in which they do something called “electroacupuncture” (EA). Basically, EA is acupuncture plus electricity. Acupuncture needles are stuck in the subject at the various acupuncture points and hooked up to an electrical source, after which as weak electrical current is applied. Whenever I see this bait-and-switch, the first question that comes to my mind is: Those ancient Chinese must have been really brilliant to have discovered how to use electricity thousands of years ago! Obviously, attaching electrodes to acupuncture needles is a modern twist on acupuncture, which is why all the language about this “ancient Chinese therapy” is so grating. Indeed, the Georgetown Medicine article claims that acupuncture dates back 4,000 years, which is further than I’ve ever heard anyone claim. One wonders how Bronze Age craftsmen made such exquisitely thin needles. In any case, EA is not ancient at all, nor is it acupuncture. Really, it’s just transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) grafted onto acupuncture to produce a mutant Frankenstein’s monster of a therapy that has little to do with either. When I see a study like this, my usual reaction is a big, “Meh.” This doesn’t demonstrate that acupuncture works. If it demonstrates anything at all (which is questionable) it demonstrates that passing an electrical current through the skin has physiological effects.
Does this study demonstrate anything? Let’s take a look. There were two experiments. In the first, the investigators divided the rats into four groups. Three of these groups were stressed and divided into groups receiving electroacupuncture, sham acupuncture (delivered to an area that is not an acupuncture point), and a third group that did not receive acupuncture. A fourth group of animals served as controls; they received no acupuncture and were not subjected to the stress stimulus. The stressed animals were placed in a 1 cm deep ice water bath for one hour daily for 14 days, after which they were returned to their cages. On day 5 experimental treatments were begun, which consisted of acupuncture or sham acupuncture 30 minutes after the cold exposure. (Poor rats.) The acupuncture point used was St36, which in humans is on the leg, one finger width lateral from the anterior boarder of the tibia and four finger breadths below the patella. Its action and effects are said to include:
    • Tonify deficient Qi a/or Blood.
    • Tonify Wei Qi and Qi overall – low immunity, chronic illness, poor digestion, general weakness, particularly with moxibustion, very important acupuncture point for building and maintaining overall health.
    • All issues involving the Stomach a/or the Spleen – abdominal/epigastric pain, borborygmus, bloating, nausea, vomiting, GERD, hiccups, diarrhea, constipation, etc.
    • Clear disorders along the course of the channel – breast problems, lower leg pain.
    • Earth as the mother of Metal – will support Lung function in cases of asthma, wheezing, dyspnea.
    • Psychological/Emotional disorders – PMS, depression, nervousness, insomnia.
Whatever.

The nonacupuncture point used as “sham” for sham electroacupunture (sham-EA) was on the back 2 cm lateral to the tail region. The needles were then attached to an electroacupuncture machine via electrodes and were stimulated for 20 minutes at a frequency of 10 Hz with 2 mA output. Ten of the 14 rats in both the sham-EA and the EA St36 groups continued to receive EA for the 14 days that they were exposed to the cold stress. However, after 10 days, 4 of the animals in each of the sham-EA and EA St36 groups stopped receiving the EA treatments, whereas exposure to cold stress was continued for the remaining 4 days, to determine whether the effects of the sham-EA and/or EA St36 were long lasting.
In a second experiment, rats were assigned to five groups: Group 1 (no treatment and no RU-486); group 2 (no treatment but started RU-486 at day 10); group 3 (daily cold stress and start RU-486 at day 10); group 4 (sham EA + RU-486 + cold stress); and group 5 (EA + RU-486 + cold stress). The mice were also tested in other stress tests, including the forced swim tests and open field test. In this case, RU-486 was not used for its properties that allow it to work as a “morning after” pill, but rather for its ability to block the glucocorticoid receptor, the hypothesis being that however EA “works” it does so through glucocorticoid (steroids), a hormone signaling axis known as the hypothalamic pituitary adrenal (HPA) axis, which mediates stress.
The first thing I noticed was that levels of ACTH (which stimulates cortisol production) and cortisol were not impressively different, particularly ACTH (Figure 1; the paper is open-access if you want to check for yourself). Indeed, the differences in ACTH are so modest that my reaction was a yawn. Cortisol showed more difference, but a most unimpressive difference between EA and sham-EA. In the second experiment, there were a whole lot of graphs that didn’t show much difference in anything. The best that the authors could say is that RU-486 didn’t affect EA or sham-EA, but that ACTH didn’t go up in the St36 group. It was reported that stress behaviors were less in stressed EA St36 animals, but looking at the graphs sure didn’t impress me. Basically, the authors conclude that application of EA St36 after initiation of chronic stress prevents the stress-induced increases in the hormones evaluated, adding that “this action may be specific to EA St36 vs the sham points used, as sham-EA does not prevent the rise in stress hormones as effectively.” One notes that the sham treatment did have an effect. The effect, if real, was very modest.
There were a lot of other problems, as well. For instance, it’s important to note that the controls chosen were not exactly…robust. There was no group of rats in which the needle was inserted but no current was applied, nor was there another non-St36 control. (Choosing one “incorrect” acupuncture point to apply “sham” acupuncture to might be (barely) justifiable in human trials because of how hard it is to get enough subjects, but in an animal trial there is no excuse. How do the investigators know they weren’t just lucky picking their control? Also, there is no mention of blinding. Zero. Zilch. Since humans were evaluating behavior in the second experiment, it was critical that the observer doing the evaluations of how the rats reacted to the swim test and open field test were blinded to the experimental group from which the rats came. This appears not to have done. Finally, as noted on PubPeer, a website for post-publication peer review, Figures 6B and 6C appear to be the same figure even though they are said to represent different experiments.
The kindest description of the conclusions of this study is that it shows that running electrical current through the leg, as opposed to running current through the skin of the back, might decrease stress by decreasing the effect of stress hormones. It does not show that acupuncture works. A more realistic description of these results is that they don’t show much of anything that is scientifically interesting. One even wonders if, for instance, there is a simpler explanation, namely that having a needle stuck in the leg and having current run through it hurts less than having a needle stuck in the back and having current run through it. There’s no way of knowing because we can’t ask the rat. Alternatively, I also note that St36 is rather close to the sciatic nerve, whereas the acupuncture point on the flank used for the sham-EA control is nowhere near a major nerve.
Basically, this is a poorly done study with small numbers that doesn’t even test acupuncture but electricity. If this is the “evidence” for acupuncture that Georgetown touts, it’s thin gruel indeed. Yet it was published in a respectable journal, Endocrinology. Clearly, Endocrinology needs a better class of peer reviewers, as peer review utterly failed in this case.
Unfortunately, this doesn’t stop Eshkevari from wanting to “translate” these results to the clinic:
The next stage for her research will be human trials—an expensive and complicated endeavor but one she is determined to explore.
“This is where I’m now stuck,” she explains. “I’m trying to get grant funding to do research on humans to see if these discoveries translate.”
Eshkevari remains hopeful that, with rising interest from both the public and scientific communities, this next critical step will find support.
To me, it would be unethical to carry out a human study based on such poor quality and equivocal preclinical evidence. Unfortunately, it would not surprise me if Eshkevari succeeds in getting funding to do one. Such is the pernicious effect of quackademic medicine on clinical trial ethics. Eshkevari argues that doctors didn’t know how inhalational anesthesia worked when it was first discovered but used it anyway, the implication being that we should not be uncomfortable using acupuncture because we don’t yet understand its mechanism of action. Does anyone see the flaw in that reasoning? It’s obvious. That inhalational anesthesia worked was indisputable. In contrast, there is no good evidence that acupuncture works better than placebo. This brings up another problematic attitude in the mindset of quackademics:
“Western, allopathic physicians and nurse practitioners want to be able to point to the evidence, and see the research published in peer-reviewed journals,” says Eshkevari. “This helps us comfortably recommend complementary medicine to our patients. Finding the evidence—I think that’s the biggest step.”
In other words, rather than finding out if acupuncture works, quackademics like Eshkevari assume that it does work and then go chasing mechanisms. It is, as Harriet Hall so aptly described it, Tooth Fairy science.
Faith healing in the chemotherapy suite
I frequently call homeopathy The One Quackery To Rule Them All. However, there is a definite challenger for that title, which can be looked at a different way as well; i.e., as Saruman trying to usurp Sauron on his dark throne. I’m referring, of course, to “energy medicine.” Whatever form energy medicine takes, it’s based on prescientific vitalism of a variety that posits the existence of a “life energy” that can be manipulated or infused into the patient for healing effect.
The two most common forms of energy medicine in quackademia are therapeutic touch and reiki. Therapeutic touch (TT) is a misnomer in that it doesn’t usually involve actual touching (which negates the potential pleasure of a good massage or back rub), but rather involves the placing of hands close to the body. It rests on the concept that there is a human “energy field” that TT practitioners can manipulate to make patients feel better. It’s a concept so ludicrous that even an 11 year old girl could show that TT practitioners cannot detect a human energy field any better than random chance alone would allow them to guess. Unfortunately, TT is almost ubiquitous in nursing programs and hospitals. The second is reiki. The main differences between the two are that (1) reiki involves more elaborate hand gestures and (2) reiki posits the existence of an external source of life energy (the “universal source”) into which the reiki practitioner can tap to direct the healing energy into the patient. Reiki is, in essence, faith healing based on Eastern mysticism rather than the Christian religion. Unfortunately, reiki is commonly offered in many medical centers, academic or community, and even in NCI-designated comprehensive cancer centers.
Including Georgetown’s, apparently, as shown in the Georgetown Medicine article, “A Patient’s Experience With Energy Healing“:
For a long time Denise von Hengst had a secret she kept from friends and physicians alike. As she was undergoing treatment at Georgetown Lombardi Comprehensive Cancer Center for a particularly aggressive type of breast cancer—triple positive, HER2 positive—she was also regularly receiving Reiki, an ancient form of Japanese healing, to mitigate the debilitating anxiety and fear that accompanied her cancer diagnosis.
“At first I told no one about the Reiki,” says von Hengst. “Fear of the ‘woo-woo’ factor. People might think I’m nuts.”
No, a patient like Denise von Hengst is not “nuts,” although, it must be noted, she discovered reiki before coming to Georgetown for her cancer and ultimately became a reiki master. However, the Georgetown Lombardi Comprehensive Cancer Center is unethical and irresponsible for offering, in essence, magic to its patients as therapy. If I were not a physician and didn’t know anything about reiki, if an NCI-designated comprehensive cancer center offered it I’d think it must be evidence-based. That’s how most patients perceive it. The failure is on Georgetown’s part for offering reiki as though it were anything more than prescientific vitalistic superstition and claiming that it has a scientific basis, not on the part of patients like von Hengst, who trust that doctors are offering science-based therapy. In this case, Georgetown reinforced von Hengst’s initial attraction to reiki by giving it the appearance of scientific validity.
To her credit, the author of this article does acknowledge the “skepticism” that doctors have about reiki:
However, skepticism remains, not only in the general population, but also within the medical field. Recently, several clinical trials have emerged attempting to prove, or disprove, the effectiveness of Reiki. Many of these studies have been criticized for the trial. design, number of participants and reporting mechanisms. Results of the trials are often inconclusive.
Note that Bayes theorem tells us that “inconclusive” results plus an incredibly implausible mechanism = negative trial. So, yes, these are are negative trials. None of that matters, though, because the article quickly shifts gears to use anecdotal evidence and appeals to authority and popularity:
Yet as the anecdotal proof mounts and Reiki’s popularity increases, prestigious medical centers around the country are taking note and offering the treatment to patients at their facilities. Reiki can be found at hospitals and medical centers such as Boston Children’s Hospital, Dana Farber Cancer Institute, Stanford Health Care, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, Duke University Health System and Cleveland Clinic, to name a few. Many academic medical centers such as Georgetown incorporate complementary therapies into their teaching curricula.
And all of these hospitals have failed to uphold a science-based standard of care. Sadly, they are not alone. Far from it. Worse, they are training the next generation of doctors to embrace pseudoscience.
Integrating quackery: The future of medicine?
Perhaps the most disturbing part of this issue of Georgetown Medicine is an article entitled “Putting Integrative Medicine Into Practice.” Basically, it’s a profile of medical students and recent Georgetown graduates doing exactly what the title says. It also includes a profile of an acupuncturist named Rebecca Berkson, who works at a Georgetown-affiliated facility, the Kaplan Center for Integrative Medicine in McLean, Virginia. In the name of Georgetown, she provides “acupuncture, its associated techniques including moxabustion and cupping, and Chinese herbal medicine.” Cupping, remember, claims to remove unnamed “toxins” from the skin thusly:
It’s a treatment almost as ridiculous as TT, and it’s being offered at Georgetown as though it has validity.
There’s also a medical student from the Howard University class of 2015 named Brian Nwannunu. He graduated from Georgetown’s CAM master’s degree program. Now he’s a believer:
My plan is to go into orthopedic surgery. For my patients experiencing back pain, I will work with CAM practitioners such as acupuncturists and chiropractors in addition to offering allopathic medicine. After my own experience with a low-back injury during a workout, I went to a chiropractor for a few weeks and felt tremendously better.
And:
I took a holistic medicine and pediatrics course last summer, and people were speaking quietly about homeopathy. I find it interesting to see how many practitioners approach complementary medicine like it’s voodoo. But that is changing. As holistic medicine becomes more prevalent, more students are talking about it, and we’re being taught to be aware and accepting.
Pardon me while I pound my head against the nearest wall.
Then there’s Megan Blunda, who graduated from Georgetown in 2011 and is now a family practice doctor:
I worked with Steve Schwartz, M.D., in the Introduction to Osteopathic Manipulative Medicine elective at Georgetown. I have carried the skills I learned in that course to my career as a family physician in Seattle. Over the last year and a half, I have been training in the art of cranial osteopathy. Through work with a mentor and an intensive 40-hour course, I have learned the skills to perform basic treatments for patients with headaches, neck pain and back pain. The ability to actually make a patient’s pain better, instead of masking it with medications, is incredibly fulfilling.
That’s right. Here’s a Georgetown graduate who is practicing cranial osteopathy, also known as craniosacral therapy, which is what Mark Crislip likes to call a “SCAM of infinite jest“—and for very good reason. Worse, Blunda is proud of this, claiming that her integration of such treatments into her practice allows her to “provide higher quality and more personalized care.”
Conclusion: The future of medicine is quacky
Unless checked, this is the future of medicine. Indeed, this entire issue makes the case that integrating quackery into medicine, bringing the Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry to life as medical schools, is the future of medicine. Unfortunately, strive as we might against it, I’m having a hard time disagreeing. Proponents of “integrating” witchcraft like reiki, acupuncture, homeopathy, and craniosacral therapy into medicine will say that it’s not at all like Hogwarts. They have a point, but not in the way they think. In marked contrast to the magic gaining traction in the current world of quackademic medicine, in J.K. Rowling’s fictional world of Hogwarts, magic could be studied rigorously and actually worked. Would that this Brave New World of integrative medicine could say the same thing.

Pseudoscience North: What’s happening to the University of Toronto?
Scott Gavura on February 26, 2015
Link

Today’s post is a reluctant challenge. I’m nominating my own alma mater, the University of Toronto, as the new pseudoscience leader among large universities – not just in Canada, but all of North America. If you can identify a large university promoting or embracing more scientifically questionable activities, I’ll happily buy you a coffee. Yes, it’s personal to me, as I have two degrees from U of T. But I’m more concerned about the precedent. If Canada’s largest university is making decisions that appear to lack a careful consideration of the scientific evidence, then what does that suggest about the scientific standards for universities in Canada?
Documenting the spread of pseudoscience within academic institutions, particularly in health and medicine, is a recurring topic at this blog. In recent years, these tactics have usually been branded as a move towards what has been called “integrative” medicine, where the apparent objective is to “integrate” unproven or disproven treatments into health programs and disciplines. It has been pointed out many times that there simply no basis or need to redefine medicine, “alternative”, “integrative” or otherwise. Integrative medicine is simply a marketing term, nothing more. This statement on alternative medicine, from Fontanarosa & Lundberg, back in 1998, still rings true:
There is no alternative medicine. There is only scientifically proven, evidence-based medicine supported by solid data or unproven medicine, for which scientific evidence is lacking. Whether a therapeutic practice is “Eastern” or “Western,” unconventional or mainstream, or involves mind-body techniques or molecular genetics is largely irrelevant except for historical purposes and cultural interest. We recognize that there are vastly different types of practitioners and proponents of the various forms of alternative medicine and conventional medicine, and that there are vast differences in the skills, capabilities, and beliefs of individuals within them and the nature of their actual practices. Moreover, the economic and political forces in these fields are large and increasingly complex and have the capability for being highly contentious. Nonetheless, as believers in science and evidence, we must focus on fundamental issues—namely, the patient, the target disease or condition, the proposed or practiced treatment, and the need for convincing data on safety and therapeutic efficacy.– Phil B. Fontanarosa & George D. Lundberg
Academic institutions that grant legitimacy to pseudoscience create problems beyond their own walls. They do so by either lending their good name to questionable practices, or they facilitate education on pseudoscience under the rubric of “alternative” or “integrative” practices. Not only do educational standards suffer, but the affiliation gives alternative medicine practices the imprimatur of scientific legitimacy in the wider community.
What’s painful about documenting the problems with the University of Toronto is that it ought to know better. It’s the biggest university in Canada and one of the largest universities in the world, and U of T is consistently ranked among the best schools in the world. Its medical faculty and research output are highly regarded worldwide. Insulin and stem cells were discovered at U of T. Despite this stellar reputation, a recent series of decisions and announcements has made me question where U of T is headed. Is this a series of missteps, or a deliberate trend? Here are the four reasons for my nomination:
1. The University has endorsed the study of homeopathy for treating ADHD
Last week Joe Schwarcz documented that the Dean of the Leslie Dan Faculty of Pharmacy is the principal investigator in a clinical trial examining the use of homeopathy for ADHD. In an open letter to the Dean, Heather Boon, Schwarcz and 90 other individuals (including several SBM editors and contributors) asked Boon to explain the rationale for this research. In a related column, Schwarcz noted that there has been no response yet, which is disappointing given the circumstances of this clinical trial, as Schwarcz notes:
ADHD is a serious condition that merits serious research. Apparently, the University of Toronto researchers carried out a pilot study involving homoeopathy that seemed to indicate benefit. That study, however, was unblinded, devoid of randomization, had no control group and relied on a subjective outcome, making any data derived from it essentially meaningless. Even if we were to attach some importance to the claimed reduction of symptoms, the effect was about half of that seen with conventional medication, making the homeopathic treatment clearly inferior. Furthermore the proposed study would use individualized treatments for each subject as determined by a homeopathic consultation, so at best the results would be ambiguous in terms of making any recommendation.
The study is actually to be carried out at the Riverdale Homeopathic Clinic, a private institution that also offers ear candling, cranial sacral therapy and “nosodes,” which are homeopathic versions of vaccines. No public funding is involved; support comes from a foundation dedicated to alternative medicine. Nevertheless, one wonders why with various nutritional and biofeedback treatments with significant potential for helping with ADHD needing exploration, a scientifically insolvent notion is being pursued.
Why the Faculty of Pharmacy is sponsoring a trial of homeopathy raises a number of troubling questions. And when that trial is being conducted by the head of the school, it’s even more important for Boon to explain her research. What is also troubling, and remains unexplained, is how this trial came to be approved by the University of Toronto’s Research Ethics Board (REB) (what Canadians call an IRB). Presumably the REB felt this is ethically acceptable research. This is puzzling, because homeopathy is rank quackery. If homeopathy actually works, then almost everything the Faculty of Pharmacy currently teaches its pharmacy students is wrong, as are the foundational facts of biology and chemistry. Yet despite the overwhelming implausibility of sugar pills having any medicinal effect on children with ADHD, the REB gave this trial a green light. Why?
How this trial was approved is problematic for the University and it needs to be addressed. To be clear, Boon’s research hasn’t always been favourable to CAM, and she has gone on record criticizing a popular herbal remedy. She has also given statements that are not supportive of homeopathy (see video around 2:07), making it all the more important for there to be a clear explanation for this homeopathy trial, and an detailed disclosure on how this trial was considered by the university to be ethically acceptable for children.
2. The University has established a new Centre for Integrative Medicine
In a past post I noted that the University of Toronto was establishing a new “Centre for Integrative Medicine”, which I described as the perfect Trojan rabbit to embed pseudoscience in both the pharmacy and medical schools. Here’s how it was described:
The mission of this new Centre is to facilitate, conduct, and obtain support for collaborative basic, clinical, and health services research in complementary and alternative medicine; to serve as an educational and to develop integrative curricula and educational programs on complementary and alternative medicine; to work collaboratively with other departments within both Faculties and their hospital partners to support the integration of evidence-based complementary and integrative medicine into existing clinical settings and clinical research programs.
As this is a partnership between the Faculties of Medicine and Pharmacy, I noted this was a clever strategy to truly embed alternative medicine into practice. To change the standard of medical practice, you have to target both pharmacists and physicians – otherwise one group will call out the other for quackery. Normalize CAM as part of the curriculum, and students might not even notice. The program even has an explicit intent to embed practices into teaching centres – where it’s more likely to be accepted as standard medical practice.
Since my last post there has been an update: a new head of the Centre and an explicit objective to integrate CAM and Traditional Chinese Medicine into medical practice:
Today, the University of Toronto (U of T) and The Scarborough Hospital (TSH) announced a partnership that will provide new answers for the 74% of Canadians who are using some form of complementary and alternative medicine, including traditional Chinese medicine. Called the Centre for Integrative Medicine (CIM), it will bring together researchers from U of T’s Leslie Dan Faculty of Pharmacy and Faculty of Medicine alongside health care professionals at TSH to provide evidence-driven practices. Together, U of T and TSH will create a living laboratory that will allow us to study ways to safely and effectively integrate evidence-informed complementary therapies and traditional Chinese medicine with conventional medical care.
With an appeal to popularity seemingly the rationale for this work, the University of Toronto is well on its way to starting the integration of CAM into medicine. Let’s be clear. Studying if “alternative” medicine practices actually work is important. What’s not necessary is a different evidentiary framework for evaluating them. For example, pharmacognosy is the study of natural products. It’s an appropriate (and productive) research stream, given so many therapeutic drugs have their origins in natural substances. There’s no need to study natural remedies in an “alternative” or “integrative” manner. The same scientific standards should be applied. And as has been pointed out before, the history of Traditional Chinese Medicine is an invented history – not a factual one. Studying TCM needs to start with evaluating the underlying science – which has already been found to be pseudoscience.
3. The University has announced a collaboration with the Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College
The University of Toronto has announced it will collaborate with a chiropractic school to do the following:
The Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College (CMCC) has signed an official Memorandum of Understanding to explore education and research collaborations with the University of Toronto, through the Faculty of Medicine, Leslie Dan Faculty of Pharmacy and the Faculty of Kinesiology and Physical Education.
“This collaboration shows our commitment to expanding research and educational opportunities across the health care spectrum,” said Professor Catharine Whiteside, U of T’s dean of medicine and vice-provost, relations with healthcare institutions. “We’re delighted to partner with an organization committed to improving health with an evidence-based approach.”
This is quite the coup for CMCC, which reportedly has been seeking a collaboration or affiliation with a university for decades. What’s concerning is that chiropractic lacks a sound scientific basis. Chiropractic research has produced no evidence to support the underlying chiropractic theory. While there is evidence that spinal manipulation therapy can be effective for low back pain, that treatment is not exclusive to chiropractors. Beyond low back pain, there’s no evidence that chiropractic treatments offer any meaningful benefit for other conditions. It’s possible to be an evidence-based chiropractor, as SBM contributor and chiropractor Sam Homola has taught us. Unfortunately the profession of chiropractic is not made up of Sam Homolas. This collaboration between U of T and CMCC is reminiscent of an attempt by CMCC to affiliate with York University almost 15 years ago. At that time it was noted that there were serious scientific concerns about chiropractic that made the incorporation of the school into York University inappropriate. It’s not clear what’s changed with chiropractic since that time.
4. The University gives a platform for the promotion of pseudoscientific ideas about health and medicine
It’s been noted by many that there is no such thing as “alternative” medicine, as medicine doesn’t fail to work in a conventional sense yet work in an “alternative” manner. Medicine either works or it doesn’t. What works we call medicine. The rest is either proven not to work, or is not proven to work. Despite this the University of Toronto Scarborough (a satellite campus) is hosting a conference that’s filled with pseudoscience. Coming this Saturday is Alternative Cares of Medicine, a Population Health and Policy Conference:
Among the speakers is Beth Landau-Halpern, a Toronto homeopath recently caught on camera by the CBC television show Marketplace selling homepathic “nosodes” to a mother as a substitute for a real vaccine. Homeopathic “nosodes” are a dangerous consequence of the pseudoscience of homeopathy. “Nosodes” are just sugar pills, like all homeopathy, but may be sold by homeopaths as substitutes for vaccination. They are not. After the Marketplace episode aired, Landau-Halpern went on record noting that while Health Canada requires nosodes to be labelled “not a vaccine”, that she is not required to do so. She knows they are not to be sold as a substitute for a vaccine, yet she did so anyway. This conference is labelled as being about population health, and given the resurgence of measles in Ontario and across North America, there is no better case study for the threat that homeopaths make to public health than examining homeopathic “nosodes” and the behaviour of homeopaths. What’s even more concerning is that Landau-Halpern actually seems to have a teaching appointment at the university. How a homeopath has obtained a teaching appointment in the Department of Anthropology at the University of Toronto is another question that the university should answer. Given the recent public outcry over a professor at Queen’s University teaching anti-vaccine pseudoscience, why the University of Toronto is sponsoring a talk by an anti-vaccine homeopath deserves an explanation.
Another speaker is Bryce Wylde, another homeopath and self-described “alternative medicine expert, philanthropist, television host” who certainly gets significant television exposure, whether it’s his own show or guest appearances on The Dr. Oz Show. He’s been criticized for repeatedly promoting ideas and treatments that lack good evidence. There’s also Jennifer Yun, a naturopath who is the co-founder and “clinical director” of Adara Integrative Clinic which offers quackery like intravenous vitamin infusions and a pseudoscience I’d never heard of, esoteric acupuncture, described by her clinic as:
Drawing upon the disciplines of Traditional Chinese acupuncture, sacred geometry, the qabbalastic tree of life, the ayurvedic nadi system, and high Qi nutrition, esoteric acupuncture brings the subtle and finer aspects of Qi (vital energy) into balance.
The entire program is a cornucopia of pseudoscience, and I see little on the agenda that is going to contribute meaningfully to supporting population health. It’s not surprising to see this program is also sponsored by the Toronto School of Chinese Medicine and the Canadian College of Naturopathic Medicine. It’s a clever way to leverage the credibility of the university while promoting your particular form of pseudoscience.
Conclusion
Like many universities, the University of Toronto appears to be taking a new and discouraging turn towards supporting pseudoscientific ideas about health and medicine. The line between science and pseudoscience is increasingly becoming difficult to see, especially when alternative medicine and quackery is rebranded as “integrative” medicine. Yet as can be seen with the resurgence of infectious disease driven by dropping vaccination rates, there are very real consequences to promoting incorrect ideas about health and wellness. We need academic centres like the U of T to be strong societal proponents of the scientific method and the best scientific evidence, rather than using appeals to popularity to determine academic programs and collaborations. Moreover, when the university or its staff make decisions that raise questions about their judgement, the university owes the community an explanation.

University of Toronto Coddles Quackery
Steven Novella on July 8, 2015
Link

The ongoing saga of quackademic medicine continues. The University of Toronto School of Public Health has been caught teaching utter nonsense to its students. Even worse, when called out on this dereliction of their academic responsibility, they defended it. Unfortunately, it is all too clear how something like this can happen.
The department was teaching an alternative medicine course at U of T’s Scarborough campus. The course was taught by Beth Landau-Halpern who is a homeopath Scott has discussed before, and who also happens to be the wife of the dean of that campus (it’s hard to imagine this was not a factor). Landau-Halpern should never, in my opinion, be anywhere near the classroom of a legitimate university.
The fact that she is a homeopath is enough to disqualify her to teach any health topic. On her website she boldly claims that “homeopathy works,” even though the evidence shows that homeopathic potions are indistinguishable from placebo. She also specializes in treating children with ADHD and autism. She advertises her training as a CEASE practitioner – CEASE stands for:
Complete Elimination of Autistic Spectrum Expression. Step by step all causative factors (vaccines, regular medication, environmental toxic exposures, effects of illness, etc.) are detoxified with the homeopathically prepared, that is diluted and potentized substances that caused the autism.
It is clear she is operating under a non-scientific narrative, which is typical of practitioners of alternative medicine.
Many universities, however, have been sold a bill of goods. They are told that “alternative medicine” is about holistic, patient-centered care, that it is “evidence-based” and that patients are using it, and students are interested in it, so it is appropriate to teach it. Of course, university deans are likely not to know much about alternative medicine, and therefore may be inclined to buy this line or propaganda. Further, if they agree to teach such a course they are often happy to turn the details over to an “expert,” which translates into an alternative medicine practitioner.
Worse still, there is often very little oversight over the contents of the curriculum. The practitioner is free, once inside the gates, to teach utter pseudoscientific nonsense. This is exactly what appears to have happened at U of T, with the alternative medicine practitioner being the wife of the dean as an added bonus.
What sometimes happens is that a real scientist gets wind of what is being taught in the course and decides to do something about it. This does not happen often enough, but it does occasionally happen. In this case letters were written to the deans complaining about two aspects of the course in particular: anti-vaccine propaganda, and the abuse of quantum mechanics to explain how magic works. There were physicists among the letter writers, who were particularly offended at the misuse of quantum mechanics.
The material on vaccines included:
The required reading and viewing material for that lecture included a two-hour long interview with Andrew Wakefield, the disgraced former British surgeon who popularized the false idea vaccines are linked to autism and other chronic illness. Other course material included a video promoting the idea vaccines are unsafe; a video titled Vaccine’s Safety: A Crime Against Humanity; and a book that claims vaccines have not reduced rates of disease or increased lifespan.
The course material also had this to say about quantum mechanics:
We will delve into a quantum physics’ understanding of disease and alternative medicine to provide a scientific hypothesis of how these modalities may work. Quantum physics is a branch of physics that understands the interrelationship between matter and energy. This science offers clear explanations as to why homeopathic remedies with seemingly no chemical trace of the original substance are able to resolve chronic diseases, why acupuncture can offer patients enough pain relief to undergo surgery without anesthesia, why meditation alone can, in some instances, reduce the size of cancerous tumors.
Of course, quantum mechanics has zero explanatory power regarding homeopathy and acupuncture, and homeopathy and acupuncture don’t, in fact, work. This is so-called “quantum woo” that we have been dealing with for years. It is a classic example of pseudoscience. The logic is nothing more than this: quantum mechanics is weird, homeopathy (or ESP or name your favorite pseudoscience) is weird, therefore homeopathy works by quantum mechanics.
The university responds
More interesting than the mere fact that a university is teaching pseudoscience (which unfortunately is no longer shocking) is the response of the deans when confronted with their failure. In their report they argue that it is not their job to evaluate course material. That is the job of the department or program. They therefore limited their review to the process used by the department, not the course material itself (although they do then go on to comment on this). This is a reasonable position, for ordinary concerns, but is not a reasonable position when the accusations are this severe. You don’t need special expertise that only exists at the departmental level to see that this course is flagrant pseudoscience and lacks even basic scholarly quality control.
Further, the university did not address the concerns about the abuse of quantum mechanics at all. They only addressed the concerns about the inclusion of anti-vaccine propaganda. They gave no reason for ignoring half the complaint.
Their comment on the anti-vaccine propaganda was the most shocking and deplorable aspect of their response. They essentially say that the students are taught the real science of vaccines in their other courses, this course is an elective for seniors who are expected to be able to critically assess the content, and the purpose of this course was to present the “other side,” therefore:
As a result, I do not find that the instructor’s approach in this class has been, or would have reasonably been perceived to be unbalanced, in the sense that it deviated from a presentation of material that, in context, would enable critical analysis, and inquiry. Thus, from an academic pedagogy perspective, I do not find that there has been sufficient deviation from the range of normal approaches to warrant concerns.
This is nothing more than the ‘false balance” defense. This is identical to defending the teaching of creationism at a university – teaching creationism uncritically as if it were a real scientific theory and challenge to evolution – on the grounds that the students learn evolution in their biology course and should be able to critically analyze the content, therefore it is balanced. This logic could be used to defend the teaching of astrology alongside astronomy, geocentrism alongside heliocentrism, and alchemy alongside chemistry.
Conclusion
Universities need a wake-up call. Deans need to understand that it is not academically acceptable to teach pseudoscience, errors of fact, bad scholarship, invalid logic, and dangerous nonsense in their schools on the justification that it is “balanced,” that they are “teaching the controversy“, or that they are just respecting academic freedom. These strategies should all sound familiar, because they have been used for decades by creationists to attack the teaching of evolution and to introduce creationist pseudoscience into curricula at every level of education.
The deans who wrote the U of T response must be completely tone deaf to these creationist strategies – perhaps because they are Canadian and it is not as much of an issue there.
Further, scientists and scholars in universities can no longer justify remaining “shruggies” – we all need to take an active interest in basic quality control at our own institutions. I am not talking about micro-managing course content or interfering with other departments. For most courses the usual process of content creation and oversight is adequate. But these types of course are not usual. They represent a deviation from the typical material being taught at university, and they deserve special attention and oversight.
Optimally, courses promoting pseudoscience would not be taught at any university. If a university wants to teach about alternative medicine, or creationism, or astrology, they should teach it from a critical point of view. This should not be confused with promoting pseudoscientific propaganda, however.
It should be obvious that teaching nonsense as if it were legitimate does a disservice to the students, even if the students don’t perceive it themselves. Scholarly quality control does not happen at the student level.
Further, giving access to a university classroom to pseudoscientists compromises the academic integrity of the institution. It also legitimizes the pseudoscientist and the pseudoscience. Landau-Halpern can now claim she is an instructor at the University of Toronto, and that homeopathy is taught there, therefore it must be legitimate.
The response of the University of Toronto to these complaints is scandalous. It is completely inadequate, it is clearly defensive, and they should be embarrassed.

The Biopolitics of Quackademic Medicine in Iran
The problem of quackademic medicine in a place we in the US don’t often consider.
Kiarash Aramesh on August 27, 2024
Link

For ordinary people – or patients – who have been overwhelmed by the mixture of valid and invalid health information they receive from the mass or social media and wonder which one to trust, one helpful piece of advice would be to ask a healthcare professional or look at academic sources. A healthcare professional is a person with a degree and license in healthcare, such as a doctor, who can always be trusted and relied upon to tell apart valid health information from misinformation. The disaster happens when those degree and license-holder physicians become the purveyors of health pseudoscience. The worst happens when they hold academic positions in well-reputed medical institutes. As a result, academic sources also turn into the suppliers of misinformation. That is what has been happening in Iran for more than two decades.
Quackademic is a term coined to identify the infiltration of pseudoscientific institutions in the academic community. Biopolitics has been used with various meanings. However, this paper adopts the definition that describes it as the interference of politics and political powers in life sciences and the way people live. In many countries, religious and political ideologies support various branches of health pseudoscience or antiscience. When they are in power, they exploit public resources to promote those pseudo- or antiscientific ideas in different ways, including nestling them in academic institutions. This is an obvious instance of biopolitics. This article depicts Iran’s ongoing experience with quackademic medicine promoted by biopolitics.
A Brief History of a Politically Supported Medicine
The School of Persian Medicine, the birthplace of the first academic group and Ph.D. program of Traditional Iranian Medicine (TIM), was established in 2007 as a new part of the Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Iran’s oldest and most prestigious medical school. Its establishment was not a mere academic endeavor but a political one, with both the Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, and the President, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, staunchly advocating for TIM. This political support, which has endured under subsequent presidents and their administrations, is deeply entrenched in the political ideology of the Islamic Republic, which is characterized by anti-Western sentiments and a commitment to self-reliance.
Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, the Islamic Republic’s President from 2005 to 2013, was pivotal in establishing and expanding the academic institutions dedicated to TIM. His fervent belief in medical pseudoscience was no secret, recurrently expressed in his presidential speeches. For instance, he once proclaimed:
“I know individuals who, by simply examining your pulse, can diagnose your body more accurately than the most advanced digital machines, such as C.T. Scan, and identify all the issues and malfunctions in your bodily systems. These are not hearsay; I have personally had my pulse examined twice, and they diagnosed all the problems and diseases in my body and their causes [!].”
For thee, but not for me
The Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Khamenei, has never shied away from supporting TIM. In addition to many sayings, he included a solid mandate to promote and establish TIM in the “General Health Policies,” a document that the Ministry of Health and other governmental stakeholders in the health sector must follow.
It is worth mentioning that the Supreme Leader has always used the most advanced medical technologies and Western-educated physicians for himself and his family. He has never risked his health by trusting the providers of TIM or other quackeries such as Islamic Medicine. However, when it comes to advising people, while he has never banned or disparaged scientific medicine as a whole, he promotes TIM.
Despite some scattered resistance in the governing bodies of the health system, the continuous support of the top leaders, including the Ministers of Health, has led to the near-full implementation of the abovementioned General Policies in the country. So far, tens of TIM schools, departments, research centers, clinics, and other academic institutions have been established within medical universities. Hundreds of Ph.D. students who hold an M.D. degree and are licensed to practice TIM have graduated. The integration of TIM into the primary healthcare system, along with insurance coverage for TIM treatments, is being pursued.
TIM is Pseudoscience
The main feature that differentiates TIM from other (valid or invalid) branches of medicine is not its reliance on herbal remedies, ancient treatments, or medieval manuscripts but its reliance on the theory of four humors and temperaments. TIM is pseudoscience because (1) in the realm of basic sciences (the understanding of health, disease, and treatment), it relies on obsolete and wrong identity-making theories, and (2) in the realm of clinical medicine, it refuses to follow the standards of evidence-based medicine (EBM).
The humoral theory is the core theory that forms TIM’s identity. To preserve this identity, the practitioners and purveyors of TIM need to safeguard this theory from falsification. In other words, they need to keep the humoral theory as a sacred dogma that should be preserved at any cost! This is their exit from the highway of science to the wrong way of pseudoscience and quackery.
Ancient Origins
The version of the humoral theory adopted by TIM was first developed in ancient Greece by physicians and philosophers such as Hippocrates (460-370 BC) and Aristotle (384-322 BC). It was then further developed and expanded in ancient Rome by Galen (129-216 CE). Galen’s books were translated into Arabic during the translation movement by great translators of the House of Translation in Baghdad, including Hunayn ibn Ishaq al-Ibadi (808–873 CE), who translated almost all of Galen’s books into Arabic. Those books were studied all over the Muslim-majority world then, from Cordoba in today’s Spain to Samarqand and Bukhara in today’s Uzbekistan. Some great physicians and philosophers, such as Al-Razi (865–925 CE) and Ibn Sina (080-1037 CE), significantly contributed to this branch of medicine and authored encyclopedic books such as The Canon of Medicine by Ibn Sina.
Their accounts of anatomy, physiology, and pathophysiology are now obsolete. For example, according to them, the liver digests the ingested food into four humors: phlegm, blood, yellow bile, and black bile. These fluids are circulated in the veins. All the veins originate from the liver. The concentration of these humors forms the organs, while their more diluted and refined form, the Pneuma (or Rowh), is circulated in the arteries. Health is the status of balance among the humors and temperaments (wet, dry, hot, and cold), and disease is the status of imbalance among them because of excess or deficiency. Therefore, treatment aimed to correct the imbalance by remedies or treatments such as blood-letting, cupping, purging, or enema. These theories were invented centuries before the development of modern theories such as the cell theory, the germ theory, the genes theory, and others that help us understand human health and disease today. Today, even a high school student knows that those humoral theories are wrong and have been rejected.
Appeal to Tradition Fallacy
The departments of TIM try to smuggle all those obsolete theories and practices into medical universities. They teach them as “alternative medicine” to medical students and their Ph.D. students, who will be licensed to practice accordingly.
In clinical medicine, the academic centers of TIM, after nearly two decades of consuming a large portion of the health sector’s budget, have yet to introduce a remedy derived from their old manuscripts that is more effective than scientific medicine medications in treating a serious disease. They have long publication lists because their students need to publish articles to graduate, and their faculty members need to publish to get promotions. Also, they publish in a wide array of journals dedicated to medical pseudoscience, some of which have been established in their own institutions. Most of these articles are historical papers exploring old manuscripts. In addition, there are numerous published clinical trials among them with lots of methodological faults and shortcomings. At the end of the day, as mentioned above, they have been embarrassingly unsuccessful in conducting well-designed clinical trials and achieving any noteworthy results.
Quackademic Medicine at Work
Today, major medical universities in Iran host tens of academic centers of TIM. Many of them offer master’s and PhD degrees. The Iranian Ministry of Health and Medical Education has an office dedicated to promoting TIM. Numerous clinics called “Salamatkadeh,” meaning the House of Health, have been established under the umbrella of medical universities and even within major university hospitals. According to law, TIM medications are exempted from many conditions and steps for obtaining marketing approval from Iran’s Food and Drug Organization. A number of medicines have already received such approval without having clear supporting evidence.
Hundreds of M.D.s have obtained their Ph.D. degrees in TIM. They are licensed to practice TIM. The professors and practitioners of TIM are frequently invited by the government TV (the only formally permitted TV in Iran) as health experts. They publish on websites and social media pages of the Ministry of Health and medical universities. Therefore, their audience finds them approved by and a part of medical academia and has no reason not to trust them. The number of TIM visits is claimed to be ever-increasing in a way that there is a shortage of practitioners with a TIM degree.
It is separate from various other branches of quackery medicine, such as Islamic medicine, homeopathy, energy therapy, magnetic therapy, and countless other branches of pseudoscience and antiscience that exploit the scientific illiteracy of the public in contemporary Iran. What makes TIM different, and more dangerous and harmful, is mainly their being “quackademic.”
The Role of Bioethics
The institution of bioethics has a crucial role in defending society against the harmful intrusion of biopolitically motivated pseudoscience. Certain widely accepted bioethical principles, including nonmaleficence and scientific validity, can be relied upon to create a theoretical model for addressing such problems.
Some ethical and professional guidelines in Iran emphasize the importance of evidence-based methodology in clinical medicine. However, in the absence of a robust civil society, the government controls almost all the professional bodies, such as the Medical Council of the Islamic Republic of Iran, and the regulatory institutions, such as the national and regional Research Ethics Committees. Therefore, when infesting academia with pseudoscience is a government-supported project, none of them shows any motivation to stand against it.
The burden of educating the public and even health professionals about the pseudoscientific aspects of TIM and the danger of medical pseudoscience is on the shoulders of a number of intellectuals who feel a personal responsibility to do this job and accept its burden and risks.
Purveyors of Pseudoscience
Around the globe, biopolitics plays a crucial role in promoting various types of health pseudoscience and antiscience. Religious and political powers have their perspectives on health, disease, and medicine and advocate for branches of medicine that concord with those perspectives. When in power, they help their supported branches of pseudoscience to infiltrate governmental bodies, health systems, and academic institutions.
If it happens, as has already been in progress in Iran, the worst and most harmful type of health pseudoscience emerges because the institution people should trust to distinguish science from pseudoscience, namely the professionals and academic bodies, turn into the purveyors of pseudoscience. That is what has happened in Iran over the past two decades, and it is still in progress.
Escaping the Dungeon of Medical Pseudoscience
Medical traditions and traditional medicines all over the world, including in rich and old civilizations like Iran, are sources for considerable therapeutic hypotheses, such as traditional herbal remedies and other treatments. Nobody argues that they are entirely useless and ineffective. There is a reasonable possibility that some of them are truly safe and effective. However, their safety and effectiveness must be assessed by well-designed and conducted clinical trials before being marketed or prescribed.
The TIM departments in Iran, at the very beginning, were supposed to accomplish this mission. However, the difficulty of scientific research and the lucrative business of practicing pseudoscience, in addition to the political support, directed them toward their current path. It was a bad idea, even at the beginning, to establish TIM departments for such a purpose because when they are named TIM, they adopt a mission to defend their identity as a separate and valid branch of medicine, that is, the entrance of the dungeon of pseudoscience.
Instead, the best way to explore the potential of traditional remedies is by conducting research with the collaboration of pharmacognosy or ethnopharmacology departments. That is the only exit from the dungeon of medical pseudoscience. Right now, however, it looks like nobody in the Iranian Ministry of Health or TIM departments is looking for such an exit.

The American Medical Student Association: On “integrating” quackery with science-based medicine
David Gorski on October 22, 2012
Link
There’s a saying in medicine that we frequently hear when a newer, more effective therapy supplants an older therapy or an existing therapy is shown not to be as efficacious as was once thought, and it has to do about how long it takes for the use of that therapy to decline. The saying basically says that the therapy won’t die out until the current generation of established physicians retire and are replaced by the new generation coming up through medical schools. From my perspective, it’s a bit of an exaggeration, because in the mere 13 years that I’ve been a real doctor (i.e., an attending physician) our practices in breast cancer surgery has changed markedly. Although certain core principles of breast cancer care remain the same, there have been major changes in terms of how we deal with the axillary lymph nodes, our use of hormone therapy and chemotherapy, and our very understanding of the different subtypes of breast cancer. Of course, I have spent my entire career as faculty at two different NCI-designated comprehensive cancer centers; so my experience is not representative of that of most physicians, particularly given that I’m super subspecialized. It’s generally expected that if you’re faculty in an academic medical center you will be at the very least up to date, if not beyond at the cutting edge.
Even so, there is some truth to the observation that it takes the rise of a new generation of physicians to force out certain old ideas, which means that how we train our medical students is of utmost importance. Unfortunately, these days, it is medical students who have become a major force for promoting the “integration” of quackery into medicine (which these days is known as, appropriately enough in a way unintended by its proponents, “integrative medicine”). No, I’m not saying that all or even most medical students are prone to the blandishments of quackademic medicine, but rather that there is a large enough contingent of medical students who have gone beyond being shruggies to become activists for unscientific medicine. There are CAM clubs, CAM interest groups, and student-driven CAM electives.
And then there’s the American Medical Students Association (AMSA), specifically its various initiatives in “integrative medicine.” I fear that each successive generation of medical students is more prone to embracing unscientific medicine than the last.
AMSA and CAM: A long history together
On its website, AMSA describes itself as the oldest and largest independent association of physicians-in-training in the United States. Founded in 1950, it currently boasts a membership of approximately 68,000 medical students, premedical students, interns, and residents. The goals of the organization, as described on its website, are as follows:
    • Quality, Affordable Health Care for All
    • Global Health Equity
    • Enriching Medicine Through Diversity
    • Professional Integrity, Development and Student Well-Being
It’s hard to argue with any of these aims as goals, but, of course, as always the devil is in the details. For instance, AMSA has managed to cause some controversy with its PharmFree initiative, which is fine on the surface, but, as some argue, might have unintended consequences. Another problem is that AMSA declares itself to be all about the evidence and evidence-based medicine, as well as ethics. This would be great if it were true, but there’s one big hole in the claim. It’s a hole big enough to pilot an aircraft carrier through, and that hole is, to put it briefly, “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM). To boil it down, AMSA promotes integrating quackery into medicine, and it does it in a big way. Let’s see how.
I first became aware of how AMSA promotes “integrative medicine” several years ago, when Dr. R. W. Donnell pointed it out to me. This led me to a document, still available on the AMSA website on a page called the ICAM Resource Center (Integrative, Complementary and Alternative Medicine), Complementary Therapies Primer (formerly “The Quick and Dirty Guide to Complementary Therapies”) and the 2006 UCSF Guide to Integrative Medicine. I’ll get to the primer in a minute. First, let’s look at AMSA’s position on CAM laid out on its ICAM webpage:
AMSA believes that students and physicians can best serve their patients by recognizing and acknowledging the availability of integrative medicine in their communities. By pursuing education in complementary and alternative medical (CAM) treatments, medical students and physicians can better facilitate the appropriate education, treatment and counseling of patients and consumers.
    • AMSA believes that an empowered patient can serve as a powerful and central actor in their own healing.
    • Appropriate education in CAM treatments uses scientific and ethnographic methods, including quantitative and qualitative outcomes research of efficacy and effectiveness. Although it is informed by evidence, it considers explanatory models and cultural.
    • AMSA supports students who wish to work within the healthcare system to create an environment which is supportive of the whole patient.
    • AMSA believes that medical students and other health care professionals need to be restored and whole in order to be empowering and healing for their patients.
Let’s look at numbers one, three, and four first. These are nothing more than CAM-speak blather worthy of one of Kimball Atwood’s installment of Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo. For instance, there is nothing in SBM that says an “empowered patient” is a bad thing or that he can’t serve as a “powerful and central actor” in his own healing. Indeed, as I’ve pointed out before many times, paternalism is steadily going away within EBM/SBM, and most physicians of my generation and younger agree that’s a good thing for the most part. We want our patients to be engaged and provide input into their care and what’s important to them. Most of us don’t feel comfortable anymore taking a “doctor knows best” attitude in which we simply give orders and prescriptions and expect to be obeyed. This brings us to number three, which is what I like to call the “holistic” trope, in which CAM practitioners claim to be so much better than conventional medicine at caring for the “whole patient.” It’s utter bunkum, nonsense, a fetid pair of dingo’s kidneys. A good science-based primary care doctor is a holistic doctor! A good science-based primary care doctor does take care of the “whole patient.” A good science-based primary care doctor also “empowers” the patient. None of these things are inherent in or exclusive to CAM, nor are they unachievable in SBM. It’s a false dichotomy that AMSA fully buys into, lumping its CAM promotion initiatives under “humanistic medicine.” Again, I resent that — I don’t need CAM to practice “humanistic medicine.”
More importantly, let’s look at number two, how AMSA supports using both “scientific and ethnographic methods” and claims that appropriate education in CAM uses explanatory models and culture. While this is not completely unreasonable on the surface (certainly to understand how traditional Chinese medicine came about one has to understand a bit about the Chinese culture out of which TCM sprang), but notice the not-so-subtle denigration of science. Notice how AMSA considers qualitative and quantitative outcomes research and doesn’t even mention proper randomized clinical trials (RCTs), unless one assumes it to be subsumed under “scientific” methods. Odd that it’s not mentioned, though, isn’t it? Well, no, it’s not so odd. As we’ve discussed many times, CAM proponents are very much enamored of “pragmatic” research, of the sort that seeks to see how various modalities perform in “real world” settings. The problem with this emphasis is that pragmatic studies and outcomes research are not appropriate for modalities that have not yet been shown to be efficacious and safe in proper clinical trials. The reason for “pragmatic” research is to test whether treatments shown to work in RCTs do as well once they are let “out in the wild,” so to speak, where they will be used to treat patients who might not have fit the inclusion criteria of the RCTs used to test the treatment or in hospitals and settings where the capabilities for monitoring the therapy might not be as good as they were for the RCTs. Doing outcome studies on therapies that haven’t been validated in RCTs is putting the proverbial cart before the horse.
Informational resources that AMSA recommends: Quackery
Now, let’s go back and look first at the UCSF guide. It begins with a disclaimer:
Inclusion of a therapy, resource, or practitioner in this guide does not imply endorsement by UCSF, the Integrative Medicine Network, or the Osher Center for Integrative Medicine.
Too bad this disclaimer and the frequent mention that many of these modalities are pure pseudoscience and that there are no good randomized clinical trial data demonstrating the efficacy of most of these treatments is belied by the utterly credulous description of various alt-med modalities found in many of the chapters. For example, check out this description of acupuncture:
Acupuncture relies on the idea of Qi, the energy force that run in regular patterns called meridians through the body. A person’s health is influenced by the flow of Qi in the body, in combination with the universal forces of Yin and Yang. If the flow of Qi is insufficient, unbalanced or interrupted, Yin and Yang become unbalanced, and illness may occur. By inserting fine needles on the body’s surfaces at specific points to connect the meridians, acupuncture is used to regulate or correct the flow of Qi to restore health.
At the initial visit, the practitioner evaluates the patient’s current problems, medical history, available laboratory values and radiological tests, as well as a traditional physical exam of the tongue, reflex points, radial pulse, and external ear. The goal of the evaluation is to link the patient’s problems to a specific imbalance or block of Qi
Note how the description of qi is described as fact, not as an explanation that has no scientific basis for whatever effects (if any) acupuncture has on pain or disease in humans. Even in the section on scientific studies, there is no mention that qi has never been measured or detected, despite many attempts. But the description of acupuncture isn’t that bad compared to some others. At least acupuncture has a potential physiologic mechanism for doing something, as misrepresented and exaggerated as it is. OK, over time I’ve become less and less convinced of this; certainly claimed mechanisms do not persuade me. However, acupuncture does involve sticking needles in the skin. Not knowing anything else about it, one might think that something could be going on. In contrast, most homeopathic remedies are nothing more than water, pure placebo, but that doesn’t stop the fine folks at UCSF from serving up another heaping helping of credulity:
Dr. Hahnemann first formulated his principle of the Law of Similars after testing quinine, a cure for malaria. He found that it produced the symptoms of malaria in a healthy individual. However, when he discontinued the quinine, the symptoms disappeared. After several similar studies, Hahnemann found that very small doses of the substance are nontoxic and yet still work to produce the desired symptoms of the illness in healthy individuals. Homeopathic remedies are therefore diluted to different degrees so that only traces of the original substance are present. Often chemical testing will show no presence of the active ingredient. This, however, is completely consistent with homeopathic philosophy as they believe that the ingredient leaves an imprint on the remedy and it is this ghost print which then acts within the body.
There are also several testimonials, just as good as that of any seen on Mercola.com or NaturalNews.com (or any alternative medicine website selling products). For example, here’s one from a Reiki practitioner:
“I am a Second Degree Reiki Practitioner of the Mikao Usui Tradition. In the 10 years of my Reiki practice I have seen healing transformations in all my clients, on all levels (mental, emotional, spiritual, and physical). One patient that stands out most is a nurse for the U.S. Embassy that had been suffering from Shingles for nearly three years. After several hospitalizations and medical evacuations for treatment, she called me for an appointment. She was on daily doses of morphine painkillers, was exhausted and in pain all the time and had gained a lot of weight. We began weekly Reiki treatments that lasted for about six months. During the six months, she first began sleeping well, feeling more energetic, reducing her morphine and ultimately eliminating all pain medicine, and arriving at full energy balance and recovery.” — Lauretta Agolli, Reiki Practitioner
This, of course, follows a credulous description of what Reiki is, although at least the manual does mention that “Reiki is not recommended as the sole treatment for potentially serious medical conditions, and its use should not delay the time it takes to consult with a health care provider or receive established therapies.” Imagine my relief, after that lovely testimonial and the glowing description of Reiki that preceded this disclaimer.
I could go on, but what’s the point. The UCSF manual has credulous and, in some cases, promotional treatments of a wide variety of woo, including reflexology, Reiki, naturopathy, fasting, spiritual healing, and others, mixed in with the occasional less woo-filled modality, like biofeedback. But what disturbed me even more was some of the descriptions of treatments for specific diseases, for example cancer (of course). Take a look at this schizophrenic passage:
Alternative therapies may be dangerous because they are often unproven and administered in lieu of traditional treatment such as chemotherapy or radiation. Using alternative therapies instead of conventional treatment for highly curable, early-stage cancers is not recommended.
CAM therapies are also considered useful approaches to recurrence, metastatic cancers, and secondary cancers.
In actuality, as far as the cancer goes, alternative therapies are no more useful for curing recurrent or metastatic cancers than for curing early stage curable cancers. The only reason they sometimes appear useful for early stage cancers is because most such cancers are cured by the surgery, with adjuvant chemotherapy and radiation therapy serving mainly to reduce the risk of recurrence. If you undergo surgery for an early stage tumor and use an “alternative” medical therapy on top of that, you’ve almost certainly added exactly nothing to the surgery, whereas chemotherapy and radiation produce measurable decreases in the risk of cancer recurrence. Basically, you got lucky.
Worse, there are yet more credulous descriptions of all manner of cancer quackery, including megavitamins, “colon detoxification” with coffee enemas (as in the Gerson/Kelley/Gonzalez protocol), antineoplastons, the same is found for all the other diseases discussed individually, all with liberal comparisons between the woo and the dreaded “allopathic” medicine. Indeed, the only quackery I can think of that the UCSF manual does not mention, to its credit, is chelation therapy.
That’s where AMSA’s very own manual comes in. While the UCSF manual is a bit—shall we say?—reticent about promoting the quackier therapies, the AMSA manual has no such compunction. For instance, on p.20, this is what AMSA says about chelation therapy:
Chelation is used to reverse the process of atherosclerosis by removing calcium from plaques. It is used to prevent myocardial infarction and stroke, and as an alternative to bypass surgery and angioplasty. Since it improves blood flow, it is also helpful in gangrene, intermittent claudication caused by peripheral vascular disease, and poor memory due in part to insufficient cerebral blood flow. Reduction in metal ions reduces inflammation caused by free radicals, and makes chelation therapy helpful in arthritis, scleroderma, and lupus. Chelation therapy has also been used to normalize cardiac arrhythmias, improve vasculogenic vision loss, reduce cancer mortality, protect against iron poisoning and detoxification of snake and spider bites.
Chelation therapy involves between twenty and thirty treatments given at intervals of two to seven days. Each treatment takes approximately three and a half hours, and involves the intravenous infusion of EDTA, vitamins and minerals. Oral chelation is also effective for patients with mild disease, or as a preventive measure. EDTA and penicillamine (another chelating agent used in heavy metal poisoning, Wilson’s disease and rheumatoid arthritis) can be used orally, leading to reduced serum cholesterol.
The only warning given about chelation therapy provided is to point out that chelation therapy is “contraindicated in pregnancy, renal failure (the drug is cleared by the kidneys), and hypoparathyroidism (due to its calcium-binding properties).” There’s no mention that it doesn’t work, that it doesn’t clear plaques from coronary arteries, or that it doesn’t do anything for autism.
Then there’s this description of homeopathy:
The Law of the Infinitesimal Dose was formulated by Dr. Hahnemann when he experimented with dilute solutions, seeking to avoid toxicities, and found them to be more effective than full strength preparations. Homeopathic remedies are repeatedly mixed with water or alcohol and shaken (succussion), often diluting the substances to such a degree that no amount of the original medication can be found in the remedy. Some believe that the remedies retain their effect because of electromagnetic frequency imprinting, changing the structure of the diluent subtly.
Initially, as a patient is treated by a homeopathic physician, he or she may actually worsen. This is know as a “healing crisis.” As the presenting, most recent, symptoms are treated, older, underlying disorders come to the surface. Dr. Constantine Hering, the father of American homeopathy, believed that healing progresses from recent diseases to chronic maladies, from emotional imbalances to physical disorders, from superior to inferior, and from the deep structures to the superficial. This is known as Hering’s Laws of Cure. By following Hering’s Laws when treating a patient, a practitioner can successively unravel many layers of pathology, eventually recreating internal order and achieving a more permanent cure.
The skeptical take included in this guide? It’s mentioned that homeopathy has “lost favor with the medical establishment in the US” (gee, that couldn’t possibly be because homeopathy is a load of pseudoscientific rubbish with a mystical vitalistic overlay, could it?), after which a 1991 BMJ study finding that most controlled clinical trials suggested a beneficial effect of homeopathic remedies is cited. Unfortunately, there are also similarly credulous takes on a wide variety of dubious, non-science-based therapies, including aromatherapy, acupuncture, chiropractic, naturopathy, and others. I can see AMSA apologists retorting that this particular guide was written in 1995, making it 17 years old and potentially out of date. If that were the case, however, why would AMSA not remove it from its website as one of its suggested resources? Ditto the UCSF guide. Alternatively, AMSA could add a note to its 1995 guide pointing out that chelation therapy is dangerous and doesn’t work or remove that section altogether. It hasn’t. At worst, this failure implies endorsement of this particular form of quackery; at best, it implies indifference to whether chelation therapy is science- and evidence-based or not. The same could be said for all the other quackery credulously discussed in these two tomes of pseudoscience.
If the above doesn’t convince you, just peruse AMSA’s webpage for its Naturopathic Medicine Interest Group, which not only represents naturopathy as scientific but actively encourages interactions and “cross pollination” between medical students and naturopathy students, complete with a link to a list of alternative medicine conferences.
Promotion of CAM and a bootcamp for quackery
Unfortunately, AMSA goes far beyond simply providing unscientific and pseudoscientific information on its website and falling for typical distortions of language used by CAM apologists. In other words, it goes beyond words into deeds. For instance, if you peruse AMSA’s website, it won’t take you long to find several initiatives related to CAM. One example is AMSA’s Educational Development for Complementary & Alternative Medicine (EDCAM), whose goals are described as:
     1.  Improve medical student proficiency in CAM theory, methods, and practice;
     2.  Enhance medical student education of preventive health, holistic care, and self-care through clinical examples using integrative medicine; and
     3.  Improve cultural competence and comfort of future physicians increasingly exposed to a diversity of world populations and healing methods.
To manage that, EDCAM has created modules whose use it encourages medical schools to use in their curriculum that it refers to as Core Curriculum CAM Integration in 10 categories. These include:
     1.  Nutrition and Lifestyle: Diet, Exercise, Sleep and Stress Management
     2.  Mind-Body Medicines 
     3.  Alternative Systems of Medical Thought: Traditional Chinese Medicine, Kampo, Tibetan Medicine and Acupuncture 
     4.  Alternative Systems of Medical Thought: Yoga, Ayurveda, Native American and Yoruba Based Medicines 
     5.  Alternative Systems of Medical Thought: Homeopathy and Flower Essences (updated 5/03)
     6.  Bioenergetic Medicines 
     7.  Pharmacologic/Biologically Based: Herbal Medicines 
     8.  Pharmacologic/Biologically Based: Nutrition, Dietary Supplements and Vitamins 
     9.  Manipulative Therapies: Chiropractic and Osteopathy 
     10.  Manipulative Therapies: Therapeutic Massage
Let’s take a look at one of these, the section on bioenergetic medicines. This is a subcategory of CAM commonly referred to as “energy healing” and includes therapeutic touch, reiki, and several others. The objectives described include being able to:
    • understand the concept of subtle energy, the vital force, qi, and prana and their roles in medicine, now and historically.
    • define the terms bioelectromagnetic medicine, biofield therapies, biofield, frequency, electromagnetic field, magnet therapy, medical qigong, Reiki, therapeutic touch, and external qi.
    • explain how energy medicine works according to our present scientific understanding and discuss what scientific questions and controversies still remain, discussing the scientific loopholes in studying bioenergetic fields.
    • understand what skeptics say about energy medicine, and what scientific arguments are used to refute those claims.
    • explain the present and most promising future applications of bioelectromagnetic therapies, citing some key studies showing effectiveness of bioelectromagnetic therapies.
    • list the main types of biofield therapies used in the U.S. and know what they are clinically used for.
    • discuss several key studies examining effectiveness of biofield therapies.
    • experience some form of biofield or bioelectromagnetic energy practice.
AMSA states that “bioenergetic medicine” (BEM) can be used to treat bone fractures, soft tissue injuries, chronic venous insufficiency, osteoporosis, Alzheimer’s disease, and others. Interestingly, the most recent references cited to support these claims date back to the 1990s. Instead of stating that there is no evidence that the “life energy,” “vital force,” or qi exists, this is what the BEM section states:
The biofield refers to the complex, dynamic, extremely weak EM field within and around the human body that has been proposed as a super-regulator of health and healing (Rubik, 2002). Besides the EM components of the biofield emitted by the brain (EEG) and heart (ECG) that are well known in conventional medicine, the human biofield may also consist of more subtle energy fields as elaborated in Oriental Medicine, Ayurvedic Medicine, and other indigenous systems of medicine.
This subtle energy, vital force, or cosmic life energy is a key concept in many CAM modalities, and it is referred to by the many terms listed above from various medical systems (Rubik et al., 1994a). Such vitalistic principles underlie many CAM modalities besides energy medicine, but have been banished from conventional medicine. This fundamental philosophical difference is at the root of medicine’s divided legacy (Coulter, 1994).
Amusingly, the BEM module does cite Emily Rosa’s famous study of therapeutic touch that demonstrates that it doesn’t work and tries to refute it:
Several methodology issues were questioned in this study: 1) consistency of the distance between the experimenter’s and subjects’ hands, 2) lack of reference or use of methodology used by TT experts in 28 prior quantitative studies, 3) lack of accounting for conditions during which HEF cannot be detected by those denying desire for interaction with proper intention. Researchers have concluded in other studies that college students can sense another’s intention to interact with them (Schwartz 1995, 1998).
One notes that the two studies cited that claim that college students can detect another’s intention to interact with them appeared in a journals called Subtle Energies and the Journal of Scientific Exploration. Interestingly enough the Subtle Energies website triggered a malware warning on Safari when I tried to access it; so I didn’t. Maybe its energies are more powerful than expected! Be that as it may, neither journal is what I would describe as reputable, and neither study is a good study. (Maybe I could go into detail on another occasion.) None of the other modules are any better, either. If you don’t believe me, take a look at the homeopathy module, where one of the objectives is to “discuss the scientific controversies and questions that remain for homeopathy and explain basic evidence for and against its clinical application.” There are no “scientific controversies” about homeopathy. It is water; it is a placebo. How many times does this need to be pointed out?
Unfortunately, this is the sort of stuff that AMSA wants to place in medical school curricula, and, to a large extent, it’s succeeding.
In case that isn’t enough, though, AMSA goes far beyond informational resources, helpfully providing its AMSA Medical School CAM Directory, which allows a fast and easy search of CAM programs at various medical schools for medical students looking for CAM electives and sponsors an International Integrative Medicine Day. If that’s still not enough, AMSA offers what is in essence a boot camp for students who want to become leaders in integrative medicine, which it calls Leadership and Education Program for Students in Integrative Medicine (LEAPS into IM). LEAPS into IM is designed to groom future thought leaders in CAM and integrative medicine by choosing 30 students to take part in a week long retreat at the Kripalu Center for Yoga & Health in Berkshire Mountains of Massachusetts. If that’s not enough, there’s also a month long retreat offered known as the Humanistic Elective in Alternative Medicine, Activism and Reflective Transformation (HEART):
Specific sessions will be focused on intentional community building, complementary and alternative/holistic and integrative medicine, social justice and activism, reflective transformation including meditative practices, and personal growth skills such as communication and intention. Any clinical site visits will demonstrate ways to incorporate social justice and patient advocacy into clinical care.
There’s nothing like tying the idealistic impulses of young people to indoctrination in pseudoscience and quackery, is there?
Finally, for students who can’t travel to Massachusetts next June or give up a month of their lives for HEART, there is an online CAM course AMSA calls the Integrative Medicine Scholars Program that allows students interested in integrative medicine to learn and interact online.
Conclusion
As admirable as many of AMSA’s initiatives might be, it is very clear that, when it comes to the promotion of nonscientific medicine, AMSA is far more part of the problem than the solution. I wish it were otherwise, but it is not. That being said, I realize that the “humed” (humanistic medicine) contingent of AMSA is the minority, and my conversations with numerous medical students leads me to believe that many of them quite correctly take a dim view of AMSA’s promotion of woo in the medical school curriculum. Unfortunately, the majority of them are also shruggies, much like most of physicians they will “grow up” to join and ultimately replace, which probably explains why they don’t band together to do something about AMSA’s blatant promotion of pure quackery. How to get medical students more interested in science-based medicine and willing to confront the infiltration of pseudoscience into their main professional organization is the most pressing issue supporters of SBM have in medical education. One wonders what would happen if an SBM-minded group of students tried to form an SBM interest group within AMSA. We can only encourage, offer help to interested students, and hope.

Tens of millions for CAM research — and it’s all on your dime
Jann Bellamy on August 21, 2014
Link

The Federal Funding Accountability and Transparency Act (FFATA) was signed on September 26, 2006. The intent is to empower every American with the ability to hold the government accountable for each spending decision. The end result is to reduce wasteful spending in the government. The FFATA legislation requires information on federal awards (federal financial assistance and expenditures) be made available to the public via a single, searchable website, which is www.USASpending.gov.
And what subject is more deserving of being held accountable by the American people than complementary/alternative/integrative medicine? After all, in what other area of government spending does scientific implausibility – indeed, even scientific impossibility – offer no impediment to spending millions of taxpayer dollars in research funds? We’ve complained about the NCCAM’s wasteful spending on pseudomedicine here on SBM several times: here, here, here and here, among others. As you shall see, the problem doesn’t stop at that particular $2.5 billion.
I ask you: does NASA fund astrology research? No. Does it give money to schools teaching astrology? No. Does the Department of Transportation fund studies of perpetual motion machines as an “alternative” engine for vehicles? Not to my knowledge. How about the Department of the Interior? Do they give people money to look for woodland nymphs? Don’t think so.
The beauty of www.USASpending.gov is that it allows us to hone in on exactly who the beneficiaries of this wasteful government largesse are and what are they are being compensated for, over a period of 2001 to 2014. (Imperfectly, however. The website is somewhat creaky and it’s not always clear how they are getting their totals. Also, I’m using amounts from a search of the “prime awards” only. Your results may differ.) That’s how I know the federal government has not spent a single penny on perpetual motion machines or locating woodland nymphs. I did find one study of “Art and Astrology in Renaissance Italy” that got $40,000 from the National Endowment of the Humanities. Of course, the 1300s – 1500s is exactly where astrology should be, along with acupuncture and other pre-scientific concepts.
Acupuncture
Acupuncture, on the other hand, has received more government funding than astrology. Much, much more. A whopping $76,848,958 since 2001, in the form of contracts, grants and direct payments. Small Business Association loans accounted for an additional $250,000, including $80,000 to the Eternal Health Wellness Acupuncture Center in San Jose, California, which claims to treat a wide variety of diseases and conditions, such as MS, macro [sic] degeneration, bipolar disorder and herpes, among many others.
The biggest beneficiary of acupuncture research funds has been Massachusetts General Hospital, which received $23,229,593 from NIH between 2009 and 2014 (we are just shy of finishing the 2014 fiscal year). Many of those research dollars went into brain imaging studies of patients being treated with acupuncture, or who were thinking about being treated with acupuncture (“An fMRI study of expectancy on acupuncture treatment outcomes in knee OA”). As Steve Novella and David Coloquhoun pointed out, looking at surrogate outcomes is inappropriate until it is shown that patients get a useful degree of relief, and that hasn’t happened yet. (You can see some of the fruits of your tax dollars being used to stick people with needles and look at their brains here.)
The Department of Defense and Veterans Administration are also big fans of acupuncture research. Although they can’t match NCCAM, they’ve spent close to $8 million on such unpromising research projects as that conducted by the New England School of Acupuncture for “Effectiveness of Acupuncture in the Treatment of Gulf War Illness.” The school, recipient of a little over $5.5 million, promotes such appalling quackery as this:
Pediatrics in general and neurodevelopmental pediatrics in particular are perfect opportunities to apply the principles and practices of Chinese Medicine to help children manifest their destiny. In this two-day workshop, Stephen Cowan MD, developmental pediatrician and author of Fire Child Water Child will offer an in-depth discussion of the physiological unfoldings in child development and the treatment approaches to common developmental dysfunctions that include: attention deficit disorder, emotional dysregulation, learning disabilities and autism.
To add insult to injury, the school has a white coat ceremony for students. Yet another honored medical tradition corrupted by “alternative medicine.”
The Department of Defense paid $750,000 to the Samueli Institute for “Acupuncture for the Treatment of Trauma-Induced Spectrum Disorder: A Three-Arm Randomized Pilot Study.” (The results of a Samueli-sponsored study of acupuncture for PTSD touted before a Congressional Committee last year still have not been reported, as far as I can tell.)
The Samueli Institute is led by Wayne Jonas. M.D., and promotes “integrative medicine” and various “alternative” therapies, such as acupuncture and healing touch, an issue I addressed before on SBM. All in all, the Institute has received over $31 million in taxpayer funds from the Department of Defense and over $43 million in taxpayer dollars altogether since 2003, although none in 2014.
Dr. Jonas recently wrote an opinion piece in JAMA Internal Medicine in which he expressed concern over opioid use for pain in the military and called for a “better way.” And how might we discover this “better way?” More research on integrative medicine. I think we can see where this is headed.
Perhaps just as disturbing as the actual studies are the monies spent in spreading acupuncture throughout the military. Last year, the Henry M. Jackson Foundation for the Advancement of Military Medicine Research got over $3 million for acupuncture training “across clinical settings.” Joseph M. Helms, MD, PC, (a proponent of medical acupuncture) has received $1.3 million, much of it for education and curriculum development
Chiropractic
The government has spent almost $120 million on chiropractic, including $4.4 million on Small Business Administration loans to chiropractic practices. There are also direct student loans, but those show up as $0, a curious outcome considering the default rate on chiropractic student loans runs into the millions of dollars. (Again, it’s not clear how the government is reaching the totals given on the website.) The balance is in grants, contracts and direct payments.
One of the primary benefactors of government monies is Palmer Chiropractic College, which received $14 million from the NIH and the Department of HHS Health Resources and Services Administration, as well as the military. These monies have gone toward the establishment of, and research conducted by, the Palmer Research Center. We’ve mentioned the Center before, in its conduct of a study which didn’t seem to produce much of anything in the way of useful results. (See Orac’s dissection here.) That didn’t stop another $7 million plus from going to the RAND Corporation, which will, with the help of the Research Center and the Samueli Institute, conduct an even larger study of standard medical care alone plus standard medical care and “chiropractic care.” One wonders why not just spinal manipulative therapy, not “chiropractic care?” At least that would help isolate the variable that may produce an effect. Or why not medical care and physical therapy?
The study’s title reveals a curious mixture of subjects: “Assessment of Chiropractic Treatment for Low Back Pain, Military Readiness, and Smoking Cessation in Military Active Duty Personnel.” Smoking cessation, by the way, will not be a part of standard medical care – only the chiropractors will get to do that. Let’s just imagine what the results will be: patients who get the extra time and attention beyond standard medical care will do better and this study won’t tell us why, including whether it was simply the extra attention.
But the problems with giving Palmer College all this money go beyond the questionable utility of spending millions of dollars on this study. Palmer is firmly rooted in the non-existent subluxation and its students are required to be proficient in its “detection” and “correction.” As befitting a school loyal to the subluxation, it teaches quack diagnostic and treatment methods like the NUCCA technique and the Atlas Orthogonal Technique. And although the Palmer College website is suspiciously silent on immunizations, chiropractic opposition to vaccination is well-known and one doubts that students are taught objective, evidence-based guidelines for immunizations.
The Center has also participated in other sketchy government-funded research, including the TACT trial. This year, a study was conducted on “Effect of Lumbar Hypo & Hypermobility on Sensory Responses to Spinal Manipulation.” Let’s decode this title. Hypo/hypermobility of the vertebrae is of legitimate concern to manual therapists, but to some chiropractors this hypo/hypermobility is an indication of the presence of a “subluxation.” In other words, it appears Palmer researchers are continuing to look for evidence that the elusive subluxation actually exists.
Why do I think this is a reasonable suspicion? One, as discussed, Palmer College is loyal to the subluxation as a viable “theory” and teaches the concept and its clinical application to students. Two, although the page was removed after I mentioned it in a post last year, as of July, 2013, the Center was telling the public that one of its three areas of research was “mechanisms of care, which encompass normative data, spine lesions (e.g. vertebral subluxation complex) and spinal manipulation/adjustment.”
Contrast the school’s credulous acceptance of a pseudo-scientific concept with the Palmer Research Center director’s taking the American Heart Association/American Stroke Association “to task” over their warning that stroke may be associated with cervical manipulation. Here’s what Christine Goertz, DC, PhD, had to say about that:
“The facts are that VADs are very, very rare events, and there’s absolutely no research that shows a cause-and-effect relationship between chiropractic care and stroke,” said Dr. Goertz. “Doctors need to be careful about how they counsel patients based on misleading statements, like this one from the American Heart Association.”
(Note the euphemistic “chiropractic care” used as a substitute for neck manipulation.)
In sum, looking for evidence of the non-existent chiropractic subluxation is perfectly reasonable, but we need research “that shows a cause-and-effect relationship between chiropractic care and stroke” to conclude that stroke may be associated with cervical manipulation.
Naturopathy, etc.
Compared to acupuncture and chiropractic, naturopathy has received a paltry $6 million since 2003, and the amount has dwindled to a less than $400,000 this year. The majority of that was spent at naturopathic schools to teach naturopaths how to do research and most of it went to the National College of Natural Medicine, with a small portion going to Bastyr. Educating naturopaths in research seems like a fool’s errand, since the evidence indicates they care little about evidence-based practice. (See also: here, here and here, among others.)
A small amount of naturopathic funding went to actual research, including “Carpal Tunnel Syndrome and Static Magnetic Field Therapy.” There was also a small (n=40) prospective study of adjunctive naturopathic care for Type 2 diabetes, in which patients got up to 8 visits to a naturopath in addition to medical care, but any positive results could not be attributed to anything the naturopaths did. (This seems to be a recurring theme in CAM practitioner research: giving CAM an advantage in comparing it to standard medical care by providing extras to the CAM care group.)
Homeopathy got about $230,000 in government funding (including a study titled “Polysomnography in Homeopathic Remedy Effects” at the University of Arizona) although no money’s been spent since 2008. Reiki, on the other hand, has gotten almost a million dollars, including over $400,000 paid by the Department of Defense to a “Reiki Master” in El Paso, Texas.
Why are we doing this?
As has been pointed out before, the government should not be funding research of pseudomedicine and quackery because it doesn’t appear to affect CAM practices. Why bother? It is also a terrible waste of resources. How many other worthy projects went wanting due to lack of available funding?
But the spending has another deleterious effect. It perpetuates institutions that have little respect for science. It helps businesses get started that promote quackery. Even where their operations are not directly affected by government largesse, this money allows those institutions to burnish their images with the presumed respectability of, for example, NIH research funding. It also builds infrastructure and allows the hiring of staff. I doubt there would be a Palmer Research Center without government funding. According to its 2011 tax return, over half of the Samueli Institute’s annual expenses of about $12.5 million came from the government. Dr. Jonas’s salary from this and a related organization were reported at just over $500,000.
Gosh, what we wouldn’t give for a measly half a million dollars to promote science-based medicine?
Addendum: I had no idea when I wrote this post that a pointed and well-deserved critique of complementary/alternative/integrative medicine research would appear practically simultaneously in the journal Trends in Molecular Medicine, written by SBM’s own David Gorski and Steve Novella. Be sure to read the post (found here) for more information and a link to this excellent article.

Related by coincidence only? University and medical journal press releases versus journal articles
David Gorski on August 20, 2012
Link
There are certain topics in Science-Based Medicine (or, in this case, considering the difference between SBM and quackery) that keep recurring over and over. One of these, which is of particular interest to me because I am a cancer surgeon specializing in breast cancer, is the issue of alternative medicine use for cancer therapy. Yesterday, I posted a link to an interview that I did for Uprising Radio that aired on KPFK 90.7 Los Angeles. My original intent was to do a followup post about how that interview came about and to discuss the Gerson therapy, a particularly pernicious and persistent form of quackery. However, it occurred to me as I began to write the article that it would be better to wait a week. The reason is that part of how this interview came about involved three movies, one of which I’ve seen and reviewed before, two of which I have not. In other words, there appears to be a concerted effort to promote the Gerson therapy more than ever before, and it seems to be bearing fruit. In order to give you, our readers, the best discussion possible, I felt it was essential to watch the other two movies. So discussion of the Gerson protocol will have to wait a week or two.
In the meantime, there’s something else that’s been eating me. Whether it’s confirmation bias or something else, whenever something’s been bugging me it’s usually not long before I find a paper or online source to discuss it. In this case, it’s the issue of why scientific studies are reported so badly in the press. It’s a common theme, one that’s popped upon SBM time and time again. Why are medical and scientific studies reported so badly in the lay press? Some would argue that it has something to do with the decline of old-fashioned dead tree media. With content all moving online and newspapers, magazines, and other media are struggling to find a way to provide content (which Internet users have come to expect to be free online) and still make a profit. The result has been the decline of specialized journalists, such as science and medical writers. That’s too easy of an answer, though. As is usually the case, things are a bit more complicated. More importantly, we in academia need to take our share of the blame. A few months ago, Lisa Schwartz and colleagues (the same Lisa Schwartz who with Steven Woloshin at Dartmouth University co-authored an editorial criticizing the Susan G. Komen Foundation for having used an inappropriate measure in one of its ads) actually attempted to look at how much we as an academic community might be responsible for bad reporting of new scientific findings by examining the relationship between the quality of press releases issued by medical journals to describe research findings by their physicians and scientists and the subsequent media reports of those very same findings. The CliffsNotes version of their findings is that we have a problem in academia, and our hands are not entirely clean of the taint of misleading and exaggerated reporting. The version as reported by Schwartz et al in their article published in BMJ entitled Influence of medical journal press releases on the quality of associated newspaper coverage: retrospective cohort study. It’s an article I can’t believe I missed when it came out earlier this year.
Until fairly recently (i.e., since I first started blogging nearly eight years ago), I didn’t pay much attention to press releases from medical journals and universities promoting published research to the media. If anything, the very existence of medical journal press releases about such studies puzzled me, striking me as unnecessary and unseemly self-promotion. (Yes, I was that naive, as amazing as it sounds to me now.) In fact, although I could sort of understand why universities would issue press releases when one of their investigators published a paper that might be of high interest or that appeared in a high impact journal, I wondered why on earth journals would even bother. After all, the quality and impact of science shouldn’t depend upon how many news stories are published about it in the lay press, should it? However, back in the late 1990s, research from investigators in Spain found that journal press releases work; journal press releases are associated with subsequent publication of news stories about the journal article(s) featured in the press release. Other studies suggest the same effect, although a subsequent study suggested that it’s not entirely clear whether this is correlation or causation. The reason is that journal press releases tend to be associated with “medical information that is topical, stratifies risk based on demographic and lifestyle variables, and has lifestyle rather than medical implications.” The authors concluded that medical journals “issue press releases for articles that possess the characteristics journalists are looking for, thereby further highlighting their importance.” Although I can’t prove it, intuitively this rings true, and it’s a finding that is reinforced by a survey of science and health journalists, who reported the “potential for public impact” (which studies that stratifies risk based on demographic and lifestyle variables almost always have) and “new information or development” as their major criteria for newsworthiness, followed by the “ability to provide a human angle” and “ability to provide a local angle.”
It’s hard not to note that these characteristics are pretty much completely unrelated to scientific rigor or importance.
Whatever criteria journals use to choose specific articles to issue press releases about and how large the effect journal and university press releases have on whether the media pick up on a study and report it, there’s a paucity of research out there that looks at how journal press releases influence the actual quality of the reporting on the articles touted by the journals. Therein lies the value of Schwartz et al, because it suggests that we as an academic community are at least as much to blame as reporters and the media companies for which they work. A surgery attending under whom I trained back in the early 1990s used to have a most apt saying whenever we had a patient transferred in: What they tell you the patient has and what the patient actually has are related only by coincidence. In the case of press releases, it sometimes seems that what the press release says and what the study says are related only by coincidence. As a result, since many news articles are based largely on the press release, that means that what the news reports of a study say and what the study itself says are often related only by coincidence.
What Schwartz et al did was to review consecutive issues (going backwards from January 2009) of five major medical journals (Annals of Internal Medicine, BMJ, Journal of the National Cancer Institute, JAMA, and New England Journal of Medicine) to identify the first 100 original research articles with quantifiable outcomes and that had generated any newspaper coverage. These journals were chosen because their articles frequently receive news coverage but they have widely differing editorial practices. For instance, Annals and JNCI routinely include editor notes and editorials highlighting the significance and limitations of the studies featured, while the other journals do not. The NEJM doesn’t issue press releases. Here is how they chose their articles and press releases to study:
Their methodology is described further:
To rate newspaper stories on how they quantified results, we included only journal articles with straightforward quantifiable outcomes (that is, we excluded qualitative studies, case reports, biological mechanism studies, and studies not using an individual unit of analysis). To identify associated newspaper stories, we searched Lexis Nexis and Factiva (news article databases) for stories that included the medical journal name (the time frame for the search extended from two months before the journal article’s print date, to two months after).
The authors then did content analysis on the press releases and the news stories using the following criteria:
    • Basic study facts. These include factors such as study size, funding source(s), identification of randomized trials, longitudinal study time frames, survey response rates, and accurate description (compared with the abstract) of study exposure and outcome.
    • Main result. This included asking several questions, including: “Was the main result quantified? If so, was it quantified with any absolute risks (including proportions, means, or medians)? Were numbers used correctly (for example, did the numbers reported correspond to those in the abstract in terms of magnitude and time frame, or were odds or odds ratios misinterpreted as risks or risk ratios? The odds ratio issue was included under the category of numbers used correctly rather than as a separate measure.”
    • Harms. These included questions such as (for studies of interventions claiming to be beneficial): Were harms mentioned (or a statement asserting there were no harms)? Were harms quantified? If so, were they quantified with any absolute risks?
    • Study limitations. The authors asked if major limitations of the study were correctly described (or described at all) and considered “limitations noted in either the journal abstract or editor note, or on a design specific list that we created (web appendix) that includes limitations inherent in various study designs: small study size, inferences about causation, selection bias, representativeness of sample, confounding, clinical relevance of surrogate outcomes, clinical meaning of scores or surrogate outcomes, hypothetical nature of decision models, applicability of animal studies to humans, clinical relevance of gene association studies, uncontrolled studies, studies stopped early because of benefit, and multifactorial dietary or behavioural interventions.”
So what were the findings? To those of us in the science/medicine blogging biz, the findings are depressing but not surprising. For instance, although nearly all stories reported the exposure and outcome accurately, most stories were missing critically important information. For instance, only 23% quantified the main result using absolute risks (which actually surprised me; I would have guess the number to be lower, but perhaps there was a sampling difference between what I read and what Schwartz et al picked to study). Meanwhile, only 41% mentioned harms associated with interventions reported as beneficial (which, I admit, is lower than I would have guessed), and only 29% mentioned any study limitation (which is about what I would have guessed).
So now that we know that the medical reporting in the sample studied in this article was not so hot, what is the correlation between the press release and the news reporting:
For all 13 quality measures, newspaper stories were more likely to report the measure if the relevant information appeared in a press release (that is, a high quality press release) than if the information was missing (P=0.0002, sign test; fig 2⇓). This association was significant in separate comparisons for nine quality measures (fig 2). For example, when the press release did not quantify the main result with absolute risks, 9% of the 168 newspaper stories provided these numbers. By contrast, when the press release did provide absolute risks, 53% of the 77 newspaper stories provided these numbers (relative risk 6.0, 95% confidence interval 2.3 to 15.4). Because the accessibility of absolute risks varies with study design, we repeated this analysis for randomised trials only, in which absolute risks are always easily accessible. For the 140 newspaper stories reporting on randomised trials, the influence of press releases reporting absolute risks was the same as the main analysis (relative risk 5.8, 95% confidence interval 2.2 to 15.5).
It also turns out that the presence or absence of a quality measure in the press release had more influence than the presence or absence of the quality measure in the journal article abstract on whether that measure ended up being included in subsequently reported news stories:
Presence of a quality measure in the press release had a stronger influence on the quality of associated newspaper stories than its presence in the abstract (table 3⇓). The association between information in the press release and in the story was significant for seven of the 12 quality measures that could be compared (table 3). The corresponding association between information in the abstract and in the story was significant for two of the 12 measures. In absolute terms, the independent effect of information in the press release was larger than the effect of information in the abstract for eight of 12 measures. The only measure for which the absolute effect of the abstract was greater than that of the press release was for quantifying the main result (although press releases were substantially more influential for quantifying the main result with absolute risks).
Interestingly, the existence of a press release of high quality had little effect on reporting compared to reporting on articles that had had no press release issued at all for the basic study facts. High quality press releases did, however, positively influence reporting of quantification using absolute risks, mentioning harms, and discussing limitations of the study. More disturbingly, Schwartz et al suggests that poor quality press releases are worse than no press release at all in that important caveats and fundamental information were less likely to be reported in news stories if they weren’t included in the press release than if there was no press release at all. This, however, was a trend, because Schwartz et al point out that these latter findings were not statistically significant. The wag in me can’t resist asking why Schwartz et al even mentioned this last finding, even though it seems to make intuitive sense.
It’s not just medical journals, of course. Universities and academic medical centers have press offices, and these press offices frequently issue press releases touting the research of their investigators, sometimes in parallel with journals when a new article is published, sometimes independently, and, I can’t help but note, sometimes even before a researcher’s work has even passed muster in the peer review process. It turns out that Woloshin et al (including Dr. Schwartz) looked at this issue three years ago in a study published in the Annals of Internal Medicine entitled Press Releases by Academic Medical Centers: Not So Academic? They didn’t try to determine the influence of university press releases on subsequent media coverage (although I’d be shocked if such a study weren’t in the works as a followup to this one), but they did look at the quality of university press releases.
Because the investigators used similar methodology in their 2009 paper as they did in their 2012 paper, I’m not going to slog through this paper’s details as much as I did for the previous one. Its key findings are probably enough. Specifically, the results support the hypothesis that university press offices are prone to exaggeration, particularly with respect to animal studies and their relevance to human health and disease, although press releases about human studies exaggerated 18% of the time compared to 41% of the time for animal studies. Again, this seems to make intuitive sense, because in order to “sell” animal research results it is necessary to sell its relevance to human disease. Most lay people aren’t that interested in novel and fascinating biological findings in basic science that can’t be readily translated into humans; so it’s not surprising that university press offices might stretch a bit to draw relevance where there is little or none. In addition, a Woloshin et al observed a tendency for universities to hype preliminary research and to fail to provide necessary context:
Press releases issued by 20 academic medical centers frequently promoted preliminary research or inherently limited human studies without providing basic details or cautions needed to judge the meaning, relevance, or validity of the science. Our findings are consistent with those of other analyses of pharmaceutical industry (12) and medical journal (13) press releases, which also revealed a tendency to overstate the importance and downplay (or ignore) the limitations of research.
It’s well-known that industry press releases tend to do all of these things, which is the main reason I’m not harping on them so much in this post. It’s just expected that big pharma exaggerates because the evidence that it does is so overwhelming. In contrast, however, such exaggeration is usually not expected from universities. At least, it wasn’t in the past. Apparently today is a new day.
In human studies, the problem appears to be different. There’s another saying in medicine that statistical significance doesn’t necessarily mean that a finding will be clinically significant. In other words, we find small differences in treatment effect or associations between various biomarkers and various diseases that are statistically significant all the time. However, they are often too small to be clinically significant. Is, for example, an allele whose presence means a risk of a certain condition that is increased by 5% clinically significant? It might be if the risk in the population is less than 5%, but if the risk in the population is 50%, much less so. We ask this question all the time in oncology when considering whether or not a “positive” finding in a clinical trial of adjuvant chemotherapy is clinically relevant. For example, if chemotherapy increases the five year survival by 2% in a tumor that has a high likelihood of survival after surgery clinically relevant? Or is an elevated lab value that is associated with a 5% increase in the risk of a condition clinically relevant? Yes, it’s a bit of a value judgment, but small benefits that are statistically significant aren’t always clinically relevant.
Now here’s the kicker that suggests that investigators are part of the problem. Nearly all of the press releases included investigator quotes. This is not in itself surprising; investigator quotes would seem to be a prerequisite for even a halfway decent press release. What is surprising is that 26% of these investigator quotes were deemed to be overstating the importance of the research, a number that is strikingly similar to the percentage of press releases judged to be exaggerating the importance of the research (29%). Indeed, at one point Woloshin et al characterize the tone of many of these investigator quotes as “overly enthusiastic.” This suggests that it is the investigators, at least as much as their universities, who drive the exaggeration of the importance of their research findings. Our culpability as scientists in distorting our own science is even more glaring in light of the additional finding that all 20 major universities studied said that investigators routinely request press releases and are regularly involved in editing and approving them. In addition:
Only 2 centers routinely involve independent reviewers. On average, centers employed 5 press release writers (the highest-ranked centers had more writers than lower-ranked centers [mean, 6.6 vs. 3.7]). Three centers said that they trained writers in research methods and results presentation, but most expected writers to already have these skills and hone them on the job. All 20 centers said that media coverage is an important measure of their success, and most report the number of “media hits” garnered to the administration.
Five press release writers can churn out a heck of a lot of press releases in a year! Also, lack of outside evaluation can very easily lead to a hive mentality in which nothing is questioned.
There were several potential actions listed in the papers I’ve just discussed that universities and medical journals can take to lessen the problem, although it’s improbable that the problem of bad press releases will ever go away. Perhaps the most important (and most unlikely to be implemented) is for universities and medical journals to stop hyping preliminary research so heavily. It’s noted that 40% of meeting abstracts and 25% of abstracts that garner media attention are never subsequently published as full articles in the peer-reviewed literature. Unfortunately, universities are highly unlikely to show such restraint to any great degree, because the rewards of not showing restraint are too great. After all, it is the preliminary research that is often the most exciting to the public and—let’s face it—to scientists. It’s the sort of research that gets an institution (or journal) noticed. There’s a reason why journals like Nature, Cell, Science, and the NEJM like to publish preliminary, provocative studies. Unfortunately, it is just such research that is likely to be subsequently shown to be incorrect. Another thing universities could do is to to be sure to include as many of the quality indicators for each study as is appropriate, including absolute effects, study limitations, warnings that surrogate outcomes don’t always translate into clinical outcomes, and the like.
Perhaps most importantly, we scientists have to do two things. First, we have to avoid the temptation to oversell and overhype our results in press releases or when talking to the press. It’s a very strong temptation, as I’ve become aware, because we want to look good and we want to please our employers by making them look good too. We also want to justify the press release. Too many caveats and cautions make our work sound less important (or, more accurately, less certain) to a lay audience, and if it’s one thing that’s hard to explain to a lay audience it’s the inherent uncertainty in science. We can’t avoid that; we have to embrace it and work to explain it to the public.
Finally, I don’t want to leave you with the impression that reporters are off the hook. Nothing could be further from the truth. While some reporters definitely “get it” (Trine Tsouderos of the Chicago Tribune and Marilyn Marchione of the Associated Press come to mind), many do not. However, we as an academic community—investigators, universities, and medical journals—can greatly decrease the chances that reporters will produce grossly exaggerated or incorrect reporting if we make sure that their sources are scientifically accurate and don’t fall prey to the sins enumerated in the studies discussed here. That’s part of our job as scientists, every bit as much as making sure our science is rigorous and obtaining funding for our labs.

Malingering: The Lord Voldemort of Medicine
Understanding of malingering isn’t advanced with acquiescence and silence
Jonathan Howard on April 8, 2022
Link
Definitions
Malingering occurs when a person feigns symptoms to get something tangible, such as money, time off from work, or food and shelter. This is called secondary gain. Malingering is distinguished from factitious disorder where a person feigns symptoms in the absence of external rewards. This is called primary gain and occurs when people get something intangible from feigning illness, namely attention and sympathy.
Malingering is a “diagnosis of exclusion”, meaning that it can only be made when other conditions have been definitively ruled out. Symptoms such as seizures, chest pain, paralysis, and psychosis are commonly feigned as they take time to evaluate and dangerous diseases cannot be instantly excluded. Malingering itself is not a diagnosis. It is not a psychiatric illness according to The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. As such, it is not clear that people who malinger are really patients any more than someone who pretends to be a doctor is really a doctor.
A controversy
Last year, a psychiatrist, Dr. Derek Tracy, received substantial criticism on Twitter after announcing he was going to lecture students on malingering. In response, he cancelled the talk and released the following statement:
I have cancelled the proposed talk on ‘malingering.” I have seen some of the postings on Twitter about the talk, and reflected on the hurt it has caused, particularly for people who have personal experience of not being believed by mental health professions or services. I am very sorry for this.
Over the past ten years or so, evaluation of malingering has been a relatively small part of academic work that I do. It originated from assessing cognitive testing, and some medico-legal/court work. It is the case that some people have lied and feigned mental illness for various reasons in these environments, and it is important, as in any case of fraud, that the courts try detect this. Professionals, including psychiatrists, have been involved in some such instances.
However, it is also try that this is very much a minority occurrence, and the vast majority of people are doing their best to manage their mental health with or without the support of professional services. It is also the case that many people have felt ignored, marginalized, and disbelieved when engaging with services. The title of the proposed talk, the manner in which was advertised, and the lack of consideration for the wider context has understandingly caused upset.
Where professional discussions on malingering occur, I think that they are best kept to more specialist medico-legal settings and forums. A general medical student conference was not the place for this. The responsibility for giving the talk is mine, and not the medical students- I am the one who should have better anticipated this.
I apologize for the hurt and upset I have cause.
After the cancellation was announced, critics commented that:
    • Malingering is generally accepted to be very rare and should be a fringe interest.
    • Malingering is not common & the discourse on it is toxic for patients.
    • Malingering happens but I think most people who might be mislabeled as malingering are just struggling to express their complex mental health issues in understandable terms.
    • The damage caused by mislabeling and not trusting the narrative of those with mental ill health is immeasurable.
    • Malingering should be a problem for practicing clinicians, not students still only learning.
    • Those of us that do speak out with regard to our chronic mental health conditions are often silenced and not believed and accused of ” faking it”
While these concerns are valid, I believe that not talking about malingering in a formal setting with students is a mistake and more likely to increase these unfortunate outcomes.
“You are calling them a liar”
The word malingering is often quite pejorative in medicine. It conjures an image of someone who lies and fakes symptoms for unethical reasons. This happens occasionally. A decade ago several Long Island Railroad employees were prosecuted after they “falsely claimed to be disabled upon early retirement so they could receive extra pension benefits typically between the ages of 50 and 65”. Doctors, who were often paid in cash, were in on the scheme. According to prosecutors, some doctors “ran disability fraud mills, serving as willing rubber stamps for fraud rather than as independent medical professionals”.
Given its negative connotations, malingering must be discussed with care. As Dr. Jeffrey Keller, who works with inmates, wrote,
The most important consideration of the term “malingering” is not its actual definition. The most important part is its emotional meaning. This is a word that causes others to instantaneously have a strong emotional reaction. When you say that a patient is malingering, whether you are using the term correctly or not, what that patient (and others) understand is that you are calling them a liar.
He’s right.
However, if a clinician is confident that a patient is feigning symptoms, they should not shy away from saying so. Using a diagnosis other than malingering would require clinicians to be dishonest as well. Given that it is such an emotionally laden term, clinicians should recognize that by labeling a person a malingerer, they will likely affect their encounters with future health care providers. People with a documented history of malingering are greeted with suspicion when they present with new symptoms, which is problematic. As such, some doctors have suggested getting rid of the term malingering all together. While I understand the reasons for this, medicine needs some term to describe people who feign illness, and whatever term replaces malingering will soon come to be seen as pejorative as well.
How common is malingering?
Doctors have wildly different perceptions of how common malingering is. My career has afforded me relatively unique perspective on this topic, I believe. I’ve worked on hospital wards at both Bellevue, a public hospital with a jail ward, and New York University, a private hospital up the street. I’ve worked in outpatient clinics at both hospitals. For over a decade, I worked the Sunday overnight shift in the Bellevue psychiatric emergency room.
My impression is that the frequency of malingering varies greatly based on the location, time of day, and season. I’ve only clearly seen it once in my outpatient neurology clinics, in a man who was suing an airline. In contrast, I encounter it often in the ER at 2AM on a snowy night. Often times it is easy to detect, such as a person who comes to the ER for the fourth time that week calmly reporting “voices telling me to hurt myself and others”, and later requests to leave with their symptoms completely resolved after a hot meal and a night’s sleep. Occasionally, these individuals will admit to feigning symptoms so they are not retained in the hospital against their will.
Determining the true rate of malingering is obviously difficult as patients are unlikely to respond to questions asking them if they are lying about their symptoms. One study found:
Twenty-nine percent of personal injury, 30% of disability, 19% of criminal, and 8% of medical cases involved probable malingering and symptom exaggeration. Thirty-nine percent of mild head injury, 35% of fibromyalgia/chronic fatigue, 31% of chronic pain, 27% of neurotoxic, and 22% of electrical injury claims resulted in diagnostic impressions of probable malingering.
Another study found “the prevalence of malingering in patients suffering from chronic pain with financial incentive was found to be between 20% to 50% depending on the diagnostic system used”. Yet another study of psychiatric patients in the correctional setting, found that 66% were malingering. In certain settings at least, malingering is not rare.
However, a corollary to this is that malingering occurs only in a very small minority of medical encounters. Several of Dr. Tracy’s critics worried that his lecture would encourage students to detect malingering where it does not exist. While this is a valid concern, a well-done lecture would instead teach students that the overwhelming majority of people do not feign illness to get something tangible in return. The very small number of people who do malinger tend to do so in limited, predictable circumstances. Malingering almost never occurs outside these situations. Even the majority of people with a with personal injury claims, for example, are not malingering. Doctors should know this.
Why is malingering worth talking about?
Unfortunately, malingering is almost never formally discussed as part of the medical curriculum. There are lectures and discussions on all manners of disease, including those that occur in literally one-in-a-million people. Even though it is not rare in certain settings, I’ve never heard any talk on malingering. As Dr. Tracy found out, clinicians who attempt to lecture on this subject may face withering criticism. It is truly the Lord Voldemort of medicine. Everyone knows it exists, no one likes it, and those who try to talk about it are silenced.
Yet, malingering is worth talking about because it happens, and not talking about it doesn’t make it go away. If students don’t learn about malingering in a lecture, they will instead learn about it informally in work rooms and on rounds, almost certainly without the wisdom and compassion Dr. Tracy would have brought to the topic. Indeed, some informal rules in medicine assume patients will lie. For example, clinicians are often taught to automatically double the amount of alcohol a patient says they consume. This “informal curriculum” of medical school is not the ideal place to learn about a sensitive topic such as malingering.
Not talking about malingering in a formal setting may increase the chances that patients will be “ignored, marginalized, and disbelieved”, the outcome Dr. Tracy rightly wants to avoid. Dr. Tracy was right when he said that malingering “is very much a minority occurrence, and the vast majority of people are doing their best to manage their mental health with or without the support of professional services”. However, I disagree when he said that “a general medical student conference was not the place” to learn about this. In my opinion, a general medical student conference is the ideal place for students to learn that malingering is generally rare. They won’t learn this anywhere else.
Students also need to be learn about potential pitfalls in treating these individuals. Depending on the feigned condition, malingering can be dangerous. Not uncommonly, I see patients who feign symptoms and then receive multiple unnecessary tests and procedures, including radiation from CT scans. Occasionally, I have seen them receive medications with potentially devastating side effects, such as thrombolytic medications for strokes. Although malingering is a diagnosis of exclusion, once a clinician is convinced a person is malingering, care must be taken not to hurt them through iatrogenesis.
Importantly, feigning or exaggerating symptoms is often not an all-or-nothing phenomenon, something that students need to learn as well. Doctors have several tricks to help determine who is feigning a symptom such as leg weakness. Earlier in my career, I might have dismissed a patient if I “caught” them with one of these tricks. I still use them occasionally, but I’ve learned to do so with care. Some people with legitimate illness may exaggerate their symptoms so they are not ignored or to communicate their discomfort to clinicians, though this is not malingering of course. A clinician who feels a patient is exaggerating some symptoms should be very careful not to then discount everything else the patient says. Moreover, someone who malingers chest pain on a Saturday is not protected from having a heart attack on a Sunday. Doctors must try to balance this fact while not subjecting patients to repeated batteries of expensive, potentially harmful diagnostic tests. This is a difficult task, but it is not made easier by forbidding discussions of malingering.
Additionally, clinicians should try to understand how malingerers make them feel and how this may impact their care. Like the existence of malingering in the first place, its effect on clinicians is almost completely ignored. Yet, malingering can have a corrosive effect on clinicians, leading them to believe everyone is lying to them. As obstetrician Dr. Amy Tuteur wrote,
The patients who are deliberately deceptive seem to have an outsize influence on the practice of medicine. During internship and residency, young doctors are repeatedly fooled, and therefore embarrassed, by patients. Drug addicts are notorious for presenting themselves as model citizens with serious pain problems. After several episodes of unwittingly giving an addict a fix, or a prescription for drugs that will be sold, young doctors begin to listen to a patients’ stories with increasing cynicism. The subtext for many physicians, consciously or unconsciously, is that they must be convinced that the patient is telling the truth.
Clinician surveys bear this out. In a Medscape survey from 2016, malingerers were rated among as those that most were likely to trigger bias. This is not a surprise. No one likes to be deceived. As such, clinicians should be encouraged to talk about how malingering make them feel, rather than allowing negative feelings to fester undiscussed and unexamined, impacting the care of future patients.
I know for example that I am often distrustful of prisoners. I am not proud of this fact, but after seeing wheelchair-bound prisoners suddenly regain the ability to walk after being bailed out, it is an involuntary association at this point. I know I am not alone. Patients will not be well served by doctors who deny their feelings and never introspect about how this may impact their decisions. Knowing my biases, I try to go the “extra mile” for patients of whom I am automatically suspicious to make sure I don’t miss anything. After all, a prisoner who says that can’t walk may actually have a spinal cord disorder. I’ve seen that many times too. Almost every doctor will have the experience of disbelieving a patient who turns out to have a genuine illness. It’s terrible when this happen, and frank discussions of malingering may lessen the frequency of such events.
Additionally, doctors should learn how to manage people who malinger, though this is difficult. Confronting them is usually counterproductive, as they may feel required to “prove” the clinician wrong and maintain the sick role. Instead, clinicians should do their best to maintain an alliance with them and express optimism about their condition, so there is no shame when they get “better”.
“Understanding isn’t advanced with acquiescence and silence”
Most importantly, clinicians should be sensitive to the fact that most people have perfectly legitimate reasons to malinger. The railroad employees who feigned illness as a scam are outliers. Almost every patient I have seen malinger has done so for a very valid reason, and I’ve become much more sympathetic to most of them as a result.
Faking a seizure may be a rational response for a prisoner who is housed with rival gang members. A woman who feigns chest pain may be doing so to escape an abusive partner. Patients with substance dependence may feign an injury to stave off withdrawal, a violently unpleasant experience. I’ve seen all of this and more. Most commonly in my experience, patients malinger simply to get food and a safe place to sleep. This is an entirely adaptive response for a hungry, vulnerable, homeless person on a freezing cold night.
As such, people who malinger should treated with kindness and respect. Most are marginalized and suffering. They usually have nothing and nobody to help them. Even if the hospital is not the right place for them to get food and a bed night after night, they deserve our sympathy. Too often they do not receive it. Clinicians who quickly dismiss malingerers may not bother to learn what motivated them to feign symptoms in the first place, and they may miss other ways they can help the person. A referral to a domestic violence shelter or a suggestion that corrections officers transfer an endangered inmate to a safer jail unit can be life-altering. I wish I had been more attuned to this early in my career.
Not everyone agreed with Dr. Tracy’s decision to cancel his talk. A physical therapist named Cameron Tudor wrote,
The reasons you give for cancelling seem to be exactly the reasons why you should give this talk. We need people with specific expertise to help others understand, to shift paradigms. Understanding isn’t advanced with acquiescence and silence.
This is exactly why Dr. Tracy should proudly teach students about malingering.

Ad-Conned: A Critical Look At CASPer
Medical schools are facing a flood of applicants, and have started using for-profit tests alleged to assess people skills as a way to distinguish candidates. The evidence is weak, and lacks transparency.
Braden MacBeth on January 29, 2021
Link

Over the past few months, I’ve been working on a little side project that requires me to look at the websites of every medical school in the country. There was one particular point of similarity with some schools that was equal parts intriguing and suspicious. Schools that required applicants to submit CASPer scores use the exact same description of CASPer and why they choose to require it:
CASPer is an online, video-scenario based test which assesses for non-cognitive skills and interpersonal characteristics that we believe are important for success in our program and will complement the other tools that we use for applicant selection.
A surprising amount of schools use this exact verbiage: Baylor, Temple, Howard, Michigan State, and Wisconsin. I could keep going through the list, but it seems like 75% of schools that require CASPer use this exact verbiage. I find this strange because it seems like some type of affirmative defense. We all understand why the MCAT is used for med school admissions and the schools don’t feel the need to justify why it is used: it tests all of the content typically required of medical school prerequisite courses in a standardized way. CASPer is a bit different though.
Altus describes CASPer as an effective screening tool for “people skills” backed by more than 12 years of academic research. The exam consists of word and video scenarios and test-takers must write an open-ended response to a series of questions after the scenario is presented. The responses are graded by human graders, and a percentile-based score is sent to every school the test-taker designates. The exam costs $12 to take, and $12 to send the results to each school that requires CASPer results. Altus started out marketing CASPer to medical schools but has expanded its market to all manner of healthcare-adjacent graduate programs.
The published evidence does not support any of Altus’s claims about CASPer. The test lacks transparency about its scoring or content. Based on published evidence, CASPer may be biased against certain groups. CASPer should not be incorporated into the medical school admissions process, and should be considered the standardized testing equivalent of homeopathy. Let’s look at why.
The rules are made up and the points don’t matter
Altus wants adcoms (admissions committees) to see CASPer in the same light as the MCAT – as a selection factor for admission. Historically the MCAT has consistently been one of the most important selection factors for medical school adcoms because adcoms can simply look at the score and understand how well an applicant knows the prerequisite content areas. That’s ultimately meant to be the appeal of CASPer as well – a simple score they can make a decision about, only for soft skills. But while the design of the MCAT allows adcoms to do this, the design of CASPer doesn’t.
While Altus doesn’t market CASPer as a standardized test, it’s a standardized test. The scores of a standardized test reflect how well someone performs against a standard. To understand what the scores mean, you have to understand the standard for the test. The AAMC publishes a book-length document about what is on the MCAT: the format of the exam, nature of questions, and what areas are being assessed. They specifically define what skills like “Data-Based Statistical Reasoning” means and how it might be assessed in its content sections. Without being able to contextualize what the score means from looking at the standard in this way, the MCAT score would be meaningless.
CASPer provides no documented standard for how the skills are defined and assessed in the exam. On CASPer’s website they claim to assess for collaboration, communication, empathy, equity, ethics, motivation, problem solving, professionalism, resilience, and self-awareness. You actually have to define what “professionalism” and “problem solving” mean in the context of the exam, and explain how these will be assessed on the exam. Altus provides no documentation for how the open-ended responses are scored other than spelling not being a part of the score. As a result, test-takers have no idea how to structure their responses, or what constitutes a good response. But Altus markets this issue as one of CASPer’s killer features.
Altus states in its FAQ that no preparation is required:
The general literature suggests that situational judgment tests (SJTs), like the CASPer test, are relatively immune to test preparation (i.e. that coaching is unlikely to provide benefit).
This is simply untrue. While there are many papers claiming to be able to minimize coaching effects in situational judgement tests, most of these papers focus on the effects of coaching in multiple choice or other discrete answer style situational judgement tests. Their findings do not necessarily apply to CASPer. Furthermore, many of these papers have serious financial conflicts of interest. There are papers like this one that state that situational judgement tests are very prone to coaching. If test-takers knew how the test was being scored, the test would probably be a joke.
There are multiple companies offering CASPer test prep courses. Altus claims “We have heard students directly recommending to other students that they don’t think it helped them.” I have no idea how a company that effectively boasts ‘our test is a scientific way to assess what a good person you are’ can justify anything with: ‘dude, trust me’. Altus does not provide scores to test-takers, with the exception of a few schools participating in their revolutionary program where they actually send scores back to test-takers. However, that doesn’t mean that companies couldn’t get the scores by simply asking someone with access to them. The only reason there hasn’t been a flood of CASPer prep products coming out is because it’s unclear how adcoms actually use these scores. Nobody knows if it’s worth the trouble to figure it out that much. If test-takers have no idea what advantage they get from scoring highly on the exam, they don’t have any real incentive to prepare for it. As soon as it becomes clear how much weight adcoms place on CASPer scores, the test’s entire scoring system will be leaked or reverse-engineered and strategies will be developed for prep courses and shared online.
The marketing research
There’s very little research on CASPer, and there’s no evidence that CASPer is effective at identifying people more likely to succeed in medical school. Of the research that does exist, they only correlate CASPer scores with secondary endpoints or simulated outcomes: not actual medical school admissions outcomes. The only paper that attempts to show that CASPer scores correlate with success in medical school is a 2016 study published in Advances in Health Sciences Education titled “CASPer, an online pre-interview screen for personal/professional characteristics: prediction of national licensure scores“. In the study, the authors administered the CASPer video exam to Canadian medical school applicants and followed the board scores of those who were accepted. The only real correlation was moderate between CASPer scores and scores on the Considerations of Legal, Ethical and Organizational Aspects of the Practice of Medicine (CLEO) section of the MCCQE Part II. The authors conclude:
CASPer is able to predict for personal/professional characteristics with similar magnitude that GPA and MCAT predict for cognitive outcomes.
Then invalidate their own conclusion with:
Additionally, CASPer demonstrated no correlation with cognitive outcomes and measures of medical expertise.
The CLEO of the MCCQE, in addition to all other sections of the MCCQE, is an assessment of medical knowledge, clinical skills and knowledge of professional behaviors and attitudes at a level expected of a physician in independent practice in Canada. The CLEO standards defines professional characteristics and behaviors and tests for them. Professionalism, medical ethics, and principles of health law are part of the body of knowledge that medical students are expected to learn and know for the CLEO exam as part of their education. CLEO scores are not a reflection of “personal attributes”. CASPer does not measure professional characteristics because professionalism is an individualized body of knowledge defined by each profession. While there might be a mathematical correlation, that doesn’t mean it logically follows. You should also be relieved to know that most students score very well on the CLEO section of the MCCQE exam.
The other major study looking at CASPer was published in Academic Medicine titled “Addressing the Diversity–Validity Dilemma Using Situational Judgment Tests“. This study also features the two co-creators of CASPer as authors. The authors collected the data of all applicants to the New York Medical College School of Medicine including: GPA, Multiple Mini-Interview Score (MMI, used to assess nonacademic competencies), MCAT, and CASPer score. CASPer was not used in decision-making at any point in the admissions process. The authors then performed simulations using applicant CASPer, MMI, GPA, and MCAT scores, giving different weights to each to predict how many applicants of different demographics would be admitted as those metrics were changed. They found that increasing the weight of CASPer scores in the simulations increased the number of female, and racial and ethnic minority, applicants who are invited to interview.
This study is fundamentally flawed both in its methods and its conclusions. Simulations can be incredibly powerful tools in predicting future outcomes, but they’re only useful if realistic assumptions are made – and in this case the weights used were laughably unrealistic. The four simulations included:
    • MCAT/GPA only
    • One-third weight given to CASPer
    • One-half weight given to CASPer
    • Only CASPer
When CASPer score was given 1/2 weight in comparison to the MCAT and GPA, it only resulted in three additional African-American, and seven Hispanic, applicants being invited for an interview. The problem is that adcoms would never give that amount of weight to CASPer scores, as evidenced by published data.
GPA and MCAT are of the highest importance to adcoms when deciding who to invite for an interview. The assumption that CASPer scores would be given half weight against GPA and MCAT is just absurd. It is well established in the literature that lower GPAs and MCAT scores from black applicants are due to economic status. Anyone from a lower-income background is likely to spend less money on MCAT prep products like third-party practice tests, review books, or entire preparation courses, and may also be working part- or full-time, resulting in less time to study for classes and the MCAT. Naturally, this tends to lower scores, and adcoms account for this when looking at applications from traditionally underrepresented groups.
At the time this paper was written, likely there were no preparation products for CASPer and little reason to purchase any such products if they existed in the first place. As a result, scores across groups would likely not reflect the same sort of racial and economic bias as other standardized testing scores. The CASPer exam can be prepared for, there is little incentive to do so based on the (lack of) weight the admission process puts on it. The reason that CASPer doesn’t display the same sort of racial and economic biases in outcomes is that the circumstances that lead to that bias do not yet exist. Further, all of this is based on the assumption that the test isn’t biased against certain groups in the first place.
The second study on CASPer shows that the exam is biased against men based upon the data. Men made up 54% of the applicants in the study. In the simulation where CASPer was not considered at all, a near-equal amount of men and women were invited for an interview. As soon as CASPer was included in the simulation the gender split included more women: in the one-third CASPer weight condition, 55% of applicants invited to an interview were women, rising to 64% when only CASPer was considered (predictably, with a 50% CASPer weight the result is 58%). Simply using GPA and MCAT with no consideration of CASPer scores resulted in a simulated interview pool whose gender breakdown was closest to the applicant pool and society.
It’s unclear how much this gender bias in scoring could affect actual admissions outcomes because nobody knows how CASPer is weighted in the admissions process. It’s also unclear if CASPer exhibits racial and ethnic bias because no such study has been done. To summarize, the use of CASPer wouldn’t likely benefit minority applicants under realistic conditions. This study also doesn’t show that the CASPer exam isn’t biased against racial and ethnic minorities. The primary demographic, if any, that would benefit from CASPer being weighted a realistic amount by admissions committees would likely be women – who have made up the majority of medical school applicants and graduates since 2017.
Conflicts of interest in CASPer and MMI research
There are significant issues with the conflicts of interest disclosed in the research on CASPer. These conflicts of interest are so apparent it makes it incredibly difficult to take the conclusions of these studies seriously even if I were to ignore their unacceptable methodological flaws. The first two authors in the Advances in Health Sciences Education article were Kelly Dore and Harold I. Reiter, who are the creators of the CASPer exam and shareholders in Altus Assessments, the private company that administers and profits from CASPer (Dore is also the vice president of the company). The fourth author, Geoffrey Norman, is the founding editor of the journal that published this article. This is the only article that could possibly be cited as evidence that CASPer scores can be used to predict professional behavior, which it didn’t show in the slightest. Every article pertaining to CASPer being used for med school admissions currently features the co-creators of CASPer as authors.
In the Academic Medicine article, the same conflicts of interest exist. However, there is a statement in the discussion section that is really intriguing and I think warrants a closer look:
The differences in performance between UIMs and “traditional” applicants tended to be smaller or reversed with assessments of nonacademic competency (CASPer, MMI) compared with academic assessments. For example, when comparing low SES relative to no economic disadvantage, African Americans relative to whites, and Hispanics/Latinos relative to non-Hispanics/non-Latinos, CASPer demonstrated smaller but still evident group effect sizes, whereas the MMI demonstrated the absence of any significant subgroup differences with African Americans. However, this beneficial result has not been found with MMI use at other schools, so caution must be taken in the extrapolation of these MMI results.
This seems like a subtle implication that some schools that have implemented multiple mini-interviews have done it differently than other schools might be biased. Potentially. Maybe. Who knows? However, I feel like it might push the readers to look into what a MMI structure would lead to minority groups not being disadvantaged. Perhaps an interested reader might find structured MMI programs that fit that criteria available for purchase at no small expense. This may include an “off-the-shelf” MMI interview program from a company called ProfitHR or ProspectHR; of which Harold Reiter is a shareholder. The ProspectHR site states that they have consulted with over 75 universities that have a lot more name recognition than Slippery Rock. Harold Reiter was also the primary author of the landmark study talking about the concept of a multiple mini-interview. Reiter doesn’t disclose this in the conflicts of interest section in this Academic Medicine, despite this being an obvious material conflict of interest.
To be fair, Reiter discloses this fact on other papers that directly discuss multiple mini-interviews. However, there is a reason that we have conflicts of interest disclosure sections. If positive results from a study would benefit your personal business, your positive results should be viewed with more skepticism. The only studies that I can find looking at CASPer and actual admissions outcomes were authored by the two creators of CASPer. You can produce bad papers, and you can have serious conflicts of interest, but if you publish papers so fundamentally flawed with results that would only encourage people to purchase your product, I think there should be consequences for that. The consequence should be that I’m not going to listen to anything you have to say about that research topic ever again. I don’t think anyone else should either.
Conclusion: Many qualified applicants
Graduate school admissions are competitive, and no graduate admissions process is more competitive than medical school. Med school admissions have been growing more competitive with increasing GPAs and MCAT scores of matriculants. It’s not uncommon for medical schools to receive more than 100 applications for every seat. Medical school admissions are frequently adding new prerequisite courses or increasing their minimum requirements to reduce the number of applications. It makes sense that admissions committees would want a fast way to identify the applicants who are compassionate, ethical, and wouldn’t go on to become the next Mark Hyman. Sure, it would be nice if there were a test that could tell you how virtuous a person is, but no such test exists.
CASPer is the multivitamin of med school admissions criteria. Little to no evidence suggests that using it will actually provide any long-term benefits. It sounds like it might be a fair way to select applicants for their soft skills, and it’s also easy to add as a requirement so what’s the harm? But like multivitamins, admissions committees are being sold the idea of an objective tool that will increase the fairness of the admissions process – not the reality. There is nothing objective or fair about a computerized test that uses human graders for open-ended responses, doesn’t outline how responses are evaluated, and doesn’t provide feedback. If anything, CASPer is the least objective or fair metric ever introduced to the admissions process. Apparently test-takers are just supposed to be born with the knowledge of what profiteering medical school faculty would do in response to an ethical dilemma.
To medical school admissions committee members who might be reading this: I’m not telling you how to do your jobs. I’m just saying if you want physicians who are compassionate and empathetic, I think you’re working against your own goals by requiring more things like CASPer and VITA. How many times can premed students be asked to spend their time and money on some type of performance for medical school admissions before it starts to affect them as a person? There are dozens of articles in medical journals discussing “premed culture” and not in a good way. A 2019 letter to the editor in Academic Medicine said this about the effects of premed culture:
This generation of students has been trained to clear obstacles, but they have not been taught to think, to be skeptics of knowledge, or to learn, not as a means but as an end.
I view CASPer as just one more obstacle that serves little more than to perpetuate this way of thinking. It’s natural to want to select the best applicants, and that becomes near impossible when you might have 10 applicants who all look identical. This problem is only going to get worse as schools are experiencing an explosion in the number of applications within the past year. We don’t need more quick metrics to compare applicants by. No arms race in history has ever been solved by starting new weapon development programs.
CASPer is the symptom of a growing problem in medical school admissions, but that’s a topic for another time. The evidence does not support Altus’s claims about the use of CASPer in medical school admissions. From a premed to admissions committees: if you’re looking for a reason to choose me over another seemingly identical applicant, please just flip a coin. I understand that you’re flooded with applications and care a lot about choosing the best applicant in a fair and unbiased manner. That’s not a sustainable solution though. How could I complain? A coin-flip is much more unbiased and transparent than CASPer.

The Residency Match is Broken
The National Resident Matching Program (Match), the program to align med school applicants with their preferred residency program, is broken and filled with disincentives. The fix might be easy.
Braden MacBeth on April 3, 2021
Link
In their last year of medical school, med students get to look forward to a once in a lifetime holiday that’s a mix between Christmas and Tax Day. Match Day is the day when medical students find out which post-graduate residency training program they will be attending for the next couple of years. The National Residency Match Program (NRMP) was created in 1952 in response to an intern appointment process that become so chaotic, students were expected to accept internship offers over the phone as soon as they received them. With the Matching process, applicants apply to programs, typically through the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC)’s Electronic Residency Application Service (ERAS) software. Programs interview applicants, and both applicants and programs send rank lists to the NRMP where they are fed into an algorithm that matches applicants with programs based on their preferences. The result is that both parties get a better outcome than if residency followed a traditional hiring process. But the Match, like all system, has its flaws.
Like most things in our lives, the Match was not unaffected by the COVID-19 pandemic. Programs had to switch to virtual interviews, which had a large impact on Match outcomes. The Match rate for graduating seniors at American MD programs has remained 94% for a long time…until this year where the Match rate declined to 92.7%, which is the lowest Match rate for US seniors since 1997 [PDF]. While it may not seem like such a big deal, a 1-1.5% decrease kind of is when we’re talking about matching algorithms. But my main concern isn’t the Match rate, it’s the Match results. The COVID-19 pandemic didn’t cause the inefficiencies and inequities of the Match, it exposed longstanding ones that were already there.
The Match has become increasingly inefficient over the years, to the point where I would argue that it’s no longer achieving its intended goals. Applicants are spending more money with each passing year, and getting worse results. In 2010, 56% of Matched applicants got their top ranked program. But in 2020, only 49.2% Matched their first ranked program. Program directors are increasingly experiencing applicants that cancel interviews at inopportune times, and are flooded with applications. The Match is increasingly a topic of discussion in medical journals because it seems program directors aren’t happy. I’d argue that neither medical students nor program directors are being served by the Match in its current form. When neither of your system’s stakeholder groups are being served by your system, you don’t need to wait for the x-rays to come back. The residency Match is broken and I want to talk about why.
Application fever
Every major problem inherent to the Match can be tied to a simple phenomenon: application fever. Application fever is the result of a positive feedback loop that has led to an increase in the number of programs applicants every year. In 2007, the average American senior applied to 30 residency programs in ERAS. In 2018, they applied to 60 programs. It’s important to point out at this point: applying to more programs isn’t free. Applicants pay money for every program they apply to and there is a non-linear increase in fees. Applying to 30 programs in ERAS costs $419 while applying to 60 costs $1,200.
Obviously, applicants don’t want to spend all of this money. So, why are they doing it? Well…they have to, because that’s what every other applicant is doing. Applicants need to attend a certain number of interviews to essentially guarantee their chances of Matching. It’s in every applicant’s interest to get as many interviews as possible. The limiting factor for programs on how many applicants they interview is how many they need to before it becomes a waste of time. That number is basically constant for programs based on the number of positions they have. The only limit for applicants on how many programs they apply to is how much money they have, and how many programs there are. This mismatch in limits is what leads to application fever – applicants have incentive and the ability to apply to as many programs as they can afford, while programs have no way to limit applicants or increase the number of available positions.
Since the number of interview positions is constant, that means that the probability of receiving an interview invitation decreases as the number of applications to that program increases. So, the number of programs candidates have to apply to has to be based upon the probability that any given application will lead to an interview. A good way to figure out that number is to look at the average number of programs the average Matched applicant applied to the past cycle. But if you aren’t so sure about your chances, applying to more programs is the easiest way to improve your odds. When you’re $1,000 in, what’s $200 more? Applying to fewer programs is only a viable option if you are absolutely sure of your chances. Other than that, applying to fewer programs than the average means you risk going unmatched. The result is a residency application process that doesn’t work for anyone.
Program directors are flooded with applications – the average orthopedic surgery program received 150 applications for every open position in 2020. Program directors can’t review all of those applications by hand, at least not thoroughly, so they come up with a standardized process to filter them. The problem is that when program directors use a standardized process for filtering applications, there’s going to be a significant degree in overlap in their filtering criteria. When every applicant is applying to more than half of all orthopedic surgery programs, there’s going to be an overlap in who gets through, so program directors are increasingly selecting for the same small group of top applicants. In the 2016 otolaryngology Match, just 26% of applicants accounted for half of all possible interview positions. While programs interview the same number of applicants every year, they send an increasing number of interview invitations annually. That means that more interview invitations get declined or there are a lot of no-shows on interview day.
With virtual interviews, the cost of attending interviews is much lower. There’s no disadvantage for highly competitive applicants to attend every interview they’re invited to. That’s ultimately what lead to the reduced Match rate this year. I was actually surprised the Match rate wasn’t lower. So will things go back to normal after the pandemic? Not necessarily, and that question assumes that everything was fine before. I just don’t think that’s the case.
This ain’t a scene, it’s an arms race
While it can seem like a small issue, the effects of application fever are far-reaching. If you look at any big problem in medical education, that issue is often tied to application fever.
Let’s start with how application fever affects the environment of medical school itself. The residency Match has become increasingly competitive over the past two decades. When the Match is more competitive, medical education as a whole becomes more competitive. As programs move to more quick metrics to filter applications, applicants start trying harder to get higher board scores, more publications, and other things to stand out. In 2007 the average medical student at a US medical school who Matched had a USMLE Step 1 Score of 221, a USMLE Step 2 Score of 226, two research experiences, and two abstracts, presentations or publications. In 2018, the average medical student at a US MD medical school who Matched had a USMLE Step 1 score of 230, a USMLE Step 2 Score of 246, about three research experiences, and four abstracts, presentations or publications. And it doesn’t stop there – medical students today are getting more graduate degrees, and going to more interviews than they did in the past.
There is serious competition for research opportunities in medical school, because having research publications will make them more competitive. It also means students will take any opportunity they can get, even when those opportunities are terrible. A perfect example is MedBikini kerfuffle on social media. Back in August the Journal of Vascular Surgery published a paper titled “Prevalence of unprofessional social media content among young vascular surgeons”, which has since been retracted. The study was taken down following social media backlash, and the study just being really, really, dumb. However, other medical students on Twitter felt the need to harass one of the med students who was second author on the study, causing him to delete his account. I would think they would feel some sort of empathy for their fellow med student because the only reason he contributed to that paper was to get publications to put on his vascular surgery application.
The high costs of applying to competitive specialties such as dermatology is viewed as a barrier to entry for applicants from low-income and minority backgrounds. It’s not because people from underrepresented backgrounds aren’t qualified or interested – it’s because they’re playing a pay-to-win game in a country with an inverse relationship between the melanin in your skin and the money in your pocket. It’s no coincidence that the medical specialties with the highest number of applications per applicant are the least diverse in medicine. This highly competitive residency selection also creates a toxic environment in medical education. The increased focus on Step 1 Scores created what some students describe as:
[A] tiered system of “worthiness” among students, which residency program directors use as part of their selection process. Those with high scores are steered toward “competitive” specialties, whereas those who do not are restricted to “noncompetitive” ones.
It was announced recently by the National Board of Medical Examiners that the USMLE Step 1 would be converted to a Pass/Fail scoring system, but it is likely this will just turn Step 2 CK scores into a filter metric. I also expect this is shift in focus is going to negatively affect osteopathic medical students who previously would only take Step 1 in addition to the COMLEX series of exams.
While I could go on, the point is the problems with the Match don’t happen in isolation. It’s about the hundred other problems the Match causes or makes worse. The question isn’t “should the Match be changed?” but rather how it should change. It turns out there is an easy fix.
Patching the match
Application fever is the lead in medical education’s water supply. I don’t have time to cover every single issue it causes, so I will refer you to Dr. Bryan Carmody’s blog which covers the state of the Match in much more detail if you’re interested. So, what can be done to fix the Match for program directors and students, and what obstacles stand in the way?
It’s always going to be within applicants’ interests to apply to as many programs as possible if they want to maximize their odds of Matching. But when that comes at the cost of programs not being able to tell who is actually interested in their program, it leads to the process not working for anyone. Any solution to application fever has to limit or increase the cost to apply to programs. While some professional societies have tried preference signaling programs, it’s the equivalent of putting a Band-Aid on a bullet wound.
Application caps are the best solution to every problem with the Match because they address application fever directly. Application caps also make the Match fairer and more predictable. Under application caps, applicants can maximize their chances of Matching by simply applying to the programs they’re interested in and competitive for. Applicants would have a much higher chance at receiving an interview at their preferred programs, minimizing the cost of applying. In addition, the ERAS fee structure should be changed to a one-time cost to discourage applicants from applying to an excessive number of programs.
Application caps are controversial on places like StudentDoctorNetwork and Reddit, but application limits would benefit the vast majority of applicants and residency programs. Those same SDN nay-sayers also don’t like it when programs start requiring things like CASPer as part of their application process as a means to have more quick data points to filter applications. I also don’t want residency programs do business with Altus Assessments, and wrote an entire piece about why they shouldn’t. The only data I could find showed that 60% of surveyed otolaryngology applicants would be in-favor of some form of application limit. But there are an increasing number of articles in medical journals arguing for residency application caps.
So, what’s stopping application caps from happening? Well, many people are against application caps to begin with. But more importantly even if the majority of the medical community were in favor of application caps, the organization with the power to make that happen really, really doesn’t want that to happen. The AAMC brought in $94 million in 2019 from ERAS fee revenue alone. If you’re wondering if even a fraction of the cost goes into the operating costs of ERAS, just know that $94 million is enough to cover the entire production cost of The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. You could use the remaining 13 million dollars increase the AAMC’s IT budget by 3 million. Now sure, you might say it’s more complicated than that. Is it though? ERAS is not providing value to its stakeholders anywhere near in-proportion to its revenue. Applicants pay ERAS enough money that the AAMC could provision them their own personal ERAS server. Yet this year the ERAS portal crashed during the start of the first Supplemental Offer and Acceptance Program (SOAP) cycle. The pricing structure of ERAS is predatory, and that in itself warrants more criticism from the medical community.
So, let’s say all of the advocacy of the world wouldn’t get the AAMC to implement application caps. While program directors have their problems with ERAS and the Match, pulling out still might not be worth it for them. Does that mean they just have to accept the process as it is? There’s no action they could take to achieve the outcome they want? Of course not. Program directors have all the power with regards to how their residency selection process works for their program. If they want to pull out of the Match, they can pull out of the Match. But if program directors want application caps, their only option is to hope the AAMC puts application caps in ERAS? Of course not. What if I told you there was a way to implement application caps in ERAS without the approval of the AAMC, so long as enough programs agreed?
To implement application caps, all you would have to do would be to create a website where programs that want application caps would sign-up. They would make it as clear as possible that they won’t consider applications unless an application token has been sent through the website. Applicants would sign up to the website and be given a limited number of application tokens. When it’s time to send their applications, applicants send a token to the program through the third-party website, then send the program an ERAS application like they would normally. Then the Match would proceed normally.
Work would need to be done to determine the ideal application limit based on the number of sign-ups from programs and applicants. You would need to do some simple tooling to remove applications from program director’s portals for applicants who haven’t sent the program tokens. But after that, application caps would effectively be implemented for programs as a residency application process with application caps. The only obstacle would be getting enough programs to participate for this option to have a functional economy. It wouldn’t affect the general rhythm of the application process in a substantial way other than clicking a few buttons for applicants, a far less significant burden than what programs and applicants are dealing with now.
A question from a program director might be: “How do you know this will work?” There are no certainties in life, but I’m as sure as I can be. The only major obstacle outside of getting enough programs to participate would be not scuffing the technical execution. So long as there is a large enough pool of programs, the payoff would be huge. Application pressure would be reduced by 50-75%. Program directors could be sure that the reduced number of applicants they do receive are actually interested and would show up for interviews. Applicants would be heavily incentivized to use the website because it’s the only way to have their application considered by participating programs. It’s also worth the little extra effort for applicants because their odds of getting an interview invite at participating programs are much higher. The system gives everyone what they want, and it could probably be a free service developed using open-source tools.
Another reasonable question from program directors might be “What if things go wrong?” Well, the first thing to understand is that even the most catastrophic outcome you could imagine isn’t that bad. Let’s say for the sake of argument all of your slots go unmatched. You could still use the SOAP program to fill all of your slots; there are still more residency applicants than residency positions. Even applicants who don’t Match are highly qualified, and you’ll probably perfectly happy with them. That’s the worst possible outcome, and literally isn’t possible unless you don’t submit your rank list or something. But let’s look at some realistic pitfalls and how they could be avoided.
Let’s say some programs don’t have enough applicants to be able to Match all of their slots. There are lots of ways to fix this issue after it’s been raised. Those programs could be put into a special pool and tokens could be granted to applicants to apply within the special pool. The program could simply drop the token requirement and get the word out to applicants. Finally, even if the program had unmatched slots, which still happens under the current system, they could still SOAP their unmatched slots.
The biggest issue that could happen early on is with a small number of early adopter programs and a huge number of applicants that want to apply to programs such that the token economy wouldn’t work. The only thing you could do is run the system sub-optimally by being overly stringent with tokens or overly generous. But so long as there are a sufficient number of programs that want to participate to have a functional economy, this shouldn’t happen.
On the technical side, nothing about this is complicated. You’re basically just storing a list of participating programs, and who sent tokens to what programs. The only hard part is calculating what the ideal cap should be based upon the number of programs and applicants. A lot of that is going to come down to community feedback. It’s not a particularly sophisticated solution; the hard part is convincing program directors that the results would be worth it, and actually doing it.
Conclusion: Status calamitous
I’ve been wanting to write this piece for about three years now. As a software engineer, I’ve always found the problems with the residency Match incredibly interesting. The reason why I find the Match interesting…is because it’s hilarious. The Match is a brilliant idea, in theory. In practice applicants are spending $1,100 for API requests. Lifeguard certification is about to become a graduation requirement for orthopedic surgery programs because residents need to know how to rescue program directors from drowning in ERAS applications. The fee structure of ERAS is so predatory it makes Ticketmaster look like a charity. I’ve tried to think of policy changes that would make the Match substantially worse, but so far I can’t. It’s patently absurd. How is the Match like this? Do people actually like it this way?
As software engineer, sure, the Match is hilarious. But I also find the issues that come from the Match deeply concerning. The system isn’t efficiently achieving its intended goals. I think it’s safe to say that everyone is being done dirty by the Match. It’s within everyone’s interest to advocate for change. But I don’t think any progress is being made here. In 2016, the AAMC sent program directors a survey on their top three pain points. The large volume of applications, lack of information about which applicants were in genuinely interested in their program, and applicants cancelling interviews were some of the biggest complaints. To those program directors: has the AAMC done anything in the past 5 years to address your concerns? I’m going to guess the answer is no. They have a growing number of reasons not to each passing year. Things aren’t going to get better on their own, and I don’t think the AAMC is on your side.
I think application caps are the only logical solution to most of the problems people have with the residency Match. While there are a lot of ways the Match could be changed, application caps are the only solution that fixes the problems caused by application fever without introducing new problems or significantly changing the flow of the Match. At the Council of Orthopaedic Residency Directors spring conference this year, one of the main topics on the agenda was “What should we do differently?”, where application caps were mentioned. Unfortunately, after mentioning application caps, they stated that application caps were not within their control. The AAMC won’t implement application caps which means a 3rd party service for application limits is really the only way forward.
The good news is that the implementation is so easy that a random software engineer could probably develop such a service on their own. It also seems that program directors have a random software engineer in their corner. While I won’t make any promises, developing an open-source application limit service is something I might be interested in. The only thing I need to know is if that’s something that programs are interested in even just talking about. I’m not asking anyone to commit to anything, just testing the waters. I don’t want to make money off this, I’d like this to be a free service. Even talking about application caps as a possible solution if programs want them would be a huge step forward.
To program directors who might be reading this: I’m not trying to tell you what to do or how you should feel about the Match. I’m just giving my take based on what I’ve read based on the data and what program directors and applicants have been saying. The power to shape the residency selection process has always rested with individual program directors doing what they think is best. So, if you’re a program director who isn’t happy with the way things are going, you have a lot of power to change the outcome. Even just saying that you’re unhappy with aspects of the Match is doing something. But choosing to do nothing is still a choice, and I’d argue it’s the wrong choice.
The biggest obstacle to changing the Match is the belief that the Match can’t be changed. Proposed changes to the Match have always contentious and people are always going to have different ideas about what an ideal residency selection process looks like. If you aren’t happy with the way things are going, just know that things aren’t going to get better on their own. If they do improve, it will only be by comparison. From where I’m sitting, things can’t get much worse. The bar for improvement is a tripping hazard.

Can Medical Schools Really Teach 71 Nutrition ‘Competencies’?  Should They?
Henry Miller on May 12, 2026
Link

In recent years, nutrition has become the focus of renewed attention in medical education. Advocates argue that physicians receive too little formal training about diet and that more comprehensive nutrition education is needed to address chronic diseases such as obesity, diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and certain cancers. A greater focus on the “root causes of chronic diseases” is a mantra of the Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) movement.
That concern has now culminated in a proposal from the Department of Health and Human Services for “Comprehensive Nutrition Education Reforms.” Providing details for that proposal, the department issued the Medical Education Nutrition Competency Framework, which suggests 10 domains and 71 competencies intended to provide guidance for a curriculum for undergraduate medical school nutrition education that meets a 40-hour equivalent minimum and for “identifying gaps in covered topics.”
In announcing the framework at a press conference, HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. said that chronic disease “is overwhelming the country and it is accelerating. …Today, we spend $4.5 trillion a year on healthcare, and 90% of it goes to managing chronic disease, and poor nutrition is often at its core.” He did not present any evidence for those claims.
Easier Said Than Done
The goal — better equipping physicians to advise patients about diet — sounds reasonable, but it raises an important question: Is it realistic for medical schools to incorporate even a fraction of these competencies into already crowded curricula?
Medical education is famously dense. In four short years, students must absorb enormous bodies of knowledge ranging from molecular biology and pharmacology to pathology, clinical diagnosis, and the complexities of patient care. As I did in medical school, some students also spend some rotations doing research in the labs of faculty members. Every discipline, understandably and predictably, believes its subject deserves more time.
The nutrition competency framework illustrates the tension between worthwhile aspirations and practical realities.
The Proposed Framework
The framework organizes nutrition training into 10 domains, encompassing basic science, clinical care, counseling skills, public health, and health-system practice: Within those domains, advocates have proposed 71 specific “competencies” that medical students should be able to demonstrate:
Foundational Nutrition Knowledge (21 competencies, 48 hours)
Nutrition Assessment and Diagnosis (8 competencies, 27.5 hours)
Food and Nutrition-Related Communication Skills (9 competencies, 29.5 hours)
Collaborative, Interprofessional Referral and Patient Management (5 Competencies, 12.0 hours)
Public Health Nutrition (6 Competencies, 15.5 hours)
Experiential Hands-on Learning (Culinary Medicine) (5 Competencies,16.0 hours)
Medical Interventions in Combination with Lifestyle Practices (6 Competencies, 17.5 hours)
Personal Food & Lifestyle Behaviors for Health Care Professionals (4 Competencies, 6.0 hours
Food Systems and Environmental Impacts (6 Competencies, 16.5 hours)
Billing, Coding, and Reimbursement for Food and Nutrition Services (1 Competency, 3.0 hours)
Domain #9 – “Food Systems and Environmental Impacts” is totally irrelevant to medical students, dealing with such things as “understand[ing] relationship between soil microbiota diversity and mineral/nutrient content of foods” and “participat[ing] in on-site learning at farms including soil sampling, composting, crop rotation”.
Some of the competencies are ridiculously arcane, such as #17: “Epigenetic modulation through nutrition: comprehend how methyl donors, phytochemicals, and feeding rhythms influence gene expression.” Or irrelevant to medical students, such as #71: “Billing for nutrition services, culinary medicine consultations with RDNs.”
A Worthy Goal—But an Already-Overloaded Curriculum
On paper, most of these competencies seem entirely sensible. None of them is unreasonable in isolation (except, perhaps, domain #9 and competency #71, described in the previous section). Physicians should understand the role of nutrition in disease and should be able to counsel patients about diet. But the scale of the proposal is imposing. It reads more like the requirements for certification as a dietician than a minor aspect of training for an MD degree.
Seventy-one competencies — spread across subjects ranging from biochemistry to sustainability policy — represent a significant educational burden. Even if each competency required only modest instruction, the cumulative time required could be substantial. Consider that devoting only an hour of class time to each of the competencies would require 71 hours – about two weeks.
And consider that medical schools already face severe curricular constraints.
Over the past several decades, the volume of biomedical knowledge has expanded dramatically. Students must master genetics, molecular biology, immunology, advanced imaging technologies, complex pharmacology, and increasingly sophisticated diagnostic tools. New topics—from artificial intelligence in medicine to genomic medicine and health-system science—are continually being added.
Every new innovation and requirement competes with existing content. Medical educators often describe the curriculum as “a suitcase that is already overpacked.” Adding something new almost always requires removing or truncating something else.
Are the “Suggestions” Really “Suggestions”?
But the biggest flaw in the HHS prescription is the focus on “functional medicine” competencies for physicians under the guise of nutrition, which, as Kevin Klatt, PhD, RD, has observed, not only risks integrating pseudoscience into medicine but also distracts from real nutrition competencies. It has the distinctive stench of the influence of HHS Secretary RFK, Jr. and the Means grifter twins – Calley, a senior adviser to Kennedy who focuses on food, nutrition policy, and the “Make America Healthy Again” (MAHA) agenda; and Casey, President Trump’s famously unqualified nominee to be U.S. Surgeon General, whose nomination was just abandoned.
It is true that it might not be mandatory for every competency to be included in the curriculum. The federal directive to medical schools states:
After conducting an assessment of your current nutrition curriculum and identifying gaps in covered topics, we recommend schools choose from the competencies” to “design a curriculum for undergraduate medical school nutrition education that meets a 40-hour equivalent minimum.
However, “suggestions” or “proposals” from the federal government about university curricula raise concerns, given the recent history of the Trump administration using federal funding mechanisms as leverage against universities perceived to be politically or culturally oppositional. In several high-profile disputes, universities lost research grants or other federal support after conflicts over issues such as campus speech, diversity policies, or compliance with federal directives. Such punitive measures could be applied to medical schools, which receive more than $30 billion in federal research funding annually, if they did not conform sufficiently to the nutritional domains and competencies.
The Independent, May 1, 2026
Nutrition Is Already Embedded in Medical Education
Another problem with the framework is the implicit assumption that nutrition education is inadequate in current medical training. In reality, nutrition already permeates many aspects of medical education, although it may not appear as a separate course labeled “nutrition.”
Medical students encounter nutrition repeatedly during both their classroom and clinical training.
For example:
Biochemistry courses teach the metabolic pathways that govern carbohydrate, fat, and protein metabolism.
Physiology courses explain energy balance, hormonal regulation of appetite, and nutrient absorption.
Pathology and internal medicine address diseases in which diet plays a critical role—diabetes, cardiovascular disease, kidney disease, liver disease, and many others.
Clinical rotations frequently involve dietary management as part of care of patients with cardiac, endocrinological, genetic, and other diseases.
In hospitals, students also observe and interact with dietitians participating in patient rounds, especially for patients with complex metabolic or nutritional problems. These professionals often provide detailed dietary assessments and recommendations. I found them to be especially valuable, both as a medical student and as an intern and resident.
For patients with specific medical conditions, dietary management is often central to treatment. Examples include:
sodium restriction in heart failure
carbohydrate management in diabetes
low-protein diets in certain kidney diseases
gluten-free diets for celiac disease
food allergies
specialized feeding regimens for premature infants
In such contexts, medical students see firsthand how nutrition becomes integrated into clinical decision-making. An additional educational experience for me occurred during my rotations at a VA hospital: Meals were delivered to the wards even when patients weren’t able to eat them because of an impending procedure, such as a colonoscopy or surgery, so I’d consume the food. (I found “clear liquid,” “full liquid,” “pureed,” “no added salt,” and “kidney disease” diets to be pretty unpalatable, while “high protein” and “high calorie” were pretty good!)
Learning Through Clinical Context
Medical education has long recognized that students learn most effectively when knowledge is connected to real clinical problems. Nutrition is particularly well-suited to this approach.
Consider a student caring for a patient with newly diagnosed diabetes. The management plan naturally includes dietary counseling, glucose monitoring, and lifestyle changes. A dietitian may join the clinical team to explain carbohydrate counting and meal planning.
In this setting, the student learns nutrition in the context of a disease that requires it—an approach that favors retention more than memorizing isolated competencies.
Similarly, during a gastroenterology rotation, a student might encounter patients with inflammatory bowel disease, malabsorption syndromes, or short-bowel syndrome. Each condition involves distinctive nutritional considerations.
These experiences already teach many of the competencies listed in the framework.
The Risk of Competency Inflation
The nutrition competency proposal reflects a broader trend in modern education: the proliferation of competency frameworks.
Competency-based education can be valuable when it emphasizes essential skills. But frameworks can also expand endlessly as advocates add more goals and sub-goals.
In some cases, the result is a long checklist of aspirations rather than a realistic curriculum. Seventy-one “core nutrition” competencies risk becoming exactly that.
Moreover, some competencies in the framework extend well beyond clinical nutrition into areas such as food systems, sustainability, and public policy. These topics may be intellectually interesting (to some), but their relevance to day-to-day medical practice varies.
Medical students must above all become competent clinicians. Time spent on peripheral topics inevitably displaces training in core medical knowledge.
The Importance of Collaboration
Another reason the framework may be overly ambitious is that physicians do not practice nutrition care in isolation. Modern medicine relies heavily on multidisciplinary teams. Dieticians, nurses, and other specialists possess extensive training and experience in nutritional science and counseling. In many cases, they are better equipped than physicians to provide detailed dietary guidance, and AI has become an increasingly useful adjunct.
The physician’s role is often to identify when nutrition is relevant and involve the appropriate specialists.
Several competencies in the framework acknowledge this reality by emphasizing collaboration with dietitians. But if collaboration is central to effective care, then expecting physicians to master an exhaustive list of nutrition competencies is, arguably, unnecessary.
A More Practical Approach
None of this means that nutrition education should be neglected. Physicians should certainly understand basic nutritional principles and should be able to recognize when diet plays a role in disease and its treatment. But rather than attempting to teach dozens of discrete competencies, medical education might focus on a smaller number of core concepts, reinforced through clinical experience.
For example:
understanding the basic physiology of metabolism
recognizing the role of diet in major chronic diseases
querying AI for information and suggestions about patients’ diseases
knowing when to refer patients for specialized nutritional counseling
communicating clearly with patients about diet and lifestyle
These goals can be achieved through existing courses and clinical rotations without dramatically expanding the curriculum.
The Real Challenge: A Sensible Balance
The nutrition competency framework highlights an important issue: The role of diet in health is substantial, and physicians should not ignore it. But the proposed list of 71 competencies illustrates the risk of trying to solve every supposed educational shortcoming by piling on more requirements.
As discussed above, medical students already encounter nutrition in numerous contexts—from biochemistry lectures to hospital rounds with dietitians—and, as in my case, by consuming the various kinds of customized meals prepared for hospitalized patients. These experiences provide a practical understanding of how diet influences health.
The challenge is not necessarily a lack of nutrition course content but rather ensuring that students appreciate its clinical relevance. Achieving that goal does not require an encyclopedic checklist of competencies. Instead, it must integrate nutrition thoughtfully into the broader fabric of medical education.
In the end, the most effective nutrition training may come not from endlessly expanding the curriculum, but from teaching students how to recognize when nutrition matters—and how to work with experts who specialize in it.


Science-Based Satire: Cleveland Clinic Subscription Box Service Introduces Integrative Medicine to Curious Consumers
Clay Jones on December 2, 2016
Link


Cleveland, OH- Cleveland native Kelly Anderson is looking forward to the end of the month like a young child anxiously awaiting Christmas morning. That’s because on a day between the 20th and the 28th of December, she will receive the gift of hope. Anderson, a 43-year-old mother of five who was diagnosed with chronic Lyme disease and numerous nutritional imbalances earlier this year by a Naturopathic doctor during a visit to discuss her unexplained fatigue, is part of a growing number of people interested in an alternative path to wellness.
CAMCrate, a new monthly subscription box service developed by the experts at Cleveland Clinic’s Center for Integrative and Lifestyle Medicine, will deliver boxes of high quality and thoroughly tested alternative medical experiences right to customer’s doorstep starting this month. Anderson, who learned about the new service during a routine check-up at the office of her Cleveland Clinic affiliated primary care doctor, is quick to point out that she loves her conventional medical doctor. “I’m not against Western scientific medicine, I’m just looking to augment it with something different, something special. Who doesn’t want a little magic and mystery in their lives?”
Interest in alternative therapies, particularly when combined synergistically with conventional healthcare to form a highly effective hybrid known as integrative medicine, is at an all-time high. According to National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health Director Josephine Briggs, proponents of integrative medicine are excited but a bit surprised by the trend. “People just can’t seem to get enough these days, which is amazing considering that just a few decades ago we couldn’t have given most of this stuff away for free.”
“At the Cleveland Clinic, we believe that there are a lot of people out there looking for a more holistic approach to health, with an open minded focus on finding the true cause of their problems rather than merely treating symptoms,” Delos M. Cosgrove MD, CEO and president of Cleveland Clinic explained. “Once we found a way to work around the efficacy vacuum and to rationalize the ethical concerns, we realized that the two biggest roadblocks to customer expansion were a lack of awareness of the myriad options out there and the inconvenience of leaving the house.”
Subscription box services, which are generally broken down into convenience and discovery categories, are big business with over $5 billion in revenue in 2014. The Cleveland Clinic’s CAMCrate would serve both purposes depending on the particular consumer. Experienced customers with a good handle on their individual needs, such as a wifi-allergic investment banker diagnosed with splenic ennui and a touch of systemic candidiasis by a professional, will be able to tailor their service accordingly. Subscribers will have the option of choosing from one of several unique “Experiences”, such as The Energy Within, The Power of Faith, East Meets West, or Functional Medicine. But for novices, a monthly Awakenings CAMCrate will serve as a gateway into a world where methodological naturalism and fundamental laws of physics and chemistry can be comfortably ignored.
Until now, curious healthcare consumers would have had to make an appointment for a one-hour comprehensive Integrative Medicine consultation with a Cleveland Clinic specialist. Or they could take their chances with a non-academic provider chosen based on anecdotes and testimonials, which can be misleading. With the CAMCrate, a customer can gain personal experience with a variety of alternative medical modalities in the comfort of their own home. They can then make an informed choice regarding their desired experience.
Each CAMCrate will consist of 2-3 basic alternative medical experiences handpicked by Cleveland Clinic experts, with options for extra items and services at additional cost. For example, a box may come packed with an assortment of essential oils, a set of adhesive rare-earth acu-magnets, and a chiropractic self-adjustment device. Accompanying each experience will be information on the history of that alternative healing modality and step-by-step instructions on their use. Customers will also gain access to exclusive instructional videos developed by Cleveland Clinic and coupons for personal Integrative Medicine sessions.
The CAMCrate will range in cost from $29.99 for the entry level “Beginner’s Box” described above to $399.99 for the “Elite Experience Box.” Pricier boxes come stocked with an amazing array of advanced alternative medical experiences, such as a home Kirlian photography kit or medical-grade dowsing rods, and even private home sessions with endorsed local providers. Customers who sign up for 6- or 12-month packages by December 31st will be automatically entered into a prize drawing for a chance to win an appearance on the Dr. Oz show.
“We feel that the CAMCrate would make an ideal Christmas gift for those hard-to-shop-for folks on your list,” Cosgrove added. “And regular customers can expect some pretty amazing deals and partnerships in the future!”
One of those partnerships has already been announced by Cleveland Clinic. Starting in July of 2017, Cleveland Clinic will partner with Blue Apron, the popular national meal box delivery service, to offer a service designed to help customers concerned about possible food allergies and intolerances. Each Blue Apron MediBox will contain a variety of recipe ingredients as well as a home IgG food antibody testing kit specific to that week’s meals.

   Continuing Medical Education

   A Meeting of Incompatibles
Wallace Sampson
Link
On October 3,4, 2007, a conference at Harvard University School of medicine, the first annual “Fascia Research Conference“ was held, sponsored by a notable group of organizations. Organized by Thomas Findley, MD, Phd, Prof. of Physical Medicine and physiatrist at Veterans Administration Hospital East Orange, New Jersey. It was notable for several reasons, and is of interest to medical objectivists – also for several other reasons. First, the conference was the first research conference devoted solely to the study of fascia (a type of connective tissue) – stated to be a forgotten tissue. Second, it included scientific subjects such as intra-cellular structure and stress changes in fascial cells, but also unscientific ones such as on acupuncture and “Rolfing.”
Sponsors included pseudoscientific occupational guilds with economic and political agendas that obviously could take advantage of their association with scientific presentations – even though no scientific association exists. Included were:
Rolf institute
Massage Therapy Association
AT Still Research Inst. (Osteopathic)
International Association of Structural Integrators (Structural Integration)
University of Ulm (Germany) Anesthesia Dept.
University of Westminster (UK) Veteran’s Biomed. Res. Inst. (East Orange NJ)
(Both universities and Institute where organizers work)
Elsevier (Publisher of “alternative” med journals)
A survey of their respective web sites shows a preoccupation with licensing and insurance payment eligibility.
Thirty-two supportive organizations included chiropractic, acupuncture, “bodywork,” massage, Cranio-sacral (osteopathic offshoot) therapy, alternative medicine institutes, chronic fatigue syndrome, and osteopathic organizations.
The conference was organized by physician scientists with one foot in alternative medicine methods, and another in medicine. Some hold academic positions through which pseudo-medicines and sectarian health systems may ally themselves and gain a tinge of respectability – in academic, clinical, and popular realms.
Some speakers’ subjects had little to nothing to do with the clinical and occupational associations. Using academic institutions as sites for conferences, a technique now used for several decades – is a legal and acceptable procedure, with a reputation advantage even when faced with institutional disclaimers of non-association. In this case, the conference was held at Harvard. Why? There was one PhD individual from Harvard – otherwise there was no specific reason, other than the association with a prestigious institution.
According to Dr. Findley, the congress has seven primary objectives: 1) To create a forum in which the most current research on fascia will be presented and critically evaluated, including basic science, clinical mechanistic research and research methodology; 2) To foster interdisciplinary, inter-institutional and international collaboration among scientists active in fascia research and clinicians whose methods may impact fascia; 3) To explore developments in research methodologies applicable to complementary therapy investigations; 4) To heighten professional awareness about advances in basic sciences and the importance of formulating hypotheses and testing CAM therapeutic mechanisms; 5) To publish a volume of conference proceedings in the Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies and generate articles published in internationally indexed journals; 6) To foster networking among attendees, both at the conference and afterward; and 7) To enable future researchers (students and postdoctoral trainees) to strengthen their motivation and interest in a career in fascia research.
The major problem here is that the “complementary” therapy methods of the sponsors and supporters and the presenters have little or nothing to do with fascia. The leaders of the organizations have simply proclaimed such relationships.
Compounding this confusion was a two page report in Science magazine that focused on the personalities and histories of the organizers and a few presenters, their difficulties in becoming recognized and in uniting their academic and their “alternative” interests. The article’s slant was sympathetic to the personalities and their academic plights. One researcher was described as having an epiphany experience when he saw the enthusiasm of the audience – which was filled with CAM supporters and practitioners.
The Science reporter was informed about the subterfuge of sectarian and off-beat medical organizations obtaining respect and legitimacy from association with a meeting constructed to emphasize science yet introduces the quasi-miraculous personal discoveries of devotees of medical sects. Yet no reference to that issue appeared.
One revelation experience is recorded below on the meeting’s web page : (http://www.fascia2007.com/news_comments.htm)
A reaction to the Fascia Research Congress from one of the principal speakers, Serge Gracovetsky PhD, Emeritus Professor, Concordia University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada…
“That conference was one of the most productive I have been involved with. I am not a clinician, but I knew that manual therapy was effective since I witnessed the benefits that my wife received from a chiropractic friend following a car accident. Why it worked was a mystery to me, and the absence of hard data in the literature (i.e. convincing blind studies with control group) did not help. Boston 2007 changed all that. On Thursday morning, the direct impact of stress at the cellular level, including the expression of DNA targeting the build up of muscle was coolly laid out in no uncertain terms. I was mesmerized by the movie of Dr. Guimberteau which instantly obsoleted all mathematical models of tissue biomechanics that I knew. That was the evidence I was looking for. The question is no longer whether manual therapy is an efficient alternate form of medicine. The data demonstrates that the therapy intervenes at a very primitive and fundamental level in our systems. It has to have a major effect. That was a total surprise to me.”
The testimony above is by a researcher in body mechanics at a major university.
Readers of the Science article will see one skeptical comment to the effect that science really does not work that way, forcing clinical observations into a scientific forum which is used to justify inaccurate observations by association. It works the other way, organically, in which clinical methods derive from scientific observations or from accurate and repeatable clinical phenomena.
But there was no mention of the subterfuge of pseudo medicines hiding behind the skirts of unrelated scientific findings. The producers plan future meetings.

   Collision of Incompatibles
Wallace Sampson 
Link
Last week’s post was about a recent (October 2007) meeting held at Harvard University on the subject of fascia. The purposes for commenting were several.
First, the organizers were partial believers in some forms of “Complementary and Alternative Medicine” (“CAM”), now being called “Integrative” but more realistically called sectarian or anomalous, aberrant medicine. The meeting is another in a long series of associating sectarian medicines with science – a bad fit.
Second, it illustrated an increasing infiltration of sectarianism, ideological thinking, and pseudoscience into medical schools and academia.
Third, this infiltrating change is no natural evolution, but is a political and economically driven external force, intent on both selfish and ideological interest. The forces are intent on radically changing society with medicine as the point of their phalanx. They chose medicine because of its admitted openness and self-criticism (no trade secrets, no state secrets, no top secret clearances; its self-criticism is open for all to see.) A vulnerable and often willing victim.
Fourth, the somewhat naïve writeup in Science (November, 2007) shows how even the scientific press takes the soft approach to quackery, showing it in a rosy light.
In contrast, sectarian movers, dealing pseudoscience, are occult and secretive, use obscure and distorted language. They use obscure financing behind the scenes. Progressing over 15 years or more, using cultural relativism and postmodern thought and rationales, its own advocates have described “CAM” as “the quiet revolution.”
The purposes of the fascia meeting, set out in a seven point statement, were in part to integrate the basic research being done on biochemical, molecular biological levels with clinical practitioners and results.
Problem is that there is no clinical specific disease condition or set of scientific therapy methods relating directly to “fascia.” But there are sectarian practices that claim to affect “fascia” in some way. These include massage, “structural integration” and forms of bodywork (Rolfing,) classical osteopathy and its sectarian offshoots like “cranio-sacral therapy,” chiropractic, and acupuncture. Organizations representing all of these were sponsors or supporters of the meeting. They all hoped to receive a dose of “respect” by association.
TAKING OVER.
When the sectarian advance became obvious in the early 1980s, we first became suspicious of advocates’ language. Bill Jarvis of the National Council against Health Fraud called attention to misuse of the word “alternative” in a NCAHF sponsored meeting in 1982. We will explore the history of more language distortions in future posts.
We also recognized the politics of takeover used by militaries and early 20th century communists in other countries and in other American institutions such as unions. Takeover followed a certain set of steps, in varying order, similar to objectives in military takeovers. The military first destroy means of resistance – both military and civilian. These are means of communication – the radio, printed press, other publishing, transportation, and education.
Having no need for or relevance to anything military, the sectarians concentrated on institutions that affect mind and opinion. They gained acceptance into academia by claiming having been ignored or unheard, and claiming to represent just other systems of thought and practice; that those systems could not be rejected by lack of proof, but could be rejected only by disproof.
You get the point here – and how sectarianism eased into a self-examining and self-critical medical system and how difficult it has been to disprove the moving targets of claims by experiment rather than by using prior knowledge. Academia, instead of rejecting this challenge, stepped in, up to both knees, thinking that disproof would be easy, short, and cheap. It is hard, long, and expensive (over $1 billion so far with little proved or disproved.)
Sectarians easily claimed the popular press with its naïve cub reporters and scientifically naïve editors. (Some editors actually being anti-“Establishment” biased.) We have had 25 years of naïve press coverage – devoted to non-judgmental reporting. Three to four page articles quoting advocates, 1-2 paragraphs of skeptics‘ quotes, buried midway in the article, and the last word given to the advocates. Radio and television are conquered by quackery and pseudoscience from paid commercials through standard news broadcasts. Naivete still reigns.
With the press wowed and academics cowed, and no need for transportation or airfields and barracks, the takeover plateaued, now rising slowly in the general population as our educational system turns out more students devoid of thinking skills, suspicious of authority, and attracted to conspiracies.
In 1994-7, I surveyed all US medical schools by questionnaire and telephone specifically as to how they taught “CAM”, and evaluated how much time or exposure was given to critical, scientific views. The survey found only four schools that taught significant amounts of critical analysis of claims, the rest teaching entirely from a position of non-judgment or, as for most, advocacy. I published the results in “The Need for Educational Reform in Teaching about Alternative Therapies.” (Acad-Med. 2001 Mar; 76(3): 248-50) in the journal, Academic Medicine in in 2001.
Since then we have been collecting information on medical school teaching. Several of us have actively opposed sectarian attempts to create new large centers and courses in selected schools – SUNY Stony Brook, Pittsburgh, Colorado, and chiro schools at Florida State and York (Toronto.) plus a few others. The Pitt and Fla. State experiences are published in SRAM and SI.
As a correlate study we have collected names of wealthy private foundations sponsoring med school programs. The Bravewell Collaborative sponsors the Consortium for Academic Healthcare in at least 36 medical schools, and another system for indoctrinating residents and physicians. It also indoctrinates the public, having sponsored the recent PBS series, The New Medicine.
Other sectarian sponsors include, Samueli (money made in broad band technology) which is devoted mainly to homeopathy and paying its medical leader, Wayne Jonas formerly NCCAM Director. Despite its wealth, it sucks on the nipple of the Congress, having been granted several million dollars in 2007 through Senator Tom Harkin’s earmarks (again) and 2 million five years ago from the Dept. of the Army to investigate homeopathy for battlefield wounds.
Add to these, smaller foundations such as Zakeim (Harvard) and Osher (Harvard and UCSF,) Fetzer (financer of the 1988, Bill Moyers PBS TV series Cancer and the Mind, Templeton (religion and science) Rosenthal (Columbia.) The engine of the “Integrative” and “CAM” systems are ideological, revolutionary, anti-science groups and foundations that at this moment are hard at work revolutionizing medicine and society.
Like it or not.

   The 2nd Yale Research Symposium on Complementary and Integrative Medicine. Part I
Kimball Atwood
Link
March 4, 2010
Today I went to the one-day, 2nd Yale Research Symposium on Complementary and Integrative Medicine. Many of you will recall that the first version of this conference occurred in April, 2008. According to Yale’s Continuing Medical Education website, the first conference “featured presentations from experts in CAM/IM from Yale and other leading medical institutions and drew national and international attention.” That is true: some of the national attention can be reviewed here, here, here, and here; the international attention is here. (Sorry about the flippancy; it was irresistible)
I’ve not been to a conference promising similar content since about 2001, and in general I’ve no particular wish to do so. This one was different: Steve Novella, in his day job a Yale neurologist, had been invited to be part of a Moderated Discussion on Evidence and Plausibility in the Context of CAM Research and Clinical Practice. This was not to be missed.
I arrived early enough to take a relatively inconspicuous seat near the back. My plan was to honor the Prime Directive, at least until late in the day when Steve was to speak. Alas, ‘twas not to be. Not long after I’d lodged myself there, the young man who had organized the conference came right up to me and said “welcome, Dr. Atwood.” He is 2nd year Yale medical student John Millet, an enthusiastic kid who had clearly worked hard on this task and who later gave a nice talk. He said that he recognized me from the picture on my blog, by which I guess he meant SBM (which, he said, he reads faithfully). Except that there is no picture of me on SBM, so clearly he is an empath!
For a “CAM” Conference, there wasn’t much “CAM”
The welcoming comments were offered by our John and by Deputy Dean of Education Richard Belitsky, one of two speakers who had borne the brunt of the criticism following the 2008 conference. I criticized him at the time for his “obsequious welcoming statement,” which “betrayed either an ignorance of science and critical thinking or an ignorance of ‘CAM’.” I am happy to report that it seems to have been the latter, both because he apparently had something to do with inviting Dr. Novella to the conference and because his welcoming statement today was more measured than the last. In particular, he said something to the effect (my pen had run out of ink at that point) that “this is the Yale University School of Medicine, and we consider it very important that all conference material be presented with the utmost scientific rigor.”
The agenda seemed to reflect that theme. The 2008 conference had included talks on Therapeutic Touch, Reiki, chiropractic, Qi Gong, “integrating mind, body, and spirit,” David Katz’s infamous “invitation to think more fluidly about evidence,” and, well, Bernie Siegel. This conference, in contrast, had hardly any “CAM” talks at all. Below is the schedule. For the talks that I attended (in the early afternoon there were two, competing tracks), I’ve indicated which ones were about “CAM” and which were not; among those that I missed were a couple on “mindfulness meditation” for stress reduction and one on hypnosis to reduce anxiety, which are hardly “CAM.” Another that I missed was “auricular acupuncture,” which I assume was “CAM”:
Yale Research Symposium on Complementary and Integrative Medicine
Welcome and Opening Remarks
John Millet YSM 2012 and Richard Belitsky MD
Plenary Session: An Integrative Approach to Cancer: The Biology of Lifestyle Interventions and Cancer Survival
D. Barry Boyd MD, MS (Not CAM)
Keynote Lecture: Progress in Research in Complementary and Alternative Medicine
Josephine P. Briggs MD (Mostly Not CAM )
Concurrent Sessions:
Traditional Chinese Medicine, Nutrition, and Research Methods Track
Auricular Acupuncture as a Treatment for Pregnant Women Who Have Low Back and Posterior Pelvic Pain: A Pilot Study
Shu-Ming Wang MD, Lac (CAM)
Globalization of Chinese Medicine: A Case Study of PHY906, A Traditional Chinese Medicine Formula as Adjuvant Chemotherapy for Cancer Treatment
Yung-Chi “Tommy” Cheng PhD (Mostly Not CAM)
N-Acetylcysteine for Pediatric Trichotillomania
Michael H. Bloch MD (Not CAM)
Effects of Walnut Consumption on Endothelial Function in Type 2 Diabetes: A Randomized, Controlled, Crossover Trial
John Millet YSM 2012 (Not CAM)
Patient Experiences and CAM Use in Chronic Lyme Disease: A Qualitative Study
Ather Ali ND, MPH and Lawrence A. Vitulano PhD
(CAM, but not quite as bad as it looks)
The Impact of Dietary Protein on Calcium Absorption and Kinetic Measures of Bone Turnover in Women
Karl L. Insogna MD (Not CAM)
Psychological Stress and Sudden Cardiac Death: The Downside of the Mind-Body Connection
Rachel Lampert MD (Not CAM)
Piloting a Mindfulness Based Stress Reduction Curriculum for Internal Medicine Residents
Auguste H. Fortin VI MD, MPH
Development and Initial Psychometric Testing of the Determinants of Meditation Practice Inventory
Anna-leila Williams PA, MPH, PhD(c)
Mindfulness Training as Treatment and Mechanistic Probe for Addictions
Judson Brewer MD, PhD
How Does Stress Increase Alcoholism Relapse and Affect Chronic Disease Risk?
Rajita Sinha PhD
Pre-Operative Hypnosis: A Bio-behavioral Model for Reduction of Anxiety in Surgical Patients
Haleh Saadat MD
Moderated Discussion on Evidence and Plausibility in the Context of CAM Research and Clinical Practice
Moderator: D. Barry Boyd MD, MS
Panel: David Katz MD, MPH
and Steven Novella MD
Open Forum Discussion with Expert Panel
Moderator: Lawrence A. Vitulano PhD
Panel: D. Barry Boyd MD, MS, David Katz MD, MPH, Steven Novella MD
In this post I will discuss the conference up to the point at which Dr. Novella became involved (oh no, you’re thinking: that’s the best part!), but I’ll try to follow with the second part within a day or so.
The Morning: Drs. Boyd and Briggs
Most of the “Not CAM” talks were reasonably presented and, well, reasonable. Two that are worth mentioning in a bit of detail were those by oncologist Barry Boyd, on “An Integrative Approach to Cancer: The Biology of Lifestyle Interventions and Cancer Survival,” and the talk by Josephine Briggs, the Director of the NCCAM since 2008. Dr. Boyd’s talk, in spite of a title promising everything from “visualize your immunocytes” to “antineoplastons,” was mainly about one thing: diet/exercise and cancer progression (and to a lesser extent cancer formation). It boiled down to some intriguing evidence from animal studies, biochemistry, and epidemiology suggesting that purposeful, modest weight loss may improve cancer prognosis in patients who are still in relatively good shape. The physiology is essentially the physiology of the “metabolic syndrome,” involving insulin resistance, up-regulation of insulin and insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1, which probably acts as a tumor growth factor), and a systemic inflammatory state (which, by leading to epithelial cell proliferation, provides more opportunity for carcinogenesis).
If you’re interested, Dr. Boyd has an article available online covering similar material. I talked to him several times during the course of the day: he seemed completely scientific in his outlook, and excited about new possibilities in the way that smart people in academic medicine can be. He correctly called the Gonzo regimen “nonsense.” In his talk he showed a slide with a small box labeled chemotherapy-radiation therapy-surgery-biological; it was contained within a “the bigger box” labeled lifestyle changes-dietary interventions-exercise-stress reduction (hormonal was kind of on the surface of the little box). Beyond the bigger box, which was labeled Non-Conventional Medicine, was the real “CAM”: TCM, Ayurvedic, Energy Healing, Homeopathy, Botanical.
I agree with him: diet and exercise, other than pseudoscientific drivel, are not “CAM.” At one point I asked him why he even thought of himself as “integrative.” He replied that he did not! Why, then, does he identify himself with the woo crowd? Why does he tout Michael Lerner, who defends boundless nonsense including Gerson (whose regimen is similar to Gonzo’s)? Why does he tout Ralph Moss, who championed Gonzo? Why does he tout James Gordon, who pushed at least one hapless patient into the hell that was the Gonzo trial? Doesn’t he know how the politics of quackery works? In spite of those issues, I had a good time talking with him and I hope to do it again sometime.
Josephine Briggs, the NCCAM Director, talked mostly about “supplements” studies sponsored by the Center. Surprise: they’ve all been disconfirming. Hoodathunk? Well, she did present evidence for something that I’ll admit I’d poo-poo’d in the past. It turns out that there was a large-enough-to-be-noticeable diminution in public demand for echinacea and glucosamine-chondroitin sulfate beginning not long after each NCCAM-sponsored trial had been publicized; the same is now expected, not only by Dr. Briggs but according to a trade magazine that she cited, for ginkgo biloba. Not that this justifies such trials at taxpayers’ expense, of course.
Dr. Briggs identified “areas of promise in natural products research,” naming “insight into molecular targets of dietary small molecules [etc.]” Hmmm: that sounds suspiciously like “lend[ing] a drug development aspect to an otherwise ‘herbal’ application.” Later I asked her if, in fact, the NCCAM had changed its previous attitude about refusing to fund studies proposing to look for active molecules in natural products, and she said “yes.”
Dr. Briggs herself seems to have a rational, scientific way of looking at things. No surprise: she was, for decades, a renal physiologist. She betrayed her own nerdiness with a slide titled “Quirky ideas from outside the mainstream,” which purported to show examples of, well, quirky ideas whose time eventually arrived: physical resistance training for people recovering from physical trauma (Pilates 1915); breathing techniques to help with labor pains (Lamaze 1940); breast feeding better than formula for babies (Froelich 1950s); dying patients would be better off with fewer medical interventions and more palliative support (Saunders, etc. 1960s); mindfulness-based stress reduction can help with pain management (no author or date). No arguments there, except that those ideas were never “quirky,” unless the term is defined by what the preponderance of practicing physicians was NOT doing or recommending at the time. How do those histories justify investigating implausible claims?
They don’t, but listening to Dr. Briggs one would think that the future of the NCCAM will stay away from the highly implausible. Rather, it will involve rational natural products research, investigations of reasonable physical techniques (“yoga and Tai chi for balance and avoiding falls in elderly people”), uncontroversial (i.e., not psychokinesis) mind-body techniques to help with symptoms, mainly pain, and research into the nature of the placebo effect. (She listed acupuncture as a “mind-body practice.” Did she really mean that? Was she acknowledging that it is a placebo?) If that were the extent of it, I could think of better things to do than spend my time criticizing the Center.
Alas, it won’t be, because Dr. Briggs must walk on a tightrope being shaken by Senator Harkin at one end and Senator Hatch at the other, with Congressman Burton making sure that there is no safety net underneath. And there will remain such sticky problems as the NCCAM putting the cart before the horse by funding “integrative medicine centers”; by continuing to wear its blindfold regarding the ongoing, largest and most expensive NCCAM trial yet funded, that should have long ago been terminated because of scientific and ethical misconduct and unnecessary risks to human subjects; and by continuing to offer misleading information to the public, right on the NCCAM website.
Dr. Briggs seemed unaware of the last point (I don’t recall her mentioning the other two). She was quite pleased with the website and recommended it more than once. Lover of irony that I am, I offer an example of misinformation attributed to the NCCAM website that unwittingly insults some of the Center’s own ‘stakeholders,’ and is printed right in the 2010 Yale Research Symposium syllabus:
In homeopathic medicine, there is a belief that “like cures like,” meaning that small, highly diluted quantities of medicinal substances are given to cure symptoms…”
Ouch! That’s, er, the opposite of homeopathy. To wit:
The curative power of medicines, therefore, depends on their symptoms, similar to the disease but superior to it in strength, so that each individual case of disease is most surely, radically, rapidly and permanently annihilated and removed only by a medicine capable of producing (in the human system) in the most similar and complete manner the totality of its symptoms, which at the same time are stronger than the disease.
It is the despised “allopathy” that seeks merely to cure the symptoms:
Whenever it can, it employs, in order to keep in favour with its patient, remedies that immediately suppress and hide the morbid symptoms by opposition (contraria contrariis) for a short time (palliatives), but that leave the disposition to these symptoms (the disease itself) strengthened and aggravated.
That language is the historical basis for homeopaths (and related sects) claiming to cure “the underlying cause of the disease, not just the symptoms.” (I wonder if Dr. Briggs knows that she might get into trouble if she spends too much effort advocating for studies of methods that offer “contributions to symptom management”). Unlike that example, of course, most of the misinformation on the NCCAM website serves not to diminish “CAM” practices but to embellish them.
The Afternoon
There is little to say about the talks that I attended; most of them were straightforward and uncontroversial, as their titles suggest (I don’t consider studying walnut consumption as a source of polyunsaturated fatty acids to be “CAM”). Each of the small efficacy trials showed some evidence of benefit. OCD expert Michael Bloch reported that N-acetylcysteine, a drug already used for other purposes, shows promise in the treatment of trichotillomania, an obsessive-compulsive disorder in which the individual pulls out her hair to the point of being severely disfigured, and for which there is currently no good pharmacologic treatment. I don’t know why this topic was even presented at a “CAM” conference, except perhaps that the drug is sold as a “supplement.”
Walnuts appear to improve endothelium-dependent vasodilatation in type II diabetics; impaired vasodilatation is correlated with cardiovascular disease, so perhaps walnuts are useful for this high-risk group. John Millet, the medical student who had “outed” me at the beginning of the day, gave that talk in a most competent fashion and is one of the authors of the published article.
Dietary protein appears to increase calcium absorption from the gut in post-menopausal women, according to Karl Insogna, an endocrinologist who is Director of the Yale Bone Center. He gave a great talk; look for the results of his Spoon study (Supplemental Protein to Offset Osteoporosis Now) within a couple of years.
The talk on “CAM use in Chronic Lyme Disease” deserves mention. The speaker was Ather Ali, a very deferential and soft-spoken young man whose background appears to include a large dollop of pseudoscience (Bastyr University) followed by a sprinkling of science at the Yale School of Public Health, folded into a ribbon cake of mixed messages at David Katz’s Integrative Medicine Center. Why the talk was not quite as bad as it looks is that the speaker mostly backed away from “Chronic Lyme Disease” (CLD) as a formal label, deferring to “medically unexplained symptoms.” These, he noted, might also be labeled chronic fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia, multiple chemical sensitivity, and more. The choice of the term “Chronic Lyme Disease” is an operational one: the ongoing qualitative study that he discussed asks questions of subjects who “self-identify or (have been) diagnosed with CLD” and “providers who diagnose and/or treat patients with CLD.”
Some of the preliminary results reveal problems with this purely qualitative study—both interpretational and ethical. The questions that the subjects are asked are many, ranging from cultural influences and “narratives” to laboratory values. One of the “salient insights” that Ali presented was this statement from a patient:
On finally obtaining a diagnosis:
It felt really good. That’s actually an understatement. It felt like for as sick as I was, and as awful as I felt that day, it just felt like I had a ray of hope for the first time in I don’t know how long.
This is no surprise; we don’t need a study to find this out. What we probably won’t find from this study, because of self-selection of subjects, are any who do not feel so good when given this “diagnosis.” Some may be scared out of their wits; others may recognize the scam and walk right out the door. In any event they have all been told a lie. What is the message here? I’m reminded of another such foray by naïve academic “CAM” enthusiasts (immortalized in the very first W^5), who unwittingly gave a perfect description of quackery when they wrote:
Chiropractors never have to put a patient’s pain in the category of the “mind.” They never fail to find a problem. By rooting pain in a clear physical cause, chiropractic validates the patient’s experience.
Are we to conclude that real physicians should be so dishonest?
The ethical problem with this survey arises because the investigators will inevitably stumble upon practitioners who are pushing dangerous treatments; that’s the nature of the beast known as “Lyme Literate.” The preliminary results have already identified an example, colloidal silver, which appeared on one of Ali’s slides (without his commenting, as I recall). In the question period I made that point and asked if either the IRB or the investigators had addressed it. He replied that the IRB had not, that he hadn’t seen anyone injured, and that he felt that it wasn’t an issue because this is merely an observational, not an interventional, study. I was tempted to ask, “what are you going to do, wait until someone turns gray?”—but I held my tongue.
I was confident, when I asked that question, that the IRB had not considered the issue. IRBs, like most people and most physicians, have no idea what dangers lurk under rocks dignified with labels such as “holistic,” “integrative,” “functional,” and the like. IRBs and investigators, however, are responsible for protecting human subjects, even in purely observational studies. There are numerous ethical and legal bases for this assertion, but for now consider this quotation:
…the lack of treatment was not contrived by the USPHS but was an established fact of which they proposed to take advantage.”
–Dr. Charles Barnett, Emeritus Professor of Medicine at Stanford, quoted in “Debate Revives on the PHS Syphilis Study,” Medical World News (April 19, 1974), p. 37
The statement was an attempt to excuse the Tuskegee Syphilis Study on the grounds that it had been merely “observational.” The Yale IRB need only replace “lack of treatment” with “mistreatment,” and “USPHS” with “Yale investigators,” to understand the point. The IRB might also consider that the mere presence of “experts” from Yale will be interpreted by subjects as tacit (at least) approval of the practices and the practitioners.
It is, nevertheless, possible that the qualitative CLD study will yield useful information. More likely is that it will be understood and presented by its authors in a “non-judgmental” way or as sympathetic to the practitioners (see above re: chiropractors), and thus it will be up to those with more savvy to read between the lines.
End of Part I

   The 2nd Yale Research Symposium on Complementary and Integrative Medicine. Part II
Kimball Atwood
Link
The Main Event: Novella vs. Katz
The remainder of the Symposium comprised two panels. The first was what I had come to see: a Moderated Discussion on Evidence and Plausibility in the Context of CAM Research and Clinical Practice, featuring our Founder, Steve Novella, who is also Assistant Professor of Neurology at Yale; and David Katz, the speaker who had borne the brunt of the criticism after the 2008 conference (as I wrote in Part I). According to the Symposium syllabus, he is:
David L. Katz, MD, MPH, FACPM, FACP, an internationally renowned authority on nutrition, weight management, and the prevention of chronic disease, and an internationally recognized leader in integrative medicine and patient-centered care. He is a board certified specialist in both Internal Medicine, and Preventive Medicine/Public Health, and Associate Professor (adjunct) in Public Health Practice at the Yale University School of Medicine. Katz is the Director and founder (1998) of Yale University’s Prevention Research Center; Director and founder of the Integrative Medicine Center at Griffin Hospital (2000) in Derby, CT; founder and president of the non-profit Turn the Tide Foundation; and formerly the Director of Medical Studies in Public Health at the Yale School of Medicine for eight years. He currently serves as Chair of the Connecticut Chapter of the Partnership to Fight Chronic Disease and represents Yale University on the Steering Committee of the Consortium of Academic Health Centers for Integrative Medicine.
The syllabus had excerpted that statement from a much larger, remarkable document, which I urge you to review.
I will attempt to report the Moderated Discussion as neutrally as possible, as though I were a disinterested journalist (don’t worry: later I’ll rail).
The session began with 10-minute remarks by each of the two panelists. Each was then asked to respond to a few scripted questions posed by the moderator, Dr. Barry Boyd (whose earlier talk I discussed in Part I). The panelists were aware of the questions beforehand.
Dr. Novella went first. He began by suggesting that everyone in the room shares a common ground: wanting to do what’s best for patients, and in particular wanting to offer them things that work. He proceeded to summarize what he means by “science-based medicine.” My notes are scant and illegible, but I’ll try to re-create the points. Steve can fill in any glaring omissions later.
Science-based medicine, said Dr. Novella, is not a list of treatments, procedures, specialties, drugs, diseases, or whatever; rather, it is a methodology. It seeks the best diagnostic and therapeutic options wherever it may find them; it is, like science in general, always open to new directions and willing to scrap existing ones, if the evidence so leads. It is based in the natural sciences, especially biology, but it also applies scientific methods to practical aspects of clinical medicine, such as testing diagnostic and therapeutic hypotheses. It assumes “consilience”: like science itself, it is not “Eastern” or “Western,” but universal.
Science-based medicine doesn’t “cherry-pick”: it starts with a problem and follows the evidence toward or away from potential solutions; it does not first pick a solution and then assemble whatever evidence there may be to support it. It acknowledges numerous sources of bias and error, from our flawed brains to small studies and studies sponsored by advocates (Steve cited drug companies). It recognizes the necessity to consider the “meta-evidence” (I think that was Steve’s term), meaning evidence gleaned from the entire range of potential sources: basic science to clinical trials to clinical realities.
Dr. Katz followed. He began by observing that it isn’t very often that he begins a debate by agreeing with the other debater. This yielded a smattering of appreciative chuckles. He continued with a series of “bullets,” and once again I’m afraid I don’t have them all in my notes, but here’s my attempt, followed by most of the points that Dr. Katz made in his opening remarks:
    • “Plausibility and Pandora”
    • “Tail wags Dog”
    • (illegible), Serendipity
    • Absolute Relationship
    • Scylla and Charybdis
Dr. Katz mentioned that according to astrophysicists (or perhaps one in particular that he had read or heard speak), there is more empty space between the elementary particles in each of our bodies than exists in the entire universe. He doesn’t understand it himself, but assuming it is true he wonders, for example, how others can so easily dismiss Therapeutic Touch merely because it isn’t really touch, since what we think of as touch isn’t really touch, either.
He listed a few innovations in the recent history of medicine that were “heresy” when first proposed, suggesting that if plausibility had ruled the day they would never have emerged:
     1.  H. pylori shown to be the cause of peptic ulcers;
     2.  Beta-blockers beneficial even for patients prone to congestive heart failure;
     3.  Rocky Mountain spotted fever established as caused by a bacterium.
     4.  (Later he mentioned the right heart catheter as an example of something that everyone thought was safe and effective, until a study showed that it wasn’t; but even then it took a long time for MDs to finally stop using it)
He mentioned that the monoamine oxidase inhibitor (MAOI) class of antidepressants had been discovered serendipitously when TB patients taking isoniazid (INH), a related drug, didn’t seem so depressed.
He said, “relative absence of evidence is not absolute evidence of absence.”
Evoking Scylla and Charybdis, he invited the audience to consider this choice: that something “works whether or not it’s plausible”; or that something is “implausible whether or not it works.”
He offered the metaphor of a solid floor and a moving ceiling to represent proven and unproven treatments, and noted that if we insist on using only proven treatments, we will soon get squeezed (he didn’t say it exactly that way, but I think you get the point).
The two participants then sat down and the moderator asked the questions. I can remember only one, but I remember most of the discussion. A large part of it involved how to deal with patients who are suffering, but for whom scientific medicine has no clear solution. Dr. Novella argued that he would never abandon such a patient, and that there are ways to be compassionate and caring without offering implausible treatments. He has also discussed similar points here on SBM. When asked what he would do if a patient asked his opinion about a particular method, he replied that he would be honest. He said that according to surveys, only a small fraction of those who seek “CAM” do so because of having exhausted all “conventional” options. Most do it for other reasons, having more to do with their beliefs.
I must admit that I can’t remember exactly how Dr. Katz responded to that point and to Dr. Novella’s opinions, but it presumably had to do with his floor/ceiling metaphor; his views on the same general topic are available elsewhere.
The scripted question that I distinctly remember went something like this: “what would you do if your hospital decided, in response to a perceived demand in its community, to establish a Therapeutic Touch program?”
Dr. Novella replied that he would oppose it on the grounds that hospitals have made an implicit commitment to offer science-based treatments, and Therapeutic Touch does not meet that standard.
Dr. Katz disagreed, suggesting that we don’t really know that TT doesn’t work; there have been intriguing studies, he said, showing effects on cells in tissue culture that couldn’t possibly be explained by a placebo effect. He suggested that extreme skeptics believe that TT doesn’t work and can’t work, while extreme advocates are certain that it does, and thus the reasonable, moderate position—represented by himself, presumably—would seem to be somewhere in the middle. He made similar comments about homeopathy.
Dr. Katz said that if he were advising the hospital in question and certain physicians were adamantly opposed, he would suggest that the hospital offer Therapeutic Touch to patients but provide them with a disclaimer stating that those (named) physicians were opposed to it.
Dr. Novella, referring to Dr. Katz’s earlier point about the space between elementary particles justifying a tentative plausibility for TT, asserted that counter-intuitive concepts in quantum mechanics and cosmology do not apply to the macroscopic, everyday world of clinical medicine.
There was a brief exchange about plausibility and mechanism. After Dr. Katz asserted that we needn’t know the mechanism to conclude that something works, Dr. Novella replied that “knowing the mechanism” and plausibility are not equivalent.
Dr. Novella asked if “CAM” advocates would ever be willing to say that something doesn’t work; he noted that even among Cochrane Reviews one doesn’t find such conclusions for “CAM” methods. Dr. Katz said that he had concluded that one particular substance (I don’t remember what it was) doesn’t work, but he was not willing to say the same for many others, including homeopathy, TT, and Meyers’ Cocktail, although his own studies of homeopathy and Meyers’ cocktail had not shown benefit. He argued that his studies had been hampered by stipulations from the IRB that made them not applicable to typical use.
………
I’ve witnessed these sorts of debates before. The usual scenario is that the audience is heavily biased in favor of the pro-“CAM” stance, and the skeptic finds himself backpeddling from the outset. The pro-“CAM” participant need merely raise his eyebrows or utter a word such as “reductionistic” to get supportive laughter or applause, whereas the skeptic can barely open his mouth without being hissed and booed. That this did not happen at the Yale Symposium is a tribute to Steve Novella, who is better at being sympathetic to others’ heartfelt beliefs while maintaining his intellectual integrity than anyone I’ve seen in such a spot. It also reflects the civil tone of the meeting as a whole and of the tone presented by the moderator, Barry Boyd. I congratulate them all, even Dr. Katz—although I must admit to a secret suspicion that he was frustrated by not having succeeded in making Steve Novella look like a curmudgeon. I could be wrong.
………
The final panel of the day consisted of Drs. Novella, Katz, and a few other Symposium faculty fielding questions from the audience. Most of the questions were directed to the two debaters, who reiterated several of the previous points. Other panelists spoke to an extent; Auguste Fortin, Associate Professor of Medicine and Director of Communication Skills Training for the Yale Primary Care Internal Medicine Residency Program, repeatedly referred to himself and his colleagues as “allopaths.”
Comment
A quick aside to Dr. Fortin: please, for the sake of your residents and of accurate communication skills in medicine, learn the basis for the term “allopath” and cease using it to refer to physicians. (Hint: look here). Modern medicine is “modern medicine.” We are “medical doctors.”
Regarding Dr. Katz’s assertions, particularly amusing to me was the one about H. pylori and plausibility. I usually find wanton self-promotion distasteful, but He Who Debunked the Marshall-and-Warren-as-Galileo Myth was sitting right there in the audience! The short story, for the benefit of John Millet and medical students in general, is that even if clinicians scoffed at the hypothesis when they first heard it, there was no discernible effect on its progress from bench to practice.
Practicing physicians and even academics tend to be conservative (with a small ‘c’) and risk-averse; this is a different issue from that of how scientific medicine as a whole deals with novel hypotheses. (Josephine Briggs also failed to appreciate the distinction when she offered her list of “quirky ideas from outside the mainstream,” reported in Part I). The notion that bacteria might cause an inflammatory lesion was entirely plausible, of course, and even if some physicians were surprised to hear that bacteria can adapt to an acidic environment, bacteriologists were not.
The H. pylori hypothesis became intriguing at the moment that Marshall and Warren reported having successfully cultured the organism. It was rapidly investigated all over the world, and within a few years the old etiologic “paradigm”—ironically, a rather implausible mind-body hypothesis involving stress—was no more. The story of H. pylori is a great triumph of science-based medicine, not a reason to dismiss plausibility arguments.
After the conference I approached Dr. Katz and suggested that the time it took for H. pylori to be accepted as the cause of peptic ulcer disease was entirely reasonable. He replied, “reasonable for whom? What about patients?” I’d meant, of course, “reasonable according to how long it takes to do the work,” which I told him, adding, “so what do you mean about patients? That we should have started treating them with antibiotics before…?” I didn’t finish the obvious question, but what would we have been treating? Marshall and Warren had no idea what the organism was when they first saw it.
In talking with Katz I quickly realized that he is surprisingly naïve for someone who holds himself out as an expert in “integrative medicine.” It hadn’t occurred to him that Therapeutic Touch (like all versions of “energy medicine”) is a form of psychokinesis (PK), nor did he know that PK has been studied for well over 100 years without having yielded any reproducible evidence for its existence. (The notion that it is a recent hypothesis deserving the attention of medical academia is a ruse). In an attempt to offer another example of strange powers that are beyond our understanding, he stumbled when he reported that during his recent vacation, a “mentalist” in a restaurant had come right up to him and effortlessly bent the tines of his fork with merely two fingers of one hand, a task that Katz himself could barely accomplish with both hands. He exclaimed, “I don’t know how he did it, but I know he did it!” I replied, “but you know that it was a trick, don’t you?”
There is no shame in being fooled by a good conjurer—most people are—unless the very field in which you claim expertise requires that you know about such things. Spoon bending (or, in this case, fork bending), is claimed by some of its more illustrious practitioners to be a form of PK. There is a pattern here: Dr. Katz’s counterpart at Harvard, Dr. David Eisenberg, is also innocent of such matters. He is also the co-author of language quoted in Part I of this report, praising chiropractors for “never failing to find a problem.”
Dr. Katz betrayed a naïveté about clinical trials, in spite of his professed expertise in that realm. When Dr. Novella and I asked what he thought the aggregate results of several trials of an ineffective but passionately advocated method are likely to be, he replied that they would certainly hover around the null. We would all like this to be true, but it isn’t. Clinical trials are not physics experiments. Even RCTs are fraught with opportunities for error and bias.
Experience shows that the typical history of clinical research for a “CAM” method is this: early trials, usually small, poorly designed, and performed by advocates, tend to be “positive”; later ones that are larger and better trend toward the null, but it can take years and many trials before it becomes clear that this is their fate—if it happens at all. There will inevitably be sporadic “positive” studies that are trumpeted by advocates, even if they can’t be replicated. The study that Dr. Katz mentioned at the Symposium, purporting to demonstrate Therapeutic Touch exerting an effect on cells in culture, is a perfect example.
It may be formally true that one can’t “prove a negative,” but this is no reason to take seriously every crackpot notion that comes along. To position oneself as “middle of the road” or “balanced” regarding a claim such as homeopathy or Therapeutic Touch is misleading and unscientific. It is the equivalent of asserting the same for long-settled questions such as whether the earth is planar or spheroid, whether or not perpetual motion machines can work, and so on. It is akin to a call to “teach the controversy” of evolution vs. “creation science.”
In the meantime, implausible “CAM” methods continue to be held out as “promising” or at the least not disproven, and more trials are invariably called for—no matter that in many cases existing knowledge is sufficient to refute the hypothesis. This has been the trajectory of research in homeopathy, acupuncture, ‘distant healing,’ the ‘supplements’ discussed by Dr. Briggs at the Symposium, and other “CAM” proposals. (Natural products are not highly implausible, of course, but for a number of reasons are usually moderately implausible). In acupuncture and homeopathy research, such futility has continued for decades. The same is true for the entire field of parapsychology (the investigation of paranormal claims such as PK, ESP, etc.), in spite of highly sophisticated experimental designs over the past 30-40 years—more sophisticated than would be possible for most “CAM” trials.
As several have argued, parapsychology research is an example of pathological science. I suspect that this is the inevitable result of performing trials of any highly implausible claim that has passionate adherents, and that much of “CAM” research is doomed to repeat this history. Just as paranormal claims are an important subset of “CAM,” parapsychology research is an important historical precursor of “CAM” research—even if most medical academics, including those who identify with “integrative medicine,” are unaware of it.
I’ve sparred with Dr. Katz in the past, in print, addressing some of the other points that he made at this Symposium:
Dr. Katz here; my reply (to his and a ton of other indignant letters) here (included are responses to his right heart catheter argument, a discussion of “mechanism” as it applies to plausibility, a rebuttal to post-modern language devices, and more).
Dr. Katz’s response to his critics following the 1st Yale Symposium here; my take on his response: here and here (including comments on the false dichotomy of proven methods vs. “CAM”; his hyping of homeopathy, TT, craniosacral therapy, Myers’ Cocktail, and other bogus treatments; his and others’ casual flouting of well-established medical ethics)
Conclusion
Most of the content of the 2nd Yale Research Symposium on Complementary and Integrative Medicine, Dr. Katz’s comments being a notable exception, was not “complementary” or “integrative,” but simply medicine. What proponents mean by the term “integrative medicine” seems to vary according to political expediency. To onlookers it is not substantially different from the “holistic medicine” of 30 years ago, described by philosophers Clark Glymour and Douglas Stalker:
Is there another, holistic, conception of medicine distinct from [modern medicine]? Certainly, many people seem to think so…Popular bookstores are filled with works on “holistic medicine,” many edited by medical doctors…[or]…authored by professors at distinguished medal schools… The therapies described and recommended in a typical book of the genre include biofeedback, hypnosis, psychic healing, chiropractic, tai chi, iridology, homeopathy, acupuncture, clairvoyant diagnosis, human auras, and Rolfing…
What ties together [these] diverse practices…? In part, a banal rhetoric about the physician as consoler… In part, familiar and rather useless admonitions about not overlooking the abundance of circumstances that may contribute to one condition or another. Such banalities are often true and no doubt sometimes ignored, with disastrous consequences, but they scarcely amount to a distinctive conception of medicine. Holist therapies can be divided into those that are adaptations of traditional medical practices in other societies—Chinese, Navajo, and so forth—and those that were invented, so to speak, the week before last by some relatively successful crank…
The recent success of the “Integrative Medicine” (IM) movement at medical schools is a curious turn of history. Enthusiasts portray it as “patient-centered,” “healing-oriented,” “preventive health” and more, but what can honestly be held out as distinct from modern medicine is no more than a collection of practices that don’t withstand either scientific or ethical scrutiny. To claim otherwise distorts the history of medicine and of what the practice of modern medicine involves. It misrepresents the relation between science and medicine and the extent to which the tools of Evidence-Based Medicine can be brought to bear on highly questionable claims. It distracts from the usefulness of physicians learning a wide range of critical thinking skills. Such skills might be applicable, for example, to evaluating strange powers such as PK and fork-bending, or to the ethics of studying “Lyme-Literate” practitioners. Perhaps most importantly, it constitutes a radical departure from firmly established medical ethics.
Fundamental to the movement is euphemism: accurate terms are replaced by those that seek to reassure and soothe. This obscures, rather than elucidates the phenomenon. It facilitates bait-and-switch ruses both for individual practices and for “CAM” or IM as a whole. One of our fellow bloggers, a Stanford oncologist who has been a student of such matters since the peak years of the Laetrile fraud, wrote a depressingly accurate satire explaining how medical schools have been duped by what amounts to a clever PR campaign. Language distortions have literally changed the standards of care in medicine, and not for the better. The term “integrative medicine” is now central to that change.
Medical students have not been told these things by “integrative medicine” mentors, who themselves are largely innocent of them—just as they tend to be naïve about many of the practices that they find so intriguing, as documented in the two parts of this report.
I hope that this report provides some small impetus for John Millet and other IM enthusiasts at Yale and elsewhere to re-evaluate their thoughts. They are, almost without exception I’m sure, smart, committed, enthusiastic, caring young people who are trying to become the best that they can be in medicine. I certainly developed that opinion of John in the short time that I spoke with him and observed him. He reminded me, in fact, of our very own Tim Kreider. I hope that this report will suggest to John and others that there is more to an honest, comprehensive, and ethical evaluation of IM than its proponents acknowledge.
In addition to this report and the links from it, here is a short template for how medical schools might begin to teach “CAM” in an honest, rigorous way (scroll down to “ ‘CAM’ for Medical Students”). I’m slightly embarrassed to say that we at SBM have been talking for a couple of years about creating a more comprehensive set of materials just for that purpose, perhaps to occupy its own website, but we’ve not yet done it.
For John and other Yalies, of course, there is a much better resource: Dr. Steve Novella himself, who is without a doubt the most knowledgeable skeptic under the age of 80 that I’ve ever met. I’m not kidding, Yale medical students: this guy is the real deal, and you don’t want to miss your brief opportunity to learn from him.
Finally, I’m imagining that some who read this report will wonder whether it really matters: if medical students are learning real medicine anyway, so what? Who cares if a little woo sneaks through the doors of the White Coat Academy? Isn’t it better that IM is calling attention to some things (walnuts, nutrition, exercise, relaxation methods) that tend to be short-changed by medicine even if they shouldn’t be?
Uh, nupe. Those who are interested in walnuts and exercise and relaxation are to be encouraged, but should also be encouraged to repudiate “CAM” or IM precisely because of its pseudoscientific, unethical content. There are all sorts of hazards awaiting those who fail to understand this—we saw a small example in Part I, regarding “Lyme-Literate” practitioners prescribing colloidal silver. (If the Yale IRB is still watching, please scroll down Part I to the comment from ‘rosemary’). There are, of course, larger, almost unbelievable hazards emanating from the very pinnacles of “CAM” research: for starters, look here and here.
Afterword
The philosophers Glymour and Stalker were uncanny in their predictions, made more than 25 years ago:
If holistic-health advocates were content with encouraging sensible preventive medicine or with criticizing the economic organization of American medicine, we might be enthusiastic, but they are not. If the movement were without influence on American life, we would be indifferent, but it is not. Holistic medicine is a pablum of common sense and nonsense offered by cranks and quacks and failed pedants who share an attachment to magic and an animosity toward reason. Too many people seem willing to swallow the rhetoric—even too many medical doctors—and the results will not be benign. At times, physicians may find themselves in sympathy with the holistic movement, because some fragment of the rhetoric rings true, because of certain practices and attitudes they encounter in their daily work with colleagues and patients, or because of dissatisfaction with the economic and social organization of medicine. One hopes they will speak bluntly, but it does no good to join forces with cranks and quacks, magicians and madmen.
A not-benign result that even Glymour and Stalker may not have predicted is the epidemic of commercialism and self-promotion that would have been unthinkable only a few years ago. It is abundantly evident on Dr. Katz’s website and on “integrative medicine” websites elsewhere. If the mood of society has changed so much that this does not strike today’s medical students as profoundly unprofessional (as it would have struck us in the 1970s), I hope that they will at least consider the conflicting interests of practitioners whose patients expect untainted advice. It is self-evident that we should strive to immunize ourselves, our patients, and our institutions against sales pressures from Big Pharm, no? Why should this, which by virtue of its infatuation with magical thinking is even more likely to lead us astray, be any different?

Learning quackery for Continuing Medical Education credit
Jann Bellamy on August 20, 2015
Link

The Integrative Addiction Conference 2015 (“A New Era in Natural Treatment”) starts tomorrow in Myrtle Beach, SC. Medical doctors, doctors of osteopathy, naturopaths and other health care providers will hear lectures on such subjects as “IV Therapies and Addiction Solutions,” given by Kenneth Proefrock, a naturopath whose Arizona Stem Cell Center specializes in autologous stem cell transplants derived from adipose tissue. Proefrock, who was disciplined for using prolotherapy in the cervical spine without proper credentialing in 2008, claims that stem cells treatments are an “incredibly versatile therapy” and uses them for variety of conditions, such as MS and viral diseases. At the same time, he admits that they are not FDA approved and he is not claiming they are effective for anything (and he’s right), which leads one to wonder why he employs them.
Proefrock also offers a typical naturopathic mish-mash of services, from oncology to urology to “naturopathic endocrinology,” and claims he specializes in treating influenza, high blood pressure and kidney stones, as well as addiction. In other words, he doesn’t seem to be the sort of expert you’d find speaking at a science-based conference on addiction medicine.
You’ll find similarly troubling bios of some of the other speakers, as well as dubious treatments for addiction, on the conference website. Here, for example, are speaker Giordano’s and Eidelman’s websites.
Dalal Akoury, MD, is the “Title Sponsor” of the conference and appears to be running the show. Although she is listed by the S.C. Board of Medicine as board certified in pediatrics, she is the founder of the “Integrative Addiction Institute” and runs the “AwareMed Health and Wellness Resource Center” in Myrtle Beach. Like the Arizona Stem Cell Center, it offers a range of treatments that defy categorization as any particular specialty: addiction recovery, “adrenal fatigue” treatment, stem cells, “anti-aging,” weight loss, “functional medicine” and “integrative cancer care“. Yet, only Akoury and one licensed practical nurse are on the staff of the Center. Again, it is questionable whether she is has sufficient qualifications in addiction medicine to run a conference on the subject.
Regular readers of this blog won’t be shocked that this sort of conference goes on. But what we should find disturbing is that a medical doctor can get continuing medical education credits for conference attendance. Why? Because it is sponsored jointly by Continuing Education, Inc. and the Southwest College of Naturopathic Medicine (no surprise there). Continuing Education, Inc. is accredited by the American Council for Continuing Medical Education (ACCME) as a provider of continuing education for physicians. Continuing Education, Inc. has designated this conference for a maximum of 19.75 hours of AMA (yes, that AMA) PRA (Physicians Recognition Award) Category 1 Credits, a decision it is empowered to make because of its ACCME accreditation.
The American Council for Continuing Medical Education
A bit of background (bear with me here): Like other professionals, such as lawyers and accountants, medical doctors must earn a certain number of continuing education credits to keep their state licenses current and to retain a specialty board certification. State medical boards and specialty boards (such as the American Academy of Family Physicians and the American Board of Internal Medicine) set the number of hours and sometimes the subject matter of these courses. They also decide which courses they will accept as valid CME hours. Some of these accept courses offered by CME providers accredited by the ACCME. Others may not accept certain ACCME-accredited providers directly, but will accept hours approved by other entities that do. For example, my state, Florida, will accept courses approved for the AMA Physician Recognition Award.
Putting this all together, the Integrative Addiction Conference is presented by an organization accredited by the ACCME and qualifies for AMA PRA credit. In turn, because it is eligible for AMA PRA credit, it will be accepted by the Florida Board of Medicine.
The ACCME accredits organizations, not individual courses, based on set criteria. Once the organization is accredited to provide CME, it must maintain recognition through a continuing compliance process. ACCME member organizations include the AMA, the American Hospital Association, the American Board of Medical Specialties and the Federation of State Medical Boards of the U.S. There are a total of 2,100 organizations accredited by the ACCME, conducting 125,000 events annually. In other words, if you take a CME course in the U.S., your getting credit for it likely involved the ACCME.
Here’s how the ACCME explains its work:
The Accreditation Council for Continuing Medical Education (ACCME®), a nonprofit corporation based in Chicago, is responsible for accrediting institutions that offer continuing medical education (CME) to physicians and other health care professionals. . . . The ACCME’s mission is to identify, develop, and promote rigorous national standards for quality CME that improves physician performance and medical care for patients and their communities. [Emphasis added.]
According to ACCME policy:
Accredited providers are responsible for validating the clinical content of CME activities that they provide. Specifically,
     1.  All the recommendations involving clinical medicine in a CME activity must be based on evidence that is accepted within the profession of medicine as adequate justification for their indications and contraindications in the care of patients.
     2.  All scientific research referred to, reported, or used in CME in support or justification of a patient care recommendation must conform to the generally accepted standards of experimental design, data collection and analysis.
     3.  Providers are not eligible for ACCME accreditation or reaccreditation if they present activities that promote recommendations, treatment, or manners of practicing medicine that are not within the definition of CME, or known to have risks or dangers that outweigh the benefits or known to be ineffective in the treatment of patients. An organization whose program of CME is devoted to advocacy of unscientific modalities of diagnosis or therapy is not eligible to apply for ACCME accreditation. [Emphasis added.]
I’m not a physician, but I think the Integrative Addiction Conference 2015 falls a bit short of these standards, don’t you?
Boning up on pseudoscience
Let’s look at a few other courses from ACCME-accredited CME providers and see how they measure up.
The Institute for Functional Medicine (IFM) is an ACCME-accredited CME provider as well. For those of you who aren’t familiar with Functional Medicine, we’re not sure we can explain it either. As David Gorski said:
what constitutes functional medicine has never been clear to me, although it’s clear that a lot of it is pseudoscience. . . . It postulates “imbalances” in hormones and neurotransmitters, oxidation-reduction, detoxification and biotransformation, immune function, inflammation, and cell structure. It’s all so vague that these “imbalances” could mean almost anything, and when practitioners of “functional medicine” refer to them, they usually do. Arguably the most famous practitioner of “functional medicine” is Mark Hyman, known for creating “Ultrawellness,” the very name of which should tell you pretty much all you need to know about functional medicine. Indeed, it just seems to be a label used to encompass a whole lot of alternative medicine practices being “integrated” with real medicine.
The theme for IFM’s Annual International Conference, held this past May, was “The Omics Revolution: Nature and Nurture,” for 19 hours of CME. I’ll wager this is the type of “omics” that could be categorized as “Woo-Omics.”
On the faculty were:
Jeffrey Bland, PhD, the “father of functional medicine,” whose outsized claims for his nutritional products got him into trouble with the FTC in the early 1990s.
Paul Anderson, a naturopath whose clinic in Seattle offers hyperbaric oxygen therapy and IV therapy delivering “micronutrients and pharmaceuticals” for, among other things, “support for detoxification” and “heavy metal chelation.”
Yousef Elyaman, MD, a Florida functional medicine practitioner and author of the upcoming book, Your Healing Power, “a guide to mastering one’s genes to reverse disease.” (Who knew?)
If you missed the May conference, there are several other opportunities on the horizon to earn CME credits from the IFM. In November, the IFM will be presenting “Energy: Illuminating the Energy Spectrum: Evidence and Emerging Clinical Solutions for Managing Pain, Fatigue, and Cognitive Dysfunction,” for which the physician can earn 20 CME credits. The descriptions of the program and its presentations are so full of word salads you could open a restaurant with them.
For example:
Energy drives all biologic activity—within individual atoms and molecules, as part of cellular physiology, up through organ-system and whole-person functioning, and, ultimately, the entire biosphere. The last 20 years have brought us dramatic breakthroughs in understanding about how mitochondria work and what they require for enduring optimal function. Genetic and epigenetic vulnerabilities have been discovered; the effects of toxic environmental exposures on energy production have been revealed; and connections between dysregulation in energy production and many clinical conditions have been described.
And:
Physiology is one side of the coin, but we are also learning about the larger energy landscape, including the mechanisms underlying the clinical effects of magnetic fields and microcurrent, hands-on therapies such as manipulation and craniosacral, acupuncture, and the profound power of the therapeutic partnership.
As for those “clinical effects of magnetic fields,” a “post-module activity” includes “Identifying Clinical Manifestations of EMF/RF: Adverse Impacts Including Electromagnetic Hypersensitivity Syndrome,” (a fabricated condition), by Devra Davis, PhD, a cell phone radiation alarmist who warns against keeping your cell phone in your bra due to an increased risk of breast cancer (another fabrication).
IFM is big into “detox.” Just this past July, it offered 19 CME credits for a sold-out conference styled “Detox: Understanding Biotransformation and Recognizing Toxicity: Evaluation and Treatment in the Functional Medicine Model.” And who better to teach MDs about detoxification than naturopaths, of which there were several on the faculty.
Also on the faculty is a chiropractor, Richard Mayfield, who lectured on “Ensuring a Safe Detox Program: Applying Oral Chelation Therapy to Reduce an Elevated Heavy Metal Burden with Case Studies,” one of 6 courses he teaches at the IFM “Detox” conference.
Mayfield’s own practice reveals a truly impressive array of such quackery, including chiropractic “adjustments” to remove “nerve interference,” bioidentical hormones, something called BioCranial treatments, and screening for “undiagnosed gluten intolerance,” among others. He treats autism spectrum disorder with a “biomedical approach” and is a former DAN! practitioner.
To be fair, the pseudoscience was not confined to ND and DC presenters. There were MDs and a dentist as well. The latter was Mary Ellen Chalmers, DMD, whose practice offers removal of mercury amalgam fillings, a totally unnecessary and expensive dental procedure that is based on the unproven “theory” that they are “toxic” to everyone.
One would be hard pressed to find better exemplars of CME courses “devoted to advocacy of unscientific modalities of diagnosis or therapy,” as the ACCME puts it, than these IFM conferences.
Or, maybe not.
If, unlike IFM, your organization does not have its own ACCME accreditation, you can glom onto one that does to present your pseudoscience for CME credit. For example, the American Academy of Integrative Health & Medicine offered CME for its 2015 conference under the auspices of Scripps Health, in the form of the pretentiously titled “People, Planet and Purpose: Global Practitioners United in Health and Healing.” (Interestingly, for all of its chumminess with DCs and NDs, there doesn’t seem to be either on the Scripps staff.) Here the speakers include:
Deepak Chopra, MD, who is famous for loony sayings, like:
I know people who ascribe to this philosophy. They are called “toddlers.”
John Weeks, a relentless promoter of integrative medicine, who believes that chiropractors and naturopaths are capable of practicing as primary care physicians.
Bill Wolfe, a speaker on “biological dentistry,” another dentist who advocates the removal of mercury fillings and believes “any degenerative condition in the mouth is a potential energetic disruption of the associated energy meridian.” And apparently believes that having two different metals in the mouth (e.g., gold and mercury) generates an electric current capable of disrupting one’s “energy meridians.”
Bill Reddy, an acupuncturist, who lectured on “Leaky gut.” (It must be awfully easy to master the understanding and treatment of “leaky gut” if your education as an acupuncturist is sufficient to lecture on it.)
Joseph Pizzorno ND, talked about “Assessing Body Burden” and “Detoxification.” There is not a detailed description of these courses available, so I’m not sure what he will say about “assessing body burden,” but I found a hint in The Encyclopedia of Natural Medicine, of which Pizzorno is co-editor. This Encyclopedia tells us that 25% of the US population suffers from heavy metal poisoning. The preferred method of assessing this mythical burden is provoked urine testing.
Amy Rothenberg, ND, spoke on “Clinical Applications of Homeopathy.” She memorably testified at the recent FDA hearing that homeopathy’s mechanism of action (of which there is none) can be explained by hormesis (a “theory” shot down here). She also said she uses homeopathy to treat autistic children.
I note that the listed conference speakers recommend all of the Five Things Patients and Physicians Should Question, according to the American College of Medical Toxicology and the American Academy of Clinical Toxicology. Doesn’t sound like “recommendations involving clinical medicine . . . based on evidence that is accepted within the profession of medicine,” per ACCME policy.
Integrative Practitioner, John Weeks’s organization, is also able to offer CME courses by attaching itself to a medical school. In 2015, it teamed up with Mount Sinai/Beth Israel, to present the Integrative Healthcare Symposium Annual Conference, at which the physician could earn 17.75 CME credit hours. The keynote speaker was Nick Ortner, CEO of the Tapping Solution, LLC, a company with a mission to bring “simple, effective, natural healing into the mainstream through Emotional Freedom Techniques (EFT)” or “tapping.” According to Ortner, tapping is a healing modality that combines ancient Chinese acupressure and modern psychology which:
utilizes the body’s energy meridian points by stimulating them with your fingertips – literally tapping into your body’s own energy and healing power.
No, not “literally,” Mr. Ortner. Ortner is also the author of a “revolutionary” book about tapping. As well, he:
created and produced the breakthrough documentary film, The Tapping Solution, which follows ten people who used tapping to overcome tremendous challenges, including 30 years of chronic back pain, fibromyalgia, insomnia, devastating grief and more.
No shortage of superlatives in his bio. EFT is, of course nonsense.
Sadly for the integrative MD, someone thought to exercise some discretion here and Ortner’s talk could not be included in the attendee’s CME credits. Also not approved for credit was Dr. Devra’s talk: “Experimental and Clinical Observations on the Impact on Reproductive Health of Wireless Radiation from Cell Phones and Other Devices.” It was, however, approved CE for chiropractors, naturopaths, acupuncturists, and (unfortunately) nurses.
There were a lot of functional medicine presentations, including a naturopath’s discussion of how foods can “reduce our toxic body burden” and another presentation by a naturopath who claims that a simple urine test can find two different markers reflective of both the amount of hydroxyl radical damage to the DNA, and the ability of the DNA to repair this damage as well as indicate whether a person is under “oxidative stress.”
Another Integrative Healthcare Symposium, “Focus On: the Microbiome,” teams up with the University of Miami medical school and “has been reviewed and is acceptable for up to 12.00 Prescribed credit(s) by the American Academy of Family Physicians” (AAFP).
Conference chair is David Perlmutter, MD, author of “Grain Brain.” Here, attendees, among other things:
Appreciate how leading edge novel techniques to restore a healthy microbiome may pave the way for meaningful treatment of autism, autoimmune conditions and inflammatory disorders
Perlmutter got his equivalent of an Oz takedown in a recent New York Magazine article by Alan Levinovitz, author of The Gluten Lie (a book highly recommended by SBM’s own Clay Jones.) It’s an excellent exposé and well worth reading.
On its website, The AAFP offers this disclaimer regarding CME for integrative medicine courses:
[The AAFP] maintains there is value in providing information about integrative medicine (also referred to as complementary and alternatve [sic] practices and other terms) to help family physicians respond to patients who use these therapies and who would consider using them. Family physicians need to understand new medical practices and products including integrative approaches to effectively counsel patients, understand potential drug or treatment interactions, and better evaluate patient outcomes.
Continuing Medical Education (CME) activities that include information about integrative medicine must meet all existing AAFP CME Credit Eligibility Requirements. Among these is the requirement that clinical content that is not considered to be evidence-based or customary and generally accepted medical practice must be deemed neither dangerous nor proven ineffective by the Commission on Continuing Professional Development (COCPD). The COCPD relies on its collective clinical expertise, as well as findings (meta-analyses or systematic reviews) reported by sources it deems acceptable. The COCPD considers diagnostic and therapeutic interventions in which the risks substantially outweigh the benefits to patients to meet the definition of “dangerous.”
Yes, of course family physicians need to know about integrative, complementary and alternative medicine, but there are better ways than sending them to conferences that teach them how to practice sub-par medicine. And there are more risks than a treatment being “dangerous” or proven ineffective. Does it not matter that the patient is being ripped off by a physician who fails to use “evidence-based or customary and generally accepted medical practice.”
But wait, there’s more . . . quackery!
Before we end, here are a few more questionable, but CME-approved, courses:
“Aromatherapy & Health: An Introduction” (4 hours CME credits), from the University of Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine.
“Bioidentical Hormone Replacement Therapy Symposium,” sponsored by the American Academy of Anti-Aging Medicine, which seems to fit nicely into Kimball Atwood’s Pseudomedical Pseudoprofessional Organization category. (27 hours CME credits)
Auricular Acupuncture, from the University of Miami Miller School of Medicine; (14 hours CME credit):
Auriculotherapy is effective for a wide range of health problems, including musculoskeletal pain, addiction, respiratory and gastrointestinal issues, skin problems, eye-ear-nose-throat disorders, control of blood pressure & many others.
“And many others?” Somehow I doubt that these claims of effectiveness are based on research that, again quoting the ACCME, “conform[s] to the generally accepted standards of experimental design, data collection and analysis.”
It is unfortunate to see the continued normalization of quackery as accepted medical practice. And it is unfortunate that the AMA and state medical boards, with the help of the ACCME, are facilitating that process by allowing CME credit for courses in pseudoscience. If these courses are “based on evidence that is accepted within the profession of medicine as adequate justification” for their use in patient care, then that standard has no meaning.

   Acupuncture CME
Mark Crislip
Link
Some Universities have more cachet than others. On the West coast it is Stanford that has the reputation as the best. There is Oxford, Yale, MIT, and maybe Whatsamatta U. I would wager that in most people’s mind the crème de la crème is Harvard. Harvard is where you find the best of the best. If Harvard is involved, a project gains an extra gobbet of credibility. Brigham and Women’s Hospital also has a similar reputation in the US as one of the hospitals associated with only Harvard and the New England Journal of Medicine. Premier university, premier hospital, premier journal.
So if Brigham and Women’s Hospital and Harvard Medical School are offering continuing medical information (CME) for acupuncture, there must be something to it, right? A course called “Structural Acupuncture for Physicians” must have some validity.
Brigham and Women’s Hospital, which is a teaching affiliate of Harvard Medical School, includes the Oscher Clinical Center for Complementary and Integrative Medical Therapies. The Oscher center offers acupuncture, yoga, chiropractic and a variety of other modalities including craniosacral therapy.
There are few things, in a world of alternative nonsense, as nonsensical as craniosacral therapy .
A craniosacral therapy session involves the therapist placing their hands on the patient, which they say allows them to tune into what they call the craniosacral system. The practitioner gently works with the spine and the skull and its cranial sutures, diaphragms, and fascia. In this way, the restrictions of nerve passages are said to be eased, the movement of cerebrospinal fluid through the spinal cord is said to be optimized, and misaligned bones are said to be restored to their proper position.
Cranial Sacral therapists think they can improve the flow of spinal fluid flow by gently massaging the skull. Really. I can’t make this stuff up. I operate under the assumption that you can judge a person by the company they keep, although guilt by association is problematic in medical institutions. Programs are often started in hospitals for financial reasons without the benefit of scientific or medical input. It is one of the many prices we pay in the US for a for-profit medical system. But if there is a institution whose scientific standards are such that they allow craniosacral therapy, well, they lose a major chunk of credibility. As the saying goes, you lie down with pigs, you come up smellin’ like garbage.
On the other hand, it would be much easier to participate on committee work. The Pharmacy and Therapeutics committees in which I participate spends significant time evaluating the literature to decide how best to utilize new drugs and therapies. If only we offered craniosacral therapy: I would never have to justify a treatment based on science and reality again. So now I realize, sadly, that Brigham and Women’s and, by extension Harvard, has questionable scientific standards, or, if they have standards, they apply them selectively.
The brochure states
This unique course provides practical, hands-on training in acupuncture. The training program is designed to bring together Eastern and Western views of health and disease into a result-oriented acupuncture style. You will learn to evaluate and treat patients using modern Japanese acupuncture techniques that link classical Chinese theory to concrete, understandable clinical diagnostic and treatment techniques.
Whenever I hear about the Eastern views of health and disease I always think of General Westmoreland in the movie “Hearts and Minds.” I know, cheap shot. But an Eastern heart attack is different from a Western heart attack how?
What, I wonder, is a “result-oriented acupuncture style.” Since acupuncture has little, if any, efficacy, it cannot have therapeutic results. Maybe the key word is style. There is style and there is substance. I suppose they could be suggesting that the acupuncture they are teaching will only look like it is working?
Style probably refers to the type of acupuncture, as in Kiiko Style acupuncture. Like the kung fu movies I watched as a teen, there are various acupuncture styles that need to compete in a winner take alltournament, to determine once and for all whose acupuncture is strongest.
Modern Japanese acupuncture differs from Chinese acupuncture in that they use finer needles that are not placed as deeply. Japanese acupuncture does seem to share one feature with Chinese acupuncture, at least to judge from the videos of the procedure I can find searching YouTube: a complete lack of understanding of sterile technique. I you want to get the willies watch a video on acupuncture, Japanese or otherwise. Barehanded, no hand washing, the practitioner touches the area to be pierced, no alcohol wipe is used, and the junction of needle/skin is manipulated. The Kiiko style, to judge from the photographs on the website, does not include gloves. These videos should be entitled “How to transmit infectious diseases.”
I assume they will use sterile technique at the course, since “emphasis is given to “hands-on” point location and needling techniques based upon palpatory feedback” although one cannot be sanguine in regards to a hospital system that uses craniosacral therapy. Germ theory is, after all, just a theory.
The didactic portion of the course will focus on bridging the gap between acupuncture practice and science. The scientific basis of acupuncture and the methodological problems with acupuncture research is presented as part of the discussion of specific clinical conditions throughout the course.
That will be an interesting discussion. Since the acupuncture literature, as discussed at length on this blog, is such that the best studies show no effect and the science is only barely applicable to acupuncture and pain treatment, it would be fun to be a fly on the wall and see how they ‘bridge the gap” for the justification of the covered uses: Pain Control, Hormonal Imbalances, OB/GYN Problems, GI Disorders, Scar Treatments, Structural and Orthopedic Problems, Cardiac and Vascular Disorders, Autoimmune and Autonomic Disorders, Mood Disorders, Myofascial and Neuroanatomic Treatment.
Not only will they be teaching Japanese acupuncture and classic Chinese acupuncture, but also auricular acupuncture and the German Microsystem approach (MAPS: Mikro-Aku-Punkt-Systeme). That last one
… is based on the Somatotopic fields comprising of specific points of correspondence in the Auricle (Ear), Scalp, Oral Cavity etc. A micro system is like a Map of the body — somatotope or a cartography of the whole organism similar to the homunculus discovered in the sensory motor cortex of the brain. Each of the Micro system points have a clearly defined correlation to and interrelation with a particular organ or function…For Example EAR Acupuncture is one such Micro-system. It was discovered by the french doctor Nogier who decoded the functional correspondences of the respective ear points. The punctual cartography of the Ear resembles an upside down embryo.
MAPS is apparently the result of the unholy mating of acupuncture and phrenology.
I am surprised they did not include Korean Hand Acupuncture, foot acupuncture and tongue acupuncture. They are leaving out three key styles of acupuncture. One wonders how six styles of acupuncture can all be valid, share similar physiology, and be supported by the same science, given their differences. I suppose it is like asking which is the valid style of astrology: Indian, Western, or Mayan. It is a trick question. They are all nonsense.
The best constructed study to date on acupuncture demonstrated that sham acupuncture by twirling toothpicks on the skin is arguably more effective and definitely has fewer side effects when compared to ‘real’ acupuncture. I can use quotes with the best of them. I wonder it they will pass out a box of toothpicks. Since twirling toothpicksgives similar results with fewer complications, one wonders how they justify teaching acupuncture styles that are less efficacious and more dangerous than toothpicks. Can you ethically offer an equivalent therapy with more side effects than a known competitor?
Let’s see, cost of the class: $6650. For that kind of cash, who needs ethics? That’s right, if you are a Harvard-affiliated hospital you can charge the cost of two loaded, top-of-the-line MacBook Pros to teach magic. I bet they get it. “Harvard-trained acupuncturist” would look great on a business card and provide instant credibility. A quick google finds practitioners whose websites mention the Harvard course for their training. Premium price for premium nonsense.
I am only disappointed they did not charge ten dollars more. $6660. Now there’s a number.
As the web page for the Oscler center says
The market for complementary and integrative medicine is vast and shows no sign of diminishing. This trend must be guided by scientific inquiry, clinical judgment, regulatory authority, and shared decision-making. – Dr. David Eisenberg.
The market. Not the need. The market. It is depressing when good institutions promote worthless nonsense.
Next time I read the NEJM and see an article from Harvard or Brigham and Women’s, I will not be as accepting of the result as I was in the past. They have lost some of their credibility with me. It is sad. Great institutions can have feet of clay. At least there are still institutions you can believe in. Mom. Apple Pie. Baseball. Go Barry Bonds.

   Crank “scientific” conferences: A parody of science-based medicine that can deceive even reputable scientists and institutions
David Gorski 
Link
If there’s one thing that purveyors of pseudoscientific medical modalities crave, probably above all else, it’s legitimacy. They want to be taken seriously as Real Scientists. Of course, my usual reaction to this desire is to point out that anyone can be take seriously as a real scientist if he is able to do science and that science actually shows that there is something to his claims. In other words, do his hypotheses make testable predictions, and does testing these predictions fail to falsify his hypotheses? That’s what it takes, but advocates of so-called “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or “integrative medicine” (IM, or, as I like to refer to it: “integrating” quackery with scientific medicine) want their woo to be considered science without actually doing the hard work of science.
There are several strategies that pseudoscientists use to give their beliefs the appearance of science, a patina of “science-y” camouflage, if you will. One, of course, is the cooptation and corruption of the language of science, which has been a frequent topic on this blog, particularly in posts written by Drs. Atwood and Sampson. Another is to produce journals that appear to be science, but are anything but. I’ve discussed one example, the Journal of American Physicians and Surgeons and Medical Acupuncture, but others include Homeopathy, the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, and Medical Hypotheses, which recently was forced to retract a horrible paper by arch-HIV/AIDS denialist Peter Duesberg. What’s worse is that some of these journals are even published by what are considered major publishers, such as Mary Ann Liebert, Inc., and Elsevier.
There is, however, a third strategy. How do scientists communicate their findings to other scientists, as well as meeting and mingling with other scientists? Why, they hold scientific meetings, of course! These meetings can be small or even as large as the American Association for Cancer Research meeting, which is attended by around 15,000 cancer researchers each year. So, too, do cranks hold meetings. These meetings often have all the trappings of scientific meetings, with plenary sessions, smaller parallel sessions, poster sesssions, and an exhibition hall, complete with exhibits by sponsoring companies. Sometimes these meetings can even appear so much like the real thing that they take in legitimate researchers and legitimate universities. Here, I present two examples of such conferences.
THE UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO: DUPE OR WILLING ACCOMPLICE?
The first such conference that comes to mind when I think of fake scientific conferences is the autism quackfest known as Autism One. Autism One is a conference of believers in two things: (1) that vaccines cause autism and (2) that “biomedical” and CAM/IM therapies can treat and even reverse autism. This conference, heavily promoted on anti-vaccine websites like Age of Autism, is held every year in Chicago near or on Memorial Day weekend. It is generally held in a hotel near O’Hare International Airport (downtown locations must be too expensive), and in general features the “luminaries” of the vaccines-cause-autism underground giving talks on the “science” of the vaccine-autism link and all manner of “biomedical” interventions, the vast majority of which are, in my opinion, pure quackery. For instance, the 2008 Autism One conference featured Boyd Haley, the father-son team of autism woo-meisters Mark and David Geier, Mayer Eisenstein, and a number of others. Examples of the talks at that conference included “Over 50 years of known toxicity! (Unsafe at any Concentration)” by Frank Engley, who said this: “NOT GRAM- NOT MILLIGRAM – NOT MICROGRAM- BUT NANOGRAM!” Its keynote speaker was–surprise! surprise!–Jenny McCarthy, whose ignorance of science is beyond belief and has led her to become, in essence, the celebrity face of the anti-vaccine movement, even leading marches on Washington against vaccines.
In 2009, Autism One made a bit of a splash, but not in a good way. Basically, what happened is that the Chicago Tribune noticed the Geiers’ Lupron protocol for autism. Specifically, Mark and David Geier have been subjecting autistic children to a drug that is a powerful suppressor of sex hormone production because they actually think that testosterone somehow binds mercury and that lowering testosterone concentrations will make chelation therapy work better. Truly, this is some of the most despicably off the wall woo that I’ve ever encountered. it combines bad biochemistry with anti-vaccination pseudoscience of combining testosterone-lowering treatments with the dangerous quackery that is chelation therapy for autism. Then there was Dr. Mayer Eisenstein, founder of the crunchy and “alternative” HomeFirst practice. This is the same guy who said that he had never seen a case of autism in an unvaccinated child in his practice, a case of data-free selective memory so blatant that later the story morphed into his practice having a huge computer database to back up his claim. He is a master of anti-vaccine rhetoric, including his beliefs that vaccines cause autism, that the government is covering it up, that the American Academy of Pediatrics is hopelessly in the thrall of big pharma, and that “every doctor now essentially in this country has done something as heinous as the Nazis did, unknowingly” because they give vaccines to children.
And, of course, Jenny McCarthy was the keynote speaker in 2008 and then again in 2009. Any one want to make any bets against her being the keynote speaker for Autism One 2010? I don’t.
As annoying as Autism One in Chicago is, however, there is one thing that very obviously distinguishes it from real scientific conferences, specifically the lack of a university or academic organization sponsoring it. It’s held out in a hotel near the airport, far from downtown Chicago, and there is very little pretense of academic endeavor. The patina of a scientific conference is thin indeed.
I wish I could say the same thing about an offshoot of Autism One, namely Autism One Canada:
If you live in Canada, the Northeastern United States, the Great Lakes area, or beyond, you will not want to miss this conference from Autism One, Autism Canada, and the University of Toronto’s Dalla Lana School of Public Health. The 2-day main conference will be held Saturday, October 31 and Sunday, November 1, preceded by a 1-day training program for practitioners on Friday, October 30. This conference features two dozen of the most highly respected names in the autism community and provides the most up-to-date information to help your child. From implementing the best biomedical treatments to realizing the benefits of educational therapies to adolescence and adulthood issues, the conference brings you the answers to be your child’s most effective healer and powerful advocate.
The flier then advertises that it is sponsored by the SickKids Foundation, Spectrum Supplements, and Ontario Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy Centre Inc. A scan of the actual pamphlet advertising the conference can be found below:

Autism One Canada doesn’t appear quite as bad as the Mothership Autism One in Chicago usually is. At least, “scientists” like the Geiers don’t appear to be speaking there. But there’s still plenty of dubious science there to go around, starting with the keynote speaker, Dr. Martha Herbert. She shares one characteristic with at least a couple of “luminaries” of the anti-vaccine “biomedical” movement. As Autism Diva and Kevin Leitch pointed out, like Dr. Mark Geier and Dr. Boyd Haley, Dr. Herbert has been slapped down by the courts, which used the Daubert standard to reject her testimony claiming that a child was made autistic by a reaction to mold growing in the condo she was living in. The court found:
Dr. Herbert’s publications indicate that she is an outspoken advocate of increased attention to the possibility of environmental influences. Even she, however, despite that acknowledged perspective, speaks in her published work of possibilities and potentialities, rather than of the ‘reasonable degree of medical certainty’ to which she offers to testify under oath in this case.10 Neither Dr. Herbert’s publications, nor any others cited, identify mold exposure as even a suspected, still less a known or proven, trigger of autism……Dr. Herbert’s method, to the extent the Court can discern it from the materials offered, is a series of deductions based on possibilities…..*Clearly, Dr. Herbert’s method is not generally accepted in the scientific community*. Dr. Herbert’s theory of environmental triggers of autism may some day prove true. It has not yet. Her proffered testimony does not meet the standard of reliability required by the case law, and cannot be admitted in evidence at trial.
Dr. Herbert is, it turns out, a big fan of the idea that autism has something to do with neuroinflammation. Unfortunately, none of her publications persuasively presents evidence for this hypothesis, and lately she’s publishing in bottom-feeding alternative medicine journals articles with titles like Learning From the Autism Catastrophe: Key Leverage Points. Suffice it to say, Dr. Herbert is big on “biomedical” woo, so much so that anti-vaccine propagandist David Kirby likes to cite her and Age of Autism loves her. Unfortunately, for all her grandiose claims that neuroinflammation is a major cause of autism and that mold and other environmental influences trigger it, Dr. Herbert’s publication record does not support these assertions. Go ahead. Head over to PubMed and look at Dr. Herbert’s publication record. I’ll wait. She has listed 15 publications about autism, of which:
six are review articles
two are in alt-med journals, and one of these is an interview
one is a paper with dozens of authors reporting the results of mapping autism risk loci using genetic linkage and chromosomal rearrangements. (Dr. Herbert is solidly right in the middle of the huge pack of authors.)
Of the remainder, Dr. Herbert only appears to be first author or senior author on four publications on autism containing original research, and these appear to be all imaging studies of the brains of autistic children. In other words, Dr. Herbert is making claims far beyond what her publication record in the peer-reviewed literature can, even under the most charitable interpretation possible, support. Nothing in her publication record appears to support her concept of autism being a systemic, rather than brain-based condition. There’s nothing there to support a link between autism and gut disorders; nothing to support a link between autism and immune dysfunction; and nothing to support a link between “environmental influences” and autism. That’s not to say that there aren’t environmental factors that influence the development of autism; it’s just that there’s nothing in Dr. Herbert’s publication record to support such a hypothesis or to identify what, if anything, those environmental factors might be.
This is the “keynote speaker.” She is, however, faculty at Harvard University.
The other speakers aren’t much better. I’ll admit, the woo-to-normal ratio isn’t as high as it was in Chicago last May, but it’s still pretty high. It’s just that this is mostly second tier “biomedical” stuff. It’s the second stringers, for the most part. For instance, there’s Dan Rossignol, who’s big on hyperbaric oxygen as a treatment for autism with very little data. There’s Amy Yasko, who’s known for somehow thinking that one can treat autism (and lots of other disorders) with orally administered RNA solutions. I work with RNA all the time. It’s damned unstable. It would not survive even the saliva without being broken down into its components. Actually, RNA won’t survive long in aqueous solution without being frozen at at least -20° C, preferably -80° C. Yet this Dr. Yasko claims that “we have found that by using highly specific solutions of RNAs we are able to enhance our cells natural ability to communicate with one another.”
I’d call Yasko’s woo homeopathic RNA therapy, except that apparently there are real yeast nucleotides in her concoction. Speaking of homeopathy, there’s a real homeopath there called Rudi Verspoor, HD(RHom), DMH, whose presentation is described thusly:
Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is a complex disorder with multiple causes, and each case presents its own unique and distinct challenges. The key is to treat the causes and not just the effects. Treating symptoms may provide some improvement but does not provide a permanent solution. Heilkunst, which includes homeopathy, is a comprehensive approach to addressing the multiple deeper underlying causes of a case in a given sequence over time, while using energetic, homeopathic medicines. It provides a clear map of the problem and of how to get out of the swamp of autism spectrum disorders that is safe, non-toxic, and effective even in complex seemingly non-responsive cases.
Well, two out of three ain’t bad, I guess. There’s no doubt that homeopathy is safe and nontoxic. After all, it’s water. But effective? Not so much. Come to think of it, I take back what I said about Autism One Canada not being as bad as Autism One Chicago. Advocating homeopathy definitely ups the ante to anything the mothership could come up with. But other forms of woo rule too: For instance, there’s Bryan Jepson, who comes straight from Andrew Wakefield’s Thoughtful House. His talk will be:
Treating Autism: Understanding Biomedical treatment options
Dr. Jepson will describe the multiple organ system involvement of the autism spectrum including the brain, the gut, the immune system and the detoxification/metabolic system. He will discuss the mechanisms for disease in each of these areas and then talk about treatment options that are being used by clinicians in order to try to correct the underlying biochemical abnormalities that are contributing to the behavioral presentations of the disorder.
Whenever you hear anything about “detoxification” and “biomedical” in the same talk, run, don’t walk. You’re almost certainly hearing only the finest anti-vaccine and environmental woo. If the speaker is someone like Dr. Jepson, who is currently working with the Dark Lord of the Anti-vaccine Movement himself, the man who, while on the payroll of a lawyer who sues vaccine companies, produced an incompetently done and fraudulent study that launched a thousand anti-vaccine quacks in the U.K., in the process producing a scare that the MMR causes autism so great that vaccination rates fell to the point where the measles has become pandemic again, you’re certain to hear anti-vaccine nonsense.
Finally, let’s not forget that Dr. Bob Sears will be speaking there, too. Dr. Bob craves respectability and wants his “alternative” vaccination schedule to be taken seriously as a viable alternative, but he can’t marshal one bit of science to support his beliefs. Worse, lately he’s been writing for Age of Autism and that repository of all things anti-vaccine, The Huffington Post. I refer readers to Dr. Snyder’s excellent post Cashing In On Fear: The Danger of Dr. Sears for a more detailed deconstruction of his “alternative” vaccine schedule and why he has gravitated closer to the anti-vaccine movement.
When I first heard of Autism One Canada, I wondered if this was a case of Autism One and Autism Canada simply renting space at the University of Toronto and trying to coopt its good name, much as creationists tried to coopt the name of the Smithsonian by showing The Privileged Planet there. I’d like to hope that it’s the same sort of deal at the University of Toronto, where such events have to be listed as “co-sponsored” by the host institution in order for the event to occur there. I’ve searched the Dalla Lana School of Public Health at the University of Toronto and haven’t been able to find a single mention of this conference. Alternatively, what may have happened is that someone at the University of Toronto confused anti-vaccine pseudoscience for “cutting edge” and somehow was thus fooled into cosponsoring this conference. What it is is half and half.
First the good half. A reader at my other blog has informed me that the Dana Lana School of Public Health has completely disavowed any involvement in the conference other than that one of its junior faculty, Dr. Marianna Ofner, Assistant Professor of Epidemiology, is giving a talk there, entitled The Epidemic of Autism in Canada, which does not sound encouraging, as it sounds as though she may buy into the concept of an “autism epidemic” so beloved by the anti-vaccine movement. Be that as it may, it’s unclear why or how Autism One Canada thought it could get away with listing the Dalla Lana School of Public Health as one if its sponsors.
Now the bad half. A number of people, myself included, upon learning that the SickKids Foundation was listed as having sponsored Autism One Canada, wrote e-mails and letters of complaint and concern. They received in response a canned reply from the Grants Officer at SickKids Foundation, Pam Gilliland:
Dear Mr. [suppressed],
Thank you for your email concerning the conference: Changing the Course of Autism in Canada, organized by Autism Canada Foundation in collaboration with the Dalla Lana School of Public Health University of Toronto and Autism One.
The goal of this conference is to provide a respectful forum for parents, therapists, doctors, researchers and individuals with Autism Spectrum Disorder to share, learn and work collaboratively to expand knowledge of treatment interventions for Autism. There will be a cross section of speakers.
As part of SickKids Foundation’s National Grants Program, support is offered for conferences, workshops or symposia which are relevant to the health of Canada’s children. The purpose of the conference grants program is to support events which are organized by and/or for families with children with health challenges.
The review process is competitive and funding is limited, with a maximum of $5,000 per grant. Each conference grant application is assessed in terms of its relevance to the health of Canadian children up to 18 years of age, as well as for its fit with the conference grants program goals.
The Foundation sees value on information sharing between medical staff, community organizations, and families. It is important for families to have opportunities for open dialogue with health professionals in order to get an understanding of current research and practices.
The Foundation takes a neutral stance on complementary and alternative health care. We actually have a history of funding research on complementary and alternative health care for paediatrics. The use of complementary and alternative health care products and therapies are on the rise across Canada and there is little research on the safety and efficacy of many of these treatments and products for children and youth, as well as the effects of the interactions between natural health products and conventional medicine. For this reason, the Foundation has taken a first step to build research capacity on which to base practice and policy in these areas.
To this end SickKids Foundation funded Autism Canada in the amount of $5,000 to support their conference: Changing the Course of Autism in Canada.
I hope this helps to answer some of your questions.
Best regards,
Pam Gilliland
Grants Officer, National Grants
SickKids Foundation
525 University Avenue, 14th Floor
Toronto, Ontario M5G 2L3
(P) 416.813.6166 x 2354
(F) 416.813.7311
Pamela.Gilliland@sickkidsfoundation.com
http://www.sickkidsfoundation.com/nationalgrants
Depressing. Regular readers of this blog will recognize this e-mail as worthy of the Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo (W5) What bothered me about Ms. Gilliland’s e-mail even more than what she wrote is what Ms. Gilliland left unwritten. Despite several of the letters of complaint mentioning the anti-vaccine slant of Autism One, Ms. Gilliland wrote not a word about vaccines, as if she were assiduously and intentionally ignoring this very important point, namely that by funding Autism One Canada, the SickKids Foundation is lending its name to one of the greatest threats to the health of children: the anti-vaccine movement. If the anti-vaccine movement gets its way, vaccination rates will fall, and children will suffer and die. I realize that the anti-vaccination movement doesn’t see it that way, that its adherents think that vaccines cause autism, but the end result of their efforts will be the suffering and deaths of children nonetheless. Yet, here is a charity dedicated to helping children through scientific research and which funds a large amount of truly good research supporting a group that is part of a movement that is the most serious threat to public health in general and children’s health in particular. I would like to think that Gilliland probably has no clue that this is the case, but her refusal to address the issue implies to me a level of shame, as though she knows what Autism One really stands for.
This is the sort of thing that happens when pseudoscience infiltrates academia.
WHEN SCIENTISTS FAIL TO SEE THE OBVIOUS
The National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC) has a deceptively benign-sounding name. There’s little doubt that this was an intentional choice of its founder, Barbara Loe Fisher, who is profoundly antivaccine, as her blog’s title Vaccine Awakening suggests, as does her defense of Andrew Wakefield, spreads misinformation about the HPV vaccine and brain injury (and it is misinformation), and her promotion of “vaccine choice” (which is very much like the Orwellian term “health freedom” in that it is designed to disguise the true intent behind it. It’s not a coincidence that a well-known “vaccine injury” litigator is on the board of directors of NVIC or that it includes a list of law firms on its website that specialize in “vaccine injury” cases.
The bottom line is that the NVIC is one of the oldest anti-vaccine groups out there, and Barbara Loe Fisher is the grande dame of the anti-vaccine movement, having been at it since the 1980s. A brief perusal of the NVIC website will show that it supports the discredited idea that mercury in vaccines causes autism and the equally discredited notion that vaccines cause autism and all sorts of dire outcomes. Indeed, there’s even a “vaccine memorial” for the “victims” of vaccines.
The NVIC has a conference, too, the 4th International Public Conference on Vaccination in October. Barbara Loe Fisher announces her conference in this YouTube video:
Note the clever P.R. Note how Fisher never once uses the word “against” or “anti-” anything. She paints her antivaccine group NVIC as “pro-education” and “pro-informed consent” and for “defending your right to choose.” She even ends her video by saying, “Stand up for vaccine freedom of choice.” To look at Generation Rescue, note how Jenny McCarthy is always saying she’s not “anti-vaccine” but rather “pro-safe vaccine.” The anti-vaccine crowd knows that it’s far better PR to be seen as being for something rather than just against something. Of course, her spin belies the speaker list:
Andrew Wakefield. Readers of this blog need no introduction to Dr. Wakefield. He’s the guy who started the MMR scare in the U.K. through a combination of bad science, lack of ethics, and falsifying data.
Barbara Loe Fisher. The founder of NVIC. ‘Nuff said.
Joe Mercola, DO. Woo-meister supreme, anti-vaccinationist, spreader of misinformation, and promoter of quackery on his website Mercola.com.
Rick Rollens. One of the strongest believers in the pseudoscience claiming that vaccines cause autism.
Kim Stagliano. Blogs for Age of Autism. Enough said.
Gary Null. Whoa. This guy has it all. He’s a perfect storm of pseudoscience: Anti-vaccine to the core, an HIV/AIDS denialist, and a promoter of all manner of dubious medicine–to put it kindly.
Look who else is speaking, though. That’s right, it’s David Ayoub. Yes, that David Ayoub, whom I like to call David “New World Order” Ayoub. This is a guy who’s so into conspiracy theories that he thinks that vaccines are part of a population control plot by the Illuminati, along with birth control, women’s rights, and all sorts of other nefarious plots by the government, all complete with black helicopters and everything. Really. Just check out this video:
Check it out especially around the 44 minute mark, where Ayoub starts talking about “stealth population control” and genocide. Truly, there is some serious craziness in his talk. I have to wonder if Ayoub will manage to restrain his New World Order/Illuminati/Black Helicopter ramblings for this conference. (No doubt Barbara Loe Fisher told him to check his crazy at the door.) Speaking of Black Helicopters, Ayoub actually does mention them right around the 57 minute mark of the video above.
But, wait, there’s more! Check out these talks:
“Homeopathy: The Impossible Cure”
Amy Lansky, PhD
Executive Board, National Center for Homeopathy
“Pregnancy, Birth & Child Health: Why Chiropractic Works”
Jeanne Ohm, DC
Executive Board, International Chiropractic Pediatric Association
“Vaccines & Inflammation”
Andrew Wakefield, MD
Executive Director, Thoughtful House Center for Children
“Homeopathy & Vaccines: What Our Pets Teach Us”
Richard Pitcairn, DVM, PhD
Founder, Animal Natural Health Center
“Vaccines, Informed Consent & Public Health: A Chiropractic Perspective”
Matthew McCoy, DC,MPH
Associate Professor, Clinical Sciences, LIFE University
Wow! So, there’s not just Andrew Wakefield, the subject of a rather shoddy NBC news report a couple of weeks ago and the man who is more than anyone else responsible for the MMR scare in the U.K., but two talks on homeopathy! What does homeopathy have to do with vaccines, I wonder? Who knows? Yes, I realize that some homeopaths try to liken homeopathy to vaccination as “like cures like,” but that’s a specious analogy. In any case, if you peruse the list further, you’ll see lots of talks on “health freedom” (which I like to call “freedom for quacks”) and how to evade vaccination by using philosophical exemptions. It’s not a coincidence that a well-known “vaccine injury” litigator is on the board of directors of NVIC.
Yet, paradoxically, despite the presence of so many–shall we say?–scientifically dubious speakers, there are a handful of reputable scientists and academics speaking at the NVIC conference For example, there is (or, as we shall see, was) Tom Jefferson, MD, who is a prominent member of the Cochrane Group, being one of the editors of the Cochrane ARI Group, a member of four other review groups and two methods groups, and the coordinator of the Cochrane Vaccines Field. In his capacity with the Cochrane Group, he is also co-author on many of the Cochrane Reviews on influenza and the flu vaccine. So what is Dr. Jefferson doing listed not only as a speaker at the NVIC Conference, but as an award recipient? Indeed, a general e-mail to NVIC attendees forwarded to me by a “mole” states:
The Saturday night special Awards Banquet recognizes the
accomplishments of Andrew Wakefield, who is receiving NVIC’s Humanitarian Award; and presentations of the NVIC Courage in Science Award to Italian epidemiologist Tom Jefferson; the NVIC Visionary Award to holistic health pioneer Joe Mercola; the NVIC Courage in Journalism Award to Mothering magazine founder Peggy O’Mara; and the NVIC Parent Leadership Award to child health advocate Vicky Debold.
As a proponent of science-based medicine, I’d love to be in the same awards ceremony receiving a “Courage in Science” award from the NVIC along with Andrew Wakefield, Joe Mercola, and the editor of Mothering magazine (yes, that Mothering magazine, the same one that promoted Christine Maggiore’s HIV/AIDS denialism and whose contents and discussion boards are filled with the rankest anti-vaccine pseudoscience). (Obviously, that’s sarcasm; what the NVIC considers “courageous” science considers pseudoscience.) So what on earth motivated Dr. Jefferson to accept this invitation? Was he buttered up by the possibility of receiving an award? Was he ignorant about the nature of the NVIC, the nature of which a simple perusal of its website, with its online shrine and memorial to “victims” of vaccination, its Cry for Vaccine Freedom Wall and its approving links to all manner of pseudoscience would have told him in less than a few minutes?
The reasons why Barbara Loe Fisher invited him are obvious, at least to me. Jefferson is well-known as a bit of a gadfly when it comes to the influenza vaccine, having authored a BMJ commentary in 2006 that criticized the evidence for the efficacy of flu vaccines as being of lower quality. This article is widely cited in anti-vaccine circles. Similarly, he authored a systematic review of the literature that concluded that industry influence has an undue effect on the studies that are published about the efficacy of seasonal flu vaccination, which is also widely cited by anti-vaccinationists, including Barbara Loe Fisher herself. Don’t get me wrong; publishing those studies does not make Jefferson in any way “anti-vaccine,” nor is the possibility of one’s work being abused by cranks for their own ends a reason not to publish. However, Jefferson seems quite naive if he thought that he was invited for any reason other than using him to apply a patina of scientific respectability to the rank pseudoscience much of the rest of the NVIC conference promotes.
Fortunately, I have learned from a private source whom I trust that, in response to e-mails to him pointing out the true nature of the NVIC, Dr. Jefferson has pulled out of the conference and will not be speaking there. I wish I could say more to back up my assertion right now. For the moment you’ll just have to take my word for it because Jefferson’s name is still prominently listed on the NVIC website, but I assure you that he will not be speaking there. The reasons he gave mainly emphasized his displeasure at being on the same stage with Wakefield, whose abuse of his research to support anti-vaccine nonsense greatly annoyed Jefferson; and his desire not to be used and manipulated by the NVIC. Good for him! Beter late than never! But that still leaves three others who are scheduled to speak.
These include Peter Doshi, Visiting Researcher, Faculty of Medicine, University of Tokyo and a doctoral candidate at Massachusetts Institute of Technoloy (MIT) in History, Anthropology, and Science, Technology and Society, who is known for skepticism about whether the bird flu would become pandemic and has written commentaries stating as such, one of which revere has roundly criticized. He is also known for claiming that the CDC intentionally inflates the death figures from influenza and that pandemic flu is no worse than seasonal flu. So it’s not surprising that he was invited. Moreover, I know that the same source from whom I learned of Jefferson’s withdrawal from the NVIC conference has also contacted Doshi and been rebuffed with a lame “my speaking there does not imply endorsement” gambit. Doshi will speak at the NVIC conference.
Next up is Diane M. Harper, MD, MPH. She’s an Associate Professor in the Department of Obstetrics/Gynecology and Community & Family Medicine at Dartmouth Medical School in Hanover, New Hampshire; serves in the Women’s and Gender Studies Department of Dartmouth College; and is the Director of the Gynecologic Cancer Prevention Research Group at the Norris Cotton Cancer Center in Lebanon, New Hampshire. She directs the referral colposcopy/high resolution anoscopy clinics at DHMC. Dr. Harper is know for her views on the HPV vaccine (Gardasil in the U.S.). It’s not that she thinks the vaccine is not effective or that it’s unsafe. She doesn’t, although I do think she overstates the risk of Guillan-Barré syndrome from the vaccine. Rather, Dr. Harper questions whether Gardasil should be incorporated into the adolescent vaccination schedule and promoted the way it’s being promoted, given that the regular Pap smears most women in industrialized countries undergo produce similar benefits against cervical cancer:
However, there is also another very important part to the cervical cancer prevention story, Dr. Harper said, and that is regular Pap tests. Even women who are vaccinated need to have regular Pap testing, as otherwise they are still at risk of developing cervical cancer. And women who decide not to have the vaccine can still protect themselves by undergoing Pap testing.
Dr. Harper feels this message has not been made clear to the general public and that it has been overshadowed by what she considers to be aggressive and inappropriate promotion of Gardasil. As a gynecologist dealing with the general population, her advice on the HPV vaccine is that “if you are at all concerned, then don’t have the vaccine — have regular Pap smears and you will be equally protected from cervical cancer.”
In other words, she thinks it’s a potentially useful vaccine for countries where women don’t get regular Pap smears but its benefits are not nearly as impressive in industrialized countries. I actually happen to agree with her (mostly) in that I’m not yet convinced that Gardasil’s benefits are worth the expense or that the risk-benefit ratio of the vaccine is so overwhelmingly in favor of the vaccine as MMR and other common childhood vaccines. However, unfortunately, at times Dr. Harper’s rhetoric has not been quite so measured, particularly when she has blasted Merck and referred to the vaccine as a “great big public health experiment.”
It’s fairly easy to figure out why Dr. Harper was attractive as a speaker for the NVIC Conference. I don’t think she’s anti-vaccine; she’s just skeptical of the HPV vaccine and its overpromotion, skepticism I share to some extent. However, I also don’t think that Dr. Harper has clue one about what the NVIC is and represents or that she is being brought in to bolster the NVIC’s anti-vaccine viewpoint. At least, I hope she doesn’t. Perhaps I will e-mail her a link to this post after it goes live and ask her, pointing out to her that she is being used.
Finally, there’s George Annas, JD, MPH. I don’t know much about him other than that he’s the Chair and Edward R. Utley Professor of the Department of Health Law, Bioethics & Human Rights at Boston University and that he is a highly respected lawyer and bioethicist. Doing a Pubmed search on his name only revealed five articles relevant to vaccines, the most recent of which was published in 2003 and was about bioterrorism and public health. He’s also written numerous books on bioethics, patients’ rights, and human experimentation, three of which have been listed on an anti-vaccine website as being recommended, although almost certainly not because Professor Annas is in any way anti-vaccine. My guess, given the title of his talk (“False Choices & Worst Case Scenarios: How Taking Informed Consent Seriously Can Improve Public Health”), is that the NVIC roped him in by asking him to talk about informed consent and vaccines (or just the issue of informed consent), without revealing the sheer amount of pseudoscience that will be presented in the very same conference. I suspect he will be quite disturbed at the talks he will see before and after him. Or maybe not. The day’s schedule around his talk appears carefully constructed to keep Dr. Harper, Peter Doshi, and Professor Annas carefully insulated from the likes of Wakefield, Ayoub, et al. If Professor Annas just flies in for one day to give his talk, he might not ever even realize the pseudoscience being promoted during the rest of the NVIC conference.
CRANKS AND THE APPEARANCE OF SCIENTIFIC RESPECTABILITY
If there’s one thing that cranks in general, and the antivaccine movement in paritcular, crave, it’s to be taken seriously by the scientific community. Moreover, although such cranks often show a marked hostility to science in that they ignore or attack scientific evidence that contradicts their beliefs (as well as the scientists who generate that data); rely on anecdotal evidence instead of epidemiology or randomized clinical trials; and engage in extreme conspiracy mongering about scientists and physicians who advocate science-based medicine. Yet, on the other hand, they desperately crave the appearance of science. To achieve this appearance, they adopt the conventions of science, including “scientific” studies that are not; crank journals to report the results of these “studies”; and “scientific” conferences like the NVIC Conference. When they can, they especially like to hold their conferences in a way that implies endorsement or support by a real scientific organization or a university, as Autism One has done with its Autism One Canada conference.
They also realize that it’s not enough just to have the same old cranks, like Wakefield, Ayoub, Rollens, et al. speaking at their conferences. They need to co-opt real scientists and real academics, like Drs. Jefferson and Harper and Professor Annas. My guess is that they were all persuaded to speak through appeals to individual rights versus public health (Prof. Annas) or controversies over the HPV and flu vaccines (Drs. Harper and Jefferson), with the invitations phrased in such a manner as to camouflage the true nature of the conference. That’s one thing that the NVIC is very good at. Alternatively, groups such as Autism One hide their real agenda behind terms like “biomedical interventions” and “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM), coming across as just another CAM conference and even getting grants from reputable foundations like the SickKids Foundation and being allowed to hold their conference at a University of Toronto building.
Most physicians, academic or otherwise, or scientists doing research on topics like vaccines are not like me. They’re not like the bloggers here at SBM or even many of the readers in that the vast majority of them do not pay much attention to cranks like those in the anti-vaccine movement. It’s very similar to the situation with evolutionary biologists, the vast majority of whom also don’t pay much attention to attempts by creationists to deny and subvert the theory of evolution or to prevent its teaching in the public schools. They may be aware of the existence of such cranks but all too often consider them inconsequential, wondering how on earth anyone could take them seriously. So it is with the anti-vaccine movement. Morever, with the infiltration of pseudoscience into medical academia (what Dr. R. W. Donnell has termed “quackademic medicine,”) fueled by big money interests like the Bravewell Collaborative, “on the ground” it is becoming increasingly difficult for the average academic to distinguish pseudoscience from science, given the promotion of the latter by so many large academic institutions. Even when they do realize the difference, all too often academics adopt a “shruggie” attitude towards pseudoscience.
So what to do? Certainly, education is key. I highly doubt that either Professor Annas, Drs. Harper or Jefferson, or even Peter Yoshi knew when they accepted that the NVIC is an anti-vaccine organization or that they were invited that they would be used to provide the illusion of scientific or academic legitimacy to the conference. There are many venues in which to discuss legitimate scientific and policy controversies regarding vaccines, but the NVIC conference is certainly not one of them. It is a conference devoted to the manufactroversy that vaccines cause autism and all sorts of other neurological conditions, that vaccines don’t work, and that they do more harm than good, all cleverly couched as appeals to ethics, vaccine safety, and individual freedom. That’s why it is incumbent upon academics such as these, who express viewpoints that are easily co-opted by cranks, to be very careful about whom they endorse or where they speak, lest they taint their legitimate and useful criticisms of current science and public health policy with the stench of crankery. If anything, they should avoid being connected with such organizations because such connections make it easier for their opponents to dismiss them as cranks. Also, at the very least, they should avoid them because of the potential harm to their academic reputations. But, above, all they should avoid contact with such organizations because their presence at such events provides the illusion of legitimacy and actual scientific controversy that cranks crave. That is why I hope that Dr. Harper and Professor Annan–and, yes, even Peter Yoshi–will reconsider their previous acceptance of an offer to speak at the NVIC conference. At the very least, if they still end up speaking there, I hope they will be very careful not to give the NVIC any sound bites that they can use as “proof” that respected academics support the NVIC’s pseudoscience.
I’ll even take the risk that, should any of these academics actually back out of speaking at the NVIC conference, it will be trumpeted as evidence that “they” got to them and wouldn’t let them speak The Truth.

   CAM practitioners react to Andrew Weil’s proposal for a board certification for integrative medicine. It isn’t (all) pretty.
David Gorski 
Link
About a month ago, I discussed a rather disturbing development, namely the initiative by Dr. Andrew Weil to set up something he was going to call the American Board of Integrative Medicine, all for the purpose of creating a system of board certification for physicians practicing “integrative medicine” (IM), or, as I prefer to call them, physicians who like to integrate pseudoscience with their science, quackery with their medicine. Harsh? Yes. Accurate? Also yes. Unfortunately, many medical centers, both academic and community, are hopping on the IM bandwagon while more and more medical schools are “integrating” pseudoscience into their curricula. While one might expect Josephine Briggs of the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) to be cozy with IM, depressingly, even current director of the National Institutes of Health, Francis Collins, seems to have fallen into the trap.
As was admitted by Dr. Weil and his colleagues, this decision to create a board certification in IM was a huge about-face in that Weil had always argued that IM should be infused into all specialties of medicine. What happened, of course, is that once again marketing won out over idealism. Dr. Weil was concerned that there were lots of physicians and practitioners out there claiming to practice “integrative” medicine, many of whom had no qualifications in the field. At this point, the wag in me can’t resist pointing out that, given that IM “integrates” pseudoscience with science and that there really are no standards, scientific or otherwise, to guide IM practitioners (mainly because so much of IM is rank pseudoscience), why would this matter? The answer, again, comes down to branding and turf protection.
All of this is why seeing the reactions to Dr. Weil’s initiative from members of the “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) and IM community is very instructive. Fortunately, John Weeks of the Integrator Blog has come through again, quoting over twenty different people, including physicians, naturopaths, chiropractors, journalists, and other IM practitioners in an article entitled, appropriately enough, Integrator Forum: 20 Voices on Weil/U. Arizona and the American Board of Integrative Medicine. Yours truly is even mentioned (disparagingly, of course).
Uncharacteristically (for me), I’ll cut to the chase and tell you the results before I show you some of the quotes (with, of course, my own translation of what the IM-speak really means). Basically, physicians practicing IM tend to love what Dr. Weil is doing. All other practitioners (chiropractors, naturopaths, etc.) hate it. Of course, that’s not a big surprise given that Weil’s plan would in essence cut out all non-physician IM practitioners from being able to call themselves “integrative physicians” or, at the very least, to relegate them to a lower, non-board-certified rung in the practice hierarchy, which, I suspect, was the point all along. Andrew Weil wants IM to be “respectable,” and to him it will only become so if the riff-raff (i.e., non-physicians) are excluded.
A typical reaction from MDs can be found from doctors like Patrick Massey, MD, PhD, the medical director for complementary and alternative medicine for the Alexian Brothers Hospital Network. (Remind me never to use an Alexian Brothers-affiliated hospital) In any case, Dr. Massey, a graduate of Dr. Weil’s IM residency, is very happy:
Certification is a topic that is long overdue.
Integrative medicine is a complex area of medicine that incorporates many aspects of traditional and nontraditional medicine: formal education is important. Considering how many people are blending medicine on their own, it is important for them to have qualified physicians to make sure they are not doing anything dangerous.
It cannot be done by primary care physicians. They are barely able to keep abreast of the recommendations for diabetes, HTN and CAD. Integrative medicine is not remotely in their sphere of expertise, nor the expertise of PAs and NPs, unless specifically trained in integrative medicine.
Again, one wonders what science-based standards exist to guide IM practitioners. I’ve asked the question before many times: When do you choose acupuncture versus, say, homeopathy? Or will MD IM practitioners finally admit that homeopathy is nothing more than pure quackery with no basis in basic or clinical science but a huge basis in prescientific magical beliefs? Or how do you know what herb you should use? Or when is chiropractic more appropriate than other therapies? They don’t know. There’s no real science behind many of the modalities that fall under the rubric of IM.
One physician, Richard “Buz” Cooper, MD, pointed out something that, quite frankly, hadn’t occurred to me but should have:
This is just one more of example of Weil’s entrepreneurial reach. It will enhance his 1,000 hour costly and profitable training program. He is pursuing it through a rump group, the American Board of PHYSICIAN Specialties [ABPS], which “certifies” a few marginal specialties (e.g., urgent care), rather than through the American Board of MEDICAL Specialties [ABMS], the recognized authority, which certifies legitimate specialties and which apparently has turned down the idea of certifying Weil’s Integrative Medicine. Tainting the emerging discipline of Integrative Medicine with ‘Weil’s Entrepreneurism’ will push it in the wrong direction and be a disservice to generations of patients.
You know, I really should have thought of this one myself when I wrote my first post on this issue. Dr. Cooper makes a devastatingly accurate point about how Dr. Weil has chosen to seek board certification for IM through a less-than-respected board, namely the American Board of Physician Specialties. It’s very obvious that the ABMS wouldn’t be interested in Dr. Weil’s plan; so he looked elsewhere. Weeks, ever the Weil apologist, criticizes Dr. Cooper for “personalizing” his commentary against Dr. Weil. While this is to some extent a legitimate point, it’s also legitimate to point out that Dr. Weil’s residency program in IM would become a whole lot more desirable, both to graduating medical students and, more importantly, to the medical schools and residency programs to which Weil franchises his program, if IM became more respected as a specialty and especially if there were a real board certification in the specialty. (The two, of course, often go together.) Moreover, there’s more to personal interest than just money. Weil is an ideologue who wants to spread his “faith” of IM to as many people as possible. Indeed, Weeks basically admits this in response to Dr. Cooper when he points out, “He is investing in something that may swell the historic importance of his work. Big egos are often associated with good things. Who isn’t seeking to have more rather than less positive impact?” And IM is lucrative, as are Weil’s many, many other business interests related to IM.
Interestingly, and perhaps not surprisingly, those most vociferously opposed to Dr. Weil’s program were all chiropractors. I say “not surprisingly” because of the history of battles between chiropractic and the American Medical Association. For example. chiropractor Lou Sportelli comments:
Look at the Medical board of this proposed group, I care not who they are, but what they know. It will take a lot of convincing to get me to believe that this is nothing more than the old medical model at work in three stages.
     1.  Condemn
     2.  Investigate
     3.  Take over
The AMA was notorious for doing this to any thing that was not allopathic. This is their modus operandi and they had been successful with it until folks got wise.
Dr. Weil and his new idea are not so novel, but are highly suspect. Sounds like a lot of hype and no substance
Chiropractor James Winterstein:
[This is] an interesting move on their part. Down deep, I fear it is more of the same – dominance at all costs – in a circumstance over which they have had little control (the interest by the public in alternative medicine). Now, they form a specialty and take it [over]. I hate to say it, but I think that is a likely probability. We have already seen them work toward usurping our ‘tools.’ I don’t like the sound of this, John.
Chiropractor and homeopath Nancy Gahles:
You KNOW [the MDs] will get the juice because they are the REAL doctors. The ones you can trust. What do they even study to make them ‘integrative’? Homeopathy? NO. Functional medicine…betcha! Little nutraceutical is now the new Big Pharma. Please tell me I am dead off base here, please!
My comment is that this looks like a duck, walks like a duck and acts like a duck: co-opting integrative healthcare, calling it integrative MEDICINE and creating a Board Specialty will identify integrative healthcare with medical doctors and they will own it, be reimbursed for it and thereby drive consumers to use them only as they will get insurance for it.
One notes that Gahles is described as someone who “has been the modern leader in pushing the field of homeopathy into the nation’s health policy dialogue” as the president of the National Center for Homeopathy. I never thought I’d be in partial agreement with a homeopath, but what Gahles says is more or less what I said in my previous post when I pointed out that Weil’s desire to infuse all medical specialties with his woo apparently can’t stand up to the cold, hard reality of how medicine really works. I’ve also pointed out that excluding the real woo, such as homeopathy, from IM is but a tiny first step in trying to make the specialty into something respectable.
Perhaps the most amusing retort from a chiropractor comes from Stephen Marini. Unfortunately, it’s not amusing because it’s a devastating criticism of Andrew Weil and the concept of board certification for IM. It’s unintentionally hilarious because…well, just read for yourself how he describes himself as “a vitalist trained in classical science and conventional medicine” who appreciates “the role of energy/information on an individual’s health and healing processes.” Also note that the link to information on Marini used by Weeks comes from an entry on that repository of all pseudoscience and conspiracy theories Whale.to and that Marini is on the board of directors for the International Chiropractic Pediatric Association (ICPA). With that background, you can truly appreciate Marini’s criticism of Dr. Weil in its proper context:
The concept of a medical specialty in integrative medicine is inherently contradictory. The paradigm of conventional medicine is reductionistic, hierarchical, & mutually exclusive to other paradigms of health and healing. So to ponder the concept of such a medical doctor would require drastic changes on a medical, anthropologic, sociologic, political levels etc…..
What is needed within a complementary system is a new species of health care provider that can appropriately triage a patient with regard to Era 1, Era 2 & Era 3 health care components.
If Era III reminds you of this, you will be forgiven. So what does Marini mean by “Era 3″? Apparently this:
    • Era I Medicine: Allopathic Therapies. Paradigm: CHEMISTRY – STRUCTURE – FUNCTION
    • ERA II Medicine: Holistic/Holoenergetic Therapies. Paradigm: ENERGY – CHEMISTRY – STRUCTURE – FUNCTION
    • ERA III Medicine: Intercessory Therapies. Paradigm: UNIFIED – ENERGY – CHEMISTRY – STRUCTURE – FUNCTION FIELDS
I say this in particular because following another link from the Whale.to entry on Marini leads to a statement that Marini provided to Jochim Shafer, who apparently wrote a book entitled The Trial of the Medical Mafia, in which Marini states bluntly that there ” is no credible scientific evidence to negate the hypothesis that vaccines cause immediate or delayed damage to the immune and nervous systems of children resulting in a rise in auto-immune and neurological disorders including asthma, learning disabilities, hyperactivity, autism, chronic fatigue syndrome, lupus, diabetes, epilepsy, multiple sclerosis, Guillain-Barre Syndrome, and other diseases.” He concludes that the “universal compulsory vaccination of all healthy children should be halted.”
You know, I think I’ll stick with Era 1 medicine, thank you very much, especially if in Era 3 medicine I have to rely in intercessory therapies and am not allowed to vaccinate children against infectious disease. After all, intercessory prayer has been shown more than once not to work, and vaccines have arguably saved more lives than all other science-based medical interventions combined. Say what you will about Andrew Weil (and we at SBM have certainly said a lot), I’ve never perceived him as being anti-vaccine. Marini clearly is.
In the five weeks or so since I wrote the first installment about Dr. Weil’s initiative to develop a board certification for IM, I’ve thought a bit about what the intent might be and what the consequences might come to be. The more I think about this, the more I think that the chiropractors and naturopaths who don’t like the plan are probably perceiving it quite correctly. It is a dagger aimed right at their hearts, and it is MDs who are holding the hilt. Dr. Weil’s denials notwithstanding, led by Dr. Weil, the pro-woo physician contingent is trying to make sure that no non-physician specialty can claim to be “integrative physicians.” It’s a big deal, too. If you don’t believe just how much it matters to non-physician CAM/IM practitioners to be able to claim the title “physician,” read this revealing article by John Weeks himself.
As I said before, this in and of itself might not be that bad a thing in that many of the practitioners being targeted base their practices on nothing more than prescientific vitalism tarted up with science-y-sounding language. Certainly acupuncturists, chiropractors, homeopaths, and, yes, naturopaths do this. Making it harder for them to practice their non-science-based placebo medicine is probably a good thing, as would be increasing the scientific rigor of what passes for “integrative medicine” now.
Unfortunately, I don’t see that happening. What I do see happening is that, like the Thing in John Carpenter’s famous 1982 movie of the same name, Weil will try to kill off the non-physician “integrative” practitioners but after doing so he will take on their appearance, just as the monster in The Thing took on the appearance of the people it killed. (Hey, it’s Halloween; I had to pick a horror movie metaphor.) In doing so, he will then permanently infect the entire body of academic medicine with the virus that is IM. At least, that is his plan. He has, after all, said as much.

“Eliminating cancer” with Traditional Chinese Medicine and other state-sanctioned quackery
State-approved continuing education courses pump a steady stream of fresh pseudoscience into acupuncture and Traditional Chinese Medicine practice. Courses include claims of “eliminating cancer” and “reversing pediatric asthma” as well as anti-vaccination tropes.
Jann Bellamy on October 24, 2019
Link

Via the magic of Legislative Alchemy, state legislatures incorporate pseudoscience into health care practitioner licensing laws, giving chiropractors, naturopathic “doctors”, and acupuncturists free rein to impose their particular paradigms of nonsense on patients. For acupuncturists, that paradigm is control of the body’s putative “energy” (or, “qi”), which allegedly flows via “meridians”, to treat disease by sticking patients with needles at specified (but elusive) “acupuncture points”. Having legalized this magical system of human functioning, the legislatures include a cornucopia of quackery in the practitioner’s toolkit via the authority, for example, to prescribe dietary supplements, Chinese herbs, and homeopathic remedies and to perform gua sha, moxibustion, and cupping.
Acupuncturists are licensed or registered in 47 states and D.C. In some jurisdictions they can also practice what is variously called Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), Oriental Medicine, and East Asian Medicine. Their scope of practice can approach that of a medical doctor. While the methods allowed are different (e.g., surgery vs. cupping), the scope – treating any patient of any age with any disease or condition – is similar.
New Mexico, for example, defines acupuncture as
the surgical use of needles inserted into and removed from the body and the use of other devices, modalities and procedures at specific locations on the body for the prevention, cure or correction of any disease, illness, injury, pain or other condition by controlling and regulating the flow and balance of energy and function to restore and maintain health.
[Emphasis added.]
“Oriental medicine” is the use of
all allied techniques of oriental medicine, both traditional and modern, to diagnose, treat and prescribe for the prevention, cure or correction of disease, illness, injury, pain or other physical or mental condition by controlling and regulating the flow and balance of energy, form and function to restore and maintain health.
[Emphasis added.]
“Doctors of Oriental Medicine” in New Mexico are allowed to call themselves physicians and practice primary care.
Acupuncture regulatory boards add even more pseudoscience (and additional income streams) to the mix via their rules and regulations. The Florida Board of Acupuncture allows acupuncturists to use Kirlian photography as a diagnostic method. The Arkansas Board of Acupuncture permits the use of bleeding.
But wait, there’s more! Perhaps underappreciated in its perniciousness, these regulatory boards (operating under the fiction that they are protecting the public’s health by requiring practitioners to remain up-to-date in their field) approve continuing education courses that pump a steady stream of fresh pseudoscience into the system. Freed from the strictures of actual science, courses can offer their own permutations of pseudoscience for practitioners to foist on their patients. (Unfortunately, “integrative medicine” practitioners do the same thing.) Today, we’ll take a look at some of these courses and see how, once again, the states are serving as handmaidens to the quackery industry.
The National Certification Commission on Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine (NCCAOM), a private agency organized and run by acupuncturists and TCM practitioners, creates and administers exams required in 46 jurisdictions to become licensed. It also approves courses accepted for continuing education credit by many states. Some merely fleece the gullible; others are downright dangerous. (Actual course names [with link] are followed by a brief description of the course.)
Stroke, cancer, and other serious conditions
10,000 needles: The Future of Stroke Rehab Using Nanopuncture: Teaches post-stroke rehab for paralysis, a “highly effective system” that can “produce drastic improvements” in post-stroke patients. Claims acupuncture is “highly effective” for treating post-stroke sequelae.
The TCM Treatment of Post Stroke, Apoplexia & Paraplegia: “Covers the classifications, diagnosis, and treatment plans via TCM; with the most commonly used acupuncture points and herbal formulas.”
Advanced Chinese Medical Oncology: Treating cancer patients with Traditional Chinese Medicine, including learning to make early diagnosis and using “Shen Xiang Wen Tong Therapy to recall the lost immunity and restore the homeostasis, eventually eliminating cancer.”
A Case Study Analysis: Lung Cancer Symptoms to Brain Tumor: A “renowned pulse diagnostician . . . shares how to treat symptoms of lung cancer and a brain tumor . . . what the pulse can reveal and what are the most appropriate herbal formulas to treat the symptoms.” [Link added.]
Acupuncture Technique for Cancer Care: Teaches how to treat nose and throat cancer with acupuncture point prescriptions for each of three types of diagnosis: “A. Heat pathogen invades Lung, B. Liver depression with phlegm congestion, and C. Blood stagnation interrupts the channels.”
Acupuncture for Parkinson’s Disease and Dementia: “Skillful acupuncture approaches to the treatment of Alzheimer’s Disease and Parkinson’s Disease.”
Clinical Orthopedic Strategies: Arthritis and Bi Syndrome: “Designed to give the practicing acupuncturist a working knowledge of various forms of arthritis, including how to make a differential diagnosis using physical exam, laboratory and x-ray.” [For an “explanation” of Bi Syndrome see here.]
A Complete Course of Treating Diabetes Mellitus by Acupuncturists – Part I: “An effective TCM way to treat diabetes mellitus – the ear magnet therapy is introduced. . . Related health conditions such as ear magnet treat food craving, weight lose [sic], insomnia, nausea, etc. are presented.”
Heart Disease Prevention and Treatment: Using Traditional Chinese medicine to recognize, diagnose, and treat the conditions of chest pain, arrhythmias, hyperlipidemia, hypertension, coronary artery disease, and heart failure.
Treating lupus and infections using Tung points and nutrition: Acupuncture point prescriptions and TCM herbal remedies for treating lupus.
Dr. Tan’s Balance Method for Traumas and Sports Injuries: Learn “the five systems of the Balance Method to uncover the magic healing power of acupuncture for all types of traumas and sports injuries.”
Modern and Classical Chinese Medicine Approach to Multiple Sclerosis: “Important treatment protocols effective for MS using some body and scalp acupuncture, moxibustion and herbal medicine.”
Cholesterol, Asthma, Depression, and More! Drugs and Their Herbal Alternatives: Discussed “Western medications for cholesterol, asthma, and depression, their actions, side effects and herbal alternatives.”
Allergies, IBS, and Chronic Infection: Acupuncture, Hara, and Herbs – Part I: Based on “extensive clinical research and time-tested protocols” learn “to easily find effective distal points for internal conditions relating to the Lung and Heart such as the common cold, allergies, nasal issues, palpitations, anxiety, and insomnia.”
Treating HIV and AIDS with Western and Oriental Medicine: Learn to “identify the western and TCM diagnosis for HIV and AIDS and its chief clinical manifestations. Both western and TCM treatments for HIV and AIDS, common side-effects associated with prescription drug treatments, and an herbal alternative treatment.”
Cardiovascular & Respiratory Disorders: Pulse Dx & Herbal Tx: “Using Master Chang’s unique system of pulse diagnosis techniques, derived from years of clinical experience, you can learn to correctly identify and effectively apply his strategic herbal treatments towards the treatment of cardiovascular and respiratory disorders.”
Pregnancy, women’s health, and pediatrics
Complex diseases of pregnancy: Covers “difficult to treat conditions that many experienced practitioners seem to treat effortlessly” including TCM diagnosis and treatment of “abdominal pain, hypermobility, acute and chronic digestive and urinary complaints, and conditions such as pre-eclampsia.”
Pregnancy Complications: Differential Pulse Diagnosis & Herbal Treatment: Using “unique diagnostic methods” of pulse diagnosis, skin temperature, vital signs and the ears in treatment of pregnancy complications, including “appropriate herbal formulas.”
Pregnancy: Maternity Acupuncture Care: Problem Solving Through Clinical Scenarios: Acupuncture treatment for birth preparation, medical induction, miscarriage, stillbirth, and breech presentation.
Why Treat Children: “Major childhood ailments such as asthma. [sic] allergies and chronic infections can be easily and effectively treated with acupuncture, herbal medicine and diet therapy.”
Effective Immune Support from Pediatrics to Geriatrics and Understanding the Vaccine Myths: “Immunizations are widely touted by conventional medicine and mainstream media as being responsible for eradicating and preventing many infectious diseases. This course will cover the following: Discussions and research reviewing the history and current risks and use of vaccinations; debating mass vaccination and the history of vaccine implementation; vaccine adverse reactions and mortality. The seminar presents objective data on the history, questionable efficacy and inconsistent safety of vaccine programs. It goes on to train clinicians in using safe, effective and practical tools for improving the immune health of their patients.” The course was given by Standard Process of North Carolina, a dietary supplement company that sells through licensed healthcare professionals in N.C. This is not the only course teaching anti-vaccination tropes sponsored by a company affiliated with Standard Process.
The Treatment Of Children Using Classic Formulas: Teaches how to integrate “the type of child with the type of illness.” For example, “which type of child with allergic purpura will respond well to Xiao Chai Hu Tang, Ban Xiao Hou Po Tang, Ma Xing Shi Gan Tang or Xiao Jian Zhong Tang”, all of which can be used to treat this illness based on “differentiating the type of child.”
Acupuncture Manipulation and Scalp Needling for Pediatric Autism: “The most important and most difficult technique in all manipulations is Heat-producing Needling and Coldness due to Heaven-penetrating. . . . This unique acupuncture method is widely used in medicinal diseases. Although the operation is difficult, as long as you master the key points and practice more, you can still master it.”
Advanced Pediatrics: Childhood Eczema & Dermatology: Teaches the etiology and pathogenesis of eczema from the Oriental perspective and the “importance of the Spleen, Lungs and Kidney in the progression of eczema.” Looks at “the conventional methods of treatment and the harm they do in the long term”. Covers TCM patterns of differentiation, acupuncture point prescriptions, sho-ni-shin protocol and herbal formulas with modifications for acute and chronic eczema.” [Sho-ni-shin is apparently a panacea for pediatric illnesses.]
Advanced Pediatric & Sho-ni-shin: Behavioral Disorders: Covers “a wide range of children’s behavioral disorders, from hyperactivity, Attention Deficit Disorder and autism as well as anxiety, insomnia and night terrors.” In-depth treatment protocols with acupuncture, Sho-ni-shin techniques and herbal medicine. “On Sunday afternoon I will demonstrate on live children.”
Chinese Medicine Pediatrics and Ear Infections: Covers diagnostics, treatment principles, acupuncture point prescriptions, herbal formulas, moxa techniques, shoni-shin techniques and dietetics recommendations for pediatric ear infections-otitis media. “Learn how to diagnose and treat pediatric ear infections by downloading the course material, taking an online quiz and receiving a certificate of completion.”
Reversing Pediatric Asthma with Chinese Medicine: “Helps practitioners who aren’t sure how to treat pediatric asthma, learn the step-by-step process for using Chinese medicine to address acute asthma symptoms for immediate relief” and “to create and implement long term treatment plans to reverse asthma symptoms altogether.”
Chinese Medicine Pediatrics and Gynecology: “Chinese Medicine pediatric and gynecologic case histories. Learn treatments for life-threatening illnesses to newborn babies, complications after labor and delivery, irregular menstruation, infectious diseases and chronic gynecological and pediatric conditions.”
Advanced Gynecology: Treatment of many common gynecological conditions “as per the Chengdu University of TCM and the extensive clinical experiences of” the instructor. Includes “irregular cycles, dysmenorrhea, amenorrhea, menorrhagia, metrorrhagia, PCOS (polycystic ovaries and syndrome), Leiomyomas (fibroids), Bartholins cysts, dermoid cysts / teratoma’s, endometriosis and adenomyosis, P.I.D. (Pelvic Inflammatory Disease), vulvovaginitis, HPV and granuloma, HSV (genital Herpes), vaginismus, vaginal dryness, vaginal discharges and infections (parasitic, bacterial, viral and fungal), and UTI’s.”
Integrative quackery
(Like integrative medicine, but without the real medicine part.)
First Aid Homeopathy: ‘First Aid Homeopathic Remedies for acute and or emergency situations. . . Includes a chart with easy to understand diagram and useful remedies.”
Introduction to Drainage Homeopathy: “Both Chinese Medicine and Homeopathy rely on the bodies [sic] natural healing ability. . . .The Unda drops are unique homeopathic formulations which are based on strongly stimulating the bodies [sic] ability to free itself from the heaviness of both mental and physical toxins allowing the body to follow the natural course of healing itself.”
Acu-point Injection Part IV: Herbs & Homeopathy: For certification in “acu-point injection”. Class covers “herbal injectable preparations” for “specific maladies” and homeopathy. Includes “hands on practice.”
CranioSacral Therapy for Pediatrics: “How to work with the special issues that surround the application of CranioSacral Therapy and SomatoEmotional Release as they relate to infants and children.” [Link added.]
Mending the Mind: Using Nutrition, Herbs and Lifestyle to Reawaken the Brain from Dementia: “Learn how to recognize and address the root causes of dementia from a nutritional, herbal and functional medicine approach.” [Link added.]
Functional Medicine: GI, Thyroid & Adrenal Assessment: “Utilizing Functional Medicine to optimize health using patient symptoms as a guide to the underlying cause of specific conditions. Healthcare professionals will learn more about autoimmunity, leaky gut and how to address symptoms and conditions with diet and nutrients, as well as specific testing that should be done.” Course was presented by a dietary supplement company.
Essential Oils for Colds, Flu, Viral & Bacterial Infection: “Discover how essential oils have been used safely and with proven efficacy for herpes virus, shingles, MRSA and other viral and bacterial infections. The antimicrobial action (antibacterial, antifungal, and antiviral) of essential oils is one of their most effective properties.” Course given by Bastyr University.
Adrenal Fatigue: “In terms of TCM, exhaustion of mingmen fire will affect production and distribution of qi and blood, and negatively impact stomach fire and heart yang.” Diagnosis with lab saliva testing, various Oriental medicine approaches to diagnosis and differentiation, therapeutic use of Chinese herbal products and formulas, and Chinese and Japanese acupuncture approaches. [“Adrenal fatigue” is explained here.]
Endocrine Mastery: Optimizing Thyroid, Adrenal and Blood Sugar: “The combined, cumulative and negative effects of chemical toxicity, over medication, radiation exposure, vaccinations, and genetically-modified foods are devastating. Endocrine-related conditions are spreading at an alarming rate, and include diabetes and pre-diabetes (#1), hypothyroid (#2), adrenal fatigue, obesity, cardiovascular disease, infertility, insulin resistance and metabolic syndrome.”
Reversing Thyroid Conditions and Brain Inflammation with Acupuncture and Stem Cells: “Confidently assess clinical and sub- clinical inflammation in patients who present with thyroid and brain conditions [and] . . . learn treatment protocols to address the cause of the inflammation using acupuncture techniques and stem cells.”
Aesthetics and more nonsense
4 Hour Advanced Cosmetic Acupuncture Video: Learn to “treat and significantly improve aging facial conditions” (e.g., wrinkles, skin sagging), general health, and overall well-being using cosmetic acupuncture.
Celestial AcuLift – Cosmetic Acupuncture: For a “deeper insight into how and why cosmetic Acupuncture works.” The “first time old and new, traditional Chinese medicine and 5 element are combined in such a way.”
Bodyintuitive: “The language and philosophical understandings of Chinese medicine are woven together with a Western medical view of the mind and body . . . You’ll become fluent in both languages, moving back and forth between what are known as the rarified energies of the body – Qi, Blood, Yin, Yang and Essence – and the latest 21st century scientific understanding of hormonal, structural and biochemical imbalances . . .”
Acupuncture is a theatrical placebo, effective for nothing. Yet acupuncturists and TCM practitioners, with the states’ blessing, are claiming they can treat serious illnesses. Many of their continuing education courses seem to be little more than marketing opportunities for the dietary supplement companies who sponsor them. As well, practitioners are fabricating even more fantasy therapies, slapping the term “acupuncture” or “TCM” on them, and selling them to the public, again with the states’ blessing. They appear to have little sense of professional responsibility or ethics. Without intervention from the state legislatures, this situation will only worsen.
And the states’ response? Expanding their scope of practice.

Is the ACCME cracking down on quackery in continuing medical education (CME) offerings? Richard Jaffe thinks so.
Richard Jaffe, a lawyer who has made a career out of defending quacks like Dr. Stanislaw Burzynski, thinks that the ACCME, the main accrediting body for continuing medical education (CME) credits, is cracking down on “complementary and alternative medicine” CME courses. That would be a very good thing indeed, but is it really happening? More importantly, would it be enough?
David Gorski on March 20, 2017
Link

As I write this, I’m winging my way home from Seattle, where I just finished imbibing the latest clinical and translational science in surgical oncology (cancer surgery) at the Society of Surgical Oncology (SSO) meeting. (I find that four hour flights are a very convenient time to write posts and do other work, because otherwise the travel time would go to waste.) Given that my practice involves primarily breast cancer surgery, I attended mostly the sessions concentrating on breast cancer surgery and therapy, but, because I like to see what’s going on in other specialties, I also checked out other tracks, such as melanoma, GI surgery, and the like. Basically, physicians attend meetings like the SSO meeting for several reasons: to learn the latest research in their specialties, to meet up with colleagues and friends form across the country (all over the world, actually), and, of course, continuing medical education (CME) credits.
Although the requirements vary from state to state, all states require that physicians obtain a certain number of CME credits every licensure period in order to renew their medical licenses. Also, although again the specific requirements vary by specialty board, in order to retain board certification physicians and surgeons must meet certain specific CME credit requirements. Indeed, a particularly annoying new requirement is that a certain number of these credits be “MOC” credits, where MOC stands for “maintenance of certification,” a particularly contentious topic among physicians. Basically, in surgery at least, an MOC credit means that the CME activity has to have a post-test of some sort that the participant must pass in order to claim the credits. The American Board of Surgery, for example, requires, in addition to the usual CME requirements, 60 of these “higher level” credits every three years, to be documented—you guessed it—every three years. Personally, I find these sorts of credits to be a major pain and not particularly helpful when it comes to actually learning what the CME activity is supposed to be teaching, but that’s just me. However it’s done though, the processes by which CMEs courses are accredited is a big deal in the world of medicine.
The number one defender of quacks perceives a threat
The reason I started out with a little primer on CME credits is because there is a form of CME that I very much don’t like. I bet that you can probably guess what it is. Did you know that doctors can receive CME credits for studying pseudoscience and quackery? Regular readers won’t be surprised, as we’ve touched on this problem before (and, rest assured, I will discuss it again momentarily). After all, if we physicians have to imbibe a certain number of CME credits in order to maintain our medical licensure and specialty board certification, we’d like the information that we’re expected to be exposed to and learn to be high quality, science-based information, preferably recent updates in our specialties, so that chasing CMEs isn’t just a chore but a way that actually helps us to practice according to the latest science- and evidence-based standards. It’s the minimum that our patients deserve.
What got me started on this topic over the weekend was a post by someone we’ve met before, a post from the “other side.” The man writing the post is Richard Jaffe. You might remember him as the longtime attorney for a man who has been a frequent topic of this blog, Dr. Stanislaw Burzynski, the Polish expat physician based in Houston who has been administering peptides he calls “antineoplastons” (ANPs) to cancer patients for four decades now, with authorities seemingly unable to stop him. Jaffe might well have ceased to be Burzynski’s attorney last year, thanks to a falling out based (apparently) on Burzynski’s failure to pay his legal bills accrued during his defense against the Texas Medical Board. (Unfortunately, Burzynski got off lightly yet again, even without Jaffe shepherding his defense across the finish line.) Their falling out aside, over more than two decades, Jaffe defended Burzynski from all threats, be they from the FDA or the Texas Medical Board. Indeed, he was the architect of a scheme that allowed Burzynski to set up over 70 dubious clinical trials of ANPs, a strategy he’s been milking for 20 years to continue to administer ANPs without being prosecuted, despite ANPs lacking FDA approval. Even though he and Burzynski appear to have parted ways, though, Jaffe is still very much into defending quackery, as is easily verified by a perusal of his blog. Oh, and he’s pro-“vaccine freedom”—cough, cough, antivaccine—too.
Right now, Jaffe is not pleased, and if he’s not pleased that means I probably should be pleased. He expresses his displeasure in a post entitled “The next big CAM battle is here, and it’s ugly.” Guess what the battle is about?
CME:
CAM or integrative medicine doctors have had their problems with the state medical boards. And CAM organizations have had their run-ins with governmental agencies. However, the groups have always survived in large part because they have had a steady income from membership dues and from their annual conferences, where their members learn the latest and greatest from their thought leaders. But the CAM organizations’ income stream is now in jeopardy, and thus so is their existence, based on what looks to be well-planned, systematic effort to put CAM groups out of business, and stop the dissemination information about CAM therapies.
AND THAT MY FRIENDS IS A VERY BIG DEAL.
I can’t help but wonder if Jaffe really wanted to start his post that way. Think about it. He’s just basically admitted that CAM organizations exist on membership dues and by hawking their conferences as a source of CME. But wait, you say, isn’t that what all professional societies in medicine do? Yes, but that’s usually not all, and the big difference is that legitimate professional societies don’t peddle pseudoscience. CAM (complementary and alternative medicine) organizations do. Being able to offer CME provides a patina of legitimacy, too, because the organizations that offer CMEs have to meet standards laid down by the Accreditation Council for Continuing Medical Education (ACCME). The AMA, which certifies a large proportion of the CME credit programs in the US, requires that the activity meet all the requirements by either the ACCME or a recognized state medical society (SMS).
So what is this horrific threat to CAM or “integrative medicine” (IM) CME? Jaffe is more than happy to tell us:
For months, at least two CAM groups have been under review/ investigation by the primary private CME accrediting company, the ACCME (Accreditation Counsel for Continuing Medical Education). Recently, the ACCME has determined that a significant portion of the groups’ prior year’s CME courses does not meet various ACCME standards. ACCME is demanding that everyone involved in these courses be informed that:
“they were presented invalid information….”
and that the groups:
“instruct them [everyone] to avoid making any clinical decisions for testing and/or treatment based on what was presented, and direct the registrants to accurate and valid sources of information for the problems or systems presented.”
I should point out that this “incorrect” information came from some of the most accomplished, respected and published thought leaders/teachers in the CAM community. These folks have been giving CME courses without incident for decades.
My first thought upon reading this passage was that this is exactly the problem. Physician “thought leaders” in integrating quackery into medicine have been giving CME courses without incident for decades. My second thought was a retort to Mr. Jaffe, “Gee, you say this as though it were a bad thing.” My third thought was to wonder which two CAM organizations have run afoul of the ACCME, and how can we as skeptics get the ACCME to look into other CAM organizations running pseudoscientific conferences? After all, we’ve been complaining about the ACCME accrediting CAM conferences for CME for years, which makes the next passage in Jaffe’s little screed music to my ears, if it is indeed true (remember, this is Jaffe who is relating this story):
Further, in terms of future CME courses at their conferences, ACCME has informed these groups – and this is the key to understand what this is all about – that:
“recommendations involving clinical medicine must be based on evidence that is accepted within the profession of medicine as adequate justification for their indications and contraindications in the care of patients and all patient care recommendations must conform to evidence emanating from guidelines and data that meet generally accepted standards of experimental design, data collection, and analysis.”
In short, ACCME is trying to require these groups to only teach mainstream medicine! This is crazy and a huge deal!
I actually half agree here. Yes, this would be a very big deal indeed if the ACCME is actually starting to enforce some scientific rigor on CME conferences seeking its accreditation. No, it would not be “crazy.” It would be a long-overdue course correction, something the ACCME should have done at least a decade ago, if not much longer. You don’t believe me? Let’s take a look at what sorts of “courses” have received certification by the ACCME. Of course, it’s not just CAM organizations that get these courses certified. It’s some heavy hitters in the world of academic medicine too, an outgrowth of the problem of “quackademic medicine” (the integration of quackery into academic medicine) that has taken root in dozens of medical schools and academic medical centers across North America.
“Quack!” goes the CME course
There are a number of courses and conferences that offer CME credits for learning about “integrative medicine” or CAM. For example, Steve Novella once discussed how physicians can receive CME for acupuncture through Brigham and Women’s Hospital and Harvard Medical School’s course on “structural acupuncture,” as have others. I can’t help but note that the webpage is no longer there, but thankfully the almighty Wayback Machine still has it. Not that it matters that much, because, alas, Harvard is still offering the course. Only this time it’s called the The International Structural Acupuncture Course for Physicians: A Palpation Based Approach. Basically, at one of the most respected academic institutions in the world, you can take a course that spans nine months and requires you to come to Boston five times for live “hands-on” teaching about meridians and the latest quackademic studies trying to show that acupuncture “works.” Somehow, I bet that they’ll forget to mention how it doesn’t matter where you stick the needles or even if you stick the needles in because acupuncture is all an elaborate, theatrical placebo.
You can earn a lot of CME credits, too. The Harvard acupuncture course as currently constituted offers 300.25 (why the quarter?) CME credits, of which “182 hours will focus on the theory and science of acupuncture and 118.25 hours will involve live, clinical experience.” The course is run by Joseph F. Audette, MD, and an acupuncturist, David Euler, L.Ac., who in previous fliers was described as a “graduate of the Tristate Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine in New York” and “a recognized authority in utilizing dry needling techniques for the treatment of pain.” Mr. Euler is described as a “recognized authority on modern Japanese styles of acupuncture and its integration with traditional Chinese styles and Western medical practice.” What amused me is that there is an actual professor of anatomy, Frank Willard, PhD, included in the course faculty, but he is not Harvard faculty. Rather, he is faculty at the College of Osteopathic Medicine, University of New England. Personally, as I did when I discovered that Georgetown University was “integrating” the teaching of acupuncture meridians into its first year anatomy courses, lo, these many years ago, I wonder just what the heck Prof. Willard will say about the anatomy of acupuncture, given that it’s based on a prescientific understanding of the human body. Now there’s a lecture I’d love to sit in on, if only for the yuks.
It’s not just Harvard, and it’s not just acupuncture, either, unfortunately. Harriet Hall has lamented how the American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP) has succumbed to the quackery embedded “integrative medicine” in its CME program. Basically, the AAFP started including various “integrative medicine” modalities in its CME offerings without skepticism or critical thinking.
Then, in my own specialty, there’s the Society for Integrative Oncology (SIO)—which really, really, really does not like me—and its annual conference, which this year will be held in Chicago. The schedule and speakers haven’t been announced yet, given that the conference is in November, and its overarching goals are the usual CAM pabulum, but we can look at past conferences; e.g., when Dr. Francis Collins was the keynote speaker at the 2011 SIO conference. Let’s just say that, in addition to the usual science-based medicine modalities rebranded as somehow “alternative” or “integrative” (e.g., diet, exercise, and lifestyle), there was a whole lot of pseudoscience as well, plus a lot of “spirituality” thrown in, allowing the SIO to be far too generous in its assessment of reiki and other “energy medicine” modalities (or, as I like to call them, faith healing). You can get an idea of the sorts of activities that the SIO allows from “integrative oncology” guidelines for breast cancer that it published two years ago. Let’s just say that the science was…weak.
Of course, the SIO objected mightily when I published a perspective article on integrative oncology two and a half years ago. In particular, it objected to devoting so much verbiage to homeopathy in my article, where I used it as an example of how prior plausibility is so important in clinical trials. (Ironically, I expanded the section on homeopathy based on reviewer comments; the original version had a much shorter section on this, The One Quackery To Rule Them All.) “Oh, no,” Great Minds in SIO protested. “We know homeopathy is pseudoscience. We are evidence-based! We would never, ever recommend the use of homeopathy, and it was a horrible distortion on your part, Dr. Gorski, to imply otherwise.” I shut that down with one observation (well, three). First, SIO allows naturopaths in its organization. Second, homeopathy is an integral part of naturopathy. It’s required in the curriculum of naturopathy schools and is included on the NPLEX, the test used for licensure in states that license naturopaths. So most, although not all, naturopaths use homeopathy. Finally, one of the authors of the SIO’s breast cancer guidelines at the time had a clinical trial of homeopathy registered at ClinicalTrials.gov.
This is the sort of organization that offers CME for CAM conferences.
Mr. Jaffe has a plan
Based on learning that the ACCME might be cracking down on accrediting CME courses and meetings that promote pseudoscience, Mr. Jaffee is afraid:
Beyond these two professional groups, a disease based group has recently been informed that its CME status for future conferences has been rescinded by its CME intermediary. The intermediary denies that it received any pressure or orders from ACCME.
Three CAM groups which have previously received ACCME course certification without any undue problems who in the last few months have had their prior CME course approval rescinded and/or their future CME approval withdrawn or placed in serious doubt.Is this all a coincidence? Not a chance in hell.
My guess is that more of the same has or is going to happen to other CAM groups.
I certainly hope so. After all, I’ve seen examples as egregious as the offering of CME credits for a course offered at that quackiest of quacky “autism biomed” quackfests, Autism One. Oddly enough, I would not favor retroactively rescinding CME credit, which would harm physicians who attended courses in good faith, believing they were offering CME credits. However, I would very much favor the ACCME shutting down CME credits for future CAM and integrative medicine conferences teaching pseudoscience like reiki, acupuncture, homeopathy, and the like.
Jaffe is also curious how this horrible (in his mind) state of affairs came about:
Someone out there has to know something or know someone who knows something about how this came about, and who or what group is behind it. (My guess is that ACCME is the vehicle not the originator.)
I think there is a smoking gun out there, and if we find it, we can probably reverse ACCME’s decision quickly, so my suggestion is that all the CAM groups and interested parties get the word out to search for the smoking gun.
How much does anyone want to bet against my prediction that in a future post he announces that he’s discovered that big pharma or the FDA was behind this move on the ACCME? Yeah, you’re probably wise not to take that bet.
Not surprisingly, Jaffe’s plan is to go straight to state legislators, because state laws generally require ACCME accreditation of CME credits used for state medical licensure:
In all the big CAM states like Texas and California, I know there are legislators who are pro CAM. My suggestion would be to identify who they are (not hard in Texas). I think the boards in a few of these states need to hear from some legislators about how ACCME is undercutting board rules (in Texas) or the CAM statutes (like in California).
These legislators should copy ACCME on their concerns expressed to the boards. If one of them is on a legislative health committee, even better. Better still would be for a couple states to start an investigation on ACCME’s motives. Maybe even an invitation to appear at a specially called hearing. Legislators can hold hearings for all kinds of reasons. So can federal legislators. I think with all the politically connected CAM docs out there, mulitipled [sic] by their politically connected patients, well I think there’s a heap of trouble that could be stirred up for ACCME.
It doesn’t have to happen in every state, or even many states, just a couple of the big ones. The story is going to get out, and questions are going to be raised. The widespread dissemination of ACCME’s action might even turn-up that smoking gun I mentioned earlier. And once the nefarious motive and scope of the conspiracy publicly surfaces, I think ACCME will be forced to rescind its actions. So, we need to shine some light on these jokers.
Actually, it’s the CAM groups who are promoting the teaching of this sort of nonsense who should have some light shined on them.
Still, this is classic Jaffe. It’s the very technique he used to strike back in favor of his client Stanislaw Burzynski against the FDA. He’d use his connections, such as to Rep. Joe Barton, who in the 1990s would regularly haul the FDA Commissioner in front of his committee to demand why the FDA was “persecuting” Burzynski. It worked, too. There are a lot of quackery-friendly (or at least sympathetic) legislators out there, particularly in Texas, where appeals to “health freedom” are powerful enough to fuel a resurgent antivaccine movement. Then, of course, California is home to all manner of quacks.
Jaffe’s plan might just work.
The real problem
I have no idea what two CAM organizations are the ones running into trouble with the ACCME over their CME offerings, and, to be honest, it doesn’t really matter that much. The reason is simple. Jaffe is throwing red meat to his base over a perceived threat that is really not a huge threat at all. Yes, there are CAM groups that hold dubious conferences, and, yes, they are a problem. However, they’re not the biggest problem. They are not existential threats to medicine as a science-based discipline.
The most serious threats to medicine as a science-based discipline do not come from most CAM groups. Rather, they come from within medical academia itself. Do you think that Harvard had any trouble getting the ACCME to accredit its CME offering for its acupuncture course? I highly doubt it did. Similarly, I really doubt that quackademic medicine conferences offered by high profile, respected medical schools and academic medical centers have trouble getting the ACCME to accredit the CMEs for their courses, either. The same thought applies to the AAFP; I’d be surprised if there were any pushback by the ACCME against its inclusion of dubious CAM in its “integrative” offerings. The list of academic medical centers offering dubious CAM courses for CME appears to be growing, as well, with examples like the aforementioned Harvard, the University of Arizona, the University of Florida, The Ohio State University, the University of Michigan, and many more. Add to that the infiltration of CAM into medical school curricula, the infiltration of integrative medicine residencies, and even board certifications, and Jaffe’s getting the quacks riled up over a minor issue.
The real problem is not that the ACCME is targeting two CAM organizations, if it’s really doing anything of the sort. The problem is that it’s not targeting all the universities that offer courses integrating quackery with medicine and that medical academia is embracing CAM in its medical school curricula and residencies, two areas where the ACCME has no authority. The ACME really needs to go much, much farther in enforcing scientific rigor in its CME accreditation process, but, even if it does that, it won’t mean much if the LCME (which accredits medical schools) and the ACGME (which accredits residency programs) don’t do the same.

AAFP CME Program Succumbs to “Integrative Medicine”
Harriet Hall on April 2, 2013
Link
For many years I have been using Continuing Medical Education (CME) programs offered by the American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP). The FP Essentials program consists of a monthly monograph with a post-test that can be submitted electronically for 5 hours of CME credit. Over a 9-year cycle, a complete family medicine curriculum is covered to prepare participants for the re-certification board exams. Some examples of typical subjects are skin cancer, hand and wrist injuries, valvular heart disease, and care of the newborn. I rely on these programs to learn, review, and keep up-to-date in my specialty. Imagine my dismay when I opened the latest package to find a monograph on Integrative Medicine.
First it was called various names like folk medicine, quackery, and unproven/untested treatments, then all of those (the less rational right along with the more rational) were lumped together under the umbrella term “Alternative Medicine,” then it became “Complementary and Alternative Medicine” (CAM), and now it has been re-branded as “Integrative Medicine.” The term is designed to make unscientific treatments seem more acceptable to science-based doctors. “Integrative Medicine” is a marketing term, not a meaningful scientific category. It is a euphemism for combining Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) with mainstream medical practice, unproven with proven, magic with science. It has been critiqued many times on this blog. We have stressed that there is only one medicine, and that when a treatment is proven to work by good evidence, it is just “medicine.” When the evidence for a CAM treatment is not good, it essentially amounts to experimental treatments and/or comfort measures. Worse, sometimes CAM even persists in using treatments that have been proven not to work or that are totally implausible, like therapeutic touch or homeopathy.
Integrative Medicine is a shameless thief: it has tried to appropriate aspects of real medicine and pretend that it invented them. Some of the things integrative medicine claims as uniquely its own are clearly not: exercise, diet, prevention, and a holistic approach to the patient are co-opted from good mainstream medical practice. “Integrative Medicine” doesn’t make sense. As Mark Crislip explained:
If you integrate fantasy with reality, you do not instantiate reality. If you mix cow pie with apple pie, it does not make the cow pie taste better; it makes the apple pie worse.
When Andrew Weil, the “father of integrative medicine,” was chosen to give the keynote speech at the annual AAFP scientific meeting many people complained, and the Institute for Science in Medicine sent a formal letter of protest to the AAFP. They responded that choosing Weil did not imply any endorsement of his work or products, and said that no continuing medical education credits were attached to his presentation.
While FP Essentials does not represent the official policy of the AAFP, it is an important CME program sponsored by the organization, so the AAFP can no longer deny that it offers CME credit for the kind of faulty thinking epitomized by Weil.
No conflicts of interest are disclosed, but 4 of the 5 authors of the AAFP monograph clearly have a personal interest in promoting integrative medicine. One of them, Tieraona Low Dog, is a Director at Weil’s Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine and she even speaks at seminars that hawk Weil’s “Seasonal Supplements.” 
The FP Essentials editor introduces the monograph by saying:
We want to integrate the best and most effective therapies into a patient-centered treatment plan. As part of integrative medicine, CAM therapies are not to be feared, eschewed, or ignored. Rather, they can be integrated successfully into traditional management approaches to fill a treatment gap, reduce adverse effects from traditional remedies, augment traditional therapies, or honor a patient’s wholeness.
I would argue that all those goals can be accomplished within the scope of conventional mainstream medicine, and that if anything in the sphere of CAM were really “the best and most effective therapy,” it would be part of evidence-based medicine and could no longer be designated as CAM.
The stated learning objectives for the monograph are not achieved. Among other things, they include:
    • “Discuss the effect of exercise on mental health.” (Exercise is a mainstream recommendation, not an integrative one.)
    • Describe the rationale for recommending IM therapies in chronic pain management. (Various IM therapies are discussed, but not the rationale for recommending them over other therapies, and certainly not the rationale against recommending them.)
    • Summarize difficulties in conducting and interpreting research focused on IM therapies, for instance finding an appropriate control in acupuncture studies. (That would indeed have been a worthwhile learning objective, but it is not covered at all in the text.)
    • Devise an IM treatment plan to improve health after a breast cancer treatment and to prevent recurrent breast cancer. (They present evidence that the kind of health advice offered by mainstream medicine can improve quality of life in breast cancer patients. There is no evidence that IM can prevent cancer recurrence.)
The 5 key practice recommendations they derive from the monograph are pretty skimpy and do nothing to impress me that “integrative” medicine offers any advantages:
    • Consider adding folate to selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors. (This is already considered in mainstream medicine.)
    • Offer butterbur to patients with migraine. (This is rated as only “Possibly Safe” and “Possibly Effective” by the Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database. And in the text the authors themselves warn that butterbur may contain hepatotoxins and that monitoring liver function would be a good idea.)
    • Consider fish oil to lower triglycerides. (Fish oil is already one of the standard recommendations; there is nothing “integrative” about it.)
    • Ask patients with cancer if they are using integrative medicine therapies. (This is something every doctor should already be asking patients, especially since we know that certain herbal remedies can interfere with chemotherapy or increase the risk of bleeding after surgery.)
    • Consider multiple modalities including massage and acupuncture for cancer patients with pain. (The first is a conventional comfort measure; the second is arguably a placebo. All doctors should suggest comfort measures; it is not ethical to offer placebos.)
The preface tells us that “nontraditional approaches can address pathophysiology in a way that biomedical treatments cannot.” But the text offers no evidence to support that claim.
The monograph is divided into 4 sections, addressing depression, chronic pain, cardiovascular health, and oncology with a focus on breast cancer.
Depression
This section starts with a paragraph on the importance of establishing a therapeutic relationship with the patient. That goes without saying: it’s a basic principle of mainstream medicine. They discuss various therapies as adjuncts to prescription antidepressants or as alternatives to them: St. John’s wort, SAMe, Folate, Vitamin B12, Omega-3 fatty acids, exercise, light therapy, music therapy, and mind-body therapies such as mindfulness. They summarize the available evidence. The evidence for mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (MBCT) consists of one recent randomized controlled trial showing that it may be as effective as cognitive behavioral therapy.
Chronic Pain
For migraine: biofeedback, butterbur, dietary modifications, and acupuncture.
For low back pain: acupuncture, manipulation, mind-body therapies, and massage therapy.
For knee osteoarthritis: glucosamine, chondroitin, acupuncture, SAMe, balneotherapy (bathing in hot mineral water), and herbal supplements.
For fibromyalgia: tai chi, magnesium, spa therapy, mind-body therapies.
For spinal manipulation, they cite two Cochrane reviews showing small benefits not superior to other treatments. For mindfulness, they cite a small study that compared a mindfulness meditation class to being in a wait-list control group. For massage, they cite a study showing that massage was as good as acupuncture, but we know that acupuncture only acts through placebo effects. They cite small trials, mixed results, and generally very poor quality evidence, the kind of thing that is routinely seen when advocates design studies that can be predicted to favor their treatments. They cite evidence from pilot studies, pragmatic studies, and preliminary studies, the kind of evidence that is so often overthrown when more rigorous, larger, better-designed studies are done.
They say:
As the physician’s comfort level and experience increase, the focus becomes how to integrate these approaches into practice.
In other words, “Try it. The more experience you get, the more you’ll like it. Then instead of asking whether it works, you can just assume it works and figure out how to do more of it.” Sorry, but that’s not how the scientific method works. Remember Mark Crislip’s words of wisdom: “In my experience” are the three most dangerous words in medicine.
Cardiovascular Health
For dyslipidemia, they cover fish oil including a prescription fish oil, Lovaza. How could a prescription drug be considered “integrative”?!! They cover niacin, which was a mainstream treatment long before the term “integrative medicine” was coined. For fiber and plant stanols, they cite “cholesterol treatment guidelines” (from mainstream medicine). They cover other therapies like garlic only to say they don’t work.
They cover red yeast rice, saying it effectively lowers cholesterol and is cost-effective. The active ingredient is the same thing that is in prescription Lovastatin in a standardized dosage. They warn that red yeast rice is not standardized and may contain too-high levels of the active ingredient. They apparently don’t realize that by federal mandate the active ingredient has been removed from all red yeast rice products sold in the US. 
For treating high blood pressure, they provide some questionable evidence. Dandelion root is listed because it is a diuretic, but there is no evidence that its diuretic effect leads to lower BP, much less to any reduction in cardiovascular events. For hibiscus, they cite a study whose authors concluded that it could not be recommended, but in the table of “Herbals and Supplements for HTN Management” they list hibiscus nevertheless. They even mention lavender aromatherapy, but only to say it doesn’t decrease BP.
Oncology: Breast Cancer
They say integrative medicine is popular. (So what? So is astrology.) Patients use it “to prevent recurrence, to improve and support their immune system, and to manage immediate adverse effects and long-term sequelae from treatment.” But there’s little evidence that it actually does what they use it for. They suggest that energy medicine modalities can be useful, even though the evidence is poor; they say more studies should be done. They cover studies on therapeutic touch without a shred of skepticism. They provide the traditional explanation for acupuncture without questioning the existence of acupuncture points or qi. For hot flushes they cite a Cochrane review showing that the only nonhormonal treatment that works is relaxation therapy. Then they cite a small, uncontrolled study showing that magnesium worked, so they list it as a recommended treatment.
For preventing recurrence of breast cancer, they admit there is no real evidence. But they recommend healthy lifestyle choices that “might” decrease breast cancer recurrence risk. Here they co-opt all the things non-integrative doctors recommend to their patients: not smoking, physical activity, 5 servings a day of fruits and vegetables.
Homeopathy is conspicuous by its absence from this monograph, yet they uncritically mention therapeutic touch and other forms of energy medicine that are equally improbable. One can only wonder what privileges one form of magic over another in their minds.
They conclude that one barrier to the use of integrative medicine therapies is:
The proven efficacy of integrative medicine is not well established, and many therapies are not covered by health insurance.
“Proven efficacy is not well established”? Awkward. Perhaps that’s their way of saying that they think integrative medicine has been proven to work (by their experience and by inferior quackademic standards), but that the scientific community remains unconvinced. I submit that this is a good argument for not advocating it and not making health insurance pay for it.
Conclusion: Quackademic Medicine Strikes Again
They conclude:
Although many studies lack statistical power, certain integrative medicine modalities show promise for improving patient outcomes when used in conjunction with conventional therapies.
This assertion is based on wishful thinking rather than on evidence. It could even be read as science denial. Lots of things “show promise,” but science requires that they be tested to find out whether it is a false promise. This whole monograph is a travesty. It cites questionable low-quality evidence. It epitomizes the reasons we on SBM have objected to “evidence-based medicine” as commonly implemented and it underscores the need for true science-based medicine. The authors seem to think it’s enough to find any supporting study in the literature: they are willing to accept a study’s findings at face value without rigorously considering prior plausibility, pitfalls and flaws in experimental design, or the fact that most research findings are false (as Ioannidis explained). It amounts to a poorly conceived infomercial, marketing their non-rigorous approach to medicine. This kind of thing has no place in a science-based CME program.

Student Health Professionals and Attitudes about CAM
Scott Gavura on October 24, 2013
Link
While I’m now two full decades out of pharmacy school, I am occasionally invited to return to give a lecture or facilitate a workshop. Pharmacy education has changed a lot since the 1990’s. For me, pharmacy was a Bachelor’s degree program you started right out of high school. Today, students must have a few years of university completed before they can apply (some already have one degree), and the more common degree granted is doctorate-level, the Pharm.D. The clinical training has been bulked up and the practical training is much more rigorous. I see all this as positive change, as the practice of pharmacy has changed along with the education standard. The era of the “count, pour, lick and stick” pharmacist is disappearing as these tasks are automated or delegated to others. Today’s pharmacist has the opportunity to deliver care in different ways, including new roles like vaccine provider, and medication review/drug therapy optimizer. Many find positions that allow them to leverage their drug-related expertise to other areas of the healthcare system.
With pharmacists’ knowledge of drug products it should not be a surprise that they are consulted widely for advice by patients as well as other health professionals. Public surveys on trust show pharmacists lead other health professionals on this measure. It should also not be a surprise that pharmacists can be quite influential in shaping drug use, particularly when it comes to advice about complementary and alternative medicine (CAM), especially when it is used with conventional, science-based drug treatments. After all, drug stores are becoming (to my professional embarrassment) purveyors of all forms of CAM, ranging from homeopathic “treatments” through aisles of herbal remedies, vitamins, and other supplements. One pharmacy I used to work at sold copper bracelets, magnets, salt lamps, ear candles, homeopathic “first aid” kits, and detox packages that were purported to “balance” your pH. If there was a plausibility limit to what this pharmacy would sell, I never saw it reached. I gave the best science-based advice I could, but eventually left due to my concerns about what was on the shelves. But my time in that setting showed me the opportunity to improve care: the pharmacist is well positioned to advise on the evidence for or against any particular treatment, as well as the describe the potential risks with combining CAM with evidence-based treatment approaches.
Given the continued popular interest in CAM, and its proximity to pharmacy practice, research on roles and professional/ethical responsibilities are of interest to academics and researchers. Regrettably, from what I’ve seen in the literature, those with an academic interest or focus in CAM tend to lean towards being believers, rather than scrutinize the promotion of these products and their incorporation into medical therapeutics. (Pharmacy education really needs its own Edzard Ernst, a fierce critic of CAM, who has discussed CAM and health professional ethics). Almost exclusively the criticism of pharmacy and its role as a purveyor of CAM tends to come from outside the profession, with rare, but notable, exceptions.
Mark Crislip has mused that surveys on CAM seem to be an easy path to getting published, given the thousands that exist. Given my personal and professional interests in CAM and pharmacy practice I couldn’t resist reviewing a new survey of attitudes among student pharmacists. Just published in the Journal of the American Pharmacists Association, and entitled Student pharmacists’ attitudes toward complementary and alternative medicine, the paper is from Marwa Noureldin, a pharmacist and graduate student at Purdue University. The survey included 62 questions and was distributed to first, second, and third-year pharmacy students at 10 schools of pharmacy across the United States. There were 887 complete and usable responses. The average student was 25 years old, white, and female. Among the products categorized as CAM, respondents had personally used vitamins (64%), supplements (48%) and massage (39%) in the past.
The survey was divided into three parts – the first section queried attitudes towards CAM, using Likert scales (1=strongly disagree, 5=strongly agree). Questions were adapted from the CAM Health Belief Questionnaire and were modeled after the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) categorization of CAM:
     1.  Biologically-based therapies (e.g., supplements, vitamins, etc.)
     2.  Manipulative and body-based therapies (e.g., massage, chiropractic & acupuncture)
     3.  “Mind-Body” interventions (hypnosis, biofeedback, prayer)
     4.  “Energy” therapies (e.g., reiki, qi gong)
     5.  Alternative medicine systems (e.g., homeopathy, traditional Chinese medicine, Ayurvedic medicine)
Here’s the results (click to embiggen):
The CAM Health Belief Questionnaire, while it has been “validated” seems to have been designed by CAM proponents as is evident from the common tropes embedded within the survey. Describing health as a consequence of “balance” that is “self-healing” are subtle references to the ideas of vitalism that are common across many alt-med practices. Notably there is no reference anywhere to the fact that CAM therapies are either not proven effective, or are proven to be ineffective. (Any CAM therapy that is therapeutically effective, is by definition not CAM, and should just be called medicine.). The survey paints CAM as a separate set of therapies that represent an equally valid therapeutic choice, rather than more accurately describing it as a collection of therapies and practices that lack evidence of benefit. The surveys also lumps vitamins in as a category of CAM, when some vitamin use can be appropriate and science-based (e.g., folic acid supplementation in pregnancy). It also include interventions like massage, and massage therapy isn’t necessarily CAM at all, depending on the treatment goals.
The student responses lean toward the positive, with most ranging from neutral to strongly agree. This is perhaps not surprising, given how the questions are worded. The strongest support was for the statement “A patient’s health beliefs should be integrated into the patient care process” with 91% of students agreeing. This question is one that could be answered affirmatively by someone that takes a strongly science-based perspective, so what this implies about CAM is unclear. There was also strong agreement that CAM knowledge is required in the practice of pharmacy – a question I also strongly agree with, though my vision for CAM education would likely be quite different than what CAM proponents would like to see. As I have argued before, specialized CAM training in academia is designed and delivered to distract from the fact that CAM (often branded as “integrative medicine”) attempts to embed a double standard of evidence for products and procedures that don’t meet the standard of care for medicine. It should not be surprising then, that students who had taken previous CAM courses had much more favorable views towards the statements in the survey than students without any formal CAM coursework (55.89 vs 48.87, respectively).
The second part of the survey asked about views on acceptability of using CAM with “conventional medical therapies” (the authors’ words), again using the same Likert scale:
Few students disagreed with any CAM therapy. There was the greatest support for vitamins and minerals (94%, mean 4.29) which could include the science-based use these products. But there was strong support for demonstrably ineffective treatments like acupuncture, with 64% agreeing it was acceptable. Even homeopathy, which any pharmacy student with basic medicinal chemistry skills ought to know is absurd, was supported by over 40% of students. In fairness, these questions could be interpreted in different ways – I agree there are no medical or therapeutic reasons why homeopathy cannot be taken concurrently with actual medicine. However, I’d say the same about qi gong and reiki, yet students gave somewhat less support to concurrent use of those treatments.
Finally, students were asked for the influences on their own philosophy about CAM:
The biggest influence was personal experience (“It worked for me”?), which exceeded coursework, faculty attitudes, family and professional experience. Surprisingly there was no explicit question about the direct influence of the scientific evidence itself. Perhaps disappointingly for bloggers like myself, media (including the internet) was cited as the least popular influence, with 25% indicating it was “not at all influential”.
The discussion section of the paper raises more questions about the overall intent of the survey. Negative opinions about CAM (such as concerns about safety and efficacy) seem to be viewed as problems that can be addressed with more CAM education, rather than crucial issues that call into question the entire endeavor of CAM as a distinct system of treatment. Completely absent from the discussion is any statement about the double standard created by specialized CAM education – the authors draw conclusions that seem to suggest that mixed or negative opinions on CAM are problematic, and that more CAM education is advantageous for pharmacy practice.
The limitations to surveys like this are substantial, which needs to be considered as we study the findings. Given this was a voluntary survey, with a low response rate (23%), it’s quite likely that non-responder bias is a factor. It is plausible that those that are indifferent to CAM, or have critical perspectives, may not have participated in the survey. A second factor was the exclusion of fourth (final) year students from the survey. It’s conceivable that students in their final year might have more critical perspectives on CAM. A third limitation is the use of NCCAM’s categorization of CAM which incorporates science-based therapies alongside rank quackery. The result is a mix of science and pseudoscience, bundled up as “CAM”, which could increase positive perceptions, giving unscientific and disproven treatments the appearance of being deemed acceptable. Finally, the statements and questions were worded in ways that fail to distinguish between what’s appropriate from a science-based perspective, and what’s acceptable from a patient-focused perspective. I would never recommend homeopathy to a patient and would actively advise against its use. However, to an insistent patient, I would assure them that concurrent homeopathy use poses no medical consequences. The survey fails to distinguish between the two scenarios.
Conclusion
This survey on CAM attitudes paints a concerning portrait of American pharmacy students. However, limitations in the survey process may have created biases that could have exaggerated the overall perspective presented. More concerning than the results themselves are the researchers’ interpretation of this data: Critical and negative perspectives on CAM seem to be viewed as problematic, rather than positive examples of good critical thinking.
One lesson from surveys like these is they illustrate the educational goals of CAM proponents. Just like “integrative” medicine that is making its ways into academic hospital settings, CAM education on campus is another tactic that is being used by proponents to shape health professional attitudes and perspectives early in their careers. The objective is obvious: normalize pseudoscience with students, and watch it become embedded into pharmacy practice.
Is this going to change? Unless there is a deliberate and explicit attempt to call out and push back against the degradation of academic and scientific standards created by existing forms of CAM education and “integrative medicine” programs, we should expect to see a growing normalizing of pseudoscience in health professions like pharmacy.
Reference
Noureldin M. Student pharmacists’ attitudes toward complementary and alternative medicine, Journal of the American Pharmacists Association, e205. DOI: 10.1331/JAPhA.2013.12212

Alternative Medicine Is Infiltrating Veterinary Continuing Education
Harriet Hall on September 6, 2016
Link

My friend Carmen Czachor is a science-based veterinarian practicing in Port Angeles, Washington. She has alerted me to a disturbing development that she fears will “put veterinary medicine back in the dark ages.” The Washington State Department of Health is contemplating a rule change in the regulations requiring continuing education for veterinarians. Current requirements are for 30 hours of continuing education every 3 years; the only restriction is that no more than 10 hours can be earned in practice management courses. The Veterinary Board of Governors had observed an increase in the volume of continuing education courses related to CAVM (complementary and alternative veterinary medicine) and they wanted to provide some guidance. They explain:
The board originally proposed a ten hour limit on the number of veterinary CAVM CE hours that can be earned in any three year reporting period. After stakeholder feedback from multiple veterinary practitioners who practice solely in CAVM, the board decided to revisit the proposal. The board now proposes to establish a twenty hour limit on CAVM continuing education and add a ten hour minimum requirement for conventional medicine. The board finds that doing so would not result in a reduction in the quality of care provided and supports the consumer’s choices about what kind of care they seek.
Note: “stakeholder feedback from multiple veterinary practitioners who practice solely in CAVM.” I find this alarming. Veterinarians are licensed to practice veterinary medicine, not CAVM. Alternative medicine is called “alternative” because it is not supported by the kind of evidence that would earn it a place in conventional medicine. What does it mean that veterinarians are “practicing solely in CAVM”? Does that mean they have abandoned the conventional veterinary medicine that they were licensed to practice?
And how on earth did they determine that the proposal “would not result in a reduction in the quality of care provided”? They just made that up because they wanted to believe it and because they believe alternative medicine constitutes quality care.The board’s chairman is biased
The Veterinary Board of Governors is chaired by Suzan Seelye,DVM. That explains a lot. I looked at her website and was appalled. She practices “Quantum Veterinary Healing,” offering “non-toxic wholistic/holistic methods while addressing both body and mind.” She says it allows healing at the DNA level. She is a certified Tui-na practitioner, a graduate of the Chi Institute (a school of traditional Chinese Veterinary Medicine), a certified veterinary acupuncturist, and claims to have studied quantum physics, neurophysiology, molecular biology, therapeutic touch, Qigong, homeopathy, “nutraceutics,” Chinese and Western Herbal medicine, and Feldenkrais.
Her article on quantum physics says we create reality by what we focus on; that’s a complete distortion of what quantum physics actually says. Her website recommends books by unreliable New Age authors like Candace Pert and Lynne McTaggart. It recommends the ridiculous movie What the Bleep, which critics have characterized as “moronic beyond belief” and “not even wrong;” scientists have pointed out that the movie “…distorts science to fit its own agenda, it is full of half-truths and misleading analogies, and some of its so-called scientific claims are downright lies.”
Seelye also recommends a book I had not heard of, Zero Limits: The Secret Hawaiian System for Wealth, Health, Peace, and More. She says:
It is about a psychologist who helped heal an entire ward of mentally ill criminals without ever seeing any of them professionally. He used an unusual healing method from Hawaii called ho’oponopono. It takes self responsibility to whole new heights. The technique, in part, is seeing everything that comes into your life as a part of yourself and cleansing by saying “forgive me”, “I love you”, “thank you”.
Elsewhere on her website are references to “detox,” “animal communicators,” and locally prepared organic herbal blends for horses (which she not only gives to her horses but takes herself). The website provides numerous testimonials but nothing in the way of scientific studies.
Her article on DNA refers to “DNA frequencies” and claims that a Russian scientist has “uncovered the linguistic and psychic capabilities of junk DNA, ushering in a re-evaluation of the human gene in terms of words, wave genetics and grammar of spirituality.” She says “Man can literally reprogram his genetic blueprint through words” and “man originated billions of years ago in waves of consciousness.” Also, “group consciousness can bring about changes that dissolve violence and restore earth to its natural balance.”
I kid you not. I couldn’t make this stuff up. I can’t even repeat it with a straight face. It seems she has exchanged the realm of science and reality for full-blown New Age fantasies. In my opinion, a person who accepts these beliefs and who practices alternative or “quantum veterinary healing” should not be on a Board of Governors that makes rules for conventional veterinarians.
What kind of CAVM education are they talking about?
In my opinion, some kinds of education about CAVM would be useful. Veterinarians could be given factual, unbiased information that they could use to help educate patients who ask about CAVM. They could be told that when chiropractors claim to be fixing “subluxations” in a horse’s spine with manual “adjustments,” the bones are not actually out of place (and if they were, manual pressure wouldn’t be enough to reposition them: it would take a crowbar!). They could be told that homeopathy is bogus and that the evidence for acupuncture is compatible with a theatrical placebo. They could be told that “energy medicine” is based on a myth and has not been shown to work in rigorous controlled trials.
But unfortunately, the rules related to continuing education do not address criteria for the approval of CAVM courses. They would allow uncritical “how to” courses where “true believer” instructors teach students how they, too, can do CAVM. Anything goes.
This problem is not limited to Washington State. In 2012 two Swedish authors wrote a guest post on Science-Based Medicine describing how chiropractic is being taught to veterinarians around the world in courses that “mix science, pseudoscience and fantasy and make no visible effort to show which is which.”
Other problems
Dr. Czachor tells me three of the five veterinarians on the board use quackery in their practices: cold laser and stem cell at one, tui na at another, along with Seelye’s quantum quackery. She plans to file an ethics complaint saying they should recuse themselves from the vote. She also points out that it was the chair who suggested increasing the hours and that under Robert’s Rules of Order the chair should have NO opinion.
Dr. Czachor knows whereof she speaks: she is a former Board of Governors member and chair herself; her term ended in December 2012. She is also a Regional Officer of the Evidence-Based Veterinary Medical Association (EBVMA), representing the Western United States and Mexico. The EBVMA is a prestigious organization whose Past President and current Board Member is Brennen McKenzie, whose name you may recognize from the numerous articles he has written for Science-Based Medicine; he also writes the SkeptVet blog.
What can we do?
This is a horrible proposal. It would allow veterinarians to get 2/3 of their continuing education credits from courses based on fantasy rather than on science. It doesn’t address approval criteria for CAVM courses. It doesn’t even define what it means by conventional medicine.
Dr. Czachor has emailed and messaged everyone she can think of, but she says she feels like she’s tilting at windmills. We can help. A public hearing will be held on September 19th. Comments on the proposed rules can be submitted on the department’s Rules Comment webpage, or directly to the program manager, Loralei Walker, at [email protected] by September 12, 2016.
Time is of the essence.

Acupuncture for Heart Attacks and more State-Sanctioned Pseudoscience
States default to a private organization run by acupuncturists and TCM practitioners to vet continuing education courses, with predictable results.
Jann Bellamy on June 2, 2026
Link

Here’s a word salad for you, from an “advance course” taught through the Chi-Akra Center for Ageless Aging:
Five Element Intergenerational Patterns and GeneAstrology is a vibrational protocol that utilizes Acutonics tuning forks on acupuncture points and the Eight Extraordinary Meridians, to address imbalances in our genetic code and ancestral lineage. This advance course includes an in-depth journey into sound healing, an overview of the qualities, resonance and usage of the Earth, Moon, Sun, 8 planets, the 3 suprapersonal planets, the 4 asteroids, and the Fibonacci tuning forks, integrated with GeneAstrological chart dynamics, Qi, and Chinese medicine. This interactive seminar focuses on transformation, freedom, and the ability to manifest our Ming, our unique destiny in life.
This is quite obviously nonsense. It was also, until recently, a state-approved continuing education course for licensed acupuncture and Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) practitioners, and is still listed on the website of the National Certification Board for Acupuncture and Herbal Medicine. (More about them in a moment).
I bring this up as a reality check in response to the deceptively benign descriptions of acupuncture and TCM served up in three recent hagiographies published by supposedly reputable outlets: the New York Times, National Geographic, and Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. All were ably deconstructed here on SBM by Drs. Steve Novella (also here), David Gorski (also here), and Mark Crislip.
Focused mostly on acupuncture’s putative effectiveness for pain, with a lot of handwaving about a hypothesized basis in real science, they wholly failed to convey the rank pseudoscience and dangerous overreaching that comprises actual practice.
If you want to see how acupuncture and TCM operate in real life, a good place to start is the continuing education courses practitioners are required, by law, to take. After all, what better exemplar of up-to-date practice than courses specifically intended to keep you, well, up to date in your field?
But first, a bit of background: Why are these courses required in the first place?
Legislative Alchemy
Via the magic of Legislative Alchemy, 47 states and D.C. have passed practice acts to define and regulate the practice of acupuncture. Some jurisdictions also specifically include what is variously called Traditional Chinese Medicine (the term we’ll use here), Oriental Medicine, or East Asian Medicine.
While people may envision acupuncture as a procedure (sticking needles into elusive acupuncture points), it is important to remember that it encompasses an entire system of disease classification, diagnosis, and treatment that, in the U.S., according to the National Certification Board for Acupuncture and Herbal Medicine,
incorporates medical traditions from China, Japan, Korea, and other countries.
This system assumes that a “pattern of disharmony” is responsible for human (and animal) ailments, that the practitioner can accurately diagnose this pattern via “palpation, visual inspection, and olfactory-auditory data collection” and, via treatment with acupuncture and other implausible, unproven and potentially dangerous methods like Chinese herbs, gua sha, moxibustion, and even homeopathy, the practitioner can “prompt the patient back to functional harmony”.
In other words, a system unknown to medicine or science.
It is this magical system of human functioning in its entirety that state legislatures have incorporated into law, not just the needle sticks.
State governments have farmed out crucial aspects of practice regulation to a private organization, run by acupuncturists and TCM practitioners, the aforementioned National Certification Board for Acupuncture and Herbal Medicine (NCBAHB) (until recently known as the National Certification Commission on Acupuncture and Oriental Medicine, or NCCAOM).
This organization administers state licensing exams in acupuncture and herbal medicine. It also approves continuing education courses that practitioners must take to renew their state licenses. (The NCBAHB uses the term “Professional Development Activity”, or “PDA”, for continuing education, but we’ll use the latter here.)
Thus, today we will again take a look at continuing education courses for acupuncturists and TCM practitioners as a window into what they’re up to in their practices. (I looked only at course descriptions, not the actual courses, taking them at their word that they accurately describe what is taught.)
Based on my review of dozens of course descriptions, some basic characteristics of acupuncture and TCM practice emerge:
    • True to the NCBAHB’s vision, TCM is presented as a complete, stand-alone diagnostic and treatment system that encompasses all diseases and conditions; therefore, nothing is beyond the reach of its putative benefits. It is not meant to be “integrative” or “complementary”, although lip service is sometimes given to those concepts.
    • Any ailment can be “explained” by the pseudoscientific concepts of TCM, and this “explanation” informs the appropriate TCM treatment plan. (You can see how the Chinese government did this with COVID here.)
    • No evidence, as a scientist would understand the term, is required to support a diagnosis or treatment.
    • Because they are based on pseudoscience, TCM and acupuncture are infinitely malleable. Both new paradigms of TCM (see “GeneAstology”, above) as well as other, totally unrelated, pseudosciences, like homeopathy, are readily absorbed into practice.
    • “Biomedical” diagnosis is easily taught, making acupuncturists and TCM practitioners competent to see the undifferentiated patient, translate the patient’s “biomedical” condition into TCM pseudoscience, and treat accordingly. (“Biomedicine” and “Western medicine” are commonly used in TCM to describe what we would simply call “medicine”, that is, reality-based medicine.)
With that, let’s turn to the continuing education course descriptions, where you’ll see these characteristics play out again and again. Most of them are currently available for credit. Some have expired but are recent enough that a current practitioner could still be incorporating their lessons into practice.
Heart disease, neurological conditions and, well, everything
Exploration and Discovery of Acupuncture for Acute Myocardial Infarction: Offers both the “theoretical basis” and “clinical efficacy” of abdominal acupuncture in treating heart attacks as well as other cardiac conditions.
Experience and Insights into the Application of Traditional Chinese Medicine Acupuncture in Regulating Blood Sugar and Peripheral [Neuropathy]: In a 2-hour online course, “participants will gain a comprehensive understanding of diabetes” and its treatment, learning how to use acupuncture and TCM “ to effectively address diabetes and its associated neuropathic complications”.
Treating Thyroid Conditions with Chinese Medicine: In a mere 2 hours, participants will understand thyroid conditions “from a biomedical perspective”, apply both Chinese and biomedical diagnostics to those conditions, and treat them with acupuncture and herbs.
Treating Alzheimer’s and other Dementias with Chinese Medicine: Again, in a mere 2 hours, students learn both the biomedical and Chinese perspectives on dementias of all kinds, and “discuss Chinese medical diagnostics and therapeutics” because “Chinese medicine can help treat and support patients with dementia.”
Cognition Health: Mold and Microbes. The #1 Cause of Cognitive Decline: Two Doctors of Oriental Medicine discuss “the main cause of cognition issues”, “biotoxin illness”, and teach how to screen patients for “Chronic Inflammatory Responses Syndrome”. Course is sponsored by Standard Process, a dietary supplement company and approved continuing education provider.
Treating Acid Reflux with TCM: “The western diagnosis of acid reflux or GERD needs to be categorized as hot or cold, as the wrong herbal formula will cause a worsening of symptoms.”
Simplified Pulse and Tongue Diagnosis for GI Disorders: Pulse diagnosis “that allows accurate differentiation of . . . patterns leading to . . . acid reflux, nausea, irritable bowel syndrome” and other GI disorders. “The key is understanding the energetic relationships of liver, stomach and spleen.” [You can read Dr. Harriet Hall’s analysis of TCM tongue and pulse diagnosis here, and Dr. Crislip’s take on pulse diagnosis here.]
Acupuncture and Herbs for Migraines, Tremors, and Insomnia: Learn acupuncture, herbs, and “other modalities” for treatment of movement disorders, including dystonia, essential tremors, trigeminal neuralgia, and Bell’s palsy. Promises “quick and effective results”.
Ear Acupuncture for Eczema: Protocol “for treating active reflex points on the ear for eczema.”
Ear Acupuncture for Allergies: Protocol “for treating active reflex points on the ear for allergies.”
Difficult Cases: Eye Health Series: Learn “the direct connections of the eyes to our organs and emotional expression. You will understand how Qigong, herbs, and acupuncture can restore harmony and create better eye health.” Covers the “root causes and treatment” for cataracts, macular degeneration, floaters, and glaucoma.
Difficult Cases: Common Conditions: “[I]ntegrates meridian theory and Five Element principles to create comprehensive healing plans” for “conditions such as” headaches, food allergies, immune disorders, Type 1 diabetes, autoimmune disease, and sleep issues “that often appear unsolvable from a Western medical perspective”.

Treating Bell’s Palsy with Chinese Medicine: Discusses “diagnosing and treating” Bell’s Palsy, for which acupuncture and herbs “can be very useful”.
Guide to Identifying Atopic Eczema on Under Represented [sic] Skin Tones: Teaches participants to diagnose atopic eczema and rashes. Taught by a TCM practitioner who sells herbal teas to treat skin conditions, including those in children.
Alleviating Genital Lichen Sclerosis with Chinese Herbs, Supplements and Topical Skin Care: Teaches diagnosis of genital lichen sclerosis using both TCM and biomedical approaches and “personalized herbal treatment plans based on TCM principles”. Taught by “dermatology expert” TCM practitioner.
Gynecology Pearls: Teaches assessment of “key facial features to help you accurately diagnose and treat a range of menstrual conditions: Irregular and painful menses, PCOS, PMS, breast disorders, beng-luo [whatever that is], menopause and more”, including abnormal uterine bleeding, abdominal masses, abnormal vaginal discharge, and breast distention and lumps.
Cancer
TCM Approach to Cancer: Not a course, but a truly alarming “explanation” of TCM cancer diagnosis and treatment posted on the website of an approved continuing education provider.
Tongue Diagnosis in Cancer Care: Teaches “specialty maps and key regions of the tongue” to “clarify the common features diagnostic of cancer and key concerns of cancer care”, as well as “a method for tracking the course of treatment through the keen observation of subtle changes on the tongue.”
TCVM [Traditional Chinese Veterinary Medicine] Cancer Therapy: “Learn what common veterinary cancers can be treated with Chinese medicine alone.”
Treating Ovarian Cancer with Western and Chinese Medicine: Practitioners learn to “identify the western and TCM diagnosis for ovarian cancer” and “herbal alternative treatments”.
Traditional Chinese Medicine: A Quantum View of Breast Cancer: Doctor of Oriental Medicine and Acupuncturist explains the “development and progression of disease . . . based on quantum principles such as Five Element Consciousness, meridians . . . and the interconnectedness apparent in Yin-Yang theories”. Course teaches “breast health and cancer suppression”.
Pediatrics
Chinese Medicine Pediatrics: Normal physiology and childhood development “according to Chinese medicine”. Participants learn “diagnosis for pediatric conditions” and the “Chinese medical patho-physiology unique to children”. Acupuncture, moxa, cupping, tui-nua, electrostimulation, and herbs for children.
Treating Chronic and Acute Otitis Media: Chinese herbal medicine course, offering “detailed diagnosis and treatments for both acute and chronic otitis media.” Offered, along with other courses on pediatric conditions by a TCM practitioner who owns a mail-order Chinese herb business.
Diagnosing and [sic] Conjunctivitis, Styes and Eye Trauma: Diagnosis and Chinese herbal medicine treatments for adult and pediatric eye conditions.
Treating Pediatric Colds and Fevers: Chinese herbal medicine course teaching “the nature progression and resolution of exterior pathogens” and “master of mixed excessive and deficient patterns concerning these diseases”, the latter apparently a reference to pseudoscientific TCM diagnostic methods.
Treating Childhood Digestive Disorders: Chinese herbal medicine course discussing “patterns, strategies and topical and internal formulas”, along with “common western medical diagnosis”.
Fake diagnoses, fake diseases, and fake treatments
Face Reading Mastery: A series of courses teaching how to see “the face as a map of the body’s meridians and organ systems” and how to recognize “imbalances” via changes in “colors and structures of the face”, including how specific conditions and disorders present on the face. Can be used for facial rejuvenation as well as bipolar disorder, among other conditions.
Treatment of Leaky Gut Syndrome: “Chinese herbal treatments within zang-fu organization to effectively navigate through and treat this common but complex syndrome.” Also, how to use “lab testing (stool, saliva, urine, blood) to focus treatment and the use of effective nutritional medicines”. [Here’s an excellent article on why “leaky gut syndrome” is a bogus diagnosis and why testing for it isn’t valid.]
Integrating Functional Medicine with TCM: Adrenal Fatigue: Examines “the causes, its consequences on the endocrine system in Western physiology, diagnosis with lab saliva testing, and various Oriental medicine approaches to diagnosis and differentiation.” Includes “therapeutic use of Chinese herbal products” and “acupuncture approaches”. [“Adrenal fatigue” is a fake condition, “saliva testing” for “adrenal fatigue” is not clinically validated, and “functional medicine” remains unproven.]
Moxibustion Therapy: Mugwort (the substance burned in moxibustion) “is able to pass through all of the channels / meridians and regulate the qi and blood. The acrid flavor governs scattering cold and the bitter flavor governs drying dampness.”
Therapeutic Cupping of the Face: “For cosmetic and therapeutic purposes”. Cutting right to the chase: “This straightforward technique is easy to integrate into your practice and can attract a broader client base.”
Treating Phlegm with Acupuncture and Herbs: “Phlegm emerges when the body’s internal equilibrium is disrupted, forming a stagnant and murky substance that hinders the harmonious circulation of Qi and blood.” Phlegm includes “cholesterol, lipids, kidney stones, etc.”
Treating Stagnation with Acupuncture and Herbs: “The Five Stagnations are Qi, Blood, Fluid, Cold and Food. Is Stagnation the Root of all Disease?” [No.]
Homeopathic Dental Remedies: “Homeopathic treatment can be ideal to prepare patients for surgery, to help them recover from the trauma of surgery, and will be of great assistance to diminish pain and enhance healing.”
Sound Healing for Animals: “[T]eaches you how to use tuning forks, singing bowls, and other sound healing tools to reduce anxiety, relieve pain, and promote emotional balance. You’ll learn how to safely approach animals, read their energetic cues, and offer both in-person and distance healing sessions.”
Chinese Medicine Dreamwork for Chronic Lyme Disease: Because the “Projective Dreamwork methodology of Jeremy Taylor” is “remarkably consistent with Chinese classical sources”, participants learn “how to unravel the medical information that is hidden in patient dreams”, which is “particularly helpful in cases of complex diseases such as Chronic Lyme Disease” and can “deliver important insights into diagnosis and treatment”. [Links added.]
Exercise and Death
As if exercise and death weren’t hard enough already.
Motion Acupuncture Protocols: A “unique” acupuncture protocol, during which the patient performs exercises with needles inserted, combining “channels and meridians theories”, anatomy, and kinematics, among other things.
Finally, even in dying one cannot be assured of freedom from the assaults of TCM. In a course titled Hospice and Palliative Care Acupuncture students are taught “specific acupuncture protocols to help patients and their circle of care move through the grieving process”, “insights into signs and symptoms of active dying as they relate to Oriental medicine and patient examinations, including tongue and pulse diagnosis”.
The scientific community is rightfully outraged at the mangled science and medical hucksterism that permeates the current administration’s approach to the nation’s health. Yet, for decades, a state-sponsored system of outrageous pseudoscience known as Traditional Chinese Medicine has been welcomed into mainstream healthcare in the form of “integrative medicine” and touted in credulous media reports and medical journals. It’s a double standard that defies rational explanation.

   Politics and Law

   The National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM): Your tax dollars hard at work
David Gorski 
Link
What’s an advocate of evidence- and science-based medicine to think about the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, better known by its abbrevation NCCAM? As I’ve pointed out before, I used to be somewhat of a supporter of NCCAM. I really did, back when I was more naïve and idealistic. Indeed, as I mentioned before, when I first read Wally Sampson’s article Why NCCAM should be defunded, I thought it a bit too strident and even rather close-minded. At the time, I thought that the best way to separate the wheat from the chaff was to apply the scientific method to the various “CAM” modalities and let the chips fall where they may.
Two developments over the last several years have led me to sour on NCCAM and move towards an opinion more like Dr. Sampson’s. First, after its doubling from FY 1998-2003, the NIH budget stopped growing. In fact, adjusting for inflation, the NIH budget is now contracting. NCCAM’s yearly budget remains in the range of $121 million a year, for well over $1 billion spent since its inception as the Office of Alternative Medicine in 1993. Its yearly budget contains enough money to fund around 75 to 100 new five year R01 grants, give or take. In tight budgetary times my view is that it is a grossly irresponsible use of taxpayer money not to prioritize funding for projects that have hypotheses behind them that have a reasonable chance of being true. Scarce NIH funds should not be for projects that have as their basis hypotheses that are outlandishly implausible from a scientific standpoint. Second, I’ve seen over the last few years how NCCAM is not only funding research (most of which is of the sort that wouldn’t stand a chance in a study section from other Institutes or Centers)) but it’s funding training programs. Indeed, that was the core complaint against NCCAM: that it facilitates and promotes the infiltration of nonscience- and nonevidence-based treatments falling under the rubric of so-called “complementary and alternative” or “integrative” medicine into academic medicine. However, NCCAM cannot do otherwise, given its mission:
    • Explore complementary and alternative healing practices in the context of rigorous science.
    • Train complementary and alternative medicine researchers.
    • Disseminate authoritative information to the public and professionals.
If, in fact, NCCAM actually did devote itself solely to “rigorous science” with regard to “alternative” healing practices, I would have much less problem with it than I do. However, it broadly interprets the second and third parts of its mission. For example, it views part of its mission as promotion, rather than study: “Supporting integration of proven CAM therapies. Our research helps the public and health professionals understand which CAM therapies have been proven to be safe and effective.” This would be all well and good if NCCAM had as yet actually proven any CAM therapies to be at least effective, but it has not. Worse, it has not even managed to demonstrate any of them to be ineffective, either, thus leading to endless studies of modalities that either do not work or at the very least would have marginal efficacy.
Still, I thought; All questions of promotion of CAM modalities aside, least there’s the science. Surely, under the auspices of the NIH, NCCAM must be funding some high-quality studies into CAM modalities that couldn’t be done any other way. That thought died when NCCAM announced last week the studies that it had funded during FY 2007.
Before I discuss the studies, it’s useful to explain briefly for the benefit of those not familiar with NIH grant mechanisms (in other words, the vast majority of our readers) just exactly what the alphabet-number soup describing the types of NIH grants means:
    • R01. The gold standard of NIH research awards, this mechanism describes investigator-initiated multiyear grants (usually four or five years) to study whatever the investigator wants to study, provided that he or she can convince a study section of the worth of the project and that the project is related to the program interests of one of the NIH Institutes. As such, they generally require a fairly large amount of preliminary data and a well-defined research plan to study a clear and scientifically reasonable and interesting hypothesis.
    • R21. These grants are usually one or two year exploratory rewards designed to investigate more risky hypotheses. As such, they require much less, if any, preliminary data.
    • P01 and P50. P-series awards are known and program project grants and are intended to fund large, multi-investigator projects (P01), often encompassing more than one institution, or research centers (P50).
    • K-awards. These awards are intended to fund the development of junior faculty and are also known as career development awards. The idea is that these awards, which require a mentor to support and guide the applicant, are supposed to be a bridge to independent funding.
    • Small Business Research Awards (R41, R42, R43, R44). These are granted to small businesses to fund the development of (usually) biotech and related projects.
    • T32. T32 and related grants fund training and fellowship programs. For example, my surgical oncology fellowship was funded by a T32 award, and our cancer institute has a T32 to fund medical oncology fellows who want to spend two years in the lab.
These by no means encompass all of the funding mechanisms of the NIH, but they are the most common and ubiquitous across Centers and Institutes. Now, let’s look at the breakdown for NCCAM:
It should also be noted that the NIH funds its grants by the fiscal year. Consequently, a five year grant is, in reality, made up of five one-year awards. The difference is that investigators do not have to compete for the renewal of their grants during the years encompassed by them. Rather, they simply have to submit progress reports, and, if reasonable progress is being made, the NIH will usually rubberstamp the renewal of the grants. These are called “noncompetitive renewals,” appropriately enough. The suffixes (-01, -02, -03, etc.) tell us which year of the grant is represented. At the end of the grant period, for R01 and other mechanism, (but not, for example, R21 grants, which are meant to be followed up by other mechanisms), the investigator can either submit a competitive renewal for a continuation of the grant or let the grant lapse.
We see from the above chart that NCCAM funded two new and nine ongoing P01 grants and 14 new and 47 ongoing R01 grants, but a more illuminating analysis comes when we look at the breakdown of general topics being covered in the P01, R01, R21, and training grants. I’m going to take the liberty of concentrating on studies of herbal remedies or dietary supplements or manipulations (mainly because these are the grants that could easily be funded by one of several other NIH Institutes), other modalities that are considered “alternative” for unclear reasons (such as studies of various light therapies on different diseases), studies of CAM usage (many of which seem designed to promote CAM usage), true “alternative therapies” (homeopathy, chiropractice, etc.), and then funding for training programs. A caveat is that not everyone will agree with which studies I chose for each group, but the relative numbers are such that minor quibbles on a few studies will not change the overall trend. Finally, I’m going to concentrate mainly on the R01, P01, and training mechanisms:
What we can see from this is that by far the largest category of NCCAM grants for research not related to small businesses is a topic that could just as easily be funded by numerous other Institutes or Centers within the NIH: the study of herbal remedies, which, when you come right down to it is nothing more than the study natural products, and studies of dietary manipulations to treat disease and improve health. If you peruse the list, you’ll see numerous studies of chromium supplementation, gingko bilova, saw palmetto, various dietary manipulations, and similar studies. Since when did the study of natural products and diet become “alternative”? There is no good reason why these sorts of proposals need a special “CAM” Center to fund them or why they could not be evaluated by the appropriate study sections in the appropriate disease-specific Institute of the NIH.
Then there are a number of other studies (you may disagree with me about the specific studies chosen) that examine physical treatments that are considered “alternative” for unclear reasons, studies such as near infrared therapy or the effects of blue light on alertness. There’s no reason why such these studies need to be under the rubric of “alternative” or “complementary” medicine, either. These are the same sorts of studies that “conventional” physicians have been doing for decades. Indeed, when it comes to natural products and herbal remedies, I suspect some pharmacologists, dieticians, and medicinal chemists probably look at NCCAM as easy money (or, in this disastrously tight NIH funding environment, at least less torture to get) if they just slap together a project to study the most popular herb du jour. Finally, there are the 28 grants funding either fellowships or large collaborative CAM centers or projects and 13 funding studies that either examine CAM usage or seem custom-made to promote CAM usage, such as this study of the effect of increased coverage of CAM therapies by insurance companies.
That just leaves approximately 61 P01- , R01, or R21-level grants that seem to look at therapies that might truly be called “CAM” (at least by NCCAM’s definition). These are, not surprisingly, weighted towards acupuncture or accupressure (17 grants), mind-body interactions (15, with a huge emphasis on “mindfulness,” a distinctly religious concept), and then assorted miscellaneous CAM therapies that constitute a grab-bag of mostly unrelated modalities. There are also some rather disturbing grants here, a few of which look as though they couldn’t get through an Institutional Review Board (IRB) review. For example, there is actually a grant to fund the study of acupuncture for acute spinal cord injury. I wish I were joking. It even pulls the usual acupuncture trick of including electrical stimulation (which, by the way, is not acupuncture, but rather transcutaneous electric nerve stimulation, a decidedly conventional therapy that has been well-studied to treat chronic pain) as part of it.
Worst of all, there are two grants to study arguably the most scientifically implausible of all CAM modalities, homeopathy. For instance, there is an R21 grant funding a study called Polysomnography in Homeopathic Remedy Effects. Yes, you have it right. Your tax dollars are going to fund at least a study this year on homeopathic remedies (a.k.a. water). But it’s even worse than that. There was actually awarded an R21 grant to study homeopathic dilution and succussion and how they affect the dose-response curve of homepathic remedies. This latter grant actually proposes to study whether succussion (the vigorous shaking done with each homeopathic dilution) that, claim homeopaths, is necessary to “potentize” their remedies affects the dose-response characteristics of homeopathic remedies up to 30C dilution (30 times 100-fold, or a dilution factor of 1 x 10-60). This is a dilution factor many orders of magnitude larger than Avagaddro’s number, which is makes a 30C homeopathic remedy nothing but water. Period. In fact, the investigators are actually going to compare stirring with succussion to see whether succussion, as homepaths claim, improves the dose-response curve. It beggars the imagination that such a project was actually seriously considered and then scored highly by a study section. There can also be found grants studying seriously dubious modalities such as craniosacral therapy, prolotherapy, and even qi gong for treating cocaine addicition. Truly, it’s like studying whether eye of newt or pixie dust is more efficacious in curing cancer!
Here’s another thing to consider: An NIH-funded grant is the pinnacle of external funding mechanisms to universities, largely because the government gives the universities additional “indirect costs” of around 50 cents on the dollar to administer the grants and maintain their infrastructure. In the eyes of universities (and probably the public) it doesn’t matter whether that grant came from NCCAM, the NCI, NHLBI, NIAA, NIDDK, or whatever. Universities will be just as happy if investigators get grants from NCCAM as from any other agency within the NIH. More insidious still are the grants to fund fellowship and training programs. It’s easy enough to laugh at grants being offered to study whether homeopathic succussion does anything other than aerate the solution, but when I see how much NCCAM is laying out for the promotion of non-evidence-based medicine through “education” grants, I find it truly disturbing. There are grants to fund fellowships in CAM at the University of North Carolina Chapel Hill, the Weill Medical College of Cornell University, the University of Virginia, Harvard University, the University of Arizona, Oregon Health and Science University, UCSF, and a naturopathic college (Bastyr University). Most of these centers are not there to look at CAM from a truly scientific or skeptical viewpoint. Most are run by believers, and their NIH-funded existence lends a patina of undeserved scientific credibility to the enterprises, particularly since most of them are housed in academic medical centers.
As two of my co-bloggers Wally Sampson and Kimball Atwood IV have pointed out, NCCAM was created not because of any groundswell of support from the scientific community. Rather, it was CAM-friendly legislators who foisted it upon the NIH and made sure that its budget skyrocketed–at least until the recent flattening and decline of the NIH budget put the brakes on. It doesn’t seem to matter if a bona fide scientist is placed in charge, either. For example, Dr. Stephen Strauss was the Director of NCCAM from 1999 to just last year, and he was a hardcore scientist who promised to “explore CAM healing practices in the context of rigorous science, to educate and train CAM researchers and to disseminate authoritative information about CAM to the public.” Yet that is not what has happened. Recently, it was announced that Dr. Strauss’ replacement would be Josephine Briggs, MD, another accomplished researcher with a strong CV making similar promises. Can she deliver on them?
It’s highly unlikely.
Here’s why. First, she has only minimal control over who is appointed to the two councils charged with advising the Director on matters related to research funding and clinical trials, and, in any case, the Council is mandated to be constituted as follows:
Of the 18 appointed members, 12 shall be selected from among the leading representatives of the health and scientific disciplines (including not less that 2 individuals who are leaders in the fields of public health and the behavioral or social sciences) relevant to the activities of the NCCAM, particularly representatives of the health and scientific disciplines in the area of complementary and alternative medicine. Nine of the members shall be practitioners licensed in one or more of the major systems with which the Center is involved.
In other words, they must be CAM practitioners and “leaders” in the field. It’s unlikely that such a group will support rigorous science that might threaten their livelihood, and indeed they don’t. In fact, its stated mission notwithstanding, NCCAM was never originally intended as a means of rigorously investigating CAM therapies but was rather as a government agency to give these therapies the patina of credibility and respectability that they can’t earn through the science. Dr. Strauss may have tried to do what he said he would do during his tenure, but it clearly just didn’t work. He couldn’t change NCCAM. Moreover, no matter what he did, he couldn’t win either way. On the one hand, he was criticized by scientists and physicians who support science- and evidence-based medicine (like me) for allowing highly dubious studies to be funded, while on the other hand he was castigated for being too scientifically rigorous and not being a CAM practitioner because CAM advocates didn’t like his emphasis on determining whether their therapies worked or not. The same thing appears to be true of Dr. Briggs. Indeed, I found an open letter to Dr. Briggs from a CAM supporter that is most revealing, from which I draw a key excerpt:
Your predecessor, Stephen Straus, MD, also had no experience in complementary and alternative medicine. He told the New York Times during his tenure that he had no plans to experiment. I always thought that an odd waste of human imagination. This is not cancer, or renal failure we’re typically talking about. These are therapies and approaches which many view as particularly valuable for creating health and vitality – often altering the course of disease, or a person’s experience of disease, in doing so. Why spend 7 years as an “investigator” and never personally investigate?
Now, a decade later, the NIH has done it again. Director Zerhouni appointed you, despite the fact that you too have no visible professional experience in the field that you were selected to lead. Of your 125 publications, none appear to touch on the kinds of interventions which will be on your desk at your new job.
The writer of this letter, John Weeks, then tries to give Dr. Briggs some advice, most importantly to “go get yourself some experience of complementary, alternative and integrative practices.” He then goes on a rant against NCCAM for, in essence, not being friendly enough to the CAM practices he supports because it does not spend as much as he would like on “whole systems” and “whole practice” approaches. Even worse, from his perspective, NCCAM actually is out of compliance with the mandate that 50% of NACCAM members be licensed in the specialties studied by NCCAM in that only 25% are so licensed. (Actually, if true, this was the only heartening information I found during my research). Mr. Weeks goes on:
I spoke with a conventional academic medicine colleague and researcher yesterday who is a close NCCAM watcher. He said he was “flabbergasted – not in a positive way” by your appointment. His gut feeling was that “the appointment makes it very clear that the NIH wants to bury NCCAM.” He wondered why you took the job, given your career path. Did you just want to be on the NIH director’s Council? Is it, for you, merely a step in dirty water, a post in Siberia on a career path which you hope will veer back into other zones more prestigious in your view – a plum position in Moscow? – as soon as possible?
My colleague told me he believes that, with all of the momentum in recent years, and the increased interest among employers and consumers, the field of integrative medicine is going to keep growing. The question on the table, he believes, is “whether NCCAM will provide leadership or become irrelevant.”
What this letter encapsulates to me is the attitude of CAM advocates towards NCCAM. They don’t want truly rigorous scientific studies to determine if these therapies work. They want studies that assume that these therapies work and then simply look at utilization and cost-effectiveness. They want funding of fellowships in CAM (taught, of course, by true believers). In brief, they want CAM promotion.
This is why we can only hope that the NIH really is trying to bury NCCAM. There’s nothing that NCCAM does, other than its advocacy for CAM therapies in academic medicine, that couldn’t be done as well or much better by other Institutes and Centers of the NIH appropriate to each question. This is particularly true for the study of herbal remedies and dietary interventions, neither of which are “alternative” except when claims are made that diet or herbs can, for example, cure cancer. Unfortunately, as protected as it is by powerful legislators, the best we can hope for is a career scientist like Dr. Briggs trying to slow NCCAM’s descent into pseudoscience. It can’t last forever, though. Sooner or later a true believer will be appointed Director at NCCAM. It’s virtually inevitable. The only thing keeping that from happening, I’d guess, is that the most prominent CAM practitioners (like Andrew Weil, for instance) make far too much money to be easily willing to take a huge pay cut to work for NCCAM. When that day comes, any pretense of rigorous science taking into account scientific plausibility will fly out the window.

NCCIH has a new director, and she’s a true believer in acupuncture.
Helene Langevin has been named the new director of the National Center for Complemenary and Integrative Health. Given her history of dodgy acupuncture research, my prediction is that the quackery will flow again at NCCIH, the way it did in the 1990s when Tom Harkin zealously protected it from any attempt to impose scientific rigor.
David Gorski on September 3, 2018
Link


[Note: It’s a holiday here in the US. So if large chunks of this post look familiar to some, well, you have your explanation. I’m enjoying a long weekend.]
You might or might not be aware that the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) is currently without a permanent director and has been since last year, when its latest director, Dr. Josephine Briggs, retired. Late last week I learned that Dr. Briggs’ successor had been named, and Dr. Helene Langevin will be the new director of the NCCIH. Regular readers know that we here at SBM don’t much like the NCCIH, formerly known as the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM). The reason is simple. Basically, “integrative medicine” or “integrative health” or whatever you want to call it is nothing more than a strategy for mainstreaming quackery by combining it with science-based medicine. When this happens in academic medical centers, I like to call it quackademic medicine. Of course, the vast majority of the “alternative medicine” that “integrative medicine” purports to integrate with real medicine and that quackademic medicine investigates has either not been proven scientifically to be efficacious and safe, has proven not to be efficacious, or is based on physical principles that violate well-established laws of physics (such as homeopathy or “energy healing”). Indeed, if the term “integrative medicine” were not thus, it would be a completely unnecessary moniker.
To paraphrase Tim Minchin, Richard Dawkins, John Diamond, Dara Ó Briain, and any number of skeptics, there is no such thing as “alternative” medicine because “alternative” medicine that is shown through science to work becomes simply medicine. Thus, newly validated medical treatments have no need to be called “integrative” because medicine will “integrate” them just fine on its own. That’s what medicine does, although admittedly the process is often messier and takes longer than we would like. Integrative medicine, like alternative medicine before it, is a marketing term that is based on a false dichotomy. Only unproven or disproven medicine needs the crutch of being “integrative”, a double standard that asks us to “integrate” unproven treatments as co-equal with science-based medicine even though they have not earned that status. So when I see that a new NCCIH director has been named, my question is: Will this director make NCCIH more or less scientific than it already is. Given that this new director is Dr. Helene Langevin, my prediction is that we’re going to be heading back to the salad days of quackery that NCCAM used to engage in back in the 1990s.
A brief recent history of NCCIH: Dr. Josephine Briggs
To understand why, let’s step back a few years to the director before Helene Langevin was named. I’m referring, of course, to Josephine Briggs. Dr. Briggs was a nephrologist with impeccable scientific credentials, which is probably why CAM advocates like our old friend John Weeks were appalled by her appointment. At the time of her appointment, her history was described thusly in an announcement:
Dr. Briggs received her A.B. cum laude in biology from Harvard-Radcliffe College and her M.D. from Harvard Medical School. She completed her residency training in internal medicine and nephrology at the Mount Sinai School of Medicine, followed by a research fellowship in physiology at Yale School of Medicine. She was a professor of internal medicine and physiology at the University of Michigan from 1993 to 1997. From 1997 to 2006 she was director of the Division of Kidney, Urologic, and Hematologic Diseases in the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases. For the last year and a half she has been senior scientific officer at the Howard Hughes Medical Institute.
Dr. Briggs has published more than 125 research articles and is on the editorial boards of numerous journals. She is an elected member of the American Association of Physicians and a fellow of the American Association for the Advancement of Science. She is also a recipient of the Volhard Prize of the German Nephrological Society. Her research interests include the renin-angiotensin system, diabetic nephropathy and the effect of antioxidants in kidney disease.
As you can see, when she was appointed as director of then-NCCAM, Dr. Briggs was an interesting and odd choice. She had no background in complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) or “integrative medicine” (which is what Mr. Weeks was so unhappy about) and, as far as I can tell, had not used CAM in her practice or done any research into it. I suspect that, at the time, she was intended as a director to impose scientific rigor to NCCAM, although I also wondered how she could have met with the approval of the National Advisory Council for NCCAM, the committee that oversaw it and to whom any NCCAM director had to report. The reason is that the Council by charter has to include as half of its voting members, practitioners “licensed in one or more of the major systems with which the Center is involved”; i.e., they must be acupuncturists, naturopaths, and other practitioners of alternative medicine. Two-thirds must be “selected from among the leading representatives of the health and scientific disciplines (including not less than 2 individuals who are leaders in the fields of public health and the behavioral or social sciences) relevant to the activities of the NCCIH.” In other words, the Council is overwhelmingly made up of true believers. This was by design when Senator Tom Harkin was crafting the legislation that guided the creation of NCCAM, in order to prevent too much scientific rigor. Remember, the original purpose of NCCAM was to prove that quackery worked, not to produce negative studies. Indeed, nine years ago, when that’s pretty much all that NCCAM had produced, Sen. Harkin admonished Dr. Briggs by saying:
One of the purposes of this center was to investigate and validate alternative approaches. Quite frankly, I must say publicly that it has fallen short. It think quite frankly that in this center and in the office previously before it, most of its focus has been on disproving things rather than seeking out and approving.
Note what Harkin said first here. He didn’t say that the purpose of NCCAM was to investigate alternative approaches and determine if they work or not. Rather, he said that the purpose of NCCAM was to investigate and validate alternative approaches.
I had my disagreements with Dr. Briggs over the years. Mainly, these derived from my view that what NCCAM was trying to research consisted of pseudoscience and quackery and that the interventions that it was studying that weren’t pseudoscience and quackery were well within the realm of science-based medicine. It’s what I refer to as the “rebranding” of modalities like diet, exercise, and lifestyle as being somehow “alternative”. Even so, I gave Dr. Briggs some credit because I thought she was in an impossible situation. She was a real scientist trying to impose scientific rigor on an enterprise that was inherently resistant to such an imposition.
You could see her efforts to try to impose scientific in the two five-year strategic plans she produced. For example, the 2011-2015 plan basically proposed doing just that. And that was basically accurate. It didn’t work, which is why I referred to the second strategic plan (2016-2021) as, “Let’s try to do some real science for a change“. On the other hand, that plan made explicit one of the most harmful tactics of quacks to legitimize their quackery under the banner of “integrative medicine,” the co-opting of the opioid crisis as an excuse to claim all nonpharmacological treatments for pain as being “integrative”. The results are threatening great harm to chronic pain patients by misguided governments wanting to force them to undergo quack treatments like acupuncture as a means of getting them off opioids.
Which brings us to Helene Langevin.
Helene Langevin: True quackademic believer
Helene Langevin has been mentioned in the digital pages of this very blog on a number of occasions. Why? Simple. She’s all-in when it comes to “integrative medicine” and totally believes in the theatrical placebo known as acupuncture. Most of her career has been in integrative medicine, and she’s done some howlingly bad studies. First, let’s see what the NCCIH says about her:
Dr. Langevin comes to NIH from the Osher Center for Integrative Medicine, jointly based at Brigham and Women’s Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston. She has served as director of the Osher Center and professor-in-residence of medicine at Harvard Medical School since 2012. She has also served as a visiting professor of neurological sciences at the University of Vermont Larner College of Medicine, Burlington.
As the principal investigator of several NIH-funded studies, Dr. Langevin’s research interests have centered around the role of connective tissue in low back pain and the mechanisms of acupuncture, manual, and movement-based therapies. Her more recent work has focused on the effects of stretching on inflammation resolution mechanisms within connective tissue.
Basically, Langevin’s whole thing is connective tissue. She believes that the stretching of connective tissue is how a number of CAM modalities “work”, such as chiropractic, massage, and, of course, acupuncture. Of course, it’s not entirely unreasonable to think that connective tissue has something to do with massage therapy and even chiropractic. Of course, the problem with chiropractic is not so much the manual manipulation of the spine (with the exception of cervical manipulation, which is potentially dangerous) and muscles, along with connective tissue. It’s that the whole rationale for chiropractic is vitalistic at its core and based on pseudoscience. It’s also that chiropractors claim to be able to do far more than you could reasonably expect manipulation to do, such as treat allergies and all manner of diseases, as well as even prevent diseases like the flu. (No, really. I kid you not.) That’s why I like to say that chiropractors are middling to incompetent physical therapists with delusions of grandeur.
One time when I took note of Dr. Langevin was when she wrote a truly horrendous defense of acupuncture for the Harvard Health Blog, specifically a defense of acupuncture for headache. It basically bought into every trope about acupuncture, including buying into acupuncture as a potential solution to the opioid crisis and characterizing acupuncture as an “ancient practice with a theoretical foundation incompletely understood by modern science”.
For a taste of what she’s about, when we take a look at Dr. Langevin’s website at the Osher Center, we see this:
Imagine a body that is totally coordinated, strong and flexible, healing quickly when injured and able to fight off infections and cancer cells. This would be a body with healthy connective tissue. The goal of the Osher Center Connective Tissue Lab is to learn how to keep connective tissue flexible and free from pain, slow down aging and increase the health of the whole body.
We believe that many of the seemingly unsolvable riddles of medicine (why do some injuries heal while others result in chronic pain? how does the body defend itself against cancer?) are due to the fact that their answers involve connective tissue, which medicine so far has mostly neglected.
One of the limitations of conventional medicine is its fragmentation of the body into separate systems and body parts. Connective tissue is a body-wide network that connects all the systems and parts of the body together, and therefore is important for the integrated functioning the whole body.
I can’t help but think this reminds me of the whole “discovery” of the “interstitium” based on a dubious study that made the news a while back. Let’s just put it this way: Deepak Chopra liked that study, thinking the interstitium validated a whole lot of woo. I get the same vibe from Langevin’s work.
It gets worse than that, though. To see what I mean, take a look at her work on acupuncture by checking out this interview in which she talks about her research:
Notice that Langevin has been studying acupuncture ever since at least the 1990s, when she came up with the idea that somehow the needle interacting with the connective tissue is how acupuncture “works”. Of course, nowhere in her “research” have I been able to see anything resembling a coherent or even suggestive mechanism as to how connective tissue could modulate the “activity” of acupuncture. Also, to her it’s not just the needles, but the twirling of the needles that is so important to do…something. Somehow this minute stretching of the tissue is enough to explain acupuncture’s miraculous “effects.” It’s not quite clear. She also seems unduly impressed by ultrasound findings in patients with chronic low back pain suggesting more thickened tissue, as though chronic inflammation might be going on. Ya think? What could sticking little needles into the body do for this? It doesn’t even make sense.
She also regurgitates her previous work in cadavers and human subjects in which she claims that acupuncture meridians correspond to areas where two muscles come together. And guess what? That’s where connective tissue is and the likelihood of getting deeper into connective tissue is higher. As a surgeon, I laughed out loud when I heard that part. Let’s just put it this way. I can jam a needle as deep into a body as I want pretty much anywhere other than where it hits bone, no need to go into grooves between muscles, and there’s a lot of connective tissue within muscles as well, for instance, around the fascicles. (Seriously, Dr. Langevin, look up epimysium, perimysium, and endomysium.) I can’t help but mention at this point that a lot of acupuncture meridians run pretty close to the courses of major nerves as well. Why isn’t she studying that?
I think it’s worth taking a look at what is perhaps Dr. Langevin’s most famous study in a bit more depth in order to get an idea of just what we as advocates of science-based medicine will be dealing with
Seeking an anatomic basis for acupuncture?
In 2010, Dr. Langevin published a paper entitled “Electrical Impedance of Acupuncture Meridians: The Relevance of Subcutaneous Collagenous Bands” in PLoS One. Acupuncturists like it because it claimed to have found a possible basis for acupuncture, but did it? I think you know the answer. So let’s take a look. I knew right away that there was a serious problem right from the very first sentence of the abstract:
The scientific basis for acupuncture meridians is unknown.
Well, I suppose that’s true enough in a very trivial fashion, you know, the same sort of fashion that the scientific basis for homeopathy is “unknown”.
And then there’s first paragraph of the introduction to the paper:
To this day, the fundamental tenets of acupuncture, the acupuncture point and meridian, remain a mystery. What are they anatomically and how do they function physiologically? Past studies have anatomically linked these Traditional Chinese anatomical structures to neurovascular bundles [1], [2], [3], trigger points [4], [5], [6], and connective tissue fascial planes [7]. Other studies have identified functional correlates including reduced electrical impedance [8], [9], [10] and enhanced migration of nuclear tracers [11], [12], [13], [14], [15], [16]. However, due to multiple study design limitations – including inadequate descriptions of acupuncture point/meridian localization, small sample size, and unexplained statistical analysis – a definitive conclusion regarding the scientific basis of these structures is difficult to establish.
A better way to put it would be that there is no known physiological or anatomic structure that corresponds to acupuncture meridians, which brings up the issue of how it was supposedly possible for practitioners of traditional Chinese medicine to have identified these meridians in the first place. Science can’t tell any difference; they don’t really correspond to any nerves; and there’s no criteria by which a meridian can be distinguished from a non-meridian other than drawings on mannequins. It’s magic. It’s fairy dust. In fact, as I’ve described many times before, meridians are irrelevant to acupuncture. It doesn’t matter if you stick the needles in a meridian or not, which meridian, or even if you stick the needles in. Virtually any old place will do. Given that, one wonders why Dr. Langevin even bothered to try to undertake a study. But undertake it she did, trying to use a combination of ultrasound and impedance measurements. It’s a tour de force of what our very own Harriet Hall once so famously dubbed Tooth Fairy science and Dr. RW termed quackademic medicine using the following rationale:
Given these two reported associations [allegedly between acupuncture meridians and decreased electrical impedance and between decreased impedance and increased intramuscular connective tissue], we hypothesized in a previous study that intermuscular connective tissue was the anatomical basis for the reduced electrical impedance reportedly observed at acupuncture meridians. We tested this hypothesis and found that electrical impedance at Pericardium meridian-associated connective tissue was significantly reduced compared to an adjacent muscle control [22]. The Spleen channel segment, on the other hand, showed no statistical difference. This lack of difference was attributed to unintended placement of Spleen-control needles in an adjacent intermuscular plane.
So, did Dr. Langevin actually find a physiological basis for acupuncture points, or was she measuring how much money the Tooth Fairy leaves behind? Did she find an objective way to demonstrate that there is an anatomic difference between the tissue under meridians and the tissue elsewhere that could produce a plausible biological mechanism by which acupuncture “works”? Or did she simply measure which sorts of teeth bring a larger haul of cash from the Tooth Fairy?
Let Harriet apply the general beat down to Tooth Fairy Science:
You could measure how much money the Tooth Fairy leaves under the pillow, whether she leaves more cash for the first or last tooth, whether the payoff is greater if you leave the tooth in a plastic baggie versus wrapped in Kleenex. You can get all kinds of good data that is reproducible and statistically significant. Yes, you have learned something. But you haven’t learned what you think you’ve learned, because you haven’t bothered to establish whether the Tooth Fairy really exists.
In other words, carefully applied scientific methodology used to study fairy dust produces results that are still fairy dust. Prove the phenomenon exists and that acupuncture works, before you go to all these contortions to try to relate it to subcutaneous connective tissue and changes in impedance.
Let’s see what Langevin and her team did:
To avoid confounding by an adjacent connective tissue plane and to see whether the findings from the Pericardium (PC) channel were generalizable to other body sites, we assessed the electrical impedance of skin and underlying subcutaneous connective tissue at the Large Intestine (upper arm), Liver (thigh), and Bladder meridians (calf). These sites were originally chosen because they represented a good balance of anatomical locations and meridian types (2 Yang and 1 Yin channel), and the meridians were not located close to another meridian or intermuscular tissue plane. Acupuncturists determined the location of meridian sites, and ultrasound images were obtained at each test site to record any potential structural associations with electrical impedance. There were two primary aims for this study: (1) to determine whether the electrical impedances at acupuncture meridians were significantly lower than impedances at adjacent controls, and (2) to assess whether echogenic collagen was significantly associated with electrical impedance obtained at the test sites.
So very science-y.
Basically, Langevin’s team signed up 28 subjects (19 female, 9 male). Exclusion criteria included: age under 18 years old; pregnancy; anticoagulant usage; history of a bleeding disorder; implanted ventricular defibrillator; chronic skin conditions; chronic skin inflammation (eczema or psoriasis, for example), or a collagen disorder. They also excluded obese people with a BMI greater than 30. Meridians were identified by two different acupuncturists and in the case of any disagreements the two came to a consensus. According to the methods section, the acupuncturists had an average of seven years of experience, and each represented a different acupuncture style, one Chinese, one Japanese.
Now here’s where it gets odd. The acupuncturists originally intended to insert the needles into the intermuscular connective tissue but had a hard time getting the needles in there. That’s some pretty deep insertion, which makes me wonder what relevance this even had for acupuncture. Neither did the acupuncturists, either, it would appear, because there’s a most telling passage in the methods:
Furthermore, the intermuscular trajectory mapped out by imaging did not consistently match the trajectory mapped out by the acupuncturists. This was particularly true for the intermuscular plane near the LV meridian where the Sartorius muscle runs obliquely along the leg and across the LV meridian path. For these reasons, we decided to focus on the skin and underlying subcutaneous connective tissue in all our subjects. In other words, impedance measurements were limited to the subcutaneous fat region above muscle.
So basically, our intrepid team of researchers decided to give up on trying to measure impedance in intramuscular collagen bands and stick to the skin and subcutaneous tissue. They even showed in Figure 2 ultrasound images showing muscles with thin bands of connective tissue between them. Of course, any orthopedic surgeon could have told them that they’d have a hell of a time hitting those bands of intramuscular connective tissue. Heck, if they had asked me, I could have told them that they’d have a lot of trouble hitting those bands, even with ultrasound guidance, which, by the way, acupuncturists don’t normally have or use in deciding where to place the needles.
So, having failed at their first objective, our intrepid band of acupuncturists decided to look at impedance measurements in the superficial perimuscular fascia; i.e., the band of connective tissue that surrounds each skeletal muscle, comparing impedance measurements for meridian versus control. Then, they in essence went anomaly hunting. What do I mean by that? Basically, the investigators used all sorts of statistical models looking for associations between differences in impedance and meridians and correlations between differences in impedance and ultrasound-measured tissue density. Of course one thing that must be noted is that it would be completely unremarkable to find correlations between ultrasound-measured echogenicity (the ability to reflect sound) and differences in impedance. After all, if there’s one thing ultrasound is good at, it’s measuring differences in water content, which, along with various other mechanical properties of the tissue, determine differences in echogenicity between tissues. Consequently it would be utterly trivial to find correlations between tissue impedance and echogenicity, and not at all surprising. It would also not be particularly surprising if differences were not found, because there could well be too much variation in tissue impedances to produce a statistically significant results. Either finding would not be “evidence” for acupuncture meridians.
It’s also rather remarkable that the investigators felt the need to use such sophisticated statistical methodology to look for differences in impedance between meridian and non-meridian segments and for correlations between ultrasound-measured echogenicity and differences in impedance. Let’s put it this way: if there were a clear-cut difference in impedance between the meridian and non-meridian segments tested, the investigators wouldn’t need to do all the analyses they did. Doing something as simple as a t-test or one-way ANOVA will usually suffice to show the difference. Even if the statistics were appropriate for the data, again, what we appear to have in Dr. Langevin’s study is an example of the Texas sharpshooter fallacy. Basically, all those mixed model statistical methods were modeling was how fast the Tooth Fairy can complete her rounds of harvesting teeth and leaving goodies under the pillows of little boys and girls.
So what did the authors find? Let’s take a look. First, they claimed to have found a small difference in impedance between the Large Intestine meridian impedance and the control (345±15 Ω versus 355±15 Ω, p=0.021, at 10 kHz; 432±23 Ω versus 449±23 Ω, p=0.017 at 1 kHz). Everything else was negative. Does this mean anything? Who knows? Does it validate the existence of the Large Intestine meridian? No, but nice try. All it says is that there might be a difference in impedance between one area on the upper arm and another area. Worse, the observers aren’t blinded at all. Without blinding, there’s the possibility of subtle bias creeping into the measurements and sampling. Would it have been so hard to have the acupuncturists place the needles and then leave the room, after which the technicians doing the measurements come into the room to do the impedance and ultrasound measurements?
Finally, the investigators undertook a multivariate analysis to see if they could identify any factors that explained the differences in impedance other than meridians. They looked at subcutaneous tissue thickness, dermal zone echogenicity, subcutaneous zone echogenicity, and perimuscular zone echogenicity. The result are the graphs in Figure 4, which are what I call star charts. About the best that all these multiple comparisons could come up with was the earth-shattering observation that percent echogenicity in the subcutaneous zone correlated with differences in impedance. Personally, I’m surprised that more measurements didn’t correlate with changes in impedance.
If there’s one thing about complementary and alternative medicine (CAM), it’s that its adherents do more stretching and twisting to try to contort data into proving that there’s something to fairy dust. This is a perfect example. It’s in essence a fishing expedition to find any differences, no matter how small or irrelevant, between acupuncture meridian points and tissue somewhere nearby. Investigators find one difference and use the sharpshooter fallacy to declare it evidence supporting the existence of acupuncture meridians. One thing I always ask myself when I see a study like this is: Why these three acupuncture meridians? Why not others? No real explanation is given. Or maybe the investigators tried other acupuncture meridians and they didn’t work. That certainly wouldn’t surprise me.
Of late, Dr. Langevin has been looking at connective tissue in cancer. To me, this is about the only area where she is doing research that might be of value for anything other than as a justification and to produce a made up “mechanism” for woo. For instance, this year she published a study suggesting that gentle stretching could decrease the rate of breast cancer xenograft growth in a mouse model, but it’s just one study and one has to wonder if there’s a confounder she’s missing. For one thing, other than for the caliper measurements of the tumors, none of the scientists doing the experiments were blinded to experimental group, and I’m not entirely sure that the treatment of the two groups was adequately matched other than the gentle stretching. Whatever the case, such a finding could be consistent with findings that exercise is associated with improved cancer survival, but it says pretty much nothing about acupuncture.
Is the tide shifting towards more quackery at NCCIH?
Delving back into the history of NCCAM/NCCIH, I note that there have been a few constants. The scientific community never wanted this Center, nor did the scientific leadership of the NIH ever ask for it. It was foisted upon NIH by a woo-loving senator who thought that bee pollen cured his allergies, along with his allies and a bunch of quacks who supported him. As a result, from its very formation, NCCAM/NCCIH has been riven by constant war between those who are true believers and, like Sen. Harkin, want to “validate” quackery, and those who wanted to impose serious scientific rigor. It’s a battle that goes back to before NCCIH was NCCIH or even NCCAM was NCCAM, all the way back to when all that existed was a precursor organization known as the Office of Alternative Medicine (OAM). Indeed, the very first director of OAM, Joseph M. Jacobs (who, by the way, was very open to the concept of alternative medicine) almost immediately ran afoul of Sen. Harkin by insisting on rigorous methodology to study alternative medicine. Ultimately Jacobs resigned under pressure from Harkin and the “Harkinites” on the OAM advisory panel.
Oddly enough, since the late 1990s, the side of science has more or less been at least able to hold its own. Dr. Stephen Strauss was the director of NCCAM from 1999 until 2006, and he fought the same battles. Then Dr. Briggs was director from 2008 until last year, when she retired, and she actually went quite far in eliminating the worst quackery from NCCAM. Gone were studies of homeopathy, and she pledged to fight the antivaccine nonsense promoted by so much CAM. Her two strategic plans tried to lay the groundwork for real science. Of course, as a result, the modalities that the real supporters of NCCAM/NCCIH like, the actual quackery, were deemphasized to the point where most NCCIH studies were of nutrition, exercise, pharmacognosy (natural products pharmacology, but in this case primarily of things like herbs used in traditional Chinese medicine) and other modalities that are within the realm of science-based medicine. Sure, there was mindfulness, which might or might not end up being science-based, and acupuncture never really went away, but a lot of the worst quackery (like energy healing) was relegated to the fringes, if not eliminated. That’s because Drs. Strauss and Briggs, whatever their faults (such as ambition leading them to accept the assignment of running an inherently pseudoscientific and unnecessary Center) had backgrounds as real scientists. Also, aside from their efforts to be more scientific, they failed badly in not stopping NCCIH’s cheerleading for pseudoscience through funding credulous “education” about CAM. Even worse, Dr. Briggs glommed onto the whole propaganda effort by CAM practitioners to claim nonpharmacologic treatments for pain as “CAM” or “integrative” and to include acupuncture and other quackery with that. This campaign is starting to lead to horrible policy.
Helene Langevin, on the other hand, is clearly a true believer in acupuncture and any treatment modality involving with manual manipulation of muscle and tissue. Whatever her background as a real scientist might have been it’s now distant, with her having been steeped in acupuncture woo for at least 25 years if not longer. She is a quackademic in every sense of the word. That’s why I think the balance of power at NCCIH is about to shift back more towards pseudoscience and quackery than it’s been since the late 1990s. Worse, Dr. Langevin will have the largest budget ever at NCCIH to fund that shift.

NCCIH Strategic Plan 2021⁠–⁠2025: Meet the new plan, same as the old plan…?
The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health recently released its latest 5 year strategic plan. It’s basically the same as the last strategic plan, but with one new addition. It’s not really a new addition, but it signals a resurrection of an old trope about “integrating” quackery with science-based medicine.
David Gorski on June 28, 2021
Link

And now for something completely different. (Well, not quite…)
It seems that I’ve been blogging about COVID-19 on this blog almost nonstop without (much) interruption for close to the last 16 months because, well, I have. Starting with what in retrospect seems like an overly optimistic post about the World Health Organizations official declaration on March 11, 2020 that the epidemic of disease due to the then-novel coronavirus had become a pandemic, followed by then-President Trump’s declaration of a national emergency, it seems that my output on this blog has been almost all COVID-19 all the time. True, I’m not the only one, but at least much of the rest of the crew covered other topics more often than I have. Be it conspiracy theories, doctors behaving badly (as they did throughout the pandemic), “wonder drugs” for COVID-19 like hydroxychloroquine or ivermectin, or antivaccine lies about the new COVID-19 vaccines that have led wealthy countries (like the US) to get out from under the worst of the pandemic, COVID-19 has been my niche. I could use a break.
That’s why I thank Scott Gavura for sending me this week’s topic. I’m sure I’ll soon be back to more information, disinformation, science, and pseudoscience regarding COVID-19, as the pandemic isn’t over yet. The report I’m about to discuss, however, allows me to follow up on a favorite topic of ours here at SBM, the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH), which before its “rebranding” a few years ago was formerly known as the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM). I’m referring, of course, to the NCCIH Strategic Plan FY 2021–2025, which, having apparently been published last month (which I should have noticed), must have been a bit late due to the pandemic, given that one would expect a strategic plan set to begin in fiscal year 2021 to be published before that fiscal year started in October 2020. I figure, though, that if NCCIH can be a bit late with its latest five year strategic plan, then I can be several weeks late writing about it.
The illustrious history of NCCIH five year strategic plans
Regular readers of SBM know that we are not a fan of this particular Center in the NIH. The reasons are many and have been documented extensively going back to the very beginning of this blog. (Just use the search function for “NCCAM” or “NCCIH” for copious examples.) As you might recall at the time of the founding of the Office of Alternative Medicine in 1991, a relatively tiny office that would later “evolve” into NCCAM and then NCCIH, physicians and scientists at the NIH were not exactly clamoring for a center to study quackery to see if any of it worked. Rather, it was forced on the NIH by Senator Tom Harkin (D-IA). Longtime readers know how NCCAM really came about. One wonders if Rothenberg Gritz ever came across the late, great Wally Sampson’s classic 2002 article, “Why the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) Should Be Defunded” or the now retired (and dearly missed) Kimball Atwood’s “The Ongoing Problem with the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine“. Even if you buy into the false notion that NCCIH (née NCCAM) has completely reformed itself and doesn’t study or promote quackery any more, a history lesson is important. What really happened matters. I went into the details of the story six years ago, but I think it’s worth it right here to do a brief recap before I delve into the latest strategic plan.
Basically, Sen. Tom Harkin was a believer in a lot of alternative medicine and had claimed that bee pollen had cured his allergies. He learned of bee pollen from two constituents, Berkley Bedell and Frank Wiewel. Bedell believed in colostrum to treat “chronic Lyme disease” and that his prostate cancer had been cured by an alternative treatment called 714-X (which was derived from camphor), while Weiwel was a champion of immunoaugmentative therapy for cancer, which was a mixture of blood sera. Bedell introduced Harkin to Royden Brown, a promoter of High Desert bee pollen capsules. Persuaded by Brown to take 250 bee pollen capsules within five days, he rejoiced that his allergies had seemingly disappeared.
It soon became clear that the OAM was not intended to rigorously study alternative medicine, but rather to provide a seemingly scientific rationale to promote it. The office was initially set up with an acting director and an ad hoc panel of twenty members, many of whom Harkin hand-picked, including advocates of acupuncture, energy medicine, homeopathy, Ayurvedic medicine, and several varieties of alternative cancer treatments. Deepak Chopra and Bernard Siegel were also included. Critics of quackery were consulted and considered for panel membership, but—surprise, surprise!—none not selected. These pro-alt med panel members became known in the OAM as “Harkinites”. Much of the history of the NCCAM, back when it was the OAM in the 1990s and then after it was renamed NCCAM, consisted of battles between directors of the organization, who were trying to be scientifically rigorous, and the Harkinites, who had veto power over much of what the new center could do. In fact, even though Sen. Harkin retired at the end of 2014, his influence lives on in that the National Advisory Council for Complementary and Integrative Health (NACCIH), the committee that oversees NCCIH and to which the NCCIH director answers, includes naturopaths, acupuncturists, and chiropractors, among other quacks on its roster.
Also, I can’t help but point out that in 2009 Sen. Harkin bemoaned what NCCAM had accomplished:
One of the purposes of this center was to investigate and validate alternative approaches. Quite frankly, I must say publicly that it has fallen short. It think quite frankly that in this center and in the office previously before it, most of its focus has been on disproving things rather than seeking out and approving.
That was basically saying the quiet part out loud. As Dr. Peter Lipson put it:
Well, at least he’s honest. He comes right out and bemoans the fact that science hasn’t upheld his quasi-religious medical beliefs. He just doesn’t get it. If you choose to investigate a scientific question, you have to be prepared for “bad news”. You don’t get to decide the outcome before the fact.
Indeed. But Sen. Harkin went beyond that:
It is time to end the discrimination against alternative health care practices.
It is time for America’s health care system to emphasize coordination and continuity of care, patient-centeredness, and prevention.
And it is time to adopt an integrative approach that takes advantage of the very best scientifically based medicines and therapies, whether conventional or alternative.
This has been the mission of NCCIH since Sen. Harkin set up its predecessor 30 years ago. Its mission has never been to determine if “unconventional” and “alternative” treatments work, but rather to assume they do work and look for evidence to support “ending the discrimination” against them.
Meet the new Director, not quite the same as the old Director?
There’s an interesting twist now, too, which is one reason why I was more interested in this strategic plan than the last one. The NCCIH has a (relatively new) director, and this is her first five year strategic plan. Say what you will about Dr. Josephine Briggs, who retired in 2018, she was a real scientist, so much so that I not infrequently wondered how she had been roped into becoming director of the NCCIH. You might even recall, that Steve Novella, Kimball Atwood, and I even met with her back in 2010. On the other hand, even Dr. Briggs was prone to making credulous speeches about the glories of “integrative medicine” to naturopaths.
In any event, the woman appointed to replace Dr. Briggs as director in 2018 is Dr. Helene Langevin. Her background is very different from that of her predecessor Dr. Briggs, who was a nephrologist with impeccable scientific credentials at the time of her initial appointment (much to the frustration and consternation of some advocates). Indeed, Dr. Briggs was an interesting and odd choice because she had no background in “integrative medicine” and had not used CAM in her practice or done any research into it. I suspect that, at the time, she was probably intended as a director to impose some scientific rigor to NCCAM, although I also wondered how she could have met with the approval of NACCIH. Be that as it may, although I had my disagreements with Dr. Briggs over the years, most derived from my view that what NCCIH was studying consisted of pseudoscience and quackery and that the interventions that it was studying that weren’t pseudoscience and quackery were well within the realm of SBM. It’s what I refer to as the “rebranding” of modalities like diet, exercise, and lifestyle as being somehow “alternative”. Even so, I gave Dr. Briggs some credit because I thought she was in an impossible situation. She was a real scientist trying to impose scientific rigor on an enterprise that was, by its very design, resistant to rigorous science. That she largely failed is probably not her fault; it was an impossible task.
Dr. Langevin, on the other hand, has fit right into the culture at NCCIH, because she is a true believer. In brief, Langevin has been studying acupuncture ever since at least the 1990s, when she came up with the idea that somehow the needle interacting with the connective tissue is how acupuncture “works”. Of course, nowhere in her “research” have I been ever able to see anything resembling a coherent or even suggestive mechanism as to how connective tissue could modulate the “activity” of acupuncture. Also, to her it’s not just the needles, but the twirling of the needles that is so important to do…something. Somehow this minute stretching of the tissue is enough to explain acupuncture’s miraculous “effects.” It’s not quite clear. She also seems unduly impressed by ultrasound findings in patients with chronic low back pain suggesting more thickened tissue, as though chronic inflammation might be going on. Ya think? What could sticking little needles into the body do for this? It doesn’t even make sense.
The first time I ever encountered Dr. Langevin was when I considered a study that she published in 2010, in which she used all sorts of statistical models looking for associations between differences in impedance and meridians and correlations between differences in impedance and ultrasound-measured tissue density. Her team claimed to have found a small difference in impedance between the Large Intestine meridian impedance and the control, while all other comparisons were was negative. Did it mean anything? All I could come up with is that there might be a difference in impedance between one area on the upper arm and another area. She’s also published a number of other studies looking for correlations between the density of fascia (the connective tissue lining muscles) and acupuncture points. It’s basically been quackademic medicine at its…not finest.
As I said, she fits right in. So what does her first five year strategic plan say?

Meet the new plan, same as the old plans?
Since I’ve written about the 2011-2015 and 2016-2021 NCCIH strategic plans, I thought it would be fun to list their key strategic objectives first, as a bit of history against which to compare the key bullet points of the 2021-2025 strategic plan.
The 2011-2015 (then-)NCCAM Strategic Plan included three main goals:
     1.  Advance the science and practice of symptom management.
     2.  Develop effective, practical, personalized strategies for promoting health and well-being.
     3.  Enable better evidence-based decision making regarding CAM use and its integration into health care and health promotion.
NCCAM proposed five strategic objectives through which to achieve these goals.
     1.  Advance Research on Mind and Body Interventions, Practices, and Disciplines
     2.  Advance Research on CAM Natural Products
     3.  Increase Understanding of “Real-World” Patterns and Outcomes of CAM Use and Its Integration Into Health Care and Health Promotion
     4.  Improve the Capacity of the Field To Carry Out Rigorous Research
     5.  Develop and Disseminate Objective, Evidence-Based Information on CAM Interventions
At the time, I couldn’t help but note that research into natural products is already a subdiscipline of the science of pharmacology known as pharmacognosy and that “real world” patterns and outcomes struck me as code for avoiding having to do rigorous double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trials to test whether any of the quackery being studied has any effect detectable above sham or placebo. That was just me. Let’s fast forward five years.
The 2016-2021 NCCIH Strategic Plan didn’t include overarching goals, sticking to five strategic objectives. At the time, I sarcastically referred to the plan as “Let’s do some real science for a change!” I think you’ll see why fairly quickly. Here are the five objectives:
     1.  Advance Fundamental Science and Methods Development
     2.  Improve Care for Hard-to-Manage Symptoms
     3.  Foster Health Promotion and Disease Prevention
     4.  Enhance the Complementary and Integrative Health Research Workforce (cross-cutting)
     5.  Disseminate Objective Evidence-based Information on Complementary and Integrative Health Interventions (cross-cutting)
Unsurprisingly, given the way that “integrative medicine” proponents have been “rebranding” quackery like acupuncture as “nonpharmacological treatments for pain“, pain was at the top of the scientific priority list:
    • Nonpharmacologic Management of Pain
    • Neurobiological Effects and Mechanisms
    • Innovative Approaches for Establishing Biological Signatures of Natural Products
    • Disease Prevention and Health Promotion Across the Lifespan
    • Clinical Trials Utilizing Innovative Study Designs to Assess Complementary Health Approaches and Their Integration into Health Care
    • Communications Strategies and Tools to Enhance Scientific Literacy and Understanding of Clinical Research
In 2016, I couldn’t help but notice the similarity between this plan and its predecessor, at least in outline. For instance, Objectives 1 and 4 in the new plan are little more than a repackaging of Objective 4 in the old plan, all of which carry with them an implicit admission of how poor the science carried out by NCCIH-funded investigators has been over the years. Indeed, one of the sub-objectives of Objective 1 was to “Develop new and improved research methods and tools for conducting rigorous studies of complementary health approaches and their integration into health care.” Objective 5 was even more similar in both plans; the two even have almost identical wording. Meanwhile, Objective 3 in the old plan was basically the same as one of the scientific priorities, namely “Clinical Trials Utilizing Innovative Study Designs to Assess Complementary Health Approaches and Their Integration into Health Care”. Of course, just as “real world outcomes” is code in NCCIH-speak for doing less rigorous “pragmatic” studies of various health interventions, whenever you see any sort of discussion of “innovative study design” with respect to “integrative” modalities, it almost always means “coming up with study designs that make it look as though this quackery actually works”.
Of course, as I said at the time, there’s nothing fundamentally wrong with a new five year plan strongly resembling the previous five-year plan. Such similarities do, however, make one wonder what progress has been made on the objectives shared by both plans and whether something new needs to be done to meet those objectives. Let’s see what we get with the 2021-2025 NCCIH Strategic Plan.
“Mapping a Pathway to Research on Whole Person Health”?
The subtitle of the plan is “Mapping a Pathway to Research on Whole Person Health“. I mention that right off the bat because it is a favorite trope of proponents of “integrative medicine” or “integrative health” (or, as I like to put it, “integrating” quackery with science-based medicine) that somehow “integrative health” is all about taking care of the “whole person” in a way that “conventional” medicine cannot or will not. I sense in this the influence of the new NCCIH director. If you read the previous two strategic plans, you’ll see a more conventional scientific approach, even if certain commonalities were there, including an emphasis on “innovative” or “real world” (i.e., less rigorous) study designs that provide a better chance of results that appear to support placebo interventions like acupuncture.
Dr. Langevin even lays it out right in her director’s message, which I will quote rather extensively here, noting that, as Dr. Briggs invoked the opioid addiction epidemic five years ago, Dr. Langevin invokes the COVID-19 pandemic of the last year and a half, noting that we have “witnessed the dire consequences” of chronic disease “during the COVID-19 pandemic, which illustrates how chronic underlying conditions pose immediate and long-term risks to those infected” before launching into this justification:
Now, more than ever, we need to look at the multiple factors that promote either health or disease and scientifically consider the whole person as a complex system in which health and disease are part of a bidirectional continuum. Our current biomedical research model is superb in advancing the diagnosis and pharmacologic treatment of organ-specific diseases with growing precision. This knowledge is based on an increasingly sophisticated understanding of pathogenesis, or the mechanisms by which diseases occur. On the other hand, health restoration through self-care, lifestyle, or behavioral interventions is much less studied. Examples of health restoration, or “salutogenesis,” would be the return to health after an acute viral illness or flareup of a chronic condition; normalization of cholesterol, hemoglobin A1C, and/or blood pressure in a patient with metabolic syndrome through lifestyle modification; and return to function and mobility following a musculoskeletal injury. We currently do not know whether salutogenesis consists of “pathogenesis in reverse” or whether it requires some specific salutogenic or healing pathways to be engaged to bring an individual back toward health. Unlike the treatment of disease with drugs that target specific molecular pathways, health restoration through salutogenesis is likely complex and multifactorial and involves the whole person. Advancing research on whole person health will support the investigation of nondrug and noninvasive approaches to improve and restore health.
Meeting this challenge is right up our alley. By its nature, the mission of NCCIH includes both integration and health. NCCIH was created more than 20 years ago to facilitate the study and evaluation of complementary and alternative medical practices and to disseminate the resulting information to the public. Over time, we incorporated a focus on integrative health research to bring conventional and complementary approaches together in a safe, coordinated way with the goal of improving clinical care for patients, promoting health, and preventing disease. Now, we are expanding our definition of integrative health to include whole person health, or empowering individuals, families, communities, and populations to improve their health in multiple interconnected domains: biological, behavioral, social, and environmental. This strategic plan, built on the foundation NCCIH has fostered for two decades, continues to advance our mission through an effort to better define and map a path to whole person health.
My first thought was that by embracing complexity in the name of “whole person health,” whether Dr. Langevin realizes it or not, she’s making it easier to seem to demonstrate that ineffective treatments work. She’s also embracing a research model that would deemphasize nasty, reductionist things like randomized controlled clinical trials, all in the name of embracing “whole person” or “holistic” health, while she doubles down on common tropes in quackery:
And with the goal of improving and restoring health rather than just treating disease, we offer strategies to foster research on health promotion and restoration, resilience, disease prevention, and symptom management. As always, we remain committed to enhancing the complementary and integrative health research workforce and disseminating what we learn.
I hate this commonly asserted false dichotomy with a passion, the claim that “conventional medicine” only “just treats disease” while “integrative medicine” is so much better than that because it is about “improving and restoring health”. I don’t recall Dr. Briggs stating this false dichotomy so brazenly, but, then, she was a real scientist and a bit of a fish out of water at NCCIH.
The false dichotomy gets even more irritating in the Introduction, specifically the section entitled “Building a Path to Whole Person Health“. First, there’s another common trope:
The concept of whole person health will continue to evolve, just as the concept of complementary medicine has changed over time as the line between conventional and complementary medicine has increasingly become blurred.
The reason this line has become “blurred” is not because woo works. It’s because “integrative medicine” advocates have been so successful at rebranding lifestyle interventions that have long been part of science-based medicine, such as nutrition and exercise, as somehow first “alternative”, then “complementary”, and now “integrative”, and then combining them with quackery like naturopathy, huge swaths of traditional Chinese medicine, and the like.
Here comes the doubling down:
Any kind of knowledge base includes both analysis and synthesis: analysis breaks things down into individual components, and synthesis puts them back together to understand the whole. For more than a century, biomedicine has been strongly pulled toward analysis, from its early organization into organ systems in the late nineteenth century to cellular and molecular biology with its increasingly detailed understanding of cells, molecules, genetics, and signaling pathways. In the last few decades, systems biology, derived from ecology, has begun to influence biomedical research, with a greater awareness of how body systems relate to one another and how networks of genes influence physiological processes. Nevertheless, our predominantly biochemical approach to treatment remains overwhelmingly pharmacologic. And because we tend to think about a specific disease or specific organ system, even when co-occurring conditions are present, we typically treat them separately, sometimes with medications that interfere with one another.
Now is the time for biomedical science to work toward restoring its balance between analysis and synthesis. We can do this by strengthening our efforts toward integration of knowledge across disciplines, focusing on the whole person, and taking a transdisciplinary approach that integrates the natural, social, and health sciences and transcends traditional boundaries.
Notice the very old trope beloved of quacks everywhere, namely the disparagement of “reductionist” science, compared to—of course!—the quacks, who supposedly are the only ones to take care of the “whole person” and, conveniently enough, “treat the causes” instead of the symptoms of disease. (I have a hard time not mentioning that homeopathy was invented to treat symptoms, not causes, but that’s just me.) Moreover, even though there might be a germ of truth to this, I would argue that it was more due to the limitations of basic scientific techniques than anything else. These days, with the rise of genomics, proteomics, metabolomics, and various flavors of systems biology, “conventional” science is getting very good at studying not just whole organs, but the whole person.
The real meat of the “reframing” that Dr. Langevin is pushing, though, is in the next section of the introduction, “Reframing How We Think About Natural Products and Mind and Body Practices“. Instead of all those previous categorizations of “alternative,” “complementary,” or “integrative therapies” (such as mind-body, herbal/natural products, “energy medicine”), we now get just three: nutritional, psychological, and physical.
But it’s more than that:
To ensure continuity, the Center is not abandoning its mind and body practices and natural products terminology or research but is recategorizing the approaches that fall within our research mission based on their primary therapeutic input. This categorization illustrates where there are partially overlapping boundaries, including with pharmacologic drugs and devices. For example, a single natural product can be available as a food or food component, dietary supplement, or medication (e.g., niacin). Foods, probiotics, and dietary supplements, such as fish oil, are often used as part of a healthy diet and are also frequently recommended by practitioners. Mind and body practices, such as mindfulness-based stress reduction, can overlap with more conventional practices like psychotherapy. For example, cognitive behavioral therapy increasingly incorporates relaxation, meditation, and other modalities.
And, guess what? This is just like “conventional” therapies:
There are both conventional and complementary examples of multicomponent interventions. Conventional cardiac rehabilitation often includes nutritional recommendations, exercise, and a psychological component such as mindfulness-based stress reduction. Tai chi is also increasingly being incorporated into these programs. Although this example illustrates a holistic approach that recognizes interconnectedness of the psychological and physical components, the diagnostic and therapeutic framework under which these combined therapies are used is that of conventional medicine. In contrast, other types of multicomponent therapeutic interventions or systems bring together different modalities using diagnostic and/or therapeutic frameworks that are different from those of conventional medicine. For example, traditional Chinese medicine includes nutritional components like herbs and physical components like tai chi, soft tissue manipulation, and acupuncture. The difference between traditional Chinese medicine and conventional cardiac rehabilitation is that the framework that ties each intervention together in traditional Chinese medicine is distinct from those of conventional medicine. It is important to address this from a research perspective to gain more insight into whole person health.
It is true that there are multimodality treatments in “conventional” medicine. It’s even true that we combine dietary recommendations with exercise and, when appropriate, pharmacologic interventions. The treatments for heart disease and type 2 diabetes are but two examples. Here’s the difference that reveals what Dr. Langevin’s game is. In “conventional” medicine, the diagnoses are based on science, as are the “framework” that ties the interventions together in multimodality treatments. The contrast with, for instance, traditional Chinese medicine couldn’t be more obvious, even though this report is asserting that TCM is more “holistic.”
This is a narrative that we hear time and time and time again about TCM, that it considers the “whole patient,” that it is “wholistic”, that it considers the patient as a “system”. Of course, if that “system” isn’t based on science and evidence, then who cares? After all, what about ancient “European” medicine, which stated that imbalances in the four humors (phlegm, blood, yellow bile, and black bile) caused disease? It’s pretty similar in many ways to TCM postulates, which ascribes illness to six pernicious influences. These include wind, cold, heat, dampness, dryness and summer heat, which are, like totally not like the four humors. (There are, after all, six pernicious influences. Can’t you count?) TCM also has the “five elements” (fire, wood, earth, water, and metal), which are associated with different organs. So maybe TCM is on to something because its prescientific belief is a bit more complicated than the prescientific belief system that undergirded “Western medicine” for many centuries before scientific medicine arose. That means TCM must be better, right? After all, there must be a reason why there’s all this scientific interest in studying diagnoses based on the five elements and six pernicious influences, but no love left over for studying diagnoses based on imbalances between the four humors, right?
I know, I know. This is a comparison I’ve made many times.
Five more objectives, five more years
With the introduction out of the way, let’s look at the five objectives in this strategic plan. They will sound familiar, but not entirely:
    • Objective 1: Advance Fundamental Science and Methods Development
    • Objective 2: Advance Research on the Whole Person and on the Integration of Complementary and Conventional Care
    • Objective 3: Foster Research on Health Promotion and Restoration, Resilience, Disease Prevention, and Symptom Management
    • Objective 4: Enhance the Complementary and Integrative Health Research Workforce
    • Objective 5: Provide Objective, Evidence-Based Information on Complementary and Integrative Health Interventions
Objectives 4 and 5 seem to appear in pretty much every NCCIH strategic plan in one form or another. In fact, Objective 5 has appeared in almost the same wording since the 2011-2015 plan, complete the part about “objective, evidence-based information.” Similarly, so does some variation on Objective 1, which, as I mentioned before, I like to refer to as “Let’s do some real science for a change!” Come to think of it, Objective 3 just combines Objectives 2 and 3 from the last strategic plan, combining symptom management with health promotion and adding “restoration and resilience” to the mix, because “resilience” is the latest hot term.
That leaves Objective 2 doing the heavy lifting. This is where Dr. Langevin, true believer that she is in acupuncture, appears to be starting to make her mark on NCCIH. This objective has four strategies:
    • Strategy 1: Promote basic and translational research to study how physiological systems interact with each other.
    • Strategy 2: Conduct clinical and translational research on multicomponent interventions, and study the impact of these interventions on multiple physiological systems (e.g., nervous, gastrointestinal, and immune systems) and domains (e.g., biological, behavioral, social, environmental).
    • Strategy 3: Foster multicomponent intervention research that focuses on improving health outcomes.
    • Strategy 4: Conduct studies in real world settings, where interventions are routinely delivered, to test the integration of complementary approaches into health care.
Let’s dispense with Strategy 4 first. It’s the same old, same old. Basically “real world” settings is code for doing so-called “pragmatic trials”. I’ve discussed the problem with this many times, as has Steve. There is one requirement for a pragmatic trial. That requirement is that the novel modality being tested against standard-of-care must already have been demonstrated to work in randomized clinical trials. As much as, for example, acupuncture aficionados like Dr. Langevin like to try to claim that acupuncture has been shown to work for the various health issues for which it is used, in reality when you look closely it’s not hard to see that the studies are most consistent with acupuncture “working” through placebo effects, not through any specific physiologic effect. As I like to say when discussing acupuncture studies, doing pragmatic studies on “integrative” interventions of the sort under consideration at NCCIH is putting the cart before the horse.
Come to think of it, I’ll just dispense with Strategy 1 as well, which is, at its heart, no different than what the various disciplines falling under systems biology are already doing—and have been doing for the last couple of decades, at least. It’s also the sort of thing best left to scientists who don’t believe in magic, as well.
I must admit that I laughed out loud when I read this part of Strategy 2:
NCCIH hopes to expand research on integrated multicomponent therapies. One challenge in clinical research on complex interventions is that researchers may want to tailor the interventions to specific populations, study individual components, or change the intervention to make it more convenient, but these modifications may make replication difficult and reduce the effect size of the intervention. It is important to have a reproducible intervention or algorithm of care that can be consistently delivered by different clinicians at different sites to conduct multisite trials to assess efficacy or effectiveness of the multicomponent intervention. Another challenge is how to power a study for multiple primary outcomes. NCCIH is also interested in the development of innovative strategies to evaluate multiple outcomes in a single trial.
So NCCIH wants to study multi-modality, multistep treatments and look at multiple outcomes in a single trial! What could possibly go wrong? Here’s a hint: The more outcomes you look at in a single trial, the harder it is to power the trial to determine if a difference in one of these outcomes between control and intervention is significant, as the problem of multiple comparisons comes into play. As you might recall, the more comparisons you make, the greater the chance of one or more of them producing a “statistically significant” difference by random chance alone. That problem has to be taken into account, which usually means more subjects, often a lot more. In fairness, I will give NCCIH credit for one thing. That part about having a “reproducible intervention or algorithm of care” sounds suspiciously like standardization, which is usually anathema to quacks, who love to tout how they “personalize” their interventions to the individual patient.
As for Strategy 3, well:
There is a fundamental lack of translational research on the mechanisms of resilience and health restoration in humans. In particular, the mechanisms of nutritional, psychological, and physical interventions in restoring health after an acute illness or recovery from a chronic condition are an understudied area that needs a multisystem approach to identify mechanisms and predictive biomarkers that could be used to optimize their effects. NCCIH seeks to support research that could expand the mechanistic and evidence base on complementary health approaches for preventing mental, emotional, and behavioral disorders and for promoting psychological and physical health, resilience, and health restoration.
This is another example of the “rebranding” that “integrative health” proponents are so slick at. At its core, Strategy 3 is little different from what scientists and physicians are already doing in terms of research into combining different modalities. The difference is, of course, that NCCIH will include prescientific systems of medicine, such as TCM and Ayurveda and quack modalities of naturopathy (which always includes The One Quackery To Rule Them All, homeopathy), chiropractic, and osteopathy, none of which are based on a scientific understanding of the human body and its biology, disease, and pathophysiology. It says so right in the part of the introduction that describes the vision of NCCIH:
NCCIH supports research on a diverse group of nondrug and noninvasive health practices encompassing nutritional, psychological, and physical approaches that may have originated outside of conventional medicine, many of which are gradually being integrated into mainstream health care. These include natural products, such as dietary supplements, plant-based products, and probiotics, as well as mind and body approaches, such as yoga, massage therapy, meditation, mindfulness-based stress reduction, spinal/joint manipulation, and acupuncture. In clinical practice, these approaches are often combined into multicomponent therapeutic systems, such as traditional Chinese medicine, Ayurveda, chiropractic, osteopathy, and naturopathy, that have distinctive underlying diagnostic and theoretical frameworks. Integrative health care seeks to bring conventional and complementary approaches together in a safe, coordinated way with the goal of improving clinical care for patients, restoring health, promoting resilience, and preventing disease.
This description of NCCIH’s mission and vision gives the game away, as does the emphasis on “biomarkers” of response to…quackery. So does this image:
Notice how there’s little mention of specific modalities, at least compared to past emphases. Everything has been subsumed into one of three areas: nutritional, psychological, and physical. Notice how surgery is included under the category of “mind and body practices,” along with acupuncture, because, you know, they’re both basically the same.
Meet the new plan, same as the old plan…?
As you can see, much of the new NCCIH strategic plan is more or less the same as the old NCCIH strategic plan. All the usual areas are emphasized, but Dr. Langevin cleverly combined two Objectives into one and then added what was clearly her own: Advance Research on the Whole Person and on the Integration of Complementary and Conventional Care. It’s actually rather brilliant, if your objective is to make quackery seem equivalent to science-based care. Add a bunch of complexity to the interventions being studied by “studying” them as “systems” and then “study” the “interactions” between them on multiple outcomes. It’s a strategy that’s guaranteed to produce some seemingly “positive” results.
The new plan is the same as old plans, and then some. It’s smarter in that it hides the quackery, something the last plan did, but in a cleverer way. Sadly, NCCIH appears to be back and poised to be as quacky as ever.

The NIH funding process according to John Ioannidis: “Conformity” and “mediocrity”?
John Ioannidis published a paper that concluded that the NIH study section process prioritizes “safe” science and “conformity.” Is he correct, or is this an exaggeration that uses a view of science that “brave mavericks” advance science far more rapidly than teams collaborating to make incremental progress?
David Gorski on December 10, 2012
Link
When we refer to “science-based medicine” (SBM), it is a very conscious choice to emphasize that good medicine should be based on a solid foundation of science. The name was coined to contrast the difference between the current evidence-based medicine (EBM) paradigm, which fetishizes randomized clinical trial evidence above all else and frequently ignores prior plausibility based on well-established basic science, and the SBM paradigm, which takes prior plausibility into account. The purpose of this post will not be to resurrect old discussions on these differences, but before I attend to the study at hand I bring this up to emphasize that progress in science-based medicine requires progress in science. That means all levels of biological (and even non-biological) basic science, which forms the foundation upon which translational science and clinical trials can be built. Without a robust pipeline of basic science progress upon which to base translational research and clinical trials, progress in SBM will slow and even grind to a halt.
That’s why, in the U.S., the National Institutes of Health (NIH) is so critical. The NIH funds large amounts of biomedical research each year, which means that what the NIH will and will not fund can’t help but have a profound effect shaping the pipeline of the basic and preclinical research that ultimately leads to new treatments and cures. Moreover, NIH funding has a profound effect on the careers of biomedical researchers and clinician-scientists, as having the “gold standard” NIH grant known as the R01 is viewed as a prerequisite for tenure and promotion in many universities and academic medical centers. Certainly this is the case for basic scientists; for clinician-scientists, having an R01 is certainly highly prestigious, but less of a career-killer if an investigator is unable to secure one. That’s why NIH funding levels and how hard (or easy) it is to secure an NIH grant, particularly an R01, are perennial obsessions among those of us in the biomedical research field. It can’t be otherwise, given the centrality of the NIH to research in the U.S.
It’s also why the current hostile NIH funding environment, with pay lines routinely in the range of the 7th percentile, has brought this issue to the fore once again, and when NIH funding levels come to the fore, inevitably the topic of the peer review of NIH grants comes to the fore with it. The system by which NIH grants are reviewed involves what is known as a study section, which consists of scientists with (hopefully) the relevant expertise to evaluate the grants submitted, who all read and review a certain number of grants. They then meet, usually in Bethesda but increasingly more often by video conference, to discuss and score the proposals. Having participated in a number of NIH study section meetings as an ad hoc reviewer, I have some appreciation for the process, which sometimes involves a lot of contentious discussion and other times is amazingly cordial.
Regular readers know that many of us here at SBM are great admirers of John Ioannidis, who is best known for an analysis he published several years ago entitled Why most published research findings are false. Personally, I’ve commented on a couple of other of Ioannidis’ publications, including an analysis of the life cycle of translational research (hint: it takes a loooong time for an idea to make it through basic science studies to clinical trials to become an accepted therapy). This time around, Ioannidis has published, with co-author Joshua M. Nicholson, a commentary in Nature entitled Research Grants: Conform and Be Funded, which is about the very issue of which sorts of grants the NIH funds. As is often the case, Ioannidis is provocative in making his point. As is less often the case, I’m not entirely sure he’s on-base here.

The issue of whether the NIH supports “safe” and “unimaginative” science is something that scientists have been debating since long before I ever got into the business. It’s a question that particularly comes up during harsh funding times (like now). Back when I was in graduate school 20 years ago, the NIH was in another “bust” phase of a boom-or-bust cycle, and pay lines were as tight as they are now. Well do I remember seeing two different tenured professors forced to shut their labs down because they could no longer secure funding after successfully having done so for a long time before that. In any case, it makes a lot of sense that during tight funding times the NIH would become more conservative in what it funds. After all, when money’s tight you don’t want to risk wasting it. During such times, study sections have been observed to require more and more preliminary data for grant applications and be more and more critical of ideas that don’t look on the surface like a “slam dunk.” A measure of arbitrariness to the funding also sets in. After all, the process isn’t so objective that there is a clear difference between a grant scoring in the 5th percentile (fundable) and the 10th percentile (probably not fundable).
Ioannidis, as he frequently tries to do with many things, tries to quantify the level of conservativeness and conformity of the NIH review process, introducing the concept this way:
The NIH has unquestionably propelled numerous medical advances and scientific breakthroughs, and its funding makes much of today’s scientific research possible1.
However, concern is growing in the scientific community that funding systems based on peer review, such as those currently used by the NIH, encourage conformity if not mediocrity, and that such systems may ignore truly innovative thinkers2, 3, 4. One tantalizing question is whether biomedical researchers who do the most influential scientific work get funded by the NIH.
The influence of scientific work is difficult to measure, and one might have to wait a long time to understand it5. One proxy measurement is the number of citations that scientific publications receive6. Using citation metrics to appraise scientists and their work has many pitfalls7, and ranking people on the basis of modest differences in metrics is precarious. However, one uncontestable fact is that highly cited papers (and thus their authors) have had a major influence, for whatever reason, on the evolution of scientific debate and on the practice of science.
So basically, you can see where this is going. Ioannidis is going to try to analyze whether the most “influential” scientists are NIH-funded. One can quibble about whether the most cited papers are truly the most “influential,” of course. After all, sometimes the most cited papers are influential in a bad way or are cited as an example of a paradigm that was later rejected. However, there aren’t any really good ways of measuring a scientist’s influence; citations are probably about as useful a way as one can come up with. At least it’s an objective number that can be measured. After his analysis, Ioannidis also makes some interesting, although perhaps unworkable suggestions for improving the process.
First, let’s look at the key finding of the entire exercise. Nicholson and Ioannidis first identified 700 papers in biomedical research journals published since 2001 that have received 1,000 or more citations. They then examined the record of the primary author of those papers. It’s fairly amazing what a select group this is. There were more than 20 million papers published worldwide between 2001 and 2012, of which only 1,380 had received 1,000 or more citations. Of these, 700 were catalogued in the life or health sciences and had an author affiliation in the U.S. These 700 papers produced 1,172 discrete single, first, or last authors. The reason Ioannidis concentrated on these authors is because in biomedical research publications, the first author is usually the one who did most of the work and wrote the paper, while the last author is usually the principal investigator (PI); i.e., the researcher in whose laboratory the research was carried out. Frequently, therefore, the first author is a graduate student or postdoctoral fellow working in the laboratory of the PI.
So what were the results? Because I’m going on vacation and feeling a little lazy right now, I’ll let Ioannidis describe it:
We discovered that serving on a study section is not necessarily tied to impact in the scientific literature. (see ‘Is funding tied to impact?). When we cross-checked the NIH study-section rosters against the list of 1,172 authors of highly cited papers, we found only 72 US-based authors who between them had published 84 eligible articles with 1,000 or more citations each and who were current members of an NIH study section. These 72 authors comprised 0.8% of the 8,517 study-section members. Most of the 72 (n = 64, 88.9%) currently received NIH funding.
We then randomly selected 200 eligible life- and health-science papers with 1,000 or more citations (analysing all 700 would have required intensive effort and yielded no extra information in terms of statistical efficiency). We excluded those in which the single, first or last author was a member of an NIH study section, and those in which the single or both the first and last author were not located in the United States on the basis of their affiliations at the time of publication. This generated a group of 158 articles with 262 eligible US authors who did not participate in NIH study sections. Only the minority (n = 104, 39.7%) of these 262 authors received current NIH funding.
These data are presented in graphical form in the article:
So the basic finding is that researchers viewed as “highly influential” are often not on NIH study sections. Ioannidis notes that these rates of NIH funding are not any higher and might be worse than biomedical scientists in general. Ioannidis cites data that suggests that between 24% and 37% of biomedical researchers applying for grants from 2001 to 2011 were funded as principal investigators. True, Ioannidis points out that the funding rates for individual grants are considerably lower (after all, the pay lines over the last few years have been in the 7th percentile range) and that researchers submit multiple grants, resulting in a significant number of researchers ultimately receiving NIH funding. There is one problem using this particular range, however. The early part of the range is very different from the more recent part of the range as far as pay lines go. from 1998 to 2003, the NIH budget nearly doubled, the result of an initiative started under the Clinton Administration and completed under the Bush Administration. Truly, back then it was the land of milk and honey for researchers trying to compete for NIH grants, with pay lines well over the 20th percentile in some institutes. Then, after the doubling ended in 2003, the NIH came in for what has since become known as a “hard landing.” Budget increases did not keep up with inflation. Also, because grants funded during the time of the doubling could be as long as 5 years, the commitments from those grants funded during the time of the doubling remained for several years after the large budget increases ended, leaving less money for new grants. Thus, this period encompasses a “time of plenty” that lasted until around 2003 and 2004 and the current drought, which got really severe after around 2006. Despite all sorts of moves by the NIH to increase the number of new grants, such as cutting the budgets of existing grants and newly awarded grants, the current situation shows no signs of abating any time soon. All of this is why I would be curious if Ioannidis’ estimate still holds for the period from, say, 2006 to 2011 as it did in the earlier time period from 2001 to 2005.
Whether it does or not, the finding remains that there doesn’t seem to be a discernable difference between the NIH funding rates between these highly cited scientists and the rest of us hoi polloi, which does rather suggest that the current NIH system isn’t identifying the truly best and brightest. At least, this is what Ioannidis argues. First, however, he also points out another interesting observation. Study section members and non-members showed no significant difference in their total number of highly cited papers:
Among authors of extremely highly cited papers, study-section members and non-members showed no significant difference in their total number of highly cited papers, despite the fact that members of study sections were significantly more likely than non-members to have current NIH funding. This was true both for authors with multiple highly cited papers (13/13 versus 13/19, p = 0.024) and for those with a single eligible highly cited paper (51/59 versus 91/243, p
It’s important to clarify here. There is a reason why study section members are significantly more likely to have NIH funding, and that’s because the NIH invites holders of NIH grants, particularly R01s, to join study sections, and many do. Indeed, among the requirements for study section members is that they must be a principal investigator “on a research project comparable to those being reviewed.” In other words, to be an official standing member of a study section, in general you have to have an NIH grant, usually an R01 or larger. The rest of the study section is then rounded out with a rotating band of ad hoc reviewers picked for specific areas of expertise. That’s the point, and that’s why Ioannidis mentions this. The point is that being on a study section or holding an NIH grant has no correlation with being one of these highly cited scientists.
Another observation made by Ioannidis using the similarity or “match” score on the NIH rePORTER website, where you can find listings of all federally funded research projects, is that the grants of study section members were more similar to other currently funded grants than were non-members’ grants. In other words, the funded grants of members of NIH study sections resemble each other and grants in general funded by the NIH. I can certainly guess why this might be true. One of the pieces of advice I received when I was starting out (and that is given to lots of young investigators) is to find a way to get on a study section. The rationale is that by learning how the NIH evaluates grants you can learn how to craft grants more likely to be funded. It therefore makes sense that a certain level of conformity creeps in, and there’s little doubt that that conformity becomes more pronounced when funding is tight. Study sections and the NIH do not want to “waste” taxpayer’s money on risky projects.
Or, as Ioannidis puts it:
If NIH study-section members are well-funded but not substantially cited, this could suggest a double problem: not only do the most highly cited authors not get funded, but worse, those who influence the funding process are not among those who drive the scientific literature. We thus examined a random sample of 100 NIH study-section members. Not surprisingly, 83% were currently funded by the NIH. The citation impact of the 100 NIH study-section members was usually good or very good, but not exceptional: the most highly cited paper they had ever published as single, first or last author had received a median of 136 (90–229) citations and most were already mid- or late-career researchers (80% were associate or full professors). Only 1 of the 100 had ever published a paper with 1,000 or more citations as single, first or last author (see Appendix 1 of Supplementary Information for additional citation metrics).
And, from a news report about the Ioannidis’ study:
Top scientists are familiar with NIH’s penchant for the safe and incremental. Years ago, biologist Mario Capecchi of the University of Utah applied for NIH funding for a genetics study with three parts. The study section liked two of them but said the third would not work.
Capecchi got the grant and put all the money into the part the reviewers discouraged. “If nothing happened, I’d be sweeping floors now,” he said. Instead, he discovered how to disable specific genes in animals and shared the 2007 Nobel Prize for medicine for it.
Although I think Ioannidis definitely has a point, anecdotes like this are rife in the research world. Usually, they take the form of scientists with ideas that they couldn’t persuade the NIH to fund despite multiple grant applications but that later turned out to be revolutionary or to lead to highly useful new therapies. The most common such anecdote that I hear is that of Dennis Slamon, who proposed targeting the HER2 oncogene in breast cancer. I’ve touched on his saga before, along with the whole issue of supporting risky science versus safer, more incremental science. It’s the issue of “going for the bunt versus swinging for the fences.” Basically Slamon likes to go on and on about he had trouble getting NIH funding to develop a humanized monoclonal antibody against HER2, but, as I pointed out, the story was actually a lot more complex than that. For instance, Slamon’s applications were submitted around a time when other scientists were having difficulty replicating their results, and very likely study section members knew that. Also, Slamon had no trouble getting NIH funding for other projects at the time.
To me, these anecdotes represent the scientific variant of the mad scientist in horror movies ranting, “They thought me mad, mad, I tell you! But I’ll show them.” OK, I’m being a bit sarcastic, but these stories are so ubiquitous whenever anyone complains about the “conformity” and conservativeness of the NIH review process that I tend to want to gag every time I read one of them. They’re pure confirmation bias. Yes, occasionally the daring or bizarre idea will pay off. However, far more often risky ideas do not pan out because, well, they are risky. Most risky ideas fail. It’s very easy to recognize innovative ideas with a high potential for impact in retrospect. With the benefit of hindsight, we now know that Slamon and Capecchi have made huge contributions to science. At the time they were doing their seminal work, it wasn’t nearly as obvious. Both Slamon and Capecchi got lucky. Such is the fate of riskier ideas that it could just as easily have gone the other way and their big ideas gone nowhere.
But back to Ioannidis. I see a lot of problems with his analysis, not the least of which is his metric. For one thing, in some specialized fields, even papers with a very high impact would have difficulty reaching 1,000 citations, because there just aren’t enough scientists working in that field to produce such blockbusters. Another issue is consistency. Truly influential and creative scientists tend to produce multiple influential papers, and even an average scientist can stumble onto something. Even Ioannidis concedes that “one cannot assume that investigators who have authored highly cited papers will continue to do equally influential work in the future.” Indeed, how many of these papers analyzed by Ioannidis were one-shot papers in which the scientists who published them never published papers anywhere near as influential again? To be fair, Ioannidis does make a good point that such investigators have reached a bar that should entitle them to a chance to prove that they can keep doing such good work.
Finally, as NIH Director Francis Collins pointed out, scientists funded by the NIH have won 135 Nobel Prizes. The situation is not as clearly a problem as Ioannidis makes it sound. Besides, it is the very nature of science that “game changing” studies tend to be relatively few and far between. Most of the hard work of advancing science does come from incremental work, in which scientists build upon what has come before. We fetishize the “brave mavericks” and “geniuses,” and, yes, they are important, but identifying these geniuses at the time they are doing their work is not a trivial thing. Often the importance of their ideas and work is only appreciated in retrospect.
In the end, as much as I admire Ioannidis, I think he’s off-base here. It’s not that I don’t agree that the NIH should try to find ways to fund more innovative research. However, Ioannidis’ approach to quantifying the problem seems to suffer from flaws in its very conception. In light of that, I can’t resist revisiting the discussion in my last post on the question of riskiness versus safety in research, and that’s a simple question: What’s the evidence that funding more risky research will result in better research and more treatments? We have lots of anecdotes of scientists whose ideas were later found to be validated and potentially game-changing who couldn’t get NIH funding, but how often does this really happen? As I’ve pointed out before, the vast majority of “wild” ideas are considered “wild” precisely because they are new and there is little good support for them. Once evidence accumulates to support them, they are no longer considered quite so “wild.” We know today that the scientists whose anecdotes of woe describing the depredations of the NIH were indeed onto something. How many more proposed ideas that seemed innovative at the time but ultimately went nowhere?
Ioannidis does bring up a disturbing point, namely that scientists who have authored highly influential papers are apparently no more likely to achieve NIH funding than the rest of us and, more relevant, that scientists on NIH study sections differ from those not on study sections only in their ability to persuade the NIH to fund them. NIH study sections are a lot of work, and there is also a culture there, with a definite “in” crowd. It is quite possible that the truly innovative thinkers and scientists don’t want to be bothered with the many hours of work that each study section meeting involves, which can require members to review five to ten large grants and then travel to Bethesda, and it is equally possible that such scientists “don’t play well with others” in the study section. It is certainly worthwhile to investigate whether this is the case and then to try to find a way to bring such creative minds into the grant review process. However, the assumption underlying Ioannidis’s analysis seems to be that there must be “bolts out of the blue” discovered by brilliant brave maverick scientists. It’s all very Randian at its heart. However, science is a collaborative enterprise, in which each scientist builds incrementally on the work of his or her predecessors. Bolts out of the blue are a good thing, but we can’t count on them, nor has anyone demonstrated that they are more likely to occur if the NIH funds “riskier research.” It’s equally likely that the end result would be a lot more dud research.
No one can say, and that’s the point.

   Medical Practice

   “Urban Zen” and homeopathy at Beth Israel Medical Center, or: Dr. Gorski destroys his chances of ever being invited to join the faculty at BIMC or the Albert Einstein College of Medicine
David Gorski 
Link
I guess I never really wanted to work in Manhattan anyway. At least, that’s what I keep telling myself.
I mean, why on earth would I want to? What’s the attraction? Living in the heart of it all, all those shows and all those amazing cultural activities, all those world-class restaurants? Being close to Boston, Philadelphia, and other cool East Coast cities, which are all just a quick Acela train ride away? Who cares about those things, anyway?
Apparently I don’t, because I’m about to destroy my chances of working at what has been considered one of the premiere academic hospitals in New York City, specifically Beth Israel Medical Center, an academic affiliate of the Albert Einstein College of Medicine. It’s possible for me to have been ignored when I first included the Albert Einstein College of Medicine and its affliated Continuum Center for Health & Healing in my roll call of shame as a medical center that has not just added woo to its offerings, but actively embraced it. At the time I originally discovered it, though, its offerings seemed limited to fairly mild woo, the usual stuff like acupuncture, what I like to call “gateway modalities” that centers embrace first because they’re relatively tame and commonplace. All too commonly, though, dabbling in gateway modalities leads to the “hard stuff,” outright quackery with zero scientific basis like homeopathy, reflexology, and craniosacral therapy. Such is the pathway an academic medical center follows when it degenerates from science-based medicine to what Dr. R. W. famously dubbed “quackademic medicine,” usually driven by a few famous true believers, which, alas, is exactly what happened at fearless leader Steve Novella’s institution of Yale, thanks to Dr. David Katz and his “more fluid concept of evidence.”
In any case, last week, I realized that I’ve been completely neglecting the aforementioned roll call of shame. Perusing it, I now realize that it’s been over five months since I did a significant update to it. You just know that, given the rate of infiltration of unscientific medical practices into medical academia as seemingly respectable treatment modalities that there must be at least several new additions to this roll of shame. Alas, even today, having been shamed myself by the realization of my failure to keep the list updated, I’m not going to do the full update and revamping that the Roll Call of Quackademic Medicine cries out for. However, that doesn’t mean I can’t do a piecemeal addition here and there. That doesn’t mean I can’t point out new additions as they pop up, even if it takes me a while to find the time to give the list the facelift it cries out for. It doesn’t mean I can’t call out hospitals like Beth Israel when they fall into woo, especially when they dive into quackademic medicine in a big way for cancer patients.
The first thing to know about this degeneration of a once great academic powerhouse is that, as is the case for many centers of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or of “integrative medicine” (IM), when looking for the reason why physicians ostensibly dedicated to scientific medicine would embrace cult medicine, look for the financial motive. Indeed, as has been extensively documented by my cobloggers and myself, the National Center for Complmentary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) and the Bravewell Collaborative, spearheaded by extremely wealthy believers in unscientific medicine, are pouring millions upon millions of dollars to fund “research” and “training” (read: prosletyzing) for “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM), a.k.a. “integrative medicine” (IM). In this case, the financial incentive comes from Donna Karan, founder of the famous DKNY line of clothing. In search of her dollars, Beth Israel has turned over an entire cancer treatment floor to woo:
Medical advances sometimes happen in strange ways. Someone finds a fungus in dirty lab dishes and — eureka! — penicillin is born. Now a premier Manhattan hospital is turning a cancer-treatment floor over to a world-famous fashion designer in the hope that serendipity, science and intuition will strike again.
A foundation run by Donna Karan, creator of the “seven easy pieces” philosophy of women’s wardrobes and founder of the much-imitated DKNY line of clothing, has donated $850,000 for a yearlong experiment combining Eastern and Western healing methods at Beth Israel Medical Center. Instead of just letting a celebrated donor adopt a hospital wing, renovate it and have her name embossed on a plaque, the Karan-Beth Israel project will have a celebrated donor turn a hospital into a testing ground for a trendy, medically controversial notion: that yoga, meditation and aromatherapy can enhance regimens of chemotherapy and radiation.
I can’t help but wonder here whatever happened to the days when a wealthy donor would be happy just to have her name on a building or on a floor. I guess those days never truly existed. Wealthy patrons frequently want more than just their names to live on in the form of a building or patient wing and always have. It’s the same reason they funded great artists hundreds of years ago. That’s not to say that such patrons don’t do truly great things with their money and influence. Certainly they can and do, as Evelyn Lauder has done in creating and running the Breast Cancer Research Foundation, which funds science-based research without giving in to the temptation to be trendy and fund research into unscientific modalities, largely thanks to Dr. Larry Norton, who is Chairman of its Executive Board of Scientific Advisors. In addition, my scientific hero, the late Dr. Judah Folkman, was funded by the BCRF for many years. (Full disclosure: I, too, am currently doing research funded by the BCRF. However, that aside, the more I’ve learned about the organization the more it impresses me. Just search the website for their research projects; you’ll be very hard-pressed to find even a hint of dubious research.)
All too often, unfortunately, wealthy patrons have a tendency to fund projects that serve to reinforce their own personal and non-science-based beliefs. Such is the case with Donna Karan funding this new oncology floor at BIMC. It’s truly depressing to see a former academic powerhouse accommodate such wishes just because they’re trendy, because a wealthy donor is willing to fund them, and because, no doubt, hospital administrators perceive it as good publicity and a potential draw for credulous patients. I wish I could view this as merely a cynical ploy to add a spoon full of woo to make the real scientific medicine go down easier, but somehow I fear that it’s more than that. There’s a big element of real belief in CAM and “spirituality” there. Indeed, it appears to be no different than what was discussed by Harriet Hall last week: An attempt to inject “spirituality,” which, let’s face it, when used in this context is almost always nothing more than a code word for trying to get medicine to endorse religion as a scientifically valid adjunct or primary treatment for various conditions. In other words, it’s the injection of religious belief into into medical practice in an inappropriate manner. The only difference is that, instead of “mainstream” Christian religion, in this case it’s Eastern mysticism in the form of yoga, which is composed not just of potentially useful low impact exercise but also a large amount of religious and spiritual beliefs. In the U.S., you can get your yoga relatively “spirituality”-free (most people do), but that’s not what Donna Karan appears to intend here, as you will see. In her proposed program, the “spiritual” elements of yoga are front and center.
There’s an old saying, though, that’s so famous and overused that it’s become a cliché, and that’s that the road to Hell is paved with good intentions. This is an excellent example of just that. Donna Karan hopes that her new “Urban Zen” center at BIMC will help patients deal with the side effects of chemotherapy, a worthy goal, to be sure. There’s no doubt that, depending on the specific regimen and patient, chemotherapy can cause very unpleasant side effects, and the alleviation of those side effects is an active and major area of research in scientific oncology, because not only are these side effects extremely distressing but they are sometimes so distressing that patients decide not to continue chemotherapy, thus reducing their chances of long term survival. Targeted chemotherapeutics with much lower toxicity and measures to alleviate chemotherapy-induced symptoms are right up there, close to being the Holy Grail of cancer research. Consequently, it’s hard to argue against trying yoga out for such an indication without seeming harsh and close-minded. I would argue that it’s bad to be so open-minded that your brains fall out.
To see why, observe what the program will involve:
Fifteen yoga teachers will be sent to Beth Israel’s ninth-floor cancer ward starting in January to work with nonterminal patients, and nurses will be trained in relaxation techniques. Their salaries, as well as a cosmetic overhaul of the ward, are being paid for by Ms. Karan’s Urban Zen Foundation, created after her husband and business partner, Stephan Weiss, 62, died of lung cancer in 2001.
While other hospitals in New York and across the country have dabbled in yoga, the new Beth Israel project is broader, better financed and more integrated into the medical protocol, and because of Ms. Karan’s concern that it might be dismissed as touchy-feely nonsense, it includes a research component. Ms. Karan hopes to prove that the Urban Zen regime can reduce classic symptoms of cancer and its treatment, like pain, nausea and anxiety (thereby cutting hospital stays and costs) and serve as a model for replication elsewhere.
In a couple of online discussions of this program, I’ve seen it asked: Wouldn’t that money be better spent funding the salaries of 15 RNs for the oncology unit? Almost certainly it would. But, as is the case with virtually all such efforts, this is about proselytization, not science-based medicine. Donna Karan is a believer, and she is looking for evidence to support her belief in order to justify further proselytizing of her Urban Zen program to other hospitals. It’s all very much like a religion, so much so that we’re hearing the usual excuses that that evil reductionistic “Western” medicine can’t adequately study whether yoga can do what is claimed for it:
But Dr. Benjamin Kligler, the research director in integrative family medicine for the Beth Israel-affiliated Continuum Center for Health and Healing and the research project’s principal investigator, acknowledged that the experiment of yoga teachers and their interaction with patients did not lend itself to the random, double-blind placebo trials favored in the medical world.
“The truth is, from a very traditional research perspective, that’s a problem,” Dr. Kligler conceded, adding that it might be time for the medical establishment to consider a new research model for what he called “lifestyle interventions.”
Poppycock.
Even though a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial can’t be done in the classical sense, in most cases that’s nothing more than a convenient excuse used by true believers for not doing the most rigorous studies possible given the limitations placed by the specific modalities under consideration on what studies can be done. A classic example of this was published in the medical literature about a year and a half ago. It involved a study of Tai Chi as an immune booster. In fact, when looked at dispassionately and with a science-based eye, the study itself was not really a study of Tai Chi per se but rather a study of mild exercise versus no exercise in the elderly and whether mild exercise in the form of Tai Chi increased vaccine-stimulated levels of cell-mediated immunity (CMI) to varicella zoster virus in older adults. The results were predictable; it did. Of course, the positive results from that trial were attributed to the Tai Chi, rather than to mild, low impact exercise in general. After all, when stripped of all its Eastern mysticism, that’s all Tai Chi really is: low impact exercise. The huge, gaping hole in the study was that the only two groups in the study were the Tai Chi group and a group receiving passive health education. There was no additional no control group in which patients participated in another form of mild, low impact exercise without all the “spiritual” trappings to see if that had a similar effect. Ironically enough, yoga might have been a reasonable additional group, but any form of low impact exercise of the same intensity as the Tai Chi regimen used in this study would have been acceptable. It wasn’t there, and the authors didn’t seem to comprehend why their study didn’t show what they thought it did.
I’m expecting to see the same sort of studies coming out of Urban Zen at BIMC.
Of course, it’s not entirely unreasonable to hypothesize that low impact flexibility exercise might make people undergoing chemotherapy feel better, just as exercise makes people feel better, through whatever mechanism, be it distraction or a physiological effect attributable physical activity. Indeed, the scientific literature already contains studies suggesting that exercise speeds recovery from the adverse effects of chemotherapy and that it can reduce fatigue in patients undergoing chemotherapy. Whatever studies performed at Urban Zen are almost virtually assured to be “positive” simply because they encourage mild exercise in patients undergoing chemotherapy. However, this particular form of flexibility exercise, yoga, is overlaid with all sorts of “Eastern” mysticism that credulous CAM aficionados love so dearly, and it is the mysticism that Donna Karan believes in and wants to sell, not just mild exercise. It’s a classic “bait and switch,” although I’m guessing Karan has no idea that that’s what it is. She appears to believe, but belief is not science. It’s also depressing to think that a large part of what drives movements like this comes from the failure of our hospitals practicing science-based medicine to provide patients with a sufficient degree of human warmth and encouragement; I often think that the attraction of these touchy-feely non-science-based modalities would be much attenuated if we were able to provide more emotional support and our time to listen to patient concerns. Purveyors of woo are doing nothing more than seeing an opening and rushing in to fill it. The problem is that it’s not necessary to embrace religion or pseudoscience to fill this hole, and all the mystical and pseudoscientific baggage that accompanies such woo represents a profound threat to science-based medicine.
In any case, the “problem” that Dr. Kligler laments about testing yoga for this indication is really not nearly as big a problem as he makes it sound, certainly not big enough that we need a new paradigm to test CAM modalities scientifically. True, blinding is impossible for a study of the effect of exercise on chemotherapy-induced side effects, but we surgeons do unblinded randomized experiments in surgery all the time. After all, it’s rarely possible or practical to blind surgeons to the surgical procedure performed, nor is a sham surgery control group usually feasible. It’s a bit more difficult to get usable scientific data from clinical trials under such circumstances, but by no means anywhere near impossible. It just takes more effort to be rigorous elsewhere, and it usually takes more studies carried out at different institutions, to be sure to eliminate institutional and investigator biases as much as possible. Certainly, it’s not so difficult that we should consider jettisoning current clinical trial methodology, as Dr. Kligler seems to imply that we should.
Of course, it’s highly doubtful that Donna Karan would have tried to sell her yoga program to an institution not likely to be receptive to it, and, boy, oh, boy does BIMC qualify as being “open” to such ideas. Just get a load of its Continuum Center for Health & Healing. Peruse its webpage, and it’s a veritable cornucopia of woo and unscientific medical modalities. It’s all there. There’s reiki, Rolfing, prayer, Therapeutic Touch, traditional indigenous healing therapies, acupuncture, even that woo of woo, that One Quackery To Rule Them All (apologies to J.R.R. Tolkien), homeopathy:
As a pediatrician Dr. Stern finds that homeopathic medicines, which are safe and efficacious, are particularly well suited for the care of children’s common ailments. In her practice Dr. Stern uses homeopathy not only to treat acute problems such as upper respiratory infections and acute ear infections but also to treat more chronic conditions. For children suffering from conditions such as asthma, recurring ear infections, eczema and behavioral problems homeopathy has helped reduce or eliminate daily doses of antibiotics and steroids which are often required for symptomatic control.
Quackery such as homeopathy has no place in an academic medical center–or any medical center, for that matter. (There, I said it.) Worse, this quackery is being administered to children, and belief in homeopathy has led to unethical clinical trials with children as subjects. Homeopathy is water. Period. Diluting a substance does not render it more potent, nor does shaking it. Period. There is no plausible physiological mechanism by which homoepathy could work, and homeopathy goes against well-established science. Period. Barring incredibly compelling evidence for its efficacy in non-self-limited diseases, there is no reason to suspect that whatever effects are attributed to homeopathy are due to anything more than the placebo effect, regression to the mean, the expectation effect, confirmation bias, or a combination thereof. Period. Yet homeopathy is being offered at Beth Israel as though it’s on par with scientific medicine. Worse, its being promoted by true believers. Don’t believe me? Then consider this detailed and credulously positive description of homeopathy. I just about spit up my drink when I saw Samuel Hahnemann’s homeopathic provings as “meticulously executed experiments” (for an antidote, read Kimball Atwood’s post on “provings”) and indulged in appeals to ancient knowledge:
Although Hahnemann was the first to clearly formulate the law of similars and first began to use its principals in a systematic way, he clearly states that a number of people before him had very similar ideas. The “Law of Similars” has a very rich historical basis. Hippocrates (VI century, B.C.) wrote: “through the like, disease is produced, and through the application of the like it is cured”. Celsus and Paracelsus are known to have used the Law of Similars in their practice. The Delphic Oracle proclaimed:” That which makes sick shall heal”. In one of the ancient Jewish writings, called Mekilta, we read: “Man does not heal with the same thing with which he wounds, but he wounds with a knife and heals with a plaster. The Holy One, blessed be He, however is not so, but He heals with the very same thing with which he smites.” Modern medicine uses this principle daily. The “father” of immunology , Dr. Emil Adolph von Behring, wrote about the origins of immunology: “By what technical term could we more appropriately speak of this influence than by Hahnemann’s word “homeopathy”? Desensitization techniques used by conventional allergologists utilize very small doses of allergens to stop a pathological response in the patient.
If ancient knowledge is so great, I always ask whether believers in these ancient modalities would like to go back to the medical systems that existed thousands, or even 200 years ago (the time of Samuel Hahnemann) and see how well it worked compared to today’s scientific medicine. Right on cue after appeals to ancient knowledge are also appeals to popularity:
In England, Australia, New Zealand, India, Russia, Brazil and many other countries homeopathy is recognized as a valid mode of treatment. In the United Kingdom, around 42% of physicians refer patients to homeopathic practitioners, and homeopathic training is the most popular post-graduate training program. In France, approximately 36% of the public and 32% of the physicians use homeopathic remedies. Moscow, Russia, has a homeopathic hospital with a large homeopathic outpatient clinic and many homeopathic pharmacies with many people using various homeopathic preparations daily. India has approximately 125 four- and five-year homeopathic medical colleges with over 100,000 homeopathic doctors practicing around the country.
If you really want to throw up (homeopathically, of course), read another homeopathy article entitled Homeopathy — How it works and when to use it. The deconstruction of this article is left as an exercise for the reader. (“Decontruction”? How postmodernist of me!) I know you can handle such a task just fine. While you’re at it, feel free to take on the other woo on the Continuum Center for Health & Healing website. Suffice it to say it’s–shall we say?–a very, very “target-rich environment” for skeptics–depressingly so, in fact. It’s profoundly disturbing to find an academic medical center willing not merely to embrace such unscientific medicine but to actively promote it as science-based without a shred of evidence that any critical thinking whatsoever was applied to writing the material on the website touting its benefits.
Of course, no true floor dedicated to the “integration” of yoga and Eastern mysticism into our nasty, reductionist science-based medicine would be complete without real “integration” plus feng shui:
“A lot of other hospitals have integrative medicine, but it’s kind of stuck away in the basement,” said Dr. Merrell, who, not coincidentally, is Ms. Karan’s internist. “People like to think it’s not there.” Starting in November, the cancer ward will be renovated by Ms. Karan, the architect David Fratianne and Alex Stark, a feng shui master. The dull beige walls and green linoleum tile floors will be replaced with bamboo wallpaper and cork floors. Nooks and crannies now used for brown-bag lunches and naps and crammed with a desultory selection of dusty books will be turned into yoga, prayer and meditation retreats for patients, their families and nurses.
As I said before, this is religion–excuse me, “spirituality”–not science. And, true to most “alternative” medicine, it relies on testimonials. In this case, it’s the story of Lynn Kohlman, a photographer, model and DKNY fashion director who inspired Donna Karan with her battle against cancer. In fact, a quote by Karan is most revealing as to the true motivation for the Urban Zen center:
She [Kohlman] intensified her yoga. “She asked for it in the hospital,” said Ms. Karan, who practices yoga daily. “She needed it, she wanted it.
“This works,” Ms. Karan insisted. “Now we have to prove it in the clinical setting.”
That’s exactly the problem. Karan intensely believes that yoga “works” (although what “works” means in this context is not entirely clear), and she’s looking for evidence to support her belief, not to see if her belief stands up to experimental testing that could falsify it. There’s no malignant intent in her championing of yoga; after all, she thinks it will help people. However, her attitude of looking for evidence to support her preexisting belief rather than testing her belief, trying to falsify it, to see if it stands up to scrutiny is one key difference between scientific medicine and pseudoscientific medicine. Given Karan’s attitude, think about this: If the results of the “clinical trials’ being carried out at Beth Israel fail to bear out her belief, how long do you think her generosity will continue? CAM boosters frequently criticize trials of what they disparagingly call “conventional” pharmaceuticals because of perceived conflicts of interest due to the funding source. Make no mistake, this is indeed a serious problem in the research underpinning of science-based medicine, as I’ve pointed out before twice recently. However, with respect to programs such as Urban Zen, that argument cuts both ways. Don’t think that doctors running the “studies” of yoga at Urban Zen don’t know what their wealthy patron hopes that they will find in their “studies” of yoga and the relief of chemotherapy symptoms. Of course, any possible conflicts of interest may not matter. After all, they, like Karan, are true believers as well; so they want to find that yoga “works,” too.
I’m not opposed to patients using yoga because it makes patients feel better, and I’m certainly not opposed to using yoga as a form of mild (or even not-so-mild) exercise that may help ease recovery from the effects of chemotherapy. Exercise is good; exercise very likely helps patients who can do it deal with the side effects of chemotherapy. Remember, though, at its core that’s not really what the Urban Zen program is about, no matter how much Donna Karan and the boosters of quackademic medicine who have latched onto her belief and largesse at Beth Israel try to argue otherwise. I wish it were, but it’s not. No, in reality at its very heart it’s about the rejection of science in favor of a specific flavor of “spirituality” and the injection of that spirituality into the heart of the practice of oncology. It’s about the embrace of testimonial evidence over scientific evidence, and the abandonment of science and reason in medicine–or, even worse, their subversion to serve the beliefs of the people promoting these modalities. Again, none of this is because Donna Karan is evil or stupid. She truly believes she is doing good, but science doesn’t work the way she thinks it does. Worse, there are several enablers unwilling to disabuse her of her misunderstanding of science because to a greater or lesser extent they share her misunderstandings. To bring it all back home to the Urban Zen program, I’ll just say that, if you don’t believe me, take a look at the section on yoga on the Center for Health & Healing website:
What is Yoga? Most people think of Yoga as a physical practice of stretching the body in different ways. To some, Yoga evokes images of seemingly impossible contortions accomplished only by the adept. But the physical practice of Yoga is only one facet of a holistic system that addresses all aspects of our experience. The Sanskrit word Yoga literally means to yoke, bind, focus one’s attention; it also means union or communion. The ancient Yogis sought to experience our essential nature, beyond the bounds of body and mind. Through practice and discovery using the instruments of our very existence- the body, breath, senses and mind- they reconnected with the universal of which we are all an expression. This is the essence of Yoga. By moving into stillness through the layers of the body, emotions and thoughts, we find at our core a sense of deep peace and connection.
The science of Yoga is a guide to that peace. Recognizing the multifaceted nature of human beings, the system of Yoga addresses our complex relationship with the external and internal worlds. This system, called Astanga Yoga or the Eight-Limbed Path, encompasses Yama (ethical observances), Niyama (personal disciplines), Asana (physical postures), Pranayama (control of the breath), Pratyahara (drawing in of the senses), Dharana (concentration), Dhyana (meditation) and Samadhi (higher consciousness). These Eight Limbs are like rungs on a ladder; each one is an important step on the path and leads naturally to the next.
And this is how the practitioners at BIMC claim that yoga “works”:
In the Yogic view, disease is the result of imbalance. Yoga approaches dis-ease by restoring ease. To understand the benefits of Yoga it’s helpful to first look at one of the roots of dis-ease-stress. Sometimes in the absence of an identifiable cause of a condition, we assume “it must just be stress.” But the effects of chronic stress are quite specific and in a very real way lead to illness if unchecked.
What is stress? The stress response (“fight-or-flight”) is a survival mechanism that enables us to respond quickly to dangerous situations. In the face of a perceived threat, a cascade of physiological events takes place that prepares the body to get itself out of trouble. Stress hormones are released, heart rate and breathing rate increase, blood vessels constrict, blood pressure increases, muscle tension increases, resting processes such as digestion and repair cease, immune function is impaired, fats and sugars are released into the bloodstream, and insulin production increases. Fight-or-flight is carried out by the sympathetic nervous system, part of the autonomic nervous system.
Ideally when the emergency is resolved, the body returns to its natural state of balance. But because the stress response is nonspecific, it may be set off by events, thoughts and feelings on a daily basis. Without relief, without restoring balance, the state of stress can become a chronic condition and we become vulnerable to illness.
Aside from all the “balance” blather, a good rule of thumb is that whenever you see the word “disease” spelled as “dis-ease” you can be quite confident that you’re dealing with grade A, top-notch woo. Snark aside, though, no wonder Donna Karan saw the faculty at BIMC as kindred “spirits” and decided to shower her patronage on them, who in turn were apparently more than happy to accept her largesse and run with it. No doubt in future years, there will be a series of publications arising from BIMC and the Albert Einstein College of Medicine touting the benefits of yoga for chemotherapy-induced nausea and other symptoms. No doubt they will fail to include critical controls, just as the Tai Chi study I discussed did. And no doubt they will be uncritically trumpeted in the press, particularly given the publicity engendered by the well-meaning but unscientific benefactor of the Urban Zen effort, Donna Karan. Albert Einstein, if it were possible for him to know what sort of pseudoscience is being perpetrated by members of the faculty at the medical school bearing his name, would proceed to do backflips in his grave.
And, no, I guess I don’t want to live in New York that badly after all. In fact, I’m quite happy with my current position, and I wouldn’t fit in with the “holistic” approach at BIMC anyway. Besides, in the unlikely event I ever became disenchanted with my current job and decided to relocate again, I’d much rather move to Chicago than New York anyway. I’m a Midwest guy at heart.

   The Good Rewards of Bad Science
Ben Kavoussi
Link
All the world sees us
In grand style wherever we are;
The big and the small
Are infatuated with us:
They run to our remedies
And regard us as gods
And to our prescriptions
Principles and regimens, they submit themselves.
Molière, The Imaginary Invalid (1673)1
The passage above is part of a burlesque doctoral conferment ceremony, where the French playwright Molière (1622-1673) mocks the unscrupulous physicians of his time. “All the excellency of their art consists in pompous gibberish, in a specious babbling, which gives you words instead of reasons, and promises instead of results,” he writes. In Moliere’s plays doctors never cure anyone; they are put on stage just to display their own vanity and ignorance.2 The Spanish painter Francisco de Goya (1746-1828) also took on the same issue by painting in 1799 a well attired jackass taking the pulse of a dying man, in a pose that accentuates the large gem on his hoof.
Imge 1. De qué mal morirá (Of what illness will he die?) by Francisco de Goya is held at the Biblioteca Nacional, Madrid, and The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York.
But if the asinine doctors of Molière and de Goya’s time never cured anyone, it is because they held prescientific views, and believed that disease was caused by imbalances in “humors,” and by malefic influences of the Heavens. Even the most educated among them treated illnesses in good faith by purging, bloodletting and enema at astrologically auspicious times. In contrast, current physicians who for the sake of funding embrace and endorse unscientific views and practices under the guise of CAM or integrative medicine, do so knowing that they often contradict the established principles of physics, chemistry, and biology. Therefore, in addition to promoting “snake oil science”3 (as R. Barker Bausell calls it), these physicians are also guilty of bad faith. Most of this takes place at large academic centers, where funding seems to outweigh the concern for science. As Val Jones, MD, writes in 2009′s Top 5 Threats To Science In Medicine:
Often referred to by David Gorski as “Quackademic” Medical Centers – there is a growing trend among these centers to accept endowments for “integrative” approaches to medical care. Because of the economic realities of decreasing healthcare reimbursements – these once proud defenders of science are now accepting money to “study” implausible and often disproven medical treatments because they’re trendy. Scientists at these centers are forced to look the other way while patients (who trust the center’s reputation that took tens of decades to build) are exposed to placebo medicine under the guise of “holistic” healthcare.
A list of these centers, available at the Academic Woo Aggregator website, reveals the prestigious University of California (UC) as the most represented, with 3 centers: the UCSF Osher Center for Integrative Medicine; the Susan Samueli Center for Integrative Medicine at UC Irvine; and the Collaborative Centers for Integrative Medicine at UCLA, which includes the Center for East-West Medicine. The William R. Pritchard Veterinary Medical Teaching Hospital at UC Davis, with its Acupuncture and Traditional Chinese Veterinary Medicine (TCVM) clinic, should perhaps be added to the list.
Among them, UCSF’s Osher Center for Integrative Medicine has the largest funding, with a cumulative sum of over $28 million. Established in 1997 by the Dean Emeritus of the School of Medicine, Haile T. Debas, MD, and the very generous support of the Bernard Osher Foundation, the UCSF Center collaborates with Harvard University, and the Karolinska Institute in Stockholm.
Some of the “integrative” medicine research involves acupuncture, even if it might end up being a source of scientific embarrassment. Consider, for instance, the dubious research during the 1990s at UC Irvine by the physicist Zang-Hee Cho, who claimed to have in vivo evidence by fMRI for acupuncture’s putative effects. Cho and his colleagues published a series of papers, notably one in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS), where they claimed to have observed a correlation between the visual cortex and an acupuncture point on the toe. Based on this unconfirmed observation, they became persuaded that acupuncture involves the activation of the cortical region associated with the targeted organ.4 Cho went as far as claiming that the cortical activation depends on the subject’s personality type, which could be yin or yang! Fortunately, the PNAS article, which is often referenced by acupuncture apologists, was retracted in June 2006 by Cho himself and a number of its coauthors:
Accumulating evidence suggests that the central nervous system is essential for processing these effects, via its modulation of the autonomic nervous system, neuro-immune system, and hormonal regulation. We, therefore, carried out a series of studies questioning whether there really is point specificity in acupuncture, especially vis-à-vis pain and acupuncture analgesic effects as we originally reported in our PNAS article, that had not yet been confirmed by other studies… Having concluded that there is no point specificity, at least for pain and analgesic effects, and that we no longer agree with the results in our PNAS article, the undersigned authors are retracting the article.
Z. H. Cho
S. C. Chung
H. J. Lee
E. K. Wong
B. I. Min5
Cho has since left the University of California, and is now the Director of the Neuroscience Research Institute at Gachon University of Medicine and Science in Korea. However, his research lead to a $5.7 million gift to UC Irvine in 2000 by Henry and Susan Samueli to research acupuncture, herbal therapy, and the “Indian science of life,” Ayurveda. This funding was used to create the Susan Samueli Center for Integrative Medicine.
UCLA’s “integrative” medicine also involves acupuncture. Although several separate groups and individuals provide acupuncture at UCLA, most of it is now centralized at the Center for East-West Medicine, which was founded in 1993 by its current Director, Ka-Kit Hui, MD. The Center’s website states that in March 2005, the Annenberg Foundation awarded $2 million to UCLA to establish the Wallis Annenberg Endowed Chair in Integrative East-West Medicine. An additional $115,790 grant allowed for the creation of a “healing environment.” Meanwhile, the Center is using UCLA’s international fame to lend legitimacy to Chinese folk medicine. Take a peek at UCLA Today of Jun 17, 2010:
Representing a 5,000-year history of traditional Chinese medicine, Chinese Vice Minister of Health Dr. Wang Guoqiang and a six-person delegation came to campus June 11 to see what they could learn from UCLA, which has long been at the forefront of research in integrative medicine and education in the western world… The Chinese delegation, which had a four-day stay in the U.S., chose UCLA as the only academic medical center to visit to learn how traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) and integrative medicine are practiced as a new health care model… Wang is the highest-ranking official in China overseeing the development of Chinese medicine and integrated medicine.
Image 2. UCLA Vice Chancellor for Health Sciences, Dr. Eugene Washington (left); Chinese Vice Minister of Health, Dr. Wang Guoqiang; and Dr. Ka-Kit Hui, Director of the UCLA Center for East-West Medicine (right). Image Source: UCLA Today.
Now read the following grim news about UCLA’s budget, announced just three months before, which might put the arrival of the Chinese delegation in a whole new perspective. UCLA Today wrote on Feb 18, 2010 that:
In planning for next year’s budget, campus leaders believe that UCLA will face a permanent loss of $117 million in state funding for 2010-11, the same as in 2009-10, but with one difference. The $55 million cut that was made on a one-time basis in 2009-10 will become permanent… And although Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger seeks to restore the one-time $305 million reduction made to UC’s budget this fiscal year — $55 million of which was cut from UCLA’s budget — campus leaders said they are assuming that the State Legislature is going to reject his proposal.
With UCLA experiencing an unprecedented drop in state support, even snake oil science is welcomed, as long as it leads to further funding prospects. After all, as the Roman Emperor Vespasian once said: Pecunia non olet (money does not smell).
In my 2009 post Astrology with Needles, I presented images from European manuals of bloodletting, which clearly indicate that the acclaimed 5,000-year history of traditional Chinese medicine does not include acupuncture as we know it today. What the Chinese practiced is lancing and bloodletting with bodkins and lancets, which significantly resembled what Europeans and Muslims also practiced. This is why the venipuncture points portrayed in European medieval manuscripts significantly overlap with key points described in the Chinese classics. In addition, the evidence presented in my recent post, The Acupuncture and Fasciae Fallacy, shows that the tools described in the Chinese classics resemble fleams and other venipuncture instruments of medieval Europe, and have little resemblance to what is currently considered an acupuncture needle. This is because acupuncture with fine needles is a modern invention; one that was transformed from a side-lined practice of the early 20th-century to an essential and high-profile part of the national health-care system under the Chinese Communist Party.6
Finally, the visit of the Chinese delegation to UCLA reminds me of a 1998 French film called The Dinner Game (Le dîner de cons). In it, Pierre and his Parisian friends organize a dinner party each week, where everyone invites the most ridiculous character he can find, so they can all have a good time mocking him. But when Pierre invites François, who he thinks will steal the show, his clueless guest inadvertently exposes hidden and embarrassing aspects of Pierre’s life. The visitors that have come to UCLA to represent 5,000 years of hocus-pocus, and are eager to learn about an integrative medicine that is mainly a showcase to obtain funding, might have–like François–unknowingly exposed a mockery, and with it, a great charade.
REFERENCES:
1. Poqulin JB (Author), Frame DM (Translator, Introduction). The Misanthrope and Other Plays. Signet Classics. 1968. The quoted section was translated by Barbara J. Becker, PhD.
2. Livingston PN. Comic Treatment: Molière and the Farce of Medicine. Vol. 94, No. 4, French Issue: Perspectives in Mimesis (May, 1979), pp. 676-687.
3. Barker Bausell R. Snake Oil Science: The Truth about Complementary and Alternative Medicine. Oxford University Press. 1st edition. 2007.
4. Cho ZH, Chung SC, Jones JP, Park JB, Park HJ, Lee HJ, Wong EK, Min BI. New findings of the correlation between acupoints and corresponding brain cortices using functional MRI. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1998 Mar 3;95(5):2670-3.
5. Retraction in Cho ZH, Chung SC, Lee HJ, Wong EK, Min BI. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2006 Jul 5;103(27):1052.
6. Taylor K. Chinese Medicine in Early Communist China, 1945-1963: A Medicine of Revolution. Routledge. 2005.

   Be careful what you wish for, Dr. Dossey, you just might get it
David Gorski
Link
If there’s one thing about the so-called “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) movement that I’ve emphasized time and time again, it’s that its adherents have a definite love-hate relationship with science. They hate it because it is the single greatest threat to their beliefs system and the pseudoscience that underlies it. At the same time, they crave the legitimacy that science confers. They crave it not because they have any great love for science. Quite the contrary. It is simply that they recognize that science actually delivers the goods. Of course, they believe that they deliver the goods too, but they come to this belief not through science but rather through all the cognitive shortcomings and biases to which humans are prone, such as confusing correlation with causation, confirmation bias, not recognizing regression to the mean, and being fooled by the placebo effect. Whether it’s through a misunderstanding of science or less innocent reasons, they go to great lengths to torture it into superficially appearing to support their claims through a combination of cherry-picking of studies that seem to support them and misrepresenting ones that don’t, discussions of which abound right here in this very blog.
The other thing I’ve emphasized about the CAM movement is that, even more than scientific credibility, they crave legitimacy. To them, however, science is but one pathway to legitimacy, because, unlike practitioners of science-based medicine, they are more than willing to bypass science to obtain the legitimacy–or at least the appearance of the legitimacy–they so crave. If it means doing an end run around science by trying to hijack the Obama health insurance reform bill that is currently being negotiated to resolve the differences between the Senate and House versions, so be it. Indeed, earlier this year, I described how Senator Tom Harkin has tried to promote CAM through the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) and trying to insert provisions into the bill that would mandate that government-subsidized insurance exchanges pay for CAM. Meanwhile, prominent CAM advocates have been carpet-bombing the media with dubious arguments in support of CAM, as in when Deepak Chopra, Rustum Roy, Dean Ornish, and Andrew Weil teamed up in different combinations to promote the idea that CAM is all about “prevention” and that science-based medicine, in all its reductionistic evil, is nothing more than pushing pills.
They’re at it again.
This time around, Deepak Chopra and Rustum Roy have apparently ditched Andrew Weil, but their replacement, although not nearly as famous as Weil, is more than capable of holding up his part of the woo. I can only speculate that Andrew Weil, who is clearly one of the cleverest CAM advocates, recognized a loser argument when he saw it and declined to participate. No problem. They managed to sign up Dr. Larry Dossey, and the hostility towards science-based medicine flows apace without interruption. In fact, Dr. Dossey is more than “qualified” for this honor:
Dr. Larry Dossey is a former physician of internal medicine and former Chief of Staff of Medical City Dallas Hospital. He received his M. D. degree from Southwestern Medical School (Dallas), and trained in internal medicine at Parkland and the VA hospitals in Dallas. Dossey has lectured at medical schools and hospitals throughout the United States and abroad. In 1988 he delivered the annual Mahatma Gandhi Memorial Lecture in New Delhi, India, the only physician ever invited to do so. He is the author of ten books dealing with consciousness, spirituality, and healing, including the New York Times bestseller HEALING WORDS: THE POWER OF PRAYER AND THE PRACTICE OF MEDICINE, most recently THE POWER OF PREMONITIONS. Dr. Dossey is the former co-chairman of the Panel on Mind/Body Interventions, National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, National Institutes of Health. He is the executive editor of the peer-reviewed journal EXPLORE: The Journal of Science and Healing. Dr. Dossey lectures around the world. He lives in Santa Fe with his wife Barbara, who is a nurse-consultant and the author of several award-winning books.
So Dossey’s the executive editor of EXPLORE? Truly, the woo is strong in this one. Remember, EXPLORE is the “journal” that publishes allegedly scientific papers on topics such as “distant healing” in cancer patients and, even more hilariously, imbuing chocolate with “intent.” His editorial standards, suffice it to say, do not impress me. However, he’s just the man for the job of helping Deepak Chopra and Rustum Roy launch what is nothing more than an all-out attack on science-based medicine in an article that is breathtaking in its concentration of logical fallacies and its naked hostility towards science-based medicine entitled The Mythology Of Science-Based Medicine (crossposted on Deepak Chopra’s very own Intent Blog). It appears in that repository of quackery, woo, and pseudoscience, The Huffington Post. This article is depressingly similar to an article that was published in the Wall Street Journal almost exactly a year ago, even recycling some of the same dubious arguments.
The article is an exercise that combines cherry-picking, logical fallacies, and whining, raising the last of these almost to an art form. It begins with a false dichotomy:
The current healthcare debate has brought up basic questions about how medicine should work. On one hand we have the medical establishment with its enormous cadre of M.D.s, medical schools, big pharma, and incredibly expensive hospital care. On the other we have the semi-condoned field of alternative medicine that attracts millions of patients a year and embraces literally thousands of treatment modalities not taught in medical school.
Note the dichotomy. To Dossey, Chopra, and Roy, it’s all “big pharma” and incredibly expensive hospital care versus the “thousands of treatment modalities not taught in medical school”; i.e., big medicine, big pharma, and technology versus “natural cures.” If there’s one thing boosters of unscientific and pseudoscientific treatments want, it’s to be viewed as on par with science-based medicine, as an “alternative” but equal system. Framing the issue this way from the first paragraph is likely an intentional strategy to implant right from the beginning in the reader’s brain that there really is a dichotomy. Actually, I’ve argued time and time again that the entire concept of “alternative medicine” versus science-based medicine is a false dichotomy. There is no such thing as “alternative medicine.” Well, actually, there is, but by definition “alternative” medicine is medicine that either hasn’t been scientifically validated and shown to work or medicine that has been shown not to work. “Alternative medicine” that is shown to be effective and safe through science ceases to be “alternative” and becomes just “medicine.” If Dossey, Chopra, and Roy could show that their preferred nostrums work through science, I’d happily add them to the armamentarium of science-based medicine. In fact, they’d become science-based medicine! That brings me to another issue, the massive straw man behind this article:
When scientific minds turn to tackling the complex business of healing the sick, they simultaneously warn us that it’s dangerous and foolish to look at integrative medicine, complementary and alternative medicine, or God forbid, indigenous medicine for answers. Because these other modalities are enormously popular, mainstream medicine has made a few grudging concessions to the placebo effect, natural herbal remedies, and acupuncture over the years. But M.D.s are still taught that other approaches are risky and inferior to their own training; they insist, year after year, that all we need are science-based procedures and the huge spectrum of drugs upon which modern medicine depends.
If a pill or surgery won’t do the trick, most patients are sent home to await their fate. There is an implied faith here that if a new drug manufacturer has paid for the research for FDA approval, then it is scientifically proven to be effective. As it turns out, this belief is by no means fully justified.
I like the bit about “grudging concession to placebo effect.” In reality, I think that’s a huge case of projection. CAM relies almost exclusively on the placebo effect, and only recently has grudgingly started to attempt to include placebo controls. The plethora of acupuncture studies with sham acupuncture where the results show that sham acupuncture is just as effective as “real” acupuncture are more than enough evidence of that. Acupuncturists don’t like it, though, because they don’t like being shown that their woo is no more effective than a placebo, and they certainly don’t like being shown that it doesn’t matter where you stick the needles (making the acupuncture concept of “meridians” meaningless) or that it doesn’t even matter whether needles pierce the skin. The bottom line is that science-based medicine has incorporated placebos into its clinical trials for decades now. It’s CAM that’s late to the game, and its practitioners don’t much like how, when valid placebo controls are included, almost inevitably it’s found that the vast majority of CAM procedures don’t do any better than a placebo.
Then there’s the straw man. Dossey et al seem to be claiming that science-based medicine practitioners show disdain for “alternative” medicine. In any case, note the subtle use of the word “procedures.” Not “treatments.” Not “medicines.” Not “therapies.” Procedures. Note how that is then juxtaposed against “alternative medicine” or “indigenous medicine.” This framing intentionally makes another false dichotomy: Between “procedures” of science-based medicine and the nice, fuzzy, happy “treatments” of alt-med. And, of course, they’re “enormously popular,” leading to the classic logical fallacy of argumentum ad populum.
More annoying is Dr.Dossey’s nonsense about medicine being unrelentingly hostile to alt-med. In fact, in a case of being so open-minded that its brains are falling out, academic medicine is embracing woo wholesale. How many times have I complained about just that right here on this blog, be it about NCCAM wasting $120 million of taxpayer money every year studying woo or the infiltration of woo into academic medical centers? The problem isn’t that “mainstream medicine” is hostile to alt-med. It used to be, but no more. The problem is that, at the same time mainstream medicine is promoting “evidence-based” medicine, it is also embracing non-evidence-based medicine. It is embracing a “more fluid concept of evidence” in order to allow CAM to obtain legitimacy.
The next part of the article consists of a whole lot of special pleading, topped off with some serious cherry-picking and deception by omission. First up, Dossey et al make a huge deal out of the British Medical Journal‘s attempt to evaluate mainstream medical treatments and determine which ones have solid evidence to support them. Unfortunately, I do not have access to the website, and neither does my institution; so I can’t evaluate much of it. From what I could evaluate, Dossey et al make much of the observation that 46% of treatments were “unknown” in their effectiveness or that, if you believe BMJ‘s analysis, only 36% are likely to help. Even if this were true, I notice one glaring omission. Notice how Dossey et al don’t mention comparable numbers for their treatments. Even if scientific medicine performed this poorly, it’s virtually certain that alt-med performs far more poorly. Moreover, I’d be willing to bet that the evidence base in favor of the woo that Dr. Dossey favors is pathetic in comparison to that supporting science-based medicine. In other words, this is a massive case of the pot calling the kettle black, except that the kettle isn’t even black in this case.
I also notice another glaring omission in this statement:
This left the largest category, 46 percent, as unknown in their effectiveness. In other words, when you take your sick child to the hospital or clinic, there is only a 36 percent chance that he will receive a treatment that has been scientifically demonstrated to be either beneficial or likely to be beneficial. This is remarkably similar to the results Dr. Brian Berman found in his analysis of completed Cochrane reviews of conventional medical practices. There, 38 percent of treatments were positive and 62 percent were negative or showed “no evidence of effect.”
There’s a huge and deceptive assumption behind this rather amazing claim. Can you see what it is? It’s the assumption that all these treatments are equivalent in terms of how common they are and how common the diseases and conditions for which each therapy is designed are. If that were true, then one could conclude what Dossey et al just concluded. But it’s not. Some conditions are far more common than others and are far more studied than others. If, for instance, a child is brought to the ER with the classic history, symptoms, and signs of appendicitis, it’s far more than a 36% chance that the intervention (an appendectomy) will take care of the problem. In fact, it’s close to 100%.
Dossey et al then start to get sloppy with their claims:
We all marvel at the technological advances in materials and techniques that allow doctors to perform quadruple bypass surgeries and angioplasties without marveling that recent studies indicate that coronary bypass surgery will extend life expectancy in only about three percent of cases. For angioplasty that figure sinks to zero percent. Those numbers might be close to what you could expect from a witch doctor, one difference being that witch doctors don’t submit bills in the tens of thousands of dollars.
Wow! Dossey compared us practitioners of science-based medicine to witch doctors. The wag in me can’t resist pointing out that the CAM crowd includes actual witch doctors in its ranks.
In any case, this is the study to which Dossey is referring. However, it is not exactly as Dossey represents it, as you can see if you read the abstract. I’ll paraphrase what I said before about it the last time Deepak Chopra and his merry band of woo-meisters abused this study for their ends. What this particular study did was to compare one science-based percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI, otherwise known as angioplasty) with another science-based medical therapy, namely optimal medical therapy plus PCI. Again, let me hammer home the point that both sets of interventions are science-based and not in any way “alternative.” The study concluded that adding PCI to medical therapy with drugs and diet only provided 3% additional benefit in terms of survival. Also note how Dossey et al, as Deepak Chopra did last year, misrepresents one conclusion of the study by claiming that coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgery prolongs life in only 3% of those who receive it as though that was a conclusion of the study. It wasn’t, and, as Chopra didn’t cite his source last time, Dossey et al don’t cite their source this time. (That this error is repeated makes me think that Chopra probably wrote this section of this article.) In any case, what Dossey et al also fail to mention was that patients in the PCI plus medical intervention group required fewer procedures (32% of the medical therapy required additional revascularization procedures to 21.1% of the PCI/medical therapy group at 4.6 years) and a higher likelihood of being free from angina, albeit modest (42% versus 36% at 5 years). Moreover, Dossey et al conveniently forget to mention that these results were derived from studying patients with stable coronary artery disease, not with unstable angina. They are not in any way blanket evidence that “angioplasty and CABG don’t prolong life.”
Dossey et al do a bit of similar prestidigitation by citing a meta-analysis and characterizing it as concluding that antidepressants don’t work:
The theory behind standard antidepression medication is that the disease is caused by low levels of key brain chemicals like serotonin, dopamine, and norepinephrine, and thus by manipulating those imbalanced neurotransmitters, a patient’s depression will be reversed or at least alleviated.
This turns out to be another myth. Prof. Eva Redei of Northwestern University, a leading depression researcher, has discovered that depressed individuals have no depletion of the genes that produce these key neurotransmitters compared to people who are not depressed. This would help explain why an estimated 50 percent of patients don’t respond to antidepressants, and why Dr. Irving Kirsch’s meta-analysis of antidepressants in England showed no significant difference in effectiveness between them and placebos.
Dr. Dossey needs to learn proper scientific terminology. It’s breathtakingly sad that an the journal editor of an allegedly scientific journal would confuse genes, which are the DNA that codes for proteins, with the gene products (namely the proteins themselves) so carelessly. You can’t “deplete” genes, at least not in humans. (Knockout mice are another issue, but that takes genetically engineering and breeding a new mouse strain.) You can deplete gene products, but not genes. Dossey et al thus show a complete lack of understanding of how cDNA microarray studies are performed and analyzed, which hardly gives me much confidence in the rest of their analysis. In any case, I find it curious how Dossey characterizes the Kirsch meta-analysis as saying just that “antidepressants don’t work.” There may be evidence that this is true for patients with mild to moderate depression, for severe depression even the meta-analysis cited supports the efficacy of anti-depressants, albeit more weakly than previously believed.
Finally, of course, the ever popular “medicine kills lots and lots of people” claim, so beloved of quacks like Gary Null and discussed by our very own Harriet Hall in 2008, rears its ugly head. (I loved how Harriet compared the “death by medicine” claims to “death by food.”) First, there’s the claim that “Dr. Barbara Starfield, writing in the Journal of the American Medical Association, estimated that between 230,000 and 284,000 deaths occur each year in the US due to iatrogenic causes, or physician error, making this number three in the leading causes of death for all Americans.” Quite frankly, this figure has actually always bothered me, as it’s clearly the highest of the usual apocalyptic estimates for how many people doctors supposedly kill through error or negligence, and the reason is simple math. Each and every year in the U.S., approximately 2.5 million people die. If Dr. Starfield is to be believed, approximately 10% of all deaths are from iatrogenic causes, which would make iatrogenic death the third leading cause of deaths in the U.S. after heart disease and cancer.
Patients in hospitals tend to be sick and more prone to complications, otherwise they wouldn’t be in the hospital, and hospitals do have systemic problems. For instance, Starfield counts 80,000 deaths from nosocomial infections in hospitals. Nosocomial infections (hospital-acquired infections) are a big problem, no doubt, but lumping them in with medical error is rather questionable. Many nosocomial infections can’t be prevented easily and are not the fault of the physicians treating the patient. (Many can be, however, the most striking example of which is a recent study showing how a checklist before inserting a central line leading the physician through careful, sterile technique can dramatically decrease the number of catheter-associated infections.)
Similar considerations apply to non-error adverse reactions, which are said to claim 100,000 deaths a year. Remember, these were not medicines given in error. They were medicines given for correct clinical indications that happened to produce an adverse reaction. Again, in very ill hospitalized patients on multiple powerful medications, the likelihood of this happening increases. Consider the example of aminoglycoside antibiotics. These are used for very serious infections, but they produce a risk of renal failure, and renal failure can be life-threatening, particularly if added onto other organ system failures. Yet, if a critically ill patient has a serious infections, sometimes you have to bite the bullet and give them Tobramycin or Gentamycin. At least, we didn’t back when I was a resident. Fortunately today, thanks to science-based medicine, there are less toxic alternatives. The point remains, however. Consider another example: Cytotoxic chemotherapy. If a patient comes in with acute leukemia, he is likely to die if not treated. However, the medicines used to treat acute leukemia are toxic and can cause complications that will kill the patient, such as severe neutropenia and its attendant immunosuppression. Yet the patient will surely die without treatment, and the drugs save far more people than they kill; so the benefits outweigh the risks and we treat with these drugs — and, these days, we do it with careful informed consent. In other words, to compare these apocalyptic numbers honestly, you have to look at them in comparison to the number of lives saved every year by scientific medicine. In other words, as Peter Lipson put it, you have to compare the risks versus the benefits:
But there is a more important fact that should keep you from being scared away from real medicine.
Advances in the treatment of coronary artery disease, the number one killer of Americans, reduced the number of deaths by over 340,000 in 2000 alone. And that’s just one disease.
So, in one year, medical errors may cause a few tens of thousands of deaths (and these are preventable deaths), but real medicine, in one disease alone, saves an order of magnitude more.
And, as Harriet Hall put it:
Drug reactions? All effective drugs also have side effects. It’s meaningless to count the side effects without counting the benefits. An insulin reaction counts as an adverse drug reaction, but if the patient weren’t taking insulin he probably wouldn’t be alive to have a reaction. Some of the counted drug reactions are transient minor annoyances like a rash. People have iatrogenic infections in the hospital, for instance post-op infections; but without hospitalization and surgery they might have been dead instead of infected.
Iatrogenic deaths? How many of those were of people who would have died many years earlier without modern medical care? How many of those iatrogenic causes were high-risk treatments in high-risk patients who had no other option?
Let’s take another example. I’m a surgeon. Although I haven’t taken general surgery call for over a decade now and have subspecialized, I did used to do trauma and general surgery call, however, and as recently as two years ago I did surgical oncology call in a hospital where the medical oncologists didn’t call the general surgeons whenever general surgery problems cropped up in their cancer patients. They called us. The effect, as I used to joke, was that when I was called for a patient with a hot gallbladder, it wouldn’t be the straightforward patient with cholecystitis; it would inevitably be a septic patient in the bone marrow transplant unit on a ventilator with no white blood cells and no platelets — in other words, very high risk patients. If I operated on such a patient and he died within 30 days or before getting out of the hospital, that counts as a postoperative mortality; i.e., an “iatrogenic” death. Yet, that patient would surely have died without surgery; surgery would be his only chance of survival. Moreover, going upstream to the patient’s original chemotherapy, which is what likely rendered his bone marrow so suppressed, the patient would surely die without chemotherapy. Chemotherapy, which has the risk of fatal bone marrow suppression, is his only chance at survival, contrary to what certain cancer quacks I’ve lambasted on this blog may say. None of the statistics cited by Dossey et al take any of this into consideration; without that information we’re left with large numbers whose significance is unclear. Moreover, when criticized for these lapses with regard to the Starfield article and the selective representation of two studies in their original blog post, they posted a follow-up in which they basically regurgitated the same points about the Starfield article and completely ignored the criticisms of how they misused the angioplasty study and the antidepressant meta-analysis.
Don’t get me wrong. We ought to be doing everything we can to decrease complications and death due to medical errors. The Institute of Medicine suggests the number may be from 44,000 to 98,000. By any measure this is far too many, but remember this: it wasn’t Chopra, Dossey, Roy, or any of the other celebrity physicians promoting alternative medicine or the promoters of alt-med who did the studies to derive these estimates. It was science-based physicians trying to improve the practice of medicine, and there is nothing even coming close to a similar data set maintained by alt-med practitioners.
Dossey and pals then finish up with a heaping helping of straw man, trying to outdo our previous pyromaniac in a field of straw men with this claim:
You have a right to be shocked by these findings and by the overall picture of a system that benefits far fewer patients than it claims. The sad fact is that a disturbing percentage of the medicine we subject ourselves to isn’t based on hard science, and another percentage is risky or outright harmful. Obviously, every patient deserves medical care that is evidence-based, not just based on an illusory reputation that is promoted in contrast to alternative medicine.
Do I detect the scent of burning martyr here?
Promoters of science-based medicine do not deny that there is a disturbingly high proportion of medicine practiced that is not based on firm science and evidence. It’s not as high a percentage as woo promoters like Dossey like to exaggerate it to be, but it is too high. In fact, that’s one of the very reasons we promote science-based medicine, because we believe, based on what we think is good evidence, that more SBM will decrease those complication rates and rates of iatrogenic injury and death while increasing the likelihood of doing good. In other words, we’d like to shrink that percentage to as close to zero as is feasible.
Of course, another element to this highly disingenuous response is, I suspect, that Dr. Dossey is conflating dismissing a treatment based on prior scientific probability as being so incredibly unlikely to work that it is not worth testing anymore (homeopathy, of course, comes to mind right away as one of the best examples) with “dismissing out of hand.” A commenter by the ‘nym “anxiousmedic” put it well in the comments of a follow-up post when he pointed out that “the interventions used in modern medicine are not practiced because doctors saw them in a dream one night” and that “physiology, genetics, the germ theory etc. all point to interventions which are more plausible than others.” Indeed, there is a pathway to discovering what “works” in medicine that begins with basic science. Let’s take the example of homeopathy again. For homeopathy to “work,” our understanding of huge swaths of well-established science in physics, chemistry, and biochemistry would have to be shown not just to be in error, but in massive error. For remedies diluted and succussed to the point that not even a single molecule is likely to remain, water would have to have a magical “memory” that remembered the remedy and, as Tim Minchin so brilliantly put it, forgets all the poo that it’s been in contact with. To overcome such massive amounts of evidence and science and lead scientists to start to think that the principles of homeopathy might have something to them would require compelling evidence at least somewhere within an order of magnitude in quality and quantity of the evidence showing that homeopathy can’t work. Dubious studies in cells and occasional clinical trials showing effects barely distinguishable from placebo responses that could easily be due to random chance alone do not qualify as being sufficient in quantity or quality to overturn the two hundred years of physics and chemistry since Samuel Hahnemann first conceived the idea of homeopathy.
Dossey et al then conclude with a statement that I can totally agree with, just not in the way they think:
We are not suggesting that Americans adopt any and all alternative practices simply because they are alternative. These, too, must demonstrate their effectiveness through objective testing. But alternative modalities should not be dismissed out of hand in favor of expensive and unnecessary procedures that have been shown to benefit no one absolutely except corporate stockholders.
This, too, is a straw man. We do not “dismiss out of hand” alt-med modalities, nor has the criticism of CAMsters like Dr. Dossey based on thinking that they are “suggesting that Americans adopt any and all alternative practices because they are alternative.” In fact, as has been documented on this very blog time and time again, NCCAM spends $120 million a year studying and — yes, promoting — these modalities. Hospitals are rushing to add “integrative” and CAM programs to their portfolios. Given how little evidence supports these modalities, I’m sure that The Cherrypickers Three would be happy to join me in condemning this push to fund useless studies that waste taxpayer money and as yet have produced nothing of value, to teach non-evidence-based woo in medical schools (even Harvard) and residency, and to offer non-science-based (at this time) treatments. (I won’t hold my breath waiting.)
I also find it highly disingenuous of Dr. Dossey to claim that they are not promoting any particular alternative therapies. Deepak Chopra is most definitely promoting his “quantum consciousness” nonsense and many CAM modalities, and Rustum Roy promotes homeopathy every chance he gets (hence my choice of homeopathy as an example of a therapy with nearly zero prior probability). Dr. Dossey himself in his books promotes something he calls “Era III medicine (nonlocal medicine),” which “incorporates all the benefits and warnings we have gleaned from intensified understanding of the effects of prayer and intention,” as well as “distant healing.”
Let’s put it this way. If a reader knew nothing about Dossey, Chopra, and Roy, that reader might believe their claims that they aren’t promoting any particular “alt-med” treatment. But this reader does know a bit about these three, and he can Google. In context, we have three people who elsewhere are actively promoting “alternative” medicine modalities teaming up to write an article attacking promoters of science-based medicine for dismissing CAM based on science. Moreover, the article’s entire argument can be boiled down to: “Science-based medicine has a lot of problems and does a lot of harm; so don’t dismiss our woo as being ‘unscientific.’” Sorry, but that’s a non sequitur. Whether SBM has problems and even if the apocalyptic figures cited by Dossey et al were exactly correct, that SBM is not sufficiently science-based does not mean that any of the alt-med modalities promoted by Dossey and his merry band are science-based. Even if the British Medical Journal estimates are correct and 46% of treatments have unknown efficacy when subjected to stringent science, I’d be willing to bet that the equivalent number for CAM modalities is south of 1%.
That’s why, if Dr. Dossey wants us to compare science-based medicine with “alternative medicine,” then I daresay that I speak for everyone here at SBM when I say, “Bring it, dude!” In fact, right here, right now, I challenge Dr. Dossey to live up to his own words in the comments:
We are not promoting any particular alternative therapy. We are promoting a level playing field for the evaluation of ALL therapies and the abandonment of the double standard that now exists, as we described. We are promoting a ruthless adherence to science and objective methods of evaluation. We are promoting an elevation of the standards of efficacy and safety for ALL treatments, whatever they may be.
All of us here at SBM have argued time and time again for a level playing field for the evaluation of all medical treatment modalities, whatever they may be and from wherever they may have been derived. Certainly, I have. The problem, of course, is that CAM is actually being given a free ride, being introduced into hospitals on the basis of nonexistent evidence or the thinnest of evidence. It’s being taught in medical schools and residency programs even though the evidence base to support doing so is just not there. Meanwhile, NCCAM spends $120 million dollars a year studying CAM not based on compelling evidence, but rather the advocacy of a woo-friendly Senator, and provisions mandating reimbursement for modalities not validated by science are being inserted into health care reform legislation, again, thanks to woo-friendly legislators.
Dr. Dossey just spent two articles whining that his beloved CAM is being treated so very, very unfairly by promoters of science-based medicine, but from my viewpoint it’s being treated more than fairly these days; it’s being given a free pass, by and large. Again, that’s why I’ll repeat it one more time. If Dr. Dossey really wants CAM to be evaluated on a truly equal scientific footing with science-based medicine, I have one thing to say to him one last time:
Bring it on!
Oh, and that Dr. Dossey might want to be careful what he wishes for. He might just get it. At least, I sincerely hope he does.

   “Integrative” oncology: Trojan horse, quackademic medicine, or both?
David Gorski
LInk
One of the main topics that we’ve covered here on this blog over the last couple of years is the relatively rapid, seemingly relentless infiltration of pseudoscience into what should be bastions of science-based medicine (SBM), namely medical schools and academic medical centers promoted by academics who should, but apparently don’t, know better. From the very beginning, we’ve written numerous posts about this infiltration and how it has been facilitated by a variety of factors, including changes in the culture of medical academia and our own culture in general, not to mention a dedicated cadre of ideologues such as the Bravewell Collaboration, whose purpose is to blur the lines between science and pseudoscience and promote the “integration” of quackery into science-based medicine. Certainly promoters of what Dr. Robert W. Donnell termed “quackademic medicine” wouldn’t put it that way, but I would. Indeed, promoters of quackademic medicine scored a major victory last month, when a credulous piece of tripe about acupuncture passing as a review article managed to find its way into the New England Journal Medicine, a misstep that was promptly skewered by Mark Crislip, Steve Novella, and myself. It’s rare for more than two of us to write about the same topic, but it was earned by a mistake as dire as the editors of the NEJM allowing rank pseudoscience to sully its normally science-based pages.
Today, I want to riff a bit on one aspect of this phenomenon. As a cancer surgeon, I’ve dedicated myself to treating patients with cancer and then subspecialized even further, dedicating myself to the surgical treatment of breast cancer. Consequently, the interface of so-called “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) in the treatment of cancer both interests and appalls me. The reason for my horror at the application of CAM to cancer patients, as you might expect, is that cancer is a disease that is highly feared and can be highly deadly, depending upon the specific kind of cancer. Cancer patients deserve nothing less than the best science-based evidence that we have to offer, free of pseudoscience. Yet in even the most highly respected cancer centers, such as M.D. Anderson Cancer Center and Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, there are departments or divisions of what is increasingly called “integrative oncology.” The claim behind “integrative oncology” is that it is “integrating the best of science-based and ‘alternative’ medicine,” but in reality all too often it is “integrating” quackery with science-based medicine. I have yet to hear an explanation of how “integrating” pseudoscience or nonscience into science-based oncology benefits cancer patients, but, then, that’s probably just the nasty old reductionist in me. Let’s find out.
“Integrative oncology”
I was reminded by the level of “progress” in integrating woo into oncology last week when the July 25 issue of HemeOnc Today showed up. Right there on the front page I saw a story Integrative oncology combines conventional, CAM therapies, with a subtitle reading “This growing medical discipline incorporates methods such as yoga, acupuncture and stress management.” And so it does. But I worry that that’s just the beginning:
The National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine defines integrative medicine as treatment that combines conventional medicine with complementary and alternative therapies that have been reported to be safe and effective after being studied in patients.
Lorenzo Cohen, MD, PhD, of M.D. Anderson Cancer Center is conducting a phase 3 trial of the effects of yoga on women with breast cancer.
“Integrative medicine is a philosophy based on treating patients by focusing on the whole person and using both conventional and complementary therapies in a multidisciplinary care fashion,” Lorenzo Cohen, MD, PhD, director and professor of the Integrative Medicine Program at The University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, told HemOnc Today.
“It is similar to complementary medicine, but one key difference is that there is an open communication between practitioners of the different traditions,” he said.
“Between the traditions”? Note the clever use of language that Kimball Atwood is so fond of pointing out. Note how Dr. Cohen equates “conventional” and “alternative” therapies (the latter of which he calls “complementary”) as though they had equal validity and equal efficacy. It’s just two different traditions! What’s the problem with bringing them together, and integrating one into the other? It’s the best of both worlds, right?
Also notice another thing. I’ve referred to certain aspects of CAM, sometimes called “integrative medicine” (IM) and, in this case called “integrative oncology” (IO), as a “Trojan horse” to bring woo into medical schools and academic medical centers. Most — but not all — academic medical centers do not use hard core quackery like homeopathy, although many appear to be using a modality just as bad, reiki, which happens to be Dr. Mehmet Oz’s favorite modality. In any case, whenever you see discussions of “integrative medicine” and in particular “integrative oncology,” chances are, the modalities discussed generally include yoga, various dietary modalities, exercise, and, quite frequently, acupuncture. Sometimes, they include various herbal remedies. In other words, “integrative oncology” rebrands modalities that have no reason not to be counted as part of science-based medicine as “alternative” or “integrative” and points to them as having some promise. They then lump together pseudoscience like reiki and acupuncture with the rebranded modalities, such as herbal therapies. This story demonstrates exactly what I mean in this passage:
According to Cohen, integrative medicine includes a plethora of therapies and methods but can be most easily classified into five categories: biologically based therapies, mind/body medicine, manipulative body-based practices, energy medicine and whole medical systems.
Biologically based therapies include ingestibles such as herbs and supplements, megadoses of vitamins or specialized diets. Mind/body medicine consists of techniques that typically help with stress management. These techniques include meditation, yoga, guided imagery and other forms of relaxation, according to Cohen. Manipulative body-based practices include therapies such as massage, medical acupuncture and chiropractic work.
The most controversial area of integrative medicine, according to Cohen, is energy medicine, which includes techniques such as healing touch, Reiki, a Japanese form of energy healing, or the use of magnets for healing. Healing touch techniques such as Reiki and Qigong, an ancient Chinese healing therapy, are based on the theory that human beings are energetic bodies and certain individuals with specific training can emit energy into another person for therapeutic purpose.
I realize that HemeOnc Today isn’t the NEJM, but on the other hand, given how the NEJM recently fell for the pseudoscience that is acupuncture, maybe they aren’t so different after all. In any case, this entire article is the sort of credulous treatment that drives me crazy, particularly the last paragraph quoted above. Energy medicine isn’t just “controversial”: it’s quackery, pure and simple, and Dr. Cohen should know that. The best that can be said about so-called “energy medicine” is that it is religion, not science, or that the various modalities that fall under the rubric of “energy medicine” are based on a prescientific understanding of how the human body works and how diseases attack it. Some of them are not even “ancient.” Reiki, for instance, only dates back to 1922. It was invented by a man named Mikao Usui, who wanted to find out how Jesus healed the sick. His answer, reiki, is no more than faith healing; the only difference between it and what Benny Hinn does is that reiki is based on Eastern mysticism instead of Christian faith. None of this discussion of “energetic bodies” and the claims that practitioners can either channel some form of “universal energy” or manipulate the flow of human “life energy” for therapeutic intent belongs in science-based medicine, at least until someone can characterize the claimed energy and actually show that these practitioners can actually do anything other than wave their hands over patients.
Cohen also speaks of “whole medical systems.” In other words he refers to ancient medical systems, such as traditional Chinese medicine and Ayurvedic medicine, characterizing them as having “their own methods and techniques for diagnosing patients, prescribing treatments and following patients over time.” That much is certainly true, but none of these techniques were based on science, either. They were based on much the same thoughts that early “Western” medicine was based on. After all, when you come right down to it, “balancing” or “adjusting” the flow of qi is not that different than the idea that the four humors must be balanced or that disease comes from “contamination” due to miasmas. As Ben Kavoussi has pointed out, there isn’t that much difference between the concepts used to justify blood letting as a treatment for disease. Yet, somehow “integrative medicine” and CAM love modalities based on Eastern mysticism. Where’s the love for black bile, yellow bile, phlegm, and blood, which make just as much sense, from a science-based standpoint as the concept of qi? In fact, they make more sense, because they, at least, exist and can be observed.
The Trojan horse
Time and time again, when I observe integrative oncology programs, I notice that many of them heavily emphasize modalities like diet and exercise. Indeed, in the HemeOnc Today article, the various advocates and “experts” in integrative oncology emphasized time and time modalities like yoga:
Karen Mustian, PhD, MPH, assistant professor of radiation oncology and preventive medicine at the University of Rochester Medical Center, discussed the findings of a yoga study at the 2010 ASCO Annual Meeting, held in Chicago in June.
Researchers enrolled 410 survivors of non-metastatic disease who participated in the Yoga for Cancer Survivors program. Survivors reported suffering from moderate or severe sleep disruption 2 months to 24 months after completing adjuvant therapy.
The participants were assigned to breathing exercises, 18 gentle Hatha and restorative yoga postures and meditation for 4 weeks with twice-weekly sessions.
Patients practicing yoga had greater improved sleep quality (22% vs. 12%), decreased incidence of clinically impaired sleep (31% vs. 16%) and less daytime sleepiness (29% vs. 5%) compared with those who did not practice yoga.
Adding to these findings, a study of the effects of yoga on women with breast cancer is also in the works. In April, Cohen received a $4.5 million grant to conduct a phase 3 trial in women with breast cancer to determine the improvement in physical function and quality of life during and after radiation treatment.
The results of the study presented at ASCO described above are, of course, utterly unsurprising. Would anyone expect that gentle exercise and meditation would harm quality of life and sleep quality? My guess is that substituting gentle exercise and prayer or non-yoga meditation would likely produce the same result. But yoga is “Eastern,” so it’s automatically way more cool than “Western” exercises. In any case, I bet I could save the NIH $4.5 million by predicting the results of Dr. Cohen’s study. Yes, yoga very likely will be found to improve physical functioning and quality of life, because, by and large, it is relatively gentle, low-impact flexibility exercise. In fact, in women who have undergone axillary dissection (removal of the lymph nodes under their arms), I would predict that yoga probably will decrease the incidence of impaired range of motion. The reason I make this latter prediction is because I already prescribe gentle stretching exercises to women who have undergone axillary surgery because it does decrease the incidence of impairments in range of motion. In fact, I would go so far as to predict that virtually any low impact exercise, be it yoga, Tai Chi, or simply low impact “Western” forms of exercise, such as walking and stretching, would produce the same results.
Oddly enough, I have been unaware of any investigators being awarded $4.5 million to study whether walking preceded by some gentle “limbering up” has all these effects in cancer patients. Why is that? This is the sort of stuff that is well-within the purview of science-based medicine, leading me to ask: Since when did exercise become “alternative” or “integrative”? Dr. Cohen’s study compares yoga versus “stretching/relaxation” (which is what I thought much of yoga was; so I’m not sure what the difference is) versus a wait list control group. So my being unaware of such a study is at an end, because apparently that’s just what Dr. Cohen will study. But does anyone think that the NIH would have funded such a study if it were about exercise and relaxation rather than yoga? My prediction for the outcome: the first two groups will both do better than the control group in terms of the outcome measures. I also wonder why on earth it will take $4.5 million and five years to answer this question. In any case, given the copious science already demonstrating that low impact exercise results in better quality of life outcomes for cancer patients, I would question the value, the “bang for the buck,” of spending $4.5 million in order to study an “alternative” or “complementary” therapy that is nothing more than a fancy form of stretching exercises and relaxation, the former of which is already known to be of benefit in cancer patients undergoing chemotherapy, surgery, and radiation. Surely such a study could be done for $1 million? Heck, for $4.5 million, I could start up a multi-investigator P01 with teams of investigators doing heavy duty basic science.
I know, I know. Sour apples. I really am in the wrong business.
The HemeOnc Today article, as credulous as it is, though, is merely an indication of just how far the concept of “integrative oncology” has gone. To appreciate just how far it has gone, I thought I’d peruse the websites of what are commonly accepted as two of the most respected institutions devoted to cancer in the United States, if not the world.
“Integrative oncology” invades and metastasizes
“Inspired” by the HemeOnc Today article, I decided to peruse the “integrative oncology” website of one of the two premier cancer centers in the country, that of the M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, as well as to take a peak at what the National Cancer Institute website says about various “alternative,” “complementary,” or “integrative” modalities. What many readers may not know is that the NCI has an Office of Cancer Complementary and Alternative Medicine (OCCAM, perhaps the most unfortunate acronym ever, given what it stands for). Moreover, OCCAM has a budget that is of approximately the same magnitude as that of the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM), in the range of $121 million a year. Thus, OCCAM is potentially as large a force in studying and promoting CAM as NCCAM has ever been.
Let’s start with M.D. Anderson first. On its website, it has a webpage called Complementary/Integrative Medicine Education Resources (CIMER). On the CIMER webpage, perhaps the most telling and useful “resource” is a page on therapies. On this page are links to several review articles authored by CIMER staff and physicians in the Integrative Medicine Program of the M.D. Anderson Cancer Center.
Whenever I take a look at a cancer center’s website, I go straight for the most hard core quackery to see what it says about it. Usually, I go straight for homeopathy. If a website concludes anything other than that homeopathy is pure quackery and that there is not a single molecule of active substance in most true hemopathic remedies (the dilution and succussion process having diluted it to nothing), then I know I’m dealing with quackademic medicine. Here’s an excerpt from what the great M.D. Anderson says about homeopathy:
The practice of homeopathy is based on its “law of similars” which proposes that “like cures like”. That is, a substance that causes specific symptoms in a healthy person is believed to ultimately relieve those same symptoms in a sick person. A few homeopathic physicians treat cancer by prescribing minute doses of tumors and carcinogenic substances.
The intent of homeopathic medicine is to help the body begin the healing process. Rather than focusing on a specific diagnosis, prescriptions are tailored to an entire set of symptoms and may vary between individuals with the same disease.
Significant reduction of some side effects of cancer treatments has been reported in two randomized controlled trials justifying further research with larger trials.
Current research includes a National Cancer Institute (NCI) clinical trial of a homeopathic substance for chemotherapy induced mucositis in children.
So far, not so good. The passage above is completely credulous, without the least bit of skepticism about the very basis of homeopathy. It reports homeopathy as a homeopath would report it, which makes me wonder if it was written by a homeopath. Particularly disturbing is the “detailed scientific review” of homeopathy. I’ll give the author credit because he at least mentions Avogadro’s number, but then credulously parrots the typical homeopath claim that water has “memory.” The article also cites primarily articles from that journal of pure woo, whose editorial standards I’ve lambasted here and elsewhere time and time again, the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, as well as homeopathy journals, such as the British Homeopathic Journal. It is beyond the scope of this post to explain why such journals are generally not good sources (perhaps I’ll do a post on that someday), but they aren’t. The only “real” journal article I saw was the infamous TRAUMEEL S study from 2001 looking at whether homeopathic TRAUMEEL S can alleviate stomatitis in children undergoing treatment for lymphoma and leukemia. (I shudder at the unethical nature of testing magic water in a clinical trial with children as the subjects.) In any case, this study reported a positive effect; however, one might also note this from the study itself:
TRAUMEEL S® is a homeopathic-complex remedy that has been sold over the counter in pharmacies in Germany, Austria, and Switzerland for over 50 years. It contains extracts from the following plants and minerals, all of them highly diluted (10−1–10−9 of the stem solution): Arnica montana, Calendula officinalis, Achillea millefolium, Matricaria chamomilla, Symphytum officinale, Atropa belladonna, Aconitum napellus, Bellis perennis, Hypericum perforatum, chinacea angustifolia, Echinacea purpurea, Hamamelis virginica, Mercurius solubilis, and Hepar sulfuris. Information from the manufacturer indicates that TRAUMEEL S is used normally to treat trauma, inflammation, and degenerative processes.
In other words, this is an herbal remedy in which there is still ingredient, given that even a 10-9 dilution is not enough to dilute away what’s in there. Why it’s even called homeopathic, I have a hard time figuring out, given that there are many herbs and minerals in there, with no rationale of “like curing like” obvious for them all. If TRAUMEEL S “works,” it’s not any sort of validation of homeopathy; all it shows is that maybe some of the herbs or minerals in the concoction have a beneficial effect. One also notes that this is a small study (N=30, 15 per group) and that the distribution of disease in the two groups was very different and that this study has never been replicated. Both Edzard Ernst and the Cochrane Reviews note this study but conclude that there is no evidence that homepathy is any better than placebo for cancer side effects.
But apparently not M.D. Anderson. M.D. Anderson appears to believe in magic. If you don’t believe me, just take a look at its review on reiki, including the “scientific evidence” for its efficacy in cancer patients, or its review on healing touch, which is more or less reiki shorn of explicit Eastern mysticism. Particularly nauseating is this introduction to “energy therapy” methods, which divides the very concept of energy itself into “Western” and “Eastern” notions of energy. (Silly me, I thought that energy was energy, and it was defined scientifically.) The author then postulates the “blending” of “Eastern” and “Western” concepts of energy thusly:
Modern physics has shown that light can exist as two interchangeable forms: a particle (form and structure) and a wave (movement and vibration). The rest of nature can also be experienced in the form of a particle and a wave. For example, water in the ocean is both particles of water and movement of coastal currents, thermal layers and tides. As in the ocean, the human body contains and is affected by energy that can be blocked, flow freely or vary in frequency. Various forms have been postulated:
    • An all-pervasive background frequency without form that extends beyond the limits of the body structure
    • Vertical energy flows that serve as conduits to external energy
    • Additional currents of energy with identifiable paths and patterns
The extent to which a background field extends beyond a person reportedly varies with each individual. Some people have said that they are sensitive to these fields – seeing or hearing these projections. Heat emanating from a body is one form of energy and one expression of that person’s energy field8.
Notice that no evidence is presented showing that these claims are valid.
The introduction concludes:
Contemporary energy therapies are only recent manifestations of a larger and more ancient body of energetic and spiritual concepts that are beyond the scope of these reviews of a few contemporary energetic healing practices. MD Anderson recognizes that physical healing is only part of the cancer treatment process and also offers spiritual support through many different programs such as the Chaplaincy Services — representing a wide range of faiths and spiritual beliefs — and the Place … of wellness — where people touched by cancer can enhance their quality of life with activities that help to heal the mind, body and spirit.
Remember, this is the website of the M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, which is widely viewed to be one of the top two or three cancer centers in the United States, if not the world, and its Integrative Medicine Program appears to be based on magic more than anything else. Quackademic medicine, indeed.
Unfortunately, the NCI’s OCCAM website isn’t all that much better. Because I spent longer than anticipated going through the M.D. Anderson website, I’ll wrap it up fairly quickly. OCCAM has some fairly disturbing pages itself. For instance, its Categories of CAM Therapies is a simple list of CAM therapies with little discussion at all other than defining what they are in the way any woo-meister would be happy with. OCCAM is superior to M.D. Anderson’s CAM pages in that it does from time to time throw in passages like this:
Biofield therapies are intended to affect energy fields that purportedly surround and penetrate the human body. The existence of such fields has not yet been scientifically proven.
If there is no good science to show that these fields even exist, then why study trying to manipulate them? I never understood putting the cart before the horse like that. There’s a lot of that sort of stuff going on in the list of CAM therapies referenced by OCCAM, although a lot of the articles are in fact NCCAM articles. One article on a CAM therapy that is hosted by the NCI and apparently was written by NCI staff is entitled Questions and answers about acupuncture. Depressingly, it begins with a credulous discussion of qi and meridians that is credulous and full of magic. It also contains statements like:
Scientific studies on the use of acupuncture to treat cancer and side effects of cancer began only recently. Laboratory and animal studies suggest that acupuncture can reduce vomiting caused by chemotherapy and may help the immune system be stronger during chemotherapy. Animal studies support the use of electroacupuncture to relieve cancer pain.
And:
Human studies on the effect of acupuncture on the immune system of cancer patients showed that it improved immune system response.
One wonders just how critically the studies to which this article refers were evaluated. Certainly, the lists mix “electroacupuncture” (which is not acupuncture at all — as Mark says, where were those batteries in ancient China to hook up to the acupuncture needles?) with acupuncture studies. One wonders if this is another case of accepting the authors’ misinterpretation of their own results, as I discussed for one such study a couple of months ago. As for the effects of acupuncture on the immune system, the physician’s version of the review points out that all these studies were conducted in China, and, unfortunately, it’s well known that acupuncture studies from China tend to be overwhelmingly positive, in marked contrast to acupuncture studies from other countries, leading some writers of meta-analyses to question how to handle these studies. In any case, it would appear that the NCI, although its material on its website is not as credulous as that of M.D. Anderson, is not exactly a bastion of science when it comes to some “alternative” medical modalities.
Indeed, let me tell you a brief anecdote. Two years ago, at the AACR Meeting, I visited the NCI booth on the convention floor because I knew there was going to be a representative from OCCAM there. My confidence in the scientific rigor of the entire OCCAM enterprise was not boosted by the conversation I had there. In brief, after a brief (and neutral) conversation about what OCCAM does, I gently challenged the OCCAM representative regarding alternative medicine by pointing out that there really isn’t that much evidence for much of it and asking him if he could point me in the right direction. In particular, I asked him why one would think that a mixture of herbal medicines would do better than pharmaceuticals. He then began to pontificate about “royal herbs” and couldn’t provide a good rationale why anyone should conclude that impure mixtures of compounds would be more effective or reliable than pharmaceuticals. When he started going on about “emperor” herbs, “minister” herbs, and “assistant” herbs, I couldn’t take it anymore and looked for an opportunity to politely excuse myself.
“Integrative oncology”: The quackademic oncology that’s here to stay?
I first became aware of the phenomenon of quackademic medicine several years ago. Before then, I was blissfully ignorant. Over the last several years, in particular the last couple of years, I’ve become increasingly alarmed at just how much pseudoscience is finding its way into medical academia in general and into oncology in particular in the form of “integrative” oncology. When the websites of what have in the past been a bastion of science-based oncology, M.D. Anderson Cancer Center and the NCI, become infiltrated with this sort of pseudoscience, I become alarmed. But it’s far, far worse than that. I only picked two websites. There are many more out there, thanks to promoters of woo like the Bravewell Collaborative and others. I only picked on M.D. Anderson and the NCI because of their reputation for being much better than this, a reputation they are endangering by their embrace of woo. Cancer patients, as I say frequently, are among the most vulnerable of patients. Many of them are facing a very unpleasant death without treatment; seeing that they receive the most effective medicines and treatments we have, free of quackery, is a moral imperative, and I fear that we will soon be failing our patients. We now even have a Society of Integrative Oncology promoting the “integration” of pseudoscience into oncology.
The Trojan horse of herbals, diet, and exercise in the form of yoga may have breeched the walls of academia, bringing with it pseudoscience like acupuncture, reiki, and even homeopathy, but still I see reason for hope. Val Jones once coined the term “shruggie” for health care professionals who have seen the infiltration of pseudoscience into medicine and in essence shrug their shoulders, dismissing it as not being important or as not being their business if people choose quackery instead of science-based medicine. However, as the infiltration of pseudoscience reached a critical mass, it started to alarm even some of the shruggies. There has been pushback. We here at SBM like to think that we have been a significant part of that reaction, but we also know that there are many others, such as Edzard Ernst, Ben Goldacre, and Simon Singh. Even though a disturbing number of skeptics seem to have a blind spot when it comes to quackery, the broader skeptical movement appears to be taking more and more notice. I only hope that it’s not too late. When an admired and esteemed institution like M.D. Anderson goes woo, we have an uphill battle to reverse that.

“Integrative oncology”: The Trojan horse that is quackademic medicine infiltrates ASCO
David Gorski on June 9, 2014
Link
You might have noticed that I didn’t produce a post last week, something that’s unusual for me, given how prolific I have been in the blogosphere. One reason was personal. The other reason was that last weekend I was attending the annual meeting of the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) meeting in Chicago. I also must confess that, while I was there, I caused a bit of a stir on the meeting hashtag (#ASCO14) in the name of science-based medicine (SBM) on Twitter under my handle @gorskon. (What? You aren’t following me on Twitter? Get thee hence to my Twitter feed and add me. I’ll wait. Did you do it yet? Good. Now we can move on.) Of course, I know what you’re thinking: Cuddly, lovable me? Causing trouble? Making sure that I’ll almost certainly never be invited to be an official social media doc or to participate in panels on social media at ASCO, despite my extensive experience blogging, using Twitter, and just in general being a pain in the rear online to those who promote quackery and quackademic medicine? Perish the thought!
Of course, it was for just that reason that I was making a bit of a stir on Twitter. ASCO is one of the biggest (if not the biggest) and most organized oncology meetings out there, and there were several people considered “social media rock stars” in the world of oncology such as Mike Thompson, Deanna Attai, Matthew Katz, and Robert Miller live Tweeting the meeting, along with those viewed, correctly or incorrectly, as lesser lights, such as myself. In any case, on Sunday I noticed that a lot of people, including the official ASCO Twitter feed @ASCO, were Tweeting and re-Tweeting a link to this official story from ASCO, “Integrative Oncology Can Add Benefit to Traditional Cancer Treatments.” It was a description of a session that had been held on Saturday morning, Integrative Oncology: The Evidence Base, which, unfortunately, I had missed due to circumstances entirely beyond my control. Fortunately, however, ASCO is benevolent (not to mention that it also justifies the high cost of meeting registration) by providing immediate access to recordings of every major session, not to mention the slide sets used. If I couldn’t be there in person, at least I could cruise on over to the ASCO website and use my access to the 2014 virtual meeting to see what sort of quackademic medicine was being featured at ASCO.
There were three presenters and a panel discussion. Two of the presenters I was well familiar with, making me sad that I had missed the opportunity to be in the same room with them. First up, was Barrie Cassileth, PhD, whom we have met several times before and who is a big name in “integrative oncology,” as befits her position as the chief of the integrative medicine service and current holder of the Laurance S. Rockefeller Chair in Integrative Medicine at one of the greatest cancer centers in the world, Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center and her having founded the Society for Integrative Oncology (SIO), her topic being an introduction and overview, entitled, appropriately enough, “Integrative Oncology: Overview.” Next up was another big name whom we have met before, Lorenzo Cohen, PhD, who is basically Dr. Cassileth’s counterpart over at the other most famous cancer center in the US, the University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, holding the titles of Professor and Director of the Integrative Medicine Program and having co-founded SIO with Dr. Cassileth. His topic was “Mind-Body Practices in Cancer.” Finally, to complete the trio, there was Michelle Harvie, PhD, with whom I am not familiar. She described on the website of the research institute where she works, the Manchester Breast Centre, as a research dietitian at the Genesis Breast Cancer Prevention Centre, University Hospital South Manchester Trust. She’s obviously nowhere near as big a name as Drs. Cohen and Cassileth, but she’s sure enough working on it.
Dr. Barrie Cassileth: “Integrative oncology isn’t quackery. Really, it isn’t!”
Dr. Cassileth seems to have a bit of a chip on her shoulder over “integrative oncology.” Clearly, she resents its being referred to as quackery, quackademic medicine, and not science-based. Indeed, of late, she has labored mightily to try to convince oncologists that “integrative” oncology isn’t cancer quackery, something I first noticed her doing with vehemence a couple of years ago in a review article that was, in part, a broadside against cancer quackery, such as Essiac, the German New Medicine, Entelev, shark cartilage, oxygen therapies, energy therapies, electrical devices (such as Hulda Clark’s “zapper,” prayer, and “healers” using therapeutic touch. That part of her article was something that anyone supporting SBM could appreciate. She also did, as I phrased it, question the “central dogma” of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or, as I like to call it, “wishing makes it so.” Unfortunately, some of that central dogma was evident in Dr. Cohen’s talk, as I will discuss in the next section. Much to my disappointment, there was no throwdown in the panel discussion between Dr. Cassileth and Dr. Cohen over this.
In any case, this same insistence that integrative medicine is evidence-based, in contrast to all that other cancer quackery, bubbled up again near the end of Dr. Cassileth’s talk in the form of a series of slides, one of which can be seen here, in which Dr. Cassileth, to her credit, emphasizes that alternative medicine is mostly quackery. In the accompanying article on the ASCO website, Cassileth says:
The first step in unraveling the beneficial from the detrimental may be a new understanding of the terminology used to describe these additive therapies, Barrie Cassileth, PhD, of the Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center said during the session. Whereas complementary and adjunctive therapies may have beneficial therapeutic effects, it would be inappropriate to allow them to replace traditional interventions. The term ‘alternative treatments’ more aptly describes those modalities that proffer to replace medical or surgical intervention—although the word quackery may be even more fitting, Dr. Cassileth added.
To me, the “money slide” in the whole series was:
And that’s what bothers Dr. Cassileth the most. To her, quacks are “usurping” or co-opting the term “integrative oncology” in order to peddle cancer quackery. Of course, that’s not the way I saw it. The way I see it is that “integrative oncology” is integrating quackery into oncology. To paraphrase one of my Tweets at the meeting, the only thing “integrative” oncology adds to traditional cancer treatments is pseudoscience. To that, I now add that, if anyone is usurping or co-opting anything, it’s practitioners of “integrative oncology” and “integrative medicine.” They are co-opting perfectly science-based modalities, such as exercise and diet as somehow being “alternative” (word choice intentional, because something has to be “alternative” to fit into the paradigm of “integrating” non-standard therapies into conventional medicine) and then giving the appearance of “integrating them” into conventional medicine when they are already part of conventional medicine.
Indeed, it is not a coincidence that Dr. Cassileth broke down “integrative oncology” into six categories that the session would address:
Meditation and other “mind-body” therapies (Dr. Cohen)
Optimal nutrition, special diets, and supplements (Dr. Harvie)
Massage therapies
Music therapy
Acupuncture treatment
Exercise
Tellingly, Dr. Cassileth spent more effort discussing acupuncture, citing more studies, than she did for any other treatment listed above. It’s understandable that she didn’t discuss mind-body” treatments or nutrition, given that other speakers were going to address these, but, compared to acupuncture, she barely touched on massage and music therapy. She did discuss exercise a bit more, but, of course, from my perspective part of the reason she didn’t discuss exercise more is because it’s largely uncontroversial that at least mild-to-moderate exercise benefits cancer patients and that obesity is associated with a growing list of cancers. Again, there’s nothing “integrative,” “complementary,” or “alternative” about exercise. It’s science-based medicine. The same is true of nutrition. As for massage and music, I tend to agree with our co-editor and co-blogger Kimball Atwood, who simply says that he has no objection to massage, as long as there’s no medical contraindication, because it feels good, and what’s wrong with making patients feel better using something non-invasive? Back in the old days, we used to call such services “supportive” services, things done for patients to take their minds off being in the hospital and the sometimes painful and invasive treatments they require. The problem only comes when something like massage or music is “medicalized,” as in claiming that it treats specific diseases, or “woo-ified,” an all-too-common phenomenon for massage in particular in which massage becomes coupled or conflated with various forms of “energy healing.”
But what about the acupuncture studies? None of the studies presented by Dr. Cassileth provided any compelling evidence that acupuncture is anything more than what Steve Novella and David Colquhoun called it, a theatrical placebo. To this, I would add, given the claims that acupuncture can work to relieve symptoms or reverse virtually everything, be it infertility, nausea and vomiting from chemotherapy, pain, xerostomia, hot flashes, insomnia, lymphedema, and peripheral neuropathy due to certain chemotherapy drugs like taxol, chances are that means that it works for nothing. Dr. Cassileth’s presentation included the usual studies such as this study with no sham acupuncture control claiming that acupuncture relieved symptoms due to neck dissection. Indeed, in the discussion, Dr. Cassileth justifies this design thusly:
For our control arm, we opted for a pragmatic rather than a placebo control. A pragmatic control arm has the advantage of providing an estimate of effect size most consistent with the questions of greatest interest facing patients and clinicians. These questions include: What effects will an acupuncture referral have on a patient’s pain, and will the patient use less pain medication as a result? One disadvantage of a pragmatic comparison of acupuncture with usual care concerns lack of blinding and potential placebo effect.
Yup, which makes me ask: Why even bother doing this study? It shows nothing, Jon Snow. (Sorry. Game of Thrones is getting exciting as it nears the season finale.) She also cited a study indicating that acupuncture is helpful for post-surgery lymphedema in breast cancer patients, a conclusion that I characterized as: Keep those acupuncture needles away from my lymphedematous arm!
Other studies presented included a meta-analysis from 2005 that demonstrates the principle of GIGO as well as most acupuncture meta-analyses do with respect to relief of chemotherapy-induced nausea and vomiting. A more recent Cochrane meta-analysis, although still mildly positive, was a lot less so, concluding, “Overall, acupuncture-point stimulation of all methods combined reduced the incidence of acute vomiting (RR = 0.82; 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.69 to 0.99; P = 0.04), but not acute or delayed nausea severity compared to control.” That would be barely statistically significant, with the relative risk coming close to including 1.0. GIGO, indeed, plus theatrical placeboes!
If the studies she cited were the best that Dr. Cassileth could come up with for acupuncture, either she wasn’t trying very hard, or the evidence base stinks because acupuncture is nothing more than a theatrical placebo. Take your pick, but I pick the latter. In any case, there was nothing in Dr. Cassileth’s talk to change my opinion of either integrative oncology or acupuncture. “Rebranding” the others, such as diet and exercise, as being “additive,” “nonpharmacological,” or somehow “integrative” doesn’t change the fact that what Dr. Cassileth was doing was the same thing that “integrative practitioners” have been doing for a couple of decades now: Rebranding science-based modalities as somehow “integrative” or “alternative.” It is admirable that Dr. Cassileth can and does on occasion attack quackery in a way that would do SBM proud. Unfortunately, it is equally frustrating that she doesn’t seem to grasp that much of the “integrative” oncology she promotes, such as acupuncture, is based on the very same pre-scientific, vitalistic concepts as the cancer quackery she so rightly detests.
Dr. Lorenzo Cohen: Wishing makes it so!
Of all the modalities that Dr. Cassileth introduced in the first talk, the two that have traditionally been considered “alternative” were acupuncture, which she discussed, and various “mind-body” modalities, which Dr. Cohen discussed. I’ve discussed on multiple occasions how M.D. Anderson, sadly, has delved deeply into woo. Unfortunately, Dr. Cohen is the Delver-in-Chief, and he showed why in his talk. He’s definitely good. Sadly, what he’s good at is “integrating” pseudoscience into science-based medicine. He’s also good at “rebranding.”
One thing that has always bothered me about so-called “mind-body” modalities is the dualism inherent in the very name used to categorize these modalities. Think about it. The very term “mind-body” implies that the mind is somehow separate from the body. The assumption behind such modalities seems to be that training the “mind” to control what the “body” is doing will result in prolonged survival in cancer patients. It’s the very concept that Dr. James Coyne argued so eloquently against on this very blog a couple of years ago. To be honest, it’s also a concept that Dr. Cassileth herself argued against in the very same review article that got her into hot water with the “integrative medicine” crowd a couple of years ago as well. Let’s just cite some of her words:
Many of these ideas were promoted by a former Yale surgeon, a popular author who advocated special cancer patient support groups in his books. The importance of a positive attitude was stressed, as was the idea that disease could spring from unmet emotional needs. This belief anguished many cancer patients, who assumed responsibility for getting cancer because of an imperfect emotional status. Among alternative modalities, the mind/body approach has been especially persistent over time, possibly in part because it resonates with the American notion of rugged individualism.
To be fair, in the article Cassileth stated that there were “complementary” therapies that could improve quality of life, but she also stated that some promoters of “mind-body” treatments “overpromise,” by “suggesting that emotional stress or other emotional issues can cause diseases like cancer and that correction of these deficiencies through mind-body therapies can effectively treat major illnesses.”
That is exactly what Dr. Cohen suggested, albeit in a somewhat more subtle way than, say Ryke Geerd Hamer of German New Medicine fame, but, make no mistake, in his talk Dr. Cohen was arguing that mental states and stress contribute to cancer development and progression and that reversing those “bad” mental states can contribute to improved survival. Indeed, he started right out making that very argument, citing a study suggesting that depression is associated with decreased survival in cancer patients, an interesting but highly speculative eight year old review article on potential mechanisms by which stress can contribute to cancer (an article he kept coming back to again and again and again), a ten year old PNAS article contributed by Elizabeth Blackburn (a relatively newly converted proponent of “integrative medicine” whom we’ve met before) claiming that stress leads to shortened telomere length and thus diminished lifespan, and a study relating high social attachment to increased survival in ovarian cancer (which, ironically enough, also reported that “no significant association was found between access to instrumental social support and survival,” meaning that support groups weren’t correlated with increased survival). Why would he have mentioned these studies if he weren’t arguing that somehow the mind influences cancer mortality and that his “mind-body” interventions could potentially result in better survival?
I got the distinct feeling from Dr. Cohen’s talk that yoga is his big thing. He presented multiple studies of yoga in women with breast cancer. As I’ve said before, stripped of its spiritual elements, yoga is nothing more than a specific form of exercise involving stretching and various other body motions; so it’s not surprising that it would have potentially beneficial effects. Of course, that’s what Dr. Cohen noted, citing this recently published study from his group that compared women with breast cancer undergoing radiation therapy, dividing them into three groups: yoga, stretching exercises, and a wait list control. Of course, that means the study was not blinded, making it pretty much useless for saying much of anything about the effect of yoga, given that most of the measurements were subjective measurements of fatigue and health using self-reporting through survey tools. One change noted to be better in the yoga group was cortisol slope, which is a dubious measure, as Dr. Coyne and I have pointed out before. Cohen also cited another recent study that omitted the stretching control and was also similarly unblinded, that looked at inflammatory markers in the wait list control versus the yoga group. It reported much higher vitality and lower fatigue in the yoga group, along with a decrease in some inflammatory cytokines.
The list went on, including animal studies that related chronic stress to tumor progression, a progression that was reversed by beta blockers (drugs that block the effects of epinephrine signaling), an interesting finding, but one that hasn’t yet made it to the level that we recommend beta blockers for cancer patients. If this finding ends up being validated, it would then also become science-based medicine, and oncologists would start prescribing beta blockers to appropriate cancer patients, no woo needed.
Color me unimpressed. Also color me disappointed in that, yes, Dr. Cohen was arguing for exactly the sorts of contentions that Jim Coyne has refuted so well, both in the literature with his colleagues, and here on SBM.
Michelle Harvie: One of these things is not like the others
The last talk came from Dr. Michelle Harvie. To be honest, there’s really not a whole lot for me to say about it or to object to. Here are a couple of the key slides:
Her conclusions:
As I said, it’s hard for me to argue with most of this. It’s all pretty well evidence-based and unremarkable. She even showed data in which dietary interventions, including vegan diets, failed to arrest or slow the progress of prostate cancer, pointed out that the evidence that observational data regarding whether obesity and/or intentional weight loss has an effect on cancer progression is shaky at best (although it’s better for breast cancer and maybe prostate cancer), and cited a study that high fruit and vegetable intake appear not to affect the outcomes in breast cancer patients. She did point out, however, that a healthy diet can reduce overall mortality, but appears not to affect cancer-specific mortality much, if at all. That, of course, is not particularly surprising, given that healthy diets can definitely impact cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and other lifestyle-associated conditions. Basically, her overall message was that the data regarding diet and cancer survival are a lot less strong than we would like, although it is fairly clear that alcohol intake more than relatively low consumption, is associated with worse outcomes. She even cited an animal study in which nutraceuticals containing antioxidants decreased lifespan, pointed out that the evidence for ketogenic diets and cancer are inconclusive and that intermittent fasting probably has little effect on chemotherapy efficacy, and cited an abstract presented at ASCO that suggested that underweight patients with kidney cancer do worse than overweight patients.
In the end, Dr. Harvie’s talk was largely science-based medicine. Including it in a session on “integrative oncology” was nothing more than rebranding what should be a science-based modality, the effects of nutrition and diet on cancer treatment and survival, as being somehow “alternative” or “integrative.”
Yet another bit of “rebranding,” this time at ASCO
As is frequently the case in sessions like this at academic medical meetings, the last part of the session was a 20 minute panel discussion, in which members of the audience asked questions. What was incredibly disappointing to me was how little there was in the way of any sort of challenge to the assertions made by panel members in their talks or the assumptions underlying those talks. There were questions about green tea and whether it was beneficial, whether yoga has any benefit in relieving the symptoms of chemotherapy, leading to Dr. Cohen promoting a poster discussion he was going to present in a couple of days reporting the results of just such a study, and a question about how to keep “patients honest” about the supplements they’re taking. All of these warnings about dietary supplements not always mixing well with chemotherapy are useful, but it doesn’t really address whether integrative oncology is evidence-based, particularly given the bon mot delivered by Dr. Cohen that somehow it’s better to get antioxidants from foods than from supplements, even though, if antioxidants truly do interfere with chemotherapy action in some cases, chemically it would be the same and only the dose might be different. There was a question on juicing, which was generally not recommended.
I will point out that there was one hilarious question, in which an audience member asked how one can differentiate who is a good acupuncturist who will get the sorts of results claimed in the randomized clinical trials, from an acupuncturist who is a “charlatan.” Dr. Cassileth answered by saying that—of course!—MSKCC has six acupuncturists on staff, making her lucky that she can count on all of them as being highly skilled and doesn’t have to worry about “charlatan” acupuncturists. She also fried yet another of my irony meters when she declared quackery to be a huge problem in acupuncture, proclaiming that there are many acupuncturists who are not well-trained and who are not trained to work with cancer patients and that there’s a big difference between treating adults who might have some “aches and pains” and treating cancer patients. I, of course, agree, but not in the way that Dr. Cassileth meant her statements. There is indeed a big difference between treating benign aches and pains, which will almost always get better, and treating patients with serious disease, like cancer patients, for whom acupuncture is pretty much never appropriate. Come to think of it, acupuncture is pretty much never appropriate for anyone, because it doesn’t work.
And, of course, MSKCC offers a 21 hour Internet course for acupuncturists teaching how to use acupuncture for cancer patients! At only $495, it’s a total bargain! Helpfully, Dr. Cohen chimed in about how there’s a national credentialing board for acupuncturists, and you can look up acupuncturists online to see if they are trained and skilled. Yes, that’ll totally keep you away from quacks and charlatans! Oh, wait. Acupuncture is quackery; so maybe that won’t work so well. Sadly, none of this stopped Dr. Cassileth from suggesting acupuncture for postoperative pain right after this question.
Integrative oncology: Wanting to have it both ways
After having indulged myself in this session, I left very disappointed. On the one hand, I wished that I could have made it to the actual session instead of having to review it online, even though, given the credulity of the questions and the utter lack of challenge by anyone to the scientific basis of what was presented, I’m not sure I would have had the guts to get up there and say what needed to be said. On the other hand, it’s very clear that, for ASCO at least, the session was planned to scream as loudly as possible, “Pay no attention to the man behind the curtain (or prior plausibility or biology)! Integrative oncology is science!” To do that, the session focused pretty tightly on actual science-based modalities, such as diet and exercise, that could easily be “rebranded as somehow being “alternative” or “integrative,” while cherry picking data selling acupuncture as more than an elaborate placebo and implying that “mind” can control body and improve cancer survival based on animal studies and highly selective observational evidence. In essence, Drs. Cassileth and Cohen want to have it both ways, claiming for “integrative oncology” anything about diet, stress, and exercise that might be science- and evidence-based, “rebranding” them and lumping them together with the woo, like acupuncture, which, as mightily as they strive to make it appear evidence-based, remains prescientific, vitalistic nonsense.
ASCO, like many other medical professional societies—I’m talking to you, American Academy of Pediatrics—has a problem. Quackademic medicine is not only infiltrating oncology in the form of “integrative oncology,” but it’s becoming increasingly accepted. It’s not for nothing that we frequently refer to diet and exercise (rebranded as “integrative medicine,” of course!) as a Trojan horse that, once in the fortress of science-based medicine, opens up to disgorge pseudoscience. Sadly, oncology is not immune, as the increasing popularity of “integrative oncology” demonstrates. Unfortunately, “integrating” pseudoscience into science-based oncology does no good for cancer patients, the imprimatur of MSKCC, M.D. Anderson, and, yes, ASCO, notwithstanding.

The Harm of Integrative Medicine: A Patient’s Perspective
I was diagnosed with cancer and entered treatment, at which point I directly experienced both excellent scientific care, and also the utter nonsense that is alternative medicine, rebranded as integrative medicine. Here are my reflections on the experience.
Jesse LukeonJune 12, 2016
Tweet


Being an avid reader of SBM and a cancer patient, I have come to deeply appreciate the writing and respect the various contributors for their expertise and attention to detail on a topic as important as cancer treatment. I have unfortunately found SBM lacking when it comes to a patient’ or lay-person’s’ perspective. This is understandable, as the average person is typically not well versed in science, medicine, or logical fallacies, all important when examining medical claims and practices. Nonetheless, this is a general problem because lack of patient and public involvement in healthcare is partly responsible for the spectacular growth of the integrative medicine industry. Under the integrative and CAM umbrella there is an almost-endless list of topics (as readers are well aware) to write on but there is only so much space in one article. To address this gap, I would like to focus on the general harm caused to patients by the presence of integrative medicine in healthcare (hence the creative title).
How I encountered integrative medicine
As a result of becoming ill I have had the great pleasure of touring most of the major hospital networks in Manhattan, specifically the hematology/oncology services, as I had a blood condition that eventually turned out to be a rare cancer. At every initial visit I was recommended to schedule an appointment with the integrative medical service by most nurses and the occasional doctor. I was already aware that alternative medicine was at best a collective delusion but I wasn’t’ familiar with “integrative medicine” (IM). Upon inquiring, I was met every time with a different yet equally-nebulous and ambiguous definition that typically included the words “balance,” “harmony,” “holistic,” and “wellness.” I was curious. After some quick research on my own I was a bit confused; it seemed to be nothing but alternative health approaches being marketed as part of real medicine. After seeing articles with titles like “The effects of Reiki therapy and companionship on quality of life, mood, and symptom distress during chemotherapy“, I realized that IM was just the continuation of a scam I thought was relegated to the fringes. However, it was back, and no longer peddled solely by the familiar (and laughable) flower children, but by mainstream healthcare workers and highly respected healthcare institutions. Among the myriad surface dangers posed by this “new” field are its appeal, ease of access, and most of all, faulty science. More on the resulting harm later.
Integrative medicine preys on a patient’s desire for hope and control
Anyone that has ever faced a serious illness, or been close to someone who has, should be able to easily understand the initial appeal of integrative medicine. There seems to be limited options to treat the primary condition, symptoms, medication side effects, and even psychological effects. In any (other) field of medicine, you get sick and the doctor will recommend a treatment. Out-of-office information truly accessible to the average person is usually not very specific, normally providing only a brief description and listing general treatments a doctor may provide, such as medications or surgery. These sources use general terms, not out of secrecy or malevolence, but simply out of the desire to not overload an already-overwhelmed patients with complex information.
However, when a patient looks at an integrative medicine website, hospital pamphlet, flyer, or any other means of promotion they are met with a plethora of options with “detailed” descriptions to pick from, all offering the possibility to help in some way. The majority of these descriptions are filled with catchy, enticing, and non-specific terms that could apply to nearly everyone and any condition. Take, for example, these quotes from the’ Center for Comprehensive Wellness at the Columbia University Medical Center, a part of the New York Presbyterian Hospital that utilizes CAM therapies on pediatric patients:
Reiki is an ancient, gentle hands-on healing technique originating in Japan. Reiki promotes relaxation, eases pain, and reduces anxiety and stress. It also assists the body in cleansing toxins and balances the flow of subtle energy.[source]
Acupuncture and acupressure, both forms of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), stimulate specific points on the body known as acupoints in order to reduce tension, help the body relax deeply, and strengthen resistance to disease. These approaches relax the muscle fibers, resulting in increased blood flow and release of toxins.[source]
Reading these, it is easy to see how a person could be misled, since this is information coming from a reputable source and sounds very convincing if not read with a skeptical lens. No well-conducted study has shown that either of the above treatments will heal or prevent disease, aid in removing toxins (always unspecified) from the body, or manipulate a non-existent energy field. They may cause an improvement in mood and/or relaxation through (very real) placebo effects and a simple human connection, but both a positive mood and relaxation can be brought about through far less mystical ways. Indeed, acupuncture actually carries an actual risk of infection with no actual benefit.
Upon personally reading such pamphlets and information, I was led through a gamut of feelings, the first of which being confusion. One pamphlet listed several of these “modalities” in a chart on one axis and symptoms or problems on the other. At the intersection of each were circles ranging from empty to fully shaded, similar to Consumer Reports reviews, which represented the evidence behind each technique. Unsurprisingly, the majority were in support of even the most bizarre CAM therapies. When I questioned my oncologist about these claims he had (in his professional opinion) no clue why they would endorse remedies that were known not to work. This seemed contradictory to me but I trusted my oncologist even though all the information about integrative care was presented in a medical fashion. The trust was not blind, all CAM therapies seemed disconcertingly like medical advice given by Dr. Oz to me and as a result felt the need to do a little digging. Though fortunately I was able to recognize the faulty science by consulting medical textbooks and journals, I understand that most people are unable to do that, which is how’ they are lured in. Despite discovering the truth, I am still left with the nagging feeling that I was misled and/or lied to by a hospital and medical professionals, which is something that no one should ever have to feel or be concerned about when ill.
Access to these options provides a false sense of control to someone who felt that they had little or none. Appeal is also generated by the way these “treatments” are presented. As above, they are often portrayed as ancient, natural, indigenous, or spiritual. In fact, reiki originated in 1922, a year not considered ancient by anyone I know. In addition, the terms “Western medicine” and “conventional medicine” are frequently used to create a false dichotomy that implies those outside of integrative medicine are shut off from the rest of the world and society, that other incarnations of medicine are of equal or more value.
An evolution, or regression, of medicine?
From Mount Sinai’s website:
Integrative Medicine represents an evolution in healthcare that combines conventional medical practices with other indigenous and western healing approaches, using scientific evidence as the rationale for incorporating these modalities into patient care. The integrative approach emphasizes patient empowerment and encourages patients to take an active role in their health.
If Integrative medicine is truly an evolution of healthcare and not a step backwards, then one would expect to see results in research, research that meets the most stringent requirements inherit to the scientific process. Yet, very rarely are proper placebo-controlled studies done, and when they are, there is absolutely no benefit to any alternative “treatment” now part of integrative medicine. Studies are then pursued with less rigor and so many confounding factors that make success almost certain (this is without accounting for possible data manipulation). These studies allow “practitioners” to make dubious claims about unscientific “modalities” that are backed up by such “pseudo-research”. If an intelligent person decides not to take things at face value and do some basic (but not intensive) investigation, they could be met with comments such as the following from the Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, one of the world’s most respected cancer research institutions:
We know that a therapy works only when it has been scientifically tested and found to be effective and safe. Anecdotal reports may provide research ideas, but they are not proof that a therapy works. Patients and the public have a right to know whether therapies of all kinds fulfill the claims they make.
Coming from such a prestigious institution, these comments make it seem as if there is no question that integrative medicine is legitimate. If doubt still persists and a search of a medical database such as PubMed is done, there is what seems to be overwhelming support for these CAM practices, with many studies producing positive results. Only when these studies are closely examined can it be seen they are of terribly poor quality and that properly conducted studies do not reveal any positive effects beyond that of a placebo. I will not belabor the faulty science aspect of integrative medicine as it can take an entire article or more to properly examine just one bad study. I will say that twenty bad studies are not worth one well-designed and properly conducted study, and that the CAM industry has done a wonderful job of making people of all educational levels think otherwise.
The harms of integrative medicine
Finally, we are left with the harms occurring as a result of integrative medicine. The most dangerous result is the same that has always been a part of alternative medicine, that patients will not seek appropriate medical care in a timely manner or at all. As demonstrated recently in a study on CAM use and chemotherapy (covered by Dr. Gorski), this is, as we know, not an imaginary occurrence, fear mongering, or hyperbole. People are less likely to use real medicine when CAM is a factor. A defining factor of integrative medicine is that “practitioners” claim they advise all patients to use other “modalities” only in addition to “Western medicine”. This does not mean that patients will listen to that advice. When the idea is put into a patient’s head that not only do medicine and science not have all the answers, but that other “options” exist that will never turn someone away, always claim to be effective, never admit that hope is lost, and are always presented warmly, there will undoubtedly be some inclination not to go back to a long office wait for a 10 minute visit to get medications with unpleasant side-effects, and instead get a relaxing session of reiki. This will obviously not occur with all patients, but some will likely stray from proper treatment even if only a bit. Others may move completely away and into the arms of a genuinely alternative provider where they certainly won’t get proper medical care, lose a lot of money in the process, and possibly their lives.
As frightening as all the dangers above are to us adults, we also have to realize that there has been a massive proliferation of services offered to pediatric patients. When truly ill children are receiving inappropriate medical care it is a clear warning bell that something needs to change. If just one child dies as a result that is one too many (and there has already been one).
Economics is another factor to be concerned about when it comes to integrative medicine. Costs are rarely covered by insurance but seem affordable at first glance. The patient is soon caught in the web and paying for multiple sessions in multiple forms, sometimes by the same provider. Even without a serious illness these costs can put a drain on a person financially. Those unfortunate enough to have a serious illness typically don’t have much money to play around with. The risk of running out of money is very real for many people, and not a penny should be spent on ineffective care in such cases. Further, society bears an economic burden, as well as individuals; some hospitals will claim to provide some CAM services free of charge but there is always an opportunity cost, as everything must be funded in one way or another and every dollar that goes towards providing integrative care or researching a treatment that has been disproved multiple times takes that money away from truly valuable medicine. There are still studies being conducted on the widely-discredited practice of therapeutic touch when cancer immunology researchers are producing real results.
Though not as personally imaginable to the general person, there is also the psychologically destructive occurrence of patient victimization that I have personally been subjected to. In this article, victimization refers not to that done by the public but more specifically by other patients, practitioners, and even family members of the sick. This may be difficult to comprehend to those who have not experienced it, and I’m sure there will be outright deniers (mostly by those responsible), but it is very real. Integrative medicine has reached the point where it is shoved down our collective throats in hospitals, doctor’s’ offices, television, and especially the internet, making it difficult for people not to have it in their minds.
My own experiences with integrative medicine
Even without a study we know the above to be true; not only can the editors of SBM speak to this as medical professionals but so can I as a patient. Until very recently I had attended several support groups for those with cancer in New York City, some weekly, some monthly. The focus of each varied, one was general, two were for young adults, two were for those with advanced cancer, and one was for blood cancers. I did not stop because I got better, but because I was tired of losing members of the group to their disease. Yes, that’s partly to be expected but not exactly. Some of those deaths I can say could have been prevented, or at least put off for a while, most of them in the young-adult and advanced cancer groups. If there were 10 people, on average, three of them were using CAM therapies either exclusively or almost exclusively. That was not the case when I met them though; they adhered strictly to their doctors’ directions and recommendations but were being treated by integrative practitioners as well. The story was always the same when that day of the week or month came when they announced their departure from standard care, different words but same content. They were tired of feeling the side effects of their medications, searching for better combinations of anti-emetics or seeing their doctor for a brief visit once a month or so. They had the option of CAM where the doctors seemed to care more, spent more time with them, and rarely said “some side effects can’t be avoided.” There was the common delusion among them that if something made them feel better it had to be better, that it had to be doing more. I met one gentleman that had completely renounced modern medicine for a “health coach” that told him the only thing he needed to do was ejaculate more often. Don’t get me wrong, I see that this would make any guy feel better, but hardly find it useful in combating the metastatic anal cancer he had. I do want to stress again that these were not people already entrenched in an alternative medicine mindset, but were pulled and pushed towards it.
At this point I must ashamedly admit I have tried a few integrative therapies (mind you, not because I felt they were worth a try but for the same reason most men do things they don’t want to, an attractive woman). I have had the displeasure of participating in a “restorative” yoga session that included reiki, aromatherapy, and Tibetan singing bowls, and separately I also utilized “essential oil therapy”. The yoga class was a two-hour ordeal in a room of mostly very fit women. I wore jeans and a sweater (There wasn’t a chance in hell I was putting spandex shorts on) that made me stand out right away to everyone. Scents were burned for our “pleasure” and then we were informed of what we were in for. We were told that “Restorative yoga helps the body to drop into the parasympathetic nervous system and restore balance.” I honestly can’t even begin to tell you how that makes no sense as I was unaware that I was separated from my parasympathetic nervous system. The Tibetan singing bowls were meant to “restore balance and harmony in a person’s whole being.” Once again, I have no idea. I was told afterward (by that pretty girl) I also received reiki. I was questioned as to whether I felt the heating of her hands and the tingling. I said “no” and was met with a “you’ll feel it soon” and that was it. I never felt whatever “it” was and that was my last class. In addition to all of that I also tried “essential oil therapy” on several occasions at the bequest of, you guessed it, a pretty girl. I tried rubbing ginger oil on the soles of my feet to help with nausea. I knew it made no sense but it did accomplish something – I had to change my sheets. On another occasion I rubbed lavender oil in my hair to help me sleep. It didn’t work. I blame it on the overwhelming smell of lavender, myself. Overall, I found all of the above to be useless but can personally see the attraction of having a human connection and will admit that parts of the class were relaxing (but punctuated by spirituality-based pseudoscience that sounds sensible to the uninformed individual).
If you think that you’re seeing a pattern in the last paragraph or in the field of integrative medicine it’s because you are. As I stated before regarding the false dichotomy presented in the form of Western vs. Eastern medicine, there is an inexplicable obsession with anything even remotely Eastern in the field (Reiki-Japanese, Acupuncture-Chinese, Yoga-Hindu). I suspect that is because they carry a mystical, ancient, and mysterious aspect, making them easier to sell to Westerners. That is just a guess though; I will leave that to sociologists to figure out. This obsession with another culture above your own has been termed xenocentrism. Though this attitude may be exciting and sometimes advantageous when you are an interior designer, it is a disadvantage in the field of medicine. Not only is it harmful because it convinces patients that unscientific ideas are equal to those that are actually beneficial, but it also has the unintended consequence of portraying every medical doctor in the East as a quack. It implies they wouldn’t know hepatosplenomegaly (swollen spleen and liver) could be caused by bone marrow failure but instead believe it was caused by a blocked energy channel, an idea often seen in “traditional Chinese medicine”.
I have seen this in discussions in waiting rooms with other patients, sometimes off-topic, sometimes about our diagnosis and treatment. A large number mentioned some form of CAM therapy or another, often overseen or provided by the integrative service at that hospital. When I was asked about which of those “treatments” I took advantage of, I gave the simple and reasonable answer that they had no benefit and I didn’t use any. That answer was not only met by most with a refusal to believe in their lack of efficacy, but also probed as to why I didn’t care about my health or my family. In addition, I was advised to switch oncologists several times to one that was more “open” or “knowledgeable”. These ideas were most likely planted in their heads by their integrative care team. Far worse, I have heard similar remarks from family and various friends; “If you don’t feel well, see a chiropractor,” “I’ve heard gluten-free diets are good for cancer,” and my personal favorite, “you can’t trust medicine to help.” In multiple conversations with an integrative medicine advocate and “practitioner” I know personally, multiple “points” were made in the same vein. Upon refusing to try reiki and “essential oil therapy” again, I was told that I could never expect to get better if I didn’t use the “solutions at hand.” When I explained the science behind such refusal and wanting truthful, reliable treatment, I was met with, “Only your truth and that of science” (At that point I obviously had to leave the room). The message of all of these incidents to me was that it is our own fault, as patients that prefer science-based treatments, for not getting better, our fault for not using CAM approaches.
We all need to ask ourselves: is the slight mood boost and relaxation worth all of the above effort when the same can be accomplished with some smooth jazz and a hug?

For-profit stem cell clinics, universities, and “pay-to-play” clinical trials for autism
Stem cell therapies show great promise, but as yet the vast majority of that promise has not been validated in rigorous clinical trials. Unfortunately, for-profit stem cell clinics are running clinical trials that require patients to pay to be part of it. These trials are not rigorous. Even more unfortunately, it appears that some universities are also running “pay-to-play” clinical trials that bear an uncomfortable resemblance to those run by for-profit clinics.
David Gorski on July 29, 2019
Link

There is little doubt that stem cell therapy has considerable promise to treat a wide variety of degenerative diseases. Unfortunately, little of that promise has been realized yet, and, even more unfortunately, the promise of stem cell therapy has attracted scammers and quacks like the proverbial flies to honey. Dubious stem cell clinics try to attract customers using a combination of high pressure sales techniques akin to those used by time share salespeople, providing free products to celebrities in order to gain publicity and testimonials, and even using dubious clinical trials and ClinicalTrials.gov as advertising tools. It’s for that reason that I have said on multiple occasions, every for-profit stem cell clinic is a predatory quack clinic. At least, if there’s an exception to that rule of thumb, I haven’t found it yet, and I’ve been looking for years. Unfortunately, these clinics have proliferated all over the world, including the US, without any strong scientific evidence that the stem cell treatments used are effective.
With that background in mind, I came across an article in Spectrum:
Hyperbaric chambers. Dietary supplements. Special diets. Dorinda Weeks’ son Aaron had tried them all. Ever since Aaron was diagnosed with autism at age 4, Weeks had resisted medication and behavioral therapies supported by science in favor of alternative approaches.
Aaron had repetitive behaviors such as hand-flapping, persistent gastrointestinal distress, hyperactivity and sensory sensitivities to food. And none of these treatments helped.
In 2014, when Aaron was 9, Weeks decided to try a more invasive therapy. “I was at a point in my life where I just had to do something for [him],” Weeks recalls.
She enrolled Aaron in a clinical trial led by a for-profit company called the Stem Cell Institute in Panama City, Panama. During four visits to Panama over nine months, Aaron received infusions of stem cells harvested from tissue that lined donated umbilical cords; using stem cells from donated umbilical cord tissue is illegal in the United States. The institute charged $1,800 for each of Aaron’s visits, according to his mother.
Of course, charging a patient to be part of a clinical trial is, from an ethical standpoint, highly dubious, particularly when it’s a for-profit clinic doing the trial and even more so when the trial itself isn’t particularly rigorous. We’ll get back to that. This trial, such as it was, was published last month in Stem Cells Translational Medicine. It’s a single-arm (meaning that there was no control group) trial of 20 subjects with autism spectrum disorder. The treatment was mesenchymal stem cells derived from umbilical cord tissue (UC-MSCs).
Like most stem cell treatments for most diseases hawked by clinics like the Stem Cell Institute, the biological rationale for the treatment consists of a bunch of handwaving:
Mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) have immune‐modulatory and anti‐inflammatory properties and have been safely used in the treatment of a variety of neurological and autoimmune conditions15, 26-33. In particular, MSCs derived from the Wharton’s jelly of umbilical cord tissue (UC‐MSCs) may possess greater immune‐modulatory activity34 and proliferative capacity compared with other MSCs35, 36. The rationale for MSC therapy to treat ASD has been discussed over the past decade37, 38; our group proposed the use of stem cell therapy to treat ASD in 200739. Some studies to date have demonstrated the safety of treatment that included MSCs40: of note, the results of a study by Sharma et al. showed that the majority (96%) of children with ASD treated with bone marrow‐derived cells including MSCs showed global improvements including behavior patterns (66%), social relationships (90.6%), and speech, language, and communication (78%)41.
Translation: There are some immune abnormalities associated with autism that no one really understands, and MSCs can have immunomodulatory activity; so stem cells should help. Basically, the biological rationale is: Stem cells are magic! So they’ll magically help autistic children. Because stem cells.
The follow-up of the subjects of the trial was as follows:
During the first visit, in week 1, participants were evaluated for safety and efficacy baseline values, and received 36 million UC‐MSCs intravenously over the course of 1 week, in four intravenous infusions of 9 million viable UC‐MSCs in each infusion. Twelve weeks later, at week 13, the subjects received the same dose of UC‐MSCs and were evaluated for safety and efficacy endpoints. This procedure was repeated at week 25 and week 37 after the start of treatment. The total dose received over the course of treatment was 144 million UC‐MSCs (4 × 36 million). In the follow‐up phase, visits occurred at week 49 (12 months after the start of treatment, 3 months after the last dose) and week 89 (21 months after the start of treatment, 12 months after the last dose).
The primary endpoint was safety, which was assessed at six different time points during the study using complete psychiatric and medical evaluations, laboratory exams, and occurrence of adverse events. Now here’s where the scientific value of the study falls to near zero:
Signals of efficacy were evaluated by parent‐reported outcomes via the CARS and ATEC tools44, in collaboration with the study pediatric psychiatrist, who evaluated the appearance, behavior, mood, speech, and intellectual functioning of the subjects to supplement parental
Parent reported outcomes with no controls? Even worse, the ATEC is the Autism Treatment Evaluation Checklist. It’s a dubious “tool” to measure the severity of autistic behaviors and symptoms used by autism quacks to “evaluate” treatment efficacy. Specifically, it was invented by Bernard Rimland and Stephen M. Edelson of the Autism Research Institute, and it was favored by autism quacks like Mark and David Geier.
Another issue is that this trial had no control group. Of course, it was a phase I/II trial; so it didn’t have to have a control group. Single arm designs are acceptable in this type of study because safety, not efficacy, is the primary endpoint and biomarkers and behavioral markers are the secondary endpoints. Unfortunately, what this means is that this trial cannot demonstrate efficacy. There are exceptions in which such a trial could demonstrate efficacy, but they are rare; specifically, if the effect size is so huge that it’s clear that there is efficacy. One example was the phase I clinical trial for Gleevec, in which the drug caused cancer to disappear in the majority of patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia (CML) that were in the early, or chronic, phase of the disease. Five years later, 98% of patients from the trial were still in remission. It is true that sometimes you can find signals of efficacy in a single arm phase I/II clinical trial, hints that the treatment being tested is having a therapeutic effect, but such signals need to be validated in a randomized trial.
This is not such a trial to me. The decreases in various cytokine levels reported were not impressive, and the changes in the ATEC and CARS scores was similarly unimpressive at twelve months and returned nearly to baseline by 21 months. In other words, I am singularly underwhelmed by the results of this study. Interestingly, there was considerable dropout as time went on such that only 14 of the subjects were evaluated at the 21-month time point. Moreover, only eight subjects showed a decrease in their ATEC and CARS scores, only five showing concomitant decrease in cytokine levels. It’s all pretty thin gruel.
As for the Stem Cell Institute, a perusal of its website reveals very quickly that it’s just another for-profit stem cell clinic, and you know what I think of for-profit stem cell clinics. Stem Cell Institute claims to be able to treat autism, cerebral palsy, heart failure, multiple sclerosis, osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis, spinal cord injury, and autoimmune diseases, among others. The website is full of testimonials, like this one:
And this one:
NEW VIDEO – Stem Cell Therapy for Autism: Reese Reese's dad discusses his improvements after stem cell therapy in Panama. https://t.co/ExBYJO1sxB #stemcells #autism pic.twitter.com/68LeXpgflS
— Stem Cell Institute (@Stemcellspanama) June 18, 2019
Neil Riordan, founder, chairman and chief science officer of the Stem Cell Institute, is even appeared on Joe Rogan’s podcast with Mel Gibson, which real stem cell scientist Paul Knoepfler characterized thusly:
In it Rogan is very upbeat about stem cells and doesn’t probe much as an interviewer. He also mentions his own perceived positive experiences with stem cells. To me he seems too cheery about stem cells, and I’m a big fan of stem cells.
Gibson talks about how he believes stem cells from Riordan were transformative for his elderly father. When Gibson talks about his dad, it is powerful, but that doesn’t mean this stuff really works. Gibson has also himself gotten stem cells.
Riordan makes a number of medical claims about what his institution can achieve with stem cells for a whole rainbow of conditions. It is mentioned that there are published papers on this specific stuff, but from what I’ve seen there isn’t much scientific rigor there in my opinion. Mostly we hear very big, unsupported claims about outsized positive outcomes for almost any medical problem. Does it sound too good to be true? I’m highly skeptical of the safe and effective use of these cells at this time in aging and especially in autism. Injecting laboratory-cultured stem cells into kids also invokes more bioethical considerations and there could be unique long-term risks that we do not understand.
Overall, to me this video again feels like an informercial that has likely greatly benefited Riordan.
No doubt it has, given that it’s had over 2.6 million views in the year and a half since the podcast first hit YouTube.
But what about the science? It is, as Dr. Knoepfler described it, not particularly scientifically rigorous. There are some preclinical studies in cell culture and animals, some speculative articles discussing the rationale for the use of stem cell treatments in various diseases, biomarker studies after stem cell infusions, and this rather uninformative phase I/II study of MSCs in autism.
This study, of course, is monstrously unethical. There was no plausible biological rationale for using MSCs to treat autism, and the treatment, although safe, is not without risk. In this trial, although there were no severe or life-threatening adverse events, there were a number of mild to moderate severity ones, including weight loss, inflammation at the site of infusion, headache, fever, and an increase in tics, hyperactivity and aggression, irritability, and obsessive-compulsive behaviors. There was, of course, also the risk of infection, blood-borne diseases, and other potential complications of any infusion of human blood- or tissue-based products, all without compelling evidence that the treatment is likely to work. To make it even more unethical, the patients’ families paid to be part of the clinical trial.
Of course, subjects in clinical trials often bear costs of being in the trial, specifically travel, time off work, and the like. Patients’ health insurance usually covers all their care not directly related to the clinical trial, such as other treatments and drugs, routine laboratory values and tests that would have been ordered anyway if not for the clinical trial, and the like. However, in general, the sponsor of the clinical trial provides experimental drug or treatment for free and bears the costs of the clinical trial itself, including the costs of the offices needed for randomization, data collection, and other expenses related to the clinical trial. However, it is generally considered at best ethically problematic to charge patients to be subjects in a clinical trial, usually in the form of making them pay for the experimental intervention, in this case stem cells. Arguments for this “pay-to-play” funding mechanism generally boil down to five, such as enhancing informed consent because the patient actually pays. There’s also an argument that pay-to-play is no different than taking part in expanded access programs, in which patients are often expected to pay for the experimental drug. Then, of course, clinics like this often claim that studies like the Stem Cell Institute study would never be done otherwise. (I, of course, would counter: Good. Studies like the Stem Cell Institute’s study shouldn’t be done.) Then, of course, there’s the “because freedom” argument.
On the other hand, there are a number of arguments against pay-to-play clinical trials, which were well enumerated in this article from 2015. To me, the most powerful argument against pay-to-play clinical trials is that they are exploitative, the psychological exploitation of individuals desperate to do anything to save their own or a loved one’s life. Desperate patients (or parents of patients) often feel tremendous pressure to raise funds. We’ve seen this many times before discussed on this very blog for dubious cancer therapies. Such patients go to great lengths to raise funds. They often take out large loans, raid their retirement savings, or even sell their house. They launch GoFundMe efforts and relentlessly fundraise on social media.
Also:
Paying for research participation might actually undermine social value and scientific validity by skewing research priorities or encouraging methodologically inferior research. Whatever its limitations, one of the critical functions of peer review is the comparative assessment of the worthiness and methodological rigor of alternative research projects. Peer reviewers can evaluate the potential social benefit of research and prioritize longer-term but more beneficial projects. Pay-to-play funding would prioritize research needs of the wealthy and their ailments. These priorities are unlikely to align with research that might be worthy but afflict individuals without the means to pay, such as interventions for lead poisoning, tuberculosis, or schistosomiasis. If successful, pay-to-play research could also skew researchers and research institutions to pursue lucrative studies that are not necessarily socially valuable. This might lead to a brain and facilities drain. Last, pay-to-play funding might enable studies that ask important questions but lack the methodological rigor to survive traditional peer review. At the extreme, pay-to-play arrangements might enable charlatans to pursue—and profit from—flawed trials that offer no, or even negative, social value (4–6).
And:
Pay-to-play arrangements also create challenges for the ethical implementation of a research study. Having a participant pay could lead to the bending of inclusion criteria, pressure on investigators not to remove participants from a study, and even inappropriate influences on decisions to terminate a study. For instance, it is not hard to imagine a pay-to-play participant pressuring a researcher to grant an exception to inclusion criteria and a researcher agreeing to do so because of the additional financial support. Similarly, patients with limited therapeutic options sometimes demand access to drugs even after studies have proven them to be ineffective. Finally, the paying participants might be reluctant to fully disclose symptoms and side effects. Having invested substantial sums, participants may not want to acknowledge problems that might result in their exclusion or removal from a study.
We can see this in this study by the Stem Cell Institute. A far more methodologically rigorous clinical trial would have been to do a randomized, double-blind, controlled clinical trial. Who would pay to be part of that study, though, given that there would be a 50-50 chance of winding up in the placebo control group? So the Stem Cell Institute did a less rigorous phase I/II study of patients who would have paid to travel to Panama and get the stem cell treatments anyway. To the Stem Cell Institute, this wasn’t a clinical trial. It was advertising. Riordan claims that “$7,200 the institute charged parents was ‘to defray costs outside of the treatment. The actual treatments were provided free of charge.'” One of the patients’ parents claimed that her expenses totaled over $20,000. Even if Riordan did defray some of the costs of the clinical trial, I’d conclude that it was an investment in advertising, to give the appearance of scientific rigor.
Then, I came across this:
This clinic was the largest recipient of crowdfunding $, including for stem cell 'treatments' for autism, in the recent study @LeighGTurner and I published. Duke and Northwestern showed up too. https://t.co/3Slbo3PzVh
— Jeremy Snyder (@jeremycsnyder) July 25, 2019
So the Stem Cell Institute was the largest recipient of money from patients who crowd-funded their stem cell treatments. Also, given that Duke came up on the list, this implies that there is a “pay-to-play” or “pay-to-participate” component to its stem cell trials, including a stem cell trial for autism:
For families interested in receiving this treatment (who are not in the trial) they can pay Duke for the treatment through Expanded Access Protocol, but Kurtzberg said some families are frustrated because there’s a long waiting list to get in.
To me, this is disturbingly similar to what the Stem Cell Institute is doing, as was the phase I clinical trial run by Duke to show safety published in 2017. It was an open label study; so huge placebo effects were, of course, possible.
Paul Knoepfler also did a disturbing series of posts about a stem cell trial run by Richard Burt of Northwestern University that required patients to pony up $100,000 to be part of the trial, while marketing “cure-like” outcomes, thus raising (to me more than him, in fairness) uncomfortable parallels to predatory trials by for-profit stem cell clinics like the Stem Cell Institute in Panama.
Stem cells definitely show enormous promise for a number of conditions, but all too often they are treated like magic, as though just infusing them, whatever type of cells, will lead to the cells magically homing in where they are needed and magically doing what they need to do. However, testing these therapies in any sort of “pay-to-play” model is an ethical minefield that universities enter at their peril. Bioethicist Alison Bateman-House noted that there is going to be a conference at the Department of Health and Human Services that will address pay-to-play clinical trials as one of its topics:
Setting aside everything else, I have serious concerns about any pay to play “trial.” That’s 1 of the topics to be discussed at this upcoming meeting (https://t.co/xqmeOhR1iD). There’s a webcast
— Dr. Alison Bateman-House (@ABatemanHouse) July 25, 2019
The Secretary’s Advisory Committee on Human Research Protections (SACHRP) is a committee that provides expert advice and recommendations to the Secretary of HHS on issues pertaining to the protection of human subjects in research. I’ll be interested in what it ends up saying about pay-to-play research of any kind, but in particular in stem cell trials, which seem to be particularly highly represented in requiring patients to pay.

Hypothesized benefit from integrative treatments for veterans’ chronic pain fails to materialize
Researchers hypothesized that chiropractic, acupuncture and massage would benefit veterans with chronic pain. Their results said otherwise.
Jann Bellamy on April 12, 2018
Link


A recent review of thousands of Veterans Administration (VA) medical records concluded that there was no significant difference in self-rated pain intensity between veterans who received complementary and integrative healthcare treatments (chiropractic care, acupuncture or massage) and those who did not. This calls into question the both the VA’s aggressive campaign to incorporate integrative medicine into veterans’ healthcare and the promotion of integrative treatments as a solution to the opioid crisis.
The researchers, who reported their findings in the journal Pain Medicine, observed that several meta-analyses of randomized and non-randomized trials showed small to moderate effects of acupuncture, massage and spinal manipulation (which they collectively refer to as “Complementary and Integrative Health” or “CIH”) on pain intensity “relative to no treatment or usual care.” (Of course, as David Gorski and others have pointed out, what matters is how the treatment compares to sham treatment, but never mind.) However, they noted, trials were conducted in small samples (<100 patients) over short follow-up durations (<6 months). Therefore, they concluded, these trials might not be representative of the natural course of chronic pain or the patients who suffer from it.
Thus, the authors wanted to evaluate the effectiveness of acupuncture, massage and chiropractic care on chronic pain using a different method and a much larger population. Researchers culled a study sample of almost 310,000 musculoskeletal disorder (MSD) cases from VA medical records. Each veteran was followed from initial diagnosis until death, loss to VA care, or for a maximum of 3 years. From these cases, they identified 7,621 who received one or more clinical visits for acupuncture, massage or chiropractic care during the study period. Self-reported pain scores of CIH recipients were then compared to what are referred to as “non-CIH recipients,” that is, veterans who did not have acupuncture, massage or chiropractic care visits during the same period (n=301,656), using statistical methods we’ll return to in a moment.
We sought to evaluate CIH effectiveness on chronic pain . . . among a large cohort of US veterans receiving care in VHA facilities. Our hypothesis was that treatment with CIHs should have a modest benefit on reducing intensity of chronic pain. Accordingly, we expect that on average veterans who received one or more courses of CIH therapies would report less intense pain than those who did not receive such therapies, after appropriate control of potential selection and confounding biases inherent to observational data. [Emphasis added.]
Like others who are overly sanguine about the value of CIH for pain, the authors note the high burden of chronic pain among veterans and concern over the “opioid epidemic” (their quotation marks, not mine). And, as is also the case with others who promote CIH, their optimism is curious, in light of their admission that:
randomized trial evidence for CIH is inadequate.
To test their hypothesis, the authors used what is called “Propensity Score” (PS)-based causal methods. Without getting too much into the statistical weeds (where I would be totally lost), PS-based methods, according to these researchers:
attempt to tackle potential selection and confounding biases in a similar fashion to randomized trials by resampling hypothetically more comparable treatment and control groups . . .
The authors say that the “real world effectiveness” of CIH treatments on chronic pain have yet to be investigated by PS methods, thus their choice of methodology. I note that it is possible to investigate “real world effectiveness” of treatments with inadequate randomized trial evidence of effectiveness only because we are dealing with CIH here. In real, or “conventional,” medicine, not knowing whether a treatment works or not normally bars its use and a vast database tracking the use of unproven treatments on patients simply would not exist.
Basically, they carry this out by matching individual patient characteristics, or, in statistics parlance, “covariates,” in the two groups to avoid confounding factors. These included co-morbidities such as hypertension and diabetes, mental health diagnoses like PTSD, substance abuse, and opioid use. When compared head-to-head, without removing potential confounders, CIH recipients scored almost a point higher on pain intensity ratings. Application of various propensity score methods reduced this disparity to about a third of a point and eventually equalized the scores.
(If you want to know more about their methods, you can read the article. Although “the work is written by US Government employees and is in the public domain,” I could find it only in Pain Medicine, which is behind a paywall.)
Thus, contrary to their hypothesis:
we evaluated CIH approaches among >300,000 veterans with musculoskeletal pain over three years and did not find a significant difference in self-rated pain intensity between those receiving and not receiving the approaches. PS-based causal methods were able to balance [confounders between the two groups], yet they failed to “recover” the potential CIH benefit reported from some randomized trials.
In other words, when you use treatments with inadequate, or even negative, clinical trial evidence in the real world they are not magically transformed into effective treatments. Whodathunk?
The authors do admit it’s possible that their results:
may actually reveal the clinical truth that such CIH therapies may not have an overall benefit as expected, [but – wait for it – the inevitable qualifier!] at least as delivered in current practice. Indeed, the effect sizes reported from randomized trials are generally small to moderate, with multiple negative findings.
Of course, as we know, one never says “never” in complementary and integrative medicine research. The authors suggest – you guessed it –
further research is needed.
That’s because, they say, CIH approaches “may be” effective for certain subgroups, or certain types of chronic pain, or patients with “unique characteristics,” or at different doses, or with better matched confounders among patient groups (more than the 35 covariates accounted for in this study, that is), or at different frequencies, or different durations, or without potential misclassifications of CIH exposure, or with different analytical methods, or different study populations.
In conclusion:
Given the inadequate evidence for CIH effectiveness for chronic pain and the mounting concern over side effects of chronic opioid treatment, further studies using innovative and rigorous research methodologies and more comprehensive and precise data on CIH “dose,” both randomized and observational data are warranted.
Nope. Don’t buy it. We’ve been waiting for this elusive potential of integrative medicine to reveal itself for over a quarter of a century, and it hasn’t happened yet. Funded in part at taxpayer expense by the CAM cash cows of NCCIH (over $2 billion) and the military (who together funded this study), we know:
    • Acupuncture’s proposed mechanism of action is highly implausible. It has already been the subject of thousands of clinical trials and the evidence for its use in treating chronic pain, and anything else for that matter, is unconvincing. It is a theatrical placebo.
    • “Chiropractic care” is often subluxation-based diagnosis and treatment and assorted other pseudoscience. Anything beneficial chiropractors do (such as spinal manipulation and mobilization, in appropriate cases) can be done just as well by physical therapists, who practice evidence-based healthcare.
    • Massage therapy, while relaxing, is not supported by sufficient evidence (also here) for pain relief and is full of quack practices like reiki, reflexology, polarity therapy and cranial sacral therapy.
Unfortunately, this study is highly unlikely to affect the practices of the firmly entrenched military-integrative complex at the VA, in the form of its Office of Patient Centered Care and Cultural Transformation. Under its auspices, the VA has abandoned even the pretense of requiring evidence of effectiveness and incorporated quack practices like reiki and reflexology into veterans’ healthcare, a move of dubious legality under federal law.
Integrative medicine proponents at the VA are part of a much larger effort to promote the incorporation of pseudoscience into medicine, most recently as a magic bullet for the opioid crisis. Spinning negative trial results into positive PR is an art form in integrative medicine.
In fact, that’s an excellent reason not to waste more money doing studies of CAM: They don’t affect the practice of integrative medicine one bit.

ICD-11: A triumph of the “integration” of quackery with real medicine
ICD-10 is an a standardized system of alphanumeric codes for diagnoses maintained by the World Health Organization used throughout the world for billing, epidemiology, research, and cataloging causes of death. Its successor, ICD-11, is nearing completion, and unfortunately appears to be taking the “integration” of traditional medicine to a whole new level by integrating quack diagnoses with real diagnoses.
David Gorski on March 19, 2018
Link

Like most doctors, I detest ICD codes, and in particular I detest ICD-10. Of course, I realize that most non-physicians reading this are asking, “What the heck is an ICD code, and what is ICD-10”? Basically, ICD stands for International Classification of Diseases, and ICD codes are alphanumeric codes used to classify diagnoses. They system’s history dates back to 1893, and the World Health Organization has been responsible for its maintenance and updating since its founding in 1948, at which time ICD-6 was the most current version. Indeed, The WHO Nomenclature Regulations, adopted in 1967, stipulated that Member States use the most current ICD revision for mortality and morbidity statistics. The ICD has been revised and published in a series of editions to reflect advances in health and medical science over time. The most current version is ICD-10, which was endorsed in May 1990 by the Forty-third World Health Assembly and formally adopted by the WHO in 1994.
ICD codes started out as being a standardized list of diseases and conditions to be used on death certificates as causes of death. These days, ICD codes are used for a number of purposes, although most doctors encounter these codes when they use them for billing insurance companies, Medicare, or Medicaid for their services. However, ICD codes are also used for epidemiology, health management, clinical diagnoses, and death certificates. According to the WHO:
ICD is the foundation for the identification of health trends and statistics globally, and the international standard for reporting diseases and health conditions. It is the diagnostic classification standard for all clinical and research purposes. ICD defines the universe of diseases, disorders, injuries and other related health conditions, listed in a comprehensive, hierarchical fashion that allows for:
    • easy storage, retrieval and analysis of health information for evidenced-based decision-making;
    • sharing and comparing health information between hospitals, regions, settings and countries; and
    • data comparisons in the same location across different time periods.
Uses include monitoring of the incidence and prevalence of diseases, observing reimbursements and resource allocation trends, and keeping track of safety and quality guidelines. They also include the counting of deaths as well as diseases, injuries, symptoms, reasons for encounter, factors that influence health status, and external causes of disease.
Normally, ICD codes were updated roughly every ten years, but ICD-10 is now nearly a quarter of a century old. As you might imagine, it’s getting a bit long in the tooth, no matter how long the US delayed in requiring its use. (The US, being ever so slow, didn’t switch from ICD-9 to ICD-10 until 2015, after most of the rest of the world had been using ICD-10 for decades. I could go on about how much fun it was to make that switch at the hospital and clinic level, given that I was in charge of creating new billing forms for our breast center in preparation for the adoption of ICD-10, but I doubt that it would interest most of you.) So ICD-11 is in active development, having undergone field testing in 2017, with a current goal of a version to be approved in 2018, as this report indicates. There’s also this:
Do you see what I see all the way to the right of the timeline, near the end? Yes, it’s traditional medicine, and, yes, it is exactly what you think. Traditional Chinese medicine diagnoses are being incorporated into the ICD-11. Truly, the “integration” or “unification” of traditional Chinese medicine with science-based medicine is nearly complete. Let’s take a look. Soon (or maybe not so soon if the US takes as long to implement ICD-11 as it did to implement ICD-11), I will be able to code for liver yin deficiency pattern (ICD-11 code SF50) or liver qi stagnation pattern (ICD-11 code SF57). This is not the first time we have discussed the issue on SBM. Would that it were the last.
Quackery codes to be introduced in the ICD-11?
I decided to write about how quackery is insinuating itself into the ICD-11 because a reader sent me this link, which is a browser for the latest beta draft of ICD-11. You can scroll down to 26, which is Traditional Medicine conditions – Module 1, where the WHO describes this section thusly:
This chapter refers to disorders and patterns which originated in ancient Chinese Medicine and are commonly used in China, Japan, Korea, and elsewhere around the world. This list represents a union set of harmonized traditional medicine conditions of the Chinese, Japanese, and Korean classifications. For an extended list of traditional medicine conditions, please refer to the International Classification of Traditional Medicine (ICTM).
Oh, yes. There is an International Classification of Traditional Medicine (ICTM). I’ll get to that momentarily. First, let’s look at what the WHO has come up with for “integrating” traditional medicine into real medicine. In fairness, I will note that the introduction specifies this:
The use of the ICD-11 TM Chapter is optional for those who would like to record epidemiological data about traditional medicine practice. This chapter should not be used for mortality reporting.
Well that’s a relief! Of course, you and I know that, once ICD-11 is adopted, practitioners of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), such as naturopaths, acupuncturists, and the like, will be lobbying hard to make sure that this chapter is used. But let’s look at what the WHO says about TCM:
A disorder in traditional medicine, disorder (TM)*, refers to a set of dysfunctions in any of the body systems which presents with associated manifestations, i.e. a single or a group of specified signs, symptoms, or findings. Each disorder (TM) may be defined by its symptomology, etiology, course and outcome, or treatment response. 1 Symptomology: signs, symptoms or unique findings by traditional medicine diagnostic methods, including inspection such as tongue examination, history taking (inquiry), listening and smelling examination, palpation such as pulse taking, abdominal examination, and other methods. 2 TM Etiology: the underlying traditional medicine explanatory style, such as environmental factors (historically known in TM translations as the external contractions), emotional factors (historically known in TM translations as the seven emotions), or other pathological factors, processes, and products. 3 Course and outcome: a unique path of development of the disorder (TM) over time. 4 Treatment response: known response to traditional medicine interventions. In defining a disorder (TM), symptomology and etiology are required. Course and outcome, and treatment response are optional.
A pattern in traditional medicine, pattern (TM), refers to the complete clinical presentation of the patient at a given moment in time including all findings. Findings may include symptomology or patient constitution, among other things. 1 Symptomology (as above). 2 Constitution: the characteristics of an individual, including structural and functional characteristics, temperament, ability to adapt to environmental changes, or susceptibility to various health conditions. This is relatively stable, being in part genetically determined while partially acquired.
Let’s take a look at some of the more…interesting…TCM diagnoses that ICD-11 will allow practitioners to code for:
SG26 Bladder meridian pattern (TM)A pattern characterized by clashing headache and sensation that the eyes are being torn out. The nape of the neck is tight, there is pain in the spine, the waist arches backwards, the thigh cannot flex, the back of the knee has lumps and there is a sensation that the calf is being split apart. Symptoms and signs also include excess lacrimation, nasal congestion, pain in the head, neck, back, waist, sacrum, back of the knee, calf and foot, and impaired use of the little toe. It may be explained by Bladder meridian dysfunction.
I do like the addition of “impaired use of the little toe.” It’s such a nice little detailed touch to the otherwise nonspecific. That’s the symptom that cinches the diagnosis, I bet. Of course, if you have a headache so severe that it feels as though your eyes are being torn out, along with pain in the spine and all these other symptoms, I’d be worried about either a brain tumor or meningitis, among other potentially life-threatening conditions. Of course, adding all these other symptoms just makes the whole thing a mess. But you’ll soon be able to code for it!
I like this next one just for the name:
SG29 Triple energizer meridian pattern (TM)A pattern characterized by deafness and tinnitus, swelling and obstruction of the throat. Symptoms and signs also include sweating, pain at the lateral corners of the eye and cheeks, pain behind the ear and along the shoulders, upper arms, elbows and outer border of the forearms and impaired use of the fourth finger. It may be explained by Triple Energizer meridian dysfunction.
I suppose this must be worse than the double or single energizer meridian pattern. Actually, there doesn’t appear to be such a diagnosis. Why always triple? Who knows. I do note, though, that there are various subdiagnoses, including upper energizer stage patterns (SG70), middle energizer stage patterns (SG71), and lower energizer stage patterns (SG72). Of course, you know this is an ICD classification, because even diagnoses based on prescientific mystical beliefs include something like triple energizer stage patterns (TM), unspecified (SG7Z). Doctors, nurses, medical coders, and others who use ICD-10 codes on a regular basis will get that joke.
Before I move on, I can’t resist listing a couple more. I mentioned that I’ll soon be able to code for liver qi stagnation, but what does that mean? It means exactly what it sounds like:
SF57 Liver qi stagnation pattern (TM)A pattern characterized by distending and burning pain of the hypochondrium, along with restlessness, irritability, bitter taste, dry mouth, red tongue with yellow coating or a wiry rapid pulse. It may be explained by long-term stagnation of liver system qi induced internal fire factor that affects tissues and functions associated with the liver system.
Because I sure don’t want my qi stagnated by internal fire factor or qi stagnation producing internal fire factor. (I can’t tell which they mean from the rather garbled phrasing of that definition.) In any case, these Traditional Medicine codes are all based on several patterns. Here are several:
    • Principle-based patterns: “Based on the analysis of symptomatology and constitution of a patient, patterns are categorized into eight principles which consist of four groups of opposing characteristics i.e. Yin & Yang, Heat & Cold, Deficiency & Excess and Interior & Exterior (and with the addition of three intermediate patterns). These principles constitute the most basic patterns which may be combined for pattern differentiation in more refined detail.”
    • Environmental factor patterns: “This section comprises patterns with a shared explanation related to environmental factors (i.e. wind, cold, dampness, dryness, fire, summer-heat) and the presence of the pathogens, parasites or toxins.”
    • Body constituents patterns: “This section comprises a range of dysfunctions of four body constituents, which is qi, blood, fluid and essence. These patterns are grouped together on the basis of their common etiology such as an abnormal flow of qi, blood, or essence or dysfunctional distribution of fluid.” (I note that this section has diagnoses like qi deficiency pattern, qi stagnation pattern, qi uprising pattern, qi collapse pattern, qi sinking pattern, and, of course, qi patterns, unspecified.)
    • Organ system patterns: “This section comprises a range of Qi disturbance patterns grouped together on the basis of their having in common a demonstrable etiology in Qi, which means invisible action, function, or working that circulates throughout the body. Qi Patterns (TM) may be explained by a disorder of physical energy supply, mental disorder, or a [sic] autonomic nerve system disorder.”
    • Meridian and collateral patterns: “This section contains a group of TM patterns caused by functional disorder of meridians consisting of twelve main meridians and eight extra meridians.”
    • Six stage patterns: “This section contains patterns in accordance with the six-stage theory. A common characteristic of the Six-stage patterns included in this section is their relationship with the acute febrile conditions.”
    • Triple energizer stage patterns: “This section comprises dysfunctional systemic patterns of coordination, assimilation, elimination and integration attributed to invasion and transformation of the dampness-heat factor on the three portions of the body cavity (upper energizer, middle energizer and lower energizer), through which the visceral qi is transformed.” And you wouldn’t want your visceral qi transformed, now would you?
    • Four constitution medicine patterns: “Four Constitution Medicine Patterns are classified by each type of constitution: Large Yang Type (Large Lung Small Liver), Small Yang Type (Large Spleen Small Kidney), Large Yin Type (Large Liver Small Lung), and Small Yin Type (Large Kidney Small Spleen). Metabolic processes in Four Constitution Medicine can be divided into 2 categories: Qi-Humor metabolism and Water-Food metabolism. Large Yang Type patterns and Large Yin Type patterns are caused by disorder of the Qi-Humor metabolism while Small Yang Type patterns and Small Yin Type patterns are caused by disorder of the Water-Food metabolism. Patterns occurring for each type of constitution can be subdivided into three types: external TM disorder, internal TM disorder and external-internal combined TM disorder. External TM disorder is caused by imbalance of Seong (Innate Nature) and internal TM disorder is caused by the imbalance of Jeong (Emotional Disposition).”
I could go on, as I didn’t list all of them, but you get the idea. These diagnoses are not based in science or modern medicine, but rather in prescientific beliefs about the body and vitalistic mystical and religious beliefs dating back millennia. Such diagnoses have no place being included in a classification system that is supposed to reflect the latest in medical science. If you don’t believe me, I encourage you to go to the ICD-11 Beta Draft and peruse Traditional Medicine Conditions.
Why is the WHO “integrating” quackery with real medicine in ICD-11?
As I perused the ridiculous pseudoscientific “diagnoses” in the Traditional Medicine section of the ICD-11 Beta Draft, one question kept going through my mind: Why? Why is the WHO “integrating” quackery with real medicine in the official disease classification system used by basically the whole world? Why is it betraying the trust it was granted when the maintenance and updating of the International Classification of Diseases were first entrusted to it in 1948? It began with something I mentioned above, the International Classification of Traditional Medicine (ICTM), a project designed to classify the use of traditional medicine. The WHO justified starting the ICTM project by pointing to a survey of its member nations that showed that in some Asian countries, over 80% of the population depends on some form of traditional medicine. Of course, my response to that factoid would be that greater efforts must be made to get science-based medicine to these people, not that we should infect the ICD system with quack diagnoses, but that’s just me.
In any event, this is the WHO’s justification for developing the ICTM:
“We recognize that the use of traditional medicine is widespread. For many people – especially in the Western Pacific, South-East Asia, Africa and Latin America – traditional medicine is the primary source of health care,” said Dr Marie-Paule Kieny, Assistant Director-General of Innovation, Information, Evidence and Research at WHO. “Throughout the rest of the world, particularly Europe and North America, use of herbal medicines, acupuncture, and other traditional medicine practices is increasing. Global classification and terminology tools, for traditional medicine, however, have been lacking.”
And:
“Several countries have created national standards for the classification of traditional medicine but there is no international platform that allows the harmonization of data for clinical, epidemiological and statistical use. There is a need for this information to allow clinicians, researchers and policy-makers to comprehensively monitor safety, efficacy, use, spending and trends in health care,” said Kieny.
The classification will initially focus on traditional medicine practices from China, Japan and the Republic of Korea that have evolved and spread worldwide.
Believe it or not, I could support an international classification system for traditional medicine if its sole purpose were as a research tool and it were kept separate from science-based classifications. For instance, such a classification could be used to study herb-drug interactions, an area where there is a great deal that is still unknown. Also, if we knew who uses TCM, for what conditions, and why, we might be able to develop more effective strategies to encourage the use of effective science-based medicine in such populations. I am even sympathetic to one argument, which is that many indigenous peoples are essentially “invisible” to health statistics because they use only traditional medicine.
To address these problems does not require integrating such a classification system with ICD-11, and, such uses were never the intent for the ICTM, which was always intended to be integrated into ICD-11 from its very inception. Indeed, the WHO has been promoting traditional medicine use for a long time. I first became aware of it a few years ago, when the WHO participated in writing supplements for Science promoting the “integration” of TCM with science-based medicine. One of the supplements discussed the WHO’s Traditional Medicine Strategy (2014– 2023), highlighting the global scientific challenges and showing how a systems biology approach can be applied to traditional medicine like acupuncture.
Before that, though, in 2008, the WHO held a Congress on Traditional Medicine in Beijing and adopted the Beijing Declaration, which was basically a declaration to support the use of traditional medicine. You can read the whole declaration for yourself here, but here are some key statements:
I. The knowledge of traditional medicine, treatments and practices should be respected, preserved, promoted and communicated widely and appropriately based on the circumstances in each country.
Yes, you read that right. It gets worse, though. Here are three more parts of the Declaration:
III. Recognizing the progress of many governments to date in integrating traditional medicine into their national health systems, we call on those who have not yet done so to take action.
And:
V. Governments should establish systems for the qualification, accreditation or licensing of traditional medicine practitioners. Traditional medicine practitioners should upgrade their knowledge and skills based on national requirements.
VI. The communication between conventional and traditional medicine providers should be strengthened and appropriate training programmes be established for health professionals, medical students and relevant researchers.
This is nothing less than a call for the full “integration” of TCM quackery with science-based medicine. I can’t help but point out that the WHO’s own press release on ICTM in 2010 stated that its purpose was to “assist in creating an evidence base for traditional medicine,” as though the assumption was that traditional medicine works. As Ryan Abbott, director of research and project management for Nova Worldwide Consulting and a former member of WHO’s traditional medicine team, put it, “Inclusion in the WHO Family of International Classifications, a very conventional tool of mainstream medical care, would be a powerful endorsement of traditional medicine.” Abbott also noted that an additional impact might include greater insurance reimbursement for traditional providers and services.
Because of course it will. That’s a huge part of the purpose. Insurance companies, governments, and third party payers use ICD-10 codes and CPT procedure codes to determine reimbursement. Inclusion of traditional medicine diagnoses in ICD-11 would provide a powerful tool for quacks to use to lobby for reimbursement for their services.
Proponents also know what the purpose of ICTM and its integration into ICD-11 really is:
The ICTM can be used as an independent, stand-alone classification and could also be included as an additional chapter within the ICD, in part or as a whole. This will enable unification of the conventional and traditional medicine classifications for diagnosis and interventions. The project will establish links with the WHO Family of International Classifications (WHOFIC) network to enable the membership of ICTM as a derived classification of the WHO family.
That’s the real purpose of ICTM and the inclusion of a subset of it in ICD-11: The “integration” of quackery as an equal with science-based medicine. Yes, the WHO says that the traditional medicine module of ICD-11 is optional. For now. I predict that it won’t be long after ICD-11 is adopted and various nations begin to implement it that it will cease to be optional.
Somewhere Chairman Mao Zedong is smiling
I’ve written before, as have other SBM bloggers, about how the construct that we know today as “traditional Chinese medicine” was actually created by Communist dictator Chairman Mao Zedong in the 1940s and 1950s. Basically, Mao, seeing that he did not have the resources to provide real medicine to all his people, decided to tap into the various schools of traditional medicine. In doing so, he and his physicians and scientists essentially retconned the history of TCM to turn it into seemingly an intellectually consistent whole system, when in reality there were many forms of traditional Chinese medicine flowing out of many folk traditions. Meanwhile, Mao himself eschewed TCM, not believing in it:
…In The Private Life of Chairman Mao, Li Zhisui, one of Mao’s personal physicians, recounts a conversation they had on the subject. Trained as an M.D. in Western medicine, Li admitted to being baffled by ancient Chinese medical books, especially their theories relating to the five elements. It turns out his employer also found them implausible.
“Even though I believe we should promote Chinese medicine,” Mao told him, “I personally do not believe in it. I don’t take Chinese medicine.”
Yet in a 1950 speech, Mao proclaimed:
Our nation’s health work teams are large. They have to concern themselves with over 500 million people [including the] young, old, and ill. … At present, doctors of Western medicine are few, and thus the broad masses of the people, and in particular the peasants, rely on Chinese medicine to treat illness. Therefore, we must strive for the complete unification of Chinese medicine. (Translations from Kim Taylor’s Chinese Medicine in Early Communist China, 1945-1963: A Medicine of Revolution.)
Indeed, much of the reason why TCM spread beyond China to much of the developed world, to the point that major academic medical centers such as the Cleveland Clinic offer it, is because Mao aggressively promoted it. Indeed, if you want to know just how aggressively over how long a period of time Mao promoted the export of TCM, it’s worth it to read Kimball Atwood’s epic “Acupuncture Anesthesia”: A Proclamation from Chairman Mao, particularly part III, in which Mao’s efforts to unify TCM with “Western” medicine into a new “whole” are detailed. Indeed, it’s worth repeating Communist Party slogans about medicine from Mao’s era:
1945-50 ‘The Co-operation of Chinese and Western Medicines’
1950-8 ‘The Unification of Chinese and Western Medicines’
1950-53 ‘Chinese Medicine studies Western Medicine’
1954-8 ‘Western Medicine studies Chinese Medicine’
1958- ‘The Integration of Chinese and Western Medicines’
Lest you think that the above slogans are merely artifacts of history from 60+ years ago, think again. A little over a year ago, China passed a law requiring the “integration” of TCM with “Western” medicine, explicitly elevating its status with respect to the state to be on “equal footing.” It also goes a long way towards protecting the business interests of TCM industries, such as those that manufacture herbal remedies. So China is still in the business of promoting the export of TCM, even more than 40 years after Mao’s death.
I doubt that even Mao could have imagined such a triumph of completely integrating TCM into the very codebook for modern medical diagnoses, the ICD-11, but that triumph will soon be upon us. My only hope in the US is that we will be as slow to adopt ICD-11 as we were to adopt ICD-10.

Academic Consortium plan: force medical residents to practice integrative medicine
Jann Bellamy on April 14, 2016
Link


“Integrative medicine” (IM) is an ideological movement within medicine driven in large part by those whose livelihoods depend on its continued existence. This includes both those with positions in academic medicine and individual practitioners who use the IM brand to attract patients.
Despite IM and its antecedents (alternative, complementary, alternative and complementary, complementary and integrative) having been around for about a quarter century, we still do not have a working definition of integrative medicine or have any idea whether it positively affects patient outcomes. And, despite the lip service given to IM being evidence-based, or “evidence-informed” or incorporating “appropriate” services into conventional medicine, there does not seem to be any standard for determining which modalities are appropriate for inclusion. We can infer, however, that evidence of effectiveness is not a criterion, as reiki, cranial sacral “therapy”, and homeopathy are standard fare.
In fact, the prospect for actually improving patient outcomes by importing CAM treatments (such as acupuncture) into medical practice would seem to be decreasing over time, as more and more fail to hold up under the scrutiny of well-designed and conducted clinical trials. Perhaps the dearth of evidence for “alternative” treatments is the impetus behind the importation of conventional modalities, such as nutrition and exercise, into the IM fold, treatments that were never viewed as CAM when the whole enterprise started. It has also led to special pleading demanding that research standards be loosened, most recently by the NCCIH, its director’s promise to ensure “rigorous science” notwithstanding.
There is no standard delivery model for integrative medicine or, importantly, an agreed-upon role for the various practitioners who bring the “integrative” to integrative medicine, such as chiropractors, naturopaths and acupuncturists. For example, should they be allowed to practice independently or should the medical doctor have final say on patient care? And, if they differ in their proposed diagnoses and treatments, how are those issues to be resolved?
None of these deficiencies have stopped the establishment of IM programs at more than half of the medical schools in the US and Canada. And, as we shall see in a moment, the federal government (meaning you, the taxpayer) continues to fund an effort to force integrative medicine on medical students even though a previous government-funded IM experiment in residency training failed to produce positive results.
We don’t know what IM is, but let’s do it anyway
But first, let’s take a look at a recent article in Academic Medicine, the journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges, which details just how dysfunctional the whole academic IM program enterprise is. The lead and second authors of the article, “Establishing an Integrative Medicine Program Within an Academic Health Center: Essential Considerations,” are David Eisenberg, MD, and Ted Kaptchuk, two of IM’s biggest cheerleaders. Kaptchuk, as regular readers of SBM will recall, made a recent appearance in another of my SBM posts, as the co-author of two execrable journal articles advocating the “public health benefits” of homeopathy, including homeopathic vaccines.
Eisenberg, et al., offer some tips on how to construct your own academic IM center based on their experience in creating and running the Osher Clinical Center for Integrative Medicine at Brigham and Women’s Hospital and Harvard Medical School, or “OCC” for short. They begin with the observation:
Surprisingly little attention has been devoted to developing optimal delivery models whereby individuals can responsibly access IM care safely, effectively, and reproducibly across medical setting in a coordinated and cost-effective way.
Frankly, I’m surprised that they’re surprised. What were they thinking would happen when the whole IM enterprise started? That a vague idea about incorporating pseudoscience into medicine for some as-yet-to-be-determined patient benefit would somehow blossom into a structured system offering cost-effective care?
Not surprisingly, allowing CAM providers into the medical fold raises some sticky questions, such as: should CAM practitioners participate in the Electronic Health Records (EHR) system? If so, the authors note,
A considerable amount of effort may be necessary to establish a lexicon which can be readily understood by both “conventional” care practitioners and CAM professionals. Without such attention, office “notes” of some CAM professionals (e.g., acupuncturists) may be unintelligible to the average conventional medical colleague who is caring for the same patient.
I think the issue is bigger than they let on. It’s not just the office notes that are the problem. I’d venture that all of acupuncture is “unintelligible” to the “average,” or even above-average, conventional medical doctor because it doesn’t make any sense whatsoever.
Yet no amount of effort or expense seems to have been spared in trying to solve this one:
An extensive lexicon of terms, definitions, and standardized EMR templates and forms was developed, and all IM team members were required to document all clinical encounters on the hospital’s shared EMR system.
Unfortunately, we aren’t given a single example of this “extensive lexicon,” which would have been highly informative, just not in the way these lexicographers intended.
Of course, in the IM setting, one must address the delicate issue of the CAM providers’ scope of practice. The authors tiptoe around this one:
While licensed CAM professional groups often have suggested scope-of-practice guidelines, individual institutions may choose to limit certain practices or procedures.
I’ll be they do. No academic medical institution is going to let a chiropractor or naturopath loose to do as they wish. Even if they wanted to, the folks in risk management wouldn’t stand for it.
Apparently, their liberal attitude toward evidence does not extend to practices that might actually cause patient harm, as opposed to their being merely ineffective and “unintelligible.”
By way of example, some medical institutions’ clinical leaders oppose the chiropractic manipulation of the cervical spine owing to concerns about elevated risks of cerebrovascular accident. [An issue discussed last week by Harriet Hall]
Good call. Unfortunately, the OCC didn’t see it that way. They allow it, but limit it. (Presumably, for example, cervical manipulation for “wellness” wouldn’t be allowed.) And they require “hospital-approved informed consent” even though chiropractors argue there isn’t a risk and informed consent is unnecessary.
The article ends with a recognition that we don’t know if these IM centers produce an enhancement in clinical outcomes and a reduction in overall costs, or, at least, at comparable costs. But first things first. Eisenberg, Kaptchuk, et al. say all the IM centers need to get together and decide “how IM models are to be organized, replicated and evaluated,” admitting that “we are still in the early days of organizational development and consensus building.” And, for that, you need data, which the IM centers are just beginning to share. So, they say, we need
a commitment from advocates and skeptics of this controversial area to jointly describe and evaluate integrative care model more precisely in an effort to prove or disapprove their comparability, replicability, clinical effectivity, and costs-effectiveness (or lack thereof) for a range of patient populations.
For this they need “resources” from the public and private sectors to sponsor “best practices” research so they can be standardized. It is only then, they say, that we can apply “rigorous cost-effective evaluations.”
So, basically, these people want to decide on an optimal product delivery model and then decide whether the product works. And they admit they are going to continue treat patients with this nebulous concept even though they admit they don’t know if it works. Do they not see any ethical issues with doing this? Are they going to close the doors if this research they want to carry out shows the whole thing doesn’t improve patient outcomes? As you will see as you read further, the answer is “no.”
And let’s force it on medical residents
Undaunted by these barriers, the good people at the Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine and Health (ACIMH) (formerly, The Consortium for Academic Health Centers for Integrative Medicine) have teamed up with the Academic Collaborative for Integrative Health (ACIH) (formerly, The Academic Consortium for Complementary and Alternative Health) and the Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine to bring you the National Center for Integrative Primary Health Care. (The ACIH is the CAM equivalent of the ACIMH, including chiropractic, naturopathic, acupuncture, ayurvedic, massage therapy, homeopathic and direct-entry midwifery organizations.)
(Please bear with me while we wade through the rest of this alphabet soup.)
Also on board are several integrative medicine organizations. One is Integrative Medicine in Preventive Medicine Education (IMPriME), funded by the government as part of the American College of Preventive Medicine (ACPM) to provide technical support for medical residency and other health care profession training programs interested in incorporating “evidence-based integrative medicine content into their programs.” (We’ll return to that effort shortly.) There’s also Integrative Medicine Access (IMA), an organization that connects people who can’t afford CAM with CAM practitioners. For example, if you have cancer, the IMA can hook you up with practitioners of homeopathy, healing touch, reiki, chiropractic or naturopathy, which are, according to the website, “modalities that have been shown to treat cancer.” Finally, IM4US, another organization promoting CAM for the “underserved,” is participating.
One thing becomes immediately clear as you explore the website of the National Center for Integrative Primary Health Care (NCIPH): medical education, at least in the eyes of ACIMH, has gone beyond merely teaching medical students about various CAM practices so they know what is out there. In ACIMH’s view, primary care (including pediatrics) now includes a “collaboration” between physicians and naturopaths, chiropractors and acupuncturists. These are seen as “primary care disciplines” with which medical residents will share “10 ‘meta-competencies'” developed “through a collaborative process” with CAM providers, who are “team members.” (As is typical of pro-IM discussions, all manner of conventional practitioners are lumped in with the CAM providers as “team members:” pharmacy, public health, nutrition and behavioral medicine.)
And, if all goes according to plan, this collaborative system of primary care and its recently-developed “core competencies” will ultimately become required part of primary care physician education and training. Medical residents will have to master all 10 competencies, including
developing a personalized plan of care to promote health and wellbeing that incorporates integrative approaches including lifestyle counseling and the use of mind-body strategies.
They must be able to “work effectively as a member of an interprofessional team” and must “incorporate IH into community settings and into the healthcare system at large.”
In other words, family practice and pediatric residents will be forced to learn “core competencies” of an IM ideology that views naturopaths, chiropractors and acupuncturists as fellow primary care practitioners, whether they embrace IM or not, or even view the whole enterprise as nonsense.
The development of these “core competencies” in IM and the plan to require IM training with this “interprofessional team” are set out in an article, “Interprofessional Competencies in Integrative Primary Healthcare,” published in a journal called Global Advances in Health and Medicine. Just to give you a flavor of the kind of thing the editors of this journal go for, a recent special supplement was devoted to the “biofield,” and included an article co-authored by Deepak Chopra, “Biofield Science and Healing: An Emerging Frontier in Medicine.”
According to the authors of “Interprofessional Competencies,”
Published evidence is accumulating regarding both the clinical effectiveness and cost effectiveness of IH [integrative healthcare, yet another new name for CAM/IM?].
Had I been a reviewer of this manuscript, I would have required citation of more than one article each for the proposition that clinical and cost effectiveness evidence is “accumulating,” but that’s just me. One article, “Acupuncture for chronic pain: individual patient data meta-analysis,” was decimated by both David Gorski and Steve Novella. The other, “Are complementary therapies and integrative care cost effective?” was deconstructed in a post by Scott Gavura, appropriately titled “Don’t call CAM ‘cost-effective’ unless it’s actually effective.”
As is typical of IM/IH ideology, the rationale for including CAM providers in this effort has nothing to do with CAM:
    • Providing “quality care.”
    • Strong emphasis on prevention and patient engagement to control cost and deliver quality care
    • Whole-person, patient-centered care.
These, according to the authors, have been absent or underemphasized in conventional care but are the “core skills” of IH practitioners. I have yet to see any actual evidence that naturopaths, chiropractors or acupuncturists have some unique ability to provide these skills, but you see this sort of statement over and over in the medical literature.
The authors are aware that “finding time in the curriculum” of medical education and training will be a barrier, yet they are committed to this mandatory IH training, including “onsite experiential and clinical activities in order to assess the knowledge in IH skills” and “faculty development” to support it. One wonders what subjects will be bumped in favor of the IH program. They also acknowledge “the lingering criticisms of IH as non-evidence-based that persist in some sectors of the primary care system.” Just wait until these “sectors” find out about this plan of forced indoctrination into IH. I image the criticisms will “linger” even longer and spread to even more “sectors,” especially those sectors whose subjects will be bumped from the curriculum in favor of IH.
For starters, the NCIPH has developed a 45-hour on-line pilot program “Foundations in Integrative Health.” According to the Oregon College of Oriental Medicine, one of the sites selected by NCIPH for the pilot course, you can complete just 80% of the course and attain a score of 70 on the test to get a Certificate of Completion from the University of Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine. I don’t know if this is a special deal just for OCOM students and faculty or applies to all participants.
There’s no such thing as failure
This project was funded by the Health Services Research Administration (HSRA), a part of the Department of Health and Human Services, to the tune of about $1.7 million. HSRA, whose mission “is to improve health and achieve health equity through access to quality services, a skilled health workforce, and innovative programs,” has taken an unfortunate turn toward handing out funds to promote IM. Perhaps they will be relieved of this burden now that Sen. Tom Harkin, who is behind this effort, is gone. HRSA also funded the establishment of an “Integrative Medicine in Preventive Medicine Education program” in 12 preventive medicine residency programs, an undertaking headed by Dr. David Katz and covered in my previous SBM post, “The elusive ‘potential’ of integrative medicine.” This program was carried out under the auspices of IMPriME, which, as noted above, is a partner in NCIPH.
Apparently, nothing was learned from the preventive medicine residency experiment, or maybe they just chose to ignore what they learned. As I said in the previous post,
At the end of the two-year grant, it was far from clear that the PM residency programs would continue with IM training. According to the post-program analysis, the most prevalent expectations were for IM rotations to continue, but only as elective rotations, and for IM lectures and grand rounds to become less frequent. . . .
In the post-program analysis, the inclusion of CAM emerged as the main stumbling block in implementation of IM training in residency. . . .
[T]he authors of the post-program analysis think the “foremost” question to be answered in further discussion among the preventive medicine community in integrating IM into training and practice may be “the extent to which inclusion of CAM procedures is essential to the practice of IM.” They note that the IOM [report on Integrative Medicine] offers “little guidance” in answering this question and that the reference in the definition to “therapeutic factors known to be effective and necessary . . .” could exclude CAM just as well as include it.
In other words, our last experiment involving IM in residency programs showed us that no one really liked the idea, so let’s spend more money on a plan to force IM on medical residents. But, of course, lack evidence is never a barrier to implementation in integrative medicine.

Pseudoscience sneaks into Ohio guidelines for non-drug pain treatment
Jann Bellamy on February 4, 2016
Link


Ohio recently issued Acute Pain Prescribing Guidelines as part of an effort to reduce the epidemic of opioid abuse and death from overdose. They were drafted under the auspices of the Governor’s Cabinet Opiate Action Team (GCOAT), assisted by medical organizations and other groups.
The guidelines include recommendations for non-pharmacologic treatment, a typical feature of pain treatment guidelines and a worthy effort to avoid prescribing opioids for pain. Unfortunately, the guidelines include treatments that are not evidence based and potentially harmful. We’ll return to that issue shortly.
But first, a brief look at the extent of the opioid problem. According to the CDC, opioids are used to treat moderate-to-severe pain and are often prescribed following surgery, injury, or for painful health conditions, like cancer. In the past few years, there has been a dramatic increase in the acceptance and use of prescription opioids for the treatment of chronic, non-cancer pain, such as back pain or osteoarthritis. From 1999 to 2013, opioid prescription and sales in the U.S. have nearly quadrupled, and overdose deaths have quadrupled right along with them.
The most common drugs involved in prescription overdose deaths include:
    • Hydrocodone (e.g., Vicodin)
    • Oxycodone (e.g., OxyContin)
    • Oxymorphone (e.g., Opana)
    • Methadone (especially when prescribed for pain)
44 people in the U.S. die from overdose of prescription painkillers every day, and a big part of the overdose problem results from prescription opioid painkillers. These drugs can be highly addictive – in some cases, all it takes is one prescription. Once addicted, it can be hard to stop. In 2013, nearly two million Americans abused prescription painkillers. Almost 7,000 people are treated in emergency departments each day for using these drugs in a manner other than as directed.
There is wide variation in opioid prescribing between states that can’t be explained by state differences in health issues that cause people pain. Because the states have the authority to regulate health care practices, they are at the front lines of strategies to reduce improper prescribing and overdose.
State prescription drug monitoring programs (PDMPs) and regulation of pain clinics have shown promising results. My state, Florida, became well known for its “pill mills” and Broward County (Ft. Lauderdale) was ground zero for the industry. In 2010, there were more pill mills than McDonald’s restaurants in the county, and people were driving in from states like Tennessee and Kentucky for their meds. (The local sheriff speculated that Broward’s popularity as a drug destination was due to “better beaches.”) That year, the state enacted more stringent pain clinic regulations and stopped practitioners from dispensing prescription painkillers from their offices. By 2012, there was a 50% decrease in oxycodone overdose deaths.
Where one-stop shopping isn’t available, one strategy used by addicts is to see multiple providers for painkillers. In 2012, both New York and Tennessee began requiring prescribers to check the state’s PDMP before prescribing painkillers. By 2013, these states had a 75% and a 36% drop, respectively, in patients seeing multiple providers for the same drugs.
Like Ohio, several states and medical organizations have issued prescribing guidelines for practitioners, as has the CDC (now in draft), although not without criticism. (These guidelines are for chronic pain, while Ohio’s are for acute pain, but they share recommendations that are addressed in this post.)
According to the Institute of Medicine,
trustworthy clinical practice guidelines appropriately manage conflict of interest, use systematic reviews of the evidence to inform recommendations, and rate the strength of the evidence and recommendations.
A common element of opioid prescribing guidelines is the recommendation that practitioners try non-opioid pharmacologic treatment (e.g., NSIADS) and non-pharmacologic treatment for pain. That is certainly reasonable in appropriate situations – no opioids, no addiction and no overdoses. Ohio’s new Guidelines for non-pharmacologic treatment of acute pain include (emphasis mine):
    • Ice, heat, positioning, bracing, wrapping, splints, stretching
    • Massage therapy, tactile stimulation, acupuncture/acupressure, chiropractic adjustment, osteopathic neuromusculoskeletal medicine
    • Biofeedback
    • Directed exercise such as physical therapy
The guidelines received a fair amount of attention in the Ohio media. Unfortunately, in one media report, Dr. Mary DiOrio, medical director for the state Department of Health, stretched the guidelines even further by saying “seeing a chiropractor” was an appropriate alternative to drug therapy.
I could find no report or discussion of the research backing up these recommendations. Even without that information, one can confidently conclude that acupuncture, acupressure and chiropractic adjustments are not evidence-based recommendations.
Acupuncture can be readily dispensed with, as the lack of convincing research supporting its effectiveness for pain (or anything else) has been widely discussed on SBM. Acupuncture is nothing more than a theatrical placebo. SBM has an excellent short description of acupuncture, plus many additional posts. To summarize:
    • There is no plausible basis in science for the notion that a mysterious force called “qi” runs through the body along “meridians” or that sticking needles in certain points along those meridians can affect any bodily function.
    • Attempts to provide a scientific rationale for acupuncture’s putative effects have failed to come up with a plausible explanation.
    • It doesn’t matter where you stick the needles, or if you use needles at all.
    • All the evidence, taken together, leads to the inevitable conclusion that acupuncture doesn’t work. For anything.
Acupressure is based on the same pre-scientific idea as acupuncture, except that it uses pressure instead of needle insertion. There is no more reason to think it would work, and no more reason to believe any study that “shows it works,” than there is for acupuncture. There is another form of acupressure, auricular acupressure, which suffers from, again, the same fantastical explanation of its supposed mechanism of action as well as lack of evidence of effectiveness. Here, a picture is worth a thousand words:

Ohio should “adjust” the Guidelines
Whatever the mistakes made in recommending acupuncture/acupressure, I have to believe that GCOAT and its collaborators knew what acupuncture is, at least in its needle acupuncture form. But I also have to believe this group (with one exception) had no idea what they were doing when they recommended “chiropractic adjustments.” I imagine they thought that “chiropractic adjustment” is simply another name for spinal manipulation.
Here’s what the GCOAT needs to know: Spinal manipulation and the “chiropractic adjustment” are two entirely different concepts, although easily confused by those who aren’t familiar with chiropractic lingo.
Chiropractors, and only chiropractors, believe in the existence of the “subluxation” and the ability of “chiropractic adjustments” to “correct” them. They use the term “subluxation” differently than the medical profession and physical therapists, to whom it means a partial dislocation of a joint, such as a dislocated shoulder. Chiropractors define subluxation (or one of its many synonyms, like “joint dysfunction” or “neurobiomechanical lesion” or “vertebral subluxation complex”) as
a health concern that manifests in the skeletal joints, and, through complex anatomical and physiologic relationships, affects the nervous system and may lead to reduced function, disability, or illness.
They’ve never been able to explain what these “anatomical and physiologic relationships” are and how they “affect the nervous system” or “lead to reduced function, disability, or illness” in any way that accords with basic anatomy or physiology. Nevertheless, chiropractors purport to be able to detect these mythical subluxations (sometimes with x-rays, thereby exposing the patient to totally unnecessary radiation) and “correct” them with “adjustments,” all to the purported, but never proven, benefit to the patient’s health.
What does this have to do with spinal manipulation? Spinal manipulation is a legitimate manual therapy used by physical therapists, osteopathic physicians, medical physicians and some evidence-based chiropractors. According to SBM’s own Sam Homola:
Recent reviews of the literature indicate that manipulation may not be any more effective than other treatment methods in affecting the ultimate outcome in recovery from back pain. For symptomatic relief of uncomplicated mechanical-type back pain, however, use of hands-on manipulation may provide more immediate and dramatic relief by stretching tight muscles and mobilizing the spine.
But only chiropractors who believe in the non-existent subluxation (and these are in the majority) use “spinal manipulation” as a synonym for the “chiropractic adjustment,” the purpose of which is to “realign” the spine and get rid of the subluxation. Again, according to Dr. Homola:
Endorsement of the use of manipulation in the treatment of mechanical-type back pain is not an endorsement of chiropractic adjustments used to correct subluxations or some other “joint disturbance” alleged to cause illness or poor health.
Nor is it appropriate to use the term “chiropractic adjustment” when describing spinal manipulation as an appropriate manual therapy for pain.
GCOAT might have legitimately recommended spinal manipulation as a non-pharmacologic treatment (putting aside the issue of its questionable effectiveness). But, in using the term “chiropractic adjustment,” it adopted a pseudoscientific treatment, the “adjustment,” for a pseudoscientific condition, the “subluxation.” If GCOAT would like to see examples of Ohio chiropractors who subscribe to these beliefs, here are a few: from Chiropractic Care for Women (Columbus), Upper Arlington Family Chiropractic (Upper Arlington), and Chagrin Natural Health Clinic (Chagrin Falls).
Patient belief in the efficacy of chiropractic adjustments is not without consequences. A chiropractor adjusts the spine at the location of the “subluxation,” which may not be where the patient is actually experiencing his pain, as in this notorious example. Some chiropractors adjust the cervical spine exclusively, which can cause an arterial dissection leading to a stroke. (Despite chiropractors’ unconvincing protestations to the contrary.)
In addition to these risks, patients being subjected to worthless treatments due to chiropractic belief in the “subluxation” and “adjustments” to correct it have been documented numerous times on SBM, such as Clay Jones series of posts on chiropractic treatment (via “adjustments”) of newborn supraventricular tachycardia, for SIDS prevention, nocturnal enuresis, colic, and ear infections, as well as chiropractors use of general fear-mongering about the health effects of normal childhood activity (such as play) if one’s child is not regularly “adjusted.”
How did this happen?
Last fall the Ohio State Chiropractic Association was appointed to the Opiates and Other Controlled Substances Committee to offer their professional insight as to how to tackle the addiction problem in Ohio. Currently, the OSCA’s President, Dr. Kreg Huffer and the association’s executive director, Bharon Hoag, are the OSCA’s representatives to the committee.
Given this input, I have to assume that the other members of the Committee did not come up with the term “chiropractic adjustments” on their own. And I have to assume that none of the other members had any idea what they were endorsing when “chiropractic adjustments” was added as a treatment option. But the Ohio State Chiropractic Association representatives damn sure knew what they were doing.
This is the danger of an “integrative” approach to patient care. You can’t combine science-based health care professions with those steeped in an unscientific culture. The two don’t mix. Other members of the committee saw the guidelines as an opportunity to stem the tide of opiate abuse in Ohio. Chiropractors saw it as a marketing opportunity, and it worked.
Note: Thanks to the pre-med student who alerted SBM to the Ohio Guidelines and their inclusion of acupuncture and chiropractic. It is gratifying to know that we have science-based physicians in the pipeline.

Survey Says… Infectious Disease Docs and CAM
Mark Crislip on August 23, 2013
Link
Surveys are evidently a popular way to get a paper published. Put “complementary alternative medicine survey” into Pubmed and get 2,353 hits. I would have trouble coming up with a hundred groups about whom I would be interested in their use of SCAMs, but I tend to be a lumper rather than a splitter. But if you want to know about SCAM use in chronic pain patients in one Singapore hospital, the information is available.
I am a survey magnet and a remarkable number of people send me dead tree and electronic surveys which I generally ignore. So people like me, those who ignore surveys (but support public television), are underrepresented in surveys. But evidently there is no group whose attitudes about SCAM are not amenable to analysis including my medical brethren, Infectious Disease doctors.
So I was understandably curious when I was sent a link to “Infectious Diseases Physicians’ Attitudes and Practices Related to Complementary and Integrative Medicine: Results of a National Survey“. The abstract makes it sound like my colleagues are a bunch of ignorant rubes who just fell off the turnip truck:
ID physicians were most familiar with vitamin and mineral supplementation (83%), massage (80%), acupuncture (79%), chiropractic (77%), yoga (74%), and herbal medicine (72%). ID physicians most recommended vitamin and mineral supplementation (80%) and massage (62%). Yoga, meditation, and acupuncture were recommended by 52%, 45%, and 46%, respectively. Drug interactions, clinical research, and knowledge of CAM/IM modalities were factors that were considered a major influence. Almost 80% of respondents indicated an interest in IM versus 11% for CAM. Most respondents (75%) felt that IM modalities are useful, and more than 50% believed that they could directly affect the immune system or disease process. Conclusion. ID physicians expressed a markedly greater interest for IM versus CAM. They appear to be familiar and willing to recommend some CAM/IM modalities and see a role for these in the management of certain infectious diseases. Data regarding clinical efficacy and safety appear to be important factors.
Or are they? Abstracts can be misleading and the issue with many SCAM studies revolves around definitions as to what is a SCAM: it can vary from the wackaloon modalities like homeopathy and energy therapies to the potentially reasonable ones like minerals and herbs to interventions that are not alternative at all, like diet and exercise.
The first paragraph does not inspire confidence in what is to follow in the rest of paper.
In the United States of America (USA), as defined by the National Center for complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM), complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) is a group of diverse medical and health care systems, practices, and products that are not presently considered part of conventional medicine and integrative medicine is medicine that combines treatments from conventional medicine and CAM for which there is some high-quality evidence of safety and effectiveness (1)
So I follow the reference to the NCCAM website where they do not give a definition for integrative medicine, instead saying:
There are various definitions for “integrative health care,
and instead give general examples and then state:
The scientific evidence is limited. In many instances, a lack of reliable data makes it difficult for people to make informed decisions about using integrative health care.
I do so love it when a reference does not reflect the claim. Of course, it may be a misplaced footnote, although it does come across as disingenuous.
Since Appeal to Popularity is perhaps the most common logical fallacy used to justify SCAM, a survey was done to see if three ID docs can make a tiger. So they surveyed 1,000 ID docs to:
…determine how ID practitioners in the USA view CAM and integrative medicine modalities by defining the following. (1) How familiar are ID practitioners with CAM and integrative medicine modalities and which ones do they recommend? (2) What are the perceived obstacles to the use of these modalities? (3) What are ID physicians’ beliefs and attitudes toward them and what role, if any, do they see for them in their patients?
311 replied. I didn’t receive the survey as it would have been one I would have filled out.
How you phrase a question determines the answer. CAM is defined as:
a group of diverse medical and health care systems, practices, and products that are not presently considered to be part of conventional medicine.
and integrative medicine is defined as:
the practice of medicine that reaffirms the importance of the relationship between practitioner and patient, focuses on the whole person, is informed by evidence, and makes use of all appropriate therapeutic approaches, health care professionals, and disciplines to achieve optimal health and healing.
Wait. What? That is an interesting definition for the purpose of the survey, since it is an excellent definition not of integrative medicine but of medicine. It is what I aspire to do as a physician and what we teach our residents. However as a marketing ploy, it is excellent as it avoids the details as to what is being integrated.
Almost 80% of respondents indicated an interest in integrative medicine versus 11% for CAM. With those definitions it is no wonder there was interest in integrative medicine. If you are unaware that what is being integrated is fantasy (homeopathy, reiki, acupuncture etc.) with reality-based medicine… To quote me, when you integrate cow pie with apple pie, you do not make the cow pie better, you make the apple pie worse.
The abstract suggests that ID docs:
…appear to be familiar and willing to recommend some CAM/IM modalities and see a role for these in the management of certain infectious diseases.
Although the text would suggest that it depends on which SCAM. The truly wackaloon interventions are low with 8% in favor of homeopathy and 16% in favor or reiki and its ilk. Chiropractic gets a 33% “would recommend” rating and acupuncture a whopping 46%, not too surprising given the ubiquity of the former and the undeserved cachet of the latter.
I do not know whether to be proud or saddened by those numbers. I wonder how knowledgeable these physicians truly are, since it is a self-assessment. Would that embarrassing 8% offer hyperdilute duck liver as a treatment for the ‘flu? I hope not. I used to think that understanding the fantasy-based therapies would lead to their abandonment; that familiarity would breed contempt. Not so, yet again. The issues that influenced the use of SCAM were:
…drug interactions with botanicals and supplements (82%), clinical research showing clear benefit (80%), and knowledge of CAM and integrative medicine modalities (72%).
That 20% thought that clinical research was unimportant in using CAM is almost as sad as the embarrassing 8%. More information to suggest that knowledge of nonsense does not necessarily lead to wisdom with their application.
Or it could be more Dunning-Kruger than true knowledge, given that 75% felt that CAM and IM were useful for symptom relief. 50% thought the effects were due to placebo. Which is true. You are probably aware of my simple equivalency rule. SCAM effects are placebo. Placebo effects are nothing. Therefore SCAM effects are nothing.
What was really depressing was:
…more than 50% also believed that one or more CAM and integrative medicine modalities could directly affect the immune system or the disease process: mind-body modalities (n = 90), botanicals/supplements (n = 96), manipulative and body-based medicine (n = 63), energy medicine (n = 24), and whole medical systems (n = 35).
But then it is hard to say exactly what was going through the minds when filling out the survey, he says, desperately wanting to give his colleagues some benefit of the doubt. Maybe they were thinking about selenium and sepsis or treating vitamin D deficiency or, hell, please, I can’t do it. 35 thought Ayurveda or homeopathy could affect the immune system and 24 thought the same of reiki and therapeutic touch. I can’t make a silk purse out of this sow’s ear. Sorry. That is 24 to 35 too many.
And the madness continues, using SCAM for:
HIV and HIV-related complications (n = 191), recurrent bacterial infections (n = 138), autoimmune complications (n = 121), “chronic Lyme disease” (n = 116), hepatitis B, C (n = 74), acute bacterial infections (n = 35), and others (n = 43).
116 would treat the nonexistent chronic Lyme? Probably by boosting their immune system with the powerful placebo of homeopathy. Or acute bacterial infections? Or HIV? What are they thinking? Maybe I am missing some subtle thought process that would allow these modalities to be used, since the responders say that clinical research is only important 68% of the time. Or, maybe because 20% of the respondents are not Board Certified and 15% have an affiliation with a CAM center, perhaps the 311 who responded were not the best and brightest in the field.
Again, I love the flexible and inclusive way SCAM providers define their field. They call artemisinins, an extremely effective treatment for malaria, alternative. Like taxol. And aspirin. That 14% had insufficient knowledge of artemisinins and 6% thought them slightly beneficial and about half thought cranberries effective for UTI supports my thesis that the best-read in the field were not filling out the survey.
So what can you say about ID docs and SCAM? Given the broad response rates depending on the SCAM surveyed should I be happy or depressed with a statement like:
The practice of infectious diseases relies heavily on information and data; therefore it is not surprising that ID practitioners are data-driven in their clinical practice. The findings from this study support this, as 68% of respondents reported that data based on clinical research was the most important factor in determining treatment plan.
As if they expected surprise at the use of information and data. And what part of medicine does not rely on information and data? Oh, yeah. Evidently SCAM/IM practitioners.
This was a painful entry to write as it generated some cognitive dissonance. I tend towards strong loyalty to my various tribes, or perhaps my various granfalloons: SBM, ID, Trailblazers etc. And I had long considered that ID docs are without a doubt the smartest docs in the hospital and the best diagnosticians. We have to be, since ID crosses all specialties. I leave it to my readers to decide how much exaggeration I am making. But as a group we are evidently no better when it comes to thinking about SCAMs.
I went searching the Pubmeds. There are many articles on cognitive biases as they relate to diagnostic errors. There was a good reference in a recent CID. But there is very little I could find about the errors we make in deciding on a therapy. The only one that comes close is the classic “Observations on spiraling empiricism: its causes, allure, and perils, with particular reference to antibiotic therapy“.
There is nothing I can find that directly addresses the errors so routinely made in the research, evaluation, and specially application of SCAMs. The results of this survey should not come as a surprise. Most docs, even ID docs, are not given the tools to approach fantasy-based interventions.
My wife likes to sew and she has numerous tricks of the trade that she uses when putting a piece together. I am amazed when she watches Sewing with Nancy at all the shortcuts and techniques seamstresses have that allows them to make some amazing creations. She understands the subtleties that can make sewing easier. We need a similar collection of tips and tools for SCAMs.

   Medical Journals and Organizations 

World Health Organization Endorses Quackery
The World Health Organization fails its primary function by promoting traditional quackery.
Steven Novella on October 3, 2018
Link

The World Health Organization (WHO) has announced their 11th version of the International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems (ICD). In a controversial new chapter they include Traditional European Medicine diagnoses, such as excess bile or stagnant blood.
These diagnoses refer to Galenic medicine, which is almost 2,000 years old and dominated Western medicine for 13 centuries. Treatments frequently include blood letting and purgatives, and are based on traditional examinations, which may include a detailed analysis of the color of one’s urine.
By including Galenic medicine in the latest WHO classification, this will allow researchers to track the use of these methods more accurately. Patients may also find such traditional practices more affordable and accessible, and this will also encourage insurance companies to offer coverage.
Oh, except there is one tiny change – the WHO is endorsing Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), not traditional European medicine. But the move is just as unscientific and outrageous. 
A Nature article discussing the move is also frustratingly replete with false balance. Absent in the article is the appropriate outrage that anyone who cares about people’s health and having a legitimate healthcare system should feel.
TCM is essentially the equivalent of bloodletting in the East. The Nature article gives a concise definition:
TCM is based on theories about qi, a vital energy, which is said to flow along channels called meridians and help the body to maintain health. In acupuncture, needles puncture the skin to tap into any of the hundreds of points on the meridians where the flow of qi can be redirected to restore health. Treatments, whether acupuncture or herbal remedies, are also said to work by rebalancing forces known as yin and yang.
The obvious problem with basing an entire system of medicine on qi is that qi does not exist. It does not exist anymore than miasms, the four humours, or the goblins diagnosed by Theodoric of York. There is no mysterious “life force” by any name. Such a concept is utterly devoid of any evidence, and there is no reason in our modern understanding of biology to even entertain such a hypothesis. Acupuncture points also do not exist, and there is no even theoretical physiological or anatomical basis for their existence.
None of this should be surprising. The concepts if qi, yin, and yang were developed by long before the methods of science were developed, before any real understanding of the human body or the nature of real disease. For these ideas to persist into the modern era is an affront to all that we have accomplished.
Again, the Nature article blithely tells of the difference between TCM and modern medicine:
For example, ‘wasting thirst syndrome’ is characterized by excessive hunger and increased urination and explained by “factors which deplete yin fluids in the lung, spleen or kidney systems and generate fire and heat in the body”. On the basis of those observations, physicians can work out how to treat them. The patient, who would probably be diagnosed as diabetic by a Western doctor, would probably be prescribed acupuncture, various tonics and moxibustion — in which practitioners burn herbs near the skin of the patient. Spinach tea, celery, soya beans and other ‘cooling’ foods would also be recommended.
Patients with out-of-control diabetes can have such high blood sugar that the glucose cannot be fully reabsorbed by the kidneys, and it starts spilling over into the urine. Glucose in the urine acts as an osmotic, which draws more water into the urine, causing increased urination, dehydration, and thirst. The loss of glucose, which would otherwise be feeding the cells, also causes hunger, and may result in rapid weight loss.
This is an extremely serious medical condition, that if untreated can lead to serious complications and even death. Our modern understanding is sufficient to treat the specific mechanisms of the disease, to reduce the blood glucose levels and avoid these serious outcomes.
The TCM interpretation of these symptoms is not based on any real knowledge, but on superstitious nonsense that has no relationship to reality. TCM treatments are completely ineffective, because they are not addressing anything real.
The WHO is now endorsing and encouraging the spread of nonsensical magical treatments for real and serious medical conditions for which we have effective science-based treatments. They are doing this in the name of universal health coverage. How do they justify this? With the usual dodge:
In response to queries by Nature, the WHO said that its Traditional Medicine Strategy “provides guidance to Member States and other stakeholders for regulation and integration, of safe and quality assured traditional and complementary medicine products, practices, and practitioners”. It emphasized that the goal of the strategy “is to promote the safe and effective use of traditional medicine by regulating, researching and integrating traditional medicine products, practitioners and practice into health systems, where appropriate”.
Regulating pseudoscience does not help – it just legitimizes the pseudoscience. There is no quality assurance without some objective measure of safety and efficacy, which TCM lacks. Effective regulation and quality control are incompatible with an unscientific basis of health care. As the article also notes – the committee assigned to developing the chapter on TCM was basically reduced to different traditions (Korean vs Japanese vs Chinese) arguing with each other over priority. There was no evidence to resolve differences.
Part of the reason for this unfortunate move is touched upon by the article, but the author does not really drive home the implications:
The WHO’s support applies to all traditional medicines, but its relationship with Chinese medicine, and with China, has grown especially close, in particular during the tenure of Margaret Chan, who ran the organization from 2006 to 2017.
China has been making a strong push to promote TCM, to capture a big part of the medical tourism market. Chan essentially spent 11 years as head of the WHO to promote TCM, and this is the culmination of her work.
In my opinion, this is rank exploitation. The WHO is doing a great disservice to the people of the world and are violating their very purpose for existing. The WHO exists to raise the quality and access to care around the world. Promoting pseudoscience and pre-scientific superstition will have the opposite effect. This is an epic failure.
While there are many critics of this move, their voices do not appear to be resonating. This should be a scandal, and there should be outrage at this malfeasance. TCM is now nothing more than a harmful scam hiding behind traditional culture.
What the WHO should be doing is fighting for the proper health care of Chinese citizens, and all people, and protecting them from healthcare exploitation. Instead, they are exporting this exploitation to the world.
I can only hope that a future generation will see this as the shameful failure that it is.

Reporting results from clinical trials is vital for science-based medicine
Clinical trials must report on their outcomes, irrespective their results. Doctors and their patients need all the information, not just the good news stories, to make informed decisions.
Britt Hermes on February 28, 2016
Link

Real medicine is built on high quality data. That’s one lesson I learned through my rehabilitation as a former naturopath. I can assure you that this principle does not apply to naturopathy or any of the other types of alternative medicine, which are mostly based on anachronistic traditions, magical thinking, and poor academic integrity. I now know that real medicine incorporates any therapy scientifically demonstrated to be effective and safe, regardless of origin. Therapies that fail to demonstrate effectiveness remain alternative for good reason.
I made a sharp turn in my career when I realized this, but I was recently surprised to learn that a failure to respect the data can sometimes also characterize medicine. I’m not trying to fool anyone with an appeal to hypocrisy (often used by alternative medicine zealots to argue that their beliefs are somehow valid simply because medicine has problems). But I do want to draw attention to a problem with medical research, which has the potential to undermine science-based medicine and take us down the dark path of misinformed medicine — medicine based on incomplete data.
Most people probably don’t realize that a majority of clinical trials do not report their findings.[1–3] About half of trials conducted before 2007, before it was legally required to register and report clinical trials, have never been published.[4, 5] Even since stronger legal mandates were enacted, most clinical trials still are not registered or reported.[1–3] As a result, there is a huge amount of clinical data unknown to the medical community and not available to clinicians or patients.
This effectively means that medical decisions can be based on incomplete information, not only diminishing the effectiveness of treatments but also eroding the perceived plausibility of medical interventions over time. This is what Sense About Science’s AllTrials campaign is all about: ensuring that all clinical trials register and report results in a publicly-available database. I see it as an obvious and straightforward means to improve medicine.
A brief history of trial registration laws and regulations
The ClinicalTrials.gov registry — a database of clinical trials — was created in 2000 by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) National Library of Medicine with help from the Food and Drug Administration. It was created as a response to the 1997 U.S. Federal law requiring the registration of all clinical trials involving human participants in an open-access database.[6] This was an important legislative step intended to disseminate information about clinical trials to the public and researchers.
Over the past eight years, there have been various policy improvements in reaction to poor trial registration compliance. Most notably, the Food and Drug Administration Amendments Act (FDAAA) Section 801, implemented in 2007, requires sponsors of applicable clinical trials to register and then report results at ClinicalTrials.gov. The trials affected by Section 801 include all non-phase I trials of drugs, medical devices, or biologics that
     1.  began after September 27, 2007 or, for those started earlier, were still underway by December 26, 2007;
     2.  have a research site located in the U.S., or
     3.  run under “an Investigational New Drug application or an Investigational Device exemption.”[2, 3]
The FDAAA stipulated that all trial results must be reported within 12 months of collecting data for the primary research outcome. If a study ends early, any results must be reported within one year of the termination date (some exceptions were made for patent protection).[2] In parallel, the Declaration of Helsinki was amended by the World Medical Association General Assembly to include prospective registration prior to subject recruitment and mandated disclosure of study results to the public.[6]
In January 2015, the National Cancer Institute (NIH) issued a new policy echoing the FDAAA’s requirements to report results within 12 months of the trial’s primary completion date. Importantly, this new policy has been implemented into the conditions for receiving funding.[6]
What is being reported? Not much.
In March 2015, The New England Journal of Medicine published a review by Anderson et al. stating that only 13.4% of clinical trials either completed or terminated between January 1, 2008 and August 31, 2012 reported results within the mandated 12-month time period; only 38.3% of trials had reported results within 60 months (n=13,327).[2] Based on these measly percentages, it is safe to say that many researchers keep their clinical trial results under wraps.
In the midst of rampant underreporting across the board, there is an interesting difference between studies funded by the pharmaceutical industry and those funded by government and academic sources. Based on a random sample of 205 clinical trials out of the 13,327 reviewed by Anderson et al., about 80% of pharmaceutical industry trials reported results or had a legal reason for delay within the 5-year reporting period. In contrast, trials funded by government and academic sources did far worse. Only about 50% of NIH funded trials reported results or had legal reason not to, and other government and academic institutions reported at a rate of about 45%.[2] Overall, the pharmaceutical industry is doing a better job following the law than clinical trials funded by other sources.[1]
It seems that ethical and legal obligations are not drivers for following the rules of reporting.
So what is going on? Despite obligations to report results of clinical trials, researchers clearly fail to do so in a timely manner, if ever. This inaction may be explained by two factors: too much effort and a lack of incentive to publish negative results, and a lack of regulatory oversight.
No carrot: reporting is too much work and there’s no incentive to do it
Reporting results demands effort and when results are negative and unlikely to be published in medical journals, there is little academic incentive to prepare reports for public consumption. Ideally, researchers would budget the time and money needed to report results into their grant proposals, and funding organizations would force researchers to comply, as the NIH is mandated to do, at least on paper.
In a statement to STATnews by a Stanford University communications official, Lisa Lapin, expedient reporting comes down to time and money: Stanford researchers do not have enough time or resources to register and report clinical trial results, which results in 95% of their trial results being reported late or not at all since it became legally required to do so.[1]
This effect seems to spawn from the well-known and well-studied tilt towards positive results known as publication bias, which is in turn often attributed to the cutthroat nature of academia. Scientists are judged on research performance, including number of publications, where their contributions are being published, and the overall impact of their research.[7] In such an environment, positive results seem more interesting and exciting than negative results and are rewarded in what acts as a positive feedback loop.
Outside of academia, clinical trials funded by pharmaceutical companies tend to have more results reported than trials funded by the NIH or other scholarly organizations. This differential makes sense to me given how the pharmaceutical sector is subject to great scrutiny. “Big Pharma” is constantly targeted for alleged misconduct. It is reasonable to think that a pharmaceutical or medical device company would not want to open up vulnerabilities by withholding clinical data. Recently, I happened to meet the high-ranking employee, in charge of this task at an international drug company a few months ago, who reiterated this sentiment. She stated specifically that, amongst her other duties, she keeps track of trial results needing to be reported.
No stick: lack of regulatory oversight and no enforcement of penalties
The other reason for non-industry researchers not reporting data is a lack of regulatory oversight. Penalties for not reporting results have been set by the FDAAA, but they are not enforced. According to Stuart Buck at HealthAffairs.org, the FDAAA law could result in a total collection of penalties over $60 million dollars per day if the law were enforced![8] This figure is based on the $10,000-per-day fine that could be imposed on the 6,599 trials (registered from 2008 to 2012) that failed to report findings on time.
Federal authorities have never enforced the legal requirement to report these results.[8] This lack of enforcement certainly sends the message that the United States does not value the scientific practice of reporting all clinical trial results under the ethical guidelines that scientists would probably claim to respect. The FDA Deputy Commissioner, Dr. Robert Califf, has suggested he will begin to enforce the FDAAA, but so far the FDA has not levied penalties.[1, 9] Curiously, Dr. Califf requested his name be removed from three publications outlining changes for clinical trial management.[10]
The problems with not reporting clinical data
Unpublished research is harmful to medicine and its moral standing. A failure to report trial results is a breach of the ethical obligation to human subjects set forth in the Declaration of Helsinki. Since clinical trial research depends on human volunteers, it is absolutely essential that researchers uphold their end of the deal by making results available, if not for the volunteers, but for others, who may benefit from the findings. Patient advocate AnneMarie Ciccarella reflects this sentiment on the Sense about Science USA website:
We provided our bodies, our tissue samples, our data. I’ve heard the same sentiment expressed many times from patients in clinical trials, ‘This may not help me, but it may help another person.’ It’s time to honor that sentiment.
Undisclosed clinical trial results may not hold answers for better treatment options but may be concealing the ineffectiveness or dangers of treatments. Every patient, physician, and researcher should have access to this vital information that is largely withheld from surveillance. Tragically, an ongoing news story proves to be a powerful example of why no trial should be exempt from registering trial results and basic information, including the identity of the substance under investigation.
On January 17, 2015, a participant of a Phase I clinical trial died after developing brain damage caused by an experimental drug under way in France by the company Biotrial, and five other subjects have been hospitalized for symptoms consistent with brain hemorrhaging. The drug, developed by a Portuguese firm intended to treat a variety of symptoms including anxiety and motor dysfunction associated with Parkinson’s disease as well as chronic pain caused by cancer, was being tested in humans for the first time.[4] As of the writing of this post, neither French authorities nor Biotrial have released specific information regarding the identity of the molecule in the trial.
For now, scientists can only speculate about what substance was being tested in this trial beyond the vague information that the drug is a fatty acid amine hydrolase (FAAH) inhibitor. The truth is that Biotrial has not broken French law or international standards regulating clinical trials.[5] While adverse events in Phase I clinical trials are generally thought to be very rare, we actually do not have data available to independently verify this widely held notion.[5] For now, we can only hope that the French authorities will act in the best interests of these patients and install safeguards against future harm in first-in-human studies.
One obvious step away from problems with trial secrecy is to mandate and enforce trial registration and data sharing of trials at any phase, which includes enough information for the trial to be fully understood pharmacologically and therefore reproducible. The International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) proposed in an editorial published concurrently in 14 major medical journals that authors seeking to publish in these journals must share anonymous individual patient data associated with the results of any clinical trial.[7] The editors state that such patient data is required to reproduce clinical trials and is a tenet of good and ethical scientific practice.
While new policies such as this one are well intentioned, an IPD sharing policy may not support the bigger, and more pressing issue of unavailable trial summary results. Dr. Ben Goldacre, a British physician, science writer, and co-founder of the AllTrials campaign for clinical transparency, summarizes the mismatch between the ICMJE’s policy regarding IPD and scientific need thusly:
Overall, therefore, while greater support for IPD sharing is definitely great news, it’s very odd that all this resource and effort is now going into IPD sharing, when IPD sharing is expensive and not in demand, with complex governance and access control issues, whereas summary results sharing presents no privacy issues, and has been highly in demand, for many decades, but with multiple ongoing barriers to access, and frustratingly slow progress.
The proposals for IPD set forth by the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors are necessary and important. Undoubtedly, policies that uphold ethical obligations in research should be implemented. However, we have a more urgent ethical responsibility. Before venturing into the complex and costly task of sharing IPD, the scientific community needs to address the problem of trial secrecy being perpetuated through lax legal requirements and failure to enforce clinical trial registration, including the drug agent under investigation, followed by timely trial summary results. It seems to be time for an overhaul.
A campaign with solutions
AllTrials is an international campaign demanding responsible and ethical scientific research through the registration and reporting of all past and present clinical trials. Included in its mission is a mandate that it be impossible to receive funding or to sell a product without proving registration of clinical trials first.
Spearheaded by Ben Goldacre, the AllTrials campaign was launched by Sense About Science, BMJ, the Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine, the Cochrane Collaboration, the James Lind Initiative, and PLOS in January 2013 in the UK. In July 2015, the US AllTrials campaign was launched collectively by Sense about Science USA, Dartmouth’s Geisel School of Medicine, and the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy & Clinical Practice.
The US AllTrials campaign calls for clinical trials to be registered with ClinicalTrials.gov. In total, over 634 medical organizations, including major journals, patient-advocacy groups and professional societies have joined the AllTrials campaign. This is a much needed force for change that if successful would help provide higher transparency for research conducted on human subjects. This is an important moral issue.
If all researchers publicly share negative results in a comprehensive manner (like they are legally and ethically mandated to do) we may start to cultivate a culture of research that embraces humility and honesty. In my opinion, not only will this open modus operandi help researchers resist temptations to cheat, it will also help the public learn to trust the scientific process. Without awareness of what has already been researched, scientists may be wastefully repeating clinical trials or asking questions for which answers could be found in unpublished data. In worst-case scenarios, clinical trials are protected from scrutiny even in the event of participants dying and subsequent investigations impeded by poorly implemented and enforced laws that should be protecting the integrity of patients and promoting the highest ethical standards of scientific research.
Most skeptics would probably agree that one of the most frustrating aspects of discussing science-based medicine with people who do not trust science is trying to convey that, for the most part, science is reliable and that the endeavor is honest. If scientists consistently uphold the ethical duties by reporting all results, the public may be more willing to engage in the scientific enterprise, and researchers will benefit from a greater awareness of existing scientific data to further improve their inquiries and contextualize their findings within a more complete prior corpus of data.
For information about how you can help, visit and AllTrials.net.
References
     1.  Anderson ML, Chiswell K, Peterson ED, Tasneem A, Topping J, Califf RM: Compliance with Results Reporting at ClinicalTrials.gov. N Engl J Med 2015, 372:1031–1039.
     2.  Pansieri C, Pandolfini C, Bonati M: The evolution in registration of clinical trials: a chronicle of the historical calls and current initiatives promoting transparency. Eur J Clin Pharmacol 2015, 71:1159–1164.
     3.  Patients endangered as law is ignored [http://www.statnews.com/2015/12/13/clinical-trials-investigation/]
     4.  Butler D, Callaway E: Scientists in the dark after French clinical trial proves fatal. Nature 2016, 529:263–264.
     5.  French clinical trial debacle highlights weak reporting laws [http://www.statnews.com/2016/01/20/french-clinical-trial-debacle/]
     6.  US Federal Government Efforts to Improve Clinical Trial Transparency with Expanded Trial Registries and Open Data Sharing. AMA J Ethic 2015, 17:1152–1159.
     7.  Taichman DB, Backus J, Baethge C, Bauchner H, de Leeuw PW, Drazen JM, Fletcher J, Frizelle FA, Groves T, Haileamlak A, James A, Laine C, Peiperl L, Pinborg A, Sahni P, Wu S: Sharing Clinical Trial Data — A Proposal from the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors. N Engl J Med 2016:160120050013003.

Time to Move Beyond the Impact Factor
The impact factor has become the one metric for journal quality. It’s time to rethink this system.
Steven Novella on May 29, 2019
Link

In 1975 economist Charles Goodhart observed, “Any observed statistical regularity will tend to collapse once pressure is placed upon it for control purposes.” This basic idea has had many formulations, such as by Marilyn Strathern who stated the principle as, “When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure.”
This is a subset of the more general principle of unintended consequences, sometimes called the “cobra effect”. During British colonization of India they instituted a bounty on cobras to reduce the presence of venomous snakes in the streets. This worked at first, but then the locals started breeding cobras to turn in for the bounty. When the authorities figured this out, they ended the bounty. The captive cobras were mostly then released, resulting in a net increase in loose cobras.
It has been known for some time that the journal impact factor (JIF), which is used as the primary measure of a scientific journal’s academic value, has been distorting the publication ecosystem. In 2016 Mario Biagioli wrote an editorial pointing out the problem of “cheats in the citation game“. He argued:
It is no longer enough for scientists to publish their work. The work must be seen to have an influential shelf life. This drive for impact places the academic paper at the centre of a web of metrics — typically, where it is published and how many times it is cited — and a good score on these metrics becomes a goal that scientists and publishers are willing to cheat for.
The result is that researchers are gaming the system, just like people game every system that has any value. For example, a researcher may pad the reference section of one paper with self-citations to increase impact of previous articles they have published. This sort of post-publication cheating, as Biagioli discusses, does not compromise the science, but it does reduce the integrity of the publication system.
However, there are distorting effects that do affect the quality and utility of science that gets published. Journals are more likely to publish articles that they think will be highly cited in order to improve their own JIF. This means they are biased toward new and interesting findings or those which seem to contradict conventional wisdom (the scientific equivalent of man bites dog). But these are also precisely the kinds of studies that are most likely to be erroneous in their ultimate conclusions, and even retracted. There is also a bias against publishing replications, because these are considered boring, even though they play a critical role in the legitimacy of science.
Misconduct, in turn, is the greatest cause of papers being retracted. (About two thirds of retractions are due to misconduct, and most of those are due to fraud.) This implies that the JIF system is creating not only an incentive to focus on research likely to get published in high impact factor journals (rather than research that is inherently interesting or useful) but also provides an incentive for fraud. Obviously there are other incentives in academia that contribute to this, but the pressure to not only publish but to generate citations is part of the picture.
So what is the solution? A commentary published recently in Nature proposes if not a solution an approach to developing a solution. It’s interesting that they point to the historical emergence of JIF as the sole measure of the academic value of a journal:
The Journal Citation Reports, presenting the JIF and other journal indicators, were conceived in 1975 as a summary of journals’ citation activity in the Science Citation Index (now owned by Clarivate Analytics in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania). It was specifically intended to support librarians who wanted to evaluate their collections and researchers who wished to choose appropriate publication venues, as well as to provide insights for scholars, policymakers and research evaluators. Its inventors never expected the broad use and rampant misuse that developed.
This reminded me of the p-value. As I have pointed out here before, the p-value was never intended to be the one measure of whether or not a studied effect is likely to be real, but it became that. The result was p-hacking, gaming the system in order to have a positive study, which is easier to get published in a high impact factor journal.
The authors of the Nature commentary correctly, in my opinion, point out that a core of the problem is overreliance on a single metric. Relying on a single metric is tempting Goodhart’s law. It is simply too easy to game. Therefore, it is better to rely on multiple metrics. At least then it is harder to game, and the unintended consequences will be more diffuse and may balance out somewhat.
I like that they started by asking some basic questions, like what scientific journals are even for:
We delineated the key functions of journals, which remain largely unchanged since their inception more than 350 years ago. These are to register claims to original work, to curate the research record (including issuing corrections and retractions), to organize critical review and to disseminate and archive scholarship.
Therefore, how is it best to achieve these various goals? The metrics used to evaluate the academic quality of journals should reflect all of these goals. Impact factor alone doesn’t.
They also outline the features of good metrics. For example, they should be relevant, reproducible, contextualized, justified, and informed. So, they objectively measure something real and important about the quality of a journal, they are objective enough to be reproducible, and people know how to use the metrics and how not to cheat.
But perhaps most importantly – the system of metrics must be adaptable. This is because, no matter what metrics you use, people will try to game them. You need to measure the metrics, and then make adjustments to avoid abuse.
This is essentially what Google does, and why it has remained an industry leader in search engines. There is also an entire industry of “search engine optimization” (SEO). Optimization consists of methods to game Google’s ranking algorithms – its metrics of the relative value of websites. So Google has a team of people whose job it is to make SEO not work.
The Nature authors propose a “governing body” of stakeholders whose task is to institute a system of journal metrics, and then monitor those metrics and make adjustments to minimize abuse. The governing body would make the metrics adaptable.
I think this is a great idea, and I put it alongside the same proposal for statistical analysis in articles. Get rid of the one metric to rule them all – demote JIF and p-values from their perches as sole and overly powerful metrics. Replace them with systems of metrics that are more thorough in their analysis, more properly reflect what is trying to be measured, and minimizes hacking of the systems.
This is a basic concept that needs to be incorporated into the science of science itself.

Rigor Mortis: What’s Wrong with Medical Science and How to Fix It
Medical research has been plagued by less-than-rigorous practices and a culture that rewards quantity over quality. In a new book, Richard Harris identifies the problems, proposes solutions, and offers hope.
Harriet Hall on January 2, 2018
Link

I just finished reading Richard Harris’ excellent book, Rigor Mortis: How Sloppy Science Creates Worthless Cures, Crushes Hope, and Wastes Billions. From the title, I was expecting an angry, biased polemic attacking science and scientists. I was very pleasantly surprised. He doesn’t condemn science. He points out problems with the way science is carried out, mostly problems that scientists are already aware of and are trying to correct. And he offers practical solutions.
He explains that the term “rigor mortis” in the title is hyperbole. Rigor in scientific research isn’t dead, but it needs a major jolt of energy. He says scientists have been taking shortcuts around the methods they are supposed to use to avoid fooling themselves. They have often had to choose between maintaining scientific rigor and doing what they perceive as necessary to maintain a career in a hypercompetitive field. That’s a choice no one should have to make. The challenge is not just to make technical fixes in research procedures, but to change the culture.
He cites a study published in Nature in 2012 by C. Glenn Begley on raising the standards for preclinical cancer research. Begley identified 53 potentially groundbreaking studies and tried to reproduce them, working closely with the original researchers. He was only able to reproduce the findings of six (6!) of the studies. The non-reproducible studies had been cited as many as 2,000 times by other researchers as a basis for their own studies. Non-reproducible findings had sent research off in wrong directions. Sometimes huge houses of cards are built on an error, and it can take years for the science to self-correct.
Leonard Freedman, who founded the Global Biological Standards Institute, estimates that:
    • 20% of studies have untrustworthy designs:
    • 25% use dubious ingredients such as contaminated cells or antibodies that are not as selective as they think.
    • 8% involve poor lab technique
    • 18% of the time, scientist mishandle their data analysis.
Overall, he found that over half of preclinical research was irreproducible and untrustworthy, representing a waste of $28 billion a year.
Six essential questions
Begley proposes a list of six questions researchers should ask:
     1.  Were experiments performed blinded (did researchers know which cells or animals were in the test group)?
     2.  Were basic experiments repeated?
     3.  We all the results presented?
     4.  Were there positive and negative controls?
     5.  Did scientists make sure they were using valid ingredients?
     6.  Were statistical tests appropriate?
Sources of error
Unconscious bias arises every step of the way in research design, in factors like deciding how many animals to study, deciding which results to include, and analyzing the results. Malcolm Macleod of the University of Edinburgh estimates that when you compound all the sources of bias and error, the actual percent of published studies that are correct may be as low as 15%.
In a 2010 study, Ioannidis and Chavalarias catalogued 235 forms of bias: 235 ways scientists can fool themselves.
Some examples of things that can go wrong in research studies:
    • Researchers favored male mice to prevent possible confounding by estrous cycles in female mice; this resulted in deeply skewing some of their results.
    • Muscular dystrophy researchers thought they had a valid test of performance, a timed walking test; but when they offered their young subjects a $50 incentive for improved performance, the effect was bigger than has ever been seen for a drug for that disease.
    • Mice died when their bedding was switched to a different material.
    • Two labs kept getting different results and finally found the cause: glassware was cleaned with acid in one lab and with detergent in the other.
    • Two methods routinely used in labs resulted in different findings; it made a difference whether cells were stirred by a rocking device or a system that involved a spinning bar.
    • A disease can be cured in a mouse model only to discover that the cure is irrelevant or even deadly for humans. A compound called fialuridine (FIAU) was well tolerated in mice and in a short-term human study; but in a longer study it caused liver failure in half the recipients (7 patients). Five out of the seven died, and the remaining two survived only with liver transplants.
    • A drug can fail in mice but work in humans. Statins failed testing in rats, and only ended up being evaluated for humans after a persistent researcher found that it worked in chickens.
    • Rats and mice are different: toxicity studies only reach the same conclusion about 60% of the time.
    • In mouse studies, the position of the cage or even the sex of the researcher can alter results.
    • Many human cancer cell lines used in research have been contaminated; testing shows that they are actually HeLa cells.
    • Mycoplasma can infect cells and throw results off.
    • Antibodies can be very unreliable; different batches vary, some bind to more than one unique site.
    • In one case, there were subtle differences in how the mass spectrometer worked on different days.
    • Reliance on a p value of less than 0.05 to establish statistical significance is an arbitrary standard that misleads many people. P-hacking is common. It is extremely easy to find evidence for something that is not true.
    • HARKing is a common pitfall, hypothesizing after the results are known.
    • The line between exploratory and confirmatory research is often blurred.
Solutions
These problems are fixable, and many efforts are already underway:
    • The NIH has already tightened the criteria for approving a grant.
    • Some drug testing is being farmed out to a private company that specializes in running rigorous mouse studies according to the best new standards.
    • New human-based models like induced pluripotent stem cells and artificial organs on chips can be substituted for mouse testing.
    • The International Cell Line Authentication Committee maintains a list of corrupted cell lines: 438 so far. Researchers can have their cells authenticated before and after a study by an independent commercial testing lab.
    • There are initiatives to increase transparency, to encourage data sharing, and to register trials in advance, declaring exactly what hypothesis is being tested and what endpoints will be used. Advance declarations have dropped reported success rates from 57% to 8%.
    • There are efforts to formalize the teaching of scientific thinking.
    • The federal Office of Research Integrity identifies cases of scientific misconduct, but it is understaffed and underfunded.
    • The blog Retraction Watch found about 40 retractions in 2001; now it finds 5-600 a year.
    • One journal editor now refuses to accept papers that simply report a correlation between a biomarker and a medical condition.
    • When another journal started awarding “openness badges,” the percentage of papers with open data rose from 3% to 38%.
    • A whole new field is emerging: meta-research, studying problems in how scientific research is conducted, and identifying solutions.
Conclusion: serious problems, but room for optimism
Scientific medicine has made great strides, but much of today’s research is unreliable. As Harris says, “Biomedicine’s entire culture is in need of serious repair.” He has done a stellar job of identifying the problems, possible solutions, and promising efforts that are already underway. Research jobs and tenure in academia should be awarded based on quality, not quantity of papers published. Studies must be replicated before they are relied on to direct future research. We need better incentives: today, it pays to be first to publish; it doesn’t pay to be right. We can do better. We are trying to do better.
Anyone who does research or reads about research studies will profit from reading this book. It’s well-written and accessible, with short chapters and lots of entertaining vignettes. And it’s a compact 236 pages, much shorter than the last book I reviewed (a 600-plus-page tome on Freud). Highly recommended.

Scientific Fraud in China
There is a systemic problem with fraud in Chinese medical science. The problem goes all the way to the top.
Steven Novella on November 27, 2019
Link

Editor’s note: Dr. Novella is away, so we are reposting this article from his personal blog, NeuroLogica.
There is plenty of fraud and corruption in the world, even in the halls of science. No one has a monopoly. But there are some hot spots that deserve specific attention. Recently significant concerns have been raised about the published research of Xuetao Cao, a Chinese immunologist. This story is newsworthy because Cao is not just any immunologist – he is also the President of Nankai University, in Tianjin, China. But more to the point – he is the Chairman of research integrity for all Chinese research. When your head of research integrity is exposed for massive scientific fraud, you have a problem.
Here is a thorough treatment of the evidence for fraud, which covers over 50 published papers. The fabrication of data was noticed because much of it has to do with pictures, of western blots, gels, flow cytometry images, and microscopy images. There appears to be two general types of fabrication going on. One type results from sending the same sample multiple times through analysis, but treating the data as if it came from different samples. In this case the resulting imaging will be strikingly similar in pattern, but not identical. The second type of fabrication is to simply Photoshop copy and paste images.
Either way, the resulting data fabrication is undeniable once it is noticed. The images are simply too similar (and again, sometimes identical) to be genuine data. Once researchers started pouring through Cao’s other papers, the extensive fraud became obvious. When confronted with this revelation online, Cao responded by first standing behind his work, then stating:
Nevertheless, there is no excuse for any lapse in supervision or laboratory leadership and the concerns you raised serve as a fresh reminder to me just how important my role and responsibility are as mentor, supervisor, and lab leader; and how I might have fallen short.
Wow – you see what he just did there? He simultaneously apologized and took responsibility, but only for failure of supervision. So essentially he is throwing all of the people who work for him under the bus. Either way, however, this is really bad for Cao. Even in the best-case scenario, all the fraud was perpetrated by others under his watch. Keep in mind, he is in charge of research integrity for all of China, but apparently can’t keep an eye on his own lab. There are certainly famous cases where research assistants were the ones perpetrating the fraud. Another immunologist, Jacques Benveniste, claimed to have evidence of immunological activity from high “homeopathic” dilutions. An investigation found his results to be highly unreliable at least, and likely straight-up fraudulent (although may have been due to really sloppy techniques and bias). But it also appears that the positive results all seemed to come from one lab assistant, Elizabeth Davenas – certainly a disturbing pattern.
Perhaps a similar pattern will emerge from Cao’s lab, but it seems unlikely that an overzealous assistant can be responsible for data fabrication in 50 published studies. This is clearly a systemic problem.
But there have always been reasons to suspect that Cao’s research, and the rocketing trajectory of his resultant career, were dubious. In 1988 Cao published a paper in which he claimed that the energy produced by Qi was able to prevent melanoma metastasis in mice. Whenever research claims that magic works, you have to be suspicious. But if the magic is politically favored by the powers that be, that can do wonders for your career.
The debate now focuses on how to interpret this incident, specifically what does this say about Chinese scientific research in general? There are those who point out that scientific fraud exists everywhere, so we shouldn’t over interpret the implications of this case. But I don’t buy that. While every country has its scientific fraud, there seem to be clusters that require special attention – and China is a cluster. We can only speculate, however, about the causes. The simplest explanation (so simple that it doesn’t really add much insight) is that it comes down to culture. Well, sure. Integrity is mostly about culture, the culture that exists in a profession, in a society, and in institutions. Science only works when most people follow the rules, when there are guardrails in place to maximize quality control, and when there is zero-tolerance for breaking the rules. When the single person in charge of enforcing those rules in China is exposed as a massive violator, there is a systemic problem.
There is also strong cultural pressure in China to prove that the core beliefs of their culture (traditional Chinese medicine and Qi) are real and powerful. This is ideological science. As powerful evidence for this effect is acupuncture research. Two reviews, in 1998 and again in 2014, found that 100% of acupuncture studies coming out of China were positive. This is statistically impossible, even if acupuncture worked (and it almost certainly doesn’t). This is also a bit much even for just publication bias. It could all be incredible researcher bias, but bias blurs imperceptibly into fraud. When you are fudging your research methods, and you know this isn’t pristine, how much of that is bias and how much fraud? In the end, it doesn’t really matter.
There is also legitimate concern that totalitarian governments do not create an environment in which science can flourish. Science requires transparency, it requires valuing method over results, and it should be ideologically neutral. These are not concepts that flourish under a totalitarian regime. Also, the scientists who get promoted to positions of respect and power are likely to be those who please the regime, by proving, for example, that their cultural propaganda is real. So the selective pressures for advancement do not prioritize research integrity.
Cao, I think, embodies all of this. This should not be viewed as an isolated incident, or even researcher. The very fact that Cao has risen to the highest heights of setting the standards for science in China means that we have to look at the systemic implications of this case.
There are a couple of other lessons we should note as well. First, and unfortunately, we need to look at all research coming out of China with an especially careful eye. The system is broken, and cannot be given the benefit of the doubt.
But even more broadly, scientific journals need to evaluate their methods for rooting out fraud before it is published. The existing filter is not adequate. It is unfortunate that journals need to expend resources just looking at submitted papers to detect sloppy techniques, bias, and conscious fraud, but nothing less is now acceptable. Trust in published peer-reviewed science is critical to the system, and after a blow like this (and the many others) steps need to be taken to restore trust by raising the bar of quality control.

Is scientific peer review a “sacred cow” ready to be slaughtered?
David Gorski on December 21, 2015
Link

I’ve frequently noted that one of the things most detested by quacks and promoters of pseudoscience is peer review. Creationists hate peer review. HIV/AIDS denialists hate it. Anti-vaccine cranks like those at Age of Autism hate it. Indeed, as a friend of mine, Mark Hoofnagle, pointed out several years ago, pseudoscientists and cranks of all stripes hate it. There’s a reason for that, of course, namely that it’s hard to pass peer review if you’re peddling pseudoscience, although, unfortunately, with the rise of “integrative medicine,” it’s nowhere near as difficult as it once was.
Be that as it may, peer review, the process by which scientific papers are evaluated by scientific “peers” to look for problems with the science and decide if the paper is appropriate for publication in a scientific journal, is a concept that dates back hundreds of years. However, for the most part, before the middle of the 20th century, the ultimate determination of whether a paper was appropriate for scientific publication was made by editors or editorial committees. Opinions of external reviewers were sometimes sought when deemed appropriate by journal editors, but by no means was this the practice for most manuscripts. Over the last six or seven decades, external peer review by scientists chosen by the journal editor evaluating a submission has become the standard. Similarly, decisions regarding whether or not to fund grant applications are now generally made by a panel of external reviewers. In the case of the NIH, these panels are called study sections and consist of scientists with expertise in the types of applications being referred to the study section for evaluation, along with (usually) a statistician or two and officials from the NIH who take care of organizing and running the meetings of the panel. The scientific members of a study section usually include “permanent” members, who are assigned to fixed terms on the study section, and ad hoc members, called in for one or a few meetings as needed and deemed necessary by the NIH.
I’ve not infrequently stolen the words from one of Winston Churchill’s speeches to describe our current peer review system:
Many forms of Government have been tried and will be tried in this world of sin and woe. No one pretends that democracy is perfect or all-wise. Indeed, it has been said that democracy is the worst form of government except all those other forms that have been tried from time to time.
Simply substitute the words “scientific evaluation” for “Government” and “peer review” for democracy, and you get my drift. Peer review is, like many any system devised by human beings, imperfect. Scientists know that it is not perfect or all-wise. Indeed, scientists probably complain about peer review more than anyone else, because we have to deal with it many times a year, either as applicants, authors, or peer reviewers. Of course, to the pseudoscientists and quacks we routinely discuss here, peer review is viewed as the equivalent of the Cerberus guarding the gates of Hades (the Underworld) preventing the spirits of the dead from escaping, except in this case, “escape” means breaking out of the crank journals and bottom-feeding “pay-to-publish” open access journals and getting their work published in a real scientific journal. OK, OK, I know it’s not a perfect metaphor, but peer review isn’t a perfect process; so I’ll use it anyway. Besides, if you’re a scientist trying to get a paper published and have had to deal with clueless peer reviewers, the image of the peer review process as a giant three-headed dog has undeniable appeal, given that most scientific papers are assigned to three reviewers.
I’ve been thinking about writing a post about peer review at least since August, but, since then, something always seemed to manage to catch my interest when Sunday blogging time rolled around. (Truly, I am Dug the Dog when it comes to blogging.) I figured the topic would keep for another week. Then, last week’s New England Journal of Medicine featured a Perspective article by Charlotte Haug entitled “Peer-Review Fraud — Hacking the Scientific Publication Process“, complete with an accompanying interview with her. I’m sure I’ll be seeing this article featured on quack websites very soon. That is, what we call in the biz, an “in.” So I dusted off the list of web pages I had been carefully hoarding at least since summer. Let’s dig in.
Hacking Cerberus
Quacks love it when scientists complain about peer review because they think that those complaints validate their conspiratorial belief system about “close-minded” scientists trying to “suppress” their views. Of course, our pointing out the shortcomings of the peer review system are generally intended as a starting point from which either to improve the existing system or to discuss potential alternative systems to replace it, not as agreeing that pseudoscience should be published in scientific journals. We know that science depends on transparency and honesty; if those are compromised, the trustworthiness of science itself can be compromised. In any event, beginning a few months ago, advocates of various pseudoscientific forms of medicine started circulating certain articles quoting them, citing these articles as evidence that science is irretrievably corrupt, broken, biased, or close-minded (take your pick of any or all), the implication being, of course, that their preferred form of quackery has legitimacy but is being unfairly excluded from the scientific literature by the peer review process.
In her article, Haug notes a disturbing trend in peer review, specifically peer review evaluations that are outright fraudulent. Noting that in August, Springer retracted 64 articles from ten different journals “after editorial checks spotted fake email addresses, and subsequent internal investigations uncovered fabricated peer review reports.” Later, BioMed Central, also owned by Springer, retracted 43 articles for exactly the same reason, Haug notes:
“This is officially becoming a trend,” Alison McCook wrote on the blog Retraction Watch, referring to the increasing number of retractions due to fabricated peer reviews.2 Since it was first reported 3 years ago, when South Korean researcher Hyung-in Moon admitted to having invented e-mail addresses so that he could provide “peer reviews” of his own manuscripts, more than 250 articles have been retracted because of fake reviews — about 15% of the total number of retractions.
How is it possible to fake peer review? Moon, who studies medicinal plants, had set up a simple procedure. He gave journals recommendations for peer reviewers for his manuscripts, providing them with names and e-mail addresses. But these addresses were ones he created, so the requests to review went directly to him or his colleagues. Not surprisingly, the editor would be sent favorable reviews — sometimes within hours after the reviewing requests had been sent out. The fallout from Moon’s confession: 28 articles in various journals published by Informa were retracted, and one editor resigned.3
When I first found out about “fake” peer review, I had a hard time believing it. The main reason I was so incredulous was because I couldn’t believe that journal editors would be so clueless as to let something like this happen. After all, most peer reviewers work at either university or government facilities; if you see, for example, a manuscript submission with suggested peer reviewers with Gmail, Hotmail, or Yahoo! accounts (or any account not using the domain name of the university or institution for where that peer reviewer works), you’d think that would at least raise a red flag to look a bit more closely. Yes, I know that some scientists might use their home e-mail addresses, but at the very least a non-university or non-institutional e-mail address should lead the editor to take a closer look. Most scientists’ e-mail addresses are locatable through their university’s website or by looking up the most recent papers they’ve published as corresponding author; in the case of industry it’s more difficult but not insurmountable.
Unfortunately, given how relatively easy it is (or should be) to detect the kind of fake peer reviewers mentioned above, some researchers have become more sophisticated in their peer review fraud:
Peter Chen, who was an engineer at Taiwan’s National Pingtung University of Education at the time, developed a more sophisticated scheme: he constructed a “peer review and citation ring” in which he used 130 bogus e-mail addresses and fabricated identities to generate fake reviews. An editor at one of the journals published by Sage Publications became suspicious, sparking a lengthy and comprehensive investigation, which resulted in the retraction of 60 articles in July 2014.
It goes beyond even a researcher creating his own “peer review and citation ring.” There exist companies that offer manuscript preparation services to authors. Many are reputable and exist to help with editing and figure preparation. Some provide ghost writing services. Others, as this Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) statement reports, offer services that include fabricated contact details for peer reviewers to be used during the submission process plus reviews from these fabricated addresses. COPE notes that some of these “peer reviewers” have “the names of seemingly real researchers but with email addresses that differ from those from their institutions or associated with their previous publications” and that “others appear to be completely fictitious.” COPE notes that it’s not clear how much the authors of manuscripts submitted using such services know, specifically whether they know that the reviewer names and e-mail addresses are fraudulent. My response to this is “Oh, really?”
It goes beyond even this, though, as a more detailed report of Hyung-In Moon’s and Peter Chen’s fraud documented in Nature. Moon and Chen both exploited a flaw at the heart of Thomson Reuters’ ScholarOne, a publication-management system used by quite a few publishers. Again, it’s a flaw so unbelievably obvious that, in this era of concern about identify theft and cyber-crime, it’s incredible that this is how ScholarOne works:
Moon and Chen both exploited a feature of ScholarOne’s automated processes. When a reviewer is invited to read a paper, he or she is sent an e-mail with login information. If that communication goes to a fake e-mail account, the recipient can sign into the system under whatever name was initially submitted, with no additional identity verification. Jasper Simons, vice-president of product and market strategy for Thomson Reuters in Charlottesville, Virginia, says that ScholarOne is a respected peer-review system and that it is the responsibility of journals and their editorial teams to invite properly qualified reviewers for their papers.
So, if an editor agrees to use one of the author’s fake suggestions, that author is allowed into the ScholarOne system and create whatever identity he wants as a registered “peer reviewer” in the system. Unfortunately, ScholarOne isn’t the only system with such glaring vulnerabilities. Another system, Editorial Manager, does something no halfway well-designed system in 2015 should be doing:
Editorial Manager’s main issue is the way it manages passwords. When users forget their password, the system sends it to them by e-mail, in plain text. For PLOS ONE, it actually sends out a password, without prompting, whenever it asks a user to sign in, for example to review a new manuscript. Most modern web services, such as Google, hide passwords under layers of encryption to prevent them from being intercepted. That is why they require users to reset a password if they forget it, often coupled with checking identity in other ways.
Yes, I’ve experienced this very thing as a reviewer for journals using Editorial Manager. Even so, to me the Nature article is misguided in that it seems to harp on vulnerabilities in the various computer software platforms used by publishers to manage submissions and peer review a bit too much and on the true flaw that allows self-peer review to occur a bit too little. Don’t get me wrong. Technological and security problems are serious. After all, no software should make it so easy for fake reviewers to be entered into the system, and no software should be sending out passwords in regular e-mail in plain text. However, the true problem that facilitates fraud of this sort lies less within the software used than within the system that uses the software. Even so, Nature‘s list of “red flags” that “you just might be dealing with fake peer reviewers if…” is rather simple. One is even amusing:
    • The author asks to exclude some reviewers, then provides a list of almost every scientist in the field.
    • The author recommends reviewers who are strangely difficult to find online.
    • The author provides Gmail, Yahoo or other free e-mail addresses to contact suggested reviewers, rather than e-mail addresses from an academic institution.
    • Within hours of being requested, the reviews come back. They are glowing.
    • Even reviewer number three likes the paper.
Number four amuses me just based on my own behavior. I rarely complete peer reviews in less than three days, and frequently I’m so busy that I’m late, such that the editorial software is sending me reminders. As for number five, this gives you an idea of why that’s downright funny:
Yes, “reviewer number three” is notorious for being the one whose criticisms of a submitted manuscript are the most—shall we say?—pointed.
The fox guarding the henhouse?
It should be quite clear from the discussion above that the real practice that facilitates peer review fraud is the way that many journals ask authors for names of suggested peer reviewers and then actually use those names. I’ve always wondered about this myself, because, after all, at the very minimum, no one’s going to suggest a peer reviewer who’s likely to trash the paper being submitted. Even leaving aside the possibility of fake peer reviewers, using peer reviewers suggested by an author makes it far more likely that the review will be less rigorous and far more likely to recommend publication with few changes. After all, scientists are only human. If they’re asked to pick their own peer reviewers, of course they’re going to pick ones that maximize their chances of getting published and minimize their chances of having to do multiple revisions and more experiments to satisfy reviewers’ criticisms.
Readers who aren’t scientists and haven’t dealt with peer review before might reasonably wonder: Why on earth do editors do this? Haug lists three reasons:
     1.  In highly specialized fields, authors may actually be the best qualified to suggest suitable reviewers for the manuscript in question.
     2.  It makes life easier for editors because finding peer reviewers can be difficult, given that it’s unpaid work that can be quite demanding.
     3.  Journals and publishers are becoming increasingly multinational, which means that it’s become more difficult for editors and members of editorial boards to be familiar with all the scientists throughout the world working on a topic.
These all sound very reasonable, but for them to be valid reasons to use author-recommended reviewers there have to be trust, honesty, and transparency because, as Steve Novella pointed out discussing this issue, scientists are human beings and some proportion of human beings will always cheat to gain an advantage. That can never be completely eliminated. However, any good system with an incentive for cheating (and, make no mistake, there are major incentives for scientists to publish in good journals, as such publications can make their careers and provide evidence of productivity to be used in grant applications) should implement processes to make cheating more difficult and the price of being discovered cheating more costly.
It seems to me that, at the very minimum, the era of asking scientists for suggestions for peer reviewers for their own manuscripts must end. The reasons why many (but by no means all) journals have done so for so many years are quite understandable but no longer defensible in the wake of these damaging and large scale incidents of self-peer review fraud. This practice must stop, even at the price of more work for already harried editors. One technological solution that might help would be a database of peer reviewers, each with his or her relevant field of expertise listed, as well as collaborators and those with whom they’ve published, so that editors can know not to send a manuscript to an author’s friend or collaborator for review. In the wake of these scandals, it might even be profitable for a company to develop such a database and sell access to publishers. Lacking a system like this, it will fall on the shoulders of editors to be more careful and to pick peer reviewers themselves, rather than using any recommendations by authors submitting manuscripts.
Is the peer review system a “sacred cow” that needs slaughtering?
All this brings me back to the title of this post, which is based on a quote from Richard Smith, former editor of the British Medical Journal (now The BMJ). Speaking at a Royal Society meeting in April, Smith characterized the peer review system as a “sacred cow” ready to “slaughtered.” As you can imagine, that particularly juicy quote went down quite well among those who are less than enamored with science-based medicine, such as Robert Scott Bell and, of course, Mike Adams’ minion Ethan Huff at NaturalNews.com, who twisted Smith’s quote to read ‘Sacred cow’ of industry science cult should be slaughtered for the good of humanity, BMJ editor says.
Of course, what these accounts neglected to mention was that Smith made his quotes in the context of a debate with Georgina Mace, professor of biodiversity and ecosystems at University College London, with Smith taking the “anti-” position and Mace taking the “pro-.” Thus, it might not be surprising for each debater to take a more extreme position. For instance, Smith actually characterized John Ioannidis’ famous 2005 paper “Why most published research findings are false” as meaning that “most of what is published in journals is just plain wrong or nonsense,” which is clearly not what Ioannidis was saying. Just because something turns out to be incorrect does not make it nonsense in the context of the time, and, in fact, Ioannidis was making an argument that prior plausibility has to be taken into account in doing and interpreting research studies, which is a key argument for science-based medicine.
Still, Smith did make some good points, particularly when he described a BMJ experiment in which a brief paper was sent to 300 reviewers with eight deliberate errors introduced into it. No reviewer found more than five; the median was two, and 20% didn’t spot any. Of course, I would counter that this observation is not an indictment of peer review as a process, but rather evidence that BMJ under Smith’s editorship didn’t pick its peer reviewers very well and that peer review needs improvement. Perhaps, instead of scrapping peer review, we should work to improve it.
Fix it, don’t dump it
Fixing peer review is more the approach taken by Richard Horton, who is the current editor-in-chief at The Lancet and who published an article around the same time entitled Offline: What is medicine’s 5 sigma? Of course, whenever I hear Horton pontificate about peer review, it’s hard for me not to remember that he was also the editor of The Lancet under whose regime Andrew Wakefield published his execrable 1998 Lancet case series that was has been used to blame autism on the MMR vaccine for nearly 18 years. Still, after discussing the problems with research and peer review, Horton does make some decent points. Perhaps he has learned from l’affaire Wakefield:
Can bad scientific practices be fixed? Part of the problem is that no-one is incentivised to be right. Instead, scientists are incentivised to be productive and innovative. Would a Hippocratic Oath for science help? Certainly don’t add more layers of research red-tape. Instead of changing incentives, perhaps one could remove incentives altogether. Or insist on replicability statements in grant applications and research papers. Or emphasise collaboration, not competition. Or insist on preregistration of protocols. Or reward better pre and post publication peer review. Or improve research training and mentorship. Or implement the recommendations from our Series on increasing research value, published last year. One of the most convincing proposals came from outside the biomedical community. Tony Weidberg is a Professor of Particle Physics at Oxford. Following several high-profile errors, the particle physics community now invests great effort into intensive checking and re-checking of data prior to publication. By filtering results through independent working groups, physicists are encouraged to criticise. Good criticism is rewarded. The goal is a reliable result, and the incentives for scientists are aligned around this goal. Weidberg worried we set the bar for results in biomedicine far too low. In particle physics, significance is set at 5 sigma—a p value of 3 × 10–7 or 1 in 3·5 million (if the result is not true, this is the probability that the data would have been as extreme as they are).
I always love it when physicists suggest such a strategy, given how much more variability is inherent in biological and medical research, so much so that very few experiments ever reach that level of significance statistical significance. Still, I could see decreasing the p-value for “statistical significance” to 0.01 or even 0.001. I could even see eliminating the p-value altogether, together with using Bayesian reasoning to estimate the probability that a given result is correct.
There is value in some of Horton’s other suggestions. Certainly, one problem is that, as much as we scientists want to do a good job at peer review, the fact remains that peer review is unpaid and, from an academic standpoint, doesn’t really contribute much to our career advancement. For instance, when going up for promotion, assistant professors do have to show evidence of scholarly activity, such as peer review, but peer review is of low value in that equation compared to other activities. Publishing a single peer-reviewed paper in a decent journal is worth more than reviewing dozens of papers for journals, and a single NIH grant is worth more than reviewing any conceivable number of papers. Receiving neither significant financial nor career rewards for performing the onerous duty of peer review, scientists understandably don’t knock themselves out to review papers. Is this any wonder, particularly given that, as Horton points out, there is no reward for high quality reviews and a perverse incentive (i.e., fewer papers to review) for doing low quality reviews? These are the sorts of impediments that have to be changed, along with tightening procedures to make self-peer review far more difficult to achieve. More radical changes could include a system of “open” peer review, such that reviewers are known and their comments follow the published paper, although such a system would present its own challenges, particularly given the reluctance of more junior faculty to publicly criticize the work of more renowned senior faculty.
What is becoming clear is that, whatever changes we make in the peer review system, we can’t keep doing what we’re doing any more. Referencing the Churchill quote, at the moment, as flawed as it is, our peer review system is the best system we have for evaluating science. Until someone can come up with an alternative that works at least as well (admittedly not the highest bar in the world), it would be premature to abandon it. That doesn’t mean it can’t be improved. Contrary to Richard Smith’s view, peer review is not a sacred cow, and it doesn’t yet need to be slaughtered.

   Cranks, quacks, and peer review
David Gorski
Link
Last week, I wrote one of my characteristically logorrheic meandering posts about what turns a scientist into a crank or a doctor into a quack. In a sort of continuation of this line of thinking, this week I’ll turn my attention to one of the other most common characteristics of a crank, be he scientific crank (i.e., a creationist), a quack, or historical crank (i.e., Holocaust deniers), specifically how he views the peer review system.
Not suprisingly, one of the favorite targets of pseudoscientists is, in fact, the peer review system. Indeed, it’s a very safe thing to say that, almost without exception, cranks really, really, really don’t like the peer review system for scientific journals and grant review. After all, it’s the system through which scientists submit their manuscripts describing their scientific findings or their grant proposals to their peers, and their peers make a judgment whether manuscripts are scientifically meritorious enough to be published and grant applications scientifically compelling enough to be funded. Creationists hate peer review. HIV/AIDS denialists hate it. Anti-vaccine cranks like those at Age of Autism hate it. Indeed, as a friend of mine, Mark Hoofnagle pointed out a couple of years ago, pseudoscientists and cranks of all stripes hate it. There’s a reason for that, of course, namely that vigorous peer review is a major part of science that keeps pseudoscientists from attaining the respectability that science possesses and that they crave so.
Far be it from me to get all Panglossian on you and claim that the peer review system is the “best of all possible worlds,” or anything like that. Having participated in the system at multiple levels, including at the receiving end, as a peer reviewer for journals, and as a reviewer on a study section, I know there’s no doubt that the system has problems and could do with considerable improvements. However, when I hear rabid bashers of peer review characterize it as “crony review,” I tend to echo Winston Churchill’s famous statement about democracy that peer review is “the worst way of determining what science should be published and funded except for all those others that have been tried.” Certainly, the bashers can’t seem to propose something better. Of course, that’s because the real purpose behind the numerous criticisms made by cranks about peer review is not to reform or improve the system in order to prevent bad science from being published and funded and good science from being rejected, but rather to weaken the system or alter it so that they can get their favorite pseudoscience published an/or funded, thus allowing them to attain the respectability of real science that they so crave. In other words, it is important in assessing attacks on the peer-review system to determine whether the criticism is designed to suggest real changes that might improve it or, as is the case with most cranks, to tear it down in order to make it more amenable to accepting their pseudoscience.
If there is one sterling example of this phenomenon that I’m aware of, it’s an article that I first encountered a couple of years ago by a surgeon at the University of Washington named Donald W. Miller, Jr. (website). I remember coming across it while delving into the blogs and websites of HIV/AIDS denialists. Not surprisingly, Dr. Miller is a regular columnist at LewRockwell.com, where he has referred to HIV/AIDS denialist hero Peter Duesberg as a “modern day Copernicus” and questioned the HIV/AIDS hypothesis as an “orthodoxy.” Not surprisingly, Dr. Miller is also an anti-vaccinationist, shamelessly promoting the myth that thimerosal in vaccines was a cause of the “autism epidemic” (it wasn’t; it’s a failed hypothesis) and that anthropogenic global warming is a “scam.” I first became aware of this article, The Government Grant System – Inhibitor of Truth and Innovation? on the HIV/AIDS denialist blog You Bet Your Life. It also appeared on LewRockwell.com under another title, The Trouble With Government Grants. In the article, Dr. Miller launched into a blistering attack on the current peer review system used by the NIH, an attack that revealed his profound ignorance of how government peer review systems (not system) work.
I knew there were going to be problems right away. First, Miller used the term “truth” in the title of one of the versions of his article. Science is not about “truth”; it is about understanding how the world around us works to as good an approximation as we can get. Worse, very early on in the article, Dr. Miller shows that he can’t seem to get his facts straight, mangling the concept of “triage” and making me seriously wonder if he has ever served on an NIH study section. Certainly, searching the CRISP database (the best way to find out if anyone has an NIH research grant, by the way), I could find no evidence that he has ever been the principal investigator or co-investigator on an NIH grant, which if true would more or less disqualify him from sitting on an NIH study section. I also can’t help but note briefly that Dr. Miller, like so many physicians and scientists who turn to the dark side of pseudoscience, seems to have had a respectable publication record in peer-reviewed journals as an academic cardiac surgeon until 1991, after which he has not published in peer-reviewed journals. (Note: Despite its claims otherwise, the Journal of American Physicians and Surgeons, as Dr. Miller has, does not count as a peer-reviewed journal, for reasons I have discussed extensively before.) In any case, here Dr. Miller describes the peer review system as he thinks it stands:
The Center for Scientific Review “triages” applications it receives. A cursory appraisal eliminates one-third of the applications from any further consideration, and it selects the remaining two-thirds for competitive peer review. CSR sends each application to a Study Section it deems best suited to evaluate it. Peers in Molecular Oncogenesis, Cognitive Neuroscience, Cell Structure and Function, Hematopoiesis, HIV/AIDS Vaccine, and 167 other Study Sections review grant applications. Each Study Section has 12-24 members who are recognized experts in that particular field. Members meet three times a year to review 25-100 grants at each meeting. Two members read an application and then discuss it with the other section members who collectively give it a priority score and percentile ranking (relative to the priority scores they assign to other applications). An advisory council then makes funding decisions on the basis of the Study Section’s findings, “taking into consideration the [specific NIH] institute or center’s scientific goals and public health needs” (Scarpa, 2006).
Not quite. This is what the NIH CSR says about peer review:
One or more CSR Referral Officers examine your application and determine the most appropriate Integrated Review Group (IRG) to assess its scientific and technical merit. Your application is then assigned to one of the IRG’s study sections. A study section typically includes 20 or more scientists from the community of productive researchers. Your application also will be assigned to the NIH Institute or Center (IC) best suited to fund your application should it have sufficient merit. (More than one IC may be assigned if appropriate.)
In reality, in the first pass through the CSR, Referral Officers do little more than (1) make sure the grant is formatted correctly (yes, they do check to see if you used a 10 point font instead of 11, shrank the margins beyond what the rules state, went over the page limit, or tried to get by without all the necessary institutional signatures, and if they find that you did any of those things or others the grant will not be forwarded to a study section); (2) verify that it fits the criteria for the grant mechanism being applied for; (3) check against an NIH database of grant applications to make sure that the applicant hasn’t submitted the same grant to two different funding mechanisms during the same grant cycle; and (4) figure out the most appropriate Integrated Review Group to send it to. I suppose it’s possible that 30% of scientists are too stupid or careless to follow the formatting requirements properly and to include all the needed information, but I doubt it. Even if that were the case, the scientists would have no one to blame but themselves; the instructions, although voluminous, are quite clear at least about the basic formatting requirements and page limits for an NIH grant application. In any case, pretty much every grant that’s formatted correctly and contains all the required elements is assigned to a study section for review.
During a study section, the appraisal of which grants are “triaged” is not “cursory.” Every grant application is assigned to approximately three reviewers (the number may vary, depending on the grant mechanism and study section). In the study section on which I last served, for example, every application was assigned to a two primary reviewers (Reviewer 1 and Reviewer 2) and a secondary reviewer (the Discussant). Both primary reviewers were expected to read the grant application in detail, write up a 2-4 page review of it, and assign it a proposed priority score. The discussant was also expected to read each grant assigned to him in detail but only to write up a briefer 1-2 page review and assign a proposed score. Everyone else on the study section tends to look over grants to which they are not assigned as Reviewer 1 or 2 or the Discussant, other than perhaps the abstracts of the grants, but that’s understandable, given that most reviewers are assigned around 10 grants to read in six weeks and that it can take several hours per grant to review it. (At least, that’s about how long it takes me.) At the study section meeting itself, to convene the meeting the chair listed the grants whose initial proposed priority scores were in the bottom half. Because these grants clearly had no chance at being funded during the cycle being discussed, they were then “streamlined” (or, colloquially, “triaged”), meaning that they would not be discussed in detail at the full study section. Potential streamlining candidates whose reviewers assigned them widely divergent scores, indicating a sharp disagreement over their scientific merit, were often specifically pulled aside for discussion before voting on streamlining. Indeed, if either reviewer was insistent about it such grants would usually be discussed before the whole study section despite their low average priority score, and if any study section member strongly objects to the streamlining of any grant application, it was discussed.
Unfortunately, given the largely increased number of grant applications and the down economy, which has led to NIH budgets that, until recently, have not even kept up with inflation, the percentage of NIH grants funded steadily fell from 2004 to 2008. At the low point, for some Institutes, less then 10% of grants were being funded. Consequently, often more than 50% of grants were triaged during that period, because any grant that didn’t reach at least the 30th percentile had no chance. It wasn’t even “in the zone,” so to speak. Fortunately, that trend is starting to reverse, thanks to additional funding to the NIH, although where the new equilibrium will fall is anyone’s guess.
After streamlining, once the discussion of the remaining grants started, Reviewer 1 would usually lead it it for his assigned grants, with Reviewer 2 and the Discussant chiming in. After a full discussion, each member of the study section would then assign a score. Contrary to Dr. Miller’s distorted description, the only differences in treatment between “triaged” grant applications and those discussed at the full study section is that triaged grants are not discussed in detail (although they are reviewed in detail), and a “summary statement,” which boils down the written reviews and group discussion into a summary, which is (usually) highly useful for applicants in guiding revisions of the application for resubmission. Also included are the individual reviewer comments appended to the summary statement. For triaged grant applications, on the other hand, the three written reviews are returned to the applicant, who is free to revise and resubmit based on the comments of the three reviewers. It’s not quite as useful, but still helpful. Indeed, my first application for an NIH R01 grant was triaged, and the comments were helpful in my revising and ultimately succeeding the second time around. Moreover, study sections do not assign percentile scores, only priority scores. Percentile scores are generated from the Gaussian curve of all the priority scores, and it is the percentile score that determines which grants are funded.
The bottom line is that, whatever major faults the NIH grant approval process has, doing only a “cursory” evaluation of the applications at any stage is not among them.
It’s at this point that you find out where Dr. Miller was really coming from, and it wasn’t from the perspective of someone who wants to reform the system. Indeed, the system could use some reform. Whether the “reform” of a new scoring system implemented this year or proposals to cut the page limits for grant applications from 25 to 15 in order to force applicants to deemphasize methodological detail and emphasize broad research rationale and strategy will improve peer review remains to be seen. However, that’s not where Dr. Miller is coming from in this article. Rather, he comes from the perspective of a friend of pseudoscience who feels that the system doesn’t give his HIV denialist buddies a fair shake, which is evident in how he starts out semi-reasonable and then goes right off the deep end. Here’s the semireasonable part:
The grant system fosters an Apollonian approach to research. The investigator does not question the foundation concepts of biomedical and physical scientific knowledge. He sticks to the widely held belief that the trunks and limbs of the trees of knowledge, in, for example, cell physiology and on AIDS, are solid. The Apollonian researcher focuses on the peripheral branches and twigs and develops established lines of knowledge to perfection. He sees clearly what course his research should take and writes grants that his peers are willing to fund.
There is some truth to this, again, depending on the specific grant mechanism. For example, the flagship grant of the NIH, the largest grant awarded to individual investigator (the R01), tends to emphasize research that is well-supported by preliminary data. One reason, of course, is that R01 grants can span up to five years and between $1 and $2 million. If such large investements are made in projects that are too speculative, the vast majority of them will fail and most of the money will have been wasted. Of course, the other tendency is to invest in science that is very well supported by preliminary data and therefore “safe,” meaning that the project proposed will almost certainly yield results. The problem with this latter approach is, of course, that it is so safe. Such projects are unlikely to challenge existing paradigms or create whole new areas of inquiry. Obviously, there needs to be a balance between risky, speculative projects (that are nonetheless well-supported scientifically) that could hit a home run if they succeed and “safe” projects that will produce incremental gains in knowledge and improvements in therapy (i.e., are evolutionary, rather than revolutionary, the equivalent of a base hit instead of a home run).
Where the pendulum swings between these two extremes depends upon funding levels. When funding gets tight, as it has been the last few years, reviewers tend to be more reluctant to fund riskier research, even if it is very compelling and interesting science, because they do not want to throw money at projects with a low chance of success. The “whiner” in me can’t resist pointing out that one way to get more “risky” science funded is to increase science funding overall, to make reviewers more willing to take risks, but that would just reveal me to be a tool of the system, just as Mark Crislip is a shill for big pharma and a tool of the medical-industrial complex. When the pay line (the percentile cutoff for funding) is the 20th percentile rather than the 10th percentile, reviewers are a bit more willing to score risky but brilliant projects higher and cut the applicants some slack for not having as much preliminary data as they normally might like to see. When the payline starts to plunge below the 10th percentile, scientific conservatism reigns.
In any case, there are other grant mechanisms, such as the R21, which provide smaller grants for shorter periods of time (usually one to two years) for riskier projects. Moreover, over the last few years, there has been a real push within the NIH to change the reviewing criteria for grants to emphasize novelty and impact more. Even so, if a tendency towards conservative science was Miller’s main critique of the system, I’d probably agree for the most part, but I’d also point out that the NIH is actually trying to remedy that situation. Unfortunately, Miller couldn’t resist tipping his hand that real reform of the system is not what his polemic was about. After listing what he characterized as “state-sanctioned unassailable paradigms” that will never be funded, Miller devolved completely into ranting crankery:
The human-caused global warming paradigm is most likely false (Soon et al., 2001; Editorial, 2006). Two climate astrophysicists, Willie Soon and Sallie Baliunas, present evidence that shows the climate of the 20th century fell within the range experienced during the past 1,000 years. Compared with other centuries, it was not unusual (Soon and Baliunas, 2003). Unable to obtain grants from NASA (National Aeronautics and Space Administration), Soon (personal communication, August 31, 2006) observes that NASA funds programs mainly on social-political reasoning rather than science.
Duesberg (1996), Hodgkinson (2003), Lang (1993-2005), Liversidge (2001/2002), Maggiore (2000), and Miller (2006), among others, have questioned the germ theory of AIDS. All 30 diseases (which include an asymptomatic low T-cell count) in the syndrome called AIDS existed before HIV was discovered and still occur without antibodies to this virus being present. At a press conference in 1984 government officials announced that a newly discovered retrovirus, HIV, is the probable cause of AIDS, which at that time numbered 12 diseases (Duesberg, 1995, p. 5). Soon thereafter “HIV causes AIDS” achieved paradigm status. But, beginning with Peter Duesberg, Professor of Molecular and Cell Biology at the University of California, Berkeley, a growing number of scientists, physicians, investigative journalists, and HIV positive people have concluded that HIV/AIDS is a false paradigm. The NIH awarded Duesberg a long-term Outstanding Investigator Grant and a Fogarty fellowship to spend a year on the NIH campus studying cancer genes, and he was nominated for a Nobel Prize. When Duesberg publicly rejected the HIV/AIDS paradigm the NIH and other funding agencies ceased awarding him grants. Government-appointed peer reviewers have rejected his last 24 grant applications. Peter Duesberg (personal communication, September 20, 2006) writes: “When I was the blue-eyed boy finding oncogenes and ‘deadly’ viruses, I was 100% fundable. Since I questioned the HIV-AIDS hypothesis of the NIH’s Dr. Gallo, and then the cancer-oncogene hypothesis of Bishop-Varmus- Weinberg-Vogelstein etc. I became 100% unfundable. I was transformed from a virus- and cancer-chasing Angel to ‘Lucifer.’”
Yes, anthropogenic global warming denialism and HIV/AIDS denialism (coupled with the oft-repeated cry of “martyrdom!” from Peter Duesberg, yet!) are what Dr. Miller is about. (Hint to Dr. Miller: Citing Christine Maggiore and Peter Duesberg is not a particularly good way to bolster the credibility of your arguments.) Other “unassailable paradigms” that Miller lists are not quite as ridiculous as his examples of AIDS and global warming, but they’re mostly strawmen; for example, the claim that “cholesterol and saturated fats cause coronary artery disease” is actually not quite what medical science states; rather it is that cholesterol and saturated fats are major factors, among others, that contribute to the pathogenesis of coronary artery disease. (Perhaps Dr. Miller is a member of The International Network of Cholesterol Skeptics, a.k.a. THINCS, which Harriet Hall so delightfully skewered last year.) Using these examples did not exactly bolster Miller’s credibility or case, either. Miller then went on a tear about how science is in service of the state, pulling out more HIV/AIDS denialism coupled with some rather blatant conspiracy-mongering:
AIDS research serves the interest of the state by focusing on HIV as an equal opportunity cause of AIDS. This infectious, egalitarian cause exempts the two primary AIDS risk groups, gay men and intravenous drug users, from any blame in acquiring the disease(s) owing to their behavioral choices. Duesberg, Koehnlein, and Rasnick (2003) hypothesize that AIDS is caused by three other things, singly or in combination, rather than HIV: 1) long-term, heavy-duty recreational drug use–cocaine, amphetamines, heroin, and nitrite inhalants; 2) antiretroviral drugs doctors prescribe to people who are HIV positive– DNA chain terminators, like AZT, and protease inhibitors; and 3) malnutrition and bad water, which is the cause of “AIDS” in Africa. HIV/AIDS has become a multibillion dollar enterprise on an international level. Government, industry, and medical vested interests protect the HIV/AIDS paradigm. The government-controlled peer review grant system is a key tool for protecting paradigms like this.
Personally, I always marvel at such amazing nonsense. For one thing, why would it “serve the interest of the state” for HIV/AIDS to be a “equal opportunity cause of AIDS.” Surely, it could equally serve the interest of the state to demonize one or two unpopular segments of the population, depending upon who is in charge at any one given time. Be that as it may, the evidence that HIV causes AIDS is exceedingly strong and has not been seriously challenged, not by Duesberg, and certainly not by any of Dr. Miller’s HIV “dissident” tracts published at the execrable LewRockwell.com. The views in his articles alone show that Dr. Miller’s critical thinking skills leave much to be desired, and this lack of critical thinking is very apparent in his article attacking peer review.
No wonder Dr. Miller was so unhappy about how peer review works! No wonder his article is such a gem of crankery that I remembered it two years later and have been meaning to discuss it for SBM almost since SBM began.
Personally, my view is that, whatever problems are inherent in the current peer review system (and, as I have said before, there are many), one thing the current system does do a reasonably good job of is of keeping pseudoscience (such as what Dr. Miller apparently subscribes to) from being funded by government bodies. I know, I know. There is one glaring–and I do mean glaring–exception to this rule. You probably know what it is. That’s right; I’m referring to the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM), which exists primarily to fund pseudoscience. True, it does fund studies of herbal remedies, which could be considered a part of pharmacognosy, but such studies would be much better if done by one of the other relevant Institutes or Centers that aren’t dedicated to woo. As for the rest of the “alternative” medicines of which NCCAM funds studies, the vast majority are highly implausible, and NCCAM has utterly failed to produce a single truly positive study or to conclude that any woo doesn’t work. That’s why I have castigated NCCAM time and time again, and, with other SBM bloggers, called for President Obama to defund this agency. Indeed, I even suggested a how-to guide on defunding NCCAM.
Somehow, though, I doubt that NCCAM is what Dr. Miller had in mind when he castigated peer review by government granting agencies. To me, its past ability to keep pseudoscience from being funded and, for the most part, published was one of the great strengths of our peer review system. Unfortunately, the funding of NCCAM shows just how fragile that ability can be. Any reform that is undertaken must be done carefully in such a way as to minimize any weakening this firewall against ideas that are clearly without scientific merit and overwhelmingly believed to be so by scientists. After all, one of the risks of funding “riskier” science is that pseudoscience will sneak in, along with the legitimate science. Worse, one of the risks of funding based far more on ideology than science, which is what NCCAM does given that it was imposed upon the NIH by powerful quackery-friendly legislators like Tom Harkin (who was most unhappy earlier this year because NCCAM was too scientific for his taste in that it hadn’t “proven” more alternative medical modalities to be effective) rather than developed by scientists to fill a perceived need in response to a groundswell of support, is that more pseudoscience will be funded. Of course, that’s exactly what Dr. Miller wants: Legitimacy and funding for the pseudoscience behind HIV/AIDS denialism. Finally, one thing that I have to wonder about is this: If the “unassailable state-sanctioned paradigms” that Dr. Miller detests so much are, as he seems to believe, due primarily to the inherent bias of the NIH grant peer review system that is “designed to protect the existing paradigm,” why, then, is it that scientists around the world also consider Duesberg’s ideas about HIV to be profoundly incorrect and have come, after much wrangling, to believe that human-caused global warming is occurring?
Sadly, the ideas for reform seen in Miller’s article and elsewhere among the HIV/AIDS “dissidents” seem to boil down to either “let’s find a way to fund potential cranks like us” (a.k.a. “mandatory funding of contrarian research”) or “let’s get rid of peer review.” Dr. Miller opines:
One alternative to the competitive peer review grant system that the NIH and NSF might consider for funding specific research projects is DARPA, the Defense Advance Research Projects Agency. This agency manages and directs selected research for the Department of Defense. At least up until now it has been “an entrepreneurial technical organization unfettered by tradition or conventional thinking” within one of the world’s most entrenched bureaucracies (Van Atta et al., 2003). Eighty project managers, who each handle $10-50 million, are given free reign to foster advanced technologies and systems that create “revolutionary” advantages for the U.S. military. Managers, not subject to peer review or top-down management, provide grants to investigators whom they think can challenge existing approaches to fighting wars. As long as the state controls funding for research, managers like this might help break the logjam of innovation in the biomedical and physical sciences. Science under the government grant system has failed and new kinds of funding, with less government control, are sorely needed.
I fail to see how giving appointed managers this power would be “less” government control over research. After all, who hires these managers? The government! What’s to stop the government “orthodoxy” from simply hiring managers who believe the “government orthodoxy” and will therefore disburse research funds in order to support the “orthodoxy”? Nothing! After all, it would be even easier to enforce an orthodoxy if the managers, rather than largely volunteer peer reviewers drawn from diverse academic settings, controlled funding. Besides, military technology, although a broad area, is applied, not basic, science. It probably does not require as much of an understanding of the nitty-gritty of the basic science behind technology proposals as it does to understand whether a basic science or translational research proposal is reasonable, innovative, and feasible. Moreover, remember that the entire yearly budget of the NIH is only around $30 billion, and the entire budget of the NCI is less than $5 billion, both of which are utterly dwarfed by the size of the Defense budget. In other words, the military is much more lavishly appointed and can afford to throw money at risky scientific projects in a way that the NIH and NSF cannot. Moreover, contrary to this example of DARPA, the system that the U.S. Department of Defense uses to evaluate most submitted research proposals is actually peer review. Using peer review, in fact, the Army (believe it or not!) does quite a good job of emphasizing and fostering innovative proposals; indeed, for its biomedical research programs, the Army probably does better job in many respects of supporting scientific innovation than the NIH. If the NIH is going to emulate the military, it would do far better to examine how the Army conducts its scientific peer review sessions, rather than to listen to the posturings of people like Miller.
The rest of the peer review bashers tend not to do much better than Dr. Miller. For example, going back in time a couple of years, one of the most vociferous critics of peer review that I’ve ever encountered (not to mention a hardcore HIV/AIDS denialist) is blogger Dean Esmay. I refer to his ideas, even though he expressed them a couple of years ago, because he was quite impressed with Dr. Miller’s article and decided to add his ideas to Miller’s. Basically, Dean’s ideas (old version of post in the archive) seem to boil down to the sort of reasonable to the ignorant to the unworkable. For example, Dean proposed a seemingly not entirely unreasonable idea of completely eliminating the anonymity of peer reviewers that betrays his ignorance of the process. For one thing, he doesn’t seem to have noticed that Study Section rosters are already published on the web, allowing reasonable guesses as to who specific reviewers are for applications. (In fact, the NIH helpfully sends applicants the complete roster of the members of the study section that reviewed their grant, along with the summary statements and reviews.) He also seems not to understand that it is a not infrequent occurrence for more junior faculty to be reviewing applications by senior, well-entrenched faculty, the veritable “gods” of the field, if you will. How willing would these early mid-career scientists be to provide brutally honest feedback about a bad proposal if the applicant would know who gave him the bad score? In fact, I have felt that very pressure myself. After reading a truly execrable grant application by a very highly regarded scientist that looked as though it had been thrown together over a weekend, I’m not sure I would have had the courage to give it the review it deserved if I knew that the applicant would know who I was. Indeed, completely eliminating anonymity might actually have the tendency to worsen the very problem Dean and Miller decry by leading to grants by highly established and respected scientists getting even more of a pass from study sections than they do already.
In addition, Dean proposed another idea that revealed his ignorance of the NIH, namely to make peer review funding boards “truly multidisciplinary” (whatever that means) and forcing every application to be looked at by a mathematician or someone with a “background in mathematics.” I’m not sure if he was referring to the study sections, which do initial peer review, or advisory councils of each institute, which do the second tier of peer review taking into account specific scientific and/or programmatic priorities of their Institutes, but Dean apparently has never actually looked at the roster of a few typical NIH Study Sections. If he meant study sections, I point out that they already are multidisciplinary, and virtually all of them include biostatisticians! (I hope that’s “mathematical” enough for Dean.) For example, the study section on which I sat until last year included internists, physiologists, surgeons, computer experts, radiologists, medical imaging experts, molecular biologists, a medical physicist, and biostatisticians. I suppose that we could make things even more “multidisciplinary” with “no direct interest” in the field (we could bring in an archaeologist, I suppose, to look at cancer biology proposals), but we would do so at the risk of decreasing the familiarity of reviewers and study section members with the detailed science behind grant applications assigned to them. (On second thought, maybe that’s just what Dean would like. On third thought, there’s no “maybe” about it.) On the other hand, if Dean meant Institute advisory councils, it is hard to see what added benefit that making the these second tier reviewers even more “multidisciplinary” would provide, given that the primary driver of what gets funded is the review provided by the study section, not the post-review committees, which largely rely on the study section’s priority score and the priorities of their respective Institutes to dole out funds. They tend not to make a big difference except for close calls or in cases of proposals that are highly congruent with the Institute priorities but missed the funding payline by a relatively small margin. Making these advisory councils more “multidisciplinary” would be unlikely to affect these priorities because it is not the advisory councils who determine NIH funding priorities; they only implement them. It is the NIH Director and the Directors of the various Institutes, who are appointed by the President, who determine NIH funding priorities, heavily influenced, of course, by Congress and the President.
No one denies that there are problems with the NIH peer review system for grant evaluation; like all human endeavors, there’s room for improvement. Indeed, the complaints bubbling up against it over the last few years are nothing new; I heard the same complaints when I was in graduate school in the early 1990s. Ironically enough, that, too, was a time of very tight paylines, even tighter than they are now, which makes me wonder if the recent budget travails of the NIH are a blessing in disguise, in that they are catalyzing a discussion of how we as a nation can do better with peer review and thus better at deciding what grants to fund. I’ll grant you that the recent ARRA Challenge Grant fiasco, in which we have 20,000 applications chasing between 200-400 Challenge Grants actually isn’t the best argument for this. However, that’s not because of peer reviewers; rather it’s because of a policy decision to put so little of the ARRA stimulus funds into new grants of this sort, which has led to a shortage of reviewers and likely the need to review grants so fast that peer review may suffer. Fortunately, this is a one-time program.
Despite those problems, the system has largely served us well for the last several decades, as long as politicians are kept as much as possible out of the mix, as what failed to happen with NCCAM. Despite their flaws, the NIH and NSF peer review systems, once in place, have remained remarkably immune to political influence and corruption, at least as much as any government entity can be. Certainly they have much to recommend them. For example, junior scientists compete for funds with more senior scientists on a more equal footing than perhaps any other nation in the world. In fact, new investigators who have never received a major NIH award are even given a significant (although, some would argue, not significant enough) break on funding lines to give them a better chance of being funded. Also, applicants can propose virtually any sort of health science-related research project, and it will be seriously considered for grant funding by a study section composed of experts qualified to evaluate it. Moreover, scientists are actively working to address the system’s shortcomings. Meanwhile, contrary to the impression given by Dr. Miller’s article of a system that scientists accept and never challenge, articles about the problems in the peer review system, and there has been much discussion of this at meetings that I have attended, and the NIH even maintains a web page called Enhancing Peer Review.
Of course, substantive and real reform of the peer review system in order to make it function better and allow the funding of meritorious but risky projects is not the true goal of “critics” like Miller, Esmay, and others. Neutering it is, the better to allow pseudoscience like HIV/AIDS denialism an opening. Mark Hoofnagle was right two years ago to warn us to beware the bashers of peer review.

   Peer Review and the Internet
Steven Novella
Link
Peer-review has been the cornerstone of quality control in academia, including science and medicine, for the past century. The process is slow and laborious, but a necessary filter in order to maintain a certain standard within the literature. Yet more and more scholars are recognizing the speed, immediacy, and openness of the internet as a tool for exchanging ideas and information, and this is causing some to question the methods of peer review. A recent New York Times article discusses this issue.
This issue is very relevant to Science-Based Medicine as this is in part an experiment – an attempt to produce a high quality, editorially filtered, but not peer-reviewed, online journal. Our process here is simple. Outside submissions are reviewed by two or more editors and typically are either accepted with minor revisions or rejected. In addition we have a staff of regular contributors – those who have a proven track record of producing high quality articles. There is no pre-publication review for their submissions, and they are able to post directly to SBM.
Because many of the issues we cover are timely, we emphasize speed of publication. Therefore copy-editing is done post-publication – the notion being that our readers can tolerate a few typos in order to gain access to material more quickly.
In addition our pieces are, essentially, crowd sourced. SBM editors and readers provide feedback in the comments, often pointing out ambiguous wording or even outright errors, which can then be quickly fixed or clarified. Editors also provide direct feedback to authors if a more serious issue emerges (which is rare, but happens) and steps are taken to transparently fix such issues. This is, in a way, post-publication peer-review.
By contrast, traditional peer-review is designed to take a long time to produce the highest quality article prior to going to print (even if “print” is online). The strength of this process is that several editors and peer-reviewers have thoroughly gone over the submission, corrected errors, fixed ambiguities, added missing insights, reviewed methodology, checked references, and made sure that the author’s conclusions do not overstep the data. At least this is the ideal – we often write about peer-reviewed publications on SBM that fall far short of this ideal. In the end, peer-review is only as good as the editors and reviewers. I have both been a writer and reviewer, and the process does have many strengths. In the end the article that gets printed is much improved over the original submission.
The weaknesses of the process, however, are the long delay to publications – months or even years. Further, the process is a bit hit or miss and depends largely on the quality of the reviewers. Individuals are quirky, and they may have biases or missing information that will hamper the quality of their review. The more people there are involved in the process the better the quality is likely to be.
As academia grapples with the internet age, the challenge is to rethink the process of peer-review. Specifically, are there ways to leverage the power of the internet to make the review process faster and better? This has happened in the technical sense – the traditional process of peer review is now often done online. For the last article I reviewed I was not sent a hard copy or even an electronic copy. I signed onto a secure website where I had access to the article, and I submitted my review entirely online. This was convenient and also a time-saver. But still the process was slowed by the need to choose reviewers, wait for them to accept and then for those specific reviewers to review the paper. And in the end opinions were solicited from only two reviewers.
Imagine an alternate process by which an article is published online, either on an open site or a secure site that only experts have access to. Then dozens or hundreds of experts can comment on the paper, providing feedback directly to the authors in addition to the editors, who can also respond to the commenters. The result would be more of a dynamic conversation than you get with the current review process. But most importantly, in my opinion, is that you would get a broader range of opinions, and a far greater chance to detect error or bias. An editor or editors can oversee the process, and once it has played itself out the final version of the paper can be published to the public, and become part of the official literature.
Now is the time for experimentation, in my opinion. I don’t know yet what the optimal system would be, but I think a hybrid of peer-review and open publication will emerge. There still needs to be some filter, and some editorial process selecting articles, overseeing feedback and revisions, and approving the final version. Feedback from many experts should be solicited in some fashion, and the process should be interactive.
There are many details to experiment with, however. Should commenters be named or anonymous? Anonymous feedback may be more candid, but people should be held accountable for their expert opinions as well. How should commenters be limited, if at all? Should there be a period of feedback open to the public, or should pre-publication access only be granted to experts, and how should that be limited? (How narrow a field of experts should apply?)
There is also the issue of presenting new research in an open forum prior to adequate review. Will the press troll these pre-review sites looking for juicy stories based upon flawed research that would never ordinarily make it to publication?
The strengths and weaknesses of any new process of peer-review will not be fully appreciated until it is implemented, which is why we are in a period of experimentation. But the experiment is worth doing. In the end we may gain a better, faster and more transparent review process.

Faking Peer-Review
A major cancer journal just retracted 107 papers for faking peer-review, bringing the total for that publisher to 450. How did this happen, and how do we prevent it in the future?
Steven Novella on April 26, 2017
Link

Peer-review is one of the pillars of the institutions of science. The idea is simple – have relevant experts review a submission for quality, thoroughness, and errors prior to opening up that submission to the world through publication. This concept, however, is only as good as its execution.
Recently Springer, the publisher of Tumor Biology, retracted 107 papers published in that journal between 2012 and 2016 because of falsified peer-review. This is the largest retraction to date, and clearly represents a systemic problem. This brings the total retractions by Springer for fake reviews to 450. An exploration of what happened here provides some insight into the issue.
How they faked peer-review
The process of faking peer review was not new, and was rather simple. The authors of the submitted papers suggested reviewers, and helpfully included their e-mail addresses. The names of the suggested reviewers were real experts in the field, but the e-mail addresses submitted were fake and lead to a confederate. The confederates submitted glowing reviews of the papers and suggested publication.
The scam was uncovered when the editors of the journal were doing a review of their process. They contacted the reviewers directly, and found that they had never reviewed the papers in question and that they did not own the listed e-mail address.
The fix for this specific scam is simple – when a reviewer is suggested, don’t trust the submitted contact information. Verify them independently, and contact the reviewer directly. However, this will only address this one method, not the deeper problem of researchers trying to game the system. Obviously you need to plug holes when they are discovered, but that is not enough. The process needs to be tight enough to foil the next scam, not just the last one.
This does also raise the question of allowing researchers to suggest their own reviewers. There is a range of opinions about this. Some journal editors have stated that they allow submissions to suggest reviewers, and then avoid those reviewers. Others don’t allow suggestions, and some will use suggested reviewers and those the editors find themselves.
The obvious reason to avoid suggested reviewers is that they are hand-picked to be favorable to the research or the researchers. In the worst case, friends could trade favorable reviews of each-other’s research.
In the best case, and the intended purpose of suggesting reviewers, is that experts in a field will know who the other experts are, perhaps better than the journal editors. It is meant to be a good-faith helpful suggestion. Also, some argue that a new or disruptive idea in science might be unfairly excluded by the clique of established experts. An open-minded expert might be needed to give the paper a fair shake.
Probably the best compromise is to use both suggested and independent expert reviewers, and then make a judgement about the actual quality and importance of the research taking all opinions into account. No one said being the editor of a major science journal would be easy.
The culture of science
Another important aspect of this spasm of 107 retractions is that all of the researchers were from Chinese institutions, and all were involved in cancer research. Why I think this is important is because it shows the importance of culture in science.
While I think we need a robust system within the institutions of science to ensure quality, honesty, transparency, and ethical behavior, these values also need to be shared by the scientific culture. I don’t think there is any system that can adequately compensate for a culture of scientists who are inherently dishonest.
A specific scientific culture exists at every level – it is unique to each lab, institution, field of inquiry, and nation. Norms of behavior are passed down from mentor to student, and are maintained by the community. We see this in other institutions as well, such as governments, where corruption breeds corruption. If one research group is getting a leg up by faking peer review, others will feel the pressure to do the same in order to compete, but will also feel as if the behavior is accepted.
It seems unlikely that all these Chinese cancer researchers came up with the same exact scam during the same four year period. Clearly this was an idea that was passed around, and the behavior became accepted, and perhaps even expected.
There is reason to believe that this is also not an isolated phenomenon, but a problem more generally with scientific research in China. For example, reviews have found that while about 60% of acupuncture studies from Europe and other parts of the world are positive, acupuncture studies from China are 99.8 to 100% positive (statistically unlikely even if acupuncture works, and it probably doesn’t). Part of this is cultural, and part is likely due to the recent surge in science funding in China and pressure to become an overnight scientific powerhouse. It takes time to develop mature institutions, and if you throw money at immature institutions you tend to get corruption and waste.
All of this is not to suggest that scientific fraud is unique to China. It unfortunately is not. Rather, the point is that fraud and corruption tend to occur in pockets where it is allowed for foment and spread.
Fixing the deeper problem
In order to have science-based medicine, we need science, and we need science that has all the features I named above – high quality, honesty, transparency, and ethical behavior. Fraud and poor quality in science are a massive drain on limited resources. In medicine the problem is magnified because practitioners are making day-to-day decisions about how to treat patients based on that science.
Therefore we all have a huge incentive to have robust systems of maintaining high quality and minimizing fraud. Further, we need to foster a culture where fraud is unacceptable, and honesty is expected. This does mean, in my opinion, that the cost of being caught committing scientific fraud has to be extremely high, not only for the individuals but for the involved institutions.
Journal editors have a lot of power, and responsibility, in this regard. It would be defensible, for example, to require a much higher level of scrutiny for submissions from countries or institutions that have a history of prior fraud. China, in my opinion, should be in scientific probation. Submissions from Chinese institutions should be looked upon with greater suspicion, and require greater vetting. Further, systematic reviews should consider the origin of the studies they review, and not assume a level playing field for all research.
For example, the evidence is clear that acupuncture research from China has a near 100% positive publication bias, and likely a massive positive researcher bias. And yet acupuncture papers from China contaminate all systematic reviews of acupuncture, without acknowledgement of this clearly established fact. It is reasonable to consider the reliability of the source of studies when reviewing the evidence. If one lab was the only lab that could produce positive studies, for example, that would certainly be noted and call their results into question.
I often feel the need to point out when I write such articles that I don’t think science is broken. The institutions of science are fairly robust, and true results do tend to persist over time, while false results tend to fade. Rather, this is about making the institutions of science even better, and minimizing waste of resources. Fraud creates nothing but waste and causes harm. Everyone agrees (at least publicly) that it is unacceptable. The real question is about priority. In my opinion it needs to have an extremely high priority.

Reporting Research Misconduct
Steven Novella on February 18, 2015
Link

Perhaps one of the greatest threats to the enterprise of Science-Based Medicine is research fraud and misconduct. Rigorous research methods can be used to minimize the effects of bias, but when those methods themselves are the problem there is no easy fix. Related to this is the need for transparency. When fraud or misconduct is uncovered it erodes confidence in the system because it provokes speculation about how much fraud and misconduct has not been uncovered.
A recent study published in JAMA looks at one aspect of this issue – reporting of misconduct uncovered by the FDA. The good news here is that FDA trials, those that will be used to apply to the FDA for approval of a drug, are carefully monitored and inspected by the FDA. This is an important quality control measure. When the FDA uncovers misconduct it takes steps to correct it. If the misconduct is severe enough then any data that is associated with the poor research practices will be excluded from the trial so as not to taint the results. Even an entire study can be disqualified if necessary.
The problem highlighted by the study is that there is no systematic way for the FDA to communicate its findings through the peer-reviewed literature. Tainted studies, or ones that require a correction or retraction (because the violations were discovered after publication) may therefore persist in the peer-reviewed literature without any indication of the uncovered misconduct.
The sole author, Charles Seife, found:
Fifty-seven published clinical trials were identified for which an FDA inspection of a trial site had found significant evidence of 1 or more of the following problems: falsification or submission of false information, 22 trials (39%); problems with adverse events reporting, 14 trials (25%); protocol violations, 42 trials (74%); inadequate or inaccurate recordkeeping, 35 trials (61%); failure to protect the safety of patients and/or issues with oversight or informed consent, 30 trials (53%); and violations not otherwise categorized, 20 trials (35%). Only 3 of the 78 publications (4%) that resulted from trials in which the FDA found significant violations mentioned the objectionable conditions or practices found during the inspection. No corrections, retractions, expressions of concern, or other comments acknowledging the key issues identified by the inspection were subsequently published.
Seife gives some specific examples, includes an entire trial that was deemed unreliable by the FDA (the RECORD4 trial looking at an anticoagulant for deep vein thrombosis), but the FDA’s findings are not mentioned in any of the publications describing the trial’s results.
In a separate case Seife reports:
A clinical site in China taking part in a large trial of apixaban, a novel anticoagulant, had apparently altered patient records. If one were to exclude the data from the patients at that site, the claim of a statistically significant mortality benefit disappears.179 For this reason, among others, the FDA wrestled with whether it was appropriate to allow the manufacturer to claim a mortality benefit. None of this discussion appears in the literature.
Reporting of these findings exposes a serious concern, but one that has some obvious solutions. As Seife himself suggests, when the FDA finds violations it can be required to report their findings on clinicaltrials.gov. Seife also proposes that a separate database be created just to report FDA inspections that find misconduct. Further, peer-reviewed journals can require that submitting authors disclose any FDA violations, similar to the required reporting of potential conflicts of interest.
The FDA has responded to the study by saying they are:
…committed to increasing the transparency of compliance and enforcement activities with the goal of enhancing the public’s understanding of the FDA’s decisions, promoting the accountability of the FDA, and fostering an understanding among regulated industry about the need for consistently safe and high-quality products.Regarding redaction of warning letters, the majority of information that is redacted from warning letters about clinical trials pertains to either the protocol or patient identifiers. The FDA redacts protocol information from warning letters because the information pertains to a pending application, not because it may reveal investigator misconduct. Information on pending applications is exempt from public disclosure based on several federal statutes and regulations, such as the Freedom of Information Act.
Mainstream reporting of these results have been, in my opinion, a bit hyped. This stems partly from the fact that Seife, who is an investigative journalist interested in exposing research fraud, wrote an editorial in Slate to accompany the publication of his study. Seife claims that the FDA is “burying” and has “hidden” evidence of misconduct. This is why the FDA addressed the issue of redacted warning letters in the quote above – redaction was interpreted as an effort to hide details of misconduct.
To put the problem into perspective, in 2013 FDA inspections uncovered misconduct in 2% of their investigations. Further, the FDA takes steps to correct the problems they uncover, such as excluding tainted data or even entire studies. The problem here is one of transparency, especially in the peer-reviewed literature. I don’t know if it is fair to say that the FDA buries its findings of misconduct, rather than they simply have no systematic method of reporting their findings.
As can be expected, the results of this study and the perhaps overly-hyped reporting have fueled conspiracy theories and science denial. Taken out of context, the study can be used to dismiss any scientific findings that one finds inconvenient to their ideology.
This is part of a broader problem, and one that we confront frequently at SBM. The institutions of science are certainly flawed, as is every human endeavor. Those flaws, however, are not fatal. The culture of science is also one that is self-reflective and contains a sincere motive for self-improvement and quality control.
We frequently point out flaws in the practice of science as a way to inform interpretation of the scientific literature, and to suggest specific improvements to make the practice of science more reliable and transparent. Others, however, point to the same flaws as a way of dismissing the findings of science in general, or at least anything with which they disagree.
Findings such as these can be used as a way of improving the institutions of science, or as a way of tearing it down. I prefer the former.

A formal request for retraction of a Cancer article
James Coyne on May 12, 2014
Link

I am formally requesting that Cancer retract an article claiming that psychotherapy delays recurrence and extends survival time for breast cancer patients. Regardless of whether I succeed in getting a retraction, I hope I will prompt other efforts to retract such articles. My letter appears later in this post.
In seeking retraction, I cite the standards of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) for retraction. Claims in the article are not borne out in simple analyses that were not provided in the article, but should have been. The authors instead took refuge in inappropriate multivariate analyses that have a high likelihood of being spurious and of capitalizing on chance.
The article exemplifies a much larger problem. Claims about innovative cancer treatments are often unsubstantiated, hyped, lacking in a plausible mechanism, or are simply voodoo science. We don’t have to go to dubious websites to find evidence of this. All we have to do is search the peer-reviewed literature with Google Scholar or PubMed. Try looking up therapeutic touch (TT).
I uncovered unsubstantiated claims and implausible mechanisms that persisted after peer review in another blog post about the respected, high journal-impact-factor (JIF = 18.03) Journal of Clinical Oncology. We obviously cannot depend on the peer review processes to filter out this misinformation. The Science-Based Medicine blog provides tools and cultivates skepticism not only in laypersons, but in professionals, including, hopefully, reviewers who seem to have deficiencies in both. However, we need to be alert to opportunities not just to educate, but to directly challenge and remove bad science from the literature.
A brief history
You may recall my previously blogging about the article that I am now requesting be retracted. I described how the authors unsuccessfully attempted to block publication of a criticism of their study. They then refused to respond when the criticism was published. The article spun faulty analyses and avoided simple analyses that showed that giving cancer patients breathing exercises and encouragement of healthy behaviors does not forestall recurrence or extend their lives.
But earlier papers from the same project did some spinning as well. For instance, one paper tested the more reasonable hypothesis that psychological interventions can reduce emotional distress, improve health behaviors and dose-intensity, and enhance immune responses.
There is no evidence that any changes in the immune parameters that were studied would be clinically significant or that there exists any plausible mechanisms by which recurrence and survival might be affected. But why wouldn’t we expect a support group intervention to affect mood and health behavior in the way that was hypothesized?
The abstract claimed uniformly positive results in terms of effects on anxiety and improved dietary habits, smoking, and adherence, with no negative results mentioned. However — and here I draw on my past blog post — the authors cast a wide net, with the methods section revealing assessment of at least:
9 measures of mood (there is evidence from other articles that there are even more measures of mood assessed that were not reported in this article);
8 measures of health behavior;
4 measures of adherence;
15 measures of immune function.
Turning to the actual results, only 1 of the 9 measures of mood was significant in time-by-treatment interactions. The intervention seemed to have had a significant effect on “dietary behavior” (although it is unclear why the results for very different individual dietary behaviors were not individually provided) and smoking, but no effect on exercise. As is often the case with early breast cancer patients, rates of adherence to chemotherapy were too high to allow any differences between the intervention and control groups to emerge.
In terms of immune function, results were not significant for counts of CD3, CD4, or CD8 cells, or six assays of natural killer cell lysis.
These overall results suggest that what we were told in the abstract represents a gross confirmatory bias — the suppression of negative results and the highlighting of positive ones likely to be due to chance.
Claims about biomedical outcomes such as recurrence and death need to be evaluated as such. It is unlikely that claims about a new form of chemotherapy or radiotherapy would be accepted if they were based on faulty post-hoc analyses of a study with such a small sample size, and with results contradicted by more straightforward, appropriate analyses. But for a variety of reasons, claims about psychological interventions improving survival are often given special consideration not only in the media, but in scientific journals.
Let us get real. Given the effectiveness of current treatments for early breast cancer, an effort to demonstrate an improvement over results obtained in guideline-consistent routine care would have to involve thousands of patients, not the 227 recruited for this study. In the U.S. the 5-year survival rate for women with localized breast cancer is now 98.5%. And then of course there is the lack of plausible biological mechanism by which group therapy could slow recurrence and extend survival.
Mind over cancer
The idea that the power of mind can triumph over physical illness is deeply rooted in Western folk culture and has its roots in classical Greek and Roman thinking. Yet, we showed in a systematic review of the literature, that “No randomized trial designed with survival as a primary endpoint and in which psychotherapy was not confounded with medical care has yielded a positive effect.”Investigators who had undertaken ambitious, well-designed trials to test the efficacy of psychosocial interventions but obtained null results echoed our assessment with reviews declaring “Letting Go of Hope” and “Time to Move on.”
I provided an extensive review of the literature concerning whether psychotherapy and support groups increased survival time in an earlier blog post. Hasn’t the issue of mind-over-cancer been laid to rest? I was recently contacted by a science journalist interested in writing an article about this controversy. After a long discussion, he concluded that the issue was settled — no effect had been found — and he would not succeed in pitching his idea for an article to a quality magazine.
But hold on.
Considering the question open is vital to continued federal funding of the field of psychoneuroimmunology (PNI). Without having established that psychological interventions actually improve survival of cancer, PNI seeks to explain how these interventions succeed. It is classic tooth fairy science.
The NCI in particular provides financial support to efforts to promote psychoneuroimmunology in articles in special issues of journals and symposia that exclude any anyone who might express skepticism. As an example, see an extraordinary 2013 article, “Psychoneuroimmunology and cancer: a decade of discovery, paradigm shifts, and methodological innovations published by McDonald, O’Connell & Lutgendorf in Brain, Behavior, and Immunity (30, S1-S9).The article celebrated a decade of NCI support for psychoneuroimmunology, starting with a 2002 conference and resulting 2003 monograph. The three authors were a NCI program officer, a science writer paid by NCI, and a proponent of Therapeutic Touch. The 2013 article introduced a collection of carefully selected invited reviews:
This [2003] seminal volume captured state-of-the-science reviews and commentaries by leading experts in psychoneuroimmunology (PNI) and served as a catalyst for biobehavioral1 research conducted in a cancer context. In the decade prior to the NCI commissioned supplement, Brain, Behavior, and Immunity published only 12 cancer-relevant articles. Since the 2003 supplement, the journal has featured 128 cancer-relevant papers that have generated 3361 citations (data from SCOPUS, retrieved November 1, 2012), relative to 55 papers on PNI and cancer, published in other peer review journals during the same time period. These bibliometric data highlight Brain, Behavior, and Immunity as a leading scholarly outlet for research on the biology of psychological and social experiences and the integrated mechanisms associated with cancer as a complex disease process. The current volume celebrates the 10-year anniversary of the 2003 supplement. This collection of invited reviews and research articles captures important discoveries, paradigm shifts, and methodological innovations that have emerged in the past decade to advance mechanistic and translational understanding of biobehavioral influences on tumor biology, cancer treatment-related sequelae, and cancer outcomes.
This paragraph can be interpreted in different ways. B, B, & I’s editorial board is a tight club of PNI researchers , many of those with NIH funding. The journal rarely has an article without positive findings and seldom is seen a skeptical word about PNI. The journal could represent the success of NIH funding for PNI research, particularly NCI, or the poor reception of PNI research in the larger scientific literature. Outside the incubator, PNI mostly does not survive peer review.
In 2014, a NCI program officer placed solicitations on a listserv for free training in Cancer to Health (C2H), supported by a NCI R-25 grant. The evidence mustered for the R-25 application is the project from which the Cancer article came.
At a 2014 meeting of the Society Behavioral Medicine, the NCI supported a symposium with a NCI program officer as a discussant. The author of the article for which I have requested a retraction renewed her claims of the powers of her intervention and solicited applications from professionals interested in free training with support from the NCI R-25 training grant.
In August 2014, the author of the Cancer article will fly to Groningen, the Netherlands, with another NCI program officer and again present her claims at the International Congress of Behavioral Medicine.
For political reasons, not science, the NIH is interested in keeping this line of research alive, even if it is on life support. The idea is that behavioral interventions can extend life, not just improve its quality. And to study exactly how requires not only investigator-initiated R01s but larger program grants. When the author of the Cancer article refused to respond to our critique, the task was accepted by Peter Kaufmann. He is the Deputy Chief of the Clinical Applications and Prevention Branch of National Heart Lung and Blood Institute (NHLBI) and at the time his commentary was written, President of the Society of Behavioral Medicine.
As I note in my earlier post:
Subtitling his commentary “To Light a Candle,” Kaufmann conceded that my colleagues and I had raised valid criticisms about the design and interpretation of the C2H intervention trial. However, he took issue with our recommendation that clinical trials of this kind be suspended until putative mechanisms could be established by which psychological variables could influence survival. Quoting our statement that an adequately powered trial would require “huge investments of time, money, and professional and patient resources,” he nonetheless called for dropping a “preoccupation with mechanisms and secondary aims,” and instead putting the resources to increasing the sample size and quality of an intervention trial.
Wow, so we should ignore the lack of evidence for biologically-plausible mechanisms. Kaufmann suggests we should pour what would have to be millions of dollars into a trial to test whether psychotherapy and support groups extend the lives of cancer patients.
The call for retraction
May 7, 2014
Fadlo R. Khuri, MD, FACPEditor-in-Chief, Cancer
Dear Dr. Khuri:
This open letter formally requests retraction of a 2008 Cancer article
Andersen, B. L., Yang, H. C., Farrar, W. B., Golden-Kreutz, D. M., Emery, C. F., Thornton, L. M., … & Carson, W. E. (2008). Psychologic intervention improves survival for breast cancer patients. Cancer, 113(12), 3450–3458.
According to the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE; http://tinyurl.com/kd5q28o), journal editors should consider retracting an article if
they have clear evidence that the findings are unreliable, either as a result of misconduct (e.g. data fabri­cation) or honest error (e.g. miscalculation or experimental error)
I call your attention to the basic data reported in the flow chart in Figure 2 of the cited article. Analyses that can be readily performed but that are not provided in the article directly contradict the claims that are stated in the title, get amplified in the abstract, and are repeated throughout the text. When simple 2×2 chi-square calculations are performed on raw recurrence and death events from the figure for intervention versus control group, differences do not approach significance for the proportion of women experiencing a cancer recurrence in the intervention (25.4%) versus control conditions (29.2%; Odds Ratio = 0.83, CI = 0.46 – 1.48, p = .525). There is no difference between the proportion of women who died in the intervention group (21.1%) versus the control condition (26.5%; Odds Ratio = 0.74, CI = 0.40 – 1.36, p = .332). Similar results are obtained if one examines only those deaths due to breast cancer.
My colleagues and I previously published a commentary in Cancer arguing that the authors’ data failed to support their conclusions.
Stefanek, M. E., Palmer, S. C., Thombs, B. D., & Coyne, J. C. (2009). Finding what is not there. Cancer, 115 (24), 5612-5616.
Our commentary was originally submitted as a briefer letter. It was first rejected, with a previous editor citing a standing policy of not accepting critical commentaries if authors refused to respond. This policy essentially allowed authors to suppress criticism of their work, regardless of the validity of criticism. We asked the editor to re-evaluate the policy and reconsider the rejection of our commentary. The editorial board reconsidered and invited the extended commentary that was published. However, the authors still refused to respond, a choice which many would consider extraordinary.
Our criticisms would have been directly addressed if the authors had simply provided a report of positive findings for standard, unadjusted outcomes, such as a Kaplan-Meier estimate of the survival function. We indicated strong reasons why such analyses would not be significant. Regardless of their choice not to respond to our letter, the authors had a responsibility to provide these data.
Instead of results for unadjusted outcomes, the authors had provided in the article dubious multivariate analyses with a high risk of spurious findings. Both unadjusted and adjusted analyses should have been provided. When positive results are obtained with unadjusted outcomes, readers’ confidence in them are increased when findings persist after adjustment for possible confounds. However, when positive results are obtained with unadjusted outcomes, contradictory findings after adjusting for confounds warrant special scrutiny. Interpretation of adjusted outcomes assumes complete specification of possible confounds and measurement without error, assumptions that are not typically tested or met. Analyses with adjusted outcomes are not necessarily more generalizable than those with unadjusted outcomes. On the contrary: Positive findings with adjusted outcomes may variously reflect overfitting, residual confounding, incomplete specification and imperfect measurement of covariates, and covariate selection procedures that capitalize on chance.
The multivariate analyses presented in Anderson et al.’s article control for initial group differences in a number of potential confounds. This is remarkable because the authors also reported ‘‘no significant differences between study arms in sociodemographics, disease, prognostic factors, type of surgery received, or adjuvant treatments.”
The authors relied on a backward elimination procedure to select control variables from a larger pool of at least 15 candidate variables. Eight to ten of these factors were retained as covariates in analyses predicting time to recurrence, death from breast cancer, or death from any cause. Aside from capitalizing on chance, the number of covariates was simply too high relative to the number of events being explained (i.e., recurrences, breast cancer deaths, other deaths). Anderson et al. consistently violated the general rule that predictors should not be added to the equation if the ratio of outcome events to predictor variables is not at least 10:1. For instance, the final model for recurrence-free survival included 11 predictors for 62 events: a ratio of 5.6:1.
You may ask why a claim for retraction is occurring at this time. First, the authors have continued to cite this claim in other publications without acknowledging objections to the analyses. Second, this paper continues to be widely cited and specifically as evidence that psychosocial intervention prolonged survival, a claim that does not otherwise have support. Third, this particular paper served as the basis for federal funding to disseminate training in this intervention. The paper is specifically cited in solicitations (http://tinyurl.com/n2den7g) for training at Professor Barbara Andersen’s Training Institute For Empirically Supported Biobehavioral Interventions for Cancer Patients.
Claims about time to recurrence and cancer-specific and all-cause mortality are claims about biomedical outcomes. I seriously doubt that had such claims concerning chemotherapy or radiotherapy based on flawed analyses in a small sample in a study in which survival was not a predesignated outcome been made, they would go unchallenged. I believe that these authors’ claims should be held to the same standards as other biomedical interventions.
The American Cancer Society website (http://tinyurl.com/l2f63c7) has posted a statement
The research is clear that support groups can affect quality of life, but the available scientific evidence does not support the idea that support groups or other forms of mental health therapy can by themselves help people with cancer live longer.
This is in response to widespread beliefs among patients and their families that persons with cancer can somehow boost their immune system and thus extend their chances of survival if they attend such groups.
The Andersen et al. Cancer article that lends credibility to these groups stands in direct contradiction to that statement by the ACS. Either the statement should be revised or the finding should be retracted.
Thank you for your consideration. I await your response with interest.
Sincerely,James C Coyne PhDProfessor Emeritus of Psychology in PsychiatryPerelman School of Medicine of the University of PennsylvaniaProfessor of Health PsychologyUniversity Medical Center, Groningen

Chinese BioMedical Research: Sturgeon’s Law In Action
A Chinese government investigation has found that 80%, yes eighty percent, of Chinese biomedical research is fabricated. I bet that is an underestimate for Traditional Chinese Pseudo-Medicine.
Mark Crislip on January 20, 2017
Link

A liar will not be believed, even when he speaks the truth.– Aesop

I do not have much to write about this week. Nothing came across my feeds that inspired me to prolonged pontification and much of my time this week has been spent at the local outdoor store trying to purchase weapons for my children. Both of them are in school, one on L.A. and the other in Boston, and I have been made aware of the real and serious dangers posed by grizzly bears for unarmed students. A magnum should slow down any bear that is not smarter than average.
So I offer this short entry on an issue that arose this week.
It has long been noted that there is a discrepancy in outcomes in clinical trials of Traditional Chinese Pseudo-Medicine (TCMP) between those studies that have been done in China and those done in the US and Europe.
99% of acupunctures studies in China for acupuncture are positive and:
No trial published in China or Russia/USSR found a test treatment to be ineffective.
This odd result has always been ascribed to a combination of culture bias and, perhaps, poor methodologies.
The method of randomisation was often inappropriately described. Blinding was used in only 15% of trials. Only a few studies had sample sizes of 300 subjects or more. Many trials used as a control another Chinese medicine treatment whose effectiveness had often not been evaluated by randomised controlled trials. Most trials focused on short term or intermediate rather than long term outcomes. Most trials did not report data on compliance and completeness of follow up. Effectiveness was rarely quantitatively expressed and reported Intention to treat analysis was never mentioned. Over half did not report data on baseline characteristics or on side effects. Many trials were published as short reports. Most trials claimed that the tested treatments were effective, indicating that publication bias may be common; a funnel plot of the 49 trials of acupuncture in the treatment of stroke confirmed selective publication of positive trials in the area, suggesting that acupuncture may not be more effective than the control treatments
As we have discussed at length in this blog, the poorer the methodology, the more likely a pseudo-medical study will have a positive result.
But the issue is not cultural bias or badly done studies. Nope.
Chinese researchers just make shit up.
An evaluation by the Chinese government found that:
more than 80 percent of clinical data is “fabricated,”
It seems that making up data is de rigueur in China:
“Clinical data fabrication was an open secret even before the inspection,” the paper quoted an unnamed hospital chief as saying.
Academic ethics is also an underdeveloped field in China, leading to an academic culture that is accepting of manipulation of data.I don’t think that the 80 percent figure is overstated. I grew up a science fiction fan and a follower of Sturgeon’s law: “ninety percent of everything is crap.” It looks like Chinese medical researchers use it as a commandment rather than a warning.
The review does not specifically mention if TCPM studies were included and my reading suggests that the investigation applies to standard biomedical research. But given the fantastical nature of TCPM and the vanishingly small (on order of gravitation wave detection, one-ten-thousandth the diameter of a proton (10-19 meter)) prior plausibility of TCPM and likelihood that most of TCPM is Oakland, I would wonder if 80% is a gross underestimate.
Which presents an interesting and difficult problem. At what point can you no longer trust the veracity of the literature? 1.97% of researchers admit to making up data and more have other nefarious practices. Worrisome but not as difficult as a culture of fabrication. A single researcher will do less damage than a whole society. A single fake paper is likely to be swamped by the preponderance of the literature. But what if the entire literature is built on lies? Then what?
Evaluating the medical literature as a practicing physician, I would assume that if a researcher made up his data for one study, then all his data and subsequent bloviating would be suspect. Like Wakefield. I would assume anything Wakefield says would be a lie until I could prove otherwise. And that goes against my default position to assume that people are usually not deliberately lying to me. I was raised to think a person is only as good as their word. Of course outside of the medical literature lying is not always considered a detriment. For the electoral college 80% is evidently just fine.
If patients put their health, wealth, and life in my hands, I have to know that the clinical trials I am basing my decisions on are as close to true as possible. Truthiness is not good enough.
Can we automatically assume that all the biomedical research coming out of China is fabricated? How can we tell? We can’t. And I would be especially skeptical of clinical trials of TCPM. It would also be interesting to see the results of the almost too numerous to count acupuncture meta-analyses if they were re-analyzed after removing all the Chinese studies.
Unfortunately when it comes to the medical literature from China, since the information can’t be verified you have to assume it cannot be trusted and so no longer counts. It has to be considered persona non grata unless it can demonstrate otherwise.
I assume true believers in TCPM will ignore the findings and point to the malign influence of big pharma on medical research, as if that makes the lies out of China just peachy.
Dr. Cummings over at the BMJ Blogs was recently upset that acupuncture is considered by Wikipedia to be a pseudo-science. Acupuncture/TCPM literature is likely far worse, the lying lies of liars.

Shilling for traditional Chinese medicine: Nature leaves its readers a lump of coal before Christmas
David Gorski on December 26, 2011
Link
I’ve subscribed to Nature for many years now, even though I don’t always read it. Nature is one of the oldest and most respected scientific journals around. It’s been around since 1869 and is said to be the world’s most cited journal. What makes Nature unusual these days is that it’s one of the last of the remaining general science journals and one of the two that still publish original peer-reviewed research in a wide variety of scientific fields. Astronomy, physics, chemistry, medicine, biology, Nature publishes it all. The only other journal of its type that I can think of is Science, which also has a similar high impact factor. In any case, getting published in Nature is a big deal, one that can make a career. Believe it or not, I actually have a Nature publication. True, it’s from the 1990s, and, true, I’m only the fourth author, but it is a Nature publication. Ever since then, I keep telling myself that, one of these days, I’ll manage to find a way to be published again in Nature, although I realize that it’s looking increasingly unlikely that that will happen. Such is the power and cachet of Nature. It’s a name that has provided prestige to some of its spinoff journals, such as Nature Medicine, although of late Nature appears to have diluted the brand name beyond belief.
Nature sells out
All of the above is why I’m very, very disappointed in Nature for having dropped a huge lump of coal into the stockings of supporters of science-based medicine a mere three days before Christmas. Maybe its editors thought that it wouldn’t be noticed right before the holiday season. I don’t know. I do know that I noticed. Basically, Nature sold out to a Japanese pharmaceutical company, which, along with a research institute, bought a supplement in Nature that is in essence an advertorial for its point of view. Don’t believe me? Check out this acknowledgment of the sponsors published in the advertorial:
We are grateful for the support of our sponsors, Saishunkan Pharmaceutical Co., ltd. and the Kitasato University Oriental Medicine Research Center. As always, Nature carries sole responsibility for all editorial content.
Yes, you read it right. Nature sold out to a Japanese supplement manufacturer and a quackademic medical center. But what did Saishunkan Pharmaceutical Company and the Kitasato University Oriental Medicine Research Center get in return for their money? Believe it or not, they got a whole supplement entitled Traditional Asian Medicine. This supplement is basically, with a minimal degree of skepticism, an attempt to convince Nature‘s readers that traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) is science-based and, even more than that, represents the cutting edge of medical science based on systems biology. Basically, it’s a mixture of The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly, with the vast majority falling credulously into the latter two categories by a wide margin.
Let’s start by taking a look at the main sponsor of the supplement, Saishunkan Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd., which is described thusly:
Saishunkan is a herbal medicine manufacturer which aims to help people make the most of their natural powers of healing and self-recovery. Based on the idea from herbal medicine that humans are part of the nature, our dream and joy is to ease the worries and concerns of aging, which comes to everyone. We maximize our capabilities to support lively and happy aging by using the power of nature to enhance human revitalization.
Our business started with a herbal formula “Tsusanto” for easing pains of neuralgia and rheumatism. In 1974, “Domohorn Wrinkle”, a family of basic skincare products intended for mature skin came to being from the same principles of herbal medicine.
Interestingly, Tsusanto is mentioned in a report on Pharmaceuticals and Medical Devices Safety Information and described as “ Ephedra Herb/Glycyrrhiza/Apricot Kernel/Stephania Tetrandra/Coix Seed Ephedra Herb/Apricot Kernel/Coix Seed/Glycyrrhiza/Sinomenium Stem/ Animal Bile. Meanwhile, Domohorn Wrinkle is described as containing a selection of about 150 “natural” ingredients. The company itself wants to argue that this is scientific, and, as evidence to support its products, it includes a message published in the supplement. The two-page message is basically a lot of self-serving company propaganda with a couple of Western blots and graphs, the better to make it more science-y. Apparently one of its concoctions increases levels of certain heat shock proteins, and this is trumpeted as evidence that they work. I’m not impressed.
Meanwhile the Kitasato University Oriental Medicine Research Center is described thusly:
The Oriental Medicine Research Center provides two types of clinical activities: medical treatment based on Kampo medicine theory, primarily using decoctions, and acupuncture that follows our country’s traditional techniques. To prepare Kampo medicines, we have set up an exclusive pharmacy that is in charge of dispensing and formulating these medications, focusing on crude drugs. Patients come from all over the country in search of treatments based on Oriental medicine, both Kampo medicine and acupuncture/ moxibustion.
Kampo medicine, for those of you not familiar with it, is simply the Japanese study and adaptation of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). As practiced today, it does seem somewhat different in that the Japanese government regulates Kampo medications as pharmaceutical products, rather than supplements. It is, however, the same TCM woo, just transplanted to Japan.
The selling of TCM as being “personalized” medicine
The overall approach of the articles in this supplement appear to follow roughly the form and arguments of the very first article by Michelle Grayson, Traditional Asian Medicine. So let’s start there. It’s all on display there, claims that TCM is being “integrated” into “Western” medicine, and, most annoying of all to me, the claim that TCM is so “personalized” that randomized clinical trials are very difficult, if not impossible, to do:
Yet a bit of probing revealed what a complex story this is. Not only are big efforts underway to modernize traditional medicine in China and Japan, but Western medicine is adopting some aspects of the Eastern point of view too. In particular, modern medical practitioners are coming around to the idea that certain illnesses cannot be reduced to one isolatable, treatable cause. Rather, a fall from good health often involves many small, subtle effects that create a system-wide imbalance.
But do traditional medicines actually work? Their personalized nature makes randomized controlled trials — the gold standard for testing drugs — extremely difficult. Rarely are two formulations identical. However, as modern medicine becomes more personalized, using biological and genetic markers, it is inadvertently developing the tools to better test traditional medicines.
The other theme that runs through these articles, besides the implication that TCM is just too personalized to be studied easily using randomized clinical trials is the very conscious effort to link this “personalization” with the new era of genomic medicine, whose fruits (if we ever realize them) will one day be considered truly personalized medicine based on a patient’s genomic profile. Honestly, it should be profoundly embarrassing to Nature that one of its own actually wrote this twaddle. Actually, Nature should be profoundly embarrassed at publishing so much twaddle in this supplement. I could, if I so desired, spend several days, one post per day, deconstructing these articles. I’m not sure if I’m really up for the task right now, given the proximity of the holidays, although I might very well change my mind. I’m also likely to have more to say about this supplement issue on my other blog next week.
In the meantime, the next installment in the series is Convergence: Where West meets East starts with a passage that any supporter of SBM will find incredibly irritating. See how many fallacies you can count in just this short snippet of text:
For around 200 years, two very different systems of medicine have been used in Asia to cure diseases and keep people healthy. The local Asian one is based on traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) — herbal mixtures developed though observation and experience accumulated over thousands of years, but with unknown mechanisms of action. On the other hand, modern medicine, imported from the West, consists of chemically purified compounds that have been discovered through scientific investigation and tested in controlled clinical trials.
Yes, there it is, the the false dichotomy of “East” versus “West,” which portrays the “East” as being more spiritual and the “West” as being unfeeling, scientific, and out of touch with nature. Notice the reference to “chemically purified compounds” compared to the “natural” compounds of TCM. Notice the argument from antiquity, which implies that because TCM is ancient (“Observation and experience accumulated over thousands of years”) contrasted with science. Just this brief paragraph is a veritable plethora of woo-speak! It doesn’t get any better from there.
There’s a long section on TCM diagnosis, which in reality is based on a prescientific understanding of disease and how the human body functions. In essence, they boil down to imbalances in the five “elements,” which are basically the Chinese version of the four humors plus one. Remember that a major component of TCM diagnosis is something called “tongue diagnosis,” which the article even dutifully reproduces, complete with woo diagnoses like Yin Deficiency and Yang Deficiency, not to mention Qi Stagnation. This system is described, in all seriousness by the author, as producing diagnoses that are a “finer level of classification than disease groupings in modern medicine.” I kid you not. In support of this, a study published in the American Journal of Chinese Medicine is cited in which the authors used TCM diagnoses to classify rheumatoid arthritis patients. The study concluded that patients with cold-pattern symptoms (diagnosed by TCM, of course) responded better to real medicine, while patients with qi deficiency responded better to TCM. In any case, this entire article is very much woo-omics, like the Ayurogenomics that I discussed a while back; i.e, a total abuse of genomics and systems biology. They even use and abuse poor Leroy Hood, one of the originators of systems biology. Unfortunately, this abuse appears to be not without basis, as Hood has been known to drop some rather silly statements about how “traditional medicine” is a lot like “multitargeted” therapy, something I hadn’t known until after I did a bit of Googling after having read this supplement.
The rest of the supplement is chock full of similar atrocities against skepticism and science. For example, there’s an article by Felix Chueng entitled TCM: Made in China, which is basically one long appeal to popularity, listing how many people use TCM, how many companies manufacture it, and how this number is growing, as though this were evidence that TCM must be scientifically valid. Chueng even appeals to the one example of how a blind squirrel can find an acorn every so often, namely the example of the antimalaria drug artemisinin, which was isolated from an herb described in TCM. Another article by Chueng extolls the glories of how TCM is practiced in the clinic. It’s nothing more than one long anecdote, in which the author, suffering from a “persistent back problem” that also causes leg pain (which sounds a lot like sciatica) goes to a TCM clinic. There, he’s diagnosed with xinhuo (“heart fire) and then treated with acupuncture, moxibustion, and cupping. He was even treated with–believe it or not–bloodletting to clear the “heart fire.” He concludes:
I walked happily away with my leg feeling much better. As I left the hospital, I saw the women still doing their baduanjin. I began to wonder if maybe I should start practicing baduanjin too.
Baduanjin is a form of Tai Chi.
As I read this account, I wondered: This guy is editor of Nature China in Hong Kong. I couldn’t help but also wonder if Chueng had ever heard of placebo effects, because he was describing a lovely example of them in his anecdote.
A blind squirrel finds an acorn occasionally, or: The use and abuse of systems biology
Much of this supplement has to do with a tactic that I’m seeing more and more from promoters of TCM, Ayurveda, and the like, namely that the principles of TCM are a lot like the new, more “holistic” principles of systems biology and that TCM herbal preparations are really rationally designed mixtures of active compounds designed to “hit multiple biological targets,” an example of which can be found in this bit of pure propaganda for TCM found in an article by Zhiguo Xu entitled Modernization: One step at a time. Once again, the example of artemisinin is trotted out as an example to imply that all TCM must have something to it. Of course, what’s interesting is that the description of artemisinin provided in this article is nothing more than good, old-fashioned pharmacognosy; i.e., natural products pharmacology. In fact, that, and the other example culled from TCM, arsenic trioxide, are used to imply that the view of TCM that purified compounds aren’t the best way to treat disease, that there is synergy between different compounds in herbs:
For decades, European and US regulatory agencies held the view that a drug must be either a highly purified or synthetic agent. Traditional medicines could not qualify under this definition because a TCM preparation is a concoction rather than a single compound, and the chemical structures of the active ingredients are undefined. Consequently, when it came to assessing a traditional medicine for efficacy, most effort went into identifying the principal agent within a herb or mixture of herbs and purifying it as a single chemical compound. However, “academic scientists and the pharmaceutical industry have not been very successful at isolating the active substances in TCM preparations”, says Bai Lu.
Others share Lu’s dour outlook. “Few active ingredients are extracted from TCM herbs by modern scientific approaches,” says Yi Rao, dean of life sciences at Peking University in Beijing. “Those extracted effectively have not been demonstrated to be clinically successful.” Indeed, he says, “artemisinin and arsenic trioxide are perhaps the only two examples”.
The author seems not to realize that these two examples of medications isolated from TCM treatments, far from indicating the importance of having multiple ingredients, actually demonstrate the importance of isolating the active compound and purifying it. Yet the entire focus of this particular article is to claim that there is “synergy” between ingredients of herbs and how to capture it. The problem is, there usually isn’t. Herbs can be drugs, but they are impure drugs. Perhaps the reason that so few active substances have been isolated from TCM herbs is because there just aren’t that many.
Even more amusingly, another example is described, something called the Herbalome project. This is nothing more than high throughput screening of herbs from TCM for active ingredients using liquid chromatography and other methods of separation. Analyzing 500 samples a day, the project has thus far identified the active ingredient from only one herb. Inadvertently, the Herbalome project appears to be demonstrating that there probably isn’t much that’s useful in the herbal medicine of TCM that hasn’t already been identified. Of course, that leads to this excuse:
For example, Liang acknowledges that one of the major tools used by his team as part of the Herbalome — high-throughput screening — is not ideally suited to the task. That’s because TCM concoctions are mixtures of multiple active compounds, and a typical Chinese medicine is intended to hit multiple biological targets.
Notice the rebranding. The originators of TCM had no idea what a “biological target” was. They were trying to “rebalance the elements” or “correct the flow of qi.” They weren’t trying to “hit multiple biological targets,” and they used herbs because that was all they had. Substances found in TCM that actually had some activity against real diseases (substances such as artemisinin and arsenic trioxide) were discovered by accident, not because the principles of TCM facilitated their identification. In any case, what the Herbalome project is doing is nothing different than high throughput screening of natural products that just happened to be used in TCM.
The previous article, at least, had a germ of truth to it in that there might occasionally be active compounds in various TCM medications. However, the next article takes this to the “next level” of woo by claiming that TCM is finally being appreciated because it’s being vindicated by new findings in systems biology and genomic medicine. It’s a horrible, horrible article by Jan van der Greef, principal scientist at the Netherlands Organization for Applied Scientific Research (TNO), professor of Analytical Biosciences at Leiden University and chairman of the Sino-Dutch Centre for Preventive and Personalized Medicine, entitled All Systems Go. Practically every paragraph had seriously cringe-worthy sentences in it (to supporters of SBM like me, anyway), passages like this:
The concepts and practices of systems biology align very closely with those of traditional Asian medicine. Consider the very idea of ‘health’. The current World Health Organization definition of the term is based on a 1948 consensus: “A state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity.” However, an emerging concept of health in the scientific literature describes an ability to adapt and self-manage in the face of social, physical and emotional challenges1. This perspective has, of course, long been central to the concept of health in traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), which further includes spiritual fulfilment and a sense of individual well-being.
And:
But there is a growing realization in the West that single biomarkers are not enough. A better approach is to look at patterns of biomarker responses to a challenge. These data will provide insight into the resilience of allostatic mechanisms, and hence into a person’s health, an approach not unlike the tenets of TCM.
Get it? Understand? According to van der Greef, TCM was ahead of its time, and “Western” science is only now catching up! This assertion is, of course, a pair of fetid dingo’s kidneys. What’s really going on is that woo-friendly “Western” scientists like van der Greef are retrofitting new scientific findings into the framework of TCM and declaring that they fit. In reality, what quackademics are doing is taking parts of TCM that sound vaguely as though they fit in with the latest scientific findings in systems biology and grafting them on to create a Frankenstein monster made up of parts of systems biology with a parts from TCM stitched together. Add to that the typical alt-med excuse that “your science can’t study my woo” because it’s “personalized” and randomized clinical trials can’t handle that, and you have the recipe for the infiltration of quackademic medicine into academia.
In all fairness, I will concede that the Nature supplement isn’t entirely bad. For instance, there is a reasonably good article on biodiversity and how TCM threatens it by using body parts of animals belonging to endangered species, a practice that generates a lucrative trade in endangered species. Unfortunately, the article fails to describe just how cruel some of the techniques used to obtain these body parts and fluids can be and just how much they endanger species like tigers. There is, however, a nice debunking of the idea that rhino horn has been used for thousands of years to treat cancer. (It turns out that it was made up less than 100 years ago.) There’s also an article on the dangers of herbal medicine, which can cause side effects, sometimes severe. However, overall the articles in this supplement leave this reader with the inescapable impression of boosterism. This is, of course, not surprising, given that this supplement should be viewed, more than anything else, as an advertising supplement, bought and paid for by its sponsors.
A thought comparison
As I read this supplement, I couldn’t help but think of what the reaction would be from CAM practitioners to a supplement bought and paid for by a pharmaceutical company. (Actually, this supplement was bought and paid for by a pharmaceutical company; it’s just that it was bout and paid for by a pharmaceutical company that makes TCM remedies.) The reaction would be unrelentingly hostile, and rightly so. In fact, I highly doubt that Nature would agree to publish a supplement funded by, for example, Merck, Pfizer, or Sanofi-Aventis extolling the virtues of their products. I doubt even more highly that it would hire out its own editors to write articles for such a supplement. Yet that’s exactly what Nature has done in this case for TCM.
I’m left with the conclusion that, to their eternal shame, by publishing this issue, the editors of Nature have become willing shills for the TCM industry. Nature has sold out, and its editors and publisher should be called out for it.

Pseudoacademia
Steven Novella on April 10, 2013
Link
The integrity of the scientific basis of medicine is under attack from numerous fronts. It is not only the intrusion of pseudoscience and mysticism into mainstream institutions of medicine, but also attempts to distort or game the scientific process for ideological and financial reasons.
Ideological groups such as the anti-vaccine movement, or grassroots organizations promoting pseudodiseases such as chronic Lyme, electromagnetic sensitivity, or Morgellon’s often misrepresent the scientific evidence while they lobby for special privilege to avoid the science-based standard of care within medicine.
Pharmaceutical companies, with billions on the line, have been very creative in figuring out ways to optimize their chances of getting FDA approval for their drugs, and then promoting their drugs to the medical community. Ghost-writing white papers, hiding negative trials, and designing trials to maximize positive outcomes have all been documented.
And of course there is now a vibrant subculture of “alternative” medicine proponents with their own journals, training programs, NIH center, and even their own privileged regulations existing in parallel to science-based medicine, distorting and subverting the process of science in countless ways, carefully documented over the last few years on SBM.
Now, it seems, we have a new source of pseudoscience to contend with, outlined in a recent article in The New York Times – open-access journals.
We have spoken mostly positively about online open-access journals. They allow for more transparent publication of scientific articles which are accessible to the general public, bringing science publishing into the 21st century. More access to information is generally a good thing, especially with an institution like science that requires openness and robust communication.
What typically happens is that we go into these new adventures, like the internet, the world wide web, social media, and now open-access journals, with naïve optimism about the potential new media. Then the con-artists and profiteers come in and exploit the new medium for selfish gain. I guess that is the unavoidable nature of any open society. Now we have to contend with the dark side of open-access scientific journals.
Here is how the scam works, according to the NYT article: Individuals or companies create an open-access online journal and try to give it the trappings of legitimacy. They give it an impressive sounding name, and sometimes give it a name that is very close to that of an established journal, hoping that it will be mistaken for the legitimate one. They invite recognized professionals onto their editorial board, and often enough naïve professors and researchers, hoping to support new open-access journals, sign on. Creating an impressive-looking website is now a simple task, requiring a relatively small investment for a company.
These journals then spam e-mail professors and researchers soliciting articles from them. After articles are submitted they then hit them with an author’s fee, which can be as much as several thousand dollars. Open-access journals often charge the authors a fee to publish because they do not charge readers subscriptions – that is the whole point of being open-access. So superficially the whole thing looks legit.
Such journals, however, have been described as “predatory” because of the aggressive way they solicit articles and the deceptive nature of how they pack their editorial boards and charge author fees.
The big problem is that they often lack a quality peer-review process. They will often publish anything, as long as you pay the fee. The result is that they are flooding the literature with poor quality papers which are difficult to weed out from the rest because they are doing a good job of hiding in the herd, by camouflaging themselves with the trappings of legitimacy.
For those attempting to research a medical topic, doing an online search has become much more difficult. Unless you are intimately familiar with all the journals in your field, you will likely get poor-quality results mixed in with the legitimate articles, and they will be difficult to recognize because they are convincing mimics.
The problem of bogus open-access journals is essentially the same as the more general problem of the web and social media – the field is crowded with fraud, biased sources, and simple mediocrity. There is no traditional editorial filter in place, no hurdle of getting past a publisher or editor. Lowering the barriers to publishing is still overall a good thing, in my opinion, but it means we have to invent new ways to indicate quality.
Since there is no longer any prepublication barrier, we need to add postpublication evaluation. For open-access journals this may mean creating a list of journals that have been evaluated and meet minimal criteria for quality and the legitimacy of their peer-review.
Of course, this will just be one more system to manipulate and game. Scientific quality in an open-access world requires eternal vigilance.

Bad Science Journals
Steven Novella on August 27, 2014
Link
It’s an excellent business model. The only real infrastructure you need is a website, and you can have a custom site made for $5-10 thousand. Then you just have the monthly bandwidth charges. The rest is just e-marketing, which can be done for free, or the cost of some e-mails lists. After that, the money just comes rolling in.
The best part is that other people do all the actual work. All you have to do is charge them for publishing on your open-access online journal.
What you are selling is essentially scientific/academic fraud.
Unfortunately, this is a good business model, even though it is a terrible scientific model, and so it has proliferated. We may be living in the heyday of dubious open-access scientific journals.
The open-access format itself is not a bad one, and there are some very successful and respected open-access journals, such as the PLOS journals. The idea is that, instead of charging a subscription in order to gain access to published articles (in print or online), the articles are open-access, but authors pay a fee to have their work published.
This model works well when everyone agrees to be honest. However, it quickly became clear that dubious journals could charge authors to publish a high volume of low quality papers they could not get published in real journals, and this would provide a healthy revenue stream with little overhead.
The key is (and this is where the fraud comes in) the journals are presenting themselves as if they are peer-reviewed. The peer-review process is not perfect and is no guarantee of quality science, but it is a necessary low-pass bar. Peer review provides some limit on the volume of poor quality research flooding the published literature. Without it the floodgates open, and then worthwhile research is drowning in a sea of crap.
Jeffrey Beall has created a list of dubious (also called predatory) open-access journals as a warning to would-be authors. His criteria for inclusion in the list are all reasonable red flags. They contain items such as – not identifying an editor, having the same editorial board as other journals, and listing editors that have no idea they are being listed.
The point of these practices it to create the false impression that a journal is legitimate, while not bothering to invest in actually editing submissions or having them peer-reviewed.
Recently a new wrinkle has been added to the phenomenon of predatory journals. The Canadian journal, Experimental and Clinical Cardiology, was a respected journal for 17 years that played by the rules. Its publisher was losing money, however, so a year ago he sold it to a foreign publisher.
The new publisher has apparently turned the journal into a predatory scam, but is enjoying the reputation previously earned by the legitimate journal. Therefore, rather than having to market the dubious journal and build a reputation, you can just buy an existing reputation and convert it into a predatory journal.
The Ottawa Citizen reports that they performed a little sting operation on the new journal, sending it a blatantly terrible article. As they explain, they took an HIV paper and simply did a copy-replace of the word “HIV” with the word “cardiac.” The title of the paper, “VEGF proliferation in cardiac cells contributes to vascular declension,” is meaningless jargon that any reviewer should have seen through instantly. There were other outrageous errors in the paper, but none of that kept the paper from being accepted and published.
The Citizen reports that they submitted similar nonsense to 18 other dubious journals, half of which accepted the submissions.
This sting is a mini-version of the operation published a year ago by John Bohannon in Science. He submitted 304 bogus articles to open-access journals with similar results – over half accepted the clear trash for publication.
All of this creates more work for scientists and academics who have better things to do. Scientists have to spend time vetting journals before submitting their work. Of course, everyone would like to publish in Science or Nature, but most papers are published in second- or third-tier journals which are legitimate but maybe not as well known. The predatory journals are hiding among the herd of such legitimate but more obscure journals.
Further, younger and perhaps less experienced academics are approached to be on editorial boards of new open-access journals, or are encouraged to submit their work there. Meanwhile more experienced academics with name recognition might have their name simply added to an editorial board without their consent. Promotional committees also have to spend additional time vetting every publication in a journal they don’t immediately recognize.
As dubious open-access journals proliferate, it becomes more difficult to keep track, and the published literature itself becomes overwhelmed with poor-quality papers. This generates further confusion for the media, who have a tough enough time reporting science news. Essentially this phenomenon is ramping up the noise and drowning out the signal of quality scientific research.
There are, of course, solutions. Beall’s list of predatory journals is a good start. In addition to this “black list,” a thorough and rigorous “white list,” or seal of approval would also be very helpful. This is supposed to exist, but clearly too many dubious journals are slipping through. In light of the Experimental and Clinical Cardiology episode, whenever a journal changes publishers, it needs to be removed from the white list until it is reevaluated under the new publishers.
I think open-access is a viable model for scientific journals, but this model has exposed a vulnerability that needs to be plugged.
In general, more attention needs to be paid to the editorial and peer-review quality of scientific journals. The noise to signal ratio is too high, and the internet allows easy access to all of it. In general the internet had led to more access and reduced filters, which is both a strength and a weakness. Quality control suffers, and so new mechanisms must be explored to achieve a high level of quality control. The published literature needs to be looked at as a vital resource and protected from exploitation.

   The New England Journal of Medicine Disappoints
Kimball Atwood
Links
On July 31 of this year, a collective groan could be heard emanating from critics of pseudomedicine. The causative factors (which is medical bombast for “the cause”) were two book reviews published in the usually staid New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM):
Integrative Oncology: Incorporating Complementary Medicine into Conventional Cancer Care
Edited by Lorenzo Cohen and Maurie Markman. 216 pp., illustrated. Totowa, NJ, Humana Press, 2008. $79.95. ISBN 978-1-58829-869-0.
Reviewed by Donald I. Abrams
Alternative Medicine? A History
By Roberta Bivins. 238 pp., illustrated. New York, Oxford University Press, 2008. $35. ISBN 978-0-19-921887-5.
Reviewed by Teresa L. Schraeder
The Wooification of Medical Journals
I’ll review the reviews, but first let’s consider why their presence in the NEJM is so disturbing. The NEJM is the most widely read and cited medical journal in the world. Among American journals, the top three are usually reckoned to be the NEJM, the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) and, at least for internists, the Annals of Internal Medicine (Ann Int Med). The extent to which each journal has sacrificed its integrity for the promotion of the recent wave of pseudomedicine has varied among the three: the NEJM rarely and, for the most part, unwittingly; JAMA famously in 1998 and occasionally since; and the Ann Int Med repeatedly and embarrassingly, most notably with a series of puff pieces on “CAM” that spanned several years and violated the Annals’ own policies regarding funding disclosures by authors and editors.
To the small extent that the NEJM has previously acknowledged the “CAM” fad, it has been mostly wise in its editorial stewardship. In 1983 it published the best article about pseudomedicine ever to appear in a mainstream journal, which I quoted extensively a couple of weeks ago (if I were King, that article would be reprinted each year or so). The Journal also published, in 1998, the best and most widely cited skeptical editorial on the topic. In 2005 it published a nice piece by our fellow blogger Wally Sampson, who shot holes in the rationale for studying echinacea as a treatment for viral respiratory disease.
It’s true that the Journal has occasionally been fooled, as it and many others were by David Eisenberg’s 1993 survey of the use of “unconventional medicines” by Americans—which was not only inaccurate and wrong in its primary conclusion, but has since been hyped by Eisenberg and the rest of the “CAM” cabal as their major rationale for Making Mischief out of Malarky. More recently, in 2001, Stanford psychiatrist David Spiegel slipped this past the NEJM goalie:
The literature is now evenly divided: 5 of 10 published trials report that psychotherapy prolongs survival, usually moderately, in patients with cancer. The randomized trial we began in the 1970s was based on the hypothesis that psychosocial group therapy would lessen distress in women with breast cancer but would not influence survival. We found, however, an 18-month survival advantage for patients who received group therapy, and this was not accounted for by differences in medical treatment. Since then, four other randomized trials also found that various forms of psychotherapy for patients with cancer were associated with both psychological benefit and longer survival time.
Spiegel didn’t bother to mention that studies purporting to show benefit, mainly his own, had for years been soundly criticized as not worthy of such an interpretation. He also didn’t disclose that his financial and academic fortunes were substantially dependent on readers believing otherwise. Only a year before his NEJM editorial he had published a popular book whose cover states:
Psychiatrist David Spiegel was the first to demonstrate that group support for cancer patients results in significantly enhanced survival times…
In the early 1990s he had made the same claim on the Bill Moyers PBS series, “Healing and the Mind,” a spawning ground for lucrative “CAM” careers. Dr. Spiegel’s desire to keep the public confused about this “mind-body” issue in cancer is still evident on his Stanford Center on Stress and Health website where he claims, albeit in more weaselly words, that
These benefits may lead, in turn, to delayed disease progression and prolonged survival time…
Dr. Spiegel knows, of course, that all adequately powered and methodologically sound trials—including his own attempt to replicate his previous work—have found otherwise. It has long been time to “close the books” on the matter, to borrow a phrase used by former NEJM editor Arnold “Bud” Relman in regard to a more infamous claim. Spiegel doesn’t even need this particular ruse anymore, because he seems to have learned how to milk the udders of fringe and pop-psychiatry, cancer desperation, and “CAM“ quite satisfactorily without it.
The Journal Leaves the Back Door Ajar; “CAM” Slithers In
But back to the New England Journal of Medicine: occasional missteps aside, it has been largely resistant to the “CAM”-wormholes that have recently appeared in the editorial white matter of so many other medical journals. Thus a couple of weeks ago it was particularly disheartening to read, on its pages:
This comprehensive and practical book describes the experiences of the pioneers who established integrative oncology programs at five of the leading National Cancer Institute Comprehensive Cancer Centers in the United States: the University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center in Houston, the Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center in New York, the Dana–Farber Cancer Institute in Boston, the Sidney Kimmel Comprehensive Cancer Center at Johns Hopkins in Baltimore, and the Mayo Clinic Cancer Center in Rochester, Minnesota. It discusses the challenges of providing therapies that “exist at the interface of science and healing” at institutions with reputations for “providing world class conventional, evidence-based medicine.” The book also includes strategies for meeting these challenges, leaving readers with a feeling of confidence that they now have some of the basic tools for establishing a program at their own medical centers.
That opening paragraph to the first cited review employs much of the misleading language that you, dear readers, are now well-equipped to recognize and translate. There is sloganeering, question-begging, baiting and switching, and more: “Pioneers”? “The interface of science and healing”? (healing?) “The challenges of providing therapies [at places that ought to know better]“? (therapies?) Nowhere in the subsequent text is there an answer to the implicit question that a rational person would ask, having read that paragraph: why would anyone want to “establish such a program?” Instead there is more question-begging, data-begging, and outright avoidance of pertinent issues:
Many patients with cancer want to improve their chances for successful outcomes and decrease the chances of treatment-related side effects by incorporating complementary therapeutic approaches into their overall treatment plans.
Integrative oncology is not about the use of specific unconventional approaches to treatment; it is about an overall approach to treatment of the whole patient.
How does one go about credentialing acupuncturists at a major academic cancer center?
What is the best approach for educating medical staff about the potential benefits of various complementary interventions?
Is Reiki within the scope of practice of registered nurses in your state?
The Dana–Farber team has contributed a particularly helpful chapter that includes valuable tables as well as copies of policies, procedures, and competency evaluation forms, a template for an acupuncture referral letter, and an outline of how acupuncturists document their interventions in electronic medical records.
The chapter contributed by the team from Johns Hopkins includes practical tables on indications and contraindications for acupuncture and massage for the oncology patient, clearly outlining who may benefit and how best to administer these treatments safely.
These leaders in the field all recognize that the way to ensure that these methods become fully integrated into cancer care is to provide the data that will allow even the most conventional oncologists to appreciate their value.
This book is an invaluable resource for all involved in the care of patients with cancer. Those interested in developing an integrative oncology program, or any integrative medicine services, at their institutions will find the book especially useful.
It may well inspire others to follow the lead of these courageous pioneer clinician–scientists in their attempts to maximize healing for people living with and beyond cancer.
“Courageous,” indeed. The first paragraph of the second book review is slightly more promising:
Whether acupuncture from China, Ayurvedic therapies from India, or homeopathy in Europe, in her scholarly book, Roberta Bivins presents the belief systems that gave rise to such ancient practices and then follows their subsequent problematic global voyages to other cultures. Neither an allopathic doctor nor an alternative practitioner, Bivins provides readers with a social examination of these “exotic” techniques, from moxabustion to mesmerism, and explains how each was introduced (and then studied, simulated, ridiculed, or rejected) by Western physicians in Europe and the United States. The nearly four-century transcontinental propagation was not always easy — especially when corresponding belief systems could not be transported along with the therapeutic techniques.
Other than the misnomer “allopathic” and the question-begging “therapeutic,” that paragraph might refer to a perfectly reasonable treatise on pre-scientific and non-scientific health claims. Upon reading it and noticing the question mark after “Alternative Medicine” in the title, I allowed myself a glimmer of hope that the book and its review might rise to the Journal‘s usual, scholarly standards. I shouldn’t have bothered:
The translation of these principles and techniques from East to West paralleled the interaction of the cultures themselves, with all the inherent stereotyping, superstitions, and feelings of racial and cultural superiority. Ultimately, despite British imperialism or the medical profession’s turf wars, it was often the realities of — and the lack of therapies for — epidemics of cholera and the plague, or ailments such as gout, that encouraged quick investigation and resulted in rejection or eventual co-optation of the unfamiliar treatments. Of note, the authorities investigating and discounting alternative therapies were also often “borrowing” the practices for reintroduction as their own. One example was moxabustion, a therapy that uses heat and was apparently effective in the treatment of gout.
During the 18th and 19th centuries, the Western medical establishment was looking with a critical eye at the use of Chinese herbs and the practice of homeopathy while practicing what it knew as the best standards of care — cupping and bleeding. Some ancient practices were later “discovered” in the West. Centuries before Edward Jenner determined that mild cowpox exposure conferred immunity to smallpox, Asians practiced variolation — the controlled exposure to a carefully selected mild case of smallpox in one person to produce immunity in another. This same practice is followed today by some parents, who bring their unimmunized children to chicken pox or measles parties.
Early remedies paved the way for later advances. Acupuncture was not readily adopted by Western doctors, but Bivins speculates that acupuncture helped to familiarize them with needles, domesticating needles for later use in vaccines, drug delivery, and the drawing of blood. There are important lessons in this book for practicing physicians. For example, techniques such as homeopathy may have become popular not because of consistent efficacy but because the patients appreciated attentive clinicians and were attracted to the treatment’s benign nature and affordability.
The Western physician, past and present, is made out to be mostly predatory and misguided. Bivins questions why researchers continue to assess treatments from other cultures in a Western framework. Admittedly, we do not have the technology to measure qi or to visualize prana (which of course does not disprove their existence), but we do have the tools to objectively evaluate clinical interventions. With 60% of U.S. medical schools now offering some instruction in alternative medicine, and the commitment to research being made by the National Institutes of Health’s National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, there is an effort under way to evaluate practices that may hold promise and bring them into our evidence-based world.
Bivins’s book is a work of scholarship filled with thoughtful discussion, but it is largely devoid of colorful or memorable characters, a clear timeline or plot, or clinical discussions — all of which would have made the book more appealing. Bivins does ask one provocative question, illustrated in part by the use of a question mark in the book’s title: Why do we continue to use the word “alternative” when the popularity and complementary integration of some of these therapies, especially for the treatment of chronic conditions, continues to increase? There are now more patient visits to alternative medical practitioners than to primary care physicians in the United States.
In the end, this book is about Western attitudes toward the non-Western world. It is a macroscopic analysis rich with philosophical reflection and historical observation that exposes the difficulty of exporting such therapies outside their original cultures and belief structures.
Wow.
I groan (again) as I ponder the task of trying to make sense of those words, but that is the commitment I have made to you, dear readers. We seem to be told that British Imperialism notwithstanding, “Principles and Techniques from [the] East” were found by Westerners to be effective therapies for cholera and the plague. Hmmm; I hadn’t heard that before. Next, we seem expected to share a sense of enlightened irony that during the 18th and 19th centuries two pre-scientific practices, Chinese herbal medicine and homeopathy, competed with two other pre-scientific practices, cupping and bleeding. I don’t know about you, but that strikes me as a mundane historical finding. I’m as amused as the next guy when I see an advertisement warning against “fake psychics,” but I’m smart enough to know that it doesn’t follow that there are real ones. 
I’m also educated enough to know that variolation is not the same as vaccination and that even if it were, or even if vaccination had been discovered in Asia, so what? The issue here is not the plausible; it’s the implausible, such as the notion that acupuncture “domesticat[ed] (!) needles for later use…” or that in the absence of homeopathy and other treatments that lack “consistent efficacy,” it would likely never occur to today’s physicians that people prefer their doctors to be attentive and their health care to be safe and inexpensive.
In a rare, succinct passage, the next paragraph reveals the real agenda of the book:
The Western physician, past and present, is made out to be mostly predatory and misguided.
Why didn’t the reviewer tell us that in the first place? For readers who may be new to SBM, don’t get me wrong: Some Western physicians undoubtedly are “predatory and misguided,” but this book ain’t complaining about them. Rejecting implausible health claims is not a sign of being predatory and misguided. Quite the contrary: promoting such claims is pathognomonic of those traits. And what does reviewer Teresa Schraeder, a physician, think of the book’s agenda? We can’t tell in this paragraph because the rest of it is unrelated, but later she gives us strong hints.
Now: “Bivins questions why researchers continue to assess treatments from other cultures in a Western framework.” So much for Ms. Bivins’ understanding of science, but what of Dr. Schraeder’s?
Admittedly, we do not have the technology to measure qi or to visualize prana (which of course does not disprove their existence)… 
Oh my. Dr. Schraeder is the Graduate Medical Education Editor of the NEJM. The gaffs in that phrase make her subsequent, inflated estimate of “tools to objectively evaluate [highly implausible] clinical interventions” and her naive endorsements of the NCCAM and of “instruction in alternative medicine” offered in medical schools seem almost, well, commonplace. Was it possible that she would redeem herself when she wrote…
Bivins’s book is a work of scholarship filled with thoughtful discussion, but…” ?
But what? But it lacks a pertinent discussion of science and modern medicine? But it suffers from misapplied cultural relativism? C’mon Terry, you’re this close!
…but it is largely devoid of colorful or memorable characters, a clear timeline or plot, or clinical discussions…
Oops (sigh). The book is undoubtedly filled with fictitious statements, but am I alone in having assumed, prior to reading that sentence, that it is not a work of fiction in the formal sense? We do get to find out why the question mark appears after “Alternative Medicine” in the book’s title, but by now it’s anticlimactic: rather than calling attention to the misnomer, its purpose is to suggest that “alternative” is no longer needed because
the popularity and complementary integration of some of these therapies, especially for the treatment of chronic conditions, continues to increase[.] There are now more patient visits to alternative medical practitioners than to primary care physicians in the United States.
If there remains any doubt that reviewer Schraeder agrees with author Bivins that it is popularity but not rational evaluation that determines the validity of “alternative” claims, the final quoted statement appears to put it to rest:
In the end, this book is about Western attitudes toward the non-Western world. It is a macroscopic analysis rich with philosophical reflection and historical observation that exposes the difficulty of exporting such therapies outside their original cultures and belief structures.
And there you have it. “In the end,” it isn’t about science or rational evaluations or astrologic/militaristic/demonologic/meteorologic or “constitutional” metaphors, or the occult or sympathetic magic or psi or any other magical thinking, or conjuring or ideomotor action or demand characteristics or cognitive dissonance or any of that other “Western” BS. It’s all about The Man watching his own back. Sheeit, I knew that in college.
Let history record that versus the New England Journal of Medicine on July 31, 2008, it was Game, Set and Match to Pseudomedicine.
Please, Dr. Schwartz, Say it Ain’t So!
I wish I could be consoled by the knowledge that these book reviews are, well, just book reviews. They’re kind of at the back of the journal, and a lotta people don’t bother to read them. There are precedents in other journals for whacky stuff finding its way into the book review section, stuff that would never (but I’m not so sure anymore) make it to the editorials or the original papers. JAMA published a book review a few years ago that openly asserted that psychokinesis ought to be useful in clinical medicine (the reviewer called it “the scientific evidence of the effects of nonlocal mind”). I still can’t believe that the big guns on the editorial staff were aware of it, but maybe I’m the naive one now.
Still, the NEJM should be different. The book review editor is Robert Schwartz, who knows better. He wrote an editorial a couple of years ago decrying the teaching of “intelligent design” as “pseudoscience by mandate,” and worrying that it might make its way into medical schools:
Indeed, first and foremost, intelligent design should concern physicians because the debate influences education at all levels. Now that Bill Frist, the Senate majority leader and a graduate of Harvard Medical School, has come out in favor of the teaching of intelligent design, medical students may soon be learning that only a hidden hand could be responsible for the complexities of oxidative metabolism in mitochondria. (An intelligent student might ask why the designer made mitochondria in the first place.) Moreover, the confusion between faith and science at the highest levels of public education can hardly be an asset to the pool of applicants to medical schools and graduate schools in the sciences.
What would it mean to take intelligent design seriously at the medical school level? Its proponents tell us that gaps in our knowledge of how living organisms evolved vitiate the theory of evolution. Might we conclude, then, that the cancer cell and its evolution are so complex that a creative designer must be the cause of cancer? But if the designer created cancer, is it against the hidden hand’s will to find a cure for cancer? Is it in accord with the plan of the intelligent designer to receive a treatment for cancer? After all, a Jehovah’s Witness would rather die than receive a blood transfusion. Yet today more than ever, the profession needs physicians who can channel scientific discoveries to the sick. What effect will pseudoscience-by-fiat have on medical progress?
If we accept the premise that it is not in the long-term interest of medicine to disguise a faith-based belief as a scientific discipline and indoctrinate future physicians and scientists in a creed that thwarts the science of medicine, what can physicians do now? It seems to me that leaders of professional societies and prominent academicians should start speaking up…Engaging in a public debate about intelligent design is probably not a good idea; any debate about faith and belief will surely end inconclusively. More desirable are education and acting to protect the profession and the public from pseudoscience.
I wrote the NEJM a short letter after that piece, making the point that although I agreed with everything Dr. Schwartz had written, pseudoscience has already insinuated itself into medical schools and other medical institutions to a far greater extent than most people realize, in the form of “CAM.” (Note to Dr. Schwartz, if you happen to read this: in case you had any doubts then, please read the reviews under review here). I must admit that I was surprised when my letter was refused for publication. I had figured that it would be a slam-dunk after an article such as Schwartz’s, but as far as I know there were no published letters pertaining to his article at all.
Kinda makes you think, as Bob Dylan might say. Later I met Dr. Schwartz rather by accident, and after each of us had figured out who the other was we had some good laughs about the intellectual matter. I’m afraid you’ll have to accept that it wasn’t the proper setting to raise questions about in-house politics, but as far as science and pseudoscience are concerned, he gets it. I can only imagine that he was away, or too busy to read them himself, or whatever, when the two reviews discussed here slipped through.
Should a Reviewer Disclose that He’s Palsy-Walsy with the Book’s Author? Or, a Preview of Next Week
You might have guessed that I have not read either of the books that are the subjects of the cited reviews; this post is about the reviews, not about the books. Nevertheless, the astute reader might reasonably wonder whether Donald Abrams, the reviewer of the “integrative oncology” book, can be forgiven for some of his presumptions as long as the book itself supports them. Thus there is a need for us to learn something about “the data that will allow even the most conventional oncologists to appreciate their value.” Fortunately, there are ways to do this that don’t involve shelling out $80 or, in my case, making a cumbersome and parkless trip to the venerable Countway Library of Medicine. The table of contents, the names of the contributing authors, and the introduction are available on Amazon.com. The review itself provides another clue:
…the contributors to this book are all deeply involved and committed to educating their colleagues about the advances in the field; three of them have served as presidents of the Society for Integrative Oncology.
If you go to that Society’s website, you’ll indeed find that Lorenzo Cohen, one of the book’s editors, is the Society’s president. You’ll also find there, but not in the NEJM, that Donald Abrams, the book’s reviewer, is the Society’s Secretary/Treasurer. Is it possible that they know each other? 
And finally:
Ode to the New England Journal of Medicine: a Reader’s Lament
Hark, O Journal of New England!
From whose Warrens you raised our Holmes
Even before we were Bud’s!
Of late thou seemest to be wandering;
Where is thy Guardian Angell now?
If only we Kassirer!
If not, may the Schwartz be with you!

   NEJM and Acupuncture: Even the best can publish nonsense.
Mark Crislip
Link
I realize that the New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) review of acupuncture has already been covered by Drs. Gorski and Novella. But my ego knows no bounds; so I thought I would add my two cents, especially since this review, more than any paper I have read, generates a deep sense on betrayal.
There was a time when I believed my betters. Then the Annals of Internal Medicine had their absolutely ghastly series on SCAMS, the publication of which was partly responsible for interest in the topic. Since that series of articles, I have doubt whenever I read an Annals article. When a previously respected journal panders completely to woo, they lose all respectability. Sure, the editors that were responsible for that travesty are long gone, but the taint remains. I tell my kids that once a trust has been violated, it is difficult to get it back. The Annals has permanently lost my trust, I am afraid.
But we will always have Paris. I mean the NEJM. The NEJM is the premier medical journal. Just because an article is published in the NEJM doesn’t mean it’s right; the results of clinical trials are always being superseded by new information. But the article has supposedly been rigorously peer reviewed. Its like Harvard and… Oops, Bad example. Harvard, as we have seen, has feet of clay, and so, evidently, does the The New England Journal of Medicine.
Goodness, gracious, great balls of fire, the editors of the NEJM have fallen into the depths of nonsense with this one.
Let’s go through it, shall we.
First up, the authors:
Brian M. Berman, M.D., Helene H. Langevin, M.D., Claudia M. Witt, M.D., M.B.A., and Ronald Dubner, D.D.S., Ph.D.
From the Center for Integrative Medicine, University of Maryland School of Medicine (B.M.B.), and the University of Maryland Dental School (R.D.) — both in Baltimore; the Department of Neurology and the Program in Integrative Health, University of Vermont College of Medicine, Burlington (H.H.L.); and the Institute for Social Medicine, Epidemiology, and Health Economics, Charité University Medical Center, Berlin (C.M.W.).
You always want acknowledged experts in a field to write your review. If you want a review of Lyme disease, you ask a Lyme expert (The Connecticut Attorney General not withstanding), and if you want a review of heart attacks, you ask a cardiologist.
So in that spirit, if you want a review of prescientific magic, you want someone well-versed in the practice of prescientific magic. Fortunately, these authors seem well qualified. Dr. Berman founded the Center for Integrative Medicine at University of Maryland and has a long history of research into acupuncture. The center has on its staff a reflexologist/reiki master. Really. And the center offers:
Physician Consultations, Acupuncture, Nutrition, Massage, Homeopathy, Mindfulness-based Stress Reduction, Shiatsu, Reflexology, Yoga, Qi Gong, Tai Chi, Osteopathic Manipulation.
The University of Maryland proudly offer both acupuncture and reiki to their trauma patients.
Reiki is a Japanese technique of relaxation that works similarly to acupuncture, in that you are releasing and moving energy,” explains Donna Audia, R.N., a nurse on Shock Trauma’s pain management team and a certified Reiki master. “By using Reiki with trauma patients, we are not only helping them to relax, we’re also making them active participants in their own healing, and that can be very empowering.
Reaction from trauma patients has been positive, with most requesting follow-up treatments. In fact, many family members ask to be a part of the Reiki session. A group of volunteers trained in Reiki now visits Shock Trauma regularly. The University of Maryland Medical Center is the only facility in the country offering Reiki to trauma patients, although it has also been used to treat people with cancer and other illnesses.
Seriously. Your body has been shattered in a car accident and your health care providers think they can improve your condition by moving and releasing your energy by waving their hands over you.
If, god forbid, you have trauma in Maryland, get transferred. Fast.
Dr. Berman has published extensively on acupuncture and Dr. Witt has published multiple articles on homeopathy, including one using homeopathy for low back pain.
So two of the authors are well grounded in magical thinking: who better to write a NEJM review on acupuncture? They found a Dumbledore, a Gandalf, to write the article, which explains the content as the editors of the NEJM were evidently hit with the confundus charm. As I think about it, that is not the best metaphor, since in the fantasy world, magic is real, but in the real world, magic is fantasy, as well as a review article in the NEJM.
The authors start with a case of chronic low back pain with mild degenerative disease but no anatomical or physiologic reason for the pain. The vignette ends with:
The patient wonders whether acupuncture would be beneficial and asks for a referral to a licensed acupuncturist.
Nope. Simple enough. Acupuncture is nonsense. Oh wait. There’s more.
They review the epidemiology, physiology and anatomy of chronic low back pain and note that the understanding of the disease is a long way from satisfactory and conclude with:
In addition, psychological and behavioral factors, including fear of movement, appear to play an important role in patients with chronic low back pain. Such patients have been shown to have altered brain-activation patterns at subcortical and cortical sites associated with emotion and postural control. Studies comparing psychosocial variables with anatomical findings have shown the former to have greater predictive value than the latter.
In other words, with low back pain there is a big psychological overlay. It is the psychological overlay of pain that makes it difficult to determine the effectiveness of a therapy meant to decrease the pain. When treating a condition in medicine, most interventions attempt to alter the underlying pathophysiology: block a receptor with a drug, alter anatomy with a procedure as examples. If the intervention has no effect on the underlying pathophysiology, then there is little reason to expect benefit beyond a placebo effect, which is almost no effect.
Then they jump into acupuncture.
Acupuncture is a therapeutic intervention…
It is an intervention, yes, but therapeutic? Therapeutic means relating to healing of disease. So they are front loading the language, saying at the beginning that acupuncture is effective rather than proving the case. I would have used ‘useless magical’ instead of ‘therapeutic,’ but that’s me.
Although a number of different techniques or schools of acupuncture practice have arisen, the approach used in traditional Chinese medicine appears to be the most widely practiced in the United States.
Why? Is Chinese acupuncture better? Or is popularity the criteria we use for determining appropriate medical care? There is Chinese and Japanese and tongue and foot and ear and the German head acupuncture. Is there any justification offered for using one over the other? Which is the correct style? As I have said before, it is a trick question, like asking which is the real astrology: European, Indian or Mayan. It makes no difference.
Then they delve into real nonsense.
Traditional Chinese medicine espouses an ancient physiological system (not based on Western scientific empiricism) in which health is seen as the result of harmony among bodily functions and between body and nature. Internal disharmony is believed to cause blockage of the body’s vital energy, known as qi, which flows along 12 primary and 8 secondary meridians. Blockage of qi is thought to be manifested as tenderness on palpation. The insertion of acupuncture needles at specific points along the meridians is supposed to restore the proper flow of qi.
I hate to point out that the physiologic system I use, based on so-called “Western scientific empiricism,” is also based on anatomy, chemistry, biochemistry, histology etc. All based on physical structures that can be isolated and examined.
Meridians and qi blockage is based on what? Nothing. Meridians and qi do not exist. Here is the NEJM offering up, complete with a picture, the idea of meridians and qi as if they are a meaningful construct. Next up in the NEJM will be:
Traditional European medicine espouses an ancient physiological system (not based on Western scientific empiricism) in which health is seen as the result of harmony among bodily functions and between body and nature. Internal disharmony is believed to cause blockage of the body’s vital energy, known as humors: black bile, yellow bile, phlegm, and blood which flows in the body. Blockage of humors is thought to be manifested as illness. Bleeding and purging is supposed to restore the proper flow of balance of humors.
If anyone sees a conceptual difference between the two paragraphs, let the editors of the NEJM know after they accept my review on therapeutic bleeding. Being published in the NEJM is the medical equivalent of being on the cover of the Rolling Stone, and I think I have my opportunity.
Efforts have been made to characterize the effects of acupuncture in terms of the established principles of medical physiology on which Western medicine is based.
Why? Isn’t an ancient physiological system enough upon which to base a therapeutic intervention?
These efforts remain inconclusive, for several reasons. First, the majority of studies have been conducted in animals, and it is difficult to relate findings from such studies to effects in humans. Second, acupuncture has been shown to activate peripheral-nerve fibers of all sizes, rendering a systematic study of responses complex. Third, the acupuncture experience is dominated by a strong psychosocial context, including expectations, beliefs, and the therapeutic milieu.
And fourth, having no basis in reality, acupuncture can’t work any more than homeopathy or reiki. It is tooth fairy science, published in the NEJM.
Then they delve into the physiology of acupuncture and the basic science studies. Fine. You stick people with needles, you will get a variety of physiologic responses, both locally and in the brain. The question is whether these effects are specific to acupuncture or nonspecific results of poking people with a sharp object. Like all acupuncture apologists, they lack a certain precision in what they consider acupuncture, and offer electroacupuncture as evidence.
In the rat, electroacupuncture has been shown to induce pituitary secretion of adrenocorticotropic hormone and cortisol, leading to systemic antiinflammatory effects.
Ah yes, electroacupuncture. I remember when they discovered those ancient Chinese Duracell’s and alligator clips that allowed the Chinese to shock their patients.
I quote from the electroacupuncture article, referenced above:
While the EA frequency was held constant, intensity was adjusted slowly over the period of approximately 2 min to the designated level of 3 mA, which is the maximum EA current intensity that a conscious animal can tolerate. Mild muscle twitching was observed… For sham treatment control, acupuncture needles were inserted bilaterally into GB30 without electrical stimulation or manual needle manipulation.
And when shocked, the rabbits released ACTH and cortisol, as any animal would if electrocuted. Release of ACTH and cortisol is part of the response to stress. I can just see the poor rat, “placed under an inverted clear plastic chamber” for observation saying,” don’t tase me bro, don’t tase me bro.” Wait. It’s not a taser. It’s a projectile electroacupuncture remote deliver system, and if I use it on you, you are going to release some cortisol and ACTH as well, bro.
Did the NEJM editors look at the references? They seriously need some new reviewers.
But I will grant them that sticking needles in people has physiologic effects and shocking a rat makes it squirt cortisol.
However, acupuncture is about putting needles in specific sites. In the animal models and human studies they attempt to needle specific sites that correlate with treating a disease. Most acupuncture studies use the traditional sites associated with whatever illness they are not really treating; acupuncture is about putting the needle just so.
The basic science concerns, as I read it, the effects of needling people. If you are going to recommend acupuncture, and they will, then you need to justify the use of needles in specific sites by people trained in acupuncture, and the literature doesn’t support that. It doesn’t matter where you put the needles, or even if you use needles at all, as we have mentioned, since twirling a toothpick has better effects on knee pain than needling. And I will ask again: whose style of acupuncture are you going to use? Ear, tongue, foot, Japanese or German or Chinese?
Then they move on to the clinical trials and my gaster is flabbered.
… real acupuncture treatments were no more effective than sham acupuncture treatments. There was nevertheless evidence that both real acupuncture and sham acupuncture were more effective than no treatment and that acupuncture can be a useful supplement to other forms of conventional therapy for low back pain.
Lets take a trip back in time.
There was procedure for the treatment of angina where they ligated the internal mammary artery. The theory was that by tying off the artery the back-pressure forced blood down the coronary arteries and relieved cardiac pain.
Angina improved and there are about 40 plus papers in the 50s and 60s on the benefit of the procedure as well as the underlying physiology of the procedure. Mammary artery ligation ‘worked’ and was popular in the early 60s. Until the procedure was compared to a sham operation. That’s right. They opened people up and did nothing.
The result?
The combined results of two RCTs comparing an earlier surgical procedure for angina — bilateral internal mammary artery ligation (BIMAL) — to a sham surgery clearly show that patients “experienced significant subjective improvement,” with both BIMAL (67% substantial improvement) and the sham procedure (82% substantial improvement). [see Moerman, Meaning, Medicine and the “Placebo Effect”, 2002]
So how would you interpret the study? If a procedure is equal sham, then I would say the procedure does not work. In the case of sham surgery, no underlying change occurred in the blood supply to the ischemic heart. This study is perhaps the classic clinical trial that demonstrates the difficulty in assessing the results of an intervention for pain. Patients had significant improvement in their angina. Much better than doing nothing (although these studies did not have a ‘usual care’ wing), 2/3 of angina patients do not get significant improvement on their own.
And guess what? Open heart surgery “has been shown to induce pituitary secretion of adrenocorticotropic hormone and cortisol, leading to systemic antiinflammatory effects.” Surgery releases endogenous opioids and I bet it actives both peripheral and central pain fibers.
Hmmmm. Looks like we have a justification for going back to treating angina with internal mammary artery ligation.
The authors of the review justify the recommendation on the two studies that demonstrate the equivalence of sham acupuncture and real acupuncture in treating low back pain, the same number of studies for mammary artery ligation.
Now being an article on back pain, they did not include the article that showed knee pain treated with sham acupuncture (in this case twirling tooth picks on the skin) is superior to real acupuncture. It matters not where the needles are placed or even if needles are used.
So far the authors provide no historical scientific plausibility, non-specific modern pathophysiology, a bit of gratuitous rabbit torture, and two clinical trials that demonstrate no efficacy of acupuncture over placebo. Their level of justification reaches that of mammary artery ligation. I start to wonder if the NEJM editors actually read the review before publishing it. The authors then move on to clinical use.
(Acupuncture) not been established to be superior to sham acupuncture for the relief of symptoms of low back pain [translation: it doesn’t work]. As a result, it is not often regarded as the first choice of therapy [translation: clinicians do not like to use ineffective therapy].
However, since extensive clinical trials [er, since when did two become extensive? Are the authors even reading the manuscript?] have suggested that acupuncture may be more effective than usual care, it is not unreasonable to consider acupuncture before [you mean as first line therapy? when it doesn’t work?] or together with conventional treatments, such as physical therapy, pain medication, and exercise [adding nothing to something does not increase the net effect].
That is some interesting sentence structure, worthy of Animal Farm: even though acupuncture doesn’t work, and isn’t first line therapy for pain, it should be used for first line therapy. Although the qualifiers ‘not been established,’ ‘suggested’, ‘may be,’ and ‘not unreasonable’ muddy the water with their density.
Acupuncture is a regulated discipline, and patients should be referred only to practitioners who are licensed by the state in which they practice.
Why? It’s like Duck’s Breath Mystery Theatre’s Dr. Science. A license to practice ineffective nonsense still results in ineffective nonsense.
In the traditional practice of acupuncture, needle insertion itself may be accompanied by a variety of ancillary procedures, including palpation of the radial artery and other areas of the body, examination of the tongue, and recommendation of herbal medications. All of these steps are based on the application of principles of traditional Chinese medicine, as opposed to Western physiological and medical concepts. To what extent such procedures may contribute to the psychological milieu of acupuncture is unknown, and only a few studies have examined the context in which acupuncture treatment is delivered.
Note, it is not that radial artery palpation and tongue examination increase the diagnostic accuracy, it is to contribute to the psychological milieu. Like a psychic talking to your dead parent, it is important to make the environment conducive to fooling the patient into believing that an actual effect is occurring.
Take the pulse. In TCM they are not looking for tachycardia, but imaginary diseases based on imaginary diagnosis. An example:
Each pulse position can reflect different phenomena in different situations. For example, in a state of health, the left middle pulse (Liver) will be relatively soft and smooth, neither superficial nor deep. Therefore, we can say the liver and gall bladder energies are balanced or that the Yin and Yang within the Liver/Gall Bladder sphere are balanced. If a patient is experiencing migraine headaches and her pulse feels wiry (harder or tighter than normal) and more superficial and pounding, then we may diagnose this as Excessive Liver Fire (Yang) Rising (up the Gall Bladder channel to the head). The pulse reflects the rising energy.”
Or tongue examination, which is another example of prescientific nonsense where the body is represented on the tongue.
The editors of the NEJM seem to think this is reasonable, worthy of unqualified discussion. Of course, there is no reference to demonstrate that these additions increase diagnostic or therapeutic accuracy.
The practitioner may further stimulate the needle with electrical current (electroacupuncture), moxibustion (burning the herb artemisia vulgaris at the end of the acupuncture needle), or heat.
Why? No data given that this nonsense increases efficacy. I keep telling myself this is the NEJM, adding their imprimatur to the respectability of burning a plant on top a needle stuck in the skin to ease chronic pain. Then they note that patients need multiple treatments, a minimum of 12, with boosters, and they need to come in to prophylactically keep their spine aligned — no wait, the last is what chiropractors do. It seems, at 65 to 125 dollars a pop, that acupuncturists have recognized the financial wisdom of D.D. Palmer’s descendants. The NEJM is suggesting that people pay around 1200 bucks for what is, at best, a placebo.
The authors go on to the adverse effects. “8.6% reported at least one adverse event, and 2.2% reported one that required treatment.” Pretty impressive complication rate for an expensive, ineffective therapy! They do not mention that in the acupuncture/toothpick for knee pain study, toothpicks had the same effect as acupuncture and zero side effects, nor do they mention the well-reported cases of infection from sloppy aseptic technique.
I will ask you. If you have two procedures of equal efficacy and one has zero side effects, are you not ethically bound to suggest the procedure with no complications? If you are going to suggest acupuncture, ethically you have to offer sham acupuncture with twirled toothpicks, especially when what you offer is no better than a placebo effect.
Then, in the areas of uncertainty section of the review, they note that the effects of acupuncture are mostly explained by elaborate placebo effects. Benefit from acupuncture is
mostly attributable to contextual and psychosocial factors, such as patients’ beliefs and expectations, attention from the acupuncturist, and highly focused, spatially directed attention on the part of the patient. These studies also seem to indicate that needles do not need to stimulate the traditionally identified acupuncture points or actually penetrate the skin to produce the anticipated effect.
It does nothing, and you do not need to do acupuncture to get the effect. Acupuncture has complications and ethically can one recommend and charge for an elaborate placebo? I do not think so. Not the authors.
The patient in the vignette has chronic back pain that has not responded to a number of medical treatments.
So instead, we will go with the unethical, expensive, useless placebo.
He has specifically requested a referral for acupuncture, and we would suggest a course of 10 to 12 treatments over a period of 8 weeks from a licensed acupuncturist or a physician trained in medical acupuncture.
Can you believe this? From the NEJM! Such total tripe. I rely on the NEJM to provide reviews of relevant medical topics as, outside of ID and quackery, I do not have the time to read the primary literature. If this is the best NEJM can do on a topic upon which I have some background, then I suppose I cannot trust them in the future. As I tell my kids, you can judge a person by the company they keep.
The NEJM has lost some of its credibility. I doubt they will ever get it back.

Misinformation Doctors Start a Misinformation Journal to Spread Misinformation
There is no doubt the “studies” in this journal will conclude We Want Them Infected doctors were right about everything the whole time; mitigation measure were an epic catastrophe while COVID was a harmless cold for everyone but grandma.
Jonathan Howard on February 21, 2025
Link
Most of us don’t create a fake journal to cope with that.
Several doctors I’ve discussed previously, including Martin Kulldorff, Andrew Noymer, Jay Bhattacharya, Marty Makary, John Ioannidis, Scott Atlas, and Sunetra Gupta, recently started a new journal titled the Journal of the Academy of Public Health. Predictably, this line-up of unapologetic misinformation superspreaders, none of whom treated COVID patients, raised some eyebrows. According to the article New Journal Co-Founded by NIH Nominee Raises Eyebrows, Misinformation Fears:
It lacks a subscription paywall, posts peer reviews alongside published articles, and pays reviewers for their work. But other researchers have criticized the journal’s exclusivity and lack of quality control. Only members of a newly formed body, the Academy of Public Health, can submit articles, and all submitted articles are published. Skeptics worry the publication will be used to sow doubt about scientific consensus on matters such as vaccine efficacy and safety.
An article by Walker Bragman about these doctors’ financial backers titled A New Academic Publishing Model”: Right-Wing Dark Money Group Launches Fringe Medical Journal quoted Dr. Mallory Harris as saying:
As far as I can tell, many of the people involved with this project are close ideological allies operating far outside of the scientific community. They complain about censorship and gatekeeping but it is also the case that it is sometimes hard to publish shoddy work based on bad ideas. Most of us don’t create a fake journal to cope with that.
There is no doubt the “studies” in this journal will conclude that We Want Them Infected doctors were right about everything always; mitigation measure were an epic catastrophe while COVID was a harmless cold for everyone but grandma. No article there will conclude that they were wrong that the mass infection of unvaccinated people under age 60-70 would lead to herd immunity.
The vaccine is incredibly effective… And in many ways has defanged the epidemic, it’s taken away the the specter of death and hospitalization that comes with the disease for the older population to the extent that the older population is vaccinated.
Before we examine one of their articles, let’s review the data from the original mRNA vaccine trials, where severe COVID was a secondary outcome.
    • Moderna: “Severe Covid-19 occurred in 30 participants, with one fatality; all 30 were in the placebo group.”
    • Pfizer: “Among 10 cases of severe Covid-19 with onset after the first dose, 9 occurred in placebo recipients and 1 in a BNT162b2 recipient.”
Dr. Bhattacharya was rightfully impressed with these results in 2021. However he also promised the vaccines blocked transmission, totally eliminated severe disease, and had “defanged” the pandemic. In April 2021, he and Dr. Zubin Damania had the following exchange:
Dr. Bhattacharya: I mean, I think that the central problem right now I think is the fear that people still feel about COVID…
Dr. Damania: Now, you and I are both vaccinated. We shook hands. We don’t wear masks. We’re about three feet apart from each other. And in the early days of the pandemic that would’ve gotten us both hung. But now I can say with confidence because I’ve looked at the data, like our chances of giving each other COVID are-
Dr. Bhattacharya: Are zero.
Dr. Damania: Pretty much zero…
Dr. Bhattacharya: The vaccine is incredibly effective… And in many ways has defanged the epidemic, it’s taken away the the specter of death and hospitalization that comes with the disease for the older population to the extent that the older population is vaccinated…
Dr. Damania: Yeah, so why do we keep hearing that about like these new variants affecting young people more or concerns about mortality in, in the new case surges in a way that it is younger people. Maybe why are we still hearing about this when I have not seen good evidence that variants are more deadly or, you know, so on?
Dr. Bhattacharya: Yeah. I mean, I think it’s partly the fear, right? I think that it’s hard to let go of that. You’ve lived your, for a full year under it. It’s hard to let go. I’d say it’s, I mean in some ways you can understand it, right? It’s like we’ve been conditioned to be careful. And when the, when the danger is gone, we’re still careful.
Dr. Damania: Do you think the danger is gone? Where are we in that?
Dr. Bhattacharya: I mean, I think we’re close. I think we’re very, very close to that. I think that it, I mean, and in many places, it is gone, just be paid at a high cost of course, but it’s, but it’s very close to that.
Full video here
Dr. Bhattacharya continued to over-hype vaccines and underestimate the virus in August 2021, telling Florida Governor Ron DeSantis “We have protected the vulnerable by vaccinating the older population“, right before the Delta wave ripped through the state causing record deaths including many young people. Dr. Bhattacharya was so confident about the vaccine’s ability to obviate severe disease, he launched his standard juvenile, unprofessional personal attacks against anyone who urged caution. In one interview, he said:
Dr. Fauci is probably the number one anti-vaxxer in the country in some sense, because he has modeled behavior that has made people think the vaccine won’t give you back your life, but it will. It’s an incredibly effective vaccine. You know, he was wearing a mask. He has been vaccinated, I don’t really understand what he’s trying to do here.
Key communicators told the public that the vaccine would prevent all Covid infections and transmission, perhaps even allowing the eradication of Covid disease from general circulation.
While the COVID vaccines remain the greatest scientific achievement of my lifetime, they weren’t the magic cure-all some people promised, and I was careful not to overhype them in spring 2021. I wanted to wait for more long-term data before spiking the football. One person who is now eager to lambast some people who oversold the vaccine is none other than Dr. Bhattacharya. His titled inaugural article in the Journal of the Academy of Public Health, written with Dr. Kulldorff, was titled The Covid Vaccine Trials: Failures in Design and Interpretation. They said:
For the Covid vaccines, the fundamental goal was not to prevent mild infections but to prevent deaths, hospitalizations, and transmission. Despite this, the randomized controlled trials evaluated short-term reduction in symptomatic Covid infections while failing to address important public health issues. This result was due to badly designed trials. Despite lacking key data, public health agencies made unsubstantiated vaccine claims, published unscientific vaccine recommendations, and imposed unethical vaccine mandates. As a result, vaccine hesitance has increased while the trust in public health has deteriorated…
When public health officials rolled out the vaccine campaign in December 2020 and January 2021, key communicators told the public that the vaccine would prevent all Covid infections and transmission, perhaps even allowing the eradication of Covid disease from general circulation. Officials made these claims even though the Covid vaccine trials did not include infection prevention or transmission-blocking as measured endpoints, and observational data were not yet available….
The consequence of the mismatch between what the randomized trials examined and what prominent public health officials said during the vaccine rollout is enormous… Misrepresentation of the vaccine data has led to an understandable distrust in public health authorities. When the public contrasted the waning efficacy of the vaccine, plainly visible to almost everybody who took the vaccine and then later became infected, against public statements by public health officials, public trust in public health about the Covid vaccine collapsed.
This distrust generalized to deteriorating trust in non-Covid vaccines. If public health was wrong about the Covid vaccine, maybe they are wrong about all vaccines, many members of the public may have reasoned. Estimates from CDC surveys demonstrate sharp declines in public confidence in basic childhood vaccines, such as the MMR vaccine, since the Covid vaccine rollout, leading to fears that there will be surges of these other infectious diseases that are preventable by vaccines that prevent disease transmission and infection
So let’s be clear what happened here. In the mRNA trials, 39 of the 40 severe cases occurred in the placebo group. While these were obviously amazing results, the vaccine and the virus were still brand new. Dr. Bhattacharya overhyped the vaccines, claiming they blocked transmission, obviated severe disease, and had “defanged” the pandemic. He mocked anyone who wisely took a more conservative approach.
Today, Dr. Bhattacharya, denies that the mRNA vaccines limit severe disease and wants them removed from the market. He excoriates others for his words, blaming them for vaccine-hesitancy and a loss of trust.
The one silver lining amongst these absurdities is that once Dr. Bhattacharya is confirmed to lead the NIH, he won’t be able to blame the “public health authorities” from the safety of his Stanford office. Moving forward, he’ll in charge, and if he feels we need new vaccine RCTs, it’s his job to do them. Meanwhile, from the safety of our offices, we all have the right to make endless demands of him, as he did with public health officials regarding COVID. If he fails to meet them all, we can blame and excoriate him, as he did with public health officials regarding COVID- “it was a failure of imagination on the part of public health“. He’s the medical establishment now, and he owns everything that’s going to happen.
Of course, it’s unlikely that Dr. Bhattacharya, working under RFK Jr., will perform the pristine vaccine RCTs he demanded of others. Instead, we are more likely to get more propaganda masquerading as science to further the MAGA/MAHA political agenda. Some of it will likely appear in the Journal of the Academy of Public Health, and everyone should recognize it for what it is.
    • 

Feet of Clay
Mark Crislip on March 31, 2012
Link
It has been tough in Portland this year. The Trailblazers, our NBA, and only professional team, started out on a tear, then went right down the toilet. It is painful to see such promise dribbled away. Sigh. Why is elation always followed by disappointment? Everyone and everything has feet of clay. Except Cassius Marcellus.
At the beginning of March the NEJM had a wonderful essay, What’s the Alternative? The Worldwide Web of Integrative Medicine by Ranjana Srivastava. The essay concerns a patient who is ‘diagnosed’ with cancer at an integrative medicine exhibition and the resultant diagnostic and therapeutic debacles that follow.
The quotes of note:
“At one time, the worst offense one encountered was someone prescribing a few herbs to a desperate patient who’d exhausted all other means of treatment. The usual thinking was, “At this stage, it can’t do any harm.” But insidiously and alarmingly, “alternative medicine” has crept from offering last-ditch treatments to making diagnoses. As the cancer armamentarium has expanded with targeted therapies, unscrupulous practitioners of alternative therapy have devised competing offers that sound at least as impressive to the average patient, who is often marginally health-literate and eager to embrace the promise of a cure without toxicity. But the radical, completely unregulated, and often dangerous options on offer can and do cause harm.
and
Alternative therapies need meet no burden of proof except a patient’s gullibility. One never hears of alternative therapies that failed: the patient merely waited too long to try them.
and
Physicians would be naive to ignore the elephant in the room. Integrative medicine comes in many forms — some useful, but many dangerous. It also comes at tremendous personal and societal cost. The initial expenditure may come from patients’ pockets, but often the health care system eventually inherits the problem. Although there’s probably no way of calculating the psychological cost, for many it is high and unending.
Well said. This editorial and patient story concerns cancer, not a relatively trivial problem, but the concepts are widely applicable to all manner of SCAMs. I am not a big fan of slippery slope arguments, but I am always concerned when useless or unproven therapies are recommended. I am also not a fan of ideological purity, a foolish consistency being the hobgoblin of little minds, adored by little statesmen and philosophers and science bloggers. The key word I suppose is foolish. There is nothing foolish about being serious in protecting your patients life, health, and, given the cost of care, wealth.
Fast forward a mere two weeks to Clinical Practice. Uncomplicated Urinary Tract Infection by Thomas M. Hooton. I suppose the editors of the NEJM were experiencing an F. Scott Fitzgerald moment when first they published
The phenomenon of questionable health practices is not limited to the developing world; my patient’s encounter occurred in a medically sophisticated city. Patients can even be duped at home, from the safety of their Internet connection.
only to be followed 14 days later with a review of the treatment of UTI where the editors were evidently paying no attention to the prior content of the Journal. I saw no disclaimer that the views of the Ranjana Srivastava were not those of the NEJM, so I assume the editors agreed. I know. Naive.
For in the table on prevention for UTI we find the following recommendations:
Cranberry juice, capsules or tablets
Biologic plausibility is based on the inhibition of uropathogen adherence to uroepithelial cells; clinical data supporting a protective effect have been limited by design flaws; a recent randomized, placebo-controlled trial showed no benefit from cranberry juice.
Adhesion blockers (D-mannose, available in health-food stores and online, is occasionally used as preventive therapy)
UTIs caused by E. coli are initiated by adhesion of the bacteria to mannosylated receptors in the uroepithelium by means of FimH adhesin located on type 1 pili; theoretically, mannosides could block adhesion; however, D-mannose has not been evaluated in clinical trials.
and it is noted in the discussion (talking in part about mechanical solutions such as voiding after intercourse as well as Cranberry juice and D-mannose)
Although data supporting the effectiveness of these strategies are sparse or nonexistent, they carry a low risk of adverse effects and may be helpful.
and
…although data on the efficacy of these measures are mostly lacking, they pose little risk.
Why not suggest homeopathy, reiki, acupuncture, purging and bleeding? The same concepts apply. I know that there are ‘sarcasm marks’, but on occasion I need ‘voice dripping with contempt’ marks or ‘I am so disappointed I want to cry’ marks when I write.
The data is negative or does not exist. Yet the NEJM recommends it anyway. It can’t hurt; what’s the harm? For those of you not in medicine, the word of the NEJM is close to that of god. In clinical medicine, there is the NEJM then everyone else. The recommendations are in a table that will be cut and pasted into a thousand Powerpoint talks and disseminated far beyond the readership of the NEJM.
To paraphrase:
The phenomenon of questionable health practices is not limited to the developing world; my encounter occurred in a medically sophisticated Journal. Doctors can even be duped at home, from the safety of their Internet subscription.
Years ago the Annals of Internal Medicine published a hideous series on alternative medicine and I lost confidence in the Annals and they have slid into personal irrelevance. When referring to the journal to housestaff I often pronounce it as if it had one ’n’, such is my ongoing irrational, immature, contempt for the Annals. Perhaps it is confirmation bias on my part. I expect the Annals to publish third rate articles and that is what I see. The NEJM isn’t Annals level. Yet. But it lies at the heart of my ongoing problem with all media: if they get it wrong in an area in which I am knowledgeable (Infectious Diseases, SCAMs) how can I trust them in areas in which I need to defer to the expertise of others (just about everything else)?
Is it me, or does the clay now extend to midthigh for the NEJM? Is there anyone I can trust?

   The Annals of Internal Medicine Qualifies for Fail Blog.
Mark Crislip
Link
As most readers of the blog know, I am mostly an Infectious Disease doc. I spend my day diagnosing and treating infections and infectious complications. It is, as I have said before, a simple job. Me find bug, me kill bug, me go home. Kill bug. It is the key part of what I do everyday, and if there is karmic payback for the billions of microbial lives I have erased from the earth these past 25 years, my next life is not going to be so pleasant. I will probably come back as a rabbit in a syphilis lab.
It is always fun when my hobby, writing for SBM, crosses paths with my job. This month the Annals of Internal Medicine published “Oseltamivir Compared With the Chinese Traditional Therapy Maxingshigan–Yinqiaosan in the Treatment of H1N1 Influenza. A Randomized Trial.”
I though big pharma was good at coming up with names I do not know how to pronounce. If someone could provide a pronunciation guide in the comments, it would be ever so helpful, so I will not have to embarrass myself when this entry becomes a Quackcast. Dr. Hall wrote about this article on Tuesday, and I have avoided reading her post until this one is up, so there may be overlap in what is discussed.
What is Maxingshigan–Yinqiaosan (MY)? Twelve herbs, one better than the Colonel (and speaking of pronunciation, why is it pronounced “kernel”?) but lacking the spices. It contains
zhimahuang (honey-fried Herba Ephedrae), 6 g; zhimu (Rhizoma Anemarrhenae), 10 g; qinghao (Herba Artemisiae Annuae), 15 g; shigao (Gypsum Fibrosum), 30 g; yin- hua (Flos Lonicerae Japonicae), 15 g; huangqin (Radix Scutellariae), 15 g; chaoxingren (stir-baked Semen Armeniacae Amarum), 15 g; lianqiao (Fructus Forsythiae), 15 g; bohe (Fructus Forsythiae), 6 g; zhebeimu (Bulbus Fritillariae Thunbergii), 10 g; niubangzi (Fructus Arctii Tosum), 15 g; and gancao (Radix Et Rhizoma Glycyrrhizae), 10 g.
Quite the melange of products. Could there be antiviral or immunomodulating molecules in such a hodgepodge? Certainly. There is no a priori reason that Maxingshigan–Yinqiaosan would, or would not, have efficacy against influenza or its complications.
The reasons to test MY are partly appeals to antiquity, “Traditional Chinese medicine has been used to treat seasonal influenza for thousands of years,” plus a reference that, upon searching, does not contain the word influenza. Or pneumonia. Or respiratory tract infection.
You have to wonder, when you are in the second paragraph of the introduction and looking up the primary sources and they do not match the text, just how careful the researchers and the editors of the journal are. It’s the Annals. Not very. Which is why my subscription lapsed. And, to demonstrate just how infantile I can truly be, when I discuss the journal with residents, I pronounce it as if it had one ‘n’. But do not accidentally type in the url at work with Annals spelled with one ‘n’; I discovered our firewall filter has an Anals.org weakness.
In Europe, pandemic influenza has been recognized for perhaps 500 years: “Then suddenly, in July and August 1510, a ‘gasping oppression’ with cough, fever, and a sensation of constriction of the heart and lungs began to rage, seemingly everywhere at once.” And local flu has been known for maybe 650 years. Given those numbers, “thousands of years” seems a wee bit of hyperbole, especially when the reference doesn’t support the assertion. And as best I can tell from the Googles, no influenza was reported in China until the 1800s, and given traditional diagnostic testing modalities, I doubt they were looking at patterns of disease that would be identified today as influenza.
Then they say
In a recent meta-analysis of 31 randomized clinical trials including 5514 cases of influenza, the authors concluded that TCM had significantly increased clinical efficacy compared with placebo or no intervention.
And that analysis was? A systematic review of chuanhuning for acute respiratory tract infections. Chinese Archives of Traditional Chinese Medicine. 2007;25:2200-3.
The abstract said “There were 31 RCTs with 5514 cases were involved.” 5514 cases of acute respiratory tract infections, not 5514 cases of influenza. Although I may be slapped down for this, as the original is in Chinese and there is nothing on the Pubmeds relating to chuanhuning.
Looking for the primary references of the systematic review as best as I could given the language issues, the Googles find “etiological diagnosis by clinical experiments and tissue civilization experiments show namely the product of inactivated influenza virus A type Ⅰ, Ⅲ type A, pneumonia, adenovirus (Adv) Ⅲ type, Ⅳ type, intestinal syncytial virus and respiratory syncytial virus (Rsv) have inactivation” and the few trials I could locate were for a hodgepodge of viral and other upper and lower respiratory infections.
Chuanhuning is not in the current regimen to be tested, and the authors of the systemic review mention “the evidence is not strong due to the general poor methodological quality.”
The argument, not supported by the references, for testing MY is: product A may work for influenza, so let’s try an entirely different product for influenza. Could the editors of the Annals be doing a worse job at reading the papers in their journals?
They then mention “Modern pharmacologic studies demonstrated that some TCM formulas had antiviral and immunomodulating effects (13, 14).” Reference 13 is Chen N, Ren L. [Modern pharmacology research and clinical use of max- ingshigan]. Academic Journal of Guang Dong College of Pharmacy. 2004;545-6. and reference 14 is Huang JM, Chen DP, Yang LP. [The immunomodulating effects of maxingshigan on asthma mice models]. Journal of Fujian Traditional Chinese Med- icine. 2003;34:38-9. At least both references have maxingshigan in the title, but whether the content matches the assertions, well, let’s say their credibility has not been demonstrated.
Of course, no study of “Eastern” medicine would be complete without the appeal to popularity:
During the early days of the 2009 H1N1 influenza A pandemic, the popular herbal formula maxingshigan–yinqiaosan was used widely by TCM practitioners to reduce symptoms.
Years ago, at conference, one of my attendings was being detailed about a new antibiotic, and the rep finished up with “and it is popular in Europe.” To which my attending replied “So was Hitler for a while.” A pre-Interweb version of Godwin’s Law.
Searching for Maxingshigan–Yinqiaosan in the Pubmeds yields little but the intriguing, yet unavailable, Two hundred and thirty-five cases of high fever caused by exopathogen treated with yinqiao maxing shigan tang.
I went through the tedium of searching each component of MY in the Pubmeds and its relationship to influenza and found nothing of note.
So the reason for the study, really, is that people were using it. Let’s see if it really works.
They randomized people with mild PCR proven influenza to
Oseltamivir, 75 mg twice daily; maxingshigan– yinqiaosan decoction (composed of 12 Chinese herbal medicines, including honey-fried Herba Ephedrae), 200 mL 4 times daily; oseltamivir plus maxingshigan–yinqiaosan; or no intervention (control). Interventions and control were given for 5 days.
Primary outcome was time to fever resolution. Secondary outcomes included symptom scores and viral shedding determined by using real-time reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction.
It was not blinded, only a small flaw given the endpoint, and most patients did not receive an intervention until relatively late in the disease, when the impact would be lessened
In our study, the median time from onset of illness to randomization was 34.5 hours; 23.2% of patients presented 48 to 72 hours after the onset of symptoms.
Sooner is better with the treatment of all acute infections, and given the delay in therapy, they are approaching a natural history of disease study more than a therapeutic intervention study.
They found
Significant reductions in the estimated median time to fever resolution compared with the control group (26.0 hours [95% CI, 24.0 to 33.0 hours]) were seen with oseltamivir (34% [95% CI, 20% to 46%]; P < 0.001), maxingshigan–yinqiaosan (37% [CI, 23% to 49%]; P < 0.001), and oseltamivir plus maxingshigan– yinqiaosan (47% [CI, 35% to 56%]; P < 0.001). Time to fever resolution was reduced by 19% (CI, 0.3% to 34%; P < 0.05) with oseltamivir plus maxingshigan–yinqiaosan compared with oseltamivir. The interventions and control did not differ in terms of decrease in symptom scores (P < 0.38).
The actual numbers: control had fever for 26 hours, oseltamivir for 20, the MY 16 and the oseltamivir plus MY was 15, in real numbers the results are almost clinically irrelevant. And the treatment groups were randomized later than the no treatment group, and temperatures measurement started at randomization. So if the treatment groups have a head start in temperature measurement, that wipes out at mostly of the therapeutic advantage doesn’t it? Most of the difference due to when they started counting.
If you measure from symptom onset to resolution of fevers, you get
Control: 56 hours
MY: 51 hours
Oseltamivir: 55 hours
MY plus oseltamivir: 47 hours
It is the duration of illness that is clinically the important feature, so even if the effects are statistically significant, the difference is not clinically significant. And besides fever, there was no improvement in other symptoms: “No difference in any individual symptom, including cough, sore throat, headache, or fatigue, was observed after treatment.” Fever often remits before other symptoms of influenza, and given the duration of illness, from a clinical perspective, none of the interventions did much of anything.
As to viral shedding
the median viral titer in throat swabs at enrollment was similar, and a rapid decrease in virus shedding was observed in all 4 groups (P < 0.001) Changes in virus shedding from baseline to day 5 did not differ by treatment group (P < 0.69 for time-by-treatment interaction).
Both baseline swab specimens and specimens collected on days 1 to 5 for evaluation of virus shedding were available for 148 participants. Compared with the 262 patients without viral shedding measurements, these 148 patients had lower symptom scores; a lower proportion of cough, headache, and fatigue; lower leukocyte counts; and longer time from onset of illness to randomization. Therefore, the virus shedding results from these 148 patients were not representative of the entire study population
But when you look at the actual curves,
Link
there is separation between the oseltamivir containing regimens and those without, with the MY closer to the control. It suggests that the effect of MY is anti pyretic/immunomodulatory rather than antiviral. And given that the control group started the PCR measurements earlier as well, yo would expect slighly higher viral levels. If there is an effect from MY, it is a small one, and it appears to be less antiviral and more antipyretic, although the authors state
The study could not determine whether the observed effects of maxingshigan–yinqiaosan were due to anti- pyretic or antiviral effects.
I bet the former.
Given that the patients were all healthy, had mild illness and were treated relatively late in the disease, I would expect to any intervention to have a modest effect, and theirs was modest indeed.
Non sequitur central continues in the discussion where they discuss potential mechanisms of action and note
During the outbreak of the severe acute respiratory syndrome in Hong Kong, Poon and associates (24) showed that 2 herbal formulas had immunomodulating effects. In their study of healthy volunteers, they found that the CD4 –CD8 ratio of T lymphocytes was significantly increased after participants received Chinese herbal medicine for 14 days (24).
The reference, Immunomodulatory Effects of a Traditional Chinese Medicine with Potential Antiviral Activity: A Self-Control Study, states
We investigated the immunomodulating effects of an innovative TCM regimen derived from two herbal formulas (Sang Ju Yin and Yu Ping Feng San) for treating febrile diseases.
I am limited by language, variability in TCM medications and lousy editors at the Annals, but apparently Sang Ju Yin is Mulberry & Chrysanthemum Pills and Yu Ping Feng San, or Jade Screen Teapills, and neither have any ingredients in common with MY.
Sang Ju Yin and Yu Ping Feng San has to do with the mechanism of MY how? That is the kind of discussion the Annals has for its readers: randomness. Linear, logical thought appears passé these days. The authors seem to think all TCM are the same, and there is no reason to differentiate one TCM over another for mechanism of action: “More studies are needed to clarify the mechanisms of TCM.”
Me and my reductionist Western approach, thinking that different products, with different constituents, are actually different, with perhaps different, unrelated mechanisms of action, if they have a mechanism of action at all.
There were articles, again not available in English, that demonstrate in vitro effects of shigan on influenza A. That the references indeed demonstrate what the authors purport, well, I will have to trust the researchers and the editors of the Annals. They have done a fine job to date.
It would appear from one abstract, that 31.25 mg/ml of maxing shigan had multiple effects on viral replication in the test tube and that 31.25 mg/ml was the optimal concentration of the product.
In the study patients received 200 mL of MY orally 4 times daily. So for fun, assume 100% bioavailabilty. Lets assume 31.25 mg/ml in the preparation the patients received. Who knows. 200 x 31.25 is 6250 mg. A human volume is about 70,000 mls. Assuming a uniform volume of distribution, that gives the concentration of MY at 0.089 mg/ml. Seems a wee bit below the needed MIC. Of course, a lot of assumptions in the calculation, mostly around the concentration of the medication, its absorption and the volume of distribution. The first and third were guesses, the second was probably a large overestimation (medications are rarely 100% absorbed). The real concentrations of MY are probably much less that 0.089 mg /ml.
50% alcohol will also inactivate influenza in vitro. Outside of a frat party, those levels are not achievable in vivo. Always the issue of going from in vitro to in vivo studies
The authors finish up with
In conclusion, in previously healthy young adults and adolescents who presented with uncomplicated 2009 H1N1 influenza A virus infection, therapy with oseltamivir and maxingshigan–yinqiaosan (alone and in combination) was associated with faster resolution of fever. Maxingshigan– yinqiaosan can be used as an alternative treatment of H1N1 influenza A virus infection when oseltamivir is not available.
and the abstract, which is all most people will read, ends with
These data suggest that maxingshigan– yinqiaosan may be used as an alternative treatment of H1N1 influenza virus infection
So here is where I am going to get picky.
My take, looking at the PCR data, is that MY does not treat influenza. There is no real change in the PCR viral concentrations. When you treat an infection, you kill it, or at least prevent it from reproducing. They did not treat influenza, they treated an epiphenomena of influenza, the fever. Treating fever is not the same as treating infection. And of course, it looks like the effect is an artifact of when they started counting, and given the lack of response of other symptoms, this is a mostly a natural history of influenza study.
And should you treat fever? Well, no. There is an interesting literature, with many a methodological issue, that suggests treating a fever is not a good idea.
In animal models and human studies, treating a fever is associated with prolonged illness and, depending on the study, increased mortality. There is no definitive study, but an hour of perusing the literature will show an interesting pattern. Fevers are usually good. Treating fevers is usually bad.
Fevers are an important and ancient response to infection. Most parts of the immune system function better at higher temperatures. Sometimes the patient lacks the physiologic reserve to cope with the metabolic demands of fever (poor cardiac or lung function) and strokes and heart attacks may be larger if the patient has a fever. So sometimes you need to treat fevers. But for most acute infectious diseases that have been evaluated, patients and animals that have their fever suppressed are have a more prolonged illness, more complications, or increased mortality.
I never treat my kids fevers. They make less noise when they are 102 and will probably resolve their infection faster if I let the fever go, and that will get them to school and me to work that much sooner. Of course, when my wife takes over, she gives them Tylenol. No man is a hero to his valet. Not that my wife is my valet. It is a saying.
I could find no specific data regarding outcomes in treating influenza associated fevers, but I expect like most other infections, it would be a bad idea. And there is always that point in the inflammatory response where the beneficial effects are overwhelmed by the adverse effects of too brisk a response: SIRS, sepsis, TSS and the ever popular cytokine storm, although the fever per se is not issue in those processes.
What annoys, and concerns me at the end, is the confusion between treating influenza and treating the symptoms of influenza. The first was not demonstrated, the second perhaps was and is usually a bad idea.
Conclusion
The effects of MY on fever are probably not real, and if real are mostly clinically irrelevant and probably counterproductive for the treatment of influenza.
As to the mechanics of the paper (proper use of references, critical thinking), if it were from a college student, I would give it a ‘C’. If it were from a resident on service? Flunk.
And the Annals? In my professional lifetime they have gone from a first tier journal to second tier to now? Now, I shed a tear. Almost as funny as Fail Blog.

   Testing a Chinese Herbal Flu Remedy
Harriet Hall 
Link
During the early days of the 2009 H1N1 influenza A pandemic, the popular herbal formula maxingshigan–yinqiaosan was used widely by TCM practitioners to reduce symptoms. (It’s hard to pronounce and spell, so I’ll refer to it as M-Y.) A new study was done to test whether M-Y worked and to compare it to the prescription drug oseltamivir. It showed that M-Y did not work for the purpose it was being used for: it did not reduce symptoms, although it did reduce the duration of one sign, fever, allowing researchers to claim they had proved that it works as well as oseltamivir.
“Oseltamivir Compared With the Chinese Traditional Therapy: Maxingshigan–Yinqiaosan in the Treatment of H1N1 Influenza” by Wang et al. was published in the Annals of Internal Medicine earlier this month. The study was done in China, which is notorious for only publishing positive studies. Even if it were an impeccable study, we would have to wonder if other studies with unfavorable results had been “file-drawered.” It’s not impeccable; it’s seriously peccable.
It was randomized, prospective, and controlled; but not placebo controlled, because they couldn’t figure out how to prepare an adequate placebo control. They considered that including a no treatment group compensated for not using a placebo control, and that objective temperature measurement could be expected to get around any bias. It might not: the nurses who took the temperatures were blinded to the study, but the patients were not. It’s possible that those who knew they were getting M-Y might have believed in it and their bias might have somehow subtly influenced data gathering so that M-Y appeared more equivalent to oseltamivir than it actually was.
There are other problems besides the lack of blinding.
Background
It’s always fun to read the introduction section of a CAM paper. It gives insight into the researchers’ beliefs and frequently includes footnote references to studies that don’t say what they seem to think they say. In their introduction, Wang et al. say
Traditional Chinese medicine has been used to treat seasonal influenza for thousands of years.
The article they reference to support that claim doesn’t support it. It is an opinion piece about “Chinese medicinal materials and their interface with Western medical concepts.” It’s not a historical study, and it doesn’t directly address influenza . Anyway, thousands of years ago TCM did not recognize influenza as a unique disease entity or have any way of diagnosing it accurately. And TCM does not equate to M-Y.
Next they cite a meta-analysis that they say showed the effectiveness and safety of TCM, but it was not about flu or about M-Y. It was about studies of common cold patients with wind-cold syndrome. It concluded
TCM new drugs developed in recent years for preventing and treating common cold have better therapeutic effects than the old ones. They can accelerate the onset time of lowering body temperature and improve the symptoms of common cold without any significant adverse reactions. Because of lacking of placebo-controlled and blank-controlled studies, further high-quality trials are still needed.
The abstract is too garbled to understand, but it indicates that if there was any significant effect of “TCM” it was very small in magnitude. Saying that a study of TCM for colds shows that M-Y works for influenza is like saying that a study of Western medicine for pneumonia proves that penicillin works for bronchitis.
Design
the decision about whether to initiate antiviral therapy is individualized on the basis of the clinician’s judgment and on what is known about the benefits of therapy. Therefore, it was ethically possible for us to include a control group that received no intervention.
If individual decisions are ethically acceptable, how can it be ethical to decide that a whole random group of patients will be consigned to treatment or no-treatment groups?
The new study had over 400 subjects and few dropouts. Patients were admitted to the hospital and followed closely. Viral studies confirmed H1N1 influenza. There were 4 arms: M-Y, oseltamivir, M-Y plus oseltamivir, and a no treatment group. Endpoints were both objective (temperature and viral shedding) and subjective (reported symptoms).
Results
Time to resolution of fever was significantly shorter in all treatment groups than in no-treatment control group, and was comparable in the different treatment groups. There were no differences between groups on symptoms or viral shedding. There was no difference in acetaminophen use between groups. Patients in the control group were more likely to be prescribed antibiotics, even though they acknowledge that physicians often respond inappropriately to persistent temperature elevations by administering antibiotics that are not called for in that situation. If they knew that, why did they allow it to happen?
Complications like pneumonia were rare and not significantly different between groups.
Side effects were incomprehensibly rare: Two patients reported nausea and vomiting while taking M-Y and there were no side effects in the other groups. This is puzzling, since studies of oseltamivir have shown a 9-10% incidence of nausea and vomiting with the drug and 3-6% with placebo.
They interpreted their findings as showing that maxingshigan–yinqiaosan does not act as an antiviral, whereas the benefit of oseltamivir derives entirely from its antiviral activity. Their data do not justify that interpretation.
The Mixture
When herbs are mixed, I always wonder how they decided which ones to use. In this case, maxingshigan studies have shown immunomodulatory effects, but what about the other 11 ingredients?
M-Y is a mixture of 12 herbs. In this study the herbs were tested to rule out contamination with heavy metals, insecticides, and microbes. The need for such testing brings up a concern: when patients buy M-Y on the market, what are they getting?
The 12 ingredients, as far as I could determine from the information in the paper, correspond to ephedra, anemarrhena rhizome, artemisia (wormwood), gypsum, honeysuckle, skullcap, bitter apricot kernel, forsythia fruit, peppermint, fritillaria bulb, burdock, and licorice. Only about half of these are listed in the Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database. For most of these, flu is not listed as an indication (although allergies and respiratory infections are sometimes mentioned), and most say there is insufficient evidence to rate safety or to rate effectiveness for any indication. Some include warnings: ephedra is unsafe and is illegal in the US; apricot kernels are a source of cyanide. It is hard to imagine a rationale for combining these particular 12 ingredients for any purpose, much less for flu. Maybe I lack imagination.
An appendix that lists Chinese and English names for the ingredients includes this helpful explanation:
Chinese herbs are usually prescribed in formulas that contain “king” medicines, which provide the strongest therapeutic action; “minister” medicines, which assist the “king” medicine in its therapeutic actions; “assistant” medicines, which aid the “minister” medicine in treating a lesser aspect of the disease; and “ambassador” medicines that are intended to reduce the toxicity of the other medicines in the formula or guide the formula to the targeted organ or region of the body.
They offer no justification for which ingredient has which of these purposes or how they knew whether they actually work for those purposes. These terms are not scientifically meaningful and are unexpected in a journal like the Annals of Internal Medicine.
Conclusion
Most patients with influenza recover with no specific treatment; but oseltamivir is often used with the goals of faster recovery, reduced symptoms and fewer complications. It is also used to prevent influenza. But it is far from perfect. Studies have shown that it reduced the risk of pneumonia and of pneumonia, fever, and viral shedding. Its symptom-reducing effects are not very robust, and it can have some side effects. It would be nice if we had a safer, more effective remedy.
They concluded:
Maxingshigan–yinqiaosan can be used as an alternative treatment of H1N1 influenza A virus infection when oseltamivir is not available.
I can’t really argue with that, but why not try to make oseltamivir available? Why not try to insure the purity and safety of available preparations of M-Y? More importantly, why not try to figure out what each of those 12 herbs does, whether all 12 are essential for its effectiveness, and whether worrisome ingredients like ephedra and cyanide could be eliminated?
It is admirable that TCM practitioners are trying to study their remedies scientifically; but this study doesn’t convince me that M-Y offers any advantage over oseltamivir, or even that it is a reasonable substitute.

   Trouble in the Library
Wallace Sampson
Links
Anyone attempting a systematic review of the medical literature on sectarian medical systems (“CAM”) starts with a serious disability; the literature itself. The National Library of Medicine still lists abstracts for over 30 “alternative medicine” journals, but more concerning, is my estimate that half or more of the articles on sectarian systems published in standard medical journals range from the erroneous to the fraudulent. If one is conscientious, honest, and wants to produce a realistic review of sectarian systems that reflects reality, one cannot do it.
The problem spills over and beyond boundaries of medical research and practice. Often neglected is a massive literature of the allied professions – nursing, psychology, social work, and others. There are data bases for these professions as well (CINAL, EMBASE, CISCOM, Psychlit.) So not only do physicians and patients deal with a disabled medical literature, other professions also face the same problem in theirs. Little wonder that the “CAM” – “Integrative” movement has been tolerated instead of rejected in the community of health and allied health.
The editor of Research on Social Work Practice sent me a copy of a review of intercessory prayer published in his journal (Hodge DR, A Systematic Review of the Empirical Literature on Intercessory Prayer. Res Soc Work Pract 2007;17(2):174-186.) Intercessory prayer is the prayer offered by others for an ill person, usually not in the person‘s presence. Prayer is usually performed on a regular daily schedule by groups of prayers of one or more religious denominations.
This review’s author used standard methods for collating pertinent reports for systematic reviews and also reviewed other systematic reviews, including the Astin review published in Annals Internal Medicine in 2000. Selected reports in that review of 23 papers made up a proportion of the reports in the 17 of the Hodge review. Hodge apparently used stricter criteria than did Astin, as 10 studies were published after the Astin review, leaving only 7 or fewer from the 23 of the Astin review.
The Hodge review found its 17 reports, qualified for analysis by entry criteria (randomization, masking, blinding, analyses, etc.) Of the 17 reports, 5 showed no effect of intercessory prayer on disease outcomes; 5 reports showed a “non-significant trend” to positive effects, and 7 reports showed “significant effects.” The author concluded the results to be inconclusive. The previous Astin review concluded its results showed positive effects.
Summary of the Astin Annals review. We had already shown the Astin review to be inaccurate largely because of acceptance of invalid individual reports (Sampson W. Are systematic reviews …sufficient and necessary for assessing the effectiveness of prayer? Sci Rev Altern Med 2000, 4(2):12-15.) Astin recorded 15 of 23 studies to have shown positive statistical results. The conclusion made national news at the time, and Timothy Johnson MD of ABC sang praises to it over national TV. But problems we and others discovered with the individual reports resulted in an inability to form a ratio because so many of the reports had been faked or neutralized by error or misrepresentation. Besides, 8 of the papers were from non-medical journals and 1 or 2 were from magazines. The Hodge review seems to have been more selective and includes a number of recent reports from the spirituality in medicine department at Duke, supported by the Templeton Foundation.
We have learned more about the reports in the Astin review since 2000. Although we suspected that the four reports on prayer and “non-touch healing” by Wirth were defective, we did not understand why that author of several fraudulent papers would claim to have repeated them and found negative results. Perhaps a matter of conscience. Perhaps a move to throw investigators off the track. [Barry and Bruce Beyerstein, with aid of local Bay Area Skeptic members tracked Wirth down in the 1990s, and asked some pertinent questions, and received threats of lawsuts in return - and no data.)
We did not learn with more certainty until 2002 that Wirth had probably faked some 6 studies, 4 of which were in the Astin review. The healing papers were part of Wirth’s master’s thesis, but his advisor admitted to never having seen the original data. The story of Wirth’s frauds and convictions is in preparation.
In 2001 Wirth, Cha, and Lobo published their implausible report claiming that 3 separate prayer groups in 3 countries - Canada, US, Australia - produced a 100 percent increase in pregnancies from in vitro fertilization in South Korea. Later revelations showed that Cha was involved in the fraudulent Korean cloning report a few years ago, Lobo admitted to have met Cha only after the trial data were in hand, and did not review the data. He was relieved of his post as OB-Gyn Chairman at Columbia; and Wirth has just spent 5 years in Federal prison for embezzlement and other frauds. The story of the Cha/ Wirth/ Lobo paper was published by Bruce Flamm of UC Irvine in Sci Rev Altern Med in a 3-part series several years ago. [Blackballed by “CAM” sectarian reviewers, SRAM is still unlisted on the Medline pages, so most readers are not clued to the papers’ existence.] The four prior Wirth studies in the Astin review were excluded from the Hodge review, but the probably fraudulent Cha, Wirth study of 2001 was included despite the revelation of fraud. After these revelations, one of the Astin review authors (E. Ernst) recanted his conclusion and publicly voiced his opinion that there is poor to no convincing evidence for prayer efficacy on the course of disease. Yet the Astin review remains on Medline and is often quoted in other papers. And, the Cha/Wirth paper made it into the Hodge review even though Hodge revealed his knowledge of the controversy (as published in J Repr Med, 2005, 50:71.)
Both reviews included the Sicher/Targ prayer study claiming positive results in AIDS patients. That paper was shown by a writer in the on-line Salon magazine to have had a procedure violation. The original end point for the AIDS patients, treated and controls, was to have been longevity (death.) But after the study began, triple therapy and protease inhibitors appeared, and all patients were still alive. So the authors changed the end points to multiple indirect measures such as transfusions, hospitalizations, and such. They then were able to select end points post hoc. I verified this information with the statistician of record. The authors did not reveal this violation so the report remains in all data bases. This paper was included in the Hodge review. [BTW, I was shown the raw data in confidence and saw that significant weight loss and decreased hemoglobin occurred in many of the patients but those end points were not selected for report.)
Dr. Targ, daughter of Russel Targ (of Targ and Puthoff of ESP note,) died of a brain tumor, and remains an icon of the “CAM” community.
Both the Byrd study of 1989 and the Harris study of 1999 were included in both reviews. Both recorded complications in coronary care patients in prayed-for and control groups. Kim Atwood reviewed problems with both in a letter to Annals Int. Med. as did Kevin Courcey (in: Medical claims for intercessory prayer remain elusive. Sci Rev Altern Med 2000;4(2):9-11.) Both pointed out that the results of the Byrd and Harris studies disconfirmed each other through conflicting results - many of the positive correlations in Harris were negative in Byrd and vice versa. Besides, the Harris study control patients had far more and more serious medical complications at entry to the study. The multiple end points in both allowed for all sorts of chance correlations. Perhaps worse, the Byrd study might not have been blinded as claimed, as Kim Atwood discovered from just reading closely. Neither paper should have qualified for publication had knowledgeable reviewers been employed.
So, without looking any further into the more recent studies, four of the six positive (P<.05) studies in the Hodge review 1) were probably fraudulent (Cha/Wirth) 2) were compromised by protocol - post hoc changed end point - violation (Sicher/Targ,), or 3) contradicted each other, had unbalanced control and treatment groups, or were actually negative by most criteria (Byrd, Harris.) In addition, 2 of the 6 studies showing a positive trend we have some reason to believe had broken blinding - one study by Matthews having been analyzed by Gary Posner in Sci Rev Altern Med, but these are not necessary to neutralize the positive findings of the Hodge review.
Why have these frauds and irregularities passed so many editorial and peer reviews? This evidence shows that most peer reviewers are not familiar with the numerous ways a report’s findings can be altered, they are not familiar with authors we know have cheated or otherwise misinterpreted results, and formal filters for fraud do not exist. Frauds are usually found by chance observation or by someone who had original suspicions.
Beside individual report irregularities, there is a considerable bias in authors and systematic review literature reviewers. We now have evidence that the large preponderance of investigators, report authors, and the reviewers of literature have vested interests in positive outcome. They seem to be the ones with enough interest, or who have enough grant money, to carry out a time-consuming and often unrevealing project. Not only do they depend on grants to investigate these improbable proposals, not only do their academic positions depend on obtaining positive results from their work, but the wording of their reports contains neologisms and language distortions explored in these pages and elsewhere. The failure of the research and editor communities to recognized career and ideological conflicts of interest leaves this large hole in the scientific defensive line.
What causes such distortion in the literature, with its subsequent evidence based belief? Although a majority of the US public believe in formal religions of one kind or another, the Hodge review revealed some statistics I was not aware of:
“A surprisingly high percentage of social workers appear to use intercessory prayer in their work with clients … One national survey of direct practitioners affiliated with the National Association of Social Workers (N=2069) found that 28% of respondents had engaged in verbal prayer with their clients, whereas 57% prayed privately for their clients. (Canda ER, Furman LD. Spiritual diversity in social work practice Free Press, New York, 1999.) Similarly, among a national sample of NASW affiliated gerontological workers (N=299) 43% reported praying with their clients either “sometimes” or “often.” In terms of their private prayer interventions, two thirds of respondents indicated they prayed either sometimes (43%) or often (24%) for their clients.”
Hodge in his review comments: “Qualitative research …suggests that many social workers hold strong beliefs, both in favor and against [ …] using prayer in therapeutic settings. Consequently, it is not surprising that practitioners’ personal metaphysical beliefs rather than established professional protocols may be guiding therapeutic decisions.” It is now apparent that the literature itself leaves a large opening for the play of opinion and belief in “CAM,” and especially in the effects of prayer. It is easy to regard systematic reviews as showing prayer results to have positive effects, thus reinforcing erroneous belief of health professionals.
But if one has the background information on proponents, and one is familiar with their histories of misrepresentation, and the true origins of their proposals, one can have access to openings and chinks in the sectarian propaganda armor not otherwise apparent.

JAMA on Medical Misinformation
A JAMA article addresses the issue of confronting medical misinformation. They make good recommendations – but do not go nearly far enough.
Steven Novella on April 24, 2019
Link

A recent editorial in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) addresses the growing problem of medical misinformation, such as anti-vaccine views, fake treatments, unproven alternative products and services, and others. The authors, Armstrong and Naylor, make some good recommendations, but unfortunately are about 20 years behind the times when it comes to confronting scientific misinformation.
They identify the source of the problem as being primarily the extensive availability of medical information online that is not vetted or reviewed, combined with a rising tide of anti-science sentiments in the culture. They write:
This new online world facilitates direct-to-consumer marketing by phony experts, celebrities with armies of Twitter followers, and legions of independent digital scammers, including some physicians. The result has been torrents of misinformation on topics as varied as the safety and effectiveness of vaccinations, the Zika virus outbreak, water fluoridation, genetically modified foods, and treatments for common diseases.
This is all correct, but leaves out several important factors. We could also focus on tolerance of complementary and alternative medicine in academia, education, in the medical profession more broadly, and increasingly in regulations. CAM is a huge problem because at its core it is based on breaking the rules of science, promoting conspiratorial and anti-science thinking, and loosening regulations.
Another factor to consider are government regulations that should optimally be science based but increasingly are not. Also the culture of academia needs to change, to value and promote the public understanding of medical science. They do touch on this, but do not address the underlying problem with academic culture.
They talk a lot about scientific literacy, which means they are stuck in the decades-old “knowledge deficit” model of pseudoscience. Lack of scientific knowledge is an important factor, but is probably less of one that lack of critical thinking skills. Facts don’t matter if you are stuck in a conspiracy mindset, or do not trust science, or are overwhelmed with motivated reasoning and confirmation bias.
In fact, embracing medical pseudoscience increases as general education level increases, probably due to increased access to disposable income. But this shows that education itself is not an inoculation against pseudoscience, as the authors believe.
Because their list of contributing factors is too limited, their solutions are also limited – they are good, just not nearly enough. The primary focus of their paper is what medical journals can do to address the problem. They offer four major solutions: containment of dissemination, “general immunity through scientific literacy”, health-specific education, and debunking myths.
These are all good things, and journals should absolutely be doing them, but again – they will not be nearly enough.
I think that containment of dissemination is probably a lost cause. That genie is out of the bottle. Perhaps big social media outlets like Facebook can change their algorithms so that sensational nonsense is not promoted, but short of a huge change in social media and the internet allowing for a China-style top-down control, I don’t think we are going to stop misinformation. We simply have to deal with it.
And again, they make some good recommendations, but mostly limited to the knowledge-deficit model. Journals should provide executive summaries of technical articles written for a broad lay audience. They could also provide forums in which experts can interface with the public pertaining to specific articles or topics. They recommend topic specific journals and issues tackling topics of public interest or that are a common target of misinformation. Journals and experts can also directly debunk myths and misinformation.
This is all good, but here are some further recommendations (some of which go beyond the scope of medical journals). I will start, however, with what journals can do.
The culture of academia and science needs to shift away from publishing lots of preliminary studies. The threshold for being published needs to be higher, with better statistics, better editorial review, internal replications, checks against p-hacking, and more exact replications.
Journals that are primarily dedicated to pseudoscience should not be listed as formally peer-reviewed. Basically every specialty journal dedicated to CAM should not be listed as legitimate, unless they have editors that are dedicated to science itself (not CAM) and have extremely high standards. But we cannot just let CAM proponents be their own experts and decide what is valid. That is just opening the floodgates to pseudoscience.
The entire idea of open-access also needs to be rethought. Perhaps in order to be listed as a legitimate peer-reviewed journal, certain standards need to be put in place that address both the problems of open-access journals and traditional journals. The open-access model encourages publishing lots of poor quality articles because they charge per publication. Traditional journals, rather, are chasing impact factor, which favors dramatic studies that are the most likely to be wrong and later retracted.
We need to find a model that allows for public access of important articles, or at least the lay summaries, while rewarding editorial quality (not the sensationalism of the results).
Academia and medical journals also need to get more involved in promoting rational government regulations of all aspects of health care.
But there are also factors outside the control of journal editors that also need to be addressed. The entire science education infrastructure needs an overhaul. Critical thinking needs to be incorporated from day one. Students need to develop the skills necessary to tell science from pseudoscience, to evaluate claims and sources, to be skeptical of unusual claims, and to recognize the pitfalls of conspiracy thinking and other cognitive biases.
Confronting fraud, pseudoscience, science denial, and misinformation needs to be a top priority for the academic, scientific, and medical communities. This needs to also go beyond just confronting what appears to be a short term crisis. This is forever. We need a culture change where these priorities are recognized as intrinsic to the scientific enterprise.

Nepotistic Journals
Research identifies another potential bias in scientific publishing – nepotistic journals.
Steven Novella on November 24, 2021
Tweet

The entire scientific enterprise might be viewed as an attempt to systematically weed out bias from our view of reality. At least, this is a critical component of the scientific method. But bias can be subtle, and can creep in at many stages from conception to citation of published research. The subjects of research may have bias, research methods can be biased in terms of how measurements are made or reported, which comparisons are looked at, the statistical methods used, and how data is collected. The publication process also may introduce bias, as can the way in which researchers access, evaluate, and cite published studies.
All of these sources of bias can distort the scientific literature and therefore the academic process and the conclusions that scientists and practitioners come to, with downstream effects in many aspects of how we run our society. But the key strength of science is that it can be (when done properly) self-reflective and self-corrective. This self-corrective process should apply not only to the findings of science, but to the process and institutions of science as well. This is one of the main missions of SBM, to examine and reflect upon the relationship among how science is practiced, the findings of science, and the practice and regulation of medicine.
In that vein we are always on the look out for opportunities to shine a light on new forms of bias within the institutions of science, with an eye toward how such biases can be fixed, or at least disclosed. Scientific journals are a major focus of this attention because they are the ultimate gateway for research to enter the scientific literature – the official body of scientific evidence. Biases in how journals decide what to publish can have a profound impact on the scientific literature, and therefore deserve a lot of attention. We have discussed previously, for example, the effects of predatory journals, the tendency not to publish negative studies or exact replications, and the different challenges of open access vs traditional business models of journals.
Now we can add one more phenomenon to the list of possible journal biases – nepotistic journals. 
In a massive review of publications in 5,468 biomedical journals indexed in the National Library of Medicine between 2015 and 2019, Scanff et al. examined the distribution of authors in each journal. They used two measures to quantify this: the Percentage of Papers by the Most Prolific author (PPMP), and the Gini index (level of inequality in the distribution of authorship among authors).
The authors found that the median PPMP for the journals examined was 2.9%, meaning that a typical journal may have around 3% of the papers they publish have the same author. They also used the two standard deviation model, determining the 95% cut-off for PPMP. They found that 95% of journals had a PPMP less than 10.6%, or that 5% had a PPMP of 10.6% or more. A high PPMP also correlated with a high Gini index, which indicates a highly unfair or biased distribution of authors. Further, and perhaps very significantly, they also found a correlation between the specific most prolific authors and a reduced time to publication, such as the percentage of papers that are published within three weeks of submission. This might indicate an expedited or even inadequate review process.
But the most significant correlation they found was that among that 5% of journals with the highest PPMP, in 60% of the cases the most prolific author was a member of the editorial board. This pattern held true when only research papers were considered (therefore not counting letters or editorials that might be disproportionately written by the editors). These were the journals considered “nepotistic”.
Whenever researchers crunch numbers in a massive data set, there is the potential for confounding factors (another form of bias). For example, smaller journals with fewer publications would be more susceptible to having a high PPMP as even a few publications by the same author can be a high percentage. Meanwhile, large journals with tens of thousands of submissions over this time period would necessarily have a low PPMP, because there is only so many papers a single researcher can author. Similarly, a scientific journal with a very narrow niche might have a similarly small community of researchers and very few journals in which to publish.
But even taking these factors into consideration, there seems to be a subset of nepotistic journals that cater to one or more members of their editorial staff, allowing them to publish a large number of papers with little editorial barrier. This can be a method of gaming the system, affecting academic promotion and the awarding of grants. These editorial authors can also use these same papers to deliberately reference other papers in the same (or a sister) journal, therefore gaming the impact factor measure also.
One other concern that this paper could not examine is the scientific quality of nepotistic papers. Given the favorable bias and reduced editorial review, there is concern that low quality science is finding its way into the literature via this method. A smaller study doing qualitative analysis of high PPMP papers would be an interesting follow up. I would also be interested in how this factor relates to journals with a high concern for low quality science, such as those in the alternative community.
        ◦ The simplest partial fix to this problem (like many things in science) is transparency. Journals might be required to publish alongside their impact factor (a measure of how often they are cited) their PPMP and Gini index. Because prolific journals may mask their nepotistic practices by their high number of publications, publishing the raw number of publications by their most prolific author also helps. Further, the number and/or percentage of papers published in the journal by an author on the editorial staff is critical. At least with this transparency fellow researchers and academics on promotion committees can easily detect blatant nepotistic practices, reducing the benefit of this practice.

PLOS ONE, peer review, and a “crappy” acupuncture study
Meta-analyses can sometimes suffer from the “GIGO problem” (garbage in, garbage out). The publication of a “crappy” acupuncture “network meta-analysis” for acupuncture and chronic constipation illustrates the GIGO problem on steroids and reveals a problem with peer review.
David Gorski on May 7, 2018
Link
We write about acupuncture a lot here on SBM because it’s the form of quackery that is arguably the most “respectable” and accepted among academic medical institution and “conventional” doctors. Indeed, a decade or more ago I used to be (almost) among the doctors who thought that there might be something to acupuncture. Obviously, I never believed in any of the mysticism underlying acupuncture meridians and “unblocking” the flow of qi with needles. However, because needles actually penetrate skin in acupuncture, I thought that maybe there was a mechanism by which acupuncture could “do something” therapeutic. Of course, the more I read the medical literature and actual studies purporting to show a therapeutic effect due to acupuncture, the more I realized how poor the evidence was and how the highest quality evidence out there showed that acupuncture is basically nothing more than a theatrical placebo. Basically, it doesn’t matter where you stick the needles or even if you stick the needles in. The effect is the same. Unfortunately, many journals are complicit in spreading pseudoscience.
Such were my thoughts as I was made aware by a reader of a new acupuncture meta-analysis published late last month in PLOS ONE out of the Shenzhen Longhua District Central Hospital in China entitled “Comparison of acupuncture and other drugs for chronic constipation: A network meta-analysis.” It is truly one of the worst acupuncture meta-analyses that I’ve ever seen and reveals a real problem with peer review at PLOS ONE.
A meta-analysis is a type of study that seeks to aggregate data from high quality studies in order to come to a conclusion about an intervention or therapy. When done rigorously and without bias, meta-analyses can be a very useful method for assessing the state of the evidence with regard to a particular treatment. However, meta-analyses are subject to the rule of GIGO (garbage in, garbage out). Basically, aggregating a bunch of poor-quality studies does not result in reliable conclusions.
This, however, is something I hadn’t encountered much before, mainly a network meta-analysis. So I had to look it up:
Systematic reviews use explicit, pre-specified methods to identify, appraise, and synthesize all available evidence related to a clinical question. When appropriate, systematic reviews may include a meta-analysis, that is, the statistical combination of results from two or more separate studies. Some systematic reviews compare only two interventions, in which a conventional pair-wise meta-analysis may be conducted, while others examine the comparative effectiveness of many or all available interventions for a given condition. When the comparative effectiveness of a range of interventions is of interest, appropriate statistical methodology must be used for analysis.
Also called mixed treatments comparison or multiple treatments comparison meta-analysis, network meta-analysis expands the scope of a conventional pair-wise meta-analysis by analyzing simultaneously both direct comparisons of interventions within randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and indirect comparisons across trials based on a common comparator (e.g., placebo or some standard treatment) [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]. In the simplest case, one may be interested in comparing two interventions A and C. Indirect evidence can be obtained from RCTs of either A or C versus a common comparator B (Figure 1), keeping intact the randomized comparisons within the RCTs [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]. When both direct and indirect evidence are available, the two sources of information can be combined as a weighted average when appropriate.
Right off the bat, network meta-analysis sounds very suspect as a methodology. Certainly, if regular meta-analyses are subject to GIGO and cherry picking studies, this sort of meta-analysis is even more so. In any case, the reason the authors chose a network meta-analysis is obvious. There are no studies directly comparing acupuncture to the various laxatives and drugs to which the authors wish to compare them. I knew that the study would be bad right from the introduction, where the authors opine:
The methods of treating chronic constipation currently include drugs and acupuncture. Common drugs include lactulose, polyethylene glycol, linaclotide, lubiprostone, bisacodyl, prucalopride, tegaserod, etc. But most of drugs have some side effects which couldn’t be tolerated by patients, complementary or alternative treating methods with less side effect [sic] are needed in our practice. An increasing number of studies have shown that acupuncture may have certain effects on chronic constipation. However, there have been no studies comparing acupuncture and commonly used oral drugs. The comparison between drugs and acupuncture will bring us a clear understanding of those interventions. Furthermore, various acupoints have been targeted to treat chronic constipation. Therefore, this study was designed to solve these unanswered questions.
This study was a systematic review of the literature and collected data from published randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of acupuncture and common oral drugs in the treatment of chronic constipation up to December 2017. This study aimed to answer the following questions: (1) what are the curative effects and side effects of acupuncture and drugs to improve chronic constipation?; (2) what is the curative effect of sham acupuncture as a placebo?; and (3) what are the acupoints to cure constipation?
See what I mean? The authors state as a fact that acupuncture is a method of treating chronic constipation. While that is true on a trivial level (obviously there are quacks out there treating constipation with acupuncture), the implication behind the statement is that it is an accepted method of treatment. Also notice the false dichotomy: Drugs used to treat constipation are framed as having unacceptable side effects, while acupuncture is framed as somehow more desirable. In any case, the authors searched PubMed, the Cochrane Library, Embase and 4 Chinese databases [China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), Wanfang Database, VIP Database and Chinese Biomedical Database (CBM)] for randomized clinical trials, using as their criteria:
    • Clinical trials of adult patients
    • Clinical trials of single drugs
    • Clinical trials with treatment duration greater than two weeks
    • Publications that were not comments or commentaries
    • Studies that excluded pregnant or lactating women, patients with peptic ulcers, rectal disease, or liver or other systemic disease, and patients with previous history of gastroduodenal surgery, neurologic diseases or neurologic surgery
The authors identified a total of 1,516 articles were obtained from their literature search, of which 36 duplicates were deleted and 1,438 articles were excluded, leaving a total of 40 trials including 11,032 patients with chronic constipation. The studies encompassed a total of 10 treatment modalities including A: prucalopride; B: tegaserod; C: lubiprostone; D linaclotide E: bisacodyl; F: PEG; G: lactulose; H: acupuncture; I: sham acupuncture; and J: placebo (sucrose, etc.). So right there is a problem, namely that there are ten interventions and only forty studies. Given that there are 12 studies involving acupuncture (7 of acupuncture versus lactulose, 4 involving acupuncture versus sham, and one comparing two different forms of acupuncture), for some interventions, there are only two studies (range: 1-8). None of this stopped the authors from paddling bravely up the river of bad science by comparing all the studies and comparing acupuncture with each of the other interventions and concluding:
By including more than 40 articles for network meta-analysis (NMA), acupuncture was found to be more effective than drugs in treating chronic constipation with nearly no side effects. The mechanism of action of acupuncture for the treatment of chronic constipation remains unclear, but previous studies have also shown its possible role in the treatment of chronic constipation. An important cause of chronic constipation is the decreased motility of the colon, resulting in a decreased urge to defecate, bloating, and abdominal pain or discomfort. [51] Existing studies indicate that acupuncture at heterotopic acupoints facilitates distal colonic motor ability by activating M3 receptors and somatic afferent C-fibres in normal, constipated, or diarrhoeic rats. Acupuncture can also increase distal colonic motility in normal and abnormal mice with a possible role of M3 receptors [52]. Previous studies have suggested that the ST36 acupoint can change the motor function of the colon. [53]
That’s right. The authors concluded that acupuncture was more effective than any drug commonly used to treat chronic constipation and that it had “nearly no” side effects. That’s rather convenient, given that only one of the acupuncture studies included in the meta-analysis even bothered to report side effects.
That’s not all, either. There’s the way that the authors assessed effect size. Basically, they measured and compared the proportion of patients “with improvement in chronic constipation.” No measure is made of how much constipation improved, whatever tool various investigators might have chosen to use to assess severity of constipation in each study. Think of it this way by considering two hypothetical studies. One study shows that 50% of patients saw their constipation improve based on one treatment, and those 50% averaged a 90% improvement. Now consider another study that shows that 50% of patients improved, but by only an average of 20%. Those two studies would count the same because both report that 50% of their patients got better, but obviously they do not show the same result. Obviously, you’d want the treatment with an average improvement of 90% rather than 20%.
But that’s still not all. Let’s take a look at the Forest plot of the conventional paired meta-analysis that the authors carried out before doing their network thing:
The authors report that, compared with placebo (J), acupuncture significantly improved the symptoms of chronic constipation, as did most of the other interventions. Note also, though, that sham acupuncture also improved chronic constipation symptoms with an odds ratio of 3.1 (95% confidence interval 1.5-7.2). Just look at the lower panel. That’s as good as many of the drugs. There’s a red flag right there, as far as I’m concerned. There’s a reason for this, as described by Ross Pomeroy:
The vast majority of the laxative studies were double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trials published in peer reviewed journals. On the other hand, all of the acupuncture studies were unblinded, four were not peer-reviewed, five were published in questionable journals like the Shanghai Journal of Acupuncture and Moxibustion, and all were based in China, which is notoriously friendly to acupuncture and alternative medicine. Thus, it’s no surprise that acupuncture showed stronger results in those studies.
So basically what we have here is a perfect example of what acupuncturists do to try to “prove” that their quackery works for a wide variety of conditions. It is, however, a new wrinkle in bad acupuncture meta-analyses. Instead of just GIGO, it compares garbage (the results of most acupuncture studies) with the results of better quality studies (the studies of medications) in order to conclude that the garbage is even better than medicine. Never mind that ten different acupuncture points were used, that sham acupuncture “worked” almost as well as acupuncture, and that, well, their study is the best meta-analysis so far:
However, a previous meta-analysis showed no significant curative benefits of acupuncture compared with sham acupuncture in the treatment of chronic constipation. Only some studies from China have shown that acupuncture is superior to drugs. [54] A previous study from China showed that acupuncture and sham acupuncture had similar effects on functional constipation, but moxibustion was used with ST23 and ST27 acupoints in this study. Moreover, this study was based on a small sample size [55], and therefore, we are unable to ensure the accuracy of these findings. In addition, the curative effect of sham acupuncture remains to be confirmed.
Our study was unique in that the included studies of acupuncture used the deep pricking method instead of the ordinary acupuncture method. The depth of the deep pricking method is deeper than that of ordinary acupuncture method. Further studies are needed to confirm whether the deep pricking method has a better curative effect on chronic constipation than ordinary acupuncture. In the present study, many studies conducted after 2012 were included and the studies using the same acupuncture points were included to ensure consistency. RCTs using consistent acupuncture points will yield more definitive results.
I note that the outcome evaluated in the meta-analysis mentioned above was the change in the number of weekly spontaneous bowel movements.
This is the sort of thing acupuncturists do, though. Here’s another example, but not a meta-analysis. Rather, it’s a recently published randomized controlled acupuncture trial to treat chronic constipation that compares He acupuncture, Shu‐mu acupuncture, He‐shu‐mu acupuncture, and orally administered mosapride. Notice something? There’s no placebo control, no sham acupuncture control, and, you’ll notice if you read further, no blinding. Believe it or not, the mosapride group functioned as the control group. Surprise! Surprise! All groups improved, which is exactly what one would expect in such an unblinded trial. Basically, this is as worthless a clinical study as I’ve ever seen, and Neurogastroenterology & Motility should be ashamed for having published it.
Back to the meta-analysis, though. Not surprisingly, physicians and scientists were puzzled at how PLOS ONE could publish dreck as bad as this and took Twitter:
There’s bad studies, but this #acupuncture nonsense is on a whole other level, shame on @PLOSONE https://t.co/L2u127tZwG by @RCScience (via @ACSHorg) cc @CaulfieldTim @gorskon @McGillOSS @ScienceBasedMed
— Philippe Chouinard (@DrPChouinard) April 29, 2018
Steve Salzberg even resigned from the editorial board over this article:
I agree, this is appalling bad pseudoscience that never should have been published. I just wrote to @PLOSONE and officially resigned from their Editorial Board. https://t.co/9bbBQtvlY0
— Steven Salzberg (@StevenSalzberg1) April 29, 2018
PLOS ONE even responded:
Thank you very much for bringing these concerns to our attention. We are looking into this matter and will also be in touch with you separately to discuss further.
— PLOS ONE (@PLOSONE) April 30, 2018
We’ll see what happens. After all, as James Coyne has noted, it took PLOS ONE a long time to retract a more obviously dubious study:
Please to see @PLOSONE today retracted stealth #homeopathy article, but process should not have taken years, even if authors objected. https://t.co/WhJXU3X8rI #retraction https://t.co/QlPxm75UhQ
— James C.Coyne (@CoyneoftheRealm) May 3, 2018
Here’s the retraction notice:
Following publication of this article [1], concerns were raised about the scientific validity of the study as well as a potential competing interest that was not declared. The PLOS ONE Editors discussed the concerns with the authors and consulted external experts. In light of our editorial assessment and advice received in the expert consultations, we are retracting this article due to concerns about the scientific validity of the research question, study design, and conclusions.
Specifically, we are concerned about the overall design of the study, which aims to detect effects of a reagent diluted to such a degree that the solution is not expected to contain biochemically relevant levels of antibody. The consulted experts also raised concerns about the validity and rigor of the immunoassay system used in the study. The enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) used was adjusted to give barely detectable signals, which renders the assay particularly susceptible to interference. In light of these issues, we consider that the article does not present sufficient or reliable evidence to support the conclusions.
Stealth homeopathy paper indeed. I note that this paper was first published in 2014. PLOS ONE also notes undisclosed conflicts of interest.
Scientific and clinical studies of pseudoscience like acupuncture and homeopathy pose a significant challenge to journals, including PLOS ONE. The number of people who both know enough about the modalities being tested to evaluate them and are not advocates of those modalities is small. This results in reliance on peer reviewers who are supporters or practitioners of the quackeries being evaluated. Still, I have to wonder what went wrong at PLOS ONE in this particular case. I can sort of see how the stealth homeopathy paper could fool a peer reviewer not familiar with homeopathy, but I have a hard time seeing how this network meta-analysis paper could pass muster. Whatever the case, PLOS appears to have a problem, and acupuncture still doesn’t work—for constipation or anything else.

Infomercial in PLOS One links to website selling unproven treatments for fibromyalgia and dementia
PLOS One recently published a clinical trial that was essentially a poorly-disguised advertisement for an unproven product. I object to this use of the scientific literature to market such a device.
James Coyne on May 30, 2019
Link


[Editor’s note: Scott is having a very busy week, and stepping in to help out is Dr. James Coyne with another guest post.]
Bizarrely, the megajournal PLOS One has published a paper that is suspiciously similar to an advertisement. The paper LOOKS like it’s reporting on a test of a product that supposedly treats fibromyalgia, but also pain, dementia, Parkinson’s disease and more with just SOUND: basically just listening to a 40hz tone (listen to the sound here). But it’s actually junk science that was probably created just to advertise a treatment gadget. Somehow this extremely low quality paper got through PLOS One peer review, even though it prominently links to an advertisement for the gadget. That advertisement is much more blatantly pseudoscientific, as it leans heavily on a flashy, but misleading promotional TEDx video: “Music Medicine: Sound at a cellular level.”
Join me in a call for a speedy retraction! In this article, I critique the paper and show exactly why it’s obviously junky science, and share my letter sent to the senior editor of PLOS One.
The article presents results of a pre-registered randomized controlled trial (RCT) comparing Sound Oasis Vibroacoustic Therapy System VTS-1000 to a sham treatment.
As reported in PLOS One, the RCT was designed as a crucial test of the effectiveness of the device in treating fibromyalgia. Yet, standard analyses did not find a statistically significance between the active treatment that is being promoted in the video and a sham treatment constructed as a placebo. Ouch!
Technically speaking, the study found no time-by-treatment interaction. What does that mean? Patients were assessed with a battery of at least six self-report questionnaires at baseline – before any exposure to the treatment or the sham – and afterwards, post-treatment. In this case, the time-by-treatment analysis showed that the before/after differences for patients receiving the active treatment were no different than the results for patients assigned to the sham treatment.
However, reporting of the trial emphasized only differences that occurred within the active treatment group. The paper went on to declare these results:
provide preliminary evidence that gamma-frequency rhythmic vibroacoustic stimulation may decrease fibromyalgia symptoms and ease associated comorbidities, opening new avenues for further investigation of the effects of rhythmic sensory stimulation on chronic pain conditions.
What was not emphasized is that similar analyses would have shown the same effects for patients who received the sham/placebo treatment. That is a big problem for any claims for the marketing of the device.
Presenting the results in this way disregards basic rules for interpreting a clinical trial. Peer reviewers should have caught this immediately. Actually, the PLOS One Editor should have noticed this error in interpreting the trial and not even have sent the paper out for review.
A linked website calls attention to the Clinicaltrials.gov registration of the trial:
Sound Oasis VTS-1000 – Current Medical Trials The medical potential of the VTS-1000 goes beyond sleep and stress and this is seen in the use of this potent device in three clinical trials registered with the U.S. National Institutes of Health – (1) Depression: https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02685982?term=VTS1000&rank=2 (2) Fibromyalgia: https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02493348 (3) Temporomandibular Disorder: https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02427113?term=TMD+music&rank=1
This use of trial registration as suggesting some kind of endorsement by NIH is misleading. The actual trial registration page for the trial contains the standard warning:
The introduction of the article justifies the study with reference to preliminary data concerning ‘a well-established technique’ whereby sensory stimulation delivered to the skin can reduce pain.
Mechano-acoustic vibrations have been extensively used to address acute pain during orthodontic [26–28] and cosmetic procedures [29], and is a well-established technique in orthopedic practice [30] and physiotherapy to reduce muscle soreness [31–33], low back pain [34], and orofacial pain [35]. However, little is known regarding the application of vibroacoustic stimulation in the treatment of chronic pain conditions. Previous clinical studies have explored the use of rhythmic sensory stimulation to treat fibromyalgia [36–38]. Rhythmic sensory stimulation (RSS) broadly refers to the use of sensory events – including vibrotactile, auditory, and visual flickering stimuli – applied in pulsed forms with repeated short, transient stimulus events at regular intervals, or in continuous forms which generate oscillating (e.g., sinusoidal) stimulus patterns [39]
Actual studies of treatment of fibromyalgia are cited in the introduction, but they do not clearly support the efficacy of rhythmic sensory stimulation to treat fibromyalgia.
The Discussion section concedes a lack of established plausible mechanism by which the treatment should work:
There is no consensus regarding the mechanisms underlying the effects of sensory stimulation on pain.
The Discussion section attempts to neutralize the lack of differences between active and sham treatment by raising the possibility that maybe the control/comparison group is not really a sham, but another poorly understood active, effective treatment.
(Deja vu: We often see this argument when acupuncturists cannot find differences between active and sham acupuncture.)
However, the linked TEDx talk claims strong scientific support for cartoonish, simplistic explanations of miraculous effects in some dramatic case examples.
The PLOS One article is an infomercial, a key element of a marketing strategy selling unproven medical devices to persons who believe they are suffering from health conditions that are poorly understood and that have poor outcomes within conventional evidence- and science-based medicine.
The marketing campaign leaves patients and their families with the impression that a medical device that is for sale has been proven powerful and that it is similar to what is being used in prestigious hospitals.
The marketing campaign gives no indication that treatment of debilitating, complex, and poorly understood medical conditions should be conducted under medical supervision.
The American Medical Association advises against medical journals accepting direct-to­-consumer advertisements for medical devices, even when the devices are approved by the US Food and Drug Administration.
The AMA does not even consider what we find in this PLOS One article: A spun clinical trial directly promoting an unproved medical device with a link to a shopping cart allowing payment and home delivery to be arranged. No cost to the company for the advertisement, only payment of the Article Processing Costs (APCs).
We must ask how senior PLOS management and lax editorial and review processes allow readers to be misled and exploited by a journal publishing such infomercials as peer-reviewed scientific articles, not paid advertisements.
But let’s immediately get this article retracted. See my letter to the Senior PLOS One Editor at the end of this article.
The article
Janzen TB, Paneduro D, Picard L, Gordon A, Bartel LR. “A parallel randomized controlled trial examining the effects of rhythmic sensory stimulation on fibromyalgia symptoms.” PLOS One. 2019 Mar 1;14(3):e0212021.
The abstract gives the basic design for the study:
A double-blind, two-arm parallel randomized controlled trial investigated the effects of gamma-frequency rhythmic sensory stimulation on fibromyalgia. We were interested in whether rhythmic sensory stimulation would promote significant changes in fibromyalgia and associated symptoms, and whether treatment effects would differ between two distinct treatment parameters.
A total of 50 patients who had been diagnosed with fibromyalgia were randomly assigned to two test groups.
One group received vibrotactile stimulation from a continuous sine wave single-frequency stimulation (40 Hz) for 30 minutes, five days per week, over five weeks, concomitant with usual care. The second group completed the same treatment protocol but received a different stimulation, consisting of random and intermittent complex wave gamma-range vibrotactile stimulation.
The two groups were evaluated before and after for self-reported fibromyalgia symptoms, pain severity and interference, depression symptoms, quality of life and sleep quality.
What could be seen as a clever but uncool spinning of the results:
Results indicated that there were statistically significant changes from baseline to post-treatment in measures of fibromyalgia symptom severity, pain interference, depression, and sleep quality. However, treatment outcomes did not differ significantly between groups.
The spin becomes explicit in the conclusion. The seemingly good news is great for advertising the device, but should have caused the reviewers and editor to cry foul.
These findings provide preliminary evidence that gamma-frequency rhythmic vibroacoustic stimulation may decrease fibromyalgia symptoms and ease associated comorbidities, opening new avenues for further investigation of the effects of rhythmic sensory stimulation on chronic pain conditions.
Basic study design
The presentation of the technical details of the study is linked to a picture of the device being marketed and even links to where it can be purchased.
Participants enrolled in the study were randomly assigned to one of two study arms (Fig 1). Both groups received 25 sessions of 30-minute rhythmic sensory stimulation over five weeks concomitant with usual care. Group one received vibrotactile stimulation from a continuous single-frequency sine wave at 40 Hz that was amplitude modulated on an 11-second cycle plus isochronous auditory stimulation with a 160 Hz tone amplitude modulated at 40Hz. Group two received vibrotactile stimulation from randomly intermittent sounds consisting of complex wave gamma-range noise with pitch peaks at 33 Hz and 45 Hz. In the initial trial study protocol, the stimulation delivered to group two was intended as a sham stimulation, however, careful spectral analysis of the stimulus conducted after study completion revealed that this was not the case. The stimulation was delivered via a portable consumer device (Sound Oasis Vibroacoustic Therapy System VTS-1000) with a built-in low-frequency transducer located at the middle back region and stereo speakers located at ear level (S1 Fig).
Clicking in the (S1 Fig) took the reader to a photo of the device prominently displayed at the end of the article and links to the sales page.
Portable consumer device (Sound Oasis Vibroacoustic Therapy System VTS-1000) equipped with a built-in low-frequency transducer located at the middle back region and two stereo speakers located at ear level. Source: https://www.soundoasis.com/products/sleep-sound-therapy-systems/vibroacoustic-therapy-system/
The intervention
The sound stimulus delivered to group one consisted of a continuous single-frequency sine wave at 40 Hz that was amplitude modulated on an 11-second cycle, plus isochronous auditory stimulation with a 160 Hz tone amplitude modulated at 40 Hz with secondary pitch peaks at 120 Hz and 200 Hz (Fig 2). The track has a 1-second fade-in and a 13-second fade-out, with an output level of -12.7db.
The comparison control condition
The second track, administered as stimulation to group two, comprised of randomly intermittent sounds consisting of complex wave gamma-range noise with pitch peaks at approximately 33 Hz and 45 Hz, and a secondary pitch peak at approximately 95 Hz (Fig 3). The sound was generated from a single hit on a percussion instrument (gran cassa), which generated a sound burst with a duration of 500 milliseconds. Each sound burst was separated by intervals generated by a random number generator producing numbers between 1-10. Each digit had an equivalent of 250 milliseconds; so that number 1 represented 250 milliseconds, number 2 represented 500 milliseconds, number 3 represented 750 milliseconds, and so on. These numbers were used to determine the intervals between each sound onset throughout the trial. The track was produced by arranging sound bursts separated by the random intervals until one minute of material was generated. This first minute of material was repeated four more times, but each of these five identical segments was set to a different tempo; the first minute played at 120 bpm, the second at 110, the third at 115, the fourth at 125 and the fifth 130.
Competing Interests
A competing interest statement discloses a conflict of interest, but an effort to manage it by keeping the conflicted author out of key decisions.
Authors T.B.J., D.P., L.P., and A.G. declare that no competing interests exist. L.B. declares a potential conflict of interest as he has served as a paid scientific consultant to Somerset Group and Sound Oasis, and receives limited royalties from the Somerset Group for the Sonic Aid series and from Sound Oasis on the sales of the Vibroacoustic Therapy System VTS-1000 device. To manage this potential conflict of interest, L.B. was not involved in patient recruitment, consenting, or data collection process, and had no direct role in the data analysis process. This does not alter our adherence to PLOS ONE policies on sharing data and materials.
Maybe LB was not involved in these activities, as stated. But how do we explain the alignment of the spinning of the null results in the PLOS One article with the needs of an advertising campaign for a ‘powerfully’ effective device? I do not think this declaration lets the authors off the hook for a nonstandard interpretation of the results.
The website
A click on one of the links in the PLOS One article takes one to the product page for the VTS-1000 Vibroacoustic Therapy System, just as pictured in the article, but with pricing and a full range of accessories.
I have been visiting this site over a few weeks and the “! Only one left in stock” has been there every time.
The device is described as:
Clinically Proven, Doctor Developed Sounds…The revolutionary Vibroacoustic Therapy System uses clinically proven, doctor developed sounds and vibration to help you sleep, relax and renew your body – naturally! Vibroacoustic therapy systems, costing several thousands of dollars, have been successfully used in hospitals and clinics around the world. Now you can enjoy this same therapeutic technology at a fraction of the price. Sound therapy provides soothing music with clinically proven brainwave entrainment for effective stress reduction, relaxation and healing.
Vibroacoustic research and Dr. Bartel’s TEDx talk
The webpage allows a visitor to click directly to a TEDx talk pitch for these products:
Dr. Lee Bartel’s TEDx talk at Collingwood, Ontario gives an excellent overview of the current state of vibroacoustic medical research. Dr. Bartel explains how scientifically developed sound played through Vibroacoustic devices can help reduces the symptoms of Fibromyalgia pain, Alzheimer’s Disease, Parkinson’s Disease, Depression, and increase blood flow.
The video is a classic example of a well-polished TEDx talk pitch. Lee Bartel’s requisite moment of epiphany was extracting honey on a farm in western Canada. Honey sticking to belts made them:
Go squeak squeak squeak to drive me nuts and just as inevitably a cricket would walk into the honey house and would go chirp chirp chirp… it didn’t take very long before what started as a sort of a random chirp would synchronize with the squeak on the belt. Why this was happening was a question that lingered in my head for very many years until I discovered the principle of entrainment in physics, how one rhythmic vibrating object will synchronize with another and so I used that idea and started creating music to affect your brainwaves music…

Years later, Bartel would discover a single pitch of 40 HZ would reduce pain in fibromyalgia and Alzheimer’s symptoms.
The video gives detailed clinical examples of seeming miraculous, enduring improvements in an Alzheimer’s and a fibromyalgia patient using this Vibroacoustic Therapy System. In the example of the fibromyalgia patient:
We gave her a prescription of 23 minutes of 40 Hertz sound stimulation two times a week for five weeks on this device…and what we found after five weeks was that she had stopped using all her medication. She’s reported that she could sleep much better and she was less depressed. The chiropractor checked her neck and shoulders and she had more mobility.
The effects of the sound stimulation on a patient with are given a simple explanation:
Research shows that fibromyalgia has connectivity issues between parts of the brain and then the pain circuits so the theory would be in our assumption was that 40 Hertz sound stimulation would restore this connectivity and she demonstrated that there were positive results.
The TEDx talk ends with a rousing promise of this powerful music medicine at the cellular level being integrated into routine, conventional medicine.
I could not have foreseen that the idea that came from this cricket could start to create sound that might impact cells in your body. That stimulating cells with sound can reduce the risk and impact of health problems like Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s and fibromyalgia and depression. But what I do foresee now in the not-too-distant future is that when a doctor encounters something like Alzheimer’s or Parkinson’s or depression they might take out their prescription pads and write a prescription for sound stimulation and that’s music medicine at the cellular level [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music]
The letter
I have written to Dr. Joerg Heber ([email protected]) Editor-in-Chief of PLOS One. If readers share my concerns, they might want to tell him directly.
Dear Dr. Heber:
I am writing to request a formal investigation of an article that appeared in PLOS One. I believe that a prompt retraction would be in the interest of the reputation of the journal and would protect consumers from the marketing of a dubious unproven medical device claiming dramatic effects of a 40 Hz sound on Fibromyalgia pain, Alzheimer’s Disease, and Parkinson’s Disease.
The article is
Janzen TB, Paneduro D, Picard L, Gordon A, Bartel LR. A parallel randomized controlled trial examining the effects of rhythmic sensory stimulation on fibromyalgia symptoms. PLOS One. 2019 Mar 1;14(3):e0212021.
The PLOS One article reports a RCT in which no differences were found between the active treatment of rhythmic sensory stimulation of 40 Hz Vibroacoustic Therapy System and a cleverly constructed sham treatment. Despite this being a null trial, the article focuses on the within-differences for the active treatment (no different than in the sham group) and declares the results
provide preliminary evidence that gamma-frequency rhythmic vibroacoustic stimulation may decrease fibromyalgia symptoms and ease associated comorbidities, opening new avenues for further investigation of the effects of rhythmic sensory stimulation on chronic pain conditions.
The PLOS One article contains a picture of the device that is being marketed direct to consumers and the caption to the picture is redundant with another link going directly to a product page where the VTS-1000 Vibroacoustic Therapy System is offered for $399.99, but with the admonition that there is only one device left in stock.
The website also prominently displays a TEDx talk with outlandish claims that I recommend you view.
The PLOS One article is an infomercial, part of a crass marketing of an unproven medical device to vulnerable patients and their families struggling with managing complex and poorly understood medical conditions for which conventional evidence- and science-based medicine do not offer much hope of relief.
AMA advises against medical and scientific journals accepting advertisements for medical devices, even those with FDA approval. PLOS One is now in the position of marketing an unproven device for the relatively low cost of APCs.
I hope the journal will respond promptly to this alert. I recognize that policing the quality of articles in a megajournal with ~20,000 articles published per year is a formidable task. But only a few, or even one articles displaying a few breakdowns in editorial and peer review can have substantial impact on authors and lay and professional perceptions of the trustworthiness of the journal. A prompt investigation to determine whether this article should be retracted or merely have a correction could be an important step in limiting any damage. I obvious favor a retraction.
Please let me know if I can provide further information.
Sincerely,James C. Coyne, PhD

NoteThanks to Paul Ingraham of PainScience.com for editorial assistance. I highly recommend his science-based fibromyalgia tutorial.
Note: The article was retracted.

False Balance for Homeopathy in the BMJ
Steven Novella on July 15, 2015
Link
The BMJ is a prestigious medical journal, which just goes to show that prestigious journals can sometimes make awful decisions. They recently published a pro vs con article on homeopathy. Peter Fisher dragged out the current repertoire of pro-homeopathy tropes, while Edzard Ernst did a fine job of summarizing why homeopathy is nonsense.
I also think the article is an excellent example of the difference between evidence-based medicine and science-based medicine. While EBM is led by a misguided notion of “scientific equipoise” or fairness, SBM endeavors to use all scientific knowledge to make the best judgments we can about treatments.
An SBM approach to homeopathy leads only to scathing condemnation, because it is among the purest of pseudosciences.
Ineffective treatments call for desperate measures
Fisher tries desperately to rescue the 200 year old pre-scientific notions of homeopathy, but only reveals the intellectual bankruptcy of that profession. He writes:
Homeopathy is part of a family of toxicological and pharmacological phenomena that are attracting growing interest, characterised by secondary, reverse, or paradoxical reactions to drugs or toxins as a function of dose or time or both. These include hormesis (the paradoxical, stimulatory, or beneficial effect of low doses of toxins), paradoxical pharmacology, and rebound effects.
No, it isn’t. Putting aside the legitimacy of hormesis and the question of whether or not this is clinically significant, these results depend on molecules of active ingredient doing something physiological in the body. Homeopathic potions cannot operate this way – therefore this is a false analogy.
As Ernst points out, most homeopathic preparations are diluted to the point that they do not contain any active ingredients. They are pure water.
Fisher has to further rescue his false analogy by claiming:
…basic physical research shows that the homeopathic manufacturing process changes the structure of the diluent, including the formation of nanoparticles of silica and gas.
He is playing the game of using one dubious science to support another dubious science. The existence of nanoparticles has not been established. He can only refer to a few preliminary studies of dubious quality without adequate independent replication to show that the phenomenon is real. These are the N-rays of homeopathy.
Further, there is no evidence that these dubious nanoparticles can be biologically active.
Further still, as I have pointed out before, transient anomalous phenomena of water are not a plausible explanation for a homeopathic potion. For this to be true, these miraculous nanoparticles would have to have amazing specificity – if they are to encode all of the various types of specific properties required for all the various claimed homeopathic products to work.
But even worse, they would have to maintain their properties even when placed on a sugar pill, stored in a bottle, then consumed, digested in the stomach, absorbed through the intestines, and travel through the liver and through the blood to whatever their destination is.
So, we have a questionable phenomenon (nanoparticles) that probably don’t exist that would have to have fantastical properties that defy sober speculation about how they could possibly work – and Fisher think this provides a plausible mechanism for homeopathy.
Homeopathy is magic with good PR
Let us also consider the principle of like-cures-like, which results in many fanciful starting ingredients to be diluted out of existence. There is no plausible connection between duck liver and the flu. The fact that a substance causes certain symptoms has no plausible connection to an unrelated disease process that causes superficially similar symptoms, while accounting for the patient’s personality.
This principle of homeopathy is as magical and completely devoid of evidence as astrology.
Clinical deceptions
Fisher then moves onto the clinical evidence, which he butchers. What he reveals is the astonishingly low threshold of evidence that true-believers use to support their wild theories.
In order for scientific evidence to establish convincingly that a new natural phenomenon exists we need repeatable results with a reasonable signal-to-noise ratio with adequately rigorous study design. We never get this with homeopathy.
What we get are positive results from poorly designed studies, or results that can only be produced by a particular lab, or razor thin effect sizes that look suspiciously like p-hacking – but never anything convincing.
There is a very simple and elegant explanation for this – homeopathy is bunk.
Fisher and other homeopaths, however, want to use low grade clinical evidence, like “comparative effectiveness research,” which is not controlled and not designed to test efficacy.
In essence they have built a house of cards of the weakest and worst forms of evidence possible in order to support an incredibly fantastical claim.
What are the odds that a crank physician from 200 years ago hit upon so many revolutionary ideas simultaneously, shaking the very foundations of our scientific understanding of physics, chemistry and biology, and that validation of these revolutionary ideas can only be acquired by the weakest forms of evidence, most easy to manipulate, and if you squint just right in the proper light?
It seems far more likely that homeopathy is just water, and people have a tendency to be fooled by placebo effects – something which is already very well established.
Conclusion: BMJ should be ashamed
The BMJ frankly should be ashamed of themselves. The only proper response of the scientific community to homeopathy is ridicule and outrage. It is outrageous that anyone takes homeopathy seriously. The scientific community should be united in condemning this pernicious form of pseudoscience and trying to rid humanity of this nonsense once and for all.
Giving a forum to a homeopathy apologist like Fisher, as if there is something legitimate to debate, is harmful. It legitimizes pseudoscience.

Quackery infiltrates The BMJ
As quackery in the form of “integrative medicine” has increasingly been “integrated” into medicine, medical journals are starting to notice and succumb to the temptation to decrease their skepticism. The BMJ, unfortunately, is the latest to do so. It won’t be the last.
David Gorski on May 22, 2017
Link

We here have long lamented the creeping infiltration of quackery into medical academia in which modalities once considered quackery, such as acupuncture, reiki, naturopathy, homeopathy, and various other dubious treatments, have found their way into what should be bastions of science-based medicine (SBM). Over the years, we have noted the proliferation of “integrative medicine” programs and residencies in medical academia, and professional conferences, the credulous teaching of CAM modalities as part of the normal medical school curriculum. (Georgetown University even had a program where acupuncture meridians and points were taught during gross anatomy.) Basically, CAM has been a Trojan horse for quackery in which appeals to more “humanistic” medicine and emphasis on diet and exercise have lured medical schools to bring the giant horse in, after the doors on the bellies of the Trojan horses opened to disgorge quackery such as naturopathy, homeopathy, acupuncture, reiki, and even anthroposophy.
Besides the enthusiastic embrace of quackery by large, respected academic institutions like the Cleveland Clinic and Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, this “integration” of quackery with medicine has manifested itself in medical journals. Once hard-nosed, science-based medical journals have, unfortunately, started publishing what can only be described as credulous endorsements of quackery. We’ve documented many examples of this shameful phenomena over the years, but I’m about to document a whopper of an example now in, of all places, The BMJ, which has now published two “state of the art reviews” on “integrative medicine” that can only be described as fully buying into the false paradigm that quackery needs to be “integrated” with medicine. The first “state of the art review is about the management of chronic pain using complementary and integrative medicine by Lucy Chen from the Massachusetts General Hospital Center for Translational Pain Research and Andreas Michalsen from the Institute for Social Medicine, Epidemiology and Health Economics and Immanuel Hospital in Berlin. The second is about complementary and integrative medicine in the management of headache by Denise Millstine, Christina Y Chen, and Brent Bauer, all from the Mayo Clinic. Sadly, both Harvard and the Mayo Clinic have become bastions of quackademic medicine.
The evolving language of “integrative medicine”—or whatever they’re calling it this week
One of the most striking things about both of these articles is the term their authors chose to use to describe what was once “CAM” or “integrative medicine”: “complementary and integrative medicine” (CIM). It’s an odd choice that seems a bit out of sync with what is going on in quackademic medicine these days, as I will describe. But first, let’s take a look at what I’m referring to.
Chen and Michalsen describe it thusly:
The concept of complementary and integrative medicine (CIM) encompasses both Western-style medicine and complementary health approaches as a new combined approach to treat a variety of clinical conditions. CIM may have a unique role in chronic pain management because the multidimensional nature of the pain experience requires a multimodality treatment approach. Recent advances in basic science and clinical research on CIM have substantially increased patients’ awareness about the potential therapeutic use of CIM.
Note the false dichotomy, in which “Western” (i.e., European) tradition is presented as scientific, reductionistic, and lacking in humanism, compared to “CIM,” which is the opposite.
I’ve been noticing a new step in the evolution of language about CAM, and this is another part of it. It first struck me when the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) first proposed renaming itself to the National Center for Research on Complementary and Integrative Health. The actual name NCCAM took, as we all know now, was the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH). This is just the latest iteration of rebranding quackery to try to make it respectable by calling it something else, and the BMJ articles contribute to this rebranding. Let’s look a bit at the history.
Around a quarter century or so ago, as part of a conscious effort to make quackery respectable, the term alternative medicine morphed into “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM). The process continued, such that around 15 years or so ago, the term “CAM” then “evolved” into “integrative medicine.” Each name change was an intentional use of language that served two purposes. First and foremost, the goal of CAM advocates has been for their pseudoscientific treatments like acupuncture, reiki, “functional medicine,” and the like to come to be seen by physicians and the public as legitimate medicine, rather than the rank quackery that many of them are. Second, such terms have facilitated the co-optation of real, science-based treatments (such as those involving dietary manipulation and exercise) as somehow being “alternative” or “integrative.” The reason, whether acknowledged or not, for lumping such treatments together with quackery is because “lifestyle” treatments (such as diet and weight loss for early type II diabetes) can be science-based and can work. They thus provide a patina of respectability to all the other nonsense that gets lumped together with them as “complementary” or “integrative.”
It’s telling to note how the terms evolved. I’ve discussed this in detail on several occasions over the years (most completely here), but it’s worth a brief recap. Way back in the mists of time (say, the 1980s) there was alternative medicine. Alternative medicine was (and, when the term is used, still is) medicine that does not fit into the current scientific paradigm, a term used to describe medical practices that were not supported by evidence, were ineffective and potentially harmful, and were used instead of effective therapies. Instead of giving up therapies without evidence to support them, however, alternative medicine practitioners rebranded them as “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM). Over a relatively brief period of time, the name change had its intended effect. No longer did many physicians automatically view modalities that were once considered quackery, later considered “alternative,” and now considered “CAM” as quackery, and those who still did were dismissed as close-minded, stubborn, and dogmatic, relics who were trying to stop what was clearly the future of medicine. The term “complementary”, however, soon became a problem.
Thus, back in the mists of time (say around the late 1990s to early 2000s) was born a new term: “integrative medicine.” No longer were CAM practitioners content to have their favorite quackery be “complementary” to real medicine. After all, “complementary” implied a subsidiary position. Medicine was the cake, and their wares were just the icing. That wasn’t good enough. They craved respect. They wanted to be co-equals with physicians and science- and evidence-based medicine. The term “integrative medicine” (IM) served their purpose perfectly. No longer were their treatments merely “complementary” to real medicine. The very intentional implication, was that alternative medicine was now co-equal to science- and evidence-based medicine, an equal partner in the “integrating,” and that “integrative medicine” combined the “best of both worlds” (Cue the Locutus of Borg jokes). Of course, I like to refer to such “integration” of pseudoscience into medical academia as “quackademic” medicine.
Then came the NCCIH, which broadened the term to gauzy near-meaninglessness. “Integrative health”? Just what the heck is that? Why get rid of the word “medicine”? Obviously, the intent was to expand the meaning to encompass nearly anything health-related and to further blunt any concerns that pseudoscience is being used instead of SBM (although, contrary to what CAM promoters claim, it is). Indeed, I’ve started noticing the term “integrative health” popping up more and more, supplanting “integrative medicine.”
All of this is why I find the choice of the term “CIM” to be so odd. Thus far, every step in the evolution of nomenclature for CAM or “integrative medicine” (or whatever you want to call it) has been to make it more and more indistinguishable from real medicine, to lessen its dependence on real medicine, to sell the pseudoscientific modalities embraced by integrative medicine as being co-equal with real SBM. As part of that messaging and rebranding, CAM has positioned itself as a means of “nonpharmacologically managing” pain and a large part of any potential solution to the opioid addiction epidemic, messaging that’s been going on at least five years, is part of the NCCIH’s strategic plan, and has been so successful that even the FDA is buying into it. Going from “integrative medicine” to “complementary and integrative medicine” would seem to be a step backward, a step back towards terminology in which SBM is the real medicine and “CIM” is just the icing on the cake.
Millstine et al explain it this way:
Conventional treatments, particularly drugs, are often effective in resolving acute headaches and reducing the frequency of chronic or recurrent headaches. However, many patients turn to complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) for greater improvement. CAM has evolved over time but it generally includes treatments that are not typically considered part of conventional medicine. Examples include massage therapy, acupuncture, mind-body medicine, and the use of botanicals and supplements. The distinction between CAM and conventional medicine, however, is not always clear, as is the case with several over the counter supplements now commonly recommended by conventionally trained providers, such as magnesium supplements in migraine.
However, partly as a result of research support by organizations such as the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH), a growing body of literature has shown that many CAM therapies are effective when used in conjunction with conventional care.3 This has led to the use of the more appropriate term, complementary and integrative medicine (CIM), reflecting the fact that evidence based CAM therapies are increasingly being incorporated into conventional care. The Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine and Health notes that integrative medicine “reaffirms the importance of the relationship between practitioner and patient, focuses on the whole person, is informed by evidence, and makes use of all appropriate therapeutic and lifestyle approaches, healthcare professionals and disciplines to achieve optimal health and healing.”
My head hurts after reading that. After all, the term “CAM” was originally coined to assuage the doubts of doctors who feared that alternative medicine was being used instead of conventional SBM. That was the very purpose of the term. One of the references the authors cite is an NCCIH web page entitled “Complementary Health Approaches for Chronic Pain: What the Science Says.” Let’s just say that it doesn’t really provide compelling evidence that “many CAM therapies are effective when used in conjunction with conventional care.” Even if it did, the renaming is still…curious. In essence, it does what we have been doing all along here and equates the word “integrative” with “alternative.” In essence, it almost admits to the linguistic prestidigitation that turned “complementary and alternative” to “integrative” medicine. One wonders if a lone science-based holdout editor at the BMJ forced the authors to use this term as a subtle joke. Whatever the reason for the term CIM, Edzard Ernst agrees with me that “CIM” is a nonsensical term.
But what do the articles say?
One more time: Nonpharmacologic treatments for pain ≠ CAM, CIM, or whatever it’s called
The article by Chen and Michalsen on CIM for pain is long. It clocks in at well over 18 pages, although over five of those pages are references, which brings up something that Ernst also mentioned, namely how much the authors strive to give the appearance of scholarship. After all, a lengthy references section equals strong scholarship, right? Wrong. To cite an extreme example, I can point to antivaxers who write articles with dozens of references. Indeed, one of them, Ginger Taylor, likes to list well over 100 references that supposedly support her view that vaccines cause autism. They don’t, as the articles she cites as supporting a causative role for vaccines in autism do nothing of the sort and the ones that she cites that do support a causal role are uniformly crap. No, I’m not saying that Chen and Michaelsen were that bad. I only chose the example I did as a very extreme example. I mean only to point out that quantity of references do not equal high quality science and to reinforce Ernst’s point that this article left out a whole lot of negative studies, cherry picking “only evidence for the efficacy of the treatments they promote.”
One thing that struck me about this review is that it was weighted very heavily towards either rheumatoid arthritis or studies of back or neck pain, which is not entirely unreasonable given that back and neck pain are very common. Another thing that struck me about this article right away is that it is how heavily weighted towards acupuncture it appears, with a large table of studies that supposedly establish efficacy of acupuncture for pain. Fortunately, I just wrote about acupuncture last week and a couple of weeks before that, so I don’t have to go into much detail as to why the evidence cited does not support the efficacy of acupuncture for pain. Basically, the larger and better designed the clinical trial, the less likely it is to show an effect of acupuncture above placebo. Acupuncture is theatrical placebo.
None of this stops Chen and Michalsen from enthusiastically embracing it, even buying into the multiple odd ways that acupuncturists combine acupuncture with other “treatments,” from potentially science based (electroacupuncture, which is really just transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation, or TENS, with needles) to bee venom:
Bee venom acupuncture falls into the category of herbal acupuncture, which combines the effect of bioactive compounds isolated from bee venom with acupuncture stimulation. Several meta-analyses found limited evidence assessing its effectiveness. Pain was lowered significantly more with bee venom acupuncture than saline acupuncture (n=112; weighted mean difference on 100 mm visual analog scale 14.0, 95% confidence interval 9.5 to 18.6, mm; P<0.001). However, the limited number, low quality, and small size of the RCTs make drawing conclusions difficult.73‑75
This is basically a very silly and unreliable way of administering a potentially pharmacologically active compound.
Another section of the review covers “mind-body” therapies. I always find this category problematic, because, as is the case with much “CIM,” it lumps together techniques that could be science-based, such as exercise, with other modalities that are probably not. Inevitably, the “body” part of mind-body modalities always emphasizes “exotic” forms of exercise, such as tai chi, quigong or yoga, over more mundane forms, such as walking or gentle aerobic exercise. For instance, early mobilization is recommended in the treatment of back pain now, and these forms of exercise are just more “sexy” ways of achieving that. In any event, the best that Chen and Michalsen could conclude is that yoga and tai chi might be beneficial, while the evidence for qigong was more conflicting.
Chen and Michalsen are also very much taken with supplements, herbal medicines, and dietary manipulations. For instance, they recommend the Mediterranean diet, citing a small randomized controlled trial and a larger nonrandomized controlled trial as evidence of its efficacy, both of which were thin-gruel indeed, scientifically speaking. Unfortunately, they also included a dubious dietary intervention, elimination diets:
Among a broad variety of food and nutrients that are associated with increases in disease activity, meat, milk and dairy products, wheat gluten, citrus fruit, alcohol, and coffee are ranking high.172 173 Doctors may encourage patients to find individual associations and try individual elimination after confirmation by re-challenging. Clinical research in elimination diets is difficult and complex to perform. So far, only one RCT with 53 patients has examined the concept of an elimination diet with a complex study design, including an initial washout period and specific responder analyses.188 Foods least likely to cause intolerance were reintroduced first in a stepwise manner, and any foods inducing symptoms of rheumatoid arthritis were removed from the diet. There was a significant reduction in pain with the diet in both groups during the dietary elimination phase, but differences between groups were not reported.
Elimination diets are a favorite of naturopaths who like to think that all disease is traceable to diet or various food “allergies.” It’s at best dubious and at worst quackery. (Let’s just put it this way; Gwyneth Paltrow is a fan.) Elimination diets are rarely based on properly conducted allergy testing. Indeed, the testing used to determine what foods to “eliminate” is not scientifically supported.
If you want an idea of how credulous Chen and Michalsen are, look no further than this passage:
This treatment was evaluated in a cohort study and a further prospective non-randomized comparative study. The comparative study included 86 patients with back pain and compared a complex anthroposophical therapy with the standard approach, finding comparable improvements in both groups after six and 12 months for pain, function, and quality of life.214 A longer term cohort study that assessed effects of anthroposophical medicine in 75 patients with chronic back pain found sustained benefits after two years.215 Future randomized trials are warranted.
Anthroposophic medicine is mystical hooey created by Rudolf Steiner. It’s a medical “system” (if you can call it that) that is at the bottom of a lot of quackery and antivaccine beliefs. It also encompasses biodynamic farming, which involves actions like stuffing cow manure into the horn of a cow and burying it in the autumn, leaving it to decompose during the winter, and taking crushed powdered quartz and stuffing it into a horn of a cow to bury in the spring until autumn, supposedly to control fungal diseases. You get the idea. No wonder I was so depressed when anthroposophic medicine showed up at my old alma mater.
Any review that takes anthroposophic medicine seriously is not a serious review.

All this woo is giving me a headache
The second review, by Millstine et al. suffers from many of the same issues as Chen and Michalsen’s review. For instance, it is very much as acupuncture-heavy and credulous. It even goes into auricular acupuncture, explaining it thusly:
Hand, ear, and scalp acupuncture can be more accessible than traditional acupuncture in various clinical settings. The ear holds a microsystem of the body, where stimulation of specific points on the external surface of the ear may provide therapeutic relief of symptoms that are connected to the body system (fig 2).28 Ear acupuncture, for example, can be performed quickly with the patient sitting upright and fully clothed. An RCT of 94 women with migraine without aura compared ear acupuncture in a therapeutic area with treatment in an area deemed unlikely to be beneficial. VAS was significantly reduced 10 minutes after needle insertion time and the effect lasted for two hours (P<0.001).29 Another RCT compared ear acupuncture with traditional acupuncture in 35 patients with migraine without aura. The severity of pain (using the migraine index) was reduced after eight weeks of weekly treatments; it was significantly improved from baseline and both groups were comparable after treatment and three months later (residual pain 54.83% and 63.43% for somatic and ear acupuncture, respectively). After six months residual pain was 16.80% and 48.83% for somatic and ear acupuncture, respectively (P=0.038). These results were confirmed by the visual analog scale test and by the evaluation of pain threshold.30
My brain tuned out after I read the part about the ear holding “a microsystem of the body” and how “stimulation of specific points on the external surface of the ear may provide therapeutic relief of symptoms that are connected to the body system.” Actually, my brain didn’t tune out enough not to notice that the trial cited appears to have had no sham control group and compared regular acupuncture to auricular acupuncture. I don’t have online access to the journal in which the article was published, but it also appears not to have been double-blinded. Placebo effects are therefore highly suspected as the reason for the results. (Yes, this appears to have been a comparative effectiveness trial.) Back to the silliness of ear acupuncture. Remember, auricular acupuncture basically assumes a homunculus on the ear whose parts map to organs and other body parts. It is just as scientific as reflexology, and reflexology is utter pseudoscience. Millstine et al. leave out the homunculus, but they do include an illustration of an ear that shows parts of the ear mapping to the same parts that the traditionally drawn homunculus does. Despite its utter pseudoscience, unfortunately there are military advocates who are successfully integrating auricular acupuncture into the treatment of wounded soldiers as “battlefield acupuncture.” It’s been a wildly successful effort, unfortunately.
The rest of the review reads very much like that of Chen and Michalsen, listing “mind-body” interventions, botanicals, diet, and the like, with very little compelling evidence presented for efficacy and no mention at all of the extreme implausibility of so many of the treatments. In doing so, Millstine et al. propagate the idea that there’s something about diet and exercise that is somehow “integrative” or “complementary” when dietary interventions and exercise, when used in a manner supported by sound science and evidence, are just medicine.
None of this stops Millstine et al. from concluding:
The use of CIM therapies has the potential to empower patients and help them take an active role in their care.90 91 Many CIM modalities, including mind-body therapies, are both self selected and self administered after an education period. This, coupled with patients’ increased desire to incorporate integrative medicine, should prompt healthcare providers to consider and discuss its inclusion in the overall management strategy.
Wait a minute. The evidence base for CIM strategies for migraine is low quality, but providers should recommend it because they “empower” patients and help them take an active role in their care? What a false dichotomy! Empowering patients and getting them to take a more active role in their own care do not require prescribing unscientific treatments with no compelling evidence for their efficacy. In other words, accepting quackery does not equal “patient-centered” care or “empowering” patients. These desirable outcomes can and should be achieved while recommending science-based medicine.
Count The BMJ among the fallen
With the increasing infiltration of quackery into medicine in the form of CAM, or “integrative medicine,” or “CIM,” or whatever you want to call it, we are seeing more and more journals succumb to the temptation to publish nonsense like these two review articles that appeared in The BMJ. In this case, it’s particularly puzzling, given how The BMJ has a history of publishing articles decrying the overhyping of acupuncture and warning about acupuncture-transmitted infections and potentially serious adverse events. It’s also published articles with titles like “The scam of integrative medicine“, “Integrative medicine and the point of credulity“, and “Doctors warn of dangers of complementary medicine for children.” It has also published credulous articles as well, but seldom, as far as I can tell, as “systematic reviews” as obviously biased as these two are.
Prof. Ernst is justifiably unhappy. As he says, The BMJ used to be a good journal. What is happening? Sadly, I think I know. The tide of pseudoscience that has been rising over the last quarter century has simply engulfed The BMJ too. At least in this case there has been some pushback, but I fear it will be short lived. In the meantime, I eagerly await The BMJ‘s next systematic review on the use of CIM to treat patients with a vague sense of unease or a touch of the nerves or even just more money than sense. I’m sure it will be equally positive as the reviews by Chen and Michalsen and Millstine et al.

What the heck happened to The BMJ?
Last week, The BMJ published an “exposé” by Paul Thacker alleging patient unblinding, data falsification, and other wrongdoing by a company running three sites for the massive clinical trial of the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine. It was a highly biased story embraced by antivaxxers, with a deceptively framed narrative and claims not placed into proper context, leading me to look into the broader question: What the heck happened to The BMJ?
David Gorski on November 8, 2021
Link
The British Medical Journal (now The BMJ) is one of the oldest and most respected medical journals in the world that also has a history of publishing some excellent investigative journalism. For instance, over a decade ago, it was The BMJ that published investigative journalist Brian Deer’s articles recounting the strong evidence indicating that Wakefield’s case series published in The Lancet that linked the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine to autism was based on fraud. That study launched the modern iteration of the antivaccine movement and is, as I like to say, the study that launched a thousand quackeries directed at autistic children to “cure” them of their “vaccine-induced autism.” The headline of Deer’s accompanying commentary after his account of how the “case against the MMR was fixed” even referred to Wakefield’s study as “Piltdown medicine“, after the infamous Piltdown Man fraud.
Unfortunately, more recently the investigative journalism coming from The BMJ has left a lot to be desired, and I say this even though The BMJ recently published a commentary co-authored by Gavin Yamey and me about the Great Barrington Declaration and the new “merchants of doubt“. Indeed, I almost felt a reluctance to write this post, as it felt a bit like biting the hand that feeds, but after seeing an article published by The BMJ last week I felt that I had no choice. The article was by investigative journalist turned anti-GMO muckraking crank Paul Thacker and was titled “Covid-19: Researcher blows the whistle on data integrity issues in Pfizer’s vaccine trial“. It’s an article that, since its publication last Tuesday, has been widely cited and shared by a wide variety of antivaxxers in order to portray the clinical trial of the Pfizer vaccine that led to its emergency use authorization (EUA) in the US as hopelessly corrupt. Here are a few examples from Twitter:
Wait till everybody finds out about the vaxxes Pfizer are alleged to have given to a placebo group in the tests, to make it look like the adverse events were normal when they were suffered by both groups in the #RiggedTrials.https://t.co/Z2sVflFINY
— Michael O'Bernicia (@TheBernician) November 2, 2021
Whistleblower report on Pfizer’s pivotal phase III trial:
– data falsified– unblinding of patients – untrained vaccinators– slow to follow up on adverse events– quality control staff overwhelmed by problems– whistleblower fired after warning the FDAhttps://t.co/95y4nHYXpu
— Klaus K (@KlausKblog) November 6, 2021
COVID-19 vaccines are effective at reducing the risk of severe illness, hospitalization & death. There are also concerns about uncommon but underreported adverse events, some data quality, & suppression of politically unpopular perspectives. https://t.co/Noq6I2n2ZC
— Joseph A. Ladapo, MD, PhD (@FLSurgeonGen) November 4, 2021
That last Tweet comes from Dr. Joseph Ladapo, Gov. Ron DeSantis’ selection to head up the Florida Department of Health, whom Jann Bellamy discussed in September. He’s a member of “America’s Frontline Doctors” who, in addition to supporting a “natural herd immunity” approach to the pandemic, has openly opposed mask and vaccine mandates, while echoing antivax talking points.
If you don’t believe me about how much antivaxxers have embraced Thacker’s work, take a look at Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s antivax Children’s Health Defense website, which republished Thacker’s report verbatim under the terms of the under the terms of the Creative Commons BY NC license used by The BMJ. Interestingly, Children’s Health Defense even features an “author page” for Thacker that, if you don’t look closely enough, could give the false impression that he had written the article for Children’s Health Defense. From this author’s page, one can see that Thacker wrote two other articles for The BMJ that were republished, both demonstrating that he clearly buys into the conspiracy theories surrounding the “lab leak” hypothesis for the origins of COVID-19. Perusing The BMJ‘s site itself, one can see that Thacker is a regular contributor and there are more articles about the “lab leak” hypothesis that Children’s Health Defense didn’t republish.
For this post, I’m going to focus primarily on the article about the Pfizer clinical trial because it is the one that most resembles actual journalism, albeit just barely given that its sourcing is a bit sketchy and its framing is relentlessly one-sided and clearly designed to leave the reader with exactly the sort of message that antivaxxers are taking from it, namely that Pfizer is corrupt and was careless about oversight of the massive clinical trial of its COVID-19 vaccine in 2020. Thacker’s articles about the “lab leak” hypothesis published in The BMJ in general don’t even try to resemble investigative journalism (not that I won’t briefly cover them). Basically, it’s hard not to wonder what the heck has happened to The BMJ, in much the same way I recently wondered what the heck happened to John Ioannidis, a scientist whom I used to admire greatly until his turn into COVID-19 contrarianism and minimization.
I will also preface the remainder of the post by emphasizing that, if Thacker’s report is accurate, there did appear to be some significant problems with the three sites in Texas managed by Ventavia, the company that ran the clinical trials. However, the overall impression given by the article is that the entire enterprise should now be questioned, Thacker’s Competing Interests statement that he “has been doubly vaccinated with Pfizer’s vaccine” notwithstanding. In other words, narrative matters. Context matters. Framing matters. Everything about Thacker’s article frames the clinical trial and Pfizer in the worst possible light. It’s almost as though the report is custom-made to provide grist for antivax conspiracy theories, and it definitely succeeds at doing just that. Whatever good some of the report might do, that The BMJ commissioned this report and failed in its “fact checking” to realize that every good propagandist knows how to spin verified facts into deceptive narrative does not speak well of what has happened to the journal, particularly in light of other articles it has published.
Thacker’s whistleblower report on Ventavia and Pfizer
I will begin by discussing what Thacker reports in his article, starting with this framing right at the beginning of the report, and I will quote liberally citing the same Creative Commons license that Children’s Health Defense cited when it republished the article in its entirety:
In autumn 2020 Pfizer’s chairman and chief executive, Albert Bourla, released an open letter to the billions of people around the world who were investing their hopes in a safe and effective covid-19 vaccine to end the pandemic. “As I’ve said before, we are operating at the speed of science,” Bourla wrote, explaining to the public when they could expect a Pfizer vaccine to be authorised in the United States.
But, for researchers who were testing Pfizer’s vaccine at several sites in Texas during that autumn, speed may have come at the cost of data integrity and patient safety. A regional director who was employed at the research organisation Ventavia Research Group has told The BMJ that the company falsified data, unblinded patients, employed inadequately trained vaccinators, and was slow to follow up on adverse events reported in Pfizer’s pivotal phase III trial. Staff who conducted quality control checks were overwhelmed by the volume of problems they were finding. After repeatedly notifying Ventavia of these problems, the regional director, Brook Jackson, emailed a complaint to the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Ventavia fired her later the same day. Jackson has provided The BMJ with dozens of internal company documents, photos, audio recordings, and emails.
Notice the framing. Contrary to Bourla’s statement, the narrative goes, “several” (three, actually, as it turns out) sites in Texas run by Ventavia were supposedly flouting clinical trial safety and unblinding patients, but an intrepid whistleblower reported them. Whistleblower narratives can be valuable, but they can also be potentially misleading, particularly when used as grist for a report by someone like Thacker. After all, whistleblowers often have their own axes to grind. That characteristic in and of itself is not a reason to dismiss (or not to protect) whistleblowers, but it is a reason to be cautious about basing conclusions on their claims alone, particularly a whistleblower who was employed by the company for just two weeks, as was the case with Jackson.
Similarly, when evaluating reports of problems with the conduct of a clinical trial, it is important to consider the actual details and context of the reported violations. In this case, Thacker mixes reports from Jackson that might have impacted trial data and safety with reports that could not possibly have. More than that, Thacker gleefully mixes the two, starting thusly in the more detailed discussion of his findings:
Exasperated that Ventavia was not dealing with the problems, Jackson documented several matters late one night, taking photos on her mobile phone. One photo, provided to The BMJ, showed needles discarded in a plastic biohazard bag instead of a sharps container box.
So apparently Ventavia was careless about disposing of sharps. That’s definitely sloppy lab practice, if it happened, although I feel obligated to point out that we don’t know if this was one screwup or a common problem. Either way, Ventavia’s handling of sharps couldn’t possibly have affected the results of the clinical trial and is more a concern of OSHA violation than any concern that the FDA should look into that could have resulted in data compromise or compromise of the safety of patients. It’s interesting to me that Thacker chose to lead with this tidbit in the section after his introduction, when he started to go into more detail about his more general charges listed in the introduction, given that it has nothing to do with data integrity. I understand that he’s trying to frame the story as one of poor laboratory management, but, really, this accusation seems to have been inserted at the beginning in order to provide what I like to call a “Yuck!” factor, to get the reader to feel disgust on a visceral level towards the company, before going into the more mundane and difficult-to-explain issues of clinical trial management. It’s a very transparently manipulative framing tactic akin to how Thacker likes to paint genetically modified organisms (GMOs) as “unnatural” and “Frankenfood”.
The “yuck” factor having been established, Thacker then continues:
Early and inadvertent unblinding may have occurred on a far wider scale. According to the trial’s design, unblinded staff were responsible for preparing and administering the study drug (Pfizer’s vaccine or a placebo). This was to be done to preserve the blinding of trial participants and all other site staff, including the principal investigator. However, at Ventavia, Jackson told The BMJ that drug assignment confirmation printouts were being left in participants’ charts, accessible to blinded personnel. As a corrective action taken in September, two months into trial recruitment and with around 1000 participants already enrolled, quality assurance checklists were updated with instructions for staff to remove drug assignments from charts.
Notice the contrast between what Thacker writes in the introduction, in which he claims that Ventavia unblinded patients, not that “inadvertent unblinding may have occurred”. There’s a huge difference between the two. Think about it. Leaving the printouts in patient’s charts might have compromised blinding in some cases and was definitely a sloppy practice (and was corrected), but Thacker quite noticeably presents zero evidence that unblinding ever actually occurred, despite stating unequivocally right at the beginning of the article that patients were “unblinded”. Which message do you think that readers will come away with, the one saying that Ventavia definitely unblinded patients or the one saying that unblinding “may have” happened?
I find it even more telling that the scope of problem is not mentioned until more than halfway into the report, where it’s revealed that Ventavia ran three sites in Texas out of the 153 total clinical sites participating in the Pfizer trial and signed up a small fraction (~1,000 by the time the whistleblower was fired) of the trial’s over ~44,000 subjects. Note again the framing, “Early and inadvertent blinding may have occurred on a far larger scale”. This is clearly meant to imply more than just the Ventavia sites, given the context. Of course, Thacker reports almost as an afterthought that appropriate corrective measures were eventually instituted at this one site. One could certainly argue that Ventavia took longer to institute these corrective policies than it should have, but, even so, when I looked at the details of the actual claims made they do not support the insinuation that wide-scale inadvertent unblinding had occurred in the Pfizer trial.
Thacker does something even more deceptive as well. According to an anonymous source:
After Jackson left the company problems persisted at Ventavia, this employee said. In several cases Ventavia lacked enough employees to swab all trial participants who reported covid-like symptoms, to test for infection. Laboratory confirmed symptomatic covid-19 was the trial’s primary endpoint, the employee noted. (An FDA review memorandum released in August this year states that across the full trial swabs were not taken from 477 people with suspected cases of symptomatic covid-19.)
“I don’t think it was good clean data,” the employee said of the data Ventavia generated for the Pfizer trial. “It’s a crazy mess.”
Again, note the juxtaposition. These 477 patients who reported COVID-19 symptoms but never received nasal swabs were across the entire trial of well over 40,000 subjects, but the way it’s phrased, not put into context of the size of the entire trial, makes this sound like a huge number. As has been pointed out, though, this is deceptive framing that leaves out some very important information:
What @thackerpd didn't mention: The share of non-tested trial participants was very similar in the treatment and the placebo groups (9.2% vs 10.1%), and a sensitivity check was done on this issue. https://t.co/7g4B3AUqyG pic.twitter.com/q3DDySb2KG
— Andreas B (@AndreasShrugged) November 3, 2021
In other words, the FDA and Pfizer did the appropriate analysis and demonstrated that the missing PCR test results for SARS-CoV-2 were similar in both the control and experimental groups and that excluding them had minimal effect on the estimated vaccine efficiency found by the trial. One would think that this would be an incredibly important thing to mention in order to put the figure of 477 people with COVID-19 symptoms within seven days of a dose who were not tested into proper context. Thacker’s implication that these 477 cases had an impact on the results of the trial is a big nothingburger that Thacker tries to turn into a gourmet double-decker burger of doubt.
Let’s look at some of the other charges from the whistleblower, listed in Thacker’s report in addition to the two main charges of “unblinding” (which might have happened, but Thacker never establishes to have actually happened and, if it ever did, what the frequency was) and failure to swab every subject who reported COVID-19 symptoms:
    • Participants placed in a hallway after injection and not being monitored by clinical staff
    • Lack of timely follow-up of patients who experienced adverse events
    • Protocol deviations not being reported
    • Vaccines not being stored at proper temperatures
    • Mislabelled laboratory specimens, and
    • Targeting of Ventavia staff for reporting these types of problems.
I’ll deal with the mislabeling of specimens first because it’s the easiest. This is the only place where Thacker makes this claim. A common theme you’ll be hearing from me is that details matter, and Thacker’s piece is notably lacking in details. How many specimens? What was the specific mislabeling? Without knowing these details, there is no way to determine how serious the problem was or if it could possibly have affected the clinical trial data significantly. Think of it this way. There’s a huge difference between one or two (or a handful of) specimens being mislabeled and the error caught and corrected and large numbers of specimens mislabeled so that they became useless because there was insufficient information to allow the investigators to correct the mislabeling. Which happened? We don’t know. Thacker doesn’t tell us. He just tells us it was awful.
Now, let’s move on to the first claim on the list (participants in the hallway). That is obviously less than ideal, even if it happened only once, but, again, details matter. Thacker never reports how often this happened or how many subjects were treated this way. He seems to imply that subjects were left standing in the hallway (or maybe I’m reading too much into this). Were there chairs? Again, this would have been less than ideal, particularly if monitoring was lax, but Thacker gives no details to let me as someone who’s dealt with clinical trials over his career come to a judgment. Moreover, even if this did happen, it would have been incredibly unlikely that it affected the results of the trial from these sites.
The next example is also curious. Thacker states that his whistleblower reported that Ventavia staff were “slow to follow up on adverse events”, but these are the only two examples that he could apparently find:
Ventavia was not keeping up with data entry queries, shows an email sent by ICON, the contract research organisation with which Pfizer partnered on the trial. ICON reminded Ventavia in a September 2020 email: “The expectation for this study is that all queries are addressed within 24hrs.” ICON then highlighted over 100 outstanding queries older than three days in yellow. Examples included two individuals for which “Subject has reported with Severe symptoms/reactions … Per protocol, subjects experiencing Grade 3 local reactions should be contacted. Please confirm if an UNPLANNED CONTACT was made and update the corresponding form as appropriate.” According to the trial protocol a telephone contact should have occurred “to ascertain further details and determine whether a site visit is clinically indicated.”
Again, coming back to my theme, details matter, and I bet that Thacker knows that a Grade 3 local reaction sounds horrible to the average reader, who won’t know what it is. In fact, a grade 3 local reaction is just that, local. Vaccine reaction grades, both local and systemic, are defined in this document, with a Grade 3 local reaction to the injection being a one that meets certain criteria; e.g., requiring the use of narcotics for pain, being greater than 10 cm in diameter, causing significant discomfort at rest that interferes with daily activities, association with a high fever or heart rate, and the like. These are not potentially life-threatening reactions and do not require hospitalization. (If they did require hospitalization or were life-threatening, that would automatically upgrade them to Grade 4.) While it’s obviously less than ideal that it took more than 24 hours to contact these patients, failure to do so for two patients is not such an incredible lapse that it invalidates the trial or is consistent with patients being endangered by the trial.
Regarding Thacker’s report of protocol deviations not being reported, I’m a bit confused, given this passage:
Documents show that problems had been going on for weeks. In a list of “action items” circulated among Ventavia leaders in early August 2020, shortly after the trial began and before Jackson’s hiring, a Ventavia executive identified three site staff members with whom to “Go over e-diary issue/falsifying data, etc.” One of them was “verbally counseled for changing data and not noting late entry,” a note indicates.
At several points during the late September meeting Jackson and the Ventavia executives discussed the possibility of the FDA showing up for an inspection (box 1). “We’re going to get some kind of letter of information at least, when the FDA gets here . . . know it,” an executive stated.
It sounds as though protocol violations were reported to the company, which took corrective action. You can argue if it acted fast enough or was tough enough on the staff involved, but I’m getting mixed messages here.
I also note that, although Thacker claims that Ventavia “falsified data” in the very introduction of his report, this is the only mention of “falsifying data” that occurs anywhere else. There is no description of any specific incidents of “falsifying data” listed, only a memo mentioning three staff members, one of whom was apparently counseled about “changing data and not noting late entry.” One also notes that this memo comes from early August 2020, shortly after the trial began, which means that Ventavia intervened before that many patients could have been signed up. This is truly thin gruel to make sensationalistic claims about “falsifying data” in the introduction in such a way as to make it sound as though the practice was widespread. Basically, we don’t know if falsification occurred, if it occurred how often it occurred, or what the specific “falsifications” were. Indeed, the phrasing of the memo could have indicated that the changing of data, which could have been the correction of errors for all we know, and not noting a late entry could have been discussed in the context of how even minor violations like that could be interpreted as falsifying data. Again, we just don’t know, and Thacker doesn’t tell because he doesn’t have evidence. (If he did, you know he would have cited more than just a cherry picked quote from a memo, which is very thin gruel indeed to base a charge of “data falsification” on.)
As for vaccines not being stored at the appropriate temperature, the Pfizer vaccine needed to be stored at -70°C (and was known at the time to be good for at least six months at that temperature), thus requiring either a -80°C freezer or dry ice. Once it’s thawed, the vaccine was reportedly at the time good for five days in a refrigerator. Knowing these parameters, details (of which Thacker provides none) matter. How far off were the temperatures? For how long? How many doses of vaccine were involved? If, for example, a single vial of vaccine were left out on the bench at room temperature for several hours, that would be a rather trivial violation compared to the situation where a whole shipment was stored in, for instance, a standard -20°C freezer rather than a -80°C freezer. We have no way of knowing how serious or prevalent this problem was. More importantly, Thacker doesn’t report whether the vaccines stored at an incorrect temperature were ever administered to clinical trial subjects or whether they were discarded, which matters a whole heck of a lot when it comes to vaccine trial safety and efficacy, particularly given that administering such vaccines would actually result in a lower vaccine efficacy because presumably they would lose potency the longer they were stored at too warm a temperature. Leave it to Thacker, though, to make it seem as though huge numbers of vaccine doses were messed up by being improperly stored.
The last item in Thacker’s list, if true, is the most damning charge, that Ventavia targeted employees for speaking out. It’s hard to tell if this were truly the case with Brook Jackson, but I will concede that the optics aren’t great. On the other hand, Thacker reports that Ventavia fired her the same day that she sent a complaint to the FDA detailing her concerns. It’s unlikely that the FDA contacted the company the same day of a complaint. (The FDA generally doesn’t move that fast.) Yet, Thacker goes out of his way to imply that the reason she was fired is that she ratted out Ventavia to the FDA. Similarly, it’s a bit disturbing that none of the Ventavia sites were among the sites audited by the FDA. On the other hand, there are always minor errors in trials of this size, particularly when they’re undertaken in haste, as the vaccine trials were in the middle of a pandemic. It’s impossible to know if the problems at Ventavia sites reported by Thacker rise to the level that they could have impacted the results from that site to a significant degree.
In the end, we’re left with a lot of smoke, but no clear fire. There clearly were some problems with Ventavia, which ran three clinical trial sites and signed up a small fraction of the total clinical trial subjects for the entire trial. Again, that’s not good. We have Brook Jackson and an anonymous source claiming that the environment at Ventavia was beyond the pale compared to previous places where they’d worked, coupled vaguely described incidents and allegations without even good examples or estimates of how prevalent the problem was. It’s also reported that Pfizer did audit the company and was apparently sufficiently satisfied to use it again. Of course, to Thacker, Pfizer (or any other large pharmaceutical company) is pure evil; so you can’t trust that. I would counter that, if one site’s data were so unreliable due to problems of the sort that Thacker reported, then pure profit motive would provide a strong reason for a pharmaceutical company to cut that company loose, rather than risk the FDA ever finding out.
None of this is to say that nothing should be done. Assuming that Thacker’s allegations are not a huge exaggeration, at the very least an FDA audit would be a good idea. At the very worst, even though it’s standard practice to do sensitivity analyses to look for variation in results, protocol deviations, failure to do follow-up testing, etc., between sites in a large clinical trial like this, in the worst case scenario, the data from the subjects enrolled at Ventavia sites could be excluded and the rest of the subjects reanalyzed. My guess is that, even if this most extreme step were to be undertaken, it would make minimal difference in the results of the trial.
Basically, Thacker takes fairly uncontroversial observations (e.g., that the FDA is underfunded and doesn’t audit sites as often as it should, something I’ve noted multiple times in my posts for SBM about cancer quack Stanislaw Burzynski and his bogus clinical trials, for instance) and combines them with vague reports of what are probably mostly minor violations played up as huge, impactful violations:
addressed within 24 hours? That’s a good one. I’m not going to mention what my average used to be 😂
The one good point it raises is that FDA is severely underresourced. There’s no doubt there. 2/
— Jason Gallagher (@JGPharmD) November 2, 2021
Again, the most disturbing thing about the report is the question of whether Ventavia did, in fact, retaliate against Jackson for her having agitated about problems at the site, even if the timeline suggests that it’s probably impossible for her having reported her concerns to the FDA to have been the reason she was fired. If that’s the case, then there should be an investigation and harsh penalties applied to Ventavia. The rest of the report is just Thacker being Thacker, trying to turn a molehill into the proverbial mountain, as long as it fulfills his purpose of demonizing big pharma.
What the heck happened to The BMJ?
If Thacker’s muckraking (and not in a good way) report on Ventavia were the only example of The BMJ going wrong, it wouldn’t be such a big deal. Every publication makes missteps from time to time, and no editor’s judgment is perfect. Sometimes otherwise solid publications screw up. It happens. Unfortunately, this is part of a pattern.
I first noted inklings of unease with The BMJ in 2017, when it published a couple of rather credulous “state of the art” reviews on “integrative medicine,” specifically, about using such “integration” of quackery with real medicine to treat chronic pain and headache. Again, these could have been missteps. It’s not as though The BMJ is the only respected medical journal to have published nonsense about “integrative medicine”. It is, sadly, a thing these days. Unfortunately, though, there is the case of Peter Doshi.
The first time I can recall ever having mentioned Peter Doshi was in 2009, when he spoke at an antivaccine conference hosted by Barbara Loe Fisher’s National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC) and, when contacted about it, responded with a transparent, “my speaking there does not imply endorsement”. (Remember that 2009 was the year when the H1N1 influenza pandemic was bearing down on us and that at the time Doshi had been fear mongering about the flu vaccine and questioning its efficacy.) Since then, he’s been nothing if not consistent. While all the while claiming he’s “not antivaccine”, he’s parroted more than a few antivaccine talking points himself while trying to portray himself as an authority on influenza and the flu vaccine. Through it all, he’s played the “victim” card that people who are borderline antivaccine or antivaccine love to play, claiming that they are “just asking questions” and that anyone who “questions” vaccines is labeled, in a knee-jerk fashion, “antivaccine”. In fact, Doshi’s borderline antivaccine stylings go back further than 2009, when senior pseudonymous epidemiologist whose blog I used to read religiously back then chastised him for an “unhelpful” commentary in which Doshi had claimed that estimates for yearly influenza deaths were “grossly inflated.” That was 2006.
Since then, Peter Doshi somehow managed to become an associate editor of The BMJ. How this happened, I have no idea, but periodically he publishes posts for The BMJ that are—to put it kindly—far below the standards that a medical journal with the history of The BMJ should ever associate itself with. Early this year, for instance, he published one more such blog post entitled, Pfizer and Moderna’s “95% effective” vaccines—we need more details and the raw data. It was a post custom designed to try to claim that Pfizer and Moderna had exaggerated the efficacy of their vaccines through some statistical prestidigitation. He also called for the “raw data,” echoing a Thacker technique of cloaking dubious claims in issues that almost everyone can agree on, such as transparency in clinical trials. (John Skylar and Skeptical Raptor also discussed the deception behind his articles.) Doshi once also bought into a truly risible conspiracy theory about the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) that I hadn’t even seen from antivaxxers. There was much mockery. More recently, Doshi published more misinformation in The BMJ about COVID-19 vaccines, claiming that there was “no biodistribution data” (even though there was and biodistribution data aren’t required for vaccines anyway) and insinuating that the trials had been unblinded earlier this year not out of ethical concerns about leaving the subjects in the placebo group susceptible to a potentially deadly pandemic disease, but rather to hide differences in adverse events between the groups and to facilitate the ability of businesses and local governments to mandate COVID-19 vaccines not yet approved by the FDA but only available under an EUA. (I wrote about the issue of unblinding the Pfizer and Moderna clinical trials in April. Suffice to say that it’s a complex issue of clinical trial ethics and science, far more so than what Doshi implies.)
Indeed, Doshi has history of playing footsie with the antivaccine movement, amplifying antivaccine conspiracy theories, downplaying the severity of influenza and thus feeding antivaccine narratives, using sleight-of-hand to downplay the effectiveness of flu vaccines, and generally playing the role of a false skeptic with respect to vaccines. At this point, I can’t help but note that Doshi also once signed a petition “questioning” whether HIV causes AIDS. When called out on it by Steve Salzberg, he responded disingenuously:
On the question of signing the HIV/AIDS petition, Doshi responded that “Seeing how my name was published and people have misconstrued this as some kind of endorsement, I have written the list owner and asked for my name to be removed.” He declined to state directly that he agrees that the HIV virus causes AIDS—though I gave him ample opportunity.
Here’s what Peter Doshi signed and then only asked for his signature to be removed from the document after being publicly called out. It’s a petition “questioning” the hypothesis that HIV causes AIDS, and the Wayback Machine shows his name in the list of signatories.
No surprise, Peter Doshi has his own author page over at RFK Jr.’s Children’s Health Defense of articles republished from The BMJ under a Creative Commons license, his most recent “contribution” being an op-ed in which he laments calls for state medical boards and medical specialty boards to take action against the medical licenses and board certifications, respectively, of physicians spreading COVID-19 misinformation. Let’s just say that we at SBM disagree strongly and, if anything, think that state medical boards have not gone nearly far enough to protect the public.
It goes beyond that, though. Peter Doshi actively has actively allied himself with Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. For instance, he served as one of the expert witnesses last year for the plaintiffs in Children’s Health Defense’s lawsuit against the University of California opposing its flu vaccine mandate:
Currently hand in glove with Children’s Health Defense…Acting as a sort of “expert witness” for their injunction.https://t.co/tz8PbiY6OV pic.twitter.com/jIZTpNv8wL
— Rosewind (@Rosewind2007) January 20, 2021
More recently, there’s been this:
Here is is as well:
For those of you not familiar with him, Ivor Cummins, a.k.a. “The Fat Emperor,” is one of the more famous COVID-19 contrarians, and his approval should be a red flag right there. That’s right. Peter Doshi testified before Senator Ron Johnson’s panel on COVID-19 a week ago, ostensibly about “COVID-19 vaccine injuries and mandates“. We’ve met Sen. Johnson before in the context of his promotion of dangerous “right-to-try” legislation. Since the pandemic, he has, predictably and like so much of the rest of the Republican Party, pivoted to become a COVID-19 pandemic minimizer and an opponent of COVID-19 vaccine mandates to the point of parroting antivaccine talking points. In his testimony, Doshi denies that this is a “pandemic of the unvaccinated,” citing a report from July from the UK that most hospitalizations are among the fully vaccinated. It turns out that this report was in error, substituting “vaccinated” for “unvaccinated” and the majority of hospitalizations were among the unvaccinated, even though they made up only 31% of the population at the time. He even cites cherry-picked tables to claim that the vaccine doesn’t save lives in what is basically an updated rehash of the nonsense he peddled in May (also deconstructed by Dr. Hilda Bastian). In a truly risible moment, he even cites the Merriam-Webster definition of “antivaxxer” as opposed to those supposedly opposed to mandates to argue that he and his fellow COVID-19 contrarians are “not antivaccine” and that large numbers of people would qualify as “antivaccine”. He even parrots the antivaccine talking point that mRNA vaccines are not really vaccines and therefore shouldn’t be mandated like vaccines. I kid you not.
I was flabbergasted. I knew Doshi was bad. I’ve known it since 2009. However, until I saw this video clip even I never realized he was this bad. I used to say that Doshi was not antivaccine. I’m no longer so sure and am leaning towards believing that he is antivaccine, based on his long history on the H1N1 vaccine, other vaccines, and finally the COVID-19 vaccines. Indeed, at the very least I have to agree with Dr. Zoë McLaren:
The BMJ has been regularly publishing fodder for anti-vaxxers. Appears that Peter Doshi is the reason why. @amymaxmen @jeremyfaust @GYamey @eliowa https://t.co/eFr60KiDIW
— Zoë McLaren, Ph.D. (@ZoeMcLaren) November 5, 2021
In the meantime, Paul Thacker has published some doozies of conspiracy mongering articles about the “lab leak” hypothesis of SARS-CoV-2 origins.(He even bought into a narrative beloved of cranks that discussion of the origins of the pandemic has been “suppressed” by labeling any discussion of lab leak hypotheses as a “conspiracy theory”, referring to it as a “conspiracy to label critics as conspiracy theorists.” (Meanwhile, on his own Substack, he explicitly buys into the “Fauci lied” narrative spread by US Sen. Rand Paul and right wing media.) I don’t want to go into detail about these conspiracy theories, given that I’ve discussed them before, other than to say that, recent news reports of “gain of function” notwithstanding, it is still incredibly unlikely—arguably impossible, even—that SARS-CoV-2 was engineered in a laboratory, be it in Wuhan, China, where the pandemic appears to have originated or anywhere else. It is only slightly more likely than that that COVID-19 could have arisen due to the escape of a natural coronavirus being studied in a laboratory, but a natural origin due to a “spillover event” from an animal reservoir (most likely bats) remains far, far more likely than the incredibly unlikely possibility of a lab leak of a “gain-of-function” engineered coronavirus or a natural bat coronavirus being studied causing the pandemic.
Finally, before I conclude it is necessary to recount a bit of Paul Thacker’s history. Besides being known for promulgating anti-GMO conspiracy theories, this is a “journalist” who is known for using abusive Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests in order to harass scientists, in particular Kevin Folta. More recently, Steve Novella discussed how Thacker attacked him (and me) as “vaccine cheerleaders” based on our supposed denial and downplaying of potential complications due to the Johnson & Johnson COVID-19 vaccines. Thacker was, as usual, peddling nonsense, of course, because neither Steve nor I (nor other science bloggers targeted by him) had actually denied or tried to “sweep under the rug” the clotting complications being reported for that vaccine last spring. Rather, we had adopted a “wait and see” approach given the relative rarity of the complication reported. It didn’t take us long to acknowledge that the specific clotting problem attributed to the vaccine was very likely in rare cases caused by the vaccine. Thacker, as usual, misrepresented caution for “vaccine cheerleading” and denial that vaccines could ever cause harm. It’s what he does and why I expect that I will soon be subjected to yet another article by Thacker smearing me. It’s coming. I’m willing to endure it, though, if this post forces Thacker to publish more of the evidence behind his article and provide at least some of the details enumerated above that were missing, so that I can at least have a shot at judging the actual severity of the allegations made by his whistleblower. Right now, I just can’t, and certainly I know not to take Thacker’s word for anything.
Too bad that The BMJ doesn’t know that.
Sadly, I can now see a bit more why The BMJ has fallen so far, at least in its reporting, if not the science it publishes. Its editor-in-chief, Fiona Godlee, recently echoed Thacker’s conspiracy mongering in an official editorial for The BMJ, calling for a “full and open independent investigation” into the origins of SARs-CoV-2:
But, as Paul Thacker explains (doi:10.1136/bmj.n1656), suppression of the lab leak theory was not based on any clear evaluation of the science. Indeed, it happened despite no good counter-evidence for the alternative: natural spillover from animals to humans. Instead the lab leak theory sank under the weight of a concerted campaign by heavily conflicted scientists, leading to a “year of biased, failed reporting” by science journalists and journals. Now, thanks to the seismic shift in US politics and some dogged and fearless journalism, the theory is emerging from the shadows into mainstream public debate. We don’t know which theory is right, but a lab leak is plausible and worthy of serious inquiry.
This paragraph could have been published verbatim by Fox News or on any number of websites run by COVID-19 contrarians, and the part about there being “no good counter-evidence” for natural spillover as an origin is just plain wrong, given everything that we know about previous pandemics and the nucleotide sequence of SARS-CoV-2. Indeed, it is irresponsible in the extreme to have written “we don’t know which theory is right” without providing the context of which one is more likely to be correct. (Also, it’s a hypothesis, not a “theory”. In science, the word “theory” implies a much higher level of confidence than is justifiable in this context.) I outright cringed as I read Godlee’s article, having discovered it when I wondered what else The BMJ had published by Thacker besides his most recent “exposé”. It was incredibly disappointing to me to see the editor of The BMJ write something like this op-ed.
Unfortunately, Thacker’s most recent “bombshell” is yet another example of how The BMJ has gone astray, at least in terms of its news reporting and commentary, over the last several years. Peter Doshi, for instance, has now been with the journal for several years, despite many of us asking why the heck he’s still an editor, and Thacker is just the most recent symptom of the rot. I note that Doshi, for instance, has defended Thacker’s story as having been “rigorously fact-checked“. Unfortunately, it’s not the individual “facts” that he uses to weave a deceptive narrative; rather, it’s how he weaves those “facts” together to tell a story while leaving out important context, something all skilled propagandists know. Reluctantly, as I’ve observed the descent of The BMJ‘s news reporting and commentary to the level of conspiracy theory and supporting antivaccine narratives, I must conclude that the rot must start at the top. It’s not as though the problems with The BMJ‘s reporting and having an editor like Peter Doshi haven’t been pointed out for a long time now.
        ◦ Think about it this way. If one of your editors and one of the freelance reporters that you’ve been publishing have their own pages at an antivaccine website, which republishes their work enthusiastically to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt about vaccines and COVID-19 public health interventions, you really are doing things very, very wrong and contributing to pandemic misinformation in a huge way, given The BMJ‘s status

Once again, The BMJ, wittingly or unwittingly, reinforces an antivax narrative
Last week The BMJ published an investigation alleging that the algorithm for spotting safety signals after COVID vaccination was flawed and that the FDA ignored it, amplifying an old antivax narrative. Again. WTF, BMJ?
David Gorski on September 21, 2026
Link

Et tu, BMJ? Again? Seriously?
It’s been nearly three years since I last asked: What the heck happened to The BMJ? As my frustration with this medical journal led me to sit down to write this post, I did think about entitling it the same thing but thought better of it, given that I’ve already used that title twice. Better to call what The BMJ just published last week what it is: Sensationalism custom-made for use (or, no doubt as the journalist would characterize it, misuse) by antivaxxers to spin a deceptive yarn in which, during the early months after the rollout of COVID-19 vaccines in the US began in December 2020, the CDC and FDA supposedly engaged in what is portrayed, in essence, as a cover-up or suppression of reports of adverse reactions due to COVID-19 vaccines—or just gross negligence. This narrative comes in the form of an article by David Willman entitled, US officials knew COVID vaccine safety system was flawed—but turned aside the FDA doctor who alerted them. It gets even better, because the tagline claims that “US officials embraced an algorithm for detecting signals of harm from mRNA COVID-19 vaccines that they knew was broken and suppressed efforts to fix it.”
Sounds pretty damning, doesn’t it? A close reading of the article, however, makes culpability much less clear and involves convoluted arguments over two different statistical models used for detecting an increase in specific adverse events after vaccination in a passive reporting system. Personally, too, I was rather puzzled by the seeming amazement that the vast majority of reports to the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database in 2021 were about mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines, for example:
I bet those of you who have been paying attention to the antivaccine narratives surrounding the rollout of the mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines can even guess before reading the article which specific adverse event this article is primarily about. Yes, it’s (mostly) about myocarditis in young people, predominantly young men, associated with COVID-19 vaccination and how, supposedly, the US utterly failed in pharmacovigilance because it didn’t identify the safety signals as soon as some other countries (e.g., Israel) did. There’s actually an interesting story here if one wasn’t wedded to what comes across as an intentional cover-up, which is the narrative that antivaxxers are running with based on this story.
As a number of people have pointed out, the observation that the vast majority of reports to VAERS in 2021 were regarding COVID-19 vaccines should be no surprise. Before COVID-19 vaccines, few people knew of VAERS, which is a passive reporting system to which anyone can report any problem that occurs after any vaccination. In brief, VAERS is intended to function as an early warning system, a canary in the coal mine, so to speak, that can generate hypotheses regarding specific adverse events that occur after vaccination with specific vaccines. These hypotheses then need to be tested using more rigorous systems, as VAERS is prone to a lot of false positives and is easily misused by antivax “researchers.” We’ve discussed VAERS many times before and how misusing VAERS has long been a favorite strategy of antivaxxers to attribute all manner of maladies to vaccination. I’ve discussed the shortcomings of VAERS many, many times, both here and at my not-so-super-secret other blog, going back 20 years; so I’ll just refer you to a post I did as 2021 came to a close when I described how the misuse of VAERS by antivaxxers was continuing apace, and how an old antivax technique was turbocharged and weaponized within two months of the rollout of COVID-19 vaccines.
Beginning with the rollout of the COVID vaccines in December 2020, for the first time ever the CDC and FDA really publicized VAERS and used its bully pulpit to encourage the public to report adverse events. Of course, reporting of adverse events after COVID-19 vaccines skyrocketed, far surpassing any other reports, in particular given that millions and millions of doses were being administered as fast as the vaccines could be produced. They even created the V-Safe system, which periodically texted vaccinees for months after they were vaccinated to ask them if they were having any symptoms or problems. As Jeffrey Morris pointed out, “extraordinary public, medical and media scrutiny” produced “substantial stimulated reporting to VAERS” and healthcare professionals “had specific reporting requirements for adverse events following COVID vaccination.” He further observed that “the raw fact that COVID vaccines generated vastly more VAERS reports than previous vaccines does not by itself indicate that they caused vastly more adverse events,” the important thing being “whether particular events occurred disproportionately relative to vaccination exposure and appropriate comparators.” This massive increase in reporting in 2021 is an important factor in evaluating the two statistical methods Willman discusses in his article.
Speaking of the journalist, David Willman, under whose byline this story appears, is actually a legitimate investigative journalist. Just look at his Wikipedia entry if you don’t believe me. I can guess why he might have found a story about the alleged failure of the CDC to do appropriate analyses looking for safety signals for myocarditis attractive. Specifically, he won a Pulitzer Prize in Investigative Reporting in 2001 for his LA Times series reporting on seven FDA-approved drugs later withdrawn over safety issues and deaths. (Ironically, one of his articles notes that the too-fast approval of these drugs came about as a result of policies implemented to speed the approval of drugs and treatments for HIV/AIDS.)
However, as I read his BMJ article, I couldn’t help but notice my skeptical antennae starting to twitch fiercely. I was sensing the presence of another, unnamed player in this story. It turns out that my skeptical antennae didn’t let me down (at least not this time), because, right at the end of the article, in the Competing Interests section I read:
This account is adapted from an upcoming book about covid-19 and the vaccines, written by David Willman and Peter Doshi. Doshi is senior editor, The BMJ Investigations Unit.
Bingo! Why, I wondered, wasn’t Peter Doshi a co-author of this investigation? More importantly, for those of you not familiar with Peter Doshi and why he is important to The BMJ’s heel turn on vaccines over the last decade, let me step back and briefly discuss it. If you’re familiar with Doshi’s antivax antics, his role at The BMJ as a senior editor, and the antivax narratives he’s pushed, using the imprimatur of a respected medical journal to lend them credibility, you can safely skip the next section and move on to my discussion of Willman’s article itself. However, you might be interested in revisiting this story, because it’s a doozy that makes me wonder how a legitimate journalist like Willman not only collaborated with Doshi, but co-authored a whole book with him on COVID-19 vaccines! Given Doshi’s track record, I fear that I know exactly what this book will say, aside from this new “revelation,” which basically just seems to be a chapter from the upcoming book modified to fit in The BMJ’s format.
Peter Doshi: What happened to The BMJ
Whenever I lament what has happened to The BMJ, I always feel obligated to point out that The BMJ used to be almost unambiguously a good guy when it came to vaccines. After all, it was The BMJ that published investigative journalist Brian Deer’s articles recounting the strong evidence indicating that Wakefield’s case series published in The Lancet that linked the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine to autism was based on fraud. That study launched the modern iteration of the antivaccine movement and is, as I like to say, the study that launched a thousand quackeries directed at autistic children to “cure” them of their “vaccine-induced autism.” The headline of Deer’s accompanying commentary after his account of how the “case against the MMR was fixed” even referred to Wakefield’s study as “Piltdown medicine“, after the infamous Piltdown Man fraud. No one played a bigger role in finally exposing Wakefield for the fraud that he was (and still is) than Brian Deer and The BMJ.
Fast forward to 2010, when our very own Mark Crislip noticed that Peter Doshi and Tom Jefferson published a dubious article (that he deconstructed as only he can) casting doubt on whether Tamiflu works. Interestingly, a few years later, in 2014, Peter Doshi became an associate editor at The BMJ when he was an assistant professor in the Department of Pharmaceutical Health Services Research (PHSR) at the University of Maryland School of Pharmacy. I’ve been unable to pin down exactly when Doshi was promoted to senior editor, but it was no later than 2021, which is when I first started noticing articles under his byline showing up that promoted antivax narratives.
As for me, I first noticed Doshi in 2009, when I noted that, as the H1N1 pandemic of 2009-2010 was bearing down on us, he had been scheduled to speak at an anti-vaccine conference hosted by the National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC). Indeed, he had even been contacted about the nature of the conference and replied with the lamest of lame gambits, namely saying, “my speaking there does not imply endorsement.” After that, he was nothing if not consistent. While all the while continuing to claim that he’s “not antivaccine, he parroted more than a few antivaccine talking points himself while trying to portray himself as an authority on influenza and the flu vaccine. Through it all, when challenged, he’s played the “victim” card that people who are borderline antivaccine or antivaccine love to play, claiming that they are “just asking questions” and that anyone who “questions” vaccines is labeled, in a knee-jerk—and most unfair—fashion, “antivaccine.” In fact, Doshi’s borderline antivaccine stylings go back further than 2009, when a senior pseudonymous epidemiologist whose blog I used to read religiously back then chastised him for an “unhelpful” commentary in which Doshi had claimed that estimates for yearly influenza deaths were “grossly inflated.” The year was 2006.
It was during COVID-19, though, that Doshi let his antivax freak flag fly high. In February 2021, less than two months after the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine had started being distributed first to healthcare workers and those in high risk occupations, he published an article on The BMJ’s blog entitled, Pfizer and Moderna’s “95% effective” vaccines—we need more details and the raw data. In it, he pulled some statistical prestidigitation so transparent that even I could spot it, all to cast doubt on the validity of the randomized clinical trial showing the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines to be highly effective, while using his bogus “analysis” to suggest that the real efficacy of the vaccines was far lower. The utter deceptiveness of his analysis led me to wonder why The BMJ was still employing him, and Skeptical Raptor to note dryly that “BMJ is not a hotbed of anti-vaccine pseudoscience, except for the presence of Peter Doshi.” Indeed, Doshi is not a vaccinologist or infectious disease expert, nor is he an expert in clinical trials, something very apparent to anyone who is an expert who read his post and its misuse and misrepresentation of protocol violations. In fact, Doshi received his BA in anthropology from Brown University, an MA in East Asian studies from Harvard University, and a Ph.D. in history, anthropology, and science, technology, and society from MIT. Yet, somehow, he is senior editor at The BMJ.
In his original article, based on specious reasoning, Doshi estimated that the true efficacy of the vaccines was not over 90%, but was rather only 19%. I later pointed out how Doshi’s original “reanalysis” of the clinical trial data had given birth to what I call a “slasher myth” about COVID-19 vaccines, a term I coined for medical misinformation that, no matter how many times it appears to have been killed, always reappears, just as slashers who appear to die at the end of one movie are always shown to have survived somehow so that they can kill again in the sequel.
Let’s just reiterate that The BMJ hired Doshi despite his long history of playing footsie with the antivaccine movement since at least 2009, amplifying antivaccine conspiracy theories, downplaying the severity of influenza and thus feeding antivaccine narratives, using sleight-of-hand to downplay the effectiveness of flu vaccines, and generally playing the role of a false skeptic with respect to vaccines, as well as having signed a petition in 2006 “questioning” whether HIV causes AIDS. It continues to employ him even after he’s fallen for a conspiracy theory that the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database was being made inaccessible to suppress reports. That’s not all, though; he’s also served as an expert witness for the plaintiffs in antivaccine leader Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s lawsuit against the University of California’s influenza vaccine mandates.
Finally, seeing that Doshi’s role above is listed as “senior editor BMJ Investigations,” another gross abuse of science and journalism published by The BMJ makes a lot more sense to me now. I’m referring, of course, to the November 2021 “exposé” of Ventavia, one of the companies contracted by Pfizer to run its clinical trial of its COVID-19 vaccine, alleging shoddy working conditions and unblinding of clinical trial subjects. (Hard to believe that that was nearly five years ago!) As I discussed in depth at the time, it was all either exaggerated or outright nonsense, wrapped in a big bright conspiracy theory bow, the sort of reporting far more suited for Alex Jones’ Infowars than for a legitimate news outlet or medical journal. None of this is a surprise coming from Paul Thacker, who is a conspiracy theorist and hack. Assuming Doshi was in charge of BMJ Investigations back then, it makes a whole heck of a lot of sense that The BMJ let someone like Thacker appear in its pages.
The charges
With that background and the (barely acknowledged and likely ghost) co-author Peter Doshi being involved in writing this article by David Willman, let’s take a look at what is actually charged. The depressing thing, as I mentioned above, is that there is a story here. The problem is that it is spun to make the motives of the officials at the CDC and FDA involved look as nefarious and negligent as possible, even though there is no evidence that that was the case.
to its choice of algorithm to use to monitor data from the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database. Worse, if you believe the narrative, the FDA officials refused to alter the algorithm. More specifically, the article seeks to damn the CDC for not using two algorithms to data-mine VAERS. Like most compelling exposé narratives, the story features a whistleblower who repeatedly brought up concerns but was either ignored or muzzled. Noting that at the time of the rollout of COVID-19 vaccine distribution in December 2020, the CDC had announced that it was going to be on the lookout for any harmful reactions attributable to the vaccine, Willman lays the groundwork:
Millions of people were to be vaccinated each week, and the CDC would rely on statistical “data mining” of the VAERS database to quickly identify any safety signals in need of further probing.
Two well recognised, separate algorithms were to be used. The first involved calculating “proportional reporting ratios” (PRRs), which sought to identify types of reactions reported to VAERS disproportionately or more frequently than background rates. The second data mining technique, called “empirical bayesian,” was to be provided by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), which operated VAERS jointly with the CDC, and the two agencies planned to share and discuss results.1
I can’t help but note that I wanted to read the link referenced as #1, and I clicked on the link. It was a dead link. To me, that indicates some sloppiness here. So I consulted the almighty Wayback Machine at Archive.org, and was informed that the Internet Archive services were temporarily offline. Oh, well. It’s late Sunday night, and so I’ll check back tomorrow. In any case, this strategy seemed at least not unreasonable, and I noted that the two methods had their strengths and weaknesses, which I’ll get into more later. Suffice to say for now that both methods address the same question of disproportionality, specifically: Is a particular adverse event reported disproportionately more often for the vaccine under study relative to other vaccines, which are used as a reference? I’ll get into that more shortly.
First, what happened next? According to Willman:
But in a little noticed September 2022 letter, CDC director Rochelle Walensky said that the agency did not perform PRR analyses for signals until 2022. This was more than a year into the vaccine rollout and was intended, she wrote, “to corroborate” the FDA’s approach. Instead of using the PRR and empirical bayesian methods jointly during the pandemic, Walensky explained that both the CDC and FDA instead “chose to rely” on empirical bayesian, which she characterised as “a more robust technique.”
The BMJ, however, has found that the FDA’s algorithm was mathematically compromised by the deluge of covid vaccine adverse event reports—resulting in a near total loss of signal detection sensitivity for the new mRNA vaccines made by Pfizer and Moderna. Top FDA officials were warned internally of this problem in early 2021, and the official who headed its pharmacovigilance division for vaccines commented more than two years later to his CDC and FDA colleagues: “We were aware of this [data mining] limitation before and during the pandemic.” Government documents also show that CDC officials were informed during rollout of the vaccines—on multiple occasions.
Yet instead of fixing the safety deficiency—or shutting down the unreliable signal detection system—officials continued to rely on the FDA’s broken algorithm. The officials also cited the absence of signals when assuring clinicians and the public of the vaccines’ safety.
This sounds pretty damning too, doesn’t it? It gets even worse (or is made to sound even worse):
Yet instead of fixing the safety deficiency—or shutting down the unreliable signal detection system—officials continued to rely on the FDA’s broken algorithm. The officials also cited the absence of signals when assuring clinicians and the public of the vaccines’ safety.
At the FDA, managers went a step further by silencing the career drug safety officer who had repeatedly brought the deficiency to their attention and had offered an updated algorithm intended to fix it. As a result, Americans received unfounded assurances of the safety of the most widely used covid vaccines and were denied prompt warnings of potential harms, The BMJ’s investigation found.
There we have it, the necessary element of any good story like this, the “whistleblower” whose concerns were downplayed, ignored, or blown off and, even better, who suffered career consequences for telling The Truth. In this case, the whistleblower was a career FDA official:
The concern had made its way to Marks, FDA’s top official overseeing the covid vaccines, in early 2021. And it came from a career medical officer in the FDA’s centre for drugs, not vaccines: Ana Szarfman, a doctor with a PhD in microbiology and immunology. She worked for decades on drug safety data mining at the FDA and had a lead role in modernising the agency’s approach.67
Szarfman had built a years long professional association with an accomplished statistician, William DuMouchel, who devised the particular bayesian data mining algorithm that the FDA began using more than 15 years before the pandemic.6
So what was Szarfman’s concern? Here’s where the flood of reports deluging VAERS during 2021 comes in:
The BMJ can reveal that the FDA’s algorithm failed to signal a potential relationship between mRNA covid vaccination and myocarditis, pericarditis, Bell’s palsy, tinnitus, and other reported disorders owing to a flaw in the detection methodology—a flaw that senior officials declined to rectify.
The problem arose because, in the first year of the rollout, almost all the reports coming into VAERS—more than 90% of 1.1 million—were for the mRNA covid shots, dwarfing vaccines for all other diseases.4 This meant that analysing the safety of one vaccine, for example Pfizer’s product, involved comparing it to other vaccines, which were overwhelmingly limited to Moderna’s product. But if both mRNA vaccines elevated the risk of an adverse event like myocarditis in roughly equal amounts, the “observed” frequency and “expected” frequency would be similar, resulting in no automated alert.5 The statistical phenomenon is known as “masking.”
Here’s where I first started thinking: This isn’t a problem with the statistical method chosen. This sounds like a problem with the control group chosen. Why on earth would one include any of the COVID-19 vaccines in the control group of reports of adverse events in VAERS? Notice the framing here, namely that the PRR was an “unreliable” method compared to the Bayesian system, which is utter hogwash. Even I could tell that, but I had to rely on someone who knows a lot more about what he’s talking about when it comes to statistics than I do, namely Jeffrey Morris, who posted this analysis on Twitter.
First, I think it’s useful to quote Dr. Morris on the relative strengths/weaknesses of the two methods, PRR vs. Bayesian:
The empirical-Bayes method is not some fundamentally different or defective type of analysis. It builds on the same observed-versus-expected reporting framework, but uses shrinkage to stabilize estimates, particularly when counts are small, and provides a posterior distribution for the underlying reporting ratio that can be examined statistically. That shrinkage is generally a statistical advantage. My white paper discusses this relationship in detail.
An important difference is how a potential signal is flagged. The commonly used screened PRR rule is essentially an ad hoc threshold: PRR > 2, ChiSq>4, with at least 3 reports. In contrast, FDA used the more stringent empirical-Bayes criterion EB05 > 2: the lower 5th percentile of the posterior reporting-ratio distribution must exceed 2, which is equivalent to requiring greater than 95% posterior probability that the underlying reporting ratio exceeds twofold. Not surprisingly, those criteria have different operating characteristics. EB05 > 2 is substantially more conservative: it should produce fewer false-positive alerts, particularly for sparse data, but at the cost of lower sensitivity and potentially more false negatives.
Here’s a link to the white paper, if you want to go into the nitty-gritty of the details. To boil it down, the PRR method has a higher sensitivity with a lower specificity, meaning that it will detect more events above what is expected, but at the expense of specificity, meaning that a lot of those events will turn out not to have been due to the vaccines. The empirical Bayesian method, on the other hand, is more stringent. It will detect fewer events, but the events detected will be more likely to be “true” adverse reactions actually caused by the vaccine, which is why Dr. Morris emphasizes:
The much larger number of events flagged by the classical PRR rule therefore does not by itself demonstrate that PRR was the better method or that FDA’s Bayesian methodology was defective. To establish that, one would want to compare the sensitivity, specificity, false-positive rate, and false-negative rate of the competing rules under realistic reporting conditions. The article emphasizes the greater number of PRR alerts but does not provide that type of operating-characteristic analysis. FDA itself describes data-mining signals as hypotheses for investigation, not causal findings.
According to Willman’s report, in a meeting held on February 29, 2020, Szarfman included a presentation comparing her proposed algorithm based on using PRR to the algorithm based on empiric Bayesian methods being used, and, unsurprisingly, a lot more safety signals were flagged, as shown in this figure included in the Willman article:
Fig 1: FDA medical officer Ana Szarfman’s presentation on 29 February 2021 included a comparison of signal detection using the PRR (left) and empirical Bayesian (right) algorithms.
The heat map looks pretty convincing, doesn’t it? But what does it really mean? Any method that is more sensitive will produce more “hits” than a less sensitive method. Every algorithm of this sort has to balance sensitivity and specificity. Too much sensitivity, and there will be so many signals, many of which won’t pan out, that investigating them all will become impractical. Too much specificity, and, even though the signals that are found will have a much higher proportion of true positives, a lot of potentially important signals will be missed. How much sensitivity and specificity are needed relative to one another is a legitimate scientific question about which there can be legitimate scientific disagreement, but that’s not how this argument is portrayed here. The spin here is that Szarfman was good and right, and that Peter Marks and the FDA were wrong and negligent, if not outright villains for dismissing the brave whistleblower. I do note here that she appears to have been given a respectful hearing, being invited to present her findings to Peter Marks, who was then the director of the Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research (CBER), the FDA center responsible for approving vaccines.
Moreover, as Dr. Vincent Iannelli points out, Szarfman found a bunch of signals for adverse events that COVID-19 vaccines don’t cause, in particular sudden death. According to Willman:
But by July 2021, Szarfman again sounded an alarm over a “strong signal” for “death and sudden death” that she said DuMouchel had identified using the updated algorithm. She shared the findings with a colleague, Richard Forshee, a deputy director for biostatistics and pharmacovigilance, who worked under Peter Marks. Forshee expressed his doubts about the analysis to Szarfman and wrote to Marks: “Ana Szarfman called me . . . She said that she and Bill DuMouchel had found an increased risk of mortality following covid-19 vaccination using data mining methods.
“I am very concerned that whatever association they think they have identified is spurious based on the way the covid-19 vaccination program prioritized individuals and the required and stimulated reporting we are seeing with the covid-19 vaccines. . . . Please let me know how you would like us to proceed.”
Eventually, Szarfman’s activities got the attention of Peter Marks again, leading him to write to the Director of the Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (CDER):
On 15 September 2021, Marks wrote to his counterpart in the FDA’s Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (CDER): “One of the CDER statisticians, Ana Szarfman, has decided on her own to do vaccine analyses using VAERS as part of her work at FDA. She is, however, not doing this in collaboration with our [vaccine centre] statisticians, and quite to the contrary, has been asked to cease and desist, because the strategy that she is using could create erroneous conflicts that feed in to anti-vaccination rhetoric. This is creating an issue . . . This issue came up previously during the pandemic and . . . it seemed to go away, but it is now back. Can we catch up about this sometime?”
Basically, it sounds as though Marks had finally become fed up, whether rightly or wrongly.
Now here’s the thing. As Dr. Morris points out (and so do I), it isn’t the empirical Bayesian algorithm that was the problem. It was the selection of the control group to include those vaccinated with one of the COVID-19 vaccines, which was not an inherent part of an empirical Bayesian analysis. The problem of masking was far more of an issue than the choice of specific algorithm. As Dr. Morris explains:
Second, there was a separate and legitimate problem with the particular reference distribution FDA used in its empirical-Bayes implementation. This is where the masking issue enters. FDA’s brand-specific analyses estimated expected reporting frequencies from the broader VAERS database. Because Pfizer and Moderna together accounted for an enormous fraction of COVID-era reports, an adverse event elevated similarly for both vaccines could raise the expected frequency against which each individual vaccine was compared. That can attenuate or eliminate a disproportionality signal. The published masking analysis demonstrates that this phenomenon can occur, and the newly released internal records indicate that FDA officials were aware of the issue.
But that is a problem with the construction of the comparison group, not evidence that empirical Bayes itself is an invalid method. Indeed, a conventional PRR calculated with the same poorly chosen reference set can suffer the same masking problem; the methodological literature demonstrates masking for both PRR and standard empirical-Bayes disproportionality methods.
And, left out of Willman’s report:
And importantly, CDC’s eventual PRR analysis did not use that same comparison. For its principal PRR analysis in 2022, CDC pooled Pfizer and Moderna together as the mRNA COVID-vaccine exposure and compared their adverse-event reporting proportions with those for non-COVID vaccines, using reports extending back to 2009. Thus Pfizer and Moderna could not mask one another in that pooled analysis. The dramatic difference between the number of FDA EB alerts and CDC PRR alerts therefore cannot cleanly be interpreted as “Bayesian method bad, PRR good”: both the flagging criterion and the reference population changed.
And, most importantly, Willman doesn’t mention at all that one of the biggest problems with using VAERS during a pandemic situation in which, for the first time ever, the public is being strongly encouraged to report adverse events to VAERS. These are two different situations: VAERS during “regular times,” in which relatively few people even know of the database and vaccination occurs at a reasonably constant rate from year to year, compared to VAERS during a pandemic and the rollout of a vaccine against the pandemic-causing organism, SARS-CoV-2, in which the public is being urged to report any suspected adverse event after vaccination to VAERS and there is even a new system, V-Safe, set up to remind people to report by sending text messages to people at specified time intervals ofter they receive a COVID-19 vaccine to ask them if they are experiencing any symptoms that might be attributable to the vaccine.
As Dr. Morris notes, VAERS is “susceptible to stimulated reporting, media attention, reporting requirements, and differences in the populations receiving different vaccines.” Indeed, I first wrote about this phenomenon over two decades ago, when a study was published that showed how vaccine litigation had affected reporting to VAERS. In brief, lawyers representing families suing pharmaceutical companies for their children’s autism based on the belief that vaccines had caused it. These attorneys encouraged parents to report their child’s autism to VAERS as an adverse event, thus creating “evidence” that vaccines cause autism to be used in legal actions against vaccine manufacturers and in Vaccine Court. None of this is new. The FDA and CDC knew that stimulated reporting could be a problem.
Moreover, it is likely not because of the choice of algorithm to data-mine VAERS that Israel recognized the safety signal for myocarditis associated with COVID-19 vaccination. As Dr. Iannelli points out, there was a big difference in how Israel and the US approached their COVID-19 vaccination efforts. First, myocarditis after COVID-19 vaccination is an adverse event seen more often in the young, particularly young men. Second, it’s most often seen after the second dose of the vaccine. Dr. Iannelli notes that in the early months of the rollout, in the US it was high-risk people (e.g., the elderly and those with chronic diseases, as well as those in high-risk jobs, like healthcare) who were prioritized to be vaccinated, while in Israel vaccinated all of its citizens, with no restriction on age. He further notes that it wasn’t until March and April 2021 that older teens and young adults were receiving the vaccines, concluding:
And since myocarditis was mainly found after they got their second dose, it shouldn’t be a surprise that we didn’t see a safety signal until May.
A safety signal that was detected.
A safety signal that we were all told about.
Indeed.
Putting it all in context in a way The BMJ did not
I don’t mean to say that Willman’s report is entirely misguided. Clearly, he has documented problems at the FDA and the CDC in terms of vaccine safety monitoring. It’s just that, from my reading and consideration of Dr. Morris’ points, the main problem with the algorithm used to screen VAERS for adverse events related to COVID-19 vaccines was almost certainly not the problem that Willman emphasized: the choice of an empirical Bayesian algorithm versus calculating PRR. It was the control group initially chosen while doing the Bayesian analysis, and that is a valid point. Unfortunately, Willman flubs it completely by framing the problem almost entirely as a battle between PRR and empiric Bayesian methods, with the ‘correct” method being obvious (in retrospect), rather than as an issue with choice of control group during a massive vaccine rollout and a publicity campaign designed to promote stimulated reporting. Yes, Willman does mention the stimulated reporting, but mainly in passing and in a quoted email to Peter Marks from Richard Forshee.
Another frustrating thing about this article is that it does not really acknowledge the function of VAERS, falling seemingly inadvertently into line with the antivax view of VAERS as the be-all and end-all of vaccine safety monitoring, when in fact VAERS is an early warning system whose signals cannot be taken at face value and must be investigated using more rigorous methodology. Just as frustrating is its failure even to acknowledge that any algorithm chosen to analyze VAERS reports would involve deciding upon how much of a trade-off between sensitivity and specificity would be ideal, a decision about which reasonable scientists can have reasonable scientific and public health policy disagreements, as there are pros and cons to every approach.
Finally, Willman is not wrong to report that the CDC and FDA were in a bit of the “circle the wagons” mode in response to misuse of their data by the antivaccine movement (some examples of which we here on SBM wrote about at the time). Many of us engaged in science communication at the time were frustrated by the communications from the CDC and the FDA, although I can understand and sympathize with Marks’ apparent fear that Szarfman’s report would be weaponized by the antivaccine movement, a concern that Willman doesn’t seem to take seriously. The sad thing is, Willman’s reporting could have been valuable if it hadn’t been spun as a battle of a single brave whistleblower and dogmatic—even negligent—FDA officials, rather than as a difficult choice of methodology by the FDA and CDC to screen for adverse events.
The article concludes:
But while reflecting on the events, DuMouchel said that he could not explain the government officials’ resistance. “It’s really hard to know what they really had in their mind,” he said. “Or whether to believe or to accept their excuses for not wanting to switch to a new method . . . I think that they were wrong.”
Approached by The BMJ, Szarfman insisted that she had not sought to undermine public support for the covid vaccines. She recalled her efforts with what seemed to be resigned frustration. “Very few people understand the statistics,” she said. “That’s the problem.”
Over lunch near his residence in Miami, Florida, DuMouchel voiced regret that FDA officials had rebuffed Szarfman’s attempts to overhaul the deficient approach with VAERS. “If they had paid attention to Ana, they would have done better.”
Maybe. Maybe not. An equally plausible case could be made that if they had “listened to Ana,” there would have been so many false positive signals that the CDC and FDA could not have dealt with them and that it would have undermined confidence in vaccines, Szarfman’s and DuMouchel’s insistence that such was not their goal notwithstanding. Unfortunately, as valuable as it might have been to learn about this controversy at the FDA and CDC during the early months of the rollout of the vaccines, right now, given the way Willman is reporting it and with the knowledge that this article is most likely just a lightly edited version of a chapter in his book with Peter Doshi, I have to wonder what the larger aim is. Given The BMJ’s recent history with articles by Peter Doshi and Paul Thacker, I wonder if its editors even care anymore that they are willingly lending the prestige of their journal to antivax narratives, like the one claiming that the CDC and FDA “covered up” vaccine safety signals in order to keep the vaccines flowing.

    • 

If the BMJ Wants to Revisit Venerable Institutions Who Misled the Public in 2021, They Should Look Inward at the BMJ
Until the BMJ demonstrate the integrity to revisit their own dismal failures regarding life and death matters, there’s no reason to care about their opinions regarding less consequential issues, is there?
Jonathan Howard on October 1, 2026
Link

“We may still pay a price for the pursuit of emergency use authorizations for covid-19 vaccines in children”
I got my start at SBM in May 2021 writing a response to a short opinion piece in the BMJ titled Covid vaccines for children should not get emergency use authorization. It was by Drs. Wesley Pegden, Vinay Prasad, and Stefan Baral and concluded that the vaccine should be unavailable to most children until it cleared arbitrary, time-consuming regulatory hurdles.
It claimed the vaccine’s benefit for children would be “relatively minor” and that “unlike adults, covid-19 vaccination is not addressing an emergency.” “We may still pay a price for the pursuit of emergency use authorizations for covid-19 vaccines in children,” it warned ominously.
The only facts in it were that the swine-flu vaccine caused Guillain-Barré syndrome in 1976 and that COVID was milder for children. However, the article omitted what mattered most and what I discussed at length in my article—the basic facts of how COVID had already hurt children the first year of the pandemic.
Nonetheless, despite being entirely fact-free, this article met the standards of the BMJ.
“Circulation of SARS-CoV-2 may in fact be desirable”
However, this was not the only or even the worst piece of fact-free, anti-vaccine drivel the BMJ published that month. Another opinion piece that also met the BMJ’s standard was titled Vaccinating children against SARS-CoV-2 by Drs. Jennie S Lavine, Ottar Bjornstad, and Rustom Antia. It also aged poorly.
I’ve not discussed these authors previously; however, I’ve discussed doctors like them many times before. None of them treated COVID patients, and their inexperience allowed them to speak about pediatric COVID with a sheltered casualness available only to the laptop class. Pediatricians who treated sick children never blew off what they saw as “typically mild.”
I’ve also discussed their ideas and techniques many times before. That’s what We Want Them Infected was all about, and the BMJ paper certainly wanted them infected.
It spoke as if the pandemic was ending in May 2021, and it too warned that vaccinating children could have dire consequences.
Unfortunately, as virus circulation decreases, the age of primary infection increases, and since age is directly associated with pathogenicity, vaccinating children would likely lead to lower infection rates but higher case fatality rates. Additionally, depending on the relative durations of immunity induced by vaccines and infection, and the rate of viral antigenic change, vaccinating children might increase the frequency of large seasonal epidemics, leading to overall increases in virus induced morbidity and mortality.
In their telling, vaccinating little Johnny might kill Granny, you know, based on the rate of viral antigenic change. The safer path for them both was to let Johnny get COVID, repeatedly.
They spoke about a “balanced decision” and came down firmly on the side of the virus:
Should childhood infection (and re-exposures in adults) continue to be typically mild, childhood vaccination will not be necessary to halt the pandemic. The marginal benefits should therefore be considered in the context of local healthcare resources, equitable distribution of vaccines globally, and a more nuanced understanding of the differences between vaccine and infection induced immunity.
Once most adults are vaccinated, circulation of SARS-CoV-2 may in fact be desirable, as it is likely to lead to primary infection early in life when disease is mild, followed by booster re-exposures throughout adulthood as transmission blocking immunity wanes but disease blocking immunity remains high. This would keep reinfections mild and immunity up to date.
We knew by May 2021, when these BMJ papers were published, that infections in younger people invariably spilled into older people. There was also preliminary evidence via an RCT (published later that month in the NEJM) that the COVID vaccine was safe and effective for adolescents. Neither of the BMJ papers mentioned these important results.
Instead of informing its readers, the BMJ paper did PR on behalf of the virus. It said that circulation of SARS-CoV-2 “may in fact be desirable,” followed by “booster re-exposures throughout adulthood to keep reinfections mild and immunity up to date.” Here we are, once again.
Source: xkcd comic
“COVID-19 vaccine strongly effective for children and adolescents amid delta and omicron”
The BMJ paper also made predictions. It spoke of “decreasing virus circulation” and speculated that “childhood vaccination will not be necessary to halt the pandemic.” It further presumed that “childhood infection (and re-exposures in adults) would continue to be typically mild.”
All of this turned out to be wrong, and this wasn’t some mere academic debate. The stakes were high.
The Delta and Omicron variants arrived immediately after these two BMJ papers were published, each variant spiking pediatric infections, hospitalizations, and deaths. Parents of deceased children predictably felt regret for skipping the vaccine, which unsurprisingly turned out to be very effective in preventing rare, but grave outcomes in children. Meanwhile, COVID infections failed to keep COVID infections mild. Today the headlines read: Repeat COVID infections tied to higher odds of new health conditions.
Oops.
Last week, Dr. David Gorski wrote an article titled Once again, The BMJ, Wittingly or Unwittingly, Reinforces an Antivax Narrative that discussed an “investigation” by the BMJ regarding a short delay in reporting a rare vaccine side effect. This side effect was nearly always temporary and mild, and it did not fundamentally change the risk-benefit equation for the vaccine. Nonetheless, the BMJ treated this perceived failure as a big scandal.
However, if the BMJ wants to once again revisit venerable institutions that misled the public in 2021, they should look inwards at the BMJ. Until they demonstrate the integrity to revisit their own dismal failures regarding literal life-and-death matters, there’s no reason to care about their opinions regarding issues less consequential than that, is there?


   Is there a role for speculative journals like Medical Hypotheses in the scientific literature?
Kimball Atwood
Link
The core information supporting science-based medicine resides in the scientific literature. There, scientists and physicians publish the results of experiments and clinical trials that seek to understand the biological mechanisms by which the human body functions and through which disease forms and to apply this understanding to test new treatments for diease. Consequently, the quality and integrity of the biomedical literature are topics of utmost importance to supporters of science-based medicine. We’ve discussed problems with the scientific literature before here, ranging from how pseudoscientific “complementary and alternative medicine” journals have insinuated themselves into the medical literature and how drug companies have managed exercise undue influence over clinical trials and journals.
One question that perhaps we have not dealt with so much is the question of the very nature of a good scientific journal, particularly what is suitable material for such a journal. For purposes of this discussion, I will focus mainly on the biomedical literature, which spans a range from basic science journals dealing with biomedical science to clinical journals, which mainly report the results of clinical trials and clinical research. Of these journals, there are in general two types, journals that primarily report original research and those that present reviews of existing research. Most journals do a mix of the two, the majority tending towards a form where most of the articles are reports of orginal research mixed in with a much smaller number of review articles.
There is one journal, however, that is different. It is a journal known as Medical Hypotheses. It is a journal that (or so it claims) exists to present radical scientific ideas, the more radical the better. Here is how the journal is described on its website:
The purpose of Medical Hypotheses is to publish interesting theoretical papers. The journal will consider radical, speculative and non-mainstream scientific ideas provided they are coherently expressed.
Medical Hypotheses is not, however, a journal for publishing workaday reviews of the literature, nor is it a journal for primary data (except when preliminary data is used to lend support to the main hypothesis presented). Many of the articles submitted do not clearly identify the hypothesis and simply read like reviews.
So far, there’s nothing inherently objectionable or anti-scientific in the concept behind MH. I can easily see a role for a journal that publishes speculative biomedical papers. However, there is a problem, and this problem has been brewing for a long time. Last month, apparently, it came to a head, and last week it was reported in Science that the publisher of MH, Elsevier, had issued the editor, Bruce Charlton, an ultimatum:
The editor of the journal Medical Hypotheses–an oddity in the world of scientific publishing because it does not practice peer review–is about to lose his job over the publication last summer of a paper that says HIV does not cause AIDS. Publishing powerhouse Elsevier today told editor Bruce Charlton that it won’t renew his contract, which expires at the end of 2010, and it asked that Charlton resign immediately or implement a series of changes in his editorial policy, including putting a system of peer review in place. Charlton, who teaches evolutionary psychology at the University of Newcastle upon Tyne in the United Kingdom, says he will do neither, and some on the editorial advisory board say they may resign in protest if he is fired.
Elsevier’s move is the latest in an 8-month battle over the journal; it comes after an anonymous panel convened by Elsevier recommended drastic changes to the journal’s course, and five scientists reviewed the controversial paper and unanimously panned it.
Before I go on, let me just say right here that I don’t necessarily disapprove of a journal devoted to highly speculative, even radical hypotheses. Such a journal can play a very important role for airing ideas at the fringes of what is known. Unfortunately. However, as I shall describe shortly, I believe that MH has been a big problem. Specifially, my problem with MH is that it blurred the line between the speculative and apparently confused “speculative” with “making stuff up.” Apparently the reviewers agreed:
Following the advice of an external panel whose membership has not been made public, Elsevier wrote Charlton on 22 January to say that Medical Hypotheses would have to become a peer-reviewed journal. Potentially controversial papers should receive especially careful scrutiny, the publisher said, and some topics–including “hypotheses that could be interpreted as supporting racism” should be off limits.
Elsevier also had its flagship medical journal, The Lancet, organize a formal review by five anonymous experts. The reviews, which have not yet been released publicly but were obtained by Science, were unanimously harsh–especially about the Duesberg paper, indicating that it is riddled with errors and misinterpretations. “It might entertain their friends and relatives on a cold winter evening, but it does not belong in a scientific journal,” one reviewer wrote. On 24 February, Elsevier wrote Duesberg that his paper–which had not yet been printed and had been taken down from the journal’s Web site in August–would be “permanently withdrawn.” Ruggiero received a similar letter 5 days later.
Why did it come to this? The reason is that a journal whose editor valued “radical” ideas far more than actual science has been polluting the medical literature in a manner that was too easily abused by cranks and quacks. Moreover, this was not a new problem; it had been longstanding and known to those of us who pay attention to such matters. Many are the times I have seen a wide variety of cranks cite MH papers as support for their positions. In essence, MH had become a vanity journal that will publish almost anything, no matter how much it goes against established science. For example, Mark Blaxill published pseudoscientific speculation that vaccines cause autism, and the anti-vaccine movement trumpeted Blaxill’s paper for the next several years as “evidence” in a “peer-reviewed journal” that vaccines cause autism. Similarly, MH published Mark and David Geier’s “hypothesis” proposing the use of the powerful anti-sex hormone drug Lupron to treat autism, an utterly ridiculous idea from a scientific standpoint that wasn’t just “radical”; it was demonstrably wrong. In the same vein, MH published a paper by a dream team of anti-vaccine activists proposing the use of spironolactone to treat autism based on its anti-androgen properties. Recently, MH published an article that appeared to echo attempts by the anti-vaccine movement to link mitochondrial diseases to “vaccine injury.”
It worked, too, because most lay people can’t distinguish between a highly speculative scientific article and a scientific report based on sound data from well-designed experiments and/or clinical trials, with solid scientific reasoning leading to its conclusions. Nor do most people–even scientists– have any idea of some of the other amusingly (and not-so-amusingly) wacky “hypotheses” published in MH, such as ideas that masturbation is a treatment for nasal congestion, a paper linking high heeled shoes to schizophrenia, a meditation on the nature of navel fluff, and truly offensive speculations about “mongoloids.” And there was support for the most blatant pseudoscience as well, even above and beyond support of HIV/AIDS denialism. For example, over the years MH has published several articles arguing for the “plausibility” of homeopathy, such as this, this, and this.
Perhaps the worst debacle suffered by MH came to pass last summer, when it published an article by HIV/AIDS denialist Peter Duesberg that was outrageously wrong and even downright racist. So bad was the article, that Elsevier apparently felt compelled to act and in doing so administered one of the worst indignities imaginable to a scientist. It withdrew Duesberg’s article from MH last year. Now I know what happened since then. Elsevier ordered an external review, the results of which were reported in the news article in Science cited above. Given the history of MH publishing anti-vaccine pseudoscience and other highly dubious papers, I was curious why this particular manuscript would have been withdrawn from Medical Hypotheses, given the usual low standards demonstrated by MH and that the article expresses the usual nonsensical “scientific opinions” that HIV isn’t enough to cause AIDS, that HIV doesn’t kill as many in Africa as estimated, and that anti-HIV drugs don’t work. What changed between the time that Medical Hypotheses (MH) accepted this article and decided to withdraw it? Why would this one article be worse than all the other pseudoscience routinely published by MH? Quite frankly, I was puzzled at the time.
My search led me to Ben Goldacre’s column entitled Medical Hypotheses fails the Aids test, which in turn led me to this detailed explanation on AIDSTruth.org entitled Elsevier retracts Duesberg’s AIDS Denialist article. After that, it all became clear. Basically, the slapdown administered to Duesberg and other HIV/AIDS denialists through his article being retracted by MH had its genesis in a study by Pride Chigwedere and coinvestigators at Harvard University, who estimated that delays in providing antiretroviral drugs in South Africa because of state-supported AIDS denialism (in which Duesberg played a prominent role in promoting) had caused over 300,000 deaths. In fact, the article mentioned Duesberg’s role in promoting HIV/AIDS denialism in South Africa. This is what happened:
AIDS denialist Peter Duesberg, whose influence on the disastrous South African government policies was mentioned in Chigwedere’s article, submitted a response to JAIDS that was co-authored by four others including Rasnick. After this article was rejected because of its poor academic quality, Duesberg et al. submitted it to a different journal, Medical Hypotheses. Two days later, the editor accepted the paper. Medical Hypotheses does not practice peer review, a process in which several scientists check a submitted academic paper for quality and suggest needed improvements over a period of weeks or months. The Duesberg et al. paper was accepted without such a review process, after inspection only by the editor of Medical Hypotheses.
This appears to be a relatively common occurrence, with articles rejected by real journals somehow having a way of finding their way into Medical Hypotheses. Duesberg was particularly crass, too, writing in the article:
A precursor of this paper was rejected by the Journal of AIDS, which published the Chigwedere et al. article, with political and ad hominem arguments but without offering even one reference for an incorrect number or statement of our paper (available on request).
Apparently I missed it at the time, but HIV/AIDS denialists were crowing about this, just as anti-vaccinationists crowed about papers by Mark Blaxill and Mark Geier making it into Medical Hypotheses and held them up as “evidence” that their ideas were making it into mainstream scientific journals.
The publication of Duesberg’s HIV/AIDS denialist paper also led an effort by scientists to do something that should have been done a long time ago. For some reason that has always eluded me, ever since I first discovered the land of woo that is Medical Hypotheses, this journal is indexed with MEDLINE and shows up on PubMed searches. It goes against a lot of what MEDLINE claims to be its standards for indexing a journal or even the very functions of MEDLINE. Based on the co-optation of Medical Hypotheses by HIV/AIDS denialists to their cause, a number of academics, authors, and researchers wrote a letter to Donald A. B. Lindberg, M.D. Director, National Library of Medicine Betsy L. Humphreys Deputy Director, National Library of Medicine Sheldon Kotzin Associate Director, Library Operations Library Selection Technical Review Committee calling for Medical Hypotheses to be delisted from MEDLINE.
My guess is that the serious threat of having MH removed from list of journals indexed by MEDLINE is what led Elsevier to act. After all, if a journal isn’t listed in MEDLINE, its articles won’t show up on PUBMED searches, and that is the kiss of death for any biomedical journal that hopes to maintain any sort of reputation at all. But did Elsevier go too far? Although I view Elsevier’s action as a long overdue effort at finally exercising some quality control, there are those who vigorously defend MH and its editor Bruce Charlton. In fact, Charlton published some of these defenses on his blog, and equally unfortunately some of them were quite poorly reasoned, such as this defense by Professors Lola J. Cuddy and Jacalyn M. Duffin:
If it emerges that Duesberg’s paper erred beyond his minority viewpoint to actual errors–be they deliberate or accidental, a signal comparison can be made to two leading medical journals. Medical Hypotheses would have been no less a victim or a wrongdoer than the distinguished entities The Lancet and the New England Journal of Medicine.
Earlier this month, Elsevier’s flagship journal The Lancet withdrew a 1998 paper by Andrew Wakefield et al. that helped foster the now discredited theory linking autism and MMR vaccines. No one has called for the alteration of Lancet. Indeed, the issue has drawn attention to the preeminent leadership role that The Lancet plays in the dissemination of knowledge and ideas.
Similarly, in 2000 the New England Journal of Medicine published a peer-reviewed paper that strongly supported the use of rofecoxib (known as Vioxx®). Later it emerged that the paper had suffered improper industry interference and failed to declare a treatment-related death. The drug was taken off the market in 2004. Considerable discussion surrounded the editorial responsibilites for the 2000 article when the flaws came to light in 2005. But no one called for the New England Journal of Medicine to be altered in any way. Jeffrey Drazen is still its editor-in-chief.
This is, of course, comparing apples and oranges. It’s been well known that fraud is very difficult to detect through a standard peer review of a scientific paper, and most journals do not have good systems in place to detect undisclosed conflicts of interest. In any case, in their defense of MH Cuddy and Duffin are demonstrating extreme ignorance at best or extreme disingenuousness at worst. There is a profound difference between a journal’s peer reviewers missing examples of scientific fraud, which peer review tends to be ill-equipped to detect, and a journal editor just taking any ridiculous “speculative” paper that comes along and calling it science. Although an argument can be made that Wakefield’s paper should never have been accepted for publication because it was such thing gruel, the Vioxx paper at the time it was published looked like a perfectly legitimate and reasonable randomized clinical trial. It took years to discover the problems with both papers. Cuddy and Duffin are in essence invoking the tu quoque fallacy by pointing to failures of peer review as a justification for the failure of MH not only to maintain a reasonable level of quality control but even to exercise any peer review at all. Remember, MH is not peer reviewed. It is, as Charlton has described it, “editorially reviewed,” which means basically that Charlton picks what is published. Unfortunately, he has chosen poorly so often that he finally got burned.
Another issue illustrated by this controversy is the role of editors, their editorial independence, and how far publishers should go in influencing the content of scientific journals that they publish. Editorial independence is indeed very important for preventing external forces, such as advertisers (i.e., drug companies) from having undue influence over editorial decisions over scientific content. Some argue that editorial independence is, for all intents and purposes, paramount. On the other hand, it is the responsibility of the publisher to exercise quality control, and that’s just what Elsevier’s action appears to be in this case. I’ve complained about Elsevier before in the context of its allowing a pharmaceutical company to pay it to publish what was in essence fake medical journal, but in this case it appears to be doing (mostly) the right thing. I say “mostly” because I do agree that one aspect of its actions does make me uncomfortable, specifically the part about saying that some controversial topics should be off-limits. That drifts uncomfortably close to the realm of pre-emptive censorship. Science depends on the unfettered dissemination and discussion of ideas, even ideas that many might find offensive.
Science is also served by fearlessness in discussing radical ideas. Howver, care has to be taken to make sure that there is a clear line between what is speculation and what is not, and it has to be made very clear when such a journal is not peer-reviewed. MH under Charlton’s leadership has failed on both counts. Whatever the value of the concept behind a journal like MH, in the case of MH that value has not only failed to be realized, but has in fact been degraded and brought into serious disrepute. Charlton has, through his carelessness, arrogance, and his ideologically blind refusal to enforce even the most minimal minimal scientific standards on articles submitted to MH, has resulted in embarrassment after embarrassment falling upon his journal, from its abuse by the anti-vaccine movement to the latest debacle. The Peter Duesberg HIV/AIDS denialist paper retracted by Elsevier was merely the last straw. As a result, Elsevier decided that it had little choice but to order Charlton to impose peer review or to resign. By refusing to adhere to even a modicum of scientific rigor, Charlton has destroyed the aspect of MH that he apparently most values.
A journal devoted to cutting edge, even fringe scientific hypotheses might indeed be valuable, but because of his carelessness Charlton guaranteed that Medical Hypotheses was not that journal and that it never will be. If there is ever to be a journal devoted to highly speculative scientific articles, it’s clear that Medical Hypotheses isn’t it and can no longer even attempt to be it. Bruce Charlton saw to that. Maybe MH under new editorial leadership can claim that role, or maybe a new journal will arise to fill such a niche. Either way, the old MH had to change or risk being destroyed. “Radical ideas” are all well and good, and bouncing them around may make for a fun drinking game among scientists. However, if these radical ideas are not supported by known facts, sound scientific studies, and strong reasoning, they are nothing more than a fun diversion and serve to mislead more than to enlighten. Fun diversions may serve a purpose, but they should be clearly labeled as such and not published in such a way that they could easily be confused with legitimate scientific research.

In which we are accused of “polarization-based medicine”
David Gorski on October 10, 2016
Link

A little over a month ago, I wrote about how proponents of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM), now more frequently called “integrative medicine,” go to great lengths to claim nonpharmacological treatments for, well, just about anything as somehow being CAM or “integrative.” The example I used was a systematic review article published by several of the bigwigs at that government font of pseudoscience, the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) about CAM approaches for the management of chronic pain. You can read my whole post for yourself if you want the details (and read Edzard Ernst and Steve Novella for more), but the CliffsNotes version consists of two main points. First, the review didn’t really show that any CAM approach worked, given how the authors included so many studies with no placebo or sham control and didn’t systematically assess the quality of the studies. Second, this study is the best publicized example of how NCCIH, looking for a reason to justify itself, has latched on to the opioid addiction crisis in this country and gone “all in” with CAM for chronic pain. Of course, the problem is that none of the real “alternative” treatments show any convincing evidence of efficacy; so NCCIH has to claim exercise (in the form of yoga and Tai Chi, for instance) and various other modalities that aren’t really “alternative” as being part of CAM. True, the authors did try to claim that acupuncture works for back pain and osteoarthritis of the knee, but the flaw of including mostly studies with no placebo/sham control completely undermined that claim. Basically, taken in its entirety, the NCCIH’s systematic review failed to find convincing evidence that any CAM therapy really works for chronic pain.
So I wrote my post, noting also how this review article and its framing of CAM as equivalent to any nonpharmacologic treatment were clearly in line with the last two NCCIH strategic plans, perused the comments our readers left, and pretty much forgot about the study, because fortunately, it didn’t seem to get much traction. (Releasing it right before the Labor Day weekend probably didn’t help NCCIH much.) However, there is one person who did not forget, and that person is John Weeks. Last week, he published a response to the criticisms of the NCCIH review in the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine (JACM) entitled “Polarization-Based Medicine: Protests Against the Mayo-NCCIH Pain Guidance Evoke the Bigotry of the Political Season.”
As they say, it’s on.
Meet the new editor of JACM
A couple of weeks ago, I received by snail mail at work a letter from a reader. Now, as I frequently say, it’s rarely a good idea to send me a snail mail at work, at least if you hope for any response, because it’s frequently several days before I see it, sometimes longer, and I don’t generally respond to such messages because it’s kind of a pain. However, this letter intrigued me. It was someone pointing out an announcement by Mary Ann Liebert, Inc, the publisher of JACM, about the new editor of the journal. That editor is John Weeks. (A PDF of the flyer is available online here.) The announcement reads thusly:
Mary Ann Liebert, Inc., publishers is pleased to announce that John Weeks will assume the role of Editor-in-Chief of The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, effective immediately. John has been deeply imbedded in this field in many capacities for over three decades – see his brief bio below – guiding and stimulating dialogues and initiatives in multiple areas, including research.
John is a present or past colleague of many of our authors and on JACM‘s editorial team. He is developing a core group of editors who will join him in guiding this next phase while ensuring that the Journal continues to maintain a high level of quality and integrity in the peer-review process. Among these will be Richard Hammerschlag, PhD; Heather Boon, BScPhm, PhD; Peter Wayne, PhD; Aviad Haramati, PhD; Leonard Wisneski, MD; and Pamela Snider, ND. Our Managing Editor, Susan Jensen, will remain in her role to ensure continuity.
Some of you may recall that at the banquet night of the 2014 International Research Congress on Integrative Medicine and Health in Miami, John was the recipient of a Lifetime Achievement Living Tribute award, complete with a book of testimonials from 150 leaders. In one, Josephine Briggs, MD, the director of the NIH National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, called John “a provocative voice, but a welcome one, one of the most insightful in current healthcare discussions.” We are excited to have his voice, experience and growing network on board to shape this next phase for JACM.
“Provocative”? I’m not sure that’s the word I would have used. My choice would have been a word like “telling.” Why telling? Well, first JACM is a CAM journal. If the publishers wanted to try to convince people that CAM is legitimate from a scientific standpoint, you’d think that they’d have chosen someone in CAM who at least has some scientific credentials. Lorenzo Cohen and Barrie Cassileth, for instance, come to mind. They didn’t. Instead, they promoted a full-throated booster of CAM who describes himself on his blog as a “writer, speaker, and change agent.” More importantly, Weeks has no discernable scientific or professional background relevant to being Editor-in-Chief of a biomedical scientific journal. Sure, he clearly has the skills to edit a magazine, but being the editor of a scientific journal is not the same thing.
Of course, maybe this is appropriate. After all, JACM, being a CAM journal, isn’t really a scientific journal at all. It’s more like a tooth fairy science journal, and I expect that it will become even more so under Weeks’ leadership. So, in a way, I guess appointing Weeks as Editor-in-Chief isn’t as crazy as it sounds on the surface. The journal wasn’t scientific to begin with; so a physician or scientist wasn’t required. Just look at a few of the headlines under Featured Press Releases and Editorial Content:
“Can Traditional Chinese Medicine Offer Treatments for Dementia and Alzheimer’s Disease?“
“Deepak Chopra’s Ayurvedic Retreat Program Yields Sustained Increases in Well-Being“
“Can An Integrative Medicine Approach Help Prevent Medical Errors?” (I laughed when I read this title. There is no evidence that “integrative medicine” as practiced outside of an academic medical center has any systematic concern about medical errors.)
“Acupuncture in the Military for Rapid Pain Relief on the Battlefield” (Ack, not Col. (Dr.) Richard Niemtzow and his “battlefield acupuncture” again!)
“Acupuncture Can Improve Outcomes in Dermatological Conditions” (You know, the thought of inserting needles into eczematous skin gives me the willies.)
You get the idea. Good science was never a major concern at JACM. No doubt what Mary Liebert, Inc. valued in Weeks was his promotional skills, given that the 2015 Impact Factor of JACM is only 1.395. It’s a bit misguided, though. The Impact Factor, as imperfect as it is, estimates how influential a journal is by how many times other scientific journals cite its articles. The way to get a higher impact factor is to publish better, more interesting science. On the other hand, given how CAM works, maybe all it requires is publishing more…interesting…CAM articles, regardless of the science.
In any case, Weeks and I (and many other skeptics) have a bit of a history. He has not liked some of the things I’ve written about CAM in the past. Indeed, he singles out in particular this post I wrote about his defense of alternative medicine. To get a taste of where he’s coming from, it’s worth citing the article I criticized:
The movement from “alternative” to a new language of “complementary” and “integrative” when it arrived in the mid-1990s was partly what would, on the street, be called a “suck-up” gesture. I participated, and still do. We were trying to find a way to play inside the power-centers of the juggernauts, world views, and abiding priorities that daily generate the BMJ outcomes.
You see, Weeks likes the term “alternative,” although he tried mightily to redefine it to something different than what it had always meant: Medicine outside of the mainstream of medical practice, in essence medicine not scientifically proven to work or scientifically proven not to work. Rather, he wanted the “alternative” in “alternative medicine” to mean an “alternative” to the way the business of medicine runs now. Good luck with that reframing. Once a word comes to have a meaning, it’s devilishly difficult to change it.
He also mentioned his impending appointment, although from the context it appears that he hadn’t accepted yet:
I was asked a month ago, out of the blue, if I would like to become editor-in-chief of the first peer-reviewed, indexed journal in what is now the “integrative health and medicine” field. The journal was born 20 years ago when — as my father would have put it — “integrative medicine” was hardly a gleam in anyone’s eye. The publication is the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine.
I was told that renaming is on the table. Do we keep the name as is? Do we add “integrative”? Do we, as a federal research agency and an academic collaborative have recently chosen, lose the “alternative”?
Amidst the politics of pleasing Father — or not — what do you think says it best? Do we want an “alternative” to our present way of doing business, and prioritizing treatment?
I do like how Weeks admits things about integrative medicine that I’ve been saying all along, such as how it’s a marketing term more than anything else. It reminds me of what Glenn Sabin says about integrative medicine, how it’s a brand, not a specialty. Of course, he doesn’t say these things the way I say them, and he says them as though they were a good thing when they are not.
So what’s eating Mr. Weeks about the reaction to the NCCIH review on chronic pain?
In which SBM advocates are likened to Donald Trump…
Mr. Weeks is upset. He’s so very, very upset at criticism of the NCCIH review on CAM approaches to chronic pain. He lets us know this right at the beginning of his article when he tells us that colleagues were asking him why on earth he would write such an article, becoming more than a little pretentious in the process, when, after having quoted Robert Graves’s poem To Lucia at Birth, he writes:
Why would I give any measure of visibility and credence to the transcontinental vitriol that greeted a September 1, 2016, pain guidance from the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) at the U.S. National Institutes of Health (NIH)? The language and approach of this antagonism to anything “complementary” or “integrative” or “alternative” would seem to have come from the same playbook as the U.S. presidential campaign season this year. General consensus is that no U.S. campaign has ever been as polarized, riddled with lies and half-truths, punctuated by namecalling and bigotry, or as hateful as the campaign for the presidency of Donald Trump.
The ugly tenor of the nominally scientific dialogue of these unrelenting opponents of the NCCIH reminded me of this centripetal pulling apart of civil discourse in the present political battle. The parallel is all the stronger because the stakes, in both arenas, are so high. For instance, we have a “war” against opioid addiction that, as I shared in my last column, could be moderated via enhanced collaboration.
Ah, yes, the time-honored political practice of drawing oneself up straight and portraying oneself as above the fray (the bit about his colleagues asking him why he’s bothering to respond), expressing indignation at the insults coming from one’s opponents and then throwing back similar insults; e.g., comparing them to Donald Trump and accusing them of nasty tactics. Yes, I do routinely refer to The Huffington Post as that “wretched hive of scum and quackery.” It’s a bit of an in-joke that I’ve used many times. Any Star Wars fan would recognize the exact scene that line riffs on. Truth be told, I have been thinking of no longer using that line, at least no longer applying it to HuffPo. Compared to its founding and several years after, HuffPo hasn’t been nearly as bad when it comes to promoting quackery and antivaccine pseudoscience as it was several years ago, a history that led me to portray HuffPo as being at war with medical science.
One thing I couldn’t help but notice Mr. Weeks, for all his protestations otherwise, is pretty good at the political name calling game. He even admits that that’s what he’s doing:
While the most outspoken group of detractors in the United States dubs its outlet “science-based medicine,” I have chosen in my writing to reference them only as “polarization-based medicine.” The good news is that there are recent models of respectful scientific dialogue between NCCIH and some who don’t always agree with the agency’s promulgations.
With Mr. Weeks’ indignation at all the nasty name calling dealt with, along with his decision to engage in the same, let’s move on to the substance, if it can be called that, of his complaints.
The (quackademic) empire strikes back
Reading Mr. Weeks’ piece, I became acutely aware of the need to disabuse him of an idea he seems to have, namely that all of his critics are somehow linked to this blog. His introduction speaks of SBM, but then his first volley of self-righteous fury is directed at, well, take a look:
Here is a taste of the response. An Australian medical doctor immediately characterized the synopsis as “one of the most blatant examples of quackacademic confabulation I have seen in ages.” (The pejorative is a favored description of the scientists who are members of the Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine and Health, and elsewhere around the world, who are integrating complementary and integrative approaches into their research, education, and in some institutions, clinical practices.) The members of the NCCIH team are portrayed by the same writer as “sincerely deluded cranks.”
Actually, no, “quackademic” medicine is a far more general term than that, originally coined by Dr. Robert W. Donnell in 2008 to describe the infiltration of quackery into medical academia, both research and education. As such, the term describes much, much more than merely ACIMH members; it describes a general phenomenon that SBM is resisting. This brings me to another aspect about Mr. Weeks’ article, and that’s his refusal to name those criticizing him. Come on, Mr. Weeks. That’s just childish. I name you when I criticize something you wrote. You could at least do me (not to mention the two others you criticize) the same courtesy. I mean, seriously. One of the critics of the NCCIH review was Edzard freakin’ Ernst, for cryin’ out loud! There is no critic of CAM more well-known than he that I’m aware of.
In any event, the article Mr. Weeks quotes was written by Michael Vagg, Clinical Senior Lecturer at Deakin University School of Medicine. He’s also a bona fide pain specialist, a Fellow of Australasian Faculty of Rehabilitation Medicine (RACP) and a Fellow and Board Member of Faculty of Pain Medicine (ANZCA). So what Dr. Vagg writes about the NCCIH review in his article Please can we give up on complementary, alternative and ‘integrative therapies’ now? carries considerable weight. It’s also a very good article. One wonders if he’d be willing to do a post or two for SBM on science-based pain modalities. (Hint, hint, Dr. Vagg, if you’re reading this.)
Yet another irritating aspect of Weeks’ article is that nowhere does he actually convincingly rebut on substance anything that any of us has written. His entire article is primarily one massive piece of tone trolling. For instance, about my post on the NCCIH article, Mr. Weeks writes:
In a separate column, the same USA academically based surgical oncologist noted above dismisses the NIH’s guide from the 105 RCTs as “tooth-fairy science.” He condemns the process by association: two of the NIH’s team, each with research doctorates, were separately educated as doctors of chiropractic and naturopathic medicine, respectively. He writes, “If you want to know why NCCIH supports so much pseudoscience, look no further than it having chiropractors and naturopaths in high ranking positions.” He restates his definition of “integrative medicine” as “integrating pseudoscience and quackery into medicine.”
Notice the logical fallacies, such as the appeal to authority. It’s the NIH team. How dare I criticize its results. Yes, I did mention chiropractors and naturopaths, but, unlike the impression that you get reading Mr. Weeks’ criticism, you’d think that was all I did. In fact, those were small parts of my post cherry picked by Mr. Weeks while he ignored all the substantive criticisms I had about the article. Notably, Mr. Weeks can’t rebut and doesn’t even mention a single one. Yes, I did write those things, and I stand by them, but I also wrote so much more that described the NCCIH article’s shortcomings in detail based on science and methodology.
Now, regarding Edzard Ernst:
From England, also within days of the NCCIH’s publication, a blog post from a medical doctor and former professor who has written for two decades against integrative care was titled: “Why that study about alternative therapies relieving pain is worthless.”12 The NIH team is portrayed as “actively misleading” the public with “exaggerations, sloppy research and misleading conclusions.” The name calling— and particularly the routine attributions of quackery—recall Trump’s epithets placed on each of his opponents, for example “Crooked Hillary.”
Again, this is Edzard Ernst here. At least use his name. As for insults, methinks Mr. Weeks doth protest too much. Likening an opponent to Donald Trump, particularly a British opponent, is pretty loaded language, as is Mr. Weeks’ portrayal of Prof. Ernst as hopelessly biased. In any case, here is Ernst’s blog post, “Unacceptable pseudo-science from the NIH.” Judge for yourself. Also notice that nowhere—nowhere!—in his post does Prof. Ernst use the words “quack” or “quackery.” In fact, in tone, Prof. Ernst’s post is arguably less inflammatory than Dr. Vagg’s or mine. Prof. Ernst does, however, accuse the NIH of what is bordering on scientific misconduct:
A summary of this nature that fails to take into account the numerous limitations of the primary data is, I think, as good as worthless. As I know most of the RCTs included in the analyses, I predict that the overall picture generated by this review would have changed substantially, if the risks of bias in the primary studies had been accounted for.
Personally, I find it lamentable that such a potentially worthy exercise ended up employing such lousy methodology. Perhaps even more lamentable is the fact that the NIH (or one of its Centers) can descend that low; to mislead the public in this way borders on scientific misconduct and is, in my view, unethical and unacceptable.
One notes that Prof. Ernst backs up every charge he makes with a detailed list of the review article’s shortcomings. Mr. Weeks even admits that some of Prof. Ernst’s criticisms have merit. There was a point that Mr. Weeks made that at first I thought might have validity, namely where he says that Prof. Ernst “denigrates the team for not knowing the difference between efficacy and effectiveness” and then writes that this is “the fact that the data tables available to the target audience through links in the article separate them out.” Then I went to the supplemental data tables. Let’s just say that I would…disagree…with Mr. Weeks’ characterization of the tables. To me it was very unclear where efficacy and effectiveness were being separated out. One wonders why, though, Mr. Weeks didn’t rebut any substantive criticisms by either Dr. Vagg or myself and only tried to do so with Prof. Ernst. It couldn’t be that we did better than Prof. Ernst, and Mr. Weeks’ couldn’t find anything to rebut other than our tone, could it? No, even I’m not that egotistical.
The “birther” movement is invoked
For someone who is so very, very offended by inflammatory language and has a penchant for likening his critics as being akin to Donald Trump, Mr. Weeks sure does pull a couple of Trump-like moves. For instance, he accuses the critics of NCCIH of the logical fallacy of poisoning the well:
An additional reason that the article is deemed “worthless” is particularly resonant with the strategies of candidate Trump. Trump has led “a five-year long smear of the nation’s first black president” by questioning the right to office of current president Barack Obama through suggesting—despite hard evidence to the contrary—that Obama wasn’t born in the United States. Here is the echoing language from the British antagonist to the NCCIH: “The article is from the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, a part of the NIH which has been criticised repeatedly for being biased in favour of alternative medicine.” By its birth in the NCCIH, the work is damned. Or, as the surgical oncologist suggested, if doctors of chiropractic or naturopathic medicine are involved, it must be worthless. Such logic is akin to racial profiling. Condemnation due to origin or tribe.
Wow. First, that birther analogy is really, really strained, particularly when Mr. Weeks stretches it to encompass racial profiling. Pointing out that quacks are in high ranking positions in NCCIH and using that to point out the bias in NCCIH is akin to “racial profiling”? Histrionic much, Mr. Weeks?
Of course, poisoning the well can be a logical fallacy, particularly if the only argument used is to point out negative aspects of a person or institution espousing a viewpoint one is critical of. However, it’s not always illegitimate to criticize the source of a viewpoint if that criticism suggests bias or incompetence. Indeed, criticizing the source can be valid when it is used as part (and not the main pillar) of an overall argument that is relevant to demonstrating why that viewpoint is not valid. Not surprisingly, Mr. Weeks eschews answering most of the substance of our criticisms and zeros in like a laser beam on the tone issues and what he perceives as poisoning the well. Also, one notes another big difference between criticizing NCCIH and racial profiling. A person can’t do anything about his or her race. A person is born that way. Criticizing actual behavior is much different. A better analogy would be behavioral profiling, not racial profiling. Based on what chiropractors and naturopaths do when they practice medicine, it is not at all unreasonable to be more skeptical of a purportedly scientific paper they’ve written because of their embrace of pseudoscientific systems of medicine that are not based in science or even reality.
Two tribes go to war
Now here’s the fun part. After having whined on and on about how nasty and tribalistic skeptics are, Mr. Weeks draws a contrast between the purported virtue of “his” tribe compared to “our” tribe. Noting that many CAM practitioners are not happy with the pronouncements of NCCIH on the efficacy of various CAM modalities, he brings up examples of “civil” discourse. One is by a naturopath named Michael Traub, who wrote a rebuttal to a less than enthusiastic article on the efficacy of CAM approaches to skin disorders, citing literature. That’s nice. We do the same thing when appropriate. The other is from a chiropractor, William Meeker, who wrote to Mr. Weeks with the preface of “I am biased,” which leads Mr. Weeks to exult:
Perhaps I am biased. What a welcome, humble perspective! In fact, in a context in which a third of what is done in regular medicine is unnecessary, in which quality science is still attached to but a fraction of what is done, and in which frightening levels of morbidity and mortality are endemic to medical delivery in the United States, such self questioning serves us all.
Of course, as usual, Mr. Weeks invokes some common CAM tropes here, exaggerating how little of regular medical practice is supported by good science, for instance, and pointing to problems with morbidity and mortality in medicine. Of course, I like to respond to such tropes with the observation that it is not CAM practitioners who discovered these problems, who quantify them, or who work on solutions to them. It is physicians and scientists in “conventional medicine.” That’s why I laughed when I saw the title of the paper asking whether CAM can reduce medical errors. So did Prof. Ernst, by the way.
Near the end, Mr. Weeks destroys my irony meter. Again:
Medical integration challenges us as humans. Achieving the form of justice known as optimal patient-centered care is a delicate balance scientifically, clinically, politically, and economically. Convened are historically separate and unequally resourced professions, guilds, and tribes. We need to bring our best selves to the table. In this diplomacy, we are served to apply the serenity prayer to decide where and how we spend our energies to find the optimal common ground. Wisdom leads us to the place that my colleague, at the top of this article, suggested I go, which was to not write this column. British poet Robert Graves provides us guidance: “Hark how they roar, but never turn your head/Nothing can change them, let them not change you.”
Yet, Mr. Weeks wrote this article anyway. I also take him at his word that he hasn’t been “changed.” I rather suspect that he’s been just this self-righteous and good at mud slinging all along. He’s also particularly good at the flounce. Having portrayed himself as having dirtied himself by getting into the mud with his critics despite the advice of his colleagues not to, he quickly pivots to the old “I have better things to do” ploy:
Now then, back to the challenging work of engaging and publishing the research that will best support us in “making use of all appropriate therapeutic and lifestyle approaches, healthcare professionals and disciplines to achieve optimal health and healing.”
That’ll show us! Would that that’s what Mr. Weeks were doing. Unfortunately, perusing recent issues of JACM, where I find credulous articles on cupping, associating body types in traditional Chinese medicine with hypertension, patient satisfaction with the National Acupuncture Detoxification Association Protocol in a community mental health setting, craniosacral therapy for low back pain, individualized homeopathy for psychotherapy, and grounding, I have a hard time accepting Mr. Weeks’ assertion that he’s doing anything of the sort. There’s even an article by Mr. Weeks credulously swallowing the utterly dubious case series touting the Bredesen protocol for Alzheimer’s disease, which both Steve Novella and someone near and dear to this blog discussed and found to be sorely lacking in anything resembling scientific rigor.
We at SBM are more than happy to engage in civil discourse with CAM practitioners. However, we admit to bias. (Look for that sentence to be quote-mined.) In fact, we make no bones about our bias. We are biased in favor good science and against bad science. In contrast, no matter how much he deludes himself otherwise, Mr. Weeks’ bias is so much in favor of CAM, integrative medicine, or whatever you want to call the pseudoscience and quackery that these new medical specialties are “integrating” into medicine that he fails to recognize just how bad the science is supporting it. If that’s “polarization,” so be it! Not all polarization is bad, and certainly in this case some degree of polarization is necessary.
The way to win skeptics over is not to whine about how very, very mean we are, because there are a lot of us who are actually not very mean at all and go out of our way to be civil, for example, Steve Novella. I can easily counter Mr. Weeks’ bruised feelings from a bit of sarcasm and a few insults by pointing out that I’ve had CAM advocates go far beyond simply calling me nasty names on the Internet to trying to get me fired from my job on multiple occasions over the last 12 years, to reporting me to my state medical board for my writing, to complaining to the FBI about me. (I kid you not.) So, Mr. Weeks will excuse me if I don’t leap to apologize for a bit of sarcasm and snark here and there. His tribe is at least as tribal as mine, probably even more so.
Of course, Mr. Weeks can easily silence that sarcasm and snark. All it would take would be consistent good science from well-designed, well-executed preclinical laboratory and animal experiments and clinical trials on CAM to demonstrate their value, something he is now in a position to provide. I won’t hold my breath waiting, however, because I was probably too blithe about saying how easy it would be for Mr. Weeks. After all, you can’t publish what doesn’t exist.

A whole issue of JACM devoted to “integrative oncology” propaganda? Oh, goody.
Last week, The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine published a Special Focus Issue on “integrative oncology.” In reality, it’s propaganda that promotes pseudoscience and the “integration” of quackery into oncology.
David Gorski on October 1, 2018
Link

As I’ve discussed on this blog more times than I can remember over the last decade, I’m not a fan of so-called “integrative medicine” because it involves “integrating” pseudoscience and quackery such as homeopathy and acupuncture with real, science-based medicine (SBM) and co-opting basically all dietary, lifestyle, and non-pharmacologic interventions as somehow being “alternative” and therefore “integrative” when in fact they are and always have been a part of SBM. (Particularly annoying is how integrative medicine advocates are also co-opting the opioid crisis to promote the coverage of quackery like acupuncture by insurers as part of the solution to the problem.) Because I’m a surgeon specializing in treating breast cancer, I particularly detest the bastard offspring of “integrative medicine” known as “integrative oncology,” to the point that I even managed to publish a peer-reviewed commentary in Nature Reviews Cancer explaining why, contrary to how proponents like the Society for Integrative Oncology (SIO) portray it, integrative oncology is far from being the “best of both worlds,” even as they have a hard time defining just what their specialty actually is.
So when I saw a press release drop in my email in box last week about a “Special Focus Issue” of one of the flagship journals for “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM), “integrative medicine,” or whatever you want to call it these days, I took notice. The journal is The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine (JACM), which is edited by our old “friend” John Weeks, you know, the guy who once compared me to Donald Trump, thus guaranteeing that we will never be friends. The issue is a Special Focus Issue on Integrative Oncology:
A series of fascinating and thought-provoking articles from North America, Europe, the Middle East, and Asia – 6 invited reviews, 13 original research articles, 7 commentaries, and 2 editorials – have been selected to appear in this Special Focus Issue by Guest Editors Moshe Frenkel, MD, University of Texas Medical Branch, Director of the Complementary and Integrative Medicine Unit at Meir Medical Center, Israel and Lynda Balneaves, PhD RN, President of the Society for Integrative Oncology and Associate Professor, Rady Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Manitoba, Canada.
Yes, it’s a lot to go through, 28 articles. Fortunately, I don’t have to go through it all, and if I decide after writing this that I didn’t cover as much of the issue as I think I should have, I can always do a followup post in a week or two and tie up any loose ends that might be left (and, given how much there is to read here, there will be loose ends). The issue will be available free online until October 24; so you can read it if you wish. Naturally, I’ll tend to gravitate towards articles involving my own specialty, but certainly not exclusively. I’ll also probably (mostly) ignore the “original research articles,” because I’m more interested in what advocates want to do with integrative oncology than I am in the usual dubious research used to support integrating quackery with medicine or co-opting diet or exercise as somehow “integrative.”
The editors
Before I discuss the content, I think it’s worth briefly discussing the editors. Most of our regular readers probably know who John Weeks is. He’s been a relentless activist for incorporating pseudoscience and quackery into medicine, first in the form of CAM or integrative medicine. He’s been mentioned or the main subject in quite a few posts here and at my not-so-super-secret other blog, such as the aforementioned time when he compared advocates of SBM, including Tim Caulfield, Steve Novella, and myself, to Donald Trump, leading Steve to note drily, “I wonder if it’s time to extend Godwin’s law to include gratuitous references to Trump.” (Of course, this was two years ago, a month before Trump was elected President; so with the benefit of hindsight I respond, “Hell, yes!”)
I first noticed Mr. Weeks as editor of The Integrator Blog, one of the most vociferous boosters of CAM or “integrative medicine” on the Internet. Mr. Weeks is not a scientist or physician—or even a practitioner of one of the alternative medicine “disciplines” whose “integration” into real medicine he favors; yet somehow he was appointed editor of JACM in 2016, despite having no relevant experience as an editor and writer that would qualify him to be the editor of an academic medical journal. He is, however, very good at propaganda and promotion, and that the JACM valued those skills over the skills of an actual scientist or academic physician to the point of hiring someone like Mr. Weeks as editor should tell you all you need to know about the academic rigor of the journal.
But what about Moshe Frenkel, MD? I haven’t really written about him here, although I did mention him briefly in a post about how it’s a myth that integrative oncology never recommends alternative treatments without conventional medicine. Let’s just say that Dr. Frenkel, who used to be the chief of the integrative oncology service at U.T-M.D. Anderson Cancer Center but is now back in private practice while still holding a clinical faculty appointment at the University of Texas Medical Branch at Galveston, with an additional affiliation with the Institute of Oncology Meir Medical Center, is a believer in homeopathy. Indeed, he once wrote an article entitled “Is There a Role for Homeopathy in Cancer Care? Questions and Challenges“, which was lovingly deconstructed by a friend of the blog. I first encountered him when he published a rather terrible study in which he tested homeopathic remedies against breast cancer cell lines and got a positive result, almost certainly because his methodology was so shoddy, as explained by both Rachel Dunlop and the aforementioned friend of the blog.
Then there’s Lynda Balneaves, PhD RN, Associate Professor, Rady Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Manitoba, Canada. We’ve met her before, too, specifically in her role as the current president of the SIO, as well as for her contribution to “integrative oncology” guidelines for breast cancer, trying (and failing) to define just what the heck “integrative oncology” actually is, and getting the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) to endorse SIO’s guidelines for breast cancer. I was particularly annoyed by her dismissal of “skeptics”:
I believe that there are certain people who are professional skeptics. That is the focus of their career. They have a vested interest in promoting that perspective. A lot of their criticisms, when you unpack them, are grounded in philosophical differences. From my experience in oncology, when I get those comments, their concern stems from an experience in which a patient was given bad advice and their therapy was not evidence-based. I respect that perspective. I have seen it myself.
However, these critiques sometimes may reflect ignorance about the current state of evidence that exists in integrative medicine. Many of the individuals who provide these critiques have no experience in integrative medicine research or practice. They have very limited knowledge of the therapies that exist and the evidence that supports them. Many of them have never worked with patients, particularly those with a cancer diagnosis who are looking for therapies that are going to preserve their hope, give them a sense of control, and perhaps manage some of the toxic side effects that many of our conventional therapies have.
Yes, basically she’s dismissing critics who don’t actually practice or research “integrative medicine”. Let me just say that, although we don’t practice integrative medicine here (mainly because we view much of it as quackery), all of us have extensive knowledge of the therapies that exist and the evidence that supports them (or, to put it more accurately, the lack of evidence that supports them). I personally work with cancer patients. That’s why I was profoundly offended by Balneaves’ ignorant dismissal of skeptics.
So, yes, we have true believers editing this Special Focus Issue.
The propaganda begins
The first article in the issue is, as is usually the case for Special Focus Issues like this, an introduction by the editors. In this case, the introduction is entitled “Integrative Oncology: An Essential Feature of High-Quality Cancer Care“. I laughed out loud when I read that title and couldn’t help but think in my head my usual riff on The Princess Bride: “High-quality cancer care. You keep using that term. I do not think it means what you think it means.” Especially if you think that adding pseudoscience to cancer care means “high quality.” One thing I did learn from this article is that there’s a new buzzword in town that appears to be the preferred term for describe CAM or “integrative medicine”, and it’s “complementary and integrative medicine”. Unfortunately the abbreviation for this term (CIM) doesn’t slip as nicely off the tongue as the abbreviation for one of the old terms (CAM, for complementary and alternative medicine). The term is also rather self-contradictory as well. After all “complementary” is supposed to mean “in addition to” and is a term that integrative medicine has been trying to get away from over the last couple of decades because it implies that what its practitioners are doing is not necessary but merely “complementary” to real medicine. That’s the entire reason why the term “integrative medicine” evolved in the first place!
In any event, after using the usual appeal to popularity fallacy to justify integrative oncology, Frenkel and Balneaves note:
As a result, integrative oncology has emerged as a scientific field that aims to address this interest through collaborative practice and rigorous research. Integrative oncology, as defined in a recent article, “is a patient-centered evidence-informed field of cancer care that utilizes mind and body practices, natural products, and/or lifestyle modifications from different traditions alongside conventional cancer treatments.11 Integrative oncology aims to optimize health, QOL, and clinical outcomes across the cancer care continuum and to empower people to prevent cancer and become active participants in their healthcare before, during, and beyond cancer treatment.”11 This field has grown rapidly in the past decade, and integrative oncology practice has emerged in North America, Europe, the Middle East, and Asia.5,12
As integrative oncology has developed as a clinical specialty, so too has research on the efficacy and safety of CIM therapies in cancer care. In the past decade, researchers and clinicians at numerous academic centers worldwide have examined the potential supportive role of integrative oncology in symptom management and enhancing the QOL of cancer patients and their families.13–15 In addition, recent studies suggest that CIM integration might have direct effect on survival.16,17 Research in integrative oncology has now reached the point that clinical guidelines focusing on the role of integrative practices are being developed and endorsed by leading oncology organizations, including the American Society of Clinical Oncology and the Society for Integrative Oncology.18
That last part, unfortunately, is true. However, this is the first time I’ve heard it claimed by advocates of integrative oncology that “CIM” might have a direct effect on survival; so I looked up references #16 and #17. Then my memory returned. This is nothing more than the usual rebranding of exercise, nutrition, and other lifestyle changes as being “integrative”. The references list a bunch of studies regarding diet, exercise, and survival, some of which didn’t appear to control for obvious confounders. The authors of one paper were entirely too credulous towards the evidence regarding psychsocial and “mind-body” interventions in breast cancer, apparently not examining the evidence as skeptically as our occasional guest contributor Jim Coyne did. In any event, the finding that better nutrition and exercise can improve survival in some cancers is neither novel nor particularly surprising.
Teaching integrative oncology
Not surprisingly, there is a lot of emphasis on “teaching” integrative oncology, or, as I look at it, proselytizing. For instance, there’s an article by Claudia Witt, whom we’ve met before. As Mark Crislip pointed out, she’s a believer in homeopathy and has published multiple articles on it, including one on homeopathy for back pain. Amusingly, she was the lead author on an SIO-commissioned article developing a definition for integrative oncology. The article is, of course, about training oncology physicians to advise their patients on complementary and integrative medicine. Of course, I’m all for such training, but my idea of what would constitute good training in this skill is very different from what integrative oncology advocates would think of as good training.
Suzanna Zick, on the other hand, the naturopath who, much to my shame, runs the integrative medicine program for the Department of Family Medicine at my alma mater, the University of Michigan, where credulous grand rounds on homeopathy are now a feature, has just the thing: her Integrative Oncology Scholars Program, which she touts as a “model for integrative oncology education.” The goal of the program is:
It has the joint goals of training 100 integrative oncology (IO) leaders over 4 years and facilitating partnerships between IO leaders and complementary practitioners within their communities. Eligible participants, who are designated as IOS, include a multidisciplinary selection of physicians, physician assistants, nurses, psychologists, social workers, physical or occupational therapists, and pharmacists, who are actively engaged in clinical oncology practice. IOS instructors are experts in the field of IO and/or adult education and reflect the multidisciplinary nature of the program with professions as diverse as patient advocates to oncology clinicians. Details on course instructors, program eligibility, and how to apply are available on the IOS Program website.
All I can say is that if the curriculum of this program is anything like the eLearning program in acupuncture offered by Zick’s department, it’s going to be a load of credulous nonsense. I do agree, though, with Mark Crislip, who in his usual sarcastic fashion observed, in essence, that if you want someone to teach prescientific mysticism and medicine, you couldn’t do better than a naturopath, and this program just started in August with its first 25 trainees.
Attacking criticism
Next up, John Weeks can’t resist contributing an article, “Expanding the Circle for the Care of People with Cancer“. In it, he takes some verbiage to settle a score regarding a study published in July by Skyler Johnson and his colleagues showing that CAM, CIM, or “integrative medicine” use was associated with poorer survival in several cancers. Mr. Weeks is not at all happy about it, not at all:
In the closing days of making selections among the outpouring of nearly 70 article submissions, a research-inspired story hit the mainstream media with a force that underscored just why this continued bridge building and circle expansion are needed. Picture yourself as an individual in the throes of fear amid a new cancer diagnosis. You pick up the New York Times and read this headline: “People who used herbs, acupuncture and other complementary treatments tended to die earlier than those who didn’t.” The message, broadcast through many of the world’s most powerful media channels, was quickly challenged by leading integrative oncologists as a major misclassification error. The differences in lifespan found were all due to patients delaying or refusing recommended care—thus choosing “alternatives” to treatment rather than “complementary” care that would be part of an integrative oncology strategy.6 Yet, there it was for anyone considering their choices: research from a respected medical school, Yale, in a pre-eminent journal, JAMA Oncology, misleading patients who, quite likely, received little or no guidance on integrative practices from the narrow healthcare team at the institution where they are receiving their powerful and damaging cancer treatments.
This misclassification was symptom, not cause. Consider a group of male academics setting a curriculum in women’s studies, or of white people deciding how to involve people of color. The cause is the failure of the authors and the journal editors to have Thibault on their shoulder, urging them to expand their circle of collaboration. They did not need to look far to expand their circle and bring in an expert who knew something about the field on which they were passing a sort of life and death judgment. The American Society for Clinical Oncology has endorsed breast cancer guidelines from the SIO.7 The Journal of the National Cancer Institute partnered with SIO on an entire special issue.8 At the time of the Yale study, the late integrative oncologist Ather Ali, ND, MPH, was head of an integrative oncology program at a Yale teaching center for cancer treatment.
First off, Mr. Weeks points to Yale having a naturopath as the head of integrative oncology as though it were a good thing. It’s not, and I’m sure the fact that Yale had a naturopath running anything at Yale came close to giving our fearless leader Steve Novella a stroke. Naturopathy is quackery. We’ve written more articles and spilled more digital ink into the ether explaining why than there is room to recount here. It’s sad that Ali died at such a young age, but I wasn’t happy that he had a faculty appointment at Yale.
Ah, yes. Mr. Weeks does love his “no true Scotsman” fallacy. “No, no, no, it’s not us, the “respectable” ones advocating the integration of quackery into oncology”, Weeks seems to be saying. “We’d never do that.” Of course, the news stories I saw were careful to point out that this was an association, and Johnson and his coauthors themselves specifically chose patients who had used at least one conventional modality as part of their cancer treatment. They also did point out that the decreased survival observed appeared to be due to a higher tendency among those using CIM (I’ll give in and use the term Weeks likes to use, at least for this one post) to refuse at least one form of conventional therapy. I also pointed out that a common claim among “integrative oncology” advocates is that their addition of woo to the mix helps patients stay the course and make it through their treatments. As I said at the time, at the very least, the result of Johnson et al suggest that when the SIO or other CIM advocates claim that CIM is worthwhile because it keeps these patients undergoing conventional therapy, they’re either full of it or at the very least way, way, way overstating the case, and this bit of data further suggests that, even if integrative oncology does keep patients wanting “natural” therapies in the fold of SBM, it’s not doing a very good job of it. I was also amused by Weeks’ arrogance in claiming that, if only Johnson et al had consulted an integrative oncology expert, they could have avoided “embarrassing” themselves so.
But fear not. According to Mr. Weeks, integrative oncology shall overcome. He even invokes a name that quacks and pseudoscientists love to invoke when predicting that their beliefs will be vindicated, Thomas Kuhn and his book The Structure of Scientific Revolution, paraphrasing Kuhn and saying that “we see the most resistant behavior just before a paradigm shift occurs.” Maybe. Personally, I wish we saw more resistance to the creeping infiltration of quackery into oncology and medicine; from my perspective there hasn’t been nearly enough resistance, and resistance is declining, not increasing.
Exceptional responders and integrative oncology
If you want to get an idea, though, of the propaganda and how far it goes in this issue, you should check out Glenn Sabin’s contribution, “Exceptional Responders, Outliers, and Radical Remissions“. Oncologists use the term “exceptional responder” to describe a cancer patient whose response to therapy is, well, exceptional. That can range from complete remission where none is expected to a much better than expected response. The formal definition of an exceptional responder according to the National Cancer Institute is a patient with cancer who has:
    • a complete response to a drug(s) where complete response is seen in less than 10% of patients receiving similar treatment; or
    • a partial response lasting at least 6 months where such a response is seen in less than 10% of patients receiving similar treatment; or
    • a complete or partial response that lasts longer than 3 times the median response duration in the literature for the treatment
Exceptional responders are a hot research topic in precision medicine initiatives, because scientists now believe they have the tools to start to figure out why some people respond so much better to certain drugs and use that information to try to improve our treatments. Glenn Sabin, you might remember, is a man who believes he cured himself of chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) using only alternative medicine and lifestyle interventions and now advocates “N-of-1” trials of alternative medicine. As I’ve explained in great detail elsewhere, the quackery almost certainly wasn’t what resulted in his good fortune. It’s far more likely that he underwent a spontaneous remission, which, albeit rare in CLL, is not so rare as to be less likely than all the quackery Sabin used having cured him, especially since Sabin suffered from his disease for 20 years before it resolved. In any event, he argues thusly:
Researcher Kelly A. Turner, PhD, based her doctoral thesis4 on so-called spontaneous remission. Turner conducted interviews with scores of cancer patients and healers from around the world for her book Radical Remission.5 Through the book’s website, Turner and her team have captured hundreds of outlier cancer cases. It is this author’s opinion that many of these remarkable patient narratives should be vetted and certified as exceptional responders. A subset of these cases should be developed into high-quality, peer-reviewed, published, and indexed case reports. The most remarkable of these cases should consider enrolling into the NEER trial and future trials that are sure to follow.
Integrative oncology delivered in academic settings has heretofore focused on supportive cancer care—utilizing lifestyle-based therapies, along with complementary interventions and agents—to mitigate the often-deleterious side effects of conventional care. There is a growing evidence base suggesting that these interventions and adherence to long-term positive behavior change may potentiate standard care, extend periods of disease-free survival, and possibly prolong overall survival.3 However, the academic integrative oncology field has heretofore not done enough to investigate and document exceptional responder cases. The author believes that this is a significant missed opportunity.
Only once investigators are curious enough to comprehensively investigate exceptional responders will they begin to understand how this may inform the evolution of precision medicine and the role of integrative oncology therein.
I’m all for studying exceptional responders, but Sabin seems to think that the various forms of quackery he espouses are part of the answer that explain why these patients were so fortunate and why their cancers regressed or didn’t progress, when it’s incredibly unlikely that the sorts of pseudoscientific treatments that Sabin believes to be effective had anything to do with it.
Show me the money
Finally, if there’s one thing that rankles “integrative medicine” practitioners, it’s that many of their services, such as they are, are not covered by government health plans like Medicare or Medicaid or by private insurance. (Insurance plan administrators are funny that way. They don’t like to pay for treatments that don’t work. Hell, they don’t like to pay for treatments that do work if they deem them too expensive.) Indeed, it’s long been a goal of various supporters of integrating quackery to get the quackery paid for, such as the manner in which advocates are on the verge of duping Oregon into paying for acupuncture treatments under the false pretense that it will decrease opioid use and, more importantly, abuse. This brings us to an article by Patricia Herman, “The Problematic Economics of Integrative Oncology“.
In this article, I found a frighteningly passage:
What can be done to improve the economics of integrative oncology?
There are several steps that can be taken to improve the economic impacts of integrative oncology, which will increase patient access and lower financial toxicity for patients. The first is a fairly simple step available to all integrative oncology practitioners: determine the cost of your care to patients. These data can be captured from clinical records even in the absence of a formal study, and these costs can be substantial. A recent article by Standish et al.24 reports on data collected from the medical records of (n = 324) breast cancer patients at six clinics directed by oncology board-certified naturopathic doctors in Washington State. Costs were estimated to be $1,594 per year for early stage breast cancer and $6,200 per year for stage 4 breast cancer patients. Across all patients in their study, 21% of these integrative oncology costs were out-of-pocket. Note that this percentage would be higher nationally because in Washington State coverage is available for every category of provider, including naturopathic physicians. Understanding these costs is important for improving costs to patients.
So in the state of Washington we have breast cancer patients paying up to $6,200 a year for snake oil, fairy dust, and quackery, all under the imprimatur of the state’s licensing board and its apparent law mandating insurance coverage for naturopaths. Of course, it would help a lot more if there were actual…oh, you know…evidence of efficacy. Herman recommends including a cost analysis in any randomized clinical trial of integrative medicine modalities undertaken, which is all well and good, but there’s no good scientific reason to do a lot of those studies in the first place given the extreme implausibility of many “CIM” modalities. In the end, she concludes:
The economics of integrative oncology are problematic because of the lack of good studies, the lack of historic incentives for efficiency, and the high cost of cancer care and its financial toxicity on patients. However, these problems can be overcome, with help from one good economic evaluation at a time.
Personally, my retort would be to forget about the economic analyses and just show your woo works first! In the meantime, stop integrating quackery into oncology.
There are so many more articles in this Special Focus Issue that I might have to revisit it before October 24, so that readers can check out the source material if they want to. In the meantime, know that this issue is advertising and propaganda, not science.

FTC Sues Predatory Journal
Steven Novella on September 21, 2016
Link


Because I have a university e-mail address I frequently get spam from journals I have never heard of soliciting submissions, and even offering editorial positions. I have generally ignored them, and it’s probably a good thing.
Over the last decade we have seen the rise of open-access science journals. The idea is a good one – journals charge a moderate fee to publish an article to cover costs, and then make all articles freely available online. It is a great way to leverage the power of the internet and make published science freely available. This contrasts to the subscription model where published research often sits behind a very expensive paywall.
The problem with the open-access model is that it created the means to easily generate income through predatory behavior. All you need is a website and minimal infrastructure and you can look like a real journal. Since authors are paying you to publish each article, just publish anything that gets submitted.
You can pretend to do editing and peer-review without really doing it. You can also e-mail young academics inviting them to be editors and peer-reviewers and hope that enough of them will be fooled into doing this free work for you – at least enough that you can create the superficial appearance of being a real journal. To maximize profits you can also solicit articles without being up front about the fees, and then once a paper is submitted hit the author with big fees and hold their paper (which may represent years of work) essentially hostage until they pay.
The FTC steps in
This pattern of behavior has been increasingly common, and preys disproportionately on young and third-world academics, the ones who can least afford it.
Greg Ashe is an attorney for the Federal Trade Commission (FTC). He also is an astrophysicist and so is familiar with scientific publications. He is determined to go after so-called predatory journals, and is now suing one company, OMICS, which publishes more than 700 open-access journals.
As Ashe says, the FTC is not concerned with the business model or with the peer-review process. That is not their job. They are concerned with outright fraud. Their accusation against OMICS is that they are not upfront about their fees and they are not transparent about their peer-review process.
Charging hidden fees is a bait-and-switch behavior that can be considered fraud. Scientists are not aware of the fees ($900 for one article in the case reported above) until after OMICS has their paper.
Further, presenting yourself as peer-reviewed when you are not, in order to essentially trick people into buying your service, is also fraud. These are arguably within the purview of the FTC.
The FTC case against OMICS is now a test case and is likely to have a profound effect on the open-access industry. Again, Ashe is clear to point out he is not trying to make companies like OMICS stop publishing, just change their predatory behavior.
The scientific community’s response
The FTC action comes in the wake of increasing attention from the scientific community toward predatory journals. I discussed in 2014 several efforts to expose their predatory practices.
In 2013 John Bohannon published the results of a sting operation against open-access journals. He submitted a bogus article to 304 open-access journals, and over half of them published the article without any apparent editorial or peer-review.
Jeffrey Beall maintains a list of possible predatory journals. Any author can look at his black list before submitting their article.
A 2015 study of predatory journals found:
Over the studied period, predatory journals have rapidly increased their publication volumes from 53,000 in 2010 to an estimated 420,000 articles in 2014, published by around 8,000 active journals. Early on, publishers with more than 100 journals dominated the market, but since 2012 publishers in the 10–99 journal size category have captured the largest market share. The regional distribution of both the publisher’s country and authorship is highly skewed, in particular Asia and Africa contributed three quarters of authors. Authors paid an average article processing charge of 178 USD per article for articles typically published within 2 to 3 months of submission.
There is growing concern not just about the effect this has on poor third-world researchers who are targeted by such journals, but on the communication of science itself.
It is already difficult to develop an objective and reliable view of what the totality of scientific evidence says about a specific question. There is often a lot of conflicting evidence, evidence of varying quality, and multiple sources of research bias. A scientist has to sift through all of this to tease out the real signal from this noise.
The proliferation of dubious open-access journals adds tremendously to the noise – 420,000 articles in 2014. Many of these might get filtered out because they are not indexed among legitimate peer-reviewed journals, and that’s a good thing. But they are still on the internet (they are open-access) and will pollute any search for information on the topics they cover. They are also damaging to the reputation of legitimate open-access journals.
The future
It seems clear there is an enduring place for open-access journals in science and academia. Business models may continue to evolve, but having free access to scientific information is definitely a net positive.
We are, however, in an awkward transition phase. As is often the case with new opportunities, predators swoop in and take advantage of the new territory and relative lack of oversight and regulations.
It seems that the FTC has a legitimate role to play in countering outright fraud in the industry, and they are being mindful of the limits of their purview.
Meanwhile, the academic and scientific community needs to take the problem of predatory journals very seriously and continue to explore ways of reining them in and protecting young and vulnerable academics. They also need to stem the flood of low-grade information that can potentially drown out more legitimate academic activity.

The Problem with Predatory Journals
Steven Novella on September 3, 2025
Link
The World Wide Web has proven to be a transformative communication technology (we are using it right now). At the same time there have been some rather negative unforeseen consequences. Significantly lowering the threshold for establishing a communications outlet has democratized content creation and allows users unprecedented access to information from around the world. But it has also lowered the threshold for unscrupulous agents, allowing for a flood of misinformation, disinformation, low quality information, spam, and all sorts of cons.
One area where this has been perhaps especially destructive is in scientific publishing. Here we see a classic example of the trade-off dilemma between editorial quality and open access. Scientific publishing is one area where it is easy to see the need for quality control. Science is a collective endeavor where all research is building on prior research. Scientists cite each other’s work, include the work of others in systematic reviews, and use the collective research to make many important decisions – about funding, their own research, investment in technology, and regulations.
When this collective body of scientific research becomes contaminated with either fraudulent or low-quality research, it gums up the whole system. It creates massive inefficiency and adversely affects decision-making. You certainly wouldn’t want your doctor to be making treatment recommendations on fraudulent or poor-quality research. This is why there is a system in place to evaluate research quality – from funding organizations to universities, journal editors, peer reviewers, and the scientific community at large. But this process can have its own biases, and might inhibit legitimate but controversial research. A journal editor might deem research to be of low quality partly because its conclusions conflict with their own research or scientific conclusions.
There is no perfect answer. The best we can do is have multiple checks in the system and to make a carefully calibrated trade-off between various priorities. The system we have is flawed, but it basically works. High quality research tends to gravitate toward high quality journals, which have the highest “impact” on the community. Bad research generally doesn’t replicate well and will tend to get picked apart by experts. A new idea that is having trouble breaking through will tend to break through eventually – the virtue of being correct usually wins out in the end.
But eventually working out, mostly, in the end isn’t enough. We also want to know how efficient the whole system is. How quickly is fraud and bad research weeded out? We also want to make sure we are moving in the direction of improved research quality, and that the outcome of scientific research is translating to our society effectively and efficiently. This means we have to track trends – and one of those trends is the rise of so-called “predatory” journals.
Predatory or similar scientific journals result from basically two things – the ease of creating an online journal because of the web, and the open-access journal business model. The traditional journal model is based on subscriptions and advertising, which benefit from high quality, high profile, and high impact research. This has its trade-offs too, but overall it’s not a bad model. The open-access business model is to charge researchers for publishing their research, then make the results open-access to the world. This has the benefit of making scientific research open to all, and not hidden behind a paywall. But it creates the perverse incentive to publish lots of articles, regardless of quality. In many cases, that is what is happening.
Scientists and academics, once realizing the issue, have dealt with it by vetting new journals for their process and quality. They can then create essentially a black list of demonstrable low quality or even predatory journals (those that will publish and even solicit any low quality study to collect the publication fee, and then publish online with little or no editorial filter). Or you can create a white list of journals that have passed a thorough vetting process and meet minimum quality standards.
The problem is that this is a lot of work. New predatory journals are easy to create. Once they are identified and blacklisted, the company behind the journal can simply create a new journal with a slightly different name and URL. They are essentially outstripping the ability of academics to evaluate them.
One attempt to rein in the proliferation of such journals using a new AI program to screen journals for the probability that they are predatory. The researchers behind this effort published the results of their first search. They screened over 15,000 open access journals. Just that fact alone is a bit alarming – that is a lot of scientific journals. The AI flagged about 1,300 of them as probably predatory, and then human evaluators looked at those 1,300 and confirmed that about 1,000 of them were predatory – so the AI flagged about 300 false positives. Keep in mind, these thousand journals collectively publish hundreds of thousands of articles each year, which generate millions of citations.
There are lots of systemic issues at work here, and predatory journals are partly a symptom of these problems. But they significantly exacerbate these issues and are making it impossible for legitimate researchers to keep up. Developing new tools for dealing with this flood of low-quality research is essential. This one tool will not be enough, but perhaps it can help.
I think ultimately, a white list of properly vetted science journals, kept to a stringent standard of quality, is the only solution. This won’t stop other journals from popping up, but at least researchers and those in decision-making positions will be able to know if a piece of science they are relying on has been properly vetted. (Again, no guarantee it is correct, but at least it went through some legitimate process.)
Another aspect to this issue is the communication of science to the public. The existence of large numbers of low-quality journals easily accessible and shareable online means that anyone can easily find research to support whatever position they want to take. Further, AI is trained on this flood of low quality research. This makes it almost impossible to have a conversation about any scientific topic – which tends to devolve into dueling citations. Having open-access to scientific studies does not make everyone a scientist, but it makes it easy to pretend that you are.


   Andrew Weil and “integrative medicine”: The ultimate triumph of quackery?
David Gorski 
Link
A board certification in woo?
I’ve been harshly critical of the entire concept of “integrative medicine” (IM), which has over the last few years nearly supplanted the former term used for non-science-based medicine or medicine based on prescientific ideas represented as though it were scientific medicine, “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM). Indeed, just last week I pointed out how IM is far more about marketing than it is about science or medicine, and over the last three years I’ve been particularly harsh on the concept of “integrative oncology,” which is actually being represented as a “subspecialty” of IM. Despite the utter lack of a rationale based on science or the scientific basis of medicine, IM has still been making inroads into academic medical centers, where I tend to refer to it with the unapologetically disparaging term “quackademic medicine.” Even worse, now, increasingly, such woo has been insinuating its way into community medical centers as well.
Arguably, the man who has done more than any individual to promote the quackification of science-based medicine is Dr. Andrew Weil. (At least, I can’t think of any single person who’s done more during his lifetime to promote the infiltration of quackery into medicine. Readers are free to chime in if they know of someone who could challenge Weil for the title of King of Quackademic Medicine.) As I pointed out the last time I discussed him, Dr. Weil doesn’t really like science-based medicine. Oh, no, he doesn’t like it at all. Unfortunately, he’s been very successful in promoting quackademic medicine. He’s also arguably been the single most successful person at legitimizing what used to be viewed as quackery. Master of the domain of “integrative medicine,” having formed a model of an “integrative medicine in residency” that’s spread like kudzu through quackademia, all from his redoubt at the University of Arizona, Dr. Weil has now announced his intention for the next phase of his “integrating” pseudoscience with SBM. I learn this from The Integrator Blog, which has as a recent headline from last week Special Report: “Strategic Change in Direction” as Weil’s Arizona Center Commits to Creation of American Board of Integrative Medicine:
In a major strategic shift, the University of Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine (ACIM) has announced that it will lead the creation of a formal specialty for medical doctors in integrative medicine. ACIM, founded by Andrew Weil, MD and directed by Victoria Maizes, MD, is in dialogue with the American Board of Physician Specialties toward establishing an American Board of Integrative Medicine. They are collaborating with leaders of the American Board of Integrative and Holistic Medicine (ABIHM). Here is the ACIM announcement, a statement from two ABIHM leaders, a brief interview with Maizes and the list of 18 founding Board members. Is this the right strategic choice? What impact will this have on integrative medicine and the broader integrative healthcare movement?
At first, I wasn’t aware that this was, in fact, any sort of “strategic shift.” Being recognized as a medical specialty, complete with standards for an educational curriculum during residency or fellowship and board exams for certification, is the ultimate validation of legitimacy as a medical specialty, at least as far as medical education, regulation, and the overall medical world goes. If Dr. Weil could achieve this, it would become virtually impossible to eliminate woo from medicine, at least in the United States. It would be codified as a medical specialty by one of the three major certifying boards that certify physicians as being qualified in specific specialties, in this case the American Board of Physician Specialties (ABPS). The other boards include American Osteopathic Association Bureau of Osteopathic Specialists (which only certifies doctors with the DO degree) and the American Board of Medical Specialties. Of these, the last one, the ABMS, is the board that really matters in most states. For instance, the board under which I’m Board-certified in Surgery is, appropriately enough, the American Board of Surgery. The ABS is the umbrella board that certifies surgeons in General Surgery, Vascular Surgery, Pediatric Surgery, Surgical Critical Care, Hand Surgery, and others. In addition, the ABMS certifies 23 other specialties, including Anesthesiology, Emergency Medicine, Internal Medicine, Pathology, Pediatrics, and many others. These boards set up minimum standards for knowledge and skills and devise tests and documentation necessary to be “certified.” Generally, board certification requires an MD or DO degree, completion of an accredited residency in the relevant specialty, and the passing of written and oral examinations. Some specialties require documentation of practice results (such as plastic surgery, which requires a case log, complete with “before and after” photos)
One thing that our non-U.S. readers might find odd (and that a surprising number of U.S. residents don’t even know) is that there is no national licensure of physicians in the United States. Each state writes its own laws and has its own medical board. It is also necessary to understand that board certification is an entirely separate process from state licensure. In fact, you don’t have to be board-certified to have a medical license; in most states, all you have to have is a medical degree and a year of postgraduate training (internship). Indeed, I got my first medical license during my residency, long before I ever achieved Board certification in Surgery. In fact, in the old days, it was entirely possible to practice for an entire career without being board certified, and many physicians did just that. There are even a few older physicians left who still practice without board certification, having in effect been “grandfathered” into the system. These days, however, if you want to be on the staff of a hospital or be an approved provider on an insurance plan, you pretty much have to be board certified in your specialty. If you’re not, you’ll be permanently consigned to a lower tier of practice, such as moonlighting jobs or jobs as “house physicians” who cover patients in hospitals without residents during nights and weekends. Exceptions are sometimes made in rural hospitals that are desperate for physicians, but even these exceptions are disappearing. Basically, in order to practice as a fully independent professional in the United States, you have to be board-certified or board eligible.
So why would Dr. Weil want to change course and seek a form of board certification for IM? Here’s how Dr. Weil himself describes the reason in the University of Arizona press release:
We are writing to let you know about an important decision that we recently made — a decision that represents a strategic change in direction for our Center. For many years we have resisted the idea of board certification in Integrative Medicine (IM). We have always believed that the principles and practices of IM should inform all specialties, rather than be developed into a new field. In other words, that dermatologists, surgeons, and family physicians alike all need to learn the principles of nutrition and mind-body medicine, and to value the innate healing capacity of the body. We still hold that belief.
But…
Earlier this year we approached the American Board of Physician Specialties (ABPS) to discuss creating a board in IM. We did so for many reasons; chief among them was to help patients discern who truly has training and expertise in IM. It is now popular in the marketplace to say you practice IM — yet anyone can say so, whether they studied for an hour, a weekend, or ten years.
This is actually pretty hilarious in its own way. This is almost the same reason that virtually every subspecialty that has ever applied to have a board certification process has cited as its reason for doing so. The reasons such a consideration almost inevitably come down to protecting the reputation of the specialty by defining who is and is not a member of the specialty. Apparently the desire to infuse all medical specialties with his woo cannot stand up to the cold, hard reality of how medicine really works. So now he wants his own boarded specialty, because he realizes that the only way IM will ever be taken seriously by patients is for it to be its own boarded specialty. Never mind where the board certification comes from, which currently is a highly dubious “board.”
The actual board that would be overseeing any board certification in IM would be, according to the press release the American Board of Integrative Holistic Medicine (ABIHM). This board was first formed in 1996 as the American Board of Holistic Medicine. A quick perusal of its FAQ regarding certification reveals a number of interesting things. First, the only qualifications necessary to sit for the ABIHM boards are (1) and MD or DO; (2) a current medical license in the U.S. or Canada; and (3) board certification or board eligibility in a specialty accredited by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME). That’s it. No training program. No residency program in “holistic medicine,” “integrative medicine,” “complementary and alternative medicine,” or anything at all. You could be a radiologist, pathologist, or other specialties that don’t generally directly care for patients. In other words, if you’re a physician who’s board-certified or board-eligible in any currently recognized medical specialty, all you have to do to be board certified in IM is to take the test and pass it, which 85-90% of those who take it do on the first try and those who don’t can try again. Indeed, the ABIHM sends applicants its Course Curriculum Study Guide (CCSG) and recommends that applicants “be very familiar with the material in the CCSG before you sit for the exam.” The ABIHM also provides a review course but doesn’t require it.
You know, it’s half tempting for me to register for the exam and see if I can become a board-certified practitioner of IM. There’s nothing that says I can’t do it, and I’d get access to the review materials, which, I suspect, would be most illuminating. For example, how much homeopathy would I be expected to know? Acupuncture? Would I have to memorize meridians and acupuncture points? Would I have to know how to do reiki? Inquiring minds want to know, although this inquiring mind doesn’t want to know badly enough to pay the $800 it would take to register. Perhaps there are other, richer physicians who might want to go that route. If so, the deadline to get the cheap rate to take the test on November 12 is October 3.
John Weeks of The Integrator Blog describes a “town versus gown” divide in IM, in which the “townies” (i.e., the private practice, non-academic IM practitioners) very much wanted some sort of board certification, while the “gowns” (i.e., the centers of quackademic medicine) did not. He doesn’t really elaborate on the reasons for this conflict but points out that the name change to ABIHM was driven by a desire to “raise standards.” Of course, when one is discussing healing modalities not based in science but rather in prescientific mystical thinking, such as acupuncture, reiki, homeopathy, and the like, one can’t help but think that “raising standards” would involve eliminating such modalities from medicine altogether. Be that as it may, I find it rather telling as to why Dr. Weil chose to go the route he did, choosing a third rate certifying board over the certifying board that is generally recognized by every state, hospital, and insurance company:
Unlike the American Board of Medical Specialties (ABMS), which would require approval by every single specialty board, ABPS is interested in creating a single pathway, recognizes fellowship training, and is an innovator. We had hoped the ABMS would consider a Certificate of Added Qualification in IM — such as exists for geriatrics — which can be applied for by different residency specialties; but ABMS is eliminating that concept.
Our goal is to have all graduates of our 1000-hour fellowship become board certified. At the same time we have not relinquished our goal of bringing IM training to all physicians. The success of our Integrative Medicine in Residency makes us comfortable and confident that IM will become a part of all physicians’ basic training. This 200-hour program is being used in 22 family medicine and two internal medicine residencies. In 2012 we will begin a pilot in two pediatrics residencies.
This is an exciting step for the field of Integrative Medicine (IM). Board certification is widely recognized by physicians and the public alike as a critical step in establishing a field. The first meeting of the American Board of Integrative Medicine will take place in Tampa, Florida, October 10-11. Over a two-year period, we will set criteria for sitting for the board exam and develop a validated exam.
In other words, the ABMS had standards that were too high for Dr. Weil, whereas the ABPS is not. Let’s just put it this way. “Innovation” is not really what I want in a certifying board for a medical specialty. I prefer a boring dedication to science-based practice and a caution that leads new specialty acceptance to be evolutionary rather than revolutionary.
An end run around standards
Believe it or not, before I saw Dr. Weil’s press release and started doing a bit of research for this post, I had never heard of the AAPS or its companion board the ABPS. After all, the ABMS is the gold standard board through which the vast majority of physicians in this country are certified. Indeed, my very own specialty, surgical oncology, is not a boarded specialty at present. There are training programs approved by the Society of Surgical Oncology, but these fellowships do not lead to sitting for boards, and surgical oncology is viewed mainly as an offshoot of general surgery. Indeed, ever since I decided that I wanted to go into surgical oncology in the mid-1990s (and long before my entry into the field), there has been a debate over what surgical oncology is as a specialty and whether it should be fully distinct from general surgery. Remember that most cancer operations for breast cancer, GI malignancies, melanoma, and some other cancers have long been the purview of general surgeonss and even today in the U.S. most such operations are still carried out by general surgeons in the community. Surgical oncology, as envisioned, was originally going to cover more complex cancer operations, those needed by patients referred to tertiary medical centers and cancer centers like Memorial Sloan-Kettering and M.D. Anderson Cancer Centers. There was also, let’s face it, the question of turf. For example, multiple surgical specialties claim colon cancer as part of their areas of special expertise, including (now) general surgery, colorectal surgery, surgical oncology, and, increasingly, minimally invasive surgery.
The lack of board certification for surgical oncology is a situation that will not last much longer, though. It was announced at the SSO Meeting in March 2011 that, after decades of trying, the SSO had finally managed to win board certification for surgical oncology from the ABMS. The new board certification will be called Complex General Surgical Oncology and will be a subspecialty board under the ABS. It will require board certification in general surgery, plus fellowship training of at least two years beyond that in an approved fellowship program, followed by passing a board examination in surgical oncology.
Another interesting aspect of board certification in Complex General Surgical Oncology is that current practitioners and graduates of even approved surgical oncology training programs will not be grandfathered in. Whenever a new subspecialty peels off from an established, more general specialty, such as when vascular surgery peeled off of general surgery to become a recognized specialty, inevitably there are cries from current practitioners of that specialty for a mechanism to “grandfather” them in and provide a means for them to become board certified too without having to undergo residency or fellowship training again. For example, I am rapidly finishing my fifth decade of life; going back to a fellowship is not practical, nor would it be for the vast majority of mid-career surgeons like me with a lot of experience but also 15-20 years (or even more) left in their careers. This would be the case even if there were enough fellowship slots to accommodate them and surgeons finishing residency, which there are not. In marked contrast, every report I’ve seen about the new certificate in Complex General Surgical Oncology at SSO meetings over the last few years indicates that current surgical oncologists will not be able to take the examination and be grandfathered in. That includes even the eminent surgical oncologists who are the founding members of this new board. Unless I go back and do a surgical oncology fellowship again, I can never be board certified in surgical oncology. (No doubt some quack will attack me for that ten years from now, after the new system has started to crank out a significant number of board certified surgical oncologists.)
Readers might be thinking to themselves right now, “That’s all very interesting, Gorski (well, not really), but why are you explaining this? What does any of this have to do with board certification in IM?” I answer: Compare and contrast, my friends. Compare and contrast. Dr. Weil could have tried to partner with the much more respected and authoritative ABMS. Why didn’t he? Because, at least for now, the ABMS wouldn’t touch this “integrative” woo with the proverbial ten foot pool (Weil et al. even admit that in their press release). Don’t get me wrong. Given the infiltration of quackademic medicine into so many medical schools and academic medical centers, I’m under no illusion at all that the ABMS is so science-based that this situation might not change in the future and it might not become more “open” to IM, but at least for now, the ABMS appears not to be interested in pseudoscience-based medical pseudo specialties. That is, of course, a good thing. In contrast, the AAPS is apparently—shall we say?—more “open minded.” Indeed, take a look at this video from the AAPS website describing board certification through the ABPS:
Notice the arguments? “Who’s got your back?” Fight against unfair “discrimination against deserving physicians.” The ABPS has a “big tent approach to medicine.” “You’re not a mere number” with ABPS. I don’t know about you, but I know that I want a “big tent” approach to medicine. A “big tent” approach is a major reason why quackademic medicine has gotten as far as it has. For example, apparently the AAPS has been having difficulty getting its emergency medicine boards recognized because it doesn’t require a specific emergency medicine residency and is mounting a major public relations and lobbying campaign to change that, with the goal of being recognized in every state (which of course means ABPS certifications in emergency medicine are not recognized in some states:
“We have a very aggressive and active governmental affairs program for 2010,” said Timothy Bell, the AAPS director of governmental affairs. “Our strategic plan for 2010 includes Alaska, Montana, Idaho, Utah, and North and South Dakota. It will put us on the path of achieving the goal of being recognized in every state.”
The plan puts ABPS on a collision course with the American Board of Medical Specialties as well as the Bureau of Osteopathic Specialists and Boards of Certification of the American Osteopathic Association, the most widely accepted agencies for medical specialty certification. Nowhere is the clash more evident than in the field of emergency medicine, perhaps because of the Daniel v. ABEM suit that spanned 15 years, casting a shadow over the field’s attempt to move from grandfathering for the field’s pioneers, who had no chance to enter an emergency medicine residency, to a residency-based approach. While ABEM bases board certification on completing an emergency medicine residency and testing, ABPS’s certifying body, the Board of Certification in Emergency Medicine (BCEM), allows applicants to have completed a primary care or anesthesiology residency along with 7,000 hours of experience in an emergency department.
Hmmm. Maybe I should see if the ABPS will set up a competing board in surgical oncology, so that I can be board-certified too! In any case, New York and Oklahoma, at least, have recently thwarted the ABPS initiative. Meanwhile, relatively few hospitals recognize ABPS certification as being “board certified,” and the American College of Emergency Physicians does not recognize the ABPS as a valid certifying body. Neither does the American College of Surgeons.
Seen in the light of the example of emergency medicine, it’s very clear why Dr. Weil and the ABIHM chose the ABPS. First, unlike leaders in surgical oncology, Dr. Weil didn’t want to go through what could be a decades-long (or more) process of convincing the ABMS that “integrative medicine” is a valid and distinct medical specialty. Second, the ABMS has made it clear that it’s not going to “grandfather” practitioners in, whereas the ABIHM almost advertises that you should take its test now while things are still easy, before the ABIHM institutes an IM residency requirement for its board certification:
Within the next few years, the ABIHM has plans to phase out the certification of physicians without formal training from an integrative medicine residency or fellowship program. We will also be raising the benchmark for passing the exam. Thus, physicians without formal training have a time limited opportunity to become Diplomates before the new standards are implemented. Our intent is to offer “grandparent” status to those who underwent certification prior to the installment of the upgraded requirements.
Get yer IM board certification while they last at this low, low price of $800 and no special residency needed!
The bottom line
There is little doubt that Dr. Weil has realized that his specialty of IM is, despite his massive success in infiltrating quackademic medicine into medical academia, still not taken seriously where it matters, namely by certifying boards, state medical boards, and, of course, insurance companies. If he can succeed in creating a medical specialty that appears legitimate based on board certification, then recognition by state medical boards and, more importantly, third party payers might well follow. If it takes partnering with an umbrella organization for various medical boards that aren’t as well-accepted and well-respected as those under the umbrella of the ABMS, so be it. Most of the public doesn’t know the difference, anyway. So Dr. Weil and a bunch of buddies, including people we’ve discussed before on SBM such as Dr. Mimi Guarneri (who was the pro-IM counterpoint to Steve Novella when he was on The Doctor Oz Show last spring), Dr. Brian Berman (who’s managed to slip bad acupuncture papers past reviewers into high impact journals), and Dr. Benjamin Kligler (who’s the research director in integrative family medicine for the Beth Israel-affiliated Continuum Center for Health and Healing), among others, got together and formed the American Board of Integrative Medicine.
One potential consequence of this effort might well be ticking off non-MD practitioners of woo such as naturopaths. John Weeks even mentions this as a possibility:
This strategic decision by ACIM has many dimensions. There are clear public health implications. The ACIM-ABIHM alliance represents a significant new alignment. Grassroots access to the “integrative medical doctor” title or at least board certification may disappear. There are guild dimensions here, ground claiming, and not just for IM doctors. Many naturopathic doctors and acupuncturists and chiropractors use the term. The brand “integrative medicine” may become even more closely associated with, and effectively owned by, medical doctors. New clarities will emerge, new boundaries will be drawn, new possibilities empowered.
Indeed. I rather suspect that this is a blatant effort of the “MD wing” of the alternative medicine world to claim the specialty for itself and push out all the “riff raff,” like naturopaths, homeopaths, chiropractors, acupuncturists, and the like by preventing them from using the term “integrative medicine” to describe what they do. One potential result, if Weil and his merry band of woo-meisters are successful, is to marginalize non-MD practitioners, which might not be a bad thing from the point of view of science-based medicine. What would be a bad thing is that it would simultaneously allow MDs like Weil to lay claim to the woo inherent in IM in order to give it the patina of legitimacy that, despite 20 years of the best efforts of doctors like Weil, IM or CAM or whatever the pseudorespectable nom du jour is still doesn’t have and doesn’t deserve because much of it consists either of Trojan horses or pseudoscience.
Whatever happens, one consequence that will not result from this effort is any improvement in patient care.

The effort of integrative medicine advocates to co-opt the opioid crisis to claim non pharmacological treatments for pain as solely theirs continues apace
Last week, I wrote about how advocates for quackery were trying, and succeeding, at persuading state Medicaid agencies to pay for acupuncture for pain. This week, I discuss how they are promoting the integration of quackery with medicine. In this case, they are promoting a white paper and trying to influence the AHRQ.
David Gorski on January 29, 2018
Link
Leave it to integrative medicine advocates. No sooner do I discuss how they are co-opting the opioid crisis as a “rationale” for integrating quackery into medicine for the treatment of chronic pain than they serve up another example of just that tendency. I saw this example where I see a lot of examples of this sort of thing, on Twitter:
The Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine’s @imconsortium white paper on #EvidenceBased #NonDrug approaches to pain is now available here: https://t.co/QDsiAdzEUO @Integrativeonc @IntegratCancer @DukeIM @IHITeam @integrativeonco
— Dr. Linda E. Carlson (@Linda_E_Carlson) January 23, 2018
OK, it was almost a week ago, but I usually only post on SBM once a week. In any event, what we have here is an example of one of the most powerful forces promoting the “integration” of pseudoscience and quackery into medicine continuing to do so by, yes, taking advantage of the opioid crisis to present its unscientific, pseudoscientific, and mystical prescribed solutions to the crisis.
The Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine and Health: Promoting quackademic medicine for two decades
What Dr. Carlson was referring to in her Tweet was the Academic Consortium for Integrative Medicine and Health (formerly, The Consortium for Academic Health Centers for Integrative Medicine). The ACIMH, if you’ll recall, has been discussed on this blog several times for its role in promoting quackademic medicine over the years. Consisting of roughly 70 academic medical centers in North America, the ACIMH declares its mission to be to “advance integrative medicine and health through academic institutions and health systems.
That’s exactly what it does, too. Unfortunately, it’s been wildly successful, having started out with eight founding members and expanded its membership many-fold over the last two decades. Among its members (and beyond), for instance, Jann Bellamy noted that the ACIMH has been promoting the establishment of integrative medicine programs in academic health centers. While the authors, of one of the papers that she discussed, including our old friend Ted Kaptchuk, discussed the barriers to starting such programs, Jann was, as she should be, more concerned with the infiltration of pseudoscience into the residency curriculum than with how to “integrate” terminology related to pseudomedicine such chiropractic, acupuncture and traditional Chinese medicine into the electronic health record, which was one of main concerns of the article she discussed. Indeed, the ACIMH also likes to promote “partnerships” between quack schools like the naturopathic Bastyr University, and real medical schools, like Georgetown.
Of course, whenever we criticize this infiltration, there are people and forces who are displeased. We very frequently encounter pushback. Often this pushback comes from John Weeks, an early cheerleader for “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) and later the rebranding of CAM known as “integrative medicine” who is now editor of the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, even though at the time he was hired he had no relevant experience editing an academic journal and wasn’t even a physician or a scientist. Now he spends his time accusing CAM critics of “polarization-based medicine.” Although the ACIMH is not the only force promoting the infiltration of quackery into medical academia, with the Bravewell Consortium and the Samueli Institute both having closed, it is arguably the most influential such organization remaining, along with the University of California, Irvine, where Susan and Henry Samueli donated $200 million to promote integrative medicine.
The ACIMH takes advantage of the opioid epidemic
Recently, the ACIMH published its Moving Beyond Medications guidelines. The express purpose is, as was the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health’s latest strategic plan, to rebrand “nonpharmacologic treatments for pain” as being all “integrative” or “CAM.” The other part of this rebranding is that potentially science- and evidence-based interventions for pain, such as exercise, are mixed—or, dare I say it, integrated—with quackery, like chiropractic and acupuncture. This is accomplished through a white paper, a series of guides, and a series of one- or two-page evidence summaries.
For instance, here is the pocket guide. It lists five steps to treating pain. None of the steps are objectionable on the surface:
     1.  Assess the patient’s pain and well-being
     2.  Set goals jointly with the patient
     3.  Educate the patient about pain management options
     4.  Develop a treatment plan with the patient; address potential challenges
     5.  Followup, troubleshoot, and modify treatment plan as needed
I can’t think of any physician I know who would object to these steps. The devil, of course, is in the details. For instance, under #3, we see:
Describe evidence-informed non-pharmacological and self-care approaches to managing pain and promoting wellness, including but not limited to:
    • Acupuncture
    • Chiropractic, Osteopathic and Myofascial Manipulation, Massage Therapy, and
    • Physical Therapy
    • Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, Stress Management, and other psychological therapies
    • Mind-Body Approaches, Meditation, Biofeedback, Guided Imagery
    • Yoga, Tai Chi, and other movement therapies
See what I mean? Potentially evidence-based treatments, such a physical therapy, cognitive behavioral therapy, stress management, and the like, are included in a list with acupuncture (which is no more than a theatrical placebo), chiropractic (chiropractors are, as I like to say, improperly trained physical therapists with delusions of grandeur); and osteopathic and myofascial manipulation.
There are a total of four evidence summaries for the treatment of pain devoted to acupuncture alone, Acupuncture Cancer Pain, Acupuncture Chronic Pain, Acupuncture Post-Op Pain Opioid Sparing, Acupuncture Therapy Acute Pain. Perusing this evidence summary, which presumably is the best that the ACIMH could come up with, given its mission to promote integrative medicine, I was amazed at how weak and equivocal even the “best” studies were.
For instance, here’s a quote from a systematic review by the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO):
The American Society of Clinical Oncology Clinical Practice Guidelines found acupuncture and massage were effective in improving pain. The reviewers categorized these findings as ‘evidence-based; benefits outweigh harms; evidence quality: low; strength of recommendation: weak’.
Here’s a quote from a review:
A review on the management of peripheral neuropathy induced by chemotherapy found acupuncture among therapies that may be useful for PN, but not electroacupuncture.
Not exactly ringing endorsement, is it? What about acupuncture for chronic pain? It’s not much better. Not surprisingly, there’s this right at the top of the list:
The 2017 Clinical Guidelines of the American College of Physicians recommend that for acute, subacute and chronic low back pain, clinicians and patients should select nonpharmacologic treatments as a first line of care with acupuncture therapy included as one option.
I can’t help but note that the inclusion of acupuncture in the 2017 ACP Clinical Guidelines was based on incredibly thin evidence. I couldn’t help but note the questionable nature of the actual studies used to justify the recommendations. For example, this study showed that there was no difference between “true” acupuncture and sham acupuncture (which is what pretty much all well-designed acupuncture studies show). In other words, it showed that acupuncture is a placebo intervention. This study tested a sort of “scalp acupuncture” that I’ve never heard of before. Another study was from China, and, as has been discussed before, pretty much all acupuncture studies out of China are positive. The authors actually included the GERAC study in its list, which basically showed that acupuncture does not work, given that sham acupuncture was indistinguishable from acupuncture. Another study was a “bait and switch” in that it studied “electroacupuncture,” which is in reality transcutaneous nerve stimulation (TENS). We’re talking thin gruel indeed here.
Then, of course, ACIMH couldn’t help but quote the NCCIH review of integrative medicine for pain:
The National Institutes of Health (NIH) National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) reviewed evidence-based approaches for pain management and recommended acupuncture and yoga for low back pain; and acupuncture and Tai chi for knee osteoarthritis
I discussed this review in detail right here on this very blog when it was first published nearly a year and a half ago. It was one of the times I pointed out the strategy integrative medicine advocates are using, noting the careful framing. Basically, integrative medicine advocates co-opt the sensible, the science-based, and the potentially science-based lifestyle interventions for pain as being “complementary” or “integrative,” thus claiming them for their own. They also divide interventions for pain into two categories, “pharmacological” and “non-pharmacological.” Guess which one they claim for their own as being “CAM” or “integrative”? At the same time, they further the stereotype that science- and evidence-based medicine is all about nothing more than drug therapy.
Then, of course, there’s the Vickers meta-analysis from 2012:
A 2012 individual patient data meta-analysis of acupuncture for four chronic pain conditions: back and neck pain, osteoarthritis, chronic headache, and shoulder pain found acupuncture is effective beyond placebo effect and is a reasonable referral options.
I can’t help but note that this particular meta-analysis has been discussed many times on this blog, including by Steve Novella, Mark Crislip, and myself. It’s one of the most widely cited acupuncture studies used to argue that acupuncture works, but it actually doesn’t show anything of the sort. At best, it shows that if there is a difference in pain perception in patients due to acupuncture it’s statistically significant but clinically insignificant.
Of course, the two main problems with the vast majority of acupuncture trials is that they are rarely double blind and, even when they are, the sham acupuncture control is usually inadequate. There’s a reason why, if you look at the totality of the literature, as the scientific rigor of an acupuncture clinical trial increases, the effect size decreases, to the point that the very best trials generally show at best a clinically insignificant effect and in general no effect distinguishable from placebo. This is not surprising, given that, as I mentioned before, acupuncture is a theatrical placebo. Add to all this unimpressive data the extreme biological implausibility of acupuncture, and, using a Bayesian approach taking into account pretest probability based on biological plausibility, one can only conclude that the evidence for acupuncture as a treatment for pain (or anything, for that matter) is negative.
Enter the AHRQ
The US Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) is an agency in the US Department of Health and Human Services that was established in 1989 as the Agency for Health Care Policy and Research (AHCPR) with a mission to enhance the quality, appropriateness, and effectiveness of health care services and access to care by conducting and supporting research, demonstration projects, and evaluations; developing guidelines; and disseminating information on health care services and delivery systems. The AHRQ’s key areas of focus are:
    • Safety and Quality: Reduce the risk of harm by promoting delivery of the best possible care.
    • Effectiveness: Improve health care outcomes by encouraging the use of evidence to make informed health care decisions.
    • Efficiency: Transform research into practice to facilitate wider access to effective health care service and reduce unnecessary costs.
One important function of AHRQ is to fund comparative effectiveness research, which compares existing approved treatment modalities for effectiveness, safety, and cost, in order to determine which ones are preferable to use in which patients. The ACIMH states in its report:
The Consortium and other pain experts have provided comments as part of the AHRQ call for predissemination peer review of this document. The draft document is posted here as a resource to provide a comparative effectiveness review of the evidence on noninvasive, nonpharmacological treatments for common chronic pain conditions, focusing on whether improvements are seen for at least one month post-intervention. While this results in not including some studies, by doing so it focuses on more sustainable benefits of nonpharmacological approaches.
The document to which the ACIMH is referring is the Draft Comparative Effectiveness Review for Noninvasive, Nonpharmacological Treatment for Chronic Pain: A Systematic Review. The draft review notes that it has not been officially disseminated by the AHRQ yet, but has been distributed solely for the purposes of predissemination peer review. Given the power of the AHRQ, I am betting that, whatever the AHRQ concludes, the final systematic review’s findings will be a Big Deal and potentially a propaganda goldmine for advocates of integrative medicine.
So let’s take a look.
The review examines the evidence for non-pharmacological treatments for five common chronic pain conditions (low back pain, neck pain, osteoarthritis of the knee, hip or hand, fibromyalgia, and tension headache), addressing efficacy or harms compared with usual care, no treatment, waitlist, placebo, or sham intervention; compared with pharmacological therapy; or compared with exercise. The quality of included studies was assessed, data were extracted, and results were summarized.
The first thing that I noticed perusing all these conditions and interventions is that there is not a single condition paired with an intervention for which the AHRQ judged the strength of evidence (SOE) as “high.” At best, there was “moderate” SOE, and the vast majority of the SOE appraisals fell into the category of “low.” Let’s look at what the draft review says about acupuncture for low back pain as far as standardized mean difference (SMD) and other parameters:
    • Acupuncture was associated with slightly greater effects on short-term function than sham acupuncture or usual care (4 trials, pooled SMD -0.22, 95% CI -0.35 to -0.08, I2=44%). There were no differences between acupuncture versus controls in intermediate-term function (3 trials, pooled SMD -0.08, 95% CI -0.36 to 0.20, I2=75%) or long-term function (1 trial, adjusted difference -3.4 on the 0 to 100 ODI, 95% CI -7.8 to 1.0) (SOE: Low).
    • Acupuncture was associated with slighter greater effects on short-term pain than sham acupuncture, usual care, an attention control, or a placebo intervention (5 trials, pooled difference -0.55 on a 0 to 10 scale, 95% CI -0.86 to -0.24, I2=30%). There was no difference in intermediate-term pain (5 trials, pooled mean difference -0.25, 95% CI -0.67 to 0.16, I2=33%); one trial found acupuncture associated with greater effects on long-term pain (mean difference -0.83, 95% CI -1.51 to -0.15) (SOE: Moderate for short-term, low for intermediate-term and long-term).
Again, this is very thin gruel, the very essence of finding small differences that are statistically significant but almost certainly clinically insignificant. A difference of 0.55 on a visual pain scale from 0-10 is almost certainly below a threshold known as the “minimally clinically important difference” (MCID), defined as “the smallest difference in score in the domain of interest which patients perceive as beneficial and which would mandate…a change in the patient’s management.”
I could go on, but for the most part these are the sorts of results one finds for acupuncture. The results are somewhat better for some of the other modalities, such as exercise, physical therapy, multidisciplinary rehabilitation, and mindfulness-based stress reduction, although in the vast majority of cases the SOE was low, with a few examples of moderate SOE.
Maybe this report won’t be that big a bombshell after all.
The rebranding continues
The ACIMH’s Moving Beyond Medications initiative concludes with a plug for its upcoming conference in May in Baltimore. Although the website doesn’t yet show the program schedule, we do learn that major speakers will include Tracy W. Gaudet, MD, Executive Director of the Veterans Health Administration’s National Office of Patient Centered Care & Cultural Transformation. We’ve met her before in her role as being a key driving force behind the introduction of naturopathic quackery and acupuncture into the VA Medical System. Then there’s Helene Langevin, MD, who serves as Director, Osher Center for Integrative Medicine at Brigham and Women’s Hospital & Harvard Medical School. She’s best known for having claimed to have matched real anatomical structures with the elusive acupuncture “meridians.” When last I encountered her, she was still at the University of Vermont, but here I learn she’s moved up in the world.
Never forget that the real purpose of integrative medicine, whether acknowledged or not, whether even admitted to themselves by advocates or not, is to integrate quackery with medicine. Rebranding their nostrums as “nonpharmacologic” treatments for pain serves two purposes. First, it allows integrative medicine to claim certain science-based modalities, such as diet, exercise, and evidence-based physical therapy, as solely belonging in their bailiwick. Second, it allows them to give a false sense of scientific legitimacy to the pseudoscience, such as acupuncture, energy medicine, and the like into the treatments they’re so desperately trying to “integrate” into medicine. Finally, these two tactics allow integrative medicine advocates to claim all nonpharmacological treatments of pain as their own, separate from science- and evidence-based medicine, even when such treatments have existed in that realm for a long time.
That’s what the ACIMH report on nonpharmacological treatments for pain is all about.

   The Hazards of “CAM”-Pandering
Kimball Atwood 
Link
Steven Salzberg, a friend of this blog and Director of the Center for Bioinformatics and Computational Biology at the University of Maryland, is on the editorial boards of three of the many journals published by BioMed Central (BMC), an important source of open-access, peer-reviewed biomedical reports. He is disturbed by the presence of two other journals under the BMC umbrella: Chinese Medicine and BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine. A couple of days ago, on his Forbes science blog, Dr. Salzberg explained why. Here are some excerpts:
The Chinese Medicine journal promotes, according to its own mission statement, studies of “acupuncture, Tui-na, Qi-qong, Tai Chi Quan, energy research,” and other nonsense. Tui na, for example, supposedly “affects the flow of energy by holding and pressing the body at acupressure points.”
Right. What is this doing in a scientific journal?… I support BMC…But their corporate leaders seem to care more about expanding their stable than about maintaining the integrity of science. Chinese Medicine simply does not belong in the company of respectable scientific journals.
Forming a scientific journal whose goal is to validate antiquated, unproven superstitions is simply not science, whatever the editors of Chinese Medicine claim.
BMC should be embarrassed to be publishing journals that promote anti-scientific theories and otherwise muddy the literature. By supporting these journals, they undermine the credibility of many excellent BMC journals. They should cut these journals loose.
Matthew Cockerill, a molecular biologist and self-described skeptic who is Managing Director of BMC, responded. Quoting Tim Minchin’s poem Storm (“You know what they call alternative medicine that’s been proved to work?…Medicine”), he wrote:
Well-known examples of “alternative medicines” that have made the transition to “medicine” include aspirin (explicitly cited in ‘Storm’) and artemisinin, a compound identified in a type of traditional Chinese herbal medicine, derivatives of which are now used to treat malaria.
Clearly for this transition to be possible, there must be a way for effective aspects of Complementary/Alternative Medicine (CAM) to prove themselves and to become “Medicine”. Journals focused on evaluating CAM are not the only approach to doing this (such research might also be published in a regular medical journal), but they are one valid approach…
… Regular medical journals may tend to be dismissive of anything with CAM-associations…
In a second comment (which at the time of this writing is unavailable, but Dr. Salzberg sent me a copy) Dr. Cockerill continued:
Steven,
In your post you suggest that journals relating to complementary/alternative medicine (CAM) including Traditional Chinese Medicine have no place in BioMed Central’s portfolio, and your broader implication is that these fields represent nothing but pseudoscience and are unworthy of (or indeed are incompatible with) scientific investigation.
BioMed Central does not share this view. We accept that this is a challenging and controversial area, and that one of the problems to be addressed is that much CAM research is lacking in scientific rigor. However, to dismiss all aspects of CAM out-of-hand and to exclude research on CAM from scientific discourse would only give ammunition to those who try to characterize the scientific process as being close-minded and based on presumptions which are not open to question.
You refer to BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine as a “pseudoscience journal” which “promote[s] anti-scientific theories”, but this is really not the case.
Dr. Cockerill argued that standards of peer-review and methodological rigor for that journal are not different from those for the rest of the BMC group. He named Edzard Ernst as a member of the editorial board. More:
Moving to the field of Traditional Chinese Medicine – while it is true that there are some aspects of TCM as traditionally practiced that are likely to hold only anthropological/psychological interest from a scientific point of view, it is also clear that there are many active ingredients in traditional Chinese Herbal Medicine (CHM) which are worthy of further investigation in terms of biological mechanism and clinical effectiveness. This is an area that has attracted significant funding from commercial and public sources – see for example this article from Science magazine in 2003. http://www.sciencemag.org/content/299/5604/188.long
Looking at articles published in the journal Chinese Medicine, the evaluation of active components within herbal remedies accounts for a large fraction of research articles published, and this cannot easily be dismissed as either irrelevant or inherently pseudoscientific.
In an earlier email to Steven Salzberg, Dr. Cockerill had written:
The major problem I have with such a blanket dismissal is that it lumps everything together as being equally valueless, whereas the goal of the scientific process is to winnow the wheat (however rare) from the chaff…
If you look at articles published in Chinese Medicine, you will find little if anything on “Energy fields” (not a fruitful area for scientific investigation, I quite agree, and not something which I believe should be in the scope of the journal), but a great deal on biochemical and functional genomic work in relation to traditional herbal medicine, which is quite a different matter.
Bait and Switch: the Yin and the Yang
Sigh. Where to begin? Let’s start by trying a slight revision of Dr. Cockerill’s own words: The major problem I have with such a blanket acceptance is that it lumps everything together as being equally valuable, whereas the goal of the scientific process is to winnow the wheat (however rare) from the chaff…
That’s more like it. I imagine that Dr. Cockerill will find that statement unfair, in that it fails to acknowledge that there may be reports in the two journals that disconfirm hypotheses that are not fruitful for scientific investigation (if you catch my drift). I concede that, but the point here is a different one: Dr. Salzberg objects to including anti-scientific topics in the journals precisely because doing so gives the appearance that real scientists believe that they must be intriguing enough to warrant space in real biomedical journals.
But they are not: it is clear, after a moment’s reflection, that natural products research is the ONLY worthwhile scientific endeavor within the editorial purview of Chinese Medicine, so why pretend that it justifies the rest? Matthew Cockerill may agree that “energy fields” should not be included; nevertheless they are—which was Dr. Salzberg’s point. Tim Minchin, bless his heart, probably doesn’t realize that his statement about “alternative medicine that’s been proved to work” is itself purely hypothetical: there has yet to be an example of such a medicine. Dr. Cockerill ought to know that, as I will explain a bit later in this piece.
An Article Brings Homeopathy to Mind
I have little time to investigate the non-[natural products pharmacology] articles in Chinese Medicine; Dr. Salzberg cited one, which he characterized as “a laughably bad study.” I’ll tell you a bit about another, just published in January:
Misdiagnosis and undiagnosis due to pattern similarity in Chinese medicine: a stochastic simulation study using pattern differentiation algorithm
The article is nearly incoherent. Passages such as this abound:
In Chinese medicine, diagnosis is also important. Practitioners recognise and label nosological conditions based on inspection (Ip, wang), auscultation and olfaction (AO, wen), inquiry (Iq, wen) and palpation (P, qie), also known as the Four Examinations (Sizhen). According to traditional literature, these methods should be applied in order to enhance recovery of the patients. Manifestations (ie signs and symptoms) collected from patients are interpreted using Chinese medicine theories (eg eight principles, five phases, vital substances, six channels, four levels, triple burner and Zangfu), which were developed on the basis of some observations of Nature. Similar to Western medicine, the collected manifestations are interpreted collectively; however, diagnosis is established through a pattern differentiation process whereby a unique, stable manifestation profile is obtained for the identification of a pattern among other diagnostic hypotheses.
The article appears to torture statistics to show that each additional Examination among the Four confers a slightly greater degree of certainty that the examiner will not confuse two different “diagnoses” (in the TCM sense of the term). At least I think that’s the point. But the investigator didn’t determine this by testing actual practitioners, as far as I can tell; he did it using “a stochastic computational simulation based on Monte Carlo method implemented for patient simulation from ZFSP in a dataset.” And a good thing, too, because if there’s anything useful to be gleaned from this paper, it’s found in references 19-24. They show, unsurprisingly, that there isn’t much agreement from one TCM practitioner to the next about either “diagnoses” or treatments.
Hmmm. No surprise when you consider what those diagnoses, i.e., patterns, involve. Here is the pattern of “Deficient Cold of Small Intestine…often discussed as Deficient Spleen Qi,” according to Ted Kaptchuk, an American who seems to have invented the “OMD” degree that won him a professorship at the Harvard Medical School, and who is on the editorial board of Chinese Medicine:
Signs: slight, persistent discomfort in lower abdomen; gurgling noises in abdomen; watery stools.
Tongue: pale material; thin white moss
Pulse: empty
Here is the pattern of “Deficient Cold in Stomach…often called Deficient Spleen Yang”:
Signs: chronic diarrhea; slight persistent pain in epigastrium; discomfort relieved by warmth, eating, and touching; shy; easily influenced by others
Tongue: pale material; most white moss
Pulse: deep or moderate without strength
And so on, for hundreds of patterns. According to Kaptchuk, “pulse examination can be the most important of the Four Examinations and is crucial to pattern discernment in general.” Paul Unschuld, a prolific historian of Chinese medicine, explains how this is done:
The physician has the choice of either feeling the (radial) pulse with three fingers or with one finger. Using three fingers, light pressure with the index finger above the imaginary line level with the styloid process allows him to feel the state of the lung and heart, greater pressure with the middle finger on the imaginary line enables him to feel the state of the spleen, and greater pressure still with the ring finger allows him to feel the liver and kidney. According to a third (and certainly not the last) variant, he can, with one finger, apply a pressure equal to the weight of three beans to feel the lung, a pressure of six beans to feel the heart, a pressure of nine beans to feel the spleen, a pressure of twelve beans to feel the liver, and finally a pressure that brings the fingertip almost to the bone, to feel the kidney.
What does “correct” pattern recognition mean, in the practical sense? Well, it means that the correct therapeutic intervention will occur. Kaptchuk again:
The goal of all treatment methods in Chinese medicine is to rebalance those aspects of the body’s Yin and Yang whose harmonious proportion and movement have become disordered…inappropriate anger such as that characterized by excessive Liver activity must be calmed…insufficient activity, say of the Kidney Yang, must be tonified to avoid lack of sexual energy…If there is not enough Qi in the Lungs, it must be replenished…If the Qi in the Spleen descends, causing chronic diarrhea, it must be lifted; if the Qi of the stomach ascends, it causing nausea, it must be sent down. Stagnant Qi must be moved…Too much Cold in the Kidney must be warmed; extra Fire in the Lungs must be cooled. Whatever is out of balance must be rebalanced. The complementary aspects of Yin and Yang must be harmonious.
Here’s how it’s done:
…the insertion of very fine needles into points along the Meridians can rebalance bodily disharmonies. A related technique [is] moxibustion…The action of the needles or of moxibustion affects the Qi and Blood in the Meridians, thus affecting all the fundamental textures and Organs. The needles can reduce what is excessive, increase what is deficient, warm what is cold, cool what is hot, circulate what is stagnant, move what is congealed, stabilize what is reckless, raise what is falling, and lower what is rising.
OK, enough already. Is it not obvious that this is the classic assortment of metaphors, myths, traditions, and appeals to authority that is common to the medicine of pre-scientific cultures? Were Chinese medicine theories developed on the basis of some observations of Nature? I don’t think so.
The claims regarding pulse examination are quite fanciful, to say the least: that changing the pressure of the examining finger would allow the practitioner to feel the state of the various, named organs is hard to conceive, given what is now known about anatomy and physiology; it’s also clear that pre-modern Chinese physicians would have had no way test this claim. There is a smattering of empirically gathered symptoms and signs that are based on history taking and external examinations, some of which are repeatable and might have eventually become useful, if pre-modern Chinese medicine had pursued anatomy, physiology, and pathology before those fields were developed elsewhere—thus making that aspect of “TCM” moot.
Funny: the “patterns” remind me of another conspicuous pre-scientific “school” of medicine: homeopathy, with its elaborate ‘symptom’-gathering scheme, its voluminous repertories, rubrics, and simillima. And, of course, its lack of agreement from one homeopath to the next regarding the ‘correct’ constellation of ‘symptoms’ and therefore the correct ‘remedy.’
Pharmacognosy is neither “CAM” nor “Chinese Medicine”
Dr. Cockerill’s other points are a mixture of reason and misunderstanding. Legitimate natural products research is not “CAM,” and should neither be billed as such (or as some other misnomer such as “Chinese Medicine”) nor should it be purported to justify “CAM,” which, if anything, hinders such research. Aspirin is not an example of an “alternative medicine that made the transition to medicine” any more than quinine or atropine or digoxin are such examples. Nor is artemisinin. Everyone with a modicum of education knows that many useful drugs have been, and will continue to be, derived from natural sources, exactly as biology would predict. This is completely unsurprising. The term “alternative medicine,” along with its various synonyms, refers to a recent political and quasi-religious movement, not to a longstanding branch of drug development that is scientific and that has not required the help of pseudoscientific zealots to pursue its investigations.
If Chinese Medicine were limited to pharmacognosy and had a more appropriate title—Asian Pharmacognosy, for example, referring to the geographic origin of the products studied, not to some pre-scientific medical ‘system’—I’d have little problem with it, assuming that the natural products reports are as rigorous as Cockerill claims them to be.
“Chinese Medicine” is a misnomer in several ways. First, the medicine overwhelmingly used in China today is modern, scientific medicine. Second, pre-scientific Chinese medicine was not one or even a few schools of medicine but many disparate schools, occurring at various times over millennia and in various places over a huge geographical region. Some schools were completely unrelated or even contradictory. There was much influence from abroad, including India and Greece. Third, the term “Traditional Chinese Medicine” was coined only about 55 years ago in the PRC, mainly for pitching to (gullible) Westerners. It heralded something that, paradoxically, had never before been true in China: a forced standardization, such as to make ‘Chinese Medicine’ appear to be something that it was not: a conceptual whole.
Last Thoughts
I’m running out of gas, but another straw man used by the “CAM” movement, repeated by Matthew Cockerill, is that “Regular medical journals may tend to be dismissive of anything with CAM-associations.” There was a time in the 1990s when editors of the major journals had to answer this charge on a regular basis, and each time it went something like this:
Dr. Siegel’s charge that medical journals will not publish studies of alternative medicine comes out of thin air. Journals compete avidly to publish important new clinical research, if it is rigorously done. As we indicated in our editorial, the problem with the studies funded by the Office of Alternative Medicine in 1993 was not their size, as suggested by Dr. Cherkin and Ms. Street, but their quality.
In fact, major medical journals have, to their own embarrassment and to the detriment of uninformed readers, bent over backward to accommodate substandard “CAM” treatises.
“CAM” advocacy journals, moreover, have become far more evident in the past few years, thanks in part to political pressure applied by anti-intellectual demagogues such as Dan Burton—even as the only journal committed to an appropriate, skeptical view of “CAM” was excluded from listing by the US National Library of Medicine after similar political pressure.
Perhaps someone else will look at some of the articles in BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine. I have neither the time nor the inclination, but I would like to reiterate a point that Steven Salzberg and we have all made at one time or another: even the subsequent publication of a reasonable scientific report doesn’t justify creating a journal for the purpose of “helping aspects of CAM prove themselves.” If there’s scientific promise for some new way to solve a problem, and if a legitimate study is done, there are plenty of opportunities to report it in the medical literature.

   Evidence-Based Medicine, Human Studies Ethics, and the ‘Gonzalez Regimen’: a Disappointing Editorial in the Journal of Clinical Oncology Part 1
Kimball Atwood
Link
Background: the distinction between EBM and SBM
An important theme on the Science-Based Medicine blog, and the very reason for its name, has been its emphasis on examining all the evidence—not merely the results of clinical trials—for various claims, particularly for those that are implausible. We’ve discussed the distinction between Science-Based Medicine (SBM) and the more limited Evidence-Based Medicine (EBM) several times, for example here (I began my own discussion here and added a bit of formality here, here, and here). Let me summarize by quoting John Ioannidis:
…the probability that a research finding is indeed true depends on the prior probability of it being true (before doing the study), the statistical power of the study, and the level of statistical significance.
EBM, in a nutshell, ignores prior probability† (unless there is no other available evidence) and falls for the “p-value fallacy”; SBM does not. Please don’t bicker about this if you haven’t read the links above and some of their own references, particularly the EBM Levels of Evidence scheme and two articles by Steven Goodman (here and here). Also, note that it is not necessary to agree with Ioannidis that “most published research findings are false” to agree with his assertion, quoted above, about what determines the probability that a research finding is true.
The distinction between SBM and EBM has important implications for medical practice ethics, research ethics, human subject protections, allocation of scarce resources, epistemology in health care, public perceptions of medical knowledge and of the health professions, and more. EBM, as practiced in the 20 years of its formal existence, is poorly equipped to evaluate implausible claims because it fails to acknowledge that even if scientific plausibility is not sufficient to establish the validity of a new treatment, it is necessary for doing so.
Thus, in their recent foray into applying the tools of EBM to implausible health claims, government and academic investigators have made at least two, serious mistakes: first, they have subjected unwary subjects to dangerous but unnecessary trials in a quest for “evidence,” failing to realize that definitive evidence already exists; second, they have been largely incapable of pronouncing ineffective methods ineffective. At best, even after conducting predictably disconfirming trials of vanishingly unlikely claims, they have declared such methods merely “unproven,” almost always urging “further research.” That may be the proper EBM response, but it is a far cry from the reality. As I opined a couple of years ago, the founders of the EBM movement apparently “never saw ‘CAM’ coming.”
The “Gonzalez” Trial
One such dangerous and unnecessary trial was “Evaluation of Intensive Pancreatic Proteolytic Enzyme Therapy with Ancillary Nutritional Support Versus Gemcitabine Chemotherapy in the Treatment of Inoperable Pancreatic Adenocarcinoma,” begun in 1999. It was funded by the National Cancer Institute (NCI) and the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM), and was conducted by Nicholas Gonzalez and investigators at Columbia University. The ‘enzyme therapy’ part of the trial is more commonly known as the “Gonzalez Detoxification Regimen”:
Patients receive pancreatic enzymes orally every 4 hours and at meals daily on days 1-16, followed by 5 days of rest. Patients receive magnesium citrate and Papaya Plus with the pancreatic enzymes. Additionally, patients receive nutritional supplementation with vitamins, minerals, trace elements, and animal glandular products 4 times per day on days 1-16, followed by 5 days of rest. Courses repeat every 21 days until death despite relapse. Patients consume a moderate vegetarian metabolizer diet during the course of therapy, which excludes red meat, poultry, and white sugar. Coffee enemas are performed twice a day, along with skin brushing daily, skin cleansing once a week with castor oil during the first 6 months of therapy, and a salt and soda bath each week. Patients also undergo a complete liver flush and a clean sweep and purge on a rotating basis each month during the 5 days of rest.
More than two years ago I wrote a series of posts* discussing Gonzalez, the regimen, the history leading to the funding of the trial, and aspects of the trial itself. In summary, Gonzalez appears to be a dangerous quack who should have had his medical license stripped by the state of New York during the 1990s, but was saved at the 11th hour by naïve “alternative medicine” enthusiasm; the regimen was highly implausible; there were no prior animal or clinical studies sufficient to warrant a human trial; its real impetus was the gathering political strength of the anti-intellectual “health freedom” movement in the aftermath of the Laetrile wars, culminating in Congressman Dan Burton’s bullying of NCI Director Richard Klausner; the NCI and Columbia subsequently justified the trial by citing a dubious case series provided by Gonzalez himself; the trial was unethical in numerous ways, amounting to torture-until-death for at least one hapless subject who, desperate for anything that might work, had stumbled into it because of his own scientific naïveté and because his consent was uninformed by existing knowledge—which, of course, the Columbia investigators should have provided him.
Shortly after my first series of posts it became clear that the Columbia investigators had found the Gonzalez regimen sufficiently inferior to the standard chemotherapy regimen to have stopped the trial early, in 2005. Finally, in August of 2009, the report of the trial, by John Chabot and colleagues (Gonzalez’s name was conspicuously missing from the report), was published by the Journal of Clinical Oncology (JCO): subjects in the Gonzalez arm had fared terribly, not only much worse than subjects in the chemotherapy arm, but also worse than 20,000 historical controls gleaned from the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results (SEER) Program of the National Cancer Institute.
In my last post on the topic, I explained numerous problems with the formal report, contrasting it with the Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials (CONSORT), which the JCO expects authors to honor. I explained that the results were nevertheless sufficient to disqualify the Gonzalez Regimen once and for all, Gonzalez’s own objections notwithstanding. I explained why Gonzalez’s name had not appeared in the article. I reiterated that the trial was unethical in the extreme, and lamented the JCO’s decision to publish the report—in direct violation of this statement in the Declaration of Helsinki, to which the JCO claims allegiance:
30. Authors, editors and publishers all have ethical obligations with regard to the publication of the results of research… Reports of research not in accordance with the principles of this Declaration should not be accepted for publication.
I mentioned ways in which the results of the trial could have been made public without violating that important statement. Since things had not turned out that way, I hoped that the JCO would eventually publish “an editorial acknowledging the ethical problems with the trial and the dilemma involved in choosing to publish the report.” I sent an email to an acquaintance who was a member of the JCO editorial board, asking that he or Editor-in-Chief Daniel Haller would recognize that the issue oughtn’t be ignored. I cited the pertinent SBM posts. I was ignored. When no editorial or other comment appeared in the JCO over the next few months, I stopped looking.
The Editorial
Only recently I noticed that the JCO had solicited an editorial after all; authored by Dr. Mark Levine of McMaster University, it appeared online in March, 2010. The title offered a bit of hope that the journal had finally “got it”:
Conventional and Complementary Therapies: A Tale of Two Research Standards?
Alas, ‘twas not to be. The first clue is found at the beginning of the essay:
In the early 1990s, I began to notice that some patients were choosing alternatives to the mainstream or conventional treatments. These so-called alternative therapies included a range of interventions, such as dietary and behavioral interventions, vitamin supplements and herbs, and traditional systems such as Chinese and homeopathic medicines. Most of these were not supported by sound scientific methods.
Notice the word “methods.” Dr. Levine didn’t write, “most of these were not supported by sound science.” This suggests that he was partially blinded by the EBM understanding of “evidence” and “scientific.” The next clue consists of the entire second paragraph, a series of bland restatements of proponents’ definitions (from the NCCAM, in this case) and ambiguous assertions about “CAM” that have come to be typical for medical academics who ought to know better. But I venture from the main point.
In the third paragraph, Dr. Levine verifies what we had suspected above:
I am fortunate to have spent my entire academic career at McMaster University (Hamilton, Ontario, Canada), the birthplace of evidence-based medicine, and to have had the privilege of learning from colleagues such as David Sackett, MD, and Gord Guyatt, MD.
Before proceeding, let me acknowledge—particularly for the benefit of Dr. Levine or any other EBM aficionados who may read this—that his essay is, in some ways, a good one. He was asked to comment on two reports of “CAM” treatments that had appeared in the JCO: the Gonzalez trial and a trial of acupuncture for hot flashes in women receiving anti-estrogen therapy for breast cancer. In each case he made valid criticisms of the methods and of the authors’ conclusions. He stressed that the authors hadn’t specified the questions that they were trying to answer. He wrote that “non-inferiority” studies require larger sample sizes than “superiority” studies, but that the authors of these reports hadn’t offered power calculations to justify their (small) sample sizes. He pointed out that the “control” intervention in the acupuncture trial, venlaxafine (Effexor), doesn’t work very well, thus implying that it may mean very little to judge a novel treatment similarly efficacious.
Nevertheless, in regard to the Gonzalez trial Dr. Levine faltered even as he applied what would usually be a solid EBM-style criticism:
The question addressed in the original randomized trial by Chabot et al was not specified. Was the hypothesis that chemotherapy is better than enzyme therapy, or was it that enzyme therapy is no worse than chemotherapy? My answer to this is, “I do not know.”
While this is technically correct, it misses the more important point, which can only be appreciated by looking beyond the trial itself: the interesting question, given the implausible nature of the method, is whether “enzyme therapy” for cancer of the pancreas is anything like what Gonzalez and his patrons had cracked it up to be prior to the trial. The most reasonable cohort to compare this group to, then, is not the chemotherapy arm reported in the JCO article, but Gonzalez’s case series that had ostensibly justified the trial in the first place:
As of 12 January 1999, of 11 patients entered into the study, 9 (81%) survived one year, 5 (45%) survived two years, and at this time, 4 have survived three years. Two patients are alive and doing well: one at three years and the other at four years.
Contrast those results with the 32 “enzyme-group” subjects reported in the JCO: 7 were alive at 10 months, 2 at 20 months, 1 at 30 months, and none at 40 months. Median survival was 4.3 months. We do not need formal statistics or a new, randomized trial with a larger sample size to justify dismissing the Gonzalez regimen.

   Evidence-Based Medicine, Human Studies Ethics, and the ‘Gonzalez Regimen’: a Disappointing Editorial in the Journal of Clinical Oncology Part 2
Kimball Atwood
Link
At the end of Part 1, I wrote:
We do not need formal statistics or a new, randomized trial with a larger sample size to justify dismissing the Gonzalez regimen.
In his editorial for the JCO, Mark Levine made a different argument:
Can it be concluded that [the] study proves that enzyme therapy is markedly inferior? On the basis of the study design, my answer is no. It is not possible to make a silk purse out of a sow’s ear.
That conclusion may be correct in the EBM sense, but it misses the crucial point of why the trial was (ostensibly) done: to determine, once and for all, whether there was anything to the near-miraculous claims that proponents had made for a highly implausible “detoxification” regimen for cancer of the pancreas. Gonzalez himself had admitted at the trial’s inception that nothing short of an outcome matching the hype would do:
DR. GONZALEZ: It’s set up as a survival study. We’re looking at survival.
SPEAKER: Do you have an idea of what you’re looking for?
DR. GONZALEZ: Well, Jeff [Jeffrey White, the director of the Office of Cancer Complementary and Alternative Medicine at the NCI—KA] and I were just talking a couple weeks ago. You know, to get any kind of data that would be beyond criticism is—-always be criticism, but at least three times.
You would want in the successful group to be three times — the median to be three times out from the lesser successful groups.
So, for example, if the average survival with chemo, which we suspect will be 5 months, you would want my therapy to be at least — the median survival to be at least 15, 16, 17 months, as it was in the pilot study.
We’re looking for a median survival three times out from the chemo group to be significant.
Recall that the median survival in the Gonzalez arm eventually turned out to be 4.3 months.
It would not surprise me if Dr. Levine, the author of the JCO editorial, were to take issue with what I’ve written so far. I would be remiss, for example, to leave readers with the impression that he called for another, larger trial, performed not as a cohort study but as a randomized, controlled trial, in order to prove whether (or not) “enzyme therapy is markedly inferior” to chemotherapy for cancer of the pancreas. He specifically did not make that recommendation; instead he argued, reasonably, “Given the scarcity of resources for cancer research, there are many more important questions to address.” I’ll come back to that statement, because although it hints that Dr. Levine has intuitively recognized the need for invoking prior probability when considering health research policy, he still appears confused by a strict, EBM perspective.
Human Studies Ethics: why Science Matters
Dr. Levine may also feel misrepresented by my emphases on the pseudoscientific nature of the Gonzalez regimen and the ethics of the trial. Near the beginning of his editorial, possibly to distance himself from those very issues, he wrote:
The goal of this discussion is not to debate the merits of conventional medicine versus CAM.
Let’s cut to the chase: “the merits of conventional medicine versus CAM,” at least insofar as the phrase refers to public perceptions or individual choices of patients or even physicians, are not the issues here. The overwhelming issues are ethical and scientific, and the two are not distinct: human studies ethics must be informed by science. I’ve explained this in some detail elsewhere in this long series. In summary, the Gonzalez trial repeatedly violated the Helsinki Declaration and other human studies treatises, including those established by the NIH itself and offered by NIH ethicists: it made Gonzalez, who is neither “a scientifically qualified person” nor “a clinically competent medical person,” responsible for human subjects; it did not minimize risks or enhance potential benefits, nor did “the potential benefits to individuals and knowledge gained for society … outweigh the risks” (it was a “trifling hypothesis”); it did not have “respect for enrolled subjects,” as evidenced by the horrible experience of at least one subject whose story was told by his friend, mathematician Susan Gurney; it did not “conform to generally accepted scientific principles…based on a thorough knowledge of the scientific literature, other relevant sources of information, and on adequate laboratory and, where appropriate, animal experimentation”; instead, it justified itself by citing a flawed, non-consecutive case series offered by Gonzalez himself, which both Dr. Peter Moran and I deconstructed with only a bit of effort (see also here), and by the “popularity” fallacy.
Perhaps most disturbing, even to people who aren’t familiar with the literature of human studies ethics, is that the trial investigators almost certainly failed to provide prospective subjects with the knowledge necessary for informed consent. Such knowledge would have consisted of the cancer biology known at the time, which overwhelmingly predicted that Gonzalez’s regimen would have no beneficial effect on cancer of the pancreas; of an accurate, honest assessment of his case series; and of his history of peddling pseudoscientific claims and providing incompetent care. I’ve written “almost certain” because I haven’t seen more than a short excerpt possibly from the trial’s consent form, although I’ve tried to do so (hint: if anyone reading this has a copy please send it on). I can’t imagine, however, that the consent form included comprehensive information because if it had, no competent IRB would have approved the study and very few subjects would have enrolled.
The history told by Susan Gurney about her friend, moreover, strongly suggests that he had not been adequately informed:
I told him that I was going to attend the annual conference of the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) and would report on other options to him. Once at ASCO, I learned quickly and definitively that the Gonzalez protocol was a fraud; no mainstream doctors believed it was anything else and they were surprised that anyone with education would be on it…
By remaining neutral about the Gonzalez regimen, physicians at Columbia Presbyterian who place patients in this trial effectively preclude them from starting other options, because of the demands it places on patients and their families. If physicians believe they are truly being neutral by not fully explaining the Gonzalez protocol’s nature to cancer patients, it is they who are in denial.
Michael Specter, who wrote about Gonzalez for the New Yorker in 2001, reported similar faux neutrality from Karen Antman, then the chief of Columbia’s division of medical oncology and a past president of the American Society of Clinical Oncology, who would be a co-author of the eventual JCO report. First, she showed him the excerpt that I mentioned above, which Mr. Specter characterized as “instructions that Columbia gives patients interested in the Gonzalez study”:
Many Americans who develop advanced cancer for which standard treatments have little to offer, turn to alternative or complementary therapies….There is no current conventional medical support for the theories and assumptions underlying the use of Nutritional Therapy. The Columbia College of Physicians and Surgeons does not support its use except as part of a properly conducted clinical trial.
If that bland statement was all prospective subjects were told about “conventional medical support” for the Gonzalez regimen, it hardly constituted a responsible explanation. Mr. Specter himself, who is not a physician or scientist, sensed that as well:
I asked if it would be right to infer that she thought the trial wouldn’t work. She shook her head. I asked if she had an idea why it might work. She said no. Did she have any opinions at all about the potential of nutritional therapy or the Gonzalez regime? “I have lots of opinions,” she told me, “but none of them matter.”
Except that such opinions do matter, as any human study investigator is expected to know. Susan Gurney explained why they would have mattered to her friend:
He was an artist—a painter and a sculptor—and he had little scientific knowledge. When Dr. Chabot was neutral about the Gonzalez protocol, and when Dr. Antman said nothing adverse about it, my friend assumed that they must genuinely believe that the treatment could work.
The trial’s Principal Investigator, John Chabot, was also reticent to offer subjects accurate information about the Gonzalez regimen, as evidenced by a 1999 “Dear Prospective Patient” letter. These findings—that oncologists in general thought that “the Gonzalez protocol was a fraud,” but that the Columbia investigators failed to disclose that fact, and the reasons for it, to subjects—exposes another ethical violation that I’ve previously discussed: the trial lacked clinical equipoise.
Finally, it is clear, as discussed here and elsewhere in this series, that the underlying impetus for the trial was political, not scientific. Shouldn’t that have also been included in the consent form?
EBM Gets it Wrong
Keeping all that in mind, let’s revisit the quotation from Dr. Levine explaining the goal of his editorial, this time putting it into the context of the entire paragraph:
I am fortunate to have spent my entire academic career at McMaster University (Hamilton, Ontario, Canada), the birthplace of evidence-based medicine, and to have had the privilege of learning from colleagues such as David Sackett, MD, and Gord Guyatt, MD. The goal of this discussion is not to debate the merits of conventional medicine versus CAM. Rather, the objectives are to consider whether these two paths of medicine should be held to the same standards of evidence in terms of clinical and policy decision making and to determine whether a model that historically has been based on weak evidence can be reconciled with the new paradigm of the requirement for high-quality evidence.
Yes! A thousand times yes! They should be held to the same standards of evidence. But that means that they should be required to meet the same preliminary standards before being accepted for high-quality human trials, and those standards are about scientific evidence: evidence from basic science, evidence from the biology of the disease in question, evidence from animal studies, and evidence from whatever preliminary human case reports or uncontrolled trials there may be. The Gonzalez regimen failed all of those requirements, and the trial was thus scientifically unjustified and unethical from the start.
Dr. Levine, however, is misled by the limited EBM understanding of “evidence,” as is suggested by the last line of the paragraph. Later, he leaves no doubt:
This is one of the most challenging editorials I have had to write. Wearing the hat of a clinical epidemiologist, it is difficult not to find fundamental flaws in both of these trials. Not too long ago, I would have dismissed them out of hand. However, as a clinician, I recognize that many of my patients seek CAM therapies, and many are using them and afraid to tell me. I am troubled by the lack of evidence for many of these therapies and the costs that patients incur in using them. In the past, there was a reluctance to subject CAM therapies to the same standards of evaluation as those for conventional therapies. Should CAM therapies undergo the same type of rigorous evaluation to which conventional therapies are subjected? Absolutely! When authors submit clinical trials to JCO, they are instructed to follow specific guidelines. These guidelines should be the same whether the intervention is chemotherapy, radiation, an herbal remedy, or a psychosocial intervention.
Yes, there are specific guidelines for publishing reports in the JCO, and in the case of the Gonzalez report, they were violated. I wonder why Dr. Levine didn’t mention CONSORT? Clearly, the “type of rigorous evaluation” to which he is referring is a clinical trial. Otherwise, there would be little trouble subjecting scientifically incoherent methods (not ‘CAM therapies,’ which begs the question) to the same standards of evaluation as those for scientifically coherent methods (not ‘conventional,’ which has irrelevant social connotations). The beginning of such an evaluation is to judge how plausible the method might be, and the way to do that is by considering scientific evidence. This, Dr. Levine, is evidence.
Similarly, there was not merely a “lack of evidence” for the Gonzalez regimen; there was abundant evidence against it. As suggested above, Dr. Levine must understand this at some level: although he argued, incorrectly and irrelevantly, that the trial had failed to prove that “enzyme therapy is markedly inferior” to gemcitabine, he nevertheless opined that “Given the scarcity of resources for cancer research, there are many more important questions to address.” How could he assign even a qualitative measure of “importance” without considering prior probability?
Yet again he retreats to the safe haven of EBM, failing to recognize the ethical mischief wrought by ignoring science:
Chabot et al should be congratulated on their persistence and determination to compare pancreatic enzymes versus [sic] chemotherapy.
No! A thousand times no! Compare Dr. Levine’s statement with my own:
The authors of the report should be scrutinized by the OHRP and the NIH. They should be banned from being investigators in any NIH-sponsored trial for some finite period, and their involvement in the Gonzalez trial should become a noticeable smear on their reputations.
Here is Dr. Levine’s final paragraph. Rather than comment further, I’ve provided pertinent hyperlinks:
Recently, there has been a shift from single CAM modalities for cancer management to a more comprehensive approach called integrative oncology, which is “an evolving, evidence-based specialty that uses CAM therapies in concert with biomedical cancer treatments to enhance its efficacy, improve symptom control, alleviate patient distress and reduce suffering.” I am encouraged that the leaders of the Society of Integrative Oncology (Dundas, Ontario, Canada) have developed evidentiary levels to gauge the strength of evidence for CAM therapies. It is not surprising that these levels are based on the foundational principles of evidence-based medicine established by Sackett et al. I look forward to future well-designed clinical trials that provide high-quality evidence on how CAM therapies can improve the quality of life of our patients.

Ethical Failures
Mark Crislip on July 10, 2015
Link


It is summer vacation for me in Eastern Oregon at Sunriver. Unbelievable geology, fantastic hikes, great biking, wonderful golf, delicious beer and good food. The thesaurus fails me for superlatives. It is hard to get too riled up about all things SCAM to produce a blog entry when I could be doing one or all of the above. I really don’t want to do this. Sadly, David keeps threatening me with the video he has of me touting the benefits of Integrative Medicine with its holistic approach to health care, and I just can’t have that published on the ‘net. So some brief speculation to fill the time between golf and a pint of IPA overlooking the Sisters.
Ethics, and the purpose of SBM
Steve started this blog in 2008 in part because he realized that evidence-based medicine was inadequate for the task of evaluating pseudo-medicines. He coined the term ‘science-based medicine’ with the realization that for fantastical therapies like acupuncture or homeopathy, all the potential biases and flaws in the evidence from clinical studies could result in pseudo-medicines appearing effective when at heart they are all Oakland California.
I do not suppose there could be science-based ethics. One person’s ethical certainty is another’s belly laugh. I remember a grand rounds on human cloning years ago and they had, among others, a priest discussing the ethics of human cloning, and I thought at the time there would be few speakers with less legitimacy. And really, I can see no harm in cloning an army of zombie super soldiers, especially if they were under my control.
Still, one of the issues I remain amazed at is how many clinical trials testing pseudo-medicines are approved by institutional review boards (IRB).
The changing practice of medicine
Let us ignore for the sake of this essay the issue that there is little point in testing pseudo-medical therapies from a medical practice perspective. In real medicine we do studies to guide therapies, eventually adding or abandoning interventions as the data accumulates as to their benefit or lack thereof. I have been in medicine for 30 years and the old saw that half of what you learn in medical school will be proven wrong is off by a log. So much of what I used to do has either been abandoned or superseded as new clinical trials and diagnostics have become available.
This is the opposite of pseudo-medicine. No therapy is ever abandoned as a result of the accumulation of negative clinical studies. Pseudo-medicines do change, but usually the unholy merging of two different pseudo-medicines to give a third, say, laser acupuncture or chiropractic nose balloons. But there is little reason from a practical point of view in doing pseudo-medical research as practice will never, ever, never change as a result of research. They are reality-proof endeavors. The end result of 30 years of negative or inconclusive pseudo-medical research is the growth of Integrative Medicine divisions in all the major universities.
The ethics of SCAM research
Let’s talk instead about the ethics of research. Clinical trials have to be approved by an IRB, and usually these IRBs are often at the institution where the research is being performed. Perhaps it is not for the best that your friends and colleagues are the ones to determine if a given SCAM clinical trial is actually appropriate. I would be willing to bet the average person sitting on an IRB has as much understanding and background about pseudo-medicines that I did 10 years ago: almost nothing.
The purpose of an IRB:
…is to assure, both in advance and by periodic review, that appropriate steps are taken to protect the rights and welfare of humans participating as subjects in the research. To accomplish this purpose, IRBs use a group process to review research protocols and related materials (e.g., informed consent documents and investigator brochures) to ensure protection of the rights and welfare of human subjects of research.
And it is important that they:
Safeguard the rights, safety, and well-being of all trial subjects. Special attention should be paid to trials that may include vulnerable subjects, such as pregnant women, children, prisoners, the elderly, or persons with diminished comprehension.
The IRB should, I suspect, follow the NIH ethical guidelines. Although guidelines are not commandments, they do form a conceptual framework to guide the evaluation of a clinical trial:
Social and clinical value
Every research study is designed to answer a specific question. Answering certain questions will have significant value for society or for present or future patients with a particular illness. An answer to the research question should be important or valuable enough to justify asking people to accept some risk or inconvenience for others. In other words, answers to the research question should contribute to scientific understanding of health or improve our ways of preventing, treating, or caring for people with a given disease. Only if society will gain useful knowledge — which requires sharing results, both negative and positive — can exposing human subjects to the risk and burden of research be justified.
Scientific validity
A study should be designed in a way that will get an understandable answer to the valuable research question. This includes considering whether the question researchers are asking is answerable, whether the research methods are valid and feasible, and whether the study is designed with a clear scientific objective and using accepted principles, methods, and reliable practices…Invalid research is unethical because it is a waste of resources and exposes people to risk for no purpose.
Favorable risk-benefit ratio
Uncertainty about the degree of risks and benefits associated with a drug, device, or procedure being tested is inherent in clinical research — otherwise there would be little point to doing the research. And by definition, there is more uncertainty about risks and benefits in early-phase research than in later research. Depending on the particulars of a study, research risks might be trivial or serious, might cause transient discomfort or long-term changes. Risks can be physical (death, disability, infection), psychological (depression, anxiety), economic (job loss), or social (for example, discrimination or stigma from participating in a certain trial). Has everything been done to minimize the risks and inconvenience to research subjects, to maximize the potential benefits, and to determine that the potential benefits to individuals and society are proportionate to, or outweigh, the risks? Research volunteers often receive some health services and benefits in the course of participating, yet the purpose of clinical research is not to provide health services.
Independent review
To minimize potential conflicts of interest and make sure a study is ethically acceptable before it even starts, an independent review panel with no vested interest in the particular study should review the proposal and ask important questions, including: Are those conducting the trial sufficiently free of bias? Is the study doing all it can to protect research volunteers? Has the trial been ethically designed and is the risk–benefit ratio favorable? In the United States, independent evaluation of research projects is done through granting agencies, local institutional review boards (IRBs), and data and safety monitoring boards. These groups also monitor a study while it is ongoing.
Informed consent
For research to be ethical, most agree that individuals should make their own decision about whether they want to participate or continue participating in research. This is done through a process of informed consent in which individuals (1) are accurately informed of the purpose, methods, risks, benefits, and alternatives to the research, (2) understand this information and how it relates to their own clinical situation or interests, and (3) make a voluntary decision about whether to participate.
There are exceptions to the need for informed consent from the individual — for example, in the case of a child, of an adult with severe Alzheimer’s, of an adult unconscious by head trauma, or of someone with limited mental capacity. Ensuring that the individual’s research participation is consistent with his or her values and interests usually entails empowering a proxy decision maker to decide about participation, usually based on what research decision the subject would have made, if doing so were possible.
To my mind almost all studies of pseudo-medicines like acupuncture, homeopathy, chiropractic, reiki etc. all fail first with scientific validity. Research with these modalities are the poster child for being “invalid research [that] is unethical because it is a waste of resources and exposes people to risk for no purpose.”
The ethics of dividing by zero
And clinical trials for pseudo-medicine fail to “gain useful knowledge” as well as a risk/benefit that has no meaning. Can’t divide by zero after all.
What amazes me is the perfect storm of pseudo-medicine testing in vulnerable populations, where the IRBs have failed in all ethical aspects of clinical trials.
Homeopathy is water. I cannot imagine how it could be ethical to test water for any process in children. I can’t understand how an IRB that understood homeopathy could approve a study in at risk populations.
But there are no end of homeopathy studies in children:
A total of 326 articles were identified, 91 of which were retrieved for detailed evaluation. Sixteen trials that assessed 9 different conditions were included in the study. With the exception of attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and acute childhood diarrhea (each tested in 3 trials), no condition was assessed in more than 2 double-blind randomized clinical trials. The evidence for attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and acute childhood diarrhea is mixed, showing both positive and negative results for their respective main outcome measures. For adenoid vegetation, asthma, and upper respiratory tract infection each, 2 trials are available that suggest no difference compared with placebo. For 4 conditions, only single trials are available.
And there shouldn’t be even one.
The University of Toronto (yes, that University of Toronto) wants to test homeopathy in ADHD children even though a prior pilot study was:
…unblinded, devoid of randomization, had no control group and relied on a subjective outcome, making any data derived from it essentially meaningless.
A good basis for experimenting on children. Ignoring the question of why such a study would be done in the first place, how does such a study even meet bare ethical requirements for performing a study? Maybe Canadians have a different set of ethical standards.
SCAM ethics around the world
Not that researchers around the world are any better. There are a half-dozen studies evaluating acupuncture for tonsillectomy pain in children, and studies in children for acute appendicitis. And there are trials of acupuncture in dementia patients and coma patients. And theraputic touch for the demented. And no end of chiropractic in children, from asthma to bedwetting, with all its downsides.
To my way of thinking, the most egregious abuse of at-risk populations were the trials of homeopathy for diarrhea in Nepal, Honduras, and Nicaragua. Truly vulnerable and impoverished populations who desperately need real medications have the magic that is homeopathy inflicted on them with the approval of IRBs. The gaster is flabbered.
The NCCIH evidently has an ethics counselor. As best I can determine, she has no publications on either PubMed or the NCCIH site. And I can find no discussion on the ethics of pseudo-medicinal research on the NCCIH website. Why am I not surprised?
Children, the demented and the comatose. So much for protecting at risk populations.
The paving stones to Hell, and IRBs
How do these studies get past IRBs in this century? I suspect I know the answer. I would bet that like so much SCAM treatment, the believers make a compelling argument while those on the IRB take them at their word, knowing little about the interventions and trusting to the good intentions of the researchers. And as I have recently discovered:
The opposite of good is not evil. The opposite of good is good intentions.
– Kurt Tucholsky
The PubMeds find discussions both ways: those who have no issues with the ethics of SCAM and those who find the use problematic at best. These references concern the use of pseudo-medicines, but if there are discussions concerning the ethics of CAM research, I can’t find them.
I do not see how to hold IRBs accountable for approving studies on magic. Maybe they should read their mission statement and apply it. It remains one of the conundrums of modern medicine. There are no astrologers publishing in astronomy journals or alchemists in the chemistry journals, but the study of magic continues apace in medicine with no signs of slowing down, ethical or not.
But time for a bike ride then a hike in the Sisters.

   Ghostwriting As Marketing Tool
Steven Novella
Link
An article in the latest issue of PLOS Medicine, The Haunting of Medical Journals: How Ghostwriting Sold “HRT”, details the use of ghostwriting as a marketing tool for pharmaceutical companies. It is a chilling discussion of how at least one pharmaceutical company, Wyeth, used the peer-reviewed literature as a method of distributing marketing messages to physicians.
The author, Adriane J. Fugh-Berman, details a practice that cuts at the heart of science-based medicine – the exploitation and distortion of the literature. The medical profession needs to jealously guard the legitimacy and purity of the peer-review process and the medical scientific literature. I am never one to gratuitously bash “Big Pharma” – this is often used as a method of casually dismissing inconvenient scientific evidence. But at the same time, pharmaceutical companies are in the business of making money. While they are a carefully regulated industry, some in the industry seek ways to skirt around regulations that limit their ability to market their products.
While most physicians consider themselves savvy with respect to pharmaceutical marketing, the story told by Fugh-Berman is one of profound naivete. I guess it should not be a surprise that some academics were bamboozled by expert salespersons who spent a lot of time and effort, apparently, figuring out ways to deceive and manipulate them. But now that the story is out, naivete is no longer an excuse. Here is what happened:
The FDA regulates what pharmaceutical companies can say in their marketing. For example, they are restricted to promoting on-label indications. However, the FDA does not regulate the peer-reviewed literature, and so some pharmaceutical marketers felt that this was a good opportunity to distribute marketing messages outside of FDA control. The primary process was to ghostwrite review articles, commentaries, case series, as well as the occasional primary trial report – and then have “thought leader” physicians sign their name and “author” the article.
This was done under the guise of “editorial assistance,” and “authors” were given the opportunity to edit and make changes to the draft they eventually signed off on. But the entire process was under the careful control and scrutiny of marketers who closely guarded the marketing messages in the paper. These messages included playing up the benefits of a treatment (the paper focuses on hormone replacement therapy), downplaying side effects, criticizing competitors, and promoting off-label use. Review articles are a great place to do this, because there is a great deal of judgment that goes into what to emphasize, and exactly how to present the facts. It is possible to influence opinions in this way without lying, and unless someone was looking for systematic bias it might not be apparent.
Some authors did give significant push-back against this process, but they were “managed.” The ghostwriters also helped to manage the peer-review process, suggesting responses to the editors and reviewers in order to defend core marketing messages.
All of this behavior is documented in 1500 documents revealed in litigation.
Conclusion
The author concludes:
Given the growing evidence that ghostwriting has been used to promote HT and other highly promoted drugs, the medical profession must take steps to ensure that prescribers renounce participation in ghostwriting, and to ensure that unscrupulous relationships between industry and academia are avoided rather than courted.
I completely agree. Reading the description of the ghostwriting process detailed in this paper was beyond disturbing. It gives the image of a callous disregard for the scientific process and a view of physicians and the scientific literature as something to be manipulated.
It is not clear how extensive the practice of ghostwriting is. I have never personally encountered it myself, but this fact is not terribly enlightening. What is clear is that academic institutions and peer-reviewed journals need to take definitive measures to eliminate the practice of ghostwriting articles. The behavior needs to be simply not tolerated. It may also be necessary for the FDA to ban the practice, since it is used as a means to thwart FDA regulations of pharmaceutical marketing.
I do not begrudge the pharmaceutical industry the ability to fairly market their products. But there needs to be an absolute wall of separation between the scientific process and the marketing process, and that means keeping pharmaceutical company ghostwriters out of the scientific literature.

   Threats to science-based medicine: Big pharma pays a publisher to produce a fake journal
David Gorski
Link
It’s times like these when I’m happy that I haven’t published in too many Elsevier Journals during the course of my career. Actually, I’m not sure if I’ve ever published in an Elsevier journal, although I have reviewed manuscripts for them. In any case, I say that because on Thursday, it was revealed that pharmaceutical company Merck, Sharp & Dohme paid Elsevier to produce a fake medical journal that, to any superficial examination, looked like a real medical journal but was in reality nothing more than advertising for Merck. As reported by The Scientist:
Merck paid an undisclosed sum to Elsevier to produce several volumes of a publication that had the look of a peer-reviewed medical journal, but contained only reprinted or summarized articles–most of which presented data favorable to Merck products–that appeared to act solely as marketing tools with no disclosure of company sponsorship.
“I’ve seen no shortage of creativity emanating from the marketing departments of drug companies,” Peter Lurie, deputy director of the public health research group at the consumer advocacy nonprofit Public Citizen, said, after reviewing two issues of the publication obtained by The Scientist. “But even for someone as jaded as me, this is a new wrinkle.”
The Australasian Journal of Bone and Joint Medicine, which was published by Exerpta Medica, a division of scientific publishing juggernaut Elsevier, is not indexed in the MEDLINE database, and has no website (not even a defunct one). The Scientist obtained two issues of the journal: Volume 2, Issues 1 and 2, both dated 2003. The issues contained little in the way of advertisements apart from ads for Fosamax, a Merck drug for osteoporosis, and Vioxx. (Click here and here to view PDFs of the two issues.)
This is wrong on so many levels that it’s hard to know where to begin.
If there is one thing that science-based medicine requires to function properly, it’s good science and well-designed clinical trials subjected to rigorous peer review. Moreover, that review has to be unbiased, and the journals publishing them cannot be tainted with undue influence of big pharma. A while back, JAMA editor Catherine DeAngelis was criticized for her crusade against undisclosed conflicts of interest by the authors of journal articles, and, most importantly, her hypocrisy and heavy-handed attempt to slap down a researcher and educator who pointed out the failure of a JAMA author to disclose that he had been on the speakers’ bureau for a pharmaceutical company whose drug he had been studying. What made this offense particularly egregious was that the study in question had a rather glaring methodological flaw that, when corrected for, revealed that nonpharmacological therapy was equal to that of the drug company’s medication, which the author admitted when it was pointed out to him.
What does one do when the whole journal–articles and all–is nothing more than a glossy advertisement for a pharmaceutical company’s products?
First off, if there’s one thing most physicians and scientists know, it’s that there are numerous “throwaway” journals out there. “Throwaway” journals tend to be defined as journals that are provided free of charge, have a lot of advertising (a high “advertising-to-text” ratio, as it is often described), and contain no original investigations. Other relevant characteristics include:
    • Supported virtually entirely by advertising revenue.
    • Ads tend to be placed within article pages interrupting the articles, rather than between articles, as is the case with most medical journals that accept ads
    • Virtually the entire content is reviews of existing content of variable (and often dubious) quality.
    • Parasitic. Throwaways often summarize peer-reviewed research from real journals.
    • Questionable (at best) peer review.
    • Throwaways tend to cater to an uninvolved and uncritical readership.
    • No original work.
Throwaway journals are rarely or never cited in the medical literature and virtually never indexed in PubMed. They also tend to have names like, well, Australasian Journal of Bone and Joint Medicine. However, as advertisement-packed as throwaway journals tend to be, they are actually fairly widely read–indeed as much or more so than some peer-reviewed journals. The reason, most likely, is because they tend to publish short, easily digestible review articles, perfect for busy clinicians, particularly in private practice. Moreover, as reported in this JAMA article (ironically enough), despite their lesser scientific rigor, throwaway journals have many aspects that are appealing to clinicians:
The mean (SD) quality scores were highest for peer-reviewed articles (0.94 [0.09] for systematic reviews and 0.30 [0.19] for nonsystematic reviews) compared with throwaway journal articles (0.23 [0.03], F2,391=280.8, P .001). Throwaway journal articles used more tables (P=.02), figures (P=.01), photographs (P .001), color (P .001), and larger font sizes (P .001) compared with peer-reviewed articles. Readability scores were more often in the college or higher range for peer-reviewed journals compared with the throwaway journal articles (104 [77.0%] vs 156 [64.2%]; P=.01). Peer-reviewed article titles were judged less relevant to clinical practice than throwaway journal article titles (P .001).
In other words, throwaway journals tend to be to peer-reviewed journals a lot like USA Today is to The New York Times or The Wall Street Journal. However, in general, they are not blatantly written by pharmaceutical companies, as apparently was the case with the Merck journal. (Yes, I’m going to refer to it as that. After all, that’s accurate.) Moreover, in general doctors are well aware of throwaway journals and that they aren’t meant to be taken as seriously as real journals. (If they were, they wouldn’t be delivered free to their offices, sometimes whether they want them or not, after all.) Rather, doctors tend use them as shortcuts for digesting information quickly or not to rad them at all. (There’s a reason they’re called “throwaway” journals.) They also realize that they are completely advertising-supported. In essence, any conflicts of interest are pretty well right out there in the form of numerous ads.
This effort by Merck took it far, far beyond the throwaway journal:
In response to several questions about the publication posed by The Scientist, an MSDA spokesperson wrote in an email: “MSDA understood that Elsevier envisaged the complimentary publication would draw on the vast resources of Elsevier, publishers of many leading peer-reviewed journals including Lancet, Bone, Joint Bone Spine and others, to deliver novel and timely full text articles and abstracts to physicians.” Many of the articles appearing in the Australasian Journal of Bone and Joint Medicine were in fact reprints or summaries of studies that originally appeared in other Elsevier journals.
As if that excuses the deception. Of course, they must have been reprints of articles that appeared in other Elsevier journals! Otherwise, Elsevier wouldn’t have had the rights to publish them! It’s not necessarily the quality of the reprinted articles that’s an issue. It’s their packaging in a pseudojournal that’s nothing more than an advertising vehicle for Merck without any disclosure that that’s what the purpose of the journal was! Elsevier’s got some ‘splainin’ to do, as they say:
“Elsevier acknowledges the concern that the journals in question didn’t have the appropriate disclosures,” the statement continued. “It is worth noting that project in question was produced 6 years ago and disclosure protocols have evolved since 2003. Elsevier’s current disclosure policies meet the rigor and requirements of the current publishing environment.”
The Elsevier spokesperson said the company wasn’t aware of how many copies of the Australasian Journal of Bone and Joint Medicine were produced or how the publication was distributed in Australia, but noted that “the common practice for sponsored journals is that doctors receive them complimentary.” The spokesperson added that Elsevier had no plans to look further into the matter.
So, in other words, we don’t do it anymore; so it’s not a big deal. Of course, Elsevier also publishes the pseudoscientific journal Homeopathy (after all, homeopathy is quackery, period), a fair number of “integrative medicine” journals, and the highly dubious journal Explore, which regularly publishes Dean Radin’s pseudoscientific articles on “distant healing” and food imbued with “intent.” So you’ll excuse me if I don’t take Elsevier’s hilarious “code of ethics” seriously:
Elsevier takes its duties of guardianship over the scholarly record very seriously. Our journal programs record “the minutes of science” and we recognize our responsibilities as the keeper of those “minutes” in all our policies, including the guidelines we have adopted to support editors, reviewers and authors in performing their ethical duties.
Except, apparently, when it comes to pharma-supported advertising efforts and the publication of quack journals.
Unfortunately, Merck and Elsevier couldn’t do this alone. They needed help. Depressingly, they got it from the very people who should know enough to “just say no” to such blatant marketing ploys:
One of the members of Australasian Journal of Bone and Joint Medicine‘s “Honorary Editorial Board,” Peter Brooks, a rheumatologist in Australia, said he didn’t recall who asked him to serve on the board, but noted that he was on Merck’s Asian Pacific and international advisory boards from the mid 1990s until about 2004, as well as the advisory boards of other pharmaceutical companies, including Pfizer and Amgen. “You get involved in a whole bunch of things at this level,” Brooks said, adding that he had put his name on “a few advertorials” for pharmaceutical companies about 10 years ago.
So Dr. Brooks’ excuse seems to be carelessness. The answer, of course, is for physicians to refuse to “get involved in a whole bunch of things at this level.” He also claims ignorance, namely that he didn’t know that the journal was nothing more than an advertising ploy for big pharma. That, I suppose, is possible, but surely he actually looked at the journal on whose editorial board he had agreed to serve. Surely he must have wondered when, after being on the editorial board, he wasn’t ever actually asked to do anything, such as review a submission–or even solicit a review article. Apparently he did not, even though serving on a real editorial board is generally a large amount of work. Not having any work to do on an editorial board should have been a huge red flag that tipped him that this journal wasn’t a “real” journal. So should the fact that it was listed as an “Honorary Editorial Board.” (I wonder if he put that on his CV.) Moreover, one wonders what he did when he ultimately found out. Apparently nothing, other than to deny that it was a marketing journal. Never mind that there were review articles and even an article labeled as a “meta-analysis” that only listed one or two references. Usually reviews list numerous references that were used as the source material for the review; even more importantly, you can’t do a “meta-analysis” on one or two studies. Such articles should have been even more obvious red flags.
Doctors like Dr. Brooks are every bit as guilty as Merck and Elsevier for deceptive pharma marketing like this. We physicians are supposed to represent the best interests of our patients, and, as far as I’m concerned, to defend science-based medicine. Our credibility depends upon it. Being accomplices to those using deceptive marketing practices such as this not only undermines our credibility and betrays our patients, but it provides an opening for purveyors of unscientific medicine and outright quackery to paint us as hopelessly corrupt. Pharmaceutical companies have ample resources for advertising their wares. We shouldn’t be so willing to give them such cheap access to our credibility and respect as physicians.
ADDENDUM: More commentary at blog.bioethics.net, and by Janet Stemwedel.

   The College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario’s muddled draft policy on “non-allopathic” medicine
David Gorski 
Links
Detroit is my hometown, and three and a half years ago, after nearly twenty years away wandering between residency, graduate school, fellowship, and my first academic job, I found myself back in Detroit minted as surgical faculty at Wayne State University and practicing and doing research at the Barbara Ann Karmanos Cancer Institute. One thing that I had forgotten about while I was away for so many years is just how intimately southeast Michigan interacts with Canada. This closeness is not surprising, given that Detroit and Windsor are separated by only about a half mile of Detroit River. Indeed, a there are a lot of Canadians who cross the border on a daily basis to work in the Detroit area, many of them in the medical center within which my cancer center is located. The reason I point this out is not to wax nostalgic for trips to Windsor or for the occasional trip to Stratford to see plays but to point out that Ontario is right next to us. What happens there is of concern to me because I know quite a few people who live there and because it can on occasion influence what goes on over here on the U.S. side of the border.
I recently learned that the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario (CPSO) has been working on updating its policy on the use of nonconventional medical therapies. The wag in me can’t help but wonder why such a policy would need to say anything other than that, if it isn’t science- and evidence-based, the CPSO doesn’t support using it, but in a less sarcastic moment I realized that such a policy is probably not that bad an idea, as long as it doesn’t legitimize pseudoscience, which is, of course, the biggest pitfall to be avoided when writing such a policy. Not too long ago, the CPSO released its draft policy and has asked for public comments, with the deadline being September 1. I was happy to learn that I had not missed the deadline, because there is much to comment about regarding this policy, but it’s definitely true that time’s short. Unfortunately, I wasn’t so happy when I read the title of the draft policy, namely Non-Allopathic (Non-Conventional) Therapies in Medical Practice, with a subtitle of “Formerly named Complementary Medicine.” The full policy in PDF form can be found at this link.
“Allopathy” versus everything else?
Regular readers of SBM will probably notice one thing right away, even before clicking on either of the links and reading the draft policy. The problem is right there in the title and, in fact, I was floored when I first read the title. My jaw dropped, and dropped hard. Basically, I couldn’t believe that the CPSO had decided to use the term “allopathic” to describe science- and evidence-based medicine. True, that wasn’t the only problem, but it gave me a sinking feeling to see such a term right there in the title. So what’s the problem?
“Allopathic medicine” was a derogatory term originally coined by Samuel Hahnemann, the inventor of homeopathy to contrast homeopathy with the medicine of the time, namely that of 200 years ago. Hahnemann, as you may recall, believed in what he called the Law of Similars, which states that “like cures like,” or, to be more clear, that medicines that cause the same symptoms as a disease should be used to treat the disease. Doing this would stimulate the “vital force” and lead to resolution of the symptoms. Of course, this is nothing more than the principles of sympathetic magic transmuted (if you’ll excuse the term) into a different element, namely that of medicine; there has never been any convincing evidence—or even much in the way of evidence at all—that “like cures like” (or, using the Latin that Hahnemann favored, similia similibus curentur) is a general principle in biology or medicine. According to Hahnemann, “allopathy,” as opposed to homeopathy, is medicine that violated the law of similia similibus curentur and treats disease using remedies whose effects differ from those produced by that disease, the term meaning “other than the disease.” From its very origin, in fact, “allopathy” has been a derogatory term for medicine that is not homeopathy. Indeed, you can even find quotes to that effect documented in—of all places—the Wikipedia entry on allopathy. For instance, James Whorton points out in his book Nature Cures: The History of Alternative Medicine in America:
One form of verbal warfare used in retaliation by irregulars was the word “allopathy.” Coined two hundred years ago by Samuel Hahnemann, founder of homeopathy, it was taken from Greek roots meaning “other than the disease” and was intended, among other things, to indicate that regular doctors used methods that were unrelated to the disharmony produced by disease and thus were harmful to their patients. “Allopathy” and “allopathic” were liberally employed as pejoratives by all irregular physicians of the nineteenth century, and the terms were considered highly offensive by those at whom they were directed. The generally uncomplaining acceptance of [the term] “allopathic medicine” by today’s physicians is an indication of both a lack of awareness of the term’s historical use and the recent thawing of relations between irregulars and allopaths.
The other aspect of the term “allopathy” is that it was consciously used by practitioners of “unconventional” medicine to relegate “conventional” medicine to nothing more than another “competing” school of medicine. The term thus serves the simultaneous purpose of bringing “allopathic medicine” down to homeopathy’s level and elevating homeopathy to the level of conventional medicine. Far better, albeit still imperfect, characterizations could be:
    • Science-based medicine versus nonscientific medicine
    • Conventional medicine versus unconventional medicine
    • Medicine versus unproven medicine
Other possibilities come to mind. Of course, my preferred one (reality-based medicine versus magic) is probably a bit too stark. Be that as it may, I would contend that accepting the language of practitioners of unscientific medicine and using it in an official policy statement is not a good idea. Language has power and meaning. No one knows that better than promoters of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or “integrative medicine” (IM) or whatever it is that quacks decide to call it next. While the use of language in the CPSO draft is disturbing enough in and of itself, there are more substantive problems with the draft that need to be discussed.
Beyond “allopathic medicine”
The opening of the CPSO statement does not begin any more auspiciously than the title, after which the statement quickly devolves into meaningless platitudes that accept many of the false equivalencies promoted by CAM practitioners when arguing for pseudoscience. For example, check out how the draft opens:
In increasing numbers, patients are looking beyond allopathic medicine to nonallopathic therapies for answers to complex medical problems, strategies for improved wellness, or relief from acute medical symptoms. Patients may seek advice or treatment from a range of health care providers, including Ontario physicians.
The College supports patient choice in setting treatment goals and in making health care decisions, and has no intention or interest in depriving patients of non-allopathic therapies that are safe and effective. As a medical regulator, the College does, however, have a duty to protect the public from harm. Thus, the object of this policy is to prevent unsafe or ineffective non-allopathic therapies from being provided by physicians, and to prohibit unprofessional or unethical physician conduct in relation to these therapies.
Right from the beginning, all the buzzwords and false equivalencies are right there. There’s the appeal to popularity in the form of the unreferenced, unsupported statement that more patients are embracing non-science-based medicine. That’s rapidly followed by the platitude assuring us that the CPSO supports patient “choice,” which implies by contrast that those who might not be as open to “non-allopathic” medicine are somehow against “patient choice.” particularly given the line of how the CPSO has “no intention or interest” in “depriving” (note the word choice) of their woo. Of course, one wonders what these “non-allopathic” treatments are that are both safe and effective might be. After all, if they were both safe and effective they wouldn’t be “alternative.” I’m tempted to repeat that old trope that alternative medicine that is proven to be safe and effective ceases to be “alternative” and becomes simply “medicine.” Never mind. I just did. So did the CPSO:
The categorization of specific therapies as non-allopathic is fluid: as clinical evidence regarding efficacy is accumulated, certain non-allopathic therapies may gain broad acceptance and thus be accepted in allopathic medicine.
I’ve tried to think of an example of any such therapies that have made the leap from “non-allopathic” to “allopathic” medicine and am hard-pressed to do so. Be that as it may, just because this is an old trope doesn’t mean it isn’t true. Substituting the term “non-allopathic” medicine for term “alternative” medicine or CAM in this draft statement not-so-subtly equates what was once called CAM or “alternative medicine” with “allopathic medicine.” Again, language matters, and the CPSO knows it. Its choice of the the term “non-allopathic” was deliberate:
Different operative terms have been adopted that were deemed to be value-neutral: ‘Allopathic medicine’ refers to traditional or conventional medicine (as taught in medical schools) and ‘non-allopathic therapies’ refer to complementary or alternative medicine.
Notice also how the CPSO chooses to characterize patients looking for CAM as “looking beyond” allopathic medicine, which implies that CAM modalities are somehow ahead of or superior to “allopathy.” A more appropriate way to phrase this concept would be to say that patients are looking “outside of” science-based medicine or “elsewhere than” science-based medicine. But, no. Patients are “looking beyond” that tired, old, hidebound scientific medicine.
Imagine my relief that the College is committed to preventing unsafe or ineffective “non-allopathic” therapies from being provided by physicians. You know, ineffective like homeopathy.
Platitudes mixed with disturbing statements
If there’s one thing about this draft that impresses me about the CPSO draft policy is the sheer number of meaningless platitudes the CPSO packed into it. Mixed in with these platitudes are statements that range from disturbing to just plain puzzling. For instance, one puzzling aspect of the draft occurs where the CPSO points out that physicians should “refrain from exploitation” and abusing his power over patients and avoid conflicts of interest. No one, least of all I, would argue that physicians should exploit their patients or engage in activities that represent a blatant conflict of interest, but nowhere in the draft is this principle related to the use of “non-allopathic” medicine by patients or physicians. At least for the other principles the draft at least takes a stab at trying to relate them to patient autonomy, which, of course, the CPSO supports. The CPSO also expects physicians to:
     1.  Act in patients’ best interests, in accordance with fiduciary duties;
     2.  Respect patient autonomy with respect to health care goals, and treatment decisions;
     3.  Communicate effectively and openly with patients and others involved in the provision of health care;
     4.  Maintain patient trust through a commitment to altruism, compassion and service.
As opposed to, I suppose, advocating not acting in patients’ best interests, not respecting patient autonomy, not communicating effectively and openly, and not being committed to altruism, compassion, and service. I know, I know, I’m being a bit curmudgeonly, and I realize that these sorts of principles have to be repeated and emphasized, but it’s about the specifics of how physicians will adhere to such principles “where the rubber hits the road,” so to speak that such a policy should provide guidance. I would argue that it is a physician’s responsibility always to be honest with his patients and to pull no punches when it comes to giving his professional opinion. That is the very essence of acting in the patient’s best interest and communicating effectively and openly. What, then, am I to make of some of the statements in this draft that sound suspiciously like advocating pulling punches? For instance:
The College expects physicians to respect patients’ treatment goals and decisions, even those which physicians deem to be unfounded or unwise. In doing so, physicians should state their best professional opinion about the goal or decision, but must refrain from expressing non-clinical judgements.
I can’t help but wonder whether calling, for example, homeopathy “quackery” would be viewed as a “non-clinical” judgment by the CPSO. The language used smacks of the CAM-enabling sort of language that demands that we physicians above all remain “nonjudgmental.” Personally, I would counter that it is our professional responsibility to be judgmental when it comes to evaluating the evidence for a treatment. It is our duty to judge what treatments are safe and effective and which are not; that’s what our patients come to us for.
Here’s another problematic passage:
When providing non-allopathic therapies, physicians are expected to demonstrate the same commitment to clinical excellence and ethical practice, as they would when providing allopathic care.
The problem here is that providing “non-allopathic” care that is not evidence- and science-based (in other words, virtually all of it) is inherently unethical and represents anything but “clinical excellence.” This is a rather amusing conundrum to me. Consider this example. If a physician (and, make no mistake, there are a fair number of physicians who do this) offers homeopathy, which is nothing more than magical water supposedly imbued with mystical healing caused by the “memory of water” remembering whatever remedy that was in it before and forgetting, as Tim Minchin puts it, all the poo that’s been in it. How can any physician ethically offer homeopathy, for example, to a patient? Similar arguments construct themselves for other “non-allopathic” therapies, such as reiki (which is faith healing that substitutes Eastern mysticism for Christianity as its basis) or acupuncture, which postulates that sticking needles into “meridians” that have no detectable anatomic counterpart somehow “unblocks” the flow of vitalistic mystical life energy to healing effect. Yet, the CPSO goes on to state:
Physicians must always act within the limits of their knowledge, skill and judgement9 and never provide care that is beyond the scope of their clinical competence.
This expectation applies equally to treatments or therapies that the physician proposes and those that may be requested directly by patients. Where patients seek care that is beyond the physician’s clinical competence, physicians must clearly indicate that they are unable to provide the care. Physicians should consider whether a referral can be made to another physician or health care provider for care the physician is unable to provide directly.
While this is simply a restating of basic physician ethics when it comes to science-based medicine, I can’t help but wonder: Does this policy in the context of emphasizing patient autonomy and choice somehow obligate or imply an obligation for an Ontario physician to refer to a “non-allopathic” practitioner if that is what the patient wants? Shouldn’t there be a clear statement that a physician is not obligated to support the use of “non-allopathic” medicine if he believes it—and correctly so—to be quackery? The whole thing is a muddle, particularly given the statements elsewhere in the policy about how diagnosis and treatment should be based on the principles of “allopathic” medicine?
A brief policy statement
It’s obvious from the wishy-washy approach to the scientific basis of medicine, the waffle words when it comes to whether an “allopathic” physician should support “non-allopathic” therapies, and the apparently inadvertent use of language favored by quacks that there were far too many “alternative” practitioners involved in drafting this policy. Similarly, the comments are dominated by believers, although I must admit that one of them does point out the conflict inherent in this policy, as the CPSO tries to have it both ways:
“To act in accordance with the standards of allopathic medicine, physicians providing non-allopathic care must reach an allopathic diagnosis”
This doesn’t make sense! If I want non-allopathic care, then that includes a non-allopathic diagnosis. Allopathic labelling is only useful for determining which prescription to write and has no business in non-allopathic medicine!
This would be a bit of a problem in traditional Chinese medicine, where the diagnoses are based on “imbalances” in heat, moisture, etc., and some diagnoses come about by mapping organs to locations on the tongue. Similarly, in homeopathy, diagnoses are not necessarily based on physiology and treatments are based on homeopathic “provings.” Yes, this believer nailed the conundrum that the CPSO is trying to dance around.
To that end, let me propose a much briefer policy statement for the CPSO to consider in a few bullet points:
    • Medicine should be science- and evidence-based. “Alternative” and “evidence-based,” “allopathic” and “non-allopathic,” “conventional” and “unconventional” are all false dichotomies. If a treatment is not evidence- and science-based, it is not medicine. Such a treatment becomes “medicine” only when it is demonstrated to work by science.
    • Competent adults have every right to seek out non-science-based medicine if that is what they desire. However, informed consent mandates that physicians who encounter such patients provide an honest professional assessment of such treatments based on science.
    • Physicians should always inquire about the use of non-science-based medicine when evaluating their patients, so that they can take into account possible interactions with medical treatments.
    • Physicians are in no way obligated to refer patients to “alternative medical” practitioners. For many forms of “alternative medicine” doing so is unethical because such modalities are not science- or evidence-based.
I’m sure readers can come up with their own versions or suggest modifications and/or additions to the bullet points above.
In the meantime, there is still more than a week left before the September 1 deadline for supporters of science-based medicine to let the CPSO know the problems in its draft policy by e-mailing ComplementaryMedicine@cpso.on.ca or filling out CPSO’s online survey. It’s clear from the comments that are there now that more input from supporters of science-based medicine is needed.

American Academy of Family Physicians Home Study Course Recommends Non-Science-Based Treatments
Harriet Hall on November 24, 2015
Link


Since passing my board exams in family practice in 1979 I have relied heavily on the American Academy of Family Physicians for continuing medical education via the American Family Physician and the AAFP home study programs. The AAFP prides itself on its evidence-based approach to medicine. In general, it delivers. But the recent FP Essentials Number 432 on “Chronic Pain Management” fell short. It recommended treating chronic pain with acupuncture, chiropractic, touch therapy, and S-adenosyl methionine (SAM-e), presenting them in a way that misled readers into thinking that the recommendations were based on good scientific evidence. They were not.
With 6,500 peer reviewed journals and over two million papers published every year, it is easy to find a study to support pretty much any point of view. John Ioannidis taught us that most published research findings are false, with preliminary studies frequently being overturned by larger, better follow-up studies. When evaluating the evidence for a treatment, it is not enough to find one or two positive studies. It is essential to also look for negative studies and for systematic analyses that weigh all the published evidence, and to put all the available evidence into perspective. The authors failed to do that.
Acupuncture
First, let me point out that the lead author incorporates acupuncture into her practice. This could be considered a conflict of interest. She obviously believes in it, which is bound to interfere with an objective interpretation of the published evidence. The personal experience of seeing patients improve after a treatment can be very compelling, but it is notoriously misleading. Medieval blood-letters saw patients recover after their treatments and never realized they were doing more harm than good. Surgeons who performed internal mammary artery ligations for heart disease had a 90% success rate, and it took two sham surgery experiments to convince them that the operation was actually useless. Only controlled studies can determine whether a treatment is more effective than placebo. As Mark Crislip says, “In my experience” are the three most dangerous words in medicine.
“Acupuncture” is not a single well-defined treatment. The authors themselves point out that it may refer to needles, acupressure, electrical stimulation, moxibustion, cupping, or herb placement; and it can actually refer to many more varieties such as esogetic colorpuncture (with colored light) and Tong Ren (tapping meridians on acupuncture dolls with a metal hammer). The references they cite are for more than one form of acupuncture, so their claim that “acupuncture” has been shown to relieve pain is so imprecise that it is virtually meaningless. They say it involves stimulation of specific points, but the highest quality research has shown that it doesn’t matter where you put the needles; stimulation of non-acupuncture points works just as well. It doesn’t even matter whether you use needles; one study showed that touching the skin with toothpicks worked just as well as individualized and standardized acupuncture. They say that acupuncture points are thought to be associated with unique electrical measurements, and that their stimulation results in a release of neuromodulators that can affect the central nervous system locally and systemically. Those claims are not supported by credible evidence. There have been many studies attempting to define a mechanism by which acupuncture might work, but those studies are flawed and inconclusive. They contradict each other instead of building on each other to develop a coherent body of evidence. Acupuncture has been shown to cause release of endorphins, but the same thing happens when you give patients a placebo sugar pill or when you throw a stick for a dog to fetch. There is no evidence that any effects of acupuncture are specific to acupoints, so it is premature to look for a mechanism to explain acupoints.
Edzard Ernst was the world’s first professor of complementary medicine. A former user of many kinds of alternative medicine, he set out to test which ones really worked. In Trick or Treatment: The Undeniable Facts about Alternative Medicine, the book he co-authored with Simon Singh, they concluded: “While there is tentative evidence that acupuncture might be effective for some forms of pain relief and nausea, it fails to deliver any medical benefit in any other situations and its underlying concepts are meaningless.” [emphasis added]
The FP Essentials authors cherry-picked studies showing that acupuncture is effective; they omitted other studies showing that it isn’t. When the results of studies conflict, the next step is to do a systematic review. In the case of acupuncture, the systematic reviews also conflicted. So Edzard Ernst and two Chinese colleagues did what was obviously the next step: a systematic review of systematic reviews of acupuncture for pain. They found that there were only four conditions for which more than one systematic review agreed: in three cases they agreed that acupuncture didn’t work; in the fourth, they agreed that it worked for neck pain. I ask you: if studies of a pain pill gave similarly heterogeneous results and indicated that it worked for pain in the neck but not for pain anywhere else in the body, would you choose to take that pill for pain, or would you suspect that something might have gone wrong with the positive studies?
When the Medical Letter reviewed acupuncture in 2006, they concluded:
Acupuncture alone has not been shown in rigorous, duplicated studies to benefit any defined medical condition.
The Center for Inquiry issued a policy statement on acupuncture in 2010. It said,
It is becoming increasingly clear that the placebo effect accounts for much of the optimistic research on acupuncture published between the 1970s and 1990s. With the development of sham needles during the past decade – needles which retract like stage knives [Streitberger needles] – researchers have since been able to more accurately assess the therapeutic effects of acupuncture. The result has been a complete unraveling of nearly all acupuncture claims…The bulk of recent research strongly tends towards the hypothesis that acupuncture’s positive effects are mainly due to a built-in expectation…
In June 2013, David Colquhoun and Steven Novella reviewed the history and the evidence for acupuncture for the treatment of pain in the journal Anesthesia and Analgesia. After thousands of trials and hundreds of systematic reviews, the evidence remains controversial, weak and unconvincing. All the evidence is consistent with exactly what one would expect to find if an elaborate placebo were tested. They concluded:
that the benefits of acupuncture are likely nonexistent, or at best are too small and too transient to be of any clinical significance. It seems that acupuncture is little or no more than a theatrical placebo.
Chiropractic
The authors said that weak evidence supports manipulation alone to relieve chronic neck pain. It is “weak” indeed! A Cochrane review showed that manipulation was no more effective than gentle mobilization, and that neither was effective alone, but only in combination with exercise. Any discussion of neck manipulation should include a warning that neck manipulation can result in a rare but deadly complication: stroke. These authors didn’t mention that.
Touch therapy
The authors describe touch therapy (including healing touch, therapeutic touch, noncontact therapeutic touch, and Reiki) as “a type of energy treatment in which practitioners place their hands on or above patients to manipulate their energy.” What energy? The only reference they provide is a Cochrane review that has been withdrawn from publication because it is out of date.
Touch therapies claim to manipulate a “human energy field.” Science can measure tiny energies down to the subatomic level, but it has never been able to measure a “human energy field” and we can only conclude that it is a myth and that practitioners who claim they can sense it and manipulate it are only fooling themselves. Studies of energy treatments are what I call Tooth Fairy Science. We can study how much money the Tooth Fairy leaves under the pillow in varying circumstances (family income level, birth order, whether the tooth is placed in a plastic bag or wrapped in tissue) and we can get reproducible data that is statistically significant. We can fool ourselves into thinking we have learned something about the Tooth Fairy, but we haven’t, because there’s no such thing.
The human energy field is no more real than the Tooth Fairy. Emily Rosa did a grade school science fair project to test experienced therapeutic touch practitioners to see if they could really sense the energy field they claimed to feel emanating from Emily’s hand. They could “sense” it reliably as long as they could see her hand, but when their vision was blocked by a screen, their guesses were no better than chance. Emily’s research was eventually published in the Journal of the American Medical Association. It took a child to show that the emperor had no clothes. It is ludicrous to study something before it has been shown to exist: clinical studies of energy medicine are inherently flawed and any positive results can be assumed to be false positives attributable to placebo effects and/or to the pitfalls of experimental design.
SAM-e
For SAMe, the authors cited an article from the NCCAM (now NCCIH) that showed only mixed results for SAM-e in osteoarthritis and said there was insufficient evidence for its use in other pain conditions. It even recommended “do not use SAM-e to replace conventional care.” They also cited a single positive clinical study from 2004, but didn’t mention a later Cochrane review from 2009 that concluded:
The current systematic review is inconclusive, hampered by the inclusion of mainly small trials of questionable quality. The effects of SAMe on both pain and function may be potentially clinically relevant and, although effects are expected to be small, deserve further clinical evaluation in adequately sized randomised, parallel-group trials in patients with knee or hip osteoarthritis. Meanwhile, routine use of SAM-e should not be advised. [emphasis added]
The Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database interprets the evidence as insufficient to establish effectiveness. Instead of rating SAM-e “Effective” for osteoarthritis, it rates it as only “Likely effective.” For fibromyalgia it rates it “Possibly effective.” It didn’t find any evidence to support its use in other pain conditions. There is no justification for recommending SAM-e for treatment of chronic pain in general.
Conclusion: I expected better of the American Academy of Family Physicians
The FP Essentials edition on Chronic Pain Management includes recommendations to treat chronic pain with acupuncture, chiropractic, touch therapy, and SAM-e. Those recommendations are not based on acceptable evidence. It is disappointing to see those alternative treatments misrepresented as evidence-based and recommended right along with conventional treatments that really are based on good quality evidence. I expected better of the AAFP.

AAFP should publish research behind finding that functional medicine lacks evidence, contains harmful and dangerous practices
For the public’s health and safety, the American Academy of Family Physicians should publish their research behind their claims that functional medicine lacks evidence, and contains harmful and dangerous practices.
Jann Bellamy on September 27, 2018
Link


The American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP) has partially lifted its moratorium on continuing education credit (CME) for courses in so-called “functional medicine,” but only to the extent that these courses give family practice doctors sufficient information to educate interested patients about the topic. “How-to” courses teaching various functional medicine techniques, modalities or applications for implementation in treating patients remain under the CME moratorium.
The AAFP’s decision was announced in AAFP News in March and later reprinted in the Annals of Family Medicine. Unfortunately, it is only by accessing these articles that physicians and the general public will learn the history and current rationale behind the AAFP’s decision: Previous literature reviews did not find sufficient evidence to support the use of functional medicine in family practice and “in some cases, determined the claims being made to be potentially dangerous”. Even then, we are not given a complete history of the AAFP’s review and left in the dark regarding what the research revealed or exactly which claims are “potentially dangerous”. Given the lavish claims made for functional medicine by practitioners and the paucity of research, the AAFP, in my opinion, has a duty to protect the public’s health, safety, and welfare by publishing its findings in full.
Speaking to AAFP News about the decision, the chair of the AAFP’s Commission on Continuing Professional Development (COCPD), Melody Jordahl-Iafrato, MD, explained that, following the AAFP’s third review of the evidence on functional medicine,
given the current lack of evidence, the COCPD does not deem it appropriate to learn how to practice functional medicine or implement related techniques within an AAFP-certified CME activity.
However,
The COCPD acknowledged that while sufficient evidence does not exist, patients still may be utilizing or asking about functional medicine; therefore, it’s important for [AAFP] members to be informed on the concept of functional medicine and what patients might be asking about regarding their health care and treatment options.
While, according to the COCPD chair, this may include some examples of techniques,
a session that teaches how to treat a specific disease – such as neurological or gastrointestinal disease – with functional medicine principles would not be eligible.
In a telling comment, Dr. Jordahl-Iafrato added this remark:
The AAFP Credit System strives to certify CME that is evidence-based, objective and balanced, which means benefits have been proven and all possible risks, side effects and negative outcomes should be acknowledged. Ideally, CME includes fair, balanced consideration of all usual and customary approaches and not only the approach preferred by the CME provider.
In other words, courses teaching physicians how to practice functional medicine do not meet these standards.
According to the AAFP News, the first review of functional medicine, in 2014, was in response CME providers getting inconsistent results when they applied for credit for their functional medicine courses. After a literature review, the AAFP made its initial determination that not only was there insufficient evidence to award CME credit, in some cases claims being made for functional medicine were “potentially dangerous”. Actually, according to, of all organizations, the Institute for Functional Medicine (IFM), which “certifies” physicians, naturopaths, acupuncturists and chiropractors as functional medicine practitioners, the AAFP “identified some treatments as harmful and dangerous”. Perhaps the IFM was made aware of this conclusion in the AAFP’s response to its application for CME credit for its courses.
Based on this literature review, the AAFP placed a moratorium on functional medicine courses. A similar evidence review in 2016 came to the same conclusion and the moratorium was extended to 2018. In anticipation of that deadline, last year the AAFP issued a call for comment, including a request for evidence on functional medicine’s efficacy and any additional supporting evidence and/or literature. At the time, I expressed confidence that the AAFP would stick to its guns and continue the moratorium. Unfortunately, I was only partly correct.
Next,
the information received was objectively reviewed and summarized in a report by a third party and presented to the COCPD. That information, along with several literature reviews and results from the AAFP Member Survey, informed the [COCPD’s] decision to lift the moratorium on functional medicine.
That decision was reviewed by the AAFP’s Board of Directors. The end result is a new question under “AAFP Credit System FAQ” – “Are Functional Medical topics eligible for AAFP credit?” The answer simply sets forth the new policy in anodyne terms, approving the overview, but not the “how-to,” courses. While it refers to the literature reviews, it does not mention the lack of evidence, or “potentially dangerous” claims, or “harmful and dangerous” treatments.
Predictably, the IFM lamented that the AAFP’s decision “wasn’t the exact outcome we had hoped for” but was “thrilled to see AAFP take a step forward and recognize the merits of Functional Medicine,” which the AAFP most certainly did not. The IFM explained that,
in an effort to provide a better understanding of how our programs were developed, we supplied AAFP with evidence-based literature and clinical feedback demonstrating the efficacy, safety, and effectiveness of Functional Medicine education for all family physicians. In addition, we asked our physician partners to participate in the “call for comment” process.
Putting it a different way, IFM gave the AAFP its very best effort and still came up short.
Support was not unanimous. Although the comments have not been released, the Michigan Academy of Family Physicians, to its credit, posted its comment calling for a continuation of the moratorium “because there remains much unknown about functional medicine”.
SBM’s evidence review
Fortunately for the public, over the years, SBM has conducted its own evidence review of sorts of functional medicine. As we’ve discussed numerous times, despite patronage from the venerable Cleveland Clinic, whose own genetics experts have called out functional medicine for its dubious use of genetic testing and supplement prescribing, the safety and efficacy of functional medicine, as the AAFP itself determined, has yet to be established. In fact, it’s hard to know exactly what functional medicine is, other than a marketing term, partly because there is no detailed explication of its principles and practices anywhere in the medical literature. For that (if it exists at all), physicians, chiropractors, naturopaths and the like must attend the IFM’s proprietary courses, to the tune of about $15,000, to become “certified” in functional medicine.
Wally Sampson (also here, here, and here), David Gorski, (also here, here, and here), Steve Novella, and Harriet Hall (also here) have all taken a crack at trying to fathom functional medicine and have come away wanting for information, although they were able to gather bits and pieces from, for example, published case studies, which they found less than impressive.
From what little information is available, it appears that functional medicine includes conventional practices like healthy lifestyles, good nutrition, enough exercise, adequate sleep, and cessation of habits known to be deleterious to health, all of which are rebranded “functional medicine,” combined with a whole lot of lab testing – both unvalidated tests and conventional testing that is, in Dr. Gorski’s words, “massively misinterpreted and abused.” From these lab results, said genetic and biochemical “root causes” of disease are divined and “personalized treatment” instituted, which seems to involve a lot of dietary supplements, conveniently sold to the patient by the practitioner, plus assorted other quackery.
Functional Medicine guru Mark Hyman, whose mangling of medical science and anti-vaccination sympathies have been called out before on SBM (also here) and by our good friend Orac (also here and here) is Chair of the Board of IFM. Naturopath Joseph Pizzorno, is on the Board as well. Pizzorno is co-editor of the naturopathic masterwork, The Encyclopedia of Natural Medicine, which Dr. Hall thoroughly shredded in a recent post. Faculty at past IFM presentations include a cell phone radiation alarmist who warned against keeping your cell phone in your bra (debunked here), a dentist who advocates removing amalgam fillings based on mercury fear-mongering, a chiropractor who spoke on “Ensuring a Safe Detox Program: Applying Oral Chelation Therapy to Reduce an [nonexistent] Elevated Heavy Metal Burden with Case Studies,” a naturopath whose clinic offers hyperbaric oxygen therapy and IV therapy delivering “micronutrients and pharmaceuticals” for, among other things, “support for detoxification” and “heavy metal chelation”, and an MD who authored “a guide to mastering one’s genes to reverse disease.” Unfortunately, most of these courses were approved for CME credit by the ACCME, which is decidedly more tolerant of pseudoscience, having not only accredited IFM as a CME provider, but accredited it with commendation.
While I’d like to think SBM’s information on functional medicine is persuasive, and that our posts might be consulted by anyone thinking of becoming a functional medicine practitioner or seeing one as a patient, I am far from sanguine that the science-based medicine community alone can stem the tide of pseudoscience being introduced into medical practice by the purveyors of functional medicine. Given the Cleveland Clinic’s and the ACCME’s complicity, it is of utmost concern that no one from within the medical establishment has come forward to oppose the rosily simplistic deceptions coming from the IFM and the Cleveland Clinic’s Center for Functional Medicine. If the AAFP had similar misgivings about a drug or conventional medical practice, I feel certain they would release their research and warn the public. It is a mystery to me why the AAFP is pulling its punches with functional medicine.
Author’s note: On Monday, I emailed the AAFP ([email protected]) asking for the literature reviews and other information on which they based their CME decision. A quick response simply referred me to the new policy and information on CME standards. I replied that this was not the information I needed, adding that I thought “it incumbent upon the AAFP to release its evidence reviews in the interest of the public health, safety and welfare”. There has been no response to that email.

   AFP Promotes Acupuncture
Harriet Hall 
Link
I subscribe to American Family Physician, the peer-reviewed journal of the American Academy of Family Physicians. It emphasizes evidence-based medicine and most articles include a table showing strength of evidence ratings for key recommendations for practice. Lately, its scientific rigor has been slipping. I have complained to the editor about several articles whose recommendations were not based on the best science, and I have been consistently ignored. 
Acupuncture for Chronic Low Back Pain 
A recent article on chronic low back pain recommended acupuncture and gave it an “A” rating corresponding to “consistent, good-quality patient-oriented evidence.” I wrote the following letter to the editor and to the author of the article: 
In the recent article on chronic low back pain http://www.aafp.org/afp/20090615/1067.html I was very disturbed to see acupuncture listed as beneficial with an evidence rating of “A.” That rating was supported by 4 references:
Reference 2 (Chou et al.), consisted of practice guidelines recommendations that lumped acupuncture with other nonpharmacologic interventions (intensive interdisciplinary rehabilitation, exercise therapy, acupuncture, massage therapy, spinal manipulation, yoga, cognitive-behavioral therapy, or progressive relaxation).” And labeled all of these as a “weak recommendation, moderate-quality evidence.”
Reference 22 (Sherman et al.) addressed current practices but did not comment on the efficacy of acupuncture.
Reference 23 (Furlan et al.) was a Cochrane review showing no evidence that acupuncture is effective for acute low back pain and commenting that the studies indicating its effectiveness in chronic low back pain were of “lower methodologic quality.”
Reference 24 (Witt et al.) only showed that adding acupuncture to routine care improved outcome and was cost-effective: it did not assess the effectiveness of acupuncture as a stand-alone treatment.
In contrast, this recent systematic analysis http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19250001?ordinalpos=7&itool=EntrezSystem2.PEntrez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_DefaultReportPanel.Pubmed_RVDocSum showed that true acupuncture is no more effective than sham acupuncture. Numerous studies with a retractable sham acupuncture needle (like a stage dagger) have shown that the sham procedure is equally effective (and at least in one study the sham procedure was more effective). Even toothpicks seem to work! http://www.time.com/time/health/article/0,8599,1897636,00.html
This study http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19433697?ordinalpos=3&itool=EntrezSystem2.PEntrez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_DefaultReportPanel.Pubmed_RVDocSum showed that it doesn’t matter where you put the needle or whether you penetrate the skin and commented “These findings raise questions about acupuncture’s purported mechanisms of action. It remains unclear whether acupuncture or our simulated method of acupuncture provide physiologically important stimulation or represent placebo or nonspecific effects.”
Acupuncture studies are all less than ideal in that double-blinding is impossible: the acupuncturist always knows whether he is administering a sham treatment.
Some studies have suggested that acupuncture releases endorphins in the brain, but studies also show that placebos elicit endorphin release.
All this evidence is compatible with the hypothesis that acupuncture is nothing more than an elaborate placebo.
If we had similar evidence that an analgesic drug was no better than a sham drug (a sugar pill), you would not be recommending it. How can you justify recommending acupuncture? How can you justify an “A” evidence rating?
I received no response from either the editor or the author. 
Acupuncture for Pain 
The current issue features an article “Acupuncture for Pain” by Robert B. Kelly, a family physician who is associate director of a family medicine residency program and associate professor at Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine. He is also a member of the American Academy of Medical Acupuncture and a diplomate of the American Board of Medical Acupuncture. In the “author disclosures” this was not listed as a conflict of interest, but it should have been. 
The article claims
Based on published evidence, acupuncture is most likely to benefit patients with low back pain, neck pain, chronic idiopathic or tension headache, migraine, and knee osteoarthritis. Promising but less definitive data exist for shoulder pain, fibromyalgia, temporomandibular joint pain and postoperative pain.
It assigns “A” strength of evidence ratings (consistent good-quality patient-oriented evidence) to acupuncture for low back pain, neck pain, headache (chronic idiopathic), and headache (migraine). It assigns “B” ratings (inconsistent or limited quality patient-oriented evidence) to acupuncture for shoulder pain, knee osteoarthritis, fibromyalgia, temporomandibular joint pain, and postoperative pain. Note the inconsistency: knee osteoarthritis is listed among the conditions “most likely to benefit” but then is given only a “B” rating. 
It presents a biased picture of the published research. For chronic low back pain, it cites these studies: 
    • A systematic review of RCTs that found “There is moderate evidence that acupuncture is more effective than no treatment, and strong evidence of no significant difference between acupuncture and sham acupuncture, for short-term pain relief.” In other words, acupuncture is no better than placebo, and using a placebo is better than doing nothing.
    • A randomized controlled trial showing that acupuncture was better than no treatment, but that the control (superficial needling at non-acupuncture points) was equally effective. In other words, acupuncture was no better than their placebo control.
    • A randomized controlled trial that concluded “Effectiveness of acupuncture, either verum or sham, was almost twice that of conventional therapy.” There was no significant difference between “verum” acupuncture and the sham (placebo).
    • A pragmatic randomized trial that compared usual care to acupuncture. There was no attempt to control for possible placebo effects with a sham acupuncture control.
    • A pragmatic randomized trial that compared routine care with or without acupuncture. There was no attempt to control for possible placebo effects.
    • A Cochrane review that concluded “The data do not allow firm conclusions about the effectiveness of acupuncture for acute low-back pain. For chronic low-back pain, acupuncture is more effective for pain relief and functional improvement than no treatment or sham treatment immediately after treatment and in the short-term only. Acupuncture is not more effective than other conventional and “alternative” treatments. The data suggest that acupuncture and dry-needling may be useful adjuncts to other therapies for chronic low-back pain. Because most of the studies were of lower methodological quality, there certainly is a further need for higher quality trials in this area.”
    • A meta-analysis that concluded “Acupuncture effectively relieves chronic low back pain. No evidence suggests that acupuncture is more effective than other active therapies.” 
It does not cite these studies: 
    • A systematic review of RCTs that concluded “There is moderate evidence that acupuncture is more effective than no treatment, and strong evidence of no significant difference between acupuncture and sham acupuncture, for short-term pain relief.” No significant difference between acupuncture and sham acupuncture means acupuncture is not better than placebo.
    • A Cochrane review that concluded “The evidence summarised in this systematic review does not indicate that acupuncture is effective for the treatment of back pain.”
    • A systematic review of RCTs that concluded: “Because this systematic review did not clearly indicate that acupuncture is effective in the management of back pain, the authors would not recommend acupuncture as a regular treatment for patients with low back pain.” 
It does not cite the other studies I cited in my letter showing that acupuncture is no better than placebo and that it makes no difference where you put the needle or even whether you use a needle (toothpicks and retractable needles are equally effective). 
Other Kinds of Pain 
Kelly says “A systematic review on temporomandibular joint (TMJ) pain concluded that acupuncture significantly improved symptoms.” 
That’s not exactly what the review said. Its conclusion was: 
Overall, their results suggest that acupuncture might be an effective therapy for temporomandibular joint dysfunction. However, none of the studies was designed to control for a placebo effect. CONCLUSION: Even though all studies are in accordance with the notion that acupuncture is effective for temporomandibular joint dysfunction, this hypothesis requires confirmation through more rigorous investigations. [emphasis added] 
He also discusses the use of acupuncture for other painful conditions including neck and shoulder pain, headache, and arthritis. The evidence he cites is similarly unconvincing for those conditions. 
Excuses 
Kelly offers excuses and special pleading in an attempt to validate his recommendations. He suggests that “Western scientific methods” like RCTs do not lend themselves to the study of individualized treatment based on such things as pulse diagnosis, tongue diagnosis, herbal therapies, dietary modifications, ear, hand, or scalp acupuncture in addition to or instead of body acupuncture. He admits that there is no statistical difference between sham and actual acupuncture, but he doesn’t acknowledge the implications of that fact. 
Acupuncturists believe in what they are doing. Personal experience, patient gratitude, the natural course of illness, the placebo response and other factors conspire to impair judgment. This makes it difficult for them to be as objective as an outside observer.
This is a clear case of denial. To see why, substitute “drug” for acupuncture and “sugar pill” for sham acupuncture. When a controlled study shows that your treatment works no better than your placebo control, the only logical conclusion is that the treatment is no better than placebo. Imagine a drug company saying “Our drug works and the placebo works too.” Neither the drug nor the placebo would get past the FDA. 
There is only one science. The same standards apply to acupuncture as to drug therapies. A placebo by any other name is still a placebo. 
It is sad to see a journal I respected depart from rigorous science-based medicine and succumb to the CAM temptation, especially when it tries to justify its defection by misrepresenting the state of the evidence. It has been said that there is no such thing as alternative medicine: there is only medicine that works and medicine that doesn’t. When a treatment is shown to work, it is adopted by mainstream medicine and is no longer “alternative.” Acupuncture remains “alternative,” and even AFP recognizes that fact by listing this article as one in a series on “Alternative and Complementary Medicine.”

AAFP Promotes Acupuncture
The AAFP is not following its own standards for CME. Its monograph on Musculoskeletal Therapies devotes 1/4 of its content to acupuncture, dry needling, and cupping; and one of its four “key practice recommendations” is to consider electroacupuncture for fibromyalgia.
Harriet Hall on October 9, 2018
Link

Jann Bellamy recently wrote about the American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP) and their policy on approved content for continuing medical education (CME) activities. The AAFP said, “given the current lack of evidence, the COCPD does not deem it appropriate to learn how to practice functional medicine or implement related techniques within an AAFP-certified CME activity.”
Moreover, they said:
The AAFP Credit System strives to certify CME that is evidence-based, objective and balanced, which means benefits have been proven and all possible risks, side effects and negative outcomes should be acknowledged. Ideally, CME includes fair, balanced consideration of all usual and customary approaches and not only the approach preferred by the CME provider.
Not practicing what it preaches
The AAFP speaks with forked tongue. Their own CME program is far from fair and balanced. It promotes acupuncture, dry needling, cupping, and referral to alternative practitioners.
For many years, the AAFP has offered a CME program called FP Essentials, for which they award 60 CME credits a year. Every month, they publish a monograph on a topic important to family physicians. I have subscribed for as long as I can remember, and I thought I could rely on it to keep me up-to-date with evidence-based information. I can no longer trust it. In their recent monograph on Musculoskeletal Therapies, there is a whole section (constituting a whopping 1/4 of the material presented) devoted to acupuncture, dry needling, and cupping! One-fourth of what they think family physicians should know about treating musculoskeletal conditions is non-evidence-based alternative medicine. This is not acceptable.
Their concept of evidence-based medicine is exactly the kind of thing that led us to establish the Science-Based Medicine blog. They are willing to accept any published studies at face value without considering prior plausibility and without recognizing the factors that so often lead to false conclusions in alternative medicine research.
Acupuncture
They recommend acupuncture as first-line therapy for chronic back pain. They say there is evidence that it may benefit neck pain, lateral elbow pain, peripheral joint osteoarthritis, shoulder pain, and fibromyalgia. They say, “acupuncture consistently has been shown to be more effective than no treatment.” They seem not to understand that doing anything will appear more effective than no treatment, and that studies comparing acupuncture to no treatment are useless.
A truly fair, balanced consideration of all the evidence on acupuncture led David Colquhoun and Steven Novella to conclude that acupuncture is a theatrical placebo. What’s more, its effect on pain is questionable. Edzard Ernst et al. did a systematic review of systematic reviews of acupuncture for pain. They found 57 systematic reviews; the results were a mix of negative, positive, and inconclusive results. There were only four conditions for which more than one systematic review reached the same conclusions, and in only one of the four did they agree on a positive conclusion (neck pain). (Think about this: If acupuncture worked well for pain, wouldn’t the results be more consistent, and wouldn’t it work for pain in all parts of the body rather than just in the neck?) They explained how inconsistencies, biases, conflicting conclusions, and recent high quality studies throw doubt on even the most positive reviews.
They also demolished the “acupuncture is harmless” myth by reporting 95 published cases of serious adverse effects including infection, pneumothorax, and five deaths. Admittedly some but not all of these might have been avoided by better training in anatomy and infection control.
The AAFP monograph provides many references to acupuncture studies, but it is apparent that they are cherry-picking. Colquhoun and Novella’s articles and Edzard Ernst’s review of reviews are conspicuously absent.
Assuming acupuncture works and trying to explain how it works
The AAFP monograph describes several hypothetical mechanisms of action. It says it was originally believed to work by manipulating the life force “qi” at acupuncture points along meridians. It doesn’t question that explanation. It doesn’t point out that qi, acupoints and meridians are mythical concepts from a prescientific era. It says there is some evidence that acupoints have a discrete histologic architecture with a corresponding high electrical conductivity capacity. It also mentions the gate theory of pain, endogenous endorphin release (Note: this also occurs with placebos, and they acknowledge that it is an unsatisfactory explanation because the pain relief lasts longer than the endorphin half-life), and the connective tissue theory. It says, “The connective tissue theory uses the ancient concept of meridians” – with no comment about the validity of that concept. It claims that the neurotransmitter theory may explain the effects of acupuncture on conditions such as depression, anxiety, and substance abuse. (What effects? Systematic reviews are negative.) It mentions that “placebo effects also may be involved”, but It doesn’t acknowledge that placebo could be the sole mechanism and that all the published evidence is compatible with the hypothesis that acupuncture is a theatrical placebo.
Describing the published evidence
It describes the published evidence for acupuncture for low back pain, neck pain, lateral elbow pain, peripheral joint osteoarthritis, shoulder pain, and fibromyalgia. It admits that most of the trials it cites are low quality, insufficient evidence, inconclusive, sometimes negative, or not clinically significant. One wonders why it bothered to cite them.
It doesn’t differentiate between studies of traditional acupuncture and variants like electroacupuncture and ear acupuncture. It does mention that the fibromyalgia study was for electroacupuncture, and it concluded, “Thus, electroacupuncture should be considered for patients with fibromyalgia.” In fact, that recommendation is one of the four Key Practice Recommendations listed at the beginning of the monograph.
Dry needling
After covering acupuncture, the monograph goes on to discuss dry needling. Mark Crislip reviewed dry needling for us a couple of years ago. He stressed that it had nothing to do with acupuncture. He was not impressed by the published evidence; in fact, one of the systematic reviews he found showed that the placebo was more effective than the dry needling! The monograph chose to cite another, more positive review showing that dry needling was more effective than no treatment but not more effective than traditional management, with risk of bias and little evidence of long-term benefit. They call this “low- to moderate-quality evidence”. Whaaat?
Cupping
The monograph says cupping produces hematomas (in other words, it deliberately injures the skin) and carries a risk of infection. Cupping is theorized to “increase circulation to resolve stagnant blood and lymph, which is thought to be a source of pathology”. (A source my pathology course in medical school failed to mention.) It describes the literature as “conflicting in terms of evidence of efficacy”. It acknowledges that good research is difficult due to the variety of practices and the impossibility of blinding. Since there is a lack of good evidence, why does it devote six paragraphs to cupping in a monograph about all musculoskeletal therapies? It could have just explained what cupping is and said there is no good evidence; two sentences would have been sufficient.
Issues to consider
Under this heading, it comments that patients who expect these “integrative” practices to work will report benefit even with sham procedures. It wonders whether skeptics will respond. It compares rates of acceptance by various groups (women, people of Asian descent, etc.) and reports the reasons patients give for choosing acupuncture: “The holistic and collaborative nature of treatment”. It mentions that acupuncture sessions can cost up to $200 and that insurance may not pay.
Referral guidelines
It provides guidelines for referring patients for integrative and alternative medicine therapies. It starts by saying there doesn’t appear to be increased liability for doctors to refer patients for these services. Think about that. Can you imagine commenting on liability in a discussion about referral to an orthopedic surgeon or other reputable practitioner? It says the referring doctor should ensure that the integrative practitioner is trained, licensed, and has malpractice insurance (!). Referral documents should include diagnosis, previous and ongoing treatments, and goals of therapy. The alternative treatment should have a favorable risk to benefit ratio compared to other treatments for the same conditions. It should be based on a reasonable expectation of favorable outcome and be based on the expectation that it will offer greater benefits than no treatment (but as I pointed out, any treatment will offer greater placebo benefits than no treatment). The thought process leading to the referral should be documented in the medical record, and the referring physician is required to monitor the results of treatment.
It describes how the physician can get training in these modalities. “Using the learned skill set will depend on the clinician’s practice environment.”
Conclusion: A betrayal
In response to Jann Bellamy’s article, one of our commenters said, “There are plenty of CAM methods that are safe, while also having enough supporters to have tentative credibility with the public. The public mostly doesn’t care too much about the science.” I’m sure this is true, but the AAFP should care about the science. And the AAFP’s members should care whether the AAFP maintains its reputation as a reliable source of the best science-based medical information.
Another commenter said, “Sugar pills and saline injections have also been consistently shown to be more effective than no treatment. Should we bring those back too?”
There is an obvious disconnect between what the AAFP says are its standards for CME and the CME it actually offers. I feel angry and betrayed by my own professional organization, an organization that I was once proud to belong to.

American Academy of Family Physicians Supports Integrative Medicine
The American Academy of Family Physicians supports integrative medicine and makes recommendations based on less-than-rigorous evidence.
Harriet Hall o nJuly 20, 2021
Link


I thought I could trust the American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP) to recommend the best medicine available. My family practice residency followed their philosophy. By learning what the AAFP taught I was able to pass the board certification exam with flying colors. Their flagship journal American Family Physician rates its recommendations by strength of evidence.
As I learned about alternative medicine, the many pitfalls of evidence-based medicine, and the need for science-based medicine, I began to suspect the AAFP of a less-than-rigorous approach. On several occasions, I wrote letters to the editor of American Family Physician, but they were not receptive to my arguments.
My heart sank when the AAFP’s continuing medical education program FP Essentials featured a monograph on “Integrative Medicine”! According to Mark Crislip, “If you integrate fantasy with reality, you do not instantiate reality. If you mix cow pie with apple pie, it does not make the cow pie taste better; it makes the apple pie worse.” Readers of SBM will be aware that integrative medicine is a marketing term, not a scientific term. It is designed to allow practitioners to provide treatments that are not supported by science, to facilitate the infiltration of so-called “quackademic” medicine into our hospitals and medical schools.
SORT ratings
The monograph begins with a summary of “Key Practice Recommendations” rated by “Strength of Recommendation Taxonomy (SORT).” Not a single recommendation earned evidence rating A – “based on consistent and good quality patient-oriented evidence”. They were all rated SORT B and C, based on inconsistent or limited-quality evidence, consensus, usual practice, opinion, or case series. I don’t want to know what someone’s opinion is; I want to know what the evidence shows.
Manual therapy
They claim that manipulative therapy “may improve pain and function in the short and moderate term in patients with acute and chronic back pain, neck pain, rotator cuff conditions, and temporomandibular joint disorders”. The research they cite for most of these indications is far from definitive. They say, “manual therapies have been used to manage infantile colic”. Yes, they have been used for colic, but they are not effective. They offer evidence of effectiveness from a Cochrane review, but mention that in studies where parents were blinded, the difference was not significant, suggesting that “benefits may not have been attributable to the therapies”. Simon Singh was famously sued by British chiropractors for saying chiropractors supported bogus treatments, one of which was manipulation for colic. The General Chiropractic Council subsequently issued a report saying “the evidence does not support claims that chiropractic treatment is effective for childhood colic, bed-wetting, ear infections or asthma”. The suit was withdrawn.
The monograph at least acknowledges that neck manipulation carries risks, saying “an estimated 1 in 20,000 neck manipulations result in vertebral artery dissection or aneurysm with potential stroke”. I question whether that is an acceptable risk, considering that study results varied, and considering that neck manipulation is only effective for neck pain when combined with exercise.
Acupuncture
Two of the four authors of the monograph are credentialed medical acupuncturists. Isn’t that a source of bias, if not a conflict of interest? Of course, they are not going to agree with Colquhoun and Novella that acupuncture is a theatrical placebo. They say there is strong evidence supporting the effectiveness of acupuncture for allergic rhinitis, chemotherapy-induced nausea and vomiting, chronic low back pain, headache, knee osteoarthritis, migraine prophylaxis, postoperative nausea and vomiting, and postoperative pain. They say there is moderate evidence supporting the effectiveness of acupuncture for 37 other conditions, including obesity, constipation, dry eye, allergies, female infertility, and asthma. I think most non-acupuncturist providers would disagree that the evidence is strong or moderate. They don’t mention Edzard Ernst’s systematic review of systematic reviews of acupuncture for pain.
They found “evidence” for dry needling, laser acupuncture, acupressure, and auricular acupuncture. They offer mechanisms of action, but these are mostly speculative or based on animal studies. Before trying to explain how something works, it is necessary to prove that it does work.
Pitfalls in evidence
In addition to the sections on manual therapy and acupuncture, the monograph includes sections on herbal supplements and cannabis/cannabis-related drugs. I won’t go into detail on those sections. There is a pattern throughout the monograph of accepting evidence that would not be acceptable in rigorously science-based medicine. One recurring problem is the acceptance of studies that compare an alternative treatment to usual care or no care. That’s a recipe for finding false positive results.
They are very adept at finding studies that support their beliefs, but I wish they were equally adept at searching out disconfirming evidence. I wish they would adopt my “SkepDoc’s rule” – before accepting a claim, try to find out who disagrees with it and try to understand why. I wish they would read the Science-Based-Medicine blog and absorb its lessons.
Not all bad
I’m trying to see the good side of this. Alternative medicine is very popular at present. Patients have heard good things about acupuncture, supplements, etc. They want to try them and want more information. If they are consulting an integrative medicine doctor, that means they are not going to someone who only does alternative medicine. It could be worse. The monograph is very clear about some treatments that have no evidence for efficacy, such as evening primrose for hyperlipidemia. For neck manipulation, they point out the risk of stroke. For herbal remedies, they cover side effects, drug interactions, contaminants, poor regulation, and poor quality control. They do not recommend or even discuss homeopathy, energy medicine, therapeutic touch, drinking urine, reflexology, iridology, or many other totally quacky treatments. An integrative medicine doctor may be able to exercise some control over the number of useless treatments their patients are willing to try. Many of their patients will perceive improvement from useless treatments due to placebo effects. That may be what they want, but shouldn’t it be the duty of the doctor to educate them and give them what they need?
Conclusion: The AAFP’s embrace of integrative medicine is unfortunate, but not unexpected
I can no longer trust them or respect their judgment. It is distressing to learn that my former idols have feet of clay. I respect the right of patients to try anything they want to try, but I can hope they have access to accurate scientific information and can exercise true informed consent. I’m not going to waste any more time complaining to the AAFP, because I’m convinced they are not prepared to listen. But I can hope that by writing about the true state of the evidence on SBM I will be able to reach at least a few people who will be less likely to start down that slippery slope

The American Academy of Pediatrics has an Integrative Medicine Problem
The American Academy of Pediatrics is usually a trustworthy source of high quality information for patients, caregivers, and pediatric medical providers. But when it comes to so-called integrative medicine, they have a massive biased blind spot. In this post, I discuss a recently updated clinical report from their Section on Integrative Medicine.
Clay Jones on October 20, 2017
Link


The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) has an integrative medicine problem. It’s a wonderful organization, don’t get me wrong, and they do a lot of good work advocating for children and their families, and providing evidence-based guidelines for clinical care. In fact, they claim to be “committed to the optimal physical, mental, and social health and well-being for all infants, children, adolescents, and young adults”, and I have never really questioned this goal. But they have a huge biased blind spot when it comes to quackery.
The AAP Section on Integrative Medicine
The AAP, while often speaking as a unified voice, is also subdivided into 52 sections. These sections consist of different groups of members dedicated to one particular aspect of pediatric medicine or another, each with their own internal leadership hierarchy, and they are integral in helping to develop policy and in educating fellow AAP members as well as the public. One of them is the Section on Integrative Medicine (SOIM).
Since at least as far back as the late 1990s, the AAP has shown some interest in alternative therapies, in no small part because of the influence of Kathi Kemper, who refers to herself as “the holistic pediatrician” pretty much every chance she gets. She did essentially write the book on the subject after all. She was the founding chairman of the SOIM in addition to establishing the non-AAP affiliated Council on Bioenergetic Healing, which does not appear to have ever existed except on her CV (at least there is no trace of it online). The AAP evolved along with other proponents/PR departments over the years, officially referring to alternative medicine as “integrative medicine” with the establishment of the SOIM in 2005.
The SOIM then set out to establish an integrative medicine presence in pediatrics, complete with all the standard propaganda we have come to know and love. It encourages members to speak at conferences and gives grants for various endeavors that support the cause. It supports research into integrative medicine. It promotes educational resources for medical schools and residency programs and designs CME activities.
The SOIM strategic plan
In 2013, the AAP SOIM released their strategic plan, which unfortunately is only available to members. As I’ll explain in detail, it’s pretty much just integrative medicine boilerplate that occasionally mentions children. Their mission statement starts out okay, however. I mean, who wouldn’t support “optimal health and well-being for all children and families”? But it quickly goes the expected route, all the while making the assumption that their true mission is reasonable and even necessary:
The mission of the Section on Integrative Medicine (SOIM) is to promote optimal health and well‐being for all children and families through the promotion of high quality research, education and clinical care from the integrative perspective. To accomplish its mission, the section will promote a broad view of health and wellness involving patients, caregivers and providers; educate pediatricians and other pediatric providers on how to integrate evidence‐based, safe and effective integrative therapies into high quality pediatric practice; promote research on principles of integrative medicine; and respectfully collaborate with diverse health professionals dedicated to enhancing the health of infants, children, and adolescents.
High quality research you ask? This will come up again later in the post when I describe what such research looks like according to the SOIM. I’ll just tell you that it rhymes with shmanecdote for now. And what exactly is the integrative perspective? Let’s just say it involves two types of pie.
The rest of the SOIM strategic plan discusses their belief that the philosophy of integrative medicine is somehow different than what I do, for example, because it focuses on providing “high quality and patient-centered care that prioritizes patient and family wellness and planning”. Deep breath Dr. Jones, you’re a professional. They add that only through the addition of complementary therapies can every patient “flourish in the presence or absence of disease or disability”, and that physicians should be capable of competently discussing integrative medicine principles with patients and families. I agree with that last one, but the SOIM might not appreciate my approach.
The SOIM, according to its section on values, wants all medicine to be integrative because they believe it is required for the practice of “good medicine”. They call for all therapies to be judged on a level playing field “regardless of their origin”. They then list “nutrition, movement and exercise, mind-body connection, sleep, growth and spirituality, positive relationships and the physical environment” as being in their armamentarium for “enhancing wellness”. Physical environment? Do they mean earthing?
Their “Goals and Objectives” section spells out a desire to indoctrinate educate pediatric residents with the implementation of standardized core competencies and the inclusion of integrative medicine questions on board examinations. They want to produce more educational opportunities for residents and AAP members, write policy statements for members to follow, link themselves to the NCCAM (now NCCIH), and “promote integrative medicine as a philosophy for caring for children”.
The SOIM Clinical Report
I’ve known about this issue for a long time. As part of SOIM educational outreach, for nearly ten years the AAP has provided “Complementary, Holistic, and Integrative Medicine” CME opportunities in the form of review articles in Pediatrics in Review. These invariably consist of cherry picked studies with weak methodology, biased assumptions, appeals to popularity, and calls for more research to prove what they already know is true, even after pointing out how weak the available data actually is.
But what inspired me to write about this topic today was the September publication in Pediatrics of an updated Pediatric Integrative Medicine Clinical Report from the SOIM, which is meant to guide AAP members in their approach to patient care. It’s pure propaganda with little actual substance and all the typical canards we’ve come to expect. You know something isn’t going to involve much critical thinking when it opens with “The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health defines…”
The AAP, according to a press release announcing the publication, feels differently:
The report aims to raise awareness about this emerging field, improve pediatric preventive health and expand treatment options for children and adolescents living with a wide range of medical conditions.
They then employ a classic bait and switch and some serious question begging:
Children and adolescents face serious health challenges and stressors in today’s society. Integrative medicine seeks to promote a comprehensive approach to healthy nutrition, physical activity, stress management and coping skills, sleep and judicious use of complementary therapies that can help children and their families reduce risk of preventable chronic illness across the lifespan.
As we’ve discussed countless times on the pages of SBM, there is nothing alternative about recommendations on nutrition, exercise, stress management, or sleep. There is no “complementary therapy” that reduces the risk of preventable illness. This is historical revisionism that proponents need pediatricians and the public to buy into because any unique aspects of integrative medicine offer little if any benefit. Pediatricians (and family medicine providers) have been promoting these things for a long time without the help of recommendations from the SOIM.
But that’s just the press release. Unlike the SOIM strategic plan, their clinical report is available for everyone to read so I’ll simply discuss a few highlights that stood out to me. Not all of it is bad, but it adds very little to the discussion in my opinion, serving primarily as an attempt to justify an increasing presence of integrative pediatrics in medical schools, residency programs, and pediatric CME opportunities. Most of it comes across as a regurgitation of NCCIH talking points.
     1.  They define integrative medicine as a combination of complementary and conventional therapies that are “evidence-informed” and patient-centered. This is code for lacking quality evidence and recommended or condoned because it seems to make the patient or their family happy. They say that complementary approaches may also serve as the primary treatment, but that we shouldn’t confuse this with alternative therapies, which are not evidence-based and not discussed in the report. Despite this, they do discuss herbal remedies, acupuncture, chiropractic, and biofield therapies, among many others, often implying benefit or the promise of future benefit once better studies are performed.
     2.  They devote several paragraphs to the popularity of integrative medicine in pediatric populations, particularly children with chronic diseases, and claim that this justifies a need for more pediatric integrative medicine training programs. This is almost immediately followed up with the actual data showing that pediatric use has been stagnant based on NHIS data. They mention that the bulk of CAM use in pediatrics consists of things like supplements, exercise in the form of yoga, and chiropractic manipulation. Only the latter has any business being considered CAM. They also strongly imply that the use of CAM by children, again particularly by kids with chronic illness, is so common because of how helpful it is.
     3.  They really want education/training in integrative medicine to be in all medical schools and pediatric residency programs, and they remind us that there is an actual board certification in integrative medicine through the American Board of Physician Specialties. They do not comment on the fact that the American Board of Pediatrics gives no such certification. 16 of 143 pediatric programs as of 2012 do offer integrative medicine training, however, so it’s likely going to come at some point.
     4.  They claim that CAM research is as good as research into conventional medicine. Better even in the case of systematic reviews. According to the authors, publication bias is actually reversed with CAM, meaning that negative studies are more likely to be published in the better journals than positive studies. But, they add, because CAM can be ancient and challenging to study, “experiential evidence” and N-of-1 trials are “particularly useful”. So which is it?
     5.  They are attempting to integrate a wide variety of CAM therapies into conventional medicine, and to make fundamental changes to the philosophy of patient care, yet they admit that the evidence stinks. The authors reveal that “to be comprehensive, high-quality data about both safety and effectiveness are needed…to inform policy and practice.”
     6.  They mention the role of placebo effects almost in passing, essentially to plant the seed that it’s real, and it’s spectacular. You know, just in case you have any reservations about biofield therapies.
     7.  They discuss DSHEA in detail but in such a way as to imply it’s doing a pretty good job.
     8.  They discuss the ethics involved when a patient/family chooses CAM, and I actually agree in principle although I bet the authors and I would likely disagree in many specific cases. Providers should always assess the potential risks and benefits of any intervention. If there is significant risk without benefit, it would be appropriate to discourage the treatment. If it is determined to be effective and safe, we should obviously recommend it. Safe but ineffective, it would be reasonable to condone the approach. But if there is risk and only potential benefit, either monitoring the patient closely or discouraging the intervention could be the way to go. Easy, right?
     9.  They actually provide almost no helpful information regarding specific interventions, mentioning only a handful by name, most of which aren’t CAM. Fish oil for ADHD isn’t CAM, nor is it very effective. Melatonin for sleep has similar issues. Probiotics are also fairly weak sauce. Herbal remedies are just dirty drugs, not CAM. Dietary interventions also are unfairly lumped into this report.
     10.  They actually comment on the anti-vaccine tendencies of chiropractors who treat infants and children, and mention the lack of evidence supporting chiropractic for non-musculoskeletal complaints – but they stop short of saying outright that parents shouldn’t bring their baby to a chiropractor.
     11.  They frequently mention how evidence of benefit for various therapies, such as acupuncture, is accruing or promising. Again, why are they calling for a fundamental shift in pediatric care prior to figuring out if these interventions actually work for anything?
     12.  My final observation is again one that I agree with. Pediatricians in general don’t know much about CAM or integrative medicine. And what they do know is very likely wrong because it is based on information they get from resources such the SOIM. We don’t know about them and often we don’t ask about them. And patients and their families are often reluctant to share what unconventional therapies they are using with us. This can result in harm to patients.
Conclusion: Take the integrative out of the medicine
Yes, the AAP has an integrative medicine problem and, unfortunately, it only appears to be getting worse. For the time being, at least, it is sectioned off and we aren’t seeing recommendations for quackery being incorporated into general policy. There is nothing at all about this in the AAP five-year strategic plan, for instance. I still consider the majority of AAP resources to contain high quality information, but this report, and the existence of the SOIM, grants undeserved legitimacy to integrative medicine as a concept and to the individual CAM therapies that it is attempting to incorporate into pediatric medical practice.
(Here is a AAP endorsed lecture that Kathi Kemper gives. It provides a paper thin overview of the history of integrative pediatrics and includes a great deal of propaganda. In particular, she focuses on how popular these interventions are, then smoothly transitions into how to increase the presence of integrative medicine in pediatric training and medical care. We are apparently left to assume that there is solid evidence in support of this.
My favorite is the section on “Threats to Integrative Pediatric Care”, which includes “Misinformation on internet and media; negative press about CAM”. Here is another one, where she implies that critics of integrative medicine are equivalent to the KKK waving around a Confederate flag. Seriously. It’s in there.)

Update on CPSOs Draft Policy
Steven Novella on November 30, 2011
Link
Four months ago David Gorski wrote about the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario’s (CPSO) draft policy on “non-allopathic” medicine. He pointed out:
It’s obvious from the wishy-washy approach to the scientific basis of medicine, the waffle words when it comes to whether an “allopathic” physician should support “non-allopathic” therapies, and the apparently inadvertent use of language favored by quacks that there were far too many “alternative” practitioners involved in drafting this policy.
I agree. The proposed policy addresses the issue of so-called complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) and has drawn serious criticism from Canadian physicians (at least those who are paying attention and have the slightest clue about what is going on). The backlash is good to see, but it is not nearly vigorous enough.
There is now an update to this story as the CPSO has published a revised policy proposal. There are some improvements, based on the criticism, but still there are problems with the policy.
The original proposed policy contained several recommendations that are right in line with CAM proponents – who keep trying to achieve through legislation and intimidation what they cannot achieve through science and evidence, namely acceptance and access. The proposed policy is a good example of this, as well as demonstrating how CAM proponents wish to carve out a double standard for themselves, so that they can be free to practice whatever nonsense they wish without being held to all that pesky science and evidence.
The very category of CAM is a contrived marketing strategy, not a genuine discipline. The truth is that there is science-based medicine and there is everything else. All therapies and modalities lie someone along the spectrum of safety and efficacy, and are backed by various amounts of evidence, and may even have evidence for lack of efficacy.
That is all that matters – but when one common sense and science-based standard is applied, almost all of CAM collapses and crumbles to dust. That’s why it’s CAM – if it worked it would just be medicine. So CAM proponents have desperately tried to make the debate about anything else: healthcare freedom, conspiracies, Big Pharma, protectionism or elitism, they cry that they are being treated unfairly, or that science doesn’t work – that they need a new kind of science. It’s all an elaborate game of, “ignore that man behind the curtain.” It has been distressingly effective, as the CPSO proposal indicates.
The parts of the proposed policy that have caused the most concern are those that encourage physicians to work with “alternative” practitioners, granting CAM practitioners a status they have not earned and do not deserve. The Canadian Medical Association has responded, criticizing this aspect of the proposed policy. They state:
“It is a matter of concern for us, that CPSO’s draft policy appears to require of physicians a high level of knowledge regarding [alternative medicine], and a high level of acceptance for its routine incorporation into practice,” the CMA said.
I don’t think it’s a bad thing for physicians to have greater knowledge of CAM, the better to inform their patients about it properly. But physicians should not be encouraged to incorporate unscientific practices, or refer to those who do. This is definitely a step toward requiring physicians to practice CAM or refer to those who do, as I wrote about recently.
Perhaps the most disturbing part of the original proposed policy is this statement:
The College expects physicians to respect patients’ treatment goals and decisions, even those which physicians deem to be unfounded or unwise. In doing so, physicians should state their best professional opinion about the goal or decision, but must refrain from expressing non-clinical judgements.
This is a thinly-veiled attempt to silence criticism – to silence any doctor who has the sense to understand that it is their duty to protect their patience from unsafe or ineffective treatments. CAM proponents are as clever as creationists in couching their true goals in language that seems inoffensive, but the goal is obvious to anyone who has been paying attention.
Then there is this:
In its original form, it said doctors should respect patients’ wishes to try non-conventional care and require “sound evidence,” but not necessarily clinical trials, to back up any alternative treatments they use.
Here we have the double-standard. They want different standards of evidence for CAM than for conventional medicine – a lower standard, one that allows treatments that are unscientific and not backed by sufficient evidence to be accepted by science-based practitioners.
The revised draft policy has some positive changes:
The new iteration of the Ontario draft suggests everything a doctor does should be informed by “evidence and science.” It removes a suggestion the type of evidence required to justify a therapy depends on the nature of the treatment. It also removes a statement that seemed to allow doctors to employ therapies whose effectiveness and safety are unknown, so long as they act “in a cautious and ethical manner.”
The original proposed policy makes the agenda of CAM proponents clear. They want to create a double standard, with a lower bar of evidence for their preferred practices. They want to silence critics. They want doctors who may be skeptical of CAM practices to just shut up and refer their patients to CAM practitioners. They want to pressure physicians with accusations that they are being unfair, when in fact it is the CAM proponents who are being unfair.
At the end of his original report on this issue David offered his recommended policy with regard to CAM. Here it is, with my tweaks:
    • Medicine should be science- and evidence-based. “Alternative” vs “evidence-based,” “allopathic” vs “non-allopathic,” “conventional” vs “unconventional, ” “Western” vs “Eastern” are all false dichotomies and should not be recognized as legitimate categories. All healthcare interventions should be evaluated, regulated, and practiced according to one science-based and ethics-based standard of care.
    • Competent adults have every right to seek out non-science-based medicine if that is what they desire. However, informed consent mandates that physicians who encounter such patients provide an honest professional assessment of such treatments based on science. Physicians should sufficiently familiarize themselves with unscientific yet popular healthcare products and practices so that they can properly inform their patients.
    • Physicians should always inquire about the use of non-science-based medicine when evaluating their patients, so that they can take into account possible interactions with medical treatments.
    • Physicians are in no way obligated to refer patients to “alternative medical” practitioners or to recommend non science-based options. For many forms of “alternative medicine” doing so is unethical because such modalities are not science- or evidence-based.
    • Physicians, individually and as a profession, should actively advocate for and promote the science-based standard in medicine – in academia, regulation, and practice.

The World Health Organization promotes quackery yet again
The World Health Organization held the First WHO Traditional Medicine Global Summit this weekend. Unfortunately, its claims of being “evidence-based” aside, the conference followed the WHO’s usual pattern of serving as propaganda, not science. The summit was one-sided, organized by believers with the only speakers being believers, to promote a predetermined policy goal of promoting traditional medicine and justify “integrating” it with science-based medicine.
David Gorski on August 21, 2023
Link

The World Health Organization concluded its First WHO Traditional Medicine Global Summit on Friday. The conference was co-hosted by the Indian government and held in Gandhinagar, India, where the WHO had set up a Global Centre for Traditional Medicine, with help from $250 million from the Indian government. Unfortunately, as we have long lamented, the WHO has long had a penchant for promoting “traditional medicine,” particularly Traditional Chinese Medicine but also Ayurveda and others, as “evidence-based” and worthy of being “integrated” with science-based medicine, and this conference is just one more example of how far down that road the WHO has gone. To get an idea of how this meeting is being described and promoted by its stakeholders, I refer you to a statement by the Indian government released on August 17, the first day of the summit:
WHO’s first ever Global Summit on Traditional Medicine inaugurated as part of the G20 Health Minister’s Meeting in Gandhinagar, Gujarat.
By embracing ancient wisdom and modern science, we can collectively work towards achieving the health-related Sustainable Development Goals while fostering a ‘One Earth, One Family, One Future’ ethos: Dr. Mansukh Mandaviya.
“In modern times, the demand for natural and herbal-based pharmaceuticals and cosmetics underscores the enduring significance of traditional healing practices.”
“WHO’s Global Centre for Traditional Medicine headquartered in Jamnagar, Gujarat, accelerates advancements in Traditional Medicine globally.”
Traditional Medicine can play a huge role in honouring cultural diversity, empowering communities, and celebrating our shared heritage: Shri Sarbanand Sonowal.
I hope that the Gujarat Declaration, will integrate use of traditional medicines in national health systems, and help unlock the power of traditional medicine through science: Dr. Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, WHO Director-General.
But what does the WHO itself say? Its statement announcing the summit listed the usual examples of medicines that derive from natural products used in some traditional medicine systems and touted how “evidence-based” the summit would be, before stating:
In response to this increased global interest and demand, WHO, with the support of the Government of India, established in March 2022 the WHO Global Centre for Traditional Medicine as a knowledge hub with a mission to catalyse ancient wisdom and modern science for the health and well-being of people and the planet. The WHO Traditional Medicine Centre scales up WHO’s existing capacity in traditional medicine and supplements the core WHO functions of governance, norms and country support carried out across the six regional Offices and Headquarters.
The Centre focuses on partnership, evidence, data, biodiversity and innovation to optimize the contribution of traditional medicine to global health, universal health coverage, and sustainable development, and is also guided by respect for local heritages, resources and rights.
Elsewhere, the WHO writes about its summit:
“Traditional medicine can play an important and catalytic role in achieving the goal of universal health coverage and meeting global health-related targets that were off-track even before the disruption caused by the COVID-19 pandemic,” said Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, WHO Director-General. “Bringing traditional medicine into the mainstream of health care — appropriately, effectively, and above all, safely based on the latest scientific evidence — can help bridge access gaps for millions of people around the world. It would be an important step toward people-centered and holistic approaches to health and well-being.”
Does this language sound familiar, particularly the parts about “ancient wisdom”? It is the language used by “integrative medicine” advocates to justify the “integration” of quackery with science-based medicine. Indeed, I immediately harkened back to an article I wrote for this blog nearly a decade ago about how Chairman Mao and his Communist government undertook a very systematic and intentional effort to retcon the history of Traditional Chinese Medicine. I’ll just drop a couple of quotes that I cited in that post for your edification:
“This One Medicine,” exulted the president of the Chinese Medical Association in 1952, “will possess a basis in modern natural sciences, will have absorbed the ancient and the new, the Chinese and the foreign, all medical achievements—and will be China’s New Medicine!”
Sound familiar? “This One Medicine” is about as simple a statement of what “integrative medicine” intends as I’ve ever encountered, and this one is 71 years old. Indeed, the WHO’s rationale that using “traditional medicine” to “bridge access gaps” is exactly the same as one major rationale that Chairman Mao used to promote traditional Chinese medicine. When he took power in the late 1940s, China did not have enough “Western”-trained doctors, leading to the idea of recruiting “traditional healers” (“barefoot doctors”), giving them some basic training in hygiene and more modern medical practices, and sending them to fill in the massive gaps in China’s healthcare system then.
I’ll cite another quote from Alan Levinovitz, whose writings in part inspired my 2014 article, in which he described how Chairman Mao understood that he needed to address the objections of proponents of scientific medicine:
His [Mao’s] solution was a two-pronged approach. First, inconsistent texts and idiosyncratic practices had to be standardized. Textbooks were written that portrayed Chinese medicine as a theoretical and practical whole, and they were taught in newly founded academies of so-called “traditional Chinese medicine,” a term that first appeared in English, not Chinese. Needless to say, the academies were anything but traditional, striving valiantly to “scientify” the teachings of classics that often contradicted one another and themselves. Terms such as “holism” (zhengtiguan) and “preventative care” (yufangxing) were used to provide the new system with appealing foundational principles, principles that are now standard fare in arguments about the benefits of alternative medicine.
I like to say that there is nothing new under the sun when it comes to antivaccine narratives, but it turns out that this principle also applies to narratives used to promote “ancient wisdom” as co-equal with science-based medicine. In essence, the WHO has been engaged in an effort to “scientify” (which I define as the effort to make practices based in prescientific mysticism and pseudoscience appear scientific) all of “traditional medicine,” as Mao tried (and, unfortunately, largely succeeded) to scientify TCM in the 1950s and as the Chinese government continues to do to this day. It’s an effort that has manifest itself in the WHO’s addition of “traditional medicine” diagnoses to the all-important ICD-11, the successor to the currently used ICD-10, a standardized system of alphanumeric codes for diagnoses maintained by the World Health Organization used throughout the world for billing, epidemiology, research, and cataloging causes of death. (Steve Novella described it as the WHO “endorsing quackery,” and he was correct.)
So let’s take a look at this conference. The entire proceedings can be found on video here.
The WHO’s promotion of traditional medicine vs. reality
Several days before the event, I noticed that the WHO had started promoting its summit on X, the social media platform formerly known as Twitter. I’m going to quote some of these Tweets because they reveal some very important things. Here’s the first part of the WHO’s promotion:
In 1969, Tu Youyou was tasked to search for antimalarial drugs. She turned to ancient Chinese #TraditionalMedicine books & discovered artemisinin. In 2015, Tu Youyou was awarded the Nobel Prize for her work on #malaria, which has saved millions of lives.https://t.co/TrcGF8rdeL pic.twitter.com/hqqn1D2idW
— World Health Organization (WHO) (@WHO) August 10, 2023
These are common rationales used by proponents of “traditional medicine,” namely that the existence of medicines derived from plants and other natural products, some of which were used in traditional medicine practices, validates the whole of traditional medicine. Of course, we’ve already discussed the example of Tu Youyou and why her winning the Nobel Prize for the discovery of artemisinin as an effective treatment for malaria does not somehow validate traditional Chinese medicine. Rather, it represented the triumph of natural products pharmacology, not herbalism or Traditional Chinese medicine. As Scott Gavura put it, alone “artemisinin isn’t effective as a treatment – it is eliminated too quickly from the body,” and added that what “finally turned artemisinin into a useful drug and brought this treatment to patients was in fact Big Pharma.”
The WHO continued:
For millions of people around the world #TraditionalMedicine is their first stop for health and well-being.
Which of these have you used?🖐️ Acupuncture🥣Ayurveda🌿Herbal medicine💊 Homeopathy🍃 Naturopathy💆‍♀️ Osteopathy🍵 Traditional Chinese medicine☀️ Unani medicine pic.twitter.com/VY9PUq7TMW
— World Health Organization (WHO) (@WHO) August 12, 2023
Aside from the repetition of Chairman Mao’s rationale for using TCM, I must say that it was definitely news to me that homeopathy, naturopathy, and osteopathy are in any way “traditional medicine.” After all, as longstanding readers of this blog know, homeopathy was “discovered” by a German physician named Samuel Hahnemann in the late 18th century, just 227 years ago, making me wonder if it could even qualify as “traditional” European medicine. Naturopathy, too, is European in origin, which alone doesn’t disqualify it as “traditional.” What does disqualify it as “traditional” is that it is an even more recent development than homeopathy, having arisen from the “natural cure” movement in Europe in the 1800s, and only having been named “naturopathy” in 1895, with the first school of naturopathy founded in 1901. As for osteopathy, it was invented in the US in 1874, founded by Andrew Taylor Still, a 19th-century American physician, Civil War surgeon, and Kansas state and territorial legislator.
As for norethindrone, this is an example that I had never seen advocates point to as validation of traditional medicine before, which is why I did a bit of Googling and PubMed searching. It turns out that this is just another example of the WHO citing a natural product that came to be used as a medicine as if that in itself validated “traditional medicine.” Norethindrone was indeed derived from two species of inedible wile Mexican yams, cabeza de negro (Dioscorea mexicana) and barbasco (D. composita), in the local language, and the use of the drug as birth control came about through nothing more remarkable (or “traditional”) than the application of pharmacognosy, the branch of pharmacology devoted to finding compounds in natural products that have medicinal properties.
The promotion continued:
WHO’s #TraditionalMedicine programme aims to build solid evidence base for policies and standards on traditional medicine practices and products, helping countries integrate it into their health systems & regulate its quality.
Here's how: https://t.co/Mld5hoIabv pic.twitter.com/wzaAXVNAHG
— World Health Organization (WHO) (@WHO) August 14, 2023
This represents yet another example of putting the cart before the horse. Note how the WHO doesn’t say that it will study traditional medicine to see if it works or to identify specific practices that might work. Rather, it assumes that traditional medicine works and promises to work to “build solid evidence base for policies and standards on traditional medicine practices and products, helping countries integrate it into their health systems & regulate its quality.”
Only after days of promotion, which began a week before the summit, does the WHO get around to caveats:
Listen to Dr Susan Wieland explain how to safely use #TraditionalMedicine.
Find out more in our FAQs:📌 https://t.co/BcDKRntETt
🔉 @lswieland pic.twitter.com/IccWYU792J
— World Health Organization (WHO) (@WHO) August 15, 2023
Out of curiosity, I looked at the FAQ referred to above and found more of the WHO putting the cart before the horse, for example:
A remarkable and rapid modernization of the ways traditional medicine is being studied can help realize the potential and promise of traditional medicine and traditional knowledge, for health and well-being. Taking clues from traditional uses, new clinically effective drugs can be identified through research methods such as ethnopharmacology and reverse pharmacology.
The application of new technologies in health and medicine can open new frontiers of knowledge on traditional medicine. Artificial intelligence (AI) has emerged as a game-changer, revolutionizing the study and practice of traditional healing systems. AI’s advanced algorithms and machine learning capabilities can allow researchers to explore extensive traditional medical knowledge, map evidence and identify once elusive trends.
AI…it had to be…AI. Seriously, just as adding AI to homeopathy doesn’t make it any less pseudoscientific (or ridiculous), adding AI to all of traditional medicine will not make it scientific. Notice the assumption, though. The WHO assumes that there is enormous promise in studying traditional medicine and combining it with science-based medicine. This proposition, as lawyers would say, assumes facts not in evidence, and even the WHO’s caveats about traditional medicine are the weakest of weak sauce. For example, I laughed out loud when the WHO asserted, seemingly reasonably, that natural products and traditional medicine practices “must pass the same level of scrutiny as modern pharmaceuticals.” Notice what precedes this statement:
#TraditionalMedicine practices and products must pass the same level of scrutiny as modern pharmaceuticals. 
Over 120 Member States have passed laws or regulations for herbal medicines, enhancing their safety and efficacy.https://t.co/nlTGS1BRYB pic.twitter.com/yIE6ofjah8
— World Health Organization (WHO) (@WHO) August 16, 2023
That’s right. Only right after pure boosterism for traditional medicine by an athlete does the WHO suggest that traditional medicine should be subject to the same scientific standards as science-based medicine. Here’s the problem. It already has been, for the most part, and been found wanting. I like to quote Dara ÓBriain on herbal medicine:
I’m sorry, ‘herbal medicine’, “Oh, herbal medicine’s been around for thousands of years!” Indeed it has, and then we tested it all, and the stuff that worked became ‘medicine’. And the rest of it is just a nice bowl of soup and some potpourri, so knock yourselves out.
Indeed. Or, to paraphrase an adage, “alternative medicine” that has been show through science to be effective and safe ceases to be “alternative” and becomes just “medicine.” In fairness, we “haven’t tested it all,” but it’s pretty unlikely that there’s much left untested that’s hiding any sort of amazing new treatments and cures, no matter how much the WHO wants this to be so or how much into a pretzel it has to twist the definition of “traditional medicine” in order to include other popular forms of alternative medicine, like naturopathy, homeopathy, and osteopathy. Moreover, any sort of medicine that includes homeopathy as potentially “science-based” is anything but science-based. I strongly suspect that the WHO included these European and American forms of quackery as being somehow “traditional medicine” in order to get European and American advocates of quackery on board with its summit.
A one-sided summit
But what about the summit itself? Let’s just say that my perusal and sampling of some of the talks showed it to be entirely consistent with the WHO’s promotion of traditional medicine and gauzy propaganda videos like this one:
Again, this video is propaganda, not reality.
It is not entirely unreasonable to hold a conference to examine traditional medicine practices and treatments in light of modern science. However, that is not what this is about. As Edzard Ernst was quoted saying in an article published in Nature, although he included his full statement (of which the Nature article only used a brief excerpt) on his blog:
The WHO has a long history of uncritically promoting alternative therapies. The Indian government has recently advocated irresponsibly dangerous nonsense, such as the use of homeopathy for the prevention and treatment of covid infections. The two together make an ominous initiative when it comes to alternative medicine.
Of course, there is nothing wrong in hosting a constructive dialogue about this subject. What seem ill-conceived, however, is the fact that the conference exclusively includes speakers who are staunch proponents of alternative medicine, a subject that, after all, remains highly controversial. Progress is not created by voicing one-sided, biased opinions. I fear that this meeting will result in the often before voiced platitudes and wishful thinking which no true scientist is then able to take seriously.
The Nature article only quoted the last sentence of this statement. Ernst, however, has nailed exactly the problem with this summit and pretty much every other conference held on “integrative medicine”: They are organized by believers in alternative medicine and include as speakers only believers, suffused with this “cart before the horse” mentality, for example, inadvertently described in the Nature article:
Lisa Susan Wieland, director of Cochrane Complementary Medicine at the University of Maryland School of Medicine in Baltimore, and an external adviser for the summit, says that the participants will discuss ways to gather evidence for traditional healing systems.
Wieland says that the quality and quantity of research for traditional medicine needs to improve before conclusive statements can be made about its safety and efficacy. “A lot has changed over the past 15 years,” she says. “Where there was previously insufficient good-quality research to determine what does and doesn’t work, we are now seeing more and better research on some traditional medicine.”
Cochrane Complementary Medicine? I hadn’t known before reading this that there was a Cochrane Complementary Medicine or that it was coordinated at the University of Maryland, an institution that has featured in this blog many times before since very early on for the uncritical promotion of “integrating” quackery into science-based medicine by its Integrative Medicine program. After having read this, I looked at the list of members of the advisory group for this summit. Every single member, from co-chairs Lisa Susan Weiland and Bhushan Patwardhan on down, holds a high-ranking faculty, advocacy, or government position in “integrative” or “traditional” medicine. You might think that if the WHO were truly interested in a science-based approach to studying “traditional medicine” it might include at least a token skeptic or two on the advisory group and among the speakers. It didn’t. That’s because the conclusions of the summit were foreordained before it was even convened.
Again, this is not about using science to study what does and doesn’t work in “traditional medicine.” It is about assuming that traditional medicine is of immense value on par with that of science-based medicine and then looking for evidence to support that conclusion. Again, it’s about putting the cart before the horse, as evidenced by just the titles and descriptions of some of the sessions, such as “Planetary health and well-being for all: Learning from Indigenous knowledges, and traditional, complementary and integrative health systems,” “Integrative health for well—being at all ages,” and “Contribution of Traditional Medicine to Healthcare Systems.” (Also, note the titles of many WHO press releases on the conference, like WHO summit aims to unlock power of traditional medicine through science. and describing its Global Centre for Traditional Medicine as Catalysing ancient wisdom and modern science for the health of people and the planet.) Again, note the assumptions, namely that traditional medicine is an important part of “planetary health and well-being for all” that we have to learn from and that traditional medicine has already made great contributions to the healthcare systems of many nations, if only we would just recognize that. (And, make no mistake, the purpose of this summit is to promote that idea as justification not just for the $250 million spent to found the WHO’s Global Centre for Traditional Medicine but for the continued promotion of traditional medicine and its “integration”—whether science-based practitioners like it or want it or not—into the global health system through the ICD-11 and other means.
Unsurprisingly, the day after the summit ended, the WHO released a statement, Global partners commit to advance evidence-based traditional, complementary and integrative medicine, which concluded pretty much what I expected the WHO to conclude from the day that I learned about this summit, which now seems to have renamed “traditional medicine” to “traditional, complementary, and integrative medicine” (TCIM):
Preliminary findings from the WHO Global Survey on Traditional Medicine 2023 shared at the Summit indicate that around 100 countries have TCIM related national policies and strategies. In many WHO Member States, TCIM treatments are part of the essential medicine lists, essential health service packages, and are covered by national health insurance schemes. A large majority of people seek traditional, complementary and integrative medicine interventions for treatment, prevention and management of noncommunicable diseases, palliative care and rehabilitation.
Dr Bruce Aylward, Assistant Director-General, Universal Health Coverage, Life Course at WHO, highlighted the need for a “stronger evidence base—a WHO priority—to enable countries to develop appropriate regulations and policies around traditional, complementary, and integrative medicine.”
Tell me something I didn’t know 15 years ago, when this blog was founded. Advocates of unproven and disproven treatments always claim that there is “insufficient evidence” and that we need a “stronger evidence base.” The latter statement is one of those vague generalities that is always true to one degree or another. It is something that believers in prescientific and pseudoscientific traditional medicine approachers were saying 20 years ago, when I first became heavily involved in assessing “nontraditional” health claims, that they continue to argue now, and that they will likely continue to argue long after I have shuffled off this mortal coil.
It is thus utterly unsurprising that the WHO press release after the conference concludes:
In closing the Summit, Dr Hans Kluge, WHO Regional Director for Europe said, “Together, we have gently shaken up the status quo that has, for far too long, separated different approaches to medicine and health. By taking aim at silos, we are saying we will collaborate all the more to find optimal ways to bring traditional, complementary and integrative medicine well under the umbrella of primary health care and universal health coverage.” He further added, “We have reiterated how crucial it is to get better evidence on the effectiveness, safety and quality of traditional and complementary medicine. That means innovative methodologies for assessing and evaluating outcomes.”
Dr Shyama Kuruvilla, Senior Strategic Adviser and lead for the WHO Traditional Medicine Global Centre, who also led the organization of the Summit said, “We learnt much about the existing policies, tools and practices. But it is clear we have a long journey ahead in using science to further understand, develop and deliver the full potential of TCIM approaches to improve people’s health and well-being in harmony with the planet that sustains us.”
The Summit’s summary document included conclusions and commitments from participants on wide-ranging issues, from global policy, leadership, innovation, health workforce, data, evidence, monitoring, regulation, legal frameworks and protecting biodiversity and sustainable development.
The WHO and other believers in traditional medicine are now touting the Gujarat Declaration as the key to “integrating” traditional medicine into medicine going forward. Of note, the Gujarat Declaration was referenced in the opening remarks by WHO Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus:
This summit is an important opportunity to advance the understanding and use of traditional medicine.
The Gujarat Declaration—the main outcome of this Global Summit—if effectively implemented, will enhance the appropriate integration of traditional medicine into national health systems.
Let me leave you with three specific requests.
First, we urge all countries to commit to examining how best to integrate traditional and complementary medicine into their national health systems.
Second, I urge you all to identify specific, evidence-based and actionable recommendations that can inform the next WHO traditional medicine global strategy.
Third, I urge you to use this meeting as the starting point for a global movement to unlock the power of traditional medicine through science and innovation.
Once again, my thanks to India for its hospitality and leadership in this area.
Again, note how the purpose of this summit was not to determine whether traditional medicine has value and to demonstrate what does and doesn’t work. Rather, the purpose was to promote the “integration” of “traditional medicine” into science-based medicine and to go looking for evidence to justify that predetermined goal.
Let me suggest something that might seem a bit heretical to the WHO as it exists now. The $250 million spent on its quackery-promoting Traditional Medicine Global Centre would be much better spent on—dare I say?—more traditional public health programs in areas of the world that desperately need them, programs promoting clean water, vaccination, and better nutrition, as well as providing “on-the-ground” public health workers and medical personnel to bring science-based medicine, rather than unproven woo, to the people who need it most. The WHO has done such good work in these areas over the decades, and it saddens me to see it slipping more and more into a mindset that promotes medicine based on mysticism and prescientific religious belief systems, such as TCM and Ayurveda, as somehow being co-equal with science-based medicine to the point that they should be “integrated” with it. That is not promoting “planetary health and well-being for all.” Rather, it is shunting precious global health care funds away from science-based public health and medicine to promote unproven and disproven “ancient knowledge.”

Coca-Cola and Corporate Sponsored Research
A new study reveals that Coca-Cola included restrictive clauses in some research funding contracts. This is a good opportunity to review how such behavior can be stopped.
Steven Novella on May 8, 2019
Link

One of the ways in which health research is funded is by corporations. We all know that pharmaceutical companies, for example, fund research into their own drugs to obtain FDA approval. But other food, nutrition, and health industries also fund research. The advantage of this system is that it funnels large amounts of money into research programs, which helps sustain them. However, there are obvious potential downsides, mainly corporations using their funding to put their thumb on the scale of scientific research.
Recently Coca-Cola was found to be doing just that. A report published by Cambridge researchers and others examined 87,013 pages of documents obtained through freedom of information act (FOIA) requests. Much of these documents were e-mails between Coca-Cola and researchers they were funding. They found:
Provisions gave Coca-Cola the right to review research in advance of publication as well as control over (1) study data, (2) disclosure of results and (3) acknowledgement of Coca-Cola funding. Some agreements specified that Coca-Cola has the ultimate decision about any publication of peer-reviewed papers prior to its approval of the researchers’ final report. If so desired, Coca-Cola can thus prevent publication of unfavourable research, but we found no evidence of this to date in the emails we received. The documents also reveal researchers can negotiate with funders successfully to remove restrictive clauses on their research.
We have to acknowledge the good and bad here. Researchers could negotiate to remove restrictive parts of an agreement, and the study authors could find no actual examples of Coca-Cola quashing research findings it didn’t like. The provisions themselves, however, are highly problematic, and seem designed to give Coca-Cola the power to do just that, to prevent publication without cause of any research it chose.
These findings highlight the need for comprehensive regulation ensuring the validity and transparency of corporate-funded health research. Any argument that corporations have a right to the results of research they fund is outweighed by the critical societal need for full confidence in the integrity of published research. This includes the fact that the published literature is a fair representation of all research results, and is not distorted by corporate or other narrow interests. Perhaps the worst type of distortion is the study not published – because there is no way to know what isn’t there. Any subsequent researcher doing a literature review may not be able to detect that certain studies were omitted.
It is increasingly recognized that doing research on people, and even animals, is a privilege. Society has a compelling interest in regulating such research. Further, research done by publicly funded institutions or researchers, even if that research itself is privately funded, should be in the public domain.
We also have to look beyond who has the right to any one study. Scientific research, in a very real way, exists as a whole. This is embodied in the peer-reviewed scientific literature. That literature is like a living organism, and in some ways needs to be treated that way. Society is best served when the whole of the literature follows agreed-upon rules, and fairly represents reality. In any narrow interest is able to distort the literature for its own ends, the entire organism is compromised.
The negative effects go beyond the specific question addressed by the influenced research. Such distortions reverberate throughout the literature, and also negatively affect public confidence in the entire scientific enterprise. This, perhaps, has the greatest negative societal effects. If large numbers of citizens and their representatives can ignore or dismiss the findings of scientific research, because they believe “science” is corrupt or only serves corporate interests, then the result is widespread science denial. This is exactly what we are currently seeing in the world, with devastating consequences.
There is significant denial of vaccine science, medical research in general, climate science, HIV science, psychiatry, and evolutionary science. Whenever someone prefers an ideological or convenient belief over the findings of science, they can point to Coca-Cola or other examples as evidence that “science” itself cannot be trusted.
I know this is a “meta” argument – that we must protect the integrity of all science in order to foster public confidence science itself, but recent experience supports this conclusion.
There are also many straight-forward steps we can take to promote the integrity of the scientific process and therefore public confidence in it. All of these rules already exist in one context or another, but they should be universal and enforced.
First – science requires complete transparency. Funding sources, and any relationship that might create a conflict of interest, should be fully disclosed.
Second – scientific findings also have to be complete and not cherry-picked in any way to give a reliable picture of reality. This means that no one gets to hide research findings they don’t like. You don’t get to peek at the results as the researcher is ongoing (except for safety monitoring), and you don’t get to decide whether or not to disclose the results.
Third – corporate or private grants for research should be unrestricted in specific ways. It’s fine if they are directed toward certain questions or areas of research, but funders should not control the scientific details, or what happens with the results. Nor should they be allowed to restrict transparency.
There are also multiple levels at which such science-ethics rules can be enforced. Journal editors can make any requirements they wish as criteria for being published. They can require full transparency, and that certain ethical guidelines were adhered to. Institutions can also enforce such rules, accepting private funding only when specific institution-wide guidelines are followed. Individual researchers should also be held to a standard of professional ethics, which should not allow for conducting research outside of these guidelines. Violating these rules could, for example, serve as reasons to be ejected from a professional society.
Finally, government should bake these essential scientific guidelines into any science it touches – any researcher, lab, institution, organization, publication, or research that it funds. It can also simply be made illegal to have any clause in a contract for funding of scientific research that requires breaking one of these established ethical guidelines. Simply put – you cannot contractually require someone to behave unethically.
We are certainly part of the way there in enacting such regulations to improve the integrity and transparency of scientific research. But we need to go all the way, and we need to do so in such a way that public confidence in the entire scientific enterprise will be promoted. Nothing can stop conspiracy theorists who are immune to reality, but conspiracy thinking and science denial can be marginalized and minimized by aggressive regulation of scientific ethics and transparency.

Retracted papers about COVID-19 are more highly cited than they should be
Earlier this month a study showed that papers about COVID-19 that are retracted tend to be cited far more than average and continue to be heavily cited after retraction. Clearly, scientific publishing and the scientific community need to do better.
David Gorski on May 1, 2023
Link

Some of my colleagues have been surprised at the number of really awful papers that have been published during the pandemic and reach conclusions that are at odds with thus-far established science. Examples abound, a number of which we have written about, including articles by academics whom I used to admire (or at least view more favorably than unfavorably), such as John Ioannidis, Vinay Prasad, and a number of others, some, admittedly, noto particularly admirable before the pandemic (such as Peter Doshi). Seemingly, even the Cochrane Collaborative has gotten in on this action, along with past leaders. Most were in the peer-reviewed biomedical literature, too, although not all. (The utter crapfest of an anonymously authored study that wasn’t peer-reviewed that was published by the Florida Department of Health last fall and suggested that COVID-19 vaccines are more dangerous than COVID comes to mind. Surprise! The paper went through multiple iterations personally overseen by Florida Surgeon General Dr. Joseph Ladapo and clearly designed to make the vaccines look worse than the disease.) They shouldn’t have been. Publishing academic research articles as a form of misinformation and propaganda for quackery is a longstanding tactic used by advocates of unscientific medicine, such as proponents of alternative medicine and antivaxxers.
That’s why I’m happy that one of the most prominent physicians turned COVID-19 misinformation spreaders, Dr. Peter McCullough, reminded me of a study that I had though about blogging about a couple of weeks ago. True, it’s one of his paid Substack articles, entitled Retracted COVID-19 Articles: Significantly More Cited than Others, which he touts as evidence that “biopharmaceutical complex censorship” is “backfiring.” The study itself was published three weeks ago in Scientometrics by Trenton Taros and investigators at the University of Massachusetts and entitled Retracted Covid-19 articles: significantly more cited than other articles within their journal of origin.
Since I don’t subscribe to Dr. McCullough’s Substack (and will never pay someone like him for the privilege of reading their Substack articles), all I can cite is the first paragraph, but the first paragraph is enough to give you a good idea of what Dr. McCullough is about. Naturally, he starts by bragging about his publication record, something I always find annoying because, as I like to say, I don’t care about what he published in the past. I care very deeply about the misinformation he publishes now and has published since the pandemic hit three years ago, such as the false claim that COVID-19 vaccines are killing hundreds of thousands—or even millions—of people.
Let’s see what Dr. McCullough has to say, though:
I have 685 listings in the National Library of Medicine PUBMED where my academic contributions as a first or contributing author or as a site principle investigator have been memorialized. I am the former longstanding editor Reviews in Cardiovascular Medicine and Cardiorenal Medicine—both are indexed in PUBMED. I have handled thousands of manuscripts and can tell you first hand, historically, that retractions of fully published reports was exceedingly rare. It was only done in the most grievous cases of academic fraud that was discovered after a paper had fully made it through the peer-review process. Since the onset of the crisis, starting with early treatment of COVID-19, we have seen an unprecedented number of papers retracted after full publication and indexing in the National Library of Medicine. As an author and experienced editor, I wanted to understand what is going on in the case of pandemic paper retractions.
Before I move on to the publication that he is clearly talking about (the discussion of which I thank him for reminding me to write), let’s just unpack that last part about retractions of “fully published reports” being “exceedingly rare.” Guess what? He’s correct about that! Here’s where we disagree. He views rarity of retractions prepandemic as a good thing. I do not. I’ve long argued that there’s a lot of dreck and fraud in the peer-reviewed biomedical literature that really could use some retracting. Journals have been painfully reluctant to do that. The most notorious example, one that I like to cite a lot, is how it took 13 years for The Lancet to retract Andrew Wakefield’s infamous 1998 case series that claimed to link vaccination with the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine to “autistic enterocolitis,” and it took undeniable revelations of scientific fraud unearthed by investigative journalist Brian Deer to finally prod The Lancet‘s editor Richard Horton to pull the trigger and retract. I could list a number of other truly awful antivax papers that we’ve written about here over the years that should be retracted and, in some cases, have been retracted, and note that, even when an awful or outright fraudulent paper is exposed as such, journal editors frequently resist retracting and then drag their heels as long as they can before finally retracting.
Before I go on to discuss the actual study that Dr. McCullough is presenting as “evidence” that “biopharmaceutical complex censorship” is “backfiring,” I’ll also mention that I’m rather surprised that this paper didn’t get more play in COVID-19 denial social media since its publication. After all, as you will see, what Taros et al found is that articles ultimately retracted by the journals that published them tend to garner more citations and engagement than other articles in the same journals (indeed, in the same issues of the same journals where the retracted papers had been originally published).
COVID-19 retractions
One key passage near the beginning of the study caught my eye because it so obviously went against Dr. McCullough’s lament about how rare retractions were back in his good old days. In brief, the authors note that the growth rate for scientific publication jumped dramatically in 2020, which, not coincidentally, was the year the COVID-19 pandemic hit:
In an age of expansion for modern medicine, coinciding with the continued growth of the internet, there has been a rapid expansion in the volume of scientific research activity and rate of publication. A 2021 study indicated a 4% annual growth in global publication output in peer-reviewed science and engineering journal articles as well as conference papers from 2010 to 2020 (National Science Board, 2021). The same study reports a 3% annual growth rate for biomedical and health sciences from 2009 to 2019, but an astounding 15% and 16% growth rate for each respectively in 2020. With this growth, new sets of academic standards for publication arise, along with increasingly important sets of ethical standards (Brand et al., 2004; Coats, 2009). As those standards are investigated and enforced, retraction of published papers from scientific journals becomes crucial to preserve scientific integrity and properly educate the general public and scientific community.
That last part, to me, is key. Retractions are quality control, not, as Dr. McCullough and his admiring COVID-19 contrarians and quacks characterize them, censorship. I will repeat yet again that the problem with biomedical literature is not that too many studies are being retracted; it’s that too few are and how difficult it is to get even those retracted. Taros et al point exactly this aspect of retractions out:
As the volume of scientific literature expands, retraction volume and rate have also increased (Nagella & Madhugiri, 2020; Steen, 2011). These retractions represent a self-corrective function built into the scientific research process to protect the integrity of the scientific method. Retraction of a published article can be initiated by the author or publisher for a variety of reasons: Institutional Review Board (IRB) violations, data errors, forgery, plagiarism, and inappropriate authorship, among others (Budd et al., 1998). A major concern for those articles which are retracted is their rate of citation prior to, and after retraction. This is particularly important if they are found in high-impact, prestigious, or influential journals, as this propagates the dissemination of false, inaccurate, or inconclusive information (Dinh et al., 2019).
This is indeed a concern. Andrew Wakefield’s fraudulent case series, for instance, was both widely cited and widely shared on social media. (In fact, Retraction Watch lists it as the second most highly cited retracted paper of all time, with 643 citations before retraction and 940 after retraction.) The authors note that “number of papers pertaining to COVID-19 which have been retracted continues to rise to over 200, based on the Retraction Watch Database (RWD) COVID-19 blog (Marcus & Oransky, 2022).” Coincidentally, I note, going over to the Retraction Watch blog’s weekend update, that the number is now up to over 300.
What the authors did was to test the following hypothesis:
We hypothesized that retracted COVID-19 articles received more attention, measured in citations, than would be expected for the average article in the journal they were published in over the same time period. In presenting a quantitative analysis of retracted COVID-19 articles published in medical and life science journals, we hope to shine light on the attention these articles garnered and provide possible rationale for this occurrence. The inclusion of SCImago Journal Ranking (SJR) is used to demonstrate that this phenomenon was not isolated to smaller journals but included journals of all sizes and prestige levels. It is our hope to add to the conversation regarding COVID-19 retractions and the state of scientific literature during the pandemic.
The authors did not include preprints (which is another topic to me entirely, given how often preprints have been weaponized by quacks in order to get their bogus studies in the public record before they’ve actually been peer-reviewed) or any paper published after 2021. That latter exclusion criteria was because the authors thought that papers published in 2022 would not have had enough time for their citation records to have stabilized.
This flow diagram demonstrates what they did:

Most of the 90 retracted papers were about epidemiology, disease course, and treatments; surprisingly (to me, anyway) the percentage of papers about COVID-19 vaccines that were retracted were only one-third of the number that were about epidemiology and only one-half the number about treatment.
As for the reasons for retraction:
Those 90 articles were accessed and broadly divided into categories based on content and reason for retraction. 28 of the articles focused on epidemiology, 20 on disease course, and 22 on treatment (Fig. 2). In 53 of the cases, the publisher initiated the retraction proceedings. In 18 instances the request was initiated by the author. The requesting party was unknown in the remaining 19 instances. There were a wide variety of reasons for retraction with little standardization, at least 7 articles were retracted due to concerns for plagiarism and at least 5 for IRB violations.
I will admit that it was a pleasant surprise that over half the retractions were initiated by the publisher and that only five were retracted for IRB violations. Less pleasant was the author’s finding that 32% of the retraction statement for 32% of the retracted articles did not meet the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) guidelines for retraction statements, which state that notices of retraction should:
    • Be linked to the retracted article wherever possible (ie, in all online versions)
    • Clearly identify the retracted article (eg, by including the title and authors in the retraction heading or citing the retracted article)
    • Be clearly identified as a retraction (ie, distinct from other types of correction or comment)
    • Be published promptly to minimise harmful effects
    • Be freely available to all readers (ie, not behind access barriers or available only to subscribers)
    • State who is retracting the article
    • State the reason(s) for retraction
    • Be objective, factual and avoid inflammatory language
The authors observe:
In only 71 cases was it possible to discern which party requested the retraction. Far fewer had clear explanations for why articles were retracted. In our analysis, 32% of retracted articles did not meet the COPE guidelines for retraction statements (Barbour et al., 2009). This is because either the retracting party or retraction reason was not included within the retraction notice. Obscuring the reason for retraction obfuscates the bravery and integrity needed to willingly retract one’s own work (Vuong, 2020). Additionally, it prevents researchers who have cited works that have since been retracted from evaluating the legitimacy of their own claims.
I can’t help but wonder how much of this disappointing lack of transparency among journals is due to concern about legal implications. If there’s one thing about society in general—and COVID-19 contrarians who publish papers like this, it’s that we live in a very litigious society. I have to wonder if the reason why so many retraction notices do not include a mention of which party requested the retraction and/or a clear explanation of the reason for the retraction is due to fear of legal liability.
I also note that the speed of retraction does not appear to be particularly fast for COVID-19 papers, at least no more so than for any other. Take a look at this graph, which is basically a Kaplan-Meier survival curve of time from publication to retraction:

The median time from publication to retraction was 175 days, which is nearly six months! It’s impossible to tell how much of that time is delay between the time a retraction is requested to the actual retraction and how much is how long the journal takes to come to a decision, but it’s definitely not short.
Now here’s the money finding of the paper:
Retracted articles accrued a median number of 10.0 (IQR 26) citations while CiteScore accrued a median of 4.2 (IQR 3.7) citations (Fig. 4). The difference between the average CiteScore and average citation number for a retracted article was 37.5, a statistically significant difference (p = 0.01).
Or, to show it visually:
The authors also note that by November 2020 the retraction rate for COVID-19-related papers had reached a level five times that of the general science literature, complete with clear “instances of intentional malpractice and fraudulent publications” in “some of the world’s most noteworthy journals.” This is, of course, consistent with what we at SBM have been blogging about since the very beginning of the pandemic. Noting that these papers have garnered a disproportionately high impact in the scientific literature, the authors speculate on possible reasons:
Retracted COVID-19 publications may have been more likely to include bold or novel claims that garnered a disproportionately high amount of attention from others in the scientific community. The phenomenon of “clickbait” titles could explain how certain publications gained more attention and led to further writing on a potentially misleading claim.
This is, of course, one of those findings that I intuitively sense to be almost certainly accurate, but that I cannot yet prove. Moving on, the authors conceded that COVID-19 articles in general have tended to attract more attention than other topics, because, you know, a pandemic that’s killed over a million people in just the US alone since early 2020, but argue that that alone can’t explain the difference:
It is true that COVID-19 publications accumulated a disproportionate amount of attention regardless of retraction status (Ioannidis et al., 2022). However, the large discrepancy between CiteScore and number of citations is not likely due to an increased amount of interest in COVID literature given the magnitude of the difference between CiteScore and citation number in retracted articles. A direct comparison between retracted and non-retracted COVID-19 publications for each respective journal was beyond the scope of this analysis.
This would be an interesting analysis to do. My prediction is that the difference between citation counts of retracted versus non-retracted papers would shrink but still remain substantial. Moreover, the finding that most concerns me is this:
Unfortunately, retracted COVID-19 papers continue to accumulate citations well past their date of retraction. Analysis at two time points, June and November of 2022, showed 728 total additional citations across all 93 articles analyzed across this time frame. This equates to just shy of 5 citations of retracted COVID-19 papers per day. It does not appear that measures taken to curb their citation have much effect either. For example, there was no significant difference in additional citations between those articles bearing “withdrawn” or “retracted” headings and those without them. Ultimately, this places the onus to limit the perpetuation of inaccurate, retracted information squarely on the scientific community itself. It is up to researchers to analyze their citations as closely as they analyze their conclusions.
Truly, these are what I like to refer to as either zombie studies in that they are undead and will live forever unless very specific actions are taken to kill them (e.g., a bullet to the brain), or they are “slasher studies,” named after the unstoppable killers in 1980s horror movies (like Jason Voorhees or Michael Myers) who, even after seemingly having been killed at the end of one movie, always somehow manage to live again to hunt a new group of randy teens or college students in sequels. Whichever characterization you prefer, it is up to individual scientists to vet their citations and not cite retracted papers unless the retraction is discussed or at least mentioned.
Retraction: A brief case study
I will conclude by mentioning that retraction is a two-edged sword. It is, as I have argued many times in the past, necessary quality control for the scientific literature. Unsurprisingly, cranks, quacks, and antivaxxers don’t see it that way—and never have. The most recent example is Steve Kirsch’s reaction to a very bad paper by Prof. Mark Skidmore, an economist at Michigan State University. (The shame, the shame, for my state. Even though I have no connection with MSU and never went to school there, a number of people I’ve known over the years and some of their kids have. I’ve also known some excellent faculty members at MSU.) At the time, I characterized the paper, entitled The role of social circle COVID-19 illness and vaccination experiences in COVID-19 vaccination decisions: an online survey of the United States population, as reminding me, more than anything else, of a Steve Kirsch “study” in which a fundamentally bad research design is tarted up with (some) seemingly legitimate social science research methodology and then dishonestly spun to produce a fake estimate of 278,000 fatalities due to COVID-19 vaccines, which is then “validated” by an incompetent dumpster dive into the Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System (VAERS) database of the sort that I’ve been writing about since 2006.
Yes, you read that right. Prof. Skidmore basically did survey asking people if they knew anyone who had died after vaccination against COVID-19 and then used that survey to estimate that “the total number of fatalities due to COVID-19 inoculation may be as high as 278,000 (95% CI 217,330–332,608) when fatalities that may have occurred regardless of inoculation are removed.” Let’s just say that the survey/study was every bit as bad as it sounds from just that characterization and that it was a bait-and-switch, whose purpose was ostensibly to “identify the factors associated by American citizens with the decision to be vaccinated against COVID-19” but whose true purpose rapidly became apparent: To try to “prove” that the vaccines killed hundreds of thousands of people. Unsurprisingly, Prof. Skidmore is not a scientist with any relevant expertise in epidemiology, virology, infectious diseases, or medicine. He is an economics professor.
Fortunately, BMC Infectious Diseases, the journal that had made the mistake of publishing this bit of propagandistic pseudoscientific dreck, came to its senses and retracted it, ironically announcing it the day before the study that is the topic of this post was published, listing the reasons in a retraction notice:
The editors have retracted this article as concerns were raised regarding the validity of the conclusions drawn after publication. Post-publication peer review concluded that the methodology was inappropriate as it does not prove causal inference of mortality, and limitations of the study were not adequately described. Furthermore, there was no attempt to validate reported fatalities, and there are critical issues in the representativeness of the study population and the accuracy of data collection. Lastly, contrary to the statement in the article, the documentation provided by the author confirms that the study was exempt from ethics approval and therefore was not approved by the IRB of the Michigan State University Human Research Protection Program.
Interestingly, I myself wondered if this study had been approved by an appropriate IRB, given that it obviously should have been. Reading between the lines, I suspect that Prof. Skidmore just said that the study was exempt, but that’s not how IRB exemptions work. The IRB has to decide that the study is exempt. Often, IRB exemptions are granted through an expedited process in which the IRB chair or a subset of members examines the study protocol and decides that it falls under one of the exempt categories. It is true that the study notes that the “survey instrument and recruitment protocol of the National Survey of COVID-19 Health Experiences were approved by the Institutional Review Board (IRB) of the Michigan State University Human Research Protection Program (file number: STUDY00006960, date of approval: November 17, 2021).” However, I immediately speculated that the IRB had been duped by the aforementioned bait-and-switch and that approval had likely only covered using the survey instrument for assessing factors associated with COVID-19 vaccination uptake and refusal. I further wondered if Prof. Skidmore had conveniently left out the intended analysis in which he used the survey results to estimate how many people died from COVID-19 vaccines. I can’t prove whether or not I was correct in this speculation, but in retrospect I’m pretty sure that I was.
Somehow Steve Kirsch got wind of the impending retraction a few days before it was announced and, consistent with the litigious nature of quacks, posted an article to his Substack entitled It’s time we hold these people accountable; let the lawsuits begin, adding that “I’m going to pay for the lawsuit to sue Springer and their corrupt editorial board at BMC Infectious Diseases for their decision to retract the Skidmore paper; the most popular paper in their history.”
Yes, the Skidmore paper did get incredible social media engagement, unfortunately. Hilariously, Steve Kirsch then went on to do what Steve Kirsch does so hilariously and post the results of his own web “survey,” whose results were predictably one-sided:

A few days later, Kirsch tried to argue that the reasons cited for the retraction didn’t meet COPE standards:
Do any of these apply to the Skidmore paper? No. Not a single one.
In fact, Skidmore’s result was similar to data found by other researchers which puts to bed the first concern and the others aren’t even close to valid.
Which leads us to the inevitable conclusion that the paper was retracted unethically.
Was the Editor willing to discuss the retraction decision and answer questions? No.
Will the Editor reveal who objected to the paper and which of these items they cited? No, they keep that a secret!
I’ll reveal to Mr. Kirsch that I wrote an email to the editors expressing my concerns about the methodological flaws about the paper, mainly because (1) I’m not in the least bit embarrassed by it and (2) if Kirsch really does go through with his lawsuit the email will be found during discovery anyway. I will also mention that I highly doubt that I was anywhere near the only academic who did so. More importantly, at the time, I was also very disappointed that I never received a substantive response, just an acknowledgment from someone from “editorial support”—not even from an editor!—that my email had been received. I figured at the time that my concerns were probably not being seriously considered, much less addressed.
In any event, I listed all my concerns about the paper, including how I thought that it had been a “bait and switch” in which the stated primary aim was the “bait” used to get IRB approval for the study while the true primary aim was to come up with an inflated death toll. I also noted a working paper that Prof. Skidmore had published 11 months before that had used the same methodology of the retracted paper and was full of antivax talking points that I referred to as an “antivax ‘greatest hits’ compilation.” I also noted a definite conflict of interest in that this was a single-author, single funder study, and the funder is Catherine Austin Fitts, who appeared in a COVID conspiracy movie Planet Lockdown and has worked with antivaccine activist Robert F. Kennedy, Jr, as reported in The Washington Post. Of note, Prof. Skidmore also maintains a personal blog, Lighthouse Economics that is packed with antivaccine misinformation.
Basically, I wrote nothing more than what I had published on my not-so-secret other blog, suggesting that the paper should be retracted because:
    • The methodology did not support the conclusions and was risibly substandard
    • Of serious concerns about an undisclosed conflict of interest related to the funder of the study
    • Of the likelihood that MSU’s IRB approved the survey instrument and recruitment methods for different endpoints than what they were ultimately used for, which, if true, would make this study unethical
All of these reasons to request retraction are consistent with COPE guidelines, and any one of them would, in my opinion
Yet, Mr. Kirsch and Prof. Skidmore’s allies portray this retraction as “censorship” and threaten lawsuits. I rather suspect it’s all performative. For one thing, note how Kirsch says he’ll support any author who wants to sue. This particular retracted paper was a single-author paper, with Prof. Skidmore as the sole author. If anyone were going to sue, it would have to be him. Given that discovery is a two-way street, I’d have to wonder if he really would like everything about the publication of this paper to be revealed, including all versions of the protocol, the IRB application, reviews, and approval. I rather suspect not, although I could be wrong.
The bottom line
Unfortunately, journal editors have traditionally been far more unwilling to retract bad, unethical, or fraudulent papers than they should be. While I can understand some of the reluctance, given that each retraction is an admission that they had screwed up and accepted a manuscript that should never have been published and that sometimes papers that are bad but were done honestly are not necessarily deserving of retraction. I can also understand concerns about legal ramifications. (I realize that by publicly acknowledging that I was one of the academics who wrote to the BMC Infectious Diseases editor to express concerns about the paper I might just have bought myself a deposition if Prof. Skidmore does decide to sue, but on the other hand his lawyers will see that email anyway if he does sue.) Journals need to do better despite all that because, as the study by Taros et al shows, retracted papers about COVID-19 have a malign and distorting effect on the medical literature. Going beyond the study, they often serve as clickbait that antivaxxers, pandemic minimizers, and those opposed to public health interventions use to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt about medicine, science, and public health. More broadly, we as a scientific community have to do better as well by not citing retracted papers unless it is in the context of discussing the retraction.

Improving how the NIH decides which grants to fund: Reality vs. conspiracy
Last week, the United States National Institutes of Health (NIH) announced a plan to decrease the problem of reputational bias in grant funding. I couldn’t help but contrast how hard the NIH tries to use the most rigorous scientific criteria to decide whose grants to fund with the conspiracy theory that Anthony Fauci personally doles out NIH dollars like a mob boss to scientists who support him.
David Gorski on December 12, 2022
Link

As a surgeon-scientist who has over the years applied for more research grants than I can currently remember from various funding agencies, including the NIH and other federal entities, I sometimes like to discuss how the NIH determines which grants to fund given that the current budget only allows the NIH to fund roughly 10% of the grant applications that it receives every year. (This is, unfortunately, a situation that has persisted for many years now, despite increases in the NIH budget.) After all, I have submitted far more grant applications to fund my lab to the NIH, the Department of Defense (which, little known to most people, actually funds a fair amount of cancer research), and other agencies than have ever been funded. (I will keep my percent success rate a secret, but it’s fairly low, which is not uncommon among investigators.) At the same time, I realize that a lot of these discussions might seem to be a bit too “inside baseball” for many readers but I consider them important nonetheless. This is because since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, many conspiracy theories that have cropped up that portray the NIH granting process as based on, in essence, Anthony Fauci—or the NIH director—personally deciding whose grant applications receive funding and only doling out funds to researchers who support with the “government line,” like a mob boss doling out favors to underlings in return for favors done him. Basically, such conspiracy theorists cannot imagine any government institution providing research money to any group opposed to its messaging, or funding any research whose results might not line up with the message “the government” wants to promote.
I rather suspect that the origin of this misconception about how NIH grants are funded, which has always existed but only reached the consciousness of the public outside of antivax conspiracy bubbles since the pandemic hit, comes from projection. Basically, antivax conspiracy theorists who portray Anthony Fauci and the NIH as doling out grant funds to reward supporters and withholding them to punish “dissidents” is exactly how conspiracy theorists would determine whose research is funded and whose is not. They therefore assume that this is how the NIH has always done it. With the pandemic, and Anthony Fauci becoming a major face representing the government response to COVID-19, naturally they personalized this, in particular in light of various “lab leak” conspiracy theories that claim that Fauci funded research in Wuhan that led to the creation of SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19. I’m not going into the weeds of whether the research carried out at Wuhan was truly “gain of function” research (although it does not appear to have been); rather I’m going to focus on how antivax and COVID-19-minimizing sources portrayed grants to Wuhan as having been granted by Fauci personally, such as a story in WorldNetDaily last year titled “New evidence ties COVID-19 creation to research funded by Fauci?” Let’s just say that this histrionic headline was…not accurate.
Even though I have argued on occasion that, whatever its flaws, the NIH grant selection process is about as close to a true meritocracy as any government agency gets, that doesn’t mean that there isn’t a lot of room for improvement. “As close to a true meritocracy” does not in this case mean anywhere near close enough. One common criticism of NIH granting processes dating back decades is that the study sections that evaluate and score grant applications based on scientific merit are too “conservative” and tend to favor “safe” research that might produce incremental results but nothing ground-breaking. Unsurprisingly, this is a problem that is perceived, at least, to be much worse in times of tight funding, when the top 10% or less of grant applications are funded. After all, when funds are tight, study sections feel less comfortable supporting research that is more likely to go nowhere and thereby “waste” NIH funds.
Indeed, years before the pandemic, I took issue with John Ioannidis, who made this very argument, railing against how the NIH supposedly favored “conformity” and “mediocrity”. Let’s just say that, although I see some merit in these arguments, I also strongly believe that the critics who make them have a rather exaggerated view of the supposed “brave mavericks” who are missing out on NIH funding supposedly because they are too brilliant, creative, and “outside the box” and have pointed out that the anecdotes used to make this argument are often missing important context that makes NIH decisions not to fund the work more understandable. (In one case, this involved the knowledge that other scientists were having trouble replicating the experimental results used to support the grant application.) Then there is the issue of how study sections would choose between high risk “outside the box” studies to fund, given that such studies almost by definition don’t have a lot of preliminary evidence to support them and it’s hard to judge how plausible the hypotheses being tested are to pick out the most promising study the most likely to lead to a major breakthrough. (A lot of the anecdotes used to support funding “riskier” research often suffer from selective memory and major hindsight bias.) That is, however, a discussion that I’ve had before and an updated version could be a topic for another day.
What led me to want to discuss how NIH grants are funded is another shortcoming in the NIH review process, prompted by a story published on Friday in Nature about a proposal to change the way that NIH grants are scored in order to remove what is known as “reputational bias”, one form of bias in grant scoring that inarguably does still exist. In brief, this form of bias was documented in a January 2022 NIH analysis, which found that the 10% of institutions that receive the most money from the agency get about 65% of its overall funding for research projects and the bottom half receives less than 5%, proportions that have remained persistent for years. Of course, researchers not at the “top” schools have known this for decades, referring to it as how the “rich get richer”.
First, however, let’s look at the NIH grant process.
How an NIH grant is reviewed
Contrary to the conspiracist vision of Anthony Fauci—or any other Institute director at NIH, or even the NIH director him or herself —personally viewing every grant application and deciding who gets those sweet, sweet NIH dollars and who does not, there is a long-defined, rigorous, and codified process used by the NIH to evaluate grants applications. It begins with the submission of a grant to the NIH. Before I discuss what happens next, I will note that the NIH has a number of granting mechanisms designed for different purposes. For example, the R21 grant is designed for preliminary work, often the “higher risk” studies that the brave mavericks demand, and doesn’t require a lot of preliminary data. (The claim that it can require no preliminary data, however, is generally nonsense. You need at least some data.) R21s can fund up to two years and cannot be renewed.
In contrast, the granddaddy of them all, the “gold standard” grant for an individual investigator, small groups of co-investigators, or collaborators, is the R01, which can be funded for up to five years (it’s also one of the only grant mechanisms where the investigator can propose basically anything, rather than having to address a particular topic or question). At the end of that time, the investigator can apply for a competitive renewal, which can extend the grant for up to another five years, and so on ad infinitum. There are a number of other grant mechanisms, which include training grants for graduate students, center grants (e.g., for cancer centers), larger multi-investigator grants, and more targeted grants—Wikipedia has a nice list here—but in general all of them are scored by groups of scientists with the relevant expertise in a review group called a study section, of which there are dozens in the NIH arranged by topic into Review Branches at the Center for Scientific Review. Many of these study sections are permanent, but the NIH can and does set up temporary study sections for topics of special interest at the time.
NIH grants generally undergo two levels of review, first the study section and then advisory councils. To guide the reviews, the NIH has five criteria that it uses to evaluate grant applications:
    • Significance
    • Investigator(s)
    • Innovation
    • Approach
    • Environment
Other considerations include “Additional Review Criteria”:
As applicable for the project proposed, reviewers will evaluate the following additional items while determining scientific and technical merit and in providing an overall impact score, but will not give separate scores for these items.
    • Study Timeline (specific to applications involving clinical trials)
    • Protections for Human Subjects
    • Inclusion of Women, Minorities, and Children
    • Vertebrate Animals
    • Biohazards
    • Resubmission
    • Renewal
    • Revision
Additional Review Considerations. As applicable for the project proposed, reviewers will consider each of the following items, but will not give scores for these items and should not consider them in providing an overall impact score.
    • Applications from Foreign Organizations
    • Select Agent
    • Resource Sharing Plans
    • Authentication of Key Biological and/or Chemical Resources
    • Budget and Period Support
Grants undergo anonymous peer review, and usually each application is reviewed by three or four reviewers, with one of them being a statistician where appropriate. Those assigned to do the detailed reviews score each of the above areas from 1-9, although in this case low scores are better, denoting high impact/priority, and then assign an overall impact score to the grant application. During the study section meeting, the study section member assigned as primary reviewer starts the discussion with a summary of the grant application, the score assigned to it, and why that score was assigned. Then the others who evaluated each grant application do the same, after which the whole study section discusses the application. At the end, every member assigns an overall impact score to the grant under discussion before moving on to the next application. After the study section meeting, all the impact scores are used to calculate a final overall Priority Score assigned to the grant application. Also, the membership rosters of the study sections are public knowledge, as they are published on the CSR website; so it’s not uncommon for investigators who got a bad review among their reviews to make a good guess about who was responsible.
Although I’ve never served as a permanent member of an NIH study section, I have served as an ad hoc member for specific expertise. (Ad hoc members generally serve for only one or a handful of grant review cycles, rather than being assigned for multi-year stints.) As such, I can only comment on the dynamics of study sections in which I’ve participated. One thing that I’ve noticed is that it only takes one highly negative review from a reviewer who is outspoken to tank an application. I’ve also noted that someone who really likes a grant application can sway others to score it lower, but the effect seems a bit weaker than “negative campaigning” does.
Obviously, environment is the criteria most subject to reputational bias, because it requires the reviewer to determine if the university or institution at which the research is to be performed has the facilities and expertise to give the proposed project the highest chance of success. Naturally, being at a university like Harvard, Yale, or Stanford (for example) will provide an investigator an inherent advantage, because such universities have more resources and expertise than mid- or lower-tier universities.
When an individual grant application hits the NIH, it will be assigned to a study section. Investigators can influence this process by suggesting study sections, and, unsurprisingly, some study sections have reputations for being harsher than others. Once a grant is assigned to a study section, that study section’s Scientific Review Officer (SRO) will read it, decide if it’s appropriate for the study section, and assign reviewers:
Assignment of Applications to Specific Reviewers: The SRO assigns applications to particular reviewers by matching the science in the application to the reviewer’s expertise. Assignment considerations include: reviewer knowledge about, and interest in, the goals of the project; expertise in the techniques proposed; reviewer workload; and real or perceived conflicts of interest. The SRO encourages reviewers to let him/her know of any concerns that they have about their assignments. This would include conflicts of interest, concerns about the appropriateness of the assignment, or the need for additional expertise.
The SRO also recruits scientists to serve on the study section, thusly:
Identifying and Recruiting Reviewers: Possibly the most important role of the SRO is to ensure that the reviewers present at the study section meeting have all the needed expertise to evaluate the applications under review.
In choosing regular members for study sections, it is essential that the SRO recognizes current trends in the field and ensures that the membership reflects where the field is now and where it is going. It is also critical that the expertise of each nominee complements that of the other members and strengthens the study section as a whole.
As you can see, the SRO is a big deal.
The SRO also runs the study section meeting, collates the reviews, takes notes, and from those notes and the overall reviews produces a Summary Statement that includes the overall Priority Score assigned (with a percentile measurement denoting the percentage of grant applications that were scored higher than the applicant’s), comments about the discussion at the study section, and the original “raw” reviews from each study section member who reviewed the grant. Note that now generally only grants that score in the top one-third to one-half receive overall Priority Scores and Summary Statements, because any grant with higher (and therefore worse) scores are so unlikely to be funded as to make it not worth the SRO’s effort to put the documents together. These investigators do, however, still receive the reviews carried out by individual study section members. SROs also handle appeals from applicants who question whether their review was fair or whether one or more of the reviewers had the requisite expertise.
The second level of review occurs through committees formed at each Institute and Center (IC) at the NIH called Advisory Councils:
The Advisory Council/Board of the potential awarding Institute/Center performs the second level of review (See Advisory Councils or Boards). Advisory Councils/Boards are composed of scientists from the extramural research community and public representatives (NIH Federal Advisory Committee Information). Members are chosen by the respective IC and are approved by the Department of Health and Human Services. For certain committees, members are appointed by the President of the United States.
Now here’s the part where the conspiracy might come in:
Recommendation Process
    • NIH program staff members examine applications and consider the overall impact scores given during the peer review process, percentile rankings (if applicable) and the summary statements in light of the Institute/Center’s priorities.
    • Program staff provide a grant-funding plan to the Advisory Board/Council. Council members have access to applications and summary statements pending funding for that IC in that council round.
    • Council members conduct a Special Council Review of grant applications from investigators who currently receive $1 million or more in direct costs of NIH funding to support Research Project Grants (see NOT-OD-12-140). This additional review is to determine if additional funds should be provided to already well-supported investigators and does not represent a cap on NIH funding.
    • The Advisory Council/Board also considers the Institute/Center’s goals and needs and advises the Institute/Center director concerning funding decisions.
    • The Institute/Center director makes final funding decisions based on staff and Advisory Council/Board advice
It’s that last part that the conspiracy theorists harp on. In theory, an Institute director like Anthony Fauci could override all the peer review to fund a grant, but in practice it almost never happens. Why? Because the NIH set up this process in order to minimize the possibility direct involvement of its leaders in picking and choosing grant awardees based on personal whim. The whole system exists to try to ensure as much as possible that grant selection is based on scientific merit, and few other considerations.
I won’t go through the whole appeals process, other than to say that appeals rarely succeed. I also won’t say that politics and the personal preferences of various Institute/Center (IC) directors never play a role in grant funding decisions, but I will say that the system is set up to minimize that role. Also, often the people who most characterize NIH funding decisions as the personal doling out of funding by directors are the same ones who have no compunction about trying to shut down research they don’t like themselves—and have been for a long time.
Minimizing reputational bias
With that background in hand, let’s take a look at what the NIH is proposing to do now to decrease reputational bias in its funding decisions. According to Nature:
The US National Institutes of Health (NIH) has released a tentative plan to change how its research grant applications are scored, with the aim of reducing bias and lowering the burden on reviewers. Under the new system, reviewers would no longer rate researchers’ expertise or their institutions’ access to resources, and there would be fewer scoring criteria overall.
The NIH’s Center for Scientific Review (CSR), which organizes the peer-review groups that evaluate more than 90% of the research grants awarded by the agency, announced these proposed changes at a meeting on 8 December attended by Lawrence Tabak, acting NIH director, and a panel of his advisers. The revamp has not yet been finalized, and any changes would not be implemented until 2024 at earliest.
So here is the main proposed change:
Reviewers currently score NIH research proposals according to five criteria: significance, investigator(s), innovation, approach and environment (where the research will be carried out). These criteria are defined by US legislation, so the NIH cannot modify them without approval from lawmakers, but it can change the way they’re interpreted or scored. The new system doesn’t throw out the old criteria, but groups them into three categories: the importance of the research, its feasibility and rigour, and the expertise and resources of the researcher and their institution.
Byrnes says that the last category, which won’t be scored under the proposal, is frequently misinterpreted. Reviewers sometimes score applicants and their institutions without considering them in the context of the proposed research — the original intention of the category. This has led to higher scores for prestigious institutions and individuals. Under the proposal, rather than score this category, reviewers would choose whether they think researcher expertise or institutional resources are adequate or not. If they select the latter, they can leave specific feedback about deficiencies in a text box on the review form. This will “prevent reviewers from waxing poetic about a really famous investigator that tilts the evaluation of the science”, Byrnes says.
Again, the “rich get richer” applies not just to high-reputation universities and institutions, but to individual researchers. Indeed, in 2017 the NIH proposed a plan to limit how many NIH grants any one individual researcher could hold at any one time, the idea being to “spread the wealth around” more after a report had shown that 10% of grant recipients received 40% of NIH grant funding. While it is expected that top researchers would be more effective at competing for research grants and would thus have more funding than recipients who were not as top tier, the NIH thought the disparity was too great and also wanted to direct more funding to young scientists in order to nurture the next generation. These concerns led to a proposal that applications from scientists who already controlled more than $1.5 million in NIH grants undergo an additional layer of review, a situation that only applied to 5% of grant awardees. The pushback was so fierce that the NIH ultimately backed down and scrapped the proposal. Instead, it The NIH announced the creation of a special fund drawn from its existing budget to be targeted at early- and mid-career scientists in an attempt to lower the average age of the researchers it supports.
In any event, here’s what the NIH proposes, specifically, with respect to its proposed simplified review criteria:
NIH proposes to reorganize the five review criteria into three factors, with Factors 1 and 2 receiving a numerical score. Reviewers will be instructed to consider all three factors (Factors 1, 2 and 3) in arriving at their Overall Impact Score (scored 1-9), reflecting the overall scientific and technical merit of the application.
    • Factor 1: Importance of the Research (Significance, Innovation), numerical score (1-9)
    • Factor 2: Rigor and Feasibility (Approach), numerical score (1-9)
    • Factor 3: Expertise and Resources (Investigator, Environment), assessed and considered in the Overall Impact Score, but not individually scored
Within Factor 3 (Expertise and Resources), Investigator and Environment will be assessed in the context of the research proposed. Investigator(s) will be rated as “fully capable” or “additional expertise/capability needed”. Environment will be rated as “appropriate” or “additional resources needed.” If a need for additional expertise or resources is identified, written justification must be provided. Detailed descriptions of the three factors can be found here.
Unsurprisingly, some scientists are not thrilled with the changes:
Some advisers attending the 8 December meeting pushed back on the plan, suggesting that researchers and institutional resources are crucial factors in determining the merit of research projects. “I do think there’s some value in some objective score to assess the investigator,” said Shelley Berger, an epigeneticist at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia. Without a score, Berger added, it could be difficult to understand the reviewer’s thinking and how they factored researcher expertise into their decision. Speaking at the meeting, Byrnes countered that reviewers would still have the option to leave comments about their concerns, which could be reflected in the overall impact score.
Personally, having reviewed grants, I see this as more or less a non-issue. If specific reviewers are savvy enough to know the capabilities of a given institution and whether they align with what is required to successfully complete the proposed project, then I see no reason under the new framework that they can’t state that and factor it into their overall impact score. More importantly, as I’ve discovered, mid-tier universities often have specific strengths, just not as many subject areas of strength as the “top tier” universities, but they are not infrequently penalized just based on their overall reputation compared to, say, Harvard or Stanford.
Of course, there are those who think this proposal doesn’t go far enough:
Although some critics appreciate that the agency is trying to eliminate reputational bias, they say the proposed changes do not address the root of funding disparities at the NIH. Omolola Eniola-Adefeso, a biomedical engineer at the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, who co-authored a 2021 article calling on the NIH to fund more Black scientists1, tells Nature that, to have a tangible impact, more diversity is needed among reviewers. She cites a landmark analysis published more than a decade ago2, which found that Black researchers were significantly less likely to receive NIH research funding compared with white researchers, even when factors such as scientific credentials and employer were taken into account. This means efforts to lessen the impact of reputational bias might not translate to more equitable funding, she says.
In addition to considering the race and gender of reviewers, ensuring that panels have representation from under-represented institutions could have a big impact, says Enrique Neblett, a public-health researcher at the University of Michigan. Given the persistence of funding disparities, the NIH needs to take bolder action, he says.
I know what some “purists” are going to say here, namely that scientific merit should be the be-all and end-all of determining who gets NIH grants. (Actually, they’ll say worse, but I’m being kind.) While I’m sympathetic to such an argument in the abstract, I also realize that the NIH is nonetheless an agency of the US government. I also realize that there is no such thing as true “colorblindness” when it comes to functions like evaluating grant applications, as can be seen from findings that disparities in funding success persist even when credentials and institution are taken into account. It’s a delicate balancing act between maintaining the scientific rigor of the process while promoting polices that can benefit society by supporting younger researchers and diversifying the scientific workforce, both of which can contribute to better science funded by the NIH in the future that addresses the problems in medicine and public health most relevant to our population.
Reality versus conspiratorial fantasy
One thing that this whole debate over how best to allocate limited NIH funding to scientists submitting grant proposals should dispel is the notion that the system in any way resembles the fantasy version portrayed by antivax conspiracy theorists, quacks, and grifters. Just because they view everything through a strictly transactional lens and can’t imagine any government institution not operating basically the same way does not mean that that’s how the NIH works. The NIH grant process has a lot of shortcomings, but it really does strive to be as much of a meritocracy as possible while at least not undermining societal goods, such as a more diverse workforce and supporting young scientists so that they don’t abandon biomedical research because they can’t obtain funding to support their laboratories and research programs. The proposed changes in NIH grant review criteria seek to strike this balance while maintaining scientific rigor.
What the proposed changes should help to emphasize is that the NIH, for all the deficiencies both real and exaggerated in its study section system, is constantly seeking ways to change the application process so that the most scientifically impactful and meritorious grants receive funding, even if a lot of meritorious grants do not, simply because there is not enough funding. Being a system set up by humans, the NIH will never achieve a perfect system for funding grants. However, contrary to the conspiracy theory, the NIH is set up to try to minimize the effects of IC directors (or anyone else) picking winners and losers based on a quid pro quo or personal whim, and that’s one of the things that makes the NIH great.

The Israeli Academy of Sciences and Humanities elects antivaxer Yehuda Shoenfeld to its ranks
Yehuda Shoenfeld is an Israeli scientist who has promoted the idea that adjuvants in vaccines cause ASIA, Autoimmunity/Autoinflammation Syndrome Induced by Adjuvants, a vaguely defined catch-all diagnosis that encompasses vague symptomatology and unproven links to certain autoantibodies, all caused by adjuvants in vaccines, especially aluminum. Last week, Shoenfeld was elected to the Israel Academy of Sciences and Humanities, an embarrassment to the Academy and something that will be used by the antivaxers Shoenfeld flirts with to claim they have “real science” supporting them.
David Gorski on July 1, 2019
Link

We here at SBM frequently warn about the infiltration of pseudoscience into what should be science-based medicine (i.e., conventional medicine) in the form of the “integration” of quackery into medicine under the label “integrative medicine.” However, that infiltration is often subtle, and a depressing number of integrative medicine advocates think that they are advocating rigorous science, when in fact they are doing anything but. Seldom, however, have I seen anything like what I saw in a post on For Better Science last week about famed Israeli scientist turned antivaccine “scientist” Yehuda Shoenfeld:
Yehuda Shoenfeld, the autoimmunity quack expert who loves associating with and taking money from the most notorious antivax characters, has been elected as member of the Israel Academy of Sciences and Humanities. The announcement was made on 16 June 2019, an official ceremony will take place in December during Chanukah, 2019. The reasons for this early Christmas present to antivaxxers around the world are unclear, but there is apparently big money and heavy networks involved.
Shoenfeld is portrayed as the godfather of autoimmunity research in Israel and beyond, because to him all diseases are caused by autoimmune reactions. Including autism, which according to Shoenfeld and his antivax friends is caused by inflammatory aluminium adjuvants in vaccines. For example, Professor Shoenfeld explained how aluminium in vaccines poisons people in a BMC Medicine video interview in 2013. The occasion was a paper in that journal which Shoenfeld coauthored and which contains fabricated data.
Besides my jaw dropping simultaneously as I double face-palmed after reading this, thus endangering my precious surgery hands with accidental bites, I had an immediate thought; well two actually. First, I wondered how on earth this could have happened. How could an antivax crank scientist be elected to the highest level of Israeli science? Second, it occurred to me that we haven’t written about Shoenfeld here on SBM nearly as much as we should. Maybe it’s because he’s not North American or European. Maybe it’s because he’s not that well known outside of Israel, other than in antivaccine circles. However, in antivaccine circles he is enormously influential, having invented the fake diagnosis ASIA (Autoimmune Syndrome Induced by Adjuvants).
I’ve not infrequently said that, when it comes to being a target of antivaccine pseudoscience and conspiracy theories, aluminum is now the new mercury, since mercury in the form of thimerosal preservative that used to be used in childhood vaccines was, in an abundance (or, as some have argued, and overabundance) of cautious application of the precautionary principle, removed from childhood vaccines in 2001. Since aluminum salts are still used as vaccine adjuvants, to improve the response to the antigens used in the vaccine and thus allow less antigen to be used, it was fairly predictable that antivaxers would turn their attention to aluminum. If you want to know one of the main reasons antivaxers have turned aluminum into the new mercury as a target of their fear mongering, look no further than Shoenfeld’s concept of “ASIA”. If you want to know why, other than sex and the sexually transmitted disease aspect, antivaxers concentrate on Gardasil and Cervarix (the HPV—human papilloma virus—vaccines), look no further than ASIA, because HPV vaccines use aluminum as their adjuvant. Indeed, antivaxers invoke ASIA (and other dubious inferences) to falsely claim that HPV vaccination can cause premature ovarian failure and even death.
Before I discuss ASIA and why it’s highly dubious at best, let’s first meet Yehuda Shoenfeld.
Who is Yehuda Shoenfeld?
When I started writing this blog post, my recollection was that I had first learned who Yehuda Shoenfeld was in 2011 when I reviewed an antivaccine propaganda film disguised as a documentary called The Greater Good (a precursor to Andrew Wakefield and Del Bigtree’s VAXXED by five years), where I noted the blurb at the end of the film’s closing credits that “this film was vetted by Dr. Lawrence D. Rosen, MD, FAAP and Dr. Yehuda Shoenfeld, MD, FRCP for scientific and medical accuracy.” Given that The Greater Good is pure antivaccine propaganda and that Dr. Rosen is an “integrative pediatrician” with a history of spreading antivaccine misinformation and was a speaker at a notorious antivaccine conference in Jamaica in 2011 with an “all-star lineup” of antivaxers including Andrew Wakefield, Barbara Loe Fisher, Lawrence Palevsky, Christopher Shaw, Lucija Tomljenovic, Russell Blaylock, and more, my initial impression was that Yehuda Shoenfeld must be antivaccine.
Of course, what I didn’t remember was that I had heard of Yehuda Shoenfeld three years earlier, thanks to Neurodiversity, the late lamented weblog of Kathleen Seidel. It’s no longer online, but thankfully it has been preserved by the almighty Wayback Machine at Archive.org. Let’s just say that, early in my blogging, Seidel taught me about Mark and David Geier (the father-son tag team of antivaccine pseudoscience and chemical castration as a treatment for “vaccine-induced” autism), the Association of American Physicians and Surgeons (AAPS), and many other things. It turns out that in 2007 she had written to Shoenfeld about an article by Mark and David Geier that he had published and then retracted in the journal he co-edited, Autoimmunity Reviews. The article had been about the Geiers’ biochemical “rationale” (if you can call it that) for using chemical castration to treat autistic children. In the letter, asked why the article had been retracted:
After the retraction, I learned that Dr. Shoenfeld received compensation from the the U.K. Legal Services Corporation for his service to plaintiffs in the now-discontinued MMR litigation, in which Dr. Geier was also involved.
I received no response to my original letter to Dr. Shoenfeld. A paper copy which I mailed to his office at Tel Aviv University was returned to me, marked “Not at this address.” My 23 January 2007 follow-up email remains unanswered. Dr. Shoenfeld has also been unresponsive to email and telephone inquiries by the journalist Brian Deer, who sought information about the retraction for the British Medical Journal.
It is my understanding that retraction is generally reserved for substantiated instances of scientific fraud or misconduct. Although I am pleased that Dr. and Mr. Geier’s paper was retracted, I am disturbed by Dr. Shoenfeld’s reluctance to respond to inquiries or to offer a substantive explanation for the retraction. The obligation to full disclosure becomes particularly urgent when a retracted study pertains to pharmaceutical experimentation on vulnerable, disabled children.
Shoenfeld didn’t answer. However, her complaint was echoed by Dr. Alan Tyndall of the University of Basel and Nobel-winning immunologist Dr. Rolf Zinkernagel. What was Shoenfeld’s response to them? Not good:
This issue between the lady and the Geiers is an emotional vendetta and not a scientific issue. The paper was not published in our journal!! We do not need any report to anybody except the authors why their paper was not published. I am aware of this lady “disease” also in other aspects and domains. She writes to all the world and it arrived to at a stage of nuisance. We have decided not to respond to any of her emails letters etc.
So Yehuda Shoenfeld was not only dismissive, but sexist as well, dismissing Seidel’s concerns as an “emotional vendetta”. She also documented Shoenfeld’s longtime association with antivaxers, particularly as an expert witness for the complainants. In this case, the lawyer was Clifford Shoemaker, who at one time had filed an overbroad fishing expedition of a subpoena against Seidel, which he justified by bogus conspiracy theories, including a particularly amusing bit about how Kathleen Seidel’s husband David had somehow has seized control of Wikipedia. (Bashing Wikipedia was every bit a pastime of cranks back then as it is now.) No wonder Seidel described Shoenfeld as an “eminently useful friend” of the antivaccine movement, and no wonder commenter Smut Clyde drily noted:
So Shoenfeld is identified with the anti-vaccine lobby, at least in the minds of anti-vaccine True Believers. His is the name most touted in tweets as proof that Real Science is on their side (with Drs Exley, Shaw, Gherardi and Luján as lesser authorities). I feel safe in predicting they will make the most of his induction into Israel’s Academy of Sciences as a vindication of everything they have said.
And:
But it may be that I am putting the tail before the dog, or letting the cart wag the horse, or something along those lines. Shoenfeld has also identified himself with the concept of autoimmunity, which he evangelises with prophetic, proselytic zeal, seeking to enshrine it as the heart of medical research and practice. As David Attenborough is to Nature, as Carl Sagan was to the Cosmos, so Shoenfeld is to Autoimmunity and he will not rest content until he hosts a six-part BBC documentary on the topic.
Shoenfeld even wrote an article entitled “Everything Is Autoimmune Until Proven Otherwise“. Of course, ASIA is a manifestation of that idea, which is cringeworthy in its echoing of the common quack tendency to ascribe all diseases to The One True Cause of Disease. Of course, it doesn’t help that he has appeared to speak at conferences that can only be described as clearly antivaccine, such as ones sponsored by the Children’s Medical Safety Research Institute (CMSRI), a now-defunct antivaccine “institute” formerly funded by the Dwoskin family and dedicated to funding antivaccine “research.” Smut also notes that Shoenfeld’s “sprawling Empire of Autoimmunity” is very much entwined with antivaccine pseudoscience:
It is undeniable, though, that this sprawling Empire of Autoimmunity is intimately entwined with antivax rhetoric. At the core of Shoenfeld’s 8th, 9th, 10th and 11th ICAs in Grenada, Nice, Lisbon and Leipzig, the nuclei they crystallised around, we find (respectively) the 2nd, 3rd, 4th and 5th International Symposia on Vaccines, and these were very much antivax events.
I note that at the 5th International Symposium on Vaccines, no less an antivaxer than Claire Dwoskin herself wrote:
The fifth International Symposium on Vaccines, sponsored by the Children’s Medical Safety Research Institute (CMSRI), has announced its line-up of speakers for the upcoming event in Portugal. Held the first day of the biennial Autoimmunity Congress, the Symposium draws medical researchers from around the world to share the latest research on vaccine safety and the potential links between vaccine adjuvants and adverse autoimmune reactions. To see the full program agenda, click here.
“Critical research on this topic is not always welcomed at events that are sponsored, in large part, by the makers of vaccines, but it is vital that the scientists who are courageously examining potential causes of today’s epidemic of autoimmune disorders are able to share and discuss their findings,” said Claire Dwoskin, founder and president of CMSRI. “The collaborative research projects that are conceived at — or as a result of — this symposium are truly groundbreaking.”
The organizer of the symposium is renowned aluminum toxicity expert, Dr. Christopher Exley, professor of bioinorganic chemistry at Keele University in England. Exely and his team of researchers will be presenting at the symposium, in addition to the speakers listed below. The following are abstracts for each of the presentations (note: CMSRI-funded research is highlighted in purple).
The introduction to the 4th International Symposium on Vaccines proclaimed its key questions as:
What role do vaccines play in inducing autoimmunity?
Are there safe vaccines for genetically prone subjects?
Can we vaccinate against autoimmune diseases?
What is the role of adjuvants and/or molecular mimicry in vaccines inducing autoimmune diseases?
Is it safe to vaccinate patients with autoimmune diseases?
In 2016, Claire Dwoskin had high praise for Shoenfeld:
Thank you for all that you have done to help people, put on an excellent congress, and provide a forum for the vaccine and adjuvant issue.
So Yehuda Shoenfeld is definitely antivaccine, believing that vaccine adjuvants cause a syndrome of autoimmunity. He has also been highly prolific writing about autoimmunity, with (at this counting) 66 books edited, 161 book chapters, and 1,986 articles. As is noted in For Better Science, Professor Shoenfeld used to be affiliated with Sheba Medical Center at Tel Hashomer and the Sackler Faculty of Medicine at Tel-Aviv University, and is now emeritus at the latter. He ran the Zabludowicz Center for Autoimmune Diseases at Sheba, which is funded by the Finnish-British billionaire Poju Zabludowicz. Before his elevation, Shoenfeld was a very prominent name in Israeli science. After his elevation, he’ll be even more so.
Schneider notes that Zabludowicz also likes to donate to right-wing politicians, including Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. He likely was nominated thusly:
Also because of the money flows, the Sheba hospital affiliation is said to be the source of Shoenfeld’s sway in Israeli politics and academia. For example, Dean of Sackler Ehud Grossman has a clinical affiliation with the Sheba Centre. Sources revealed it was influential Sheba clinicians who put forward Shoenfeld’s name for Academy membership, very likely Gidi Rechavi and Uri Seligsohn, plus a third bigwig from Tel Aviv University. Incidentally, just before Shoenfeld was put forward as Academy member, Sheba Medical Center advertised for his antivax rants, but had the press release and even its externally archived version purged in May 2019 (luckily, Shoenfeld’s paranoid antivax fans were quick to save screenshots and another copy in March 2019):
Top Israeli Doctor Points to Vaccines as Contributing to the Rising Rate of Autoimmune Diseases[…] “Throughout our lifetime, the normal immune system walks a fine line between preserving normal immune reactions and developing autoimmune diseases,” says the article. “The healthy immune system is tolerant to self-antigens. When self-tolerance is disturbed, dysregulation of the immune system follows, resulting in the emergence of an autoimmune disease. Vaccination is one of the conditions that may disturb this homeostasis in susceptible individuals, resulting in autoimmune phenomena and ASIA.”
[…] Dr. Shoenfeld summarizes, “…many reports that describe post-vaccination autoimmunity strongly suggest that vaccines can indeed trigger autoimmunity. Defined autoimmune diseases that may occur following vaccinations include arthritis, lupus (systemic lupus erythematosus, SLE), diabetes mellitus, thrombocytopenia, vasculitis, dermatomyositis, Guillain-Barre syndrome and demyelinating disorders. And almost all types of vaccines have been reported to be associated with the onset of ASIA.”
So what, according to Shoenfeld, is ASIA?
Autoimmunity Syndrome Induced by Adjuvants (ASIA): A fake diagnosis
As Smut Clyde also drily notes, as “David Attenborough is to Nature, as Carl Sagan was to the Cosmos, so Shoenfeld is to Autoimmunity and he will not rest content until he hosts a six-part BBC documentary on the topic.” ASIA is his claim to fame, the “nexus of autoimmunity and antivax enthusiasms, which attains a kind of apotheosis in ASIA,” which is “also known as ‘Shoenfeld’s Syndrome’ in its author’s less modest moments.” As is further noted, making up a name for a “syndrome” like this, whether the syndrome is real or not, is a win, because “just by using the name, people have accepted your hypothesis.”
Again, though, what is ASIA? Perhaps the best summary from the horse’s mouth itself is the aforementioned video foolishly published by BMC Medicine in which Shoenfeld explains it in his own words. If you read the transcript, you’ll see that the definition of ASIA is so vague that almost any immune abnormality can be so classified as long as somewhere, somehow, the patient had prior exposure to an adjuvant, especially if it was an aluminum adjuvant. For example, here is Shoenfeld’s answer to the question, “What is ASIA?”:
ASIA is a new syndrome, which refers to autoimmune syndromes induced by adjuvants. It includes several conditions that are not fully characterized as autoimmune diseases like systemic lupus, rheumatoid arthritis or scleroderma, but that are induced by chronic stimulation of the immune system by substances which may react as adjuvants. This chronic stimulation leads to the emergence of these new signs and symptoms, which include fatigue, arthritis, myalgia, and neurological manifestations.
So, basically, any symptoms of fatigue, joint aches, muscle aches, or headaches might be ASIA! Of course, not content to limit ASIA to just being caused by vaccines, Shoenfeld also lumps silicone from silicone breast implants into the category of “adjuvant,” such that silicone implants can cause ASIA as well—because why not? So what are the criteria for diagnosing ASIA? Quacks will love Shoenfeld’s answer:
We have published the criteria and classified it as we do usually with different autoimmune diseases, namely into major criteria and minor criteria. Major criteria include clinical manifestations such as severe fatigue, poor sleep, myalgia and arthralgia; the minor criteria include the presence of various autoantibodies and specific HLA (e.g., DRB1). However, as I mentioned before, over the years many of these patients may go on to develop a more well-defined autoimmune disease. For instance, if they develop scleroderma or systemic sclerosis, they will suffer from tight skin, complications of the lungs, kidneys, and so forth.
Note the cleverness here. If you have a bunch of vague symptoms that are maybe autoimmune-like, you might have ASIA, but if you go on to develop a “more well-defined” autoimmune disease, that’s ASIA too! And it’s all caused by vaccine adjuvants. Of course, it’s worse than that. Shoenfeld also claims that the MMR (measles-mumps-rubella) vaccine can cause ASIA even though, as an attenuated live virus vaccine, MMR has no adjuvants. (Aluminum would kill the virus.) He even mistakenly claims that the MMR has adjuvants, in much the same way I’ve seen those who believe that mercury in vaccines is the cause of autism, even though the MMR has never contained thimerosal. He’s also claimed that the ASIA can result from the oral polio vaccine, which again has no adjuvants and isn’t even injected.
ASIA also subsumes a number of other conditions, including the Gulf War Syndrome, which is where the concept first apparently hit Shoenfeld, where he claimed to link certain autoantibodies (antibodies against self-antigens, like proteins), supposedly induced by the squalene adjuvant used in the anthrax vaccine that troops were given prior to shipping out. It’s a contention that has long been refuted. The original term was coined in 2011, but Shoenfeld had been laying the groundwork as he testified for complainants in the Vaccine Court long before that. Interestingly, in his 2015 compendium on autoimmunity, it’s been noted that large sections of the text of the document were apparently lifted from Wikipedia.
But what’s the evidence for the existence of ASIA? It’s not very good. New Zealand commissioned Rohan Ameratunga, a practicing allergy and immunology specialist, to review the evidence for the existence of ASIA. His conclusions were not kind, as noted in two review articles. For example, Ameratunga et al bluntly noted:
Current data do not support the causation of ASIA by vaccine adjuvants containing aluminum, which should be of reassurance to patients undergoing routine immunizations as well as to those undergoing allergen-specific IT.
In another review, Ameratunga et al also conclude:
We have recently reviewed ASIA as defined by its authors. We have shown that the definition of ASIA is imprecise and includes all patients with an autoimmune disorder as well as potentially the entire population. Application of the Bradford Hill criteria for causality does not support ASIA as an outcome of exposure to aluminium containing adjuvants in vaccines. The advocates of ASIA highlight animal models as evidence for the existence of the disorder. However, as this review will demonstrate, animal models purporting to support the existence of ASIA have methodological, analytical and ethical flaws which, in our view, refute the existence of the condition.
In another review, Hawkes et al further noted:
At present, there is no evidence to suggest that ASIA syndrome is a viable explanation for unusual autoimmune diseases. Since the initial paper, over 80 publications have discussed ASIA. This systematic review examines the research that has been done to investigate whether ASIA is a broad umbrella term with little clinical significance, or whether there is some underlying mechanism which could be utilised to reduce the occurrence of adjuvant mediated disease. Twenty-seven animal, epidemiological and case studies were reviewed. Unfortunately, a robust animal model of ASIA using biologically relevant doses of adjuvants has yet to be defined. It is also apparent that the broadness of the current ASIA criteria lack stringency and, as a result, very few cases of autoimmune disease could be excluded from a diagnosis of ASIA. The current studies involving human cases are so diverse, in both external stimuli and in resulting conditions, that there is currently a lack of reproducible evidence for any consistent relationship between adjuvant and autoimmune condition.
The World Health Organization does not support the concept of ASIA caused by vaccines, in particular the HPV vaccine.
Helen Petousis Harris was more blunt, calling ASIA a “scam,” referring to it as a “sort of catch all for nebulous chronic illnesses that include fatigue” and applying the six steps in the confidence (a.k.a. con) game to the story of ASIA’s creation and promotion. The first step was foundation, including all the articles that Shoenfeld and his associates wrote in low quality journals on whose editorial board Shoenfeld sat. Personally, I’m not sure if Shoen is a grifter or not. He might actually believe in ASIA. However, there is a lot of grift associated with ASIA that to which Shoenfeld, whether knowingly or not, contributes.
There are many other sources criticizing Shoenfeld’s shoddy science and intimate connections with the antivaccine movement, such as this article by Vincent Iannelli in Vaxopedia and this post by our friend the Skeptical Raptor, who calls ASIA an antivaccine myth, because that’s what it is.
Worse, as Smut Clyde and Leonid Schneider note, Yehuda Shoenfeld’s publication record is problematic as well. He demonstrates this by publishing a letter by an Israeli clinical immunology professor to Nili Cohen, a law scholar at Tel Aviv University and President of the Israel Academy of Sciences and Humanities. After noting that Shoenfeld has no training in immunology and that there have been grave concerns expressed about the reproducibility of his work, this immunologist goes on to observe:
3. However, every reasonable investigator who ever worked in bio-medical research knows that no human being can publish 1,939 papers, unless these reflect the work of hundreds of investigators, to which Dr. Shoenfeld’ true contribution is insignificant, or to put it in a more benevolent way, questionable (see official Clarivate record sent with this mail).
4. To make these results more palpable, here are some simple calculations: In the year 2007, he has published 110 papers, which means 2.11 papers each week or 0.3 papers per day. In 2017, his productivity was reduced to 80 papers, meaning 1.54 papers each week or 0.21 papers per day. If there ever was a miracle worker, it is Dr. Shoenfeld.
5. Dr. Shoenfeld also has a most impressive citation record: 58,116 citations (of which 8,704 are self-citations!). The members of the Israel Academy of Sciences should have had a good look at his three most cited papers (3158, 1739, and 1048 citations). These have 16, 32, and 24 authors, respectively, with Dr. Shoenfeld somewhere in the middle. All three are papers of consortia dealing with nomenclature or reviews of groups of patients. One would expect that a scientist’s most cited papers to be representative of his own best work. The rest of the 1939 papers is a potpourri of every field of medicine from tobacco smoke to vitamin D and inflammatory bowel disease, to mention only a minority.
The letter concludes by expressing concern that Shoenfeld’s elevation is a “mistake” that will signify “that the Israel Academy of Sciences is impressed by self-promotion, ‘celeb’ status, and biased and lacking in objectivity recommendations, and not by an objective system of values”, all of which is true. Of course, this is a risk with all such prestigious academies, for which politics can at times matter more than scientific excellence. Friends and like-minded powerful scientists in the academy elevate friends and like-minded influential scientists, and the result is something like an antivaccine crank like Yehuda Shoenfeld being nominated and elected to the Israeli Academy of Sciences and Humanities. Having Yehuda Shoenfeld as a member of the Israeli Academy of Sciences and Humanities is a blight on the Israeli science community and will be used by antivaxers to promote their pseudoscience.
